SB 820: Settlement agreements: confidentiality.
- Session Year: 2017-2018
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2018-09-30
Existing law prohibits a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for certain enumerated sexual offenses. Existing law prohibits a court from entering an order in any of these types of civil actions that restricts disclosure of this information, as specified, and it makes a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action, entered into on or after January 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy.
This bill would prohibit a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information relating to certain claims of sexual assault, sexual harassment, or harassment or discrimination based on sex, that are filed in a civil or administrative action. The bill would make a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the claim, as described in the bill, entered into on or after January 1, 2019, void as a matter of law and against public policy. The bill would also provide that a court may consider the pleadings and other papers in the record, or any other findings of the court in determining the factual foundation of the causes of action specified in these provisions. The bill would create an exception, not applicable if a party is a government agency or public official, for a provision that shields the identity of the claimant and all facts that could lead to the discovery of his or her identity, if the provision is included within the settlement agreement at the request of the claimant.
Existing law prohibits a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for certain enumerated sexual offenses. Existing law prohibits a court from entering an order in any of these types of civil actions that restricts disclosure of this information, as specified, and it makes a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action, entered into on or after January 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy.
This bill would prohibit a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information relating to certain claims of sexual assault, sexual harassment, or harassment or discrimination based on sex, that are filed in a civil or administrative action. The bill would make a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the claim, as described in the bill, entered into on or after January 1, 2019, void as a matter of law and against public policy. The bill would also provide that a court may consider the pleadings and other papers in the record, or any other findings of the court in determining the factual foundation of the causes of action specified in these provisions. The bill would create an exception, not applicable if a party is a government agency or public official, for a provision that shields the identity of the claimant and all facts that could lead to the discovery of his or her identity, if the provision is included within the settlement agreement at the request of the claimant.
Existing law prohibits a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for certain enumerated sexual offenses. Existing law prohibits a court from entering an order in any of these types of civil actions that restricts disclosure of this information, as specified, and it makes a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action, entered into on or after January 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy.
This bill would similarly provide that, prohibit a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information relating to the action is prohibited, if the pleadings state a cause of action relating to specified claims of sexual assault, sexual harassment, or harassment or discrimination based on sex. certain claims of sexual assault, sexual harassment, or harassment or discrimination based on sex, that are filed in a civil or administrative action. The bill would make a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action, claim, as described in the bill, entered into on or after January 1, 2019, void as a matter of law and against public policy. The bill would also provide that a court may consider the pleadings and other papers in the record, or any other findings of the court in determining the factual foundation of the causes of action specified in these provisions. The bill would create an exception, not applicable if a party is a government agency or public official, if the provision preventing disclosure for a provision that shields the identity of the claimant and all facts that could lead to the discovery of his or her identity, if the provision is included within the settlement agreement at the request of the claimant.
Existing law prohibits a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for certain enumerated sexual offenses. Existing law prohibits a court from entering an order in any of these types of civil actions that restricts disclosure of this information, as specified, and it makes a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action, entered into on or after January 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy.
This bill would similarly provide that, a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information relating to the action is prohibited, unless a claimant requests the inclusion of such a provision, if the pleadings state a cause of action relating to specified claims of sexual assault, sexual harassment, or harassment or discrimination based on sex. The bill would make a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action, as described in the bill, entered into on or after January 1, 2019, void as a matter of law and against public policy. The bill would also provide that a court may consider the pleadings and other papers in the record or any other findings of the court in determining the factual foundation of the causes of action specified in these provisions. The bill would create an exception, not applicable if a party is a government agency or public official, if the provision preventing disclosure is included within the settlement agreement at the request of the claimant.
Existing law prohibits a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action in a civil action with a factual foundation establishing a cause of action for civil damages for certain enumerated sexual offenses. Existing law prohibits a court from entering an order in any of these types of civil actions that restricts disclosure of this information, as specified, and it makes a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action, entered into on or after January 1, 2017, void as a matter of law and against public policy.
This bill would similarly provide that, a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information relating to the action is prohibited, unless a claimant requests the inclusion of such a provision, if the pleadings state a cause of action relating to specified claims of sexual assault, sexual harassment, or harassment or discrimination based on sex. The bill would make a provision in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action, as described in the bill, entered into on or after January 1, 2019, void as a matter of law and against public policy. The bill would also provide that a court may consider the pleadings and other papers in the record or any other findings of the court in determining the factual foundation of the causes of action specified in these provisions.
(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to a claim filed in a civil action or a complaint filed in an administrative action, regarding any of the following, is prohibited:
(1)An act of sexual assault that is not governed by subdivision (a) of Section 1002.
(2)An act of sexual harassment, as defined in Section 51.9 of the Civil Code.
(3)An act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex, or failure to prevent an act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex or an act of retaliation against a person for reporting harassment or discrimination based on sex, as described in subdivisions (h), (i), (j), and (k) of Section 12940 of the Government Code.
(4)An act of harassment or discrimination based on sex, or an act of retaliation against a person for reporting harassment or discrimination based on sex, by the owner of a housing accommodation, as described in Section 12955 of the Government Code.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in a civil matter described in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (a), a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with subdivision (a).
(c)Notwithstanding subdivision (a) and (b), a provision that shields the identity of the claimant and all facts that could lead to the discovery of his or her identity, including pleadings filed in court, may be included within a settlement agreement at the request of the claimant. This subdivision does not apply if a government agency or public official is a party to the settlement agreement.
(d)Except as authorized by subdivision (c), a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the claim described in subdivision (a) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2019, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(e)This section does not prohibit the entry or enforcement of a provision in any agreement that precludes the disclosure of the amount paid in settlement of a claim.
(f)In determining the factual foundation of a cause of action for civil damages under subdivision (a), a court may consider the pleadings and other papers in the record, or any other findings of the court.
(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to a claim filed in a civil action or a complaint filed in an administrative action, regarding any of the following, is prohibited:
(1)An act of sexual assault that is not governed by subdivision (a) of Section 1002.
(2)An act of sexual harassment, as defined in Section 51.9 of the Civil Code.
(3)An act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex, or failure to prevent an act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex or an act of retaliation against a person for reporting harassment or discrimination based on sex, as described in subdivisions (h), (i), (j), and (k) of Section 12940 of the Government Code.
(4)An act of harassment or discrimination based on sex, or an act of retaliation against a person for reporting harassment or discrimination based on sex, by the owner of a housing accommodation, as described in Section 12955 of the Government Code.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in a civil matter described in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (a), a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with subdivision (a).
(c)Notwithstanding subdivision (a) and (b), a provision that shields the identity of the claimant and all facts that could lead to the discovery of his or her identity, including pleadings filed in court, may be included within a settlement agreement at the request of the claimant. This subdivision does not apply if a government agency or public official is a party to the settlement agreement.
(d)Except as authorized by subdivision (c), a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the claim described in subdivision (a) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2019, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(e)This section does not prohibit the entry or enforcement of a provision in any agreement that precludes the disclosure of the amount paid in settlement of a claim.
(f)In determining the factual foundation of a cause of action for civil damages under subdivision (a), a court may consider the pleadings and other papers in the record, or any other findings of the court.
(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action a claim filed in a civil action or a complaint filed in an administrative action, regarding any of the following, is prohibited in any civil action in which the pleadings state a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following: prohibited:
(1)An act of sexual assault that is not governed by subdivision (a) of Section 1002.
(2)An act of sexual harassment, as defined in Section 51.9 of the Civil Code.
(3)An act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex, or failure to prevent an act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex, sex or an act of retaliation against a person for reporting harassment or discrimination based on sex, as described in subdivisions (j) and (h), (i), (j), and (k) of Section 12940 of the Government Code.
(4)An act of harassment or discrimination based on sex, or an act of retaliation against a person for reporting harassment or discrimination based on sex, by the owner of a housing accommodation, as described in Section 12955 of the Government Code.
(b)Notwithstanding any other law, in a civil matter described in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (a), a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with subdivision (a).
(b)(c)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), (a) and (b), a provision that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action shields the identity of the claimant and all facts that could lead to the discovery of his or her identity, including pleadings filed in court, may be included within a settlement agreement at the request of the claimant. This subdivision does not apply if a government agency or public official is a party to the settlement agreement.
(c)(d)Except as authorized by subdivision (b), (c), a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action claim described in subdivision (a) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2019, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(d)(e)This section does not prohibit the entry or enforcement of a provision in any agreement that precludes the disclosure of the amount paid in settlement of a claim.
(e)(f)In determining the factual foundation of a cause of action for civil damages under subdivision (a), a court may consider the pleadings and other papers in the record, or any other findings of the court.
(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action in which the pleadings state a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
(1)An act of sexual assault that is not governed by subdivision (a) of Section 1002.
(2)An act of sexual harassment, as defined in Section 51.9 of the Civil Code.
(3)An act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex, or failure to prevent an act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex, as described in subdivisions (j) and (k) of Section 12940 of the Government Code.
(4)An act of harassment or discrimination based on sex, or an act of retaliation against a person for reporting harassment or discrimination based on sex, by the owner of a housing accommodation, as described in Section 12955 of the Government Code.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), a provision that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action may be included within a settlement agreement upon at the request of the claimant. This subdivision does not apply if a government agency or public official is a party to the settlement agreement.
(c)Except as authorized by subdivision (b), a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2019, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(d)This section does not prohibit the entry or enforcement of a provision in any agreement that precludes the disclosure of the amount paid in settlement of a claim.
(e)In determining the factual foundation of a cause of action for civil damages under subdivision (a), a court may consider the pleadings and other papers in the record, or any other findings of the court.
(a)Notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action in which the pleadings state a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
(1)An act of sexual assault that is not governed by subdivision (a) of Section 1002.
(2)An act of sexual harassment, as defined in Section 51.9 of the Civil Code.
(3)An act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex, or failure to prevent an act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex, as described in subdivisions (j) and (k) of Section 12940 of the Government Code.
(4)An act of harassment or discrimination based on sex, or an act of retaliation against a person for reporting harassment or discrimination based on sex, by the owner of a housing accommodation, as described in Section 12955 of the Government Code.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), a provision that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action may be included within a settlement agreement upon the request of the claimant.
(c)Except as authorized by subdivision (b), a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action described in subdivision (a) that is entered into on or after January 1, 2019, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
(d)This section does not prohibit the entry or enforcement of a provision in any agreement that precludes the disclosure of the amount paid in settlement of a claim.
(e)In determining the factual foundation of a cause of action for civil damages under subdivision (a), a court may consider the pleadings and other papers in the record, or any other findings of the court.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 30, 2018 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 953, Statutes of 2018. |
| Sep 30, 2018 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 30, 2018 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 5 p.m. |
| Aug 24, 2018 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 30. Noes 8.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 23, 2018 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 23, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Jul 5, 2018 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 3, 2018 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 8. Noes 2.) (July 3). |
| Jun 20, 2018 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 18, 2018 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 21, 2018 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 21, 2018 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 28. Noes 7.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 3, 2018 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 2, 2018 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (May 1). |
| Apr 10, 2018 | Set for hearing May 1. |
| Jan 16, 2018 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jan 4, 2018 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after February 3. |
| Jan 3, 2018 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 24, 2018 | Unfinished Business SB820 Leyva et al. Concurrence | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 23, 2018 | SB 820 Leyva Senate Third Reading By GONZALEZ FLETCHER | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 3, 2018 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 21, 2018 | Senate 3rd Reading SB820 Leyva et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 1, 2018 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| American Association of University Women | ** Support | Aug 23, 2018 |
| American Insurance Association | ** Against | Aug 23, 2018 |
| Attorney General Xavier Becerra | ** Support | Aug 23, 2018 |
| Brand. | ** Against | Aug 23, 2018 |
| California Ambulance Association | ** Against | Aug 23, 2018 |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | Aug 23, 2018 |
| California Employment Law Council | ** Against | Aug 23, 2018 |
| California Employment Lawyers Association | ** Support | Aug 23, 2018 |
| California News Publishers Association | * Neutral | May 1, 2018 |
| California Restaurant Association | ** Against | Aug 23, 2018 |
| California Retailers Association | ** Against | Aug 23, 2018 |
| California Rural Legal Assistance | ** Support | Jun 30, 2018 |
| California Women's Law Center | ** Support | Aug 23, 2018 |
| Civil Justice Association Of California | ** Against | Aug 23, 2018 |
| Congress of California Seniors | ** Support | Aug 23, 2018 |
| Construction Employers' Association | ** Against | Aug 23, 2018 |
| Consumer Attorneys Of California | ** Support | Aug 23, 2018 |
| Courage Campaign | ** Support | Jun 30, 2018 |
| Crime Victims United Of California | ** Support | Aug 23, 2018 |
| Equal Rights Advocates | ** Support | Aug 23, 2018 |
| Screen Actors Guild and American Federation of Television and Radio Artists | * Support | May 1, 2018 |
| We Said Enough | * Support | May 1, 2018 |
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 820
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 5-1, 5/1/18
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Monning, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Anderson
NO VOTE RECORDED: Moorlach
SENATE FLOOR: 29-7, 5/21/18
AYES: Allen, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Bradford, Dodd, Galgiani, Glazer, Hernandez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Jackson, Lara, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Newman, Nguyen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Skinner, Stern, Vidak, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NOES: Anderson, Berryhill, Fuller, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cannella, De León, Gaines
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 56-19, 8/23/18 - See last page for vote
SOURCE: California Women’s Law Center
Consumer Attorneys of California
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to specified claims or complaints. Plaintiffs in such actions retain the right to request provisions in settlement agreements that shield their identity.
Assembly Amendments
expand the claims covered by the bill, extend the scope to cover court orders, narrow the exception available at the request of the claimant, and make other clarifying changes.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Provides that a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
- An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense;
- An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1;
- An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Section 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code; or
- An act of sexual assault, as defined in paragraphs (1) to (9), inclusive, of subdivision (e) of Section 15610.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, against an elder or dependent adult, as defined in Sections 15610.23 and 15610.27 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1002.)
- Prohibits a court from entering an order, in actions described above, that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with the above provisions. However, the law does not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any medical information or personal identifying information regarding the victim of the offense or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant. This provision shall not be construed to limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information. Existing law provides that a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to such actions is void as a matter of law and against public policy. An attorney’s failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action that is not otherwise authorized as a condition of settlement, or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1002.)
- Provides that it is the policy of the State of California that confidential settlement agreements are disfavored in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for a violation of the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 15600) of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code). It further provides that provisions of such an agreement, except those requiring nondisclosure of the amount paid, may not be recognized or enforced by the court absent specified showings. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2017.310.)
- Imposes liability for sexual harassment in business, service, and professional relationships under specified conditions. (Civ. Code Sec. 51.9(a).)
- Prohibits an employer, labor organization, employment agency, apprenticeship training program or any training program leading to employment, or any other person, from harassing an employee, an applicant, an unpaid intern or volunteer, or a person providing services pursuant to a contract on the basis of sex. Such harassment includes sexual harassment, gender harassment, and harassment based on pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions. Employers are required to take reasonable steps to prevent such harassment and may be held liable for permitting such harassment to occur in the workplace. Employees may be held personally liable for acts of sexual harassment. (Gov. Code Sec. 12940(j).) Existing law also makes it an unlawful employment practice for an employer, labor organization, employment agency, apprenticeship training program, or any training program leading to employment, to fail to take all reasonable steps necessary to prevent discrimination and harassment from occurring. (Gov. Code Sec. 12940(k).)
- Makes it unlawful for an owner of a housing accommodation to harass or discriminate based on sex, or to retaliate against a person for reporting such unlawful harassment or discrimination. (Gov. Code Sec. 12955.)
This bill:
- Provides that, notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to a claim filed in a civil action or a complaint filed in an administrative action, regarding any of the following, is prohibited:
- An act of sexual assault that is not governed by subdivision (a) of Section 1002 of the Code of Civil Procedure;
- An act of sexual harassment, as defined in Section 51.9 of the Civil Code;
- An act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex, or failure to prevent an act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex or an act of retaliation against a person for reporting harassment or discrimination based on sex, as described in subdivisions (h), (i), (j), and (k) of Section 12940 of the Government Code; or
- An act of harassment or discrimination based on sex, or an act of retaliation against a person for reporting harassment or discrimination based on sex, by the owner of a housing accommodation, as described in Section 12955 of the Government Code.
- Restricts a court from entering, in the above civil matters, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with the preceding provision.
- Allows a provision that shields the identity of the claimant and all facts that could lead to the discovery of his or her identity, including pleadings filed in court to be included within a settlement agreement upon the request of the claimant. However, this provision does not apply if a government agency or public official is a party to the settlement agreement. Otherwise, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action that is entered into on or after January 1, 2019, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
- Makes clear that it does not prohibit the entry or enforcement of a provision in any agreement that precludes the disclosure of the amount paid in settlement of a claim.
- Authorizes the courts to consider the pleadings and other portions of the record to determine the factual foundation of a cause of action.
Background
Existing law disfavors the secret settlement of certain civil actions in which the public has a strong interest. AB 2875 (Pavley, Chapter 151, Statutes of 2006) prohibited the confidential settlement of a civil action the factual basis for which is a cause of action for “an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.” (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1002.)
It has also become the policy of the State of California that confidential settlement agreements are disfavored in any civil action based on a violation of the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA). (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2017.310.) The enacting legislation, AB 634 (Steinberg, Chapter 242, Statutes of 2003), established a test for the court to determine whether good cause exists to enforce a confidential settlement agreement or a stipulated protective order that hides information that is evidence of abuse of an elder or dependent adult in violation of the EADACPA. AB 634 limited the enforcement of a confidential settlement agreement or stipulated protective order if that confidentiality will hide specified information from public disclosure, but AB 634 only applied to EADACPA cases.
Seeking to ensure that the perpetrators of other sexual crimes are made known to the public, AB 1682 (Stone, Chapter 876, Statutes of 2016) prohibited a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement in a civil action for an act of childhood sexual abuse or an act of sexual assault against an elder or dependent adult and made a confidential settlement agreement void as a matter of law and against public policy. It also subjected an attorney that fails to comply with those requirements to discipline by the State Bar of California.
This bill further expands the universe of cases in which so-called “secret settlements” are restricted. This bill prohibits provisions within settlement agreements that prevent the disclosure of factual information related to a claim filed in a civil action or a complaint filed in an administrative action, regarding specified claims, including various forms of sexual harassment or discrimination and any claims for sexual assault not already covered by law. However, plaintiffs retain the right to request provisions that shield their identity.
Comments
The author states:
As we have clearly seen over the last few months, secret settlements serve one primary purpose: to keep sexual predators away from the public eye and continuing to torment and hurt innocent victims. California successfully eliminated the statute of limitations on rape and sexual assault in 2016. Our state must again stand with victims of sexual harassment and assault by ending this unjust practice of secret settlements that keep these aggressors unaccountable and able to prey on other victims. These perpetrators should not be allowed to endanger others or evade justice simply because they have a fat wallet at their disposal. SB 820 will not prevent people from mutually agreeing to settle, but it will simply prevent the perpetrator from requiring the victim to remain silent about the harassment as a condition of settlement. Everyone deserves to live and work free from sexual harassment, assault and discrimination. The STAND Act helps to end the curtain of secrecy that has existed for far too long.
Preventing secret settlements when sexual harassment is involved
Over the past year, accounts of sexual harassment and demands for reforms have arisen in almost every sector of the economy. The legal standards that prohibit sexual harassment in workplace, business, professional, service, and other contexts originated over 30 years ago. They emerged from anti-discrimination laws that date back even further. Yet, as the events of 2017 have made abundantly clear, sexual harassment remains a significant problem. Victims still suffer life-altering professional, psychological, and economic impacts. To try to avoid becoming victims, women must still remain constantly vigilant and still often choose to alter their own conduct and forgo opportunities in order to stay free from harassment. In this way, sexual harassment continues to systematically undermine the ability of women and others targeted by sexual harassment to thrive professionally, economically, and emotionally, on an equal basis with all others.
In response, the Senate Judiciary Committee and other state Legislative bodies have conducted numerous hearings, consulted with experts, and listened to public commentary with the goal of identifying legal reforms that would help to ensure a serious and lasting end to the scourge of harassment.
These public inquiries and conversations have revealed that a series of legal and policy shortcomings have enabled and, in some cases, have even facilitated harassment. Those shortcomings include: overly permissive tolerance for legal tactics that silence victims; insufficient and ineffective sexual harassment prevention training requirements; failure on the part of some judges to fully account for the power of sexual harassment to undermine the civil rights of its victims; and standards for liability that force victims to endure unwelcome conduct to the point where it becomes severe or pervasive before they are entitled to any remedy.
This bill addresses one of these legal tactics, the use of non-disclosure provisions in settlement agreements, often referred to as “secret settlements.” These agreements bind people to silence, generally with regard to all of the underlying allegations in a civil case. As has been seen in widespread media coverage, these secret settlements have the effect of preventing word from spreading about harassing or discriminatory behavior. This is part of what allows serial harassers to go undetected, sometimes for years.
The now notorious case of Harvey Weinstein offers what may be the quintessential example. (Michelle Fabio, The Harvey Weinstein Effect: The End Of Nondisclosure Agreements In Sexual Assault Cases? (Oct. 26, 2017) Forbes <https://www.forbes.com/ sites/michellefabio/2017/10/26/the-harvey-weinstein-effect-the-end-of-nondisclosure-agreements-in-sexual-assault-cases/#3dc80f ea2c11 [as of Aug. 22, 2018].) It is reported that sexual harassment and assault cases have been settled by Weinstein with at least 10 women, all including non-disclosure provisions that prevent the release of information underlying the victims’ claims. Such secret settlements have also been used by Fox News and its former founder Roger Ailes and host Bill O’Reilly to pay tens of millions of dollars to women sexually harassed by them in exchange for their silence.
It should be noted that the use of these non-disclosure provisions in settlements have some benefits. The victim and defendant may not wish to go through the burden and stress of litigation, and settlements often result in larger sums to the injured party because neither party needs to pay an attorney through the end of trial. They offer a quick resolution when both sides just want to put the matter behind them and do not want any further reputational damage to come of it. In theory at least, the victim would be agreeing to this voluntarily, although there may be an imbalance in the negotiating process for victims in practice. In addition, the settling of a civil case is not necessarily an indication of guilt.
In the context of workplace harassment claims, the defendant may be seeking to sweep the matter under the rug, so to speak, but the victim may also have a legitimate desire for privacy regarding what took place. Victims may desire such non-disclosure after suffering from sexual assault or harassment to protect them from unwanted negative attention or even retaliation. In addition, there is the possibility that without the security of silence, defendants in these cases may be less likely to settle with plaintiffs or will offer less money in such settlements.
In part to address this sensitive balance, this bill allows a plaintiff bringing specified claims for sexual harassment or sexual assault to request provisions in settlement agreements that shield their identity.
The bill also prohibits courts from entering orders that restrict disclosure of factual information in these cases, as specified.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/23/18)
California Women’s Law Center (co-source)
Consumer Attorneys of California (co-source)
American Association of University Women
Attorney General Xavier Becerra
California Employment Lawyers Association
Congress of California Seniors
Crime Victims United of California
Equal Rights Advocates
Screen Actors Guild-American Federation of Television and Radio Artists, AFL-CIO
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/23/18)
American Insurance Association
California Ambulance Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Employment Law Council
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Construction Employers’ Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Consumers Attorneys of California, a sponsor of this bill, writes, “The use of NDAs or secret settlements in these cases allows repeat offenders to continue to harass while silencing victims. Unfortunately, they are all too common. Further, court orders enforcing secret settlements signed by judges can also seal damaging documents. For example, Bill Cosby’s deposition was sealed as part of a secret settlement in 2004, so the public didn’t learn about his abuse for another decade. . . . Over the last few months, other troubling instances of secret settlements enabling ongoing sexual harassment and assault have further confirmed the need for the legislation.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Writing in opposition, a coalition of groups including the California Chamber of Commerce argues that the bill “will interfere with the settlement of claims alleging sexual harassment or assault, by forcing companies to trial in order to preserve their public image/brand.
There are many reasons why parties ultimately agree to confidentiality in a settlement. First, settling a case is often a business decision where the employer calculates the amount of time and expense it will take to litigate the case versus the amount of money to settle the case and proceeds with the less costly option. Second, allegations in a complaint are often disputed and up to the trier of fact to ultimately determine merit. Settlements are often based upon the risk that either party could lose at trial – not just the employer.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 56-19, 8/23/18
AYES: Acosta, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Baker, Berman, Bloom, Bonta, Burke, Caballero, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Daly, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez Fletcher, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Rivas, Rodriguez, Rubio, Santiago, Mark Stone, Thurmond, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Chávez, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Harper, Kiley, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Steinorth, Voepel
NO VOTE RECORDED: Travis Allen, Cooper, Gray, Grayson, Salas
8/23/18 16:37:03
**** END ****
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 820
Author:(Leyva)
As Amended Ver:June 20, 2018
Majority vote
SENATE VOTE: 29-7
Committee | Votes | Ayes | Noes |
Judiciary | 8-2 | Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Reyes, Gonzalez Fletcher | Cunningham, Kiley |
SUMMARY: Prohibits the inclusion of a settlement provision that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to a cause of action for any of the following: sexual assault, acts of sexual harassment or discrimination, as specified, and retaliation for reporting such harassment or discrimination. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to a claim filed in a civil action or a complaint filed in an administrative action for any of the following:
- An act of sexual assault that is not sexual assault or exploitation of a child or minor.
- An act of sexual harassment, as defined in Civil Code Section (CIV) 51.9.
- An act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex, or failure to prevent an act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex or an act of retaliation against a person for reporting harassment or discrimination based on sex, as described in Government Code Section (GOV) 12940(h), (i), (j), and (k)
- An act of harassment or discrimination based on sex, or an act of retaliation against a person for reporting harassment or discrimination based on sex, by the owner of a housing accommodation, as described in GOV 12955.
- Declares that a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with 1), above.
- Allows for a settlement agreement to include a provision that shields the identity of the claimant and all facts that could lead to the discovery of his or her identity, including pleadings filed in court, at the request of the claimant except in cases where a government agency or public official is a party to the settlement agreement.
- Provides that a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the claim described in 1), above, that is entered into on or after January 1, 2019, is void as a matter of law and is against public policy.
- Allows for a provision which would prevent the disclosure of the amount paid in settlement of a claim.
- Provides that, in determining the factual foundation of a cause of action for civil damages under 1), above, a court may consider the pleadings and other papers in the record, or any other findings of the court.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of the factual foundation which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
- An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense;
- An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Code of Civil Procedure Section (CCP) 340.1;
- An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Penal Code Section (PEN) 11165.1, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Penal Code Section 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6;
- An act of sexual assault, as defined in Welfare and Institutions Code Section (WIC) Section 15610.63(e) paragraphs (1) to (9), inclusive, against an elder or dependent adult, as defined in WIC Sections 15610.23 and 15610.27. (CCP 1002. All further statutory references are to the Code of Civil Procedure unless otherwise specified.)
- States that it is the policy of the State of California that confidential settlement agreements are disfavored in any civil action in which the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for a violation of the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA). (Section 2017.310.)
- Provides that an employer or other covered entity may be liable for workplace sexual harassment of an employee, applicant, unpaid intern or volunteer, or person providing services pursuant to a contract, by a non-employee, if the employer knows or should have known of the conduct and fails to take immediate and appropriate corrective action. (GOV 12940(j)(1).)
- Considers it to be an unlawful employment practice for an employer or other covered entity to fail to take all reasonable steps necessary to prevent discrimination and harassment from occurring. (GOV 12940(k).)
- Specifies the steps for filing a complaint with the Department of Fair Employment and Housing, including the type of information that must be supplied and the timeframe for filing such complaints. (GOV 12960.)
FISCAL EFFECT: None
COMMENTS: Events of the past year have brought renewed attention to an old problem: seemingly entrenched workplace behaviors and attitudes that tolerate or dismiss sexual harassment, most often (but not exclusively) against women. This measure addresses one legal strategy used to settle cases of sexual harassment and sexual assault: confidentiality agreements. Such agreements, also known as "secret settlements" or "non-disclosure agreements" (NDAs), keep the details of cases from being revealed and end up silencing victims from speaking about their experiences. Such settlements can be used to allow serial harassers – especially those with significant financial resources – to escape criminal prosecution and continue their behavior unchecked. This measure seeks to prohibit the use of secret settlements in cases of sexual harassment, sexual assault, and workplace harassment.
History of secret settlements being used to settle civil actions. As a general rule, settlement agreements are useful tools in civil litigation. They have been called the grease that keeps the wheels of the civil justice system moving. Settlements encourage timely resolution of claims and help the parties avoid the time and expense required to go to trial. Confidentiality provisions within settlement agreements can also help parties avoid the trauma and embarrassment of participating in a public trial.
However, a strong public policy argument can be made that secret settlements are inappropriate in some cases, specifically in matters of concern to the public that involve particularly vulnerable victims, highly dangerous behavior, or especially egregious conduct that can present an ongoing hazard. With regards to the issue of sexual assault and sexual harassment, the author provides a similar example of a recent high-profile case, stating:
Film executive Harvey Weinstein has been accused by at least 80 women of sexual misconduct, including rape, sexual assault and harassment. For decades, his predatory behavior was kept secret in part due to the legal instruments that allowed him to hide behind the guise of confidentiality through secret settlements or lifelong nondisclosure agreements (NDAs) crafted to protect him. The settlements commonly included draconian penalties for breach of confidentiality or disclosure. Such agreements effectively barred victims from ever sharing their stories. The use of NDAs or secret settlements in these cases allows repeat offenders to continue to harass while silencing victims.
Given that confidentiality provisions in settlement agreements can keep unsavory information from being disclosed, it is not surprising that many business-aligned groups favor the use of such provisions. In a joint letter from the California Chamber of Commerce and a number of other organizations, opponents of the bill state:
[I]t will interfere with the settlement of claims alleging sexual harassment or assault, by forcing companies to trial in order to preserve their public image/brand.
There are many reasons why parties ultimately agree to confidentiality in a settlement. First, settling a case is often a business decision where the employer calculates the amount of time and expense it will take to litigate the case versus the amount of money to settle the case and proceeds with the less costly option. Second, allegations in a complaint are often disputed and up to the trier of fact to ultimately determine merit. Settlements are often based upon the risk that either party could lose at trial – not just the employer. Third, employers are often named as a party in any sexual harassment action not just those involving supervisors, regardless of their culpability because the employer has more financial resources or "deeper pockets" from which to extract a settlement. By potentially eliminated confidentiality, SB 820 exposes employers to a public presumption of guilt even though the decision to settle was not based upon merit at all. To avoid this public image of guilt, SB 820 will drive employers to fight these cases in court instead of resulting in an early resolution.
However, the concerns raised by business groups must also be balanced against the legitimate concerns about how settlements can be used to undermine public safety and justice. Because of strong public policy concerns, existing law makes confidential settlements either disfavored or prohibited in certain cases. For example, it is the policy of the State of California that confidential settlement agreements are disfavored in any civil action based upon a violation of EADACPA. (Section 2017.310 (a).) Likewise, CCP 1002 prohibits the confidential settlement of a civil action based on "an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense."
While confidentiality agreements may help to facilitate settlements of individual claims, they also can put the public at risk by hiding sexual predators from law enforcement and the public at large. The public also has a strong interest in the prosecution of individuals who commit acts of sexual harassment, sexual assault, and workplace harassment; therefore, the ordinarily useful tool of confidentiality provisions in settlement agreements should not be allowed in civil actions based upon those acts. Like offenses that can be charged as felony sex offenses or violations of EADACPA, secret settlements of these claims could endanger the public, including other potential victims, and allow perpetrators to escape public scrutiny just because they have the financial means to pay the cost of settlements. Additionally, allowing such offenders to continue their behavior either at the same workplace or a new one can harm workplace culture more generally, which can in turn negatively affect productivity and morale.
Analysis Prepared by: Sandra Nakagawa / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0003751
Date of Hearing: July 3, 2018
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 820
Author:(Leyva) – As Amended Ver:June 20, 2018
SENATE VOTE: 29-7
SUBJECT: SETTLEMENT AGREEMENTS: CONFIDENTIALITY
KEY ISSUE: given that secret settlements have repeatedly served as a way to shield perPetrators of sexual assault, sexual harassment, and workplace harassment from public scrutiny, should such settlements be prohibited by state law?
SYNOPSIS
Confidentiality provisions in settlements are often referred to as “secret settlements” or “non-disclosure agreements” (NDAs), and such provisions can be used to prevent details of a case from becoming public. Recent revelations of sexual assault and sexual harassment brought forward in the #MeToo movement have demonstrated how secret settlements can be used to protect repeat offenders from criminal prosecution and out of the public eye. While existing law prohibits the secret settlement of certain civil actions in which the public has a strong interest, such as in civil actions based on a violation of the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA), current law does not prohibit secret settlements from being used in many, if not most, cases of sexual harassment, sexual assault, and workplace harassment. This measure would prevent the use of a secret settlement agreement in such cases while allowing the amount of the settlement to still remain confidential. Information about the identity of the claimant could be kept confidential by request of the claimant, except in cases where a government agency or public official is a party to the case. This bill is co-sponsored by the California Women’s Law Center and the Consumer Attorneys of California while it is opposed by a number of business groups, including the California Chamber of Commerce and the Civil Justice Association of California.
SUMMARY: Prohibits the inclusion of a settlement provision that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to a cause of action for any of the following: sexual assault, acts of sexual harassment or discrimination, as specified, and retaliation for reporting such harassment or discrimination. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to a claim filed in a civil action or a complaint filed in an administrative action for any of the following:
- An act of sexual assault that is not sexual assault or exploitation of a child or minor.
- An act of sexual harassment, as defined in Section 51.9 of the Civil Code.
- An act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex, or failure to prevent an act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex or an act of retaliation against a person for reporting harassment or discrimination based on sex, as described in subdivisions (h), (i), (j), and (k) of Section 12940 of the Government Code.
- An act of harassment or discrimination based on sex, or an act of retaliation against a person for reporting harassment or discrimination based on sex, by the owner of a housing accommodation, as described in Section 12955 of the Government Code.
- Declares that a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with 1), above.
- Allows for a settlement agreement to include a provision that shields the identity of the claimant and all facts that could lead to the discovery of his or her identity, including pleadings filed in court, at the request of the claimant except in cases where a government agency or public official is a party to the settlement agreement.
- Provides that a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the claim described in 1), above, that is entered into on or after January 1, 2019, is void as a matter of law and is against public policy.
- Allows for a provision which would prevent the disclosure of the amount paid in settlement of a claim.
- Provides that, in determining the factual foundation of a cause of action for civil damages under 1), above, a court may consider the pleadings and other papers in the record, or any other findings of the court.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of the factual foundation which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
- An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense;
- An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in CCP Section 340.1;
- An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Section 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code;
- An act of sexual assault, as defined in paragraphs (1) to (9), inclusive, of subdivision (e) of Section 15610.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, against an elder or dependent adult, as defined in Sections 15610.23 and 15610.27 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1002. All further statutory references are to the Code of Civil Procedure unless otherwise specified.)
- States that it is the policy of the State of California that confidential settlement agreements are disfavored in any civil action in which the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for a violation of the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act. (Section 2017.310.)
- Provides that an employer or other covered entity may be liable for workplace sexual harassment of an employee, applicant, unpaid intern or volunteer, or person providing services pursuant to a contract, by a non-employee, if the employer knows or should have known of the conduct and fails to take immediate and appropriate corrective action. (Government Code Section 12940 (j)(1).)
- Considers it to be an unlawful employment practice for an employer or other covered entity to fail to take all reasonable steps necessary to prevent discrimination and harassment from occurring. (Government Code Section 12940 (k).)
- Specifies the steps for filing a complaint with the Department of Fair Employment and Housing, including the type of information that must be supplied and the timeframe for filing such complaints. (Government Code Section 12960.)
- Specifies that a person is liable for a cause of action for sexual harassment in a business, service, or professional relationship, as specified, when a plaintiff shows that:
- The defendant has made sexual advances, solicitations, sexual requests, demands for sexual compliance by the plaintiff, or engaged in other verbal, visual, or physical conduct of a sexual nature or of a hostile nature based on gender, that were unwelcome and pervasive or severe;
- The plaintiff could not easily terminate the relationship;
- The plaintiff has suffered or will suffer economic loss or disadvantage or personal injury as a result of the defendant’s conduct. (Civil Code Section 51.9.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Events of the past year have brought renewed attention to an old problem: seemingly entrenched workplace behaviors and attitudes that tolerate or dismiss sexual harassment, most often (but not exclusively) against women. Like many bills that have come before the Committee this session, this measure responds to the well-publicized revelations of sexual harassment and sexual assault in educational, professional, and political settings, including, the California State Legislature.
This measure addresses one legal strategy used to settle cases of sexual harassment and sexual assault: confidentiality agreements. Such agreements, also known as “secret settlements” or “non-disclosure agreements” (NDAs), keep the details of cases from being revealed and end up silencing victims from speaking about their experiences. Such settlements can be used to allow serial harassers – especially those with significant financial resources – to escape criminal prosecution and continue their behavior unchecked. This measure seeks to prohibit the use of secret settlements in cases of sexual harassment, sexual assault, and workplace harassment.
Sexual harassment under existing state and federal law. The Legislature has made many efforts over the years to allow individuals who are victims of sexual harassment to vindicate their rights by bringing civil actions against persons or entities who are responsible for sexual harassment. However, the primary statute prohibiting workplace discrimination against protected classes of persons is Government Code Section 12940, which is part of the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA). State law mirrors the anti-discrimination provisions in federal law, most notably Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. Title VII prohibits employers from discriminating against employees on the basis of sex, race, color, national origin, and religion. It generally applies to employers with 15 or more employees, including federal, state, and local governments. Under Title VII, sexual harassment is considered a form of discrimination on the basis of sex. (Meritor Savings Bank v. Vinson (1986) 477 U.S. 57; Ellison v. Brady (9th Cir. 1991) 924 F.2d 872.)
History of secret settlements being used to settle civil actions. As a general rule, settlement agreements are useful tools in civil litigation. They have been called the grease that keeps the wheels of the civil justice system moving. Settlements encourage timely resolution of claims and help the parties avoid the time and expense required to go to trial. Confidentiality provisions within settlement agreements can also help parties avoid the trauma and embarrassment of participating in a public trial.
However, a strong public policy argument can be made that secret settlements are inappropriate in some cases, specifically in matters of concern to the public that involve particularly vulnerable victims, highly dangerous behavior, or especially egregious conduct that can present an ongoing hazard. For example, secret settlements were heavily critiqued in cases of childhood sexual abuse brought against the Catholic Church in the early 21st century.
Some legal experts say that the usual rationales and incentives cited in support of secret settlements do not fit priest abuse cases well. The victims were generally children, who ought to receive special protection; the abusers were often repeat offenders, who should have been stopped; and criminal prosecution of the priests was made all but impossible given the central importance of the victim's testimony in rape and other sexual abuse cases.
Prof. Stephen Gillers, who teaches legal ethics at New York University Law School, says that the arguments made against secret settlements in cases involving widespread harm, called mass torts by lawyers, apply with equal strength in this new setting. “Certain kinds of harm are so serious,” he says, “whether it's criminal conduct by priests or exploding kitchen appliances, that we should not let plaintiffs agree to confidentiality.” (Liptak, Adam. A Case that Grew in Shadows, New York Times, March 24, 2002.)
With regards to the issue of sexual assault and sexual harassment, the author provides a similar example of a recent high-profile case, stating:
Film executive Harvey Weinstein has been accused by at least 80 women of sexual misconduct, including rape, sexual assault and harassment. For decades, his predatory behavior was kept secret in part due to the legal instruments that allowed him to hide behind the guise of confidentiality through secret settlements or lifelong nondisclosure agreements (NDAs) crafted to protect him. The settlements commonly included draconian penalties for breach of confidentiality or disclosure. Such agreements effectively barred victims from ever sharing their stories. The use of NDAs or secret settlements in these cases allows repeat offenders to continue to harass while silencing victims…
Over the last year, other troubling instances of secret settlements enabling ongoing sexual harassment and assault have further confirmed the need for the legislation. SB 820, known as the STAND (Stand Together Against Non-Disclosures) Act would ban secret settlements (confidentiality provisions in settlement agreements) in cases of sexual harassment, sexual assault and sex discrimination. The bill would permit the claimant to request confidentiality if she/he so chooses.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Given that confidentiality provisions in settlement agreements can keep unsavory information from being disclosed, it is not surprising that many business-aligned groups favor the use of such provisions. In a joint letter from the California Chamber of Commerce and a number of other organizations, opponents of the bill state:
[I]t will interfere with the settlement of claims alleging sexual harassment or assault, by forcing companies to trial in order to preserve their public image/brand.
There are many reasons why parties ultimately agree to confidentiality in a settlement. First, settling a case is often a business decision where the employer calculates the amount of time and expense it will take to litigate the case versus the amount of money to settle the case and proceeds with the less costly option. Second, allegations in a complaint are often disputed and up to the trier of fact to ultimately determine merit. Settlements are often based upon the risk that either party could lose at trial – not just the employer. Third, employers are often named as a party in any sexual harassment action not just those involving supervisors, regardless of their culpability because the employer has more financial resources or “deeper pockets” from which to extract a settlement. By potentially eliminated confidentiality, SB 820 exposes employers to a public presumption of guilt even though the decision to settle was not based upon merit at all. To avoid this public image of guilt, SB 820 will drive employers to fight these cases in court instead of resulting in an early resolution.
However, the concerns raised by business groups must also be balanced against the legitimate concerns about how settlements can be used to undermine public safety and justice. Because of strong public policy concerns, existing law makes confidential settlements either disfavored or prohibited in certain cases. For example, it is the policy of the State of California that confidential settlement agreements are disfavored in any civil action based upon a violation of EADACPA. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 2017.310 (a).) Likewise, Code of Civil Procedure Section 1002 prohibits the confidential settlement of a civil action based on “an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.”
While confidentiality agreements may help to facilitate settlements of individual claims, they also can put the public at risk by hiding sexual predators from law enforcement and the public at large. The public also has a strong interest in the prosecution of individuals who commit acts of sexual harassment, sexual assault, and workplace harassment; therefore, the ordinarily useful tool of confidentiality provisions in settlement agreements should not be allowed in civil actions based upon those acts. Like offenses that can be charged as felony sex offenses or violations of EADACPA, secret settlements of these claims could endanger the public, including other potential victims, and allow perpetrators to escape public scrutiny just because they have the financial means to pay the cost of settlements. Additionally, allowing such offenders to continue their behavior either at the same workplace or a new one can harm workplace culture more generally, which can in turn negatively affect productivity and morale.
Balancing victim confidentiality with public disclosure. An earlier version of this bill would have allowed a claimant to seek a confidentiality provision if requested by the victim in order to protect his or her identity. However, such a provision would have effectively negated the bill's prohibition on secret settlements, because under secret settlements the plaintiff, by definition, agrees to the confidentiality provision. Thus, rather than the sexual harasser promoting a secret settlement during the negotiations, as is the case now, under this bill the victim would be encouraged to "request" a confidentiality provision as a condition of the settlement. However, as recently amended, the bill would only allow the victim to request to keep confidential any personal information that could reveal the victim’s identity. In this way, the privacy of the victim is protected, but the evidence that the harassment occurred would not be hidden from public view. In addition, the confidentiality provision has been amended to ensure that even this more limited confidentiality provision would not apply where one party to the agreement is a public official or government entity. This amendment responds to concerns from the newspaper industry that government records must be available to the public through the California Public Records Act.
Prior Related Legislation. AB 1682 (Stone, Ch. 876, Stats. 2016) prohibits a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement in a civil action for an act of childhood sexual abuse or an act of sexual assault against an elder or dependent adult. It also subjects an attorney that fails to comply with those requirements to discipline by the State Bar of California.
AB 1628 (Beall, 2012) would have prohibited the confidential settlement of a civil action the factual basis for which is a cause of action for an act of childhood sexual abuse. This bill was held on Suspense in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 2875 (Pavley, Ch. 151, Stats. 2006) prohibits the confidential settlement of a civil action the factual basis for which is a cause of action for “an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.”
AB 634 (Steinberg, Ch. 242, Stats. 2003) enacts a law disfavoring confidential settlement agreements in actions for a violation of Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA).
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Women’s Law Center (co-sponsor)
Consumer Attorneys of California (co-sponsor)
American Association of University Women
California Rural Legal Assistance
Congress of California Seniors
Courage Campaign
Crime Victims United of California
Screen Actors Guild-American Federation of Television and Radio Artists, AFL-CIO
Opposition
American Insurance Association
California Ambulance Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Employment Law Council
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Construction Employers’ Association
Analysis Prepared by: Sandra Nakagawa / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 820
:
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 5-1, 5/1/18
AYES: Jackson, Hertzberg, Monning, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Anderson
NO VOTE RECORDED: Moorlach
SOURCE: California Women’s Law Center
Consumer Attorneys of California
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action in any civil action in which the pleadings state a cause of action for any of the following: various acts of sexual assault, acts of sexual harassment or discrimination, as specified, and retaliation for reporting such harassment or discrimination. Plaintiffs in such actions still retain the right to request non-disclosure provisions in settlement agreements.
Existing law:
- Provides that a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
- An act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense;
- An act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1;
- An act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Section 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code; or
- An act of sexual assault, as defined in paragraphs (1) to (9), inclusive, of subdivision (e) of Section 15610.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, against an elder or dependent adult, as defined in Sections 15610.23 and 15610.27 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1002.)
- Prohibits a court from entering an order, in actions described above, that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with the above provisions. However, the law does not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any medical information or personal identifying information regarding the victim of the offense or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant. This provision shall not be construed to limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information. Existing law provides that a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to such actions is void as a matter of law and against public policy. An attorney’s failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action that is not otherwise authorized as a condition of settlement, or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1002.)
- Provides that it is the policy of the State of California that confidential settlement agreements are disfavored in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for a violation of the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 15600) of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code). It further provides that provisions of such an agreement, except those requiring nondisclosure of the amount paid, may not be recognized or enforced by the court absent specified showings. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2017.310.)
- Imposes liability for sexual harassment in business, service, and professional relationships under specified conditions. (Civ. Code Sec. 51.9(a).)
- Prohibits an employer, labor organization, employment agency, apprenticeship training program or any training program leading to employment, or any other person, from harassing an employee, an applicant, an unpaid intern or volunteer, or a person providing services pursuant to a contract on the basis of sex. Such harassment includes sexual harassment, gender harassment, and harassment based on pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions. Employers are required to take reasonable steps to prevent such harassment and may be held liable for permitting such harassment to occur in the workplace. Employees may be held personally liable for acts of sexual harassment. (Gov. Code Sec. 12940(j).) Existing law also makes it an unlawful employment practice for an employer, labor organization, employment agency, apprenticeship training program, or any training program leading to employment, to fail to take all reasonable steps necessary to prevent discrimination and harassment from occurring. (Gov. Code Sec. 12940(k).)
- Makes it unlawful for an owner of a housing accommodation to harass or discriminate based on sex, or to retaliate against a person for reporting such unlawful harassment or discrimination. (Gov. Code Sec. 12955.)
This bill:
- Provides that, notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action in which the pleadings state a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
- An act of sexual assault that is not governed by subdivision (a) of Section 1002 of the Code of Civil Procedure;
- An act of sexual harassment, as defined in Section 51.9 of the Civil Code;
- An act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex, or failure to prevent an act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex, as described in subdivisions (j) and (k) of Section 12940 of the Government Code; or
- An act of harassment or discrimination based on sex, or an act of retaliation against a person for reporting harassment or discrimination based on sex, by the owner of a housing accommodation, as described in Section 12955 of the Government Code.
- Allows a provision that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action to be included within a settlement agreement upon the request of the claimant. However, this provisions does not apply if a government agency or public official is a party to the settlement agreement. Otherwise, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action that is entered into on or after January 1, 2019, is void as a matter of law and against public policy.
- Makes clear that it does not prohibit the entry or enforcement of a provision in any agreement that precludes the disclosure of the amount paid in settlement of a claim.
- Authorizes the courts to consider the pleadings and other portions of the record to determine the factual foundation of a cause of action.
Background
Existing law disfavors the secret settlement of certain civil actions in which the public has a strong interest. AB 2875 (Pavley, Chapter 151, Statutes of 2006) prohibited the confidential settlement of a civil action the factual basis for which is a cause of action for “an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.” (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1002.)
It has also become the policy of the State of California that confidential settlement agreements are disfavored in any civil action based on a violation of the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA). (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2017.310.) The enacting legislation, AB 634 (Steinberg, Chapter 242, Statutes of 2003), established a test for the court to determine whether good cause exists to enforce a confidential settlement agreement or a stipulated protective order that hides information that is evidence of abuse of an elder or dependent adult in violation of the EADACPA. AB 634 limited the enforcement of a confidential settlement agreement or stipulated protective order if that confidentiality will hide specified information from public disclosure, but AB 634 only applied to EADACPA cases.
Seeking to ensure that the perpetrators of other sexual crimes are made known to the public, AB 1682 (Stone, Chapter 876, Statutes of 2016) prohibited a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement in a civil action for an act of childhood sexual abuse or an act of sexual assault against an elder or dependent adult and made a confidential settlement agreement void as a matter of law and against public policy. It also subjected an attorney that fails to comply with those requirements to discipline by the State Bar of California.
This bill further expands the universe of cases in which so-called “secret settlements” are restricted. This bill prohibits a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action in any civil action in which the pleadings state specified causes of action, including various forms of sexual harassment or discrimination and any claims for sexual assault not already covered by law. However, plaintiffs would retain the right to request such provisions.
Comments
The author states:
As we have clearly seen over the last few months, secret settlements serve one primary purpose: to keep sexual predators away from the public eye and continuing to torment and hurt innocent victims. California successfully eliminated the statute of limitations on rape and sexual assault in 2016. Our state must again stand with victims of sexual harassment and assault by ending this unjust practice of secret settlements that keep these aggressors unaccountable and able to prey on other victims. These perpetrators should not be allowed to endanger others or evade justice simply because they have a fat wallet at their disposal. SB 820 will not prevent people from mutually agreeing to settle, but it will simply prevent the perpetrator from requiring the victim to remain silent about the harassment as a condition of settlement. Everyone deserves to live and work free from sexual harassment, assault and discrimination. The STAND Act helps to end the curtain of secrecy that has existed for far too long.
Preventing secret settlements when sexual harassment is involved
Over the past year, accounts of sexual harassment and demands for reforms have arisen in almost every sector of the economy. The legal standards that prohibit sexual harassment in workplace, business, professional, service, and other contexts originated over 30 years ago. They emerged from anti-discrimination laws that date back even further. Yet, as the events of 2017 have made abundantly clear, sexual harassment remains a significant problem. Victims still suffer life-altering professional, psychological, and economic impacts. To try to avoid becoming victims, women must still remain constantly vigilant and still often choose to alter their own conduct and forgo opportunities in order to stay free from harassment. In this way, sexual harassment continues to systematically undermine the ability of women and others targeted by sexual harassment to thrive professionally, economically, and emotionally, on an equal basis with all others.
In response, the Senate Judiciary Committee and other state Legislative bodies have conducted numerous hearings, consulted with experts, and listened to public commentary with the goal of identifying legal reforms that would help to ensure a serious and lasting end to the scourge of harassment.
These public inquiries and conversations have revealed that a series of legal and policy shortcomings have enabled and, in some cases, have even facilitated harassment. Those shortcomings include: overly permissive tolerance for legal tactics that silence victims; insufficient and ineffective sexual harassment prevention training requirements; failure on the part of some judges to fully account for the power of sexual harassment to undermine the civil rights of its victims; and standards for liability that force victims to endure unwelcome conduct to the point where it becomes severe or pervasive before they are entitled to any remedy.
This bill addresses one of these legal tactics, the use of non-disclosure provisions in settlement agreements, often referred to as “secret settlements.” These agreements bind people to silence, generally with regard to all of the underlying allegations in a civil case. As has been seen in widespread media coverage, these secret settlements have the effect of preventing word from spreading about harassing or discriminatory behavior. This is part of what allows serial harassers to go undetected, sometimes for years.
The now notorious case of Harvey Weinstein offers what may be the quintessential example. (Michelle Fabio, The Harvey Weinstein Effect: The End Of Nondisclosure Agreements In Sexual Assault Cases? (Oct. 26, 2017) Forbes <https://www.forbes.com/ sites/michellefabio/2017/10/26/the-harvey-weinstein-effect-the-end-of-nondisclosure-agreements-in-sexual-assault-cases/#3dc80f ea2c11 [as of Apr. 22, 2018].) It is reported that sexual harassment and assault cases have been settled by Weinstein with at least 10 women, all including non-disclosure provisions that prevent the release of information underlying the victims’ claims. Such secret settlements have also been used by Fox News and its former founder Roger Ailes and host Bill O’Reilly to pay tens of millions of dollars to women sexually harassed by them in exchange for their silence.
It should be noted that the use of these non-disclosure provisions in settlements have some benefits. The victim and defendant may not wish to go through the burden and stress of litigation, and settlements often result in larger sums to the injured party because neither party needs to pay an attorney through the end of trial. They offer a quick resolution when both sides just want to put the matter behind them and do not want any further reputational damage to come of it. In theory at least, the victim would be agreeing to this voluntarily, although there may be an imbalance in the negotiating process for victims in practice. In addition, the settling of a civil case is not necessarily an indication of guilt.
In the context of workplace harassment claims, the defendant may be seeking to sweep the matter under the rug, so to speak, but the victim may also have a legitimate desire for privacy regarding what took place. Victims may desire such non-disclosure after suffering from sexual assault or harassment to protect them from unwanted negative attention or even retaliation. In addition, there is the possibility that without the security of silence, defendants in these cases may be less likely to settle with plaintiffs or will offer less money in such settlements.
In part to address this sensitive balance, this bill allows a plaintiff bringing specified claims for sexual harassment or sexual assault to request such provisions in settlement agreements. Therefore, in situations where victims would prefer non-disclosure, they can request such provisions to be included. In practice, this may operate to provide plaintiffs a stronger hand in negotiating settlements, although, as indicated above, a plaintiff would have already had to agree to such provisions in any existing settlement agreements. Therefore, in practice, defendants may still be able to pressure plaintiffs into requesting such provisions before agreeing to settle.
It should also be noted that this bill only applies to confidential settlement agreements entered into after a civil action has been filed with the court, and thus does not prohibit earlier settlement agreements or expose alleged harassers, who settle prior to a civil suit being filed, to the public. In addition, this bill does not apply to protective orders that also prevent the disclosure of information underlying these actions. Section 1002 of the Code of Civil Procedure, discussed above, addresses this latter issue. After laying out a prohibition on non-disclosure provisions in settlements for various actions involving sexual abuse and assault similar to those in this bill in subdivision (a), Section 1002 includes the following provision: “Notwithstanding any other law, in a civil action described in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (a), a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with subdivision (a).” (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1002(b).)
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Fiscal Com.: Local:
California Women’s Law Center (co-source)
Consumer Attorneys of California (co-source)
American Association of University Women
Congress of California Seniors
Crime Victims United of California
Screen Actors Guild-American Federation of Television and Radio Artists, AFL-CIO
American Insurance Association
California Ambulance Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Employment Law Council
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
Civil Justice Association of California
Construction Employers’ Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Consumers Attorneys of California, a sponsor of this bill, writes, “The use of NDAs or secret settlements in these cases allows repeat offenders to continue to harass while silencing victims. Unfortunately, they are all too common. Further, court orders enforcing secret settlements signed by judges can also seal damaging documents. For example, Bill Cosby’s deposition was sealed as part of a secret settlement in 2004, so the public didn’t learn about his abuse for another decade. In 2016, 21st Century Fox issued a public apology and reportedly settled confidentially with Fox News anchor Gretchen Carlson after she filed a sexual harassment lawsuit against the late Fox News Chairman and CEO Roger Ailes. The company also confidentially settled with several other women who similarly accused Mr. Ailes of workplace sexual harassment. Over the last few months, other troubling instances of secret settlements enabling ongoing sexual harassment and assault have further confirmed the need for the legislation.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Writing in opposition, a coalition of groups including the California Chamber of Commerce argues that this is “basically existing law,” and this bill “simply leverages a confidentiality provision as a higher value item for negotiation so that the trial attorneys can increase the amount of the settlement and, therefore, the amount of their contingency fee.”
5/4/18 14:01:00
**** END ****
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2017-2018 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 820 (Author:Leyva)
Version: January 3, 2018
Hearing Date: May 1, 2018
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Settlement agreements: confidentiality
DESCRIPTION
This bill would prohibit a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action in any civil action in which the pleadings state a cause of action for any of the following: various acts of sexual assault, acts of sexual harassment or discrimination, as specified, and retaliation for reporting such harassment or discrimination. Plaintiffs in such actions would still retain the right to request non-disclosure provisions in settlement agreements.
BACKGROUND
Existing law disfavors the secret settlement of certain civil actions in which the public has a strong interest. AB 2875 (Pavley, Ch. 151, Stats. 2006) prohibited the confidential settlement of a civil action the factual basis for which is a cause of action for “an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense.” (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1002.)
It has also become the policy of the State of California that confidential settlement agreements are disfavored in any civil action based on a violation of the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (EADACPA). (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2017.310.) The enacting legislation, AB 634 (Steinberg, Ch. 242, Stats. 2003), established a test for the court to determine whether good cause exists to enforce a confidential settlement agreement or a stipulated protective order that hides information that is evidence of abuse of an elder or dependent adult in violation of the EADACPA. AB 634 limited the enforcement of a confidential settlement agreement or stipulated protective order if that confidentiality will hide specified information from public disclosure, but AB 634 only applied to EADACPA cases.
Seeking to ensure that the perpetrators of other sexual crimes are made known to the public, AB 1682 (Stone, Ch. 876, Stats. 2016) prohibited a confidentiality or secrecy provision in a settlement agreement in a civil action for an act of childhood sexual abuse or an act of sexual assault against an elder or dependent adult and made a confidential settlement agreement void as a matter of law and against public policy. It also subjected an attorney that fails to comply with those requirements to discipline by the State Bar of California.
This bill would further expand the universe of cases in which so-called “secret settlements” are restricted. This bill would prohibit a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action in any civil action in which the pleadings state specified causes of action, including various forms of sexual harassment or discrimination and any claims for sexual assault not already covered by law. However, plaintiffs would retain the right to request such provisions.
CHANGES TO EXISTING LAW
Existing law provides that a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
- an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense;
- an act of childhood sexual abuse, as defined in Section 340.1;
- an act of sexual exploitation of a minor, as defined in Section 11165.1 of the Penal Code, or conduct prohibited with respect to a minor pursuant to Section 311.1, 311.5, or 311.6 of the Penal Code;
- an act of sexual assault, as defined in paragraphs (1) to (9), inclusive, of subdivision (e) of Section 15610.63 of the Welfare and Institutions Code, against an elder or dependent adult, as defined in Sections 15610.23 and 15610.27 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1002.)
Existing law prohibits a court from entering an order, in actions described above, that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with the above provisions. However, the law does not preclude an agreement preventing the disclosure of any medical information or personal identifying information regarding the victim of the offense or of any information revealing the nature of the relationship between the victim and the defendant. This provision shall not be construed to limit the right of a crime victim to disclose this information. Existing law provides that a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to such actions is void as a matter of law and against public policy. An attorney’s failure to comply with the requirements of this section by demanding that a provision be included in a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action that is not otherwise authorized as a condition of settlement, or advising a client to sign an agreement that includes such a provision, may be grounds for professional discipline and the State Bar of California shall investigate and take appropriate action in any such case brought to its attention. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1002.)
Existing law provides that it is the policy of the State of California that confidential settlement agreements are disfavored in any civil action the factual foundation for which establishes a cause of action for a violation of the Elder Abuse and Dependent Adult Civil Protection Act (Chapter 11 (commencing with Section 15600) of Part 3 of Division 9 of the Welfare and Institutions Code). It further provides that provisions of such an agreement, except those requiring nondisclosure of the amount paid, may not be recognized or enforced by the court absent a showing of any of the following:
- the information is privileged under existing law;
- the information is not evidence of abuse of an elder or dependent adult, as specified;
- the party seeking to uphold the confidentiality of the information has demonstrated that there is a substantial probability that prejudice will result from the disclosure and that the party’s interest in the information cannot be adequately protected through redaction. (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 2017.310.)
Existing law imposes liability for sexual harassment in business, service, and professional relationships, when the plaintiff shows that:
- the defendant has made sexual advances, solicitations, sexual requests, demands for sexual compliance by the plaintiff, or engaged in other verbal, visual, or physical conduct of a sexual nature or of a hostile nature based on gender, that were unwelcome and pervasive or severe;
- the plaintiff could not easily terminate the relationship;
- the plaintiff has suffered or will suffer economic loss or disadvantage or personal injury as a result of the defendant’s conduct. (Civ. Code Sec. 51.9(a).)
Existing law prohibits an employer, labor organization, employment agency, apprenticeship training program or any training program leading to employment, or any other person, from harassing an employee, an applicant, an unpaid intern or volunteer, or a person providing services pursuant to a contract on the basis of sex. Such harassment includes sexual harassment, gender harassment, and harassment based on pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions. Employers are required to take reasonable steps to prevent such harassment and may be held liable for permitting such harassment to occur in the workplace. Employees may be held personally liable for acts of sexual harassment. (Gov. Code Sec. 12940(j).) Existing law also makes it an unlawful employment practice for an employer, labor organization, employment agency, apprenticeship training program, or any training program leading to employment, to fail to take all reasonable steps necessary to prevent discrimination and harassment from occurring. (Gov. Code Sec. 12940(k).)
Existing law makes it unlawful for an owner of a housing accommodation to harass or discriminate based on sex, or to retaliate against a person for reporting such unlawful harassment or discrimination. (Gov. Code Sec. 12955.)
This bill would provide that, notwithstanding any other law, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action is prohibited in any civil action in which the pleadings state a cause of action for civil damages for any of the following:
- an act of sexual assault that is not governed by subdivision (a) of Section 1002 of the Code of Civil Procedure;
- an act of sexual harassment, as defined in Section 51.9 of the Civil Code;
- an act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex, or failure to prevent an act of workplace harassment or discrimination based on sex, as described in subdivisions (j) and (k) of Section 12940 of the Government Code; or
- an act of harassment or discrimination based on sex, or an act of retaliation against a person for reporting harassment or discrimination based on sex, by the owner of a housing accommodation, as described in Section 12955 of the Government Code.
This bill would allow a provision that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action to be included within a settlement agreement upon the request of the claimant. Otherwise, a provision within a settlement agreement that prevents the disclosure of factual information related to the action that is entered into on or after January 1, 2019, would be void as a matter of law and against public policy.
This bill would make clear that it does not prohibit the entry or enforcement of a provision in any agreement that precludes the disclosure of the amount paid in settlement of a claim.
This bill would authorize the courts to consider the pleadings and other portions of the record to determine the factual foundation of a cause of action.
COMMENT
1. Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
As we have clearly seen over the last few months, secret settlements serve one primary purpose: to keep sexual predators away from the public eye and continuing to torment and hurt innocent victims. California successfully eliminated the statute of limitations on rape and sexual assault in 2016. Our state must again stand with victims of sexual harassment and assault by ending this unjust practice of secret settlements that keep these aggressors unaccountable and able to prey on other victims. These perpetrators should not be allowed to endanger others or evade justice simply because they have a fat wallet at their disposal. SB 820 will not prevent people from mutually agreeing to settle, but it will simply prevent the perpetrator from requiring the victim to remain silent about the harassment as a condition of settlement. Everyone deserves to live and work free from sexual harassment, assault and discrimination. The STAND Act helps to end the curtain of secrecy that has existed for far too long.
2. Preventing secret settlements when sexual harassment is involved
Over the past year, accounts of sexual harassment and demands for reforms have arisen in almost every sector of the economy. The legal standards that prohibit sexual harassment in workplace, business, professional, service, and other contexts originated over 30 years ago. They emerged from anti-discrimination laws that date back even further. Yet, as the events of 2017 have made abundantly clear, sexual harassment remains a significant problem. Victims still suffer life-altering professional, psychological, and economic impacts. To try to avoid becoming victims, women[1] must still remain constantly vigilant and still often choose to alter their own conduct and forgo opportunities in order to stay free from harassment. In this way, sexual harassment continues to systematically undermine the ability of women and others targeted by sexual harassment to thrive professionally, economically, and emotionally, on an equal basis with all others.
In response, this Committee and other state Legislative bodies have conducted numerous hearings, consulted with experts, and listened to public commentary with the goal of identifying legal reforms that would help to ensure a serious and lasting end to the scourge of harassment.
These public inquiries and conversations have revealed that a series of legal and policy shortcomings have enabled and, in some cases, have even facilitated harassment. Those shortcomings include: overly permissive tolerance for legal tactics that silence victims; insufficient and ineffective sexual harassment prevention training requirements; failure on the part of some judges to fully account for the power of sexual harassment to undermine the civil rights of its victims; and standards for liability that force victims to endure unwelcome conduct to the point where it becomes severe or pervasive before they are entitled to any remedy.
This bill addresses one of these legal tactics, the use of non-disclosure provisions in settlement agreements, often referred to as “secret settlements.” These agreements bind people to silence, generally with regard to all of the underlying allegations in a civil case. As has been seen in widespread media coverage, these secret settlements have the effect of preventing word from spreading about harassing or discriminatory behavior. This is part of what allows serial harassers to go undetected, sometimes for years.
The now notorious case of Harvey Weinstein offers what may be the quintessential example. (Michelle Fabio, The Harvey Weinstein Effect: The End Of Nondisclosure Agreements In Sexual Assault Cases? (Oct. 26, 2017) Forbes <https://www.forbes.com/ sites/michellefabio/2017/10/26/the-harvey-weinstein-effect-the-end-of-nondisclosure-agreements-in-sexual-assault-cases/#3dc80f ea2c11> [as of Apr. 22, 2018].) It is reported that sexual harassment and assault cases have been settled by Weinstein with at least ten women, all including non-disclosure provisions that prevent the release of information underlying the victims’ claims. Such secret settlements have also been used by Fox News and its former founder Roger Ailes and host Bill O’Reilly to pay tens of millions of dollars to women sexually harassed by them in exchange for their silence.
It should be noted that the use of these non-disclosure provisions in settlements have some benefits. The victim and defendant may not wish to go through the burden and stress of litigation, and settlements often result in larger sums to the injured party because neither party needs to pay an attorney through the end of trial. They offer a quick resolution when both sides just want to put the matter behind them and do not want any further reputational damage to come of it. In theory at least, the victim would be agreeing to this voluntarily, although there may be an imbalance in the negotiating process for victims in practice. In addition, the settling of a civil case is not necessarily an indication of guilt.
In the context of workplace harassment claims, the defendant may be seeking to sweep the matter under the rug, so to speak, but the victim may also have a legitimate desire for privacy regarding what took place. Victims may desire such non-disclosure after suffering from sexual assault or harassment to protect them from unwanted negative attention or even retaliation. In addition, there is the possibility that without the security of silence, defendants in these cases may be less likely to settle with plaintiffs or will offer less money in such settlements.
In part to address this sensitive balance, this bill allows a plaintiff bringing specified claims for sexual harassment or sexual assault to request such provisions in settlement agreements. Therefore, in situations where victims would prefer non-disclosure, they can request such provisions to be included. In practice, this may operate to provide plaintiffs a stronger hand in negotiating settlements, although, as indicated above, a plaintiff would have already had to agree to such provisions in any existing settlement agreements. Therefore, in practice, defendants may still be able to pressure plaintiffs into requesting such provisions before agreeing to settle.
It should also be noted that this bill would only apply to confidential settlement agreements entered into after a civil action has been filed with the court, and thus would not prohibit earlier settlement agreements or expose alleged harassers, who settle prior to a civil suit being filed, to the public. In addition, this bill would not apply to protective orders that also prevent the disclosure of information underlying these actions. Section 1002 of the Code of Civil Procedure, discussed above, addresses this latter issue. After laying out a prohibition on non-disclosure provisions in settlements for various actions involving sexual abuse and assault similar to those in this bill in subdivision (a), Section 1002 includes the following provision: “Notwithstanding any other law, in a civil action described in paragraphs (1) to (4), inclusive, of subdivision (a), a court shall not enter, by stipulation or otherwise, an order that restricts the disclosure of information in a manner that conflicts with subdivision (a).” (Code Civ. Proc. Sec. 1002(b).)
Writing in support, the Congress of California Seniors states that “visibility and transparency is the best way to reduce the incidence of abuse.”
The Consumers Attorneys of California, a sponsor of this bill, writes:
The use of NDAs or secret settlements in these cases allows repeat offenders to continue to harass while silencing victims. Unfortunately, they are all too common. Further, court orders enforcing secret settlements signed by judges can also seal damaging documents. For example, Bill Cosby’s deposition was sealed as part of a secret settlement in 2004, so the public didn’t learn about his abuse for another decade. In 2016, 21st Century Fox issued a public apology and reportedly settled confidentially with Fox News anchor Gretchen Carlson after she filed a sexual harassment lawsuit against the late Fox News Chairman and CEO Roger Ailes. The company also confidentially settled with several other women who similarly accused Mr. Ailes of workplace sexual harassment. Over the last few months, other troubling instances of secret settlements enabling ongoing sexual harassment and assault have further confirmed the need for the legislation.
Writing in opposition, a coalition of groups including the California Chamber of Commerce argues that this is “basically existing law,” and the bill “simply leverages a confidentiality provision as a higher value item for negotiation so that the trial attorneys can increase the amount of the settlement and, therefore, the amount of their contingency fee.”
3. Concerns about non-disclosure when government entities are involved
The California Newspaper Publishers Association (CNPA) has submitted a letter requesting an amendment. It believes the provision authorizing a plaintiff to request non-disclosure is problematic. It writes: “This provision grants an individual veto power over the disclosure of public records. While that may be appropriate in the private sector, it is absolutely impermissible with respect to cases settled against government agencies.” CNPA asserts that “California law has long held that government entities cannot enter secret settlements—they must be disclosed under the [California Public Records Act] even if they contain clauses purporting to keep the agreement confidential.”
There is merit to these concerns. In fact, the California Public Records Act (CPRA) prohibits a state or local agency from allowing another party to control the disclosure of information that is otherwise subject to disclosure pursuant to the CPRA. (Gov. Code Sec. 6253.3.) The courts have held that “assurances of confidentiality are insufficient in themselves to justify withholding pertinent public information from the public.” (San Gabriel Tribune v. Superior Court (1983) 143 Cal.App.3d 762, 776.) Arguably, it is the public’s right to access these documents and to know how public funds are being expended that is at issue, and therefore, a public entity, or a plaintiff bringing suit against a public entity, does not have the authority to contract that right away.
To address this issue, the author has agreed to the following amendment:
Author’s Amendment
Insert the following language after Section 1001(b): “Subdivision (b) does not apply any time a government agency or public official is a party to a settlement agreement.”
As a result, CNPA has withdrawn its opposition.
Support: American Association of University Women; Congress of California Seniors; Crime Victims United of California; Screen Actors Guild-American Federation of Television and Radio Artists, AFL-CIO
Opposition: American Insurance Association; California Ambulance Association; California Chamber of Commerce; California Employment Law Council; California Restaurant Association; California Retailers Association; Civil Justice Association of California; Construction Employers’ Association
HISTORY
Source: California Women’s Law Center; Consumer Attorneys of California
Related Pending Legislation:
SB 1300 (Jackson, 2018) would, in relevant part, prohibit the preemptive use of non-disparagement clauses. This bill is currently in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 1038 (Leyva, 2018) would impose individual, personal liability on an employee who retaliates against anyone else for filing a complaint, testifying, assisting in a proceeding or, otherwise opposing harassment and discrimination, among other unlawful employment practices. This bill is currently in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 1223 (Galgiani, 2018) would direct the California Department of Industrial Relations to develop a harassment and discrimination prevention policy and training standard for use by employers in the construction industry. SB 1223 is currently pending consideration before the Senate Labor and Industrial Relations Committee.
SB 1343 (Mitchell, 2018) would expand the reach of workplace sexual harassment prevention training requirements to include all employees and all workplaces with more than five employees. In addition, this bill would direct the Department of Fair Employment and Housing to develop a two hour video training course on workplace sexual harassment prevention, to be hosted on its Web site and made available to all California employers. Finally, this bill would require DFEH to make its workplace sexual harassment materials available in at least three “alternate” languages. This bill is currently in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
AB 1870 (Reyes, 2018) would extend the statute of limitations for filing a claim of harassment, discrimination, or retaliation, among other unfair employment and housing practices, with the California Department of Fair Employment and Housing. AB 1870 is currently pending consideration before the Assembly Committee on Labor and Employment.
SB 224 (Jackson, 2017) would add “elected officials,” “directors and producers,” and “lobbyists” to the list of examples of relationships covered by Civil Code Section 51.9’s prohibition on sexual harassment in professional, business, and service contexts. SB 224 is awaiting policy committee assignment in the Assembly.
SB 419 (Portantino, 2017) would, with regard to sexual and related forms of harassment, explicitly apply the anti-retaliation protections of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) to legislative employees and lobbyists. It thus underscores that FEHA prohibits the Legislature from taking adverse action against a lobbyist or legislative employee who: files a sexual harassment complaint with the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH); testifies or assists in any proceeding related to such a complaint; or otherwise acts to oppose any practice forbidden under FEHA. SB 419 is awaiting policy committee assignment in the Assembly.
Prior Legislation:
AB 889 (Stone, 2017) would have limited the ability of litigants to enter into settlement agreements or obtain protective orders that keep secret evidence of a danger to public health and safety, except as specified. This bill died on the Assembly Floor.
AB 1682 (Stone, Ch. 876, Stats. 2016) See Background.
AB 1628 (Beall, 2012) would have, among other provisions, prohibited the confidential settlement of a civil action the factual basis for which is a cause of action for an act of childhood sexual abuse. This bill was held on Suspense in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 2875 (Pavley, Ch. 151, Stats. 2006) See Background.
AB 634 (Steinberg, Ch. 242, Stats. 2003) See Background.
**************
Reference is made to women because they comprise the group most victimized by sexual harassment. However, men and gender non-conforming individuals are also subjected to sexual harassment and suffer the adverse effects. ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Floor
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):