AB 1451: Petition circulators.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-09-17
(1)Existing law authorizes a person who is 18 years of age or older to circulate an initiative, referendum, or recall petition anywhere within the state.
This bill would provide that a person or organization who pays a person money or any other thing of value based on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition is guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by a specified fine, imprisonment, or both that fine and imprisonment. By creating a new crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(2)Existing law requires that each section of a petition for an initiative or referendum measure have attached thereto the declaration of the person soliciting the signatures that includes specified information.
This bill would require a person who solicits signatures for a proposed initiative measure and does not receive money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors to make additional declarations, as specified.
(3)Existing law requires local elections officials to perform various duties with respect to statewide initiative and referendum petitions including, within 8 days after the filing of a petition, determining the total number of signatures affixed to the petition. Existing law also requires an elections official, within 30 days of notification from the Secretary of State that a petition has received 100% or more of the signatures needed to declare the petition sufficient, to determine the number of qualified voters who signed the petition.
This bill would extend the time a local elections official is required to determine the total number of signatures affixed to a petition to 10 days, and would extend the time a local elections official is required to determine the number of qualified voters who signed the petition to 35 days after receiving notice from the Secretary of State that the petition has received the signatures needed to declare the petition sufficient.
This bill would require at least 10% of the signatures that are required to qualify an initiative measure to be solicited by a person who does not receive money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors. The bill would require an elections official who determines the total number of signatures affixed to a petition and verifies those signatures to also determine the total number of signatures submitted by persons who do not receive money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors and verify those signatures.
(4)Existing law requires, if the statistical sampling shows that the number of valid signatures on a petition is within 95 to 110% of the number of signatures of qualified voters needed to declare the petition sufficient, the Secretary of State to order the examination and verification of each signature filed and to notify the elections officials.
This bill, with regard to an initiative petition for which the statistical sampling shows that the number of valid signatures for all signatures submitted is more than 110% of the number of qualified voters needed to find the petition sufficient, but the number of valid signatures submitted for purposes of the 10% requirement described above is within 95 to 110% of the number of signatures needed to satisfy that requirement, would require the Secretary of State to only order an examination and verification of each signature filed to satisfy the 10% requirement.
(5)Existing law requires every proposed initiative measure, prior to circulation, to include on the petition, among other things, the circulating title and summary prepared by the Attorney General and a heading for the initiative measure, as specified. Existing law also permits a petition for a proposed initiative or referendum measure to be presented in sections, as specified.
This bill would provide that its provisions do not apply to any initiative petition for which the Attorney General issued a circulating title and summary before January July 1, 2020. The bill would require a petition for a proposed initiative measure to have printed in the one-inch space across the top of the first page of each section of the petition, in 18-point roman boldface type, the circulating title for the measure prepared by the Attorney General. The bill would additionally require a petition for a proposed initiative measure that is circulated by persons who do not receive money or other valuable consideration for the purpose of obtaining signatures of electors to be printed on white green paper in a contrasting color ink. The bill also would require a petition for a proposed initiative measure that is circulated by persons who do receive money or other valuable consideration for the purpose of obtaining signatures of electors to be printed on paper of a color other than white in a contrasting color ink. white paper in a contrasting color ink.
(6)Under existing law, an initiative petition must contain specified language advising the public of its right to ask whether the person circulating the petition is a paid signature gatherer or a volunteer.
This bill would additionally require an initiative petition to include a disclosure, as specified, notifying the public that the petition circulator is receiving money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors, or is a volunteer or employee of a nonprofit organization.
(7)Existing law provides that a person who engages in specified conduct in connection with the collection of signatures on any initiative, referendum, or recall petition is guilty of a misdemeanor.
This bill would require that an initiative petition section be deemed invalid, and would prohibit use of the petition section for the purpose of determining whether the initiative measure qualifies for the ballot, if the signatures are solicited and submitted by a person who engages in fraud, misrepresentation, or any of the specified conduct for which the person may be found guilty of a misdemeanor. The bill would authorize specified persons to enforce this provision by a civil action upon a showing of clear and convincing evidence.
(8)Because this bill would impose new requirements on local elections officials relative to calculating and verifying signatures on a petition, it would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that with regard to certain mandates no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
With regard to any other mandates, this bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs so mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
(9)This bill would incorporate additional changes to Section 9030 of the Elections Code proposed by AB 698 and AB 1829 to be operative only if this bill and those bills are enacted and this bill is enacted last.
This bill would incorporate additional changes to Section 9031 of the Elections Code proposed by AB 698 to be operative only if this bill and AB 698 are enacted and this bill is enacted last.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(1)The power of the initiative is a fundamental right reserved to the voters of California and must be protected as a means of governing through direct democracy.
(2)The voters amended the California Constitution to reserve to themselves the power of the initiative because financially powerful interests, including railroad companies, exercised a corrupting influence over state politics.
(3)The purpose of reserving the initiative power was to provide individuals, communities, and coalitions a means to protect the general interests of the State of California.
(4)For the past 30 years, a disturbing trend in the states political process has undermined the original intent of the initiative power.
(5)The presence of an initiative measure on the ballot is no longer necessarily viewed as an expression of a minimum amount of public support, but, instead, is often viewed as the result of a special interest willing to pay the necessary amount of money to qualify an initiative measure for the ballot. As a result, the integrity of the initiative process is threatened by a crowded ballot with confusing proposals and the perception of fraud and misrepresentation in the signature gathering phase.
(6)Initiative petitions circulated by volunteer and grassroots organizations demonstrate significant public support for a proposed law, but well-funded individuals and organizations that promote narrow interests may rely exclusively on paid circulators to qualify an initiative measure that does not have broad community support. In many cases, the individuals and organizations supporting an initiative petition do not reside in the state and will not be subject to the laws that they propose.
(7)As has been the case since the initiative power was created, initiatives that have broad public support continue to qualify for the ballot through the efforts of volunteers and grassroots organizations, but the availability of paid circulators has led to an excess of complex proposals that lack a broad level of public support. Paid circulators gather as many signatures as possible in the least amount of time, and may not provide electors with a full explanation of the true purpose and effect of the proposed initiative measure. Without a better measure of public support, special interests may qualify an initiative measure for the ballot regardless of the actual content of the proposal.
(8)Improving the measure of public support for a proposed initiative measure will increase the publics confidence and protect the integrity of the initiative process. A volunteer and grassroots effort to qualify an initiative measure for the ballot demonstrates a significant level of public support.
(9)The Legislature is responsible for providing the manner in which initiative petitions are circulated, presented, and certified. Consistent with this constitutional duty, the Legislature must provide for laws that are consistent with the intent of the voters in reserving the power of the initiative; protect the integrity of the initiative process; and prevent the occurrence of fraud and misrepresentation in the circulation, presentation, and certification of initiative petitions.
(b)Therefore, it is the intent of the Legislature to do all of the following:
(1)Preserve and protect the integrity of Californias initiative process.
(2)Ensure that initiative petitions have sufficient public support from informed voters to be placed on the ballot.
(3)Protect access to the initiative process and preserve the constitutional right of voters in California to engage in direct democracy.
SEC. 2.Section 102.5 is added to the Elections Code, to read:102.5.(a)A person or organization who pays a person money or any other thing of value based on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition is guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by a fine not to exceed twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000), or by imprisonment in a county jail not to exceed one year, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(b)This section does not prohibit the payment for signature gathering not based, either directly or indirectly, on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
SEC. 3.Section 9008 of the Elections Code is amended to read:9008.Each proposed initiative measure, prior to circulation, shall have placed across the top of the petition all of the following:(a)The Attorney Generals unique numeric identifier, in 12-point or larger roman boldface type, placed before the circulating title and summary upon each page where the circulating title and summary is to appear.(b)(1)The circulating title and summary prepared by the Attorney General, in 12-point or larger roman boldface type, upon each page of the petition on which signatures are to appear.(2)The circulating title and summary prepared by the Attorney General, in 12-point or larger roman boldface type, upon each section of the petition preceding the text of the measure.(3)Notwithstanding Section 9013, on the first page of each section of the petition, the circulating title prepared by the Attorney General shall be placed in the one-inch space across the top of the page in 18-point roman boldface type. (c)The circulating title and summary prepared by the Attorney General, as required by paragraph (2) of subdivision (b), shall be preceded by the following statement in 12-point or larger roman boldface type: Initiative measure to be submitted directly to the voters.SEC. 4.SEC. 3.Section 9009.5 is added to the Elections Code, to read:9009.5.(a)A petition for a proposed initiative measure that is circulated by a person who does not receive money or other valuable consideration for the purpose of soliciting signatures of electors, for purposes of Section 9036, shall be printed on white green paper in a contrasting color ink.
(b)A petition for a proposed initiative measure that is circulated by a person who receives money or other valuable consideration for the purpose of soliciting signatures of electors shall be printed on paper of a color other than white in a contrasting color ink. white paper in a contrasting color ink.
SEC. 5.SEC. 4.Section 9009.6 is added to the Elections Code, to read:9009.6.Notwithstanding any other law, a petition for a proposed initiative measure that is circulated by a person who receives money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors, except as provided by paragraph (1) of subdivision (b) of Section 9036, shall include the following statement immediately prior to the portion of the petition for voters signatures, printed names, and residence addresses, printed in 12-point boldface type:
NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: THIS PETITION IS BEING CIRCULATED BY A PERSON PAID TO OBTAIN YOUR SIGNATURE. YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO READ THE CONTENTS OF THIS PETITION BEFORE
SIGNING.
SEC. 6.SEC. 5.Section 9009.7 is added to the Elections Code, to read:9009.7.
Notwithstanding any other law, a petition for a proposed initiative measure that is circulated by a person who does not receive money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors shall include the following statement immediately prior to the portion of the petition for voters signatures, printed names, and residence addresses, printed in 12-point boldface type:
NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: THIS PETITION IS BEING CIRCULATED BY A VOLUNTEER OR AN EMPLOYEE OF A NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION. YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO READ THE CONTENTS OF THIS PETITION BEFORE SIGNING.
SEC. 7.SEC. 6.Section 9022.5 is added to the Elections Code, to read:9022.5.
In addition to the information required by Sections 104 and 9022, the declaration of a person who solicits signatures for a proposed initiative measure and does not receive money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors pursuant to Section 9036 shall declare all of the following:
(a)The person does not receive money or other valuable consideration for soliciting signatures of electors for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036.
(b)To the best of the persons knowledge, the signatures on the petition sections circulated by the person should be counted towards the requirement set forth in subdivision (a) of Section 9036.
SEC. 8.SEC. 7.Section 9030 of the Elections Code is amended to read:9030.(a)Each section of the petition shall be filed with the elections official of the county or city and county in which it was circulated, but all sections circulated in any county or city and county shall be filed at the same time. Once filed, no petition section shall be amended except by order of a court of competent jurisdiction.
(b)Within 10 days after the filing of the petition, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays, the elections official shall determine the total number of signatures affixed to the petition and, in the case of an initiative petition, the total number of signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036. The elections official shall transmit this information to the Secretary of State. If the total number of signatures filed with all elections officials is less than 100 percent of the number of qualified voters required to find the petition sufficient or, in the case of an initiative petition, the number of signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 is less than the total number needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the Secretary of State shall so notify the proponents and the elections officials, and no further action shall be taken with regard to the petition.
(c)If the number of signatures filed with all elections officials is 100 percent or more of the number of qualified voters needed to declare the petition sufficient and, in the case of an initiative petition, the number of signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 is equal to or greater than the total number needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the Secretary of State shall immediately so notify the elections officials.
(d)(1) Within 35 days after this notification, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays, the elections official shall determine the number of qualified voters who have signed the petition and the number of qualified voters who have signed a section of the petition that satisfies the requirement of subdivision (a) of Section 9036.
(2)(A)If more than 500 names have been signed on sections of the petition filed with an elections official, the elections official shall use a random sampling technique for verification of signatures, as determined by the Secretary of State. The random sample of signatures to be verified shall be drawn from all petition sections in such a manner that every signature filed with the elections official shall be given an equal opportunity to be included in the sample.
(B)For initiative petitions, a second random sample of signatures shall be drawn from all petition sections submitted to satisfy subdivision (a) of Section 9036 and verified according to the procedures set forth by the Secretary of State. The verification of signatures that are submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 shall be consistent with subdivision (g) of that section.
(C)In each case, the random sampling shall include an examination of at least 500 signatures or 3 percent of the signatures on the respective petitions or sections of petitions, whichever is greater.
(3)In determining from the records of registration the number of qualified voters who have signed the petition, the elections official may use any facsimiles of voters signatures, provided that the method of preparing and displaying the facsimiles complies with law.
(e)The elections official, upon the completion of the examination, shall immediately attach to the petition, except the signatures thereto appended, a properly dated certificate showing the result of the examination and shall immediately transmit the petition and the certificate to the Secretary of State. A copy of this certificate shall be filed in the elections officials office.
(f)If the certificates received from all elections officials by the Secretary of State establish that the number of valid signatures does not equal 95 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to find the petition sufficient or, in the case of an initiative petition, that the number of valid signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 does not equal 95 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the petition shall be deemed to have failed to qualify, and the Secretary of State shall immediately so notify the proponents and the elections officials.
(g)If the certificates received from all elections officials by the Secretary of State total more than 110 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to find the petition sufficient and, in the case of an initiative petition, the number of valid signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 total more than 110 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the petition shall be deemed to qualify as of the date of receipt of certificates by the Secretary of State showing the petition received more than 110 percent of the qualified voters needed, and the Secretary of State shall immediately so notify the proponents and the elections officials.
(h)The Secretary of State shall adopt regulations consistent with this section. The initial regulations may be adopted as emergency regulations in accordance with Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, and shall be deemed necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, safety, or general welfare.
SEC. 7.3.Section 9030 of the Elections Code is amended to read:9030.(a)Each section of the petition shall be filed with the elections official of the county or city and county in which it was circulated, but all sections circulated in any county or city and county shall be filed at the same time. Once filed, no petition section shall be amended except by order of a court of competent jurisdiction.
(b)Within eight 10 days after the filing of the petition, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays, the elections official shall determine the total number of signatures affixed to the petition and and, in the case of an initiative petition, the total number of signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036. The elections official shall transmit this information to the Secretary of State. If the total number of signatures filed with all elections officials is less than 100 percent of the number of qualified voters required to find the petition sufficient, sufficient or, in the case of an initiative petition, the number of signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 is less than the total number needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the Secretary of State shall so notify the proponents and the elections officials, and no further action shall be taken with regard to the petition.
(c)If the number of signatures filed with all elections officials is 100 percent or more of the number of qualified voters needed to declare the petition sufficient, sufficient and, in the case of an initiative petition, the number of signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 is equal to or greater than the total number needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the Secretary of State shall immediately so notify the elections officials.
(d)(1)Within 35 days after this notification, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays, the elections official shall determine the number of qualified voters who have signed the petition and the number of qualified voters who have signed a section of the petition that satisfies the requirement of subdivision (a) of Section 9036.
(d)Within 30 days after this notification, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays, the elections official shall determine the number of qualified voters who have signed the petition.(2)(A)If more than 500 names have been signed on sections of the petition filed with an elections official, the elections official shall use a random sampling technique for verification of signatures, as determined by the Secretary of State. The random sample of signatures to be verified shall be drawn from all petition sections in such a manner that every signature filed with the elections official shall be given an equal opportunity to be included in the sample. The random sampling shall include an examination of at least 500 or 3 percent of the signatures, whichever is greater. In determining from the records of registration what number of qualified voters have signed the petition, the elections official may use any facsimiles of voters signatures provided that the method of preparing and displaying the facsimiles complies with law.
(B)For initiative petitions, a second random sample of signatures shall be drawn from all petition sections submitted to satisfy subdivision (a) of Section 9036 and verified according to the procedures set forth by the Secretary of State. The verification of signatures that are submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 shall be consistent with subdivision (g) of that section.
(C)In each case, the random sampling shall include an examination of at least 500 signatures or 3 percent of the signatures on the respective petitions or sections of petitions, whichever is greater.
(3)In determining from the records of registration the number of qualified voters who have signed the petition, the elections official may use any facsimiles of voters signatures, provided that the method of preparing and displaying the facsimiles complies with law. A signature shall not be invalidated because of a variation of the signature caused by the substitution of initials for the first or middle name, or both, of the person signing the petition.
(e)The elections official, upon the completion of the examination, shall immediately attach to the petition, except the signatures thereto appended, a properly dated certificate, certificate showing the result of the examination, examination and shall immediately transmit the petition and the certificate to the Secretary of State. A copy of this certificate shall be filed in the elections officials office.
(f)If the certificates received from all elections officials by the Secretary of State establish that the number of valid signatures does not equal 95 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to find the petition sufficient, sufficient or, in the case of an initiative petition, that the number of valid signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 does not equal 95 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the petition shall be deemed to have failed to qualify, and the Secretary of State shall immediately so notify the proponents and the elections officials.
(g)If the certificates received from all elections officials by the Secretary of State total more than 110 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to find the petition sufficient, sufficient and, in the case of an initiative petition, the number of valid signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 total more than 110 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the petition shall be deemed to qualify as of the date of receipt of certificates by the Secretary of State shall certify that the measure is qualified for the ballot as provided in Section 9033. showing the petition received more than 110 percent of the qualified voters needed, and the Secretary of State shall immediately so notify the proponents and the elections officials.
(h)The Secretary of State shall adopt regulations consistent with this section. The initial regulations may be adopted as emergency regulations in accordance with Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, and shall be deemed necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, safety, or general welfare.
SEC. 7.5.Section 9030 of the Elections Code is amended to read:9030.(a)Each section of the petition shall be filed with the elections official of the county or city and county in for which it was circulated, but all sections circulated in any county or city and county shall be filed at the same time. Once filed, no petition section shall be amended except by order of a court of competent jurisdiction.
(b)Within eight 10 days after the filing of the petition, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays, the elections official shall determine the total number of signatures affixed to the petition and and, in the case of an initiative petition, the total number of signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036. The elections official shall transmit this information to the Secretary of State. If the total number of signatures filed with all elections officials is less than 100 percent of the number of qualified voters required to find the petition sufficient, the sufficient or, in the case of an initiative petition, the number of signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 is less than the total number needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the Secretary of State shall so notify the proponents and the elections officials, and no further action shall be taken with regard to the petition.
(c)If the number of signatures filed with all elections officials is 100 percent or more of the number of qualified voters needed to declare the petition sufficient, the sufficient and, in the case of an initiative petition, the number of signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 is equal to or greater than the total number needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the Secretary of State shall immediately so notify the elections officials.
(d)(1)Within 35 days after this notification, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays, the elections official shall determine the number of qualified voters who have signed the petition and the number of qualified voters who have signed a section of the petition that satisfies the requirement of subdivision (a) of Section 9036.
(d)Within 30 days after this notification, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays, the elections official shall determine the number of qualified voters who have signed the petition.(2)(A)If more than 500 names have been signed on sections of the petition filed with an elections official, the elections official shall use a random sampling technique for verification of signatures, as determined by the Secretary of State. The random sample of signatures to be verified shall be drawn from all petition sections in such a manner that every signature filed with the elections official shall be given an equal opportunity to be included in the sample. The random sampling shall include an examination of at least 500 or 3 percent of the signatures, whichever is greater. In determining from the records of registration what number of qualified voters have signed the petition, the elections official may use any facsimiles of voters signatures provided that the method of preparing and displaying the facsimiles complies with law.
(B)For initiative petitions, a second random sample of signatures shall be drawn from all petition sections submitted to satisfy subdivision (a) of Section 9036 and verified according to the procedures set forth by the Secretary of State. The verification of signatures that are submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 shall be consistent with subdivision (g) of that section.
(C)In each case, the random sampling shall include an examination of at least 500 signatures or 3 percent of the signatures on the respective petitions or sections of petitions, whichever is greater.
(3)In determining from the records of registration the number of qualified voters who have signed the petition, the elections official may use any facsimiles of voters signatures, provided that the method of preparing and displaying the facsimiles complies with law.
(e)The elections official, upon the completion of the examination, shall immediately attach to the petition, except the signatures thereto appended, a properly dated certificate, certificate showing the result of the examination, examination and shall immediately transmit the petition and the certificate to the Secretary of State. A copy of this certificate shall be filed in the elections officials office.
(f)If the certificates received from all elections officials by the Secretary of State establish that the number of valid signatures does not equal 95 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to find the petition sufficient, the sufficient or, in the case of an initiative petition, that the number of valid signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 does not equal 95 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the petition shall be deemed to have failed to qualify, and the Secretary of State shall immediately so notify the proponents and the elections officials.
(g)If the certificates received from all elections officials by the Secretary of State total more than 110 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to find the petition sufficient, the Secretary of State shall certify that the measure is qualified for the ballot as provided in Section 9033. sufficient and, in the case of an initiative petition, the number of valid signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 total more than 110 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the petition shall be deemed to qualify as of the date of receipt of certificates by theSecretary of state showing the petition received more than 110 percent of the qualified voters needed, and the Secretary of State shall immediately so notify the proponents and the elections officials.
(h)The Secretary of State shall adopt regulations consistent with this section. The initial regulations may be adopted as emergency regulations in accordance with Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, and shall be deemed necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, safety, or general welfare.
SEC. 7.7.Section 9030 of the Elections Code is amended to read:9030.(a)Each section of the petition shall be filed with the elections official of the county or city and county in for which it was circulated, but all sections circulated in any county or city and county shall be filed at the same time. Once filed, no petition section shall be amended except by order of a court of competent jurisdiction.
(b)Within eight 10 days after the filing of the petition, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays, the elections official shall determine the total number of signatures affixed to the petition and and, in the case of an initiative petition, the total number of signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036. The elections official shall transmit this information to the Secretary of State. If the total number of signatures filed with all elections officials is less than 100 percent of the number of qualified voters required to find the petition sufficient, sufficient or, in the case of an initiative petition, the number of signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 is less than the total number needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the Secretary of State shall so notify the proponents and the elections officials, and no further action shall be taken with regard to the petition.
(c)If the number of signatures filed with all elections officials is 100 percent or more of the number of qualified voters needed to declare the petition sufficient, sufficient and, in the case of an initiative petition, the number of signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 is equal to or greater than the total number needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the Secretary of State shall immediately so notify the elections officials.
(d)(1)Within 35 days after this notification, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays, the elections official shall determine the number of qualified voters who have signed the petition and the number of qualified voters who have signed a section of the petition that satisfies the requirement of subdivision (a) of Section 9036.
(d)Within 30 days after this notification, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays, the elections official shall determine the number of qualified voters who have signed the petition.(2)(A)If more than 500 names have been signed on sections of the petition filed with an elections official, the elections official shall use a random sampling technique for verification of signatures, as determined by the Secretary of State. The random sample of signatures to be verified shall be drawn from all petition sections in such a manner that every signature filed with the elections official shall be given an equal opportunity to be included in the sample. The random sampling shall include an examination of at least 500 or 3 percent of the signatures, whichever is greater. In determining from the records of registration what number of qualified voters have signed the petition, the elections official may use any facsimiles of voters signatures provided that the method of preparing and displaying the facsimiles complies with law.
(B)For initiative petitions, a second random sample of signatures shall be drawn from all petition sections submitted to satisfy subdivision (a) of Section 9036 and verified according to the procedures set forth by the Secretary of State. The verification of signatures that are submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 shall be consistent with subdivision (g) of that section.
(C)In each case, the random sampling shall include an examination of at least 500 signatures or 3 percent of the signatures on the respective petitions or sections of petitions, whichever is greater.
(3)In determining from the records of registration the number of qualified voters who have signed the petition, the elections official may use any facsimiles of voters signatures, provided that the method of preparing and displaying the facsimiles complies with law. A signature shall not be invalidated because of a variation of the signature caused by the substitution of initials for the first or middle name, or both, of the person signing the petition.
(e)The elections official, upon the completion of the examination, shall immediately attach to the petition, except the signatures thereto appended, a properly dated certificate, certificate showing the result of the examination, examination and shall immediately transmit the petition and the certificate to the Secretary of State. A copy of this certificate shall be filed in the elections officials office.
(f)If the certificates received from all elections officials by the Secretary of State establish that the number of valid signatures does not equal 95 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to find the petition sufficient, sufficient or, in the case of an initiative petition, that the number of valid signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 does not equal 95 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the petition shall be deemed to have failed to qualify, and the Secretary of State shall immediately so notify the proponents and the elections officials.
(g)If the certificates received from all elections officials by the Secretary of State total more than 110 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to find the petition sufficient, the Secretary of State shall certify that the measure is qualified for the ballot as provided in Section 9033. sufficient and, in the case of an initiative petition, the number of valid signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 total more than 110 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the petition shall be deemed to qualify as of the date of receipt of certificates by the Secretary of State showing the petition received more than 110 percent of the qualified voters needed, and the Secretary of State shall immediately so notify the proponents and the elections officials.
(h)The Secretary of State shall adopt regulations consistent with this section. The initial regulations may be adopted as emergency regulations in accordance with Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, and shall be deemed necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, safety, or general welfare.
SEC. 9.SEC. 8.Section 9031 of the Elections Code is amended to read:9031.(a)(1)If the statistical sampling shows that the number of valid signatures on all petition sections, including those submitted to satisfy subdivision (a) of Section 9036, is within 95 to 110 percent of the number of signatures of qualified voters needed to declare the petition sufficient, the Secretary of State shall order the examination and verification of each signature filed, and shall so notify the elections officials.
(2)In the case of an initiative petition, if the statistical sampling shows that the number of valid signatures for all signatures submitted is more than 110 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to find the petition sufficient, but the number of valid signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 is within 95 to 110 percent of the number of signatures needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the Secretary of State shall only order an examination and verification of each signature filed to satisfy the requirement of subdivision (a) of Section 9036.
(b)(1)Within 35 days, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays, after receipt of the order, the elections official or registrar of voters shall determine from the records of registration the number of qualified voters who have signed a section of the petition that is subject to examination under subdivision (a) and, if necessary, the board of supervisors shall allow the elections official or registrar additional assistance for the purpose of examining the petition and provide for their compensation. In determining from the records of registration the number of qualified voters who have signed the petition, the elections official or registrar of voters may use any file or list of registered voters maintained by the office of the official or registrar, or the facsimiles of voters signatures, provided that the method of preparing and displaying the facsimiles complies with law.
(2)The examination of signatures that are submitted to satisfy subdivision (a) of Section 9036 shall be made pursuant to subdivision (g) of that section.
(c)(1)During the examination and verification of the signatures filed, the elections official or registrar of voters shall submit one or more reports to the Secretary of State showing the number of signatures of qualified voters that have been verified as of that date. The Secretary of State shall determine the number of reports required to be submitted and the manner of their submission.
(2)The Secretary of State shall maintain a list indicating the number of verified signatures of qualified voters who have signed the petition based on the most recent reports submitted pursuant to paragraph (1). If the Secretary of State determines, prior to each countys completing the examination of each signature filed, that based on the list the petition is signed by the requisite number of voters needed to declare the petition sufficient, the Secretary of State shall immediately notify the elections official or registrar of voters of every county or city and county in the state of this fact. Immediately after receipt of this notification, the elections official or registrar of voters may suspend signature verification until receipt of a certificate pursuant to Section 9033 or until otherwise instructed by the Secretary of State.
(d)The elections official or registrar, upon the completion of the examination, shall immediately attach to the petition, except the signatures thereto appended, an amended certificate properly dated, showing the result of the examination and shall immediately transmit the petition, together with the amended certificate, to the Secretary of State. A copy of the amended certificate shall be filed in the elections officials office.
(e)(1)If the amended certificates establish the petitions sufficiency, the petition shall be deemed to be filed as of the date of receipt of certificates by the Secretary of State showing the petition to be signed by the requisite number of voters of the state.
(2)If the amended certificates received from all elections officials by the Secretary of State establish that the petition has still been found insufficient, the Secretary of State shall immediately so notify the proponents and the elections officials.
(f)The Secretary of State shall adopt regulations consistent with this section. The initial regulations may be adopted as emergency regulations in accordance with Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, and shall be deemed necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, safety, or general welfare.
SEC. 8.5.Section 9031 of the Elections Code is amended to read:9031.(a)(1)If the statistical sampling shows that the number of valid signatures on all petition sections, including those submitted to satisfy subdivision (a) of Section 9036, is within 95 to 110 percent of the number of signatures of qualified voters needed to declare the petition sufficient, the Secretary of State shall order the examination and verification of the signatures each signature filed, and shall so notify the elections officials. A signature shall not be invalidated because of a variation of the signature caused by the substitution of initials for the first or middle name, or both, of the person signing the petition
(2)In the case of an initiative petition, if the statistical sampling shows that the number of valid signatures for all signatures submitted is more than 110 percent of the number of qualified voters needed to find the petition sufficient, but the number of valid signatures submitted for purposes of subdivision (a) of Section 9036 is within 95 to 110 percent of the number of signatures needed to satisfy the requirement of that subdivision, the Secretary of State shall only order an examination and verification of each signature filed to satisfy the requirement of subdivision (a) of Section 9036.
(b)(1)Within 30 35 days, excluding Saturdays, Sundays, and holidays, after receipt of the order, the elections official or registrar of voters shall determine from the records of registration what the number of qualified voters who have signed the petition and if necessary a section of the petition that is subject to examination under subdivision (a) and, if necessary, the board of supervisors shall allow the elections official or registrar additional assistance for the purpose of examining the petition and provide for their compensation. In determining from the records of registration what the number of qualified voters who have signed the petition, the elections official or registrar of voters may use any file or list of registered voters maintained by his or her office, the office of the official or registrar, or the facsimiles of voters signatures, provided that the method of preparing and displaying the facsimiles complies with law.
(2)The examination of signatures that are submitted to satisfy subdivision (a) of Section 9036 shall be made pursuant to subdivision (g) of that section.
(c)(1)During the examination and verification of the signatures filed, the elections official or registrar of voters shall submit one or more reports to the Secretary of State showing the number of signatures of qualified voters that have been verified as of that date. The Secretary of State shall determine the number of reports required to be submitted and the manner of their submission.
(2)The Secretary of State shall maintain a list indicating the number of verified signatures of qualified voters who have signed the petition based on the most recent reports submitted pursuant to paragraph (1). If the Secretary of State determines, prior to each countys completing the examination of each signature filed, that based on the list the petition is signed by the requisite number of voters needed to declare the petition sufficient, the Secretary of State shall immediately notify the elections official or registrar of voters of every county or city and county in the state of this fact. Immediately after receipt of this notification, the elections official or registrar of voters may suspend signature verification until receipt of a certificate pursuant to Section 9033 or until otherwise instructed by the Secretary of State.
(d)The elections official or registrar, upon the completion of the examination or notification pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (c), examination, shall immediately attach to the petition, except the signatures thereto appended, an amended certificate properly dated, showing the result of the examination and shall immediately transmit the petition, together with the amended certificate, to the Secretary of State. A copy of the amended certificate shall be filed in the elections officials office.
(e)(1)If the amended certificates establish the petitions sufficiency, the petition shall be deemed to be filed as of the date of receipt of certificates by the Secretary of State shall certify that the measure is qualified for the ballot as provided in Section 9033. showing the petition to be signed by the requisite number of voters of the state.
(2)If the amended certificates received from all elections officials by the Secretary of State establish that the petition has still been found insufficient, the Secretary of State shall immediately so notify the proponents and the elections officials.
(f)The Secretary of State shall adopt regulations consistent with this section. The initial regulations may be adopted as emergency regulations in accordance with Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code, and shall be deemed necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, safety, or general welfare.
SEC. 10.SEC. 9.Section 9036 is added to the Elections Code, to read:9036.(a)At least 10 percent of the signatures required under Section 9035 shall be presented on a petition or section of a petition that was circulated by a person who does not receive money or other valuable consideration exclusively or primarily for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors on the petition.
(b)(1)A person who is an employee or member of a nonprofit organization, other than an organization with the primary purpose of soliciting signatures on initiative petitions, who receives money or other valuable consideration from the organization and as part of that employment or membership solicits signatures for the qualification of an initiative measure shall be deemed to be a person who, for purposes of subdivision (a), does not receive money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors, unless the primary purpose of that employment or membership is to solicit signatures on an initiative petition.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, member means any of the following:
(A)A person who, pursuant to a specific provision of an organizations articles of incorporation or bylaws, has the right to vote directly or indirectly for the election of a director or directors, or an officer or officers, or on a disposition of all or substantially all of the assets of the organization, or on a merger or a dissolution.
(B)A person who is designated in an organizations articles of incorporation or bylaws as a member and, pursuant to a specific provision of the articles of incorporation or bylaws, has the right to vote on changes to the articles of incorporation or bylaws.
(C)A person who pays or has paid membership dues in an amount predetermined by the organization, provided the organization is tax exempt under Section 501(c) of the Internal Revenue Code.
(D)A director or officer of the organization.
(3)For purposes of this subdivision, a member of a local union is a member of any national or international union of which the local union is a part and of any federation with which the local, national, or international union is affiliated. A member or employee of a national or international union, of which a local union is a part, is a member or employee of all affiliated unions of the local, national, or international union.
(4)For purposes of this subdivision, a person is not a member of a nonprofit organization solely by virtue of being on a mailing or contact list of the organization.
(5)An employee or member of a labor organization who is on a full-time, part-time, permanent, or temporary leave of absence or is otherwise relieved of the responsibilities of their regular employment and who is employed or paid by a labor organization or a committee sponsored by a labor organization for purposes of soliciting signatures of electors shall not be deemed a person who has an exclusive or primary purpose of soliciting signatures on an initiative petition.
(5)(6)For purposes of this subdivision, whether an organization, or a member or employee of an organization, has the primary purpose of soliciting signatures on an initiative petition shall be determined based on the totality of the circumstances.
(c)Signatures that are solicited by a person who is a registered voter of a political party, a member of a political party committee as defined in Section 85205 of the Government Code, or an employee of a political party or a political party committee and who receives money or other valuable consideration for soliciting signatures on an initiative petition from the political party or political party committee do not count towards the number of signatures needed to satisfy the requirement of subdivision (a).
(d)(1)Signatures on an initiative petition that are solicited through direct mail do not count towards the number of signatures needed to satisfy the requirement of subdivision (a) if the person soliciting the signatures through direct mail, or any other person who organizes, pays for, or arranges for the direct mail, receives money or other valuable consideration primarily for the purpose of soliciting signatures of electors, unless the person is an employee or member of a nonprofit organization as described in subdivision (b).
(2)This subdivision shall not be construed to preclude an organization that has a primary purpose other than soliciting signatures on initiative petitions from soliciting signatures from the organizations members through direct mail and relying on those signatures for purposes of satisfying the requirement set forth in subdivision (a).
(e)This section shall not be construed to preclude a person who receives nominal benefits other than money, benefits, such as food, transportation, or lodging, from qualifying under this section as a person who does not receive money or other valuable consideration exclusively or primarily for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors on a petition for a proposed initiative measure.
(f)Verification of a petition that contains a declaration pursuant to Section 9022.5 shall be prima facie evidence that the signatures thereon satisfy the requirement of subdivision (a).
(g)For purposes of verifying signatures under Sections 9030 and 9031 and the procedures set forth by the Secretary of State, if the signature of a qualified voter appears once on a petition or section of a petition submitted to satisfy subdivision (a) of this section, and the same voters signature appears on a petition or section of a petition that does not satisfy subdivision (a), the qualified voters signature shall only be counted once and shall be counted towards satisfying subdivision (a).
(h)A person who receives money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures on an initiative petition shall not circulate a petition or a section of a petition for purposes of satisfying the requirement of subdivision (a) for the same initiative measure.SEC. 11.SEC. 10.Section 9037 is added to the Elections Code, to read:9037.(a)The signatures on an initiative petition section shall be deemed invalid and shall not be used for the purpose of determining whether the initiative measure qualifies for the ballot if the signatures thereon were solicited by a person who, in connection with the circulation of the initiative petition, intentionally engages in fraud, misrepresentation, or any conduct described in Section 18600, 18601, or 18602, or by a person who falsely claims to have not received money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors pursuant to Section 9036.
(b)This section may be enforced by a civil action brought by the Secretary of State, the Attorney General, a district attorney, or a city attorney of a city with a population greater than 750,000. The signatures on a petition section shall be invalidated only upon a showing, by clear and convincing evidence, that the person who solicited or obtained the signatures did so through intentional fraud, misrepresentation, or other conduct described in Sections 18600, 18601, and 18602, or that the person falsely claims to have not received money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors pursuant to Section 9036. Any civil action brought pursuant to this section shall have priority over all other civil matters.
(c)The relief provided for in subdivision (a) shall not be available after the Secretary of State has certified that an initiative petition has qualified for the ballot.
(d)If a local elections official is notified of or discovers any conduct described in subdivision (a), the local elections official shall promptly notify the Secretary of State.
(e)This section does not permit a local elections official who is notified of or discovers any conduct described in subdivision (a) to refuse to examine or to stop the examination of the petition or petition sections.
SEC. 12.SEC. 11.The provisions of this act do not apply to an initiative petition for which the Attorney General issued a circulating title and summary before January July 1, 2020.
SEC. 12.The provisions of this act are severable. If any provision of this act or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 13.(a)Section 7.3 of this bill incorporates amendments to Section 9030 of the Elections Code proposed by both this bill and Assembly Bill 698. That section shall only become operative if (1) both bills are enacted and become effective on or before January 1, 2020, (2) each bill amends Section 9030 of the Elections Code, and (3) Assembly Bill 1829 is not enacted or as enacted does not amend that section, and (4) this bill is enacted after Assembly Bill 698, in which case Sections 7, 7.5 and 7.7 of this bill shall not become operative.
(b)Section 7.5 of this bill incorporates amendments to Section 9030 of the Elections Code proposed by both this bill and Assembly Bill 1829. That section shall only become operative if (1) both bills are enacted and become effective on or before January 1, 2020, (2) each bill amends Section 9030 of the Elections Code, (3) Assembly Bill 698 is not enacted or as enacted does not amend that section, and (4) this bill is enacted after Assembly Bill 1829 in which case Sections 7, 7.3 and 7.7 of this bill shall not become operative.
(c)Section 7.7 of this bill incorporates amendments to Section 9030 of the Elections Code proposed by this bill, Assembly Bill 698, and Assembly Bill 1829. That section shall only become operative if (1) all three bills are enacted and become effective on or before January 1, 2020, (2) all three bills amend Section 9030 of the Elections Code, and (3) this bill is enacted after Assembly Bill 698 and Assembly Bill 1829, in which case Sections 7, 7.3 and 7.5 of this bill shall not become operative.
SEC. 14.Section 8.5 of this bill incorporates amendments to Section 9031 of the Elections Code proposed by both this bill and Assembly Bill 698. That section shall only become operative if (1) both bills are enacted and become effective on or before January 1, 2020, (2) each bill amends Section 9031 of the Elections Code, and (3) this bill is enacted after Assembly Bill 698, in which case Section 8 of this bill shall not become operative.
SEC. 13.SEC. 15.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution for certain costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district because, in that regard, this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
However, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains other costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jan 23, 2020 | Consideration of Governor's veto stricken from file. |
| Oct 7, 2019 | Vetoed by Governor. |
| Sep 24, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 12 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 6, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (August 30). |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 9, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (July 9). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 18, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on PUB. S. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (June 18). Re-referred to Com. on PUB. S. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on E. & C.A. and PUB. S. |
| May 24, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 23, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | Coauthors revised. |
| May 1, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (April 10). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 14, 2019 | Referred to Com. on E. & R. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 11, 2019 | AB 1451 Low Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 10, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1451 Low et al. By Hertzberg | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 12, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 9, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Public Safety |
Passed |
|
| Jun 18, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Public Safety] | Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2019 | AB 1451 Low Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 10, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Elections and Redistricting |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
GOVERNOR'S VETO
GV Bill Id:AB 1451
Author:(Low)
As Enrolled Ver:September 17, 2019
2/3 vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits a person or organization that pays circulators to collect signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition from paying those circulators on a per-signature basis and requires 10% of signatures on a state initiative petition to be collected by either unpaid circulators or employees or members of nonprofit organizations, as specified.
The Senate Amendments:
- Delete provisions of the bill that would have required the circulating title and summary of a state initiative that is prepared by the Attorney General (AG) to be placed on the first page of each section of the petition in 18-point roman boldface type, as specified.
- Require that a petition for a proposed state initiative measure that is circulated by a person such that it will qualify toward the 10% requirement be printed on green paper, instead of on white paper in a contrasting color ink, and require that a petition for a proposed state initiative measure that is circulated by a person such that it will not qualify toward meeting the 10% requirement to be printed on white paper in contrasting color ink.
- Make the following changes to the definition of what constitutes a "member" or "employee" of a nonprofit organization who receives money or other valuable consideration from the organization and as part of that employment or membership solicits signatures on a petition that count toward the 10% requirement:
- Adds a director or officer of the organization to the definition of a "member."
- Clarifies that a member or employee of a national or international union, of which a local union is a part, is in effect a member or employee of all affiliated unions of the local, national, or international union.
- Provides that an employee or member of a labor organization who is on a full-time, part-time, permanent, or temporary leave of absence or is otherwise relieved of the responsibilities of their regular employment and who is employed or paid by a labor organization or a committee sponsored by a labor organization for purposes of soliciting signatures of electors is not deemed to be a person who has an exclusive or primary purpose of soliciting signatures on an initiative petition.
- Delete provisions of the bill that would have prohibited a person who receives money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures on a state initiative petition from also circulating a petition to collect signatures that qualify towards the 10% requirement for the same initiative measure.
- Provide that the provisions of this bill do not apply to any initiative measure for which the AG issues a circulating title and summary before July 1, 2020, instead of January 1, 2020.
- Add a severability clause, and make clarifying changes.
- Make technical changes to address chaptering conflicts with AB 698 (Obernolte), Chapter 14, Statutes of 2019, AB 1829 (Elections & Redistricting Committee), Chapter 562, Statues of 2019 and SB 47 (Allen), Chapter 563, Statutes of 2019.
Governor's Veto Message:
"This bill makes it a misdemeanor to pay signature gatherers based on the number of signatures they collect on a state or local initiative, referendum or recall petition, and requires that at least 10% of signatures on a state initiative petition be collected by unpaid circulators.
"While I appreciate the intent of this legislation to incentivize grassroots support for the initiative process, I believe this measure could make the qualification of many initiatives cost-prohibitive, thereby having the opposite effect. I am a strong supporter of California's system of direct democracy and am reluctant to sign any bill that erects barriers to citizen participation in the electoral process."
COMMENTS:
While signatures collected by volunteers will count toward meeting the 10% requirement, the language of the bill does not require the signatures to be gathered by volunteers in order to qualify to meet the 10% requirement. Instead, in certain circumstances, signatures collected by individuals who were paid for their time could count toward meeting the 10% requirement provided that the person wasn't paid exclusively or primarily for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures.
SB 1094 (Hernandez) of 2016, would have made numerous significant changes to provisions of state law governing state initiatives, similar to this bill. SB 1094 was vetoed by Governor Brown, stating "This bill is virtually identical to AB 857, which I vetoed in 2013. Lowering the percentage from 10% to 5 % does not change my view that this measure will not keep out special interests or favor volunteer signature gathering."
AB 1947 (Low) of 2018, would have prohibited a person or organization that pays circulators to collect signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition from paying those circulators on a per-signature basis, similar to this bill. Governor Brown vetoed this bill.
Please see the policy committee analysis for a full discussion of this bill.
According to the Author:
"AB 1451 helps maintain the integrity of the initiative process by eliminating the incentive for paid signature gatherers to obtain signatures by whatever means necessary. In addition, AB 1451 will require that 10% of the signatures gathered for an initiative are gathered by unpaid activists, or those whose primary job duty is not to collect signatures. By ensuring that a fraction of signatures are gathered by those who truly believe in the policy behind an initiative petition, AB 1451 will help curb abuses of the initiative process by special interests."
Arguments in Support:
In support of a prior version of this bill, the California Professional Firefighters wrote, "The result of the current practice is a system in which wealthy individuals and powerful corporations dominate the debate, paid circulators openly profit from deception and fraud, and voters struggle to assess the true nature of often intentionally misleading ballot measures. In short, the system has devolved into the exact opposite of what Governor Johnson intended to create over a Century ago. AB 1451…will help certify that a measure truly enjoys significant grassroots support."
Arguments in Opposition:
In opposition to a prior version of this bill, the League of Women Voters of California wrote, "The League believes that California should have a system of registration and training for signature gatherers and supports a compensation system for time and dedication to civic service. This bill dramatically changes a long-established democratic process and could result in unintended consequences. Such consequences may be significantly worse than the abuses the bill aims to prevent."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The Secretary of State would incur a one-time cost of $130,000 to promulgate regulations (General Fund).
- The Department of Justice (DOJ) indicates that it would incur General Fund costs of $629,000 in 2019-20, $1.1 million 2020-21, $918,000 in 2021-22, and $723,000 annually thereafter, to implement the provisions of the bill (General Fund).
- Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the court to adjudicate charges brought against defendants who pay circulators on a per-signature basis as proscribed by this measure. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and fee revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
- Unknown potential increase in non-reimbursable local enforcement and incarceration costs to prosecute and incarcerate those charged with and found guilty of conduct proscribed by this bill. Costs would be offset, to a degree, by fee and assessment revenue. (Local funds)
*Trial Court Trust Fund
VOTES:
ASM ELECTIONS AND REDISTRICTING: 5-2-0
YES: Berman, Calderon, Low, Mullin, Weber
NO: Gallagher, Mayes
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-5-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Diep, Fong, Obernolte
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 56-19-5
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Diep, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Eduardo Garcia, O'Donnell
SENATE FLOOR: 24-12-4
YES: Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hueso, Hurtado, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NO: Bates, Borgeas, Chang, Dahle, Grove, Hill, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Allen, Glazer, Jackson, Stern
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 58-18-3
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Daly, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Diep, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cooley, Cooper, Quirk-Silva
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 17, 2019
CONSULTANT: Nichole Becker / E. & R. / (916) 319-2094 FN: 0002525
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1451
Author:(Low)
As Amended Ver:September 6, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits a person or organization that pays circulators to collect signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition from paying those circulators on a per-signature basis and requires 10% of signatures on a state initiative petition to be collected by either unpaid circulators or employees or members of nonprofit organizations, as specified.
The Senate Amendments:
- Delete provisions of the bill that would have required the circulating title and summary of a state initiative that is prepared by the Attorney General (AG) to be placed on the first page of each section of the petition in 18-point roman boldface type, as specified.
- Require that a petition for a proposed state initiative measure that is circulated by a person such that it will qualify toward the 10% requirement be printed on green paper, instead of on white paper in a contrasting color ink, and require that a petition for a proposed state initiative measure that is circulated by a person such that it will not qualify toward meeting the 10% requirement to be printed on white paper in contrasting color ink.
- Make the following changes to the definition of what constitutes a "member" or "employee" of a nonprofit organization who receives money or other valuable consideration from the organization and as part of that employment or membership solicits signatures on a petition that count toward the 10% requirement:
- Adds a director or officer of the organization to the definition of a "member."
- Clarifies that a member or employee of a national or international union, of which a local union is a part, is in effect a member or employee of all affiliated unions of the local, national, or international union.
- Provides that an employee or member of a labor organization who is on a full-time, part-time, permanent, or temporary leave of absence or is otherwise relieved of the responsibilities of their regular employment and who is employed or paid by a labor organization or a committee sponsored by a labor organization for purposes of soliciting signatures of electors is not deemed to be a person who has an exclusive or primary purpose of soliciting signatures on an initiative petition.
- Delete provisions of the bill that would have prohibited a person who receives money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures on a state initiative petition from also circulating a petition to collect signatures that qualify towards the 10% requirement for the same initiative measure.
- Provide that the provisions of this bill do not apply to any initiative measure for which the AG issues a circulating title and summary before July 1, 2020, instead of January 1, 2020.
- Add a severability clause, and make clarifying changes.
- Make technical changes to address chaptering conflicts with AB 698 (Obernolte), Chapter 14, Statutes of 2019, AB 1829 (Elections & Redistricting Committee), and SB 47 (Allen) of the current legislative session.
COMMENTS:
While signatures collected by volunteers will count toward meeting the 10% requirement, the language of the bill does not require the signatures to be gathered by volunteers in order to qualify to meet the 10% requirement. Instead, in certain circumstances, signatures collected by individuals who were paid for their time could count toward meeting the 10% requirement provided that the person wasn't paid exclusively or primarily for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures.
SB 1094 (Hernandez) of 2016, would have made numerous significant changes to provisions of state law governing state initiatives, similar to this bill. SB 1094 was vetoed by Governor Brown, stating "This bill is virtually identical to AB 857, which I vetoed in 2013. Lowering the percentage from 10% to 5% does not change my view that this measure will not keep out special interests or favor volunteer signature gathering."
AB 1947 (Low) of 2018, would have prohibited a person or organization that pays circulators to collect signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition from paying those circulators on a per-signature basis, similar to this bill. Governor Brown vetoed this bill.
Please see the policy committee analysis for a full discussion of this bill.
According to the Author:
"AB 1451 helps maintain the integrity of the initiative process by eliminating the incentive for paid signature gatherers to obtain signatures by whatever means necessary. In addition, AB 1451 will require that 10% of the signatures gathered for an initiative are gathered by unpaid activists, or those whose primary job duty is not to collect signatures. By ensuring that a fraction of signatures are gathered by those who truly believe in the policy behind an initiative petition, AB 1451 will help curb abuses of the initiative process by special interests."
Arguments in Support:
In support of a prior version of this bill, the California Professional Firefighters wrote, "The result of the current practice is a system in which wealthy individuals and powerful corporations dominate the debate, paid circulators openly profit from deception and fraud, and voters struggle to assess the true nature of often intentionally misleading ballot measures. In short, the system has devolved into the exact opposite of what Governor Johnson intended to create over a Century ago. AB 1451…will help certify that a measure truly enjoys significant grassroots support."
Arguments in Opposition:
In opposition to a prior version of this bill, the League of Women Voters of California wrote, "The League believes that California should have a system of registration and training for signature gatherers and supports a compensation system for time and dedication to civic service. This bill dramatically changes a long-established democratic process and could result in unintended consequences. Such consequences may be significantly worse than the abuses the bill aims to prevent."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The Secretary of State would incur a one-time cost of $130,000 to promulgate regulations (General Fund).
- The Department of Justice (DOJ) indicates that it would incur General Fund costs of $629,000 in 2019-20, $1.1 million 2020-21, $918,000 in 2021-22, and $723,000 annually thereafter, to implement the provisions of the bill (General Fund).
- Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the court to adjudicate charges brought against defendants who pay circulators on a per-signature basis as proscribed by this measure. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and fee revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
- Unknown potential increase in non-reimbursable local enforcement and incarceration costs to prosecute and incarcerate those charged with and found guilty of conduct proscribed by this bill. Costs would be offset, to a degree, by fee and assessment revenue. (Local funds)
*Trial Court Trust Fund
VOTES:
ASM ELECTIONS AND REDISTRICTING: 5-2-0
YES: Berman, Calderon, Low, Mullin, Weber
NO: Gallagher, Mayes
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-5-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Diep, Fong, Obernolte
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 56-19-5
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Diep, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Eduardo Garcia, O'Donnell
SENATE FLOOR: 24-12-4
YES: Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hueso, Hurtado, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NO: Bates, Borgeas, Chang, Dahle, Grove, Hill, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Allen, Glazer, Jackson, Stern
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 6, 2019
CONSULTANT: Nichole Becker / E. & R. / (916) 319-2094 FN: 0002309
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1451 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1451
Amended: 9/6/19 in Senate
SENATE ELECTIONS & C.A. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 6/18/19
AYES: Umberg, Hertzberg, Leyva, Stern
NOES: Nielsen
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 4-1, 7/9/19
AYES: Skinner, Bradford, Mitchell, Wiener
NOES: Moorlach
NO VOTE RECORDED: Jackson, Morrell
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 56-19, 5/23/19 - See last page for vote
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits paying initiative, referendum, or recall petition circulators on a per-signature basis, and requires 10% of signatures on a state initiative petition to be collected by either unpaid circulators or employees or members of nonprofit organizations, as specified.
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/6/19 clarify which notices must appear on state petitions and address a chaptering conflict with SB 47 (Allen).
Existing law:
- Allows electors to propose statutes and amendments to the California Constitution and to adopt or reject them through the initiative process. Permits voters to approve or reject statutes or parts of statutes approved by the Legislature, except as specified, by referendum. Permits voters to remove an elective officer from state or local office before the end of the term of office, as specified, by recall.
- Requires a state or local initiative petition to contain the following notice in 12-point type before the portion of the petition for voters' signatures:
NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC
THIS PETITION MAY BE CIRCULATED BY A PAID SIGNATURE GATHERER OR A VOLUNTEER. YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO ASK.
- Requires a state initiative petition to also contain, in the same location and type size described above, the following notice:
“THE PROPONENTS OF THIS PROPOSED INITIATIVE MEASURE HAVE THE RIGHT TO WITHDRAW THIS PETITION AT ANY TIME BEFORE THE MEASURE QUALIFIES FOR THE BALLOT.”
- Establishes penalties for fraudulent activity related to signature gathering.
- Makes it a misdemeanor for a person to do any of the following:
- While circulating a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition, intentionally misrepresent or intentionally make a false statement concerning the contents, purport, or effect of the petition to any person who signs or is requested to sign the petition.
- Willfully and knowingly circulate, publish, or exhibit any false statement or misrepresentation concerning the contents, purport, or effect of a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition for the purpose of obtaining any signature to, or persuading or influencing any person to sign, that petition.
- While circulating a state or local initiative petition, intentionally make a false statement in response to an inquiry by a voter as to whether the circulator is paid or a volunteer.
- Provides that a person, company, organization, company official, or other organizational officer in charge of a person who circulates an initiative, referendum, or recall petition who knowingly directs a circulator to make a false affidavit or who knows or reasonably should know that a circulator has made a false affidavit concerning an initiative, referendum, or recall petition or the signatures appended thereto is punishable by a fine not exceeding $5,000, by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, or by both the fine and imprisonment.
This bill:
- Makes it a misdemeanor for a person or organization to pay money or any other thing of value to another person based on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition. Provides that a violation is punishable by a fine of up to $25,000, imprisonment in a county jail for up to a year, or by both the fine and imprisonment.
- Specifies that this bill does not prohibit the payment for signature gathering that is not based, either directly or indirectly, on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
- Requires at least 10 percent of the signatures collected to qualify a proposed state initiative measure for the ballot to be collected by individuals who did not receive money or other valuable consideration exclusively or primarily for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors on the petition, as specified ("10 percent requirement"), as follows:
- Provides that signatures on a petition qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement if they are collected by a person who is an employee or member of a non-profit organization, other than an organization with the primary purpose of soliciting signatures on initiative petitions, who receives money or other valuable consideration from the organization and as part of that employment or membership solicits signatures for the qualification of an initiative measure, unless a primary purpose of that employment or membership is to solicit signatures on an initiative petition.
- Defines "member" for the purposes of this provision, to include, someone who pays membership dues to a tax exempt organization and union officers and members, among others.
- Provides that signatures solicited by registered voters or employees of a political party who receive money or other valuable consideration from the political party for soliciting signatures on an initiative petition do not qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement.
- Provides that signatures solicited through direct mail do not count towards the 10 percent requirement unless the person soliciting the signatures through direct mail, and any other person who organizes, pays, or arranges for the direct mail, is eligible to solicit signatures that qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement, as described above. Provides that this provision shall not preclude an organization that has a primary purpose other than soliciting signatures on initiative petitions from soliciting signatures from its members through direct mail and relying on those signatures for the purposes of satisfying the 10 percent requirement.
- Provides that nothing in this bill shall be construed to preclude signatures that are solicited by a person who receives nominal, non-monetary benefits, including food, transportation, or lodging, from qualifying toward meeting the 10 percent requirement.
- Provides that verification of a petition that contains a declaration pursuant to the provisions of this bill is prima facie evidence that the signatures satisfy the 10 percent requirement.
- Specifies that if a qualified voter signs a petition for an initiative both on the petition section that qualifies for the 10 percent requirement and on a petition section that does not qualify for that requirement, the voter's signature on the petition that meets the 10 percent requirement shall count, and the other signature shall not.
- Provides that signatures on a petition qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement if they are collected by a person who is an employee or member of a non-profit organization, other than an organization with the primary purpose of soliciting signatures on initiative petitions, who receives money or other valuable consideration from the organization and as part of that employment or membership solicits signatures for the qualification of an initiative measure, unless a primary purpose of that employment or membership is to solicit signatures on an initiative petition.
- Requires a petition for a proposed state initiative measure that is circulated by a person such that it will qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement to be printed on green paper in a contrasting color ink and to include the following notice printed in 12-point boldface type immediately prior to the portion of the petition for voters' signatures:
"NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: THIS PETITION IS BEING CIRCULATED BY A VOLUNTEER OR AN EMPLOYEE OF A NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION. YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO READ THE CONTENTS OF THIS PETITION BEFORE SIGNING."
- Requires a petition for a proposed state initiative measure that is circulated by a person such that it will not qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement to be printed on white paper in a contrasting color ink and to include the following notice printed in 12-point boldface type immediately prior to the portion of the petition for voters' signatures:
"NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: THIS PETITION IS BEING CIRCULATED BY A PERSON PAID TO OBTAIN YOUR SIGNATURE. YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO READ THE CONTENTS OF THIS PETITION BEFORE SIGNING."
- Requires a person who solicits signatures on a petition that qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement to sign an affidavit that declares all of the following:
- That the person did not receive money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors pursuant to the requirements of this bill; and,
- That to the best of their knowledge, the signatures on the petition sections circulated by them should be counted towards the 10 percent requirement.
- That the person did not receive money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors pursuant to the requirements of this bill; and,
- Makes corresponding changes to the process for elections officials to verify signatures submitted on a state initiative petition. Requires the Secretary of State (SOS) to adopt regulations consistent with these provisions and permits the initial regulations to be adopted as emergency regulations.
- Provides that the signatures on a state initiative petition section are invalid if they are solicited and submitted by a person who engages in intentional fraud, misrepresentation, or other illegal conduct concerning the circulation of the petition, as specified. Prohibits a petition section from being invalidated after the SOS has certified that the measure has qualified for the ballot. Provides that a local elections official who is notified of or discovers any conduct described above is not permitted to refuse to examine or to stop the examination of the petition or petition sections.
- Provides that the provisions of this bill do not apply to any initiative measure for which the AG issues a circulating title and summary before July 1, 2020. Makes various findings, declarations, and technical changes, including language addressing chaptering issues with other pending bills.
Background
Other States. According to information from the National Conference on State Legislatures, at least five states (Arizona, Montana, North Dakota, Oregon, and South Dakota) limit the ability of initiative or referendum proponents to pay signature gatherers on a per-signature basis. Laws to ban per-signature payments in at least six other states (Colorado, Idaho, Maine, Mississippi, Ohio, and Washington) have been invalidated by courts.
Comments
- According to the author, AB 1451 helps maintain the integrity of the initiative process by eliminating the incentive for paid signature gatherers to obtain signatures by whatever means necessary. In addition, AB 1451 will require that 10% of the signatures gathered for an initiative are gathered by unpaid activists, or those whose primary job duty is not to collect signatures. By ensuring that a fraction of signatures are gathered by those who truly believe in the policy behind an initiative petition, AB 1451 will help curb abuses of the initiative process by special interests.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 47 (Allen, 2019), which is pending on the Assembly Floor, requires, among other things, for specified initiative, referendum, or recall petitions, that an Official Top Funders disclosure be made either on the petition itself or on a separate sheet.
AB 1947 (Low, 2018) would have prohibited a person or organization that pays circulators to collect signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition from paying those circulators on a per-signature basis, similar to this bill. AB 1947 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
SB 1094 (Hernandez, 2016) would have made numerous significant changes to provisions of state law governing state initiatives, similar to this bill. SB 1094 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
SB 168 (Corbett, 2011), a similar bill, was also vetoed by Governor Brown.
SB 34 (Corbett, 2009), which was vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger, was identical to SB 168.
AB 2946 (Leno, 2006), another similar bill, was also vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The SOS would incur a one-time cost of $130,000 to promulgate regulations (General Fund).
- The DOJ indicates that it would incur General Fund costs of $629,000 in 2019-20, $1.1 million 2020-21, $918,000 in 2021-22, and $723,000 annually thereafter, to implement the provisions of this bill (General Fund).
- Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the court to adjudicate charges brought against defendants who pay circulators on a per-signature basis as proscribed by this bill. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and fee revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund)
- Unknown potential increase in non-reimbursable local enforcement and incarceration costs to prosecute and incarcerate those charged with and found guilty of conduct proscribed by this bill. Costs would be offset, to a degree, by fee and assessment revenue. (Local funds)
Californian Labor Federation
California Professional Firefighters
City of Livermore
California Business Roundtable
California Chamber of Commerce
California Clean Money Campaign
California Taxpayers Association
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
League of Women Voters of California
Lodi Chamber of Commerce
North Orange County Chamber
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In a letter supporting AB 1451, the California Professional Firefighters stated, in part:
AB 1451 bill will help certify that a measure truly enjoys significant grassroots support. Also, by reducing the incentive for fraud and deception generated by compensating all circulators a fixed amount per signature, the 10% threshold will help protect the integrity of the signature gathering process.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In a letter opposing AB 1451, the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association stated, in part:
AB 1451 prohibits petition gatherers from being paid on a per signature basis, despite the reality that there is no compelling evidence of signature-gathering fraud. Paying gatherers on an hourly rate could actually have the unintended consequence of increasing money in politics. If we really want to end this practice, a better solution would be to increase the amount of time to gather signatures.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 56-19, 5/23/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Diep, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Eduardo Garcia, O'Donnell
Prepared by: Darren Chesin / E. & C.A. / (916) 651-4106
9/9/19 18:28:14
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1451 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1451
Amended: 8/30/19 in Senate
SENATE ELECTIONS & C.A. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 6/18/19
AYES: Umberg, Hertzberg, Leyva, Stern
NOES: Nielsen
SENATE PUBLIC SAFETY COMMITTEE: 4-1, 7/9/19
AYES: Skinner, Bradford, Mitchell, Wiener
NOES: Moorlach
NO VOTE RECORDED: Jackson, Morrell
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 56-19, 5/23/19 - See last page for vote
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits paying initiative, referendum, or recall petition circulators on a per-signature basis, and requires 10% of signatures on a state initiative petition to be collected by either unpaid circulators or employees or members of nonprofit organizations, as specified.
Existing law:
- Allows electors to propose statutes and amendments to the California Constitution and to adopt or reject them through the initiative process.
- Permits voters to approve or reject statutes or parts of statutes approved by the Legislature, except as specified, by referendum.
- Permits voters to remove an elective officer from state or local office before the end of the term of office, as specified, by recall.
- Permits any person who is 18 years of age or older to circulate a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
- Requires a state or local initiative petition to contain the following notice in 12-point type before the portion of the petition for voters' signatures:
NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC
THIS PETITION MAY BE CIRCULATED BY A PAID SIGNATURE GATHERER OR A VOLUNTEER. YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO ASK.
- Requires a state initiative petition to also contain, in the same location and type size described above, the following notice:
“THE PROPONENTS OF THIS PROPOSED INITIATIVE MEASURE HAVE THE RIGHT TO WITHDRAW THIS PETITION AT ANY TIME BEFORE THE MEASURE QUALIFIES FOR THE BALLOT.”
- Establishes penalties for fraudulent activity related to signature gathering.
- Makes it a misdemeanor for a person to do any of the following:
- While circulating a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition, intentionally misrepresent or intentionally make a false statement concerning the contents, purport, or effect of the petition to any person who signs or is requested to sign the petition.
- Willfully and knowingly circulate, publish, or exhibit any false statement or misrepresentation concerning the contents, purport, or effect of a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition for the purpose of obtaining any signature to, or persuading or influencing any person to sign, that petition.
- While circulating a state or local initiative petition, intentionally make a false statement in response to an inquiry by a voter as to whether the circulator is paid or a volunteer.
- Provides that a person, company, organization, company official, or other organizational officer in charge of a person who circulates an initiative, referendum, or recall petition who knowingly directs a circulator to make a false affidavit or who knows or reasonably should know that a circulator has made a false affidavit concerning an initiative, referendum, or recall petition or the signatures appended thereto is punishable by a fine not exceeding $5,000, by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, or by both the fine and imprisonment.
- Provides that upon conviction of any of the conduct described above in 8) or 9), among other conduct, a court may order as a condition of probation that the convicted person be prohibited from receiving money or other valuable consideration for gathering signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
This bill:
- Makes it a misdemeanor for a person or organization to pay money or any other thing of value to another person based on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition. Provides that a violation is punishable by a fine of up to $25,000, imprisonment in a county jail for up to a year, or by both the fine and imprisonment.
- Specifies that this bill does not prohibit the payment for signature gathering that is not based, either directly or indirectly, on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
- Requires at least 10 percent of the signatures collected to qualify a proposed state initiative measure for the ballot to be collected by individuals who did not receive money or other valuable consideration exclusively or primarily for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors on the petition, as specified ("10 percent requirement"), as follows:
- Provides that signatures on a petition qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement if they are collected by a person who is an employee or member of a non-profit organization, other than an organization with the primary purpose of soliciting signatures on initiative petitions, who receives money or other valuable consideration from the organization and as part of that employment or membership solicits signatures for the qualification of an initiative measure, unless a primary purpose of that employment or membership is to solicit signatures on an initiative petition.
- Defines "member" for the purposes of this provision, to include, someone who pays membership dues to a tax exempt organization and union officers and members, among others.
- Provides that signatures solicited by registered voters or employees of a political party who receive money or other valuable consideration from the political party for soliciting signatures on an initiative petition do not qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement.
- Provides that signatures solicited through direct mail do not count towards the 10 percent requirement unless the person soliciting the signatures through direct mail, and any other person who organizes, pays, or arranges for the direct mail, is eligible to solicit signatures that qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement, as described above. Provides that this provision shall not preclude an organization that has a primary purpose other than soliciting signatures on initiative petitions from soliciting signatures from its members through direct mail and relying on those signatures for the purposes of satisfying the 10 percent requirement.
- Provides that nothing in this bill shall be construed to preclude signatures that are solicited by a person who receives nominal, non-monetary benefits, including food, transportation, or lodging, from qualifying toward meeting the 10 percent requirement.
- Provides that verification of a petition that contains a declaration pursuant to the provisions of this bill is prima facie evidence that the signatures satisfy the 10 percent requirement.
- Specifies that if a qualified voter signs a petition for an initiative both on the petition section that qualifies for the 10 percent requirement and on a petition section that does not qualify for that requirement, the voter's signature on the petition that meets the 10 percent requirement shall count, and the other signature shall not.
- Provides that signatures on a petition qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement if they are collected by a person who is an employee or member of a non-profit organization, other than an organization with the primary purpose of soliciting signatures on initiative petitions, who receives money or other valuable consideration from the organization and as part of that employment or membership solicits signatures for the qualification of an initiative measure, unless a primary purpose of that employment or membership is to solicit signatures on an initiative petition.
- Requires, in addition to the aforementioned existing notices, a petition for a proposed state initiative measure that is circulated by a person such that it will qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement to be printed on green paper in a contrasting color ink and to include the following notice printed in 12-point boldface type immediately prior to the portion of the petition for voters' signatures:
"NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: THIS PETITION IS BEING CIRCULATED BY A VOLUNTEER OR AN EMPLOYEE OF A NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION. YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO READ THE CONTENTS OF THIS PETITION BEFORE SIGNING."
- Requires, in addition to the aforementioned existing notices, a petition for a proposed state initiative measure that is circulated by a person such that it will not qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement to be printed on white paper in a contrasting color ink and to include the following notice printed in 12-point boldface type immediately prior to the portion of the petition for voters' signatures:
"NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: THIS PETITION IS BEING CIRCULATED BY A PERSON PAID TO OBTAIN YOUR SIGNATURE. YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO READ THE CONTENTS OF THIS PETITION BEFORE SIGNING."
- Requires a person who solicits signatures on a petition that qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement to sign an affidavit that declares all of the following:
- That the person did not receive money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors pursuant to the requirements of this bill; and,
- That to the best of their knowledge, the signatures on the petition sections circulated by them should be counted towards the 10 percent requirement.
- Makes corresponding changes to the process for elections officials to verify signatures submitted on a state initiative petition. Increases the number of days that elections officials have to count and verify signatures on state initiative petitions, as specified. Requires the Secretary of State (SOS) to adopt regulations consistent with these provisions and permits the initial regulations to be adopted as emergency regulations.
- Provides that the signatures on a state initiative petition section are invalid if they are solicited and submitted by a person who engages in intentional fraud, misrepresentation, or other illegal conduct concerning the circulation of the petition, as specified. Provides that the SOS, the Attorney General (AG), any district attorney, or any city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, may enforce this provision by a civil action in which the plaintiff has the burden of showing a violation by clear and convincing evidence. Prohibits a petition section from being invalidated after the SOS has certified that the measure has qualified for the ballot. Requires the local elections official, if he or she is notified of or discovers any conduct described above, to promptly notify the SOS. Provides that a local elections official who is notified of or discovers any conduct described above is not permitted to refuse to examine or to stop the examination of the petition or petition sections.
- Provides that the provisions of this bill do not apply to any initiative measure for which the AG issues a circulating title and summary before July 1, 2020.
- Makes various findings and declarations about the initiative process and the influence that special interests and paid circulators have on that process.
- Makes other clarifying, corresponding, and technical changes, including a severability clause and language addressing chaptering issues with other pending bills.
Background
Other States. According to information from the National Conference on State Legislatures, at least five states (Arizona, Montana, North Dakota, Oregon, and South Dakota) limit the ability of initiative or referendum proponents to pay signature gatherers on a per-signature basis. Laws to ban per-signature payments in at least six other states (Colorado, Idaho, Maine, Mississippi, Ohio, and Washington) have been invalidated by courts.
Comments
- According to the author, AB 1451 helps maintain the integrity of the initiative process by eliminating the incentive for paid signature gatherers to obtain signatures by whatever means necessary. In addition, AB 1451 will require that 10% of the signatures gathered for an initiative are gathered by unpaid activists, or those whose primary job duty is not to collect signatures. By ensuring that a fraction of signatures are gathered by those who truly believe in the policy behind an initiative petition, AB 1451 will help curb abuses of the initiative process by special interests.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 47 (Allen, 2019), which is pending on the Assembly Floor, requires, among other things, for specified initiative, referendum, or recall petitions, that an Official Top Funders disclosure be made either on the petition itself or on a separate sheet.
AB 1947 (Low, 2018) would have prohibited a person or organization that pays circulators to collect signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition from paying those circulators on a per-signature basis, similar to this bill. AB 1947 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
SB 1094 (Hernandez, 2016) would have made numerous significant changes to provisions of state law governing state initiatives, similar to this bill. SB 1094 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
SB 168 (Corbett, 2011) was also vetoed by Governor Brown. In his veto message, the Governor stated that "per-signature payment is often the most cost-effective method for collecting the hundreds of thousands of signatures needed to qualify a ballot measure," and that "[e]liminating this option will drive up the cost of circulating ballot measures, thereby further favoring the wealthiest interests." SB 34 (Corbett, 2009), which was vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger, was identical to SB 168. A similar bill, AB 2946 (Leno, 2006), was also vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- The SOS would incur a one-time cost of $130,000 to promulgate regulations (General Fund).
- DOJ indicates that it would incur General Fund costs of $629,000 in 2019-20, $1.1 million 2020-21, $918,000 in 2021-22, and $723,000 annually thereafter, to implement the provisions of this bill (General Fund).
- Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the court to adjudicate charges brought against defendants who pay circulators on a per-signature basis as proscribed by this bill. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and fee revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
- Unknown potential increase in non-reimbursable local enforcement and incarceration costs to prosecute and incarcerate those charged with and found guilty of conduct proscribed by this bill. Costs would be offset, to a degree, by fee and assessment revenue. (Local funds)
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Californian Labor Federation
California Professional Firefighters
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/19)
California Business Roundtable
California Chamber of Commerce
California Clean Money Campaign
California Taxpayers Association
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
League of Women Voters of California
Lodi Chamber of Commerce
North Orange County Chamber
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: In a letter supporting AB 1451, the California Professional Firefighters stated, in part: AB 1451 bill will help certify that a measure truly enjoys significant grassroots support. Also, by reducing the incentive for fraud and deception generated by compensating all circulators a fixed amount per signature, the 10% threshold will help protect the integrity of the signature gathering process.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: In a letter opposing AB 1451, the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association stated, in part: AB 1451 prohibits petition gatherers from being paid on a per signature basis, despite the reality that there is no compelling evidence of signature-gathering fraud. Paying gatherers on an hourly rate could actually have the unintended consequence of increasing money in politics. If we really want to end this practice, a better solution would be to increase the amount of time to gather signatures.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 56-19, 5/23/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Diep, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Eduardo Garcia, O'Donnell
Prepared by: Darren Chesin / E. & C.A. / (916) 651-4106
9/3/19 11:14:16
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1451 (Low) - Petition circulators
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 1451 would (1) prohibit paying initiative, referendum, or recall petition circulators on a per-signature basis, and (2) require 10 percent of signatures on a state initiative petition to be collected by either unpaid circulators or employees or members of nonprofit organizations, as specified.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on August 30, 2019
Fiscal Impact:
- The Secretary of State would incur a one-time cost of $130,000 to promulgate regulations (General Fund).
- The Department of Justice (DOJ) indicates that it would incur General Fund costs of $629,000 in 2019-20, $1.1 million 2020-21, $918,000 in 2021-22, and $723,000 annually thereafter, to implement the provisions of the bill (General Fund).
- Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the court to adjudicate charges brought against defendants who pay circulators on a per-signature basis as proscribed by this measure. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and fee revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
- Unknown potential increase in non-reimbursable local enforcement and incarceration costs to prosecute and incarcerate those charged with and found guilty of conduct proscribed by this bill. Costs would be offset, to a degree, by fee and assessment revenue. (Local funds)
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Author Amendments:
(1) Strike section 3 (which would have amended Section 9008 of the Elections Code), (2) require that petition signatures gathered by volunteers are printed on green paper, and petition signatures gathered by paid individuals are printed on white paper, (3) triple-joint AB 1451 with AB 698 and AB 1829, (4) Further define member of a nonprofit organization to include a director or officer of the organization, (5) clarify that a member or employee of a national or international union is in effect a member of affiliated unions, (6) specify that an employee or member of a union who is on leave may gather signatures as a volunteer, (7) remove the section which disallows a paid signature gatherer to also circulate the petition as a volunteer, (8) mandate that this bill will apply to initiative petitions that receive their title and summary on or after July 1, 2020, and (9) include a severability clause.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1451 (Low) - Petition circulators
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 1451 would (1) prohibit paying initiative, referendum, or recall petition circulators on a per-signature basis, and (2) require 10 percent of signatures on a state initiative petition to be collected by either unpaid circulators or employees or members of nonprofit organizations, as specified.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Secretary of State would incur a one-time cost of $130,000 to promulgate regulations (General Fund).
- The Department of Justice (DOJ) indicates that it would incur General Fund costs of $629,000 in 2019-20, $1.1 million 2020-21, $918,000 in 2021-22, and $723,000 annually thereafter, to implement the provisions of the bill (General Fund).
- Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the court to adjudicate charges brought against defendants who pay circulators on a per-signature basis as proscribed by this measure. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and fee revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
- Unknown potential increase in non-reimbursable local enforcement and incarceration costs to prosecute and incarcerate those charged with and found guilty of conduct proscribed by this bill. Costs would be offset, to a degree, by fee and assessment revenue. (Local funds)
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Background:
Current law provides that notwithstanding any other provision of law, whenever an initiative, referendum, recall, nominating petition or paper, or any other petition or paper, is required to be signed by voters of a county, city, school district, or special district subject to petitioning, only a person who is an eligible registered voter at the time of signing the petition or paper is entitled to sign the petition or paper. At the time of signing a petition or paper, a signer must personally affix his or her signature, printed name, and place of residence, as specified. A person is prohibited from circulating a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition or nominating paper unless he or she is 18 years of age or older. Wherever a petition or paper is submitted to the elections official, each section of the petition or paper have attached to it must be accompanied by a declaration signed by the circulator under penalty of perjury, setting forth, in the circulator’s own hand, the following: (1) the printed name of the circulator, (2) the residence address of the circulator, as specified, (3) the dates between which all the signatures to the petition or paper were obtained, (4) that the circulator circulated that section and witnessed the appended signatures being written, (5) that according to the best information and belief of the circulator, each signature is the genuine signature of the person whose name it purports to be, and (6) that circulator is 18 years of age or older.
Additionally, a state or local initiative petition required to be signed by voters must contain in 12-point type, before the portion of the petition for voters’ signatures, printed names, and residence addresses, the following language:
NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC
THIS PETITION MAY BE CIRCULATED BY A PAID SIGNATURE GATHERER OR A VOLUNTEER. YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO ASK.
Moreover, existing law provides that the following is a misdemeanor crime:
- Circulating, as principal or agent, or having charge or control of the circulation of, or obtaining signatures to, any state or local initiative, referendum or recall petition, intentionally misrepresents or intentionally makes any false statement concerning the contents, purport or effect of the petition to any person who signs, or who desires to sign, or who is requested to sign, or who makes inquiries with reference to it, or to whom it is presented for his or her signature.
- A person who willfully and knowingly circulates, publishes, or exhibits any false statement or misrepresentation concerning the contents, purport or effect of any state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition for the purpose of obtaining any signature to, or persuading or influencing any person to sign, that petition.
- Circulating, as principal or agent, or having charge or control of the circulation of, or obtaining signatures to, any state or local initiative, intentionally making any false statement in response to any inquiry by any voter as to whether he or she is a paid signature gatherer or a volunteer.
- A person who refuses to allow a prospective signer to read the measure or petition if working for the proponent or proponents of an initiative or referendum measure or recall petition.
- A person who covers or otherwise obscures the summary of the measure prepared by the Attorney General from the view of a prospective signer if working for the proponent or proponents of a statewide initiative or referendum measure.
- A person who offers or gives money or other valuable consideration to another in exchange for that person’s signature on a state, county, municipal, or district initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
- A person who knowingly or willfully permits the list of signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition to be used for any purpose other than qualification of the initiative or referendum measure or recall question for the ballot, except as provided.
- A person who solicits any circulator to affix to any initiative, referendum, or recall petition any false or forged signature, or to cause or permit a false or forged signature to be affixed
- A person who knowingly signs his or her own name more than once to any initiative, referendum, or recall petition, or signs his or her name to that petition knowing himself or herself at the time of signing not to be qualified to sign it.
Proposed Law:
This bill would prohibit a person or organization that pays circulators to collect signatures on an initiative, referendum or recall petition from paying those circulators on a per-signature basis. This bill makes numerous other significant changes to laws governing initiatives and states the bill does not apply to any initiative for which the Attorney General (AG) issues a circulating title and summary before January 1, 2020. Specifically, this bill would, among other things, do the following:
- Provide a violation of the per-signature payment prohibition is punishable by a fine of up to $25,000, imprisonment in a county jail for up to a year, or both.
- Require at least 10 percent of the signatures collected to qualify a state initiative to be collected by individuals who did not receive money or other valuable consideration exclusively or primarily for soliciting signatures (10 percent requirement). Provides various exemptions and rules governing the 10 percent requirement.
- Require the circulating title and summary prepared by the AG to be placed on the first page of each section of the petition in the one-inch space across the top of the page in 18-point roman boldface type.
- Require a person who solicits signatures on a petition that qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement to sign an affidavit, as specified.
- Makes corresponding changes to the process for elections officials to verify signatures submitted on a state initiative petition. Increases the number of days elections officials have to count and verify signatures on state initiative petitions, as specified.
- Require SOS to adopt regulations consistent with these provisions and allows initial regulations to be adopted as emergency regulations.
- Provide signatures on a state initiative petition are invalid if they are solicited and submitted by a person who engages in intentional fraud, misrepresentation or other illegal conduct, as specified. Provide the SOS, AG, any district attorney or any city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000 may enforce this provision by civil action. Prohibits a petition section from being invalidated after the SOS has certified that the measure has qualified for the ballot. Require the local elections official, if the official is notified of or discovers any conduct described above, to promptly notify the SOS. Provide that a local elections official who is notified or discovers any conduct described above shall not refuse to examine or to stop the examination of the petition or petition sections.
Related Legislation:
- SB 47 (Allen) would require, among other things, for specified state and local initiative, referendum, or recall petitions, that an Official Top Funders disclosure be made either on the petition itself or on a separate sheet that identifies the name of the committee and any qualifying top contributors. The bill is currently pending in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- SB 1394 (Newman, 2018) would have made it unlawful for a person to pay or to receive money or any other thing of value based on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition. The bill was approved by the Senate but was held in the Assembly following the successful recall election against Senator Newman.
- AB 1947 (Low, 2018) would have prohibited a person or organization that pays circulators to collect signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition from paying those circulators on a per-signature basis, similar to this bill. The bill was vetoed by the Governor.
- SB 1094 (Hernandez, 2016) would have made numerous significant changes to provisions of state law governing state initiatives, similar to this bill. The bill was vetoed by the Governor.
Staff Comments:
DOJ anticipates that the bill would result in it receiving First Amendment challenges to the law. The department indicates it would need two positions for calendar years 2020 and 2021 to defend against such legal challenges. DOJ also anticipates an increase in workload relating to the enforcement over fraudulent signature gathering, requiring three additional positions to perform the enforcement investigation and litigation. Finally, as noted previously, the bill would create a new crime. Consequently, it would also result in an increase in arrest prints, increasing DOJ’s associated workload.
The fiscal impact of this bill to the courts cannot be known with certainty, as the actual impact will be dependent on numerous factors, including, but not limited to, judicial and prosecutorial discretion, the criminal history of a defendant, and the factors unique to each case. As the crime created by this bill is punishable as a misdemeanor with the potential for incarceration, certain rights to the defendants are attached to the proceedings, including the right to a jury trial and the right to counsel (at public expense if the defendants are unable to afford the costs of representation) which could lead to lengthier and more complex court proceedings. Consequently, to the extent that the court adjudicates eleven or more of these new crimes, on average, that otherwise would not have been filed or resulted in a criminal action but for the alleged violation of paying a petition signature gatherer on a per-signature basis, court costs of this bill, by themselves, would surpass the Suspense File threshold.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC SAFETY
Senator Nancy Skinner, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 1451 Hearing Date: July 9, 2019
Author: | Low | ||
Version: | February 22, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | MK | ||
Subject: Petition Circulators
HISTORY
Source: Author
Prior Legislation: SB 1394 (Newman) not heard in the Assembly 2018
AB 1947 (Low) Vetoed 2018
Support: California Professional Firefighters
Opposition: California Business Roundtable; California Chamber of Commerce; California Clean Money Campaign; California Public Interest Research Group; California Taxpayers Association; Courage Campaign; Endangered Habitats League; GMO Free California; Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association; Lodi Chamber of Commerce; Money Out Voters In; North Orange County Chamber of Commerce; Oxnard Chamber of Commerce; Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce; Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce; Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce; League of Women Voters of California
Assembly Floor Vote: 56 - 19
PURPOSE
The purposes of this bill is to make it a misdemeanor to pay a signature collector based upon the number of signatures collected and to make other changes regarding the circulation of a petition for an initiative.
Existing law allows electors to propose statutes and amendments to the California Constitution and to adopt or reject them through the initiative process. (Article II, Section 8 of the California Constitution)
Existing law permits voters to approve or reject statutes or parts of statutes approved by the Legislature, except as specified, by referendum. (Article II, Section 9 of the California Constitution)
Existing law permits voters to remove an elective officer from state or local office before the end of the term of office, as specified, by recall. (Article II, Section 13-19 of the California Constitution)
Existing law permits any person who is 18 years of age or older to circulate a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition. (Elections Code § 102)
Existing law requires a state or local initiative petition to contain the following notice in 12-point type before the portion of the petition for voters' signatures:
NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC
THIS PETITION MAY BE CIRCULATED BY A PAID SIGNATURE GATHERER OR A VOLUNTEER. YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO ASK. (Elections Code § 101)
Existing law requires a state initiative petition to also contain, in the same location and type size described above, the following notice:
“THE PROPONENTS OF THIS PROPOSED INITIATIVE MEASURE HAVE THE RIGHT TO WITHDRAW THIS PETITION AT ANY TIME BEFORE THE MEASURE QUALIFIES FOR THE BALLOT.” (Elections Code § 101)
Existing law establishes penalties for fraudulent activity related to signature gathering. (Elections Code §§ 18600-18614)
Existing law makes it a misdemeanor for a person to do any of the following:
- While circulating a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition, intentionally misrepresent or intentionally make a false statement concerning the contents, purport, or effect of the petition to any person who signs or is requested to sign the petition. (Elections Code § 18600)
- Willfully and knowingly circulate, publish, or exhibit any false statement or misrepresentation concerning the contents, purport, or effect of a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition for the purpose of obtaining any signature to, or persuading or influencing any person to sign, that petition. (Elections Code § 18600)
- While circulating a state or local initiative petition, intentionally make a false statement in response to an inquiry by a voter as to whether the circulator is paid or a volunteer. (Elections Code § 18600)
Existing law provides that a person, company, organization, company official, or other organizational officer in charge of a person who circulates an initiative, referendum, or recall petition who knowingly directs a circulator to make a false affidavit or who knows or reasonably should know that a circulator has made a false affidavit concerning an initiative, referendum, or recall petition or the signatures appended thereto is punishable by a fine not exceeding $5,000, by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, or by both the fine and imprisonment. (Elections Code § 18660)
Existing law provides that upon conviction of any of the conduct described above in 8) or 9), among other conduct, a court may order as a condition of probation that the convicted person be prohibited from receiving money or other valuable consideration for gathering signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition. (Elections Code § 18604)
This bill makes it a misdemeanor for a person or organization to pay money or any other thing of value to another person based on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition. Provides that a violation is punishable by a fine of up to $25,000, imprisonment in a county jail for up to a year, or by both the fine and imprisonment.
This bill specifies that it does not prohibit the payment for signature gathering that is not based, either directly or indirectly, on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
This bill requires at least 10 percent of the signatures collected to qualify a proposed state initiative measure for the ballot to be collected by individuals who did not receive money or other valuable consideration exclusively or primarily for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors on the petition, as specified ("10 percent requirement"), as follows:
- Provides that signatures on a petition qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement if they are collected by a person who is an employee or member of a non-profit organization, other than an organization with the primary purpose of soliciting signatures on initiative petitions, who receives money or other valuable consideration from the organization and as part of that employment or membership solicits signatures for the qualification of an initiative measure, unless a primary purpose of that employment or membership is to solicit signatures on an initiative petition.
- Defines "member" for the purposes of this provision, to include, someone who pays membership dues to a tax exempt organization and union members, among others.
- Provides that signatures solicited by registered voters or employees of a political party who receive money or other valuable consideration from the political party for soliciting signatures on an initiative petition do not qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement.
- Provides that signatures solicited through direct mail do not count towards the 10 percent requirement unless the person soliciting the signatures through direct mail, and any other person who organizes, pays, or arranges for the direct mail, is eligible to solicit signatures that qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement, as described above. Provides that this provision shall not preclude an organization that has a primary purpose other than soliciting signatures on initiative petitions from soliciting signatures from its members through direct mail and relying on those signatures for the purposes of satisfying the 10 percent requirement.
- Provides that nothing in this bill shall be construed to preclude signatures that are solicited by a person who receives nominal, non-monetary benefits, including food, transportation, or lodging, from qualifying toward meeting the 10 percent requirement.
- Provides that verification of a petition that contains a declaration pursuant to the provisions of this bill is prima facie evidence that the signatures satisfy the 10 percent requirement.
- Specifies that if a qualified voter signs a petition for an initiative both on the petition section that qualifies for the 10 percent requirement and on a petition section that does not qualify for that requirement, the voter's signature on the petition that meets the 10 percent requirement shall count, and the other signature shall not.
- Prohibits a person who receives money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures on a state initiative petition from circulating a petition to collect signatures that qualify towards the 10 percent requirement for the same initiative measure.
This bill requires, in addition to the aforementioned existing notices, a petition for a proposed state initiative measure that is circulated by a person such that it will qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement to be printed on white paper in a contrasting color ink and to include the following notice printed in 12-point boldface type immediately prior to the portion of the petition for voters' signatures:
"NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: THIS PETITION IS BEING CIRCULATED BY A VOLUNTEER OR AN EMPLOYEE OF A NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION. YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO READ THE CONTENTS OF THIS PETITION BEFORE SIGNING."
This bill requires, in addition to the aforementioned existing notices, a petition for a proposed state initiative measure that is circulated by a person such that it will not qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement to be printed on paper of a color other than white in a contrasting color ink and to include the following notice printed in 12-point boldface type immediately prior to the portion of the petition for voters' signatures:
"NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: THIS PETITION IS BEING CIRCULATED BY A PERSON PAID TO OBTAIN YOUR SIGNATURE. YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO READ THE CONTENTS OF THIS PETITION BEFORE SIGNING."
This bill requires the circulating title and summary prepared by the Attorney General (AG) to be placed on the first page of each section of the petition in the one-inch space across the top of the page in 18-point roman boldface type.
This bill requires a person who solicits signatures on a petition that qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement to sign an affidavit that declares all of the following:
- That the person did not receive money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors pursuant to the requirements of this bill; and,
- That to the best of their knowledge, the signatures on the petition sections circulated by them should be counted towards the 10 percent requirement.
This bill makes corresponding changes to the process for elections officials to verify signatures submitted on a state initiative petition. Increases the number of days that elections officials have to count and verify signatures on state initiative petitions, as specified. Requires the Secretary of State (SOS) to adopt regulations consistent with these provisions and permits the initial regulations to be adopted as emergency regulations.
This bill provides that the signatures on a state initiative petition section are invalid if they are solicited and submitted by a person who engages in intentional fraud, misrepresentation, or other illegal conduct concerning the circulation of the petition, as specified. Provides that the Secretary of State (SOS), the Attorney General (AG), any district attorney, or any city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, may enforce this provision by a civil action in which the plaintiff has the burden of showing a violation by clear and convincing evidence. Prohibits a petition section from being invalidated after the SOS has certified that the measure has qualified for the ballot. Requires the local elections official, if he or she is notified of or discovers any conduct described above, to promptly notify the SOS. Provides that a local elections official who is notified of or discovers any conduct described above is not permitted to refuse to examine or to stop the examination of the petition or petition sections.
This bill provides that the provisions of this bill do not apply to any initiative measure for which the AG issues a circulating title and summary before January 1, 2020.
This bill makes various findings and declarations about the initiative process and the influence that special interests and paid circulators have on that process.
This bill makes other clarifying, corresponding, and technical changes.
COMMENTS
1. Need for This Bill
According to the author:
AB 1451 helps maintain the integrity of the initiative process by eliminating the incentive for paid signature gatherers to obtain signatures by whatever means necessary. In addition, AB 1451 will require that 10% of the signatures gathered for an initiative are gathered by unpaid activists, or those whose primary job duty is not to collect signatures. By ensuring that a fraction of the signatures are gathered by those who truly believe in the policy behind an initiative petition, AB 1451 will help curb abuses of the initiative process by special interests.
Many Californians have anecdotes of having been approached by aggressive signature gatherers, and many refuse to engage with signature gatherers due to having been misled or harassed during previous interactions. By eliminating payment-per-signature, we will remove much of the incentive to commit fraud or gather signatures aggressively. The effects may not be immediate, but we hope that within a few election cycles public trust will be restored, and it will not be so difficult for signature gatherers to find people willing to engage.
Though some question the constitutionality of banning payment-signature, bans in Oregon and North Dakota have withstood court challenges.
2. Signature Requirements
Article II, Section 8 (b) of the California Constitution provides that an initiative measure may be proposed by presenting to the SOS a petition that sets forth the text of the proposed statute or amendment to the Constitution and is certified to have been signed by electors equal in number to 5% in the case of a statute, and 8% in the case of an amendment to the Constitution, of the votes for all candidates for Governor at the last gubernatorial election. According to the SOS, initiative statutes currently require 623,212 valid signatures and initiative constitutional amendments currently require 997,139 valid signatures for qualification.
3. Misdemeanor for per Signature Basis
According to information from the National Conference on State Legislatures (NCSL), at least five states (Arizona, Montana, North Dakota, Oregon, and South Dakota) limit the ability of initiative or referendum proponents to pay signature gatherers on a per-signature basis. One state (Nebraska) recently repealed a state law that prohibited petition circulators from being paid on a per-signature basis, while another state (Wyoming) recently repealed a state law that restricted initiative proponents from paying signature gatherers on a per-signature basis while continuing to ban payments on a per-signature basis for referendum petitions. Laws to ban per-signature payments in at least six other states (Colorado, Idaho, Maine, Mississippi, Ohio, and Washington) have been invalidated by courts. Alaska does not ban payments that are made on a per-signature basis, but prohibits any such payment that is greater than $1 per signature.
This bill provides that a person who pays a person money or other thing of value based on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition is guilty of a misdemeanor punishable by a fine not to exceed $25,000 and/or imprisonment in the county jail not to exceed one year. With the approximately 310% penalty assessments attached to a fine, the fine will be approximately $102,500. Is this penalty appropriate?
4. Case law
In 1988, the United States Supreme Court ruled that a Colorado prohibition against the use of paid circulators for initiative petitions violated the First Amendment's right of free speech. Writing for a unanimous court, Justice Stevens noted that "[t]he State's interest in protecting the integrity of the initiative process does not justify the prohibition because the State has failed to demonstrate that it is necessary to burden appellees' ability to communicate their message in order to meet its concerns" (Meyer v. Grant (1988), 486 U.S. 414). In 1999, the United States Supreme Court examined a Colorado law that provided a number of other restrictions on the signature collection process for ballot initiatives. In that case the court ruled that there must be a compelling state interest to justify any restrictions on initiative petition circulation (Buckley v. American Constitutional Law Foundation (1999), 525 U.S. 182).
Although the United States Supreme Court has not ruled on the constitutionality of prohibiting payment for signature collection on a per-signature basis, a number of federal courts have considered challenges to such laws, with the courts reaching different conclusions about the constitutionality of per-signature payment bans. In light of the differing opinions reached by various federal courts on the constitutionality of laws that prohibit payments on a per-signature basis for signature gathering on petitions, it is unclear whether this bill, if enacted, would be upheld in a court challenge.
5. 10% of Signatures to be Unpaid
Under the provisions of this bill, in order for a state initiative measure to qualify for the ballot, at least 10 percent of the signatures gathered on the petition for that measure would have to be collected on petition sections that were circulated by a person who does not receive money or other valuable consideration exclusively or primarily for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors on the petition, as specified. This "10 percent requirement" does not apply to state referendum or recall petitions, nor does it apply to local initiatives, referenda, or recalls.
While signatures collected by volunteers will count toward meeting this 10 percent requirement, the language of the bill does not require the signatures to be gathered by volunteers in order to qualify to meet the 10 percent requirement. Instead, in certain circumstances, signatures collected by individuals who were paid for their time could count toward meeting the 10 percent requirement provided that the person wasn't paid exclusively or primarily for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures. This bill provides that signatures will count toward the 10 percent requirement if they are collected by employees and members of nonprofit organizations who receive compensation from that organization and solicit signatures as a part of their employment or membership, as long as the nonprofit organization is not primarily focused on soliciting signatures on petitions. In the case of signatures solicited by direct mail, those signatures would apply toward the 10 percent requirement if the person soliciting the signatures through direct mail and all persons that organize, pay for, and arrange the direct mail are persons who were eligible to solicit signatures that counted toward the 10 percent requirement. Additionally, signatures solicited by direct mail would count toward the 10 percent requirement if they are collected by an organization that is soliciting signatures through direct mail from its members, as long as the organization has a primary purpose other than collecting signatures.
6. Invalidation of Signatures
Existing law is silent on the issue of whether violations of state law prohibiting improper signature-gathering tactics will result in the signatures on those petitions being invalidated. In at least one case, however, a court invalidated signatures gathered to qualify an initiative for the ballot due to improper signature-gathering tactics by the proponents of the measure. In San Francisco Forty-Niners v. Nishioka (1999), 75 Cal.App.4th 637, the California Court of Appeals for the First District, Division One, prohibited an initiative measure from appearing on the ballot because the initiative petition included false statements intended to mislead voters, in violation of Section 18600 of the Elections Code. In this case, the false statements appeared on the text of the petition itself. As a result, every person who was asked to sign the petition was exposed to these false statements that were intended to mislead voters.
In a case where petition circulators make false or misleading statements about a proposed ballot measure, or engage in other illegal signature-gathering tactics in an attempt to get voters to sign a petition, it is unclear whether that misconduct can result in signatures being invalidated.
This bill explicitly provides that signatures on a petition section are invalid if the signatures were solicited and submitted by a person who intentionally engages in fraud, misrepresentation, or other improper signature-gathering tactics, as specified. In order for signatures to be invalidated under this provision, the Secretary of State, the Attorney General, a district attorney, or a city attorney would have to file a civil action, and would have the burden of showing a violation by clear and convincing evidence, as specified.
7. Argument in Support
The California Professional Firefighters support this bill stating:
California’s initiative process dates back to 1911, when then-Governor Hiram Johnson proposed a series of constitutional amendments to give Californians the right to recall elected officials, repeal laws by referendum and enact statewide laws by initiative. Voters approved the amendments and have since enacted over 130 ballot measures. Gone are the days when the initiative process was driven by average Californians compelled to act when legislators wouldn’t. Instead, Governor Johnson’s vision of an empowered citizenry has been hijacked in recent years by wealthy individuals and corporations that exploit the initiative process to further their own parochial and often extreme agenda.
Petition circulators were once almost universally unpaid, and signature gathering campaigns failed most often from a lack of volunteers. An inability to qualify was simply a sign that proponents needed more time to recruit an army of volunteers with which to cultivate enough grassroots support. Without both public support and devoted volunteers, campaigns couldn’t generate the required number of petition signatures. They system, on its own, eliminated proposes that weren’t ready to become law.
The activists who once organizes widespread support by devoting time, energy and passion towards a cause have been replaced-often by anti-worker, anti-consumer, anti-environment forces that crowd the ballot with deceptively written measures designed to maximize corporate profits and confuse voters. In some cases, petition circulators have been paid up to $7 or more for each signature and many circulators openly mislead potential signers.
This deception, sadly, is all but encouraged by our existing regulatory framework….
The result of the current practice is a system in which wealthy individuals and powerful corporations dominate the debate, paid circulators openly profit from deception and fraud, and voters struggle to assess the true nature of often intentionally misleading ballot measures. In short the system has devolved into the exact opposite of what Governor Johnson intended to create over a century ago.
8. Argument in Opposition
The League of Women Voters opposes this bill stating:
The League believes that California should have a system of registration and training for signature gatherers and supports a compensation system for time and dedication to civic service. This bill dramatically changes a long-established democratic process and could result in unintended consequences. Those include promoting inequity by driving up costs of the initiative process in a manner that favors wealthy interests and protracted, unnecessary litigation to support a prohibition that has been historically disfavored by the judicial system. Such consequences may be significantly worse than the abuses the bill aims to prevent.
The California Business Roundtable; California Taxpayers Association; Lodi Chamber of Commerce; North Orange County Chamber; Oxnard Chamber of Commerce; Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce; Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce; and the, Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce oppose this bill stating:
It appears that the goal of AB 1451 is to prevent voter-registration fraud. While this is a worthy goal, AB 1451 would have the unintended consequence of limiting the public’s role in the ballot process. Per Article II, Section 1 of the California Constitution, “All political power is inherent in the people. Government is instituted for their protection, security, and benefit, and they have the right to alter or reform it when the public good may require.” This bill limits the people’s power in exercising their rights of direct democracy.
Additionally, AB 1451 imposes a fine of $25,000 or criminal liability for the organization that pays signature gatherers on a per-signature basis. Thus, by outlawing payment for signature collection on a per signature basis, AB 1451 would make it prohibitively expensive to sponsor an initiative or a recall and next to impossible to do a referendum.
Yet, there is no compelling evidence that there is rampant fraud with this type of payment. According to the Secretary of State's Election Fraud Investigation Unit (EFIU), between 1994 and 2010, the EFIU opened 240 cases for falsifying petitions, of which 46 were sent to district attorneys for prosecution, resulting in 33 convictions. During that same timeframe, over 100 initiatives were placed on the ballot requiring millions of signatures. Opening 240 cases resulting in 33 convictions is hardly an indication of rampant fraud.
Furthermore, it is unclear how limiting the payment type for signatures will ensure that the public will receive better information when petitioners approach them. Indeed, AB 1451 is likely to limit how far and wide these important election materials are disseminated and even exclude certain areas as petitioners attempt to reach as many California voters as possible.
The current process serves as a check and balance on government. By making it harder to qualify ballot measures, this bill would result in denying Californians the right to address grievances with government through initiatives, referenda and recalls. The people cherish direct democracy, and this would eliminate that opportunity.
-- END –
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB Hearing Date: 6/18/19
Author: | |||
Version: | 2/22/19 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Darren Chesin | ||
Subject: Petition circulators
DIGEST
This bill prohibits paying initiative, referendum, or recall petition circulators on a per-signature basis, and requires 10% of signatures on a state initiative petition to be collected by either unpaid circulators or employees or members of nonprofit organizations, as specified.
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Allows electors to propose statutes and amendments to the California Constitution and to adopt or reject them through the initiative process.
- Permits voters to approve or reject statutes or parts of statutes approved by the Legislature, except as specified, by referendum.
- Permits voters to remove an elective officer from state or local office before the end of the term of office, as specified, by recall.
- Permits any person who is 18 years of age or older to circulate a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
- Requires a state or local initiative petition to contain the following notice in 12-point type before the portion of the petition for voters' signatures:
NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC
THIS PETITION MAY BE CIRCULATED BY A PAID SIGNATURE GATHERER OR A VOLUNTEER. YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO ASK. - Requires a state initiative petition to also contain, in the same location and type size described above, the following notice:
“THE PROPONENTS OF THIS PROPOSED INITIATIVE MEASURE HAVE THE RIGHT TO WITHDRAW THIS PETITION AT ANY TIME BEFORE THE MEASURE QUALIFIES FOR THE BALLOT.” - Establishes penalties for fraudulent activity related to signature gathering.
- Makes it a misdemeanor for a person to do any of the following:
- While circulating a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition, intentionally misrepresent or intentionally make a false statement concerning the contents, purport, or effect of the petition to any person who signs or is requested to sign the petition.
- Willfully and knowingly circulate, publish, or exhibit any false statement or misrepresentation concerning the contents, purport, or effect of a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition for the purpose of obtaining any signature to, or persuading or influencing any person to sign, that petition.
- While circulating a state or local initiative petition, intentionally make a false statement in response to an inquiry by a voter as to whether the circulator is paid or a volunteer.
- Provides that a person, company, organization, company official, or other organizational officer in charge of a person who circulates an initiative, referendum, or recall petition who knowingly directs a circulator to make a false affidavit or who knows or reasonably should know that a circulator has made a false affidavit concerning an initiative, referendum, or recall petition or the signatures appended thereto is punishable by a fine not exceeding $5,000, by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, or by both the fine and imprisonment.
- Provides that upon conviction of any of the conduct described above in 8) or 9), among other conduct, a court may order as a condition of probation that the convicted person be prohibited from receiving money or other valuable consideration for gathering signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
This bill:
- Makes it a misdemeanor for a person or organization to pay money or any other thing of value to another person based on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition. Provides that a violation is punishable by a fine of up to $25,000, imprisonment in a county jail for up to a year, or by both the fine and imprisonment.
- Specifies that this bill does not prohibit the payment for signature gathering that is not based, either directly or indirectly, on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
- Requires at least 10 percent of the signatures collected to qualify a proposed state initiative measure for the ballot to be collected by individuals who did not receive money or other valuable consideration exclusively or primarily for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors on the petition, as specified ("10 percent requirement"), as follows:
- Provides that signatures on a petition qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement if they are collected by a person who is an employee or member of a non-profit organization, other than an organization with the primary purpose of soliciting signatures on initiative petitions, who receives money or other valuable consideration from the organization and as part of that employment or membership solicits signatures for the qualification of an initiative measure, unless a primary purpose of that employment or membership is to solicit signatures on an initiative petition.
- Defines "member" for the purposes of this provision, to include, someone who pays membership dues to a tax exempt organization and union members, among others.
- Provides that signatures solicited by registered voters or employees of a political party who receive money or other valuable consideration from the political party for soliciting signatures on an initiative petition do not qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement.
- Provides that signatures solicited through direct mail do not count towards the 10 percent requirement unless the person soliciting the signatures through direct mail, and any other person who organizes, pays, or arranges for the direct mail, is eligible to solicit signatures that qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement, as described above. Provides that this provision shall not preclude an organization that has a primary purpose other than soliciting signatures on initiative petitions from soliciting signatures from its members through direct mail and relying on those signatures for the purposes of satisfying the 10 percent requirement.
- Provides that nothing in this bill shall be construed to preclude signatures that are solicited by a person who receives nominal, non-monetary benefits, including food, transportation, or lodging, from qualifying toward meeting the 10 percent requirement.
- Provides that verification of a petition that contains a declaration pursuant to the provisions of this bill is prima facie evidence that the signatures satisfy the 10 percent requirement.
- Specifies that if a qualified voter signs a petition for an initiative both on the petition section that qualifies for the 10 percent requirement and on a petition section that does not qualify for that requirement, the voter's signature on the petition that meets the 10 percent requirement shall count, and the other signature shall not.
- Prohibits a person who receives money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures on a state initiative petition from circulating a petition to collect signatures that qualify towards the 10 percent requirement for the same initiative measure.
- Provides that signatures on a petition qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement if they are collected by a person who is an employee or member of a non-profit organization, other than an organization with the primary purpose of soliciting signatures on initiative petitions, who receives money or other valuable consideration from the organization and as part of that employment or membership solicits signatures for the qualification of an initiative measure, unless a primary purpose of that employment or membership is to solicit signatures on an initiative petition.
- Requires, in addition to the aforementioned existing notices, a petition for a proposed state initiative measure that is circulated by a person such that it will qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement to be printed on white paper in a contrasting color ink and to include the following notice printed in 12-point boldface type immediately prior to the portion of the petition for voters' signatures:
"NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: THIS PETITION IS BEING CIRCULATED BY A VOLUNTEER OR AN EMPLOYEE OF A NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION. YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO READ THE CONTENTS OF THIS PETITION BEFORE SIGNING."
- Requires, in addition to the aforementioned existing notices, a petition for a proposed state initiative measure that is circulated by a person such that it will not qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement to be printed on paper of a color other than white in a contrasting color ink and to include the following notice printed in 12-point boldface type immediately prior to the portion of the petition for voters' signatures:
"NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: THIS PETITION IS BEING CIRCULATED BY A PERSON PAID TO OBTAIN YOUR SIGNATURE. YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO READ THE CONTENTS OF THIS PETITION BEFORE SIGNING."
- Requires the circulating title and summary prepared by the Attorney General (AG) to be placed on the first page of each section of the petition in the one-inch space across the top of the page in 18-point roman boldface type.
- Requires a person who solicits signatures on a petition that qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement to sign an affidavit that declares all of the following:
- That the person did not receive money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors pursuant to the requirements of this bill; and,
- That to the best of their knowledge, the signatures on the petition sections circulated by them should be counted towards the 10 percent requirement.
- That the person did not receive money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors pursuant to the requirements of this bill; and,
- Makes corresponding changes to the process for elections officials to verify signatures submitted on a state initiative petition. Increases the number of days that elections officials have to count and verify signatures on state initiative petitions, as specified. Requires the Secretary of State (SOS) to adopt regulations consistent with these provisions and permits the initial regulations to be adopted as emergency regulations.
- Provides that the signatures on a state initiative petition section are invalid if they are solicited and submitted by a person who engages in intentional fraud, misrepresentation, or other illegal conduct concerning the circulation of the petition, as specified. Provides that the SOS, the AG, any district attorney, or any city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, may enforce this provision by a civil action in which the plaintiff has the burden of showing a violation by clear and convincing evidence. Prohibits a petition section from being invalidated after the SOS has certified that the measure has qualified for the ballot. Requires the local elections official, if he or she is notified of or discovers any conduct described above, to promptly notify the SOS. Provides that a local elections official who is notified of or discovers any conduct described above is not permitted to refuse to examine or to stop the examination of the petition or petition sections.
- Provides that the provisions of this bill do not apply to any initiative measure for which the AG issues a circulating title and summary before January 1, 2020.
- Makes various findings and declarations about the initiative process and the influence that special interests and paid circulators have on that process.
- Makes other clarifying, corresponding, and technical changes.
BACKGROUND
Current Signature Requirements. Article II, Section 8 (b) of the California Constitution provides that an initiative measure may be proposed by presenting to the SOS a petition that sets forth the text of the proposed statute or amendment to the Constitution and is certified to have been signed by electors equal in number to 5% in the case of a statute, and 8% in the case of an amendment to the Constitution, of the votes for all candidates for Governor at the last gubernatorial election. According to the SOS, initiative statutes currently require 623,212 valid signatures and initiative constitutional amendments currently require 997,139 valid signatures for qualification.
Other States. According to information from the National Conference on State Legislatures (NCSL), at least five states (Arizona, Montana, North Dakota, Oregon, and South Dakota) limit the ability of initiative or referendum proponents to pay signature gatherers on a per-signature basis. One state (Nebraska) recently repealed a state law that prohibited petition circulators from being paid on a per-signature basis, while another state (Wyoming) recently repealed a state law that restricted initiative proponents from paying signature gatherers on a per-signature basis while continuing to ban payments on a per-signature basis for referendum petitions. Laws to ban per-signature payments in at least six other states (Colorado, Idaho, Maine, Mississippi, Ohio, and Washington) have been invalidated by courts. Alaska does not ban payments that are made on a per-signature basis, but prohibits any such payment that is greater than $1 per signature.
Applicable Jurisprudence. In 1988, the United States Supreme Court ruled that a Colorado prohibition against the use of paid circulators for initiative petitions violated the First Amendment's right of free speech. Writing for a unanimous court, Justice Stevens noted that "[t]he State's interest in protecting the integrity of the initiative process does not justify the prohibition because the State has failed to demonstrate that it is necessary to burden appellees' ability to communicate their message in order to meet its concerns" (Meyer v. Grant (1988), 486 U.S. 414). In 1999, the United States Supreme Court examined a Colorado law that provided a number of other restrictions on the signature collection process for ballot initiatives. In that case the court ruled that there must be a compelling state interest to justify any restrictions on initiative petition circulation (Buckley v. American Constitutional Law Foundation (1999), 525 U.S. 182).
Although the United States Supreme Court has not ruled on the constitutionality of prohibiting payment for signature collection on a per-signature basis, a number of federal courts have considered challenges to such laws, with the courts reaching different conclusions about the constitutionality of per-signature payment bans. In light of the differing opinions reached by various federal courts on the constitutionality of laws that prohibit payments on a per-signature basis for signature gathering on petitions, it is unclear whether this bill, if enacted, would be upheld in a court challenge.
Under the provisions of this bill, in order for a state initiative measure to qualify for the ballot, at least 10 percent of the signatures gathered on the petition for that measure would have to be collected on petition sections that were circulated by a person who does not receive money or other valuable consideration exclusively or primarily for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors on the petition, as specified. This "10 percent requirement" does not apply to state referendum or recall petitions, nor does it apply to local initiatives, referenda, or recalls.
While signatures collected by volunteers will count toward meeting this 10 percent requirement, the language of the bill does not require the signatures to be gathered by volunteers in order to qualify to meet the 10 percent requirement. Instead, in certain circumstances, signatures collected by individuals who were paid for their time could count toward meeting the 10 percent requirement provided that the person wasn't paid exclusively or primarily for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures. This bill provides that signatures will count toward the 10 percent requirement if they are collected by employees and members of nonprofit organizations who receive compensation from that organization and solicit signatures as a part of their employment or membership, as long as the nonprofit organization is not primarily focused on soliciting signatures on petitions. In the case of signatures solicited by direct mail, those signatures would apply toward the 10 percent requirement if the person soliciting the signatures through direct mail and all persons that organize, pay for, and arrange the direct mail are persons who were eligible to solicit signatures that counted toward the 10 percent requirement. Additionally, signatures solicited by direct mail would count toward the 10 percent requirement if they are collected by an organization that is soliciting signatures through direct mail from its members, as long as the organization has a primary purpose other than collecting signatures.
It could be argued that the 10 percent requirement imposed by this bill could be susceptible to a court challenge in light of the United States Supreme Court's ruling in Meyer. However, the 10 percent requirement in this bill is distinguishable from the law struck down in Meyer. Unlike the law considered by the court in Meyer, the 10 percent requirement in this bill does not apply to all signatures gathered to qualify a measure for the ballot, but only a portion of the signatures. Furthermore, the signatures that are gathered to meet that 10 percent requirement do not necessarily have to be collected by individuals who are unpaid if they are gathered by members and employees of a nonprofit organization in furtherance of that nonprofit's objectives.
Invalidation of Signatures. Existing law generally is silent on the issue of whether violations of state law prohibiting improper signature-gathering tactics will result in the signatures on those petitions being invalidated. In at least one case, however, a court invalidated signatures gathered to qualify an initiative for the ballot due to improper signature-gathering tactics by the proponents of the measure. In San Francisco Forty-Niners v. Nishioka (1999), 75 Cal.App.4th 637, the California Court of Appeals for the First District, Division One, prohibited an initiative measure from appearing on the ballot because the initiative petition included false statements intended to mislead voters, in violation of Section 18600 of the Elections Code. In this case, the false statements appeared on the text of the petition itself. As a result, every person who was asked to sign the petition was exposed to these false statements that were intended to mislead voters.
In a case where petition circulators make false or misleading statements about a proposed ballot measure, or engage in other illegal signature-gathering tactics in an attempt to get voters to sign a petition, it is unclear whether that misconduct can result in signatures being invalidated. Committee staff is not aware of any court cases that have addressed this issue.
This bill explicitly provides that signatures on a petition section are invalid if the signatures were solicited and submitted by a person who intentionally engages in fraud, misrepresentation, or other improper signature-gathering tactics, as specified. In order for signatures to be invalidated under this provision, the SOS, the AG, a district attorney, or a city attorney would have to file a civil action, and would have the burden of showing a violation by clear and convincing evidence, as specified.
SOS Petition Fraud Investigations. According to information from the SOS's office for prior, similar bills, since 1994, the office opened hundreds of cases investigating potential petition fraud, of which at least 50 cases were referred for prosecution. These figures do not include petition fraud investigations that may have been conducted by other law enforcement agencies around the state.
COMMENTS
- According to the author: AB 1451 helps maintain the integrity of the initiative process by eliminating the incentive for paid signature gatherers to obtain signatures by whatever means necessary. In addition, AB 1451 will require that 10% of the signatures gathered for an initiative are gathered by unpaid activists, or those whose primary job duty is not to collect signatures. By ensuring that a fraction of signatures are gathered by those who truly believe in the policy behind an initiative petition, AB 1451 will help curb abuses of the initiative process by special interests.
- Argument in Support. In a letter supporting AB 1451, the California Professional Firefighters stated, in part:
AB 1451 bill will help certify that a measure truly enjoys significant grassroots support. Also, by reducing the incentive for fraud and deception generated by compensating all circulators a fixed amount per signature, the 10% threshold will help protect the integrity of the signature gathering process.
- Argument in Opposition. In a letter opposing AB 1451, the Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association stated, in part:
AB 1451 states that a statewide initiative measure must contain at least ten percent non-paid signatures. This is an arbitrary threshold that will be challenging for entities not coordinating with non-profits to accomplish, and may well be unconstitutional. In addition, singling out non-profits through a host of loopholes (including unions) and allowing them to be exempted from the above requirements puts government in a position of playing politics at the ballot box.
Finally AB 1451 prohibits petition gatherers from being paid on a per signature basis, despite the reality that there is no compelling evidence of signature-gathering fraud. Paying gatherers on an hourly rate could actually have the unintended consequence of increasing money in politics. If we really want to end this practice, a better solution would be to increase the amount of time to gather signatures.
- Contradictory Notice Requirements. As discussed above, existing law requires all state or local initiative petitions to contain the following notice:
“THIS PETITION MAY BE CIRCULATED BY A PAID SIGNATURE GATHERER OR A VOLUNTEER. YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO ASK.”
This bill additionally requires state initiative petitions to contain one of the following notices, as applicable:
"NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: THIS PETITION IS BEING CIRCULATED BY A VOLUNTEER OR AN EMPLOYEE OF A NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION. YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO READ THE CONTENTS OF THIS PETITION BEFORE SIGNING."
Or…
"NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: THIS PETITION IS BEING CIRCULATED BY A PERSON PAID TO OBTAIN YOUR SIGNATURE. YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO READ THE CONTENTS OF THIS PETITION BEFORE SIGNING."
Staff suggests that the committee and author consider amending this bill to require that only one of these notices appear on state initiative petitions, depending on which is applicable.
RELATED/PRIOR LEGISLATION
SB 47 (Allen) of 2019, which is pending in the Assembly Elections and Redistricting Committee, requires, among other things, for specified state and local initiative, referendum, or recall petitions, that an Official Top Funders disclosure be made either on the petition itself or on a separate sheet that identifies the name of the committee and any qualifying top contributors.
SB 1394 (Newman) of 2018, would have made it unlawful for a person to pay or to receive money or any other thing of value based on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition. SB 1394 was approved by the Senate but held in the Assembly following the successful recall election against Senator Newman on June 5, 2018.
AB 1947 (Low) of 2018, would have prohibited a person or organization that pays circulators to collect signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition from paying those circulators on a per-signature basis, similar to this bill. Governor Brown vetoed this bill stating, “As I stated in my veto message of an almost identical bill—SB 168 of 2011—‘per signature payment is often the most cost-effective method for collecting the hundreds of thousands of signatures needed to qualify a ballot measure. Eliminating this option will drive up the cost of circulating ballot measures, thereby further favoring the wealthiest interests.’ While I understand the potential abuses of the current per-signature payment system, my perspective has not changed since 2011.”
SB 1094 (Hernandez) of 2016, would have made numerous significant changes to provisions of state law governing state initiatives, similar to this bill. SB 1094 was vetoed by Governor Brown, stating “This bill is virtually identical to AB 857, which I vetoed in 2013. Lowering the percentage from 10 percent to 5 percent does not change my view that this measure will not keep out special interests or favor volunteer signature gathering.”
SB 168 (Corbett) of 2011, which was vetoed by Governor Brown. In his veto message, the Governor stated that "per-signature payment is often the most cost-effective method for collecting the hundreds of thousands of signatures needed to qualify a ballot measure," and that "[e]liminating this option will drive up the cost of circulating ballot measures, thereby further favoring the wealthiest interests." SB 34 (Corbett) of 2009, which was vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger, was identical to SB 168. A similar bill, AB 2946 (Leno) of 2006, was also vetoed by Governor Schwarzenegger.
PRIOR ACTION
Assembly Floor: | |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: | |
Assembly Elections and Redistricting Committee: |
|
POSITIONS
Sponsor: Author
Support: California Professional Firefighters
Oppose: California Business Roundtable
California Chamber of Commerce
California Clean Money Campaign
California Taxpayers Association
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
League of Women Voters of California
Lodi Chamber of Commerce
North Orange County Chamber
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1451
Author:(Low)
As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits a person or organization that pays circulators to collect signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition from paying those circulators on a per-signature basis, as specified. Makes numerous significant changes to provisions of state law governing state initiatives, as specified.
Major Provisions
- Makes it a misdemeanor for a person or organization to pay money or any other thing of value to another person based on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition. Provides that a violation is punishable by a fine of up to $25,000, imprisonment in a county jail for up to a year, or both.
- Requires at least 10% of the signatures collected to qualify a state initiative to be collected by individuals who did not receive money or other valuable consideration exclusively or primarily for soliciting signatures (10% requirement). Provides various exemptions and rules governing the 10% requirement, as specified.
- Requires a person who solicits signatures on a petition that qualify toward meeting the 10% requirement to sign an affidavit and attest to certain declarations, as specified.
- Makes corresponding changes to the process for elections officials to verify signatures submitted on a state initiative petition. Increases the number of days elections officials have to count and verify signatures on state initiative petitions, as specified. Requires the Secretary of State (SOS) to adopt regulations consistent with these provisions.
- Provides that the signatures on a state initiative petition are invalid if they are solicited and submitted by a person who engages in intentional fraud, misrepresentation or other illegal conduct, as specified. Provides the SOS, Attorney General, any district attorney or any city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000 may enforce this provision by civil action. Prohibits a petition section from being invalidated after the SOS has certified that the measure has qualified for the ballot. Requires the local elections official, if the official is notified of or discovers any conduct described above, to promptly notify the SOS.
COMMENTS:
While signatures collected by volunteers will count toward meeting the 10% requirement, the language of the bill does not require the signatures to be gathered by volunteers in order to qualify to meet the 10% requirement. Instead, in certain circumstances, signatures collected by individuals who were paid for their time could count toward meeting the 10% requirement provided that the person wasn't paid exclusively or primarily for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures.
AB 1947 (Low) of 2018, would have prohibited a person or organization that pays circulators to collect signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition from paying those circulators on a per-signature basis, similar to this bill. Governor Brown vetoed this bill stating, "As I stated in my veto message of an almost identical bill—SB 168 of 2011—'per signature payment is often the most cost-effective method for collecting the hundreds of thousands of signatures needed to qualify a ballot measure. Eliminating this option will drive up the cost of circulating ballot measures, thereby further favoring the wealthiest interests.' While I understand the potential abuses of the current per-signature payment system, my perspective has not changed since 2011."
Please see the policy committee analysis for a full discussion of this bill.
According to the Author:
"AB 1451 helps maintain the integrity of the initiative process by eliminating the incentive for paid signature gatherers to obtain signatures by whatever means necessary. In addition, AB 1451 will require that 10% of the signatures gathered for an initiative are gathered by unpaid activists, or those whose primary job duty is not to collect signatures. By ensuring that a fraction of signatures are gathered by those who truly believe in the policy behind an initiative petition, AB 1451 will help curb abuses of the initiative process by special interests."
Arguments in Support:
In support, the California Professional Firefighters, writes, "The result of the current practice is a system in which wealthy individuals and powerful corporations dominate the debate, paid circulators openly profit from deception and fraud, and voters struggle to assess the true nature of often intentionally misleading ballot measures. In short, the system has devolved into the exact opposite of what Governor Johnson intended to create over a Century ago. AB 1451 bill will help certify that a measure truly enjoys significant grassroots support. Also, by reducing the incentive for fraud and deception generated by compensating all circulators a fixed amount per signature, the 10% threshold will help protect the integrity of the signature gathering process."
Arguments in Opposition:
In opposition, the League of Women Voters of California writes, "The League believes that California should have a system of registration and training for signature gatherers and supports a compensation system for time and dedication to civic service. This bill dramatically changes a long-established democratic process and could result in unintended consequences. Such consequences may be significantly worse than the abuses the bill aims to prevent."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- SOS costs likely in the range of $150,000 to establish regulations (General Fund).
- Minor Department of Justice enforcement costs of less than $25,000 annually, offset to some extent by fine revenues.
- Unknown, likely minor non-reimbursable costs to cities and counties for prosecution and incarceration, offset to some extent by fine revenues.
VOTES:
ASM ELECTIONS AND REDISTRICTING: 5-2-0
YES: Berman, Calderon, Low, Mullin, Weber
NO: Gallagher, Mayes
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-5-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Diep, Fong, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: February 22, 2019
CONSULTANT: Nichole Becker / E. & R. / (916) 319-2094 FN: 0000575
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1451
Author:(Low) – As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
Policy Committee: | Elections and Redistricting | Vote: | 5 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits a person or organization that pays circulators to collect signatures on an initiative, referendum or recall petition from paying those circulators on a per-signature basis. This bill makes numerous other significant changes to laws governing initiatives and states the bill does not apply to any initiative for which the Attorney General (AG) issues a circulating title and summary before January 1, 2020. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides a violation of the per-signature payment prohibition is punishable by a fine of up to $25,000, imprisonment in a county jail for up to a year, or both.
- Requires at least 10% of the signatures collected to qualify a state initiative to be collected by individuals who did not receive money or other valuable consideration exclusively or primarily for soliciting signatures (10% requirement). Provides various exemptions and rules governing the 10% requirement.
- Requires the circulating title and summary prepared by the AG to be placed on the first page of each section of the petition in the one-inch space across the top of the page in 18-point roman boldface type.
- Requires a person who solicits signatures on a petition that qualify toward meeting the 10% requirement to sign an affidavit, as specified.
- Makes corresponding changes to the process for elections officials to verify signatures submitted on a state initiative petition. Increases the number of days elections officials have to count and verify signatures on state initiative petitions, as specified.
- Requires the Secretary of State (SOS) to adopt regulations consistent with these provisions and allows initial regulations to be adopted as emergency regulations.
- Provides signatures on a state initiative petition are invalid if they are solicited and submitted by a person who engages in intentional fraud, misrepresentation or other illegal conduct, as specified. Provides the SOS, AG, any district attorney or any city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000 may enforce this provision by civil action. Prohibits a petition section from being invalidated after the SOS has certified that the measure has qualified for the ballot. Requires the local elections official, if the official is notified of or discovers any conduct described above, to promptly notify the SOS. Provides that a local elections official who is notified or discovers any conduct described above shall not refuse to examine or to stop the examination of the petition or petition sections.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- SOS costs likely in the range of $150,000 to establish regulations (General Fund).
- Minor Department of Justice (DOJ) enforcement costs of less than $25,000 annually, offset to some extent by fine revenues.
- Unknown, likely minor non-reimbursable costs to cities and counties for prosecution and incarceration, offset to some extent by fine revenues.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
AB 1451 helps maintain the integrity of the initiative process by eliminating the incentive for paid signature gatherers to obtain signatures by whatever means necessary. In addition, AB 1451 will require that 10% of the signatures gathered for an initiative are gathered by unpaid activists, or those whose primary job duty is not to collect signatures. By ensuring that a fraction of signatures are gathered by those who truly believe in the policy behind an initiative petition, AB 1451 will help curb abuses of the initiative process by special interests.
- Support. In support, the California Labor Federation writes:
The protective measures taken in this bill will, we believe, significantly strengthen the integrity of the process, weaken existing incentives for fraud and deceit, promote transparency, and improve the overall quality of voter-approved public policy.
- Opposition. In opposition, the League of Women Voters of California writes:
The League believes that California should have a system of registration and training for signature gatherers and supports a compensation system for time and dedication to civic service. This bill dramatically changes a long-established democratic process and could result in unintended consequences. Such consequences may be significantly worse than the abuses the bill aims to prevent.
- Prior Legislation. AB 1947 (Low), of the 2017 – 18 Legislative Session, would have prohibited a person or organization that pays circulators to collect signatures on an initiative, referendum or recall petition from paying those circulators on a per-signature basis, similar to this bill. Governor Brown vetoed this bill stating:
As I stated in my veto message of an almost identical bill—SB 168 of 2011—“per signature payment is often the most cost-effective method for collecting the hundreds of thousands of signatures needed to qualify a ballot measure. Eliminating this option will drive up the cost of circulating ballot measures, thereby further favoring the wealthiest interests.” While I understand the potential abuses of the current per-signature payment system, my perspective has not changed since 2011.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 10, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ELECTIONS AND REDISTRICTING
Marc Berman, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1451 (
Author:Low) – As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
SUBJECT: Petition circulators.
SUMMARY: Prohibits a person or organization that pays circulators to collect signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition from paying those circulators on a per-signature basis, as specified. Makes numerous significant changes to provisions of state law governing state initiatives, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Makes it a misdemeanor for a person or organization to pay money or any other thing of value to another person based on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition. Provides that a violation is punishable by a fine of up to $25,000, imprisonment in a county jail for up to a year, or by both the fine and imprisonment.
- Specifies that this bill does not prohibit the payment for signature gathering that is not based, either directly or indirectly, on the number of signatures obtained on a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
- Requires at least 10 percent of the signatures collected to qualify a proposed state initiative measure for the ballot to be collected by individuals who did not receive money or other valuable consideration exclusively or primarily for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors on the petition, as specified ("10 percent requirement").
- Provides that signatures on a petition qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement if they are collected by a person who is an employee or member of a non-profit organization, other than an organization with the primary purpose of soliciting signatures on initiative petitions, who receives money or other valuable consideration from the organization and as part of that employment or membership solicits signatures for the qualification of an initiative measure, unless a primary purpose of that employment or membership is to solicit signatures on an initiative petition. Defines "member" for the purposes of this provision.
- Provides that signatures solicited by registered voters or employees of a political party who receive money or other valuable consideration from the political party for soliciting signatures on an initiative petition do not qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement.
- Provides that signatures solicited through direct mail do not count towards the 10 percent requirement unless the person soliciting the signatures through direct mail, and any other person who organizes, pays, or arranges for the direct mail, is eligible to solicit signatures that qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement, as described above. Provides that this provision shall not preclude an organization that has a primary purpose other than soliciting signatures on initiative petitions from soliciting signatures from its members through direct mail and relying on those signatures for the purposes of satisfying the 10 percent requirement.
- Provides that nothing in this bill shall be construed to preclude signatures that are solicited by a person who receives nominal, non-monetary benefits, including food, transportation, or lodging, from qualifying toward meeting the 10 percent requirement.
- Requires verification of a petition that contains a declaration pursuant to the provisions of this bill to be prima facie evidence that the signatures satisfy the 10 percent requirement.
- Specifies that if a qualified voter signs a petition for an initiative both on the petition section that qualifies for the 10 percent requirement and on a petition section that does not qualify for that requirement, the voter's signature on the petition that meets the 10 percent requirement shall count, and the other signature shall not.
- Prohibits a person who receives money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures on a state initiative petition from circulating a petition to collect signatures that qualify towards the 10 percent requirement for the same initiative measure.
- Provides that signatures on a petition qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement if they are collected by a person who is an employee or member of a non-profit organization, other than an organization with the primary purpose of soliciting signatures on initiative petitions, who receives money or other valuable consideration from the organization and as part of that employment or membership solicits signatures for the qualification of an initiative measure, unless a primary purpose of that employment or membership is to solicit signatures on an initiative petition. Defines "member" for the purposes of this provision.
- Requires a petition for a proposed state initiative measure that is circulated by a person such that it will qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement to be printed on white paper in a contrasting color ink and to include the following notice printed in 12-point boldface type immediately prior to the portion of the petition for voters' signatures:
"NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: THIS PETITION IS BEING CIRCULATED BY A VOLUNTEER OR AN EMPLOYEE OF A NONPROFIT ORGANIZATION. YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO READ THE CONTENTS OF THIS PETITION BEFORE SIGNING."
- Requires a petition for a proposed state initiative measure that is circulated by a person such that it will not qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement to be printed on paper of a color other than white in a contrasting color ink and to include the following notice printed in 12-point boldface type immediately prior to the portion of the petition for voters' signatures:
"NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC: THIS PETITION IS BEING CIRCULATED BY A PERSON PAID TO OBTAIN YOUR SIGNATURE. YOU ARE ENCOURAGED TO READ THE CONTENTS OF THIS PETITION BEFORE SIGNING."
- Requires the circulating title and summary prepared by the Attorney General (AG) to be placed on the first page of each section of the petition in the one-inch space across the top of the page in 18-point roman boldface type.
- Requires a person who solicits signatures on a petition that qualify toward meeting the 10 percent requirement to sign an affidavit that declares all of the following:
- That the person did not receive money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors pursuant to the requirements of this bill; and,
- That to the best of their knowledge, the signatures on the petition sections circulated by them should be counted towards the 10 percent requirement.
- That the person did not receive money or other valuable consideration for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors pursuant to the requirements of this bill; and,
- Makes corresponding changes to the process for elections officials to verify signatures submitted on a state initiative petition. Increases the number of days that elections officials have to count and verify signatures on state initiative petitions, as specified. Requires the Secretary of State (SOS) to adopt regulations consistent with these provisions and permits the initial regulations to be adopted as emergency regulations.
- Provides that the signatures on a state initiative petition section are invalid if they are solicited and submitted by a person who engages in intentional fraud, misrepresentation, or other illegal conduct concerning the circulation of the petition, as specified. Provides that the SOS, the AG, any district attorney, or any city attorney of a city having a population in excess of 750,000, may enforce this provision by a civil action in which the plaintiff has the burden of showing a violation by clear and convincing evidence. Prohibits a petition section from being invalidated after the SOS has certified that the measure has qualified for the ballot. Requires the local elections official, if he or she is notified of or discovers any conduct described above, to promptly notify the SOS. Provides that a local elections official who is notified of or discovers any conduct described above is not permitted to refuse to examine or to stop the examination of the petition or petition sections.
- Provides that the provisions of this bill do not apply to any initiative measure for which the AG issues a circulating title and summary before January 1, 2020.
- Makes various findings and declarations about the initiative process and the influence that special interests and paid circulators have on that process.
- Makes other clarifying, corresponding, and technical changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Allows electors to propose statutes and amendments to the Constitution and to adopt or reject them through the initiative process.
- Requires that a state initiative petition contain a notice alerting voters that the petition may be circulated by a paid signature gatherer or a volunteer, and that voters have the right to ask if a petition circulator is a paid gatherer or volunteer.
- Establishes penalties for fraudulent activity related to signature gathering.
- Permits voters to propose statutes or amendments to the state Constitution by initiative.
- Permits voters to approve or reject statutes or parts of statutes approved by the Legislature, except as specified, by referendum.
- Permits voters to remove an elective officer from state or local office before the end of the term of office, as specified, by recall.
- Permits any person who is 18 years of age or older to circulate a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
- Requires a state or local initiative petition to contain the following notice in 12-point type before the portion of the petition for voters' signatures:
NOTICE TO THE PUBLIC
THIS PETITION MAY BE CIRCULATED BY A PAID SIGNATURE GATHERER OR A VOLUNTEER. YOU HAVE THE RIGHT TO ASK. - Makes it a misdemeanor for a person to do any of the following:
- While circulating a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition, intentionally misrepresent or intentionally make a false statement concerning the contents, purport, or effect of the petition to any person who signs or is requested to sign the petition.
- Willfully and knowingly circulate, publish, or exhibit any false statement or misrepresentation concerning the contents, purport, or effect of a state or local initiative, referendum, or recall petition for the purpose of obtaining any signature to, or persuading or influencing any person to sign, that petition.
- While circulating a state or local initiative petition, intentionally make a false statement in response to an inquiry by a voter as to whether the circulator is paid or a volunteer.
- Provides that a person, company, organization, company official, or other organizational officer in charge of a person who circulates an initiative, referendum, or recall petition who knowingly directs an affiant to make a false affidavit or who knows or reasonably should know that an affiant has made a false affidavit concerning an initiative, referendum, or recall petition or the signatures appended thereto is punishable by a fine not exceeding $5,000, by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one year, or by both the fine and imprisonment.
- Provides that upon conviction of any of the conduct described above in 9) or 10), among other conduct, a court may order as a condition of probation that the convicted person be prohibited from receiving money or other valuable consideration for gathering signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. State-mandated local program; contains a crimes and infractions disclaimer; contains reimbursement direction.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of the Bill: According to the author:
AB 1451 helps maintain the integrity of the initiative process by eliminating the incentive for paid signature gatherers to obtain signatures by whatever means necessary. In addition, AB 1451 will require that 10% of the signatures gathered for an initiative are gathered by unpaid activists, or those whose primary job duty is not to collect signatures. By ensuring that a fraction of signatures are gathered by those who truly believe in the policy behind an initiative petition, AB 1451 will help curb abuses of the initiative process by special interests.
- 10 Percent Signature Requirement: Under the provisions of this bill, in order for a state initiative measure to qualify for the ballot, at least 10 percent of the signatures gathered on the petition for that measure would have to be collected on petition sections that were circulated by a person who does not receive money or other valuable consideration exclusively or primarily for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures of electors on the petition, as specified. This "10 percent requirement" does not apply to state referendum or recall petitions, nor does it apply to local initiatives, referenda, or recalls.
While signatures collected by volunteers will count toward meeting this 10 percent requirement, the language of the bill does not require the signatures to be gathered by volunteers in order to qualify to meet the 10 percent requirement. Instead, in certain circumstances, signatures collected by individuals who were paid for their time could count toward meeting the 10 percent requirement provided that the person wasn't paid exclusively or primarily for the specific purpose of soliciting signatures. This bill provides that signatures will count toward the 10 percent requirement if they are collected by employees and members of nonprofit organizations who receive compensation from that organization and solicit signatures as a part of their employment or membership, as long as the nonprofit organization is not primarily focused on soliciting signatures on petitions. In the case of signatures solicited by direct mail, those signatures would apply toward the 10 percent requirement if the person soliciting the signatures through direct mail and all persons that organize, pay for, and arrange the direct mail are persons who were eligible to solicit signatures that counted toward the 10 percent requirement. Additionally, signatures solicited by direct mail would count toward the 10 percent requirement if they are collected by an organization that is soliciting signatures through direct mail from its members, as long as the organization has a primary purpose other than collecting signatures.
In 1988, the United States Supreme Court ruled that a Colorado prohibition against the use of paid circulators for initiative petitions violated the First Amendment's guarantee of free speech. Writing for a unanimous court, Justice Stevens noted that "[t]he State's interest in protecting the integrity of the initiative process does not justify the prohibition because the State has failed to demonstrate that it is necessary to burden appellees' ability to communicate their message in order to meet its concerns." Meyer v. Grant (1988), 486 U.S. 414. It could be argued that the 10 percent requirement imposed by this bill could be susceptible to a court challenge in light of the United States Supreme Court's ruling in Meyer. However, the 10 percent requirement in this bill is distinguishable from the law struck down in Meyer. Unlike the law considered by the court in Meyer, the 10 percent requirement in this bill does not apply to all signatures gathered to qualify a measure for the ballot, but only a small portion of the signatures. Furthermore, the signatures that are gathered to meet that 10 percent requirement do not necessarily have to be collected by individuals who are unpaid if they are gathered by members and employees of a nonprofit organization in furtherance of that nonprofit's objectives. - Invalidation of Signatures: Existing law generally is silent on the issue of whether violations of state law prohibiting improper signature-gathering tactics will result in the signatures on those petitions being invalidated. In at least one case, however, a court invalidated signatures gathered to qualify an initiative for the ballot due to improper signature-gathering tactics by the proponents of the measure. In San Francisco Forty-Niners v. Nishioka (1999), 75 Cal.App.4th 637, the California Court of Appeals for the First District, Division One, prohibited an initiative measure from appearing on the ballot because the initiative petition included false statements intended to mislead voters, in violation of Section 18600 of the Elections Code. In this case, the false statements appeared on the text of the petition itself. As a result, every person who was asked to sign the petition was exposed to these false statements that were intended to mislead voters.
In a case where petition circulators make false or misleading statements about a proposed ballot measure, or engage in other illegal signature-gathering tactics in an attempt to get voters to sign a petition, it is unclear whether that misconduct can result in signatures being invalidated. Committee staff is not aware of any court cases that have addressed this issue.
This bill explicitly provides that signatures on a petition section are invalid if the signatures were solicited and submitted by a person who intentionally engages in fraud, misrepresentation, or other improper signature-gathering tactics, as specified. In order for signatures to be invalidated under this provision, the SOS, the AG, a district attorney, or a city attorney would have to file a civil action, and would have the burden of showing a violation by clear and convincing evidence, as specified. - Signature Verification: This bill makes corresponding changes to the process for elections officials to count and verify signatures submitted on a state initiative petition to reflect the 10 percent requirement. Under current law, elections officials are required to count and verify signatures on petitions within certain timeframes. While this bill increases the number of days elections officials have to count and verify signatures on state initiative petitions, as specified, will the increase be sufficient? Last November, voters considered 12 state ballot measures. At the time of writing this analysis, currently there is one state ballot measure qualified for the November 2020 general election, two initiatives eligible for the November 2020 general election, and five initiatives and referenda cleared for circulation.
- Initiative, Referendum, and Recall & Other States: According to information from the National Conference on State Legislatures (NCSL), 24 states, including California, allow voters through the initiative to propose laws, constitutional amendments, or both through a petition process. Twenty-three states, including California, allow voters through the referendum process to petition to demand a popular vote on a new law passed by the Legislature. Nineteen states, including California, permit state officers to be removed from office before the end of the term of office through the recall process.
At least five states (Arizona, Montana, North Dakota, Oregon, and South Dakota) limit the ability of initiative or referendum proponents to pay signature gatherers on a per-signature basis. In 2015, one state (Nebraska) repealed a state law that prohibited petition circulators from being paid on a per-signature basis, while another state (Wyoming) recently repealed a state law that restricted initiative proponents from paying signature gatherers on a per-signature basis while continuing to ban payments on a per-signature basis for referendum petitions. Laws to ban per-signature payments in at least six other states (Colorado, Idaho, Maine, Mississippi, Ohio, and Washington) have been invalidated by courts (additional details are available below). Alaska does not ban payments that are made on a per-signature basis, but prohibits any such payment that is greater than $1 per signature. - Payment for Signature Gathering and Constitutional Issues: While the US Supreme Court in Meyer invalidated a prohibition against the use of paid circulators for initiative petitions, it did not address the issue of whether a state may regulate the manner in which circulators are paid.
In 1999, the United States Supreme Court examined a Colorado law that provided a number of other restrictions on the signature collection process for ballot initiatives. In that case the court ruled that there must be a compelling state interest to justify any restrictions on initiative petition circulation. Buckley v. American Constitutional Law Foundation (1999), 525 U.S. 182.
In Buckley, the court invalidated Colorado's requirement that paid petition circulators wear a badge identifying themselves and identifying that they are paid circulators. The court stated that the requirement to wear badges inhibits participation in the petitioning process.
Although the United States Supreme Court has not ruled on the constitutionality of prohibiting payment for signature collection on a per-signature basis, a number of federal courts have considered challenges to such laws, with the courts reaching different conclusions about the constitutionality of per-signature payment bans.
In February 2001, the Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that a North Dakota law prohibiting payment for signature collection on a per-signature basis was consistent with the United States Constitution and with the Supreme Court's rulings in Buckley and Meyer. In reaching this decision, the court noted that the state "produced sufficient evidence that the regulation is necessary to insure the integrity of the initiative process," and also noted that no evidence was presented "that payment by the hour, rather than on commission, would in any way burden [the] ability to collect signatures." Initiative & Referendum Institute v. Jaeger (2001), 241 F.3d 614.
In February 2006, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that an Oregon law that prohibited payment to electoral petition signature gatherers on a piece-work or per-signature basis did not impose a severe burden under the First Amendment, and therefore did not unconstitutionally burden core political speech. The court found that Oregon had an "important regulatory interest in preventing fraud and its appearances in its electoral processes," and that prohibiting the payment of signature gatherers on a per-signature basis was reasonably related to that interest. Prete v. Bradbury (2006), 438 F.3d 949.
In October 2006, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals upheld a New York law that prohibited payment of any compensation to individuals hired to circulate electoral petitions if that compensation is contingent on the number of signatures obtained. Because New York does not have the initiative process, the law applies only to nomination petitions for candidates and to petitions to qualify a new political party. In its decision upholding the law, the Court referenced the decisions in the Eighth and Ninth Circuits, and noted that "[l]ike our sister circuits, we find the record presented to us provides insufficient support for a claim that the ban on per-signature payment is akin to the complete prohibition on paying petition circulators that was deemed unconstitutional in Meyer, or that the alternative methods of payment it leaves available are insufficient." Person v. New York State Board of Elections (2006), 467 F.3d 141.
On the other hand, the Sixth Circuit Court of Appeals struck down an Ohio law that made it a felony to pay anyone for gathering signatures on election-related petitions on any basis other than time worked. In its decision, the Court noted that while Ohio's interest in eliminating election fraud is a compelling state interest, "there is no evidence in the record that most, many, or even more than a de minimis number of circulators who were paid by signature engaged in fraud in the past." The court further noted that "[t]here is little dispute that operating under a per-time-only system will increase the costs of both proposing an initiative and qualifying it for the ballot," and cited evidence presented that professional coordinators and circulators were less interested in working under a per-time-only system. At the same time, however, the Court discussed the rulings in the Second, Eighth, and Ninth Circuits, noting that unlike the laws that were upheld in North Dakota, Oregon, and New York, the Ohio law was more restrictive and had harsher criminal sanctions for violations.
Specifically, the court noted that the laws in North Dakota, Oregon, and New York banned payments made on a per-signature basis, while Ohio banned all payment to circulators except on a per-time basis. The court noted that unlike the laws considered by appellate courts in other circuits, the Ohio law would prohibit bonuses to circulators based on productivity or longevity, would prohibit a person employing circulators from setting a minimum signature requirement, and could even prohibit a person employing circulators from terminating a circulator who consistently did not collect enough signatures. Additionally, the court noted that a violation of the Ohio law was a felony, compared to misdemeanor penalties for violations in North Dakota, Oregon, and New York. Although the court recognized these distinctions between the Ohio law and the laws upheld by three other appellate circuits, the court refused to discuss whether it would uphold an Ohio law that was similar to Oregon's, North Dakota's, or New York's. Citizens for Tax Reform et al. v. Deters et al. (2008), 518 F.3d 375.
A number of federal district courts have struck down bans on per-signature payments in other states, however. In 1994, a federal district court struck down a Washington law that made it illegal to pay gatherers of signatures on initiative and referendum petitions on a per-signature basis, noting in its decision that the state had failed to provide any "proof of fraud stemming specifically from the payment per signature method of collection." Limit v. Maleng (1994), 874 F.Supp. 1138. In 1997, a district court struck down a similar Mississippi law, citing evidence presented that the "payment of a flat daily rate to Mississippi circulators had yielded poor results," and concluding that the state had failed to prove "actual fraud or threat to citizens' confidence in government posed by…circulators who were paid per signature." Term Limits Leadership Council, Inc. v. Clark (1997), 984 F.Supp. 470. Federal district courts also struck down similar laws in Maine (On Our Terms '97 PAC v. Secretary of State of State of Maine (1999), 101 F.Supp.2d 19) and in Idaho (Idaho Coalition United for Bears v. Cenarrusa (2001), 234 F.Supp.2d 1159). More recently, a Colorado court issued a permanent injunction against a Colorado law that prohibited a petition circulator from being paid more than twenty percent of their compensation on a per-signature basis (Independence Institute v. Gessler (2013), 936 F.Supp.2d 1256).
In light of the differing opinions reached by various federal courts on the constitutionality of laws that prohibit payments on a per-signature basis for signature gathering on petitions, it is unclear whether the provisions of this bill that prohibit petition circulators from being paid a on a per-signature basis, if enacted, would be upheld in a court challenge. - Petition Fraud: According to information from the Secretary of State's office, between 1994 and 2015, the office opened 273 cases investigating potential petition fraud, of which 50 cases were referred for prosecution. These figures do not include petition fraud investigations that may have been conducted by other law enforcement agencies around the state.
- Increased Costs: Individuals or groups paying signature collectors may be required to provide certain benefits such as unemployment insurance and workers compensation insurance. This may result in higher costs to those groups that pay individuals to circulate petitions. In addition, prohibiting payment of individuals on a per-signature basis could increase costs because it may become more difficult to measure the work product of petition circulators. Potential increased costs may be partially offset if, by reducing the incentive to submit fraudulently-obtained signatures, this legislation results in paid circulators submitting fewer such signatures.
- Arguments in Support: In support, the California Labor Federation writes:
AB 1451 (Low) will require that 10% of all signatures submitted to qualify statewide ballot measures be gathered by volunteer or activist circulators. Paid circulators may still be used, but ballot measures will only qualify if at least 10% of all valid signatures collected were submitted by those who were not paid solely for their signature gathering efforts. This reform will help certify that a measure truly enjoys significant grassroots support. Also, by reducing the incentive for fraud and deception generated by compensating all circulators a fixed amount per signature, the 10% threshold will help protect the integrity of the signature gathering process.
With this standard enacted into law, at least a small percentage of signatures will be collected by someone with a genuine connection to the issue at hand and a real drive to see the measure become law.
The bill also prohibits paying professional circulators based on the number of signatures gathered. This reform will further achieve the broader goal of improving our initiative system by helping eliminate the existing incentive to misrepresent measures just to gain a signature. Prohibiting per-signature payment will also hopefully encourage paid circulators to engage in longer, more substantive discussions with voters, helping inform voters rather than hurrying them through the process towards the goal of a signature at any cost.
The protective measures taken in this bill will, we believe, significantly strengthen the integrity of the process, weaken existing incentives for fraud and deceit, promote transparency, and improve the overall quality of voter-approved public policy.
- Arguments in Opposition: In opposition, the League of Women Voters of California writes:
The League believes that California should have a system of registration and training for signature gatherers and supports a compensation system for time and dedication to civic service. This bill dramatically changes a long-established democratic process and could result in unintended consequences. Such consequences may be significantly worse than the abuses the bill aims to prevent.
- Previous Legislation: AB 1947 (Low) of 2018, would have prohibited a person or organization that pays circulators to collect signatures on an initiative, referendum, or recall petition from paying those circulators on a per-signature basis, similar to this bill. Governor Brown vetoed this bill stating, “As I stated in my veto message of an almost identical bill—SB 168 of 2011—‘per signature payment is often the most cost-effective method for collecting the hundreds of thousands of signatures needed to qualify a ballot measure. Eliminating this option will drive up the cost of circulating ballot measures, thereby further favoring the wealthiest interests.’ While I understand the potential abuses of the current per-signature payment system, my perspective has not changed since 2011.”
SB 1094 (Hernandez) of 2016, would have made numerous significant changes to provisions of state law governing state initiatives, similar to this bill. SB 1094 was vetoed by Governor Brown, stating “This bill is virtually identical to AB 857, which I vetoed in 2013. Lowering the percentage from 10 percent to 5 percent does not change my view that this measure will not keep out special interests or favor volunteer signature gathering.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Labor Federation
Opposition
California Business Roundtable
California Chamber of Commerce
California Taxpayers Association
Howard Jarvis Taxpayers Association
League of Women Voters of California
Lodi District Chamber of Commerce
North Orange County Chamber
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Analysis Prepared by: Nichole Becker / E. & R. / (916) 319-2094
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):