AB 1342: Nonprofit corporations: private postsecondary educational institutions: sale of assets: Attorney General approval.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-02-22
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2019 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Jul 8, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jun 26, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 1.) (June 25). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 19, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (June 19). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 29, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on ED. and JUD. |
| May 23, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 22, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 13. Noes 5.) (May 16). |
| May 16, 2019 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. |
| May 15, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| May 13, 2019 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 1609.) |
| Apr 23, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 3.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | Coauthors revised. |
| Mar 14, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on HIGHER ED. and JUD. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 8, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 25, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 19, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Education |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2019 | AB 1342 Low Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Higher Education |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1342 (Low) - Nonprofit corporations: private postsecondary educational institutions: sale of assets: Attorney General approval
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill requires a nonprofit corporation that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution to obtain the Attorney General’s (AG) approval before entering into certain agreements or transactions, including an agreement or transaction to sell or convey its assets to a for-profit corporation entity.
Fiscal Impact:
The Department of Justice estimates ongoing General Fund costs of approximately $871,000 each year to fund four positions to review all transactions involving the sale of nonprofit educational institutions to for-profit entities. The AG would have discretion to consent to the transactions and consult with other state agencies and experts on potential conditions that should be imposed. The bill provides that any costs incurred by the AG from contracting with experts and consultants, as well as direct and administrative costs for reviewing, evaluating, and monitoring of transactions are subject to reimbursement from the selling non-profit organization.
Additionally, this bill would authorize the AG, as a condition of approving the agreement or transaction, to transfer assets from the proceeds of the sale or transaction to the Student Tuition Recovery Fund, which is a continuously appropriated fund.
Background:
Existing law requires a nonprofit corporation, as defined, that operates or controls a health facility, as defined, or operates or controls a facility that provides similar health care to provide written notice to, and obtain the written consent of, the AG prior to selling or otherwise disposing of a material amount of its assets to a for-profit corporation or entity, to a mutual benefit corporation or entity, or to another nonprofit corporation or entity. Existing law also provides that the AG has discretion to give consent to, give conditional consent to, or to not consent to, the agreement or transaction and requires the AG to consider any factors deemed relevant, including, but not limited to, whether the terms are fair and reasonable.
Existing law establishes the California Private Postsecondary Education Act of 2009 (Act) until January 1, 2021, and requires Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education (BPPE), within the Department of Consumer Affairs to, in part, review, investigate and approve private postsecondary institutions (or institutions), programs and courses of instruction pursuant to the Act and authorizes BPPE to take formal actions against an institution/school to ensure compliance with the Act and even seek closure of an institution/school if determined necessary. The Act requires unaccredited degree granting institutions to be accredited by an accrediting agency recognized by the United States Department of Education by 2020. The Act also provides for specified disclosures and enrollment agreements for students, requirements for cancellations, withdrawals and refunds, and that the Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education administer the Student Tuition Recovery Fund to provide refunds to students affected by the possible closure of an institution/school.
There are several instances where a nonprofit college is sold to a for-profit company notably Bridgepoint and Heald have garnered the most attention. Heald College was originally founded in 1863 as a nonprofit headquartered in the Bay Area, growing to establish a series of successful campuses across the state. In 2007, Heald was bought by a private investor group and eventually made part of the for-profit college chain Corinthian Colleges, Inc (CCI).
On April 27, 2015, Heald shut down, along with CCI institutions like Everest College and WyoTech. In 2016, the AG secured a default judgment against CCI. In the judgment, the Court ordered restitution on behalf of students in the amount of $820 million and civil penalties totaling $350 million for a total of over $1.1 billion in monetary relief.
The final court judgement found, among other things, that: 1) from at least 2009 until the closure of its schools, many of CCI’s representations and advertisements relating to job placement were untrue and/or misleading; 2) CCI’s enrollment agreements contained unlawful clauses; 3) Corinthian College Inc. (CCI) engaged in unlawful debt collection; 4) CI misrepresented the transferability of credits and; 5) CCI misrepresented its financial stability to students.
Proposed Law:
This bill requires a nonprofit corporation, as defined, that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution provide written notice to and to obtain the written consent of the AG before entering into any agreement or transaction to do with either of the following:
- Sell, transfer, lease, exchange, option, convey, or otherwise dispose of its assets to a for-profit cooperation or entity or to a mutual benefit corporation or entity when a material amount of the assets of the nonprofit corporation are involved in the agreement or transaction.
- Transfer control, responsibility, or governance of a material amount of the assets or operations of the nonprofit corporation to any for-profit corporation or entity or to any mutual benefit corporation or entity.
This bill provides that the substitution of a new corporate member or members that transfers the control of, responsibility for or governance of the nonprofit corporation be deemed a transfer for purposes of the bill, as specified.
This bill requires that the notice provided to the AG be made public and that it include and contain information required by the AG, as specified, and requires that the notice be provided to the Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education.
This bill specifies that its provisions do not apply to a nonprofit corporation if the agreement or transaction is in the usual and regular course of its activities or if the AG waives the requirement for that corporation or any foreign nonprofit corporation that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution.
This bill requires, within 90 days of receipt of notification, the AG to notify a public benefit corporation in writing of the decision to consent to, give conditional consent to, or not consent to the agreement or transaction. This bill authorizes the AG to provide on additional 45- day period provided that the specified conditions are satisfied, and requires, prior to issuances of a decision or waiver the AG to conduct one or more public meetings, as specified.
This bill grants the AG discretion to consent to, give conditional consent to, or not consent to any agreement or transaction entered into by the specified nonprofits based on factors the AG deems relevant, as specified.
This bill requires, within 90 days of receipt of notification and in relation to terms and conditions used to determine consent, conditional consent or not consent, that the AG contract with, consult and receive advice from any state agency, including the Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education, on those terms and conditions, and contract with experts or consultants to assist in reviewing the proposed agreement or transaction within the limits specified relative to contract costs.
This bill provides that the AG is entitled to reimbursement for all actual and reasonable direct costs incurred in reviewing, evaluating, and making the determination regarding agreements and transactions, including administrative costs. This bill requires that the selling nonprofit corporation pay the AG for all those costs upon request.
This bill authorizes the AG to contract, within the specified cost limits, with experts and consultants to assist with monitoring ongoing compliance with the terms and conditions of the sale or transfer, as specified, and provides that the AG is entitled to reimbursement for a period of two years from either the selling or the acquiring nonprofit corporation, depending upon which on the burden of compliance falls for costs incurred in monitoring ongoing compliance, as specified.
This bill authorizes the adoption of regulations to implement the bill’s provisions, and for the AG to enforce conditions imposed on the AG’s consent to an agreement or transaction to the fullest extent provided by law, as specified. The conditions imposed on the AG’s consent to an agreement or transaction may include, but are not limited to:
- A transfer of assets from the proceeds of the sale or transfer to the Student Tuition Recovery Fund, established by current law.
- A requirement that the corporation file a surety bond to provide recovery to students who were enrolled at the private postsecondary educational institution upon subsequent closure of the institution.
- Any conditions deemed by the AG to be necessary to ensure that the access to certain educational courses or vocational instruction intended to be promoted by the charitable trust is not substantially and unreasonable impeded.
Related Legislation:
AB 1340 (Chiu) recodifies in state law the federal Gainful Employment rule so that it may be enforced by the BPPE. The bill is pending in Senate Education Committee.
AB 1341 (Berman) clarifies an institution of higher education is exempt only from the requirements imposed on out-of-state institutions if it meets the definition of a nonprofit corporation or public institution. The bill is pending in Senate Education Committee.
AB 1343 (Eggman) prohibits a private postsecondary educational institution from enrolling residents of California, unless the institution meets either the requirement that no more than 85% of the institution’s tuition revenue is derived from student financial aid and loans, or not less than 50% of the institution’s tuition revenue is dedicated to student instruction. The bill is pending in Senate Business, Profession and Economic Development Committee.
AB 1344 (Bauer-Kahan) increases the BPPE’s oversight over out-of-state private postsecondary institutions operating online. The bill is pending in Senate Education Committee.
AB 1345 (McCarty) prohibits a private postsecondary school from providing financial incentives or compensation to their employees, directly or indirectly, for student recruitment, enrollment, admissions, attendance, financial aid or sales of educational materials. The bill is pending in Senate Education Committee.
Staff Comments:
The bill specifies conditions imposed on the AG’s consent to an agreement or transaction which may include a requirement that proceeds of the sale be transferred to the STRF or a requirement that the corporation file a surety bond to provide recovery to students who were enrolled at the institution upon subsequent closure of the institution. The STRF reimburses “economic loss” for California residents enrolled in eligible institutions at the time of closure. Economic loss includes a student’s tuition, cost of required equipment and materials, and interest on student loan debt used to pay those charges. It does not include supplies, living expenses, or damages such as emotional distress. The STRF is traditionally supported by fees collected from each student at regulated schools. The amount of this fee was reduced to zero effective January 1, 2015 as the current balance exceeds the statutory cap of $25 million.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1342 (Author:Low)
Version: February 22, 2019
Hearing Date: June 25, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: JT
SUBJECT
Nonprofit corporations: private postsecondary educational institutions: sale of assets: Attorney General approval
DIGEST
This bill requires a nonprofit corporation that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution to obtain the Attorney General’s (AG) consent before entering into certain agreements or transactions, including an agreement or transaction to sell or convey its assets to a for-profit corporation or mutual benefit corporation.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Existing law provides for AG review and approval of the sale of nonprofit healthcare facilities to ensure that such transactions are in the public interest. The AG must hold a public hearing on the proposed sale, consider any relevant factors—such as the fairness of the transaction and the impact on the public—and notify the nonprofit of the AG’s decision within 90 days. To carry out these functions, the AG is authorized to contract with experts, seek reimbursement for actual and reasonable costs from the nonprofit or its purchaser, and enforce conditions imposed by the AG in approving the transaction.
This bill seeks to apply this basic framework in the context of the sale of nonprofit private postsecondary educational institutions to for-profit corporations. This bill is supported by educational, consumer rights, public interest law firms, and labor organizations that believe the extension of the AG’s oversight to the sale of nonprofit schools is a valuable form of consumer protection. It is opposed by Zovio, a for-profit education services company.
The Senate Education Committee passed the bill by a vote of 5-1.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes the Nonprofit Public Benefit Corporations Law, which sets forth requirements for the operation of a nonprofits public benefit corporation. (Corp. Code § 5110 et seq.)[1]
- Provides that a nonprofit corporation is subject at all times to examination by the AG. (§ 5250.)
- Establishes matching frameworks for AG review and approval of the sale of a nonprofit health care facility to either a for-profit corporation (§§ 5914-5919) or another nonprofit corporation (§§ 5920-5930). In broad strokes, these frameworks:
- require that the AG:
- hold a public hearing on the proposed sale;
- consider any relevant factors, such as the fairness of the transaction and impact on the public, in deciding whether to consent, consent conditionally, or deny the sale; and
- notify the nonprofit corporation of the AG’s decision within 90 days;
- authorize the AG to:
- contract with experts and consultants for reasonable costs of carrying out its duties to review and evaluate the sale and monitor compliance with terms and conditions imposed by the AG;
- seek reimbursement for actual and reasonable costs incurred in carrying out these functions;
- adopt regulations to implement these provisions; and
- enforce conditions imposed by the AG on an agreement or transaction and to seek judicial remedies a court deems appropriate for breach of the conditions, including the recovery of attorney’s fees and costs.
- require that the AG:
This bill replicates the existing frameworks described above by applying similar provisions to the sale of nonprofit private postsecondary educational institutions to for-profit corporations.
COMMENTS
- Seeks to regulate the sale of nonprofit educational institutions to for-profit corporations
Existing law generally does not regulate the sale of a nonprofit educational institution to a for-profit company. Although the for-profit-education industry may fill a market gap in higher education and offer more educational opportunities to minorities, it has been pockmarked by several high-profile misdeeds and a reputation for mismanagement and substandard education quality. Compared to their counterparts in comparable nonprofit schools, for-profit students have higher unemployment rates, greater student debt burdens, and higher default rates.[2] The sale of a nonprofit school to a for-profit company thus poses very significant consumer protection concerns for students.
A recent example is the 2007 purchase of Heald College by the for-profit chain Corinthian Colleges, Inc. Heald College was originally founded in 1863 as a nonprofit postsecondary institution headquartered in the Bay Area and grew to establish several campuses across the state. In 2015, Heald suddenly shut down after the U.S. Department of Education determined Heald had misrepresented job placement rates, and the federal government assessed fines against Corinthian.
According to the author:
AB 1342 ensures that nonprofit colleges are treated with similar community value as health facilities by providing for the same review by the Attorney General when a nonprofit school is sold and turned into a for-profit institution. The Attorney General’s approval would be required for any proposed sale, and conditions could be placed on that approval to ensure that the community’s interests are not jeopardized by the sale.
Higher education is a cornerstone of the American Dream — but some corporations have exploited that dream in search of making a profit at the expense of students. [AB 1342] will ensure our educational institutions remain a reflection of our community values.
- Replicates an existing framework applicable to the sale of nonprofit health care facilities
Existing law provides for AG review and approval of the sale of nonprofit healthcare facilities to ensure that such transactions are in the public interest. The AG must hold a public hearing on the proposed sale, consider any relevant factors—such as the fairness of the transaction and the impact on the public—and notify the nonprofit of the AG’s decision within 90 days. To carry out these functions, the AG is authorized to contract with experts, seek reimbursement for actual and reasonable costs from the nonprofit or its purchaser, and enforce conditions imposed by the AG in approving the transaction.
This bill replicates and applies that framework to the sale of nonprofit schools to for-profit companies. Arguably, the group of consumers the bill seeks to protect are in a similar position to health care consumers: both students and patients receive vital services at tremendous expense, yet often have limited bargaining power and a paucity of alternatives. Thus, it may also be appropriate to grant the AG the power to oversee transactions in which private nonprofit educational institutions are acquired by for-profit entities.
So argues a coalition of educational, consumer rights, public interest law firms, and labor organizations. The coalition writes:
There are currently very few limitations on the sale of a nonprofit college to a for-profit company in California, and too few protections to prevent the sale from reducing students’ access to quality higher education. This is of particular concern given California’s troubled history with for-profit companies taking over successful nonprofit institutions.
AB 1342 ensures that nonprofit colleges are treated with similar consideration as health facilities, by providing for the same review by the Attorney General when a nonprofit school is sold and turned into a for-profit institution. The Attorney General’s approval would be required for any proposed sale, and conditions could be placed on that approval to ensure that the community’s interests are not jeopardized by the sale. In this way, the community value of the school can be preserved, regardless of the institution’s owner.
3. Opposition
Zovio, a for-profit education services company,[3] opposes the bill, asserting that an extensive review process already governs substantial changes in the status of educational institutions, including approval by an accrediting agency, as well as the U.S. Department of Education and the Internal Revenue Service. Zovio additionally asserts that AB 1342 does not require outside experts enlisted by the AG to be impartial, leading to the possibility of biased evaluations. Finally, Zovio requests the following amendments to the bill:
- require the Franchise Tax Board, rather than the AG, to oversee the sale of a nonprofit educational institution;
- expedite the timeframe for the review process, which is up to four months under the bill;
- place a reasonable cap on costs an institution may be charged for the review process;
- provide for confidentiality for sensitive proprietary and financial information;
- limit conditions for approval to transfer of assets from proceeds of sale or transfer to the Student Tuition Recover Fund, or filing of a surety bond; and
- define the term “usual and regular course” to ensure specific types of transactions are not swept into an unproductive or unnecessary review process.
SUPPORT
California Association of Nonprofits
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
Center for Public Interest Law
Center for Responsible Lending
Children’s Advocacy Institute
Consumer Federation of California
Consumer Reports Advocacy
Housing and Economic Right Advocates
Public Advocates
Public Counsel
Public Law Center
SEIU California
Student Debt Crisis
The Century Foundation
The Institute for College Access and Success
Veterans Education Success
Veterans Legal Clinic
OPPOSITION
Zovio
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known
Prior Legislation: None known
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Education Committee (Ayes 5, Noes 1)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 62, Noes 14)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 13, Noes 5)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 3)
Assembly Higher Education Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 1)
**************
All further statutory references are to the Corporations Code unless otherwise specified. ↑
See Deming et al, The For-Profit Postsecondary School Sector: Nimble Critters or Agile Predators? (Dec. 2011) National Bureau of Economic Research <https://www.nber.org/papers/w17710> (as of Jun. 3, 2018). ↑
Zovio was formerly Bridgepoint Education, “the troubled parent company of Ashford University,” which moved “its headquarters and at least 600 jobs from San Diego to Chandler, Arizona.”
Bridgepoint Education becomes Zovio, moves headquarters and 600 positions from San Diego to Arizona (Apr. 4, 2019) San Diego Union Tribune https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/business/technology/story/2019-04-04/bridgepoint-education-becomes-zovio-moves-headquarters-and-600-positions-from-san-diego-to-arizona (as of Jun. 20, 2019). Bridgepoint faced “myriad probes by state attorney generals and the U.S. Department of Justice over allegations that it made false promises to prospective students and used strong-arm tactics to collect on student debt.” (Ibid.)
An NBC News article described some of the controversies involving Ashford University:
With its high sticker price, questionable job placement success and 16 percent graduation rate — considerably lower than the national average of about 60 percent. Ashford was described in a Chronicle of Higher Education investigation as “a poster child for the ills of the for-profit college sector,” and the school was sued by the state of California, which said it was misleading students about tuition cost and burying them in loan debt.
Veterans Could be first to pay as DeVos rolls back for-profit college oversight NBC News (Apr. 14, 2019) https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/politics-news/veterans-could-be-first-pay-devos-rolls-back-profit-college-n985891 (as of Jun. 14, 2019). ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON EDUCATION
Senator Connie Leyva, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 1342 Hearing Date: June 19, 2019
Author: | |||
Version: | February 22, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Olgalilia Ramirez | ||
Subject: Nonprofit corporations: private postsecondary educational institutions: sale of assets: Attorney General approval.
NOTE: This bill has been referred to the Committees on Education and Judiciary. A "do pass" motion should include referral to the Committee on Judiciary.
SUMMARY
This bill requires a nonprofit corporation that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution to obtain the Attorney General’s (AG) consent before entering into certain agreements or transactions, including an agreement or transaction to sell or convey its assets to, or to transfer control, responsibility, or governance of a material amount of its assets to, a for-profit corporation or mutual benefit corporation.
BACKGROUND
Existing law:
1) Requires a nonprofit corporation, as defined, that operates or controls a health facility, as defined, or operates or controls a facility that provides similar health care to provide written notice to, and obtain the written consent of, the AG prior to selling or otherwise disposing of a material amount of its assets to a for-profit corporation or entity, to a mutual benefit corporation or entity, or to another nonprofit corporation or entity. Existing law also provides that the AG has discretion to give consent to, give conditional consent to, or to not consent to, the agreement or transaction and requires the AG to consider any factors deemed relevant, including, but not limited to, whether the terms are fair and reasonable. (CORP Section 5914, et. seq.)
2) Establishes the California Private Postsecondary Education Act of 2009 (Act) until January 1, 2021, and requires Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education (BPPE), within the Department of Consumer Affairs to, in part, review, investigate and approve private postsecondary institutions (or institutions), programs and courses of instruction pursuant to the Act and authorizes BPPE to take formal actions against an institution/school to ensure compliance with the Act and even seek closure of an institution/school if determined necessary. The Act requires unaccredited degree granting institutions to be accredited by an accrediting agency recognized by the United States Department of Education by 2020. The Act also provides for specified disclosures and enrollment agreements for students, requirements for cancellations, withdrawals and refunds, and that the Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education administer the Student Tuition Recovery Fund to provide refunds to students affected by the possible closure of an institution/school. (Education Code § 94800 et. seq.)
ANALYSIS
This bill:
- Requires a nonprofit corporation, as defined, that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution provide written notice to and to obtain the written consent of, the Attorney General (AG) before entering into any agreement or transaction to do with either of the following:
- Sell, transfer, lease, exchange, option, convey, or otherwise dispose of its
assets to a for-profit cooperation or entity or to a mutual benefit corporation or entity when a material amount of the assets of the nonprofit corporation are involved in the agreement or transaction.
- Transfer control, responsibility, or governance of a material amount of the
assets or operations of the nonprofit corporation to any for-profit corporation or entity or to any mutual benefit corporation or entity.
- Provides that the substitution of a new corporate member or members that transfers the control of, responsibility for or governance of the nonprofit corporation be deemed a transfer for purposes of the bill, as specified.
- Requires that the notice provided to the AG be made public and that it include and contain information required by the AG, as specified.
- Requires that the notice be provided to the Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education.
- Specifies that the bill’s provisions do not apply to:
- A nonprofit corporation if the agreement or transaction is in the usual and
regular course of its activities or if the AG waives the requirement for that corporation.
- Any foreign nonprofit corporation that operates or controls a private
postsecondary educational institution.
- Requires, within 90 days of receipt of notification, the AG to notify a public benefit corporation in writing of the decision to consent to, give conditional consent to, or not consent to the agreement or transaction. This bill authorizes the AG to provide on additional 45- day period provided that the specified conditions are satisfied.
- Requires, prior to issuances of a decision or waiver the AG to conduct one or more public meetings, as specified.
- Grants the Attorney General (AG) discretion to consent to, give conditional consent to, or not consent to any agreement or transaction entered into by the specified nonprofits based on factors the AG deems relevant including whether any of the following apply:
- The terms and conditions of the agreement or transaction are fair and
reasonable to the nonprofit corporation.
- The agreement or transaction will result in inurement to any private person
or entity.
- Any agreement or transaction is at fair market value, as described.
- The market value has been manipulated by the actions of the parties in a
manner that causes the value of the assets to decrease.
- The proposed use of the proceeds from the agreement or transaction is
consistent with the charitable trust on which the assets are held by the educational institutions.
- The agreement or transaction involves or constitutes any breach of trust.
- The AG has been provided, with sufficient information and
Data to evaluate adequately the agreement or transaction or the effects thereof on the public.
- The agreement or transaction may create a significant effect on the
availability or accessibility of educational services to the affected community.
- The proposed agreement or transaction is in the public interest.
- Requires, within 90 days of receipt of notification and in relation to terms and conditions used to determine consent, conditional consent or not consent, that the AG do all of the following:
- Contract with, consult and receive advice from any state agency, including
the Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education, on those terms and conditions.
- Contract with experts or consultants to assist in reviewing the proposed
agreement or transaction within the limits specified relative to contract costs.
- Provides that the AG is entitled to reimbursement for all actual and reasonable direct costs incurred in reviewing, evaluating, and making the determination regarding agreements and transactions, including administrative costs. This bill requires that the selling nonprofit corporation pay the Attorney General for all those costs upon request.
- Authorizes the Attorney General (AG) to contract, within the specified cost limits, with experts and consultants to assist with monitoring ongoing compliance with the terms and conditions of the sale or transfer, as specified.
- Provides that the AG is entitled to reimbursement for a period of two years from either the selling or the acquiring nonprofit corporation, depending upon which on the burden of compliance falls for costs incurred in monitoring ongoing compliance, as specified.
- Authorizes the adoption of regulations to implement the bill’s provisions.
- Authorizes the AG to enforce conditions imposed on the AG’s consent to an agreement or transaction to the fullest extent provided by law, as specified. The conditions imposed on the AG’s consent to an agreement or transaction may include, but are not limited to:
- A transfer of assets from the proceeds of the sale or transfer to the
Student Tuition Recovery Fund, established by current law.
- A requirement that the corporation file a surety bond to provide recovery to
students who were enrolled at the private postsecondary educational institution upon subsequent closure of the institution.
- Any conditions deemed by the AG to be necessary to
ensure that the access to certain educational courses or vocational instruction intended to be promoted by the charitable trust is not substantially and unreasonable impeded.
STAFF COMMENTS
- Need for the bill. According to the author, “The bill expands oversight over the sale of charitable nonprofit assets dedicated toward nonprofit higher education.
The California Department of Justice is generally responsible for regulating nonprofits in California through its Charitable Trusts Section. Under existing law, nonprofit hospitals and other health facilities must notify the AG whenever they intend to sell their assets to a for-profit company. There is then a public review process in which the Charitable Trusts Section reviews the terms of the agreement, evaluates the potential impact the sale would have on the affected community, and decides whether to grant approval. Approved sales typically come with enforceable conditions to preserve standards of care and ensure that a commercial transaction involving charitably-funded assets does not occur to the detriment of the community.
There is no similar review and approval process for when a nonprofit college is sold to a for-profit company in California. This means there are currently very few protections in place to prevent the sale from reducing a community’s access to quality higher education. This is of particular concern given the controversial history of for-profit companies taking over successful nonprofit colleges.
For example, Heald College was originally founded in 1863 as a nonprofit headquartered in the Bay Area, growing to establish a series of successful campuses across the state. In 2007, Heald was bought by a private investor group and eventually made part of the for-profit college chain Corinthian Colleges. In 2017, Heald was shut down and the state secured a $1.1 billion judgment when it was revealed that Corinthian Colleges intentionally targeted low-income, vulnerable Californians through deceptive and false advertisements and aggressive marketing campaigns that misrepresented job placement rates and school programs. As a result, students who had trusted Heald’s reputation for quality education were left with nothing to show for their time there except for often staggering student loan debt.
AB 1342 ensures that nonprofit colleges are treated with similar community value as health facilities by providing for the same review by the Attorney General when a nonprofit school is sold and turned into a for-profit institution. The AG’s approval would be required for any proposed sale, and conditions could be placed on that approval to ensure that the community’s interests are not jeopardized by the sale.”
- For-profit companies purchases of non-profit institutions. There are several instances where a nonprofit college is sold to a for-profit company notably Bridgepoint and Heald have garnered the most attention. According to the Assembly Higher Education committee analysis, “In 2005, Bridgepoint Education, a for-profit higher education company, purchased the Franciscan University of the Prairies – a “brick and mortar” college located in Clinton, Iowa.
Franciscan University of the Prairies, which was founded in 1918 and had previously been known as Mount St. Clare College, maintained an enrollment of 500 students and was sponsored by the Roman Catholic Sisters of St. Francis.
Renamed as Ashford University, Bridgepoint was able to utilize the existing accreditation from the North Central Association of Colleges and Schools. Bridgepoint went on to close the Iowa campus in May of 2016. At the time, 99 percent of the 55,300 students at Bridgepoint-owned Ashford and University of the Rockies were taking classes solely online.”
Heald College was originally founded in 1863 as a nonprofit headquartered in the Bay Area, growing to establish a series of successful campuses across the state. In 2007, Heald was bought by a private investor group and eventually made part of the for-profit college chain Corinthian Colleges, Inc (CCI).
On April 27, 2015, Heald shut down, along with CCI institutions like Everest College and WyoTech. In 2016, the AG secured a default judgment against CCI. In the judgment, the Court ordered restitution on behalf of students in the amount of $820 million and civil penalties totaling $350 million for a total of over $1.1 billion in monetary relief.
The final court judgement found, among other things, that: 1) from at least 2009 until the closure of its schools, many of CCI’s representations and advertisements relating to job placement were untrue and/or misleading; 2) CCI’s enrollment agreements contained unlawful clauses; 3) Corinthian College Inc. (CCI) engaged in unlawful debt collection; 4) CI misrepresented the transferability of credits and; 5) CCI misrepresented its financial stability to students.
- Related activity with nonprofit hospitals. This bill’s provisions closely parallel an existing process required for the sale of nonprofit hospitals to for-profit corporations. Such nonprofit to for-profit transactions accounted for 1330 hours of staff time in the Attorney General’s (AG) office in 2013.
- Enforceable conditions may include Student Tuition Recovery Fund (STRF) contribution or surety bond. The bill specifies conditions imposed on the AG’s consent to an agreement or transaction of which may include proceeds of the sale to be transferred to STRF or a requirement that the corporation file a surety bond to provide recovery to students who were enrolled at the institution upon subsequent closure of the institution. STRF reimburses “economic loss” for California residents enrolled in eligible institutions at the time of closure. Economic loss includes a student’s tuition, cost of required equipment and materials, and interest on student loan debt used to pay those charges. It does not include supplies, living expenses, or damages such as emotional distress. The STRF is traditionally supported by fees collected from each student at regulated schools. The amount of this fee was reduced to zero effective January 1, 2015 as the current balance exceeds the statutory cap of $25 million.
Lastly, several states require for-profit institutions to maintain a surety bond. Surety bonds, which schools maintain, will typically refund a student’s tuition if the school closes or if the school fails to uphold the contract it signed with the student.
- Related legislation. This bills is a part of an Assembly bill package designed to
provide more accountability and state oversight of private postsecondary institutions.
AB 1340 (Chiu) recodifies in state law the federal Gainful Employment rule so that it may be enforced by the BPPE. The bill is pending in Senate Business Professions, and Economic Development committee.
AB 1341 (Berman) clarifies an institution of higher education is exempt only from the requirements imposed on out-of-state institutions if it meets the definition of a nonprofit corporation or public institution. The bill is pending in Senate Business and Economic Development committee.
AB 1343 (Eggman) prohibits a private postsecondary educational institution from enrolling residents of California, unless the institution meets either the requirement that no more than 85% of the institution’s tuition revenue is derived from student financial aid and loans, or not less than 50% of the institution’s tuition revenue is dedicated to student instruction. The bill is pending in Senate Business, Profession and Economic Development committee.
AB 1344 (Bauer-Kahan) increases the BPPE’s oversight over out-of-state private postsecondary institutions operating online. The bill is pending in Senate Business, Profession and Economic Development committee.
AB 1345 (McCarty) prohibits a private postsecondary school from providing financial incentives or compensation to their employees, directly or indirectly, for student recruitment, enrollment, admissions, attendance, financial aid or sales of educational materials. The bill is pending in Senate Business, Profession and Economic Development committee.
SUPPORT
California Association of Nonprofits
California Faculty Association
The Institute for College Access and Success
National Student Legal Defense Network
Housing and Economic Rights Advocates
Children’s Advocacy Institute Center for Public Interest Law
Public Law Center
Consumer Federation of California
Public Advocates
Consumer Reports Advocacy
OPPOSITION
Zovio
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1342
Author:(Low, et al.)
As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Requires a nonprofit corporation that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution to obtain the Attorney General's (AG) consent before entering into certain agreements or transactions, including an agreement or transaction to sell or convey its assets to, or to transfer control, responsibility, or governance of a material amount of its assets to, a for-profit corporation or mutual benefit corporation.
Major Provisions
Please refer to the Assembly Committee on Higher Education policy analysis for a detailed listing of this bill's major provisions.
COMMENTS:
The policy proposed in this bill closely parallels an existing process required for the sale of nonprofit hospitals to for-profit corporations. Such nonprofit to for-profit transactions accounted for 1330 hours of staff time in the AG's office in 2013.
According to the Author:
According to the author, "When a nonprofit college is sold to a for-profit company in California, there are currently very few protections in place to prevent the sale from reducing a community's access to quality higher education. This is of particular concern given the controversial history of for-profit companies taking over successful nonprofit colleges.
"AB 1342 ensures that nonprofit colleges are treated with similar community value as health facilities by providing for the same review by the AG when a nonprofit school is sold and turned into a for-profit institution. The AG's approval would be required for any proposed sale, and conditions could be placed on that approval to ensure that the community's interests are not jeopardized by the sale."
Arguments in Support:
A coalition of student, veteran, civil rights, and higher education advocates jointly wrote that, "There are currently very few limitations on the sale of a nonprofit college to a for-profit company in California, and too few protections to prevent the sale from reducing students' access to quality higher education. This is of particular concern given California's troubled history with for-profit companies taking over successful nonprofit institutions."
"AB 1342 ensures that nonprofit colleges are treated with similar consideration as health facilities, by providing for the same review by the AG when a nonprofit school is sold and turned into a for-profit institution. The AG's approval would be required for any proposed sale, and conditions could be placed on that approval to ensure that the community's interests are not jeopardized by the sale. In this way, the community value of the school can be preserved, regardless of the institution's owner."
Arguments in Opposition:
Ashford University wrote that the measure "overlooks the extensive review process that institutions must currently pursue in order to convert from a for-profit to a non-profit institution," including approval by both the accrediting institution and the U.S. Department of Education and the Internal Revenue Service, and including a "thorough review of academic programs offered and the operation of the institution to ensure that the institution is governed by [a] board of trustees that is independent from outside influences and free from conflict of interest."
Furthermore, Ashford argues that a conversion of a non-profit to a for-profit educational institution is "consistent with your student focused policy goals. A converted nonprofit would be permitted to participate in research grant from foundations and to accept charitable contributions, both of which work to enhance student learning and experiences." In addition, Ashford questions whether outside consultants, who could be hired via no-bid contracts by the AG to complete the review of a proposed conversion, "inviting critics to conduct and produce biased evaluation that serve neither students nor the public good."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
The Assembly Appropriations Committee notes that this bill could create ongoing General Fund costs, potentially in the hundreds of thousands of dollars annually, to the AG to review and approve any sale of a nonprofit educational institution to a for-profit entity, to the extent nonprofit institutions are sold to for-profit entities.
VOTES:
ASM HIGHER EDUCATION: 10-1-1
YES: Medina, Choi, Gloria, Bloom, Gabriel, Irwin, Gonzalez, Low, Santiago, Weber
NO: Kiley
ABS, ABST OR NV: Patterson
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-3-0
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Gallagher, Kiley, Obernolte
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-5-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Diep, Fong, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: February 22, 2019
CONSULTANT: Kevin J. Powers / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960 FN: 0000759
Date of Hearing: May 16, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1342
Author:(Low) – As Amended Ver:April 10, 2019
Policy Committee: | Higher Education | Vote: | 10 - 1 |
Judiciary | 9 - 3 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the state Attorney General (AG) to review and approve any sale of a nonprofit educational institution to a for-profit entity.
Specifically, the bill requires a nonprofit educational institution to provide a written notice to, and to obtain written consent of, the AG before entering into any agreement or transaction related to the sale or the transfer to a private postsecondary institution. Before issuing a decision, the bill requires the AG to provide notice of public hearing and conduct a public hearing in the county in which the institution is located. Within 90 days, except under certain circumstances, the bill requires the AG to notify the nonprofit institution of its decision whether to consent to the agreement or transaction. The bill specifies the AG shall be entitled to a reasonable reimbursement from the entity requesting approval for the costs of these activities.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Ongoing General Fund costs, potentially in the hundreds of thousands of dollars annually, to the AG to review and approve any sale of a nonprofit educational institution to a for-profit entity, to the extent nonprofit institutions are sold to for-profit entities.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
When a nonprofit college is sold to a for-profit company in California, there are currently very few protections in place to prevent the sale from reducing a community’s access to quality higher education. This is of particular concern given the controversial history of for-profit companies taking over successful nonprofit colleges.
- Background. There are several examples of for-profit companies purchasing nonprofit colleges. For example, Heald College was originally founded in 1863 as a nonprofit postsecondary institution headquartered in the Bay Area and grew to establish several campuses across the state. In 2007, Heald was bought by a private investor group and eventually became part of the for-profit college chain Corinthian Colleges, Inc. (CCI). In 2015, Heald colleges suddenly shut down after the U.S. Department of Education determined Heald had misrepresented job placement rates and the federal government assessed fines against CCI.
The policy proposed in AB 1342 closely parallels an existing process at the AG’s office required for the sale of nonprofit hospitals to for-profit corporations.
- Private Postsecondary Bill Package. This bill is a part of an Assembly bill package designed to provide more accountability and state oversight of private postsecondary institutions.
AB 1340 (Chiu) would recodify in state law the federal gainful employment rule so the rule may be enforced by the BPPE. The bill is pending in this committee.
AB 1341 (Berman) would clarify that an institution of higher education is exempt only from the requirements imposed on out-of-state institutions if it meets the definition of a nonprofit corporation or public institution. The bill is pending in this committee.
AB 1343 (Eggman) would prohibit a private postsecondary educational institution from enrolling residents of California, unless the institution meets either the requirement that no more than 85% of the institution’s tuition revenue is derived from student financial aid and loans, or not less than 50% of the institution’s tuition revenue is dedicated to student instruction. The bill is pending in this committee.
AB 1344 (Bauer-Kahan) would increase the BPPE’s oversight over out-of-state private postsecondary educational institutions operating online. The bill is pending in this committee.
AB 1345 (McCarty) would prohibit a private postsecondary school from providing financial incentives or compensation to their employees, directly or directly, for student recruitment, enrollment, admissions, attendance, financial aid or sales of educational materials. The bill passed out of this committee on May 1, 2019.
AB 1346 (Medina) would expand the definition of economic loss, as it pertains to the Student Tuition Recovery Fund. The bill is pending in this committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Natasha Collins / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1342
Author:(Low) – As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
SUBJECT: NONPROFIT CORPORATIONS: PRIVATE POSTSECONDARY EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS: SALE OF ASSETS: ATTORNEY GENERAL APPROVAL
KEY ISSUE: should a nonprofit corporation that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution be required to obtain the Attorney General’s consent before entering into certain agreements or transactions, including an agreement or transaction to sell or convey the institution’s assets to a for-profit or mutual benefit corporation?
SYNOPSIS
When a nonprofit college is sold to a for-profit company in California, there are currently very few protections in place to prevent the sale from reducing a community’s access to quality higher education. This is of particular concern in light of the controversial history of for-profit companies taking over successful nonprofit colleges. This bill seeks to provide more state oversight of planned transfers of nonprofit educational institution assets to for-profit entities because of the adverse impact of such transfers on the students who attend these institutions. The bill requires a nonprofit educational institution to obtain the written consent of, the AG before entering into any agreement or transaction to sell, transfer, lease, exchange, option, convey, or otherwise dispose of its assets to a for-profit or mutual benefit corporation. It also seeks to ensure that more notice of planned closures of local educational institutions, and reductions of crucial services provided by those institutions, is provided to the public and the agencies that oversee them.
Current law requires the AG to review the planned transfer of a nonprofit hospital’s charitable assets to either a for-profit corporation, or another nonprofit corporation (Corporations Code Sections 5914 and 5920), in order to ensure that those assets are used for their intended public use. The AG has 90 days from the time the hospital provides notice of its intent to sell to issue a decision (although the AG may utilize a 45-day extension under certain circumstances). During this approval process, the AG must hold at least one public hearing in the county where the facility is located to hear comments from interested parties. The AG may consent to, give conditional consent to, or deny consent to the proposed sale, transaction, or agreement. This bill is clearly modeled on the process for review of public hospital asset transfers that is described above, requiring 1) the AG to review and consent to, give conditional consent to, or deny consent to the proposed sale within 90 days (but allowing for an extension of time under specified circumstances); 2) at least one public hearing convened by the AG regarding the planned sale; 3) notification to the state regulator (the BPPE); and 4) the decision of the AG to be based upon specified factors, including whether the terms and conditions of the agreement or transaction are fair and reasonable to the nonprofit corporation.
The bill, which previously passed the Assembly Committee on Higher Education by a vote of 10-1 (with one abstention), is supported by a large coalition of consumer groups, public interest law firms, and labor organizations that support the bill and believe that it will appropriately create a mechanism of oversight—something the Attorney General has experience doing in the context of proposed public hospital closures—that is sorely needed over non-profit educational institutions. It is opposed by Ashford University.
SUMMARY: Requires a nonprofit corporation that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution to obtain the Attorney General’s (AG) consent before entering into certain agreements or transactions, including an agreement or transaction to sell or convey its assets to a for-profit corporation or mutual benefit corporation. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires any nonprofit corporation, as specified, that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution, as specified, to provide written notice to, and to obtain the written consent of, the AG before entering into any agreement or transaction to do either of the following:
- Sell, transfer, lease, exchange, option, convey, or otherwise dispose of its assets to a for-profit corporation or entity or to a mutual benefit corporation or entity when a material amount of the assets of the nonprofit corporation are involved in the agreement or transaction; and,
- Transfer control, responsibility, or governance of a material amount of the assets or operations of the nonprofit corporation to any for-profit corporation or entity or to any mutual benefit corporation or entity.
- Specifies that the substitution of a new corporate member or members that transfers the control of, responsibility for, or governance of, the nonprofit corporation shall be deemed a transfer for purposes of the article established in this legislation. The substitution of one or more members of the governing body, or any arrangement, written or oral, that would transfer voting control of the members of the governing body, shall also be deemed a transfer for purposes of this article.
- Requires that the notice provided to the AG contain the information the AG determines is required. The notice, including any other information provided to the AG, as specified, and that is in the public file, shall be made available by the AG to the public in written form as soon as is practicable after it is received by the AG.
- Requires that the notice provided to the AG is also provided to the Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education (BPPE).
- Specifies that the above shall not apply to a nonprofit corporation if the agreement or transaction is in the usual and regular course of its activities or if the AG has given the corporation a written waiver of this section as to the proposed agreement or transaction.
- Specifies that the above shall apply to any foreign nonprofit corporation that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution or an institution that provides similar educational services, regardless of whether it is currently operating or providing educational services.
- Specifies that, within 90 days of the receipt of the written notice required by Section 5940, the AG shall notify the public benefit corporation in writing of the decision to consent to, give conditional consent to, or not consent to the agreement or transaction. The AG may extend this period for one additional 45-day period if any of the following conditions are satisfied:
- The extension is necessary to obtain information, as specified;
- The proposed agreement or transaction is substantially modified after the first public meeting conducted by the AG, as specified; and,
- The proposed agreement or transaction involves a private postsecondary educational institution with a multifacility system of campuses serving multiple communities, rather than a single campus.
- Requires that, before issuing any written decision, or giving a written wavier, the AG shall conduct one or more public meetings, one of which shall be in the county in which the private postsecondary educational institution is located, to hear comments from interested parties.
- At least 14 days before conducting the public meeting, the AG shall provide written notice of the time and place of the meeting through publication in one or more newspapers of general circulation in the affected community and to the board of supervisors of the county in which the private postsecondary educational institution is located.
- If a substantive change in the proposed agreement or transaction is submitted to the AG after the initial public meeting, the AG may conduct an additional public meeting to hear comments from interested parties with respect to that change.
- Specifies that the AG shall have discretion to consent to, give conditional consent to, or not consent to any agreement or transaction; requires the AG, in making the determination, to consider any factors that the AG deems relevant, including, but not limited to, whether any of the following factors apply:
- The terms and conditions of the agreement or transaction are fair and reasonable to the nonprofit corporation;
- The agreement or transaction will result in inurement to any private person or entity;
- Whether any agreement or transaction that is subject to the bill is at fair market value. In this regard, “fair market value” means the most likely price that the assets being sold would bring in a competitive and open market under all conditions requisite to a fair sale, the buyer and seller each acting prudently, knowledgeably, and in their own best interest, and a reasonable time being allowed for exposure in the open market;
- The market value has been manipulated by the actions of the parties in a manner that causes the value of the assets to decrease;
- The proposed use of the proceeds from the agreement or transaction is consistent with the charitable trust on which the assets are held by the educational institution;
- The agreement or transaction involves or constitutes any breach of trust;
- The AG has been provided with sufficient information and data by the nonprofit corporation to evaluate adequately the agreement or transaction or the effects thereof on the public;
- The agreement or transaction may create a significant effect on the availability or accessibility of educational services to the affected community; and,
- The proposed agreement or transaction is in the public interest.
- Specifies that the AG may do the following, as specified:
- Contract with, consult, and receive advice from any state agency on those terms and conditions that the AG deems appropriate, including the BPPE; and
- In the AG’s discretion, contract with experts or consultants to assist in reviewing the proposed agreement or transaction;
- Requires that contract costs pursuant to 10a), above, shall not exceed an amount that is reasonable and necessary to conduct the review and evaluation. Any contract entered into, as specified, shall be on a noncompetitive bid basis and shall be exempt from Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 10290) of Part 2 of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code. The selling nonprofit corporation, upon request, shall pay the AG promptly for all contract costs.
- Establishes that the AG shall be entitled to reimbursement for all actual and reasonable direct costs incurred in reviewing, evaluating, and making the determination referred to above, including administrative costs. The selling nonprofit corporation shall promptly pay the AG, upon request, for all of those costs.
- In order to effectively monitor ongoing compliance with the terms and conditions of any sale or transfer of assets as specified, including, but not limited to, the ongoing use of the charitable assets in a manner consistent with the trust pursuant to which they are held, the AG may, in their sole discretion, contract with experts and consultants to assist in this regard.
- Contract costs shall not exceed an amount that is reasonable and necessary to conduct the review and evaluation. Any contract entered into under this section shall be on a noncompetitive bid basis and shall be exempt from Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 10290) of Part 2 of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code. The selling nonprofit corporation shall pay the AG promptly for all contract costs; and,
- The AG shall be entitled to reimbursement from either the selling or the acquiring nonprofit corporation, depending upon which one the burden of compliance falls, for all actual, reasonable, and direct costs incurred in monitoring ongoing compliance with the terms and conditions of the sale or transfer of assets, including contract and administrative costs. The AG shall be entitled to this reimbursement for a period of time not to exceed two years after any time period specified in the terms or conditions of sale or transfer of assets. The AG may bill either the selling or the acquiring corporation and the corporation billed by the AG shall promptly pay for all of those costs.
- Authorizes the AG to adopt regulations to implement the bill.
- Authorizes the AG to enforce conditions imposed on its consent to an agreement or transaction, as specified, to the fullest extent provided by law. In addition to any legal remedies the AG may have, the AG shall be entitled to specific performance, injunctive relief, and other equitable remedies a court deems appropriate for breach of any of the conditions and shall be entitled to recover its attorneys fees and costs.
- The conditions imposed on the AG’s consent to an agreement or transaction may include, but are not limited to:
- A transfer of assets from the proceeds of the sale or transfer to the Student Tuition Recovery Fund, established in Section 94923 of the Education Code;
- A requirement that the corporation file a surety bond to provide recovery to students who were enrolled at the private postsecondary educational institution upon subsequent closure of the institution;
- Any conditions deemed by the AG to be necessary to ensure that access to certain educational courses or vocational instruction intended to be promoted by the charitable trust is not substantially and unreasonably impeded.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires any nonprofit corporation that operates or controls a health facility, or operates or controls a facility that provides similar health care, to provide written notice to, and to obtain the written consent of, the AG prior to entering into any agreement or transaction to do either of the following:
- Sell, transfer, lease, exchange, option, convey, or otherwise dispose of, its assets to a for-profit corporation or entity or to a mutual benefit corporation or entity when a material amount of the assets of the nonprofit corporation are involved in the agreement or transaction.
- Transfer control, responsibility, or governance of a material amount of the assets or operations of the nonprofit corporation to any for-profit corporation or entity or to any mutual benefit corporation or entity. (Corporations Code Section 5920 (a).)
- Requires the AG, within 90 days of the receipt of the written notice required by 1), above, to notify the nonprofit corporation in writing of the decision to consent to, give conditional consent to, or not consent to the agreement or transaction, or to extend this period for one additional 45-day period for specified reasons. (Corporations Code Section 5921.)
- Requires the AG, prior to issuing any written decision referred to in Section 5921, to conduct one or more public meetings, one of which shall be in the county in which the facility is located, to hear comments from interested parties. (Corporations Code Section 5922.)
- Provides the AG with discretion to consent to, give conditional consent to, or not consent to any agreement or transaction described in 1), above. In making the determination, the Attorney General shall consider any factors that the Attorney General deems relevant, including, but not limited to, whether any of the following apply:
- The terms and conditions of the agreement or transaction are fair and reasonable to the nonprofit corporation.
- The agreement or transaction will result in inurement to any private person or entity.
- Fair market value of the agreement or transaction, meaning the most likely price that the assets being sold would bring in a competitive and open market under all conditions requisite to a fair sale, the buyer and seller, each acting prudently, knowledgeably, and in their own best interest, and a reasonable time being allowed for exposure in the open market.
- The market value has been manipulated by the actions of the parties in a manner that causes the value of the assets to decrease.
- The proposed use of the proceeds from the agreement or transaction is consistent with the charitable trust on which the assets are held by the health facility or by the affiliated nonprofit health system.
- The agreement or transaction involves or constitutes any breach of trust.
- The Attorney General has been provided, pursuant to Section 5250, with sufficient information and data by the nonprofit public benefit corporation to evaluate adequately the agreement or transaction or the effects thereof on the public.
- The agreement or transaction may create a significant effect on the availability or accessibility of health care services to the affected community.
- The proposed agreement or transaction is in the public interest.
- The agreement or transaction may create a significant effect on the availability and accessibility of cultural interests provided by the facility in the affected community. (Corporations Code Section 5923.)
- Provides the AG with the authority, within the timelines provided in 4), above, to do either of the following and to be reimbursed from the selling nonprofit corporation for all actual, reasonable, direct costs incurred in reviewing, evaluating, and making the determination referred to in Section 5921, including administrative costs:
- Contract with, consult, and receive advice from any state agency on those terms and conditions that the Attorney General deems appropriate.
- In his or her sole discretion, contract with experts or consultants to assist in reviewing the proposed agreement or transaction. (Corporations Code Section 5924.)
- Establishes the California Private Postsecondary Education Act of 2009 (Act) until January 1, 2021, and requires the Bureau of Private Postsecondary Education (BPPE) within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to, among other things, review, investigate and approve private postsecondary institutions, programs and courses of instruction pursuant to the Act and authorizes BPPE to take formal actions against an institution/school to ensure compliance with the Act and to seek closure of an institution if determined by the BPPE to be necessary. (Education Code Section 94800 et seq.)
- Requires unaccredited degree granting institutions to be accredited by an accrediting agency recognized by the U.S. Department of Education by 2020 and provides for specified disclosures and enrollment agreements for students, requirements for cancellations, withdrawals and refunds, and that the BPPE shall administer the STRF to provide refunds to students affected by the possible closure of an institution. (Ibid.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill, which was recently approved by the Assembly Committee on Higher Education by a vote of 10-1 (with one abstention), seeks to provide more state oversight of planned transfers of nonprofit educational institution assets to for-profit entities because of the adverse impact of such transfers on the students who attend these institutions. The bill requires a nonprofit educational institution to obtain the written consent of, the AG before entering into any agreement or transaction to sell, transfer, lease, exchange, option, convey, or otherwise dispose of its assets to a for-profit or mutual benefit corporation. It also seeks to ensure that more notice of planned closures of local educational institutions, and reductions of crucial services provided by those institutions, is provided to the public and the agencies that oversee them.
Background – Sale of Nonprofit Educational Institutions and Impact on California Consumers. When a nonprofit college is sold to a for-profit company in California, there are currently very few protections in place to prevent the sale from reducing a community’s access to quality higher education. This is of particular concern in light of the controversial history of for-profit companies taking over successful nonprofit colleges.
For example, in 2005, Bridgepoint Education, a for-profit higher education company, purchased the Franciscan University of the Prairies – a “brick and mortar” college located in Clinton, Iowa that was founded in 1918 and maintained an enrollment of 500 students. Bridgepoint went on to close the Iowa campus in May of 2016. At the time, 99% percent of the 55,300 students at Bridgepoint-owned Ashford and University of the Rockies were taking classes solely online.
Heald College was founded in 1863 as a nonprofit educational institution headquartered in the Bay Area, growing to establish a series of successful campuses across the state. In 2007, Heald was purchased by a private investor group and eventually was made part of the for-profit college chain: Corinthian Colleges. In 2017, Heald was shut down and the State of California secured a $1.1 billion judgment against Corinthian Colleges, which intentionally targeted low-income, vulnerable Californians through deceptive and false advertisements and aggressive marketing campaigns that misrepresented job placement rates and school programs. The trial court ordered restitution on behalf of students in the amount of $820 million and civil penalties totaling $350 million for a total of over $1.1 billion in monetary relief.
The trial court also found, among other things, that:
- From at least 2009 until the closure of its schools, many of CCI’s representations and advertisements relating to job placement were untrue and/or misleading.
- In numerous cases, the placement rate data in CCI’s files show that the actual placement rate was significantly lower than the advertised rate; and CCI’s published placement rates were systematically false, misleading, erroneous and/or failed to comply with applicable state and federal regulations and/or accreditor standards.
According to the author:
AB 1342 ensures that nonprofit colleges are treated with similar community value as health facilities by providing for the same review by the Attorney General when a nonprofit school is sold and turned into a for-profit institution. The Attorney General’s approval would be required for any proposed sale, and conditions could be placed on that approval to ensure that the community’s interests are not jeopardized by the sale.
Higher education is a cornerstone of the American Dream — but some corporations have exploited that dream in search of making a profit at the expense of students. [AB 1342] will ensure our educational institutions remain a reflection of our community values.
Adapting the process used for AG review of public hospital closures and transfers of assets to non-profit educational institutions. Current law requires the AG to review the planned transfer of a nonprofit hospital’s charitable assets to either a for-profit corporation, or another nonprofit corporation (Corporations Code Sections 5914 and 5920), in order to ensure that those assets are used for their intended public use. The AG has 90 days from the time the hospital provides notice of its intent to sell to issue a decision, although the AG may utilize a 45-day extension under certain circumstances. During this approval process, the AG must hold at least one public hearing in the county where the facility is located to hear comments from interested parties. The AG may consent to, give conditional consent to, or deny consent to the proposed sale, transaction, or agreement. In evaluating whether or not to consent to the transaction, the AG may look to any factors it deems relevant, including the fair market value of the hospital, whether the transaction would affect the availability of healthcare services to the community, or whether the transaction is otherwise in the public interest.
Existing law also requires a nonprofit hospital to notify both the Department of Public Health and the county health department of a planned transfer of public assets, but does not empower either the department, or the county health department, to do anything to stop the transfer after being notified. Rather, existing law seems to have the goal of ensuring that those who will likely be most affected by the planned closure or reduction--the public, the department, and the county—are aware of the plans.
This bill is clearly modeled on the process for review of public hospital asset transfers that is described above, requiring 1) the AG to review and consent to, give conditional consent to, or deny consent to the proposed sale within 90 days (but allowing for an extension of time under specified circumstances); 2) at least one public hearing convened by the AG regarding the planned sale; 3) notification to the state regulator (the BPPE); and 4) the decision of the AG to be based upon specified factors, including whether the terms and conditions of the agreement or transaction are fair and reasonable to the nonprofit corporation. (In fact, the factors for the AG to consider in deciding whether to consent to, give conditional consent to, or deny consent to the proposed sale of a nonprofit educational institution specified in this bill appear to be virtually identical to those specified in existing law for the AG to consider in the decision relating to public non-profit hospitals.) Like existing law, the bill would not give authority to the public or the regulator to stop a sale or transfer of assets, but this will would help ensure that those who will likely be most affected by the planned closure or reduction are at least aware of it.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The California Conference of the American Association of University Professors supports the bill, along with the other bills that are part of the for-profit and non-profit educational institution reform package (see below – related pending legislation) because, in their opinion, “The unregulated for profit college industry has proven to have disastrous effects on the financial future of its students, provides access to only the lowest quality education, and further destabilizes academic freedom and economic security within the higher education sector.”
Likewise, the large coalition of consumer groups, public interest law firms, and labor organizations that support the bill believe that it will appropriately create a mechanism of oversight—something the Attorney General has experience doing in the context of proposed public hospital closures—that is sorely needed over non-profit educational institutions:
There are currently very few limitations on the sale of a nonprofit college to a for-profit company in California, and too few protections to prevent the sale from reducing students’ access to quality higher education. This is of particular concern given California’s troubled history with for-profit companies taking over successful nonprofit institutions.
. . . AB 1342 ensures that nonprofit colleges are treated with similar consideration as health facilities, by providing for the same review by the Attorney General when a nonprofit school is sold and turned into a for-profit institution. The Attorney General’s approval would be required for any proposed sale, and conditions could be placed on that approval to ensure that the community’s interests are not jeopardized by the sale. In this way, the community value of the school can be preserved, regardless of the institution’s owner.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In its letter of opposition sent to the Assembly Committee on Higher Education (but not this Committee), Ashford University wrote that the measure “overlooks the extensive review process that institutions must currently pursue in order to convert from a for-profit to a non-profit institution,” including approval by both the accrediting institution and the U.S. Department of Education and the Internal Revenue Service” including a “thorough review of academic programs offered and the operation of the institution to ensure that the institution is governed by [a] board of trustees that is independent from outside influences and free from conflict of interest.” Furthermore, Ashford argues that a conversion of a non-profit to a for-profit educational institution is “consistent with your student focused policy goals. A converted nonprofit would be permitted to participate in research grant from foundations and to accept charitable contributions, both of which work to enhance student learning and experiences.” In addition, Ashford questions whether outside consultants, who could be hired via no-bid contracts by the AG to complete the review of a proposed conversion, “inviting critics to conduct and produce biased evaluation that serve neither students nor the public good.”
Pending related legislation. AB 1340 (Chiu) would establish a gainful employment rule in California similar to an Obama-era regulation recently rolled back by Education Secretary Betsy DeVos. Gainful employment rules test the value of an institution’s program by looking at the ratio of student debt to the salaries of graduates. Any school that has too high a ratio of debt to earnings would lose access to federal financial aid if rates do not improve. If AB 1340 is signed into law, California would become the first state to enact a gainful employment test.
AB 1341 (Berman) would ensure that for-profit schools do not evade oversight by posing as nonprofit or public institutions. Currently, for-profit colleges are able to use shell corporations and a variety of complicated financial schemes to masquerade as nonprofits.
AB 1343 (Eggman) would mandate that no more than 80 percent of a for profit educational institution’s revenue may come from taxpayer-funded aid like Pell grants and would close a loophole in federal financial aid laws that omits federal or state funds payable to veterans, such as GI benefits, from the calculation.
AB 1344 (Bauer-Kahan) would require out-of-state institutions enrolling California students in online courses to comply with all California consumer protection laws that apply to California educational institutions.
AB 1345 (McCarty) would prohibit colleges from requiring quotas in recruiting or paying admissions representatives commission.
AB 1346 (Medina) would allow students who have been victimized by for-profit institutions that have closed to recoup costs in addition to tuition.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Conference of the American Association of University Professors
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
Center for Public Interest Law
Children’s Advocacy Institute
Consumer Federation of California
Consumer Reports Advocacy
Housing & Economic Right Advocates
Public Advocates, Inc.
Public Counsel
Public Law Center
SEIU California
The Century Foundation
The Institute For College Access And Success
Veterans Education Success
Veterans Legal Clinic
Opposition
Ashford University
Analysis Prepared by: Alison Merrilees / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: April 9, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HIGHER EDUCATION
Jose Medina, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1342 (
Author:Low) – As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
[Note: This bill is doubled referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee and will be heard by that Committee as it relates to issues under its jurisdiction.]
SUBJECT: Nonprofit corporations: private postsecondary educational institutions: sale of assets: Attorney General approval
SUMMARY: Requires a nonprofit corporation that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution to obtain the Attorney General’s (AG) consent before entering into certain agreements or transactions, including an agreement or transaction to sell or convey its assets to, or to transfer control, responsibility, or governance of a material amount of its assets to, a for-profit corporation or mutual benefit corporation. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires any nonprofit corporation, as specified, that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution, as specified, to provide written notice to, and to obtain the written consent of, the AG before entering into any agreement or transaction to do either of the following:
- Sell, transfer, lease, exchange, option, convey, or otherwise dispose of its assets to a for-profit corporation or entity or to a mutual benefit corporation or entity when a material amount of the assets of the nonprofit corporation are involved in the agreement or transaction; and,
- Transfer control, responsibility, or governance of a material amount of the assets or operations of the nonprofit corporation to any for-profit corporation or entity or to any mutual benefit corporation or entity.
- Specifies that the substitution of a new corporate member or members that transfers the control of, responsibility for, or governance of the nonprofit corporation shall be deemed a transfer for purposes of the article established in this legislation. The substitution of one or more members of the governing body, or any arrangement, written or oral, that would transfer voting control of the members of the governing body, shall also be deemed a transfer for purposes of this article.
- Requires that the notice provided to the AG contain the information the AG determines is required. The notice, including any other information provided to the AG, as specified, and that is in the public file, shall be made available by the AG to the public in written form as soon as is practicable after it is received by the AG.
- Requires that the notice provided to the AG be provided to the Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education (BPPE).
- Specifies that the above shall not apply to a nonprofit corporation if the agreement or transaction is in the usual and regular course of its activities or if the AG has given the corporation a written waiver of this section as to the proposed agreement or transaction.
- Specifies that the above shall apply to any foreign nonprofit corporation that operates or controls a private postsecondary educational institution or an institution that provides similar educational services, regardless of whether it is currently operating or providing educational services.
- Specifies that, within 90 days of the receipt of the written notice required by Section 5940, the AG shall notify the public benefit corporation in writing of the decision to consent to, give conditional consent to, or not consent to the agreement or transaction. The AG may extend this period for one additional 45-day period if any of the following conditions are satisfied:
- The extension is necessary to obtain information, as specified;
- The proposed agreement or transaction is substantially modified after the first public meeting conducted by the AG, as specified; and,
- The proposed agreement or transaction involves a private postsecondary educational institution with a multifacility system of campuses serving multiple communities, rather than a single campus.
- Requires that, before issuing any written decision, or giving a written wavier, the AG shall conduct one or more public meetings, one of which shall be in the county in which the private postsecondary educational institution is located, to hear comments from interested parties. At least 14 days before conducting the public meeting, the AG shall provide written notice of the time and place of the meeting through publication in one or more newspapers of general circulation in the affected community and to the board of supervisors of the county in which the private postsecondary educational institution is located. If a substantive change in the proposed agreement or transaction is submitted to the AG after the initial public meeting, the AG may conduct an additional public meeting to hear comments from interested parties with respect to that change.
- Specifies that the AG shall have discretion to consent to, give conditional consent to, or not consent to any agreement or transaction, as specified. In making the determination, the AG shall consider any factors that the AG deems relevant, including, but not limited to, whether any of the following factors apply:
- The terms and conditions of the agreement or transaction are fair and reasonable to the nonprofit corporation;
- The agreement or transaction will result in inurement to any private person or entity;
- Any agreement or transaction that is subject to this article is at fair market value. In this regard, “fair market value” means the most likely price that the assets being sold would bring in a competitive and open market under all conditions requisite to a fair sale, the buyer and seller each acting prudently, knowledgeably, and in their own best interest, and a reasonable time being allowed for exposure in the open market;
- The market value has been manipulated by the actions of the parties in a manner that causes the value of the assets to decrease;
- The proposed use of the proceeds from the agreement or transaction is consistent with the charitable trust on which the assets are held by the educational institution;
- The agreement or transaction involves or constitutes any breach of trust;
- The AG has been provided with sufficient information and data by the nonprofit corporation to evaluate adequately the agreement or transaction or the effects thereof on the public;
- The agreement or transaction may create a significant effect on the availability or accessibility of educational services to the affected community; and,
- The proposed agreement or transaction is in the public interest.
- Specifies that the AG may do the following, as specified:
- Contract with, consult, and receive advice from any state agency on those terms and conditions that the AG deems appropriate, including the BPPE; and
- In the AG’s discretion, contract with experts or consultants to assist in reviewing the proposed agreement or transaction;
- Requires that contract costs pursuant to “10” above shall not exceed an amount that is reasonable and necessary to conduct the review and evaluation. Any contract entered into, as specified, shall be on a noncompetitive bid basis and shall be exempt from Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 10290) of Part 2 of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code. The selling nonprofit corporation, upon request, shall pay the AG promptly for all contract costs.
- Establishes that the AG shall be entitled to reimbursement for all actual and reasonable direct costs incurred in reviewing, evaluating, and making the determination referred to above, including administrative costs. The selling nonprofit corporation shall promptly pay the AG, upon request, for all of those costs.
- In order to effectively monitor ongoing compliance with the terms and conditions of any sale or transfer of assets as specified, including, but not limited to, the ongoing use of the charitable assets in a manner consistent with the trust pursuant to which they are held, the AG may, in their sole discretion, contract with experts and consultants to assist in this regard.
- Contract costs shall not exceed an amount that is reasonable and necessary to conduct the review and evaluation. Any contract entered into under this section shall be on a noncompetitive bid basis and shall be exempt from Chapter 2 (commencing with Section 10290) of Part 2 of Division 2 of the Public Contract Code. The selling nonprofit corporation shall pay the AG promptly for all contract costs; and,
- The AG shall be entitled to reimbursement from either the selling or the acquiring nonprofit corporation, depending upon which one the burden of compliance falls, for all actual, reasonable, and direct costs incurred in monitoring ongoing compliance with the terms and conditions of the sale or transfer of assets, including contract and administrative costs. The AG shall be entitled to this reimbursement for a period of time not to exceed two years after any time period specified in the terms or conditions of sale or transfer of assets. The AG may bill either the selling or the acquiring corporation and the corporation billed by the AG shall promptly pay for all of those costs.
- Authorizes the AG to adopt regulations to implement the article created in AB 1342.
- Authorizes the AG to enforce conditions imposed on the AG’s consent to an agreement or transaction, as specified, to the fullest extent provided by law. In addition to any legal remedies the AG may have, the AG shall be entitled to specific performance, injunctive relief, and other equitable remedies a court deems appropriate for breach of any of the conditions and shall be entitled to recover its attorney’s fees and costs incurred in remedying each violation.
- The conditions imposed on the AG’s consent to an agreement or transaction may include, but are not limited to:
- A transfer of assets from the proceeds of the sale or transfer to the Student Tuition Recovery Fund, established in Section 94923 of the Education Code;
- A requirement that the corporation file a surety bond to provide recovery to students who were enrolled at the private postsecondary educational institution upon subsequent closure of the institution;
- Any conditions deemed by the AG to be necessary to ensure that access to certain educational courses or vocational instruction intended to be promoted by the charitable trust is not substantially and unreasonably impeded.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires a nonprofit corporation, as defined, that operates or controls a health facility, as defined, or operates or controls a facility that provides similar health care to provide written notice to, and obtain the written consent of, the AG prior to selling or otherwise disposing of a material amount of its assets to a for-profit corporation or entity, to a mutual benefit corporation or entity, or to another nonprofit corporation or entity. Existing law also provides that the AG has discretion to give consent to, give conditional consent to, or to not consent to, the agreement or transaction and requires the AG to consider any factors deemed relevant, including, but not limited to, whether the terms are fair and reasonable. (CORP Section 5914, et. seq.)
- Establishes the California Private Postsecondary Education Act of 2009 (Act) until January 1, 2021, and requires BPPE, within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to, in part, review, investigate and approve private postsecondary institutions (or institutions), programs and courses of instruction pursuant to the Act and authorizes BPPE to take formal actions against an institution/school to ensure compliance with the Act and even seek closure of an institution/school if determined necessary. The Act requires unaccredited degree granting institutions to be accredited by an accrediting agency recognized by the USDE by 2020. The Act also provides for specified disclosures and enrollment agreements for students, requirements for cancellations, withdrawals and refunds, and that the BPPE shall administer the STRF to provide refunds to students affected by the possible closure of an institution/school. (Education Code (EDC) Section 94800 et. seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS: Need for the bill. According to the author, “When a nonprofit college is sold to a for-profit company in California, there are currently very few protections in place to prevent the sale from reducing a community’s access to quality higher education. This is of particular concern given the controversial history of for-profit companies taking over successful nonprofit colleges.”
“AB 1342 ensures that nonprofit colleges are treated with similar community value as health facilities by providing for the same review by the AG when a nonprofit school is sold and turned into a for-profit institution. The AG’s approval would be required for any proposed sale, and conditions could be placed on that approval to ensure that the community’s interests are not jeopardized by the sale.”
Background. There are several examples of for-profit companies purchasing nonprofit colleges. In 2005, Bridgepoint Education, a for-profit higher education company, purchased the Franciscan University of the Prairies – a “brick and mortar” college located in Clinton, Iowa.
Franciscan University of the Prairies, which was founded in 1918 and had previously been known as Mount St. Clare College, maintained an enrollment of 500 students and was sponsored by the Roman Catholic Sisters of St. Francis. Renamed as Ashford University, Bridgepoint was able to utilize the existing accreditation from the North Central Association of Colleges and Schools. Bridgepoint noted to Inside Higher Ed in 2005 that they had “been seeking a university that we could acquire,” and noted that Bridgepoint was "committed absolutely" to staying in Clinton, Iowa.
Bridgepoint went on to close the Iowa campus in May of 2016. At the time, 99% percent of the 55,300 students at Bridgepoint-owned Ashford and University of the Rockies were taking classes solely online.
Heald College was originally founded in 1863 as a nonprofit headquartered in the Bay Area, growing to establish a series of successful campuses across the state. In 2007, Heald was bought by a private investor group and eventually made part of the for-profit college chain Corinthian Colleges, Inc (CCI).
On April 27, 2015, Heald shut down, along with CCI institutions like Everest College and WyoTech. In 2016 the AG secured a default judgment against CCI. In the judgment, the Court ordered restitution on behalf of students in the amount of $820 million and civil penalties totaling $350 million for a total of over $1.1 billion in monetary relief.
The final court judgement found that:
- From at least 2009 until the closure of its schools, many of CCI’s representations and advertisements relating to job placement were untrue and/or misleading. In numerous cases, the placement rate data in CCI’s files show that the actual placement rate was lower than the advertised rate. The placement rates that CCI published were systematically false, misleading, erroneous and/or failed to comply with applicable state and federal regulations and/or accreditor standards. In addition, many of these published placement rates could not be substantiated using CCI’s own internal placement data and files.
- CCI did not offer ultrasound technician programs, x-ray technician programs, radiology technician programs, or dialysis technician programs in California. Despite this fact, from at least 2010 until the filing of this action, CCI ran millions of ads stating that they did offer those programs. CCI executives knew that these false ads misled students.
- CCI unlawfully used the official seals of the US Army, the US Navy, the US Air Force, the US Marine Corps, and the US Coast Guard, respectively.
- CCI’s enrollment agreements contained unlawful clauses.
- CCI engaged in unlawful debt collection.
- CCI failed to discloses its role in the Genesis Private Student Loan Program.
- CCI misrepresented the transferability of credits.
- CCI misrepresented its financial stability to students.
Committee comments. The policy proposed AB 1342 closely parallels an existing process required for the sale of nonprofit hospitals to for-profit corporations. Such nonprofit to for-profit transactions accounted for 1330 hours of staff time in the AG’s office in 2013.
Arguments in support. A coalition of student, veteran, civil rights, and higher education advocates jointly wrote that, “There are currently very few limitations on the sale of a nonprofit college to a for-profit company in California, and too few protections to prevent the sale from reducing students’ access to quality higher education. This is of particular concern given California’s troubled history with for-profit companies taking over successful nonprofit institutions.”
“AB 1342 ensures that nonprofit colleges are treated with similar consideration as health facilities, by providing for the same review by the AG when a nonprofit school is sold and turned into a for-profit institution. The AG’s approval would be required for any proposed sale, and conditions could be placed on that approval to ensure that the community’s interests are not jeopardized by the sale. In this way, the community value of the school can be preserved, regardless of the institution’s owner.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Conference of the American Association of University Professors
California Low-Income Consumer Coalition
Center For Public Interest Law
Children's Advocacy Institute
Consumer Federation of California
Consumer Reports Advocacy
Housing and Economic Rights Advocates
Public Advocates, Inc.
Public Counsel
Public Law Center
SEIU California
The Century Foundation
The Institute for College Access and Success
Veterans Education Success
Veterans Legal Clinic
Opposition
Ashford University
Analysis Prepared by: Kevin J. Powers / HIGHER ED. / (916) 319-3960
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):