AJR 21: Reparations for descendants of enslaved persons.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-06-19
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 4, 2019 | In Senate. To Com. on RLS. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Coauthors revised. |
| Aug 27, 2019 | From committee: Be adopted. Ordered to Third Reading. (Ayes 8. Noes 2.) (August 26). |
| Jun 24, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 20, 2019 | From printer. |
| Jun 19, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 3, 2019 | AJR 21 Gonzalez Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 26, 2019 | Be adopted. To third reading. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AJR 21
Author:(Gonzalez, et al.)
As Introduced Ver:June 19, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Proclaims the California Legislature's support for H.R. 40 (Jackson Lee), of the 116th Congress, apologizes for California's complicity in slavery, and makes various findings and declarations.
Major Provisions
- Makes the following findings and declarations:
- Approximately 4 million Africans and their descendants were enslaved in the United States and colonies that became the United States from 1619 to 1865, and the institution of slavery was constitutionally and statutorily sanctioned by the government of the United States from 1789 through 1865.
- California, despite its admission as a "free" state, permitted the virtual enslavement and trafficking of Native Americans under the 1850 Act for the Government and Protection of Indians.
- Following the abolition of slavery, governments at all levels continued to perpetuate, condone, and often profit from practices that continued to brutalize and disadvantage African Americans, including sharecropping, convict leasing, Jim Crow laws, redlining, unequal education, and unequal treatment by the criminal justice system. As a result of this history, African Americans continue to suffer debilitating economic, educational, and health hardships, as had been demonstrated a preponderance of scholarship about slavery and its legacy.
- In 1980, Congress established a commission to investigate the legacy of the internment of Japanese Americans during World War II and to recommend appropriate redress. On August 10, 1988, President Ronald Reagan signed the Civil Liberties Act to provide reparations to the more than 120,000 Japanese Americans who were incarcerated in America's internment camps during World War II.
- In January of 1989, former Representative John J. Conyers Jr. of Michigan introduced the "Commission to Study Reparation Proposals for African Americans Act," and reintroduced this measure each subsequent congressional term.
- Resolves, in the light of the above, the following:
- The Legislature strongly and unequivocally supports H.R. 40, and urges the President and the Congress of the United States to enact this legislation to study the legacy of slavery and provide recommendations for redress.
- The California Legislature acknowledges and formally apologizes for its past complicity in enabling and furthering the practice of slavery in California against African Americans, Native Americans, and others.
COMMENTS:
This resolution expresses the California Legislature's support for H.R. 40, a bill pending in the U.S. Congress that would establish a 13 member commission to study the issue of reparations for African Americans and make recommendations to Congress. The resolution also acknowledges and apologizes for California's complicity in slavery, in particular for the "virtual enslavement" of Native Americans in California. Although a 2014 article by Ta-Nehisi Coates ("The Case for Reparations," Atlantic, June 2014) forcefully revived the debate about reparations for the descendants of enslaved African Americans, arguments in favor of reparations have a very long history, pre-dating even the Civil War and emancipation. This history (as detailed in the committee analysis of this bill) shows that calls for reparations, while ultimately unsuccessful, drew the support of a cross-section of Americans of all races. It shows that calls for reparations have always recognized the complex and diffuse nature of moral culpability in a slave society and, therefore, that meaningful reparations will need to take varied forms. Finally, this history shows that the movement for reparations, especially in its more modern forms, has recognized that the harms of slavery did not end with emancipation and the Civil War, but that they lasted well into the 20th century and continue into our own time.
H.R. 40: The Commission to Study and Develop Reparations Proposals for African Americans Act: Although first introduced in 1989 as H.R. 3745 (Conyers), of the 101st Congress, beginning in 1997 Representative Conyers secured the number "40" for each bill introduced thereafter in order to reference the broken post-Civil War promise that planation land should be divided up an each freed family should receive "forty acres and a mule" in exchange for their unpaid labor. H.R. 40 does not require reparations payments to African American descendants of enslaved persons, nor does it propose any other specific programs to compensate or offer any other benefit to descendants. Rather, H.R. 40 simply provides for the establishment of a commission "to study and consider a national apology and proposal for reparations for the institution of slavery, its subsequent de jure and de facto racial and economic discrimination against African-Americans, and the impact of these forces on living African Americans." Based upon its study and findings, the Commission would then make recommendations to Congress "on appropriate remedies."
This resolution will allow the California Legislature to use its voice to help to finally bring H.R. 40 to the House floor for a vote, which has not happened since first introduced in 1989. In addition to urging enactment of H.R. 40, this resolution also seeks to acknowledge and apologize for the California Legislature's complicity in slavery and the legacy of slavery.
According to the Author:
According to the author, our country "cannot begin to address the incredible racial inequities still prevalent in our society until we accept and work towards redress of the country's original sin: the trafficking and enslavement of millions Africans and their descendants. . . AJR 21 declares California's support for H.R. 40, introduced by Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee, to establish a federal commission to study and develop proposals for reparations to descendants of enslaved persons in the United States. Furthermore, AJR 21 acknowledges and formally apologizes for the Legislature's past complicity in enabling and furthering the practice of slavery in California."
Arguments in Support:
None on file.
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-2-2
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Reyes
NO: Gallagher, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Kiley, Petrie-Norris
UPDATED:
VERSION: June 19, 2019
CONSULTANT: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001491
Date of Hearing: August 26, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AJR 21
Author:(Gonzalez) – As Introduced Ver:June 19, 2019
SUBJECT: Reparations for descendants of enslaved persons
KEY ISSUE: should the legislature express its support for H.R. 40 (a federal bill that would establish a commission to study the topic of reparations for african americans) and also acknowledge and apologize for california’s complicity in slavery?
SYNOPSIS
Former Michigan Representative John Conyers first introduced the “Commission to Study Reparations for African Americans Act” in 1989, and he re-introduced it in each subsequent session of Congress until his retirement in 2017. Representative Sheila Jackson Lee of Texas has picked up the mantle and introduced H.R. 40 in the current session. H.R. 40 does not provide for reparations or make any determination as to what form reparations, if any, would take. Rather, H.R. 40 merely calls for the creation of a Commission to study the impact of slavery and subsequent de jure and de facto discrimination on living African Americans and to make recommendations to Congress on appropriate remedies. No matter which party has controlled the U.S. Congress, H.R. 40 has apparently never even reached the House floor for a vote. Indeed, recent hearings held by a subcommittee of the House Judiciary Committee in June of this year were the first committee hearings held on the measure since 2007. The resolution before this Committee will tell Congress and the President that the California Legislature strongly and unequivocally supports H.R. 40. The resolution also acknowledges and apologizes for the California legislature’s past complicity in enabling and furthering the practice of slavery in California. There is no known opposition to this resolution.
SUMMARY: Proclaims the California Legislature’s support for H.R. 40, apologizes for California’s complicity in slavery, and makes various findings and declarations. Specifically, this resolution:
- Makes the following findings and declarations:
- Approximately four million Africans and their descendants were enslaved in the United States and colonies that became the United States from 1619 to 1865.
- The institution of slavery was constitutionally and statutorily sanctioned by the government of the United States from 1789 through 1865 and the slavery that flourished in the United States constituted an immoral and inhumane deprivation of life, liberty, citizenship rights, and cultural heritage, and denied enslaved persons the fruits of their own labor.
- California, despite its admission as a “free” state, permitted the virtual enslavement and trafficking of Native Americans under the 1850 Act for the Government and Protection of Indians.
- Following the abolition of slavery, the United States government, at the federal, state, and local level, continued to perpetuate, condone, and often profit from practices that continued to brutalize and disadvantage African Americans, including sharecropping, convict leasing, Jim Crow laws, redlining, unequal education, and disproportionate treatment at the hands of the criminal justice system.
- As a result of the historical and continued discrimination, African Americans continue to suffer debilitating economic, educational, and health hardships, including, but not limited to, an unemployment rate more than twice the current White unemployment rate and an average of less than one-sixteenth of the wealth of White families, a disparity which has worsened, not improved, over time.
- A preponderance of scholarly and legal evidentiary documentation constitutes the basis for inquiry into the ongoing effects of the institution of slavery and its legacy of persistent systemic structures of discrimination on living African Americans and society in the United States.
- In 1980, Congress established a commission to investigate the legacy of the internment of Japanese Americans during World War II and to recommend appropriate redress. On August 10, 1988, President Ronald Reagan signed the Civil Liberties Act to provide reparations to the more than 120,000 Japanese Americans who were incarcerated in America’s internment camps during World War II.
- In January of 1989, former Representative John J. Conyers Jr. of Michigan introduced the “Commission to Study Reparation Proposals for African Americans Act,” and reintroduced this measure each subsequent congressional term.
- Modern conceptualizations of reparations for descendants of enslaved persons have been heavily shaped by acts of redress by foreign governments for the atrocities and trauma they have inflicted on segments of their populations, including, but not limited to, German reparations to Holocaust survivors and their descendants and South African reparations to the victims of apartheid.
- Resolves, in the light of the above, the following:
- The Legislature strongly and unequivocally supports H.R. 40 of the 116th Congress, and urges the President and the Congress of the United States to enact this legislation to study the legacy of slavery and provide recommendations on redress for descendants of enslaved persons.
- The California Legislature acknowledges and formally apologizes for its past complicity in enabling and furthering the practice of slavery in California against African Americans, Native Americans, and others.
EXISTING LAW: Not relevant.
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this resolution is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Just over 50 years ago the late historian John Hope Franklin, a pioneer in the field of African American History and adviser to two U.S. Presidents, wrote, “If the house is to be set in order, one cannot begin with the present; he must begin with the past.” (John Hope Franklin, “Rediscovering Black America,” New York Times, September 8, 1968.) This resolution takes a small but important step towards setting the house in order by confronting our collective past as a nation and as a state. Specifically, this resolution would state that the California Legislature supports the enactment of H.R. 40, a bill pending in the U.S. Congress that would establish a thirteen-member commission to study the issue of reparations for African Americans and make recommendations to Congress. The resolution also acknowledges and apologizes for California’s complicity in slavery, in particular for the “virtual enslavement” of Native Americans in California.
Reparation Movements from the American Revolution to the Early 20th Century: Although a 2014 article by Ta-Nehisi Coates (“The Case for Reparations,” Atlantic, June 2014) forcefully revived the debate about reparations for the descendants of enslaved African Americans, arguments in favor of reparations have a very long history, pre-dating even the Civil War and emancipation. As early as 1783, an enslaved woman known as Belinda petitioned the Massachusetts General Court (the upper House of the state legislature) for a “pension” from the estate of her former master, Isaac Royall. A British loyalist, Royall fled the colonies for England at the outbreak of the American Revolution. In 1778, Massachusetts confiscated Royall’s real property – as it tended to do with Loyalist property – and freed his slaves. (Massachusetts, like most other Northern states, would implement a plan of gradual emancipation of all enslaved persons after the American Revolution.)
Destitute and having to care for an infirm daughter by the end of the war, Belinda asked the state of Massachusetts to award her and her daughter proceeds from Royall’s confiscated estate. Speaking of herself in the third person, Belinda’s petition not only appealed to the state’s sympathy; rather, it asserted that she was owed a part of Royall’s “immense wealth, a part of whereof hath been accumulated by her own industry, and . . . her servitude.” Massachusetts, perhaps influenced by the fact her owner was a Loyalist, granted the request. When the estate failed to make payments as promised, Belinda petitioned the state in 1787 and again in 1790. Unfortunately, we do not know what became of Belinda and her award after that, but as the historian Roy Finkenbine writes, her petition “achieved a life of its own,” as it was published several times in the early 19th century by abolitionists in the United States and England, who invoked Belinda’s logic that she was owed a part of Royall’s wealth because her unpaid labor had created it. (Roy Finkenbine, “Belinda’s Petition: Reparations for Slavery in Revolutionary Massachusetts,” William and Mary Quarterly, 3d Series (2007): 95-104.) Belinda’s petition is not merely an isolated anecdote, but evidence that demands for reparations, and the logic supporting it, has a long history. That logic was not only accepted by former enslaved persons like Belinda, but also, apparently, by Massachusetts lawmakers.
Religious leaders, abolitionists, and Free Black activists in the North continued to call for compensation for ex-slaves after the Northern States abolished slavery in the wake of the American Revolution. For example, a sermon delivered in 1810 by Timothy Dwight, the President of Yale College, advocated reparations for former slaves. In response to Northerners who might claim that they personally had not been involved with the early slave trade, Dwight had an answer:
It is in vain to alledge [sic], that our ancestors brought them [Africans] hither, and not we . . . We inherit our ample patrimony and all of its encumbrances; and we are bound to pay the debts of our ancestors. This debt, particularly, we are bound to discharge; and when the righteous Judge of the Universe comes to reckon with his servants, he will rigidly exact the payment at our hands. To give them liberty, and stop here, is to entail upon them a curse. (Timothy Dwight, The Charitable Blessed: A Sermon Preached in the First Church in New Haven, August 8, 1810 (New Haven: 1810), 22-23, as quoted in Finkenbine, supra, 104.)
While our secular world may no longer fear the wrath of the Judge of the Universe, the other points in Dwight’s sermon are quite relevant to the current debate over reparations and the resolution now before the Committee. First, it is no defense to claim that slavery was the work of “our ancestors,” because we have enjoyed the wealth (“ample patrimony”) produced by slavery, and that wealth comes with “encumbrances.” In addition, Dwight’s point that, to give formerly enslaved persons “liberty” but nothing else would be a curse, is similar to those later made by white and African-American advocates of land reform in the immediate aftermath of the Civil War: liberty without a means of economic independence, that is, would be a hollow form of liberty. A Black abolitionist, Hosea Easton, writing in 1837, also maintained that emancipation would not be enough. Any fair plan, he wrote, would need “to restore to [the formerly enslaved] all that slavery has taken away from them. Merely to cease beating the colored people, and leave them to their gore, and call it emancipation, is nonsense.” David Walker’s radical abolitionist tract, Appeal to the Colored Citizens of the World (1829) is perhaps most famous for calling upon Southern Blacks to arm themselves and rise up in revolt against their masters. In addition to the economic debt owed to the formerly enslaved, Walker wrote that Blacks should not be satisfied until whites “make a national acknowledgement to us for the wrongs they have inflicted upon us.” (See Lynda Morgan, “Reparations and History,” Journal of African American History 99 (Fall 2014): 403-426; Finkenbine, supra, 103-104.) Today’s calls for reparations are similarly about more than an economic reckoning; it is also about “national acknowledgement” for wrongs committed.
From “Forty Acres and Mule” to the Ex-Slave Pension Movements: Perhaps the most significant efforts to compensate formerly enslaved persons for years of unpaid labor were the various land reform proposals put forward in the immediate wake of emancipation. These proposals were often referred to as the promise of “Forty Acres and a Mule” to each freedman. As the Union Army occupied parts of the South it found itself in possession of plantations that had been abandoned by their owners. The formerly enslaved who were not recruited into the Union Army were sometimes allowed to work plots of land, often forty acres. Most famously, General William T. Sherman’s “Special Field Order No. 15” would have provided for the confiscation of abandoned lands in the Sea Islands off South Carolina and a large swath of coastal land in South Carolina, Georgia, and parts of Northern Florida. While a small number of freedman obtained a forty acre plot in this manner, President Andrew Johnson, who took office upon Lincoln’s assassination, overturned Sherman’s order and restored the lands to their former owners. (Eric Foner, A Short History of Reconstruction (New York: 1988), 70-73; Roger Ransom and Richard Sutch, One Kind of Freedom: Economic Consequences of Emancipation (Cambridge: 1977), 81-87.)
In addition to federal efforts, many of the individual Southern states, so long as they were controlled by Republicans, attempted to implement various homesteads acts and similar land reform proposals. These plans were more varied and more complicated than providing “forty acres and a mule” to each freedman, but the plans all assumed that, in one way or another, large plantations that had been worked by enslaved persons for more than 200 years should be broken up and allotted to the formerly enslaved persons to operate as small, family-owned farms. Land reform proposals recognized that nearly four million emancipated African Americans were entitled to compensation of some sort, and that land would provide a means of economic independence. Economic independence, in turn, ensured that freed persons would not become economically dependent on former masters. Except for a few scattered examples, all of these land reform efforts failed, and in any event, all such efforts were abandoned once Northern Republicans abandoned Reconstruction and Southern Democrats regained political control. Freed persons who did not leave the South found themselves locked into a sharecropping and crop lien system that left most poor, propertyless, indebted, and ultimately dependent upon white landowners. Nonetheless, the phrase “Forty Acres and Mule” survived as a reminder of an early acknowledgement of the justice and reasonableness of reparations for slavery. (Ransom and Sutch, supra, especially Chapters 4-8.)
The failure of land reform and the broken promise of “forty acres and a mule” did not end calls for reparations. In the late 19th century, African Americans formed numerous “mutual benefit” associations to help each other in hard times. Some of these associations also began to lobby Congress to enact “ex-slave pensions” for former slaves and their immediate offspring. The movement appears to have been inspired at least in part by the dramatic expansion of Civil War pensions to widows and children of former Union soldiers (made possible by a surplus of federal revenue in the late 19th century). If the federal government could provide pensions to the widows and children of Union soldiers, then it seemed just and reasonable to provide pensions to former slaves and their families for the unpaid labor that they had performed in producing a substantial part of the nation’s wealth.
In 1890, advocates finally persuaded a Nebraska Congressman to introduce a bill for ex-slave pensions. Although the bill was never enacted, it drew the support not only from organizations of former slaves, but also from a handful of Southerners who believed that the pensions would provide an economic stimulus for the South. Perhaps the most famous advocate of ex-slave pensions was Callie House, a former slave and seamstress in Nashville, Tennessee. In 1898, House and others formed the National Ex-Slave Mutual Relief, Bounty, and Pension Association (MRBPA). The MRBPA operated as both a traditional “mutual benefit” association – providing burial expenses and benefits to widows – as well as a national lobbying organization dedicated to the cause of ex-slave pensions. According to historian Mary Frances Berry, however, their activism on this front earned them the attention of U.S. Department of Justice, the Postmaster General, and the Bureau of Pensions. Federal authorities argued that the organization engaged in “mail fraud” when it solicited funds, in part on the assumption that it was fraudulent to collect money by promising pensions that Congress would never enact. While Berry found no evidence that the group engaged in fraud or enriched themselves with member donations, the federal government eventually convicted House of mail fraud and sentenced her to one year in federal prison in 1917. The prosecution of House effectively ended the MRBPA. According to Berry, however, the belief in the justness of compensation for unpaid labor continued. Berry notes that as late as 1934, a former slave writing to President Franklin D. Roosevelt during the Great Depression asked the President what had come of the idea of “giving pensions in payment for our long days of servitude.” [Mary Frances Berry, “Reparations for Freedmen, 1890-1916: Fraudulent Practices or Justice Deferred?” Journal of Negro History 57 (July 1972): 219-230; Berry gives a fuller account of House and her efforts in her book, My Face is Black Is True: Callie House and the Struggle for Ex-Slave Reparations (New York: 2005.)]
Modern Movements for Reparations: While the ex-slave pension movement had apparently run its course, or been effectively suppressed, by the early 20th century, calls for “reparations” (as opposed to “pensions”) were forcefully revived in the 1960s. Like the earlier movements, the modern calls for reparations are rooted in a conviction that the nation has never accounted for the critical role that slavery played in the economic development of the nation and the fact that national prosperity throughout the 19th century rested to a large extent on unpaid slave labor. Unlike the earlier movements, however, the modern movements stress that reparations are owed not only for unpaid labor under slavery, but even more so for the continuing legacy of slavery, including de jure and de facto segregation, employment discrimination, public and private “redlining” and related discriminatory real estate practices, and the resulting racial disparities in income and wealth, educational attainment, health and wellness, and rates of incarceration. These later developments, all in one way or another a legacy of slavery and the racist ideas that tried to justify it, took place within the lifetimes of living persons. The effects are ongoing. (See e.g. Michelle Alexander, The New Jim Crow: Mass Incarceration in the Age of Colorblindness, (New York: 2012).)
Arguably the “modern” movement for reparations began with James Foreman’s “Black Manifesto” in 1969. Foreman, a veteran of the Civil Rights movement of the late 1950s and early 1960s had become a leader of the Black Power movement by the later 1960s. In 1969, Foreman and the National Black Economic Development Conference (NBEDC) developed what became known as the “Black Manifesto,” which called upon major religious institutions, many of whom benefitted from slavery, to pay reparations. Most famously, Foreman read the Manifesto while interrupting Sunday services at the Riverside Church in New York City in May of 1969. Believing that white Christian churches and Jewish synagogues had profited from slavery, Foreman demanded that they create a fund of 500 million dollars for reparations. Foreman reasoned that, with just over 30 million Blacks in the United States, this amounted to only about $15 per African American citizen – a modest amount in light of the injustices of slavery. Not surprisingly, Foreman did not advocate providing each African American with a negligible and insulting check of $15; rather, he proposed that the money be used to launch four different initiatives: (1) a “land bank” that would allow Blacks to acquire farms in the South, including for cooperative farms; (2) four publishing and printing companies to provide an alternative to the white-dominated printing and publishing industry; (3) four television networks to provide “an alternative to the racist propaganda that fills the current televisions networks;” and (4) a research center that would provide “research on the problems of black people.” (The text of Forman’s “Black Manifesto” is available in many places online, including at “The Church Awakens: African Americans and the Struggle for Justice,” at https://episcopalarchives.org/church-awakens/items/show/202.)
Although the tone of Foreman’s manifesto was quite radical, his specific proposals are quite instructive and relevant to the current debate over reparations. As recent hearings in Congress and news media debates make clear, many critics of reparations assume that any reparations plan will take the form of “writing checks” to descendants of African-American slaves, no matter how remote the recipient’s relation to an enslaved person and regardless of economic need. However, most modern advocates do not assume that reparations will take the form of direct payments to descendants, except in rare cases where a meaningful link between a specific victim and a specific perpetrator can be established. While the notion of reparation “payments” to descendants has not been entirely abandoned, the leading organizations calling for reparations today take a broad, investment-based approach. For example, the National Coalition of Blacks for Reparations in America (N’COBRA), founded by Imari Obadele in 1987, argues that reparations can take “as many forms as necessary to equitably address the many forms of injury caused by chattel slavery and its continuing vestiges.” In some cases, reparations could take the form of “cash payments” to particular descendants, but more effective reparations will support “economic development [and] . . . funds for scholarships and community development; creation of multi-media depictions of the history of Black people . . . textbooks for educational institutions that tell the story from the African descendant’s perspective; development of historical monuments and museums; the return of artifacts and art to appropriate people or institutions; exoneration of political prisoners; and, the elimination of laws and practices that maintain dual systems in the major areas of life . . . The forms of reparations received should improve the lives of African descendants in the United States for future generations to come; foster economic, social, and political parity; and allow for full rights of self-determination.” (See N’COBRA’s statement of purpose at https://www.ncobraonline.org/reparations/)
The Failure of Litigation Shows the Need for Reparations: While movements for reparations have typically lobbied legislative bodies to provide compensation or establish programs that seek restorative justice, another track has used litigation in an attempt to obtain redress from persons, businesses, corporations, and other institutions that profited from slavery. In some cases, litigants have attempted to obtain damages for specific incidents, identifying specific plaintiffs harmed by specific defendants, such as the unsuccessful lawsuit against local agencies in Tulsa, Oklahoma, for the Tulsa riot of 1921, in which hundreds of African Americans were killed and homes and businesses destroyed. (Alexander v. Oklahoma (2004) 382 F.3d 1206; Id., 391 F.3d 1155 (En Banc), Lucero, J., dissenting.) Other lawsuits have taken a broader approach, identifying corporations that profited from transporting, insuring, financing, or otherwise supporting the slave system more generally. For example, Harvard Law Professor Charles Ogletree and his associates sued Aetna insurance and other institutions for their role in insuring and financing slavery. For the most part, these litigation effects have failed for a variety of reasons, including the running of statutes of limitation, the inability of descendants to establish legal “standing” to sue, or simply the inability of litigants, after so many years, to establish a causal nexus between the plaintiff’s alleged harm and the defendant’s alleged wrongdoing. (See e.g. the consolidated case, In Re African-American Slave Descendants Litigation (2006) 471 F.3d 754.)
What these failures demonstrate is that litigation is probably not the most fruitful avenue for seeking reparations. Critics of reparations have made arguments that echo those made the courts when dismissing actions. For example, they note the difficulty of identifying victims and perpetrators or establishing the requisite causal nexus for events long since passed. (See e.g. David Horowitz, “Ten Reasons Why Reparations for Slavery for a Bad Idea for Blacks – And Racist Too,” Frontpage Online, January 3, 2001. For a very recent example, see Jason Riley, “The Illogic of Slavery Reparation at This Late Date,” Wall Street Journal, March 19, 2019.) However, one could argue that these difficulties are not so much an argument against reparations as they are an argument against relying upon a litigation strategy. Indeed, it is precisely because the injustices of slavery and its legacy are not easily subject to traditional judicial remedies or judicial standards that makes reparations a “political question” appropriate for the representative branches of government. Unlike a judge ruling on a dispute between two parties, the representative branches of government do not need to establish direct causal links by a preponderance of evidence or beyond a reasonable doubt. Instead, a legislative or administrative body is free to remedy past and continuing injustices as a matter of making humane and equitable public policy. In sum, the court cases do not suggest the impossibility of reparations; they suggest that a remedy for such obvious injustices as slavery and continuing institutional racism may need to come from the other branches of government.
The Present Debate: The recent attention to reparations is almost certainly attributable to Ta-Nehisi Coates compelling article, “The Case for Reparations,” in the June, 2014, issue of the Atlantic. Not surprisingly, Coates was the first witness to testify in hearings that the House Judiciary Committee held in June of 2019, on the five-year anniversary of the article. Although Coates’ article certainly did not ignore the era of slavery and Jim Crow, the bulk of his article focused on Chicago in the years following World War II, when the policies of private lenders, insurance companies, and the federal government frustrated the efforts of African Americans to obtain the primary means of middle class wealth accumulation and the inter-generational transfer of wealth: home ownership. In addition, these policies perpetuated the problems of “white flight,” which carried a revenue base to white suburbs while allowing the increasingly African American cities to suffer from want of municipal services. Coates relates the stories of several African Americans who through hope, faith, hard work, and perseverance managed to become home owners against all odds. Behind the handful of success stories, however, were many more who lost their homes, as well as any equity that they would have earned if they had been able to obtain a mortgage. Coates highlights many themes outlined in the history described above: that the legacy of slavery is not merely a matter of oppression but of “theft;” that the theft did not end with emancipation but continued well into the 20th century and even into our own times; and that it will be difficult to heal the wounds of the past without some form of acknowledgement and restorative justice. Coates analysis of housing policy in Chicago is amply supported by historical studies in other cities, many of which are cited in his article.
However, the “theft” described by Coates was not restricted to African Americans in urban areas. In the most recent (September 2019) issue of the Atlantic, Vann Newkirk examines Black ownership of farmlands in rural Mississippi. His story provides a fascinating parallel to the one told by Coates about obstacles to Black homeownership in Chicago. Despite legal, extralegal, and illegal efforts to prevent African Americans in the South from owning land – and thereby escaping the burdens of the sharecropping system – a surprising number of Africans Americans somehow managed to purchase and successfully operate small farms throughout the South. Most even kept their land through the hardships of the Great Depression. Newkirk finds that most African Americans lost farmland later, between 1950 and 1969. Newkirk’s research, and numerous studies cited in his article, document the racially discriminatory practices of the federal Farm Home Administration and the federally subsidized investment that transformed large parts of the South from a patchwork of small family farms into large enterprises owned by corporations with no connection to the South or the operation of those farms. Newkirk concludes that many African Americans lost their farmlands by a combination of legal and illegal means that were either encouraged or tolerated by government policies. As noted above, efforts to obtain reparations through litigation have failed because of the difficulty in establishing causal connections and individual culpability. Newkirk recognizes this complexity. In discussing contemporary conversations about responsibility and reparations, Newkirk writes:
But that conversation too easily becomes technical. How do we quantify discrimination? How do we define who was discriminated against? How do we repay those people according to what has been defined and quantified? The idea of reparations sometimes seems like a problem of economic rightsizing—something for the quants and wonks to work out. (Vann R. Newkirk III, “The Great Land Robbery,” The Atlantic September 2019.)
However, while the manner in which the injustices occurred may be complex and technical –whether it is the loss of farmland in the rural South or the obstacles of home ownership in the urban North and West – they were clear injustices nonetheless.
In sum, the point of offering this historical overview of reparations movements from the American Revolution to the present is not merely to compile a chronology of anecdotes, but also to show that history reveals a deep, long-standing, thoughtful, and well-supported belief that slavery constituted a form of theft that has barely been acknowledgement, let alone compensated. The history shows that calls for reparations, while ultimately unsuccessful, drew the support of a cross-section of Americans of all races. It shows that calls for reparations have always recognized the complex and diffuse nature of moral culpability in a slave society and, therefore, that meaningful reparations will need to take varied forms. Finally, this history shows that the movement for reparations, especially in its more modern forms, has recognized that the harms of slavery did not end with emancipation and the Civil War, but that they lasted well into the 20th century and continue into our own time.
H.R. 40: The Commission to Study and Develop Reparations Proposals for African Americans Act: Although first introduced in 1989 as H.R. 3745, beginning in 1997 Representative Conyers secured the number “40” for each bill introduced thereafter in order to reference the broken post-Civil War promises of “forty acres and a mule.” H.R. 40 does not require reparations payments to African American descendants of enslaved persons, nor does it propose any other specific programs to compensate or offer any other benefit to descendants. Rather, H.R. 40 simply provides for the establishment of a commission “to study and consider a national apology and proposal for reparations for the institution of slavery, its subsequent de jure and de facto racial and economic discrimination against African-Americans, and the impact of these forces on living African Americans.” Based upon its study and findings, the Commission would then make recommendations to Congress “on appropriate remedies.” Although the popular conception of reparations is that it will result in some form of direct payments to African Americans – which would create a number of practical questions about just who would fund and receive payments – H.R. 40, like many calls for reparations over the years, recognizes that reparations and reconciliation could take many forms. Indeed, the purpose of the study is not only to document injustices and calculate the extent of harmful legacies, but to also study the appropriate means and forms any recompense might take.
H.R. 40 specifies that the Commission shall be composed of thirteen members, who shall be appointed within 90 days of enactment, and that it must hold its first meeting within 120 days after enactment. The members will consist of three persons appointed by the U.S. President, three by the Speaker of the House, and one by President pro tempore of the Senate. Six additional members would be selected from “the major civil society and reparations organizations that have historically championed the cause of reparatory justice.” All of the members shall be selected because of their “education, training, activism or experience, particularly in the field of African-American studies and reparatory justice.” The Commission will have the power to hold hearings, procure witnesses and documents (by subpoena or other court order if necessary), and hire experts and consultants. The Commission would then submit a report to Congress no later than one year after its first meeting. There is no requirement, of course, that Congress act on this report.
Has H.R. 40’s Time Finally Come? Because of the renewed attention attributable to the Coates’ article, the reparations movement is experiencing a revival. Many of the Democratic candidates seeking to run for president in 2020 have endorsed H.R. 40 and are at least entertaining the issue of reparations. This renewed attention prompted the House Judiciary Committee to hold hearings on the long-standing measure for the first time since 2007. Perhaps this time H.R. 40 will finally reach the floor of the House for a vote. How it fairs after that will probably hinge upon the outcome of the 2020 election. It is also possible that, as in the past, interest in the issue will once again prove fleeting and dissipate in the wake of the 2020 election, regardless of the outcome. Since 1989, the shifting balance of political power in Congress and the White House has not had any apparent impact on the fate of H.R. 40, but support seems to be growing. In 2016-2017, Representative Conyers’ bill had 35 co-sponsors. In the current session, Representative Lee’s version had 114 co-sponsors at last count.
This resolution, therefore, comes at an opportune time, allowing the California Legislature to use its voice to help to finally bring H.R. 40 to the House floor for a vote, at the very least, and perhaps even to become law. To reiterate, however, even if H.R. 40 did become law, it would not provide for reparations. It would create a Commission to study the issue of reparations and, if it finds that reparations are in order, to consider the varied forms that such reparations might take. The Commission will not have the power to enact any policies; rather, it will only make recommendations to Congress, which Congress might or might not follow. That Congress has failed to act on such a modest proposal to address such an important issue is a troubling indication of our reluctance to come to terms with our sometimes agonizing history. H.R. 40 urges us to overcome this reluctance.
California’s Complicity: In addition to urging enactment of H.R. 40, this resolution also seeks to acknowledge and apologize for the California Legislature’s complicity in slavery and the legacy of slavery. The author’s background material mentions California’s Fugitive Slave Act, which, like the federal Fugitive Slave Act, ensured that enslaved persons who escaped to California would be returned to their owners with the assistance of local authorities. Despite the fact that California entered into the Union in 1850 as a “free state,” African American slavery continued in scattered locations and for brief periods of time. For example, Archy Lee, was brought to California from Mississippi by his owner, Charles Stovall, in 1857. The federal and state fugitive slave laws allowed masters to bring slaves into free states for a short period of time as “sojourners” (that is, they were traveling through the state or visiting only for a short period of time). To allow owners to bring slaves into free states for any extended period of time would have made a mockery of the “free state” status. Stovall and Archy Lee apparently resided in the state for several months, much longer than what the law would have reasonably thought a “sojourn.” When Stovall decided to return to Mississippi and to take Lee with him, local abolitionists helped Lee escape and gave him safe harbor. In 1858 Stovall sued for Lee’s return in Sacramento Superior Court, but the judge denied the request on the quite reasonable grounds that California was a free state and Lee was, therefore, a free man. There was nothing in California law, the court reasoned, that would allow law enforcement to seize Archy Lee. However, the California Supreme Court – on the stunningly irrelevant grounds that Stovall was young, in poor health, and not aware of California law – overturned the trial court. Abolitionists refused to turn Lee over, however, and took the matter to a federal court, which overturned the California Supreme Court and ruled in Lee’s favor. The federal judge found that the fugitive slave law did not apply because Lee had not crossed any state lines as a “fugitive,” but had been voluntarily brought into a free state. Lee, understandably perhaps, moved to Canada, where he reportedly died in 1873.
We do not know how many other African Americans were brought to “free” California by their purported “owners,” but it seems safe to assume that Archy Lee was not the only one. Others could have been returned to their purported owners under the state and federal fugitive slave laws and a broad reading of what it meant to “sojourn.” California, as the author of this resolution contends, clearly was complicit in slavery, despite its being a “free” state. [On California’s Fugitive Slave Act and the Archy Lee case see, Rudolph Lapp, Archy Lee: A California Fugitive Slave Case (San Francisco: 1969); Stacey Smith, “Remaking Slavery in a Free State,” Pacific Historical Review 80 (2011); and William Franklin, “The Archy Case: The California Supreme Court Refuses to Free a Slave,” Pacific Historical Review 32 (1963.)]
This resolution cites another example of “slavery,” or at least “virtual slavery,” in California: the 1850 “Act for the Government and Protection of Indians.” Although this Act, strictly speaking, did not enslave Native Americans in California, it did contain a number of provisions creating various forms of “coerced labor,” such as the “apprenticing” of Native American orphans (which often looked more like kidnapping than apprenticing) and the convict leasing of Native Americans arrested for criminal offenses. (See e.g. Stacey Smith, Freedom’s Frontier: California and the Struggle over Unfree Labor, Emancipation, and Reconstruction (Chapel Hill: 2013).)
In light of California’s own history, and the California Legislature’s role in sustaining slavery, this resolution would acknowledge and formally apologize for the Legislature’s “past complicity in furthering the practice of slavery in California against African Americans, Native Americans, and others.”
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author, our country “cannot begin to address the incredible racial inequities still prevalent in our society until we accept and work towards redress of the country’s original sin: the trafficking and enslavement of millions Africans and their descendants. The notion that slaves, and their descendants, deserve reparations for the immoral and unjust practice of human ownership and forced work has been around for over 150 years. While slavery was abolished by the 13th Amendment to the Constitution of the United States, African Americans continued to face the debilitating economic, education, and health hardships as a result of targeted discriminatory policies. AJR 21 declares California’s support for H.R. 40, introduced by Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee, to establish a federal commission to study and develop proposals for reparations to descendants of enslaved persons in the United States. Furthermore, AJR 21 acknowledges and formally apologizes for the Legislature’s past complicity in enabling and furthering the practice of slavery in California.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
None on file
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):