AB 1478: Employment discrimination.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-09-17
Existing law prohibits an employer from discriminating against or discharging an employee for specified reasons, including that the employee is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking and takes time off work to obtain judicial or medical relief, as provided. Existing law further provides that an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, or otherwise discriminated against, as provided, is entitled to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer as well as appropriate equitable relief. Existing law authorizes an aggrieved employee to file a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement of the Department of Industrial Relations, which is created by existing law within the Labor and Workforce Development Agency.
Existing law, the Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004, authorizes an aggrieved employee on behalf of that employee and other current or former employees to bring a civil action to recover specified civil penalties, which would otherwise be assessed and collected by the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, for the violation of certain provisions affecting employees. The act prescribes specified civil penalties for violations brought under these provisions.
This bill, as an alternative to filing a complaint with the division, would authorize an employee aggrieved under the provisions prohibiting specified types of discrimination described above to bring a private civil action against the employees employer and would not require that employee to pursue any other remedy prior to bringing that action.
This bill would also make nonsubstantive changes.
(a)An employer shall not discharge or in any manner discriminate against an employee for taking time off to serve as required by law on an inquest jury or trial jury, if the employee, prior to taking the time off, gives reasonable notice to the employer that the employee is required to serve.
(b)An employer shall not discharge or in any manner discriminate or retaliate against an employee, including, but not limited to, an employee who is a victim of a crime, for taking time off to appear in court to comply with a subpoena or other court order as a witness in any judicial proceeding.
(c)An employer shall not discharge or in any manner discriminate or retaliate against an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking for taking time off from work to obtain or attempt to obtain any relief, including, but not limited to, a temporary restraining order, restraining order, or other injunctive relief, to help ensure the health, safety, or welfare of the victim or the victims child.
(d)(1)As a condition of taking time off for a purpose set forth in subdivision (c), the employee shall give the employer reasonable advance notice of the employees intention to take time off unless the advance notice is not feasible.
(2)When an unscheduled absence occurs, the employer shall not take any action against the employee if the employee, within a reasonable time after the absence, provides a certification to the employer. Certification shall be sufficient in the form of any of the following:
(A)A police report indicating that the employee was a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
(B)A court order protecting or separating the employee from the perpetrator of an act of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, or other evidence from the court or prosecuting attorney that the employee has appeared in court.
(C)Documentation from a licensed medical professional, domestic violence counselor, as defined in Section 1037.1 of the Evidence Code, a sexual assault counselor, as defined in Section 1035.2 of the Evidence Code, licensed health care provider, or counselor that the employee was undergoing treatment for physical or mental injuries or abuse resulting from an act of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
(3)To the extent allowed by law and consistent with subparagraph (D) of paragraph (7) of subdivision (f), the employer shall maintain the confidentiality of any employee requesting leave under subdivision (c).
(e)An employer shall not discharge or in any manner discriminate or retaliate against an employee because of the employees status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, if the victim provides notice to the employer of the status or the employer has actual knowledge of the status.
(f)(1)An employer shall provide reasonable accommodations for a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking who requests an accommodation for the safety of the victim while at work.
(2)For purposes of this subdivision, reasonable accommodations may include the implementation of safety measures, including a transfer, reassignment, modified schedule, changed work telephone, changed work station, installed lock, assistance in documenting domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking that occurs in the workplace, an implemented safety procedure, or another adjustment to a job structure, workplace facility, or work requirement in response to domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, or referral to a victim assistance organization.
(3)An employer is not required to provide a reasonable accommodation to an employee who has not disclosed the employees status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
(4)The employer shall engage in a timely, good faith, and interactive process with the employee to determine effective reasonable accommodations.
(5)In determining whether the accommodation is reasonable, the employer shall consider an exigent circumstance or danger facing the employee.
(6)This subdivision does not require the employer to undertake an action that constitutes an undue hardship on the employers business operations, as defined by Section 12926 of the Government Code. For the purposes of this subdivision, an undue hardship also includes an action that would violate an employers duty to furnish and maintain a place of employment that is safe and healthful for all employees as required by Section 6400 of the Labor Code.
(7)(A)Upon the request of an employer, an employee requesting a reasonable accommodation pursuant to this subdivision shall provide the employer a written statement signed by the employee or an individual acting on the employees behalf, certifying that the accommodation is for a purpose authorized under this subdivision.
(B)The employer may also request certification from an employee requesting an accommodation pursuant to this subdivision demonstrating the employees status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking. Certification shall be sufficient in the form of any of the categories described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d).
(C)An employer who requests certification pursuant to subparagraph (B) may request recertification of an employees status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking every six months after the date of the previous certification.
(D)Any verbal or written statement, police or court record, or other documentation provided to an employer identifying an employee as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking shall be maintained as confidential by the employer and shall not be disclosed by the employer except as required by federal or state law or as necessary to protect the employees safety in the workplace. The employee shall be given notice before any authorized disclosure.
(E)(i)If circumstances change and an employee needs a new accommodation, the employee shall request a new accommodation from the employer.
(ii)Upon receiving the request, the employer shall engage in a timely, good faith, and interactive process with the employee to determine effective reasonable accommodations.
(F)If an employee no longer needs an accommodation, the employee shall notify the employer that the accommodation is no longer needed.
(8)An employer shall not retaliate against a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking for requesting a reasonable accommodation, regardless of whether the request was granted.
(g)(1)An employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by the employees employer because the employee has taken time off for a purpose set forth in subdivision (a) or (b) shall be entitled to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer.
(2)An employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by the employees employer for reasons prohibited in subdivision (c) or (e), or because the employee has requested or received a reasonable accommodation as set forth in subdivision (f), shall be entitled to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer as well as appropriate equitable relief.
(3)An employer who willfully refuses to rehire, promote, or otherwise restore an employee or former employee who has been determined to be eligible for rehiring or promotion by a grievance procedure or hearing authorized by law is guilty of a misdemeanor.
(h)(1)An employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by the employees employer because the employee has exercised the employees rights as set forth in subdivision (a), (b), (c), (e), or (f) may file a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement of the Department of Industrial Relations pursuant to Section 98.7. An aggrieved employee may instead also bring a private civil action against an employer in a court of competent jurisdiction. If a complainant files an action in court against an employer based upon the same or similar facts as a complaint filed with the division under this section, the Labor Commissioner may, at their discretion, close the investigation into the matter. The court may award reasonable attorneys fees to a prevailing employee in addition to any other relief that, in the judgment of the court, will effectuate the purpose of this section, including, but not limited to, reinstatement, damages for backpay, front pay, and emotional distress. An aggrieved employee who brings a private civil action pursuant to this subdivision shall not be required to pursue any other remedy before bringing that action.
(2)Notwithstanding any time limitation in Section 98.7, an employee may file a complaint with the division or in the court of competent jurisdiction based upon a violation of subdivision (c), (e), or (f) within one year from the date of occurrence of the violation.
(i)An employee may use vacation, personal leave, or compensatory time off that is otherwise available to the employee under the applicable terms of employment, unless otherwise provided by a collective bargaining agreement, for time taken off for a purpose specified in subdivision (a), (b), or (c). The entitlement of any employee under this section shall not be diminished by any collective bargaining agreement term or condition.
(j)For purposes of this section:
(1)Domestic violence means any of the types of abuse set forth in Section 6211 of the Family Code, as amended.
(2)Sexual assault means any of the crimes set forth in Section 261, 261.5, 262, 265, 266, 266a, 266b, 266c, 266g, 266j, 267, 269, 273.4, 285, 286, 287, 288, 288.5, 289, or 311.4 of, or former Section 288a of, the Penal Code, as amended.
(3)Stalking means a crime set forth in Section 646.9 of the Penal Code or Section 1708.7 of the Civil Code.
SEC. 2.Section 230.1 of the Labor Code is amended to read:230.1.(a)In addition to the requirements and prohibitions imposed on employees pursuant to Section 230, an employer with 25 or more employees shall not discharge, or in any manner discriminate or retaliate against, an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking for taking time off from work for any of the following purposes:
(1)To seek medical attention for injuries caused by domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
(2)To obtain services from a domestic violence shelter, program, or rape crisis center as a result of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
(3)To obtain psychological counseling related to an experience of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
(4)To participate in safety planning and take other actions to increase safety from future domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, including temporary or permanent relocation.
(b)(1)As a condition of taking time off for a purpose set forth in subdivision (a), the employee shall give the employer reasonable advance notice of the employees intention to take time off, unless the advance notice is not feasible.
(2)When an unscheduled absence occurs, the employer shall not take any action against the employee if the employee, within a reasonable time after the absence, provides a certification to the employer. Certification shall be sufficient in the form of any of the categories described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 230.
(3)To the extent allowed by law and consistent with subparagraph (D) of paragraph (7) of subdivision (f) of Section 230, employers shall maintain the confidentiality of any employee requesting leave under subdivision (a).
(c)An employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by the employees employer because the employee has taken time off for a purpose set forth in subdivision (a) is entitled to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer, as well as appropriate equitable relief. An employer who willfully refuses to rehire, promote, or otherwise restore an employee or former employee who has been determined to be eligible for rehiring or promotion by a grievance procedure or hearing authorized by law is guilty of a misdemeanor.
(d)(1)An employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by the employees employer because the employee has exercised the employees rights as set forth in subdivision (a) may file a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement of the Department of Industrial Relations pursuant to Section 98.7. An aggrieved employee may instead also bring a private civil action against an employer in a court of competent jurisdiction. If a complainant files an action in court against an employer based upon the same or similar facts as a complaint filed with the division under this section, the Labor Commissioner may, at their discretion, close the investigation into the matter. The court may award reasonable attorneys fees to a prevailing employee in addition to any other relief that, in the judgment of the court, will effectuate the purpose of this section, including, but not limited to, reinstatement, damages for backpay, front pay, and emotional distress. An aggrieved employee who brings a private civil action pursuant to this subdivision shall not be required to pursue any other remedy before bringing that action.
(2)Notwithstanding any time limitation in Section 98.7, an employee may file a complaint with the division or in the court of competent jurisdiction based upon a violation of subdivision (a) within one year from the date of occurrence of the violation.
(e)An employee may use vacation, personal leave, or compensatory time off that is otherwise available to the employee under the applicable terms of employment, unless otherwise provided by a collective bargaining agreement, for time taken off for a purpose specified in subdivision (a). The entitlement of any employee under this section shall not be diminished by any term or condition of a collective bargaining agreement.
(f)This section does not create a right for an employee to take unpaid leave that exceeds the unpaid leave time allowed under, or is in addition to the unpaid leave time permitted by, the federal Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 2601 et seq.).
(g)For purposes of this section:
(1)Domestic violence means any of the types of abuse set forth in Section 6211 of the Family Code, as amended.
(2)Sexual assault means any of the crimes set forth in Section 261, 261.5, 262, 265, 266, 266a, 266b, 266c, 266g, 266j, 267, 269, 273.4, 285, 286, 287, 288, 288.5, 289, or 311.4 of, or former Section 288a of, the Penal Code, as amended.
(3)Stalking means a crime set forth in Section 646.9 of the Penal Code or Section 1708.7 of the Civil Code.
(h)(1)Employers shall inform each employee of the employees rights established under this section and subdivisions (c), (e), and (f) of Section 230 in writing. The information shall be provided to new employees upon hire and to other employees upon request.
(2)The Labor Commissioner shall develop a form that an employer may use to comply with the notice requirements in paragraph (1). The form shall set forth the rights and duties of employers and employees under this section in clear and concise language. The Labor Commissioner shall post the form on the commissioners internet website to make it available to employers who are required to comply with this section. If an employer elects not to use the form developed by the Labor Commissioner, the notice provided by the employer to the employees shall be substantially similar in content and clarity to the form developed by the Labor Commissioner. The Labor Commissioner shall develop the form and post it in accordance with this paragraph on or before July 1, 2017.
(3)Employers shall not be required to comply with paragraph (1) until the Labor Commissioner posts the form on the commissioners internet website in accordance with paragraph (2).
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jan 21, 2020 | Consideration of Governor's veto stricken from file. |
| Oct 12, 2019 | Vetoed by Governor. |
| Sep 24, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 12 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 6, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (August 30). |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 11, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 10, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 1.) (July 9). |
| Jun 26, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (June 26). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 29, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on L., P.E. & R., JUD. and APPR. |
| May 23, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 22, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 1, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 9. Noes 3.) (April 30). |
| Apr 4, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (April 3). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 28, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on L. & E. |
| Mar 27, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on L. & E. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 14, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on L. & E. and JUD. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 11, 2019 | AB 1478 Carrillo Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 10, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1478 Carrillo By Jackson | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 12, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 9, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 26, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Labor, Public Employment and Retirement |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2019 | AB 1478 Carrillo Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 30, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 3, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
GOVERNOR'S VETO
GV Bill Id:AB 1478
Author:(Carrillo)
As Enrolled Ver:September 17, 2019
2/3 vote
SUMMARY:
Provides a private right of action for an employee who is discriminated or retaliated against by their employer due to, among other reasons, their status of being a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, and stalking, and entitles a prevailing plaintiff to reasonable attorney's fees and other relief the court deems proper.
The Senate Amendments:
- Clarify that if an aggrieved employee files a private action in court based upon the same or similar facts as a complaint filed with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE), the Labor Commissioner may, at their discretion, close the investigation into the matter.
- Add a one-year statute of limitations for filing a private action in court.
- Address chaptering out issues with AB 171 (Gonzalez) of the current legislative session.
Governor's Veto Message:
Under current law, employers are prohibited from retaliating against survivors of domestic violence, sexual assault or stalking when they seek time off work to obtain relief that helps ensure the health and safety of survivors or their children. AB 1478 expressly states that employees may file a private lawsuit when such anti-retaliation provisions are violated by an employer, and they may recover attorney's fees in addition to reinstatement and damages.
Survivors of domestic violence, sexual assault or stalking already have the ability under current law to file a retaliation claim through the Labor Commissioner's Office, file a Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) claim, and to seek reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and benefits.
I look forward to continuing to work with the Legislature to ensure the state vigorously enforces laws that protect workers and survivors of abuse.
COMMENTS:
This bill seeks to prevent and address employment-based discrimination of victims of particularly abusive behaviors. The author points out that survivors of domestic violence (DV) are especially in need of additional recourse if adverse action is taken against them.
According to the Author:
"AB 1478 will ensure DV survivors have the deserved option of a straightforward and expeditious legal pathway to justice in the case of their employers' wrongdoing. DV survivors should be entitled to the opportunity to choose when and how their complaint of employer misconduct is heard, the ability to garner damages for the harm the have been caused and the right to representation by an attorney who is particularly equipped to defend the survivor's best interests. By establishing an express private right of action and authorizing payment of attorney's fees for the DV survivor seeking justice, AB 1478 recognizes and addresses the uniquely delicate circumstances of DV survivors and provides a legal pathway that is clear, direct and uniquely tailored to the harm they have suffered."
Arguments in Support:
The California Employment Lawyers Association states in support, "DV survivors deserve to have a straightforward and expeditious legal pathway for redressing discrimination or
retaliation based on their status as a DV survivor. Labor Code Section 230 and 230.1 generally prohibit employers from taking adverse employment action against a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking and must allow an employee to take time off from work to attend to issues arising as a result of the domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, as long as the employee complies with certain conditions. Current law, however, does not make clear that DV survivors would be able to legally enforce their rights by bringing their case to court."
Arguments in Opposition:
A coalition of employer organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, states in opposition, "AB 1478 exposes employers of any size to costly litigation for an alleged violation, including an employee only (i.e., one-sided) right to attorney's fees. Currently, employees may resolve any Labor Code Section 230 violation with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) through an administrative hearing. See Labor Code Section 230. Creating a private right of action with employee only attorney's fees will incentivize potentially frivolous litigation. Moreover, there is no evidence that such complaints cannot be efficiently handled through the DLSE."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate lawsuits filed for alleged unlawful retaliation by an employer because of the exercise of a specified protected right of an employee that otherwise would not be filed (e.g., the allegation would have been resolved by filing a complaint with DLSE). While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
Unknown workload reduction to the Department of Industrial Relations. A reduced workload, however, would not lead to lower costs unless there is a reduction in personnel associated with sizeable reduction of complaints.
VOTES:
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 5-2-0
YES: Kalra, Carrillo, Gonzalez, Jones-Sawyer, Luz Rivas
NO: Flora, Diep
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-3-0
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Gallagher, Kiley, Obernolte
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 44-21-13
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gloria, Gonzalez, Holden, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Quirk, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Diep, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Irwin, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Melendez, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Patterson, Smith, Voepel, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Boerner Horvath, Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Frazier, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gray, Grayson, Mayes, Medina, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Rodriguez, Salas
SENATE FLOOR: 24-11-5
YES: Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Durazo, Galgiani, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NO: Bates, Borgeas, Chang, Dahle, Grove, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Allen, Caballero, Dodd, Glazer, Hurtado
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 45-23-11
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gloria, Gonzalez, Holden, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Quirk, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Bigelow, Boerner Horvath, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Diep, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Irwin, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Salas, Voepel, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Frazier, Gipson, Gray, Grayson, Kamlager-Dove, Quirk-Silva, Rodriguez, Smith
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 17, 2019
CONSULTANT: Megan Lane / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0002237
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1478
Author:(Carrillo)
As Amended Ver:September 6, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Provides a private right of action for an employee who is discriminated or retaliated against by their employer due to, among other reasons, their status of being a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, and stalking, and entitles a prevailing plaintiff to reasonable attorney's fees and other relief the court deems proper.
The Senate Amendments:
- Clarify that if an aggrieved employee files a private action in court based upon the same or similar facts as a complaint filed with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE), the Labor Commissioner may, at their discretion, close the investigation into the matter.
- Add a one-year statute of limitations for filing a private action in court.
- Address chaptering out issues with AB 171 (Gonzalez) of the current legislative session.
COMMENTS:
This bill seeks to prevent and address employment-based discrimination of victims of particularly abusive behaviors. The author points out that survivors of domestic violence (DV) are especially in need of additional recourse if adverse action is taken against them.
According to the Author:
"AB 1478 will ensure DV survivors have the deserved option of a straightforward and expeditious legal pathway to justice in the case of their employers' wrongdoing. DV survivors should be entitled to the opportunity to choose when and how their complaint of employer misconduct is heard, the ability to garner damages for the harm the have been caused and the right to representation by an attorney who is particularly equipped to defend the survivor's best interests. By establishing an express private right of action and authorizing payment of attorney's fees for the DV survivor seeking justice, AB 1478 recognizes and addresses the uniquely delicate circumstances of DV survivors and provides a legal pathway that is clear, direct and uniquely tailored to the harm they have suffered."
Arguments in Support:
The California Employment Lawyers Association states in support, "DV survivors deserve to have a straightforward and expeditious legal pathway for redressing discrimination or
retaliation based on their status as a DV survivor. Labor Code Section 230 and 230.1 generally prohibit employers from taking adverse employment action against a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking and must allow an employee to take time off from work to attend to issues arising as a result of the domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, as long as the employee complies with certain conditions. Current law, however, does not make clear that DV survivors would be able to legally enforce their rights by bringing their case to court."
Arguments in Opposition:
A coalition of employer organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, states in opposition, "AB 1478 exposes employers of any size to costly litigation for an alleged violation, including an employee only (i.e., one-sided) right to attorney's fees. Currently, employees may resolve any Labor Code Section 230 violation with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) through an administrative hearing. See Labor Code Section 230. Creating a private right of action with employee only attorney's fees will incentivize potentially frivolous litigation. Moreover, there is no evidence that such complaints cannot be efficiently handled through the DLSE."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate lawsuits filed for alleged unlawful retaliation by an employer because of the exercise of a specified protected right of an employee that otherwise would not be filed (e.g., the allegation would have been resolved by filing a complaint with DLSE). While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
Unknown workload reduction to the Department of Industrial Relations. A reduced workload, however, would not lead to lower costs unless there is a reduction in personnel associated with sizeable reduction of complaints.
VOTES:
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 5-2-0
YES: Kalra, Carrillo, Gonzalez, Jones-Sawyer, Luz Rivas
NO: Flora, Diep
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-3-0
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Gallagher, Kiley, Obernolte
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 44-21-15
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gloria, Gonzalez, Holden, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Quirk, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Diep, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Irwin, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Melendez, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Patterson, Smith, Voepel, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Boerner Horvath, Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Frazier, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gray, Grayson, Mayes, Medina, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Rodriguez, Salas
SENATE FLOOR: 24-11-5
YES: Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Durazo, Galgiani, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NO: Bates, Borgeas, Chang, Dahle, Grove, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Allen, Caballero, Dodd, Glazer, Hurtado
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 6, 2019
CONSULTANT: Megan Lane / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0002237
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1478 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1478
Amended: 9/6/19 in Senate
SENATE LABOR, PUB. EMP. & RET. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 6/26/19
AYES: Hill, Jackson, Mitchell, Pan
NOES: Morrell
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-1, 7/9/19
AYES: Jackson, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 44-21, 5/22/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Employment discrimination
DIGEST:
This bill allows a worker to bring a private right of action against an employer for unlawful retaliation following an employee exercising their right to time off for specified reasons protected under the law, including domestic violence, jury duty or stalking.
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/6/19 remove a conflict with AB 171 and make other non-technical clarifying changes.
Existing law:
- Establishes the California Fair Housing and Employment Act, which makes it an illegal practice for an employer to refuse to hire or to discriminate against a person because of the race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition (including pregnancy), genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status of that person. (Government Code §12940)
- Establishes the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) and allows an aggrieved employee to recover a civil penalty normally assessed and collected by the Labor and Workforce Development Agency (LWDA) through a civil action. Provides that for any civil penalties recovered, LWDA shall receive 75% of the amount and the employee bringing the action shall receive the other 25%. Provides that any employee who prevails in a PAGA action shall be entitled to an award of reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, including any filing fee. (Labor Code §2698-2699.5)
- Prohibits an employer from discharging or in any manner discriminating against an employee for any of the following:
- Serving as required by law on an inquest jury or trial jury, if the employee gives reasonable notice to the employer that the employee is required to serve.
- Appearing in court to comply with a subpoena or other court order as a witness in any judicial proceeding, for an employee who is a victim of a crime.
- Taking time off from work to obtain or attempt to obtain any relief, including, but not limited to, a temporary restraining order, restraining order, or other injunctive relief, to help ensure the health, safety, or welfare of the victim or his or her the victim’s child, for an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
- An employee’s status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, if the victim provides notice to the employer of the status or the employer has actual knowledge of the status.
(Labor Code §230)
- Allows an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against by their employer because the employee has exercised the employee’s rights described in the above section may file a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE). (Labor Code §230(h))
- Requires an employer provide reasonable accommodations for a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking who requests an accommodation for the safety of the victim while at work. (Labor Code §230)
- Entitles an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against by their employer for in the above sections or because the employee has requested or received a reasonable accommodation pursuant to the to the above section to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer as well as appropriate equitable relief. (Labor Code §230(g)(2))
- Requires that an employee give their employer reasonable notice of their intention to take time off, if possible. (Labor Code §230(d)) 9) In addition to the requirements and prohibitions in the above sections, prohibits an employer with 25 or more employees from discharging, or in any manner discriminating or retaliating against, an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking for taking time off from work for any of the following purposes:
- To seek medical attention for injuries caused by domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
- To obtain services from a domestic violence shelter, program, or rape crisis center as a result of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
- To obtain psychological counseling related to an experience of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
- To participate in safety planning and take other actions to increase safety from future domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, including temporary or permanent relocation.
(Labor Code §230.1)
- Allows an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against by their employer because the employee has exercised the employee’s rights described in the above section may file a complaint with DLSE. (Labor Code §230.1(h))
- Entitles an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by their employer because the employee has taken time off for a purpose set forth in the above section to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer, as well as appropriate equitable relief. An employer who willfully refuses to rehire, promote, or otherwise restore an employee or former employee who has been determined to be eligible for rehiring or promotion by a grievance procedure or hearing authorized by law is guilty of a misdemeanor. (Labor Code §230.1)
- Requires an employee give their employer reasonable advance notice of the employee’s intention to take time off for the above section, unless the advance notice is not feasible. When an unscheduled absence occurs, the employer shall not take any action against the employee if the employee, within a reasonable time after the absence, provides a certification to the employer. (Labor Code §230.1)
- Authorizes the Labor Commissioner to investigate employee complaints. Further authorizes the Labor Commissioner to provide for a hearing, known as a Berman Hearing, in any action to recover wages, penalties, and other demands for compensation, including liquidated damages if the complaint alleges payment of a wage less than the minimum wage. (Labor Code §98)
- Allows any person who believes that they have been discharged or otherwise discriminated against in violation of any law under the jurisdiction of the Labor Commissioner to file a complaint with DLSE within six months after the occurrence of the violation. The six-month period may be extended for good cause. The complaint shall be investigated by a discrimination complaint investigator. The Labor Commissioner shall establish procedures for the investigation of discrimination complaints; a summary of the procedures shall be provided to each complainant and respondent at the time of initial contact. (Labor Code §98.7)
- Allows DLSE, with or without receiving a complaint, to commence investigating an employer that it suspects to have discharged or otherwise discriminated against an individ ual in violation of any law under the jurisdiction of the Labor Commissioner. DLSE may proceed without a complaint in those instances where suspected retaliation has occurred during the course of adjudicating a wage claim pursuant to or during a field inspection or in instances of suspected immigration-related threats. (Labor Code §98.7)
- Requires a court to order appropriate injunctive relief on behalf of an employee on a showing that reasonable cause exists to believe that the employee has been discharged or subjected to adverse action for raising a claim of retaliation or asserting rights under any law under the jurisdiction of the Labor Commissioner. (Labor Code §98.7)
- Authorizes, if the Labor Commissioner determines a violation has occurred, the Labor Commissioner to issue a determination or a citation. If the Labor Commissioner issues a determination, he or she shall notify the complainant and respondent and direct the respondent to cease and desist from any violation and take any action deemed necessary to remedy the violation, including, where appropriate, rehiring or reinstatement, reimbursement of lost wages and interest, payment of penalties, payment of reasonable attorney’s fees associated with any hearing held by the Labor Commissioner in investigating the complaint, and the posting of notices to employees. (Labor Code §98.7)
- Requires the Labor Commissioner bring an action against the respondent in the above section if the respondent does not comply with an order within 30 days following notification of the Labor Commissioner’s determination. An action by the Labor Commissioner seeking injunctive relief, reimbursement of lost wages and interest, payment of penalties, and any other appropriate relief, shall not accrue until a respondent fails to comply with the order for more than 30 days following notification of the commissioner’s determination. The Labor Commissioner shall commence an action within three years of its accrual, regardless of whether the commissioner seeks penalties in the action. (Labor Code §98.7)
- Requires the Labor Commissioner to notify the complainant and respondent and dismiss the complaint if the Labor Commissioner determines no violation has occurred. The Labor Commissioner may direct the complainant to pay reasonable attorney’s fees associated with any hearing held by the Labor Commissioner if the Labor Commissioner finds the complaint was frivolous, unreasonable, groundless, and brought in bad faith. (Labor Code §98.7)
This bill:
- Allows an employee to also bring a private civil action against an employer if they are discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by their employer because the employee has exercised their rights to take time off for specified reasons under Labor Code Sections 230 and 230.1.
- Additionally, allows the Labor Commissioner to close an investigation into a complaint regarding retaliation described above if the complainant for that case files an action in court against an employer based upon the same or similar facts as the complaint filed with DLSE.
- Allows a court to award reasonable attorney’s fees to a prevailing employee in addition to any other relief that, in the judgment of the court, will effectuate the purpose of preventing employer discrimination, including, but not limited to, reinstatement, damages for back pay, front pay, and emotional distress. An aggrieved employee who brings a private civil action shall not be required to pursue any other remedy before bringing that action.
Comments
Need for this bill? Employer stakeholders frequently contend that bills seeking to expand a worker’s ability to pursue penalties in court are unnecessary because, in addition to filing a claim with DLSE, an employee also has the ability to bring a civil action to enforce any provision of the Labor Code through PAGA.
However, PAGA does not seek to compensate employees for any damages incurred because of a Labor Code violation and, in the case of retaliatory discharge, it has no provisions for reinstating an employee or awarding damages. Rather, PAGA seeks to supplement the limited enforcement resources of the Labor Commissioner by essentially enlisting employees to bring private causes of action. The employee is merely seeking to enforce the law. This is apparent when one considers that the remedy in PAGA action is limited to a collection of the fine or civil penalty imposed on the employer. Under PAGA, 75% of the fine or civil penalty goes to LWDA and 25% going to the employee that brought the action. While an employee is entitled to recover attorney’s fees and any filing fee, the purpose of the PAGA suit is to enforce the law for the benefit of the employee suing and for all other employees who benefit from enforcement of the law. Therefore, PAGA does not provide an appropriate remedy for employees who seek compensation for having suffered retaliation for exercising rights afforded to them under law.
Furthermore, there is evidence of a substantial backlog of complaints under the relevant sections that have yet to be decided on by DLSE. According to public reports furnished by DLSE, in 2017, 2,526 cases brought between 2010 and 2017 were accepted for investigation, yet only 333 determinations were issued. This means that workers who were retaliated against for exercising rights guaranteed to them by law in 2010 could very well still be waiting for a decision in their case nearly a decade later. It serves no one to have complaints go undecided for years and AB 1478 could allow more workers to take these complaints to court and have decisions made in a more timely fashion.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 1300 (Jackson, Chapter 955, Statutes of 2018) required that all employees receive sexual harassment training and education, include bystander intervention training as a part of the training, and prohibited a release of claims or nondisparagement agreements between employers and employees under specified circumstances. Provided that plaintiffs do not need to prove that they endured sexual harassment or discrimination when alleging that an employer failed to take all necessary steps to prevent sexual harassment or discrimination.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate lawsuits filed for alleged unlawful retaliation by an employer because of the exercise of a specified protected right of an employee that otherwise would not be filed (e.g., the allegation would have been resolved by filing a complaint with DLSE). While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
Unknown workload reduction to the Department of Industrial Relations. A reduced workload, however, would not lead to lower costs unless there is a reduction in personnel associated with sizeable reduction of complaints.
*Trial Court Trust Fund
California Public Defenders Association
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Pipe Trades Council
Legal Aid at Work
Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/19)
Brea Chamber of Commerce
California Ambulance Association
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Chamber of Commerce
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California League of Food Producers
California Special Districts Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
Civil Justice Association of California
El Centro Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Job Creators for Workplace Fairness
Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce
Murrieta Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
National Federation of Independent Business
North Orange County Chamber of Commerce
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author: “AB 1478 will ensure domestic violence (DV) survivors have the deserved option of a straightforward and expeditious legal pathway to justice in the case of their employers’ wrongdoing. DV survivors should be entitled to the opportunity to choose when and how their complaint of employer misconduct is heard, the ability to garner damages for the harm the have been caused and the right to representation by an attorney who is particularly equipped to defend the survivor’s best interests. By establishing an express PRA and authorizing payment of attorney’s fees for the DV survivor seeking justice, AB 1478 recognizes and addresses the uniquely delicate circumstances of DV survivors and provides a legal pathway that is clear, direct and uniquely tailored to the harm they have suffered.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership writes in opposition: “AB 1478 exposes employers of any size to costly litigation for an alleged violation, including an employee only (i.e. one-sided) right to attorney’s fees. Currently, employees may resolve any Labor Code Section 230 violation with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) through an administrative hearing. Creating a private right of action with employee only attorney’s fees will incentivize potentially frivolous litigation. Moreover, there is no evidence that such complaints cannot be efficiently handled through DLSE.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 44-21, 5/22/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gloria, Gonzalez, Holden, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Quirk, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Diep, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Irwin, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Melendez, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Smith, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Boerner Horvath, Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Frazier, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gray, Grayson, Mayes, Medina, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Rodriguez, Salas
Prepared by: Jake Ferrera / L., P.E. & R. / (916) 651-1556
9/9/19 18:40:19
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1478 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1478
Amended: 8/30/19 in Senate
SENATE LABOR, PUB. EMP. & RET. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 6/26/19
AYES: Hill, Jackson, Mitchell, Pan
NOES: Morrell
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-1, 7/9/19
AYES: Jackson, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 44-21, 5/22/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Employment discrimination
DIGEST:
This bill allows a worker to bring a private right of action against an employer for unlawful retaliation following an employee exercising their right to time off for specified reasons protected under the law, including domestic violence, jury duty or stalking.
Existing law:
- Establishes the California Fair Housing and Employment Act, which makes it an illegal practice for an employer to refuse to hire or to discriminate against a person because of the race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition (including pregnancy), genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status of that person. (Government Code §12940)
- Establishes the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA) and allows an aggrieved employee to recover a civil penalty normally assessed and collected by the Labor and Workforce Development Agency through a civil action. Provides that for any civil penalties recovered, LWDA shall receive 75% of the amount and the employee bringing the action shall receive the other 25%. Provides that any employee who prevails in a PAGA action shall be entitled to an award of reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, including any filing fee. (Labor Code §2698-2699.5)
- Prohibits an employer from discharging or in any manner discriminating against an employee for any of the following:
- Serving as required by law on an inquest jury or trial jury, if the employee gives reasonable notice to the employer that the employee is required to serve.
- Appearing in court to comply with a subpoena or other court order as a witness in any judicial proceeding, for an employee who is a victim of a crime.
- Taking time off from work to obtain or attempt to obtain any relief, including, but not limited to, a temporary restraining order, restraining order, or other injunctive relief, to help ensure the health, safety, or welfare of the victim or his or her the victim’s child, for an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
- An employee’s status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, if the victim provides notice to the employer of the status or the employer has actual knowledge of the status.
(Labor Code §230)
- Allows an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against by their employer because the employee has exercised the employee’s rights described in the above section may file a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE). (Labor Code §230(h))
- Requires an employer provide reasonable accommodations for a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking who requests an accommodation for the safety of the victim while at work. (Labor Code §230)
- Entitles an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against by their employer for in the above sections or because the employee has requested or received a reasonable accommodation pursuant to the to the above section to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer as well as appropriate equitable relief. (Labor Code §230(g)(2))
- Requires that an employee give their employer reasonable notice of their intention to take time off, if possible. (Labor Code §230(d)) 9) In addition to the requirements and prohibitions in the above sections, prohibits an employer with 25 or more employees from discharging, or in any manner discriminating or retaliating against, an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking for taking time off from work for any of the following purposes:
- To seek medical attention for injuries caused by domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
- To obtain services from a domestic violence shelter, program, or rape crisis center as a result of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
- To obtain psychological counseling related to an experience of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
- To participate in safety planning and take other actions to increase safety from future domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, including temporary or permanent relocation.
(Labor Code §230.1)
- Allows an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against by their employer because the employee has exercised the employee’s rights described in the above section may file a complaint with DLSE. (Labor Code §230.1(h))
- Entitles an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by their employer because the employee has taken time off for a purpose set forth in the above section to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer, as well as appropriate equitable relief. An employer who willfully refuses to rehire, promote, or otherwise restore an employee or former employee who has been determined to be eligible for rehiring or promotion by a grievance procedure or hearing authorized by law is guilty of a misdemeanor. (Labor Code §230.1)
- Requires an employee give their employer reasonable advance notice of the employee’s intention to take time off for the above section, unless the advance notice is not feasible. When an unscheduled absence occurs, the employer shall not take any action against the employee if the employee, within a reasonable time after the absence, provides a certification to the employer. (Labor Code §230.1)
- Authorizes the Labor Commissioner to investigate employee complaints. Further authorizes the Labor Commissioner to provide for a hearing, known as a Berman Hearing, in any action to recover wages, penalties, and other demands for compensation, including liquidated damages if the complaint alleges payment of a wage less than the minimum wage. (Labor Code §98)
- Allows any person who believes that they have been discharged or otherwise discriminated against in violation of any law under the jurisdiction of the Labor Commissioner to file a complaint with DLSE within six months after the occurrence of the violation. The six-month period may be extended for good cause. The complaint shall be investigated by a discrimination complaint investigator. The Labor Commissioner shall establish procedures for the investigation of discrimination complaints; a summary of the procedures shall be provided to each complainant and respondent at the time of initial contact. (Labor Code §98.7)
- Allows DLSE, with or without receiving a complaint, to commence investigating an employer that it suspects to have discharged or otherwise discriminated against an individ ual in violation of any law under the jurisdiction of the Labor Commissioner. DLSE may proceed without a complaint in those instances where suspected retaliation has occurred during the course of adjudicating a wage claim pursuant to or during a field inspection or in instances of suspected immigration-related threats. (Labor Code §98.7)
- Requires a court to order appropriate injunctive relief on behalf of an employee on a showing that reasonable cause exists to believe that the employee has been discharged or subjected to adverse action for raising a claim of retaliation or asserting rights under any law under the jurisdiction of the Labor Commissioner. (Labor Code §98.7)
- Authorizes, if the Labor Commissioner determines a violation has occurred, the Labor Commissioner to issue a determination or a citation. If the Labor Commissioner issues a determination, he or she shall notify the complainant and respondent and direct the respondent to cease and desist from any violation and take any action deemed necessary to remedy the violation, including, where appropriate, rehiring or reinstatement, reimbursement of lost wages and interest, payment of penalties, payment of reasonable attorney’s fees associated with any hearing held by the Labor Commissioner in investigating the complaint, and the posting of notices to employees. (Labor Code §98.7)
- Requires the Labor Commissioner bring an action against the respondent in the above section if the respondent does not comply with an order within 30 days following notification of the Labor Commissioner’s determination. An action by the Labor Commissioner seeking injunctive relief, reimbursement of lost wages and interest, payment of penalties, and any other appropriate relief, shall not accrue until a respondent fails to comply with the order for more than 30 days following notification of the commissioner’s determination. The Labor Commissioner shall commence an action within three years of its accrual, regardless of whether the commissioner seeks penalties in the action. (Labor Code §98.7)
- Requires the Labor Commissioner to notify the complainant and respondent and dismiss the complaint if the Labor Commissioner determines no violation has occurred. The Labor Commissioner may direct the complainant to pay reasonable attorney’s fees associated with any hearing held by the Labor Commissioner if the Labor Commissioner finds the complaint was frivolous, unreasonable, groundless, and brought in bad faith. (Labor Code §98.7)
This bill:
- Allows an employee to also bring a private civil action against an employer if they are discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by their employer because the employee has exercised their rights to take time off for specified reasons under Labor Code Sections 230 and 230.1.
- Additionally, allows the Labor Commissioner to close an investigation into a complaint regarding retaliation described above if the complainant for that case files an action in court against an employer based upon the same or similar facts as the complaint filed with DLSE.
- Allows a court to award reasonable attorney’s fees to a prevailing employee in addition to any other relief that, in the judgment of the court, will effectuate the purpose of preventing employer discrimination, including, but not limited to, reinstatement, damages for back pay, front pay, and emotional distress. An aggrieved employee who brings a private civil action shall not be required to pursue any other remedy before bringing that action.
Comments
Need for this bill? Employer stakeholders frequently contend that bills seeking to expand a worker’s ability to pursue penalties in court are unnecessary because, in addition to filing a claim with DLSE, an employee also has the ability to bring a civil action to enforce any provision of the Labor Code through PAGA.
However, PAGA does not seek to compensate employees for any damages incurred because of a Labor Code violation and, in the case of retaliatory discharge, it has no provisions for reinstating an employee or awarding damages. Rather, PAGA seeks to supplement the limited enforcement resources of the Labor Commissioner by essentially enlisting employees to bring private causes of action. The employee is merely seeking to enforce the law. This is apparent when one considers that the remedy in PAGA action is limited to a collection of the fine or civil penalty imposed on the employer. Under PAGA, 75% of the fine or civil penalty goes to LWDA and 25% going to the employee that brought the action. While an employee is entitled to recover attorney’s fees and any filing fee, the purpose of the PAGA suit is to enforce the law for the benefit of the employee suing and for all other employees who benefit from enforcement of the law. Therefore, PAGA does not provide an appropriate remedy for employees who seek compensation for having suffered retaliation for exercising rights afforded to them under law.
Furthermore, there is evidence of a substantial backlog of complaints under the relevant sections that have yet to be decided on by DLSE. According to public reports furnished by DLSE, in 2017, 2,526 cases brought between 2010 and 2017 were accepted for investigation, yet only 333 determinations were issued. This means that workers who were retaliated against for exercising rights guaranteed to them by law in 2010 could very well still be waiting for a decision in their case nearly a decade later. It serves no one to have complaints go undecided for years and AB 1478 could allow more workers to take these complaints to court and have decisions made in a more timely fashion.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 1300 (Jackson, Chapter 955, Statutes of 2018) required that all employees receive sexual harassment training and education, include bystander intervention training as a part of the training, and prohibited a release of claims or nondisparagement agreements between employers and employees under specified circumstances. Provided that plaintiffs do not need to prove that they endured sexual harassment or discrimination when alleging that an employer failed to take all necessary steps to prevent sexual harassment or discrimination.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate lawsuits filed for alleged unlawful retaliation by an employer because of the exercise of a specified protected right of an employee that otherwise would not be filed (e.g., the allegation would have been resolved by filing a complaint with DLSE). While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
Unknown workload reduction to the Department of Industrial Relations. A reduced workload, however, would not lead to lower costs unless there is a reduction in personnel associated with sizeable reduction of complaints.
*Trial Court Trust Fund
California Public Defenders Association
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Pipe Trades Council
Legal Aid at Work
Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/19)
Brea Chamber of Commerce
California Ambulance Association
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Chamber of Commerce
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California League of Food Producers
California Special Districts Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
Civil Justice Association of California
El Centro Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Job Creators for Workplace Fairness
Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce
Murrieta Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
National Federation of Independent Business
North Orange County Chamber of Commerce
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the author: “AB 1478 will ensure domestic violence (DV) survivors have the deserved option of a straightforward and expeditious legal pathway to justice in the case of their employers’ wrongdoing. DV survivors should be entitled to the opportunity to choose when and how their complaint of employer misconduct is heard, the ability to garner damages for the harm the have been caused and the right to representation by an attorney who is particularly equipped to defend the survivor’s best interests. By establishing an express PRA and authorizing payment of attorney’s fees for the DV survivor seeking justice, AB 1478 recognizes and addresses the uniquely delicate circumstances of DV survivors and provides a legal pathway that is clear, direct and uniquely tailored to the harm they have suffered.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership writes in opposition: “AB 1478 exposes employers of any size to costly litigation for an alleged violation, including an employee only (i.e. one-sided) right to attorney’s fees. Currently, employees may resolve any Labor Code Section 230 violation with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) through an administrative hearing. Creating a private right of action with employee only attorney’s fees will incentivize potentially frivolous litigation. Moreover, there is no evidence that such complaints cannot be efficiently handled through DLSE.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 44-21, 5/22/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gloria, Gonzalez, Holden, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Quirk, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Diep, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Irwin, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Melendez, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Smith, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Boerner Horvath, Cooley, Cooper, Daly, Frazier, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gray, Grayson, Mayes, Medina, Petrie-Norris, Quirk-Silva, Rodriguez, Salas
Prepared by: Jake Ferrera / L., P.E. & R. / (916) 651-1556
9/3/19 11:30:53
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1478 (Carrillo) - Employment discrimination
Version: July 11, 2019 | Policy Vote: L., P.E. & R. 4 - 1, JUD. 7 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 30, 2019 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on August 30, 2019
Bill Summary:
AB 1478 would create a private cause of action against an employer for unlawfully retaliating against an employee for exercising their right under the law to time off or, in some instances, to request reasonable accommodations to deal with issues such as jury service or related to being a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate lawsuits filed for alleged unlawful retaliation by an employer because of the exercise of a specified protected right of an employee that otherwise would not be filed (e.g., the allegation would have been resolved by filing a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement). While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
- Unknown workload reduction to the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR). A reduced workload, however, would not lead to lower costs unless there is a reduction in personnel associated with sizeable reduction of complaints.
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Author Amendments:
Allow the Labor Commissioner to close an investigation into a matter if a person files an action in court against an employer based on the same or similar facts as a complaint filed with the division.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1478 (Carrillo) - Employment discrimination
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 1478 would create a private cause of action against an employer for unlawfully retaliating against an employee for exercising their right under the law to time off or, in some instances, to request reasonable accommodations to deal with issues such as jury service or related to being a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate lawsuits filed for alleged unlawful retaliation by an employer because of the exercise of a specified protected right of an employee that otherwise would not be filed (e.g., the allegation would have been resolved by filing a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement). While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
- Unknown workload reduction to the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR). A reduced workload, however, would not lead to lower costs unless there is a reduction in personnel associated with sizeable reduction of complaints.
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Background:
According to the analysis of this bill by the Senate Committee on Judiciary:
Under existing law, California workers are entitled to certain workplace protections when dealing with certain life events beyond their control. Employers cannot punish workers for taking time off to serve on a jury or to participate in a judicial proceeding. Workers who have endured sexual assault, domestic violence, or stalking have the right to take time off to deal with the consequences of those crimes and may also request reasonable accommodations from their employers to ensure their safety at work. Large California employers must also grant victims of sexual assault, stalking, or domestic violence time off to obtain medical attention, services, counseling, or safety planning in connection with what they have endured.
Relatedly, employer are prohibited from discriminating against or discharging an employee for specified reasons, including that the employee is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking and takes time off work to obtain judicial or medical relief. Further, an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, or otherwise discriminated against, as provided, is entitled to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer as well as appropriate equitable relief. An aggrieved employee may file a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement of the Department of Industrial Relations. Moreover, the Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act of 2004 (PAGA), allows an aggrieved employee on behalf of that employee and other current or former employees to bring a civil action to recover specified civil penalties, which otherwise would be assessed and collected by the Labor and Workforce Development Agency, for the violation of certain provisions affecting employees. The act prescribes specified civil penalties for violations brought under PAGA.
Proposed Law:
This bill would allow an employee, as an alternative to filing a complaint with DIR, to bring a private civil action against their employer for allegedly discriminating against or discharging the employee for specified reasons, including that the employee is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking and takes time off work to obtain judicial or medical relief. The court would be allowed to award reasonable attorney’s fees to a prevailing employee in addition to any other relief that, in the judgment of the court, will effectuate the purpose of the law, including, but not limited to, reinstatement, damages for backpay, front pay, and emotional distress. AB 1478 would not require the employee to pursue any other remedy prior to bringing that action.
Related Legislation:
AB 171 (Gonzalez, 2019) would extend to workplace sexual harassment victims the same workplace protections that apply to victims of stalking, elder abuse, domestic violence, and sexual assault and would create a 90-day period during which any adverse action taken against a victim is subject to a rebuttable presumption that it was retaliatory. AB 171 is pending in this Committee.
SB 400 (Jackson, Ch. 759, Stats. 2014) added workplace protections for victims of stalking, and required employers to make reasonable accommodations for the workplace safety of victims of sexual assault, stalking, or domestic violence. Early versions of SB 400 contained a private right of action, but it was not included in the bill as enacted.
AB 2195 (Corbett, Ch. 275, Stats. 2002) expanded the protections for victims of domestic violence to victims of sexual assault.
AB 2357 (Honda, Ch. 487, Stats. 2000) enacted the Victims of Domestic Violence Employment Leave Act, which prohibited employers with 25 or more employees from discharging or discriminating or retaliating against an employee who is a victim of domestic violence and who takes time off to seek medical attention, to obtain services from a domestic violence program, to obtain psychological counseling, or to participate in safety planning.
SB 56 (Solis, Ch. 340, Stats. 1999) prohibited employers from discharging, discriminating, or retaliating against employees who are domestic violence victims and who take time off to appear in court to obtain or attempt to obtain any relief to help ensure the health, safety, or welfare of the victim or the victim’s child, if the employee gives the employer reasonable notice, as specified. It also extended the time an employee who is a domestic violence victim has to file a claim for a violation with the Labor Commissioner from 30 days to one year.
Staff Comments:
The actual fiscal impact of AB 1478 to the courts will depend on many unknown factors, including the numbers of individuals who file a civil action instead of a complaint with DIR, the complexity of each allegation, if parties settle matters prior to litigation, and the factors unique to each case. While it is unknown how many actions for alleged retaliation would be filed, it could be a recourse used by a notable number of victims. As stated by the California Partnership to End Domestic Violence, “[a] 2010 California survey found that 38 % of survivors report either having been fired or fearing termination because of their domestic violence situation, and 34% report having to quit a job because of domestic violence.”
It generally costs about $7,644 to operate a courtroom for one day. Additionally, it costs the court almost $2,900, on average, in personnel and resources to adjudicate a limited civil case and about $12,750, on average, in personnel and resources to adjudicate an unlimited civil case. These costs takes into consideration the time from when a petition or complaint is received by the court, processing and calendaring by the clerks, any hearings presided over by a judicial officer, and the finalizing of the outcome by the clerk. Consequently, if this measure led to the filing of four or more new large cases, 18 or more smaller cases, or a few complex cases that took longer than six days to adjudicate, the cost pressures to the court would surpass the Suspense File threshold. As indicated above, while the court is not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1478 (Author:Carrillo)
Version: March 27, 2019
Hearing Date: July 9, 2019
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: TSG
SUBJECT
Employment discrimination
DIGEST
This bill establishes a private right of action through which California workers may enforce their existing right to take time off and, in some instances, request reasonable accommodations, to deal with life events beyond their control such as having to serve on a jury, participating in a judicial proceeding, or enduring domestic violence, stalking, or sexual assault.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Under existing law, California workers are entitled to certain workplace protections when dealing with certain life events beyond their control. Employers cannot punish workers for taking time off to serve on a jury or to participate in a judicial proceeding. Workers who have endured sexual assault, domestic violence, or stalking have the right to take time off to deal with the consequences of those crimes and may also request reasonable accommodations from their employers to ensure their safety at work. Large California employers must also grant victims of sexual assault, stalking, or domestic violence time off to obtain medical attention, services, counseling, or safety planning in connection with what they have endured. The author and proponents of this bill contend that, under existing law, workers’ only practical avenue for enforcing these rights is through an administrative claim with the Labor Commissioner, but this remedy often proves too slow or ineffective. This bill would empower workers to seek redress directly in court, should they choose to do so.
The bill is sponsored by the California Employment Lawyers Association and the Conference of California Bar Associations. Support is from organized labor and workers’ rights advocates. Opposition comes from employer and business associations who argue that existing administrative remedies are sufficient and that the bill will lead to increased litigation. The bill passed out of the Senate Labor, Public Employment, and Retirement Committee by a vote of 4-1.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing state law:
- Establishes within the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) the Division of Fair Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) tasked with administering and enforcing labor code provisions concerning wages, hours and working conditions. (Lab. Code § 56.)
- Establishes the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA), which allows aggrieved employees to bring a civil suit on behalf of themselves and other employees to assess and collect any civil penalty normally assessed and collected by the Labor Commissioner. Provides that for any civil penalties recovered, the Labor Commissioner shall receive 75 percent of the amount and the employee bringing the action shall receive the other 25 percent. Provides that any employee who prevails in a PAGA action shall be entitled to an award of reasonable attorneys’ fees and costs, including any filing fee. (Lab. Code § 2698 et seq.)
- Prohibits an employer from discharging or in any manner discriminating against an employee for any of the following:
- serving as required by law on an inquest jury or trial jury, if the employee gives reasonable notice to the employer that the employee is required to serve;
- appearing in court to comply with a subpoena or other court order as a witness in any judicial proceeding, for an employee who is a victim of a crime;
- taking time off from work to obtain or attempt to obtain any relief, including, but not limited to, a temporary restraining order, restraining order, or other injunctive relief, to help ensure the health, safety, or welfare of the victim or the victim’s child, for an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking; or
- an employee’s status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, if the victim provides notice to the employer of the status or the employer has actual knowledge of the status. (Lab. Code § 230.)
- Provides that any employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against by their employer because the employee has exercised the employee’s rights described in (3), above, may file a complaint with the Labor Commissioner. (Lab. Code § 230(h).)
- Requires an employer to provide reasonable accommodations for a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking who requests an accommodation for the safety of the victim while at work. (Lab. Code §230(f).)
- Entitles an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against by their employer in the above sections or because the employee has requested or received a reasonable accommodation pursuant to the to the above sections to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer as well as appropriate equitable relief. (Lab. Code § 230(g)(2).)
- Prohibits an employer with 25 or more employees from discharging, or in any manner discriminating or retaliating against, an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking for taking time off from work for any of the following purposes:
- to seek medical attention for injuries caused by domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking;
- to obtain services from a domestic violence shelter, program, or rape crisis center as a result of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking;
- to obtain psychological counseling related to an experience of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking; or
- to participate in safety planning and take other actions to increase safety from future domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, including temporary or permanent relocation. (Lab. Code § 230.1(a).)
- Allows an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against by their employer because the employee has exercised the employee’s rights described in (7), above, may file a complaint with the Labor Commissioner. (Lab. Code § 230.1(h).)
- Entitles an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by their employer because the employee has taken time off for a purpose set forth in the above section, to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer, as well as appropriate equitable relief. An employer who willfully refuses to rehire, promote, or otherwise restore an employee or former employee who has been determined to be eligible for rehiring or promotion by a grievance procedure or hearing authorized by law is guilty of a misdemeanor. (Lab. Code § 230.1(c).)
This bill:
- Provides that an employee who is retaliated against for taking time off for jury duty, to participate in a judicial proceeding, or to obtain legal relief associated with enduring sexual assault, domestic violence, or stalking or because the employee has requested reasonable accommodations to ensure their workplace safety after enduring stalking, domestic violence, or sexual assault, may bring a private civil action against an employer in a court of competent jurisdiction.
- Authorizes a court to award reasonable attorney’s fees to a prevailing employee in addition to any other relief that, in the judgment of the court, will effectuate the purpose of preventing employer discrimination, including, but not limited to, reinstatement, damages for back pay, front pay, and emotional distress. An aggrieved employee who brings a private civil action shall not be required to pursue any other remedy before bringing that action.
COMMENTS
- A new enforcement mechanism for existing workplace rights
This bill does not create any new workplace rights. California Labor Code Section 230 has long enabled workers to take time off of work for jury duty or to attend court proceedings without fear of retaliation. More recent changes to Labor Code Section 230 have expanded its protections to include time off for handling legal matters and reasonable workplace safety accommodations for victims of stalking, domestic violence, and sexual assault. For larger employers, Labor Code Section 230.1 also ensures that victims of stalking, domestic violence, and sexual assault can take time off to obtain medical attention, services, counseling, and safety planning in connection with what they have endured.
The statutes themselves make clear that workers can try to enforce these rights by filing a claim with the California Labor Commissioner. It is less clear whether workers can also seek to vindicate their rights under these laws in court. As one court recently wrote in an unpublished opinion: “[a]lthough the statutes state an employee is entitled to reinstatement, reimbursement, and appropriate equitable relief, they do not expressly authorize a civil action to obtain those remedies.”
This bill would clarify the issue by expressly authorizing workers to file a civil action in court to enforce their rights under Labor Code Section 230 and 230.1.
- Why existing remedies may not be sufficient
The opponents of this bill argue that workers already have two avenues for enforcing their rights under Labor Code Section 230 and 230.1: filing an administrative claim with the Labor Commissioner or proceeding to court through an action under PAGA. In response, the author and proponents contend that, in practice, neither method adequately protects the workplace rights of workers who have been victims of domestic violence, stalking, or sexual assault.
According to the proponents, proceeding administratively by filing a claim with the Labor Commissioner is problematic. First, it takes agency away from the victims. As the Conference of California Bar Associations puts it, “employees are at the mercy of the [Labor Commissioner] deciding whether to pursue a claim. This [bill] gives employees the control over his [sic] case.” In addition, the proponents contend that the administrative process is overextended and therefore unable to respond nimbly enough to address the needs of victims. The claims of domestic violence survivors, for example, are cast together with thousands of other retaliation claims that the Labor Commissioner’s office receive and investigate each year. Oftentimes, the author of the bill states, “DV survivors must prolong their suffering as they navigate the existing avenues through heavily impacted state agencies…” The Labor Commissioner’s own statistics appear to bear this out. In the Labor Commissioner’s 2016/2017 Budget Change Proposal seeking additional deputies to assist in the investigation of retaliation complaints, the Labor Commissioner wrote, based on 2014 statistics: “[i]t currently takes an average of 122 days from when a case is opened to the time it is assigned to a [Deputy Labor Commissioner], primarily due to the need to close out the backlog of cases…”[1] In other words, as recently as 2014, the Labor Commissioner did not even begin investigation of a retaliation complaint until four months after it was filed.
PAGA is also ill-suited for vindicating rights under Labor Code Section 230 and 230.1, the proponents assert, for at least two reasons. To begin with, it is not clear that PAGA actions could be brought to address Labor Code 230 and 230.1 violations. PAGA actions are meant to be representative claims: “the PAGA statute does not enable a single aggrieved employee to litigate his or her claims, but requires an aggrieved employee on behalf of herself or himself and other current or former employees to enforce violence of the Labor Code by their employers.” (Reyes v. Macy’s, Inc. 202 Cal.App.4th 119, 1123-4, internal citations and quotations omitted.)
In addition, even if an individual worker could proceed under PAGA, it only allows successful plaintiffs to retain 25 percent of any civil penalty that they recover on behalf of the Labor Commissioner. Since there is no civil penalty explicitly mentioned in Labor Code Sections 230 and 230.1, PAGA’s default civil penalty of $100 per violation would apply. (Lab. Code § 2699(f)(2). Thus, for being retaliated against at work for exercising rights under Labor Code Section 230 or 230.1, a worker proceeding under PAGA could likely anticipate recovering no more than $25.
Summarizing these points, the California Employment Lawyers Association concludes: “[w]hen a worker is experiencing domestic violence and is trying to find safety and keep her job, navigating the delays and hurdles of our state agencies or recovering a $25 check is a blatant failure of our laws.”
3. Policy considerations behind fee-shifting provisions
In the process of authorizing workers to bring civil actions in court to try to vindicate their rights under Labor Code Section 230 and 230.1, this bill also provides that workers can recover attorney fees if they prevail.
Ordinarily, under the so-called “American Rule,” each party to a lawsuit must bear its own attorney’s fees, regardless of the outcome. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1021; Musaelian v. Adams (2009) 45 Cal.4th 512.) However, the American Rule can be altered by contract or statute. (Ibid.) Such changes to the American Rule are known as “fee-shifting provisions.”
Fee-shifting provisions may be one-way or two-way. A two-way fee shifting provision entitles the winning party to have its attorney’s fees covered by the losing party. A one-way fee-shifting provision, such as the one proposed by this bill, only allows one side in a case, usually the plaintiff, to recover attorney’s fees, if that side prevails. One-way fee shifting provisions are generally used to help litigants obtain counsel where they might not otherwise be able to afford one. (Flannery v. Prentice (2001) 26 Cal.4th 572.) One-way fee-shifting provisions can also be employed to encourage private enforcement of a public policy aim.[2]
According to the Conference of California Bar Associations, one of the sponsors of the bill, the private right of action and the associated one-way attorney’s fees clause mirrors language found in the same Article of the Labor Code.
For their part, the opponents to this bill assert that “creating a private right of action with employee only attorney’s fees will incentivize potentially frivolous litigation.” It is likely true that, seeing a chance of getting paid for their work through an attorney’s fees award, some lawyers may take on cases that they otherwise would not. Indeed, as mentioned, creating greater access to legal representation, particularly for low-income workers, is part of the point behind the bill. At the same time, the proposed one-way fee-shifting provision is unlikely to lead to an increase in weak or meritless claims. The prospect of obtaining an attorney fee award will only tempt an economically rational lawyer to take a case if there is a good chance of winning it.
Still, if there is to be any fee-shifting in the bill, the opponents contend that it should at least be a two-way shift. A two-way fee shift would have the opposite of the author’s intended policy effect, however. Workers with meritorious claims might be dissuaded from bringing them out of fear that something will go wrong and they will wind up with the bill for their employer’s legal fees. A more reasonable ask – one that the Chamber is not currently making – might be a clause along the lines of those frequently encountered in relation to one-way fee shifting statutes: that the defendant is not entitled to an award of attorney fees, even if the defendant prevails in the action, unless the court determines that the plaintiff’s case was utterly meritless from the outset, or that the plaintiff continued to litigate that matter even after it became clear that it was meritless. Such a clause at least partially avoids the chilling effect associated with a two-way fee shift, while offering defendants some protection against truly extortionate litigants.
4. Potential for duplicative administrative and judicial remedies
As the bill currently reads, in addition to filing a claim with the Labor Commissioner, an aggrieved worker “may also” bring a private civil action against an employer in court. As the opposition to the bill points out, this language appears to allow for the possibility that a worker could have administrative and judicial claims pending simultaneously. Such an outcome could create some confusion. What would happen, for example, if the court and the Labor Commissioner came to opposite conclusions about the case? It also raises the theoretical prospect that the employer could be made liable twice for the same violation. Assuming that this was not part of the intent behind the bill, the author may wish to amend the bill to clarify that an employee may bring a claim administratively or through the courts, but not both.
5. Proposed amendments
In order to address the issues set forth in the Comments, above, the author proposes to incorporate amendments into the bill that would:
- clarify that workers may pursue remedies through the Labor Commissioner or the courts, but not both; and
- clarify that workers have one year from the time of the violation to file for relief with either the Labor Commission or the courts.
A mock-up of the amendments in context is attached to this analysis.
6. Arguments in support of the bill
According to the author:
AB 1478 will ensure DV survivors have the deserved option of a straightforward and expeditious legal pathway to justice in the case of their employers’ wrongdoing. DV survivors should be entitled the opportunity to choose when and how their complaint of employer misconduct is heard, the ability to garner damages for the harm they have been caused and the right to representation by an attorney who is particularly equipped to defend the survivor’s best interests.
By establishing an express PRA and authorizing payment of attorney’s fees for the DV survivor seeking justice, AB 1478 recognizes and addresses the uniquely delicate circumstances of DV survivors and provides a legal pathway that is clear, direct and uniquely tailored to the harm they have suffered.
As sponsor of the bill, the California Employment Lawyers Association writes:
By establishing an express [private right of action] for the DV survivor seeking justice, AB 1478 recognizes and addresses the uniquely delicate circumstances of DV survivors and provides a legal pathway that is clear, direct and uniquely tailored to the harm they have suffered.
In support, the California Partnership to End Domestic Violence writes:
A 2010 California survey found that 38 % of survivors report either having been fired or fearing termination because of their domestic violence situation, and 34% report having to quit a job because of domestic violence. The impacts of job loss can be devastating, pushing survivors and their children into economic stress, poverty, and homelessness. Domestic violence is a leading cause of homelessness for women and for families with children. Economic reasons are also a primary reason that survivors give for remaining with or returning to an abusive partner.
As it stands, it is very confusing and difficult for survivors to navigate enforcing their rights, and as a result, when a survivor faces illegal discrimination, they frequently feel that they have nowhere to turn and there’s nothing they can do. AB 1478 creates the opportunity for survivors to bring a civil action directly against their employer and receive the equitable relief they deserve.
In further support, the California Public Defenders Association writes:
When our citizens are threatened with loss of their employment after being summoned to serve as jurors it creates a substantial impediment to insuring that the fair cross section right is protected. This threat of retaliation by employers toward jurors who have agreed to serve and uphold their civic duty further restricts the potential jury pool by intimidating those who are not financially well off from participation in the jury system.
7. Arguments in opposition to the bill
In opposition to the bill, the California Chamber of Commerce and 23 co-signatories write:
AB 1478 exposes employers of any size to costly litigation for an alleged violation, including an employee only (i.e., one-sided) right to attorney’s fees. Currently, employees may resolve any Labor Code Section 230 violation with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) through an administrative hearing. […] Creating a private right of action with employee only attorney’s fees will incentivize potentially frivolous litigation. Moreover, there is no evidence that such complaints cannot be efficiently handled through the DLSE.
SUPPORT
California Employment Lawyers Association (sponsor)
Conference of California Bar Associations (sponsor)
California Public Defenders Association
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Pipe Trades Council
Western States Council Sheet Metal Workers
OPPOSITION
Brea Chamber of Commerce
California Ambulance Association
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Chamber of Commerce
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California League of Food Producers
California Special Districts Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
Civil Justice Association of California
El Centro Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Job Creators for Workplace Fairness
Murrieta Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
National Federation of Independent Business
North Orange County Chamber of Commerce
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
AB 171 (Gonzalez, 2019) extends to victims of workplace sexual harassment the same workplace protections that apply to victims of stalking, elder abuse, domestic violence, and sexual assault. The bill also creates a 90-day period during which any adverse action taken against a victim is subject to a rebuttable presumption that it was retaliatory. AB 171 is currently pending consideration before the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Prior Legislation:
SB 400 (Jackson, Ch. 759, Stats. 2014) added workplace protections for victims of stalking, and required employers to make reasonable accommodations for the workplace safety of victims of sexual assault, stalking, or domestic violence. Early versions of SB 400 contained a private right of action, but it was not included in the bill as enacted.
AB 2195 (Corbett, Ch. 275, Stats. 2002) expanded the protections for victims of domestic violence to victims of sexual assault.
AB 2357 (Honda, Ch. 487, Stats. 2000) enacted the Victims of Domestic Violence Employment Leave Act, which prohibited employers with 25 or more employees from discharging or discriminating or retaliating against an employee who is a victim of domestic violence and who takes time off to seek medical attention, to obtain services from a domestic violence program, to obtain psychological counseling, or to participate in safety planning.
SB 56 (Solis, Ch. 340, Stats. 1999) prohibited employers from discharging, discriminating, or retaliating against employees who are victims of domestic violence and who take time off to appear in court to obtain or attempt to obtain any relief to help ensure the health, safety, or welfare of a domestic violence victim or the victim’s child, if the employee gives the employer reasonable notice, as specified. The bill also authorized extended the time an employee who is a victim of domestic violence has to file a claim for a violation with the Labor Commissioner from 30 days to one year.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Labor, Public Employment and Retirement Committee (Ayes 4, Noes 1)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 44, Noes 21)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 3)
Assembly Labor and Employment Committee (Ayes 5, Noes 2)
**************
Amended Mock-up for 2019-2020 AB-1478 (Carrillo (A))
The people of the State of California do enact as follows:
SECTION 1. Section 230 of the Labor Code is amended to read:
230. (a) An employer shall not discharge or in any manner discriminate against an employee for taking time off to serve as required by law on an inquest jury or trial jury, if the employee, prior to taking the time off, gives reasonable notice to the employer that the employee is required to serve.
(b) An employer shall not discharge or in any manner discriminate or retaliate against an employee, including, but not limited to, an employee who is a victim of a crime, for taking time off to appear in court to comply with a subpoena or other court order as a witness in any judicial proceeding.
(c) An employer shall not discharge or in any manner discriminate or retaliate against an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking for taking time off from work to obtain or attempt to obtain any relief, including, but not limited to, a temporary restraining order, restraining order, or other injunctive relief, to help ensure the health, safety, or welfare of the victim or the victim’s child.
(d) (1) As a condition of taking time off for a purpose set forth in subdivision (c), the employee shall give the employer reasonable advance notice of the employee’s intention to take time off unless the advance notice is not feasible.
(2) When an unscheduled absence occurs, the employer shall not take any action against the employee if the employee, within a reasonable time after the absence, provides a certification to the employer. Certification shall be sufficient in the form of any of the following:
(A) A police report indicating that the employee was a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
(B) A court order protecting or separating the employee from the perpetrator of an act of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, or other evidence from the court or prosecuting attorney that the employee has appeared in court.
(C) Documentation from a licensed medical professional, domestic violence counselor, as defined in Section 1037.1 of the Evidence Code, a sexual assault counselor, as defined in Section 1035.2 of the Evidence Code, licensed health care provider, or counselor that the employee was undergoing treatment for physical or mental injuries or abuse resulting from an act of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
(3) To the extent allowed by law and consistent with subparagraph (D) of paragraph (7) of subdivision (f), the employer shall maintain the confidentiality of any employee requesting leave under subdivision (c).
(e) An employer shall not discharge or in any manner discriminate or retaliate against an employee because of the employee’s status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, if the victim provides notice to the employer of the status or the employer has actual knowledge of the status.
(f) (1) An employer shall provide reasonable accommodations for a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking who requests an accommodation for the safety of the victim while at work.
(2) For purposes of this subdivision, reasonable accommodations may include the implementation of safety measures, including a transfer, reassignment, modified schedule, changed work telephone, changed work station, installed lock, assistance in documenting domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking that occurs in the workplace, an implemented safety procedure, or another adjustment to a job structure, workplace facility, or work requirement in response to domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, or referral to a victim assistance organization.
(3) An employer is not required to provide a reasonable accommodation to an employee who has not disclosed the employee’s status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
(4) The employer shall engage in a timely, good faith, and interactive process with the employee to determine effective reasonable accommodations.
(5) In determining whether the accommodation is reasonable, the employer shall consider an exigent circumstance or danger facing the employee.
(6) This subdivision does not require the employer to undertake an action that constitutes an undue hardship on the employer’s business operations, as defined by Section 12926 of the Government Code. For the purposes of this subdivision, an undue hardship also includes an action that would violate an employer’s duty to furnish and maintain a place of employment that is safe and healthful for all employees as required by Section 6400 of the Labor Code.
(7) (A) Upon the request of an employer, an employee requesting a reasonable accommodation pursuant to this subdivision shall provide the employer a written statement signed by the employee or an individual acting on the employee’s behalf, certifying that the accommodation is for a purpose authorized under this subdivision.
(B) The employer may also request certification from an employee requesting an accommodation pursuant to this subdivision demonstrating the employee’s status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking. Certification shall be sufficient in the form of any of the categories described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d).
(C) An employer who requests certification pursuant to subparagraph (B) may request recertification of an employee’s status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking every six months after the date of the previous certification.
(D) Any verbal or written statement, police or court record, or other documentation provided to an employer identifying an employee as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking shall be maintained as confidential by the employer and shall not be disclosed by the employer except as required by federal or state law or as necessary to protect the employee’s safety in the workplace. The employee shall be given notice before any authorized disclosure.
(E) (i) If circumstances change and an employee needs a new accommodation, the employee shall request a new accommodation from the employer.
(ii) Upon receiving the request, the employer shall engage in a timely, good faith, and interactive process with the employee to determine effective reasonable accommodations.
(F) If an employee no longer needs an accommodation, the employee shall notify the employer that the accommodation is no longer needed.
(8) An employer shall not retaliate against a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking for requesting a reasonable accommodation, regardless of whether the request was granted.
(g) (1) An employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by the employee’s employer because the employee has taken time off for a purpose set forth in subdivision (a) or (b) shall be entitled to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer.
(2) An employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by the employee’s employer for reasons prohibited in subdivision (c) or (e), or because the employee has requested or received a reasonable accommodation as set forth in subdivision (f), shall be entitled to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer as well as appropriate equitable relief.
(3) An employer who willfully refuses to rehire, promote, or otherwise restore an employee or former employee who has been determined to be eligible for rehiring or promotion by a grievance procedure or hearing authorized by law is guilty of a misdemeanor.
(h) (1) An employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by the employee’s employer because the employee has exercised the employee’s rights as set forth in subdivision (a), (b), (c), (e), or (f) may file a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement of the Department of Industrial Relations pursuant to Section 98.7. An aggrieved employee may instead bring a private civil action against an employer in a court of competent jurisdiction. The court may award reasonable attorney’s fees to a prevailing employee in addition to any other relief that, in the judgment of the court, will effectuate the purpose of this section, including, but not limited to, reinstatement, damages for back pay, front pay, and emotional distress. An aggrieved employee who brings a private civil action pursuant to this subdivision shall not be required to pursue any other remedy before bringing that action.
(2) Notwithstanding any time limitation in Section 98.7, an employee may file a complaint with the division or in the court of competent jurisdiction based upon a violation of subdivision (c), (e), or (f) within one year from the date of occurrence of the violation.
(i) An employee may use vacation, personal leave, or compensatory time off that is otherwise available to the employee under the applicable terms of employment, unless otherwise provided by a collective bargaining agreement, for time taken off for a purpose specified in subdivision (a), (b), or (c). The entitlement of any employee under this section shall not be diminished by any collective bargaining agreement term or condition.
(j) For purposes of this section:
(1) “Domestic violence” means any of the types of abuse set forth in Section 6211 of the Family Code, as amended.
(2) “Sexual assault” means any of the crimes set forth in Section 261, 261.5, 262, 265, 266, 266a, 266b, 266c, 266g, 266j, 267, 269, 273.4, 285, 286, 287, 288, 288.5, 289, or 311.4 of, or former Section 288a of, the Penal Code, as amended.
(3) “Stalking” means a crime set forth in Section 646.9 of the Penal Code or Section 1708.7 of the Civil Code.
SEC. 2. Section 230.1 of the Labor Code is amended to read:
230.1. (a) In addition to the requirements and prohibitions imposed on employees pursuant to Section 230, an employer with 25 or more employees shall not discharge, or in any manner discriminate or retaliate against, an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking for taking time off from work for any of the following purposes:
(1) To seek medical attention for injuries caused by domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
(2) To obtain services from a domestic violence shelter, program, or rape crisis center as a result of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
(3) To obtain psychological counseling related to an experience of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
(4) To participate in safety planning and take other actions to increase safety from future domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, including temporary or permanent relocation.
(b) (1) As a condition of taking time off for a purpose set forth in subdivision (a), the employee shall give the employer reasonable advance notice of the employee’s intention to take time off, unless the advance notice is not feasible.
(2) When an unscheduled absence occurs, the employer shall not take any action against the employee if the employee, within a reasonable time after the absence, provides a certification to the employer. Certification shall be sufficient in the form of any of the categories described in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 230.
(3) To the extent allowed by law and consistent with subparagraph (D) of paragraph (7) of subdivision (f) of Section 230, employers shall maintain the confidentiality of any employee requesting leave under subdivision (a).
(c) An employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by the employee’s employer because the employee has taken time off for a purpose set forth in subdivision (a) is entitled to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer, as well as appropriate equitable relief. An employer who willfully refuses to rehire, promote, or otherwise restore an employee or former employee who has been determined to be eligible for rehiring or promotion by a grievance procedure or hearing authorized by law is guilty of a misdemeanor.
(d) (1) An employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by the employee’s employer because the employee has exercised the employee’s rights as set forth in subdivision (a) may file a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement of the Department of Industrial Relations pursuant to Section 98.7. An aggrieved employee may insteadbring a private civil action against an employer in a court of competent jurisdiction. The court may award reasonable attorney’s fees to a prevailing employee in addition to any other relief that, in the judgment of the court, will effectuate the purpose of this section, including, but not limited to, reinstatement, damages for back pay, front pay, and emotional distress. An aggrieved employee who brings a private civil action pursuant to this subdivision shall not be required to pursue any other remedy before bringing that action.
(2) Notwithstanding any time limitation in Section 98.7, an employee may file a complaint with the division or in the court of competent jurisdiction based upon a violation of subdivision (a) within one year from the date of occurrence of the violation.
(e) An employee may use vacation, personal leave, or compensatory time off that is otherwise available to the employee under the applicable terms of employment, unless otherwise provided by a collective bargaining agreement, for time taken off for a purpose specified in subdivision (a). The entitlement of any employee under this section shall not be diminished by any term or condition of a collective bargaining agreement.
(f) This section does not create a right for an employee to take unpaid leave that exceeds the unpaid leave time allowed under, or is in addition to the unpaid leave time permitted by, the federal Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993 (29 U.S.C. Sec. 2601 et seq.).
(g) For purposes of this section:
(1) “Domestic violence” means any of the types of abuse set forth in Section 6211 of the Family Code, as amended.
(2) “Sexual assault” means any of the crimes set forth in Section 261, 261.5, 262, 265, 266, 266a, 266b, 266c, 266g, 266j, 267, 269, 273.4, 285, 286, 287, 288, 288.5, 289, or 311.4 of, or former Section 288a of, the Penal Code, as amended.
(3) “Stalking” means a crime set forth in Section 646.9 of the Penal Code or Section 1708.7 of the Civil Code.
(h) (1) Employers shall inform each employee of the employee’s rights established under this section and subdivisions (c), (e), and (f) of Section 230 in writing. The information shall be provided to new employees upon hire and to other employees upon request.
(2) The Labor Commissioner shall develop a form that an employer may use to comply with the notice requirements in paragraph (1). The form shall set forth the rights and duties of employers and employees under this section in clear and concise language. The Labor Commissioner shall post the form on the commissioner’s internet website to make it available to employers who are required to comply with this section. If an employer elects not to use the form developed by the Labor Commissioner, the notice provided by the employer to the employees shall be substantially similar in content and clarity to the form developed by the Labor Commissioner. The Labor Commissioner shall develop the form and post it in accordance with this paragraph on or before July 1, 2017.
(3) Employers shall not be required to comply with paragraph (1) until the Labor Commissioner posts the form on the commissioner’s internet website in accordance with paragraph (2).
2016/2017 Budget Change Proposal (Jan. 1, 2017) Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, p. 5 http://web1a.esd.dof.ca.gov/Documents/bcp/1617/FY1617_ORG7350_BCP435.pdf (as of Jul. 3, 2019). ↑
See Krent, Explaining One Way Fee Shifting (Nov. 1993) 79 Va. L. Rev. 2039, 2044. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR, PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Senator Jerry Hill, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 1478 Hearing Date: June 26, 2019
Author: | Carrillo | ||
Version: | March 27, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Jake Ferrera | ||
SUBJECT: Employment discrimination
KEY ISSUE
Should the Legislature allow a worker to bring a private right of action against an employer for unlawful retaliation following an employee exercising their right to time off for specified reasons protected under the law, including domestic violence, jury duty or stalking?
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Establishes the California Fair Housing and Employment Act, which makes it an illegal practice for an employer to refuse to hire or to discriminate against a person because of the race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition (including pregnancy), genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status of that person. (Government Code §12940)
- Establishes within the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) the Division of Fair Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) tasked with administering and enforcing labor code provisions concerning wages, hours and working conditions. (Labor Code §56)
- Establishes the Private Attorneys General Act and allows an aggrieved employee to recover a civil penalty normally assessed and collected by the Labor and Workforce Development Agency through a civil action. Provides that for any civil penalties recovered, the Labor and Workforce Development Agency (LWDA) shall receive 75% of the amount and the employee bringing the action shall receive the other 25%. Provides that any employee who prevails in a PAGA action shall be entitled to an award of reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, including any filing fee. (Labor Code §2698-2699.5)
- Prohibits an employer from discharging or in any manner discriminating against an employee for any of the following:
- Serving as required by law on an inquest jury or trial jury, if the employee gives reasonable notice to the employer that the employee is required to serve.
- Appearing in court to comply with a subpoena or other court order as a witness in any judicial proceeding, for an employee who is a victim of a crime.
- Taking time off from work to obtain or attempt to obtain any relief, including, but not limited to, a temporary restraining order, restraining order, or other injunctive relief, to help ensure the health, safety, or welfare of the victim or his or her the victim’s child, for an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
- An employee’s status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, if the victim provides notice to the employer of the status or the employer has actual knowledge of the status.
(Labor Code §230)
- Allows an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against by their employer because the employee has exercised the employee’s rights described in the above section may file a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement. (Labor Code §230(h))
- Requires an employer provide reasonable accommodations for a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking who requests an accommodation for the safety of the victim while at work. (Labor Code §230)
- Entitles an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against by their employer for in the above sections or because the employee has requested or received a reasonable accommodation pursuant to the to the above section to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer as well as appropriate equitable relief. (Labor Code §230(g)(2))
- Requires that an employee give their employer reasonable notice of their intention to take time off, if possible. (Labor Code §230(d))
- In addition to the requirements and prohibitions in the above sections, prohibits an employer with 25 or more employees from discharging, or in any manner discriminating or retaliating against, an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking for taking time off from work for any of the following purposes:
- To seek medical attention for injuries caused by domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
- To obtain services from a domestic violence shelter, program, or rape crisis center as a result of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
- To obtain psychological counseling related to an experience of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
- To participate in safety planning and take other actions to increase safety from future domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, including temporary or permanent relocation.
(Labor Code §230.1)
- Allows an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against by their employer because the employee has exercised the employee’s rights described in the above section may file a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement. (Labor Code §230.1(h))
- Entitles an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by their employer because the employee has taken time off for a purpose set forth in the above section to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer, as well as appropriate equitable relief. An employer who willfully refuses to rehire, promote, or otherwise restore an employee or former employee who has been determined to be eligible for rehiring or promotion by a grievance procedure or hearing authorized by law is guilty of a misdemeanor.
(Labor Code §230.1)
- Requires an employee give their employer reasonable advance notice of the employee’s intention to take time off for the above section, unless the advance notice is not feasible. When an unscheduled absence occurs, the employer shall not take any action against the employee if the employee, within a reasonable time after the absence, provides a certification to the employer. (Labor Code §230.1)
- Authorizes the Labor Commissioner to investigate employee complaints. Further authorizes the Labor Commissioner to provide for a hearing, known as a Berman Hearing, in any action to recover wages, penalties, and other demands for compensation, including liquidated damages if the complaint alleges payment of a wage less than the minimum wage.
(Labor Code §98)
- Allows any person who believes that they have been discharged or otherwise discriminated against in violation of any law under the jurisdiction of the Labor Commissioner to file a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) within six months after the occurrence of the violation. The six-month period may be extended for good cause. The complaint shall be investigated by a discrimination complaint investigator. The Labor Commissioner shall establish procedures for the investigation of discrimination complaints; a summary of the procedures shall be provided to each complainant and respondent at the time of initial contact. (Labor Code §98.7)
- Allows DLSE, with or without receiving a complaint, to commence investigating an employer that it suspects to have discharged or otherwise discriminated against an individual in violation of any law under the jurisdiction of the Labor Commissioner. DLSE may proceed without a complaint in those instances where suspected retaliation has occurred during the course of adjudicating a wage claim pursuant to or during a field inspection or in instances of suspected immigration-related threats. (Labor Code §98.7)
- Requires a court to order appropriate injunctive relief on behalf of an employee on a showing that reasonable cause exists to believe that the employee has been discharged or subjected to adverse action for raising a claim of retaliation or asserting rights under any law under the jurisdiction of the Labor Commissioner. (Labor Code §98.7)
- If the Labor Commissioner determines a violation has occurred, authorizes the Labor Commissioner to issue a determination or a citation. If the Labor Commissioner issues a determination, he or she shall notify the complainant and respondent and direct the respondent to cease and desist from any violation and take any action deemed necessary to remedy the violation, including, where appropriate, rehiring or reinstatement, reimbursement of lost wages and interest, payment of penalties, payment of reasonable attorney’s fees associated with any hearing held by the Labor Commissioner in investigating the complaint, and the posting of notices to employees. (Labor Code §98.7)
- Requires the Labor Commissioner bring an action against the respondent in the above section if the respondent does not comply with an order within 30 days following notification of the Labor Commissioner’s determination. An action by the Labor Commissioner seeking injunctive relief, reimbursement of lost wages and interest, payment of penalties, and any other appropriate relief, shall not accrue until a respondent fails to comply with the order for more than 30 days following notification of the commissioner’s determination. The Labor Commissioner shall commence an action within three years of its accrual, regardless of whether the commissioner seeks penalties in the action. (Labor Code §98.7)
- Requires the Labor Commissioner to notify the complainant and respondent and dismiss the complaint if the Labor Commissioner determines no violation has occurred. The Labor Commissioner may direct the complainant to pay reasonable attorney’s fees associated with any hearing held by the Labor Commissioner if the Labor Commissioner finds the complaint was frivolous, unreasonable, groundless, and brought in bad faith. (Labor Code §98.7)
This bill:
- Allows an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by their employer because the employee has exercised the employee’s rights to take time off for specified reasons under Labor Code §§230 and 230.1 to also bring a private civil action against an employer in a court of competent jurisdiction.
- Allows a court to award reasonable attorney’s fees to a prevailing employee in addition to any other relief that, in the judgment of the court, will effectuate the purpose of preventing employer discrimination, including, but not limited to, reinstatement, damages for back pay, front pay, and emotional distress. An aggrieved employee who brings a private civil action shall not be required to pursue any other remedy before bringing that action.
COMMENTS
1. Need for this bill?
Employer stakeholders frequently contend that bills seeking to expand a worker’s ability to pursue penalties in court are unnecessary because, in addition to filing a claim with DLSE, an employee also has the ability to bring a civil action to enforce any provision of the Labor Code through the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA).
However, PAGA does not seek to compensate employees for any damages incurred because of a Labor Code violation and, in the case of retaliatory discharge, it has no provisions for reinstating an employee or awarding damages. Rather, PAGA seeks to supplement the limited enforcement resources of the Labor Commissioner by essentially enlisting employees to bring private causes of action. The employee is merely seeking to enforce the law. This is apparent when one considers that the remedy in PAGA action is limited to a collection of the fine or civil penalty imposed on the employer. Under PAGA, 75% of the fine or civil penalty goes to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency (LWDA) and 25% going to the employee that brought the action. While an employee is entitled to recover attorney’s fees and any filing fee, the purpose of the PAGA suit is to enforce the law for the benefit of the employee suing and for all other employees who benefit from enforcement of the law. Therefore, PAGA does not provide an appropriate remedy for employees who seek compensation for having suffered retaliation for exercising rights afforded to them under law.
Furthermore, there is evidence of a substantial backlog of complaints under the relevant sections that have yet to be decided on by DLSE. According to public reports furnished by DLSE, in 2017, 2,526 cases brought between 2010 and 2017 were accepted for investigation, yet only 333 determinations were issued. This means that workers who were retaliated against for exercising rights guaranteed to them by law in 2010 could very well still be waiting for a decision in their case nearly a decade later. It serves no one to have complaints go undecided for years and AB 1478 could allow more workers to take these complaints to court and have decisions made in a more timely fashion.
2. Proponent Arguments
According to the Author:
“AB 1478 will ensure domestic violence (DV) survivors have the deserved option of a straightforward and expeditious legal pathway to justice in the case of their employers’ wrongdoing. DV survivors should be entitled to the opportunity to choose when and how their complaint of employer misconduct is heard, the ability to garner damages for the harm the have been caused and the right to representation by an attorney who is particularly equipped to defend the survivor’s best interests. By establishing an express PRA and authorizing payment of attorney’s fees for the DV survivor seeking justice, AB 1478 recognizes and addresses the uniquely delicate circumstances of DV survivors and provides a legal pathway that is clear, direct and uniquely tailored to the harm they have suffered.”
3. Opponent Arguments:
The San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership writes in opposition:
“AB 1478 exposes employers of any size to costly litigation for an alleged violation, including an employee only (i.e. one-sided) right to attorney’s fees. Currently, employees may resolve any Labor Code Section 230 violation with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) through an administrative hearing. Creating a private right of action with employee only attorney’s fees will incentivize potentially frivolous litigation. Moreover, there is no evidence that such complaints cannot be efficiently handled through DLSE.”
4. Double Referral:
This bill is double referred and, if passed out of this committee, will be heard in the Senate Judiciary Committee.
5. Prior Legislation:
SB 1300 (Jackson) of 2018, Chapter 955: requires that all employees receive sexual harassment training and education, include bystander intervention training as a part of the training, and prohibits a release of claims or nondisparagement agreements between employers and employees under specified circumstances. Provides that plaintiffs do not need to prove that they endured sexual harassment or discrimination when alleging that an employer failed to take all necessary steps to prevent sexual harassment or discrimination.
SUPPORT
California Public Defenders Association
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Pipe Trades Council
Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation
Legal Aid at Work
OPPOSITION
Brea Chamber of Commerce
California Ambulance Association
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Chamber of Commerce
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California League of Food Producers
California Special Districts Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
Civil Justice Association of California
El Centro Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Job Creators for Workplace Fairness
Long Beach Area Chamber of Commerce
Murrieta Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
National Federation of Independent Business
North Orange County Chamber of Commerce
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1478
Author:(Carrillo)
As Amended Ver:March 27, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Provides a private right of action for an employee who is discharged or discriminated or retaliated against by their employer due to, among other reasons, their status of being a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, and stalking, and entitles a prevailing plaintiff to reasonable attorney's fees and other relief the court deems proper.
Major Provisions
- Provides a private right of action in court for an employee who is discriminated or retaliated against, or discharged by their employer due to the following reasons:
- Taking time off of work to serve as required by law on a jury so long as the employee gives reasonable notice to the employer prior to taking time off.
- Taking time off to appear in court to comply with a subpoena or other court order as a witness in any judicial proceeding.
- The employee's status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, if the employer has notice or knowledge of that status.
- Taking time off from work to obtain, or attempt to obtain, any relief to help ensure the health, safety, or welfare of the victim, or their child, according to specified notice requirements.
- Requesting a reasonable accommodation to ensure the victim's safety at work.
- Taking time off to obtain specified services or counseling due to an employee's status as a victim, subject to specified notice requirements, and provided the employee works for an employer with 25 or more employees.
- Provides that in a private right of action, as described above, the court may award reasonable attorney's fees to a prevailing employee and any other relief the court believes effectuates the purpose of the law, including reinstatement, back pay, front pay, and damages for emotional distress.
- Specifies that an aggrieved employee bringing a civil action under these provisions shall not be required to pursue any other remedy before bringing that action.
COMMENTS:
This bill seeks to prevent and address employment-based discrimination of victims of particularly abusive behaviors. The author points out that survivors of domestic violence (DV) are especially in need of additional recourse if adverse action is taken against them.
According to the Author:
"AB 1478 will ensure domestic violence survivors have the deserved option of a straightforward and expeditious legal pathway to justice in the case of their employers' wrongdoing. DV survivors should be entitled the opportunity to choose when and how their complaint of employer misconduct is heard, the ability to garner damages for the harm they have been caused and the right to representation by an attorney who is particularly equipped to defend the survivor's best interests."
Arguments in Support:
The California Employment Lawyer's Association (CELA) supports this bill "because DV survivors deserve to have a straightforward and expeditious legal pathway for redressing discrimination or retaliation based on their status as a DV survivor."
In addition, CELA points out that while an employee could bring a private action under the Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA), PAGA actions "are often ineffective remedies because pursuing a claim with the Labor Commissioner (LC) could take months or years to process and PAGA claims are designed to recover civil penalties for Labor Code violations, not to redress discrimination or retaliation." As such, CELA claims, "even if a worker were to pursue a claim under PAGA for a violation of Section 230 or 230.1, the recovery would likely be a trivial $100 penalty, only $25 of which would be payable to the worker. . . By establishing an express private right of action for the DV survivor seeking justice, AB 1478 recognizes and addresses the uniquely delicate circumstances of DV survivors and provides a legal pathway that is clear, direct and uniquely tailored to the harm they have suffered."
Arguments in Opposition:
The California Chamber of Commerce, other organizations, opposes the measure, "Unfairly exposes an employer to being penalized twice for the same violation by allowing an employee to file a claim with the LC and pursue a claim in civil court." That is, the Chamber believes that by stating that an employee may "also" pursue a civil action, the bill suggests that the employee could file an action in addition, rather than as an alternative to, filing a claim with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement.
The Chamber coalition also argues that this bill is "unnecessary and duplicative" because employees who chose not to file a claim with LC may already "file an alleged violation of Labor Code Section 230 in civil court pursuant to PAGA." The Chamber notes that because Labor Code Section 230 falls within a category of "serious" violations, the employee may bring the action directly without giving an employer the opportunity to cure the violation. "However," the Chamber claims, "AB 1478 intends to create a new avenue for litigation whereby the employee does not need to file a cause of action under PAGA."
Finally, the Chamber points to the legislative history of SB 400 (Jackson), Chapter 759, Statutes of 2013, which added existing protections for victims of domestic violence, sexual assault and stalking to Labor Code Section 230. According to the Chamber, "the private right of action was removed from that bill in the Assembly before it made it to the Governor and we see no need for it to be added now in this bill." Since an employee "can currently file a claim with the LC or alternatively file a civil action pursuant to PAGA," the Chamber does "not understand the need for the additional private right of action that will potentially allow an employee to penalize an employer twice for the same violation."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None
VOTES:
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 5-2-0
YES: Kalra, Carrillo, Gonzalez, Jones-Sawyer, Luz Rivas
NO: Flora, Diep
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-3-0
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Gallagher, Kiley, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: March 27, 2019
CONSULTANT: Megan Lane / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0000306
Date of Hearing: April 30, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1478
Author:(Carrillo) – As Amended Ver:March 27, 2019
SUBJECT: Employment discrimination
KEY ISSUE: should employees who suffer retaliation for exercising certain statutory rights HAVE the right to bring a civil action against an employer who COMMITTED the retaliation, without having to exhaust administrative remedies first?
SYNOPSIS
This bill would allow employees who suffer retaliation for exercising rights set forth in Labor Code Sections 230 and 230.1 to bring a private right of action against the employer without first having to file a claim with the Labor Commissioner’s Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE). Labor Code Section 230 allows employees to take time off from work to serve on a jury or to appear in court as a witness, and allows employees who are victims of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking to take time off as necessary to obtain injunctive relief for self-protection or protection of a child. Section 230 also requires the employer to make reasonable accommodations, as defined, to an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking. Finally, Section 230 prohibits an employer from discharging or otherwise retaliating against an employee who takes any action in furtherance of rights granted under the section. Section 230.1, which applies to employers with 25 or more employees, imposes all of the requirements contained in Section 230 but grants additional rights to employees who are victims of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking.
Most relevant to AB 1478 are the provisions of Sections 230 and 230.1 that permit any employee discharged, or in any manner discriminated or retaliated against, because the employee exercised any rights set forth in those sections to file a complaint for retaliation with DLSE. Although the statutes are somewhat ambiguous on this point, both courts and practicing attorneys have assumed that an employee must exhaust this administrative remedy before bringing a civil action in court for the same offense. AB 1478, however, will permit an aggrieved employee to bring a civil action against the offending employer in any court, and the bill expressly states that the employee is not required to pursue any administrative remedy before bringing that action. In addition, the bill allows the court to award reasonable attorney’s fees to a prevailing plaintiff in addition to any other relief that the court deems appropriate, including reinstatement, damages for back pay, front pay, and emotional distress. Although the supporters of this bill focus primarily on the protection the bill affords to victims of domestic violence, sexual assault, and stalking, the California Public Defenders Association supports this bill because it will also protect employees who face retaliation for taking time off to perform jury duty. The California Chamber of Commerce and business and employer groups oppose this bill because aggrieved employees may obtain relief by filing a claim with DLSE or, if they choose, bring a civil action under the Labor Code’s Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA).
SUMMARY: Permits an employee who suffers retaliation, as specified, to bring a private right of action, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Permits an employee who suffers discharge, or is threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any other manner retaliated against for exercising rights under certain provisions of the Labor Code to bring a private civil action against an employer in a court of competent jurisdiction. Specifies that an aggrieved employee who brings the civil action need not pursue any other remedy before bringing that action.
- Permits a court, in an action described in 1), above, to award reasonable attorney’s fees to a prevailing employee in addition to any other relief that, in the judgment of the court, would effectuate the purpose of this bill, including, but not limited to, reinstatement, damages for back pay, front pay, and emotional distress.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits an employer from discharging, or in any manner discriminating or retaliating against, an employee for taking time off to do any of the following:
- To serve as required by law on an inquest jury or trial jury, if the employee, prior to taking time off, gives reasonable notice to the employer.
- To appear in court to comply with a subpoena or other court order as a witness in any judicial hearing. (Labor Code Section 230 (a)-(b); subsequent references are to the Labor Code.)
- Prohibits an employer from discharging, or in any manner discriminating or retaliating against, an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, for taking time off to obtain relief, including, but not limited to, a restraining order or injunctive relief. Requires an employer with twenty-five or more employees to allow a victim to take time off for additional reasons, including seeking medical treatment, psychological counseling, safety planning, or related services. (Sections 230 (c), 230.1.)
- Prohibits an employer from discharging, or in any manner discriminating or retaliating against, an employee because of the employee's status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, as defined, if the victim provides notice to the employer of the status or the employer has actual knowledge of the status. (Sections 230 (e), 230.1.)
- Requires an employer to provide reasonable accommodations for a victim upon request, unless the accommodation would cause an undue hardship. (Sections 230 (f), 230.1.)
- Provides that an employee who suffers discharge or is in any manner discriminated or retaliated against in violation of any of the above shall be entitled to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer, as well as appropriate equitable relief. Specifies that an employer who willfully refuses to reinstate or reimburse an eligible employee as required is guilty of a misdemeanor. (Sections 230 (g) (1)-(3), 230.1.)
- Permits employees who suffer discharge, or are in any manner discriminated or retaliated against by their employer because they have exercised any rights set forth in any of the provisions above to file a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE) in the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), as provided. Specifies that notwithstanding any time limitation specified in Labor Section 98.7, an employee may file a complaint with DLSE for a violation of 2), 3), or 4) above within one year of the date of the occurrence of the violation. (Sections 230 (h), 230.1 (d).)
- Permits employees who believe they have suffered discharge or discrimination in violation of any provision of the Labor Code to file a complaint with DLSE within six months after the occurrence of the violation, and establishes procedures by which the Labor Commission shall investigate and, if appropriate, remedy the violation. Specifies, however, that this provision does not preclude an employee from pursuing any other rights and remedies under law, and further specifies that there is no requirement that an individual exhaust administrative remedies or procedures. (Sections 98.7.)
- Authorizes, under the Labor Code Private Attorneys General Act (PAGA), aggrieved employees to file lawsuits to recover civil penalties on behalf of themselves, other employees, and the State of California for Labor Code violations. Provides that for any civil penalties recovered, the Labor and Workforce Development Agency (LWDA) shall receive 75% of the amount and the employee bringing the action shall receive the other 25%. Provides that any employee who prevails in a PAGA action shall be entitled to an award of reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, including any filing fee. (Sections 2698-2699.5.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: According to the author, “AB 1478 will specify that an employee who is retaliated against for taking time off for [reasons authorized by statute] has an express right to initiate a private action against the employer.” The author notes that while existing law prohibits an employer from retaliating against an employee for taking time off for the reasons authorized under of Labor Code Sections 230 and 230.1, “there is no specific authority as to whether the statute creates a private right of action.” AB 1478 will provide that specific authority and, additionally, permit the court to award attorney’s fees to a prevailing employee.
Creating a Private Right of Action under Labor Code Sections 230 and 230.1: Labor Code Section 230 originally only allowed employees to take time off from work to serve on a jury or to appear in court as a witness, without fear of losing their job or suffering any other kind of retaliation. In addition, Section 230 prohibits an employer from discharging or otherwise retaliating against employees who exercise their rights to request or take time off under this section. SB 400 (Jackson, Chap. 759, Stats. 2013) expanded the law considerably to allow employees who are victims of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking to take time off to obtain injunctive relief for self-protection or for protection of a child. As amended by SB 400, Section 230 also requires the employer to make reasonable accommodations, as defined, to an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking. SB 400 also amended Section 230.1, which applies to employers with 25 or more employees. This section imposes all of the requirements contained in Section 230 but also grants additional rights to employees who are victims of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking. Most relevant to AB 1478, however, are the provisions of Sections 230 and 230.1 that permit any employee discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or in any manner discriminated or retaliated against for exercising any rights set forth in Section 230 or 230.1 to file a complaint for retaliation with DLSE. Sections 230 and 230.1 both require the employee to file the complaint “pursuant to Section 98.7,” which is the Labor Code’s general retaliation statute.
Although the statutes are somewhat ambiguous on this point, courts and attorneys have generally assumed that an employee who alleges retaliation under Sections 230 or 230.1 must file the complaint with DLSE and exhaust all administrative remedies set forth in Section 98.7 before bringing a civil action in court for the same offense. AB 1478 will expressly permit an employee aggrieved by a violation of Sections 230 and 230.1 to bring a civil action against the offending employer, and it expressly states that the employee is not required to pursue any other remedy before bringing that action. The bill allows the court to award reasonable attorney’s fees to a prevailing plaintiff in the civil action, in addition to awarding any other relief that the court deems appropriate, including reinstatement, damages for back pay, front pay, and emotional distress. Although the supporters of this bill focus primarily on the protection the bill affords to victims of domestic violence, sexual assault, and stalking, the bill in print would also protect employees who face retaliation for taking time off to perform jury duty or appear in court as a witness.
Existing Remedies and Ambiguities of Labor Code Section 98.7: While the right to take time off – and the prohibition against retaliating against an employee who does so – is rooted in Labor Code Sections 230 and 230.1, both of these statutes, in turn, direct an employee alleging retaliation to file a claim with DLSE “pursuant to Section 98.7.” Labor Code Section 98.7 does not create any substantive rights per se; rather it sets forth a procedure by which an employee can seek redress for retaliation “in violation of any law under the jurisdiction of the Labor Commissioner.” (Gutierrez v. RWD Technologies (2003) 279 F. Supp. 2d 1223.)
Under Section 98.7, an employee alleging retaliation under another provision of the Labor Code must file a complaint with the DLSE within six months after the occurrence of the violation. Upon the filing of any complaint by an employee, the Labor Commissioner must investigate the matter and, if necessary, hold hearings. If the Commissioner determines a violation has occurred, it may order the employer to cease the unlawful practice and provide appropriate remedies to the employee, including ordering reinstatement, reimbursement of lost wages, and payment of any reasonable attorney’s fees incurred in the investigative hearing. If the employer does not comply with the order, the Commissioner may bring an action in court for injunctive relief and damages. If the Commissioner determines that a violation did not occur and dismisses the complaint, then the employee may bring a civil action in court.
While Section 98.7 appears to require exhaustion of all administrative remedies before an employee can bring a civil action in court – apparently only allowing an employee to bring a civil action if the Commissioner determines that no violation occurred and dismisses the complaint – a relatively recent amendment to Section 98.7 creates some ambiguity on this point. Specifically, subdivision (g) of Section 98.7 states: “In the enforcement of this section, there is no requirement that an individual exhaust administrative remedies or procedures.” AB 263 (Hernandez, Chap. 732, Stats. 2013), a bill dealing with unfair immigration-related practices on the part of employers, added subdivision (g) to Section 98.7. Commenting on this provision, an analysis prepared by the Senate Judiciary Committee stated that this bill “would also clarify that an employee or job applicant is not required to exhaust administrative remedies or procedures before bringing a civil action to enforce the prohibition against discriminating, retaliating, or taking adverse action against an employee making a claim under the Labor Code.” While the subject matter of AB 263 dealt with unfair immigration-related practices, it added subdivision (g) to Section 98.7, the general labor retaliation statute, thereby giving it a much broader application.
Notwithstanding subdivision (g), both the opponents and proponents of the bill under consideration seem to agree on one thing: under existing law, an employee filing a retaliation claim under Section 230 and 230.1 (pursuant to Section 98.7) must exhaust administrative remedies before bringing a civil action against an employer in court. Both opponents and proponents – in letters of support or in communications with Committee staff – point to Gutierrez v. RWD Technologies, supra, in support of the contention that employees are required to exhaust administrative remedies. However, Gutierrez made this holding in 2003, ten years before AB 263 added subdivision (g). At any rate, however one chooses to read subdivision (g) and its legislative history, AB 1478 will make it clear that an employee alleging retaliation in violation of Labor Code Sections 230 or 230.1 will have the option of either filing a complaint with DLSE or bringing a civil action in court.
The Inadequacy of PAGA Suits as a Remedy: Opponents contend that this bill is unnecessary because, in addition to filing a claim with DLSE, an employee also has the ability to bring a civil action to enforce any provision of the Labor Code through the Private Attorneys General Act. However, PAGA does not seek to compensate employees for any damages incurred because of a Labor Code violation, and in the case of retaliatory discharge, it has no provisions for reinstating an employee or awarding damages. Rather, PAGA seeks to supplement the limited enforcement resources of the Labor Commissioner by essentially enlisting employees to bring private causes of action. Under PAGA, the employee does not seek damages for injuries that the employee may have incurred because of a labor law violation. Instead, the employee is merely seeking to enforce the law. This is abundantly apparent when one considers that the remedy in PAGA action is limited to a collection of the fine or civil penalty imposed on the employer. Under PAGA, 75% of the fine or civil penalty goes to the Labor and Workforce Development Agency (LWDA) and 25% going to the employee that brought the action. While an employee is entitled to recover attorney’s fees and any filing fee, the purpose of the PAGA suit is to enforce the law for the benefit of the employee suing and for all other employees who benefit from enforcement of the law. (See generally Labor Code Sections 2698-2699.5.) Therefore, PAGA does not provide an appropriate remedy for employees who seek compensation for having suffered retaliation for exercising rights afforded to them under law.
The Meaning of “Also:” Finally, opponents contend that AB 1478 could cause an employer to be punished twice – once as a result of an administrative action and the second time as a result of a civil action – for the same offense. Opponents base this contention on the language in the bill stating than an aggrieved employee “may also bring a private civil action against the employer.” (Emphasis added.) Opponents contend that this would allow an employee to file a claim with DLSE and then, after prevailing in the administrative action, to “also” bring a civil action seeking damages for the same violation. However, it seems doubtful that a court would construe the language in this way. For example, when an employee prevails in an administrative action, the Labor Commissioner orders the employer to cease the violation and awards appropriate relief to the employee, including reinstatement and damages for lost wages. However, if the violation has ceased and the employee is made whole by reinstatement and reimbursement of lost wages because of prevailing in the administrative action, it is difficult to see how the employee could still establish damages sufficient to support a cause of action. The Commissioner’s order to cease the violation would render moot any action for injunctive relief. Therefore, it seems unlikely that any court will construe this bill to impose double penalties on the employer by allowing an employee who receives compensation in an administrative action to turn around and seek the same remedies and compensation in a civil action.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The California Employment Lawyer’s Association (CELA) supports AB 1478 “because DV survivors deserve to have a straightforward and expeditious legal pathway for redressing discrimination or retaliation based on their status as a DV survivor.” CELA notes that existing laws “prohibit employers from taking adverse employment actions against a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, and it must allow an employee to take time off from work to attend to issues arising as a result of the domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, as long as the employee complies with certain conditions.” However, CELA claims, existing law “does not make clear that DV survivors would be able to legally enforce their rights by bringing their case to court.” In support of this claim, CELA cites Rosales v. Moneytree, 2015 Cal App. Unpub. LEXIS 8694, fn. 1, in which a court questioned whether Labor Code Sections 230 and 230.1 create a private right of action. The court noted, “Although the statutes state an employee is entitled to reinstatement, reimbursement, and appropriate equitable relief, they do not expressly authorize a civil action to obtain those remedies.” Although the court made this statement in dicta in a footnote, CELA believes that this bill is necessary to clarify that employees have a right of private action under Section 230 and 230.1.
In addition, CELA points out that while an employee could bring a private action under PAGA, PAGA actions “are often ineffective remedies because pursuing a claim with the Labor Commissioner could take months or years to process and PAGA claims are designed to recover civil penalties for Labor Code violations, not to redress discrimination or retaliation.” As such, CELA claims, “even if a worker were to pursue a claim under PAGA for a violation of Section 230 or 230.1, the recovery would likely be a trivial $100 penalty, only $25 of which would be payable to the worker. . . By establishing an express PRA for the DV survivor seeking justice, AB 1478 recognizes and addresses the uniquely delicate circumstances of DV survivors and provides a legal pathway that is clear, direct and uniquely tailored to the harm they have suffered.”
The California Partnership to End Domestic Violence (CPEDV) supports this bill for many of the same reasons articulated by CELA. In support of AB 1478, CPEDV cites a 2010 study which found that “38% of [domestic violence, sexual assault, and stalking] survivors report either having been fired for fearing termination because of their domestic violence situation, and 34% report having to quit a job because of domestic violence.” Making matters worse, CPEDV observes, “it is very confusing and difficult for survivors to navigate enforcing their rights, and as a result, when a survivor faces illegal discrimination, they frequently feel that they have nowhere to turn and there’s nothing they can do. AB 1478 creates the opportunity for survivors to bring a civil action directly against their employer and receive the equitable relief they deserve.”
Finally, while the author and supporters primarily focus on how AB 1478 will clarify that a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, and stalking may bring a civil action, the California Public Defenders Association supports this bill because it will incidentally allow employees who suffer retaliation for taking time off for jury service to bring a civil action.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Chamber of Commerce, writing on behalf of itself and several other organizations, opposes AB 1478 because it believes the measure “unfairly exposes an employer to being penalized twice for the same violation by allowing an employee to file a claim with the Labor Commissioner and pursue a claim in civil court.” That is, the Chamber believes that by stating that an employee may “also” pursue a civil action, the bill suggests that the employee could file an action in addition, rather than as an alternative to, filing a claim with DLSE.
The Chamber coalition also argues that AB 1478 is “unnecessary and duplicative” because employees who chose not to file a claim with DLSE may already “file an alleged violation of Labor Code Section 230 in civil court pursuant to PAGA.” The Chamber notes that because Labor Code Section 230 falls within a category of “serious” violations, the employee may bring the action directly without giving an employer the opportunity to cure the violation. “However,” the Chamber claims, “AB 1478 intends to create a new avenue for litigation whereby the employee does not need to file a cause of action under PAGA.”
Finally, the Chamber points to the legislative history of SB 400 (Jackson, Chap. 759, Stats. 2013), which added existing protections for victims of domestic violence, sexual assault and stalking to Labor Code Section 230. According to the Chamber, “the private right of action was removed from that bill in the Assembly before it made it to the Governor and we see no need for it to be added now in this bill.” Since an employee “can currently file a claim with the DLSE or alternatively file a civil action pursuant to PAGA,” the Chamber does “not understand the need for the additional private right of action that will potentially allow an employee to penalize an employer twice for the same violation.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Partnership to End Domestic Violence
California Public Defenders Association
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Pipe Trades Council
Western States Council of Sheet Metal Workers
Oppose
Brea Chamber of Commerce
California Ambulance Association
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Chamber of Commerce
California Construction & Industrial Materials Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California League of Food Producers
California Special Districts Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
Civil Justice Association of California
El Centro Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Job Creators for Workplace Fairness
Murrieta Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
National Federation of Independent Business
North Orange County Chamber of Commerce
Official Police Garage Association of Los Angeles
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Wine Institute
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: April 3, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1478 (
Author:Carrillo) – As Amended Ver:March 27, 2019
SUBJECT: Employment discrimination
SUMMARY: Provides a private right of action for an employee who is discharged or discriminated or retaliated against by their employer due to, among other reasons, their status of being a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, and stalking, and entitles a prevailing plaintiff to reasonable attorney’s fees and other relief the court deems proper. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides a private right of action in court for an employee who is discriminated or retaliated against, or discharged by their employer due to the following reasons:
- Taking time off of work to serve as required by law on a jury so long as the employee gives reasonable notice to the employer prior to taking time off.
- Taking time off to appear in court to comply with a subpoena or other court order as a witness in any judicial proceeding.
- The employee’s status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, if the employer has notice or knowledge of that status.
- Taking time off from work to obtain, or attempt to obtain, any relief to help ensure the health, safety, or welfare of the victim, or their child, according to specified notice requirements.
- Requesting a reasonable accommodation to ensure the victim’s safety at work.
- Taking time off to obtain specified services or counseling due to an employee’s status as a victim, subject to specified notice requirements, and provided the employee works for an employer with 25 or more employees.
- Provides that in a private right of action, as described above, the court may award reasonable attorney’s fees to a prevailing employee and any other relief the court believes effectuates the purpose of the law, including reinstatement, back pay, front pay, and damages for emotional distress.
- Specifies that an aggrieved employee bringing a civil action under these provisions shall not be required to pursue any other remedy before bringing that action.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits an employer from discriminating against or discharging an employee for taking time off of work to serve as required by law on a jury so long as the employee gives reasonable notice to the employer prior to taking time off.
- Prohibits an employer from discharging, discriminating or retaliating against an employee, including, but not limited to, an employee who is a victim of crime, for taking time off to appear in court to comply with a subpoena or other court order as a witness in any judicial proceeding.
- Prohibits an employer from discharging, discriminating or retaliating against an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking because of the employee’s status as a victim, if the employer has notice or knowledge of that status.
- Prohibits an employer from discharging, discriminating or retaliating against, an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking and who takes time off from work to obtain, or attempt to obtain, any relief to help ensure the health, safety, or welfare of the victim or his or her child, subject to the following requirements:
- The employee shall provide reasonable advance notice of the intention to take time off.
- If advanced notice is not feasible, the employee shall provide a certification to the employer to explain the absence, including but not limited to, a police report, a protective court order, or documentation from a medical professional or specified mental health counselor.
- Requires an employer to provide reasonable accommodations for a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking who requests an accommodation to ensure their safety at work.
- Prohibits an employer with 25 or more employees from discharging, discriminating or retaliating against an employee who is a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking for taking time off to obtain specified services or counseling, subject to the following requirements:
- The employee shall provide reasonable advance notice of the intention to take time off.
- If advanced notice is not feasible, the employee shall provide a certification to the employer to explain the absence, including but not limited to, a police report, a protective court order, or documentation from a medical professional or specified mental health counselor.
- Provides that an employee who is discharged, threatened with discharge, demoted, suspended, or discriminated or retaliated against in the terms and conditions of employment by their employer due to their status of being a victim, as specified above, or due to their request for time off or a reasonable accommodation related to this status, shall be entitled to reinstatement and reimbursement for lost wages and work benefits caused by the acts of the employer, as well as appropriate equitable relief.
- Authorizes an aggrieved employee to file a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement of the Department of Industrial Relations within one year from the date of the violation and authorizes the Labor Commissioner (LC), upon a finding of employer retaliation, to award appropriate remedies and recover attorney’s fees.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: Note: This bill is double-referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee upon passage out of this Committee.
This bill seeks to prevent and address employment-based discrimination of victims of particularly abusive behaviors. The author points out that survivors of domestic violence (DV) are especially in need of additional recourse if adverse action is taken against them. The author states, “AB 1478 will ensure DV survivors have the deserved option of a straightforward and expeditious legal pathway to justice in the case of their employers’ wrongdoing. DV survivors should be entitled the opportunity to choose when and how their complaint of employer misconduct is heard, the ability to garner damages for the harm they have been caused and the right to representation by an attorney who is particularly equipped to defend the survivor’s best interests.”
Related and Prior Legislation
SB 400 (Jackson) Chapter 759, Statutes of 2013, prohibits an employer from discharging or in any manner discriminating or retaliating against an employee because of the employee’s known status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking, and requires the employer to provide reasonable accommodations for such a victim. As introduced, the bill created a private right of action for an aggrieved employee to seek enforcement of the victim status protection and reasonable accommodation provisions. The private right of action provision was amended out of the bill in the Assembly.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Public Defenders Association
Oppose
Brea Chamber Of Commerce
California Ambulance Association
California Association Of Joint Powers Authorities
California Chamber Of Commerce
California Construction And Industrial Materials Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California League Of Food Producers
California Special Districts Association
Camarillo Chamber Of Commerce
El Centro Chamber Of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber Of Commerce
Job Creators For Workplace Fairness
National Federation Of Independent Business
North Orange County Chamber Of Commerce
Official Police Garage Association Of Los Angeles
Oxnard Chamber Of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber Of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Torrance Area Chamber Of Commerce
Analysis Prepared by: Megan Lane / L. & E. /
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):