AJR 22: Transgender service members.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2017-09-25
This measure would state that the Legislature respectfully disagrees with statements posted on Twitter by the President of the United States proposing to ban transgender Americans from military service, and would call upon the Governor of California to direct the Armed Forces of the state to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members on the basis of their gender identity or expression, unless superseded by federal law. The measure would also urge the United States Secretary of Defense James Mattis to allow transgender service members who are otherwise able to serve to remain in the United States Armed Forces and recommend to President Trump that transgender individuals who are otherwise able to serve be permitted to join the United States Armed Forces.
This measure would state that the Legislature respectfully disagrees with statements posted on Twitter by the President of the United States proposing to ban transgender Americans from military service, and would call upon the Governor of California to direct the Armed Forces of the state to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members on the basis of their gender identity or expression, unless superseded by federal law. The measure would also urge the United States Secretary of Defense James Mattis to allow transgender service members who are otherwise able to serve to remain in the United States Armed Forces and recommend to President Trump that transgender individuals who are otherwise able to serve be permitted to join the United States Armed Forces.
This measure would state that the Legislature respectfully disagrees with statements posted on Twitter by the President of the United States proposing to ban transgender Americans from military service, and would call upon the Governor of California to direct the Armed Forces of the state to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members on the basis of their gender identity or expression, unless superseded by federal law. The measure would also urge the United States Secretary of Defense James Mattis to allow transgender service members who are otherwise able to serve to remain in the United States Armed Forces and recommend to President Trump that transgender individuals who are otherwise able to serve be permitted to join the United States Armed Forces.
This measure would state that the Legislature respectfully disagrees with statements proposing to ban transgender Americans from military service, and would call upon the Governor of California to direct the Armed Forces of the state to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members on the basis of their gender identity or expression, unless superseded by federal law.
WHEREAS, The protection of all residents from discrimination is a fundamental role of government; and
WHEREAS, California is a national leader in protecting civil rights by enacting laws that protect transgender Californians from discrimination on the basis of gender identity or gender expression; and
WHEREAS, The Unruh Civil Rights Act provides that all persons within the state are free and equal and are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever, no matter what their sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship, primary language, or immigration status; and
WHEREAS, The California Fair Employment and Housing Act prohibits an employer from refusing to employ or from discharging a person because of his or her race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status; and
WHEREAS, In a series of tweets posted on Twitter on July 26, 2017, at 5:55, United States President Donald J. Trump announced that the United States Government will not accept or allow transgender individuals to serve in any capacity in the U.S. military, citing disruption and tremendous costs related to health care for transgender service members; and
WHEREAS, The United States Department of Defense has announced, barring further guidance from the president, they will maintain the policy of allowing currently serving transgender Americans to stay in the military, and many are serving honorably today; and
WHEREAS, The Department of Defense is currently conducting a study on the medical obligations it would incur, the impact on military readiness, and related questions associated with the accession of transgender individuals who are not currently serving in uniform and wish to join the military; and
WHEREAS, Any new policy decision would be inappropriate until that study is complete and thoroughly reviewed by the Secretary of Defense, our military leadership, and the Congress of the United States; and
WHEREAS, There is no lawful or practical reason to force service members who are able to fight, train, and deploy to leave our military regardless of their gender expression or gender identity; and
WHEREAS, Estimates suggest that between 1,320 and 6,630 transgender Americans are on active duty, which is about 0.05 percent of the total military population, and some estimate that as many as 15,000 transgender adults are currently serving on active duty in the military or in the National Guard or Reserve forces; and
WHEREAS, An estimated 1,500 Reserve transgender troops currently serve in the United States military and over 134,000 transgender veterans have served our nation; and
WHEREAS, A RAND Corporation study commissioned by the United States military found that medical care for transgender service members would cost approximately $8 million a year of the Pentagons $600 billion budget compared to $84 million, which the United States military currently spends on Viagra and other erectile dysfunction drugs; and
WHEREAS, This would represent 0.13 percent of the $6 billion annual health care expenditure for active duty service members and research suggests that costs related to health care for transgender service members would be negligible; and
WHEREAS, That same study concluded last year that the impact of allowing transgender Americans to serve openly in our nations Armed Forces would have a minimal impact on military readiness; and
WHEREAS, The United States has a volunteer army, less than 1 percent of Americans have served in the Armed Forces since September 11, 2011, the United States Army had to triple its budget for enlistment bonuses to fill its ranks, and 18 other nations currently allow transgender people to serve openly in their militaries; and
WHEREAS, It is unlawful and illogical to turn away any American from serving in our Armed Forces who is physically qualified and patriotic enough to sign up to serve and protect our country; and
WHEREAS, Equality is good for our military and for service and every able bodied American who wants to serve our country in a time of war should be able to do so; and
WHEREAS, Turning away transgender Americans from military service would be harmful, contrary to American values, and put our nations national security at risk; and
WHEREAS, California hosts more than 190,000 active and reserve service people from all five branches of the United States military and is home to three army bases, seven marine bases, 10 navy bases, six air force bases, and five reserve and national Coast Guard bases; and
WHEREAS, Thousands of transgender troops are currently serving in our military and an unknown number are currently in combat zones; and
WHEREAS, The Presidents announcement that he plans to ban transgender Americans from serving our nations Armed Forces has sent a shocking statement to our transgender troops, which undermines an unknown number of active duty troops; and
WHEREAS, Diversity makes our national security stronger and studies have confirmed that transgender troops are not only serving, but that their open service does nothing to harm military readiness; and
WHEREAS, Numerous veterans and military leaders have come out against the Presidents decision, including Senator and post-9/11 veteran Joni Ernst, Senator John McCain, former Secretary of Defense Ash Carter, and Senator and Iraq War Veteran Tammy Duckworth; and
WHEREAS, On August 25, 2017, President Trump issued directives for the United States Secretary of Defense James Mattis regarding implementation of the transgender ban, which gives Mattis discretion regarding currently serving transgender service members and requires him to submit a plan regarding ascension of transgender service members and gender reassignment surgeries; and
WHEREAS, President Trumps directive prevents transgender individuals from joining the Armed Forces unless Mr. Mattis, in consultation with the Secretary of Homeland Security, provides a recommendation to the contrary that I find convincing; and
WHEREAS, Transgender Americans have always been a part of our Armed Forces and will continue to do so in spite of the Presidents announcements; and
WHEREAS, Transgender Californians are not a burden or a disruption and as United States Senator Orrin Hatch, a stalwart Republican from the state of Utah said, transgender people are people people who want to work hard, improve their communities, and live their lives; now, therefore, be it
Resolved by the Assembly and the Senate of the State of California, jointly, That the Legislature of the State of California respectfully disagrees with the statements posted on Twitter by the President of the United States proposing to ban transgender Americans from military service; and be it further
Resolved, That the Legislature of the State of California calls upon the Governor of California to direct the California National Guard, the California Air National Guard, and the other Armed Forces of the state to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members in enlistment, promotion, or any other aspect of their service, on the basis of their gender identity or expression, unless superseded by federal law, regulation, or formal directive from the United States Department of Defense; and be it further
Resolved, That the Legislature of the State of California urges Secretary of Defense James Mattis to allow transgender service members who are otherwise able to serve to remain in the United States Armed Forces; and be it further
Resolved, That the Legislature of the State of California urges Secretary of Defense James Mattis to recommend to President Trump that transgender individuals who are otherwise able to serve be permitted to join the United States Armed Forces because transgender service members do not hinder military effectiveness, disrupt unit cohesion, or tax military resources; and be it further
Resolved, That the Chief Clerk of the Assembly transmit copies of this resolution to the President and Vice President of the United States, the Speaker of the House of Representatives, the Minority Leader of the House of Representatives, the Majority Leader of the United States Senate, the Minority Leader of the United States Senate, to each Senator and Representative from California in the Congress of the United States, to every member of the California State Legislature, and to the author for appropriate distribution.
WHEREAS, The protection of all residents from discrimination is a fundamental role of government; and
WHEREAS, California is a national leader in protecting civil rights by enacting laws that protect transgender Californians from discrimination on the basis of gender identity or gender expression; and
WHEREAS, The Unruh Civil Rights Act provides that all persons within the state are free and equal and are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever, no matter what their sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship, primary language, or immigration status; and
WHEREAS, The California Fair Employment and Housing Act prohibits an employer from refusing to employ or from discharging a person because of his or her race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status; and
WHEREAS, In a series of tweets posted on Twitter on July 26, 2017, at 5:55, United States President Donald J. Trump announced that the United States Government will not accept or allow transgender individuals to serve in any capacity in the U.S. military, citing disruption and tremendous costs related to health care for transgender service members; and
WHEREAS, The United States Department of Defense has announced, barring further guidance from the president, they will maintain the policy of allowing currently serving transgender Americans to stay in the military, and many are serving honorably today; and
WHEREAS, The Department of Defense is currently conducting a study on the medical obligations it would incur, the impact on military readiness, and related questions associated with the accession of transgender individuals who are not currently serving in uniform and wish to join the military; and
WHEREAS, Any new policy decision would be inappropriate until that study is complete and thoroughly reviewed by the Secretary of Defense, our military leadership, and the Congress of the United States; and
WHEREAS, There is no lawful or practical reason to force service members who are able to fight, train, and deploy to leave our military regardless of their gender expression or gender identity; and
WHEREAS, Estimates suggest that between 1,320 and 6,630 transgender Americans are on active duty, which is about 0.05 percent of the total military population, and some estimate that as many as 15,000 transgender adults are currently serving on active duty in the military or in the National Guard or Reserve forces; and
WHEREAS, An estimated 1,500 Reserve transgender troops currently serve in the United States military and over 134,000 transgender veterans have served our nation; and
WHEREAS, A RAND Corporation study commissioned by the United States military found that medical care for transgender service members would cost approximately $8 million a year of the Pentagons $600 billion budget compared to $84 million, which the United States military currently spends on Viagra and other erectile dysfunction drugs; and
WHEREAS, This would represent 0.13 percent of the $6 billion annual health care expenditure for active duty service members and research suggests that costs related to health care for transgender service members would be negligible; and
WHEREAS, That same study concluded last year that the impact of allowing transgender Americans to serve openly in our nations Armed Forces would have a minimal impact on military readiness; and
WHEREAS, The United States has a volunteer army, less than 1 percent of Americans have served in the Armed Forces since September 11, 2011, the United States Army had to triple its budget for enlistment bonuses to fill its ranks, and 18 other nations currently allow transgender people to serve openly in their militaries; and
WHEREAS, It is unlawful and illogical to turn away any American from serving in our Armed Forces who is physically qualified and patriotic enough to sign up to serve and protect our country; and
WHEREAS, Equality is good for our military and for service and every able bodied American who wants to serve our country in a time of war should be able to do so; and
WHEREAS, Turning away transgender Americans from military service would be harmful, contrary to American values, and put our nations national security at risk; and
WHEREAS, California hosts more than 190,000 active and reserve service people from all five branches of the United States military and is home to three army bases, seven marine bases, 10 navy bases, six air force bases, and five reserve and national Coast Guard bases; and
WHEREAS, Thousands of transgender troops are currently serving in our military and an unknown number are currently in combat zones; and
WHEREAS, The Presidents announcement that he plans to ban transgender Americans from serving our nations Armed Forces has sent a shocking statement to our transgender troops, which undermines an unknown number of active duty troops; and
WHEREAS, Diversity makes our national security stronger and studies have confirmed that transgender troops are not only serving, but that their open service does nothing to harm military readiness; and
WHEREAS, Numerous veterans and military leaders have come out against the Presidents decision, including Senator and post-9/11 veteran Joni Ernst, Senator John McCain, former Secretary of Defense Ash Carter, and Senator and Iraq War Veteran Tammy Duckworth; and
WHEREAS, On August 25, 2017, President Trump issued directives for the United States Secretary of Defense James Mattis regarding implementation of the transgender ban, which gives Mattis discretion regarding currently serving transgender service members and requires him to submit a plan regarding ascension of transgender service members and gender reassignment surgeries; and
WHEREAS, President Trumps directive prevents transgender individuals from joining the Armed Forces unless Mr. Mattis, in consultation with the Secretary of Homeland Security, provides a recommendation to the contrary that I find convincing; and
WHEREAS, Transgender Americans have always been a part of our Armed Forces and will continue to do so in spite of the Presidents announcements; and
WHEREAS, Transgender Californians are not a burden or a disruption and as United States Senator Orrin Hatch, a stalwart Republican from the state of Utah said, transgender people are people people who want to work hard, improve their communities, and live their lives; now, therefore, be it
Resolved by the Assembly and the Senate of the State of California, jointly, That the Legislature of the State of California respectfully disagrees with the statements posted on Twitter by the President of the United States proposing to ban transgender Americans from military service; and be it further
Resolved, That the Legislature of the State of California calls upon the Governor of California to direct the California National Guard, the California Air National Guard, and the other Armed Forces of the state to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members in enlistment, promotion, or any other aspect of their service, on the basis of their gender identity or expression, unless superseded by federal law, regulation, or formal directive from the United States Department of Defense; and be it further
Resolved, That the Legislature of the State of California urges Secretary of Defense James Mattis to allow transgender service members who are otherwise able to serve to remain in the United States Armed Forces; and be it further
Resolved, That the Legislature of the State of California urges Secretary of Defense James Mattis to recommend to President Trump that transgender individuals who are otherwise able to serve be permitted to join the United States Armed Forces because transgender service members do not hinder military effectiveness, disrupt unit cohesion, or tax military resources; and be it further
Resolved, That the Chief Clerk of the Assembly transmit copies of this resolution to the President and Vice President of the United States, the Speaker of the House of Representatives, the Minority Leader of the House of Representatives, the Majority Leader of the United States Senate, the Minority Leader of the United States Senate, to each Senator and Representative from California in the Congress of the United States, to every member of the California State Legislature, and to the author for appropriate distribution.
WHEREAS, The protection of all residents from discrimination is a fundamental role of government; and
WHEREAS, California is a national leader in protecting civil rights by enacting laws that protect transgender Californians from discrimination on the basis of gender identity or gender expression; and
WHEREAS, The Unruh Civil Rights Act provides protection from discrimination by all business establishments in California, including housing and public accommodations, because of age, ancestry, color, disability, national origin, race, religion, sex, and sexual orientation; that all persons within the state are free and equal and are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever, no matter what their sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship, primary language, or immigration status; and
WHEREAS, The California Fair Employment and Housing Act prohibits an employer from refusing to employ or from discharging a person because of his or her race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status; and
WHEREAS, In a series of tweets posted on Twitter on July 26, 2017, at 5:55, United States President Donald J. Trump announced that the United States Government will not accept or allow transgender individuals to serve in any capacity in the U.S. military, citing disruption and tremendous costs related to health care for transgender service members; and
WHEREAS, The United States Department of Defense has announced, barring further guidance from the president, they will maintain the policy of allowing currently serving transgender Americans to stay in the military, and many are serving honorably today; and
WHEREAS, The Department of Defense is currently conducting a study on the medical obligations it would incur, the impact on military readiness, and related questions associated with the accession of transgender individuals who are not currently serving in uniform and wish to join the military; and
WHEREAS, Any new policy decision would be inappropriate until that study is complete and thoroughly reviewed by the Secretary of Defense, our military leadership, and the Congress of the United States; and
WHEREAS, There is no lawful or practical reason to force service members who are able to fight, train, and deploy to leave our military regardless of their gender expression or gender identity; and
WHEREAS, Estimates suggest that between 1,320 and 6,630 transgender Americans are on active duty, which is about 0.05 percent of the total military population, and some estimate that as many as 15,000 transgender adults are currently serving on active duty in the military or in the National Guard or Reserve forces; and
WHEREAS, An estimated 1,500 Reserve transgender troops currently serve in the United States military and over 134,000 transgender veterans have served our nation; and
WHEREAS, A RAND Corporation study commissioned by the United States military found that medical care for transgender service members would cost approximately $8 million a year of the Pentagons $600 billion budget compared to $84 million, which the United States military currently spends on Viagra and other erectile dysfunction drugs; and
WHEREAS, This would represent 0.13 percent of the $6 billion annual health care expenditure for active duty service members and research suggests that costs related to health care for transgender service members would be negligible; and
WHEREAS, That same study concluded last year that the impact of allowing transgender Americans to serve openly in our nations Armed Forces would have a minimal impact on military readiness; and
WHEREAS, The United States has a volunteer army, less than 1 percent of Americans have served in the Armed Forces since September 11, 2011, the United States Army had to triple its budget for enlistment bonuses to fill its ranks, and 18 other nations currently allow transgender people to serve openly in their militaries; and
WHEREAS, It is unlawful and illogical to turn away any American from serving in our Armed Forces who is physically qualified and patriotic enough to sign up to serve and protect our country; and
WHEREAS, Equality is good for our military and for service and every able bodied American who wants to serve our country in a time of war should be able to do so; and
WHEREAS, Turning away transgender Americans from military service would be harmful, contrary to American values, and put our nations national security at risk; and
WHEREAS, California hosts more than 190,000 active and reserve service people from all five branches of the United States military and is home to three army bases, seven marine bases, 10 navy bases, six air force bases, and five reserve and national Coast Guard bases; and
WHEREAS, Thousands of transgender troops are currently serving in our military and an unknown number are currently in combat zones; and
WHEREAS, The Presidents announcement that he plans to ban transgender Americans from serving our nations Armed Forces has sent a shocking statement to our transgender troops, which undermines an unknown number of active duty troops; and
WHEREAS, Diversity makes our national security stronger and studies have confirmed that transgender troops are not only serving, but that their open service does nothing to harm military readiness; and
WHEREAS, Numerous veterans and military leaders have come out against the Presidents decision, including Senator and post-9/11 veteran Joni Ernst, Senator John McCain, former Secretary of Defense Ash Carter, and Senator and Iraq War Veteran Tammy Duckworth; and
WHEREAS, The Presidents announcement that he plans to bar qualified and loyal Americans from serving our nation reduces military readiness and creates division, not cohesion; andWHEREAS, On August 25, 2017, President Trump issued directives for the United States Secretary of Defense James Mattis regarding implementation of the transgender ban, which gives Mattis discretion regarding currently serving transgender service members and requires him to submit a plan regarding ascension of transgender service members and gender reassignment surgeries; and
WHEREAS, President Trumps directive prevents transgender individuals from joining the Armed Forces unless Mr. Mattis, in consultation with the Secretary of Homeland Security, provides a recommendation to the contrary that I find convincing; and
WHEREAS, Transgender Americans have always been a part of our Armed Forces and will continue to do so in spite of the Presidents announcements; and
WHEREAS, Transgender Californians are not a burden or a disruption and as United States Senator Orrin Hatch, a stalwart Republican from the state of Utah said, transgender people are people people who want to work hard, improve their communities, and live their lives; and now, therefore, be it
Resolved by the Assembly and the Senate of the State of California, jointly, That the Legislature of the State of California respectfully disagrees with the statements posted on Twitter by the President of the United States proposing to ban transgender Americans from military service; and be it further
Resolved, That the Legislature of the State of California calls upon the Governor of California to direct the California National Guard, the California Air National Guard, and the other Armed Forces of the state to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members in enlistment, promotion, or any other aspect of their service, on the basis of their gender identity or expression, unless superseded by federal law, regulation, or formal directive from the United States Department of Defense, Defense; and be it further
RESOLVED, That the Legislature of the State of California urges Secretary of Defense James Mattis to allow transgender service members who are otherwise able to serve to remain in the United States Armed Forces; and be it further
RESOLVED, That the Legislature of the State of California urges Secretary of Defense James Mattis to recommend to President Trump that transgender individuals who are otherwise able to serve be permitted to join the United States Armed Forces because transgender service members do not hinder military effectiveness, disrupt unit cohesion, or tax military resources; and be it further
Resolved, That the Chief Clerk of the Assembly transmit copies of this resolution to the President and Vice President of the United States, the Speaker of the House of Representatives, the Minority Leader of the House of Representatives, the Majority Leader of the United States Senate, the Minority Leader of the United States Senate, to each Senator and Representative from California in the Congress of the United States, to every member of the California State Legislature, and to the author for appropriate distribution.
WHEREAS, The protection of all residents from discrimination is a fundamental role of government; and
WHEREAS, California is a national leader in protecting civil rights by enacting laws that protect transgender Californians from discrimination on the basis of gender identity or gender expression; and
WHEREAS, The Unruh Civil Rights Act provides protection from discrimination by all business establishments in California, including housing and public accommodations, because of age, ancestry, color, disability, national origin, race, religion, sex, and sexual orientation; and
WHEREAS, In a series of tweets posted on Twitter on July 26, 2017, at 5:55, United States President Donald J. Trump announced that the United States Government will not accept or allow transgender individuals to serve in any capacity in the U.S. military, citing disruption and tremendous costs related to health care for transgender service members; and
WHEREAS, The United States Department of Defense has announced, barring further guidance from the president, they will maintain the policy of allowing currently serving transgender Americans to stay in the military, and many are serving honorably today; and
WHEREAS, The Department of Defense is currently conducting a study on the medical obligations it would incur, the impact on military readiness, and related questions associated with the accession of transgender individuals who are not currently serving in uniform and wish to join the military; and
WHEREAS, Any new policy decision would be inappropriate until that study is complete and thoroughly reviewed by the Secretary of Defense, our military leadership, and the Congress of the United States; and
WHEREAS, There is no lawful or practical reason to force service members who are able to fight, train, and deploy to leave our military regardless of their gender expression or gender identity; and
WHEREAS, Estimates suggest that between 1,320 and 6,630 transgender Americans are on active duty, which is about 0.05 percent of the total military population, and some estimate that as many as 15,000 transgender adults are currently serving on active duty in the military or in the National Guard or Reserve forces; and
WHEREAS, An estimated 1,500 Reserve transgender troops currently serve in the United States military and over 134,000 transgender veterans have served our nation; and
WHEREAS, A RAND Corporation study commissioned by the United States military found that medical care for transgender service members would cost approximately $8 million a year of the Pentagons $600 billion budget compared to $84 million, which the United States military currently spends on Viagra and other erectile dysfunction drugs; and
WHEREAS, This would represent 0.13 percent of the $6 billion annual health care expenditure for active duty service members and research suggests that costs related to health care for transgender service members would be negligible; and
WHEREAS, That same study concluded last year that the impact of allowing transgender Americans to serve openly in our nations Armed Forces would have a minimal impact on military readiness; and
WHEREAS, The United States has a volunteer army, less than 1 percent of Americans have served in the Armed Forces since September 11, 2011, the United States Army had to triple its budget for enlistment bonuses to fill its ranks, and 18 other nations currently allow transgender people to serve openly in their militaries; and
WHEREAS, It is unlawful and illogical to turn away any American from serving in our Armed Forces who is physically qualified and patriotic enough to sign up to serve and protect our country; and
WHEREAS, Equality is good for our military and for service and every able bodied American who wants to serve our country in a time of war should be able to do so; and
WHEREAS, Turning away transgender Americans from military service would be harmful, contrary to American values, and put our nations national security at risk; and
WHEREAS, California hosts more than 190,000 active and reserve service people from all five branches of the United States military and is home to three army bases, seven marine bases, 10 navy bases, six air force bases, and five reserve and national Coast Guard bases; and
WHEREAS, Thousands of transgender troops are currently serving in our military and an unknown number are currently in combat zones; and
WHEREAS, The Presidents announcement that he plans to ban transgender Americans from serving our nations Armed Forces has sent a shocking statement to our transgender troops, which undermines an unknown number of active duty troops; and
WHEREAS, Diversity makes our national security stronger and studies have confirmed that transgender troops are not only serving, but that their open service does nothing to harm military readiness; and
WHEREAS, Numerous veterans and military leaders have come out against the Presidents decision, including Senator and post-9/11 veteran Joni Ernst, Senator John McCain, former Secretary of Defense Ash Carter, and Senator and Iraq War Veteran Tammy Duckworth; and
WHEREAS, The Presidents announcement that he plans to bar qualified and loyal Americans from serving our nation reduces military readiness and creates division, not cohesion; and
WHEREAS, Transgender Americans have always been a part of our Armed Forces and will continue to do so in spite of the Presidents announcements; and
WHEREAS, Transgender Californians are not a burden or a disruption and as United States Senator Orrin Hatch, a stalwart Republican from the state of Utah said, transgender people are people people who want to work hard, improve their communities, and live their lives; and
Resolved by the Assembly and the Senate of the State of California, jointly, That the Legislature of the State of California respectfully disagrees with the statements posted on Twitter by the President of the United States proposing to ban transgender Americans from military service; and be it further
Resolved, That the Legislature of the State of California calls upon the Governor of California to direct the California National Guard, the California Air National Guard, and the other Armed Forces of the state to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members in enlistment, promotion, or any other aspect of their service, on the basis of their gender identity or expression, unless superseded by federal law, regulation, or formal directive from the United States Department of Defense, and be it further
Resolved, That the Chief Clerk of the Assembly transmit copies of this resolution to the President and Vice President of the United States, the Speaker of the House of Representatives, the Minority Leader of the House of Representatives, the Majority Leader of the United States Senate, the Minority Leader of the United States Senate, to each Senator and Representative from California in the Congress of the United States, to every member of the California State Legislature, and to the author for appropriate distribution.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 25, 2017 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Res. Chapter 209, Statutes of 2017. |
| Sep 25, 2017 | Enrolled and filed with the Secretary of State at 3 p.m. |
| Sep 15, 2017 | In Assembly. Ordered to Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Sep 14, 2017 | Adopted and to Assembly. |
| Sep 11, 2017 | From committee: Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 8, 2017 | In Senate. To Com. on RLS. |
| Sep 7, 2017 | Coauthors revised. |
| Aug 31, 2017 | Coauthors revised. |
| Aug 30, 2017 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Aug 29, 2017 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Amended. |
| Aug 24, 2017 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Aug 22, 2017 | From printer. |
| Aug 21, 2017 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 14, 2017 | Assembly 3rd Reading AJR22 Low et al. By Lara | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 7, 2017 | AJR 22 LOW Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 31, 2017 | Be adopted. To third reading. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Equality California | ** Support | Sep 11, 2017 |
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AJR 22 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AJR 22
Amended: 8/29/17 in Assembly
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 61-1, 9/7/17 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Transgender service members
DIGEST:
This resolution urges Secretary of Defense James Mattis to allow transgender individuals to serve in the United States military and calls on Governor Brown to direct the California National Guard and other state military forces to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members, unless required by federal law or formal directive from the United States Department of Defense.
ANALYSIS: This resolution makes the following legislative findings:
- The protection of all residents from discrimination is a fundamental role of government.
- California is a national leader in protecting civil rights by enacting laws that protect transgender Californians from discrimination on the basis of gender identity or gender expression.
- The Unruh Civil Rights Act provides that all persons within the state are free and equal and are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever, no matter what their sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship, primary language, or immigration status.
- The California Fair Employment and Housing Act prohibits an employer from refusing to employ or from discharging a person because of his or her race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status.
- In a series of tweets posted on Twitter on July 26, 2017, at 5:55, United States President Donald J. Trump announced that the "United States Government will not accept or allow transgender individuals to serve in any capacity in the U.S. military," citing "disruption" and "tremendous costs" related to health care for transgender service members.
- There is no lawful or practical reason to force service members who are able to fight, train, and deploy to leave our military — regardless of their gender expression or gender identity.
- Estimates suggest that between 1,320 and 6,630 transgender Americans are on active duty, which is about 0.05% of the total military population, and some estimate that as many as 15,000 transgender adults are currently serving on active duty in the military or in the National Guard or Reserve forces.
- An estimated 1,500 Reserve transgender troops currently serve in the United States military and over 134,000 transgender veterans have served our nation.
- A RAND (Research and Development) Corporation study commissioned by the United States military found that medical care for transgender service members would cost approximately $8 million a year of the Pentagon's $600 billion budget — compared to $84 million, which the United States military currently spends on Viagra and other erectile dysfunction drugs.
- This would represent 0.13% of the $6 billion annual health care expenditure for active duty service members and research suggests that costs related to health care for transgender service members would be negligible.
- That same study concluded last year that the impact of allowing transgender Americans to serve openly in our nation's Armed Forces would have a minimal impact on military readiness.
- The United States has a volunteer army, less than 1% of Americans have served in the Armed Forces since September 11, 2011, the United States Army had to triple its budget for enlistment bonuses to fill its ranks, and 18 other nations currently allow transgender people to serve openly in their militaries.
- It is unlawful and illogical to turn away any American from serving in our Armed Forces who is physically qualified and patriotic enough to sign up to serve and protect our country.
- Equality is good for our military and for service and every able bodied American who wants to serve our country in a time of war should be able to do so.
- Turning away transgender Americans from military service would be harmful, contrary to American values, and put our nation's national security at risk.
- California hosts more than 190,000 active and reserve service people from all five branches of the United States military and is home to three army bases, seven marine bases, 10 navy bases, six air force bases, and five reserve and national Coast Guard bases.
- Thousands of transgender troops are currently serving in our military and an unknown number are currently in combat zones.
- Diversity makes our national security stronger and studies have confirmed that transgender troops are not only serving, but that their open service does nothing to harm military readiness.
- Numerous veterans and military leaders have come out against the President's decision, including Senator and post-9/11 veteran Joni Ernst, Senator John McCain, former Secretary of Defense Ash Carter, and Senator and Iraq War Veteran Tammy Duckworth.
- On August 25, 2017, President Trump issued directives for the United States Secretary of Defense James Mattis regarding implementation of the transgender ban, which gives Mattis discretion regarding currently serving transgender service members and requires him to submit a plan regarding ascension of transgender service members and gender reassignment surgeries.
- President Trump's directive prevents transgender individuals from joining the Armed Forces unless Secretary Mattis, in consultation with the Secretary of Homeland Security, "provides a recommendation to the contrary that I find convincing."
- The President's announcement that he plans to ban transgender Americans from serving our nation's Armed Forces has sent a shocking statement to our transgender troops, which undermines an unknown number of active duty troops.
- Transgender Americans have always been a part of our Armed Forces and will continue to do so in spite of the president's announcements.
Resolves as follows, on behalf of the Legislature:
- The Legislature of the State of California respectfully disagrees with the statements posted on Twitter by the President of the United States proposing to ban transgender Americans from military service.
- The Governor of California is called upon to direct the California National Guard, the California Air National Guard, and the other Armed Forces of the state to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members in enlistment, promotion, or any other aspect of their service, on the basis of their gender identity or expression, unless superseded by federal law, regulation, or formal directive from the United States Department of Defense.
- Secretary of Defense James Mattis is urged to allow transgender service members who are otherwise able to serve to remain in the United States Military.
- Secretary of Defense James Mattis is urged to recommend to President Trump that transgender individuals who are otherwise able to serve be permitted to join the United States (U.S.) Military because transgender service members do not hinder military effectiveness, disrupt unit cohesion or tax military resources.
Comments
During the Obama Administration, then-Secretary of Defense Ash Carter announced that the military would immediately end its ban on transgender service members from openly serving in the armed forces. The policy—a groundbreaking decision—was marked with three progressive elements. First, it immediately prohibited a qualified service member from being discharged solely on the basis of gender identity. Second, it established guidance on medical care and treatment for transgender service members who seek to transition while in military service. And third, it allowed transgender individuals—beginning no later than July 1, 2017—to enter military service ("accession"). In issuing the new policy, then-Secretary Carter made the following remarks:
This is the right thing to do for our people and for the force. We're talking about talented Americans who are serving with distinction or who want the opportunity to serve. We can't allow barriers unrelated to a person's qualifications prevent us from recruiting and retaining those who can best accomplish the mission. (U.S. Department of Defense, Press Release (June 30, 2016) Secretary of Defense Ash Carter Announces Policy for Transgender Service Members; see also DTM 16-005, Military Service of Transgender Service Members.)
A year after this momentous policy decision, the federal government reversed itself. On June 30, 2017—a day before the Obama-era transgender policy was scheduled to be finalized—Secretary of Defense James Mattis delayed the effective date of the policy until January 1, 2018. (U.S. Department of Defense, Press Release (June 30, 2017) Statement by Chief Pentagon Spokesperson Dana W. White on Transgender Accessions.)
Then, on July 26, 2017, President Trump issued a statement on Twitter (in multiple tweets), stating the following:
The United States Government will not accept or allow transgender individuals to serve in any capacity in the U.S. Military. Our military must be focused on decisive and overwhelming victory and cannot be burdened with the tremendous medical costs and disruption that transgender in the military would entail.
After what appeared to be some confusion between the White House and the Department of Defense regarding the official policy, President Trump issued a memorandum on August 25, 2017, directing a new policy that prohibits transgender individuals from serving in the military. The memorandum does the following: (1) prohibits transgender service members from openly serving in the military; (2) prohibits the use of department funding for transition health procedures, unless such funding is necessary to protect the health of a service member who has already begun treatment; and (3) prohibits the accession of transgender individuals into the military. The memorandum also requires Secretary Mattis to provide a series of recommendations to the President on what action should to be taken by specified dates in 2018.
Without proffering any evidence to support the claims behind the policy change, the Presidential Memorandum stated that the policy change was based on the following reasons:
[The] previous Administration failed to identify a sufficient basis to conclude that terminating the Departments' longstanding policy and practice would not hinder military effectiveness and lethality, disrupt unit cohesion, or tax military resources, and there remain meaningful concerns that further study is needed to ensure that continued implementation of last year's policy change would not have those negative effects. (Pres. mem., 82 Fed.Reg. (Aug. 25, 2017) Presidential Memorandum for the Secretary of Defense and the Secretary of Homeland Security: Military Service by Transgender Individuals.)
In response to the Presidential Memorandum, Secretary Mattis issued a statement on August 29, 2017, stating that the Department had received the memorandum and would convene a panel of mature experts to further study the issue in order to provide a recommendation to the White House. Importantly, Secretary Mattis stated the following:
In the interim, current policy with respect to currently serving members will remain in place. I expect to issue interim guidance to the force concerning the president's direction, including any necessary interim adjustments to procedures, to ensure the continued combat readiness of the force until our final policy on this subject is issued. (U.S. Department of Defense, Press Release (August 29, 2017) Statement by Secretary of Defense Jim Mattis on Military Service by Transgender Individuals.)
This resolution. In response to this federal action, this resolution registers California's disagreement with the Presidential Memorandum and urges Secretary of Defense James Mattis to allow transgender individuals to serve openly in the United States military. This resolution also calls on Governor Brown to direct the California National Guard and other state military forces to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members unless required by federal law or formal directive from the United States Department of Defense.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
Equality California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/11/17)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 61-1, 9/7/17
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bloom, Bocanegra, Bonta, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Cervantes, Chau, Chávez, Chen, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Dababneh, Daly, Eggman, Flora, Frazier, Friedman, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez Fletcher, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Ridley-Thomas, Rodriguez, Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Melendez
NO VOTE RECORDED: Acosta, Travis Allen, Bigelow, Brough, Choi, Dahle, Fong, Gallagher, Harper, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Obernolte, Patterson, Steinorth, Voepel, Waldron
Prepared by: Jonas Austin / SFA / (916) 651-1520
9/11/17 20:25:40
**** END ****
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AJR 22
Author:(Low)
As Amended Ver:
Majority vote
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 8-0 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Cristina Garcia, Kalra, Maienschein, Reyes, Ting |
|
SUMMARY: Urges Secretary of Defense James Mattis to allow transgender individuals to serve in the United States military and calls on Governor Brown to direct the California National Guard and other state military forces to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members, unless required by federal law or formal directive from the United States Department of Defense. Specifically, this resolution:
- Makes various Legislative findings, including but not limited to the following:
- The protection of all residents from discrimination is a fundamental role of government.
- California is a national leader in protecting civil rights by enacting laws that protect transgender Californians from discrimination on the basis of gender identity or gender expression.
- The Unruh Civil Rights Act provides that all persons within the state are free and equal and are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever, no matter what their sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship, primary language, or immigration status.
- The California Fair Employment and Housing Act prohibits an employer from refusing to employ or from discharging a person because of his or her race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status.
- In a series of tweets posted on Twitter on July 26, 2017, at 5:55, United States President Donald J. Trump announced that the "United States Government will not accept or allow transgender individuals to serve in any capacity in the U.S. military," citing "disruption" and "tremendous costs" related to health care for transgender service members.
- There is no lawful or practical reason to force service members who are able to fight, train, and deploy to leave our military — regardless of their gender expression or gender identity.
- Estimates suggest that between 1,320 and 6,630 transgender Americans are on active duty, which is about 0.05% of the total military population, and some estimate that as many as 15,000 transgender adults are currently serving on active duty in the military or in the National Guard or Reserve forces.
- An estimated 1,500 Reserve transgender troops currently serve in the United States military and over 134,000 transgender veterans have served our nation.
- A RAND (Research and Development) Corporation study commissioned by the United States military found that medical care for transgender service members would cost approximately $8 million a year of the Pentagon's $600 billion budget — compared to $84 million, which the United States military currently spends on Viagra and other erectile dysfunction drugs.
- This would represent 0.13% of the $6 billion annual health care expenditure for active duty service members and research suggests that costs related to health care for transgender service members would be negligible.
- That same study concluded last year that the impact of allowing transgender Americans to serve openly in our nation's Armed Forces would have a minimal impact on military readiness.
- The United States has a volunteer army, less than 1% of Americans have served in the Armed Forces since September 11, 2011, the United States Army had to triple its budget for enlistment bonuses to fill its ranks, and 18 other nations currently allow transgender people to serve openly in their militaries.
- It is unlawful and illogical to turn away any American from serving in our Armed Forces who is physically qualified and patriotic enough to sign up to serve and protect our country.
- Equality is good for our military and for service and every able bodied American who wants to serve our country in a time of war should be able to do so.
- Turning away transgender Americans from military service would be harmful, contrary to American values, and put our nation's national security at risk.
- California hosts more than 190,000 active and reserve service people from all five branches of the United States military and is home to three army bases, seven marine bases, 10 navy bases, six air force bases, and five reserve and national Coast Guard bases.
- Thousands of transgender troops are currently serving in our military and an unknown number are currently in combat zones.
- Diversity makes our national security stronger and studies have confirmed that transgender troops are not only serving, but that their open service does nothing to harm military readiness.
- Numerous veterans and military leaders have come out against the President's decision, including Senator and post-9/11 veteran Joni Ernst, Senator John McCain, former Secretary of Defense Ash Carter, and Senator and Iraq War Veteran Tammy Duckworth.
- On August 25, 2017, President Trump issued directives for the United States Secretary of Defense James Mattis regarding implementation of the transgender ban, which gives Mattis discretion regarding currently serving transgender service members and requires him to submit a plan regarding ascension of transgender service members and gender reassignment surgeries.
- President Trump's directive prevents transgender individuals from joining the Armed Forces unless Secretary Mattis, in consultation with the Secretary of Homeland Security, "provides a recommendation to the contrary that I find convincing."
- The President's announcement that he plans to ban transgender Americans from serving our nation's Armed Forces has sent a shocking statement to our transgender troops, which undermines an unknown number of active duty troops.
- Transgender Americans have always been a part of our Armed Forces and will continue to do so in spite of the president's announcements.
- Resolves as follows, on behalf of the Legislature:
- The Legislature of the State of California respectfully disagrees with the statements posted on Twitter by the President of the United States proposing to ban transgender Americans from military service.
- The Governor of California is called upon to direct the California National Guard, the California Air National Guard, and the other Armed Forces of the state to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members in enlistment, promotion, or any other aspect of their service, on the basis of their gender identity or expression, unless superseded by federal law, regulation, or formal directive from the United States Department of Defense.
- Secretary of Defense James Mattis is urged to allow transgender service members who are otherwise able to serve to remain in the United States Military.
- Secretary of Defense James Mattis is urged to recommend to President Trump that transgender individuals who are otherwise able to serve be permitted to join the United States (U.S.) Military because transgender service members do not hinder military effectiveness, disrupt unit cohesion or tax military resources.
- The Chief Clerk of the Assembly shall transmit copies of this resolution to the President and Vice President of the United States, the Speaker of the House of Representatives, the Minority Leader of the House of Representatives, the Majority Leader of the United States Senate, the Minority Leader of the United States Senate, to each Senator and Representative from California in the Congress of the United States, to every member of the California State Legislature, and to the author for appropriate distribution.
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: During the Obama Administration, then-Secretary of Defense Ash Carter announced that the military would immediately end its ban on transgender service members from openly serving in the armed forces. The policy—a groundbreaking decision—was marked with three progressive elements. First, it immediately prohibited a qualified service member from being discharged solely on the basis of gender identity. Second, it established guidance on medical care and treatment for transgender service members who seek to transition while in military service. And third, it allowed transgender individuals—beginning no later than July 1, 2017—to enter military service ("accession"). In issuing the new policy, then-Secretary Carter made the following remarks:
This is the right thing to do for our people and for the force. We're talking about talented Americans who are serving with distinction or who want the opportunity to serve. We can't allow barriers unrelated to a person's qualifications prevent us from recruiting and retaining those who can best accomplish the mission. (U.S. Department of Defense, Press Release (June 30, 2016) Secretary of Defense Ash Carter Announces Policy for Transgender Service Members; see also DTM 16-005, Military Service of Transgender Service Members.)
A year after this momentous policy decision, the federal government reversed itself. On June 30, 2017—a day before the Obama-era transgender policy was scheduled to be finalized—Secretary of Defense James Mattis delayed the effective date of the policy until January 1, 2018. (U.S. Department of Defense, Press Release (June 30, 2017) Statement by Chief Pentagon Spokesperson Dana W. White on Transgender Accessions.)
Then, on July 26, 2017, President Trump issued a statement on Twitter (in multiple tweets), stating the following:
The United States Government will not accept or allow transgender individuals to serve in any capacity in the U.S. Military. Our military must be focused on decisive and overwhelming victory and cannot be burdened with the tremendous medical costs and disruption that transgender in the military would entail.
After what appeared to be some confusion between the White House and the Department of Defense regarding the official policy, President Trump issued a memorandum on August 25, 2017, directing a new policy that prohibits transgender individuals from serving in the military. The memorandum does the following: (1) prohibits transgender service members from openly serving in the military; (2) prohibits the use of department funding for transition health procedures, unless such funding is necessary to protect the health of a service member who has already begun treatment; and (3) prohibits the accession of transgender individuals into the military. The memorandum also requires Secretary Mattis to provide a series of recommendations to the President on what action should to be taken by specified dates in 2018.
Without proffering any evidence to support the claims behind the policy change, the Presidential Memorandum stated that the policy change was based on the following reasons:
[The] previous Administration failed to identify a sufficient basis to conclude that terminating the Departments' longstanding policy and practice would not hinder military effectiveness and lethality, disrupt unit cohesion, or tax military resources, and there remain meaningful concerns that further study is needed to ensure that continued implementation of last year's policy change would not have those negative effects. (Pres. mem., 82 Fed.Reg. (Aug. 25, 2017) Presidential Memorandum for the Secretary of Defense and the Secretary of Homeland Security: Military Service by Transgender Individuals.)
In response to the Presidential Memorandum, Secretary Mattis issued a statement on August 29, 2017, stating that the Department had received the memorandum and would convene a panel of mature experts to further study the issue in order to provide a recommendation to the White House. Importantly, Secretary Mattis stated the following:
In the interim, current policy with respect to currently serving members will remain in place. I expect to issue interim guidance to the force concerning the president's direction, including any necessary interim adjustments to procedures, to ensure the continued combat readiness of the force until our final policy on this subject is issued. (U.S. Department of Defense, Press Release (August 29, 2017) Statement by Secretary of Defense Jim Mattis on Military Service by Transgender Individuals.)
This resolution. In response to this federal action, this resolution would register California's disagreement with the Presidential Memorandum and urge Secretary of Defense James Mattis to allow transgender individuals to serve openly in the United States military. This resolution also calls on Governor Brown to direct the California National Guard and other state military forces to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members unless required by federal law or formal directive from the United States Department of Defense.
When the Department of Defense lifted the transgender ban in 2016, it relied upon a RAND Institute study that showed allowing transgender individuals to openly serve in the military would not affect unit cohesion or create significant health costs. Before the Department lifted its transgender ban in 2016, the Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness asked the RAND National Defense Research Institute to conduct a study on the policy implications of welcoming transgender persons to serve openly in the military. In its 112-page study, the RAND Institute specifically examined how allowing transgender persons would affect military readiness, and whether there would be health care costs associated with allowing transgender service members to serve in the military.
Contrary to the statements made on Twitter and in the Presidential Memorandum, the RAND study found that allowing transgender personnel to serve openly had "no significant effect on cohesion, operational effectiveness, or readiness" in the military and that "the number of U.S. transgender service members who are likely to seek transition-related care is so small that a change in policy will likely have a marginal impact on health care costs and the readiness of the force." (RAND Corporation, Assessing the Implications of Allowing Transgender Personnel to Serve Openly (2016) pp. 44, 49.)
Given the research and evidence provided in the RAND Institute study, this resolution reasonably and rightfully resolves that the Legislature disagrees with the statements posted on Twitter by the President. Additionally, given the discretion vested with the Secretary of Defense to making final recommendations to the President on this policy, this resolution appropriately urges Secretary of Defense James Mattis to allow transgender service members to remain in the United States Military and permit transgender individuals to join the military.
Although California appears to be limited in its ability to curb the national government's transgender ban on the national military, California has significant authority over the appointment of officers to the state's own state militia. It is well-established that the federal government has the authority "to provide for organizing, arming, and disciplining the militia, and for governing such part of them as may be employed in the service of the United States." (U.S. Constitution Article I, Section 8.) Consistent with these principles, when individuals of the National Guard are on federal active duty, "their state affiliation is suspended in favor of an entirely federal affiliation" and they "are subject to all applicable laws and regulations of the United States military." (Holmes v. California National Guard (2001) 90 Cal.App.4th 297, 310.) Accordingly, individuals who are part of the California National Guard must comply with federal directives. However, it is also well-established that if an officer or member of a state National Guard has lost federal recognition, that member can still remain on state active duty. (Id. at 312.) Under the State Military Reserve Act, the Governor is authorized to prescribe rules and regulations "governing the enlistment, organization, administration, equipment, maintenance, training, and discipline of forces" for the state military reserve—a state defense force that is funded entirely by the State of California. Of course, serving in the state military reserve is not completely identical to serving in the California National Guard. For example, members of the state military reserve are only paid when called into active duty and not paid during training. However, the state military reserve does follow California's antidiscrimination laws, and allows transgender individuals to serve openly.
This resolution calls on the Governor to direct the California National Guard and other state military forces to take no action in response to the Presidential Memorandum that would discriminate against transgender service members, unless the action is superseded by federal law or a formal directive from the United States Department of Defense. Although this is a laudable goal, given the strong preemption issues, it does not appear that the Governor would have the authority to continue to allow transgender individuals to openly serve in the California National Guard if the Department of Defense ultimately prohibited transgender individuals from serving in the National Guard. While this is understandably frustrating for transgender service members whose status in the military appears to be unclear, this Committee has recently learned that federal authorities have advised state authorities to not discharge transgender service members on account of gender expression or identity. Additionally, after the tweet and the Presidential Memorandum, several organizations have filed lawsuits in federal court against the new transgender policy, arguing that the President's actions violate the United States Constitution. All of those cases are still pending in federal court (e.g., District of Columbia, Western District of Washington, and District of Maryland).
Notwithstanding the recent federal action, California continues its long tradition of protecting the civil rights of all Californians. For example, under the Unruh Civil Rights Act, California law prohibits discrimination, including on the basis of (among other categories) sex, gender, gender expression, or sexual orientation, in public accommodations. Additionally, state law provides that no person in this state shall, on the basis of a number of protected categories, including sex, sexual orientation, and gender identity, be unlawfully denied full and equal access to the benefits of, or be unlawfully be subject to discrimination under, any program or activity that is conducted, operated, or administered by the state or by any state agency, is funded directly by the state, or receives any financial assistance from the state. (Government Code Sections 11135 and 11139.) Finally, under the Fair and Employment Housing Act (FEHA), it is an unlawful employment practice to refuse to hire or to discharge a person on the basis of (among other categories) sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation. Indeed, in a recent New York Times article, columnist Frank Bruni stated that California was considered one of the best places to be LGBTQ in America, given the state's pro-L.G.B.T. laws. (Bruni, The Worst (and Best) Places to Be Gay in America, N.Y. Times (Aug. 25, 2017).)
Analysis Prepared by: Eric Dang / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001567
Date of Hearing: August 31, 2017
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AJR 22
Author:(Low) – As Amended Ver:August 29, 2017
SUBJECT: TRANSGENDER SERVICE MEMBERS
KEY ISSUE: CONSISTENT WITH CALIFORNIA’S ANTI-DISCRIMINATION POLICIES THAT PROMOTE INCLUSION AND CELEBRATE THE STATE’S DIVERSITY, SHOULD THE LEGISLATURE URGE THE U.S. SECRETARY OF DEFENSE TO RECOMMEND a reversal of the WHITE HOUSE’s recent directive that prohibits TRANSGENDER INDIVIDUALS from OPENLY serving IN THE UNITED STATES MILITARY?
SYNOPSIS
On July 26, 2017, President Trump issued a statement on Twitter (in multiple tweets), stating the following, “The United States Government will not accept or allow transgender individuals to serve in any capacity in the U.S. Military. Our military must be focused on decisive and overwhelming victory and cannot be burdened with the tremendous medical costs and disruption that transgender in the military would entail.” These statements ultimately led to a Presidential Memorandum that reverses a federal policy which ended the military’s ban on transgender individuals from serving in the armed forces. The policy reversal is inconsistent with a previous study conducted by the RAND Institute which found that allowing transgender individuals to serve openly in the military does not jeopardize unit cohesion or readiness and does not significantly increase military health costs for transition health care services.
In response to this federal action, this resolution would register California’s disagreement with the President’s decisions, and urge Defense Secretary James Mattis to allow transgender individuals to serve openly in the United States military. This resolution also calls on the Governor to direct the California National Guard and other state military forces to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members unless required by federal law or formal directive from the United States Department of Defense. This resolution is sponsored by Equality California and has no opposition on file.
SUMMARY: Urges Secretary of Defense James Mattis to allow transgender individuals to serve in the United States military and calls on Governor Brown to direct the California National Guard and other state military forces to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members, unless required by federal law or formal directive from the United States Department of Defense. Specifically, this resolution:
- Makes the following Legislative findings:
- The protection of all residents from discrimination is a fundamental role of government.
- California is a national leader in protecting civil rights by enacting laws that protect transgender Californians from discrimination on the basis of gender identity or gender expression.
- The Unruh Civil Rights Act provides that all persons within the state are free and equal and are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever, no matter what their sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship, primary language, or immigration status.
- The California Fair Employment and Housing Act prohibits an employer from refusing to employ or from discharging a person because of his or her race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status.
- In a series of tweets posted on Twitter on July 26, 2017, at 5:55, United States President Donald J. Trump announced that the “United States Government will not accept or allow transgender individuals to serve in any capacity in the U.S. military,” citing “disruption” and “tremendous costs” related to health care for transgender service members.
- The United States Department of Defense has announced, barring further guidance from the president, they will maintain the policy of allowing currently serving transgender Americans to stay in the military, and many are serving honorably today.
- The Department of Defense is currently conducting a study on the medical obligations it would incur, the impact on military readiness, and related questions associated with the accession of transgender individuals who are not currently serving in uniform and wish to join the military.
- Any new policy decision would be inappropriate until that study is complete and thoroughly reviewed by the Secretary of Defense, our military leadership, and the Congress of the United States.
- There is no lawful or practical reason to force service members who are able to fight, train, and deploy to leave our military — regardless of their gender expression or gender identity.
- Estimates suggest that between 1,320 and 6,630 transgender Americans are on active duty, which is about 0.05 percent of the total military population, and some estimate that as many as 15,000 transgender adults are currently serving on active duty in the military or in the National Guard or Reserve forces.
- An estimated 1,500 Reserve transgender troops currently serve in the United States military and over 134,000 transgender veterans have served our nation.
- A RAND Corporation study commissioned by the United States military found that medical care for transgender service members would cost approximately $8 million a year of the Pentagon’s $600 billion budget — compared to $84 million, which the United States military currently spends on Viagra and other erectile dysfunction drugs.
- This would represent 0.13 percent of the $6 billion annual health care expenditure for active duty service members and research suggests that costs related to health care for transgender service members would be negligible.
- That same study concluded last year that the impact of allowing transgender Americans to serve openly in our nation’s Armed Forces would have a minimal impact on military readiness.
- The United States has a volunteer army, less than 1 percent of Americans have served in the Armed Forces since September 11, 2011, the United States Army had to triple its budget for enlistment bonuses to fill its ranks, and 18 other nations currently allow transgender people to serve openly in their militaries.
- It is unlawful and illogical to turn away any American from serving in our Armed Forces who is physically qualified and patriotic enough to sign up to serve and protect our country.
- Equality is good for our military and for service and every able bodied American who wants to serve our country in a time of war should be able to do so.
- Turning away transgender Americans from military service would be harmful, contrary to American values, and put our nation’s national security at risk.
- California hosts more than 190,000 active and reserve service people from all five branches of the United States military and is home to three army bases, seven marine bases, 10 navy bases, six air force bases, and five reserve and national Coast Guard bases.
- Thousands of transgender troops are currently serving in our military and an unknown number are currently in combat zones.
- The President’s announcement that he plans to ban transgender Americans from serving our nation’s Armed Forces has sent a shocking statement to our transgender troops, which undermines an unknown number of active duty troops.
- Diversity makes our national security stronger and studies have confirmed that transgender troops are not only serving, but that their open service does nothing to harm military readiness.
- Numerous veterans and military leaders have come out against the President’s decision, including Senator and post-9/11 veteran Joni Ernst, Senator John McCain, former Secretary of Defense Ash Carter, and Senator and Iraq War Veteran Tammy Duckworth.
- On August 25, 2017, President Trump issued directives for the United States Secretary of Defense James Mattis regarding implementation of the transgender ban, which gives Mattis discretion regarding currently serving transgender service members and requires him to submit a plan regarding ascension of transgender service members and gender reassignment surgeries.
- President Trump’s directive prevents transgender individuals from joining the Armed Forces unless Secretary Mattis, in consultation with the Secretary of Homeland Security, “provides a recommendation to the contrary that I find convincing.”
- Transgender Americans have always been a part of our Armed Forces and will continue to do so in spite of the president’s announcements.
- Transgender Californians are not a burden or a disruption and, as United States Senator Orrin Hatch, a stalwart Republican from the state of Utah said, “transgender people are people — people who want to work hard, improve their communities, and live their lives.”
- Resolves as follows, on behalf of the Legislature:
- The Legislature of the State of California respectfully disagrees with the statements posted on Twitter by the President of the United States proposing to ban transgender Americans from military service.
- The Governor of California is called upon to direct the California National Guard, the California Air National Guard, and the other Armed Forces of the state to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members in enlistment, promotion, or any other aspect of their service, on the basis of their gender identity or expression, unless superseded by federal law, regulation, or formal directive from the United States Department of Defense.
- Secretary of Defense James Mattis is urged to allow transgender service members who are otherwise able to serve to remain in the United States Military.
- Secretary of Defense James Mattis is urged to recommend to President Trump that transgender individuals who are otherwise able to serve be permitted to join the U.S. Military because transgender service members do not hinder military effectiveness, disrupt unit cohesion or tax military resources.
- The Chief Clerk of the Assembly shall transmit copies of this resolution to the President and Vice President of the United States, the Speaker of the House of Representatives, the Minority Leader of the House of Representatives, the Majority Leader of the United States Senate, the Minority Leader of the United States Senate, to each Senator and Representative from California in the Congress of the United States, to every member of the California State Legislature, and to the author for appropriate distribution.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes that no person shall be deprived of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law. (U.S. Const., 5th Amend.)
- Establishes that no state shall deprive any person of life, liberty, or property, without due process of law; nor deny to any person within its jurisdiction the equal protection of the laws. (U.S. Const., 14th Amend.)
- Establishes that Congress shall make no law abridging the freedom of speech. (U.S. Const., 1st Amend.)
- Establishes that all people are by nature free and independent and have inalienable rights. Among these are enjoying and defending life and liberty, acquiring, possessing, and protecting property, and pursuing and obtaining safety, happiness, and privacy. (Cal. Const., art. I, section 1.)
- States that all acts of the Congress of the United States relating to the control, administration, and government of the Army of the United States and the United States Air Force and relating to the control, administration, and government of the United States Navy, and all rules and regulations adopted by the United States for the government of the National Guard and Naval Reserve or Naval Militia, so far as the same are not inconsistent with the rights reserved to this State and guaranteed under the Constitution of this State, constitute the rules and regulations for the government of the militia. (Military and Veterans Code Section 101.)
- Holds that an officer or member of a state National Guard who has lost federal recognition may remain on state active duty and retain an officer position in state National Guard and United States reserve groups, provided that those positions do not require federal recognition and are not subject to being called into federal service. (Holmes v. California National Guard (90 Cal.App.4th 297, 312.)
- Establishes the State Military Reserve Act, which authorizes the Governor to organize and maintain within this State such military forces as the Governor may deem necessary to defend and for the security of this State, as provided. (Military and Veterans Code Section 550.)
- Establishes the Unruh Civil Rights Act, which provides that all persons within the state are free and equal and are entitled to the full and equal accommodations, advantages, facilities, privileges, or services in all business establishments of every kind whatsoever, no matter their sex, race, color, religion, ancestry, national origin, disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sexual orientation, citizenship, primary language, or immigration status. (Civil Code Section 51.)
- Provides that no person in this state shall, on the basis of a number of protected categories, including sex, sexual orientation, and gender identity, be unlawfully denied full and equal access to the benefits of, or be unlawfully be subject to discrimination under, any program or activity that is conducted, operated, or administered by the state or by any state agency, is funded directly by the state, or receives any financial assistance from the state. (Government Code Sections 11135 and 11139.)
- Establishes the California Fair Employment and Housing Act, which makes it an unlawful employment practice to refuse to hire or to discharge a person because of the person’s race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status. (Government Code Section 12940 et seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this resolution is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: During the Obama Administration, then-Secretary of Defense Ash Carter announced that the military would immediately end its ban on transgender service members from openly serving in the armed forces. The policy—a groundbreaking decision—was marked with three progressive elements. First, it immediately prohibited a qualified service member from being discharged solely on the basis of gender identity. Second, it established guidance on medical care and treatment for transgender service members who seek to transition while in military service. And third, it allowed transgender individuals—beginning no later than July 1, 2017—to enter military service (“accession”). In issuing the new policy, then-Secretary Carter made the following remarks:
This is the right thing to do for our people and for the force. We’re talking about talented Americans who are serving with distinction or who want the opportunity to serve. We can’t allow barriers unrelated to a person’s qualifications prevent us from recruiting and retaining those who can best accomplish the mission. (U.S. Department of Defense, Press Release (June 30, 2016) Secretary of Defense Ash Carter Announces Policy for Transgender Service Members; see also DTM 16-005, Military Service of Transgender Service Members.)
A year after this momentous policy decision, the federal government reversed itself. On June 30, 2017—a day before the Obama-era transgender policy was scheduled to be finalized—Secretary of Defense James Mattis delayed the effective date of the policy until January 1, 2018. (U.S. Department of Defense, Press Release (June 30, 2017) Statement by Chief Pentagon Spokesperson Dana W. White on Transgender Accessions.)
Then, on July 26, 2017, President Trump issued a statement on Twitter (in multiple tweets), stating the following:
The United States Government will not accept or allow transgender individuals to serve in any capacity in the U.S. Military. Our military must be focused on decisive and overwhelming victory and cannot be burdened with the tremendous medical costs and disruption that transgender in the military would entail.
After what appeared to be some confusion between the White House and the Department of Defense regarding the official policy, President Trump issued a memorandum on August 25, 2017, directing a new policy that prohibits transgender individuals from serving in the military. The memorandum does the following: (1) prohibits transgender service members from openly serving in the military; (2) prohibits the use of department funding for transition health procedures, unless such funding is necessary to protect the health of a service member who has already begun treatment; and (3) prohibits the accession of transgender individuals into the military. The memorandum also requires Secretary Mattis to provide a series of recommendations to the President on what action should to be taken by specified dates in 2018.
Without proffering any evidence to support the claims behind the policy change, the Presidential Memorandum stated that the policy change was based on the following reasons:
[The] previous Administration failed to identify a sufficient basis to conclude that terminating the Departments’ longstanding policy and practice would not hinder military effectiveness and lethality, disrupt unit cohesion, or tax military resources, and there remain meaningful concerns that further study is needed to ensure that continued implementation of last year's policy change would not have those negative effects. (Pres. mem., 82 Fed.Reg. ___ (Aug. 25, 2017) Presidential Memorandum for the Secretary of Defense and the Secretary of Homeland Security: Military Service by Transgender Individuals.)
In response to the Presidential Memorandum, Secretary Mattis issued a statement on August 29, 2017, stating that the Department had received the memorandum and would convene a panel of mature experts to further study the issue in order to provide a recommendation to the White House. Importantly, Secretary Mattis stated the following:
In the interim, current policy with respect to currently serving members will remain in place. I expect to issue interim guidance to the force concerning the president’s direction, including any necessary interim adjustments to procedures, to ensure the continued combat readiness of the force until our final policy on this subject is issued. (U.S. Department of Defense, Press Release (August 29, 2017) Statement by Secretary of Defense Jim Mattis on Military Service by Transgender Individuals.)
This resolution. In response to this federal action, this resolution would register California’s disagreement with the Presidential Memorandum and urge Secretary of Defense James Mattis to allow transgender individuals to serve openly in the United States military. This resolution also calls on Governor Brown to direct the California National Guard and other state military forces to take no action that discriminates against transgender service members unless required by federal law or formal directive from the United States Department of Defense.
Author’s statement. In support of the resolution, the author writes:
Trump’s decision to ban transgender people from serving in the U.S. military is offensive, misguided, and contrary to our American values. The thousands of transgender military service members who have put their lives on the line for our country deserve better. The California Legislative LGBT Caucus stands by our transgender service members and will do everything in our power to prevent further discrimination.
When the Department of Defense lifted the transgender ban in 2016, it relied upon a RAND Institute study that showed allowing transgender individuals to openly serve in the military would not affect unit cohesion or create significant health costs. Before the Department lifted its transgender ban in 2016, the Office of the Under Secretary of Defense for Personnel and Readiness asked the RAND National Defense Research Institute to conduct a study on the policy implications of welcoming transgender persons to serve openly in the military. In its 112-page study, the RAND Institute specifically examined how allowing transgender persons would affect military readiness, and whether there would be health care costs associated with allowing transgender service members to serve in the military.
Contrary to the statements made on Twitter and in the Presidential Memorandum, the RAND study found that allowing transgender personnel to serve openly had “no significant effect on cohesion, operational effectiveness, or readiness” in the military and that “the number of U.S. transgender service members who are likely to seek transition-related care is so small that a change in policy will likely have a marginal impact on health care costs and the readiness of the force.” (RAND Corporation, Assessing the Implications of Allowing Transgender Personnel to Serve Openly (2016) pp. 44, 49.)
Given the research and evidence provided in the RAND Institute study, this resolution reasonably and rightfully resolves that the Legislature disagrees with the statements posted on Twitter by the President. Additionally, given the discretion vested with the Secretary of Defense to making final recommendations to the President on this policy, this resolution appropriately urges Secretary of Defense James Mattis to allow transgender service members to remain in the United States Military and permit transgender individuals to join the military.
Although California appears to be limited in its ability to curb the national government’s transgender ban on the national military, California has significant authority over the appointment of officers to the state’s own state militia. It is well-established that the federal government has the authority “to provide for organizing, arming, and disciplining the militia, and for governing such part of them as may be employed in the service of the United States.” (U.S. Const., art. I, section 8.) Consistent with these principles, when individuals of the National Guard are on federal active duty, “their state affiliation is suspended in favor of an entirely federal affiliation” and they “are subject to all applicable laws and regulations of the United States military.” (Holmes v. California National Guard (2001) 90 Cal.App.4th 297, 310.) Accordingly, individuals who are part of the California National Guard must comply with federal directives. However, it is also well-established that if an officer or member of a state National Guard has lost federal recognition, that member can still remain on state active duty. (Id. at 312.) Under the State Military Reserve Act, the Governor is authorized to prescribe rules and regulations “governing the enlistment, organization, administration, equipment, maintenance, training, and discipline of forces” for the state military reserve—a state defense force that is funded entirely by the State of California. Of course, serving in the state military reserve is not completely identical to serving in the California National Guard. For example, members of the state military reserve are only paid when called into active duty and not paid during training. However, the state military reserve does follow California’s antidiscrimination laws, and allows transgender individuals to serve openly.
This resolution calls on the Governor to direct the California National Guard and other state military forces to take no action in response to the Presidential Memorandum that would discriminate against transgender service members, unless the action is superseded by federal law or a formal directive from the United States Department of Defense. Although this is a laudable goal, given the strong preemption issues, it does not appear that the Governor would have the authority to continue to allow transgender individuals to openly serve in the California National Guard if the Department of Defense ultimately prohibited transgender individuals from serving in the National Guard. While this is understandably frustrating for transgender service members whose status in the military appears to be unclear, this Committee has recently learned that federal authorities have advised state authorities to not discharge transgender service members on account of gender expression or identity. Additionally, after the tweet and the Presidential Memorandum, several organizations have filed lawsuits in federal court against the new transgender policy, arguing that the President’s actions violate the United States Constitution. All of those cases are still pending in federal court (e.g., District of Columbia, Western District of Washington, and District of Maryland).
Notwithstanding the recent federal action, California continues its long tradition of protecting the civil rights of all Californians. For example, under the Unruh Civil Rights Act, California law prohibits discrimination, including on the basis of (among other categories) sex, gender, gender expression, or sexual orientation, in public accommodations. Additionally, state law provides that no person in this state shall, on the basis of a number of protected categories, including sex, sexual orientation, and gender identity, be unlawfully denied full and equal access to the benefits of, or be unlawfully be subject to discrimination under, any program or activity that is conducted, operated, or administered by the state or by any state agency, is funded directly by the state, or receives any financial assistance from the state. (Government Code Sections 11135 and 11139.) Finally, under the Fair and Employment Housing Act (FEHA), it is an unlawful employment practice to refuse to hire or to discharge a person on the basis of (among other categories) sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation. Indeed, in a recent New York Times article, columnist Frank Bruni stated that California was considered one of the best places to be LGBTQ in America, given the state’s pro-L.G.B.T. laws. (Bruni, The Worst (and Best) Places to Be Gay in America, N.Y. Times (Aug. 25, 2017).)
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In support of this resolution, Equality California writes:
California hosts more than 190,000 active and reserve service people from all five branches of the U.S. military and is home to three army bases, seven Marine bases, 10 navy bases, six air force bases, and five reserve and national Coast Guard bases. It estimated that between 1,320 and 6,630 transgender Americans are on active duty, about 0.05 percent of the total military population, and some estimate that as many as 15,000 transgender adults are currently serving on active duty in the military or in the National Guard or Reserve forces. Over 134,000 transgender veterans have served our nation. The President’s statement [has] sent a shocking message to our transgender troops, which undermines an unknown number of active duty troops and threatens to take our armed forces back to a time of secrecy and intimidation. Barring qualified and loyal Americans from serving reduces military readiness and only creates division, not cohesion.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Equality California (sponsor)
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Eric Dang / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):