AB 1296: Joint Enforcement Strike Force on the Underground Economy: Labor Enforcement Task Force.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-08
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 8, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 626, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 8, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 26, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 14, 2019 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Joint Rule 61 suspended. (Ayes 29. Noes 8.) |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 6, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (August 30). |
| Aug 19, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Aug 13, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (July 10). |
| Jul 2, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on GOV. & F. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (July 2). Re-referred to Com. on GOV. & F. |
| Jun 21, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jun 12, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on PUB. S. and GOV. & F. |
| May 30, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 29, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 8, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 0.) (April 22). |
| Apr 2, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on REV. & TAX. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (April 2). Re-referred to Com. on REV. & TAX. |
| Mar 11, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on PUB. S. and REV. & TAX. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 14, 2019 | AB 1296 Gonzalez Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 13, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1296 Gonzalez By Galgiani | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 19, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 10, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Governance and Finance |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Governance and Finance] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| May 29, 2019 | AB 1296 Gonzalez Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Revenue and Taxation |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Revenue and Taxation] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1296
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Amended Ver:September 10, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Expands the membership, duties, and authority of the Joint Enforcement Strike Force on the Underground Economy.
The Senate Amendments:
- Add the Department of Justice (DOJ), the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, and the Franchise Tax Board to the required membership of the Joint Enforcement Strike Force on the Underground Economy.
- Authorize the Joint Enforcement Strike Force on the Underground Economy to invite other specified agencies to serve in an advisory capacity to the task force.
- Expand the duties of the strike force to include enforcement activities regarding labor, tax, insurance, and licensing law violators operating in the underground economy and authorize the provision of investigative leads to participating agencies.
- Provide for the exchange of certain information between strike force member agencies and for the confidentiality of such information, as specified.
- Authorize a member agency of the Joint Enforcement Strike Force on the Underground Economy to request specified information from the Employment Development Department, the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, and the Franchise Tax Board and would require those agencies to provide such information for prescribed enforcement purposes.
- Require DOJ to maintain two multiagency Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program investigative teams, formerly known as the Tax Recovery and Criminal Enforcement Task Force (TRaCE), in Sacramento and Los Angeles and requires those teams to continue their collaboration for the recovery of lost revenues to the state by investigating and prosecuting criminal offenses in the state's underground economy.
- Double joint this bill with AB 593 (Carillo) and AB 1340 (Chiu) of the current legislative session in order to avoid chaptering issues.
- Make other technical, non-substantive changes.
COMMENTS:
According to the Author:
"In the 'underground economy,' many workers go without basic rights and workplace protections, law-abiding businesses are put in a competitive disadvantage and the well-being of consumers are put at risk. Furthermore, due to the nature of underground activities, tax revenues that would fund education, public safety agencies and infrastructure projects are lost and uncollected. Assembly Bill 1296 would strengthen the state's efforts to combat the underground economy by codifying the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy (TRUE) Crime Enforcement Program under the California Department of Justice. This bill will allow agencies to pool law enforcement resources, enable collaboration and data sharing between participating agencies, and facilitate the efficient prosecution of violations. As a result, the TRUE Crime Enforcement Program will protect vulnerable workers and communities, punish bad actors, and help recover millions of lost tax revenue."
Arguments in Support:
According to Xavier Becerra, the Attorney General of the State of California: "According to a 2013 University of California at Los Angeles Labor Center report, the state's underground economy generates between $60 to $140 billion in revenue annually. An estimated $8.5 billion in corporate, personal, sales and use taxes go uncollected each year. To help respond to this problem, several state agencies formed a pilot program in 2014 to investigate and prosecute the most egregious felony-level multijurisdictional underground economic crimes from a tax prospective. Participating agencies include the Department of Justice, the Department of Tax and Fee Administration, the Franchise Tax Board, and the Employment Development Department.
"The Attorney General is proud to sponsor AB 1296. The bill is an important measure that would substantially strengthen the state's efforts to combat and deter underground economic crimes in California. Our workers, business owners, consumers, and taxpayers would be the biggest beneficiaries of a robust program."
Arguments in Opposition:
None.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- DOJ: Costs of $6.8 million (and 46.0 personnel) in FY 2019-20, $9.5 million (and 46.0 personnel) in FY 2020-21, $11.4 million (and 52.0 personnel) in 2021-22, $14.8 million (and 64.0 personnel) in FY 2022-23, and $14 million (and 64.0 personnel) in FY 2023-24 and annually thereafter. (General Fund)
- Department of Tax and Fee Administration: Costs of $61,000 in FY 2019-20, $626,000 in FY 2020-21, $1.2 million in FY 2021-22, $1.6 million in FY 2022-23, and $1.9 in FY 2023-24 and annually thereafter. (General Fund)
- Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO): Absorbable workload to study and report on the effectiveness of the TRUE program.
- Revenue recovery: Unknown, potentially-major recovery of tax revenue in the millions of dollars. The Department of Tax and Fee Administration, for example, estimates that the portion of the TRUE program revenues attributable to the department would be approximately $7.8 million once all three new locations are fully operational. (See Staff Comments)
VOTES:
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 8-0-0
YES: Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Bauer-Kahan, Diep, Kamlager-Dove, Quirk, Santiago, Wicks
ASM REVENUE AND TAXATION: 10-0-1
YES: Burke, Brough, Chu, Gray, Mayes, Melendez, Mullin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Luz Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Ting
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0-3
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Patterson, Petrie‑Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cooley, Eduardo Garcia, Ting
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 10, 2019
CONSULTANT: Matthew Fleming / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0002436
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1296 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1296
Amended: 9/10/19 in Senate
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 7/2/19
AYES: Skinner, Moorlach, Bradford, Jackson, Mitchell, Morrell, Wiener
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 7/10/19
AYES: McGuire, Moorlach, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Nielsen, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 5/29/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program
SOURCE: Attorney General Xavier Becerra
DIGEST:
This bill establishes the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement (TRUE) Program.
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/10/19 (1) narrow the scope the TRUE Program; (2) allow the Joint Enforcement Strike Force on the Underground Economy (JESF) to work with the Department of Justice (DOJ); and, (3) add double-jointing language with AB 593 (Carrillo) and AB 1340 (Chiu).
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/6/19 change the Legislative Analyst’s Office reporting deadline and clarify the reporting requirement for unauthorized disclosure that captures both the TRUE program and the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement (TRaCE) program.
Existing law:
- Allows taxes on or measured by income to be imposed on persons, corporations, or other entities as prescribed by law. (Cal. Const., Art. XIII, sec. 26.)
- Contains various provisions criminalizing tax evasion. (See e.g. Rev. & Tax Code, §§ 7152-7153.5 [false and fraudulent returns regarding sales and use taxes], 19701 et seq. [income tax evasion].)
- Establishes the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team as a pilot program. (Gov. Code, § 15912.)
- States that the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team shall include all of the following state entities:
- Franchise Tax Board;
- Department of Justice;
- State Board of Equalization; and,
- Employment Development Department. (Gov. Code, § 15914 (a).)
- Allows the following agencies to participate in the pilot program in an advisory capacity to the team:
- California Health and Human Services Agency;
- Department of Consumer Affairs;
- Department of Industrial Relations;
- Department of Insurance; and,
- Department of Motor Vehicles. (Gov. Code, § 15914 (b).)
- States that Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team is to serve the best interests of the state by combating criminal tax evasion associated with the underground economy, directs the team to do all of the following:
- Develop a plan for a central intake process and organizational structure to document, review, and evaluate data and complaints;
- Evaluate the benefits of a processing center to receive and analyze data, share complaints, and research leads from the input of specified agencies; and
- Provide participating and nonparticipating agencies with investigative leads where collaboration opportunities exist for felony-level criminal investigations, including, but not limited to, referring leads to agencies with appropriate enforcement jurisdiction. (Gov. Code, § 15918.)
- Establishes a sunset date of January 1, 2019, for Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team pilot program. (Gov. Code, § 15924.)
- States that the director of the Employment Development Department, or his or her designee, shall serve as Chairperson of JESF. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (a).)
- Specifies that the strike force shall include, but not be limited to, representatives of the Employment Development Department, the Department of Consumer Affairs, the Department of Industrial Relations, and the Office of Criminal Justice Planning. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (a).)
- Provides that other agencies that are not part of the administration, such as the Franchise Tax Board, the State Board of Equalization, and the Department of Justice, are encouraged to participate in the strike force. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (a).)
- Specifies that JESF has the following duties:
- To facilitate and encourage the development and sharing of information by the participating agencies necessary to combat the underground economy;
- To improve the coordination of activities among the participating agencies;
- To develop methods to pool, focus, and target the enforcement resources of the participating agencies in order to deter tax evasion and maximize recoveries from blatant tax evaders and violators of cash-pay reporting laws; and,
- To reduce enforcement costs wherever possible by eliminating duplicative audits and investigations. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (b).)
- States that JESF shall also be empowered to:
- Form joint enforcement teams when appropriate to utilize the collective investigative and enforcement capabilities of the participating members;
- Establish committees and rules of procedure to carry out the activities of the strike force;
- To solicit the cooperation and participation of district attorneys and other state and local agencies in carrying out the objectives of the strike force;
- Establish procedures for soliciting referrals from the public, including, but not limited to, an advertised telephone hotline;
- Develop procedures for improved information sharing among the participating agencies, such as shared automated information data base systems, the use of a common business identification number, and a centralized debt collection system;
- Develop procedures to permit the participating agencies to use more efficient and effective civil sanctions in lieu of criminal actions wherever possible; and,
- Evaluate, based on its activities, the need for any statutory change to accomplish specified objectives. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (c).)
- Specifies that JESF shall report to the Governor and the Legislature annually during the period of its existence. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (d).)
This bill:
- Allows DOJ to maintain the two multiagency TRUE Program investigative teams in Sacramento and Los Angeles.
- Establishes that the TRUE Program will collaborate with the DOJ, the Employment Development Department, the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration, and the Franchise Tax Board.
- States that JESF will begin to include the DOJ, which will allow DOJ to access any information regarding any felony level criminal investigations.
- Includes double-jointing language with AB 593 (Carrillo) and AB 1340 (Chiu).
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Department of Justice. Costs of $6.8 million (and 46.0 personnel) in FY 2019-20, $9.5 million (and 46.0 personnel) in FY 2020-21, $11.4 million (and 52.0 personnel) in 2021-22, $14.8 million (and 64.0 personnel) in FY 2022-23, and $14 million (and 64.0 personnel) in FY 2023-24 and annually thereafter. (General Fund)
- Department of Tax and Fee Administration. Costs of $61,000 in FY 2019-20, $626,000 in FY 2020-21, $1.2 million in FY 2021-22, $1.6 million in FY 2022-23, and $1.9 in FY 2023-24 and annually thereafter. (General Fund)
- Legislative Analyst’s Office. Absorbable workload to study and report on the effectiveness of the TRUE program.
- Revenue recovery. Unknown, potentially-major recovery of tax revenue in the millions of dollars. The Department of Tax and Fee Administration, for example, estimates that the portion of the TRUE program revenues attributable to the department would be approximately $7.8 million once all three new locations are fully operational.
Attorney General Xavier Becerra (source)
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Landscape Contractors Association
California State Council of Laborers
California Statewide Law Enforcement Association
California Teamsters
California-Nevada Conference of Operating Engineers
Engineers and Scientists of California, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO
Inlandboatmen’s Union of the Pacific
Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers of America
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 5/29/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooley, Eduardo Garcia, Ting
Prepared by: Jennifer Kaku / PUB. S. /
9/11/19 20:23:09
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1296 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1296
Amended: 9/6/19 in Senate
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 7/2/19
AYES: Skinner, Moorlach, Bradford, Jackson, Mitchell, Morrell, Wiener
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 7/10/19
AYES: McGuire, Moorlach, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Nielsen, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 5/29/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program
SOURCE: Attorney General Xavier Becerra
DIGEST:
This bill establishes the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement (TRUE) Program.
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/6/19 change the Legislative Analyst’s Office reporting deadline and clarify the reporting requirement for unauthorized disclosure that captures both the TRUE program and the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement (TRaCE) program.
Existing law:
- Allows taxes on or measured by income to be imposed on persons, corporations, or other entities as prescribed by law. (Cal. Const., Art. XIII, sec. 26.)
- Contains various provisions criminalizing tax evasion. (See e.g. Rev. & Tax Code, §§ 7152-7153.5 [false and fraudulent returns regarding sales and use taxes], 19701 et seq. [income tax evasion].)
- Establishes the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team as a pilot program. (Gov. Code, § 15912.)
- States that the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team shall include all of the following state entities:
- Franchise Tax Board;
- Department of Justice;
- State Board of Equalization; and,
- Employment Development Department. (Gov. Code, § 15914 (a).)
- Allows the following agencies to participate in the pilot program in an advisory capacity to the team:
- California Health and Human Services Agency;
- Department of Consumer Affairs;
- Department of Industrial Relations;
- Department of Insurance; and,
- Department of Motor Vehicles. (Gov. Code, § 15914 (b).)
- States that Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team is to serve the best interests of the state by combating criminal tax evasion associated with the underground economy, directs the team to do all of the following:
- Develop a plan for a central intake process and organizational structure to document, review, and evaluate data and complaints;
- Evaluate the benefits of a processing center to receive and analyze data, share complaints, and research leads from the input of specified agencies; and
- Provide participating and nonparticipating agencies with investigative leads where collaboration opportunities exist for felony-level criminal investigations, including, but not limited to, referring leads to agencies with appropriate enforcement jurisdiction. (Gov. Code, § 15918.)
- Establishes a sunset date of January 1, 2019, for Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team pilot program. (Gov. Code, § 15924.)
- States that the director of the Employment Development Department, or his or her designee, shall serve as Chairperson of the Joint Enforcement Strike Force on the Underground Economy (JESF). (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (a).)
- Specifies that the strike force shall include, but not be limited to, representatives of the Employment Development Department, the Department of Consumer Affairs, the Department of Industrial Relations, and the Office of Criminal Justice Planning. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (a).)
- Provides that other agencies that are not part of the administration, such as the Franchise Tax Board, the State Board of Equalization, and the Department of Justice, are encouraged to participate in the strike force. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (a).)
- Specifies that JESF has the following duties:
- To facilitate and encourage the development and sharing of information by the participating agencies necessary to combat the underground economy;
- To improve the coordination of activities among the participating agencies;
- To develop methods to pool, focus, and target the enforcement resources of the participating agencies in order to deter tax evasion and maximize recoveries from blatant tax evaders and violators of cash-pay reporting laws; and,
- To reduce enforcement costs wherever possible by eliminating duplicative audits and investigations. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (b).)
- States that JESF shall also be empowered to:
- Form joint enforcement teams when appropriate to utilize the collective investigative and enforcement capabilities of the participating members;
- Establish committees and rules of procedure to carry out the activities of the strike force;
- To solicit the cooperation and participation of district attorneys and other state and local agencies in carrying out the objectives of the strike force;
- Establish procedures for soliciting referrals from the public, including, but not limited to, an advertised telephone hotline;
- Develop procedures for improved information sharing among the participating agencies, such as shared automated information data base systems, the use of a common business identification number, and a centralized debt collection system;
- Develop procedures to permit the participating agencies to use more efficient and effective civil sanctions in lieu of criminal actions wherever possible; and,
- Evaluate, based on its activities, the need for any statutory change to accomplish specified objectives. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (c).)
- Specifies that JESF shall report to the Governor and the Legislature annually during the period of its existence. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (d).)
This bill:
- Establishes the TRUE Program in the Department of Justice to combat underground economic activities through a multiagency collaboration, which include all of the following:
- To protect workers, law-abiding businesses, and consumers by bringing justice to unscrupulous businesses operating in the state’s underground economy.
- To recover significant lost revenues to the state by prosecuting egregious, felony-level tax and fee evasion crimes in the state’s underground economy.
- To facilitate information sharing among participating agencies to assess leads, conduct investigations, and prosecute felony-level tax and fee evasion crimes in the underground economy.
- To support multiagency investigative teams in every region of the state.
- Specifies that the TRUE Task Force shall include an executive board to ensure efficient and effective multiagency collaboration in furtherance of this act. The executive board shall consist of the following voting members:
- A representative from the Department of Justice designated by the Attorney General to facilitate and oversee the multiagency collaboration pursuant to this Act.
- A representative from the Division of Law Enforcement at the Department of Justice;
- A representative from the Criminal Law Division at the Department of Justice;
- A representative from the Investigations and Special Operations Bureau at the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration;
- A representative from the Criminal Investigation Bureau at the Franchise Tax Board; and
- A representative from the Investigation Division at the Employment Development Department.
- Authorizes the following state agencies to join the executive board in an advisory capacity:
- The California Health and Human Services Agency.
- The Department of Consumer Affairs.
- The Department of Industrial Relations.
- The Department of Insurance.
- The Department of Motor Vehicles.
- The Department of California Highway Patrol.
- The Bureau of Cannabis Control.
- The Contractors’ State License Board.
- As well as other state, federal, and local agencies.
- States that the TRUE task force shall meet as needed, but shall meet at least quarterly, to conduct its business.
- Establishes teams in Sacramento, Los Angeles, San Diego, the San Francisco Bay Area, and Fresno.
- Requires the LAO, by July 1, 2024, to submit a report to the Legislature that includes an analysis of the effectiveness of the program, along with recommendations to improve the program.
- Allows the use and exchange of confidential information by the TRUE program, as well as the TRaCE program.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Department of Justice: Costs of $6.8 million (and 46.0 personnel) in FY 2019-20, $9.5 million (and 46.0 personnel) in FY 2020-21, $11.4 million (and 52.0 personnel) in 2021-22, $14.8 million (and 64.0 personnel) in FY 2022-23, and $14 million (and 64.0 personnel) in FY 2023-24 and annually thereafter. (General Fund)
- Department of Tax and Fee Administration: Costs of $61,000 in FY 2019-20, $626,000 in FY 2020-21, $1.2 million in FY 2021-22, $1.6 million in FY 2022-23, and $1.9 in FY 2023-24 and annually thereafter. (General Fund)
- Legislative Analyst’s Office: Absorbable workload to study and report on the effectiveness of the TRUE program.
- Revenue recovery: Unknown, potentially-major recovery of tax revenue in the millions of dollars. The Department of Tax and Fee Administration, for example, estimates that the portion of the TRUE program revenues attributable to the department would be approximately $7.8 million once all three new locations are fully operational.
Attorney General Xavier Becerra (source)
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Landscape Contractors Association
California State Council of Laborers
California Statewide Law Enforcement Association
California Teamsters
California-Nevada Conference of Operating Engineers
Engineers and Scientists of California, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO
Inlandboatmen’s Union of the Pacific
Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers of America
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 5/29/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooley, Eduardo Garcia, Ting
Prepared by: Jennifer Kaku / PUB. S. /
9/9/19 18:26:07
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1296 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1296
Amended: 8/13/19 in Senate
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 7-0, 7/2/19
AYES: Skinner, Moorlach, Bradford, Jackson, Mitchell, Morrell, Wiener
SENATE GOVERNANCE & FIN. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 7/10/19
AYES: McGuire, Moorlach, Beall, Hertzberg, Hurtado, Nielsen, Wiener
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 5/29/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program
DIGEST:
This bill establishes the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement (TRUE) Program.
Existing law:
- Allows taxes on or measured by income to be imposed on persons, corporations, or other entities as prescribed by law. (Cal. Const., Art. XIII, sec. 26.)
- Contains various provisions criminalizing tax evasion. (See e.g. Rev. & Tax Code, §§ 7152-7153.5 [false and fraudulent returns regarding sales and use taxes], 19701 et seq. [income tax evasion].)
- Establishes the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team as a pilot program. (Gov. Code, § 15912.)
- States that the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team shall include all of the following state entities:
- Franchise Tax Board;
- Department of Justice;
- State Board of Equalization; and,
- Employment Development Department. (Gov. Code, § 15914 (a).)
- Allows the following agencies to participate in the pilot program in an advisory capacity to the team:
- California Health and Human Services Agency;
- Department of Consumer Affairs;
- Department of Industrial Relations;
- Department of Insurance; and,
- Department of Motor Vehicles. (Gov. Code, § 15914 (b).)
- States that Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team is to serve the best interests of the state by combating criminal tax evasion associated with the underground economy, directs the team to do all of the following:
- Develop a plan for a central intake process and organizational structure to document, review, and evaluate data and complaints;
- Evaluate the benefits of a processing center to receive and analyze data, share complaints, and research leads from the input of specified agencies; and
- Provide participating and nonparticipating agencies with investigative leads where collaboration opportunities exist for felony-level criminal investigations, including, but not limited to, referring leads to agencies with appropriate enforcement jurisdiction. (Gov. Code, § 15918.)
- Establishes a sunset date of January 1, 2019, for Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team pilot program. (Gov. Code, § 15924.)
- States that the director of the Employment Development Department, or his or her designee, shall serve as Chairperson of the Joint Enforcement Strike Force on the Underground Economy (JESF). (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (a).)
- Specifies that the strike force shall include, but not be limited to, representatives of the Employment Development Department, the Department of Consumer Affairs, the Department of Industrial Relations, and the Office of Criminal Justice Planning. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (a).)
- Provides that other agencies that are not part of the administration, such as the Franchise Tax Board, the State Board of Equalization, and the Department of Justice, are encouraged to participate in the strike force. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (a).)
- Specifies that JESF has the following duties:
- To facilitate and encourage the development and sharing of information by the participating agencies necessary to combat the underground economy;
- To improve the coordination of activities among the participating agencies;
- To develop methods to pool, focus, and target the enforcement resources of the participating agencies in order to deter tax evasion and maximize recoveries from blatant tax evaders and violators of cash-pay reporting laws; and,
- To reduce enforcement costs wherever possible by eliminating duplicative audits and investigations. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (b).)
- States that JESF shall also be empowered to:
- Form joint enforcement teams when appropriate to utilize the collective investigative and enforcement capabilities of the participating members;
- Establish committees and rules of procedure to carry out the activities of the strike force;
- To solicit the cooperation and participation of district attorneys and other state and local agencies in carrying out the objectives of the strike force;
- Establish procedures for soliciting referrals from the public, including, but not limited to, an advertised telephone hotline;
- Develop procedures for improved information sharing among the participating agencies, such as shared automated information data base systems, the use of a common business identification number, and a centralized debt collection system;
- Develop procedures to permit the participating agencies to use more efficient and effective civil sanctions in lieu of criminal actions wherever possible; and,
- Evaluate, based on its activities, the need for any statutory change to accomplish specified objectives. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (c).)
- Specifies that JESF shall report to the Governor and the Legislature annually during the period of its existence. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (d).)
This bill:
- Establishes the TRUE Program in the Department of Justice to combat underground economic activities through a multiagency collaboration, which include all of the following:
- To protect workers, law-abiding businesses, and consumers by bringing justice to unscrupulous businesses operating in the state’s underground economy.
- To recover significant lost revenues to the state by prosecuting egregious, felony-level tax and fee evasion crimes in the state’s underground economy.
- To facilitate information sharing among participating agencies to assess leads, conduct investigations, and prosecute felony-level tax and fee evasion crimes in the underground economy.
- To support multiagency investigative teams in every region of the state.
- Specifies that the TRUE Task Force shall include an executive board to ensure efficient and effective multiagency collaboration in furtherance of this act. The executive board shall consist of the following voting members:
- A representative from the Department of Justice designated by the Attorney General to facilitate and oversee the multiagency collaboration pursuant to this Act.
- A representative from the Division of Law Enforcement at the Department of Justice;
- A representative from the Criminal Law Division at the Department of Justice;
- A representative from the Investigations and Special Operations Bureau at the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration;
- A representative from the Criminal Investigation Bureau at the Franchise Tax Board; and
- A representative from the Investigation Division at the Employment Development Department.
- Authorizes the following state agencies to join the executive board in an advisory capacity:
- The California Health and Human Services Agency.
- The Department of Consumer Affairs.
- The Department of Industrial Relations.
- The Department of Insurance.
- The Department of Motor Vehicles.
- The Department of California Highway Patrol.
- The Bureau of Cannabis Control.
- The Contractors’ State License Board.
- As well as other state, federal, and local agencies.
- States that the TRUE task force shall meet as needed, but shall meet at least quarterly, to conduct its business.
- Establishes teams in Sacramento, Los Angeles, San Diego, the San Francisco Bay Area, and Fresno.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Department of Justice: Costs of $6.8 million (and 46.0 personnel) in FY 2019-20, $9.5 million (and 46.0 personnel) in FY 2020-21, $11.4 million (and 52.0 personnel) in 2021-22, $14.8 million (and 64.0 personnel) in FY 2022-23, and $14 million (and 64.0 personnel) in FY 2023-24 and annually thereafter. (General Fund)
- Department of Tax and Fee Administration: Costs of $61,000 in FY 2019-20, $626,000 in FY 2020-21, $1.2 million in FY 2021-22, $1.6 million in FY 2022-23, and $1.9 in FY 2023-24 and annually thereafter. (General Fund)
- Legislative Analyst’s Office: Absorbable workload to study and report on the effectiveness of the TRUE program.
- Revenue recovery: Unknown, potentially-major recovery of tax revenue in the millions of dollars. The Department of Tax and Fee Administration, for example, estimates that the portion of the TRUE program revenues attributable to the department would be approximately $7.8 million once all three new locations are fully operational.
Attorney General Xavier Becerra
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Landscape Contractors Association
California State Council of Laborers
California Statewide Law Enforcement Association
California Teamsters
California-Nevada Conference of Operating Engineers
Engineers and Scientists of California, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO
Inlandboatmen’s Union of the Pacific
Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers of America
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/19)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 5/29/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooley, Eduardo Garcia, Ting
Prepared by: Jennifer Kaku / PUB. S. /
9/1/19 14:20:35
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1296 (Gonzalez) - Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program
Version: August 13, 2019 | Policy Vote: PUB. S. 7 - 0, GOV. & F. 7 - 0 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 19, 2019 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
Bill Summary:
AB 1296 would establish the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program (TRUE program) within the Department of Justice (DOJ).
Fiscal Impact:
- DOJ: Costs of $6.8 million (and 46.0 personnel) in FY 2019-20, $9.5 million (and 46.0 personnel) in FY 2020-21, $11.4 million (and 52.0 personnel) in 2021-22, $14.8 million (and 64.0 personnel) in FY 2022-23, and $14 million (and 64.0 personnel) in FY 2023-24 and annually thereafter. (General Fund)
- Department of Tax and Fee Administration: Costs of $61,000 in FY 2019-20, $626,000 in FY 2020-21, $1.2 million in FY 2021-22, $1.6 million in FY 2022-23, and $1.9 in FY 2023-24 and annually thereafter. (General Fund)
- Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO): Absorbable workload to study and report on the effectiveness of the TRUE program.
- Revenue recovery: Unknown, potentially-major recovery of tax revenue in the millions of dollars. The Department of Tax and Fee Administration, for example, estimates that the portion of the TRUE program revenues attributable to the department would be approximately $7.8 million once all three new locations are fully operational. (See Staff Comments)
Background:
According to the analysis of this bill by the Senate Committee on Governance and Finance:
In 1994, Governor Pete Wilson signed executive order W-66-93, creating the Joint Economic Strike Force (JESF), which was “responsible for enhancing the development and sharing of information necessary to combat the underground economy, to improve the coordination of enforcement activities, and to develop methods to pool, focus, and target enforcement resources.” JESF is led by the Employment Development Department (EDD) and housed within its Underground Economy Operations, and is comprised of the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA), agencies within DCA, such as the Bureau of Automotive Repair (BAR) and the Contractors State License Board (CSLB). It also includes the Franchise Tax Board (FTB), the Board of Equalization (now the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration or CDTFA), the Department of Insurance (CDI), the Department of Justice (DOJ), the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), the Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC), the United States Department of Labor, and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). JESF was codified by the Legislature (SB 1490, Johnston, 1994), and publishes an annual report documenting its efforts. However, JESF has not published an annual report since 2017.
In 2005, Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger established the Economic and Employment Enforcement Coalition (EEEC), housed in DIR, and comprised of investigators and auditors from DIR’s Division of Labor Standards Enforcement and Occupational Safety and Health, and includes EDD, DCA, BAR, CSLB, CDTFA, CDI, DOJ, and ABC. Governor Brown renamed the EEEC the DIR Labor Enforcement Task Force (LETF), effective January 1, 2012. LETF’s mission is “to combat the underground economy in order to ensure safe working conditions and proper payment of wages for workers; to create an environment in which legitimate businesses can thrive; and to support the collection of all California taxes, fees, and penalties due from employers.” LETF last published data for the first quarter of 2018. Additionally, EDD receives audit leads from the IRS through the Questionable Employment Tax Practices (QETP) Program.
RRaCE and TRaCE. In 2013, the Legislature enacted the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team Act, which created the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement (RRaCE) team to complement the state’s underground economy enforcement efforts (AB 576, V.M Perez). The team included FTB, BOE, and DOJ, and also allowed the Health and Human Services Agency, DCA, DIR, EDD, and the Department of Motor Vehicles to participate. While the state already had the LETF within DIR, and the JESF led by EDD, the Legislature established RRaCE with its own specific goal, which is to “serve the best interests of the state by combating criminal tax evasion associated with the underground economy.” AB 576 established RRaCE as a pilot program, which expired on January 1, 2019.
When Governor Brown signed AB 576, he included a signing message noting the lack of a lead agency, and directed DIR to take the lead. However, BOE and DOJ created TRaCE (Tax Recovery and Criminal Enforcement) to pursue identical aims. In 2017, the Legislature enacted the Taxpayer Transparency and Fairness Act of 2017, which created the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA), and shifted all of the BOE’s statutory tax administration functions to the newly formed Department (AB 102, Committee on Budget).
Proposed Law:
This bill would:
- Establish the TRUE program in DOJ to combat underground economic activities through a multiagency collaboration to, among other things, pool resources, collaborate and share data, prosecute violations, and recover state revenue lost to the underground economy, as specified.
- Require TRUE program investigative teams to be located in Sacramento, Los Angeles, San Diego, the San Francisco Bay area, and Fresno.
- Establish a TRUE program executive board to ensure multiagency collaboration and to oversee the investigative teams, as provided.
- Allow, and in certain circumstances require, the exchange of confidential information, as provided. Information exchanged pursuant to these provisions would retain its confidential status, as specified.
- Require DOJ, in consultation with the executive board of the program, to submit to the Legislature a report by July 1, 2021, and annually thereafter, that includes specific information relating to the program.
- Require the LAO to, by July 1, 2026, submit a report to the Legislature that includes an analysis of the effectiveness of the program, as specified, along with recommendations to improve the program.
- Permit the use of the information obtained in the administration of the Unemployment Insurance Code to enable the TRUE program to carry out its duties.
Related Legislation:
SB 1272 (Galgiani, 2018) would have established the TRaCE Task Force within DOJ to combat underground economic activities. SB 1272 was vetoed by the Governor, who stated that the bill codifies a task force that is already operational via MOU and establishes a permanent program within the Department of Justice with an ill-defined and potentially unlimited scope of operations” and that he was “reluctant to do this without additional and more detailed scrutiny through the budget process.”
AB 576 (V.M. Pérez, Ch. 614, Stats. 2013) created the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team and pilot program (until January 1, 2019) to collaborate in combating criminal tax evasion associated with the underground economy. The pilot program allowed team members to exchange information for the purpose of investigating criminal tax evasion associated with the underground economy.
SB 1185 (Price, 2012) would have created a pilot project for centralizing the investigative efforts of several governmental agencies in order to combat the underground economy. SB 1185 was held on the Suspense File of the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
Staff Comments:
Determining to what extent the actual revenues under the TRaCE task force and estimated increase in revenues under the TRUE program are attributable at least partially to revenue that would have been received without these programs is difficult. Reporting of noncompliance is highly uncertain, and the enactment of this measure may not result in increased reporting of underground economic activity, especially because the current teams, although based in Los Angeles and Sacramento, investigate cases statewide. In addition, considering that TRaCE, and eventually TRUE program, cases are investigations that proceed through the criminal court process, it is difficult, generally, to estimate future revenues.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON GOVERNANCE AND FINANCE
Senator Mike McGuire, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: | AB 1296 | Hearing Date: | 7/10/19 |
Author: | Gonzalez | Tax Levy: | No |
Version: | 6/21/19 Amended | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Grinnell | ||
Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program
Enacts the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Act, which establishes the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program in the Department of Justice.
Background
Underground economy. Prosecuting illegal activity in the underground economy is notoriously difficult: violators do not file for businesses licenses or pay taxes, and compensate their employees in cash, leaving little to no paper trail. Often times when authorities find violators, the taxes avoided do not justify the costs of deploying more auditors and prosecutors. According to the Little Hoover Commission’s (LHC’s) March, 2015, report Level the Playing Field: Put California’s Underground Economy Out of Business, “the tentacles of the underground economy reach deep in California and that it plagues both businesses and workers.” The report estimated uncollected state revenue resulting from the underground economy between $8.5 and $10 billion, and contains chapters on the current leadership void, funding issues, lax penalties, and unclear laws.
In 1994, Governor Pete Wilson signed executive order W-66-93, creating the Joint Economic Strike Force (JESF), which was “responsible for enhancing the development and sharing of information necessary to combat the underground economy, to improve the coordination of enforcement activities, and to develop methods to pool, focus, and target enforcement resources.” JESF is led by the Employment Development Department (EDD) and housed within its Underground Economy Operations, and is comprised of the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA), agencies within DCA, such as the Bureau of Automotive Repair (BAR) and the Contractors State License Board (CSLB). It also includes the Franchise Tax Board (FTB), the Board of Equalization (now the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration or CDTFA), the Department of Insurance (CDI), the Department of Justice (DOJ), the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), the Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control (ABC), the United States Department of Labor, and the Internal Revenue Service (IRS). JESF was codified by the Legislature (SB 1490, Johnston, 1994), and publishes an annual report documenting its efforts. However, JESF has not published an annual report since 2017.
In 2005, Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger established the Economic and Employment Enforcement Coalition (EEEC), housed in DIR, and comprised of investigators and auditors from DIR’s Division of Labor Standards Enforcement and Occupational Safety and Health, and includes EDD, DCA, BAR, CSLB, CDTFA, CDI, DOJ, and ABC. Governor Brown renamed the EEEC the DIR Labor Enforcement Task Force (LETF), effective January 1, 2012. LETF’s mission is “to combat the underground economy in order to ensure safe working conditions and proper payment of wages for workers; to create an environment in which legitimate businesses can thrive; and to support the collection of all California taxes, fees, and penalties due from employers.” LETF last published data for the first quarter of 2018. Additionally, EDD receives audit leads from the IRS through the Questionable Employment Tax Practices (QETP) Program.
RRaCE and TRaCE. In 2013, the Legislature enacted the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team Act, which created the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement (RRaCE) team to complement the state’s underground economy enforcement efforts (AB 576, V.M Perez). The team included FTB, BOE, and DOJ, and also allowed the Health and Human Services Agency, DCA, DIR, EDD, and the Department of Motor Vehicles to participate. While the state already had the LETF within DIR, and the JESF led by EDD, the Legislature established RRaCE with its own specific goal, which is to “serve the best interests of the state by combating criminal tax evasion associated with the underground economy.” AB 576 established RRaCE as a pilot program, which expired on January 1, 2019.
When Governor Brown signed AB 576, he included a signing message noting the lack of a lead agency, and directed DIR to take the lead. However, BOE and DOJ created TRaCE (Tax Recovery and Criminal Enforcement) to pursue identical aims. In 2017, the Legislature enacted the Taxpayer Transparency and Fairness Act of 2017, which created the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA), and shifted all of the BOE’s statutory tax administration functions to the newly formed Department (AB 102, Committee on Budget).
Last year, Attorney General Xaiver Becerra sought to have TRaCE’s structure, governance, and authority to share confidential tax information codified (SB 1272, Galgiani); however, Governor Brown vetoed the measure. The RRaCE pilot program sunset on January 1, 2019, but the TRaCE task force continues to operate through MOUs with two teams in Los Angeles and Sacramento. Before RRaCE expired, California had two separate task forces with nearly identical names pursing the same goals, but housed under the leadership of two distinct agencies.
RRaCE’s report to the Legislature that between October, 2014, and December, 2017, stated that it:
- Received 707 complaints.
- Referred 190 complaints to other agencies, primarily members of RRaCE.
- Investigated 319 complaints.
- Was prosecuting 11 cases at the time, and had successfully prosecuted 27.
- Discovered $210,851,626 of unreported or underreported sales based on the investigator’s estimation of gross sales or gross receipts during the investigation phase. Associated taxes would be a percentage of this number determined by the agencies involved.
- Resulted in $14,596,733 in court-ordered restitution to taxing agencies and other victims and investigative costs to taxing agencies or TRaCE.
- Seized $1,386,844 worth of evidence during search warrants, including money and other assets.
State law prohibits the disclosure of any taxpayer information, with some exceptions. Generally, FTB and CDTFA can disclose confidential information to other state tax agencies, federal tax agencies, and the Multistate Tax Commission solely for tax administration purposes, as well as to courts, law enforcement agencies, and the Department of Justice. State law bars unauthorized disclosure of state tax information, and provides unauthorized disclosure of federal tax information is a misdemeanor and felony.
The Attorney General wants the Legislature to establish a program to combat underground economic activities through a multiagency collaboration, and grant investigative task forces the authority necessary to use confidential tax information to pursue wrongdoing.
Proposed Law
Assembly Bill 1296 enacts the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Act, which establishes the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program (Program) in the Department of Justice to combat underground economic activities through a multi-agency collaboration to:
- Pool resources and leverage enforcement efforts,
- Collaborate and share data with state and federal partners, and
- Prosecute violations covering jurisdiction of multiple agencies to address the severity of the crimes, and impose appropriate penalties on contract violators.
AB 1296 creates an executive board (Board) to ensure efficient and effective multi-agency collaboration, and to oversee its investigative teams, consisting of representatives from:
- The Department of Justice, designated by the Attorney General to facilitate and oversee the multiagency collaboration,
- The Division of Law Enforcement at DOJ,
- The Criminal Law Division at DOJ,
- The Investigations and Special Operations Bureau at CDTFA,
- The Criminal Investigations Bureau at FTB, and
- The Investigation Division at EDD.
The Board may invite nine other specified state agencies to join in an advisory capacity, and any other state and federal agencies as it deems appropriate. Any agency can only be added in an advisory capacity by written agreement that includes provisions ensuring that confidential information is shared only when necessary to assess leads, conduct an investigation, or prosecute a case. The bill directs the Board to meet as needed, but at least quarterly.
The bill requires five teams: one each in Fresno, Los Angeles, Sacramento, San Diego, and the San Francisco Bay Area. Each investigative team must include members from the above listed agencies, as well as others under written agreements between the Board and that agency governing its participation.
AB 1296 directs duly authorized team members and representatives of other participating agencies to exchange information cases that involve criminal tax evasion associated with underground economic activities. The measure bars team members, ex-members, any agent employed by the team, or any person who has received knowledge from any agency, from divulging or making known any confidential information received by the team. The bill allows persons employed by agencies represented on the Board as well as those employed by the agencies specifically allowed to join in an advisory capacity to share confidential tax or fee information for cases that involve a known or suspected felony violation of tax related crimes when:
- The confidential tax or fee information is obtained by a person employed by an agency specifically represented on the board, specifically allowed to be on the board in an advisory capacity pursuant to existing law, agreements authorized by existing law, or order by the Governor.
- The person who receives the confidential tax or fee information is a peace officer.
- The confidential tax or fee information relates to a felony level tax or fee evasion crime.
- The person receiving the confidential tax or fee information has a legitimate need to know to assess leads, conduct an investigation, or prosecute a case.
- There is a nondisclosure agreement that prohibits the person receiving the confidential tax or fee information from doing any of the following:
- Disclosing the information to any person that is not part of the Program.
- Disclosing the information to any other unauthorized person.
- Using the information for purposes not related to the Program.
The bill directs the board to develop and adopt a standard nondisclosure agreement, the process for which is exempt from the Administrative Procedure Act.
The measure directs that intelligence, data, including confidential tax or fee information, documents, information, complaints, and lead referrals exchanged be used to:
- Assess leads or referrals in order to determine if an investigation is warranted.
- Conduct investigations.
- Prosecute violations.
- Conduct data analytics.
AB 1296 provides that any such information retains its confidential status and is subject to each agency’s confidentiality laws. The bill references specific statutes that apply to EDD, CDFTA, FTB, and DOJ, as well as any other information confidentiality provisions in federal and state law, as well as any information confidentiality provisions applicable to any agency added to the Program. The measure further bars any exchange of federal tax data without authorization from the IRS. AB 1296 further directs the executive board to oversee the Program to ensure the protection of that appropriate policies, procedures, and training are in place to protect confidential tax and fee information.
The bill also allows the Program to develop a data analytics system that enhances the efficiency and effectiveness of the multiagency collaboration should the Legislature appropriate funds for that purpose. AB 1296 directs DOJ to submit a report to the Legislature by July 1, 2021, and annually thereafter, that includes:
- Number of leads or complaints received during the reporting period,
- Number of cases investigated or prosecuted through civil action or criminal prosecution as a result of its work,
- The amount and final disposition of moneys collected from criminal prosecutions through the Program’s enforcement efforts,
- The status of the multiagency collaboration required by the bill,
- A list of the agencies that received confidential tax or fee information,
- The number of instances, if any, of unauthorized or suspected unauthorized access, use, or disclosure of confidential tax or fee information, including the number of instances, if any, of unauthorized or suspected unauthorized access, use, or disclosure of confidential tax or fee information dating back to the inception of the Program and its predecessor programs, and
- The status of any efforts to plan for, develop, and implement a data analytics system that enhances the efficiency and effectiveness of the multiagency collaboration.
The bill directs the Legislative Analyst’s Office to report to the Legislature regarding the effectiveness of Program, along with recommendations to improve it, by July 1, 2026. The measure also makes a conforming change to the Unemployment Insurance Code, and contains legislative findings and declarations supporting its purposes. AB 1296 provides that its provisions sunset on January 1, 2027.
State Revenue Impact
CDTFA estimates that is portion of the TRUE program revenues attributed to the three new office locations would be approximately $7.8 million once all three new locations are established and fully operational.
FTB estimates that its participation in the RRaCE team joint task force pilot program resulted in ordered restitution of $3.3 million, but states that the revenue impact of AB 1296 is unknown because it is difficult to predict the frequency and the value of future task force criminal investigation actions.
Comments
1. Purpose of the bill. According to the author, “the underground economy is comprised of individuals and businesses that use various schemes to conceal their activities and evade their tax liabilities by avoiding licensing, regulatory, labor and tax agencies. Businesses in the underground economy may deliberately fail to report work to appropriate government agencies, obtain proper permits, secure the appropriate insurance, provide sufficient safety and skills training to workers, or pay fees, taxes or minimum wages. Other evasive practices include paying workers a lower wage than stated on payroll reports, misclassifying workers as independent contractors to avoid paying employee-level fees and taxes, and misreporting profits and material costs to avoid taxes. To begin addressing the program of the underground economy, the multi-agency Tax Recover and Criminal Enforcement (TRaCE) Task Force pilot program was administratively established in 2014 to investigate and prosecute felony-level crimes. Under this pilot program, investigative teams are geographically based in Sacramento and Los Angeles, but are tasked with investigative leads that cover the entire state. In 2015, the Little Hoover Commission recognized the promise of the program and recommended expansion of operations to every major metropolitan region. Furthermore, the existing task force operates through a memorandum of understanding, which complicates the process through which confidential tax information sharing is conducted between the participating enforcement agencies. Assembly Bill 1296 would statutorily establish the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy (TRUE) Crime Enforcement Program under the California Department of Justice to combat underground economic and labor crimes through multi-agency collaborative efforts. The Program would consist of representatives from the following state agencies:
- Department of Justice
- Department of Tax and Fee Administration
- The Franchise Tax Board
- The Employment Development Department
- Various state and federal agencies in advisory capacities.
This bill would also establish investigative teams in Sacramento, Los Angeles, the San Francisco Bay Area, Fresno and San Diego. Furthermore, the bill codifies safeguards that prevent unauthorized data sharing of confidential information.”
2. Structure. State agencies operate under legal mandates using funding appropriated either continuously or in the Budget Act. As such, DOJ could continue to house and operate a program to combat criminal tax enforcement in the underground economy program without this bill. BOE and DOJ did so in the past after the Legislature created RRaCE in statute because the agencies believed that DIR lacked the necessary law enforcement authority to effectively implement AB 576’s goals. When Governor Brown vetoed SB 1272 in 2018, he stated:
“This bill creates the Tax Recovery and Criminal Enforcement Tax Force within the Department of Justice to combat underground economic activities.
I am sympathetic to rooting out businesses that engage in unfair competition and mistreatment of workers. This is an area of great interest to me, and one which I have worked on as Attorney General and as Governor.
This bill, however, codifies a task force that is already operational via MOU and establishes a permanent program within the Department of Justice with an ill-defined and potentially unlimited scope of operations. I am reluctant to do this without additional and more detailed scrutiny through the budget process.”
The Committee may wish to consider whether AB 1296 is necessary. If not, a better option could be to directly allocate funding to DOJ to combat criminal tax evasion in the underground economy as part of the Budget Act, set specific and measurable goals, direct appropriate agencies to collaborate to the extent needed, and require DOJ to report specific information for the Legislature to assess its performance.
3. Alphabet soup. State and local law enforcement, multiple other state agencies, LETF, JESF, and TRaCE combat counterfeiting, wage theft, worker misclassification, and tax evasion. AB 1296 would establish its program as the state’s primary felony-level criminal underground economy enforcement effort. The Committee may wish to consider whether the state needs a specific task force to combat the underground economy, and if so, whether AB 1296’s program is the best option.
4. Information sharing. AB 1296 provides statutory direction for the program, clearly places it within DOJ, creates an executive board with a specific composition, and requires separate teams and committees to operate within five distinct regions. However, its only essential element is the measure’s robust requirements for the Program’s use of confidential tax information; multiple agencies can share some information under interagency agreements, but explicit legal authorization is more helpful. Businesses who commit one type of crime, such as wage theft, are more likely to violate others, such as failing to meet tax obligations.
5. Incoming! The Senate Public Safety Committee approved AB 1296 by a vote of 7 to 0 on July 2nd. The Committee on Governance and Finance is hearing the measure as the Committee of second reference.
6. Technical. Committee staff recommends inserting the word “only” after “shall” on Page 7, line 33.
Assembly Actions
Assembly Public Safety Committee: 8-0
Assembly Revenue and Taxation Committee: 10-0
Assembly Appropriations Committee: 18-0
Assembly Floor: 77-0
Support and Opposition
(7/5/19)
Support: Attorney General Xavier Becerra; California Pool and Spa Association; California State Association of Electrical Workers; California State Council of Laborers; California State Pipe Trades Council; California Statewide Law Enforcement Association; California Teamsters; Engineers and Scientists of California, IFPTE Local 20; Inlandboatmen’s Union of the Pacific; International Association of Elevator Contractors Locals 8 and 18; International Union of Operating Engineers Cal-Nevada Conference; Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 20; SEIU California; Utility Workers of America; Western States Council of Sheet Metal Workers,
Opposition: Unknown.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Nancy Skinner, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 1296 Hearing Date: July 2, 2019
Author: | Gonzalez | ||
Version: | June 21, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | JK | ||
Subject: Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program
HISTORY
Source: California Attorney General Xavier Becerra
Prior Legislation: SB 1272 (Galgiani), 2018, vetoed by Governor
AB 576 (V. Manuel Perez), Ch. 614, Stats. 2013
SB 1185 (Price), 2012, failed passage in Assembly Appropriations
SB 1490 (Johnston), Ch. 1117, Stats. 1994
Support: UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO; CA Conference of Machinist; CA Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union; California Landscape Contractors Association; California-Nevada Conference of Operating Engineers; California State Council of Laborers; California Teamsters; Engineers and Scientists of CA, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO; Inlandboatmen’s Union of the Pacific; Utility Workers of America; Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
Opposition: None known
Assembly Floor Vote: 77 - 0
PURPOSE
The purpose of this bill is establish the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement (TRUE) Program.
Existing law allows taxes on or measured by income to be imposed on persons, corporations, or other entities as prescribed by law. (Cal. Const., Art. XIII, sec. 26.)
Existing law contains various provisions criminalizing tax evasion. (See e.g. Rev. & Tax Code, §§ 7152-7153.5 [false and fraudulent returns regarding sales and use taxes], 19701 et seq. [income tax evasion].)
Existing law establishes the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team as a pilot program. (Gov. Code, § 15912.)
Existing law states that the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team shall include all of the following state entities:
- Franchise Tax Board;
- Department of Justice;
- State Board of Equalization; and,
- Employment Development Department. (Gov. Code, § 15914 (a).)
- Franchise Tax Board;
Existing law allows the following agencies to participate in the pilot program in an advisory capacity to the team:
- California Health and Human Services Agency;
- Department of Consumer Affairs;
- Department of Industrial Relations;
- Department of Insurance; and,
- Department of Motor Vehicles. (Gov. Code, § 15914 (b).)
Existing law states that Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team is to serve the best interests of the state by combating criminal tax evasion associated with the underground economy, directs the team to do all of the following:
- Develop a plan for a central intake process and organizational structure to document, review, and evaluate data and complaints;
- Evaluate the benefits of a processing center to receive and analyze data, share complaints, and research leads from the input of specified agencies; and
- Provide participating and nonparticipating agencies with investigative leads where collaboration opportunities exist for felony-level criminal investigations, including, but not limited to, referring leads to agencies with appropriate enforcement jurisdiction. (Gov. Code, § 15918.)
Existing law establishes a sunset date of January 1, 2019, for Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team pilot program. (Gov. Code, § 15924.)
Existing law states that the director of the Employment Development Department, or his or her designee, shall serve as Chairperson of the Joint Enforcement Strike Force on the Underground Economy (JESF). (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (a).)
Existing law specifies that the strike force shall include, but not be limited to, representatives of the Employment Development Department, the Department of Consumer Affairs, the Department of Industrial Relations, and the Office of Criminal Justice Planning. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (a).)
Existing law provides that other agencies that are not part of the administration, such as the Franchise Tax Board, the State Board of Equalization, and the Department of Justice, are encouraged to participate in the strike force. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (a).)
Existing law specifies that JESF has the following duties:
- To facilitate and encourage the development and sharing of information by the participating agencies necessary to combat the underground economy;
- To improve the coordination of activities among the participating agencies;
- To develop methods to pool, focus, and target the enforcement resources of the participating agencies in order to deter tax evasion and maximize recoveries from blatant tax evaders and violators of cash-pay reporting laws; and,
- To reduce enforcement costs wherever possible by eliminating duplicative audits and investigations. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (b).)
Existing law states that JESF shall also be empowered to:
- Form joint enforcement teams when appropriate to utilize the collective investigative and enforcement capabilities of the participating members;
- Establish committees and rules of procedure to carry out the activities of the strike force;
- To solicit the cooperation and participation of district attorneys and other state and local agencies in carrying out the objectives of the strike force;
- Establish procedures for soliciting referrals from the public, including, but not limited to, an advertised telephone hotline;
- Develop procedures for improved information sharing among the participating agencies, such as shared automated information data base systems, the use of a common business identification number, and a centralized debt collection system;
- Develop procedures to permit the participating agencies to use more efficient and effective civil sanctions in lieu of criminal actions wherever possible; and,
- Evaluate, based on its activities, the need for any statutory change to accomplish specified objectives. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (c).)
Existing law specifies that JESF shall report to the Governor and the Legislature annually during the period of its existence. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329 (d).)
This bill establishes the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program (TRUE) in the Department of Justice to combat underground economic activities through a multiagency collaboration, which include all of the following:
- To protect workers, law-abiding businesses, and consumers by bringing justice to unscrupulous businesses operating in the state’s underground economy.
- To recover significant lost revenues to the state by prosecuting egregious, felony-level tax and fee evasion crimes in the state’s underground economy.
- To facilitate information sharing among participating agencies to assess leads, conduct investigations, and prosecute felony-level tax and fee evasion crimes in the underground economy.
- To support multiagency investigative teams in every region of the state.
This bill specifies that the TRUE Task Force shall include an executive board to ensure efficient and effective multiagency collaboration in furtherance of this act. The executive board shall consist of the following voting members:
- A representative from the Department of Justice designated by the Attorney General to facilitate and oversee the multiagency collaboration pursuant to this Act.
- A representative from the Division of Law Enforcement at the Department of Justice;
- A representative from the Criminal Law Division at the Department of Justice;
- A representative from the Investigations and Special Operations Bureau at the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration;
- A representative from the Criminal Investigation Bureau at the Franchise Tax Board; and
- A representative from the Investigation Division at the Employment Development Department.
This bill authorizes the following state agencies to join the executive board in an advisory capacity:
- The California Health and Human Services Agency.
- The Department of Consumer Affairs.
- The Department of Industrial Relations.
- The Department of Insurance.
- The Department of Motor Vehicles.
- The Department of California Highway Patrol.
- The Bureau of Cannabis Control.
- The Contractors’ State License Board.
- As well as other state, federal, and local agencies.
This bill states that the TRUE task force shall meet as needed, but shall meet at least quarterly, to conduct its business.
This bill establishes teams in Sacramento, Los Angeles, San Diego, the San Francisco Bay Area, and Fresno.
COMMENTS
Need for This Bill
According to the author:
The underground economy is comprised of individuals and businesses that use various schemes to conceal their activities and evade their tax liabilities by avoiding licensing, regulatory, labor and tax agencies. Businesses in the underground economy may deliberately fail to report work to appropriate government agencies, obtain proper permits, secure the appropriate insurance, provide sufficient safety and skills training to workers, or pay fees, taxes or minimum wages. Other evasive practices include paying workers a lower wage than stated on payroll reports, misclassifying workers as independent contractors to avoid paying employee-level fees and taxes, and misreporting profits and material costs to avoid taxes.
To begin addressing the program of the underground economy, the multi-agency Tax Recover and Criminal Enforcement (TRaCE) Task Force pilot program was administratively established in 2014 to investigate and prosecute felony-level crimes. Under this pilot program, investigative teams are geographically based in Sacramento and Los Angeles, but are tasked with investigative leads that cover the entire state. In 2015, the Little Hoover Commission recognized the promise of the program and recommended expansion of operations to every major metropolitan region.
Furthermore, the existing task force operates through a memorandum of understanding, which complicates the process through which confidential tax information sharing is conducted between the participating enforcement agencies.
Assembly Bill 1296 would statutorily establish the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy (TRUE) Crime Enforcement Program under the California Department of Justice to combat underground economic and labor crimes through multi-agency collaborative efforts. The Program would consist of representatives from the following state agencies:
- Department of Justice
- Department of Tax and Fee Administration
- The Franchise Tax Board
- The Employment Development Department
- Various state and federal agencies in advisory capacities.
This bill would also establish investigative teams in Sacramento, Los Angeles, the San Francisco Bay Area, Fresno and San Diego. Furthermore, the bill codifies safeguards that prevent unauthorized data sharing of confidential information.
Underground Economy
The underground economy is an arena of illegal labor practices, meaning these business do not go through legally mandated processes of registering a business and therefore do not pay associated taxes or have to abide by labor regulations, including, but not limited to, minimum wage, labor unions, health insurance, etc. Other evasive practices include paying workers a lower wage than stated on payroll reports, misclassifying workers as independent contractors to avoid paying employee-level fees and taxes, and misreporting profits and material costs to avoid taxes. Statistics associated with the underground economy are difficult to calculate but the California Franchise Tax Board estimates California’s tax gap to be about $10 billion per year.[1]
These types of unregulated businesses create environments for illicit activities such as money laundering, trafficking, and inhuman labor practices. Unfortunately, some people are faced with circumstances that force them into these types of businesses and keep them reliant on them. As of April 2019, California has a low unemployment rate of 3.9%; however, this rate is not the same across California. Some counties are still facing unemployment rates reaching 15%.[2] By cracking down on these underground economies, is the Legislature ensuring that Californians have the resources to find other means of work? According to the U.S. Department of Labor, citizens between the ages of 16-24 are seeing some of the highest rates of unemployment, with African Americans and Latinos well above the national average at 6.7% and 4.2%. Will this bill create another criminalized system that will disproportionately affect young people of color?[3]
Labor and Human Trafficking in California
Human trafficking involves the recruitment, transportation or sale of people for forced labor. Through violence, threats and coercion, victims are forced to work in, among other things, the sex trade, domestic labor, factories, hotels and agriculture. California is leading the nation in reported human trafficking cases. From 2007-2018, the National Human Trafficking Hotline had 24,800 calls, identifying 7,816 human trafficking victims in California.[4]
While sex trafficking has taken the spotlight in human trafficking discourse, labor trafficking is more prevalent. According to the International Labor Organization, 78% of human trafficking victims are forced labor and 22% are victims of forced sexual exploitation.[5] This is indicative of the lack of funding towards identifying victims of labor trafficking. This bill generally defines underground economy, meaning the task force would have more resources to pursue cases of labor trafficking.
AB 576: Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team
AB 576 (Author:V. Manuel Pérez) Chapter 614, Statutes of 2013, created the “Centralized Intelligence Partnership” pilot program consisting of specified agencies to collaborate in combating those engaged in the underground economy. AB 576 established a pilot program to create a multiagency team consisting of the Franchise Tax Board, DOJ, State Board of Equalization, and Employment Development Department, to be known as the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team, to collaborate in combating criminal tax evasion associated with the underground economy by, among other activities, developing a plan for a central intake process and organizational structure to document, review, and evaluate data and complaints. AB 576 authorized other specified state entities to participate in the pilot program in an advisory capacity. The pilot program allowed team members to exchange information for the purpose of investigating criminal tax evasion associated with the underground economy. There was a sunset date of January 1, 2019 on the pilot program. This bill would essentially refine and make permanent the program initially established by AB 576.
Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement (TRUE) Program
The Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement (TRUE) Program is a task force under the Department of Justice and led by the Attorney General to recover significant lost revenues to the state by prosecuting egregious, felony-level tax and fee evasions. There are currently other task forces dealing with the underground economy; however, TRUE will uniquely handle felony-level crimes. Currently, the Tax Recovery and Criminal Enforcement (TRaCE) Task Force has two teams in Los Angeles and Sacramento. This bill will fully establish the task force under the new name, TRUE, and open three new teams in San Diego, the San Francisco Bay Area, and Fresno. This bill also creates more regulations for what purposes, to whom, and how agencies will share information.
Governor’s Veto Message on SB 1272
SB 1272 (Galgiani) would have created an underground economy task force nearly identical to the one proposed by this bill, under a different name, the Tax Recovery and Criminal Enforcement Tax Force (TRaCE).
SB 1272 was vetoed by Governor Brown with the following message:
This bill creates the Tax Recovery and Criminal Enforcement Tax Force within the Department of Justice to combat underground economic activities.
I am sympathetic to rooting out businesses that engage in unfair competition and mistreatment of workers. This is an area of great interest to me, and one which I have worked on as Attorney General and as Governor.
This bill, however, codifies a task force that is already operational via MOU and establishes a permanent program within the Department of Justice with an ill-defined and potentially unlimited scope of operations. I am reluctant to do this without additional and more detailed scrutiny through the budget process.
Argument in Support
According to Attorney General Xavier Becerra:
According to a 2013 University of California at Los Angeles Labor Center report, the state’s underground economy generates between $60 to $140 billion in revenue annually. An estimated $8.5 billion in corporate, personal, sales and use taxes go uncollected each year. To help respond to this problem, several state agencies formed a pilot program in 2014 to investigate and prosecute the most egregious felony-level multijurisdictional underground economic crimes from a tax prospective. Participating agencies include the Department of Justice, the Department of Tax and Fee Administration, the Franchise Tax Board, and the Employment Development Department.
Under the pilot program, investigative teams were established in Sacramento and Los Angeles. In just a few years, these teams have identified $482 million in unreported gross receipts and $60 million in associated tax loss to the state. Through its criminal enforcement actions, the pilot program has obtained court orders to recover over $25 million in lost tax revenue, victim restitution, and investigation costs. The pilot program is currently seeking over $25 million in pending cases.
The pilot program received formal recognition from a wide range of stakeholders, including the White House and then-Lieutenant Governor Gavin Newsom for the program’s innovative, whole-government approach in reducing the underground economy. The Little Hoover Commission also acknowledged the accomplishments of the pilot program and published a report on the underground economy that recommends expanding the pilot program’s investigative teams to every major metropolitan region in the state.
Consistent with the Little Hoover Commission’s recommendations, AB 1296 would build off the successes of the pilot program’s work by permanently establishing the existing teams in Sacramento and Los Angeles and authorizing additional teams in three other major metropolitan regions of the state—San Diego, the Bay Area, and Fresno.
The Attorney General is proud to sponsor AB 1296. The bill is an important measure that would substantially strengthen the state’s efforts to combat and deter underground economic crimes in California. Our workers, business owners, consumers, and taxpayers would be the biggest beneficiaries of a robust program.
-- END –
https://www.edd.ca.gov/Payroll_Taxes/Underground_Economy_Operations.htm#DefinitionofUndergroundEconomy ↑
https://www.labormarketinfo.edd.ca.gov/file/lfmonth/countyur-400c.pdf ↑
https://www.bls.gov/opub/ted/2019/unemployment-rate-3-point-6-percent-in-april-2019-lowest-since-december-1969.htm ↑
https://oag.ca.gov/sites/all/files/agweb/pdfs/ht/human-trafficking-2012.pdf ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1296
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Amended Ver:April 24, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Establishes the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program (TRUE) in the Department of Justice (DOJ) to combat underground economic activities through a multiagency collaboration.
Major Provisions
- Establishes the TRUE Task Force in DOJ to combat underground economic activities through a multiagency collaboration to do, to the extent practicable, the following:
- Pool resources and leverage enforcement efforts;
- Collaborate and share data with state and federal partners;
- Efficiently prosecute violations covering jurisdictions of multiple agencies to address the severity of the crimes and impose appropriate penalties on convicted violators; and
- Recover state revenue lost to the underground economy.
- Specifies that the TRUE Task Force shall include an executive board to ensure efficient and effective multiagency collaboration in furtherance of this act. The executive board shall consist of the following voting members:
- A representative from the Division of Law Enforcement at the Department of Justice;
- A representative from the Criminal Law Division at the Department of Justice;
- A representative from the Investigations and Special Operations Bureau at the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration;
- A representative from the Criminal Investigation Bureau at the Franchise Tax Board; and
- A representative from the Investigation Division at the Employment Development Department.
- Requires reports authored by both DOJ and the Legislative Analyst's Office to be submitted to the Legislature regarding the effectiveness of the TRUE program, as specified.
COMMENTS:
According to the Author:
"In the 'underground economy,' many workers go without basic rights and workplace protections, law-abiding businesses are put in a competitive disadvantage, and the well-being of consumers are put at risk. Furthermore, due to the nature of underground activities, tax revenues that would fund education, public safety agencies and infrastructure projects are lost and uncollected. Assembly Bill 1296 would strengthen the state's efforts to combat the underground economy by establishing the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy (TRUE) Crime Enforcement Program in the California Department of Justice. By pooling law enforcement resources, enhancing collaboration and data sharing between participating agencies, and efficiently prosecuting violations, the TRUE Crime Enforcement Program will protect vulnerable workers and communities, punish bad actors, and help recover millions of lost tax revenue."
Arguments in Support:
According to Xavier Becerra, the Attorney General of the State of California: "According to a 2013 University of California at Los Angeles Labor Center report, the state's underground economy generates between $60 to $140 billion in revenue annually. An estimated $8.5 billion in corporate, personal, sales and use taxes go uncollected each year. To help respond to this problem, several state agencies formed a pilot program in 2014 to investigate and prosecute the most egregious felony-level multijurisdictional underground economic crimes from a tax prospective. Participating agencies include the Department of Justice, the Department of Tax and Fee Administration, the Franchise Tax Board, and the Employment Development Department.
"Consistent with the Little Hoover Commission's recommendations, AB 1296 would build off the successes of the pilot program's work by permanently establishing the existing teams in Sacramento and Los Angeles and authorizing additional teams in three other major metropolitan regions of the state—San Diego, the Bay Area, and Fresno.
"The Attorney General is proud to sponsor AB 1296. The bill is an important measure that would substantially strengthen the state's efforts to combat and deter underground economic crimes in California. Our workers, business owners, consumers, and taxpayers would be the biggest beneficiaries of a robust program."
Arguments in Opposition:
None
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Costs (GF) in the millions of dollars annually for DOJ to implement the TRUE Program. Specifically, DOJ reports costs will be $6.6 million in 2019-20 with costs of approximately $12 million in 2020-21 and annually thereafter.
- Costs (GF) in the millions of dollars annually for CDTFA to participate in the TRUE Program. CDTFA estimates $2.5 million in 2019-20 and $2.3 million in 2020-21 and annually thereafter.
- Costs (GF) of $2.3 million in the first year and $1.8 million annually for EDD to participate in the TRUE Program.
- Annual costs (GF) of $440,000 in the first year and $ 360,000 in 2020-21 and annually thereafter for FTB to participate in the TRUE Program.
- Unknown increase in state tax revenues, potentially in the millions of dollars to tens of millions of dollars annually.
- One-time costs (GF) of approximately $30,000 to $50,000 for LAO to prepare and submit a report to the Legislature.
- Costs (GF) of approximately $26,000 in 2019-20, $62,000 in 2020-21 and $46,000 annually thereafter for Department of Insurance to participate in the TRUE Program
Please see the policy committee analysis for a full discussion of this bill.
VOTES:
ASM PUBLIC SAFETY: 8-0-0
YES: Jones-Sawyer, Lackey, Bauer-Kahan, Diep, Kamlager-Dove, Quirk, Santiago, Wicks
ASM REVENUE AND TAXATION: 10-0-1
YES: Burke, Brough, Chu, Gray, Mayes, Melendez, Mullin, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Luz Rivas
ABS, ABST OR NV: Ting
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 24, 2019
CONSULTANT: Matthew Fleming (Counsel) / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744 FN: 0000664
Date of Hearing: May 8, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1296
Author:(Gonzalez) – As Amended Ver:April 24, 2019
Policy Committee: | Public Safety | Vote: | 8 - 0 |
Revenue and Taxation | 10 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill establishes the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement (TRUE) Program in the Department of Justice (DOJ) to combat underground economic activities. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes the TRUE Program in DOJ to combat underground economic activities through a multiagency collaboration including DOJ, the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (CDTFA), the Franchise Tax Board (FTB), and the Employment Development Department (EDD) to efficiently prosecute violations covering jurisdictions of multiple agencies and recover state revenue lost to the underground economy.
- States that for cases involving tax and fee administration associated with underground economic activities, duly authorized members of TRUE Program investigative teams, as specified, and members of the teams and committees shall exchange intelligence and data, including confidential tax or fee information, documents, information, complaints, or lead referrals for investigatory purposes.
- States that the TRUE Program shall, to the extent the Legislature appropriates funds for purposes of this section, develop a data analytics system that enhances the efficiency and effectiveness of the multiagency collaboration described in this bill.
- Requires the Legislative Analyst’s Office (LAO), on or before July 1, 2021, to submit a report to the Legislature regarding the effectiveness of the TRUE Program and any recommendation for improvement.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Costs (GF) in the millions of dollars annually for DOJ to implement the TRUE Program. Specifically, DOJ reports costs will be $6.6 million in 2019-20 with costs of approximately $12 million in 2020-21 and annually thereafter.
- Costs (GF) in the millions of dollars annually for CDTFA to participate in the TRUE Program. CDTFA estimates $2.5 million in 2019-20 and $2.3 million in 2020-21 and annually thereafter.
- Costs (GF) of $2.3 million in the first year and $1.8 million annually for EDD to participate in the TRUE Program.
- Annual costs (GF) of $440,000 in the first year and $ 360,000 in 2020-21 and annually thereafter for FTB to participate in the TRUE Program.
- Unknown increase in state tax revenues, potentially in the millions of dollars to tens of millions of dollars annually.
- One-time costs (GF) of approximately $30,000 to $50,000 for LAO to prepare and submit a report to the Legislature.
- Costs (GF) of approximately $26,000 in 2019-20, $62,000 in 2020-21 and $46,000 annually thereafter for Department of Insurance to participate in the TRUE Program
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
By pooling law enforcement resources, enhancing collaboration and data sharing between participating agencies, and efficiently prosecuting violations, the TRUE Crime Enforcement Program will protect vulnerable workers and communities, punish bad actors, and help recover millions of lost tax revenue.
- Background. AB 576 (Author:V. Manuel Pérez), Chapter 614, Statutes of 2013, created the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team and pilot program, to collaborate in combating criminal tax evasion associated with the underground economy. The pilot program allowed team members to exchange information for the purpose of investigating criminal tax evasion associated with the underground economy. There is a sunset date of January 1, 2019, on the pilot program. This bill would expand and make permanent the program initially established by AB 576.
- Support. According to Attorney General Becerra:
According to a 2013 University of California at Los Angeles Labor Center report, the state’s underground economy generates between $60 and $140 billion in revenue annually. An estimated $8.5 billion in corporate, personal, sales and use taxes go uncollected each year. AB 1296 would build off the successes of AB 576 by permanently establishing the existing teams in Sacramento and Los Angeles and authorizing additional teams in three other major metropolitan regions of the state—San Diego, the Bay Area, and Fresno.
- Prior Legislation.
- SB 1272 (Galgiani), of the 2017- 2018 Legislative Session, would have enacted the Tax Recovery and Criminal Enforcement (TRaCE) Task Force Act, establishing the TRaCE Task Force in the Department of Justice (DOJ) to combat underground economic activities through a multiagency collaboration of enforcement agencies in order to efficiently prosecute violations. SB 1272 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
- AB 576 (V. Manuel Pérez), Chapter 614, Statutes of 2013, created the “Centralized Intelligence Partnership” pilot program consisting of specified agencies to collaborate in combating those engaged in the underground economy.
Analysis Prepared by: Kimberly Horiuchi / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 22, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON REVENUE AND TAXATION
Autumn R. Burke, Chairwoman
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1296 (
Author:Gonzalez) – As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
Majority vote. Fiscal committee.
SUBJECT: Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program
SUMMARY: Establishes the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement (TRUE) Program within the Department of Justice (DOJ) to combat the underground economy. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes the TRUE program to do all of the following:
- Pool resources and leverage enforcement efforts;
- Collaborate and share data with state and federal partners;
- Efficiently prosecute violations covering jurisdictions of multiple agencies to address the severity of the crimes and impose appropriate penalties on convicted violators; and,
- Recover state revenue lost to the underground economy.
- Establishes an executive board to ensure efficient and effective multiagency collaboration in furtherance of the TRUE program. The executive board shall consist of a representative from the following voting members:
- Division of Law Enforcement and Criminal Law Division at the DOJ;
- Investigations and Special Operations Bureau at the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration (DTF);
- Criminal Investigation Bureau at the Franchise Tax Board (FTB); and,
- Investigation Division at the Employment Development Department (EDD).
- Allows the TRUE program, as the executive board deems appropriate, to invite the following state agencies to join the executive board in an advisory capacity:
- California Health and Human Services Agency;
- Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA);
- Department of Industrial Relations (DIR);
- Department of Insurance (DOI);
- Department of Motor Vehicles;
- Department of the California Highway Patrol;
- Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control;
- Bureau of Cannabis Control; and,
- Contractors’ State License Board.
- Allows the TRUE program to, as the executive board deems appropriate, invite other state and federal agencies to join the executive board in an advisory capacity. These agencies, if invited, are subject to stricter rules with respect to the disclosure of tax and fee information.
- Requires that the addition of an advisory agency to the TRUE program be by written agreement between the voting members of the executive board and the agency joining the executive board. The written agreement shall govern the participation of the agency joining the executive board. The written agreement shall include provisions ensuring that confidential information is shared only when necessary to assess leads, conduct an investigation, or prosecute a case.
- Provides that the TRUE program shall include investigative teams located in Sacramento, Los Angeles, San Diego, the San Francisco Bay area, and Fresno.
- Provides that each investigative team shall have a committee established by the TRUE program's executive board to ensure efficient and effective multi agency collaboration in each region.
- Requires the TRUE program's executive board and each investigative team's committee to meet as needed, but at least quarterly, to conduct its business.
- Requires authorized members of the TRUE program to exchange intelligence, data, including confidential tax and fee information, documents, information, complaints, or lead referrals. However, agencies that are invited to join the TRUE program that are not listed in statute are not allowed to receive confidential tax or fee information unless the case involves a known or suspected felony level tax or fee evasion crime, and if all of the following criteria are met:
- The confidential tax or fee information is obtained by a voting member or advisory member of the TRUE Program pursuant to existing law, agreements authorized by existing law, or order by the Governor;
- The person who receives the confidential tax or fee information is a peace officer;
- The confidential tax or fee information is for a crime related to a felony level tax or fee evasion, as specified;
- The person receiving the confidential tax or fee information has a legitimate need to know to assess leads, conduct an investigation, or prosecute a case; and,
- There is a nondisclosure agreement that prohibits the person receiving the confidential tax or fee information from disclosing the information to any person that is not part of the TRUE program.
- Requires that the intelligence, data, including confidential tax or fee information, documents, information, complaints, and lead referrals exchanged as part of the TRUE program be used for the following purposes:
- To assess leads or referrals in order to determine if an investigation is warranted;
- To conduct investigations;
- To prosecute violations;
- To conduct data analytics; and,
- To enforce judgments.
- Provides that any person who has been involved in the TRUE program or any person who has at any time obtained confidential information shall not divulge, or make known in any manner, any of the confidential information received by or reported to the TRUE program.
- Provides that confidential information authorized to be exchanged shall remain confidential.
- Prohibits a member of the TRUE program from exchanging federal tax data without authorization from the Internal Revenue Service (IRS).
- Provides that the executive board shall oversee the TRUE program to ensure the protection of confidential tax and fee information.
- Provides that the TRUE program shall, to the extent the Legislature appropriates funds, develop a data analytics system that enhances the efficiency and effectiveness of the multi-agency collaboration.
- Requires, on or before March 31, 2020, and annually thereafter, the DOJ, in consultation with the executive board of the TRUE program, to submit a report to the Legislature that includes, but is not limited to, the following information:
- The number of leads or complaints received by the TRUE program during the reporting period;
- The number of cases investigated or prosecuted through civil action or criminal prosecution as a result of the work of the TRUE program;
- The amount and final disposition of moneys collected through the TRUE program's enforcement efforts;
- The status of the multiagency collaboration;
- A list of the agencies that received confidential tax or fee information;
- The number of instances, if any, of unauthorized or suspected unauthorized access, use, or disclosure of confidential tax or fee information. The report shall include the number of instances, if any, of unauthorized or suspected unauthorized access, use, or disclosure of confidential tax or fee information dating back to the inception of the TRUE program and its predecessor programs;
- The status of any efforts to plan for, develop, and implement a data analytics system that enhances the efficiency and effectiveness of the multiagency collaboration; and,
- Policy considerations, if any, to help advance the purpose of the TRUE program.
- Makes findings and declarations about the underground economy and the goals of the TRUE program.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the EDD. Among its many duties, the EDD administers the collection, accounting, and auditing of payroll taxes and maintains employment records for millions of California workers.
- Establishes the FTB as a three-person board comprised of the State Controller, the Director of the Department of Finance, and the Chair of the BOE. Among its many duties, the FTB is charged with administering the state's Personal Income Tax Law and the Corporation Tax Law.
- Requires various state entities, including DTF, BOE, FTB, and DOJ, to enforce laws relating to the taxation and legal operation of businesses throughout the state under their respective jurisdictions.
- Prohibits the disclosure of any taxpayer information, except as specifically authorized by statute. Generally, disclosure is authorized to other state tax agencies, federal tax agencies, and the Multistate Tax Commission solely for tax administration purposes.
- Provides that the unauthorized disclosure of state tax information is a misdemeanor and the unauthorized disclosure of federal tax information is a felony.
FISCAL EFFECT: Pending
COMMENTS:
- The author has provided the following statement in support of this bill:
In the "underground economy," many workers go without basic rights and workplace protections, law-abiding businesses are put in a competitive disadvantage, and the well-being of consumers are put at risk. Furthermore, due to the nature of the underground activities, tax revenues that would fund education, public safety agencies and infrastructure projects are lost and uncollected. Assembly Bill 1296 would strengthen the state's efforts to combat the underground economy by establishing the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy (TRUE) Crime Enforcement Program in the California Department of Justice. By pooling law enforcement resources, enhancing collaboration and data sharing between participating agencies, and efficiently prosecuting violations, the TRUE Crime Enforcement Program will protect vulnerable workers and communities, punish bad actors, and help recover millions of lost tax revenue.
- Supporters "applaud the author for bringing this important issue to light, which will provide our agents with the appropriate resources to better target the underground economy and prosecute those individuals and businesses who have been operating in the underground market for years. Together in collaboration with other investigators within the California Health and Human Services Agency, the Department of Consumer Affairs, the Department of Motor Vehicles, the Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control, the Bureau of Cannabis Control, and others, and allowing the various state and federal agencies to share data and pool resources will ensure we are able to combat this widespread issue and disincentive these illegal operations from taking advantage of law-abiding workers and businesses."
- Committee Staff Comments:
- Background: On October 26, 1993, the Governor signed Executive Order W-66-93, which established the Joint Enforcement Strike Force (Strike Force). The Governor subsequently signed legislation placing the Executive Order's provisions into law effective January 1, 1995. (Unemployment Insurance Code Section 329.)
The Strike Force, which is chaired by the EDD's Director, is responsible for both developing and sharing information necessary to combat the underground economy. The Strike Force also works to improve the coordination of enforcement activities, and to develop methods to target the enforcement resources of participating agencies. The Strike Force is empowered to form "joint enforcement teams" when appropriate to utilize the investigative and enforcement capabilities of the Strike Force's members. In addition to the EDD, the Strike Force's formal membership is comprised of the DCA, DIR, DOI, and the Office of Criminal Justice Planning. The FTB, the BOE, and the DOJ are each encouraged, under existing law, to participate in the Strike Force's activities. The Strike Force is required to report to the Governor and the Legislature annually regarding its activities.
DIR also works to combat the underground economy in California through its Labor Enforcement Task Force. In this joint effort between state agencies and affected communities, information and resources are shared to ensure workers receive proper payment of wages and are provided a safe working environment. In addition, the Labor Enforcement Task Force works to ensure that California receives all employment taxes, fees, and penalties due from employers. The Labor Enforcement Task Force is comprised of the Division of Occupational Safety and Health, Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, DIR, EDD, Contractor's State Licensing Board, Bureau of Automotive Repair, DTF, DOI, Bureau of Automotive Repair, Alcohol Beverage Control, and the AG.
In 2013, the Legislature also enacted the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement (RRaCE) Team Act, which created the RRaCE team to complement the state's underground economy enforcement efforts (AB 576 (V. Manuel Pérez), Chapter 614, Statutes of 2013). The team includes FTB, BOE, and DOJ, and AB 576 also allowed the Health and Human Services Agency, DCA, DIR, EDD, and the Department of Motor Vehicles to participate. The Legislature established RRaCE with its own specific goal, which was to "serve the best interests of the state by combating criminal tax evasion associated with the underground economy."
When Governor Brown signed AB 576, he included a signing message noting the lack of a lead agency, and directed DIR to take the lead. According to the Little Hoover Commission report, DIR is a labor-focused agency with no tax jurisdiction, which means that DIR does not have access to confidential tax information. Tax agencies have strict controls on how they use the sensitive information they receive from businesses and individuals, and face severe penalties for sharing it inappropriately. State tax agencies could lose their access to IRS data – key to unearthing underground economy-related financial crimes – if they share information with unauthorized parties. As a result, a legislatively designated advisory member without access to tax information is leading a team of tax agencies to generate leads on tax-related crimes. In response to the Governor's designation of DIR as the lead, BOE and DOJ focused efforts on a Tax Recovery and Criminal Enforcement (TRaCE) Task Force, and listed BOE, FTB, DOJ, the Department of Motor Vehicles, EDD, as well as the IRS, Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI), and Homeland Security Investigations (HIS), as partners on its Web site.
As a result, California had two separate task forces with nearly identical names pursuing the same goals, but housed under the leadership of two distinct agencies. Both task forces have an executive board comprised of similar agencies to guide operations. DIR leads RRaCE, while DOJ houses and operates the current TRaCE task force. The Little Hoover Commission explained that "[t]he simultaneous emergence of both RRaCE and TRaCE has been challenging and confusing for some of the agencies involved in both efforts. Departments are legislatively mandated to devote resources to RRaCE, which already has spent one of its six allotted years of the pilot project holding committee meetings and developing an operational framework. Significant information-sharing challenges remain. Instead of augmenting the state's underground economy enforcement efforts, the RRACE/TRaCE bifurcation could potentially spread limited resources even thinner."
- How was TRaCE created? It is unclear to Committee staff how TRaCE is operational given that AB 576 only authorized the sharing of information within RRaCE. According to the TRaCE Web site, "[t]he [TRaCE] Task Force is a pilot program facilitated by California Assembly Bill 576, [RRaCE] Team Act.” However, according to a report submitted to the Legislature by the DIR as part of the RRaCE pilot program requirements, TRaCE was created with a memorandum of understanding (MOU), and was later adopted by RRaCE[1]. Additionally, according to a core member of the TRaCE task force, TRaCE was actually formed prior to RRaCE. As such, it does not appear that TRaCE was a byproduct of RRaCE, nor created in response to the Governor appointing DIR as the lead agency for the RRaCE task force. Instead, TRaCE appears to be a program operating in a similar structure and with similar goals as RRaCE, but clearly not as a program authorized by the Legislature.
- RRaCE Sunsets with no reinstatement: The RRaCE pilot program sunset on January 1, 2019, but the TRaCE task force continues to operate through MOUs. Last year, SB 1272 (Galgiani) was introduced, which would have codified the TRaCE program within DOJ to combat the underground economy. SB 1272 made it to the Governor but was vetoed. The Governor included the following message:
This bill creates the Tax Recovery and Criminal Enforcement Tax Force within the Department of Justice to combat underground economic activities.
I am sympathetic to rooting out businesses that engage in unfair competition and mistreatment of workers. This is an area of great interest to me, and one which I have worked on as Attorney General and as Governor.
This bill, however, codifies a task force that is already operational via MOU and establishes a permanent program within the Department of Justice with an ill-defined and potentially unlimited scope of operations. I am reluctant to do this without additional and more detailed scrutiny through the budget process.
This bill effectively enacts the TRaCE program, as provided for by AB 1272 (Galgiani), but with a new name.
- What does this bill do? This bill would make permanent and rename the TRaCE task force as the TRUE program to combat the underground economy. To the extent practicable, the program would allow resources to be pooled together and allow agreements to leverage enforcement efforts, collaborate and share data, efficiently prosecute multi-jurisdictional violations and impose appropriate penalties, and recover state revenues. This bill would also establish the TRUE executive board to ensure efficient and effective multiagency collaboration. Authorized members of the TRUE program would be allowed to exchange intelligence: data, including confidential tax or fee information; documents; information; complaints; or lead referrals. Furthermore, the executive board may, as it deems appropriate, invite other state and federal agencies to join the executive board in an advisory capacity. With respect to the oversight of the program, this bill requires DOJ, in consultation with the executive board, to submit a report to the Legislature that includes information on the number of complaints received, the number of cases investigated, the amount of money recovered, a list of agencies that received confidential information, and the number of unauthorized access to confidential information. Finally, DOJ is required to make recommendations that help advance the purpose of this program. Although DOJ can provide valid recommendations for the TRUE program, it may be more appropriate for an outside entity to review the effectiveness of the TRUE program in combating the underground economy. Therefore, the Committee may wish to require that the Legislative Analyst's Office review, on or before January 1, 2022, the effectiveness of the TRUE program, along with recommendations to either improve the program or sunset its operation.
- Why bother coming to the Legislature? Although the RRaCE program sunsets on January 1, 2019, according to staff and the sponsors of this bill, TRaCE continues to operate within DOJ. Since TRaCE continues to operate without legislative authority, it is unclear to Committee staff why legislation is needed. Supporters of this bill have stated that the MOUs and Governor's orders that allow TRaCE to operate are cumbersome and time consuming to implement. As such, by codifying the TRaCE program in statute as the new TRUE program, information will be exchanged more efficiently. Despite this claim, existing MOUs have allowed TRaCE to share information with the Department of Beverage Control, BOE, EDD, FTB, DOJ, FBI, and HSI. To the extent TRaCE is already sharing information with a wide group of departments, both state and federal, it is unclear to Committee staff how the sharing of that information has been at all hindered or complicated through the use of MOUs.
- Veto message: This bill is effectively the same bill as SB 1272 (Galgiani), which was vetoed by the Governor last year. Within the veto message, the Governor specifically highlighted the fact that SB 1272 would have enacted a "task force that is already operational via MOU," perhaps suggesting that legislation is not necessary. Additionally, the Governor explained that the program is "ill-defined and potentially unlimited in scope of operations." As mentioned earlier, this bill is effectively the same as the bill that was vetoed by the Governor. Because additional parameters have not been added, it appears that this version of the bill does not address the Governor's concern. Despite the fact that this bill is essentially the same bill vetoed last year, the new Governor may view the policy differently.
- Prior legislation: SB 1272 (Galgiani), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, was almost identical to this bill. SB 1272 was vetoed.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Attorney General (Sponsor)
California Pool and Spa Association
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Council of Laborers
California State Pipe Trades Council
California Statewide Law Enforcement Association
International Union of Elevator Constructors
Service Employees International Union
Western States Council of Sheet Metal Workers
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Carlos Anguiano / REV. & TAX. / (916) 319-2098
Department of Industrial Relations, Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team Act, Report to the Legislature, April 2018. ↑
Date of Hearing: April 2, 2019
Counsel: Matthew Fleming
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Reginald Byron Jones-Sawyer, Sr., Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1296
Author:(Gonzalez) – As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
SUMMARY:
Establishes the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program (TRUE) in the Department of Justice (DOJ) to combat underground economic activities through a multiagency collaboration. Specifically, this bill:
- Establishes the TRUE Task Force in DOJ to combat underground economic activities through a multiagency collaboration to do, to the extent practicable, the following:
- Pool resources and leverage enforcement efforts;
- Collaborate and share data with state and federal partners;
- Efficiently prosecute violations covering jurisdictions of multiple agencies to address the severity of the crimes and impose appropriate penalties on convicted violators; and
- Recover state revenue lost to the underground economy.
- Specifies that the TRUE Task Force shall include an executive board to ensure efficient and effective multiagency collaboration in furtherance of this act. The executive board shall consist of the following voting members:
- A representative from the Division of Law Enforcement at the Department of Justice;
- A representative from the Criminal Law Division at the Department of Justice;
- A representative from the Investigations and Special Operations Bureau at the California Department of Tax and Fee Administration;
- A representative from the Criminal Investigation Bureau at the Franchise Tax Board; and
- A representative from the Investigation Division at the Employment Development Department.
- Allows the TRUE Task Force to, as the executive board deems appropriate, invite other state and federal agencies to join the executive board in a membership or advisory capacity, as specified.
- States that the TRUE Task Force shall include TRUE teams located in Sacramento, Los Angeles, San Diego, the San Francisco Bay Area, and Fresno.
- States that the addition of an agency to a TRUE Task Force investigative team shall be by written agreement and the written agreement shall govern the participation of the agency joining the investigative team.
- Specifies that each TRUE investigative team shall have a committee established by the TRUE Task Force executive board to ensure efficient and effective multiagency collaboration in each region in furtherance of this act.
- Provides that the TRUE Task Force executive board and each TRUE team committee shall meet as needed, but at least quarterly, to conduct its business.
- States that for cases that involve tax and fee administration associated with underground economic activities, duly authorized members of TRUE Task Force investigative teams, as specified, and members of the teams and committees shall exchange intelligence, data, including confidential tax or fee information, documents, information, complaints, or lead referrals for investigatory purposes.
- Allows authorized agents employed by a state or federal agency invited to join the executive board, to exchange intelligence, data, including confidential tax or fee information, documents, information, complains, or lead referrals with the TRUE Task Force for investigatory purposes, as specified.
- States that for cases that involve a known or suspected felony level tax or fee evasion crime, voting members and advisory members may share confidential tax or fee information with other members of an investigatory team of the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program if all of the following criteria are met:
- The confidential tax or fee information is obtained by a voting member or advisory member of the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program pursuant to existing law, agreements authorized by existing law, or order by the Governor;
- The person who receives the confidential tax or fee information is a peace officer;
- The confidential tax or fee information is for one of the purposes listed in subdivision (c) related to a felony level tax or fee evasion crime;
- The person receiving the confidential tax or fee information has a legitimate need to know to assess leads, conduct an investigation, or prosecute a case; and,
- There is a nondisclosure agreement that prohibits the person receiving the confidential tax or fee information from disclosing the information to any person that is not part of the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program or disclosing the information to any other unauthorized person.
- The confidential tax or fee information is obtained by a voting member or advisory member of the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy Criminal Enforcement Program pursuant to existing law, agreements authorized by existing law, or order by the Governor;
- States that the intelligence, data, including confidential tax or fee information, documents, information, complaints, and lead referrals exchanged pursuant to these provisions shall be used for the following purposes:
- To assess leads or referrals in order to determine if an investigation is warranted;
- To conduct investigations;
- To prosecute violations;
- To conduct data analytics; and,
- To enforce judgments.
- To assess leads or referrals in order to determine if an investigation is warranted;
- Specifies that any person who was or has been involved in the TRUE Task Force, as specified, or any person who has at any time obtained that knowledge shall not divulge, or make known in any manner not provided by law, any of the confidential information received by, or reported to, the TRUE Task Force.
- Provides that confidential information exchanged pursuant the investigatory role of the TRUE Task Force shall retain its confidential status and shall otherwise remain subject to specified confidentiality provisions.
- States that a member of the TRUE Task Force shall not exchange federal tax data without authorization from the Internal Revenue Service.
- States that the TRUE Task Force shall, to the extent the Legislature appropriates funds for purposes of this section, develop a data analytics system that enhances the efficiency and effectiveness of the multiagency collaboration described in the provisions of this bill.
- Specifies that on or before January 1, 2020, and annually thereafter, DOJ in consultation with the executive board of the TRUE Task Force shall submit a report to the Legislature that includes, but is not limited to, the following information:
- The number of leads or complaints received by the TRUE Task Force during the reporting period;
- The number of cases investigated or prosecuted through civil action or criminal prosecution as a result of the work of the TRUE Task Force;
- The amount and final disposition of moneys collected through TRUE Task Force enforcement efforts;
- The status of the multiagency collaboration required by this act;
- The status of any efforts to plan for, develop, and implement a data analytics system that enhances the efficiency and effectiveness of the multiagency collaboration set forth in this act; and
- Policy considerations, if any, to help advance the purpose of the TRUE Task Force.
- Establishes a sunset date for the reporting requirements of January 1, 2024.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that all property is taxable unless otherwise provided by the California Constitution or the laws of the United States. (Cal. Const., Art. XIII, sec. 1.)
- Establishes the Board of Equalization (BOE) which administers sales and use taxes, excise taxes, special taxes, and the state’s fee programs. (Cal. Const., Art. XIII, sec. 17.)
- Allows taxes on or measured by income to be imposed on persons, corporations, or other entities as prescribed by law. (Cal. Const., Art. XIII, sec. 26.)
- Contains various provisions criminalizing tax evasion. (See e.g. Rev. & Tax Code, §§ 7152-7153.5 [false and fraudulent returns regarding sales and use taxes], 19701 et seq. [income tax evasion].)
- Establishes the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team as a pilot program. (Gov. Code, § 15912.)
- States that the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team shall include all of the following state entities:
- Franchise Tax Board;
- Department of Justice;
- State Board of Equalization; and,
- Employment Development Department. (Gov. Code, § 15914, subd. (a).)
- Franchise Tax Board;
- Allows the following agencies to participate in the pilot program in an advisory capacity to the team:
- California Health and Human Services Agency;
- Department of Consumer Affairs;
- Department of Industrial Relations;
- Department of Insurance; and,
- Department of Motor Vehicles. (Gov. Code, § 15914, subd. (b).)
- California Health and Human Services Agency;
- States that Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team is to serve the best interests of the state by combating criminal tax evasion associated with the underground economy, directs the team to do all of the following:
- Develop a plan for a central intake process and organizational structure to document, review, and evaluate data and complaints;
- Evaluate the benefits of a processing center to receive and analyze data, share complaints, and research leads from the input of specified agencies; and
- Provide participating and nonparticipating agencies with investigative leads where collaboration opportunities exist for felony-level criminal investigations, including, but not limited to, referring leads to agencies with appropriate enforcement jurisdiction. (Gov. Code, § 15918.)
- Develop a plan for a central intake process and organizational structure to document, review, and evaluate data and complaints;
- Establishes a sunset date of January 1, 2019, for Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team pilot program. (Gov. Code, § 15924.)
- States that the director of the Employment Development Department, or his or her designee, shall serve as Chairperson of the Joint Enforcement Strike Force on the Underground Economy (JESF). (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329, subd. (a).)
- Specifies that the strike force shall include, but not be limited to, representatives of the Employment Development Department, the Department of Consumer Affairs, the Department of Industrial Relations, and the Office of Criminal Justice Planning. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329, subd. (a).)
- Provides that other agencies that are not part of the administration, such as the Franchise Tax Board, the State Board of Equalization, and the Department of Justice, are encouraged to participate in the strike force. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329, subd. (a).)
- Specifies that JESF has the following duties:
- To facilitate and encourage the development and sharing of information by the participating agencies necessary to combat the underground economy;
- To improve the coordination of activities among the participating agencies;
- To develop methods to pool, focus, and target the enforcement resources of the participating agencies in order to deter tax evasion and maximize recoveries from blatant tax evaders and violators of cash-pay reporting laws; and,
- To reduce enforcement costs wherever possible by eliminating duplicative audits and investigations. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329, subd. (b).)
- States that JESF shall also be empowered to:
- Form joint enforcement teams when appropriate to utilize the collective investigative and enforcement capabilities of the participating members;
- Establish committees and rules of procedure to carry out the activities of the strike force;
- To solicit the cooperation and participation of district attorneys and other state and local agencies in carrying out the objectives of the strike force;
- Establish procedures for soliciting referrals from the public, including, but not limited to, an advertised telephone hotline;
- Develop procedures for improved information sharing among the participating agencies, such as shared automated information data base systems, the use of a common business identification number, and a centralized debt collection system;
- Develop procedures to permit the participating agencies to use more efficient and effective civil sanctions in lieu of criminal actions wherever possible; and,
- Evaluate, based on its activities, the need for any statutory change to accomplish specified objectives. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329, subd. (c).)
- Specifies that JESF shall report to the Governor and the Legislature annually during the period of its existence. (Unemp. Ins. Code, § 329, subd. (d).)
FISCAL EFFECT:
Unknown
COMMENTS:
- Author's Statement: According to the author, “In the ‘underground economy,’ many workers go without basic rights and workplace protections, law-abiding businesses are put in a competitive disadvantage, and the well-being of consumers are put at risk. Furthermore, due to the nature of underground activities, tax revenues that would fund education, public safety agencies and infrastructure projects are lost and uncollected. Assembly Bill 1296 would strengthen the state’s efforts to combat the underground economy by establishing the Tax Recovery in the Underground Economy (TRUE) Crime Enforcement Program in the California Department of Justice. By pooling law enforcement resources, enhancing collaboration and data sharing between participating agencies, and efficiently prosecuting violations, the TRUE Crime Enforcement Program will protect vulnerable workers and communities, punish bad actors, and help recover millions of lost tax revenue.”
- Underground Economy: The underground economy is comprised of individuals and businesses that use various schemes to conceal their activities and evade their tax liabilities by avoiding licensing, regulatory, labor, and tax agencies. Businesses in the underground economy may deliberately fail to report work to appropriate government agencies, obtain proper permits, secure the appropriate insurance, provide sufficient safety and skills training to workers, or pay fees, taxes, or minimum wages. Other evasive practices include paying workers a lower wage than stated on payroll reports, misclassifying workers as independent contractors to avoid paying employee-level fees and taxes, and misreporting profits and material costs to avoid taxes. (California and the Underground Economy, UCLA Labor Center, April 2013.)
The UCLA Labor Center notes it is difficult to calculate the size of the underground economy because underground businesses are not participating in systems that would allow for data collection . The UCLA Labor Center acknowledges that the statistics on the extent of the informal economy are unreliable and vary widely. The few numbers that do exist on the size of the underground economy are largely based on national estimates. The California Employment Development Department, based on their analysis of Internal Revenue Service date, estimates California’s underground economy at $60 - $140 billion annually. (Id.)
In addition, the Little Hoover Commission generated a detailed report on the Underground Economy and the challenges it poses to law enforcement. (Level the Playing Field: Put California’s Underground Economy Out of Business, Little Hoover Commission, March 2015, available at: https://lhc.ca.gov/sites/lhc.ca.gov/files/Reports/226/Report226.pdf, [as of March 27, 2019.) That report explains the nuances of the underground economy’s workings and covers past efforts to combat the underground economy, including the prior pilot project that forms the basis of this bill, AB 576.
- Prior Pilot Program Involving DOJ Which Targets the Underground Economy: AB 576 (Author:V. Manuel Pérez) Chapter 614, Statutes of 2013, created the “Centralized Intelligence Partnership” pilot program consisting of specified agencies to collaborate in combating those engaged in the underground economy. AB 576 established a pilot program to create a multiagency team consisting of the Franchise Tax Board, DOJ, State Board of Equalization, and Employment Development Department, to be known as the Revenue Recovery and Collaborative Enforcement Team, to collaborate in combating criminal tax evasion associated with the underground economy by, among other activities, developing a plan for a central intake process and organizational structure to document, review, and evaluate data and complaints. AB 576 authorized other specified state entities to participate in the pilot program in an advisory capacity. The pilot program allowed team members to exchange information for the purpose of investigating criminal tax evasion associated with the underground economy. There was a sunset date of January 1, 2019 on the pilot program. This bill would essentially refine and make permanent the program initially established by AB 576.
- Other Task Forces Targeting the Underground Economy: The Joint Enforcement Strike Force (JESF), and the Labor Enforcement Task Force (LETF) both have the power to investigate and combat California’s underground economy.
Joint Enforcement Task Force: The Joint Enforcement Strike Force (JESF) is a coalition of California State government enforcement agencies that work together and in partnership with local and federal agencies to combat the underground economy to ensure a level playing field for California businesses. The JESF’s goals are intended to help restore economic stability and to improve working conditions and consumer and worker protection in the State.
The goals of the JESF are to:
- Eliminate unfair business competition.
- Protect workers by ensuring they receive all compensation, benefits, and worker protections they are entitled to by law relating to their employment.
- Protect the consumer by ensuring all businesses are properly licensed and they adhere to the State’s consumer protection regulations.
- Reduce the burden on law-abiding citizens and businesses by ensuring all businesses and individuals comply with the State’s licensing, regulatory, and payroll tax laws.
- Reduce the tax gap by increasing voluntary compliance with the State’s payroll tax laws to maximize the State’s General and Special Fund revenues.
Governor Pete Wilson’s Executive Order W-66-93 created JESF on October 26, 1993. Subsequently, in 1994, the Governor signed SB 1490 (Johnston) which placed the provisions of the Executive Order into the California Unemployment Insurance Code. The Employment Development Department (EDD) is the lead agency for the JESF, and the Director of EDD is the chairperson. JESF is responsible for developing and sharing of information necessary to combat the underground economy, improve the coordination of enforcement activities, and develop methods to pool, focus, and target enforcement resources. JESF’s membership is comprised of EDD, multiple agencies within Department of Consumer Affairs, multiple divisions within the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), Department of Insurance, Franchise Tax Board, Board of Equalization (BOE), CA Department of Alcoholic Beverage Control, Internal Revenue Service, and the DOJ. (http://www.edd.ca.gov/Payroll_Taxes/Joint_Enforcement_Strike_Force.htm)
Labor Enforcement Task Force: Under the direction of the Department of Industrial Relations, the LETF is a coalition of the California State government enforcement agencies to share information and resources to ensure employees are paid properly and have safe work conditions and honest, law-abiding businesses. The participating agencies are the DIR, Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE), the Division of Occupational Safety and Health (OSHA), Employment Development Department (EDD), Board of Equalization (BOE), California Department of Insurance, the State Attorney General, Alcoholic Beverage Control, the Department of Consumer Affairs, Contractor’s State Licensing Board (CSLC), and BAR. (http://www.dir.ca.gov/letf/letf.html)
Working together with combined authority, LETF teams have access to a fuller range of enforcement tools than does each agency on its own:
DLSE has the authority under Labor Code Section 90 to access all places of employment. Other LETF partners do not have this full authority. DLSE may also issue stop orders requiring employers to cease illegal operations immediately.
OSHA has the authority to issue citations for serious, willful, and repeat violations. OSHA may also issue an order prohibiting use where a condition or practice exists that creates an imminent hazard to the safety and health of employees.
EDD has authority under Unemployment Insurance Code Section 1092 to require employers to provide records for inspection anytime during the employing unit’s business hours.
CSLB is able to suspend contractors’ licenses until the penalties issued by DLSE and EDD are paid. Penalties are far more likely to be paid promptly when the license is suspended until payment.
LETF states that joint enforcement offers a couple of advantages. First, because LETF inspection teams comprise members from multiple agencies, one LETF inspection has less impact on business operations than multiple separate inspections by the individual agencies. Second, when several agencies working together do find egregious employer misconduct, the ensuing publicity has a deterrent effect that is much more powerful than if only a single agency were enforcing. (LETF Report to the California Legislature 2015.)
Most participants of the TRUE Task Force would overlap with JESF and LETF.
- Governor Brown’s Veto Message on SB 1272: SB 1272 would have created an underground economy task force nearly identical to the one proposed by this bill, under a different name, the Tax Recovery and Criminal Enforcement Tax Force (TRaCE). SB 1272 was vetoed by Governor Brown with the following message:
“This bill creates the Tax Recovery and Criminal Enforcement Tax Force within the Department of Justice to combat underground economic activities.
“I am sympathetic to rooting out businesses that engage in unfair competition and mistreatment of workers. This is an area of great interest to me, and one which I have worked on as Attorney General and as Governor.
“This bill, however, codifies a task force that is already operational via MOU and establishes a permanent program within the Department of Justice with an ill-defined and potentially unlimited scope of operations. I am reluctant to do this without additional and more detailed scrutiny through the budget process.”
- Argument in Support: According to Xavier Becerra, the Attorney General of the State of California: “According to a 2013 University of California at Los Angeles Labor Center report, the state’s underground economy generates between $60 to $140 billion in revenue annually. An estimated $8.5 billion in corporate, personal, sales and use taxes go uncollected each year. To help respond to this problem, several state agencies formed a pilot program in 2014 to investigate and prosecute the most egregious felony-level multijurisdictional underground economic crimes from a tax prospective. Participating agencies include the Department of Justice, the Department of Tax and Fee Administration, the Franchise Tax Board, and the Employment Development Department.
“Under the pilot program, investigative teams were established in Sacramento and Los Angeles. In just a few years, these teams have identified $482 million in unreported gross receipts and $60 million in associated tax loss to the state. Through its criminal enforcement actions, the pilot program has obtained court orders to recover over $25 million in lost tax revenue, victim restitution, and investigation costs. The pilot program is currently seeking over $25 million in pending cases.
“The pilot program received formal recognition from a wide range of stakeholders, including the White House and then-Lieutenant Governor Gavin Newsom for the program’s innovative, whole-government approach in reducing the underground economy. The Little Hoover Commission also acknowledged the accomplishments of the pilot program and published a report on the underground economy that recommends expanding the pilot program’s investigative teams to every major metropolitan region in the state.
“Consistent with the Little Hoover Commission’s recommendations, AB 1296 would build off the successes of the pilot program’s work by permanently establishing the existing teams in Sacramento and Los Angeles and authorizing additional teams in three other major metropolitan regions of the state—San Diego, the Bay Area, and Fresno.
“The Attorney General is proud to sponsor AB 1296. The bill is an important measure that would substantially strengthen the state’s efforts to combat and deter underground economic crimes in California. Our workers, business owners, consumers, and taxpayers would be the biggest beneficiaries of a robust program.”
- Prior Legislation:
- SB 1272 (Galgiani), of the 2017- 2018 Legislative Session, would have enacted the Tax Recovery and Criminal Enforcement Tax Force Act, establishing the TRaCE Task Force in the Department of Justice (DOJ) to combat underground economic activities through a multiagency collaboration of enforcement agencies in order to efficiently prosecute violations. SB 1272 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
- AB 576 (Author:V. Manuel Pérez), Chapter 614, Statutes of 2013, created the “Centralized Intelligence Partnership” pilot program consisting of specified agencies to collaborate in combating those engaged in the underground economy.
- SB 1185 (Author:Price), of the 2011-12 Legislative Session, would have created the “Centralized Intelligence Partnership” as a clearinghouse for multiple agencies to collaborate to prosecute violators engaged in illegal activity as part of the underground economy. SB 1185 was held on the Assembly Appropriations Committee's Suspense File.
- SB 1490 (Johnston), Chapter 1117, Statutes of 1994, codified the Joint Enforcement Strike Force on the Underground Economy under the Employment Development Department.
- SB 1272 (Galgiani), of the 2017- 2018 Legislative Session, would have enacted the Tax Recovery and Criminal Enforcement Tax Force Act, establishing the TRaCE Task Force in the Department of Justice (DOJ) to combat underground economic activities through a multiagency collaboration of enforcement agencies in order to efficiently prosecute violations. SB 1272 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Attorney General for the State of California
California State Council of Laborers
California Statewide Law Enforcement Association
Opposition
None
Analysis Prepared by:
Matthew Fleming / PUB. S. / (916) 319-3744
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):