AB 1753: Immigration consultants.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-04-25
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Aug 30, 2019 | In committee: Held under submission. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (July 9). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 12, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 30, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 29, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 13. Noes 4.) (May 16). |
| May 8, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 3.) (April 23). |
| Apr 22, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 26, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 12, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 9, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| May 29, 2019 | AB 1753 Carrillo Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1753 (Carrillo) - Immigration consultants
Version: April 25, 2019 | Policy Vote: JUD. 5 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 12, 2019 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
Bill Summary:
AB 1753 would reform who, for compensation, may engage in the business or act in the capacity of an immigration consultant.
Fiscal Impact:
- State Prison: Unknown, potential increase in state costs for new commitments to state prison that otherwise would not have resulted in criminal conduct absent this measure. The 2019-20 fiscal year per capita cost to detain a person in a state prison is $84,848 annually, with an annual marginal rate per inmate of over $12,000. The contract bed rate averages to about $29,000 annually. The actual costs would depend on how many defendants are sentenced to prison. (General Fund)
- Courts: Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate civil complaints and criminal charges brought against defendants who engage in the business of being an immigration consultant unlawfully. While the courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fee, fine, and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
- Secretary of State (SOS): The office reports first-year costs of about $40,000 with ongoing costs of under $1,000 annually thereafter. One-time costs would be related to developing a webpage; updating bond and disclosure forms, website information, and procedures; providing notices to active immigration consultants; and issuing cease-and-desist notices and orders. Ongoing costs would be related to paper, printing, and storage costs. (General Fund, fees)
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Background:
Current law provides that a person, for compensation, engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of an immigration consultant may offer only non-legal assistance or advice in an immigration matter. Current law establishes that a person engages in the business or acts in the capacity of an immigration consultant when that person gives non-legal assistance or advice on an immigration matter. Assistance or advice includes, but is not limited to, the following:
- completing a form provided by a federal or state agency but not advising a person as to their answers on those forms;
- translating a person’s answers to questions posed in those forms;
- securing for a person supporting documents, such as birth certificates, which may be necessary to complete those forms; and,
- submitting completed forms on a person’s behalf and at their request to the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services.
Current law defines immigration matter as any proceeding, filing, or action affecting the immigration or citizenship status of any person that arises under immigration and naturalization law, executive order or presidential proclamation, or action of the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services, the U.S. Department of State, or the U.S. Department of Labor.
In order to become an immigration consultant in California, a person must satisfactorily pass a background check and submit the following to the SOS: a copy of a current surety bond in the amount of $100,000 obtained from a corporate surety admitted to do business in California, a completed immigration consultant disclosure form, a copy of a valid and current photo identification, a passport photo, and a filing fee.
It is unlawful to engage in the business or act in the capacity of an immigration consultant outside of these criteria. A violation is subject to a civil penalty of up to $100,000 per violation and punishable as a misdemeanor with up to one year of imprisonment in jail, a base fine of between $2,000 and $10,000, or both the imprisonment and fine. Subsequent violations of certain provisions are punishable as a felony with imprisonment in state prison for sixteen months, two years, or three years.
Proposed Law:
This bill would change who may be an immigration consultant in California. Specifically, it would:
- Make it unlawful, starting January 1, 2021, for a person, for compensation, other than a person authorized to practice law in this state, a person authorized to represent others under federal law in an immigration matter, or a supervised paralegal, as specified, to provide advice or services related to any immigration matter or to hold themselves out as an immigration consultant or as a person authorized to provide advice in immigration matters.
- Make it unlawful, starting January 1, 2021, for any person or entity, other than those who are authorized, to advertise immigration services using the term “immigration consultant,” “immigration specialist,” “notary public,” “notary,” “licensed,” “attorney,” or “lawyer,” or to literally translate any of those terms for any advertising purposes.
- Require the SOS, by January 1, 2020, to notify any individual or entity registered as an immigration consultant on or after January 1, 2018, and that is listed on a specified website, of the prohibition on providing, or holding oneself out as a person who is authorized to provide, advice or services related to any immigration matter, and of the operative date of that prohibition.
- Expand the definition of immigration matter to include proceedings, filings, and actions arising under action of the U.S. Department of Justice, the U.S. Department of Homeland Security, and the Board of Immigration Appeals.
- Require the SOS, starting January 1, 2021 and in coordination with specified state agencies, to develop a website that would include specified information related to immigration services available in California. It should include information related to persons recognized or accredited as authorized providers of immigration services by the U.S. Department of Justice.
- Remove notaries public, starting January 1, 2021, from provisions relating to filing an application under the federal program referred to as the deferred action program.
Related Legislation:
AB 638 (Caballero, 2018) would have reformed who, for compensation, may engage in the business or act in the capacity of an immigration consultant. AB 638 failed passage on the Senate floor.
Staff Comments:
The fiscal impact of this bill cannot be known with certainty, as the actual impact will be dependent on numerous factors, including, but not limited to, judicial and prosecutorial discretion, the criminal history of the a person charged with violating the immigration consultant requirements, and the factors unique to each case. A violation of the immigration consultant provisions is a misdemeanor; multiple violations are a state prison felony. To the extent even one additional defendant is committed to state prison as a result of this bill, state incarceration costs would surpass the Suspense File threshold. Additionally, as the crimes created by this bill are punishable with the potential for incarceration, certain rights to the defendants are attached to the proceedings, including the right to a jury trial and the right to counsel (at public expense if the defendants are unable to afford the costs of representation) which could lead to lengthier court proceedings. Consequently, to the extent that the court adjudicates a dozen or more of these new crimes as misdemeanors (or three as felony cases), on average, that otherwise would not have been filed or resulted in a criminal action but for the alleged violation of the new restrictions added by this bill, the cost pressures to the court would surpass the Suspense File threshold.
California is subject to a federal court order to sustainably reduce its in-state adult institution population to 137.5 percent of design capacity. The state has undertaken efforts to implement a durable remedy to reduce and avoid prison overcrowding. On July 31, 2019, 114,921 inmates were detained in the state’s 36 adult institutions, 2,826 in camps, and 6,181 were held in in-state contract beds. The prison population changes daily as new inmates are admitted and others are released, but, on that date, the population at the state’s adult institutions was approximately 135.1 percent of design capacity. By potentially increasing the inmate population in state facilities, this bill could make it more difficult for the state to comply with the court order.
Subdivision (c) of section 22441 would provide that it is a violation for non-authorized persons to engage in the conduct described in subdivision (a) of that section. Subdivision (a) provides an explicit list of permissible conduct but states that the assistance or advice “is not limited to” those activities. The open-endedness of permissible conduct could lead to difficulty in determining what conduct not explicitly listed is within or outside the scope of an immigration consultant. This ambiguity could lead to an increase of prosecutions (and could raise issues of vagueness), resulting in the use of additional resources and time by the court and other state and non-state entities.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1753 (Author:Carrillo)
Version: April 25, 2019
Hearing Date: July 9, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: MEC
SUBJECT
Immigration consultants
DIGEST
This bill, on and after January 1, 2021, makes it unlawful for a person, for compensation, other than a person authorized to practice law in this state, a person authorized to represent others under federal law in an immigration matter, or a supervised paralegal, as specified, to provide advice or services related to any immigration matter or to hold themself out as an immigration consultant or as a person authorized to provide advice in immigration matters. This bill brings California law in line with longstanding federal law designed to protect consumers in their immigration matters.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Stakes are higher than ever for California’s 2.5-3 million undocumented immigrants as the President of the United States recently threatened to round up immigrants and immigrants are currently being held in deplorable conditions. Immigrants in California have been grappling with a heightened fear of adverse immigration actions since the election of President Donald Trump and his various inhumane policies against immigrants, including separating children from their parents and imprisoning children in cages. During his campaign for President, and ahead of his inauguration, Trump promised to deport millions of immigrants.
When an immigrant is deported due to an error by an immigration consultant, the immigrant is not meaningfully able to seek justice because the consequence of the error is removal of the immigrant from this country. Federal regulations make it clear that only five classes of people may fill out immigration forms for more than a nominal fee.[1] However, an entire industry, that charges more than a nominal fee to fill out immigration forms, currently exists in California because of statutes on the books that seemingly permit that which federal regulations do not allow. This bill aligns state law with federal regulations by making it unlawful in California for a person, other than a licensed attorney or a person or organization federally authorized to represent individuals in immigration matters, or a paralegal, as specified, to provide immigration-related services for a fee.
This bill is sponsored by the Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office, Los Angeles County, California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation, Central American Resource Center, and Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights Los Angeles. The bill is also supported by the Office of the California Attorney General and other immigrant and civil rights organizations. The bill is opposed by numerous immigrant consultants, clients of immigration consultants, and the National Notary Association.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Prohibits the federal government from returning to their home countries people whose life or freedom would be threatened because of the alien’s race, religion, nationality, membership in a particular social group, or political opinion. (8 U.S.C. § 1231(b)(3).)
- Provides for the protection of people who have fled persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group. (UN General Assembly, Universal Declaration of Human Rights, Dec. 10, 1948, 217A(III), Art. 14.)
- Protects all asylum seekers by prohibiting the federal government from returning to their home countries people who have fled persecution on account of race, religion, nationality, political opinion, or membership in a particular social group. (8 U.S.C. §1101(a)(42)(A).)
- Provides that youth may have temporary protection from deportation and work authorization for two-year periods, as specified. (See Janet Napolitano, June 15, 2012 policy memorandum announcing the DACA program, <https://www.dhs.gov/xlibrary/assets/s1-exercising-prosecutorial-discretion-individuals-who-came-to-us-as-children.pdf> [as of Dec. 1, 2016].)
- Provides that victims of certain crimes may obtain immigration relief through a Victim of Crime Visa (U-Visa) and victims of human trafficking may obtain immigration relief through a Victim of Trafficking Visa (T-Visa). (8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(15)(U); 8 U.S.C. § 1101(a)(15)(T).)
- Provides immigration relief that relies on a state’s interest in the welfare of children by providing for Special Immigrant Juvenile Status where a state determines that reunification with one or both of the immigrant’s parents is not viable due to abuse, neglect, abandonment, or similar basis found under state law and that it would not be in the child’s best interest to return to their home country. (8 U.S.C. § 1101 (a)(27)(J).)
- Provides that no person shall practice law in California unless the person is an active member of the State Bar. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6125.)
- Provides that anyone engaged in the unauthorized practice of law is guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by up to one year in a county jail or by a fine of up to $1,000, or by both. Existing law provides for increased penalties for second or subsequent convictions. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6126.)
- Provides that it is unlawful for any person, for compensation, other than persons authorized to practice law or authorized by federal law, to represent persons before the Board of Immigration Appeals or the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS), to engage in the business or act in the capacity of an immigration consultant within this state except as provided under the Immigration Consultants Chapter. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22440.)
- Establishes that a person engages in the business or acts in the capacity of an immigration consultant when that person gives nonlegal assistance or advice on an immigration matter. Assistance or advice includes, but is not limited to, the following:
- completing a form provided by a federal or state agency, but not advising a person as to their answers on those forms;
- translating a person’s answers to questions posed in those forms;
- securing for a person supporting documents, such as birth certificates, which may be necessary to complete those forms; and
- submitting completed forms on a person’s behalf and at their request to the USCIS. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 22441(a).)
- Defines “immigration matter” as any proceeding, filing, or action affecting the immigration or citizenship status of any person which arises under immigration and naturalization law, executive order or presidential proclamation, or action of the USCIS, the United States Department of State, or the United States Department of Labor. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22441(b).)
- Provides that a person engaged in the business or acting in the capacity of an immigration consultant shall only offer nonlegal assistance or advice in an immigration matter. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22441(d).)
- Provides that a person must pass a background check by the Secretary of State, as specified, to engage in the business or act in the capacity of an immigration consultant. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22441.1(a).)
- Provides that every person engaged in the business, or acting in the capacity of an immigration consultant who enters into a contract or agreement with a client to provide services shall, prior to providing any services, provide the client with a written contract, as specified. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22442(a).)
- Specifies that an immigration consultant’s written contract must include the following:
- an itemization and explanation of the purpose and process of each service to be performed;
- the cost of each itemized service to be performed;
- a 10-point boldface type statement that the immigration consultant is not an attorney and may not perform the legal services that an attorney performs;
- a list of documents to be prepared with the purpose, process, and cost for preparing each document;
- a statement of the purpose for which the immigration consultant has been hired and the actions to be taken by the immigration consultant regarding each document, including the agency and office where they will be filed and the approximate processing times according to current published agency guidelines;
- information regarding where the client may report complaints related to immigration consultants and the unauthorized practice of law (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22442(b).); and
- a statement that the client shall have the right to rescind the contract within 72 hours of signing the contract. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22442(f).)
- Prohibits an immigration consultant from making the following statements to a client orally or including the following provisions in the written contract: any guarantee or promise, unless the immigration consultant has some basis in fact for making the guarantee or promise; or any statement that the immigration consultant can or will obtain special favors from or has special influence with the USCIS, or any other governmental agency, employee, or official, that may have a bearing on a client’s immigration matter. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22442(c).)
- Provides that the written contract must be in English and the client’s native language, and is void if not in both languages. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22442(d) & (e).)
- Provides that the contract requirements do not apply to employees of nonprofit, tax-exempt corporations who help clients complete application forms in an immigration matter free of charge or for a nominal fee, as specified. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22442(h).)
- Provides that immigration consultants shall provide receipts and statements of accounting, as specified. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22442.1 (a) & (b).)
- Provides that an immigration consultant shall conspicuously display in their office a notice that shall be at least 12 by 20 inches with boldface type or print, as specified, in English and in the native language of the immigration consultant’s clientele, that contains specified information, including a statement that the immigration consultant is not an attorney, evidence of compliance with any applicable bonding requirement, the particular services provided, and the current and total fee for each service. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22442.2(a).)
- Establishes certain requirements on immigration consultants when they advertise services, including that they are not an attorney, as specified. Attorneys licensed in other states shall include in any advertisement for immigration services a clear and conspicuous statement that they are not a California licensed attorney but are licensed in another state or territory of the United States and are authorized by federal law to represent persons before the USCIS or Board of Immigration Appeals. If the advertisement is in a language other than English, the required statements must also be in the other language. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22442.2(c).)
- Requires a person seeking to engage in the business or act in the capacity of an immigration consultant in this state to file a bond for $100,000, and other related forms, with the Secretary of State. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22443.1(a), (c), (f), (g) & (h).)
- Requires the Secretary of State to conduct a background check of any person who files a bond of that nature, and requires the Secretary of State to post on its website information on any person who has complied with the requirement to file a bond and passed the requisite background check. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22441.1 & 22443.1(e).)
- Specifies, through regulations that the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has adopted, who can provide representation before the USCIS. (8 C.F.R. §§ 1.1, 1.2, 292.1.) Under these regulations, “representation” is defined as including both “practice” and “preparation.” (8 C.F.R. § 1.2). “Practice” means “appearing in any case, either in person or through the preparation or filing of any brief or other document, paper, application, or petition on behalf of another person or client before or with DHS.” (8 C.F.R. § 1.2)
- “Preparation” means “the study of the facts of a case and the applicable laws, coupled with the giving of advice and auxiliary activities, including the incidental preparation of papers…” (8 C.F.R. § 1.2) Preparation does not include “service consisting solely of assistance in the completion of blank spaces on printed DHS forms, by one whose remuneration, if any, is nominal and who does not hold themself out as qualified in legal matters or in immigration and naturalization procedure.” (8 C.F.R. § 1.2)
- “Case” means “any proceeding arising under any immigration or naturalization law, Executive Order, or Presidential proclamation, or preparation for or incident to such proceeding, including preliminary steps by any private person or corporation preliminary to the filing of the application or petition by which any proceeding under the jurisdiction of the Service or the Board is initiated. (8 C.F.R. § 1.2)
- Provides that representation does not include solely assisting by completing blank spaces on DHS forms as long as the assistance is only for a nominal fee; and by one who does not hold themselves out to be qualified in legal matters or in the immigration and naturalization procedure. (8 C.F.R. § 1.2.)
- The following five classes of people are authorized to provide “representation” as federally authorized persons:
- attorneys in good standing;
- accredited representatives, who have been authorized by the EOIR;
- unpaid law students supervised by an attorney;
- reputable individuals, who are of good moral character, provided they have a preexisting relationship with the client and do not receive compensation; and
- accredited officials of the client’s foreign government. (8 C.F.R. §§ 1.2 & 292.1.)
This bill:
- On and after January 1, 2021, makes it unlawful for a person, for compensation, other than a person authorized to practice law in this state, a person authorized to represent others under federal law in an immigration matter, or a supervised paralegal, as specified, to provide advice or services related to any immigration matter or to hold themself out as an immigration consultant or as a person authorized to provide advice in immigration matters.
- Requires the Secretary of State, on or before January 1, 2020, to notify any individual or entity registered as an immigration consultant on or after January 1, 2018, and that is listed on a specified website, of the prohibition on providing, or holding oneself out as a person who is authorized to provide, advice or services related to any immigration matter, and of the operative date of that prohibition.
- Expands the definition of immigration matter to include proceedings, filings, and actions arising under action of the U.S. DOJ, DHS, and the Board of Immigration Appeals.
- Requires the Secretary of State beginning January 1, 2021, in coordination with specified state agencies, to develop a website that would include specified information related to immigration services available in California, including information related to persons recognized or accredited as authorized providers of immigration services by the U.S. DOJ.
- Removes notaries public from provisions relating to filing an application under the federal program referred to as the deferred action program, beginning January 1, 2021.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
According to the author:
Due to the complexity of immigration laws, a person seeking help on an immigration matter should consult only with an individual who is trained and educated in this legal field. AB 1753 will ensure that immigration services are limited to licensed attorneys, paralegals and federally-accredited representatives who are authorized to provide legal advice and represent clients before the U.S. Department of Justice and/or the U.S. Department of Homeland Security in their immigration matters. Four other states and Washington D.C. have passed similar legislation in recent years to ensure immigrant consumers receive the best legal representation and it is time that California does the same.
According to the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s Office, a sponsor of this bill:
Current anti-immigration Federal policy agenda has caused increased numbers of undocumented immigrants to seek options to legalize their immigration status, and many unscrupulous individuals prey on this vulnerability and defraud immigrants and their families by falsely promising pathways to immigration benefits in exchange for costly fees. Non-attorneys or individuals unauthorized to represent people in immigration matters often charge thousands of dollars to unsuspecting undocumented immigrants and their families for immigration promises they fail to keep. [ . . . ] Immigrants often end up in deportation proceedings due to the action of individuals who were supposed to have helped them. To compound this issue further, in June 2018, federal policy was modified that puts immigrants at greater risk of deportation by allowing officials to start the deportation process for denied immigration petitions and to refer cases to the Immigration and Customs enforcement (ICE) on criminal or security grounds.
2. Immigration consultants
As explained by California Attorney General Xavier Becerra, a sponsor of this measure:
In 1986, the California Legislature passed the Immigration Consultant Act (the Act) authorizing and regulating services provided by non-attorneys. [ . . . ] [T]he Legislature passed the Act in order to address the influx of individuals who needed assistance filling out immigration forms as a result of the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986 (federal law that provided legalization and citizenship for millions of immigrants). [ . . . ]
Under the state Immigration Consultant Act, a person engages in the business or acts in the capacity of an immigration consultant when that person gives nonlegal assistance or advice on an immigration matter. Assistance or advice is defined as including, but not limited to, the following:
- completing a form provided by a federal or state agency but not advising a person as to their answers on those forms;
- translating a person’s answers to questions posed in those forms;
- securing for a person supporting documents, such as birth certificates, which may be necessary to complete those forms; and
- submitting completed forms on a person’s behalf and at their request to the USCIS. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 22441(a).)
Immigration matter is defined under the state Immigration Consultant Act as any proceeding, filing, or action affecting the immigration or citizenship status of any person which arises under immigration and naturalization law, executive order or presidential proclamation, or action of the USCIS, the United States Department of State, or the United States Department of Labor.
In order to become an immigration consultant in California, a person must pass a background check and submit the following items to the Secretary of State: a copy of a current surety bond in the amount of $100,000 obtained from a corporate surety admitted to do business in California; a completed immigration consultant disclosure form; copy of a valid and current photo identification; a passport photo; and a $30 filing fee. (See Secretary of State website’s Immigration Consultant Checklist available at http://www.sos.ca.gov/business-programs/special-filings/immigration-consultant-checklist/ [as of July 4, 2019].)
As further explained by the Attorney General:
The conditions that prompted the need for immigration consultants have changed, and now the Act has become problematic for California consumers. First, federal law provides more protection than the Act. For example, federal law does not recognize “immigration consultants” or permit non-attorneys to render many of the services that the Act allows. Federal law generally only recognizes attorneys, law students acting under the supervision of an attorney, clergy, consular officers, and representatives accredited by the U.S. Department of Justice and those who may provide the services allowed by the Act. [ . . . ]
Second, the Act’s existence creates confusion. Although it is called the “Immigration Consultant Act,” individuals who market themselves as “immigration consultants” are not required to be trained in immigration matters. This makes the title of “immigration consultant” misleading because these individuals are not authorized to provide consultation services of any kind. [ . . . ]
Lastly, the complexity of immigration law makes it unclear when an “immigration consultant” is engaging in the unauthorized practice of law. “Immigration consultants” in California are only authorized to provide non-legal assistance such as completing immigration forms and translation services. The mere act of deciding which form or forms to complete on behalf of an immigrant involves complex legal questions that can affect whether an immigrant is ultimately deported or authorized to remain in the United States.
3. Immigration consultants are likely operating in violation of federal law
A recent California case makes clear that many immigration consultants are operating in violation of the law. In People v. Salcido, 34 Cal. App. 5th 1092 (2019) the court explained that unless a person is operating within the exception built into the definition of “preparation” activities that constitute “representation,” meaning they charge no or nominal fees and do not hold themselves out as qualified in legal matters or in immigration and naturalization procedure, even the filling out of immigration forms could constitute “representation,” thus requiring federal authorization. In other words, a person who satisfies the requirements for immigration consultants under state law, but is not federally authorized to provide “representation,” would still be prohibited, under federal law, from filling out immigration forms if they did so for compensation above a nominal fee or held themselves out as qualified in immigration procedures.
Section 22440 of the Business and Professions Code applies the statutory requirements for immigration consultants to persons who receive compensation for their services. If the compensation a person is receiving for their services is more than nominal, the person would need to be federally authorized. However, Section 22440 explicitly excludes from the requirements for immigration consultants those persons who are authorized to practice law or authorized by federal law to represent persons before the BIA or USCIS. Accordingly, anyone who is truly an “immigration consultant” is likely out of compliance with federal law.
In People v. Salcido, the court confirmed several key points about the Immigrant Consultants Act that are relevant to AB 1753. The defendant provided services regarding immigration to immigrants for a fee. The court explained that under federal regulations, only attorneys and other federally authorized persons can engage in “preparation,” which means “the study of the facts of a case and the applicable laws, coupled with the giving of advice and auxiliary activities, including the incidental preparation of papers.” States are prohibited from allowing non-attorneys or federally unauthorized persons to engage in “preparation” of immigration-related documents. The court noted that a state law would be preempted if it allows non-attorneys or federally unauthorized persons to fill out immigration forms for more than a nominal fee.
The State Bar Court also determined that a person who assists another in completing preprinted government immigration forms violates federal law unless they receive no more than nominal consideration. (In re Valinoti, 4 Cal. State Bar Ct. Rptr. 498 (2002).) The Valinoti court explained that preparing immigration forms for anything but a nominal fee constitutes “representation” under the federal regulations. The court noted that the Immigration Consultants Act only authorizes non-attorneys to do certain non-legal tasks. According to the court, only a “federally authorized” non-attorney can engage in “representation” of immigrants without violating federal law. The scope of “representation” under the federal regulations is very broad, and includes incidentally preparing papers for a person. Even a person who merely assists another in completing preprinted government immigration forms violates federal law unless they receive no more than nominal consideration.
4. Selection of forms requires an exercise of legal judgement and is the practice of law
A person charging a fee and selecting the appropriate form as part of the service is practicing immigration law and is subject to requirements of federal and state law regarding who is authorized to practice law. Under federal law, the definition of the practice of immigration law is stringent due to the complexity and high stakes of immigration law. Improper advice leads to ineligibility of immigration benefits and deportation from the country.
Federal law defines the “practice of law” in the context of immigration as the act or acts of any person appearing in any case, either in person or through the preparation or filing of any brief or other document, paper, application, or petition on behalf of another person or client before or with DHS, or any immigration judge or the Board. (8 C.F.R. § 1001.1(i).) The term preparation, constituting practice, means the study of the facts of a case and the applicable laws, coupled with the giving of advice and auxiliary activities, including the incidental preparation of papers. (8 C.F.R. § 1001.1(k).) In order to protect family and friends who help immigrants fill out forms, the regulations exclude “service consisting solely of assistance in the completion of blank spaces on printed Service forms by one whose remuneration, if any, is nominal and who does not hold himself out as qualified in legal matters or in immigration and naturalization procedure. Id. The federal regulations define “representation” in terms of the preceding definitions: “[t]he term representation before the Board and the Service includes practice and preparation as defined in paragraphs (i) and (k).” (8 C.F.R. § 1001.1(m).)
In practice it is impossible to imagine an immigration consultant preparing a form without selecting it. Selecting a form requires a legal decision about what immigration benefit the immigrant qualifies.
5. Immigration forms are complex and require legal judgment for proper completion to avoid negative consequences for the applicant
As explained by the California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation, a sponsor of this bill:
Immigration law is extremely complex. Federal courts have compared U.S. immigration law to “King Mino’s labyrinth in ancient Crete” and “second only to the Internal Revenue Code in complexity. [citing to Lok v. INS, 548 F.2d 37, 38 (2d Cir. 1977); and Castro-O’Ryan v. INS, 847 F.2d 1307, 1312 (9th Cir. 1988)] Changes in recent years have added layers of complexity, while heightening the risk of deportation for non-citizens whose applications are denied.
[ . . . ]
Completing what some may consider basic immigration applications requires the provision of legal advice. Assessing eligibility for immigration benefits requires a thorough understanding of U.S. immigration law. Answering questions such as which form to use, or how a customer should answer a question on a form, requires training and legal judgment. Immigration consultants have a very limited scope and little to offer a customer. Thus, consultants frequently cross the line into the unauthorized practice of law, dispensing legal advice to individuals desperate for immigration relief.
The National TPS Alliance Los Angeles Committee and San Francisco Bay Area Committee, in support of the bill, explain the following:
[T]his bill protects immigrant legal service consumers at a critical time of growing fear of deportation which includes Temporary Protected Status (TPS) holders currently in legal limbo. [ . . . ]
There is no doubt that immigration law is extremely complex. We understand that changes in recent years have added layers of complexity, while heightening the risk of deportation for non-citizens whose applications are denied and we understand this means that we have to be extra cautious in addressing and preventing the furthering of vulnerability of our immigrant communities. AB 1753 is a way of preventing and alleviating more confusion in our communities who are not getting right legal advice and a way to prevent even more family separations.
It has become even more difficult for immigrants to obtain immigration relief and has become commonplace for the federal government to deny immigration relief and deport immigrants. As an example, USCIS recently enacted a policy change by expanding the presumption of misrepresentation by nonimmigrant Visa entrants. Now there is a presumption of willful misrepresentation if a noncitizen engages in conduct inconsistent with their nonimmigrant status within 90 days of entry. Under the new rule, engaging in unauthorized employment, enrolling in an academic course without authorization, or marrying a U.S. citizen or legal resident creates a presumption that the noncitizen willfully misrepresented their intentions in seeking a visa or entry to the U.S. A finding of misrepresentation will permanently bar many family and employment-based residence applicants from the U.S. if they are unable to obtain a discretionary waiver, which is only available to certain family-based visa applicants.
The following are some examples of forms that immigration consultants fill out for immigrants and an explanation of their complexity.
a. Completing form I-485 (Application to Register Permanent Residence or Adjust Status)
The I-485 form was once fairly straightforward, but is now complicated and usually requires legal advice to get right. Section 245(i) of the Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) provided a mechanism whereby a person who entered the United States without inspection, or fell out of status, could pay a penalty fee and obtain permanent residence through a family petition process. Beneficiaries of section 245(i) went through a fairly straightforward application process, the final stage of which included completion of form I-485. Immigration consultants commonly completed applications for these persons that were successful. INA section 245(i) expired on April 30, 2001. Since then, the adjustment of status process has become complicated and requires legal advice.
A small percentage of the undocumented population is still eligible to adjust status through section 245(i). This includes persons still waiting for a visa to become current, and certain other individuals who are “grandfathered” through a previous petition process. However, most of the undocumented population is not eligible to adjust status in the U.S. because section 245(i) no longer exists and/or the immigrant has triggered other grounds of inadmissibility. For example, departing the U.S. after being out of status for a year and returning unlawfully permanently bars the immigrant from adjusting status.
Determining whether or not an undocumented person is eligible to adjust status in the U.S. by filing form I-485 now requires a complex analysis requiring substantial legal training and judgment. In many cases, immigrants are not eligible to adjust status in the US and must proceed abroad, a process which requires approval of discretionary inadmissibility waivers in order for them to return. Some immigrants require complex waivers of inadmissibility along with their I-485 application, or they are permanently barred from adjustment of status due to adverse immigration or criminal history. The I-485 application has also grown in length and complexity. Once a four-page application, the recent version, that was updated on December 13, 2017, is now 18 pages and includes questions whose answers necessitate legal judgment. The official instructions that accompany the I-485 application are 42-pages long. Removal proceedings are often initiated against ineligible immigrants who file form I-485. The I-485 application fee of $1,225 is considerable, though the total fee in many cases is $2,760 for a single applicant, when including a penalty fee and related I-130 fee.
b. Completing the I-589 (Asylum Application)
The I-589 application has long been a vehicle for immigration fraud. Seeking asylum in the U.S. is a complex legal process and government data shows that a majority of applicants are denied. The I-589 application form asks general questions regarding why the individual is seeking asylum, how they have been harmed, and why they fear returning to their country. Determining the legally relevant facts to include on a successful application requires substantial legal judgment and training in U.S. asylum law. Moreover, the supporting documentation submitted with the application, including evidence of persecution and country conditions evidence are critical components of a successful application. For example, the Real ID Act of 2005 made a difficult application process even stricter, heightening the burden of proof for applicants and imposing a requirement of corroborating evidence in many cases.
The DHS initiates removal proceedings against all out of status asylum applicants whose cases are denied. However, asylum applicants whose cases are not adjudicated within 180 days become eligible for employment authorization. Unscrupulous individuals use the asylum application process as a means of obtaining a work permit for clients and or seeking other forms of immigration relief in immigration court. In a recent published decision, the Board of Immigration Appeals held that it is an abuse of the asylum process to file a meritless asylum application with the U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services for the sole purpose of seeking other relief in court. (Andrede Jaso and Carbajal Ayala, 27 I&N Dec. 557 (BIA 2019).). Due to adjudication backlogs, many individuals receive a work permit for a period of time before the DHS denies their application and initiates removal proceedings.
c. Completing inadmissibility waivers I-601A
Inadmissibility waivers require legal advice and judgment at all stages of the application process. Filling out biographic information on a form is but a small part of the process for a successful applicant. Analyzing whether an immigrant is subject to a ground of inadmissibility and thus necessitating the waiver application, is a legal determination. The applicant’s answers to questions on the waiver, as well as the determination about what evidence to include in support of the waiver, are individualized determinations that require legal advice and judgment. The consequences of poor advice and judgment can be severe. Denied applicants often have no other means of obtaining legal status. The I-601A provisional unlawful presence waiver is arguably among the most likely waiver form completed by immigration consultants. But even when this waiver is approved by U.S.C.I.S, the immigrant must still proceed abroad to complete the process of obtaining permanent residence. Information not revealed or properly addressed on the waiver application may still arise at the consular interview conducted by the U.S. Department of State and result in denial of residence despite the prior approval of the I-601A provisional waiver. This may result in prolonged family separation and in some circumstances even a permanent bar from returning to the United States.
d. Completing documents for immigration relief through the U Visa, T Visa, VAWA, and Special Immigrant Juvenile Status
U Visa, T Visa, Violence Against Women Act, and Special Immigrant Juvenile Status applications are generally complex cases requiring legal advice and judgment at all stages of the process. Some immigration consultants complete U Visa applications, including law enforcement certification form I-918B. Even if a law enforcement agency signs the certification form, a requirement to submit a U Visa application, a form completed in an incorrect or incomplete manner may cause a delay or result in denial of the application by U.S.C.I.S.. Moreover, the evidence submitted with the application, including the statement by the victim and other supporting documentation, are essential to successful applications. Simply filling out the applicant’s biographic information on the forms, even if done correctly, is generally insufficient to obtain case approval. The type of evidence that should be submitted can vary widely in each case and virtually always requires legal judgment. Initial review/pre-adjudication of U Visa applications now takes up to three years, leaving crime victims vulnerable and in legal limbo. If an application is denied and must be resubmitted, the victim will languish for years without legal status despite being eligible for an immigration benefit.
6. Immigration consultants cause harms that cannot be redressed by a bond because the victim is deported
This Committee has received numerous letters of support for repealing the state’s Immigration Consultant Act. The letters document incidents where immigrants were harmed by immigration consultants. Letters also document where immigrants were harmed by persons who are not registered immigration consultants. The Committee has been contacted by law enforcement officers who have provided details regarding immigrants who have been harmed by immigration consultants and those who are not registered as immigration consultants.
Numerous examples of immigration consultants violating the immigration consultant statutes have been presented to the Committee. For example, San Francisco City Attorney Dennis J. Herrera sued a fraudulent immigration consulting business for unlawfully providing legal services. According to the City Attorney, for “decades, Lacayo & Associates defrauded clients with large fees for services they were neither qualified nor legally authorized to provide—risking clients’ immigration cases.” The lawsuit alleged “that in deceptively operating their immigration consulting business, the Lacayos consistently violated a long list of safeguards mandated by the California Immigration Consultant Act.” As another example, an immigration consultant was charged by the Santa Clara County District Attorney for violating the Immigration Consultant Act. (Jason Green, Bay Area immigration consultant charged (June 8, 2017) The Mercury News http://www.mercurynews.com/2017/06/08/bay-area-immigration-consultant-charged/ [as of July 5, 2019].) Her actions, according to prosecutors, resulted in a victim being stranded in a foreign country. Id. The immigration consultant allegedly had her staff fill out immigration paperwork and then she signed it as though she prepared it. Id.
Public Counsel, a supporter of the bill, explains that:
[Immigration] consultants frequently cross the line into the unauthorized practice of law, dispensing legal advice to individuals desperate for immigration relief. Passage of AB 1753 is of particular importance to the clients Public Counsel serves[.] […] We regularly see clients after immigration consultants and other individuals who are not authorized to practice immigration law, have billed them for preparing immigration applications for which they are not eligible, failed to timely file clients’ immigration applications, or enticed them into paying for legal services by falsely promising faster processing times. Consultants often charge substantial fees for form preparation that nonprofit legal programs offer at low-cost or free of charge. Botched immigration forms also leave immigrants vulnerable to deportation, tearing apart families after they have lost years of hard-earned savings. If a case can be salvaged, the burden falls disproportionately on resource-strapped nonprofit organizations like Public Counsel. Meanwhile, consultants rarely face consequences for defrauding customers for botched applications that expose immigrants to deportation proceedings.
The Legal Aid Foundation of Los Angeles highlighted the example of a person who had been given legal assistance by an immigration consultant “who filled out the initial asylum application with errors.” Since the client “signed the asylum application under penalty of perjury, USCIS is now arguing that he is not credible because he ‘lied’ on his asylum application.” Now the immigrant is in danger of being placed in removal proceedings.
IMPORTA Santa Barbara, a DOJ recognized provider of immigration legal services, in a letter of support to the Committee wrote the following:
Not a week goes without our seeing clients who were charged large fees by “immigration consultants” for applications that were denied. [ . . . ] The unfortunate truth is that under our present immigration laws, a large majority of undocumented immigrants do not have a path to legalization [ . . . ] We have heard heartbreaking stories from family members of deportations of other family members that resulted from incompetent work by consultants, and these deportations will certainly increase with the new USCIS policy of placing undocumented immigrants in removal proceedings if an application is denied.
The Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors, a sponsor of this bill writes:
The harm that immigration consultants can inflict on immigrants cannot be overstated. The fees of many consultants are comparable or higher than market rates of immigration attorneys in private practice. Consultants often charge substantial fees for form preparation that nonprofit legal programs offer at low-cost or free of charge. Erroneous immigration forms also leave immigrants vulnerable to deportation, tearing apart families after they have lost years of hard-earned savings. Meanwhile, immigration consultants rarely face consequences for defrauding their clients or for erroneous applications that may lead to deportation proceedings. By the time victims discover the harm caused by immigration consultants, they are afraid to report them out of fear of deportation.
7. Opposition concerns
This Committee has received over 100 letters in opposition to this bill from immigration consultants. The Committee has also received letters of opposition to this bill from over 500 individuals who indicate they have been helped by immigration consultants and praise their work.
The opposition argues this bill will result in unintended consequences for the immigrants this legislation seeks to help. For example, the opposition argues repealing the Immigration Consultant Act will result in a larger underground market of unscrupulous document preparers. Opposition also notes more immigrants of limited financial means will be forced to complete their own forms with errors that will jeopardize their ability to receive immigration relief to which they may otherwise be entitled. Additionally, opposition argues small business owners will lose their livelihood.
A Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) recipient wrote to the Committee to explain how immigration consulting services are less expensive than attorney services:
The [immigration consultant] has aided me in the completion of the DACA paperwork for a few years and I believe that this in the best interest, for myself and other families with similar situations, for services such as Ms. Romero’s to remain available for the immigrant community in the state of California.
In addition, Ms. Romero’s professional help has been significantly more affordable than other alternatives. Ms. Romero charged my family $450 for the initial DACA application and $275 for her help with the renewal; an attorney would charge my family around $1000 dollars for the same service. I come from a low-income family, and many people who seek legal aid from Ms. Romero and other public notaries face the very economic limitations my family does.
Another happy customer of an immigration consultant wrote about how she was charged $120 by an immigration consultant to fill out her naturalization application in contrast to the $,3500 and $4,500 attorneys were offering to charge her.
Some of the letters the Committee received opposing the ban highlight how some immigration consultants may be in violation of existing law as well as the confusion around whether the immigration consultant is, in fact, acting as an attorney.
In one opposition letter from a bonded immigration consultant, the consultant wrote she has “been working as an Immigration Paralegal since 1993.” In another letter, a client of an immigration consultant wrote that she consulted attorneys who “were so incompetent they fumbled with the law and couldn’t answer simple questions” but when she “consulted” the immigration consultant, she charged her “a meager amount for reviewing” her case, and gave her “straight answers,” and “knew the law like the back of her hand” and gave her “a solution at a FRACTION of the cost of every other person.” In another letter, a client writes about her satisfaction with a man who helped her with her green card. She states that in her letter that she “was told that he was a very good attorney that he was not a lawyer.” Although this individual referred to her helper as an “attorney,” he is actually an immigration consultant registered with the Secretary of State.
The Committee received a letter of opposition from the National Notary Association where the National Notary Association suggested that instead “of abolishing the good immigration consultants,” they “believe the goal of AB 1753 should be to use all necessary resources to compel the unscrupulous immigration consultants to comply with the law and be bonded.” Opponents believe that a few bad actors are engaging in harm to immigrants and those persons are generally not bonded or registered, thus operating outside of the law. Opponents to this bill also highlight that there should be mandatory educational courses on the law, responsibilities, and ethics of immigration consultants, as well as refresher course every two years. Some letters of opposition propose that the bill be amended to do the following: narrow the services immigration consultants can provide by excluding asylum, T-Visa, U-Visa, Violence Against Women Act, and Special Immigrant Juvenile Status applications; require education as part of registration; and change the name “immigration consultant” to something like “immigration form assistant.” These proposed amendments do not get around the fact that immigration consultants who fill out immigration forms for more than a nominal fee would still be doing so in violation of federal law unless these persons are federally authorized to represent individuals in immigration matters.
SUPPORT
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation (sponsor)
Central American Resource Center (CARECEN) of California (sponsor)
Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights Los Angeles (sponsor)
Los Angeles County Board of Supervisors (sponsor)
Los Angeles District Attorney’s Office (sponsor)
American Civil Liberties Union of California
California Attorney General Xavier Becerra
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Reinvestment Coalition
Central Valley Immigrant Integration Collaborative
City of Los Angeles
City of Stockton Mayor, Michael Tubbs
Consumer Attorneys of California
Cruz Reynoso Bar Association
Esperanza Immigrant Rights Project, CCLA, Inc.
Families in Schools
The Fresno Center
IMPORTA Santa Barbara
Khmer Parent Association
Long Beach Immigrant Rights Coalition
Los Angeles County Office of Education
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Promesa Boyle Heights
Public Counsel
Public Law Center
Service Employees International Union, California
Services, Immigrant Rights & Education Network
UFW Foundation
United Food and Commercial Workers Western States Council
Voices for Progress
OPPOSITION
City of Downey, Council Member Claudia M. Frometa
City of Downey, Council Member Alex Saab
Comité de Padres Unidos (United Parents Committee)
Gudwara Sant Sagar
Latin America Immigration Association
National Notary Association
One Stop Immigration and Educational Center, Inc.
Vista Legal Services
Over 100 immigration consultants
Over 500 individuals
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known
Prior Legislation: AB 638 (Caballero, 2018) would have repealed California’s immigration consultant law and done away with the immigration consultant industry as of January 1, 2019. The bill failed passage on the Senate floor.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 57, Noes 17)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 13, Noes 4)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 3)
**************
The following five classes of people are authorized to provide “representation” as federally authorized persons: (1) attorneys in good standing; (2) accredited representatives, who have been authorized by the Executive Office for Immigration Review (EOIR); (3) unpaid law students supervised by an attorney; (4) reputable individuals, who are of good moral character, provided they have a preexisting relationship with the client and do not receive compensation; and (5) accredited officials of the client’s foreign government. (8 C.F.R. §§ 1.2 & 292.1.) ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1753
Author:(Carrillo)
As Amended Ver:April 25, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits any person from providing advice or services related to an immigration matter for compensation, and from holding themselves out to the public as a person with specialized knowledge in immigration law or procedure, unless they are authorized to practice law, authorized by federal law to represent persons on immigration matters, or licensed as a paralegal and acting under the active supervision of an attorney.
Major Provisions
- Prohibits any person within this state, other than a person authorized to practice law, a person authorized by federal law to represent persons before the United States Department of Homeland Security or the United States Department of Justice, or licensed as a paralegal and acting under the active supervision of an attorney to the extent and in the capacities currently permitted, from providing advice and/or services related to any immigration matter, as specified, for compensation, or holding him or herself out as an immigration consultant or as a person authorized to provide advice on immigration matters.
- Prohibits any person or entity, other than those expressly authorized to provide advice and/or services related to immigration matters, from advertising immigration services using the term "immigration consultant," "immigration specialist," "notary public," "notary," "licensed," "attorney," or "lawyer," or literally translating any of those terms for any advertising purpose.
- Sets the provisions above to take effect on January 1, 2021.
COMMENTS:
In response to increased demand for immigration services, the Immigration Consultants Act of 1986 (ICA) permitted the provision of certain non-legal services related to preparing immigration documents by persons who are not licensed to practice law or represent clients on immigration matters. The ICA placed several restrictions on the services that could be provided by these "immigration consultants," and enumerated requirements to practice in that capacity, including background checks, $100,000 surety bonds, and registration with the Secretary of State. However, the requirements to provide these non-legal services do not include any education, training, or other types of competency standards with respect to immigration and naturalization law, which is a particularly complex and high stakes area of the law. Though immigration consultants—like all other persons who are not licensed as attorneys--are prohibited from providing legal advice to clients, the lines between legal advice and document preparation in this area are not well defined, as seemingly simple tasks, such as selecting forms to prepare or submitting applications, if performed improperly, could result in denial of immigration relief, or, especially under current federal policies, deportation.
This bill makes it unlawful as of January 1, 2021 to act as an immigration consultant in this state, and limits the lawful provision of immigration services for compensation to those licensed to practice law and those authorized to represent clients on immigration matters in front of the United States Departments of Justice and Homeland Security. The bill also requires the Secretary of State to establish a website that informs the public of the process for receiving federal accreditation to provide immigration services as well as several other immigration legal resources.
According to the Author:
Despite additional amendments and reforms to the Immigration Consultants Act since it was first enacted, the practices of immigration consultants often blur the line between assisting immigrants with immigration documents and offering legal advice, which amounts to the illegal practice of law. Because of the possibility of deportation, a person seeking help with an immigration matter should only consult with an individual who is competent in naturalization and immigration law. AB 1753 will repeal the current authorization and registration system for immigration consultants and restrict the provision of immigration services to licensed attorneys and federally accredited representatives.
Arguments in Support:
Supporters of the bill believe that the stakes in the context of immigration law are too high to entrust to an industry that lacks competency standards, and that the lines between preparation of immigration documents and provision of legal advice are too nebulous to expect a profession predicated on legal form preparation to recognize and refrain from doing the latter. Supporters also contend that the title "immigration consultant" is inherently misleading and carries an unsubstantiated implication of expertise that is especially likely to confuse immigrants who are unfamiliar with United States immigration procedures and may face language barriers.
Arguments in Opposition:
Opponents of the bill are concerned that eliminating immigration consultants, in addition to putting hard-working Californians out of work, will also create a gap in low-cost immigration services and force immigrants to choose between paying for expensive legal services that are already stretched thin and preparing immigration forms on their own. Opponents also assert that prohibiting the lawful practice of immigration consulting will not eliminate the "bad actors" who harm the public and will instead funnel immigrants to unscrupulous underground networks of immigration service providers who would lack bond accountability.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations analysis, costs (GF) possibly in the hundreds of thousands of dollars to SOS in increased workload to contact and notify individuals or entities currently licensed as immigration consultants who may no longer offer such services pursuant to the terms of this bill.
Minor and absorbable costs for SOS and DOJ to coordinate on updating SOS' existing website regarding immigration consultants to include information regarding licensing and authorized providers of immigration services. SOS already has a website for immigration consultants, so it would only be required to provide updated information on an existing webpage.
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-3-0
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Gallagher, Kiley, Obernolte
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-4-1
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Fong, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Diep
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 11, 2019
CONSULTANT: Landon Klein / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0000512
Date of Hearing: May 8, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1753
Author:(Carrillo) – As Amended Ver:April 25, 2019
Policy Committee: | Judiciary | Vote: | 9 - 3 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits, as of January 1, 2021, any person from providing for compensation any advice or services related to an immigration matter or from holding themselves out to the public as a person with specialized knowledge in immigration law or procedure, unless they are authorized to practice law, authorized by federal law to represent clients on immigration matters or licensed as a paralegal and acting under the supervision of an attorney. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the Secretary of State (SOS), on or before January 1, 2020, to notify any individual or entity registered as an immigration consultant after January 1, 2018, and that is listed on a SOS internet website, of the prohibition against acting as an immigration consultant unless qualified pursuant to this bill and of the operative date of that prohibition.
- Requires the SOS, in coordination with the Department of Justice (DOJ) and the State Bar, to establish an internet website that informs the public, among other things, about how an organization may become recognized, or an individual may become accredited, as an authorized provider of immigration services and a list of entities funded by the state that provide assistance in immigration matters.
- Prohibits any person or entity, other than those expressly authorized to provide advice or services related to immigration matters, from advertising or otherwise holding themselves out to the public as an entity or person with specialized knowledge in immigration law or procedure.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Costs (GF) possibly in the hundreds of thousands of dollars to SOS in increased workload to contact and notify individuals or entities currently licensed as immigration consultants who may no longer offer such services pursuant to the terms of this bill.
Minor and absorbable costs for SOS and DOJ to coordinate on updating SOS’ existing website regarding immigration consultants to include information regarding licensing and authorized providers of immigration services. SOS already has a website for immigration consultants, so it would only be required to provide updated information on an existing webpage.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
California law has contributed to the widespread misperception that individuals with no training or professional standards are experts who are authorized to provide advice in immigration matters.” The author further states, “AB 638 will prohibit any individual acting as an immigrant consultant who is not an attorney or accredited representative with the federal government.
- Background. Existing law requires a person engaged in business as an immigration consultant to register with the SOS, have a $100,000 bond and submit fingerprints and other information to DOJ. While existing law prohibits immigration consultants from engaging in specified bad business practices or illegal acts, state law does not require immigration consultants have specific training or certifications to ensure that they have sufficient knowledge to appropriately help their clients navigate the complexities of immigration law. In addition, existing law prohibits the practice of law by individuals who are not attorneys. It is possible that some existing immigration consultants may be violating this provision by offering what amounts to legal advice when they are not attorneys. Practicing law without a license in California is a misdemeanor.
- Support. According to the California Catholic Conference:
Immigration consultants frequently cross the line into the unauthorized practice of law dispensing legal advice to individuals desperate for immigration relief. Botched immigration forms leave immigrations vulnerable to deportation, tearing apart families and after they have lost years of hard-earned savings.
- Opposition. According to the National Notary Association:
AB [1753] also is misguided … Prohibiting the practice of immigration consulting will eliminate a low-cost option for immigrants seeking to file for a change or adjustment to their immigration status, making it more difficult for them to emerge from the shadows and openly contribute to the economy, life and culture of the state of California.
- Prior Legislation. AB 638 (Caballero), of the 2017-2018 Legislative Session, would have made it unlawful for a person not authorized to practice law to receive compensation for immigration services and punished any violation as a felony punishable in state prison. AB 638 failed passage on the Senate floor.
Analysis Prepared by: Kimberly Horiuchi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1753
Author:(Carrillo) – As Amended Ver:April 11, 2019
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: IMMIGRATION CONSULTANTS
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD IT BE UNLAWFUL FOR ANY PERSON TO PROVIDE ADVICE OR SERVICES RELATED TO IMMIGRATION MATTERS FOR COMPENSATION WITHIN CALIFORNIA IF THEY ARE NOT AUTHORIZED TO PRACTICE LAW, AUTHORIZED BY FEDERAL LAW TO REPRESENT PERSONS ON IMMIGRATION MATTERS, OR LICENSED AS A PARALEGAL AND ACTING UNDER THE SUPERVISION OF AN ATTORNEY?
SYNOPSIS
In response to increased demand for immigration services, the Immigration Consultants Act of 1986 (ICA) permitted the provision of certain non-legal services related to preparing immigration documents by persons who are not licensed to practice law or represent clients on immigration matters. The ICA placed several restrictions on the services that could be provided by these “immigration consultants” and enumerated requirements for them to be able to practice in that capacity, including background checks, $100,000 surety bonds, and registration with the Secretary of State. However, the requirements to provide these non-legal services did not include any educational or other competency standards with respect to immigration and naturalization law, which is a particularly complex and high stakes subject. Though immigration consultants are prohibited by current law from providing legal advice to clients, the lines between legal advice and document preparation in this area are not well defined, as seemingly simple tasks, such as selecting forms to prepare, or submitting applications, if performed improperly, could result in the denial of immigration relief, or, especially under current federal policies, deportation. The title “immigration consultant” can also be misleading, as it implies a level of expertise with the immigration process that may not actually be possessed and a level of consultation that cannot be given. California has attempted to address this problem by providing several disclosure requirements regarding the capacities in which immigration consultants are permitted to work and their status as non-attorneys. Still, for those unfamiliar with the language or laws of this country, this distinction can be difficult to understand. This bill, as in print, makes it unlawful as of January 1, 2021 to act as an immigration consultant in this state, and limits the lawful provision of immigration services for compensation to those persons who are licensed to practice law and those who are authorized to represent clients on immigration matters in front of the United States Departments of Justice and Homeland Security. The bill in print also requires the Secretary of State to establish a website that informs the public of the process for receiving federal accreditation to provide immigration services, as well as several other immigration legal resources.
As proposed to be amended, the bill would also require the Secretary of State to provide notice by January 1, 2020 to any active immigration consultant of the impending prohibition imposed by the bill and its effective date, as well as a list of organizations in California that are recognized by the United States Department of Justice as being eligible to provide representation on immigration matters and information outlining the process for acquiring federal accreditation. The author has also agreed to require currently active immigration consultants to post a sign informing clients of the impending prohibition and its effective date. Finally, the author has agreed to include paralegals acting under the supervision of attorneys among those permitted to provide immigration services, as long as they are operating only to the extent and in the capacities otherwise permitted by state law. The author’s amendments are described and reflected in the analysis.
This bill is co-sponsored by the County of Los Angeles, the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA), the California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation, and the Central American Resource Center (CARECEN). It is supported by a coalition of immigrants’ rights groups, workers’ rights groups, and social justice organizations, including the SEIU and the ACLU, who argue that the practice of immigration consultants is inherently misleading, and the lack of competency standards puts vulnerable immigrant communities at risk of exploitation or, worse yet, deportation due to malpractice. It is opposed by trade organizations that represent immigration consultants and other non-attorney immigration service providers and numerous individual immigration consultants, who point out the vacuum of low cost immigration assistance that would result if immigration consultants were eliminated, and argue that this bill is throwing the baby out with the bath water – eliminating the whole profession in response to the incompetency or misconduct of a few bad apples.
SUMMARY: This bill prohibits any person from providing advice or services related to an immigration matter for compensation, and from holding themselves out to the public as a person with specialized knowledge in immigration law or procedure, unless they are authorized to practice law, authorized by federal law to represent persons on immigration matters, or licensed as a paralegal and acting under the active supervision of an attorney. Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits any person within this state, other than a person authorized to practice law, a person authorized by federal law to represent persons before the United States Department of Homeland Security or the United States Department of Justice, or licensed as a paralegal and acting under the active supervision of an attorney to the extent and in the capacities currently permitted, from providing advice and/or services related to any immigration matter, as specified, for compensation, or holding him or herself out as an immigration consultant or as a person authorized to provide advice on immigration matters.
- Prohibits any person or entity, other than those expressly authorized to provide advice and/or services related to immigration matters, from advertising or otherwise holding themselves out to the public as an entity or person with specialized knowledge in immigration law or procedure.
- Prohibits any person or entity, other than those expressly authorized to provide advice and/or services related to immigration matters, from advertising immigration services using the term “immigration consultant,” “immigration specialist,” “notary public,” “notary,” “licensed,” “attorney,” or “lawyer,” or literally translating any of those terms for any advertising purpose.
- Requires the Secretary of State, in coordination with the Department of Justice and the State Bar, to establish an internet website that does all of the following:
- Informs the public about how an organization may become recognized or an individual may become accredited as an authorized provider of immigration services by the United States Department of Justice.
- Provides the public with a list, to be updated annually, of recognized entities and individuals accredited as authorized providers of immigration services by the United States Department of Justice.
- Provides the public with a list of entities funded by the state that provide assistance in immigration matters.
- Provides any other legal resources related to immigration matters.
- Provides the public with information of any complaint hotline regarding immigration-related services and information on how to file a complaint with the appropriate local and state agencies.
- Provides that a person engages in the business of providing immigration advice and/or services when that person, for compensation, gives legal or nonlegal assistance or advice on an immigration matter, including, but not limited to:
- Providing legal advice regarding an immigration matter, including but not limited to assessing whether an individual is eligible or not eligible for any immigration benefit, otherwise assisting an individual in making such a determination, or advising as to the consequences of applying for or not applying for any immigration benefit.
- Completing any immigration form provided by a federal or state agency for a person.
- Advising a person as to the person’s answers on any immigration form provided by a federal or state agency.
- Translating a person’s answers to questions posed in those forms.
- Securing for a person supporting documents, such as birth certificates, which may be necessary to complete those forms.
- Submitting completed forms on a person’s behalf and at the person’s request to the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services, the United States Department of State, or the United States Department of Justice.
- Making referrals to persons who could undertake legal representation activities for a person in an immigration matter, unless authorized by the State Bar of California as an attorney referral service.
- Repeals provisions detailing requirements for authorization and practices for compliance as an immigration consultant and for notaries public to act as immigration consultants.
- Sets the provisions in 1) through 6), above, to take effect on January 1, 2021.
- Requires the Secretary of State to, by January 1, 2020, notify any individual or entity registered as an active immigration consultant at any time on or after January 1, 2018 of the prohibition on immigration consulting and the operative date of that provision.
- Requires the Secretary of State to, by January 1, 2020, provide any individual or entity registered as an active immigration consultant at any time on or after January 1, 2018 with the following:
- A list of organizations in California that are actively recognized by the United States Department of Justice as eligible to provide representation through accredited representatives.
- Resources outlining the process for acquiring federal accreditation.
- Requires any immigration consultant to conspicuously display in their office a notice that shall be at least 12 by 20 inches with boldface type or print with each character at least one inch in height and width in English and in the native language of the immigration consultant’s clientele, that notifies clients of the prohibition on immigration consulting and the operative date of that prohibition.
- Requires a person who is not licensed as an attorney in any state or territory of the United States, but is authorized by federal law to represent persons before the United States Department of Justice or the United States Department of Homeland Security, to include in any advertisement for immigration services a clear and conspicuous statement of this fact, and to include in any contract the same information as well as a web address at which a current version of the “Recognized Organizations and Accredited Representatives Roster” published by the United States Office of Legal Access Programs can be accessed to verify the accreditation of that person.
- Requires a person who is not an active member of the State Bar in California, but is an attorney licensed in another state or territory of the United States and is admitted to practice before the United States Department of Justice or the United States Department of Homeland Security, to include in any contract or advertisement for immigration services a clear and conspicuous statement of this fact, as well as the state or territory in which the person is licensed to practice law, and the associated license number.
- Provides that these provisions shall not be construed to prohibit the following:
- A person, or qualified designated entity, authorized by federal law from representing persons before the United States Department of Homeland Security or the United States Department of Justice.
- An attorney from providing legal advice in an immigration matter.
- An employee of a nonprofit tax-exempt corporation from helping clients complete application forms in an immigration matter free of charge or for a nominal fee, including reasonable costs.
- A notary public from providing services that the notary public is authorized to provide under any other law.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits an immigration consultant to advertise or hold himself or herself out as practicing or entitled to practice law, or to otherwise practice law. (Business and Professions Code Section 6126.4. All further statutory references are to the Business and Professions Code, unless otherwise stated.)
- Provides that a person acts as an immigration consultant when that person gives non-legal assistance or advice on an immigration matter, including by doing any of the following:
- Completing a form provided by a federal or state agency, but not advising a person as to their answers on those forms.
- Translating a person’s answers to questions posed on those forms.
- Securing for a person’s supporting documents, such as a birth certificate, which may be necessary to complete a form.
- Submitting completed forms on a person’s behalf and at their request to the United States Citizenship and Immigration Services.
- Making referrals to persons who could undertake legal representation for a person in an immigration matter. (Section 22441 (a).)
- Prohibits an immigration consultant, with the intent to mislead, from literally translating, from English into another language, any words or titles, including but not limited to, “notary public,” “notary,” “licensed,” “attorney,” or “lawyer,” that imply that the person is an attorney, in any document, including an advertisement, stationery, letterhead, business card, or other comparable written material describing the immigration consultant. (Section 22442.3.)
- Requires a person engaged in the business, or acting in the capacity of an immigration consultant, to submit to the Department of Justice (DOJ), fingerprint images and related information required by the DOJ for the purpose of obtaining information as to the existence and content of a record of state and federal convictions and arrests. (Section 22442.4.)
- Requires a person, prior to engaging in the business or acting in the capacity of an immigration consultant, to file with the Secretary of State a bond of one hundred thousand dollars ($100,000) executed by a corporate surety admitted to do business in this state. (Section 22443.1.)
- Prohibits an immigration consultant from doing any of the following:
a) making a false or misleading statement to a client while providing services to that client;
b) making any guarantee or promise to a client, unless that guarantee or promise is in writing and the immigration consultant has some basis in fact for making the guarantee or promise;
c) making any statement that the immigration consultant may obtain special favors; and
d) charging a client for a referral of the client to another for services which the immigration consultant cannot or will not provide to the client. (Section 22444.)
- Prohibits any person who is not an attorney from literally translating from English into another language, in any document, including an advertisement, stationary, letterhead, business card, or other comparable written material with any words or titles including “notary public, notary, licensed, attorney, or lawyer” that imply the person is an attorney. (Section 6126.7.)
- Prohibits a notary public from advertising himself or herself as an immigration specialist. (Government Code Section 8223.)
- Defines “paralegal” to mean a person who holds himself or herself out to be a paralegal, who is qualified by education, training, or work experience, who either contracts with or is employed by an attorney, law firm, corporation, governmental agency, or other entity, and who performs substantial legal work under the direction and supervision of an active member of the State Bar of California. (Section 6450 (a).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: In response to increased demand for immigration services, the Immigration Consultants Act of 1986 (ICA) permitted the provision of certain non-legal services related to preparing immigration documents by persons who are not licensed to practice law or represent clients on immigration matters. The ICA placed several restrictions on the services that could be provided by these “immigration consultants,” and enumerated requirements to practice in that capacity, including background checks, $100,000 surety bonds, and registration with the Secretary of State. However, the requirements to provide these non-legal services do not include any education, training, or other types of competency standards with respect to immigration and naturalization law, which is a particularly complex and high stakes area of the law. Though immigration consultants—like all other persons who are not licensed as attorneys--are prohibited from providing legal advice to clients, the lines between legal advice and document preparation in this area are not well defined, as seemingly simple tasks, such as selecting forms to prepare or submitting applications, if performed improperly, could result in denial of immigration relief, or, especially under current federal policies, deportation.
The title “immigration consultant” can also be misleading, as it implies a level of expertise with the immigration process that may not actually be possessed and an amount of “consultation” that cannot lawfully be provided. California has attempted to address these issues by providing several disclosure requirements regarding the capacities in which immigration consultants are allowed to work and their status as non-attorneys. Still, for those unfamiliar with the language or laws of this country, this distinction can be difficult to understand.
This bill makes it unlawful as of January 1, 2021 to act as an immigration consultant in this state, and limits the lawful provision of immigration services for compensation to those licensed to practice law and those authorized to represent clients on immigration matters in front of the United States Departments of Justice and Homeland Security. The bill also requires the Secretary of State to establish a website that informs the public of the process for receiving federal accreditation to provide immigration services as well as several other immigration legal resources. According to the author:
Given the complexities of immigration law, the [Immigration Consultants Act’s] restrictions are impractical even for well-intentioned immigration consultants. During the course of consultations between immigration consultants and clients, legal advice is inevitably dispensed because the clients are often unfamiliar with immigration laws and uncertain about which type of benefit, if any, they are eligible for. Therefore, immigrants who hire the services of immigration consultants are vulnerable to getting advice from immigration consultants about whether they qualify for immigration relief, how to qualify and what they need to do to qualify – all activities prohibited by ICA. Undocumented immigrants are especially vulnerable to the consequences of poor legal advice, [and] affected immigrant victims often lack the resources to correct the mistakes for a number of reasons.
Despite additional amendments and reforms to the Immigration Consultants Act since it was first enacted, the practices of immigration consultants often blur the line between assisting immigrants with immigration documents and offering legal advice, which amounts to the illegal practice of law. Because of the possibility of deportation, a person seeking help with an immigration matter should only consult with an individual who is competent in naturalization and immigration law. AB 1753 will repeal the current authorization and registration system for immigration consultants and restrict the provision of immigration services to licensed attorneys and federally accredited representatives. These individuals are authorized to provide legal advice and represent clients before the U.S. Department of Justice and/or the U.S. Department of Homeland Security in their immigration matters. Several other states that have passed similar legislation in recent years to protect immigrant consumers and it is time that California does the same.
The Immigration Consultants Act was passed to accommodate the surge in demand for immigration services following the Immigration Reform and Control Act of 1986. Facing mounting public pressure to curb illegal immigration into the United States, Congress proposed a set of laws in the 1980s to prohibit employment of undocumented immigrants in order to deter new immigrants from coming into the country seeking work. This set of laws came to be known as the Immigration Reform and Control Act and was signed into law by President Ronald Reagan in 1986. (99 P.L. 603, 100 Stat. 3359.) However, because persons without documentation of lawful presence in the United States comprised a significant segment of the workforce, particularly in the agricultural sector, the Act also included a provision granting lawful status to persons who entered the United States before January 1, 1982 if they had resided in the country continuously since then, agreed to admit that they had entered the country unlawfully, and paid a fine along with any back taxes. (Ibid.) This reform allowed millions of undocumented persons, who otherwise would have been ineligible for legal residence, to apply for visas and green cards, and to pursue naturalization. The result was a dramatic increase in the demand for services providing advice and assistance in securing documents and preparing applications related to immigration. In response to this demand, along with the high cost and limited availability of appropriate legal services, underground markets for documentation and fraudulent applications emerged. So-called “notarios,” individuals offering advice and legal assistance to undocumented immigrants in the preparation of immigration documents, exploited the deficiency in legitimate immigration services by charging “clients” for services that they did not ultimately provide, or by providing incompetent service that resulted in improper or missing paperwork. Such abuses swindled indigent persons who had little legal recourse out of scant funds, and, in some cases, resulted in deportation or the denial of asylum due to improper filing.
This practice of providing documents or legal “assistance” became so widespread that policymakers believed it could only be managed by legitimizing and regulating the industry. Toward this end, and with the strong support of immigrant rights groups, the Legislature passed the Immigration Consultants Act (ICA) in 1986. (Business and Profession Code Sections 22440-22449.) The ICA required notaries or other individuals providing immigration services, who came to be known as “immigration consultants,” to register with the Secretary of State (SOS), and prohibited immigration consultants from providing legal advice. Over the following decades, the ICA underwent extensive amendment, mostly to expand requirements for qualification, and to require a surety bond as accountability against malpractice. The ICA paved the way for a small but persistent industry of registered and bonded immigration consultants. Unfortunately, violations, including fraud by those who fail to register and pay bond, as well as the unlawful provision of dubious legal advice, nevertheless continue to be common.
The required qualifications for immigration consultants are minimal, leading to an inherent risk of unauthorized practice of law or professional malpractice. The ICA defines and regulates immigration services provided by individuals who are neither licensed attorneys nor authorized by Federal law to represent people in immigration matters. Under the ICA, immigration consultants must satisfy certain requirements to operate legally in the state. First, an immigration consultant must submit to a background check conducted by the Department of Justice (DOJ) and must 1) not have been convicted of a felony, 2) not have been convicted of a disqualifying misdemeanor within 10 years of the background check, and 3) disclose any arrest or conviction. Second, upon application for registration within the state, the immigration consultant must file a $100,000 surety bond with the SOS. This bond is payable to the people of the state for the benefit of any person damaged by fraud, misstatement, misrepresentation, unlawful act or omission, or failure to provide the services of the immigration consultant or the agents, representatives, or employees of the immigration consultant. After satisfying these requirements, the immigration consultant must register with the SOS to be listed on an online roster of approved immigration consultants. (Ibid.)
The ICA prohibits immigration consultants from providing legal advice including telling clients whether they qualify for immigration relief, how they qualify, and what they need to do in order to qualify. It instead limits the services they can provide to non-legal services, such as completing forms as instructed by customers, translating documents, and submitting documents to immigration officials on behalf of customers. Immigration consultants must also provide customers with certain disclosures, including a written contract in the customer’s language, contact information for the consultant, registration and bond information, and a statement that the immigration consultant is not an attorney and cannot offer legal advice. (Ibid.)
Despite the requirements to become an immigration consultant and the restrictions in operation that apply thereafter, there is no requirement for the immigration consultant to demonstrate any degree of competency in naturalization and immigration law. Immigration consultants that wish to serve their clients effectively will sometimes take it upon themselves to receive the necessary education and take continuing education programs, but these courses are often expensive, resulting in many “self-taught” immigration consultants. The lack of a competency requirement for immigration consultants can lead to improper application or disregard for the law and places the immigrant community at risk of fraud, misrepresentation, and negligence, as well as possible deportation.
Misconduct and malpractice among immigration consultants has been reported, despite presumed accountability through bond requirements. Currently, approximately 1,000 immigration consultants have registered with the SOS pursuant to ICA. Opponents of this bill contend there are very few documented malpractice claims against the $100,000 bonds that these immigration consultants have posted, and emphasize that significantly more claims are made against attorneys. This statistic may be misleading, however, given the much larger pool of licensed attorneys in the state, the clear organizational accountability of attorneys to the State Bar, and the comparative capacity and willingness for many non-immigrant legal clients to report misconduct by attorneys, in contrast to immigrants who may risk deportation or lack the resources to challenge improper behavior. In spite of infrequent misconduct reports against immigration consultants, proponents contend there is significant troubling evidence of major violations in recent years. For example:
- In August of 2016, GDS, an immigration consultant, pleaded guilty to the unauthorized practice of law, which negatively impacted the immigration status of her clients.
- Also in August of 2016, the San Francisco City Attorney filed suit against one couple for falsely misleading clients into believing they were immigration attorneys.
- In 2008, JR was found liable for ICA violations for misleading his clients into believing that he could obtain work permits and legal residence for the plaintiffs if each plaintiff paid him $16,000.
- In 2011, the Department of Homeland Security made several arrests of persons serving as immigration consultants who defrauded hundreds of Chinese immigrants with the promise of asylum.
Opponents of the bill contend, in response, that ICA violations by some unscrupulous immigration consultants should not be attributed to the entire profession, and that by many accounts, there are large numbers of immigration consultants who provide respectable and necessary services.
Immigration law is extremely complex. Though it is not unusual for an area of law to be complex and difficult to access, immigration law is exceptional in this respect. Statutes and regulations governing the immigration process are extensive, labyrinthine, and dynamic, and the wide latitude given to the executive branch to dictate immigration policies and priorities means the context and content of immigration law can change rapidly. In a 2003 federal district court decision relating to the retroactive application of certain immigration laws, Judge Jose Cabranes detailed the complexity of this area of law as follows:
This case vividly illustrates the labyrinthine character of modern immigration law – a maze of hyper-technical statutes and regulations that engender waste, delay, and confusion for the Government and petitioners alike. The inscrutability of the current immigration law system, and the interplay of the numerous amendments and alterations to that system by Congress during the pendency of this case, have spawned years of litigation, generated two separate opinions by the District Court, and consumed significant resources of this Court. (Drax v. Reno (2003) 338 F.3d 99.)
Similarly, in a 1977 federal district court decision interpreting statutory requirements surrounding grounds under which an immigrant can be deported, Chief Judge Irving Kaufman remarked:
We have had occasion to note the striking resemblance between some of the laws we are called upon to interpret and King Minos’s labyrinth in ancient Crete. The Tax Laws and Immigration and Nationality Acts are examples we have cited of Congress’s ingenuity in passing statutes certain to accelerate the aging process of judges. In this instance, Congress, pursuant to its virtually unfettered power to exclude or depart natives of other countries, and apparently confident of the aphorism that human skill, properly applied, can resolve any enigma that human inventiveness can create, has enacted a baffling skein of provisions for the [Immigration and Naturalization Service] and courts to disentangle. The fate of the alien faced with imminent deportation often hinges upon narrow issues of statutory interpretation. (Lok v. Immigration & Naturalization Service (1977) 548 F.2d 38.)
The stakes of error in the provision of immigration services have skyrocketed under current federal enforcement priorities. Under the Trump Administration, which has made limiting both legal and illegal immigration to the United States a priority, the complexity of interpreting these laws and the stakes of improper interpretation have increased dramatically. In carrying out federal policies for “extreme vetting” of visa, green-card, and naturalization applicants, the administration has increased the amount of information that must be provided. For instance, some visa applicants are now required to produce a supplemental questionnaire providing fifteen years of travel and employment histories and residential addresses, along with usernames on social media accounts used in the last five years. (U.S. Department of State, 60-Day Notice of Proposed Information Collection: Application for Immigrant Visa and Alien Registration (March 30, 2018), Federal Register 83, no. 62, at pp. 13806-07.) These requirements are not mandatory for all applicants, further complicating the process. (Ibid.)
Additionally, on April 18, 2017, President Trump signed the “Buy American and Hire American” executive order which encouraged the Departments of State, Justice, Labor, and Homeland Security to issue new rules and guidance to “protect the interests of U.S. workers and to prevent fraud and abuse in the immigration system.” (White House, Executive Order 13788.) Several steps have been taken in compliance with this policy that have made immaculate procedure through the immigration process essential. Updated policies for the United States Customs and Immigration Service (USCIS) as of July 2018, for instance, expedite denial of applications to remain in the country by refusing opportunities to supplement applications with additional supporting evidence or corrected forms, leaving very little room for error in the accuracy, submission, or completeness of these applications. (USCIS, USCIS Updates Policy Guidance for Certain Requests for Evidence and Notices of Intent to Deny (July 13, 2018, www.uscis.gov/news/news-releases/uscis-updates-policy-guidance-certain-requests-evidence-and-notices-intent-deny.) USCIS has also adopted new policies as of June 2018 that direct immigration officials to place all immigrants whose applications are denied for any reason into proceedings for deportation if, upon denial, they are unlawfully present in the country. (USCIS, Updated Guidance for the Referral of Cases and Issuance of Notices to Appear (NTAs) in Cases Involving Inadmissible and Deportable Aliens (June 28, 2018), policy memorandum, www.uscis.gov/sites/default/files/USCIS/Laws/Memoranda/2018/2018-06-28-PM-602-0050.1-Guildance-for-Referral-of-Cases-and-Issuance-of-NTA.pdf.) This means that any error in the application process, or submission of an application for a person who is ineligible for legal residence, can result in deportation. Finally, the Trump Administration’s policy of “Zero Tolerance”—in which all persons without documentation of lawful presence, regardless of how long they have lived in the United States, their breath and depth of family ties, or whether they have remained law-abiding for the duration of their presence are subject to deportation—has raised the stakes of getting accurate immigration advice and information even further. Under these conditions, it is thus particularly essential that applications for immigration relief are prepared with the highest possible level of expertise.
AB 638 (Caballero; 2017-2018) restricted legal provision of immigration services to attorneys and federally accredited immigration representatives. AB 1753 is based in large part on last session’s AB 638, which was introduced in 2017 by Assemblymember Caballero. AB 638 similarly made it unlawful to practice as an immigration consultant, and restricted the provision of immigration services to persons who were licensed to practice law and persons federally accredited to represent clients before the United States Department of Homeland Security or the United States Department of Justice on immigration matters. The bill passed out of this Committee on an 8-3 party-line vote with amendments to permit paralegals to provide immigration services to the extent they are permitted by other state laws governing the paralegal-attorney relationship, and to provide a one-year grace period before the provisions of the bill would take effect. Over the course of the legislative process, the bill became increasingly contentious, with strong support from immigrants’ rights groups and strong opposition from some immigrant groups, as well as trade associations for non-attorney immigration service providers. The bill ultimately failed on the floor of the Senate, receiving 13 Aye votes and 17 No votes, with 10 senators in abstention.
Concerns remain that eliminating a (sometimes) low-cost immigration resource in an already-overburdened legal sector will create a problematic gap in immigration services. Unlawful practice and inadequate representation notwithstanding, eliminating immigration consultants from the California service market will inevitably reduce the available resources for low-income individuals with simple immigration-related needs. According to a 2009 report by the Legal Services Corporation, 80-90% of low-income individuals in the United States with civil legal needs do not receive any help from a lawyer. (Documenting the Justice Gap in America: The Current Unmet Civil Legal Needs of Low-Income Americans (2009), Legal Services Corporation.) Since immigrants are not guaranteed the free services of a court-appointed attorney when they appear in immigration court, only 41% of the people appearing before immigration judges as of 2001 had lawyers, to say nothing of those filing immigration documents. (Lisa Getter, Few Applicants Succeed in Immigration Courts, Los Angeles Times, Apr. 15, 2001.) In the interim, the number of persons in the United States without documentation of lawful presence has increased substantially, expanding the size of the cohort in need of immigration services. A 2015 report by the Department of Homeland Security estimated that roughly 12 million undocumented persons live in the United States, an increase of 5 million compared to similar INS estimates in 2000. (Bryan Baker, Estimates of the Illegal Alien Population Residing in the United States: January 2015, Office of Immigration Statistics, Department of Homeland Security; Estimates of the Unauthorized Immigrant Population Residing in the United States: 1990 to 2000, Office of Policy and Planning, U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service.)
The number of affordable immigration lawyers is thus likely insufficient to satisfy the community needs relating to immigration services. Some of that unmet need is satisfied by immigration assistance provided by non-profit organizations, under the oversight of attorneys, with non-attorney employees who have received accreditation from the United States Department of Justice to represent immigrant clients before the Department of Homeland Security or the DOJ. California currently hosts roughly 260 such organizations, according to the most recent “Recognized Organizations and Accredited Representatives Roster” provided by the DOJ. These organizations, which provide low cost or no cost legal services and immigration assistance, nonetheless suffer from lengthy wait times and insufficient staff to accommodate community need. The elimination of 1,000 active immigration consultants, each of which can address the needs of up to 200 clients in a year, will further burden these already strapped immigration resources, potentially increasing erroneous self-filing of immigration documents. While it is likely that many of these clients may not qualify for immigration relief, improper filing due to language, logistical, or technological barriers to form completion and submission still poses a significant legal and financial risk to California’s population.
This bill weighs the possibility of insufficient immigration service capacity against the possibility of insufficient immigration service competency. The central tension of this bill involves balancing sufficient capacity to address the immigration-related needs of the community with the potential perils of incompetent or unscrupulous activity that stem from an under-regulated or under-qualified workforce. The author points out that the State of California has dramatically increased the service capacity for nonprofit organizations by increasing funding allocated to provide immigration services from $15 million during the 2015-2016 budget cycle to $79 million for the proposed 2018-2019 budget cycle. The sponsors, author, and supporters contend that building the accredited workforce employed by these nonprofits not only results in a better qualified and better supervised immigration service sector, but also helps to ensure that the cost of these services is low enough to provide sufficient access. The author also contends that because such a large percentage of undocumented immigrants do not qualify for immigration relief, it is more harmful to improperly file applications than to not file at all.
Nonetheless, it is likely that categorically eliminating a portion of the immigration service workforce will reduce the availability and accessibility of less complex immigration services for which the cost of an attorney is not warranted.
Author’s amendments. To mitigate the severity of this effect, the author has accepted an amendment to permit paralegals, who are subject to competency standards and regulated in terms of their relationships with attorneys the services they can offer, to provide immigration services if they are within the purview of their express practices and working under the supervision of an attorney. The author has also accepted an amendment to require the Secretary of State to provide to active immigration consultants, along with notification of prohibitions, information regarding the process for federal accreditation and a list of federally recognized immigration service providers in California where they may be able to seek employment.
The author has also agreed to accept amendments that require the Secretary of State to provide notice by January 1, 2020 to any active immigration consultant of the impending prohibition and its effective date, as well as a list of organizations in California that are recognized by the United States Department of Justice as eligible to provide representation on immigration matters and resources outlining the process for acquiring federal accreditation.
Finally, in order to provide notice to the public about the future effect of the bill, the author has agreed to require that currently active immigration consultants post a sign informing clients of the impending prohibition and its effective date.
The author may wish to consider an approach that allows certain immigration consultants to continue operating if they meet competency standards required for “legal document assistants.” Still, the author may wish to consider taking a less categorical approach to this issue involving expanded regulation of immigration consultant practice requirements that include competency standards and prohibit the use of titles like “immigration consultant” that may be misleading. One possible approach would be to require immigration consultants to, in addition to existing requirements, meet the qualifications for the profession of a “legal document assistant” as provided in Section 6400, et seq., of the Business and Professions Code. Because immigration consultants are primarily preparing legal documents (i.e. immigration relief applications), it is reasonable to expect similar proficiency, including possessing at least one of the following: 1) a high school diploma or general equivalency diploma, and two years of law-related experience under the supervision of a licensed attorney, 2) a baccalaureate degree in any field and one year of law-related experience under the supervision of a licensed attorney, 3) a certificate of completion from a paralegal program that is institutionally accredited but not approved by the American Bar Association, that requires successful completion of a minimum of 24 semester units, or the equivalent, in legal specialization courses, or 4) a certificate of completion from a paralegal program approved by the American Bar Association. In addition, legal document preparers must complete 15 hours of continuing legal education courses in the two-year period preceding renewal of registration. The author may also consider requiring some proficiency or educational standards for translating legal documents in the event an immigration consultant is performing these duties. Necessitating these competency standards, changing the misleading title of “immigration consultant,” and enhancing enforcement to eliminate illegal practice would go a long way to resolving many of the issues the authors raise regarding the dangers of this profession while reducing the impact on the availability of immigration resources.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters of the bill believe that the stakes in the context of immigration law are too high to entrust to an industry that lacks competency standards, and that the lines between preparation of immigration documents and provision of legal advice are too nebulous to expect a profession predicated on legal form preparation to recognize and refrain from doing the latter. Supporters also contend that the title “immigration consultant” is inherently misleading and carries an unsubstantiated implication of expertise that is especially likely to confuse immigrants who are unfamiliar with United States immigration procedures and may face language barriers.
The Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (CHIRLA), California’s largest immigrant rights organization and a co-sponsor of the bill, argues:
Completing what some may consider basic immigration applications requires the provision of legal advice. Assessing eligibility for immigration benefits requires a thorough understanding of U.S. immigration law. Answering questions such as which form to use, or how a customer should answer a question on a form, requires training and legal judgment. Immigration consultants have a very limited scope and little to offer a customer. Thus, consultants frequently cross the line into the unauthorized practice of law, dispensing legal advice to individuals desperate for immigration relief.
The harm that consultants inflict on immigrants cannot be overstated. The fees of many consultants are comparable or higher than market rates of immigration attorneys in private practice. Consultants often charge substantial fees for form preparation that nonprofit legal programs offer at low-cost or free of charge. Botched immigration forms also leave immigrants vulnerable to deportation, tearing apart families after they have lost years of hard-earned savings. If a case can be salvaged, the burden falls disproportionately on resource-strapped nonprofit organizations. Meanwhile, consultants rarely face consequences for defrauding customers or botch applications that expose immigrants to deportation proceedings. Victims often discover the harm years after their initial contact with the consultant. By that time, they are afraid to report unscrupulous consultants out of fear of deportation.
The California Department of Justice similarly argues:
The conditions that prompted the need for immigration consultants have changed, and now the Act has become problematic for California consumers. First, federal law provides more protection than the Act. For example, federal law does not recognize "immigration consultants" or permit non-attorneys to render many of the services that the Act allows. Second, the title of "immigration consultant" [is] misleading because these individuals are not authorized to provide consultation services of any kind. According to the California State Bar, even the preparation and filing of immigration applications by nonattorneys may fall within California's definition of the unauthorized practice of law. AB 1753 would resolve this problem by making the law very clear that it is unlawful for anyone other than licensed attorneys or individuals authorized by federal law to represent individuals in immigration matters or to charge for related services. Lastly, the complexity of immigration law makes it unclear when an "immigration consultant" is engaging in the unauthorized practice of law. The mere act of deciding which form or forms to complete on behalf of an immigrant involves complex legal questions that can affect whether an immigrant is ultimately deported or authorized to remain in the United States.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents of the bill are concerned that eliminating immigration consultants, in addition to putting hard-working Californians out of work, will also create a gap in low-cost immigration services and force immigrants to choose between paying for expensive legal services that are already stretched thin and preparing immigration forms on their own. Opponents also assert that prohibiting the lawful practice of immigration consulting will not eliminate the “bad actors” who harm the public and will instead funnel immigrants to unscrupulous underground networks of immigration service providers who would lack bond accountability.
The National Notary Association argues:
[The bill] is misguided for the following reasons:
- Prohibiting the practice of immigration consulting will eliminate a low-cost option for immigrants seeking to file for a change or adjustment to their immigration status, making it more difficult for them to emerge from the shadows and openly contribute to the economy, life and culture of the state of California.
- The only other legal, low-cost option for immigrants comes from non-profits, to whom immigration consultants work very closely with. However, as the circumstances at the border worsen, non-profits deal with massive waiting lists and funding shortages. Often an immigration consultant is the only available choice within the needed time frame.
- Prohibiting anyone from engaging in the business of an immigration consultant for compensation will not root out the bad actors who harm the public. In fact, AB 1753 could send more immigrants into the hands of these notarios by removing one of only two legal, low-cost options for them.
- Repealing the current immigration consultant act will displace hundreds of honest and upstanding immigration consultants who provide legitimate and valuable nonlegal immigration assistance to a segment of California’s immigrant population.
The Latin American Immigration Association (Uniendo Familias), an industry trade organization representing non-attorney immigration assistance providers throughout the Unitied States, further argues:
The idea of punishing an entire group for the bad actions of a few in fundamentally wrong. Passage of AB 1753 in its current language would end the careers and professional livelihood of nearly 1000 registered and bonded immigration consultants. And for what purpose? For the bad actions of a few? Every profession has a few “bad apples”. This includes attorneys, insurance agents, tax preparers, real estate agents and many others. If a profession is conducted by a human being, there are always going to be a few “bad apples”. We do not however protect the public by eliminating these valuable and needed professionals. We protect the public by enforcing existing laws and by aggressively fining and prosecuting those who violate the law.
Repealing the current Immigration Consultants Act will also repeal the mandatory $100,000 surety bond requirement, which will in turn eliminate an effective means of financial protection that is currently available to immigrants injured in any way by an immigration consultant. A surety bond is effective in protecting the public, because the surety must pay losses on the bond even if the immigration consultant is unable to pay damages that may be awarded by a court.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation (co-sponsor)
Central American Resource Center (co-sponsor)
Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights (co-sponsor)
County of Los Angeles (co-sponsor)
ACT For Women And Girls
American Academy of Pediatrics, California
American Civil Liberties Union of California
Bet Tzedek Legal Services
California Catholic Conference
California Collaborative for Immigrant Justice
California Department of Justice
California State Council of Service Employees (SEIU)
Centro La Familia Advocacy Services
Education and Leadership Foundation
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Inner City Struggle
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
OneJustice
The Fresno Center
United Food and Commercial Workers, Western States Council
Western Center on Law & Poverty, Inc.
Oppose
Latin American Immigration Association
National Notary Association
Numerous Individuals
Analysis Prepared by: Landon Klein / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):