SB 1446: Grocery retail store and retail drug establishment employees: self-service checkout and consequential workplace technology.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-08-05
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-08-15: Coauthors revised.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law imposes certain requirements on grocery employers, as defined, upon the purchase or change in control of a grocery establishment, including requiring a successor grocery employer to retain eligible grocery workers for a specified period after transfer of the grocery establishment.
This bill would prohibit a grocery retail store or a retail drug establishment, as those terms are defined, from providing a self-service checkout option for customers unless specified conditions are satisfied, including having no more than 2 self-service checkout stations monitored by any one employee and requiring the employee to be relieved of all other duties. The bill would require a grocery retail store or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout to include self-service checkout in the employers illness and prevention program, as required by Division of Occupational Safety and Health regulations. The bill would require a grocery retail store or retail drug establishment that intends to implement consequential workplace technology, as defined, to notify workers, their collective bargaining representatives, and the public at least 60 days in advance of the implementation of the technology with a general description of the technology and the intended purpose for of the technology. technology, as specified. This bill would establish remedies and penalties for a violation of the bills provisions, including a civil penalty of $100 for each day in violation, not to exceed an aggregate penalty of $10,000.
Existing law imposes certain requirements on grocery employers, as defined, upon the purchase or change in control of a grocery establishment, including requiring a successor grocery employer to retain eligible grocery workers for a specified period after transfer of the grocery establishment.
This bill would prohibit a grocery establishment retail store or a retail drug establishment, as those terms are defined, from providing a self-service checkout option for customers unless specified conditions are satisfied, including having no more than 2 self-service checkout stations monitored by any one employee and requiring the employee to be relieved of all other duties. The bill would require a grocery establishment retail store or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout to include self-service checkout in the employers illness and prevention program, as required by Division of Occupational Safety and Health regulations. The bill would require a grocery establishment retail store or retail drug establishment that intends to implement consequential workplace technology, as defined, to notify workers, their collective bargaining representatives, and the public 60 days in advance with a general description of the technology and the intended purpose for the technology. This bill would establish remedies and penalties for a violation of the bills provisions, including a civil penalty of $100 for each day in violation, not to exceed an aggregate penalty of $10,000.
Existing law imposes certain requirements on grocery employers, as defined, upon the purchase or change in control of a grocery establishment, including requiring a successor grocery employer to retain eligible grocery workers for a specified period after transfer of the grocery establishment.
This bill would prohibit a grocery establishment or a retail drug establishment, as those terms are defined, from providing a self-service checkout option for customers unless specified conditions are satisfied, including having no more than 2 self-service checkout stations monitored by any one employee and requiring the employee to be relieved of all other duties. The bill would require a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout to include self-service checkout in the employers illness and prevention program, as required by Division of Occupational Safety and Health regulations. The bill would require a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that uses or procures a intends to implement consequential workplace technology, as defined, to complete a worker and customer impact assessment before using or procuring the consequential workplace technology. The bill would require the assessment to include, among other things, the salaries, benefits, jobs, and work hours that would be eliminated by the consequential workplace technology. The bill would require the grocery establishment or retail drug establishment to notify specified workers and their collective bargaining representative at least 60 days before conducting the assessment, to provide the assessment to specified employees or their collective bargaining representatives at least 60 days before implementation of the consequential workplace technology, and to post a copy of the assessment in a location accessible to its employees and customers before, and for at least 90 days following, implementation of the consequential workplace technology. to notify workers, their collective bargaining representatives, and the public 60 days in advance with a general description of the technology and the intended purpose for the technology.
Existing law imposes certain requirements on grocery employers, as defined, upon the purchase or change in control of a grocery establishment, including requiring a successor grocery employer to retain eligible grocery workers for a specified period after transfer of the grocery establishment.
This bill would prohibit a grocery establishment or a retail drug establishment, as those terms are defined, from providing a self-service checkout option for customers unless specified conditions are satisfied, including having no more than 2 self-service checkout stations monitored by any one employee and requiring the employee to be relieved of all other duties. The bill would require a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout to include self-service checkout in a specified analysis of potential work hazards for purposes of their injury and illness prevention programs. the employers illness and prevention program, as required by Division of Occupational Safety and Health regulations. The bill would require a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that develops or implements technology that significantly affects the essential job functions or eliminates jobs or essential job functions of its employees, or that enables self-service, to complete a specified assessment before implementing the technology. uses or procures a consequential workplace technology, as defined, to complete a worker and customer impact assessment before using or procuring the consequential workplace technology. The bill would require the study assessment to include, among other things, the salaries, benefits, jobs, and work hours that would be eliminated by the consequential workplace technology. The bill would require the grocery establishment or retail drug establishment to notify and solicit input from its employees at least 60 days before drafting the study, specified workers and their collective bargaining representative at least 60 days before conducting the assessment, to provide the study to assessment to specified employees or their collective bargaining representatives at least 60 days before implementation, implementation of the consequential workplace technology, and to post a copy of the study assessment in a location accessible to its employees and customers before, and for at least 90 days following, implementation of the consequential workplace technology.
Existing law imposes certain requirements on grocery employers, as defined, upon the purchase or change in control of a grocery establishment, including requiring a successor grocery employer to retain eligible grocery workers for a specified period after transfer of the grocery establishment.
This bill would prohibit a grocery establishment or a retail drug establishment establishment, as those terms are defined, from providing a self-service checkout option for customers unless specified conditions are satisfied, including having no more than 2 self-service checkout stations monitored by any one employee and requiring the employee to be relieved of all other duties. The bill would require a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout to include self-service checkout in a specified analysis of potential work hazards for purposes of their injury and illness prevention programs. The bill would require a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that develops or implements technology that significantly affects the essential job functions or eliminates jobs or essential job functions of its employees, or that enables self-service, to complete a specified assessment before implementing the technology. The bill would require the study to include, among other things, the salaries, benefits, jobs, and work hours that would be eliminated by the workplace technology. The bill would require the grocery establishment or retail drug establishment to notify and solicit input from its employees at least 60 days before drafting the study, to provide the study to employees or their collective bargaining representatives at least 60 days before implementation, and to post a copy of the study in a location accessible to its employees and customers before, and for at least 90 days following, implementation of the workplace technology.
Existing law imposes certain requirements on grocery employers, as defined, upon the purchase or change in control of a grocery establishment, including requiring a successor grocery employer to retain eligible grocery workers for a specified period after transfer of the grocery establishment.
This bill would prohibit a grocery establishment or a retail drug establishment from providing a self-service checkout option for customers unless specified conditions are satisfied, including having no more than 2 self-service checkout stations monitored by any one employee and requiring the employee to be relieved of all other duties. The bill would require a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout to include self-service checkout in a specified analysis of potential work hazards for purposes of their injury and illness prevention programs. The bill would require a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that develops or implements technology that significantly affects the essential job functions or eliminates jobs or essential job functions of its employees, or that enables self-service, to complete a specified assessment before implementing the technology. The bill would require the study to include, among other things, the salaries, benefits, jobs, and work hours that would be eliminated by the workplace technology. The bill would require the grocery establishment or retail drug establishment to notify and solicit input from its employees at least 60 days before drafting the study, to provide the study to employees or their collective bargaining representatives at least 60 days before implementation, and to post a copy of the study in a location accessible to its employees and customers before, and for at least 90 days following, implementation of the workplace technology.
Existing law requires the Department of Industrial Relations to keep advised of the industrial conditions in the state that affect employment of labor and, in certain specified circumstances, study and report to the Governor whether a period of extraordinary unemployment caused by industrial depression exists.This bill would additionally require the department to report its findings to appropriate committees of the Legislature.Existing law requires the Department of Industrial Relations to keep advised of the industrial conditions in the state that affect employment of labor and, in certain specified circumstances, study and report to the Governor whether a period of extraordinary unemployment caused by industrial depression exists.
This bill would additionally require the department to report its findings to appropriate committees of the Legislature.
For purposes of this part, the following definitions shall apply:
(a)Consequential workplace technology means artificial intelligence or automated decisionmaking systems technology that significantly impacts, eliminates, or automates eliminates, automates, or electronically monitors the core job functions agreed upon between an employer and an employee upon hire or following a subsequent change in position or department. Consequential workplace technology includes, but is not limited to, self-checkout robotics, wearable sensors, scanners, and electronic monitoring. and scanners.
(b)(1)Grocery retail store includes either of the following:
(A)A grocery establishment, defined as a retail store in this state that is over 15,000 square feet in size and that sells primarily household foodstuffs for offsite consumption, including the sale of fresh produce, meats, poultry, fish, deli products, dairy products, canned foods, dry foods, beverages, baked foods, or prepared foods. Other household supplies or other products shall be secondary to the primary purpose of food sales.
(B)A superstore, defined as a store in this state that is over 75,000 square feet in size, that generates sales or use tax pursuant to the BradleyBurns Bradley-Burns Uniform Local Sales and Use Tax Law (Part 1.5 (commencing with Section 7200) of Division 2 of the Revenue and Taxation Code), and that devotes more than 10 percent of sales floor area to the sale of nontaxable merchandise.
(2)For purposes of Section 2531 only, grocery retail store does not include a discount warehouse or retail store where more than one-half of the items carried by the discount warehouse or retail store are sold in large quantities or in bulk and the discount warehouse or retail store requires shoppers to pay a membership or assessment fee.
(c)Manual checkout station means a station that is not a self-service checkout station and at which an employee provides human assistance to a customer scanning, bagging, or accepting payment for the customers purchases.
(d)Retail drug establishment means a person, including an individual, a corporation, a partnership, a limited partnership, a limited liability partnership, a limited liability company, a business trust, an estate, a trust, an association, a joint venture, a proprietorship, a joint venture, an agency, an instrumentality, a corporate officer, an executive, or any other legal or commercial entity, whether domestic or foreign, that has 75 or more businesses or establishments located within the state and is identified as a retail business or establishment in the North American Industry Classification System within the retail trade category 45611.
(e)Self-service checkout means an automated process that enables customers to scan, bag, and pay for their purchases without human assistance.
(f)Self-service checkout station means a station at which a customer can engage in a self-service checkout for the customers purchases.
2531.(a)A grocery retail store or retail drug establishment shall not provide a self-service checkout option for customers unless all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(1)At least one manual checkout station is staffed by an employee of the establishment who is available to any given customer at the time that a self-service checkout option is made available to that customer.
(2)(A)The employer has established a workplace policy that limits self-service checkouts to purchases of no more than 15 items.
(B)The establishment shall include signage within the self-service checkout area indicating the number of items that are permitted through the self-service checkout station.
(3)Customers are prohibited from using self-service checkout to purchase either of the following:
(A)Items that require customers to provide a form of identification, including, but not limited to, alcohol and tobacco products.
(B)Items subject to special theft-deterrent measures, including, but not limited to, locked cabinets and electronic article surveillance tags, that require the intervention of an employee of the establishment for the customer to access or purchase the item.
(4)(A)No more than two self-service checkout stations are simultaneously monitored by any one employee of the establishment.
(B)An employee shall be relieved from all other duties when monitoring a self-service checkout station, including, but not limited to, operating a manual checkout station.
(b)A grocery retail store or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout shall include self-service checkout in their analysis of potential work hazards for purposes of their injury and illness prevention programs required by Section 3203 of Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations.
2532.(a)If a grocery retail store or a retail drug establishment intends to implement consequential workplace technology, the grocery retail store or retail drug establishment shall notify workers, their collective bargaining representatives, and the public at least 60 days in advance of the implementation of the technology with a general description of the technology and the intended purpose for of the technology. technology pursuant to subdivision (c).
(b)If a grocery retail store or retail drug establishment intends to implement consequential workplace technology for a purpose other than the intended purpose specified in the notice described in subdivision (a), the grocery retail store or retail drug establishment shall notify workers, their collective representatives, and the public of the other purpose 60 days in advance of the implementation of the technology pursuant to subdivision (c).
(c)(1)The grocery retail store or retail drug establishment shall notify workers and their collective bargaining representatives in writing by usual means of communication.
(2)The grocery retail store or retail drug establishment shall notify the public by posting the notice in a location accessible to the grocery retail stores or retail drug establishments employees and customers.
2533.(a)An employer who violates this part shall be subject to a civil penalty of one hundred dollars ($100) for each day in violation, not to exceed an aggregate penalty of ten thousand dollars ($10,000).
(b)Upon the filing of a complaint by an employee, the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement shall enforce this part, including investigating an alleged violation, and ordering appropriate relief.
(c)In addition to other remedies as may be provided by the laws of this state or its subdivisions, any public prosecutor, as defined by Section 180, may also institute an action for a violation of this part, including an action seeking injunctive relief.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.For purposes of this part, the following definitions shall apply:
(a)Consequential workplace technology means artificial intelligence or automated decisionmaking systems that significantly impacts, eliminates, or automates the core job functions agreed upon between an employer and an employee upon hire or following a subsequent change in position or department. Consequential workplace technology includes, but is not limited to, self-checkout robotics, wearable sensors, scanners, and electronic monitoring.
(b)Grocery establishment is as defined in Section 2502.(b)(1)Grocery retail store includes either of the following:
(A)A grocery establishment, defined as a retail store in this state that is over 15,000 square feet in size and that sells primarily household foodstuffs for offsite consumption, including the sale of fresh produce, meats, poultry, fish, deli products, dairy products, canned foods, dry foods, beverages, baked foods, or prepared foods. Other household supplies or other products shall be secondary to the primary purpose of food sales.
(B)A superstore, defined as a store in this state that is over 75,000 square feet in size, that generates sales or use tax pursuant to the BradleyBurns Uniform Local Sales and Use Tax Law (Part 1.5 (commencing with Section 7200) of Division 2 of the Revenue and Taxation Code), and that devotes more than 10 percent of sales floor area to the sale of nontaxable merchandise.
(2)For purposes of Section 2531 only, grocery retail store does not include a discount warehouse or retail store where more than one-half of the items carried by the discount warehouse or retail store are sold in large quantities or in bulk and the discount warehouse or retail store requires shoppers to pay a membership or assessment fee.
(c)Manual checkout station means a station that is not a self-service checkout station and at which an employee provides human assistance to a customer scanning, bagging, or accepting payment for the customers purchases.
(d)Retail drug establishment means a person, including an individual, a corporation, a partnership, a limited partnership, a limited liability partnership, a limited liability company, a business trust, an estate, a trust, an association, a joint venture, a proprietorship, a joint venture, an agency, an instrumentality, a corporate officer, an executive, or any other legal or commercial entity, whether domestic or foreign, that has 75 or more businesses or establishments located within the state and is identified as a retail business or establishment in the North American Industry Classification System within the retail trade category 45611.
(e)Self-service checkout means an automated process that enables customers to scan, bag, and pay for their purchases without human assistance.
(f)Self-service checkout station means a station at which a customer can engage in a self-service checkout for the customers purchases.
2531.(a)A grocery establishment retail store or retail drug establishment shall not provide a self-service checkout option for customers unless all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(1)At least one manual checkout station is staffed by an employee of the establishment who is available to any given customer at the time that a self-service checkout option is made available to that customer.
(2)(A)The employer has established a workplace policy that limits self-service checkouts to purchases of no more than 15 items.
(B)The establishment shall include signage within the self-service checkout area indicating the number of items that are permitted through the self-service checkout station.
(3)Customers are prohibited from using self-service checkout to purchase either of the following:
(A)Items that require customers to provide a form of identification, including, but not limited to, alcohol and tobacco products.
(B)Items subject to special theft-deterrent measures, including, but not limited to, locked cabinets and electronic article surveillance tags, that require the intervention of an employee of the establishment for the customer to access or purchase the item.
(4)(A)No more than two self-service checkout stations are simultaneously monitored by any one employee of the establishment.
(B)An employee shall be relieved from all other duties when monitoring a self-service checkout station, including, but not limited to, operating a manual checkout station.
(b)A grocery establishment retail store or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout shall include self-service checkout in their analysis of potential work hazards for purposes of their injury and illness prevention programs required by Section 3203 of Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations.
2532.If an employer a grocery retail store or a retail drug establishment intends to implement consequential workplace technology, the employer grocery retail store or retail drug establishment shall notify workers, their collective bargaining representatives, and the public 60 days in advance with a general description of the technology and the intended purpose for the technology.
2533.(a)An employer who violates this part shall be subject to a civil penalty of one hundred dollars ($100) for each day in violation, not to exceed an aggregate penalty of ten thousand dollars ($10,000).
(b)Upon the filing of a complaint by an employee, the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement shall enforce this part, including investigating an alleged violation, and ordering appropriate relief.
(c)In addition to other remedies as may be provided by the laws of this state or its subdivisions, any public prosecutor, as defined by Section 180, may also institute an action for a violation of this part, including an action seeking injunctive relief.
For purposes of this part, the following definitions shall apply:
(a)Assessment or worker and consumer impact assessment means a study evaluating the potential negative effects on employees, consumers, or the public of a consequential workplace technology. The assessment shall include all of the following:(1)A detailed description of the consequential workplace technology, its intended purpose, and justification for adoption by the employer.(2)A description of the data used by the consequential workplace technology, including the specific categories of data that will be processed as input and any data used to train the technology.(3)The number of employees, identified by job classification, whose duties would be affected by the consequential workplace technology, as well as a description of how the duties of employees in each job classification would be affected.(4)The number of jobs, identified by job classification, that would be eliminated by the consequential workplace technology.(5)The number of work hours, identified by job classification, that would be eliminated by the consequential workplace technology.(6)The total amount of salaries and benefits that would be eliminated as a result of the consequential workplace technology.(7)A description of the potential gaps in skills of employees affected by the workplace technology that may result from the consequential workplace technology.(8)The total amount budgeted for, and descriptions of, training and retraining programs for affected employees.(9)An analysis of whether there will be human oversight of the consequential workplace technology.(10)An analysis of the potential effect of the consequential workplace technology on consumers, including any barriers to access that the technology could create for certain populations of consumers, including, but not limited to, seniors, the disabled, the unbanked, those without access to appropriate technology, youth, or other vulnerable populations, and what proportion of customers is likely to be impacted.(11)An analysis of the potential health and safety hazards created for employees, customers, or the public at large by the consequential workplace technology and what measures the employer will take to mitigate those potential hazards.(12)What data will be collected from employees and consumers by the consequential workplace technology and whether they will have the option to opt-out of personal data collection. (b)(a)Consequential workplace technology means artificial intelligence or automated decisionmaking systems that significantly impacts, eliminates, or automates the core job functions agreed upon between an employer and an employee upon hire or following a subsequent change in position or department. Consequential workplace technology includes, but is not limited to, self-checkout robotics, wearable sensors, scanners, and electronic monitoring.
(c)(b)Grocery establishment is as defined in Section 2502.
(d)(c)Manual checkout station means a station that is not a self-service checkout station and at which an employee provides human assistance to a customer scanning, bagging, or accepting payment for the customers purchases.
(e)(d)Retail drug establishment means a person, including an individual, a corporation, a partnership, a limited partnership, a limited liability partnership, a limited liability company, a business trust, an estate, a trust, an association, a joint venture, a proprietorship, a joint venture, an agency, an instrumentality, a corporate officer, an executive, or any other legal or commercial entity, whether domestic or foreign, that has 75 or more businesses or establishments located within the state and is identified as a retail business or establishment in the North American Industry Classification System within the retail trade category 45611.
(f)(e)Self-service checkout means an automated process that enables customers to scan, bag, and pay for their purchases without human assistance.
(g)(f)Self-service checkout station means a station at which a customer can engage in a self-service checkout for the customers purchases.
2531.(a)A grocery establishment or retail drug establishment shall not provide a self-service checkout option for customers unless all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(1)At least one manual checkout station is staffed by an employee of the establishment who is available to any given customer at the time that a self-service checkout option is made available to that customer.
(2)(A)The employer has established a workplace policy that limits self-service checkouts to purchases of no more than 15 items.
(B)The establishment shall include signage within the self-service checkout area indicating the number of items that are permitted through the self-service checkout station.
(3)Customers are prohibited from using self-service checkout to purchase either of the following:
(A)Items that require customers to provide a form of identification, including, but not limited to, alcohol and tobacco products.
(B)Items subject to special theft-deterrent measures, including, but not limited to, locked cabinets and electronic article surveillance tags, that require the intervention of an employee of the establishment for the customer to access or purchase the item.
(4)(A)No more than two self-service checkout stations are simultaneously monitored by any one employee of the establishment.
(B)An employee shall be relieved from all other duties when monitoring a self-service checkout station, including, but not limited to, operating a manual checkout station.
(b)A grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout shall include self-service checkout in their analysis of potential work hazards for purposes of their injury and illness prevention programs required by Section 3203 of Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations.
2532.(a)A grocery establishment or retail drug establishment shall complete a worker and consumer impact assessment before using or procuring a consequential workplace technology. The grocery establishment or retail drug establishment shall notify workers potentially impacted by the consequential workplace technology, and their collective bargaining representative, at least 60 days before conducting the assessment. The employer shall conduct all major phases of the assessment with the direct, meaningful, and sustained involvement of impacted employees and their collective bargaining representative, if applicable.(b)The assessment shall be provided to employees potentially affected by the consequential workplace technology, or their collective bargaining representative, 60 days before implementation of the consequential workplace technology. The grocery establishment or retail drug establishment shall post a copy of the assessment in a location accessible to its employees and customers before, and for at least 90 days following, implementation of the consequential workplace technology.2532.If an employer intends to implement consequential workplace technology, the employer shall notify workers, their collective bargaining representatives, and the public 60 days in advance with a general description of the technology and the intended purpose for the technology.
For purposes of this part, the following definitions shall apply:
(a)Assessment or worker and consumer impact assessment means a study evaluating the potential negative effects on employees, consumers, or the public of a consequential workplace technology. The assessment shall include all of the following:
(1)A detailed description of the consequential workplace technology, its intended purpose, and justification for adoption by the employer.
(2)A description of the data used by the consequential workplace technology, including the specific categories of data that will be processed as input and any data used to train the technology.
(3)The number of employees, identified by job classification, whose duties would be affected by the consequential workplace technology, as well as a description of how the duties of employees in each job classification would be affected.
(4)The number of jobs, identified by job classification, that would be eliminated by the consequential workplace technology.
(5)The number of work hours, identified by job classification, that would be eliminated by the consequential workplace technology.
(6)The total amount of salaries and benefits that would be eliminated as a result of the consequential workplace technology.
(7)A description of the potential gaps in skills of employees affected by the workplace technology that may result from the consequential workplace technology.
(8)The total amount budgeted for, and descriptions of, training and retraining programs for affected employees.
(9)An analysis of whether there will be human oversight of the consequential workplace technology.
(10)An analysis of the potential effect of the consequential workplace technology on consumers, including any barriers to access that the technology could create for certain populations of consumers, including, but not limited to, seniors, the disabled, the unbanked, those without access to appropriate technology, youth, or other vulnerable populations, and what proportion of customers is likely to be impacted.
(11)An analysis of the potential health and safety hazards created for employees, customers, or the public at large by the consequential workplace technology and what measures the employer will take to mitigate those potential hazards.
(12)What data will be collected from employees and consumers by the consequential workplace technology and whether they will have the option to opt-out of personal data collection.
(b)Consequential workplace technology means artificial intelligence or automated decisionmaking systems that significantly impacts, eliminates, or automates the core job functions agreed upon between an employer and an employee upon hire or following a subsequent change in position or department. Consequential workplace technology includes, but is not limited to, self-checkout robotics, wearable sensors, scanners, and electronic monitoring.
(a)(c)Grocery establishment is as defined in Section 2502.
(b)(d)Manual checkout station means a station that is not a self-service checkout station and at which an employee provides human assistance to a customer scanning, bagging, or accepting payment for the customers purchases.
(c)(e)Retail drug establishment means a person, including an individual, a corporation, a partnership, a limited partnership, a limited liability partnership, a limited liability company, a business trust, an estate, a trust, an association, a joint venture, a proprietorship, a joint venture, an agency, an instrumentality, a corporate officer, an executive, or any other legal or commercial entity, whether domestic or foreign, that has 75 or more businesses or establishments located within the state and is identified as a retail business or establishment in the North American Industry Classification System within the retail trade category 45611.
(d)(f)Self-service checkout means an automated process that enables customers to scan, bag, and pay for their purchases without human assistance.
(e)(g)Self-service checkout station means a station at which a customer can engage in a self-service checkout for the customers purchases.
2531.(a)A grocery establishment or retail drug establishment shall not provide a self-service checkout option for customers unless all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(1)At least one manual checkout station is staffed by an employee of the establishment who is available to any given customer at the time that a self-service checkout option is made available to that customer.
(2)(A)Self-service checkouts are limited to purchases of 10 or fewer items.(2)(A)The employer has established a workplace policy that limits self-service checkouts to purchases of no more than 15 items.
(B)The establishment shall include signage within the self-service checkout area indicating that only 10 or fewer items the number of items that are permitted through the self-service checkout station.
(3)Customers are prohibited from using self-service checkout to purchase either of the following:
(A)Items that require customers to provide a form of identification, including, but not limited to, alcohol and tobacco products.
(B)Items subject to special theft-deterrent measures, including, but not limited to, locked cabinets and electronic article surveillance tags, that require the intervention of an employee of the establishment for the customer to access or purchase the item.
(4)(A)No more than two self-service checkout stations are simultaneously monitored by any one employee of the establishment.
(B)An employee shall be relieved from all other duties when monitoring a self-service checkout station, including, but not limited to, operating a manual checkout station.
(b)A grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout shall include self-service checkout in their analysis of potential work hazards for purposes of their injury and illness prevention programs required by Section 3203 of Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations.
2532.(a)For purposes of this section, worker and consumer impact assessment means a study evaluating the potential negative effects on employees, consumers, or the public of a new or modified workplace technology that significantly affects the essential job functions of employees, eliminates jobs or essential job functions of employees, or that enables self-service by customers. A worker and consumer impact assessment shall include all of the following:(1)A detailed description of the workplace technology, its intended purpose, and justification for adoption by the employer.(2)A description of the data used by the technology, including the specific categories of data that will be processed as input and any data used to train the technology.(3)The number of employees, identified by job classification, whose duties would be affected by the workplace technology, as well as a description of how the duties of employees in each job classification would be affected.(4)The number of jobs, identified by job classification, that would be eliminated by the workplace technology.(5)The number of work hours, identified by job classification, that would be eliminated by the workplace technology.(6)The total amount of salaries and benefits that would be eliminated as a result of the workplace technology.(7)A description of the potential gaps in skills of employees affected by the workplace technology that may result from the workplace technology.(8)The total amount budgeted for, and descriptions of, training and retraining programs for affected employees.(9)An analysis of whether there will be human oversight of theworkplace technology.(10)An analysis of the potential effect of the workplace technology on consumers, including any barriers to access that the technology could create for certain populations of consumers, including, but not limited to, seniors, the disabled, the unbanked, those without access to appropriate technology, youth, or other vulnerable populations.(11)An analysis of the potential health and safety hazards created for employees, customers, or the public at large by the workplace technology and what measures the employer will take to mitigate those potential hazards.(12)What data will be collected from employees and consumers by the workplace technology and whether they will have the option to opt-out of personal data collection.(b)2532.(a)A grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that develops, procures, uses, or otherwise implements artificial intelligence, automation, or any new or modified technology that significantly affects the essential job functions of its employees, eliminates jobs or essential job functions of its employees, or that enables self-service by its customers shall complete a worker and consumer impact assessment before implementing the technology. The grocery establishment or retail drug establishment shall notify and solicit input from its employees potentially affected by the workplace technology, or their collective bargaining representative, at least 60 days before drafting the worker and consumer impact assessment. shall complete a worker and consumer impact assessment before using or procuring a consequential workplace technology. The grocery establishment or retail drug establishment shall notify workers potentially impacted by the consequential workplace technology, and their collective bargaining representative, at least 60 days before conducting the assessment. The employer shall conduct all major phases of the assessment with the direct, meaningful, and sustained involvement of impacted employees and their collective bargaining representative, if applicable.
(c)
(b)The worker and consumer impact assessment shall be provided to employees potentially affected by the consequential workplace technology, or their collective bargaining representative, 60 days before implementation of the consequential workplace technology. The grocery establishment or retail drug establishment shall also post a copy of the worker and consumer impact assessment in a location accessible to its employees and customers before, and for at least 90 days following, implementation of the consequential workplace technology.
For purposes of this part, the following definitions shall apply:
(a)Grocery establishment is as defined in Section 2502.
(b)Manual checkout station means a station that is not a self-service checkout station and at which an employee provides human assistance to a customer scanning, bagging, or accepting payment for the customers purchases.
(c)Retail drug establishment means a person, including an individual, a corporation, a partnership, a limited partnership, a limited liability partnership, a limited liability company, a business trust, an estate, a trust, an association, a joint venture, a proprietorship, a joint venture, an agency, an instrumentality, a corporate officer, an executive, or any other legal or commercial entity, whether domestic or foreign, that has one 75 or more businesses or establishments located within the state and is identified as a retail business or establishment in the North American Industry Classification System within the retail trade category 45611.
(d)Self-service checkout means an automated process that enables customers to scan, bag, and pay for their purchases without human assistance.
(e)Self-service checkout station means a station at which a customer can engage in a self-service checkout for the customers purchases.
2531.(a)A grocery establishment or retail drug establishment shall not provide a self-service checkout option for customers unless all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(1)At least one manual checkout station is staffed by an employee of the establishment who is available to any given customer at the time that a self-service checkout option is made available to that customer.
(2)(A)Self-service checkouts are limited to purchases of 10 or fewer items.
(B)The establishment shall include signage within the self-service checkout area indicating that only 10 or fewer items are permitted through the self-service checkout station.
(3)Customers are prohibited from using self-service checkout to purchase either of the following:
(A)Items that require customers to provide a form of identification, including, but not limited to, alcohol and tobacco products.
(B)Items subject to special theft-deterrent measures, including, but not limited to, locked cabinets and electronic article surveillance tags, that require the intervention of an employee of the establishment for the customer to access or purchase the item.
(4)(A)No more than two self-service checkout stations are simultaneously monitored by any one employee of the establishment.
(B)An employee shall be relieved from all other duties when monitoring a self-service checkout station, including, but not limited to, operating a manual checkout station.
(b)A grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout shall include self-service checkout in their analysis of potential work hazards for purposes of their injury and illness prevention programs required by Section 3203 of Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations.
2532.(a)For purposes of this section, worker and consumer impact assessment means a study evaluating the potential negative effects on employees, consumers, or the public of a new or modified workplace technology that significantly affects the essential job functions of employees, eliminates jobs or essential job functions of employees, or that enables self-service by customers. A worker and consumer impact assessment shall include all of the following:
(1)A detailed description of the workplace technology, its intended purpose, and justification for adoption by the employer.
(2)A description of the data used by the technology, including the specific categories of data that will be processed as input and any data used to train the technology.
(3)The number of employees, identified by job classification, whose duties would be affected by the workplace technology, as well as a description of how the duties of employees in each job classification would be affected.
(4)The number of jobs, identified by job classification, that would be eliminated by the workplace technology.
(5)The number of work hours, identified by job classification, that would be eliminated by the workplace technology.
(6)The total amount of salaries and benefits that would be eliminated as a result of the workplace technology.
(7)A description of the potential gaps in skills of employees affected by the workplace technology that may result from the workplace technology.
(8)The total amount budgeted for, and descriptions of, training and retraining programs for affected employees.
(9)An analysis of whether there will be human oversight of the workplace technology.
(10)An analysis of the potential effect of the workplace technology on consumers, including any barriers to access that the technology could create for certain populations of consumers, including, but not limited to, seniors, the disabled, the unbanked, those without access to appropriate technology, youth, or other vulnerable populations.
(11)An analysis of the potential health and safety hazards created for employees, customers, or the public at large by the workplace technology and what measures the employer will take to mitigate those potential hazards.
(12)What data will be collected from employees and consumers by the workplace technology and whether they will have the option to opt-out of personal data collection.
(b)A grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that develops, procures, uses, or otherwise implements artificial intelligence, automation, or any new or modified technology that significantly affects the essential job functions of its employees, eliminates jobs or essential job functions of its employees, or that enables self-service by its customers shall complete a worker and consumer impact assessment before implementing the technology. The grocery establishment or retail drug establishment shall notify and solicit input from its employees potentially affected by the workplace technology, or their collective bargaining representative, at least 60 days before drafting the worker and consumer impact assessment.
(c)The worker and consumer impact assessment shall be provided to employees potentially affected by the workplace technology, or their collective bargaining representative, 60 days before implementation of the workplace technology. The grocery establishment or retail drug establishment shall also post a copy of the worker and consumer impact assessment in a location accessible to its employees and customers before, and for at least 90 days following, implementation of the workplace technology.
For purposes of this part, the following definitions shall apply:
(a)Grocery establishment is as defined in Section 2502.
(b)Manual checkout station means a station that is not a self-service checkout station and at which an employee provides human assistance to a customer scanning, bagging, or accepting payment for the customers purchases.
(c)Retail drug establishment means a person, including an individual, a corporation, a partnership, a limited partnership, a limited liability partnership, a limited liability company, a business trust, an estate, a trust, an association, a joint venture, a proprietorship, a joint venture, an agency, an instrumentality, a corporate officer, an executive, or any other legal or commercial entity, whether domestic or foreign, that has one or more businesses or establishments located within the state and is identified as a retail business or establishment in the North American Industry Classification System within the retail trade category 45611.
(d)Self-service checkout means an automated process that enables customers to scan, bag, and pay for their purchases without human assistance.
(e)Self-service checkout station means a station at which a customer can engage in a self-service checkout for the customers purchases.
2531.(a)A grocery establishment or retail drug establishment shall not provide a self-service checkout option for customers unless all of the following conditions are satisfied:
(1)At least one manual checkout station is staffed by an employee of the establishment who is available to any given customer at the time that a self-service checkout option is made available to that customer.
(2)(A)Self-service checkouts are limited to purchases of 10 or fewer items.
(B)The establishment shall include signage within the self-service checkout area indicating that only 10 or fewer items are permitted through the self-service checkout station.
(3)Customers are prohibited from using self-service checkout to purchase either of the following:
(A)Items that require customers to provide a form of identification, including, but not limited to, alcohol and tobacco products.
(B)Items subject to special theft-deterrent measures, including, but not limited to, locked cabinets and electronic article surveillance tags, that require the intervention of an employee of the establishment for the customer to access or purchase the item.
(4)(A)No more than two self-service checkout stations are simultaneously monitored by any one employee of the establishment.
(B)An employee shall be relieved from all other duties when monitoring a self-service checkout station, including, but not limited to, operating a manual checkout station.
(b)A grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout shall include self-service checkout in their analysis of potential work hazards for purposes of their injury and illness prevention programs required by Section 3203 of Title 8 of the California Code of Regulations.
2532.(a)For purposes of this section, worker and consumer impact assessment means a study evaluating the potential negative effects on employees, consumers, or the public of a new or modified workplace technology that significantly affects the essential job functions of employees, eliminates jobs or essential job functions of employees, or that enables self-service by customers. A worker and consumer impact assessment shall include all of the following:
(1)A detailed description of the workplace technology, its intended purpose, and justification for adoption by the employer.
(2)A description of the data used by the technology, including the specific categories of data that will be processed as input and any data used to train the technology.
(3)The number of employees, identified by job classification, whose duties would be affected by the workplace technology, as well as a description of how the duties of employees in each job classification would be affected.
(4)The number of jobs, identified by job classification, that would be eliminated by the workplace technology.
(5)The number of work hours, identified by job classification, that would be eliminated by the workplace technology.
(6)The total amount of salaries and benefits that would be eliminated as a result of the workplace technology.
(7)A description of the potential gaps in skills of employees affected by the workplace technology that may result from the workplace technology.
(8)The total amount budgeted for, and descriptions of, training and retraining programs for affected employees.
(9)An analysis of whether there will be human oversight of the workplace technology.
(10)An analysis of the potential effect of the workplace technology on consumers, including any barriers to access that the technology could create for certain populations of consumers, including, but not limited to, seniors, the disabled, the unbanked, those without access to appropriate technology, youth, or other vulnerable populations.
(11)An analysis of the potential health and safety hazards created for employees, customers, or the public at large by the workplace technology and what measures the employer will take to mitigate those potential hazards.
(12)What data will be collected from employees and consumers by the workplace technology and whether they will have the option to opt-out of personal data collection.
(b)A grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that develops, procures, uses, or otherwise implements artificial intelligence, automation, or any new or modified technology that significantly affects the essential job functions of its employees, eliminates jobs or essential job functions of its employees, or that enables self-service by its customers shall complete a worker and consumer impact assessment before implementing the technology. The grocery establishment or retail drug establishment shall notify and solicit input from its employees potentially affected by the workplace technology, or their collective bargaining representative, at least 60 days before drafting the worker and consumer impact assessment.
(c)The worker and consumer impact assessment shall be provided to employees potentially affected by the workplace technology, or their collective bargaining representative, 60 days before implementation of the workplace technology. The grocery establishment or retail drug establishment shall also post a copy of the worker and consumer impact assessment in a location accessible to its employees and customers before, and for at least 90 days following, implementation of the workplace technology.
SECTION 1.Section 2012 of the Labor Code is amended to read:2012.The department shall keep constantly advised of industrial conditions throughout the State as affecting the employment of labor. Whenever the Governor represents or the division has reason to believe, that a period of extraordinary unemployment caused by industrial depression exists in the state, it shall immediately hold an inquiry into the facts relating thereto, and report to the Governor and appropriate committees of the Legislature whether, in fact, such condition exists.The department shall keep constantly advised of industrial conditions throughout the State as affecting the employment of labor. Whenever the Governor represents or the division has reason to believe, that a period of extraordinary unemployment caused by industrial depression exists in the state, it shall immediately hold an inquiry into the facts relating thereto, and report to the Governor and appropriate committees of the Legislature whether, in fact, such condition exists.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on RLS. (Ayes 10. Noes 3.) (August 15). Re-referred to Com. on RLS. |
| Aug 15, 2024 | Coauthors revised. |
| Aug 7, 2024 | August 7 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jul 8, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 8, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 3.) (July 2). |
| Jun 20, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on P. & C.P. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (June 19). Re-referred to Com. on P. & C.P. |
| Jun 11, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on L. & E. |
| Jun 6, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on L. & E. |
| Jun 3, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on L. & E. and P. & C.P. |
| May 22, 2024 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 21, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 25. Noes 12. Page 4101.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 20, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 3983.) (May 16). |
| May 10, 2024 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 6, 2024 | May 6 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| Apr 26, 2024 | Set for hearing May 6. |
| Apr 25, 2024 | April 29 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Apr 22, 2024 | Set for hearing April 29. |
| Apr 17, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 1. Page 3662.) (April 17). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 9, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on L., P.E. & R. |
| Apr 5, 2024 | Set for hearing April 17. |
| Mar 20, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on L., P.E. & R. |
| Feb 29, 2024 | Referred to Com. on L., P.E. & R. |
| Feb 20, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 18. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Rules] | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection |
Passed |
|
| Jun 19, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Privacy and Consumer Protection] | Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment |
Passed |
|
| May 21, 2024 | Senate 3rd Reading SB1446 Smallwood-Cuevas | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 6, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 17, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Labor, Public Employment and Retirement |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| CalAsian Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| California African American Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| California Black Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| California Business Properties Association | * Against | Jun 19, 2024 |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | * Against | Jul 2, 2024 |
| California Coalition For Worker Power | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| California Democratic Party | ** Support | |
| California Grocers Association | * Against | Jul 2, 2024 |
| California Hispanic Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| California Labor Federation | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| California Professional Firefighters | ** Support | |
| California Retailers Association | * Against | Jul 2, 2024 |
| California School Employees Association | ** Support | |
| California Teamsters | * Support | Jun 21, 2024 |
| California United for a Responsible Budget | ** Support | |
| Californians for Safety and Justice | ** Support | |
| Capitol Advocacy | * Against | Jun 21, 2024 |
| Central City Association Of Los Angeles | ** Against | |
| CFT- a Union of Educators & Classified Professionals, Aft, Afl-cio | ** Support | |
| Civil Justice Association Of California | * Against | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Consumer Attorneys Of California | ** Support | |
| Consumer Federation Of California | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Consumer Technology Association | * Against | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Courage California | ** Support | |
| CWA Local 9413 | * Support | Jun 19, 2024 |
| CWA Local 9421 | * Support | Jun 19, 2024 |
| El Dorado County Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| El Dorado Hills Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Elk Grove Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Ella Baker Center For Human Rights | ** Support | |
| Family Business Association of California | ** Against | |
| Folsom Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Fresno Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Fund Her | ** Support | |
| Initiate Justice | ** Support | |
| Initiate Justice Action | ** Support | |
| Inland Empire Economic Partnership | ** Against | |
| Legal Services for Prisoners with Children | ** Support | |
| lincoln area chamber of commerce | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles Area Chamber Of Commerce | * Against Unless Amend | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Mesa Verde Group | * Support | Jun 19, 2024 |
| North State Grocery | * Against | Jun 19, 2024 |
| Political Solutions Inc | * Against | Jun 21, 2024 |
| Prosecutors Alliance | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Rancho Cordova Area Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Rocklin Area Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Roseville Area Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| San Diego Regional Chamber Of Commerce | * Against | Jul 2, 2024 |
| San Francisco Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| SEIU California | ** Support | |
| Shingle Springs/cameron Park Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Smart Justice California | ** Support | |
| Smart Transportation State legislative Board | * Support | Jun 19, 2024 |
| Target Corporation | * Against | Jul 2, 2024 |
| Tech Equity | ** Support | |
| TechEquity Collaborative | ** Support | |
| Technet | * Against | Jul 2, 2024 |
| The California State Legislative Board of the Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation Workers – Transportation Division | ** Support | |
| Tri County Chamber Alliance | ** Against | |
| Ufcw | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| UNITE-HERE | ** Support | |
| United Chamber Advocacy Network | ** Against | |
| VALLEY INDUSTRY AND COMMERCE ASSOCIATION | ** Against | |
| Vera California | ** Support | |
| Voices for Progress | ** Support | |
| Western Center on Law & Poverty, INC. | ** Support | |
| Young Women's Freedom Center | ** Support | |
| Yuba Sutter Chamber of Commerce | ** Against |
Date of Hearing: August 7, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1446
Author:(Smallwood-Cuevas) – As Amended Ver:July 8, 2024
Policy Committee: | Labor and Employment | Vote: | 5 - 2 |
Privacy and Consumer Protection | 7 - 3 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits a grocery or drug store (“retail store”) from providing a self-service checkout option for customers unless specified workplace conditions are met.
Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a retail store from providing a self-service checkout option unless certain workplace conditions are met, such as adopting a policy to limit self-service purchases to no more than 15 items, having one employee monitor no more than two self-service stations while relieved of all other duties, and including self-service checkout in the employer’s illness and prevention program required by the Division of Occupational Safety and Health.
- Requires a retail store that intends to implement “consequential workplace technology” to provide notice to workers, workers’ collective bargaining representatives, and the public at least 60 days in advance of implementing the technology. Such technology includes self-checkout robotics, wearable sensors, and scanners that eliminate, automate, or electronically monitor the core job functions of an employee.
- Requires the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) to enforce these requirements upon the filing of an employee compliant and subjects an employer to a civil penalty of $100 for each day in violation, not to exceed an aggregate penalty of $10,000. A public prosecutor may also enforce these provisions, including seeking injunctive relief.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Annual costs of an amount in the millions of dollars to DLSE to investigate complaints and impose penalties for violations of self-service checkout and technology notice requirements (Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund).
- By authorizing a public prosecutor to bring a civil action to enforce self-service checkout and technology notice requirements, this bill may increase the volume of alternative enforcement prosecutions, resulting in cost pressures of an unknown amount to the state ((General Fund (GF) or Trial Court Trust Fund (TCTF)). It is unclear how many actions may be filed statewide, but the estimated workload cost of one hour of court time is $1,000. Although courts are not funded on the basis of workload, increased pressure on staff and the TCTF may create a need for increased court funding from the GF to perform existing duties. The Budget Act of 2024 includes $37.3 million ongoing GF to backfill declining TCTF revenue.
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the GF faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Over recent years a growing body of evidence has shown that the rapid spread of self-checkout stands has contributed to retail theft in stores across the nation. While these stands create more loss than manual checkout, retailers have used them to cut staff and reduce labor costs. This shift has left lone clerks to serve customers while at the same time watching for shoplifters, and dealing with disruptions, making stores even easier targets for theft and violence. SB 1446 protects workers and the public by ensuring safer staffing levels, deterring theft, and ensuring that workers and the public know the purpose of new technologies that may replace their essential job functions.
- Support and Opposition. This bill is co-sponsored by the California Labor Federation and United Food and Commercial Workers, Western States Council, with the former arguing this bill “improves the customer experience and ensures the job quality and safety for workers” while also being “forward-looking to the development of future technologies…to mitigate harms to workers and customers including racial, economic, ability, age, or other biases potentially baked into the [artificial intelligence] algorithm.” This bill is also supported by other labor organizations and social justice groups.
This bill is opposed by a coalition of business groups led by the California Grocers Association, which argues, “From dictating store staffing and operations to deterring investment and innovation, this bill is detrimental to our customers and employees while being challenging to implement and enforce.”
- Background.
Self-service Checkout. AB 183 (Ma), Chapter 726, Statutes of 2011, prohibited the sale of alcohol at any customer-operated checkout stand. Since then, self-checkout stations have become more common across various retail settings. Recently, however, large retailers such as Safeway, Target, and Walmart are removing or imposing item limits at self-checkout stations in light of inventory loss that occurs when checkout is not done by a cashier. This bill prohibits a retail store from providing a self-service checkout option for customers unless certain conditions are met, such as adopting a 15-item limit, operating at least one full-service cashier lane, and requiring one employee to monitor every two self-service stations.
Other Consequential Workplace Technology. This bill also requires a retail employer to provide workers, workers’ bargaining representatives, and the public with a 60-day notice before implementing consequential workplace technology likely to eliminate, automate, or monitor core job functions. Thus, consequential workplace technology may impact cashiers and the checkout process, but also other types of retail job duties, such as those related to inventory or delivery. Upon the filing of an employee complaint, DLSE must provide enforcement over a retail store’s provision of self-service checkout stations and the notice required before implementing consequential workplace technology. This bill also authorizes public prosecutors to provide enforcement.
Analysis Prepared by: Irene Ho / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 2, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PRIVACY AND CONSUMER PROTECTION
Rebecca Bauer-Kahan, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1446
Author:(Smallwood-Cuevas) – As Amended Ver:June 11, 2024
AS PROPOSED TO BE AMENDED
SENATE VOTE: 25-12
SUBJECT: Grocery retail store and retail drug establishment employees: self-service checkout and consequential workplace technology
SYNOPSIS
According to the author, “While companies proclaim there has been an increase in retail theft, much of the losses they allege can be traced to self-checkout and the reduction in their workforce. Data shows that self-checkout machines cause 16 times more shrink than checkout via a cashier.”
Toward that end, this bill makes a number of changes related to the adoption of consequential technology in grocery stores and drug stores. In addition, it establishes worker ratios when those stores utilize self-checkout stations. Specifically, the bill requires the following:
- A full-service cashier lane must be open if self-checkout machines are available for customers.
- One employee per every two open self-checkouts must be dedicated to the self-checkout area and relieved of all other duties.
- Stores utilizing self-checkout stations must adopt a 15-item limit policy.
- Expands the categories of items that are prohibited from being purchased through self-checkout to include all items that require ID verification, and any items that are locked or secured with anti-theft protections.
- Employers must, as part of their Workplace Violence Prevention Plans, address self-checkout machines as a potential workplace hazard.
- Employers must provide workers, their bargaining representative, and the public with a 60 day notice before implementing technologies that are likely to eliminate, automate or monitor core job functions.
There are two distinct parts to this bill. The first part, as noted above, establishes staffing requirements for self-checkout stations and item limitations. It is this part, which is under the purview of the Labor and Employment Committee, that the author argues has the ability to curb retail theft. More closely monitoring people utilizing self-checkout, she argues, makes it less likely people will use self-checkout as a way to steal merchandise.
The second part, which is under the purview of this Committee, defines “consequential workplace technology” and requires grocery store and drug store employers to notify employees and their customers at least 60 days before implementing any new consequential workplace technology.
As currently in print, the definition raised several concerns for the Committee that are addressed in proposed amendments:
- It included as “consequential” any type of technology that might “significantly impact” a worker’s core job function. Arguably, any new technology, including changes to refrigeration systems that do not need to be monitored as often or motorized shopping cart movers that make it less physically demanding for workers to collect and return carts to the stores, could require a 60-day notification before being implemented, despite that fact that they are not likely to reduce the number of workers needed per shift.
The proposed amendments remove the term “significantly impact” and instead consequential technology is defined as any technology that eliminates, automates or electronically monitors an employee’s core job functions.
- The definition also included “artificial intelligence” and “automated decisionmaking systems” as the types of technology that were of concern. However, including those two terms unnecessarily limited the type of technology that could be consequential. There are many technologies that can be used in stores that can eliminate or automate a core job function that do not fall within the definition of “artificial intelligence” or “automated decisionmaking systems.”
The proposed amendment removes those two terms, which makes it technology neutral, and simply requires a notification for any technology that is deemed consequential to a worker’s job. Technology encompasses artificial intelligence, automated decisionmaking, and any other technology that currently exists or may exist in the future that has the potential to eliminate jobs or monitor employees.
In addition to updating the definition, the author and sponsors requested several updates to the notification language, which are detailed below.
This bill is co-sponsored by the California Labor Federation and the United Food and Commercial Workers, Western States Council. It is also supported by a number of labor and criminal justice reform organizations. The California Grocers Association, California Retailers Association, and the California Chamber of Commerce are among the groups in opposition. The bill passed the Labor and Employment Committee on a 5-2 vote.
SUMMARY: Limits the use of self-service checkout stations in grocery retail stores and retail drug establishments and requires advance notification of the implementation of consequential workplace technology to workers, their representatives, and the public. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines “consequential workplace technology” to mean technology that eliminates, automates, or electronically monitors the core job functions agreed upon between an employer and an employee upon hire or following a subsequent change in position or department. Consequential workplace technology includes, but is not limited to, self-checkout robotics, wearable sensors, and scanners.
- Provides that “grocery retail store” includes either of the following:
- A “grocery establishment,” defined as a retail store in this state that is over 15,000 square feet in size and that sells primarily household foodstuffs for offsite consumption, including the sale of fresh produce, meats, poultry, fish, deli products, dairy products, canned foods, dry foods, beverages, baked foods, or prepared foods. Other household supplies or other products shall be secondary to the primary purpose of food sales.
- A “superstore,” defined as a store in this state that is over 75,000 square feet in size, that generates sales or use tax pursuant to the Bradley-Burns Uniform Local Sales and Use Tax Law (Part 1.5 (commencing with Section 7200) of Division 2 of the Revenue and Taxation Code), and that devotes more than 10 percent of sales floor area to the sale of nontaxable merchandise.
- Provides that for the self-service checkout provisions of the bill, “grocery retail store” does not include a discount warehouse or retail store where more than one-half of the items carried by the discount warehouse or retail store are sold in large quantities or in bulk and the discount warehouse or retail store requires shoppers to pay a membership or assessment fee.
- Defines “manual checkout station” to mean a station that is not a self-service checkout station and at which an employee provides human assistance to a customer scanning, bagging, or accepting payment for the customer’s purchases.
- Defines “self-service checkout” to mean an automated process that enables customers to scan, bag, and pay for their purchases without human assistance.
- Prohibits a grocery retail store or retail drug establishment from providing a self-service checkout option for customers unless all of the following conditions are satisfied:
- At least one manual checkout station is staffed by an employee who is available to any given customer at the time that a self-service checkout option is made available to that customer.
- The employer has established a workplace policy that limits self-service checkouts to purchases of no more than 15 items.
- The establishment shall include signage within the self-service checkout area indicating the number of items that are permitted through the self-service checkout station.
- Customers are prohibited from using self-service checkout to purchase either of the following:
- Items that require customers to provide a form of identification, including, but not limited to, alcohol and tobacco products.
- Items subject to special theft-deterrent measures, including, but not limited to, locked cabinets and electronic article surveillance tags, that require the intervention of an employee for the customer to access or purchase the item.
- No more than two self-service checkout stations are simultaneously monitored by any one employee of the establishment.
- An employee shall be relieved from all other duties when monitoring a self-service checkout station, including, but not limited to, operating a manual checkout station.
- Customers are prohibited from using self-service checkout to purchase either of the following:
- Requires a grocery retail store or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout to include self-service checkout in their analysis of potential work hazards for purposes of their injury and illness prevention programs.
- Requires, if a grocery retail store or a retail drug establishment intends to implement consequential workplace technology, the grocery retail store or retail drug establishment to notify workers, their collective bargaining representatives, and the public at least 60 days in advance with a general description of the technology and the intended purpose for the technology.
- Provides that an employer that violates these provisions shall be subject to a civil penalty of one hundred dollars ($100) for each day the employer is in violation, not to exceed an aggregate penalty of ten thousand dollars ($10,000).
- Requires, upon the filing of a complaint by an employee, the Department of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) to enforce these provisions, including investigating an alleged violation, and ordering appropriate relief.
- Authorizes, in addition to other remedies as may be provided by the laws of this state or its subdivisions, any public prosecutor, as specified, to institute an action for a violation of the above provisions, including an action seeking injunctive relief.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the DLSE within the Department of Indutrial Relations, to enforce, among other things, wage and hour law, anti-retaliation provisions, and employer notice requirements. (Lab. Code §79 et seq.)
- Authorizes, until January 1, 2029, a public prosecutor to prosecute an action, either civil or criminal, for a violation of certain provisions of the labor code or to enforce those provisions independently. (Lab. Code §181(a) and (e).)
- Establishes certain worker notice and retention requirements for a grocery employer that is merging or being acquired by another grocery store. (Lab. Code §2500 et. seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print, this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS:
1) Purpose. The author presents this bill primarily as a retail theft prevention bill. Background provided by the author’s office points to data demonstrating that self-checkout machines contribute significantly to retail theft. According to the materials provided to the Committee:
While companies proclaim there has been an increase in retail theft, much of the losses they allege can be traced to self-checkout and the reduction in their workforce. Data shows that self-checkout machines cause 16 times more shrink than checkout via a cashier. In 2022, self-checkout accounted for under 30% of total transactions, yet self-checkout machines have cost food retailers more than $10 billion in lost profits annually. Nearly 7% of self-checkout transactions had at least some partial shrink compared to 0.32% with cashiers. On a revenue basis, this suggests a shrink rate of 3.5% for self-checkout machines versus only 0.21% for full-service cashier stations staffed by an employee. Even further, over 20 million Americans have said they have stolen from self-checkout, with another 8.3 million planning to do it again. Recent stories, like one in San Francisco stole over $60,000 worth of merchandise through self-checkout only further demonstrate the risk for theft these machines create.
This bill intends to address concerns about self-checkout driven retail theft by requiring that one employee be stationed exclusively in the self-checkout area for every two self-checkout stations. In addition, given that retail theft has also increased, according to the author, since self-checkout has reduced the overall number of employees in stores, the bill requires workers, union representatives, and customers to be notified 60 days in advance of consequential technology being installed that is likely to further reduce the number of workers per shift.
2) Author’s statement. According to the author:
In recent years, as concerns about retail theft have grown, it is crucial we offer solutions that address the root drivers of theft. Over recent years a growing body of evidence has shown that the rapid spread of self-checkout stands has contributed to retail theft in stores across the nation. While these stands create more loss than manual checkout, retailers have used them to cut staff and reduce labor costs. This shift has left lone clerks to serve customers while at the same time watching for shoplifters, and dealing with disruptions, making stores even easier targets for theft and violence. SB 1446 protects workers and the public by ensuring safer staffing levels, deterring theft, and ensuring that workers and the public know the purpose of new technologies that may replace their essential job functions.
3) What this bill does. This bill makes a number of changes related to the adoption of consequential technology in grocery stores and drug stores. In addition, it establishes worker ratios when those stores utilize self-checkout stations. Specifically, the bill requires the following:
- A full-service cashier lane must be open if self-checkout machines are available for customers.
- One employee per every two open self-checkouts must be dedicated to the self-checkout area and relieved of all other duties.
- Stores utilizing self-checkout stations must adopt a 15-item limit policy.
- Expands the categories of items that are prohibited from being purchased through self-checkout to include all items that require ID verification, and any items that are locked or secured with anti-theft protections.
- Employers must, as part of their Workplace Violence Prevention Plans, address self-checkout machines as a potential workplace hazard.
- Employers must provide workers, their bargaining representative, and the public with a 60 day notice before implementing technologies that are likely to eliminate, automate or monitor core job functions.
4) Retail theft. According to the California Department of Justice’s Open Justice database, reports of shoplifting (one aspect of retail theft) increased significantly between 2021 and 2022, but, as shown in the table below, it remained significantly lower than the years prior to the COVID19 pandemic.
In 2022, the National Retail Federation (NRF) claimed that “nearly half” of the shopping industry’s $94.5 billion in losses due to “shrink” in 2021 were caused by “organized retail theft.”[1] This claim was reported widely and cited in connection with stories about retail theft incidents. Store owners said that the prevalence of retail theft led them to raise prices.[2] Large companies like Walmart, Home Depot, and CVS agreed that the rate of retail theft was increasing.[3] Media outlets carried regular stories about the huge numbers of people who were walking into stores and walking out with armloads of merchandise. Retailers large and small were ringing alarm bells about increases in retail theft. In May of 2023, CNN reported that Target was bracing to lose half a billion dollars because of rising theft. Nordstrom, Whole Foods and some other big chains said they were abandoning San Francisco because of changing economic conditions or employee safety. Many other retailers have blamed crime for closing stores.[4] Despite the panicked reports about increases in shoplifting, the data did not bear that out, particularly in San Francisco.[5]
In 2023, the NRF walked back its claim about the epidemic of organized theft because they lacked evidence to support it.[6] In the last few months, retailers have been more neutral about the threat of retail theft.[7] According to retailers, the reduced threat is due to some changed behavior on their part—such as cutting back on self-checkout and locking up certain merchandise—as well as state and federal legislation targeted at retail theft.[8]
5) Analysis. As described previously, there are two distinct parts to this bill. The first part establishes staffing requirements for self-checkout stations and item limitations. It is this part, which is under the purview of the Labor and Employment Committee, that the author argues has the ability to curb retail theft. More closely monitoring people utilizing self-checkout, she argues, makes it less likely people will use self-checkout as a way to steal merchandise.
The second part, which is under the purview of this Committee, defines “consequential workplace technology” and requires grocery store and drug store employers to notify employees and their customers 60 days before implementing new consequential workplace technology.
As currently in print, the definition raised several concerns for the Committee:
- It included as “consequential” any type of technology that might “significantly impact” a worker’s core job function. Arguably, any new technology, including changes to refrigeration systems that do not need to be monitored as often or motorized shopping cart movers that make it less physically demanding for workers to collect and return carts to the stores, could require a 60-day notification before being implemented, despite that fact that they are not likely to reduce the number of workers needed per shift.
The proposed amendments remove the term “significantly impact” and instead consequential technology is defined as any technology that eliminates, automates or electronically monitors an employee’s core job functions.
- The definition included “artificial intelligence” and “automated decisionmaking systems” as the types of technology that were of concern. However, including those two terms unnecessarily limited the type of technology that could be consequential. There are many technologies that can be used in stores that can eliminate or automate a core job function that do not fall within the definition of “artificial intelligence” or “automated decisionmaking systems.”
The proposed amendment removes those two terms, which makes it technology neutral and simply requires a notification for any technology that is deemed consequential to a worker. This definition would include artificial intelligence, automated decisionmaking, and any other technology that currently exists or may exist in the future that has the potential to eliminate jobs or monitor employees.
In addition to updating the definition, the author and sponsors requested several updates to the notification language, which are detailed in the following section.
6) Suggested Committee amendments. The Committee amendments clarify the type of technology and provide additional details about the required notification.
Amendment#1:
2530. For purposes of this part, the following definitions shall apply:
(a) “Consequential workplace technology” means artificial intelligence or automated decisionmaking systems technology that significantly impacts, eliminates, or automates, or electronically monitors the core job functions agreed upon between an employer and an employee upon hire or following a subsequent change in position or department. Consequential workplace technology includes, but is not limited to, self-checkout robotics, wearable sensors, and scanners. and electronic monitoring.
Amendment #2:
2532. (a)If a grocery retail store or a retail drug establishment intends to implement consequential workplace technology, the grocery retail store or retail drug establishment shall notify workers, their collective bargaining representatives, and the public at least 60 days in advance of implementation of the consequential workplace technology with a general description of the technology and the intended purpose for of the technology. An employer that implements the consequential workplace technology for purposes other than those specified in the notice shall provide the workers, their collective bargaining representatives, and the public with additional notice of any other purpose or purposes.
(b) The notice shall be provided to workers potentially affected by the consequential workplace technology and their collective bargaining representative in writing by means usually used to communicate. The notice shall be provided to the public by posting a copy of the notice in a location accessible to its employees and customers.
7) Related legislation. AB 183 (Ma; Ch. 726, Stat. of 2011) prohibited the sale of alcohol at any customer-operated checkout stand.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to a coalition supporting the bill that includes United Food and Commercial Workers, Western States Council (UFCW), Smart Justice California, and Courage California:
In 2011, California passed into law AB 183 (Ma) which banned the sale of alcohol via self-checkout machines. This was in response to "evidence of inadequate staffing, inconsistent monitoring, and technological failures” at self-checkout that increased illegal purchases of alcohol and harmed public health.
Since then, self-checkout has rapidly spread in retail grocery and drug stores, with some stores that do not sell alcohol having eliminated human workers from checkout entirely. Retailers have increasingly implemented automated checkout to drastically cut staffing and reduce labor costs. Self-checkout and the reduction in front-line grocery workers have created a range of problems for retailers, workers, and the public.
While companies proclaim there has been an increase in retail theft, much of the losses they allege can actually be traced to self-checkout and the reduction in their workforce. Data shows that self-checkout machines cause 16 times more shrink than checkout via a cashier. In 2022, self-checkout accounted for under 30% of total transactions, yet self-checkout machines have cost food retailers more than $10 billion in lost profits annually. Nearly 7% of self-checkout transactions had at least some partial shrink compared to 0.32% with cashiers. On a revenue basis, this suggests a shrink rate of 3.5% for self-checkout machines versus only 0.21% for full-service cashier stations staffed by an employee.
The elimination of workers’ jobs due to self-checkout is especially harmful. The reduction in frontline checkers has caused a crisis with chronic understaffing and an overworked workforce. Self-checkout machines are notoriously glitchy, which creates more work for the reduced workforce and workers are expected to monitor anywhere from four to ten machines on their own.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: A coalition that includes the California Chamber of Commerce, TechNet, and the California Grocers Association, among a number of others, argues in opposition of the bill:
Limiting the number and type of items that can be purchased at self-checkout will be difficult to enforce and will only frustrate customers. Grocers and pharmacies currently staff and operate self-checkout lanes in a manner that reflects the clientele of that location. There’s no one-size-fits-all approach. Setting a specific ratio of employees to self-checkout lanes undermines the flexibility that stores need to address the needs of their customers and employees. Further, this bill’s restrictions regarding which items can go through selfcheckout will vary store to store, increasing customer frustration and subjecting stores to thousands of dollars in penalties under the June 11, 2024 amendments. This bill would codify one of the worst situations our employees saw during the pandemic – when they were required to police their customers and enforce the law around masking and social distancing. It did not work then, and it will not work now.
[. . .]
Most concerning is that the June 6, 2024 amendments swapped out an overreaching “assessment” for an ambiguous notice requirement. The bill requires covered entities to provide notice to all workers, their bargaining representatives, and the public 60 days before implementing “consequential workplace technology”. “Consequential workplace technology” is a term created by SB 1446 that covers a whole host of things, including not only self-checkout, but all AI or automated decision-making systems that “impact” a core job function of an employee.
This is a significant requirement that reaches far beyond the stated goal of the bill. Its unintended consequences are problematic. For example, “electronic monitoring” is undefined. That could include security mechanisms, data storage, or routine systems like email or phone usage. Has an employer engaged electronic monitoring by maintaining a phone log? Does a covered employer need to tell the public every time it implements a new AI tool into its internal email system? Or if it is updating a function related to security? There is also concern about the unintended consequences to any internal investigations or safety. Arguably, everything could “impact” a core job function and the June 11, 2024 amendments add in a penalty structure that could amount to $10,000 in penalties for any error. Providing over-disclosures of every such activity will be of little value to the public or employees as it will not only lend to notice fatigue but will also overshadow important notices.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Labor Federation, Afl-cio (co-sponsor)
UFCW - Western States Council (co-sponsor)
California Coalition for Worker Power
California Democratic Party California Federation of Teachers
California Professional Firefighters
California School Employees Association
California State Legislative Board of The Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation Workers - Transportation Division (SMART-TD)
California United for A Responsible Budget (CURB)
Californians for Safety and Justice
CFT- a Union of Educators & Classified Professionals, Aft, Afl-cio
Consumer Attorneys of California
Courage California
Ella Baker Center for Human Right
Fund Her
Initiate Justice
Initiate Justice Action
Legal Services for Prisoners With Children
SEIU California
Smart Justice California
Tech Equity
Techequity Collaborative
United Food and Commercial Workers, Western States Council
Vera California
Voices for Progress
Western Center on Law & Poverty, INC.
Young Women's Freedom Center
Oppose
CalAsian Chamber of Commerce
California African American Chamber of Commerce
California Black Chamber of Commerce
California Chamber of Commerce
California Grocers Association
California Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
California Retailers Association
Central City Association of Los Angeles
Civil Justice Association of California
Consumer Technology Association
El Dorado County Chamber of Commerce
El Dorado Hills Chamber of Commerce
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Fresno Chamber of Commerce
Inland Empire Economic Partnership
Lincoln Area Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Area Chamber of Commerce
Rocklin Area Chamber of Commerce
Roseville Area Chamber of Commerce
San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce
San Francisco Chamber of Commerce
Shingle Springs/Cameron Park Chamber of Commerce
TechNet
Tri County Chamber Alliance
United Chamber Advocacy Network (UCAN)
Valley Industry and Commerce Association (VICA)
Yuba Sutter Chamber of Commerce
Analysis Prepared by: Julie Salley / P. & C.P. / (916) 319-2200
Helmore, US retail group retracts claim that half of $94.5bn inventory loss was from theft (Dec. 11, 2023), The Guardian, https://www.theguardian.com/business/2023/dec/07/retail-theft-losses-inventory-nrf. All links in this analysis are current as of March 29, 2024. ↑
Stark, Are you spending more because of retail theft? Can California workers chase shoplifters?, Sacramento Bee (Nov. 9, 2023), available at https://www.sacbee.com/news/california/article281619043.html. ↑
Fonrogue, et al., America’s biggest companies say retail crime is an epidemic, but just how big is it?, CNBC (Mar. 18, 2023; updated Mar. 20, 2023), https://www.cnbc.com/2023/03/18/organized-retail-crime-debate.html. ↑
Parija Kavilanz, Why retail theft is soaring: inflation, the economy – and opportunity, CNN (May 23, 2023). https://www.cnn.com/2023/05/23/business/retail-crime-economy/index.html. ↑
Nicole Lewis, What the Panic Over Shoplifting Reveals About American Crime Policy, the Marshall Project (Feb. 27, 2023). https://www.themarshallproject.org/2023/02/27/shoplifting-retail-theft-lawmakers-response. ↑
E.g., Helmore, supra. ↑
Sulyukh, supra. ↑
Ibid. ↑
Date of Hearing: June 19, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT
Liz Ortega, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1446
Author:(Smallwood-Cuevas) – As Amended Ver:June 11, 2024
SENATE VOTE: 25-12
SUBJECT: Grocery retail store and retail drug establishment employees: self-service checkout and consequential workplace technology
SUMMARY: Limits the use of self-service checkout stations in grocery retail stores and retail drug establishments and requires advance notification of the implementation of consequential workplace technology to workers, their representatives, and the public. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines “consequential workplace technology” to mean artificial intelligence or automated decisionmaking systems that significantly impacts, eliminates, or automates the core job functions agreed upon between an employer and an employee upon hire or following a subsequent change in position or department. Consequential workplace technology includes, but is not limited to, self-checkout robotics, wearable sensors, scanners, and electronic monitoring.
- Provides that “grocery retail store” includes either of the following:
- A “grocery establishment,” defined as a retail store in this state that is over 15,000 square feet in size and that sells primarily household foodstuffs for offsite consumption, including the sale of fresh produce, meats, poultry, fish, deli products, dairy products, canned foods, dry foods, beverages, baked foods, or prepared foods. Other household supplies or other products shall be secondary to the primary purpose of food sales.
- A “superstore,” defined as a store in this state that is over 75,000 square feet in size, that generates sales or use tax pursuant to the Bradley-Burns Uniform Local Sales and Use Tax Law (Part 1.5 (commencing with Section 7200) of Division 2 of the Revenue and Taxation Code), and that devotes more than 10 percent of sales floor area to the sale of nontaxable merchandise.
- Provides that for the self-service checkout provisions of the bill, “grocery retail store” does not include a discount warehouse or retail store where more than one-half of the items carried by the discount warehouse or retail store are sold in large quantities or in bulk and the discount warehouse or retail store requires shoppers to pay a membership or assessment fee.
- Defines “manual checkout station” to mean a station that is not a self-service checkout station and at which an employee provides human assistance to a customer scanning, bagging, or accepting payment for the customer’s purchases.
- Defines “self-service checkout” to mean an automated process that enables customers to scan, bag, and pay for their purchases without human assistance.
- Prohibits a grocery retail store or retail drug establishment from providing a self-service checkout option for customers unless all of the following conditions are satisfied:
- At least one manual checkout station is staffed by an employee who is available to any given customer at the time that a self-service checkout option is made available to that customer.
- The employer has established a workplace policy that limits self-service checkouts to purchases of no more than 15 items.
- The establishment shall include signage within the self-service checkout area indicating the number of items that are permitted through the self-service checkout station.
- Customers are prohibited from using self-service checkout to purchase either of the following:
- Items that require customers to provide a form of identification, including, but not limited to, alcohol and tobacco products.
- Items subject to special theft-deterrent measures, including, but not limited to, locked cabinets and electronic article surveillance tags, that require the intervention of an employee for the customer to access or purchase the item.
- No more than two self-service checkout stations are simultaneously monitored by any one employee of the establishment.
- An employee shall be relieved from all other duties when monitoring a self-service checkout station, including, but not limited to, operating a manual checkout station.
- Requires a grocery retail store or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout to include self-service checkout in their analysis of potential work hazards for purposes of their injury and illness prevention programs.
- Requires, if a grocery retail store or a retail drug establishment intends to implement consequential workplace technology, the grocery retail store or retail drug establishment to notify workers, their collective bargaining representatives, and the public 60 days in advance with a general description of the technology and the intended purpose for the technology.
- Provides that an employer that violates these provisions shall be subject to a civil penalty of one hundred dollars ($100) for each day the employer is in violation, not to exceed an aggregate penalty of ten thousand dollars ($10,000).
- Requires, upon the filing of a complaint by an employee, the Department of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) to enforce these provisions, including investigating an alleged violation, and ordering appropriate relief.
- Authorizes, in addition to other remedies as may be provided by the laws of this state or its subdivisions, any public prosecutor, as specified, to institute an action for a violation of the above provisions, including an action seeking injunctive relief.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the DLSE within the Department of Indutrial Relations (DIR), to enforce, among other things, wage and hour law, anti-retaliation provisions, and employer notice requirements. Labor Code §79 et seq.
- Authorizes, until January 1, 2029, a public prosecutor to prosecute an action, either civil or criminal, for a violation of certain provisions of the labor code or to enforce those provisions independently. Labor Code §181(a) and (e).
- Establishes certain worker notice and retention requirements for a grocery employer that is merging or being acquired by another grocery store. Labor Code §2500 et. seq.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill’s fiscal impact to the State is unknown, and would depend on the extent to which future administrative and enforcement activity occurs at the state level (General Fund and/or special fund).
COMMENTS: This bill is double referred to the Assembly Privacy and Consumer Protection Committee upon passage out of this Committee.
As provided by the author to this Committee, recent data on the costs associated with self-checkout reveal that the technology may not achieve the cost savings initially projected by retailers. In 2022, self-checkout accounted for under 30 percent of total transactions, yet self-checkout machines have ironically cost food retailers more than 10 billion in lost profits annually. Utilizing self-checkout machines causes 16 times the inventory loss, presumably in part from retail theft, than checkout with a cashier.[1] Thus, it’s an open question whether installing self-checkout stations to replace cashier jobs is a net positive for grocery employers.
In response to this downward trend, some of the biggest retailers like Safeway, Target, and Walmart, are removing self-checkout stations. Even Lowe’s CEO recently commented that the way to reduce losses is to remove the self-checkout option and increase staffing levels.[2] Similar concerns regarding profit loss have caused other large retailers to limit the number of items that may be purchased through self-checkout stations.
According to the author, “In recent years, as concerns about retail theft have grown, it is crucial we offer solutions that address the root drivers of theft. Over recent years a growing body of evidence has shown that the rapid spread of self-checkout stands has contributed to retail theft in stores across the nation. While these stands create more loss than manual checkout, retailers have used them to cut staff and reduce labor costs. This shift has left lone clerks to serve customers while at the same time watching for shoplifters, and dealing with disruptions, making stores even easier targets for theft and violence. SB 1446 protects workers and the public by ensuring safer staffing levels, deterring theft, and ensuring that workers and the public know the purpose of new technologies that may replace their essential job functions.”
The author further states, “SB 1446 prioritizes workers and ensures their safety and wellbeing come first. Many frontline workers in grocery and retail stores come from minority and low-income communities. Analyses of nearly 44,000 jail bookings between 2020 and 2023 has found that proposals to increase penalties for retail theft disproportionately impact Black and Latinx Californians only furthering the mass incarceration crisis throughout the state. Data shows that the majority of people booked for retail theft in California are largely Black and Latinx. While Black people only make up 7 percent of the population, they make up 22 percent of the share of people booked for retail theft. This is true for shoplifting and organized retail theft.
In the context of increased concern about retail theft, this bill is a positive step at crime prevention, rather than another bill that would increase sentences for nonviolent property crime, and contribute to mass incarceration, a policy that hurts low-income individuals of color, their families and their communities. Longer sentences do not deter crime and they do not make victims whole. Crime prevention is smarter.
There is strong evidence that longer sentences are a massive fiscal burden on low-income families, and contribute to greater state and local costs as families become dependent on public benefits and more children are sent to foster care or juvenile camps, as a result of the financial and emotional disruption of the families caused by long sentences.
Increased penalties for shoplifting are unlikely to have any significant impact on rates of shoplifting. Crime prevention is more humane and more cost effective, than the high-cost, high-pain, and low-efficacy policy of arresting and incarcerating low-income people for shoplifting. Currently clearance rate for property crime in California in 2021 and 2022 was approximately 7%. In 93% of property crimes in California, there is no arrest and conviction. Asking retail employers to create safer conditions for workers and consumers is a key piece of reducing the societal costs of shoplifting and retail theft.”
Committee Comments
Committee staff recommends the author consider adding more specificity to the notice requirement of the implementation of consequential workplace technology in proposed Labor Code Section 2532. The author may wish to specify how notice will be provided to the public and clarify that the 60 days begins when the employer acquires the technology they intend to implement so to give the workers more time to provide feedback on its implementation. Furthermore, the author may want to require that the notice to the workers and their collective bargaining representative include a summary of the employer’s plans to mitigate the impact(s) of the new technology on the workforce.
Arguments in Support
The California Labor Federation, co-sponsor of the bill, states, “The rapid advancement of AI and adoption by stores like Amazon Go means employers are poised to implement new technology most likely to replace workers, reduce labor costs, and increase the use of invasive body and facial scanning, tracking, and data collection. Self-checkout is just one of the strategies retail employers are using to reduce costs.
Amazon Go stores utilize “Just Walk Out Technology” that eliminates human cashiers or frontline workers. Customers enter the store, pick out items they want, walk out and their Amazon account is automatically charged for the items they take. Retailers are also using AI-enabled “smart” carts along with customer tracking and shelf scanners to eliminate checkout lanes altogether. The Whole Foods in San Mateo is one of six locations nationally testing the technology. Both these technologies use artificial intelligence including computer vision, continuous tracking, sensor fusion, and other tools to enable the process, like the technologies used in self-driving cars. Customers, or their companions, who enter Amazon Go stores are scanned, tracked, and any data related to their shopping, including which items they browse and which they buy, are collected by Amazon.
The rise of wearable or mobile self-checkout further eliminates the need for workers all over the store. It also raises questions about the potential bias and harms the technology creates. For one, these technologies require invasive tracking and scanning of customers and their companions and children. It uses computer vision technology, like facial recognition, which has been shown to have racial bias built in. In addition, the technology’s design may exclude the disabled, unbanked, seniors, youth, and others. It also creates a two-tier system where those with Amazon or other accounts, credit cards, and tech-savvy have dedicated lanes and other perks, while the rest of the public contend with understaffed stores.”
Arguments in Opposition
A coalition of employer organizations, including the California Grocers Association, is opposed and state, “SB 1446 is deeply flawed on every level. From dictating store staffing and operations to deterring investment and innovation, this bill is detrimental to our customers and employees while being challenging to implement and enforce. For the reasons outlined below, we strongly oppose this legislation.
Limiting the number and type of items that can be purchased at self-checkout will be difficult to enforce and will only frustrate customers. Grocers and pharmacies currently staff and operate self-checkout lanes in a manner that reflects the clientele of that location. There’s no one-size-fits-all approach. Setting a specific ratio of employees to self-checkout lanes undermines the flexibility that stores need to address the needs of their customers and employees. Further, this bill’s restrictions regarding which items can go through self-checkout will vary store to store, increasing customer frustration and subjecting stores to thousands of dollars in penalties under the June 11, 2024 amendments. This bill would codify one of the worst situations our employees saw during the pandemic – when they were required to police their customers and enforce the law around masking and social distancing. It did not work then, and it will not work now.”
Prior Legislation
AB 183 (Ma) Chapter 726, Statutes of 2011 prohibited the sale of alcohol at any customer-operated checkout stand.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
United Food and Commercial Workers, Western States Council (Sponsor)
California Democratic Party
California Federation of Teachers
California Labor Federation
California Professional Firefighters
California State Legislative Board of The Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation Workers -- Transportation Division (SMART-TD)
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
California United for A Responsible Budget
Californians for Safety and Justice
CFT- a Union of Educators & Classified Professionals, AFT
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
Courage California
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Fund Her
Initiate Justice
Initiate Justice Action
Legal Services for Prisoners With Children
Prosecutors Alliance of California, a Project of Tides Advocacy
Smart Justice California
Tech Equity
Unite-HERE
Vera California
Voices for Progress
Opposition
CalAsian Chamber of Commerce
California African American Chamber of Commerce
California Black Chamber of Commerce
California Chamber of Commerce
California Grocers Association
California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce
California Retailers Association
Central City Association of Los Angeles
Civil Justice Association of California
Consumer Technology Association
Fresno Chamber of Commerce
Inland Empire Economic Partnership
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce
San Francisco Chamber of Commerce
Technet
Tri County Chamber Alliance
Valley Industry and Commerce Association
Analysis Prepared by: Megan Lane / L. & E. /
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1446 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1446
Author: Smallwood-Cuevas (D)
Amended: 5/16/24
Vote: 21
SENATE LABOR, PUB. EMP. & RET. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 4/17/24
AYES: Smallwood-Cuevas, Cortese, Durazo, Laird
NOES: Wilk
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 5/16/24
AYES: Caballero, Ashby, Becker, Bradford, Wahab
NOES: Jones, Seyarto
SUBJECT: Grocery establishment and retail drug establishment employees: self-service checkout and consequential workplace technology
SOURCE: California Labor Federation
Prosecutors Alliance of California
United Food and Commercial Workers, Western States Council
DIGEST:
This bill (1) prohibits a grocery or retail drug establishment from providing a self-service checkout option for customers unless specified conditions are met, including that at least one manual station is staffed by an employee and that self-service checkouts be limited to purchases of no more than 15 items; and (2) requires a grocery or retail drug establishment to complete a worker and consumer impact assessment before using or procuring a consequential workplace technology that significantly impacts, eliminates, or automates the core job functions agreed upon between an employer and an employee, as specified.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- The California Occupational Safety and Health Act, assures safe and healthful working conditions for all California workers by authorizing the enforcement of effective standards, assisting and encouraging employers to maintain safe and healthful working conditions, and by providing for research, information, education, training, and enforcement in the field of occupational safety and health. (Labor Code §6300)
- Establishes the Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) within the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) to, among other things, propose, administer, and enforce occupational safety and health standards. (Labor Code §6300 et seq.)
- Requires employers to establish, implement and maintain an effective Injury and Illness Prevention Program (IIPP) that must include, among other things, a system for identifying and evaluating workplace hazards, including scheduled periodic inspections to identify unsafe conditions and work practices and the employer’s methods and procedures for correcting those unsafe or unhealthy conditions and work practices in a timely manner. (Labor Code §6401.7)
- Requires an employer to establish, implement, and maintain an effective Workplace Violence Prevention Plan (WVPP) that is in writing, available and easily accessible to employees, authorized employee representatives, and representatives of the division at all times, and be specific to the hazards and corrective measures for each work area and operation. Provides that the WVPP may be incorporated as a stand-alone section in the employer’s existing IIPP or maintained as a separate document. (Labor Code §6401.9)
- Requires the WVPP, among other elements, to include:
- Names or job titles of the person responsible for implementing the plan.
- Procedures to obtain the active involvement of employees and authorized employee representatives in developing and implementing the plan.
- Effective procedures for the employer to accept and respond to reports of workplace violence, and to prohibit retaliation against an employee who makes such a report.
- Effective procedures to respond to actual or potential workplace violence emergencies, including evacuation and sheltering plans, as specified.
- Procedures to develop and provide specified training to respond to emergencies.
- Procedures to correct workplace violence hazards, as specified, and procedures to review the effectiveness of the plan and revise as needed.
(Labor Code §6401.9)
- Requires employers to record information in a violent incident log of every workplace violence incident, as specified, and include detailed information regarding the type of attack, weapons used, and consequences including whether or not law enforcement was contacted and their response. (Labor Code §6401.9)
- Authorizes Cal/OSHA to enforce these provisions by issuing a citation alleging a violation and a notice of civil penalty, as specified, and authorizes any person cited to appeal the citation and penalty to the appeals board in a manner consistent with Labor Code Section 6319. (Labor Code §6401.9)
- Prohibits a person from discharging or in any manner discriminating or retaliating against any employee because the employee, among other things, reported a work-related fatality, injury, or illness, requested access to occupational injury or illness reports and records, or exercised any other rights protected by the federal Occupational Safety and Health Act (29 U.S.C. Sec. 651 et seq.), as specified. (Labor Code §6310)
This bill:
- Defines, among others, the following terms:
- “Grocery establishment” as defined in existing Labor Code Section 2502.
- “Manual checkout station” means a station that is not a self-service checkout station and at which an employee provides human assistance to a customer scanning, bagging, or accepting payment for the customer’s purchases.
- “Retail drug establishment” means a person, including an individual, a corporation, a partnership, a limited partnership, a limited liability partnership, a limited liability company, a business trust, an estate, a trust, an association, a joint venture, a proprietorship, a joint venture, an agency, an instrumentality, a corporate officer, an executive, or any other legal or commercial entity, whether domestic or foreign, that has 75 or more businesses or establishments located within the state and is identified as a retail business or establishment in the North American Industry Classification System within the retail trade category 45611.
- “Self-service checkout” means an automated process that enables customers to scan, bag, and pay for their purchases without human assistance.
- “Assessment” or “worker and consumer impact assessment” means a study evaluating the potential negative effects on employees, consumers, or the public of a consequential workplace technology. The assessment shall include all of the following:
- A detailed description of the consequential workplace technology, its intended purpose, and justification for adoption by the employer.
- A description of the data used by the consequential workplace technology, including the specific categories of data that will be processed as input and any data used to train the technology.
- The number of employees, identified by job classification, whose duties would be affected by the consequential workplace technology, as well as a description of how the duties of employees in each job classification would be affected.
- The number of jobs, identified by job classification, that would be eliminated by the consequential workplace technology.
- The number of work hours, identified by job classification, that would be eliminated by the consequential workplace technology.
- The total amount of salaries and benefits that would be eliminated as a result of the consequential workplace technology.
- A description of the potential gaps in skills of employees affected by the technology that may result from the consequential workplace technology.
- The total amount budgeted for, and descriptions of, training and retraining programs for affected employees.
- An analysis of whether there will be human oversight of the consequential workplace technology.
- An analysis of the potential effect of the consequential workplace technology on consumers, including any barriers to access that the technology could create for certain populations of consumers, including, but not limited to, seniors, the disabled, the unbanked, those without access to appropriate technology, youth, or other vulnerable populations, and what proportion of customers is likely to be impacted.
- An analysis of the potential health and safety hazards created for employees, customers, or the public at large by the consequential workplace technology and what measures the employer will take to mitigate those potential hazards.
- What data will be collected from employees and consumers by the consequential workplace technology and whether they will have the option to opt-out of personal data collection.
- “Consequential workplace technology” means artificial intelligence or automated decision-making systems that significantly impacts, eliminates, or automates the core job functions agreed upon between an employer and an employee upon hire or following a subsequent change in position or department. Consequential workplace technology includes, but is not limited to, self-checkout robotics, wearable sensors, scanners, and electronic monitoring.
- Prohibits a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment from providing a self-service checkout option for customers unless all of the following conditions are satisfied:
- At least one manual checkout station is staffed by an employee at the time that a self-service checkout option is made available.
- The employer has established a workplace policy that limits self-service checkouts to purchases of no more than 15 items and includes signage within the self-service checkout area to that effect.
- Customers are prohibited from using self-service checkout to purchase either of the following:
- Items that require customers to provide a form of identification, including, but not limited to, alcohol and tobacco products.
- Items subject to special theft-deterrent measures, including, but not limited to, locked cabinets and electronic article surveillance tags, that require the intervention of an employee of the establishment for the customer to access or purchase the item.
- No more than two self-service checkout stations are simultaneously monitored by any one employee and the employee is relieved from all other duties while monitoring, including, but not limited to, operating a manual checkout station.
- Customers are prohibited from using self-service checkout to purchase either of the following:
- Requires a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout to include self-service checkout in their analysis of potential work hazards for purposes of their existing Injury and Illness Prevention Plans.
- Requires a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment to complete a worker and consumer impact assessment before using or procuring a consequential workplace technology.
- Requires the grocery or retail drug establishment to notify workers potentially impacted by the consequential workplace technology, and their collective bargaining representative, at least 60 days before conducting the assessment and requires the employer to conduct all major phases of the assessment with the direct, meaningful, and sustained involvement of impacted employees and their collective bargaining representative, if applicable.
- Requires that the assessment be provided to employees potentially affected by the consequential workplace technology, or their collective bargaining representative, 60 days before implementation of the workplace technology.
- Requires the grocery or retail drug establishment to post a copy of the assessment in a location accessible to its employees and customers before, and for at least 90 days following, implementation of the consequential workplace technology.
Background
Technology and its Impact on Employment. With technological advancements happening faster than humans can react, the opportunities for pausing to evaluate its impact are often missed. Until recently, advancements in technology often automated physical tasks, such as those performed on factory floors or self-checkouts, but artificial intelligence (AI) functions more like human brainpower. As this technology develops, so do fears of worker displacement in more areas and industries. According to the Pew Research Center, in 2022, 19 percent of American workers were in jobs that are the most exposed to AI, in which the most important activities may be either replaced or assisted by AI.[1] Because technology can be used to either replace or complement the work of employees, it is difficult to identify which industries or occupations will be most impacted.
Self-Checkouts and Retail Theft. With the help of self-checkouts and other models like curbside pick-up, technology has made some aspects of everyday shopping easier. Unfortunately, it also appears to have contributed to retail theft or inventory “shrink” and understaffing, which increases potential for verbal and physical altercations, and the displacement of workers.
Recent news articles have reported many companies moving away from its use. A January 2024 CNN article references a study by Drexel University published in the Journal of Business Research, which found that regular check-out lanes staffed by cashiers made customers more loyal to the store and more likely to revisit in the future as opposed to using self-checkout.[2] The article further reports that self-checkouts lead to higher merchandise losses from customer errors and more intentional shoplifting than when human cashiers are ringing up customers. According to this article, a study of retailers in the United States, Britain and other European countries found that companies with self-checkout lanes and apps had a loss rate of about 4 percent - more than double the industry average.[3]
Several companies, including Target and Walmart, have recently announced changes to their automated register options in stores throughout the country, scaling back on the use of self-checkout and imposing item limits. Some retailers are taking other approaches to try to curb retail theft with the help of technology. For example, Sam’s Club is replacing the practice of having workers verifying receipts as shoppers’ exit the store with the use of AI powered technology that can visually scan a customer’s cart and verify items are paid.[4]
Need for this bill? According to the author, “self-checkout machines are notoriously glitchy, which creates more work for the reduced workforce and workers are expected to monitor anywhere from four to ten machines on their own. The issues with self-checkout machines and understaffing also increase customer irritation and workers are at risk of verbal and physical assault by frustrated customers. Self-checkout also creates other problems for the public. Customers who are not tech savvy or need human assistance have limited access when there are fewer staffed check stands open. Self-checkout often does not have language options other than English, making them more challenging for speakers of other languages. The overall lack of workers available for customer assistance makes the shopping experience unpleasant and inconvenient.”
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 553 (Cortese, Chapter 289, Statutes of 2023) required employers to establish, implement, and maintain an effective workplace violence prevention plan (WVPP) that includes, among other elements, requirements to maintain incident logs, provide specified trainings, and conduct periodic reviews of the plan. This bill also authorizes a collective bargaining representative of an employee who has suffered unlawful violence from any individual, to seek a temporary restraining order (TRO) and an order after hearing on behalf of the employee(s) at the workplace.
AB 183 (Ma, Chapter 726, Statutes of 2011) prohibited off-sale licensees from selling alcoholic beverages using a customer-operated checkout stand located on the licensee’s physical premises.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, this bill’s fiscal impact to the State is unknown, and would depend on the extent to which future administrative and enforcement activity occurs at the state level (General Fund and/or special fund).
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/16/24)
California Labor Federation (co-source)
Prosecutors Alliance of California (co-source)
United Food and Commercial Workers, Western States Council (co-source)
California Federation of Teachers
California Professional Firefighters
California School Employees Association
California State Legislative Board of the Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation
Workers – Transportation Division (SMART-TD)
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
California United for a Responsible Budget
Californians for Safety and Justice
Consumer Attorneys of California
Consumer Federation of California
Courage California
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Fund Her
Initiate Justice Action
Legal Services for Prisoners with Children
Smart Justice California
TechEquity Collaborative
UNITE-HERE
Vera California
Voices for Progress
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/16/24)
California Chamber of Commerce
California Grocers Association
California Retailers Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Proponents argue that, “lone frontline clerks must serve customers while at the same time watching for shoplifters and dealing with disruptive individuals. The issues with self-checkout machines and understaffing also increase customer irritation and workers are at risk of verbal and physical assault by frustrated customers. All the while, violence against retail workers is at an all-time high. According to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), workplace violence is the third leading cause of fatal occupational injuries and affects nearly two million workers annually.” Proponents further argue that, “the shift away from self-checkout does not mean a return to human staffing. The rapid advancement of AI and adoption by stores like Amazon Go means employers are poised to implement new technology most likely to replace workers and reduce labor costs. The lesson of self-checkout is that employers need to thoroughly assess the impact on workers and customers before adopting technology to prevent harm.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to opponents, “this bill attempts to insert burdensome regulations on retailers who are already reevaluating how to best use self-checkout technologies, with some moving to new forms of technology to help deter theft and make the workplace safer. Specifically, this bill requires retailers to complete ‘a worker and consumer impact assessment’ for every new technology that has a ‘significant’ impact on job functions. Not only is the assessment unnecessarily intrusive into a retailer’s business practices, the ‘significant’ language is undefined and vague. While it is important to consider the potential effects of new technologies on employees and consumers, overly burdensome regulations, such as those proposed in this bill, may stifle business growth, innovation, and competitiveness in an increasingly digital economy.”
Prepared by: Alma Perez-Schwab / L., P.E. & R. / (916) 651-1556
5/18/24 14:06:50
**** END ****
“Which U.S. Workers Are More Exposed to AI on Their Jobs?” Pew Research Center, Washington, D.C. (July 26, 2023) https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2023/07/26/which-u-s-workers-are-more-exposed-to-ai-on-their-jobs/ ↑
Meyersohn, N. (January 23, 2024) Customers have soured on self-checkout, and a new study says there’s proof. CNN. https://www.cnn.com/2024/01/23/business/self-checkout-shopping-stores/index.html ↑
Ibid. ↑
Ibid. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 1446 (Smallwood-Cuevas) - Grocery establishment and retail drug establishment employees: self-service checkout and technologies affecting essential job functions
Version: April 9, 2024 | Policy Vote: L., P.E. & R. 4 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 16, 2024 | Consultant: Robert Ingenito |
Bill Summary:
SB 1446 would (1) prohibit a grocery or retail drug establishment from providing a self-service checkout option for customers unless specified conditions are met, and (2) require a grocery or retail drug establishment that develops, procures, uses, or otherwise implements artificial intelligence, automation, or any new or modified technology that significantly affects the essential job functions of its employees, eliminates jobs or functions, or that enables self-service by its customers to complete a worker and consumer impact assessment before implementing the technology.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 16, 2024
Fiscal Impact:
This bill’s fiscal impact to the State is unknown, and would depend on the extent to which future administrative and enforcement activity occurs at the state level (General Fund and/or special fund).
Author Amendments:
- Increase the bill’s item limit to 15, as specified.
- Require a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment to complete a worker and customer impact assessment, as defined, before using or procuring consequential workplace technology, also as defined.
- Require a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment to (1) notify specified workers and their collective bargaining representatives at least 60 days before conducting the worker and customer impact assessment, (2) provide the assessment to specified employees or their collective bargaining representatives at least 60 days before the implementation of the consequential workplace technology, and (3) post a copy of the assessment in an assessable location, as specified.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 1446 (Smallwood-Cuevas) - Grocery establishment and retail drug establishment employees: self-service checkout and technologies affecting essential job functions
Version: April 9, 2024 | Policy Vote: L., P.E. & R. 4 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: May 6, 2024 | Consultant: Robert Ingenito |
Bill Summary:
SB 1446 would (1) prohibit a grocery or retail drug establishment from providing a self-service checkout option for customers unless specified conditions are met, and (2) require a grocery or retail drug establishment that develops, procures, uses, or otherwise implements artificial intelligence, automation, or any new or modified technology that significantly affects the essential job functions of its employees, eliminates jobs or functions, or that enables self-service by its customers to complete a worker and consumer impact assessment before implementing the technology.
Fiscal Impact:
This bill’s fiscal impact to the State is unknown, and would depend on the extent to which future administrative and enforcement activity occurs at the state level (General Fund and/or special fund).
Background:
Current law requires employers to have a written Injury and Illness Prevention Program (IIPP). Among other elements, the IIPP must include procedures for identifying and evaluating workplace hazards as well as procedures for correcting them. Employers are also required to periodically review and update the IIPP to account for changing work conditions.
SB 553 (Cortese) was enacted in 2023. This measure additionally required employers to establish, implement, and maintain an effective Workplace Violence Prevention Plan (WVPP) that includes, among other elements, requirements to maintain incident logs, provide specified trainings, and conduct periodic reviews. WVPP requirements specifically focus on injuries that could result from violence experienced while at work. The bill defined “workplace violence” as, among other things, the threat or use of physical force against an employee that results in, or has a high likelihood of resulting in, injury, psychological trauma, or stress, regardless of whether the employee sustains an injury.
Proposed Law:
This bill would, among other things, do the following:
- Prohibit a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment (as defined) from providing a self-service checkout (also as defined) option for customers unless all of the following conditions are satisfied: (1) at least one manual checkout station (as defined) is staffed by an employee at the time that a self-service checkout option is made available, (2) self-service checkouts are limited to purchases of 10 or fewer items and the establishment must include signage to that effect, (3) customers are prohibited from using self-service checkout to purchase specified items, and (4) no more than two self-service checkout stations are simultaneously monitored by any one employee and the employee is relieved from all other duties while monitoring, including, but not limited to, operating a manual checkout station.
- Require a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout to include self-service checkout in their analysis of potential work hazards for purposes of their existing IIPP.
- Require a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that develops, procures, uses, or otherwise implements artificial intelligence, automation, or any new or modified technology that significantly affects the essential job functions of its employees, eliminates jobs or essential job functions of its employees, or that enables self-service by its customers to complete a worker and consumer impact assessment, as defined, before implementing the technology.
- Specify that a worker and consumer impact assessment shall include all of the following: (1) a detailed description of the workplace technology, its intended purpose, and justification for adoption by the employer, (2) a description of the data used by the technology, including the specific categories of data that will be processed as input and any data used to train the technology, (3) the number of employees, identified by job classification, whose duties would be affected by the workplace technology, as well as a description of how the duties of employees in each job classification would be affected, (4) the number of jobs, identified by job classification, that would be eliminated by the workplace technology, (5) the number of work hours, identified by job classification, that would be eliminated by the workplace technology, (6) the total amount of salaries and benefits that would be eliminated as a result of the workplace technology, (7) a description of the potential gaps in skills of employees affected by the workplace technology that may result from the workplace technology, (8) the total amount budgeted for, and descriptions of, training and retraining programs for affected employees, (9) an analysis of whether there will be human oversight of the workplace technology, (10) an analysis of the potential effect of the workplace technology on consumers, including any barriers to access that the technology could create for certain populations of consumers, including, but not limited to, seniors, the disabled, the unbanked, those without access to appropriate technology, youth, or other vulnerable populations, (11) an analysis of the potential health and safety hazards created for employees, customers, or the public at large by the workplace technology and what measures the employer will take to mitigate those potential hazards, and (12) what data will be collected from employees and consumers by the workplace technology and whether they will have the option to opt-out of personal data collection.
- Require the grocery or retail drug establishment to notify and solicit input from its employees potentially affected by the workplace technology, or their collective bargaining representative, at least 60 days before drafting the worker and consumer impact assessment.
- Require that the worker and consumer impact assessment be provided to employees potentially affected by the workplace technology, or their collective bargaining representative, 60 days before implementation of the workplace technology.
- Require the grocery or retail drug establishment to post a copy of the worker and consumer impact assessment in a location accessible to its employees and customers before, and for at least 90 days following, implementation of the workplace technology.
Related Legislation:
- SB 553 (Cortese, Chapter 289, Statutes of 2023) required employers to establish, implement, and maintain an effective workplace violence prevention plan (WVPP) that includes, among other elements, requirements to maintain incident logs, provide specified trainings, and conduct periodic reviews of the plan. This bill also authorizes a collective bargaining representative of an employee who has suffered unlawful violence from any individual, to seek a temporary restraining order (TRO) and an order after hearing on behalf of the employee(s) at the workplace.
- AB 183 (Ma, Chapter 726, Statutes of 2011) prohibited off-sale licensees from selling alcoholic beverages using a customer-operated checkout stand located on the licensee’s physical premises. This bill makes findings and declarations regarding the negative effects of allowing alcoholic beverages to be sold using self-service checkouts.
Staff Comments:
As noted above, the fiscal impact that would result from this bill is unknown. The bill as currently drafted does not have an explicit enforcement mechanism. Specifically, it does not assign enforcement activities to the Attorney General or to any specific department. However, this bill could nevertheless result in increased costs to the State. For instance, it would require a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout to include self-service checkout in its analysis of potential work hazards for purposes of its IIPP, which could potentially result in increased state administrative costs.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR, PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Senator Lola Smallwood-Cuevas, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 1446 Hearing Date: April 17, 2024
Author: | Smallwood-Cuevas | ||
Version: | April 9, 2024 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Alma Perez-Schwab | ||
SUBJECT: Grocery establishment and retail drug establishment employees: self-service checkout and technologies affecting essential job functions
KEY ISSUES
This bill prohibits a grocery or retail drug establishment from providing a self-service checkout option for customers unless specified conditions are met, including, among others, that at least one manual station is staffed by an employee and that self-service checkouts be limited to purchases of 10 or fewer items.
This bill requires a grocery or retail drug establishment that develops, procures, uses, or otherwise implements artificial intelligence, automation, or any new or modified technology that significantly affects the essential job functions of its employees, eliminates jobs or functions, or that enables self-service by its customers to complete a worker and consumer impact assessment before implementing the technology.
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- The California Occupational Safety and Health Act, assures safe and healthful working conditions for all California workers by authorizing the enforcement of effective standards, assisting and encouraging employers to maintain safe and healthful working conditions, and by providing for research, information, education, training, and enforcement in the field of occupational safety and health. (Labor Code §6300)
- Establishes the Division of Occupational Safety and Health (Cal/OSHA) within the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) to, among other things, propose, administer, and enforce occupational safety and health standards. (Labor Code §6300 et seq.)
- Requires employers to establish, implement and maintain an effective Injury and Illness Prevention Program (IIPP) that must include, among other things, a system for identifying and evaluating workplace hazards, including scheduled periodic inspections to identify unsafe conditions and work practices and the employer’s methods and procedures for correcting those unsafe or unhealthy conditions and work practices in a timely manner. The IIPP must also include the employer’s system for communicating with employees on occupational health and safety matters. (Labor Code §6401.7)
- Requires an employer to establish, implement, and maintain an effective Workplace Violence Prevention Plan (WVPP) that is in writing, available and easily accessible to employees, authorized employee representatives, and representatives of the division at all times, and be specific to the hazards and corrective measures for each work area and operation. Provides that the WVPP may be incorporated as a stand-alone section in the employer’s existing IIPP or maintained as a separate document. (Labor Code §6401.9)
- Requires the WVPP, among other elements, to include:
- Names or job titles of the person responsible for implementing the plan.
- Procedures to obtain the active involvement of employees and authorized employee representatives in developing and implementing the plan.
- Effective procedures for the employer to accept and respond to reports of workplace violence, and to prohibit retaliation against an employee who makes such a report.
- Effective procedures to respond to actual or potential workplace violence emergencies, including evacuation and sheltering plans, as specified.
- Procedures to develop and provide specified training to respond to emergencies.
- Procedures to correct workplace violence hazards, as specified, and procedures to review the effectiveness of the plan and revise as needed.
(Labor Code §6401.9)
- Requires employers to record information in a violent incident log of every workplace violence incident, as specified, and include detailed information regarding the type of attack, weapons used, and consequences including whether or not law enforcement was contacted and their response. (Labor Code §6401.9)
- Authorizes Cal/OSHA to enforce these provisions by issuing a citation alleging a violation and a notice of civil penalty, as specified, and authorizes any person cited to appeal the citation and penalty to the appeals board in a manner consistent with Labor Code Section 6319. (Labor Code §6401.9)
- Prohibits a person from discharging or in any manner discriminating or retaliating against any employee because the employee, among other things, reported a work-related fatality, injury, or illness, requested access to occupational injury or illness reports and records, or exercised any other rights protected by the federal Occupational Safety and Health Act (29 U.S.C. Sec. 651 et seq.), as specified. (Labor Code §6310)
- Establishes grocery worker retention provisions requiring an incumbent (buyer) of an existing grocery establishment to retain employees for a 90-day transition period during which an employee may only be discharged for cause, as specified, and considered for continued employment at the end of the transition period. (Labor Code §2500-2522)
- Defines “grocery establishment” to mean a retail store in this state that is over 15,000 square feet in size and that sells primarily household foodstuffs for offsite consumption, including the sale of fresh produce, meats, poultry, fish, deli products, dairy products, canned foods, dry foods, beverages, baked foods, or prepared foods. Other household supplies or other products shall be secondary to the primary purpose of food sales. A distribution center owned and operated by a grocery establishment and used primarily to distribute goods to or from its owned stores shall be considered a grocery establishment, regardless of its square footage. A grocery establishment does not include a retail store that has ceased operations for 12 months or more. (Labor Code §2502)
This bill:
- Defines, among others, the following terms:
- “Grocery establishment” as defined in existing Labor Code Section 2502.
- “Manual checkout station” means a station that is not a self-service checkout station and at which an employee provides human assistance to a customer scanning, bagging, or accepting payment for the customer’s purchases.
- “Retail drug establishment” means a person, including an individual, a corporation, a partnership, a limited partnership, a limited liability partnership, a limited liability company, a business trust, an estate, a trust, an association, a joint venture, a proprietorship, a joint venture, an agency, an instrumentality, a corporate officer, an executive, or any other legal or commercial entity, whether domestic or foreign, that has 75 or more businesses or establishments located within the state and is identified as a retail business or establishment in the North American Industry Classification System within the retail trade category 45611.
- “Self-service checkout” means an automated process that enables customers to scan, bag, and pay for their purchases without human assistance.
- Prohibits a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment from providing a self-service checkout option for customers unless all of the following conditions are satisfied:
- At least one manual checkout station is staffed by an employee at the time that a self-service checkout option is made available.
- Self-service checkouts are limited to purchases of 10 or fewer items and the establishment must include signage to that effect.
- Customers are prohibited from using self-service checkout to purchase the following:
- Items that require customers to provide a form of identification, including, but not limited to, alcohol and tobacco products.
- Items subject to special theft-deterrent measures, including, but not limited to, locked cabinets and electronic article surveillance tags, that require the intervention of an employee of the establishment for the customer to access or purchase the item.
- No more than two self-service checkout stations are simultaneously monitored by any one employee and the employee is relieved from all other duties while monitoring, including, but not limited to, operating a manual checkout station.
- Requires a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that offers self-service checkout to include self-service checkout in their analysis of potential work hazards for purposes of their existing Injury and Illness Prevention Plans.
- Requires a grocery establishment or retail drug establishment that develops, procures, uses, or otherwise implements artificial intelligence, automation, or any new or modified technology that significantly affects the essential job functions of its employees, eliminates jobs or essential job functions of its employees, or that enables self-service by its customers to complete a worker and consumer impact assessment before implementing the technology.
- Defines “worker and consumer impact assessment” to mean a study evaluating the potential negative effects on employees, consumers, or the public of a new or modified workplace technology that significantly affects the essential job functions of employees, eliminates jobs or essential job functions of employees, or that enables self-service by customers.
- Specifies that a worker and consumer impact assessment shall include all of the following:
- A detailed description of the workplace technology, its intended purpose, and justification for adoption by the employer.
- A description of the data used by the technology, including the specific categories of data that will be processed as input and any data used to train the technology.
- The number of employees, identified by job classification, whose duties would be affected by the workplace technology, as well as a description of how the duties of employees in each job classification would be affected.
- The number of jobs, identified by job classification, that would be eliminated by the workplace technology.
- The number of work hours, identified by job classification, that would be eliminated by the workplace technology.
- The total amount of salaries and benefits that would be eliminated as a result of the workplace technology.
- A description of the potential gaps in skills of employees affected by the workplace technology that may result from the workplace technology.
- The total amount budgeted for, and descriptions of, training and retraining programs for affected employees.
- An analysis of whether there will be human oversight of the workplace technology.
- An analysis of the potential effect of the workplace technology on consumers, including any barriers to access that the technology could create for certain populations of consumers, including, but not limited to, seniors, the disabled, the unbanked, those without access to appropriate technology, youth, or other vulnerable populations.
- An analysis of the potential health and safety hazards created for employees, customers, or the public at large by the workplace technology and what measures the employer will take to mitigate those potential hazards.
- What data will be collected from employees and consumers by the workplace technology and whether they will have the option to opt-out of personal data collection.
- Requires the grocery or retail drug establishment to notify and solicit input from its employees potentially affected by the workplace technology, or their collective bargaining representative, at least 60 days before drafting the worker and consumer impact assessment.
- Requires that the worker and consumer impact assessment be provided to employees potentially affected by the workplace technology, or their collective bargaining representative, 60 days before implementation of the workplace technology.
- Requires the grocery or retail drug establishment to post a copy of the worker and consumer impact assessment in a location accessible to its employees and customers before, and for at least 90 days following, implementation of the workplace technology.
COMMENTS
1. Background on Existing Employer Obligations:
In California, every employer has a legal obligation to provide and maintain a safe and healthful workplace for their employees. Employers must have a written Injury and Illness Prevention Program (IIPP) that is developed and implemented effectively with emphasis on staff safety and health. Among other elements, the IIPP must include procedures for identifying and evaluating workplace hazards as well as procedures for correcting them. Employers are also required to periodically review and update the IIPP to account for changing work conditions.
Last year, SB 553 (Cortese) was chaptered, which additionally required employers to establish, implement, and maintain an effective Workplace Violence Prevention Plan (WVPP) that includes, among other elements, requirements to maintain incident logs, provide specified trainings, and conduct periodic reviews. WVPP requirements specifically focus on injuries that could result from violence experienced while at work. The bill defined “workplace violence” as, among other things, the threat or use of physical force against an employee that results in, or has a high likelihood of resulting in, injury, psychological trauma, or stress, regardless of whether the employee sustains an injury.
2. Technology and its Impact on Employment:
With technological advancements happening faster than humans can react, the opportunities for pausing to evaluate its impact are often missed. Until recently, advancements in technology often automated physical tasks, such as those performed on factory floors or self-checkouts, but artificial intelligence (AI) functions more like human brainpower. As this technology develops, so do fears of worker displacement in more areas and industries. According to the Pew Research Center, in 2022, 19 percent of American workers were in jobs that are the most exposed to AI, in which the most important activities may be either replaced or assisted by AI.[1] Because technology can be used to either replace or complement the work of employees, it is difficult to identify which industries or occupations will be most impacted.
3. Self-Checkouts and Retail Theft:
Self-checkout lanes were introduced as a way to cut down on wait times, boost efficiency in stores, and both reduce the need for staff in those lanes or allow for their reassignment to other tasks. Self-checkouts served a critical role during the COVID-19 pandemic and helped address the need to isolate and limit contact with other people to reduce the spread of the virus. With the help of self-checkouts and other models like curbside pick-up, technology has made some aspects of everyday shopping easier. Unfortunately, it also appears to have contributed to retail theft or inventory “shrink” and understaffing, which increases potential for verbal and physical altercations, and the displacement of workers.
Recent news articles have reported many companies moving away from its use. A January 2024 CNN article references a study by Drexel University published in the Journal of Business Research, which found that regular check-out lanes staffed by cashiers made customers more loyal to the store and more likely to revisit in the future as opposed to using self-checkout.[2] The article further reports that self-checkouts lead to higher merchandise losses from customer errors and more intentional shoplifting than when human cashiers are ringing up customers. According to this article, a study of retailers in the United States, Britain and other European countries found that companies with self-checkout lanes and apps had a loss rate of about 4 percent - more than double the industry average.[3]
Several companies, including Target and Walmart, have recently announced changes to their automated register options in stores throughout the country, scaling back on the use of self-checkout and imposing item limits. Target, for example, is restricting self-checkout to customers buying 10 items or less and directing larger item purchases to full service lanes with cashiers. Target has cited the impetus as customer feedback and a desire to provide a better shopping experience.[4] Dollar General is another retailer scaling back on self-checkouts, reporting that in 9,000 of its stores the company will be converting some or all of the self-checkout registers to assisted-checkout options.[5]
Some retailers are taking other approaches to try to curb retail theft with the help of technology. For example, Sam’s Club is replacing the practice of having workers verifying receipts as shoppers’ exit the store with the use of AI powered technology that can visually scan a customer’s cart and verify items are paid.[6]
As these new technologies are developed, it is imperative that the state provide guidance to employers on how to review and disclose the impacts to workers and consumers.
4. Need for this bill?
According to the author, “Self-checkout and the reduction in front-line grocery workers have created a range of problems for retailers, workers, and the public. While companies proclaim there has been an increase in retail theft, much of the losses they allege can be traced to self-checkout and the reduction in their workforce. Data shows that self-checkout machines cause 16 times more shrink than checkout via a cashier. In 2022, self-checkout accounted for under 30% of total transactions, yet self-checkout machines have cost food retailers more than $10 billion in lost profits annually. Nearly 7% of self-checkout transactions had at least some partial shrink compared to 0.32% with cashiers. On a revenue basis, this suggests a shrink rate of 3.5% for self-checkout machines versus only 0.21% for full-service cashier stations staffed by an employee.
The elimination of workers’ jobs due to self-checkout is especially harmful to the workers’ health and safety. The reduction in frontline checkers has caused a crisis with chronic understaffing and an overworked workforce creating opportunities for theft, assault, and violent incidents. Self-checkout machines are notoriously glitchy, which creates more work for the reduced workforce and workers are expected to monitor anywhere from four to ten machines on their own. The issues with self-checkout machines and understaffing also increase customer irritation and workers are at risk of verbal and physical assault by frustrated customers.
Self-checkout also creates other problems for the public. Customers who are not tech savvy or need human assistance have limited access when there are fewer staffed check stands open. Self-checkout often does not have language options other than English, making them more challenging for speakers of other languages. The overall lack of workers available for customer assistance makes the shopping experience unpleasant and inconvenient. The touted convenience of self-checkout is, in reality, understaffed stores, glitchy machines, and increased retail theft.”
5. Proponent Arguments:
The sponsors of the measure, the United Food and Commercial Workers, argue that “Understaffed stores create the opportunity for theft, assault, and violent incidents. Lone frontline clerks must serve customers while at the same time watching for shoplifters and dealing with disruptive individuals. The issues with self-checkout machines and understaffing also increase customer irritation and workers are at risk of verbal and physical assault by frustrated customers. All the while, violence against retail workers is at an all-time high. According to the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA), workplace violence is the third leading cause of fatal occupational injuries and affects nearly two million workers annually.”
Furthermore, they note “retailers have used the threat of theft caused by understaffing as an excuse to lock up products, creating more work and further frustrating customers. The types of products that are locked up, and in which stores, also indicate racial bias, rightfully angering customers who see that stores are unfairly targeting them.” They argue that, “in recognition of the problem, companies like Walmart, Target, Dollar General, and other major grocery stores, are moving away from self-checkout as the losses from retail theft hit their bottom line. Lowe’s CEO has come out and said that the way to reduce losses, now being the industry norm, is to remove self-checkout and increase staffing in the stores, not just at checkout but in every department.[7]”
Proponents further argue that, “the shift away from self-checkout does not mean a return to human staffing. The rapid advancement of AI and adoption by stores like Amazon Go means employers are poised to implement new technology most likely to replace workers and reduce labor costs. The lesson of self-checkout is that employers need to thoroughly assess the impact on workers and customers before adopting technology to prevent harm.”
6. Opponent Arguments:
The California Chamber of Commerce and the California Retailers Association are opposed, arguing that, “this bill attempts to insert burdensome regulations on retailers who are already reevaluating how to best use self-checkout technologies, with some moving to new forms of technology to help deter theft and make the workplace safer. Specifically, this bill requires retailers to complete ‘a worker and consumer impact assessment’ for every new technology that has a ‘significant’ impact on job functions. Not only is the assessment unnecessarily intrusive into a retailer’s business practices, the ‘significant’ language is undefined and vague. While it is important to consider the potential effects of new technologies on employees and consumers, overly burdensome regulations, such as those proposed in this bill, may stifle business growth, innovation, and competitiveness in an increasingly digital economy.”
Additionally, they write that, “Retail theft committed in stores has been brazenly committed regardless of whether there’s employees staffing checkout lanes or the presence of self-checkout lanes. Importantly, many retailers have policies that prevent employees from intervening in theft instances to protect their safety. It should also be noted that SB 1446 requires self-checkout to be included in their analysis of potential work hazards for the purposes of their injury and illness prevention programs. If self-checkout stations are potential hazards, then this is arguably already covered by existing law and the passage of SB 553 (Cortese, Chapter 289, Statutes of 2023), which takes effect July of this year. Adding the duplicative requirement to the injury and illness prevention program is unnecessary and would add confusion to retailers who are already working on compliance with existing law. Because SB 1446 adds provisions to the Labor Code, any error in implementing this new law would expose the retailer to penalties under PAGA.”
Regarding the 10-item limit for self-checkout provisions, they argue, “to place this type of restriction in statute opens the door for meaningless litigation and forces retailers to police the number of items going through self-checkout lanes, which could create a point of friction between a customer and a retail employee, something retailers try to avoid. Many customers appreciate the convenience of self-checkout, particularly for quick purchases, and imposing unnecessary restrictions may deter them from patronizing these establishments altogether.”
Additional opposition from the California Grocers Association notes, “self-checkout is a tool given to a customer to choose how they want to fulfill their shopping experience. Proponents of the measure will say that self-checkout has led to loss of jobs, but that is not the reality. Grocery store operators make sure the workers who, otherwise would have been at the cash register, move to other departments to improve the customer experience.” Furthermore, they argue, “self-checkout is generally a smaller controlled area with several check stands, to have multiple employees in that small area crowds the field for employees and customer. Additionally, the requirement to have an employee to stay in the self-checkout area and not move until relieved by another employee will not allow that employee to go to other departments to help customers, ultimately hurting the customer experience.”
7. Prior/Related Legislation:
SB 553 (Cortese, Chapter 289, Statutes of 2023) required employers to establish, implement, and maintain an effective workplace violence prevention plan (WVPP) that includes, among other elements, requirements to maintain incident logs, provide specified trainings, and conduct periodic reviews of the plan. This bill also authorizes a collective bargaining representative of an employee who has suffered unlawful violence from any individual, to seek a temporary restraining order (TRO) and an order after hearing on behalf of the employee(s) at the workplace.
AB 183 (Ma, Chapter 726, Statutes of 2011) prohibited off-sale licensees from selling alcoholic beverages using a customer-operated checkout stand located on the licensee’s physical premises. This bill makes findings and declarations regarding the negative effects of allowing alcoholic beverages to be sold using self-service checkouts.
SUPPORT
California Labor Federation (Co-Sponsor)
Prosecutors Alliance of California (Co-Sponsor)
United Food and Commercial Workers, Western States Council (Co-Sponsor)
California Federation of Teachers
California State Legislative Board of the Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation Workers –
Transportation Division (SMART-TD)
California United for a Responsible Budget
Californians for Safety and Justice
Consumer Attorneys of California
Courage California
Ella Baker Center for Human Right
Fund Her
Initiate Justice Action
Legal Services for Prisoners with Children
Smart Justice California
TechEquity Collaborative
Vera California
Voices for Progress
OPPOSITION
California Chamber of Commerce
California Grocers Association
California Retailers Association
-- END --
“Which U.S. Workers Are More Exposed to AI on Their Jobs?” Pew Research Center, Washington, D.C. (July 26, 2023) https://www.pewresearch.org/social-trends/2023/07/26/which-u-s-workers-are-more-exposed-to-ai-on-their-jobs/ ↑
Meyersohn, N. (January 23, 2024) Customers have soured on self-checkout, and a new study says there’s proof. CNN. https://www.cnn.com/2024/01/23/business/self-checkout-shopping-stores/index.html ↑
Ibid. ↑
Meyersohn, N. (November 18,2023) Target is testing a new self-checkout policy. CNN. https://www.cnn.com/2023/11/18/business/target-self-checkout-new-system/index.html ↑
PYMTS. (March 21, 2024) Retailers’ Self-Checkout Enthusiasm Dwindles Amid Elevated Theft. PYMTS. https://www.pymnts.com/news/retail/2024/retailers-self-checkout-enthusiasm-dwindles-amid-elevated-theft/ ↑
Ibid. ↑
https://www.businessinsider.com/lowes-ceo-workers-are-greatest-deterrent-for-retail-theft-2023-9 ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Standing Committee on Privacy and Consumer Protection
Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Labor, Public Employment and Retirement
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):