AB 1519: Healing arts.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-13
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 13, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 865, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 13, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 26, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Sep 12, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on B. & P. pursuant to Assembly Rule 77.2. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 6, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (August 30). |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 8, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 0.) (July 8). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 2, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on B., P. & E.D. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Com. on B., P. & E.D. |
| May 24, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 23, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 18. Noes 0.) (May 16). |
| May 1, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 19. Noes 0.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 14, 2019 | Referred to Com. on B. & P. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Read first time. |
| Feb 23, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 25. |
| Feb 22, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 13, 2019 | AB 1519 Low Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 13, 2019 | With recommendation: That Senate amendments be concurred in. | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Passed |
|
| Sep 11, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1519 Low By Glazer | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 12, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 8, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Business, Professions and Economic Development |
Passed |
|
| May 23, 2019 | AB 1519 B. & P. Assembly Third Reading By LOW | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Business and Professions |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA2 Bill Id:AB 1519
Author:(Low)
As Amended Ver:September 6, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Extends the sunset date for the Dental Board of California (DBC) until January 1, 2024 and makes additional technical changes, statutory improvements, and policy reforms in response to issues raised during the DBC's sunset review process.
The Senate Amendments:
- Merge the DBC's two special funds;
- Eliminate the suspended Registered Dental Assistant practical exam;
- Require the DBC to report on the status of portfolio examinations;
- Transition approval for foreign dental schools from the DBC to a national accreditor;
- Clarify the application of professional responsibility laws to all dentists regardless of practice setting and state that it is unprofessional conduct for a dentist to engage in the initial diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or initial use of orthodontic appliances without performing an examination, including the review of the patient's most recent diagnostic digital or conventional radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging suitable for orthodontia.
- Require dentists on probation to make disclosures to patients prior to treatment.
COMMENTS:
Sunset review is a legislative oversight process conducted by the Assembly and Senate Committees on Business and Professions. Nearly every regulatory board under the Department of Consumer Affairs is statutorily subject to repeal on a certain date through a "sunset provision"; this date must be extended through a sunset bill. AB 1519 is the sunset bill for the DBC, which is subject to repeal on January 1, 2020 unless the bill is enacted.
As part of the review process, the DBC submitted a comprehensive report to the Legislature, then the B&P Committees authored a background paper on the board and a series of current issues. This background paper has been available to the public online since February 2019. Every substantive provision in this bill was discussed in that background paper. Additionally, the board appeared before the committees in a public hearing back in March 2019, where several of the issues were discussed. The issues contained in the sunset background paper were as follows:
ISSUE #1: Merger of Special Funds. Should the State Dentistry Fund and the State Dental Assisting Fund be merged to simplify and streamline accounting and budgeting processes for the DBC?
ISSUE #2: Dental Hygiene Board. What is the current state of the DBC's relationship with the Dental Hygiene Board of California, which also regulates licensees involved in the dental profession?
ISSUE #3: Board Attorney. Does the DBC have sufficient legal counsel?
ISSUE #4: NC Dental. Are there any outstanding concerns that the Supreme Court's decision in North Carolina State Board of Dental Examiners v. FTC could have implications for the DBC?
ISSUE #5: RDA Practical Examination. Should the practical examination requirement for registered dental assistants be permanently eliminated?
ISSUE #6: Portfolio Examinations. Is the DBC's portfolio examination process adequately providing pathways to licensure for dental students as an effective alternative to conventional examinations?
ISSUE #7: Foreign Dental Schools. Should the current process by which the DBC approves foreign dental schools continue?
ISSUE #8: Consumer Products. Does the DBC have sufficient oversight over consumer products advertising self-applied corrective treatments for structural or aesthetic oral health conditions?
ISSUE #9: Enforcement Targets. Does available data relating to enforcement timelines suggest any inefficiencies in discipline cases brought by the DBC in collaboration with the Attorney General?
ISSUE #10: Opioid Crisis. What role do dentists play in the ongoing epidemic of opioid abuse and addiction, and how can the DBC support efforts to curb overprescribing within the dental profession?
ISSUE #11: Probation Disclosure. Should dental professionals placed on probation by the DBC be required to disclose their probation status to patients in a manner similar to other healing arts licensees?
ISSUE #12: Dynamex. Does the new test for determining employment status, as prescribed in the court decision Dynamex Operations West Inc. v. Superior Court, have any potential implications for licensees working in the dental profession as independent contractors?
ISSUE #13: Pediatric Anesthesia. Does the DBC anticipate a smooth implementation of Senate Bill 501 (Glazer), a recently enacted measure regarding pediatric dental anesthesia?
ISSUE #14: Technical Cleanup. Is there a need for technical cleanup?
ISSUE #15: Continued Regulation. Should the licensing of dental professionals be continued and be regulated by the Dental Board of California?
According to the Author:
"AB 1519 is the sunset bill for the Dental Board of California, authored by the Assembly Committee on Business and Professions. Passage of this bill is necessary to extend the operation of the Dental Board, which is currently scheduled for repeal at the end of this year. This bill also makes various adjustments to the Dental Practice Act in response to issues raised during the sunset review process. Every provision in this bill is specifically related to an issue discussed in the B&P committees' joint sunset background paper, which was published last February and discussed at a public hearing in March."
Arguments in Support:
Dr. Paul Glassman, Professor Emeritus at the University of the Pacific Arthur A. Dugoni School of Dentistry, writes in support of the bill. Dr. Glassman is "a dentist who has been developing teledentistry systems and is a strong supporter of improving access to dental care through using teledentistry." Dr. Glassman argues that "this bill establishes fundamental consumer protections for patients receiving care through teledentistry. With emerging business models offering various health services partially or completely online, it is imperative that healthcare continues to meet the professional standard of care."
Arguments in Opposition:
Several companies offering teledentistry products in California, including Byte, oppose the bill's language requiring dentists to review a radiograph prior to prescribing orthodontics. These companies argue that "our organizations comprise of some of the largest teledentistry aligner companies operating in the United States, all of which have a large presence and employees in California. Our organizations believe in the importance of thoughtful regulation and are dedicated to responsibly expanding access to care for thousands of consumers in California. Recent advances in technology have opened a door to safe, high quality orthodontic treatments for people who were historically priced out of the market. Unfortunately, the language recently added to AB 1519 could undermine important progress made in the last few years."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Committee on Appropriations, the Budget Act of 2019 includes $17.7 million (State Dentistry Fund) and 77 positions for the Dental Board of California.
VOTES:
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 19-0-1
YES: Low, Brough, Bloom, Chen, Cunningham, Dahle, Eggman, Fong, Gipson, Gloria, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Obernolte, Quirk-Silva, Ting
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chiu
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0-2
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cooley, Eduardo Garcia
SENATE FLOOR: 37-0-3
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wiener
ABS, ABST OR NV: Durazo, Wieckowski, Wilk
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 18-0-1
YES: Low, Arambula, Bloom, Chen, Chiu, Cunningham, Eggman, Fong, Gipson, Gloria, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Obernolte, Ting
ABS, ABST OR NV: Brough
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 6, 2019
CONSULTANT: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301 FN: 0002468
Date of Hearing: September 13, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Evan Low, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1519
Author:(Low) – As Amended Ver:September 6, 2019
NOTE: This bill has been re-referred to the Committee pursuant to Rule 77.2.
SUBJECT: Healing arts: Dental Board of California.
SUMMARY: Extends the sunset date for the Dental Board of California (DBC) until January 1, 2024 and makes additional technical changes, statutory improvements, and policy reforms in response to issues raised during the DBC’s sunset review process.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes the DBC under the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to regulate the practice of dentistry. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 1600 et seq.)
- Subjects the DBC and its Executive Officer to repeal on January 1, 2020, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2020, deletes or extends that date. (BPC § 1601.1)
- Establishes the State Dentistry Fund and the State Dental Assistant Fund within the State Treasury’s Professions and Vocations Fund. (BPC § 205)
- Authorizes applicants to the DBC to apply for licensure through a portfolio examination. (BPC § 1632)
- Requires the DBC to review and approve applications from foreign dental school seeking approval to offer degrees equivalent to schools within the United States. (BPC § 1636.4)
- Enumerates numerous acts and omissions that constitute unprofessional conduct by a person licensed by the DBC. (BPC § 1680)
- Requires applicants for licensure as a registered dental assistant to pass a practical examination, which is currently suspended until January 1, 2020. (BPC § 1752.3)
THIS BILL:
- Extends operation of the DBC until January 1, 2024.
- Merges the DBC’s two special funds into a single fund.
- Eliminates the suspended Registered Dental Assistant practical exam.
- Requires the DBC to report on the status of portfolio examinations.
- Transitions approval for foreign dental schools from the DBC to a national accreditor known as the Commission on Dental Accreditation (CODA).
- Clarifies the application of professional responsibility laws to all dentists regardless of practice setting and states that it is unprofessional conduct for a dentist to engage in the initial diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or initial use of orthodontic appliances without performing an examination, including the review of the patient’s most recent diagnostic digital or conventional radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging suitable for orthodontia.
- Requires dentists on probation to make disclosures to patients prior to treatment.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Committee on Appropriations, the Budget Act of 2019 includes $17.7 million (State Dentistry Fund) and 77 positions for the Dental Board of California.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is authored by the Assembly Business and Professions Committee. This bill is one of five “sunset review bills” authored by the Assembly Business and Professions Committee. There are also five sunset review bills authored by the Chair of the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee. This bill extends the sunset date for the Commission, as recommended during the Joint Sunset Review Hearings held in February and March. The other Assembly sunset bills are: AB 1519 (Committee on Business and Professions), relating to the Dental Board of California, AB 1520 (Committee on Business and Professions), relating to the Court Reporters Board of California, AB 1521 (Committee on Business and Professions), relating to the California Board of Accountancy, and AB 1521 (Committee on Business and Professions), relating to the Board of Professional Engineers, Land Surveyors, and Geologists. The Senate sunset bills review are: SB 606 (Glazer) relating to the Cemetery and Funeral Bureau and the California Board of Barbering and Cosmetology, SB 608 (Glazer) relating to the Board of Architects and Landscape Architects, SB 609 (Glazer) relating to Bureau of Security and Investigative Services, and SB 610 (Glazer) relating to the California Contractors State License Board.
Background.
Overview of the DBC. The (DBC is responsible for licensing and regulating dental professionals in California. The DBC was originally created as the Board of Dental Examiners in 1885 during the twenty-sixth session of the California Legislature. Enacted “to insure the better education of practitioners of dental surgery, and to regulate the practice of dentistry in the State of California,” the original Dental Practice Act required all persons engaged in the practice of dentistry to register with a board of appointed professionals, with a registration fee of one dollar. The Act further allowed for dentists to voluntarily appear before the board of examiners to demonstrate their “knowledge and skill in dental surgery” in exchange for state certification of their qualifications.
Today, the DBC licenses an estimated 89,000 dental professionals, of which approximately 43,500 are fully licensed dentists; 44,500 are registered dental assistants (RDAs); and 1,700 are registered dental assistants in extended functions (RDAEFs). The DBC is also responsible for setting the duties and functions of an estimated 50,000 unlicensed dental assistants. Dental hygienists are licensed and regulated by a separate and distinct regulatory body, the Dental Hygiene Board of California.
Statute defines dentistry as “the diagnosis or treatment, by surgery or other method, of diseases and lesions and the correction of malpositions of the human teeth, alveolar process, gums, jaws, or associated structures; and such diagnosis or treatment may include all necessary related procedures as well as the use of drugs, anesthetic agents, and physical evaluation.” Dentists are health care practitioners authorized to write and issue prescriptions for controlled substances. Oral and maxillofacial surgeons are a surgically trained specialty of dentistry that have completed additional residency requirements.
The Dental Assisting Council within the DBC makes recommendations regarding the DBC’s regulation of dental assistants. Three categories of dental assistants are regulated by the DBC, distinguished by what duties they may perform based on their training. This includes unlicensed dental assistants, authorized to perform “basic supportive dental procedures”; registered dental assistants, authorized to perform more complex duties; and registered dental assistants in extended functions, authorized to perform additional restorative procedures following diagnosis and intervention by a dentist.
The DBC’s regulation of dental professionals includes licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary responsibilities. The DBC reviews and approves applications for initial or renewed licensure, determining whether an applicant has sufficient education and training to possess a license, certification, or permit. The DBC also engages in disciplinary activities through its own enforcement division, investigating potential violations of the Dental Practice Act and taking action against professional misconduct. The DBC additionally monitors licensees who have been placed on probation and manages a diversion program for licensees whose practice may be impaired due to abuse of drugs or alcohol.
Staff. As established in the Dental Practice Act, board staff for the DBC is led by an Executive Officer, who is exempt from civil service and appointed by the board with approval from the Director of Consumer Affairs. Karen Fischer has been Executive Officer for the past six years. Statute also establishes an additional management level staff position, “whose sole responsibilities shall be the management of matters related to dental assisting, including, but not limited to, education, examination, licensure, and enforcement.”
The DBC has a total of 74.3 authorized positions, of which 70.5 are currently filled. The DBC’s organizational chart is divided into divisions on Administration, Licensing & Examination, and Enforcement. Statute states that the DBC “shall have full power to employ all necessary investigators, clerical and other assistants and appoint its own attorney.” The DBC has its own dedicated investigators, led by an Enforcement Chief. However, as of March 5, 2019, no individual has been appointed to the dedicated attorney position expressly authorized for the DBC in statute.
Fiscal and Fund Analysis. Like other regulatory boards and bureaus under the Department of Consumer Affairs, the DBC receives no General Fund support and is operated solely through revenue derived from fees. Currently, fee moneys collected by the DBC are deposited into one of two Special Funds: the Dentistry Fund, which supports operating expenses & equipment (OE&E) and personnel services for the DBC’s regulation of dentists; and the Dental Assisting Fund, which supports OE&E and personnel services for RDAs and RDAEFs. These funds are not comingled and represent a distinguishing bifurcation of the DBC’s licensing and regulation of dentists and dental assistants, respectively.
The DBC has set its own objective of maintaining a three-month reserve in both of its funds. Both funds are currently solvent with a strong level of reserve funding. All loans previously made to the General Fund have been fully repaid with interest. The DBC notes, however, that due to the impending fiscal impact of recently enacted legislation, a structural imbalance is anticipated beginning Fiscal Year 2022-23. The DBC is currently working with the Department of Consumer Affairs Budget Office to develop a plan for addressing this potential shortfall.
The current health of the DBC funds is attributable to the board’s current fee structure. A fee increase for all licenses and permits was achieved in October 2017. For example, license renewal fees increased from $525 to $650; oral and maxillofacial surgery permit fees increased from $365 to $650; and initial application fees for RDA licensure increased from $20 to $120. Prior to that fee increase, the DBC had last adjusted its fee schedule with increases to the DDS renewal fee in 2014 and 2015, and most of the DBC’s fees had not been increased in 15 years. The 2017 fee adjustment followed a fee audit conducted to address potential expenditure increases related to the Consumer Protection Enforcement Initiative and the roll-out of the new BreEZe licensing technology.
Licensing. Statute directs that “protection of the public shall be the highest priority for the Dental Board in exercising its licensing and regulatory functions.” The Dental Practice Act, both directly within statute and through regulations promulgated by the DBC, establishes the requirements for licensure within the dental profession. The DBC’s Licensing Program is responsible for ensuring that licenses and permits are issued only to applicants who meet the minimum requirements and who have not done anything that would warrant denial.
Performance targets for the DBC’s licensure of dentistry are contained in regulations. These regulations set forth a variety of timeline expectations for the DBC to process an application for a license or permit. For example, issuance of a dental license is expected to be completed by the DBC within 90 days of receipt of a completed application; renewal applications are expected to be completed within 30 to 90 days.
Currently, the DBC is meeting these expectations. In 2018, initial application processing for a dental license by each pathway for licensure was completed on average of 27 days. Once an applicant has met all the requirements for a dental license based on the pathway applied for, a separate application for the issuance of a license number is required. Approval of the application and issuance of the license number is completed within 10 days. The processing of renewals was completed on average within 6 days.
Similar regulations lay out timeline expectations for the DBC’s Dental Assisting Program. Regulations state that the DBC should take no longer than 90 days to notify an applicant that their application is complete or deficient, with a final licensing decision within 180 days. License renewals are expected to be completed within 30 days with issuance within a maximum of 90 days.
The current average time from receipt of a completed RDA, RDAEF, Orthodontic Assistant (OA), or Dental Sedation Assistant (DSA) application to approval is 42 days. Upon approval of the application a license is issued to the applicant. An incomplete application is processed in an average of 145 days; these delays are a result of the applicant not providing the necessary information to complete the application process. The processing of renewals is completed on average within 14 days. The DBC is therefore also meeting the performance expectations for licensing of RDAs, RDAEFs, OAs, and DSAs.
On average over the past four years, the DBC has issued approximately 1,119 dental licenses; 1,896 RDA licenses; and 72 RDAEF licenses each year. There are currently 34,172 actively licensed dentists, 29,664 actively licensed RDAs, and 1,447 licensed RDAEFs. The volume of incoming applications has remained steady for nearly every licensing category over the past four years, with the exception of a 33% growth in Orthodontic Assistant permit applications. There are no licensing backlogs.
The DBC fingerprints all applicants as part of the application process, and the National Practitioners Data Bank is reviewed for disciplinary actions taken against applicants by regulators in other states. Beginning July 1, 2020, the process through which boards under the Department of Consumer Affairs may deny an application for licensure due to prior misconduct will have substantively changed. Causes for denial will be limited to criminal convictions reported on an applicant’s rap sheet, along with prior regulatory discipline. Nonviolent, nonsexual offenses will be washed out after seven years. In the past four years the DBC has denied one applicant for a dental license, one applicant for an oral conscious sedation permit, and 22 applicants for a registered dental assistant license.
The DBC currently inquires with applicants and licensees about whether the individual is serving in, or has previously served in, the military. The DBC has received approximately 319 responses to date. All renewal application fees charged by the DBC are waived for licensees who identify themselves as having active military status. In the prior fiscal year, the DBC has waived fees or requirements for 77 licensees. The DBC accepts military clinical practice hours toward satisfying clinical practice requirements, and the DBC will also accept military education, training and experience if the applicant lists this under the general work experience or education requirements for RDA, OA, and/or DSA licensing programs. Further, approximately 35 licenses were expedited in FY 2017/18 for licensed military spouses.
Education. Applicants for licensure are required to submit proof that they have met certain education requirements. For example, applicants for licensure as dentists must demonstrate that they have “completed at dental school or schools the full number of academic years of undergraduate courses required for graduation.” The DBC accepts the findings of the American Dental Association Commission on Dental Accreditation (CODA) when they approve or reapprove a dental school located within the United States. These schools are accredited and re-evaluated by CODA every seven years.
The DBC is responsible for the approval of all foreign dental schools eligible for fulfilling licensure requirements for dental professionals in California. Two international dental schools have been approved by the DBC: the University De La Salle School of Dentistry, located in Leon, Guanajuato, Mexico, and the State of Medicine and Pharmacy “Nicolae Testemintanu” of the Republic of Moldova. Approved foreign dental schools must also undergo reevaluation every seven years, and the DBC may at any time withdraw its approval of an institution that no longer meets the requirements of the Act.
The DBC is also responsible for approving all Dental Assistant Educational Programs and Courses, including Registered Dental Assistant Educational Programs, RDAEF Educational Programs, Coronal Polishing Courses, Orthodontic Assistant Permit Courses, and other courses whose requirements are outlined in board regulations. The approval of several Dental Assisting programs is an administrative responsibility shared with the Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education, which generally regulates private for-profit colleges.
The DBC has approved 97 Registered Dental Assisting Programs, 11 Registered Dental Assistant in Extended Functions Programs, 147 Orthodontic Assistant Permit Courses, 26 Dental Sedation Assistant Permit Courses, and numerous courses for Infection Control, Coronal Polish, Pit and Fissure Sealants, Radiation Safety, Interim Therapeutic Restorations, and Ultrasonic Scaling. These programs and courses are also reevaluated every seven years and may be disapproved if any program or course does not meet the requirements of the Dental Practice Act.
Continuing Education. Dental professionals licensed by the DBC are required to take continuing education as a condition of license renewal. Pursuant to regulations, the DBC has adopted standards for the continuing education of its licensees. At the time of license renewal, the licensee must certify completion of mandatory coursework and the minimum number of units required for each license and/or permit held.
Dentist licensees are required to complete a minimum of 50 units of continuing education, including mandatory coursework, during the two-year period immediately preceding the expiration of their license. RDA, RDAEF, OA, and DSA licensees are required to complete a minimum of 25 units of continuing education, including mandatory coursework, during the two-year period immediately preceding the expiration of their license. Unlicensed dental assistants in California must complete a DBC-approved eight-hour Infection Control course, a DBC-approved two-hour Dental Practice Act course, and a course in Basic Life Support through the American Red Cross or the American Heart Association.
As part of the renewal process, licensees certify under penalty of perjury that they have completed mandatory coursework and the have taken minimum number of units required for the active license or permit. The DBC also conducts random CE audits of one-twelfth of one percent of the total active licensing population for each license type (approximately 30 DDS and 30 RDA licensees per month). Audited licensees are required to supply certificates of completion as proof of meeting the continuing education requirements. As of April 30, 2018, approximately 1,050 DDS licenses were audited for continuing education, of which 195 licensees, or 18.5%, failed the audit. During that same time, approximately 405 RDA licensees were audited for continuing education. 183 of these licensees, or 45%, failed the audit.
There have been no changes made to these requirements over the last four years. However, the DBC is currently anticipating the promulgation of additional regulations to establish Basic Life Support equivalency standards to update this section in the near future. The DBC is also considering requiring additional mandatory continuing education relating to the risks of addiction associated with the use of Schedule II drugs in response to the opioid crisis.
The DBC is tasked with approving providers of continuing education for dental professionals. However, excluding mandatory courses, the DBC does not individually approve specific courses offered by that approved registered provider. Course outlines, brochures, and summaries are required as part of the application process. For mandated courses, the minimum requirements for course content must be adhered to, or the provider risks their registered status. Within the past four fiscal years, the DBC received approximately 523 registered education provider applications. Of these applications submitted, 413 providers were approved. Currently, the DBC does not audit CE providers.
Examination. In addition to the payment of fees and the completion of prelicensure education requirements, dentist applicants are required to make a final demonstration of their readiness to practice dentistry through one of several pathways.
- WREB Examination. Applicants may apply for licensure after passing the Western Regional Examining Board (WREB) examination. This examination tests clinical competence through the use of patients to evaluate candidates for licensure. The examination consists of Operative, Endodontics, and Comprehensive Treatment Planning sections, as well as an optional Periodontal section. The applicant must also pass Parts I and II of the National Board Written Examinations.
- Licensure by Credential. This pathway to licensure is available to dentists who are currently licensed to practice dentistry in another state. To be eligible for Licensure by Credential, the out-of-state dentist must prove that they have either been in active clinical practice or have been a full-time faculty member in an accredited dental education program and in active clinical practice for a total of at least 5,000 hours in five of the seven consecutive years preceding the date application.
- Licensure by Residency. As of February 2008, applicants may apply for licensure on the basis of having completed of a minimum of 12 months of a general practice residency or advanced education in general dentistry program approved by CODA. The applicant must also pass Parts I and II of the National Board Written Examinations, and must have graduated from a CODA-approved dental school.
- Licensure by Portfolio Examination. The Licensure by Portfolio Examination process has been available to dental applicants since November 2014. Under portfolio licensure requirements, instead of taking a single examination, students build a portfolio of completed clinical experiences and clinical competency examinations in six subject areas over the normal course of their clinical training during dental school. The portfolio option gives students in California an alternative to being tested on a live patient over the course of one weekend. The applicant’s portfolio is assessed for demonstration of experiences and competencies, following a letter of good standing signed by the dean of the applicant’s dental school. The applicant must also pass Parts I and II of the National Board Written Examinations.
Under statute, RDA applicants must pass three examinations: a computerized written general knowledge examination; a computerized law and ethics written examination; and a hands-on practical examination performed on a typodont, (a model of the oral cavity). However, the RDA practical examination was suspended in April 2017 following a review by the Office of Professional Examination Services (OPES) of the Department of Consumer Affairs. This suspension was subsequently extended until January 1, 2020 through Assembly Bill 1707 (Low, Chapter 174, Statutes of 2017).
The OPES review had determined that inconsistencies in different test site conditions, deficiencies in scoring criteria, poor calibration of examiners, and the lack of a clear definition of minimum acceptable competence indicated that the RDA practical examination did not meet critical psychometric standards. The OPES believed the presence of other examination requirements prompted a low risk in the practical examination’s suspension. To date, the DBC has not identified any resulting harm from the suspension.
Enforcement. The DBC investigates complaints against licensees through its Enforcement Division. Each year, the DBC receives an average of 3,568 complaints, which has remained consistent over the past four years. Once a complaint is investigated, the DBC decides whether to refer the case to the Attorney General to file an administrative accusation and seek disciplinary action. Filed cases are litigated and adjudicated by an Administrative Law Judge, with ultimate disciplinary action subject to a final vote by the board.
A series of Performance Measures have been put into place to evaluate the effectiveness of the DBC’s enforcement program. In many categories, the DBC is meeting expectations. For example, the target average time for a complaint to be received, assigned to an analyst, and fully investigated is 270 days. For the last three years, the average intake and investigation cycle time was 265 days.
For the entire enforcement process for cases resulting in formal discipline, the target average time is 540 days. Over the past four years, the average has been 886 days. This average falls short of the DBC’s performance measures, but represents an improvement over the 998-day average reported in the DBC’s prior sunset review.
The DBC prioritizes potential disciplinary cases based on guidelines outlined in the Department of Consumer Affair’s 2009 memorandum titled Complaint Prioritization for Health Care Agencies. These guidelines are integrated early in the process during complaint intake and followed throughout the investigation. The standard is for cases to be prioritized during complaint intake with prime consideration assigned to those cases where there has been or is likely to be imminent consumer harm.
Allegations involving patient death, sexual misconduct, pharmaceutical or substance abuse, or physical mental incapacity, as well as unlicensed activity, will receive an “urgent” priority, depending on the details of the allegation. These cases are immediately referred to a sworn investigator. Cases prioritized as “urgent” may reveal the need for immediate action—for example, obtaining an interim suspension order, a temporary restraining order, or compelling a licensee to undergo a mental or physical examination to determine their ability to practice.
Complaints and investigations evaluated as having a “high” priority level include allegations relating to actions that do not pose an immediate threat to the public’s health, safety, or welfare. For example, cases alleging negligence or incompetence, physical or mental abuse (without injury), prescription-related allegations, unlicensed activity, aiding and abetting unlicensed activity, or multiple prior complaints. Depending on the facts behind the allegation, high priority cases may be assigned to a sworn Investigator, or to non-sworn staff. These cases are then also prioritized by investigators based on caseload.
Complaints deemed to be “routine” may include allegations relating to general quality of care, billing fraud, patient abandonment, documentation/records, conviction notifications, out-of-state discipline, and malpractice settlements and judgments. These “routine” investigations may be assigned to investigators or enforcement staff. After assignment, these too are prioritized within each investigator’s caseload.
Many investigated cases do not go to administrative hearing, but are instead settled with the Respondent. Over the past four years, 136 pre-accusation cases were settled. This included 29 probationary licenses, 35 surrenders, 8 diversion referrals and 64 citations. The number of post-accusation cases settled was 201 and included 60 public reprimands, 97 probation orders, and 44 surrenders. 72 cases went to hearing. Overall, 26% of cases resulted in administrative hearing and 52% resulted in settlements.
In addition to full disciplinary action against licensees, the DBC has cite and fine authority. Citations may be used when patient harm is not found, but the quality of care provided to the consumer is substandard. When issuing citations, the DBC’s goal is not to be punitive. Rather, the DBC seeks to protect consumers by getting the subject dentist’s attention, re-educating them, and emphasizing the importance of following dental practices that fall within the community’s standard of care. A variety of factors are considered when deciding whether to issue a citation. The issuance of citations has increased each year—there was a total of 47 citations in FY 2015/16; 56 citations in FY 2016/17; and 64 citations in FY 17/18. Citations are commonly issued to licensees for violations such as failure to produce patient records, failure to follow Infection Control guidelines, and unprofessional conduct.
In addition to using citations to address less egregious violations that would not result in meaningful discipline, the DBC views citation as a means of establishing a public record of an event that might otherwise have been closed without action, and thereby remain nondisclosable. Moreover, citations can address skills and training concerns promptly. In the event that a licensee fails to pay their fine, a hold is placed on the license and it cannot be renewed without payment of the renewal fee and the fine amount. Statute also authorizes the DBC to take disciplinary action for failure to pay a fine within 30 days.
Diversion. Statute directs the DBC to “seek ways and means to identify and rehabilitate licentiates whose competency may be impaired due to abuse of dangerous drugs or alcohol, so that licentiates so afflicted may be treated and returned to the practice of dentistry in a manner that will not endanger the public health and safety.” The DBC has fulfilled this mandate through its Diversion Program. As previously discussed, the DBC has created two Diversion Evaluation Committees—one in Southern and one in Northern California—to manage the Diversion Program. Quarterly meetings are traditionally scheduled in Los Angeles and Sacramento, with four meetings per year for each committee.
The Diversion Program is a voluntary, confidential program that offers an alternative to traditional disciplinary actions for dental licensees whose practice may be impaired due to chemical dependency. The goal of the Diversion Program is to protect the public by early identification of impaired dentists and dental assistants and by providing licensees access to appropriate intervention programs and treatment services. Public safety is protected by suspension of practice, when needed, and by careful monitoring of the participants. Any California licensed dental professional residing in the state and experiencing an alcohol or drug abuse problem is eligible for admission into the program.
A licensee seeking help for substance abuse issues may self-refer themselves by proactively contacting the Diversion Program. Licensees may also be referred by enforcement staff as a result of an investigation, or as a probationary condition following a disciplinary order. Diversion Evaluation Committee members review the history and profiles of applying licensees for consideration into the program and determining eligibility, or if they do not meet the criteria.
Upon acceptance into the program, Diversion Evaluation Committee members are responsible for developing an individual treatment plan that provides both structured support during a participant’s recovery and strict monitoring to ensure California dental consumers are not at risk from impaired licensees. Careful consideration is given in designing a plan that not only includes the appropriate means of rehabilitation, but also considers the participant’s ability to pay for such treatment. In more egregious cases, participants may be suspended from work with outpatient treatment and other structured support, or suspension with more costly in-patient treatment.
Upon entering the program, participants are each assigned a Diversion Evaluation Committee member as their case consultant. The case consultant is responsible for closely following the recovery progress of each of their assigned participant. The consultant leads the interview when their assigned participant appears before the full committee. Each participant must attend scheduled Diversion Evaluation Committee meetings when face-to-face interviews allow the case consultant to monitor their appearance and conduct. During the meetings, Diversion Evaluation Committee members will also consider participant requests for contract changes. Some examples include requests to: reduce or exchange health support group/AA/NA meetings, schedule vacation trips, increase work hours, or change work site monitors.
Depending on the progress observed, Diversion Evaluation Committee members can increase or decrease biological fluid testing times, (including order back-to-back or additional weekend tests), temporarily suspend a participant from practice, or mandate inpatient treatment. In addition to the monthly fees, participants are required to pay the cost of all biological fluid tests ordered (approximately $62.50 per test), and the costs to attend any inpatient or outpatient treatment modalities ordered by the Diversion Evaluation Committee.
Decisions to terminate a participant from the Diversion Program are also made by the Diversion Evaluation Committee. The committee shall determine, based upon the recommendation of both the Diversion Program Manager and the assigned case consultant, whether to terminate participation in the program. Termination can be for failing to comply with the treatment program, failing to derive benefit from the treatment plan, or testing positive on more than one occasion and being deemed a public risk.
Successful completion of the program is granted by the Diversion Evaluation Committee if the participant has demonstrated all of the following:
- The ability to refrain from the use of alcohol and drugs;
- A sound understanding of addiction;
- A commitment to recovery;
- An acceptable relapse prevention plan; and
- A transition period of at least one year, during which time they demonstrate that they are in recovery.
Public Information Policies. The DBC maintains an email list of all interested parties and sends out emails to these individuals each time something new is posted on the website. All board meeting materials are posted online at least one week prior to each meeting, along with draft minutes from the prior meeting. Meeting materials and approved final meeting minutes remain online indefinitely.
The DBC has been webcasting all of the public board and committee meetings since 2012, and plans to continue webcasting all of its public board and committee meetings. Webcasts are archived online for three years. The DBC establishes the following year’s meeting dates at the August Board meeting and posts them on the website immediately.
Online Practice Issues. The DBC actively investigates and prosecutes individuals who dispense or furnish any dangerous drug or device on the internet for delivery to any person in this state without a prescription, as prohibited by law. If an individual is not licensed in California, the additional charge practicing dentistry without a license is also sought. The DBC regularly investigates inappropriate or illegal drug prescribing, although most is unrelated to internet sales. More frequently, the DBC receives complaints regarding online advertising violations. This often includes licensees who are claiming superiority in their treatments and products. Such complaints are typically dealt with by the use of cease and desist letters, as well as citations.
In advertising cases involving the use of neurotoxins or injectable fillers, the DBC investigates whether the products are offered for treatment of a bona fide dental condition or are offered for strictly cosmetic purposes. These cases may facilitate an undercover operation to confirm the illegitimate use which may result in a citation, administrative action against the licensee or criminal charges filed for unlicensed practice of dentistry or medicine.
The DBC has also received complaints of unlicensed denturists advertising to create dentures for customers without a prescription from a licensed dentist. These types of complaints may result in an undercover visit to confirm whether dentistry is taking place, which could result in furtherance of a search warrant, arrest and conviction, or merely an investigator confirming that the location is a legitimate dental lab.
The DBC is currently looking closely at tele-dentistry statutes to determine if dental professional corporations are interpreting the law too broadly, or whether the DBC should seek statutory language to narrow the application of tele-dentistry in order to ensure public protection. Additionally, the DBC is in the process of gathering background information on the newly recognized specialty of dental radiology to determine whether utilizing dental radiologists, outside the state, would be unlicensed activity.
BreEZe. The BreEZe computer system was approved in 2009 and was intended to replace the DCA’s outdated legacy systems. The transition to this new computer system was scheduled incrementally in three phases referred to as “Releases.” Ten boards and bureaus were initially transitioned in Release I, and eight boards were placed in Release II. Release III has been suspended following cancellation of the vendor’s contract as the Department of Consumer Affairs works with each entity to identify a more effective technology solution for their business needs.
The DBC has been on BreEZe since January 19, 2016 as a Release II entity. The DBC participated extensively in the development and implementation of the BreEZe computer system. Board staff has also participated in ongoing testing, updates, and training programs and exercises to identify programmatic issues. The DBC will continue to test, evaluate, and communicate any issues or problems that arise to the Department of Consumer Affairs Office of Information Systems on an ongoing and as needed basis.
To fund the DBC’s transition to the BreEZe system, the Dentistry Fund has contributed approximately $1,758,598 and the Dental Assisting Fund has contributed approximately $1,251,522 from FY 2009-10 through FY 2016-17. This includes vendor costs, Department of Consumer Affairs staff, and other related costs. As the BreEZe program transitions from the project phase into the maintenance phase, the Department of Consumer Affairs anticipates the State Dentistry Fund will contribute approximately $1,404,000 from FY 2017-18 through FY 2019-20. The Dental Assisting Fund will contribute approximately $1,062,000 through the same period.
Workforce Development and Job Creation. The DBC is currently participating in two legislatively mandated programs to gather work force data in order to address issues relating to access to care. The DBC developed a work force survey, which each licensee (dentist and registered dental assistant) is required to complete upon initial licensure and at the time of license renewal. The survey does not include questions related to earnings and benefits, job satisfaction, temporary departure from practice, or future plans of working licensees.
The DBC participates in the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD)’s health care workforce Clearinghouse Database design phase of its data collection project. The results of this data collection can be found in the OSHPD Facts Sheets for Dentists, RDAs, and RDHs that are available at: http://www.oshpd.ca.gov/hwdd/hwc.
Issues Identified in the DBC’s Sunset Background Paper. The DBC’s most recent sunset background paper highlighted the following issues for consideration during its current review by the Legislature.
ISSUE #1: Merger of Special Funds. Should the State Dentistry Fund and the State Dental Assisting Fund be merged to simplify and streamline accounting and budgeting processes for the DBC?
ISSUE #2: Dental Hygiene Board. What is the current state of the DBC’s relationship with the Dental Hygiene Board of California, which also regulates licensees involved in the dental profession?
ISSUE #3: Board Attorney. Does the DBC have sufficient legal counsel?
ISSUE #4: NC Dental. Are there any outstanding concerns that the Supreme Court’s decision in North Carolina State Board of Dental Examiners v. FTC could have implications for the DBC?
ISSUE #5: RDA Practical Examination. Should the practical examination requirement for registered dental assistants be permanently eliminated?
ISSUE #6: Portfolio Examinations. Is the DBC’s portfolio examination process adequately providing pathways to licensure for dental students as an effective alternative to conventional examinations?
ISSUE #7: Foreign Dental Schools. Should the current process by which the DBC approves foreign dental schools continue?
ISSUE #8: Consumer Products. Does the DBC have sufficient oversight over consumer products advertising self-applied corrective treatments for structural or aesthetic oral health conditions?
ISSUE #9: Enforcement Targets. Does available data relating to enforcement timelines suggest any inefficiencies in discipline cases brought by the DBC in collaboration with the Attorney General?
ISSUE #10: Opioid Crisis. What role do dentists play in the ongoing epidemic of opioid abuse and addiction, and how can the DBC support efforts to curb overprescribing within the dental profession?
ISSUE #11: Probation Disclosure. Should dental professionals placed on probation by the DBC be required to disclose their probation status to patients in a manner similar to other healing arts licensees?
ISSUE #12: Dynamex. Does the new test for determining employment status, as prescribed in the court decision Dynamex Operations West Inc. v. Superior Court, have any potential implications for licensees working in the dental profession as independent contractors?
ISSUE #13: Pediatric Anesthesia. Does the DBC anticipate a smooth implementation of Senate Bill 501 (Glazer), a recently enacted measure regarding pediatric dental anesthesia?
ISSUE #14: Technical Cleanup. Is there a need for technical cleanup?
ISSUE #15: Continued Regulation. Should the licensing of dental professionals be continued and be regulated by the Dental Board of California?
Direct-to-Consumer Orthodontic Products. The sunset background paper discussed the issue of whether certain self-applied consumer products relating to dentistry raise any public protection concerns. As emerging technologies disrupt the way that health services are delivered—particularly through telehealth—a balancing test must be applied to determine whether the convenience and cost of these new product models outweigh the risks to consumers.
In the case of orthodontia, there has been a growing national concern that products intended to physically change the positions of teeth without a dentist examining them in person. It is unclear how the Dental Board would be able to determine whether professional judgement was appropriately exercised in approving a treatment plan for a patient they have not personally examined. This bill intends to set a baseline standard for orthodontic treatment plans by requiring all dentists, regardless of how they practice, to review a radiograph to ensure the treatment plan will be safe and effective.
Nothing in this bill requires that an x-ray be taken specifically for purposes of orthodontia. What the bill requires is that a dentist review either a radiograph or other equivalent bone imaging, which may have been taken during an earlier office visit with a dentist. This would be equivalent to taking an optical prescription obtained during an optometric exam and taking it to a potentially cheaper retail store for glasses.
The treatment plan agreement for the major direct-to-consumer orthodontic products already does not allow patients to receive orthodontia without first receiving an examination from a dentist.. For example, the leading company states in its terms that “it is your responsibility to see a dentist within 6 months prior to starting [company] aligners, and requires an acknowledgement by the consumer that “my dentist took x-rays of my teeth” and “my dentist checked my x-rays” for various conditions. This bill would essentially codify the requirement that a dentist has done this necessary examination, and require the dentist who actually approves the treatment plan to review the images.
The direct-to-consumer products impacted by this bill are relatively cheaper (typically around $2,000) but they are not intended to offer medically necessary treatments or any correction that is not mild-to-moderate. The intent of these products is to improve the aesthetic appearance of the teeth, and are not a substitute for traditional braces. Many efforts have been taken to expand access to actual dental care for low-income patients, with reforms and expansions to the Denti-Cal program made this year.
It is not entirely uncommon to codify standards of care when it is in the interest of protecting the public. Under the Business and Professions Code, health practitioners are typically not given statutory direction as to how to treat their patients, but are instead held accountable for their professional judgement by a board. AB 1519 does not dictate what treatment plans must be offered by a dentist – instead, it simply codifies the information that a dentist’s professional judgement must take into account before making an independent decision.
There are several examples of where similar language has previously been enacted in the California Dental Practice Act. For instance, BPC Section 1684.5 requires dentists to conduct an examination, review medical and dental history, and have a diagnosis and a treatment plan in order to treat a patient of record. Further, a dentist must have conducted a preliminary oral exam before a dental auxiliary can perform a diagnostic procedure.
Foreign School Approval. Currently, the Dental Board is charged with approving schools outside of the United States and Canada that wish to have their graduates’ dental school degrees accepted by the board under the same process that degrees obtained in the United States are accepted. This involves two board members and staff traveling to the foreign country to review the campus, as well as the review of an extensive application. To date, only two schools have been approved by the Dental Board: one in Mexico, and one in Moldova.
This bill would transfer the authority for approving foreign dental schools to the Commission on Dental Accreditation, or CODA. The two currently approved schools would remain approved for four years or until their existing approval runs out. In the meantime, they would be expected to seek and obtain CODA approval.
CODA is the entity that currently facilitates interstate reciprocity for schools within the United States and Canada. The Dental Board knows whether to accept the degree from a small dental school in Alabama based on whether it has received CODA approval. Previously, CODA did not approve schools outside of the United States and Canada; they recently established their own foreign dental school approval program, and have already approved its first school. The Dental Board’s official opinion is that CODA is much better equipped to review and approve foreign dental schools, considering their expertise and ability to update their standards as necessary.
California is the only state where the Dental Board is tasked with approving foreign schools. Other health boards in California rely on national accreditors for similar approvals. For example, the Medical Board’s foreign school approval authority was transferred to a pair of international accreditors during its last sunset.
Current Related Legislation. AB 1520 (Low) is the sunset review bill for the Court Reporters Board of California. This bill is pending in this committee.
AB 1521 (Low) is the sunset review bill for the California Board of Accountancy. This bill is pending in the Assembly.
AB 1522 (Low) is the sunset review bill for the Board for Professional Engineers, Land Surveyors, and Geologists. This bill is pending in this committee.
SB 606 (Glazer) is the sunset review bill for the Cemetery and Funeral Bureau and the Board of Barbering and Cosmetology. This bill is pending in the Senate.
SB 608 (Glazer) is the sunset review bill for the California Architects Board and the Landscape Architects Technical Committee. This bill is pending in the Senate.
SB 609 (Glazer) is the sunset review bill for the bill for the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services. This bill is pending in the Senate.
SB 610 (Glazer) is the sunset review bill for the Contractors’ State License Board. This bill is pending in the Senate.
Prior Related Legislation. AB 179 (Bonilla, Chapter 510, Statutes of 2015) was the most recent sunset extension vehicle for the DBC to be enacted.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
Dr. Paul Glassman, Professor Emeritus at the University of the Pacific Arthur A. Dugoni School of Dentistry, writes in support of the bill. Dr. Glassman is “a dentist who has been developing teledentistry systems and is a strong supporter of improving access to dental care through using teledentistry.” Dr. Glassman argues that “this bill establishes fundamental consumer protections for patients receiving care through teledentistry. With emerging business models offering various health services partially or completely online, it is imperative that healthcare continues to meet the professional standard of care.”
Latino Coalition for a Healthy California (LCHC) also supports this bill. According to LCHC, “telehealth provides a valuable opportunity to provide quality healthcare through emerging models that address the lack of access to care experienced by millions of Californians. The provisions in AB 1519 ensure that telehealth advancements continue to grow in a thoughtful way that puts patient safety first and is as effective as in-person treatment.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
Several companies offering teledentistry products in California, including Byte, oppose the bill’s language requiring dentists to review a radiograph prior to prescribing orthodontics. These companies argue that “our organizations comprise of some of the largest teledentistry aligner companies operating in the United States, all of which have a large presence and employees in California. Our organizations believe in the importance of thoughtful regulation and are dedicated to responsibly expanding access to care for thousands of consumers in California. Recent advances in technology have opened a door to safe, high quality orthodontic treatments for people who were historically priced out of the market. Unfortunately, the language recently added to AB 1519 could undermine important progress made in the last few years.”\
TechNet also opposes this bill. According to TechNet, “this bill, as currently written, will reduce competitiveness in the dental industry and cut down on an option that is more affordable and accessible for all Californians. Under current law in California, consumers who have an issue with their dentist can already file complaints with the Dental Board of California, whether they utilize “traditional” dentistry or teledentistry. Teledentistry should be supported as a tool to practice dentistry and ensure consumers have access to affordable dental and orthodontic options. We should not create an unnecessary standard of care in California that will discriminate against this technology solution. We urge you to discuss this innovative industry with us over the interim so we ensure this technology solution can continue to exist and we can work together to find an appropriate path forward.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
American Association of Orthodontists
California Association of Dental Assisting Teachers
California Association of Orthodontists
California Dental Assisting Association
California Dental Association
California Society of Dentist Anesthesiologists
California Society of Pediatric Dentistry
California Society of Periodontists
California State Association of Endodontists
Children Now
Dental Hygiene Board of California
Dental Board of California
Latino Coalition for a Healthy California
University of the Pacific Professor Emeritus Dr. Glassman
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
American Teledentistry Association
Big Brothers Big Sisters of Orange County & the Inland Empire
Byte
California Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
Candid
Dr. Jack Lipton
Learning Lab Ventures
Prostate Cancer Research Institute
SmileDirectClub
SmileLove
Startup UCLA
TechNet
Webb Schools
Youth Policy Institute
Two individuals
Analysis Prepared by: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 1519
Author:(Low)
As Amended Ver:September 6, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Extends the sunset date for the Dental Board of California (DBC) until January 1, 2024 and makes additional technical changes, statutory improvements, and policy reforms in response to issues raised during the DBC's sunset review process.
The Senate Amendments:
- Merge the DBC's two special funds;
- Eliminate the suspended Registered Dental Assistant practical exam;
- Require the DBC to report on the status of portfolio examinations;
- Transition approval for foreign dental schools from the DBC to a national accreditor;
- Clarify the application of professional responsibility laws to all dentists regardless of practice setting and state that it is unprofessional conduct for a dentist to engage in the initial diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or initial use of orthodontic appliances without performing an examination, including the review of the patient's most recent diagnostic digital or conventional radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging suitable for orthodontia.
- Require dentists on probation to make disclosures to patients prior to treatment.
COMMENTS:
Sunset review is a legislative oversight process conducted by the Assembly and Senate Committees on Business and Professions. Nearly every regulatory board under the Department of Consumer Affairs is statutorily subject to repeal on a certain date through a "sunset provision"; this date must be extended through a sunset bill. This bill is the sunset bill for the Dental Board, which is subject to repeal on January 1, 2020 unless the bill is enacted.
As part of the review process, the Dental Board submitted a comprehensive report to the Legislature, then the Business and Professions Committees authored a background paper on the board and a series of current issues. This background paper has been available to the public online since February 2019. Every substantive provision in this bill was discussed in that background paper. Additionally, the board appeared before the committees in a public hearing back in March 2019, where several of the issues were discussed. The issues contained in the sunset background paper were as follows:
ISSUE #1: Merger of Special Funds. Should the State Dentistry Fund and the State Dental Assisting Fund be merged to simplify and streamline accounting and budgeting processes for the DBC?
ISSUE #2: Dental Hygiene Board. What is the current state of the DBC's relationship with the Dental Hygiene Board of California, which also regulates licensees involved in the dental profession?
ISSUE #3: Board Attorney. Does the DBC have sufficient legal counsel?
ISSUE #4: NC Dental. Are there any outstanding concerns that the Supreme Court's decision in North Carolina State Board of Dental Examiners v. FTC could have implications for the DBC?
ISSUE #5: RDA Practical Examination. Should the practical examination requirement for registered dental assistants be permanently eliminated?
ISSUE #6: Portfolio Examinations. Is the DBC's portfolio examination process adequately providing pathways to licensure for dental students as an effective alternative to conventional examinations?
ISSUE #7: Foreign Dental Schools. Should the current process by which the DBC approves foreign dental schools continue?
ISSUE #8: Consumer Products. Does the DBC have sufficient oversight over consumer products advertising self-applied corrective treatments for structural or aesthetic oral health conditions?
ISSUE #9: Enforcement Targets. Does available data relating to enforcement timelines suggest any inefficiencies in discipline cases brought by the DBC in collaboration with the Attorney General?
ISSUE #10: Opioid Crisis. What role do dentists play in the ongoing epidemic of opioid abuse and addiction, and how can the DBC support efforts to curb overprescribing within the dental profession?
ISSUE #11: Probation Disclosure. Should dental professionals placed on probation by the DBC be required to disclose their probation status to patients in a manner similar to other healing arts licensees?
ISSUE #12: Dynamex. Does the new test for determining employment status, as prescribed in the court decision Dynamex Operations West Inc. v. Superior Court, have any potential implications for licensees working in the dental profession as independent contractors?
ISSUE #13: Pediatric Anesthesia. Does the DBC anticipate a smooth implementation of Senate Bill 501 (Glazer), Chapter 929, Statutes of 2018, a recently enacted measure regarding pediatric dental anesthesia?
ISSUE #14: Technical Cleanup. Is there a need for technical cleanup?
ISSUE #15: Continued Regulation. Should the licensing of dental professionals be continued and be regulated by the Dental Board of California?
According to the Author:
"AB 1519 is the sunset bill for the Dental Board of California, authored by the Assembly Committee on Business and Professions. Passage of this bill is necessary to extend the operation of the Dental Board, which is currently scheduled for repeal at the end of this year. This bill also makes various adjustments to the Dental Practice Act in response to issues raised during the sunset review process. Every provision in this bill is specifically related to an issue discussed in the B&P committees' joint sunset background paper, which was published last February and discussed at a public hearing in March."
Arguments in Support:
Dr. Paul Glassman, Professor Emeritus at the University of the Pacific Arthur A. Dugoni School of Dentistry, writes in support of the bill. Dr. Glassman is "a dentist who has been developing teledentistry systems and is a strong supporter of improving access to dental care through using teledentistry." Dr. Glassman argues that "this bill establishes fundamental consumer protections for patients receiving care through teledentistry. With emerging business models offering various health services partially or completely online, it is imperative that healthcare continues to meet the professional standard of care."
Arguments in Opposition:
Several companies offering teledentistry products in California, including Byte, oppose the bill's language requiring dentists to review a radiograph prior to prescribing orthodontics. These companies argue that "our organizations comprise of some of the largest teledentistry aligner companies operating in the United States, all of which have a large presence and employees in California. Our organizations believe in the importance of thoughtful regulation and are dedicated to responsibly expanding access to care for thousands of consumers in California. Recent advances in technology have opened a door to safe, high quality orthodontic treatments for people who were historically priced out of the market. Unfortunately, the language recently added to AB 1519 could undermine important progress made in the last few years."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Committee on Appropriations, the Budget Act of 2019 includes $17.7 million (State Dentistry Fund) and 77 positions for the Dental Board of California.
VOTES:
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 19-0-1
YES: Low, Brough, Bloom, Chen, Cunningham, Dahle, Eggman, Fong, Gipson, Gloria, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Obernolte, Quirk-Silva, Ting
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chiu
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0-2
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Obernolte, Patterson, Petrie‑Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
ABS, ABST OR NV: Cooley, Eduardo Garcia
SENATE FLOOR: 37-0-3
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wiener
ABS, ABST OR NV: Durazo, Wieckowski, Wilk
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 6, 2019
CONSULTANT: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301 FN: 0002434
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1519 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1519
Amended: 9/6/19 in Senate
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 9-0, 7/8/19
AYES: Glazer, Chang, Archuleta, Dodd, Galgiani, Hill, Leyva, Pan, Wilk
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 5/23/19 - See last page for vote
DIGEST:
This bill extends the operations of the Dental Board of California (DBC) until January 1, 2024, and makes other changes to the Dental Practice Act (Act).
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/6/19 clarify that imagery only need to be reviewed for the initial prescription of orthodontics; clarify that a treating dentist’s contact and license information only need to be provided to a patient prior to treatment and upon request; require any new applications for foreign school approval to be deemed complete prior to January 1, 2020, to be eligible for DBC approval; clarify that graduates of a foreign school that had DBC approval, at the time of the individual’s graduation, are eligible for licensure; remove the requirement for DBC to appoint its own attorney by July 1, 2020; and resolve chaptering conflicts.
ANALYSIS: Existing law establishes the DBC within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to regulate the practice of dentistry and subjects the DBC and its Executive Officer to repeal on January 1, 2020, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2020, deletes or extends that date. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 1600 et seq.)
This bill:
- Extends the operations of the DBC until January 1, 2024.
- Requires DBC to report on how many other states have recognized licensure by portfolio examination at the time of its next sunset review.
- Requires schools seeking approval as foreign dental school to complete the international consultative and accreditation process with the Commission on Dental Accreditation of the American Dental Association (CODA) or a comparable accrediting body approved by DBC. Requires, by January 1, 2024, in order to remain an approved foreign dental school in the state, all schools previously approved by DBC as a foreign dental school to have successfully completed the international consultative and accreditation process with CODA or a comparable accrediting body approved by DBC.
- Requires DBC licensees, as of July 1, 2020, to provide a patient or the patient's guardian or healthcare surrogate with a disclosure prior to the patient's first visit if the licensee is on probation on or after July 1, 2020, that contains specified information and requires licensees to obtain a signed copy of a disclosure containing information about the probation. Requires DBC, on and after July 1, 2020, to provide information about licensees on probation and licensees practicing under probationary licenses on the licensee’s profile page on DBC’s license information website.
- Makes failure by the treating dentist, prior to the initial diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or initial use of orthodontic appliances, to perform an examination, according to requirements under current law, including the review of the patient’s most recent diagnostic digitical or conventional radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging suitable for orthodontia, unprofessional conduct. Specifies that new radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging shall be ordered if deemed appropriate by the treating dentist.
- Requires any entity that provides dental services through telehealth must make the name, telephone number, practice address, and California state license number available of any dentist involved in providing services to a patient prior to providing services and upon request by the patient.
- Makes numerous technical and clarifying changes to the Act.
Background
Sunset Review Oversight. Beginning in 2018, the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee and the Assembly Committee on Business and Professions began their comprehensive sunset review oversight of 10 regulatory entities and the DCA. This bill makes numerous changes to the Board as a result of the Board’s 2018 sunset review report and its subsequent participation in a sunset review hearing on March 5, 2019.
Dental Board of California. The DBC is responsible for licensing and regulating dental professionals in California. Today, the DBC licenses an estimated 89,000 dental professionals, of which approximately 43,500 are fully licensed dentists; 44,500 are registered dental assistants; and 1,700 are registered dental assistants in extended functions. The DBC is also responsible for setting the duties and functions of an estimated 50,000 unlicensed dental assistants. Dental hygienists are licensed and regulated by a separate and distinct regulatory body, the Dental Hygiene Board of California. Statute defines dentistry as “the diagnosis or treatment, by surgery or other method, of diseases and lesions and the correction of malpositions of the human teeth, alveolar process, gums, jaws, or associated structures; and such diagnosis or treatment may include all necessary related procedures as well as the use of drugs, anesthetic agents, and physical evaluation.” Dentists are health care practitioners authorized to write and issue prescriptions for controlled substances. Oral and maxillofacial surgeons are a surgically trained specialty of dentistry that have completed additional residency requirements.
Response to Issues Raised During Sunset Review Oversight. The background paper prepared by staff of the Assembly Business and Professions Committee for the sunset review oversight hearing of DBC identified 15 issues for the DBC to address. Some of the issues required legislation to resolve while others were related to the Commission’s administrative and regulatory processes.
Fund Merger. Combining of the two separate funds and two separate appropriations into one would create efficiencies in budgeting and accounting processes in the long term and make budgeting issues simpler to understand. In light of the extensive research that was conducted into the feasibility and benefits of merging the Dentistry and Dental Assisting Funds in the long-term, the background paper for DBC recommended that statute should be amended to facilitate the process of combining the funds. This bill implements the recommendation to merge the funds.
DBC Attorney. Business and Professions Code § 1616 expressly provides the DBC with “full power to … appoint its own attorney, prescribe his duties and fix his compensation.” However, the DBC does not currently have its own dedicated attorney. Legal representation in disciplinary prosecution is provided by the Attorney General’s Licensing Section, and the DCA offers counsel as part of the centralized services it provides to boards, as needed to assist with rulemaking, address legal issues that arise, and support compliance with open meeting laws. Dedicated board counsel is, however, considered to provide substantial value when questions of law occur regularly enough to warrant the presence of attorney who specializes in a board’s Practice Act and areas of jurisdiction. It is under this line of thinking that the Legislature has authorized the DBC to appoint its own lawyer, and any reasons for that position remaining unfilled should be discussed before the committees. This bill requires DBC to appoint its own attorney by July 1, 2020.
Portfolio Examination. Licensure by portfolio is a recently enacted alternative pathway to licensure as a dentist in California, available to applicants since November 2014. Since California has the distinction of being one of the first states to pursue this method of qualifying for licensure, dentists who have obtained their license through the portfolio pathway may face difficulties when seeking reciprocal acknowledgment of qualification by other states. The DBC’s successful implementation of licensure by portfolio continues to be an important demonstration of the effectiveness of what could be considered regulatory innovation. However, if applicants are denied license portability as a result of the novel nature of this examination alternative, the DBC should consider whether additional steps should be taken to safeguard licensee mobility. This bill requires DBC to report on how many other states have recognized licensure by portfolio examination at the time of its next sunset review.
Foreign Dental Schools. Statute enacted in 1998 granted the DBC responsibility for approving foreign dental schools, recognizing that “graduates of foreign dental schools who have received an education that is equivalent to that of accredited institutions in the United States and that adequately prepares their students for the practice of dentistry shall be subject to the same licensure requirements as graduates of approved dental schools or colleges.” Schools outside the United States and Canada seeking approval to graduate students eligible for licensure as dentists in California must apply to the DBC and undergo an evaluation process, with renewal applications required every seven years.
Two foreign dental schools are currently approved by the DBC: the University De La Salle School of Dentistry, located in Leon, Guanajuato, Mexico, and the State of Medicine and Pharmacy “Nicolae Testemintanu” of the Republic of Moldova. The Moldova dental school Moldova received a two-year provisional approval in December 2016 and full approval in May 2018.
Subsequently, members of the DBC grew concerned that additional details of the Moldova school’s recruitment program and admission standards were not disclosed in the application or to the DBC site evaluation team during the review. During the DBC’s November 2018 meeting, the board discussed a recently uncovered flyer advertising the Moldova school titled “Become a dentist… while living in Europe!” The flyer was widely distributed in California through “the University of Moldova USA Inc.”—a separate entity operating an admissions office for the Moldova dental school based in Encino, CA. According to the DBC, the relationship between the dental school and the entity in Encino “was never divulged during the site evaluation conducted in October 2016.” It is apparent that the Moldova dental school has actively recruited students in California, promising DBC-approved dental school education (taught entirely in English) without the need for a four-year college degree. Further, the tuition charged to students recruited in the United States appears to be four times that of Moldovan students.
As the DBC continues to debate what appropriate action should be taken concerning the Moldova school’s approval status, the DBC has concluded that it does not have the resources or expertise to sufficiently evaluate foreign dental schools. During the DBC’s last sunset review, an issue was raised regarding whether the DBC should “consider heavier reliance on accrediting organizations for foreign school approvals if those options become available.” Currently, dental schools established within the United States but outside California are approved by CODA, which further recognizes Canadian dental schools approved by the Commission on Dental Accreditation of Canada. CODA has established an International Accreditation process designed to assess and approve foreign dental schools through robust investigation and evaluation. To date, CODA has yet to approve any foreign dental schools through this lengthy process. However, CODA has begun to evaluate applications for approval, including one submitted by a school in Leon, Guanajuato, Mexico. This bill requires schools seeking approval as foreign dental school to complete the international consultative and accreditation process with CODA or a comparable accrediting body approved by DBC and requires, by January 1, 2024, in order to remain an approved foreign dental school in the state, all schools previously approved by DBC as a foreign dental school to have successfully completed the international consultative and accreditation process with CODA or a comparable accrediting body approved by DBC.
Consumer Products. Within the many professions and occupations regulated in California, the advent of new technologies has enhanced access and ease for service to consumers. Dentistry and oral health is no exception, and individuals seeking a “better smile” are able to participate in a growing marketplace for products enabling consumers to improve their oral health and appearance from the comfort of their homes. Like with all services contained within the scope of a profession licensed by the state, however, there is benefit to analyzing the balance of convenience and any potential risk of consumer harm.
A growing market for self-applied dental treatments is in the field of orthodontia. Several companies offer aligners that can be customized for the consumer at either a boutique storefront or through an at-home kit mailed to the customer. Through these products, an individual is able to realign the positioning of their teeth into what they believe will be a straighter smile. While companies offering such products describe the mailed aligners as being “reviewed” by a dental professional through the use of remote tele-dentistry, it is possible for a consumer to go through the realignment process without ever actually consulting with a licensed dentist. This may be cause for some concern in light of reported incidents where teeth have been misaligned when using at-home aligners. Dental boards in other states have begun to take action against the marketers of such products, and ongoing litigation has resulted. This bill makes failure to review diagnostic digital or conventional radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging suitable for orthodontia prior to the diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or use of orthodontic appliances unprofessional conduct. The bill also specifies that the required notice to patients informing them that a practitioner is licensed, for purposes of receiving services through telehealth, must be accessible electronically for patients receiving dental services through telehealth. The bill also requires any entity that provides a service authorized under the Act through teledentistry to make the name and state license number of any dentist providing services available and makes a violation of this requirement unprofessional conduct.
Probation Disclosure. Last year, Senate Bill 1448 (Hill, Chapter 570, Statutes of 2018) enacted the Patient’s Right to Know Act of 2018, requiring various healing arts licensees on probation for certain offenses to provide their patients with information about their probation status prior to the patient’s first visit following the probationary order beginning July 1, 2019. Licensees covered by the bill include physicians and surgeons, podiatrists, chiropractors, acupuncturists, and naturopathic doctors. The bill did not, however, include dentists. The DBC background paper noted “If the ultimate objective of probation disclosure is protecting patients from being unknowingly placed in vulnerable contexts with licensees placed on probation for serious offenses, there is no clear reason as to why dentists should be treated differently and excluded from the patient notification requirement.” This bill requires licensees on probation to disclose their probation status to patients if they are on probation for specified violations of law.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the Budget Act of 2019 includes $17.7 million (State Dentistry Fund) and 77 positions for the DBC.
American Association of Orthodontists
California Association of Dental Assisting Teachers
California Association of Orthodontists
California Dental Assistants Association
California Dental Association
California Society of Dentist Anesthesiologists
California Society of Pediatric Dentistry
California Society of Periodontists
California State Association of Endodontists
Children Now
Delta Dental
Latino Coalition for a Healthy California
University of the Pacific
Big Brothers Big Sisters of Orange County and the Inland Empire
Byte
California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce
Candid
Center for Public Interest Law
Learning Lab Ventures
Prostate Cancer Research Institute
SmileDirectClub
Smilelove
Startup UCLA Accelerator
TechNet
Youth Policy Institute
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters believe extending the operations of DBC is in the public’s interest.
Supporters state that this bill would require all dentists to review a patient’s x-rays prior to the movement of teeth, which is the standard of care and applies regardless of whether the treating dentist is in person with the patient or provides services through teledentistry. Recent x-rays, either ordered by the treating dentist or previously taken during a recent dental visit, are essential to provide the diagnostic information for safe and appropriate treatment. Providing dental care to patients, including the movement of teeth, without sufficient diagnostic information, can lead to serious patient harm, including: loose or cracked teeth, shortening of teeth roots, gum recession and bone loss, a misaligned bite, and tooth loss. According to supporters, telehealth provides a valuable opportunity to provide quality healthcare through emerging models that address the lack of access to care experienced by millions of Californians. The provisions in AB 1519 ensure that telehealth advancements continue to grow in a thoughtful way that puts patient safety first and is as effective as in-person treatment.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Center for Public Interest Law (CPIL) supports this bill if it is amended to “reform the Board’s composition to guard against potentially anticompetitive conduct by the Board, and to bring DBC’s composition more in line with other boards under the umbrella of the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA)… CPIL strongly recommends that the authors of AB 1519 amend the bill to phase out at least two of the licensee members of the Board, and replace those positions with public member positions instead. This would align DBC’s composition with other health care boards, and protect consumers against potential anticompetitive conduct by the Board.”
Opponents are concerned about provisions in the bill related to teledentistry and unprofessional conduct. According to opponents, this bill codifies an orthodontia standard of care contrary to what is the standard of care today and contrary to the available clinical data for mild to moderate correction of human teeth malpositions. Opponents state that the language has no scientific citation, no apparent authority in law, and is not even in alignment with either the California Dental Association’s own guidelines or those of the American Dental Association. According to opponents, both organizations state in documents establishing standards for the use of x-rays during treatment “[t]hese recommendations are subject to clinical judgment and may not apply to every patient” and this bill attempts to strip clinical judgment from the hands of doctors who are best suited to make those determinations.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 5/23/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooley, Eduardo Garcia
Prepared by: Sarah Mason / B., P. & E.D. /
9/9/19 18:28:14
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1519 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1519
Amended: 7/2/19 in Senate
SENATE BUS., PROF. & ECON. DEV. COMMITTEE: 9-0, 7/8/19
AYES: Glazer, Chang, Archuleta, Dodd, Galgiani, Hill, Leyva, Pan, Wilk
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 5/23/19 - See last page for vote
DIGEST:
This bill extends the operations of the Dental Board of California (DBC) until January 1, 2024, and makes other changes to the Dental Practice Act (Act).
ANALYSIS: Existing law establishes the DBC within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to regulate the practice of dentistry and subjects the DBC and its Executive Officer to repeal on January 1, 2020, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2020, deletes or extends that date. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 1600 et seq.)
This bill:
- Extends the operations of the DBC until January 1, 2024.
- Merges, as of July 1, 2022, the Dental Assistant Fund with the State Dentistry Fund.
- Requires DBC to appoint its own attorney by July 1, 2020.
- Requires DBC to report on how many other states have recognized licensure by portfolio examination at the time of its next sunset review.
- Requires schools seeking approval as foreign dental school to complete the international consultative and accreditation process with the Commission on Dental Accreditation of the American Dental Association (CODA) or a comparable accrediting body approved by DBC. Requires, by January 1, 2024, in order to remain an approved foreign dental school in the state, all schools previously approved by DBC as a foreign dental school to have successfully completed the international consultative and accreditation process with CODA or a comparable accrediting body approved by DBC.
- Requires DBC licensees, as of July 1, 2020, to provide a patient or the patient's guardian or healthcare surrogate with a disclosure prior to the patient's first visit if the licensee is on probation on or after July 1, 2020, that contains specified information and requires licensees to obtain a signed copy of a disclosure containing information about the probation. Requires DBC, on and after July 1, 2020, to provide information about licensees on probation and licensees practicing under probationary licenses on the licensee’s profile page on DBC’s license information website.
- Makes failure to review diagnostic digital or conventional radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging suitable for orthodontia prior to the diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or use of orthodontic appliances unprofessional conduct.
- Specifies that the required notice to patients informing them that a practitioner is licensed, for purposes of receiving services through telehealth, must be accessible electronically for patients receiving dental services through telehealth. Requires any entity that provides a service authorized under the Act through teledentistry to make the name and state license number of any dentist providing services available and makes a violation of this requirement unprofessional conduct.
- Makes numerous technical and clarifying changes to the Act.
Background
Sunset Review Oversight. Beginning in 2018, the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee and the Assembly Committee on Business and Professions began their comprehensive sunset review oversight of 10 regulatory entities and the DCA. This bill makes numerous changes to the Board as a result of the Board’s 2018 sunset review report and its subsequent participation in a sunset review hearing on March 5, 2019.
Dental Board of California. The DBC is responsible for licensing and regulating dental professionals in California. Today, the DBC licenses an estimated 89,000 dental professionals, of which approximately 43,500 are fully licensed dentists; 44,500 are registered dental assistants; and 1,700 are registered dental assistants in extended functions. The DBC is also responsible for setting the duties and functions of an estimated 50,000 unlicensed dental assistants. Dental hygienists are licensed and regulated by a separate and distinct regulatory body, the Dental Hygiene Board of California. Statute defines dentistry as “the diagnosis or treatment, by surgery or other method, of diseases and lesions and the correction of malpositions of the human teeth, alveolar process, gums, jaws, or associated structures; and such diagnosis or treatment may include all necessary related procedures as well as the use of drugs, anesthetic agents, and physical evaluation.” Dentists are health care practitioners authorized to write and issue prescriptions for controlled substances. Oral and maxillofacial surgeons are a surgically trained specialty of dentistry that have completed additional residency requirements.
Response to Issues Raised During Sunset Review Oversight. The background paper prepared by staff of the Assembly Business and Professions Committee for the sunset review oversight hearing of DBC identified 15 issues for the DBC to address. Some of the issues required legislation to resolve while others were related to the Commission’s administrative and regulatory processes.
Fund Merger. Combining of the two separate funds and two separate appropriations into one would create efficiencies in budgeting and accounting processes in the long term and make budgeting issues simpler to understand. In light of the extensive research that was conducted into the feasibility and benefits of merging the Dentistry and Dental Assisting Funds in the long-term, the background paper for DBC recommended that statute should be amended to facilitate the process of combining the funds. This bill implements the recommendation to merge the funds.
DBC Attorney. Business and Professions Code § 1616 expressly provides the DBC with “full power to … appoint its own attorney, prescribe his duties and fix his compensation.” However, the DBC does not currently have its own dedicated attorney. Legal representation in disciplinary prosecution is provided by the Attorney General’s Licensing Section, and the DCA offers counsel as part of the centralized services it provides to boards, as needed to assist with rulemaking, address legal issues that arise, and support compliance with open meeting laws. Dedicated board counsel is, however, considered to provide substantial value when questions of law occur regularly enough to warrant the presence of attorney who specializes in a board’s Practice Act and areas of jurisdiction. It is under this line of thinking that the Legislature has authorized the DBC to appoint its own lawyer, and any reasons for that position remaining unfilled should be discussed before the committees. This bill requires DBC to appoint its own attorney by July 1, 2020.
Portfolio Examination. Licensure by portfolio is a recently enacted alternative pathway to licensure as a dentist in California, available to applicants since November 2014. Since California has the distinction of being one of the first states to pursue this method of qualifying for licensure, dentists who have obtained their license through the portfolio pathway may face difficulties when seeking reciprocal acknowledgment of qualification by other states. The DBC’s successful implementation of licensure by portfolio continues to be an important demonstration of the effectiveness of what could be considered regulatory innovation. However, if applicants are denied license portability as a result of the novel nature of this examination alternative, the DBC should consider whether additional steps should be taken to safeguard licensee mobility. This bill requires DBC to report on how many other states have recognized licensure by portfolio examination at the time of its next sunset review.
Foreign Dental Schools. Statute enacted in 1998 granted the DBC responsibility for approving foreign dental schools, recognizing that “graduates of foreign dental schools who have received an education that is equivalent to that of accredited institutions in the United States and that adequately prepares their students for the practice of dentistry shall be subject to the same licensure requirements as graduates of approved dental schools or colleges.” Schools outside the United States and Canada seeking approval to graduate students eligible for licensure as dentists in California must apply to the DBC and undergo an evaluation process, with renewal applications required every seven years.
Two foreign dental schools are currently approved by the DBC: the University De La Salle School of Dentistry, located in Leon, Guanajuato, Mexico, and the State of Medicine and Pharmacy “Nicolae Testemintanu” of the Republic of Moldova. The Moldova dental school Moldova received a two-year provisional approval in December 2016 and full approval in May 2018.
Subsequently, members of the DBC grew concerned that additional details of the Moldova school’s recruitment program and admission standards were not disclosed in the application or to the DBC site evaluation team during the review. During the DBC’s November 2018 meeting, the board discussed a recently uncovered flyer advertising the Moldova school titled “Become a dentist… while living in Europe!” The flyer was widely distributed in California through “the University of Moldova USA Inc.”—a separate entity operating an admissions office for the Moldova dental school based in Encino, CA. According to the DBC, the relationship between the dental school and the entity in Encino “was never divulged during the site evaluation conducted in October 2016.” It is apparent that the Moldova dental school has actively recruited students in California, promising DBC-approved dental school education (taught entirely in English) without the need for a four-year college degree. Further, the tuition charged to students recruited in the United States appears to be four times that of Moldovan students.
As the DBC continues to debate what appropriate action should be taken concerning the Moldova school’s approval status, the DBC has concluded that it does not have the resources or expertise to sufficiently evaluate foreign dental schools. During the DBC’s last sunset review, an issue was raised regarding whether the DBC should “consider heavier reliance on accrediting organizations for foreign school approvals if those options become available.” Currently, dental schools established within the United States but outside California are approved by CODA, which further recognizes Canadian dental schools approved by the Commission on Dental Accreditation of Canada. CODA has established an International Accreditation process designed to assess and approve foreign dental schools through robust investigation and evaluation. To date, CODA has yet to approve any foreign dental schools through this lengthy process. However, CODA has begun to evaluate applications for approval, including one submitted by a school in Leon, Guanajuato, Mexico. This bill requires schools seeking approval as foreign dental school to complete the international consultative and accreditation process with CODA or a comparable accrediting body approved by DBC and requires, by January 1, 2024, in order to remain an approved foreign dental school in the state, all schools previously approved by DBC as a foreign dental school to have successfully completed the international consultative and accreditation process with CODA or a comparable accrediting body approved by DBC.
Consumer Products. Within the many professions and occupations regulated in California, the advent of new technologies has enhanced access and ease for service to consumers. Dentistry and oral health is no exception, and individuals seeking a “better smile” are able to participate in a growing marketplace for products enabling consumers to improve their oral health and appearance from the comfort of their homes. Like with all services contained within the scope of a profession licensed by the state, however, there is benefit to analyzing the balance of convenience and any potential risk of consumer harm.
A growing market for self-applied dental treatments is in the field of orthodontia. Several companies offer aligners that can be customized for the consumer at either a boutique storefront or through an at-home kit mailed to the customer. Through these products, an individual is able to realign the positioning of their teeth into what they believe will be a straighter smile. While companies offering such products describe the mailed aligners as being “reviewed” by a dental professional through the use of remote tele-dentistry, it is possible for a consumer to go through the realignment process without ever actually consulting with a licensed dentist. This may be cause for some concern in light of reported incidents where teeth have been misaligned when using at-home aligners. Dental boards in other states have begun to take action against the marketers of such products, and ongoing litigation has resulted. This bill makes failure to review diagnostic digital or conventional radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging suitable for orthodontia prior to the diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or use of orthodontic appliances unprofessional conduct. The bill also specifies that the required notice to patients informing them that a practitioner is licensed, for purposes of receiving services through telehealth, must be accessible electronically for patients receiving dental services through telehealth. The bill also requires any entity that provides a service authorized under the Act through teledentistry to make the name and state license number of any dentist providing services available and makes a violation of this requirement unprofessional conduct.
Probation Disclosure. Last year, Senate Bill 1448 (Hill, Chapter 570, Statutes of 2018) enacted the Patient’s Right to Know Act of 2018, requiring various healing arts licensees on probation for certain offenses to provide their patients with information about their probation status prior to the patient’s first visit following the probationary order beginning July 1, 2019. Licensees covered by the bill include physicians and surgeons, podiatrists, chiropractors, acupuncturists, and naturopathic doctors. The bill did not, however, include dentists. The DBC background paper noted “If the ultimate objective of probation disclosure is protecting patients from being unknowingly placed in vulnerable contexts with licensees placed on probation for serious offenses, there is no clear reason as to why dentists should be treated differently and excluded from the patient notification requirement.” This bill requires licensees on probation to disclose their probation status to patients if they are on probation for specified violations of law.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the Budget Act of 2019 includes $17.7 million (State Dentistry Fund) and 77 positions for the DBC.
American Association of Orthodontists
California Association of Dental Assisting Teachers
California Association of Orthodontists
California Dental Assistants Association
California Dental Association
California Society of Dentist Anesthesiologists
California Society of Pediatric Dentistry
California Society of Periodontists
California State Association of Endodontists
Children Now
Delta Dental
Latino Coalition for a Healthy California
University of the Pacific
Big Brothers Big Sisters of Orange County and the Inland Empire
Byte
California Hispanic Chambers of Commerce
Candid
Center for Public Interest Law
Learning Lab Ventures
Prostate Cancer Research Institute
SmileDirectClub
Smilelove
Startup UCLA Accelerator
TechNet
Youth Policy Institute
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Supporters believe extending the operations of DBC is in the public’s interest.
Supporters state that this bill would require all dentists to review a patient’s x-rays prior to the movement of teeth, which is the standard of care and applies regardless of whether the treating dentist is in person with the patient or provides services through teledentistry. Recent x-rays, either ordered by the treating dentist or previously taken during a recent dental visit, are essential to provide the diagnostic information for safe and appropriate treatment. Providing dental care to patients, including the movement of teeth, without sufficient diagnostic information, can lead to serious patient harm, including: loose or cracked teeth, shortening of teeth roots, gum recession and bone loss, a misaligned bite, and tooth loss. According to supporters, telehealth provides a valuable opportunity to provide quality healthcare through emerging models that address the lack of access to care experienced by millions of Californians. The provisions in AB 1519 ensure that telehealth advancements continue to grow in a thoughtful way that puts patient safety first and is as effective as in-person treatment.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The Center for Public Interest Law (CPIL) supports this bill if it is amended to “reform the Board’s composition to guard against potentially anticompetitive conduct by the Board, and to bring DBC’s composition more in line with other boards under the umbrella of the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA)… CPIL strongly recommends that the authors of AB 1519 amend the bill to phase out at least two of the licensee members of the Board, and replace those positions with public member positions instead. This would align DBC’s composition with other health care boards, and protect consumers against potential anticompetitive conduct by the Board.”
Opponents are concerned about provisions in the bill related to teledentistry and unprofessional conduct for “failure to review diagnostic digital or conventional radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging suitable for orthodontia prior to the diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or use of orthodontic appliances.” According to opponents, this bill codifies an orthodontia standard of care contrary to what is the standard of care today and contrary to the available clinical data for mild to moderate correction of human teeth malpositions. Opponents state that the language has no scientific citation, no apparent authority in law, and is not even in alignment with either the California Dental Association’s own guidelines or those of the American Dental Association. According to opponents, both organizations state in documents establishing standards for the use of x-rays during treatment “[t]hese recommendations are subject to clinical judgment and may not apply to every patient” and this bill attempts to strip clinical judgment from the hands of doctors who are best suited to make those determinations.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 78-0, 5/23/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooley, Eduardo Garcia
Prepared by: Sarah Mason / B., P. & E.D. /
9/6/19 8:11:29
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1519 (Low) - Healing arts
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
Assembly Bill 1519 would extend the Dental Board of California’s (DBC) sunset date from January 1, 2020, to January 1, 2024, and make other changes to the Dental Practice Act.
Fiscal Impact:
The Budget Act of 2019 includes $17.7 million (State Dentistry Fund) and 77 positions for the Dental Board of California.
Background:
The DBC licenses and regulates 89,000 dental professionals, of which approximately 43,500 are fully licensed dentists; 44,500 are registered dental assistants (RDAs); and 1,700 are registered dental assistants in extended functions (RDAEFs). The DBC is also responsible for setting the duties and functions of an estimated 50,000 unlicensed dental assistants. Dental hygienists are licensed and regulated by a separate and distinct regulatory body, the Dental Hygiene Board of California.
The DBC’s regulation of dental professionals includes licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary responsibilities. The DBC reviews and approves applications for initial or renewed licensure, determining whether an applicant has sufficient education and training to possess a license, certification, or permit. The DBC also engages in disciplinary activities through its own enforcement division, investigating potential violations of the Act and taking action against professional misconduct. The DBC additionally monitors licensees who have been placed on probation and manages a diversion program for licensees whose practice may be impaired due to abuse of drugs or alcohol.
The sunset review paper, prepared the Senate Business, Professions, and Economic Development and Assembly Business and Professions Committees, identified 15 issues for consideration, some of which are incorporated into this sunset vehicle.
Proposed Law:
AB 1519 would extend the sunset date for the Dental Board to January 1, 2024, and makes other specified changes, including, among other provisions:
- Merges the Dental Assistant Fund with the State Dentistry Fund, as of July 1, 2022.
- Requires the DBC to appoint its own attorney by July 1, 2020.
- Requires DBC licensees to provide a disclosure containing specified information to a patient or a patient’s guardian or healthcare surrogate prior to the patient’s first visit if the licensee is on probation.
- Requires schools seeking approval as a foreign dental school to complete the international consultative and accreditation process, and requires, by January 1, 2024, previously approved foreign dental school in the state to complete specified accreditation.
Staff Comments:
This bill makes changes to the DBC and Act as a result of the DBC’s 2018 sunset review report and its subsequent participation in a sunset review oversight hearing on March 5, 2019. Some of the issues addressed in the bill include:
Fund Merger. Combining the State Dentistry Fund and the State Dental Assisting Funds and two separate appropriations into one would create budgeting and accounting efficiencies.
DBC Attorney. Existing law authorizes the DBC to appoint its own attorney (BPC § 1616). However, the DBC does not currently have its own dedicated attorney. Legal representation in disciplinary prosecution is provided by the Attorney General’s Licensing Section, and the DCA offers counsel as part of the centralized services it provides to boards.
Foreign Dental Schools. Two foreign dental schools are currently approved by the DBC: the University De La Salle School of Dentistry, located in Leon, Guanajuato, Mexico, and the State of Medicine and Pharmacy “Nicolae Testemintanu” of the Republic of Moldova. The background paper suggests DBC does not have the resources or expertise to evaluate foreign dental schools.
Probation Disclosure. Last year, Senate Bill 1448 (Hill), Chapter 570, Statutes of 2018, enacted the Patient’s Right to Know Act of 2018, requiring various healing arts licensees on probation for certain offenses to provide their patients with information about their probation status prior to the patient’s first visit following the probationary order beginning July 1, 2019. Licensees covered by the bill include physicians and surgeons, podiatrists, chiropractors, acupuncturists, and naturopathic doctors. The bill did not, however, include dentists. This bill would include dentists to existing law’s provisions.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
BUSINESS, PROFESSIONS AND ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT
Senator Steven Glazer, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: Hearing Date: July 8, 2019
Author: | |||
Version: | July 2, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Sarah Mason | ||
Subject:
SUMMARY: Extends the operations of the Dental Board of California (DBC) until January 1, 2024 and makes other changes to the Dental Practice Act (Act).
Existing law:
- Establishes the DBC within the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to regulate the practice of dentistry. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 1600 et seq.)
- Subjects the DBC and its Executive Officer to repeal on January 1, 2020, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2020, deletes or extends that date. (BPC § 1601.1)
This bill:
- Extends the operations of the Dental Board of California (DBC) until January 1, 2024.
- As of July 1, 2022, merges the Dental Assistant Fund with the State Dentistry Fund.
- Authorizes each appointing authority, rather than only the Governor as authorized under current law, to remove any appointed member of the board from office at any time who was appointed by that authority for the board members’ continued neglect of duty required by the Act or for incompetency or unprofessional or dishonorable conduct.
- Requires DBC to appoint its own attorney by July 1, 2020.
- Requires applicants to for licensure to practice dentistry to provide a signed release allowing disclosure of information from the National Practitioner Data Bank and verification of registration status with the federal Drug Enforcement Administration and requires DBC to review this information to determine if it presents sufficient evidence to warrant the submission of additional information from the applicant or the denial of the application for licensure.
- Requires DBC to report on how many other states have recognized licensure by portfolio examination at the time of its next sunset review.
- Requires schools seeking approval as foreign dental school to complete the international consultative and accreditation process with the Commission on Dental Accreditation of the American Dental Association (CODA) or a comparable accrediting body approved by DBC. Requires, by January 1, 2024, in order to remain an approved foreign dental school in the state, all schools previously approved by DBC as a foreign dental school to have successfully completed the international consultative and accreditation process with CODA or a comparable accrediting body approved by DBC.
- As of July 1, 2020, requires DBC licensees to provide a patient or the patient's guardian or healthcare surrogate with a disclosure prior to the patient's first visit if the licensee is on probation on or after July 1, 2020 that contains the following:
- The licensee's probationary status.
- The length of the probation and the end date.
- All practice restrictions placed on the licensee by DBC.
- DBC's phone number.
- An explanation of how the patient can find further information on the licensee's probation on the licensee's profile page on DBC’s online license information site.
- Requires licensees to obtain a signed copy of the disclosure outlined above from the patient or the patient's guardian or health surrogate. Provides an exemption to the disclosure requirement if the patient is unconscious or otherwise unable to comprehend the disclosure and if a guardian or health care surrogate is unavailable to comprehend the disclosure and sign the receipt of disclosure; if the visit occurs in an emergency room and the licensee who will be treating the patient during the visit is not known to the patient until immediately prior to the start of the visit and; if the licensee does not have a direct treatment relationship with the patient.
- Requires compliance with the notification requirements above if there is a final adjudication by DBC following an administrative hearing, or admitted findings or prima facie showing in a stipulated settlement establishing any of the following:
- The commission of any act of sexual abuse, misconduct or relations with a patient or client.
- Drug or alcohol abuse directly resulting in harm to patients or the extent that such use impairs the ability of the licensee to practice safely.
- Criminal conviction involving harm to patient safety or health.
- Inappropriate prescribing resulting in harm to patients and a probationary period of five years or more.
- Requires DBC licensees to comply with the notification requirements above if an accusation or statement of issues alleged that the licensee committed any of the acts in a) to d) above in situations where the licensee pleas no-contest or agrees to a similar compromise that does not include any prima facie showing or admission of guilt of fact but does include an express acknowledgement that notification would serve to protect the public interest.
- Requires DBC, on and after July 1, 2020, to provide information about licensees on probation and licensees practicing under probationary licenses on the licensee’s profile page on DBC’s license information website.
- Makes failure to review diagnostic digital or conventional radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging suitable for orthodontia prior to the diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or use of orthodontic appliances unprofessional conduct.
- Specifies that the required notice to patients informing them that a practitioner is licensed, for purposes of receiving services through telehealth, must be accessible electronically for patients receiving dental services through telehealth. Requires any entity that provides a service authorized under the Act through teledentistry to make the name and state license number of any dentist providing services available and makes a violation of this requirement unprofessional conduct.
- Makes numerous technical and clarifying changes to the Act.
FISCAL EFFECT: This bill is keyed fiscal by Legislative Counsel. According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations analysis dated
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. The Author is the Sponsor of this bill. According to the Author, This bill is one of five “sunset review bills” authored by the Assembly Business and Professions Committee. This bill extends the sunset date for the DBC, as recommended during joint sunset review oversight hearings held in February and March.
- Background.
Sunset Review. Beginning in 2018, the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee and the Assembly Committee on Business and Professions (Committees) began their comprehensive sunset review oversight of 10 regulatory entities and the DCA including: Board of Accountancy, California State Athletic Commission, Board of Barbering and Cosmetology, Bureau of Security and Investigative Services, California Architects Board and Landscape Architects Technical Committee, Cemetery and Funeral Bureau, Court Reporters Board of California, DBC, Board for Professional Engineers, Land Surveyors and Geologists, and the Contractors State License Board. This bill makes changes to the DBC and Act as a result of the DBC’s 2018 sunset review report and its subsequent participation in a sunset review oversight hearing on March 5, 2019.
DBC. The DBC is responsible for licensing and regulating dental professionals in California. The DBC was originally created as the Board of Dental Examiners in 1885 during the twenty-sixth session of the California Legislature. Enacted “to insure the better education of practitioners of dental surgery, and to regulate the practice of dentistry in the State of California,” the original Dental Practice Act required all persons engaged in the practice of dentistry to register with a board of appointed professionals, with a registration fee of one dollar. The Act further allowed for dentists to voluntarily appear before the board of examiners to demonstrate their “knowledge and skill in dental surgery” in exchange for state certification of their qualifications.
Today, the DBC licenses an estimated 89,000 dental professionals, of which approximately 43,500 are fully licensed dentists; 44,500 are registered dental assistants (RDAs); and 1,700 are registered dental assistants in extended functions (RDAEFs). The DBC is also responsible for setting the duties and functions of an estimated 50,000 unlicensed dental assistants. Dental hygienists are licensed and regulated by a separate and distinct regulatory body, the Dental Hygiene Board of California.
Statute defines dentistry as “the diagnosis or treatment, by surgery or other method, of diseases and lesions and the correction of malpositions of the human teeth, alveolar process, gums, jaws, or associated structures; and such diagnosis or treatment may include all necessary related procedures as well as the use of drugs, anesthetic agents, and physical evaluation.” Dentists are health care practitioners authorized to write and issue prescriptions for controlled substances. Oral and maxillofacial surgeons are a surgically trained specialty of dentistry that have completed additional residency requirements.
The Dental Assisting Council within the DBC makes recommendations regarding the DBC’s regulation of dental assistants. Three categories of dental assistants are regulated by the DBC, distinguished by what duties they may perform based on their training. This includes unlicensed dental assistants, authorized to perform “basic supportive dental procedures”; registered dental assistants, authorized to perform more complex duties; and registered dental assistants in extended functions, authorized to perform additional restorative procedures following diagnosis and intervention by a dentist.
The DBC’s regulation of dental professionals includes licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary responsibilities. The DBC reviews and approves applications for initial or renewed licensure, determining whether an applicant has sufficient education and training to possess a license, certification, or permit. The DBC also engages in disciplinary activities through its own enforcement division, investigating potential violations of the Act and taking action against professional misconduct. The DBC additionally monitors licensees who have been placed on probation and manages a diversion program for licensees whose practice may be impaired due to abuse of drugs or alcohol.
DBC is composed of eight practicing dentists, one registered dental hygienist, one registered dental assistant, and five public members. Of the eight practicing dentists, one is required to be a member of a faculty of any California dental college, and one is required to be a dentist practicing in a nonprofit community clinic. The professional members are required to have been in practice for a minimum of five years prior to their appointment. Each board member may serve a maximum of two full four-year terms. The Governor is responsible for appointing three of the public members, the registered dental hygienist member, the dental assistant member, and the eight licensed dentist members of the board; the Speaker of the Assembly and the Senate Committee on Rules are responsible for appointing one additional public member each. Board staff for the DBC is led by an Executive Officer, who is exempt from civil service and appointed by the board with approval from the DCA.
Response to Issues Raised During Sunset Review Oversight. The background paper prepared by staff of the Assembly Business and Professions Committee for the sunset review oversight hearing of DBC identified 15 issues for the DBC to address. Some of the issues required legislation to resolve while others were related to the Commission’s administrative and regulatory processes.
Fund Merger. Following discussions conducted during the DBC’s last sunset review, board staff researched the feasibility of merging the State Dentistry Fund and the State Dental Assisting Funds, in consultation with the DCA’s Budget Office. Combining of the two separate funds and two separate appropriations into one would create efficiencies in budgeting and accounting processes in the long term and make budgeting issues simpler to understand. DCA’s Budget Office has stated its belief that the long-term benefits of merging the two funds outweigh the short-term concerns and increased workload. In light of the extensive research that was conducted into the feasibility and benefits of merging the Dentistry and Dental Assisting Funds in the long-term, the background paper for DBC recommended that statute should be amended to facilitate the process of combining the funds. This bill implements the recommendation to merge the funds.
DBC Attorney. Business and Professions Code § 1616 expressly provides the DBC with “full power to … appoint its own attorney, prescribe his duties and fix his compensation.” However, the DBC does not currently have its own dedicated attorney. Legal representation in disciplinary prosecution is provided by the Attorney General’s Licensing Section, and the DCA offers counsel as part of the centralized services it provides to boards, as needed to assist with rulemaking, address legal issues that arise, and support compliance with open meeting laws. Dedicated board counsel is, however, considered to provide substantial value when questions of law occur regularly enough to warrant the presence of attorney who specializes in a board’s Practice Act and areas of jurisdiction. It is under this line of thinking that the Legislature has authorized the DBC to appoint its own lawyer, and any reasons for that position remaining unfilled should be discussed before the committees. This bill requires DBC to appoint its own attorney by July 1, 2020.
Portfolio Examination. Licensure by portfolio is a recently enacted alternative pathway to licensure as a dentist in California, available to applicants since November 2014. Under portfolio licensure requirements, instead of taking a single examination, students build a portfolio of completed clinical experiences and clinical competency examinations in six subject areas over the normal course of their clinical training during dental school. The portfolio option gives students an alternative to being tested on a live patient over the course of one weekend, which is the method of assessing competency used in the Western Regional Examination Board exam process, as well as other examinations throughout the country. The applicant’s portfolio is assessed for demonstration of experiences and competencies, following a letter of good standing signed by the dean of the applicant’s dental school. The applicant must also pass Parts I and II of the National Board Written Examinations. The portfolio process offers multiple benefits to students and patients, including letting students extend treatment over multiple patient visits, which reduces the stress of a one-time testing event and more closely simulates real-world care. The pathway provides an opportunity for patients to receive follow-up treatment as needed; and provides a method by which students are ready for licensure upon graduation.
Concerns have been raised that because California has the distinction of being one of the first states to pursue this method of qualifying for licensure, dentists who have obtained their license through the portfolio pathway may face difficulties when seeking reciprocal acknowledgment of qualification by other states. The DBC’s successful implementation of licensure by portfolio continues to be an important demonstration of the effectiveness of what could be considered regulatory innovation. However, if applicants are denied license portability as a result of the novel nature of this examination alternative, the DBC should consider whether additional steps should be taken to safeguard licensee mobility. This bill requires DBC to report on how many other states have recognized licensure by portfolio examination at the time of its next sunset review.
Foreign Dental Schools. Statute enacted in 1998 granted the DBC responsibility for approving foreign dental schools, recognizing that “graduates of foreign dental schools who have received an education that is equivalent to that of accredited institutions in the United States and that adequately prepares their students for the practice of dentistry shall be subject to the same licensure requirements as graduates of approved dental schools or colleges.” Schools outside the United States and Canada seeking approval to graduate students eligible for licensure as dentists in California must apply to the DBC and undergo an evaluation process, with renewal applications required every seven years.
The DBC’s investigative process for reviewing applications from foreign dental schools is outlined in regulations. Schools are required to meet basic curriculum requirements as well as administrative and programmatic standards to ensure a certain degree of equivalency with schools operating within the United States. An “onsite inspection and evaluation team” appointed by the board is then responsible for making “a comprehensive, qualitative onsite review of each institution that applies for approval.” This review includes examining documents, inspecting facilities, auditing classes, and interviewing administrators, faculty, and students. Reviewed schools are required to reimburse the DBC for all reasonable costs incurred by staff and the site team relating to the inspection. The DBC must notify the school of whether it has been approved within 225 days of a completed application.
Two foreign dental schools are currently approved by the DBC: the University De La Salle School of Dentistry, located in Leon, Guanajuato, Mexico, and the State of Medicine and Pharmacy “Nicolae Testemintanu” of the Republic of Moldova. The Moldova dental school Moldova received a two-year provisional approval in December 2016 and full approval in May 2018. Subsequently, members of the DBC grew concerned that additional details of the Moldova school’s recruitment program and admission standards were not disclosed in the application or to the DBC site evaluation team during the review. During the DBC’s November 2018 meeting, the board discussed a recently uncovered flyer advertising the Moldova school titled “Become a dentist… while living in Europe!” The flyer was widely distributed in California through “the University of Moldova USA Inc.”—a separate entity operating an admissions office for the Moldova dental school based in Encino, CA. According to the DBC, the relationship between the dental school and the entity in Encino “was never divulged during the site evaluation conducted in October 2016.” It is apparent that the Moldova dental school has actively recruited students in California, promising DBC-approved dental school education (taught entirely in English) without the need for a four-year college degree. Further, the tuition charged to students recruited in the United States appears to be four times that of Moldovan students. To date, representatives of the Moldova school have not thoroughly responded to the DBC’s questions and concerns. However, representatives of the school will attend the May 2019 meeting to address the DBC’s concerns.
As the DBC continues to debate what appropriate action should be taken concerning the Moldova school’s approval status, the DBC has concluded that it does not have the resources or expertise to sufficiently evaluate foreign dental schools. During the DBC’s last sunset review, an issue was raised regarding whether the DBC should “consider heavier reliance on accrediting organizations for foreign school approvals if those options become available.” Currently, dental schools established within the United States but outside California are approved by CODA, which further recognizes Canadian dental schools approved by the Commission on Dental Accreditation of Canada. CODA has established an International Accreditation process designed to assess and approve foreign dental schools through robust investigation and evaluation. To date, CODA has yet to approve any foreign dental schools through this lengthy process. However, CODA has begun to evaluate applications for approval, including one submitted by a school in Leon, Guanajuato, Mexico. This bill requires schools seeking approval as foreign dental school to complete the international consultative and accreditation process with CODA or a comparable accrediting body approved by DBC and requires, by January 1, 2024, in order to remain an approved foreign dental school in the state, all schools previously approved by DBC as a foreign dental school to have successfully completed the international consultative and accreditation process with CODA or a comparable accrediting body approved by DBC.
Consumer Products. Within the many professions and occupations regulated in California, the advent of new technologies has enhanced access and ease for service to consumers. Dentistry and oral health is no exception, and individuals seeking a “better smile” are able to participate in a growing marketplace for products enabling consumers to improve their oral health and appearance from the comfort of their homes. Like with all services contained within the scope of a profession licensed by the state, however, there is benefit to analyzing the balance of convenience and any potential risk of consumer harm.
A growing market for self-applied dental treatments is in the field of orthodontia. Several companies offer aligners that can be customized for the consumer at either a boutique storefront or through an at-home kit mailed to the customer. Through these products, an individual is able to realign the positioning of their teeth into what they believe will be a straighter smile. While companies offering such products describe the mailed aligners as being “reviewed” by a dental professional through the use of remote tele-dentistry, it is possible for a consumer to go through the realignment process without ever actually consulting with a licensed dentist. This may be cause for some concern in light of reported incidents where teeth have been misaligned when using at-home aligners. Dental boards in other states have begun to take action against the marketers of such products, and ongoing litigation has resulted. This bill makes failure to review diagnostic digital or conventional radiographs or other equivalent bone imaging suitable for orthodontia prior to the diagnosis and correction of malpositions of human teeth or use of orthodontic appliances unprofessional conduct. The bill also specifies that the required notice to patients informing them that a practitioner is licensed, for purposes of receiving services through telehealth, must be accessible electronically for patients receiving dental services through telehealth. The bill also requires any entity that provides a service authorized under the Act through teledentistry to make the name and state license number of any dentist providing services available and makes a violation of this requirement unprofessional conduct.
Probation Disclosure. Last year, Senate Bill 1448 (Hill, Chapter 570, Statutes of 2018) enacted the Patient’s Right to Know Act of 2018, requiring various healing arts licensees on probation for certain offenses to provide their patients with information about their probation status prior to the patient’s first visit following the probationary order beginning July 1, 2019. Licensees covered by the bill include physicians and surgeons, podiatrists, chiropractors, acupuncturists, and naturopathic doctors. The bill did not, however, include dentists. The DBC background paper noted “If the ultimate objective of probation disclosure is protecting patients from being unknowingly placed in vulnerable contexts with licensees placed on probation for serious offenses, there is no clear reason as to why dentists should be treated differently and excluded from the patient notification requirement.” This bill requires licensees on probation to disclose their probation status to patients if they are on probation for specified violations of law.
- Arguments in Support. Supporters believe extending the operations of DBC is in the public’s interest.
The Center for Public Interest Law (CPIL) supports this bill if it is amended to “reform the Board’s composition to guard against potentially anticompetitive conduct by the Board, and to bring DBC’s composition more in line with other boards under the umbrella of the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA)…CPIL has long argued that regulatory boards composed in majority of licensee members — who can
then control their own regulation and stand to benefit from anticompetitive decisions the board makes — violates federal antitrust law. In 2015, the U.S. Supreme Court validated CPIL’s position in North Carolina State Board of Dental Examiners v. FTC, __U.S.__, 135 S.Ct 1101 (2015) (“North Carolina”). In that case, the Court recognized the inherent conflict of interest that exists when a state licensing board is controlled by members of the profession regulated by that board, and unequivocally held that state regulatory boards are not immune from federal antitrust scrutiny unless they are controlled by public members (and not “active market participant” licensees) or the state has created a mechanism to actively supervise the acts and decisions of these boards to ensure they benefit the public, and not merely the professions themselves. Since the issuance of the
North Carolina decision, CPIL has participated in public hearings, submitted numerous letters explaining the decision, and supported legislation that would properly implement the decision…
“The Dental Board is neither controlled by public members, nor is it subject to “active state supervision” as that term is defined in the decision. DBC is composed of ten dental professionals and five public members. This composition is wildly inconsistent with the composition of most other DCA boards, which either have a public member majority (for example, the California Board of Accountancy) or have a fairly even balance between licensee members and public members. The Medical Board is composed of eight physicians and seven public members. The Board of Pharmacy is composed of seven pharmacists and six public members. DBC’s longstanding supermajority of dental professional members improperly allows dentists to control their own regulation and automatically risks a North Carolina violation — which carries with it the possibility of criminal charges, treble damages, and attorneys’ fees. While no California board has yet been subject to a lawsuit under North Carolina, regulatory boards in other states have, and it is just a matter of time for California boards that maintain a licensee member majority, because California lacks an “active state supervision” mechanism…Dental Board members make final disciplinary and other policy decisions which are not subject to review or ratification by the Department or any other state agency…
“CPIL strongly recommends that the authors of AB 1519 amend the bill to phase out at least two of the licensee members of the Board, and replace those positions with public member positions instead. This would align DBC’s composition with other health care boards, and protect consumers against potential anticompetitive conduct by the Board.”
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support:
California Dental Association
Center for Public Interest Law.
Dental Hygiene Board of California
Opposition:
None on file as of July 3, 2019.
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1519
Author:(Committee on Business and Professions)
As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Extends the sunset date for the Dental Board of California (DBC) until January 1, 2024.
COMMENTS:
The DBC is responsible for licensing and regulating dental professionals in California. The DBC licenses an estimated 89,000 dental professionals, of which approximately 43,500 are fully licensed dentists; 44,500 are registered dental assistants (RDAs); and 1,700 are registered dental assistants in extended functions (RDAEFs). The DBC is also responsible for setting the duties and functions of an estimated 50,000 unlicensed dental assistants. Dental hygienists are licensed and regulated by a separate and distinct regulatory body, the Dental Hygiene Board of California.
Statute defines dentistry as "the diagnosis or treatment, by surgery or other method, of diseases and lesions and the correction of malpositions of the human teeth, alveolar process, gums, jaws, or associated structures; and such diagnosis or treatment may include all necessary related procedures as well as the use of drugs, anesthetic agents, and physical evaluation." Dentists are health care practitioners authorized to write and issue prescriptions for controlled substances. Oral and maxillofacial surgeons are a surgically trained specialty of dentistry that have completed additional residency requirements.
The Dental Assisting Council within the DBC makes recommendations regarding the DBC's regulation of dental assistants. Three categories of dental assistants are regulated by the DBC, distinguished by what duties they may perform based on their training. This includes unlicensed dental assistants, authorized to perform "basic supportive dental procedures"; registered dental assistants, authorized to perform more complex duties; and registered dental assistants in extended functions, authorized to perform additional restorative procedures following diagnosis and intervention by a dentist.
The DBC's regulation of dental professionals includes licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary responsibilities. The DBC reviews and approves applications for initial or renewed licensure, determining whether an applicant has sufficient education and training to possess a license, certification, or permit. The DBC also engages in disciplinary activities through its own enforcement division, investigating potential violations of the Dental Practice Act and taking action against professional misconduct. The DBC additionally monitors licensees who have been placed on probation and manages a diversion program for licensees whose practice may be impaired due to abuse of drugs or alcohol.
According to the Author:
This bill is authored by the Assembly Business and Professions Committee. This bill is one of five "sunset review bills" authored by the Assembly Business and Professions Committee. There are also five sunset review bills authored by the Chair of the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee. This bill extends the sunset date for the Commission, as recommended during the Joint Sunset Review Hearings held in February and March.
Arguments in Support:
The California Dental Association (CDA) supports this bill. CDA states that it "appreciates the committee's attention to … important matters in the Sunset review to ensure the safe and effective provision of dental care to Californians; we look forward to continued collaboration with the board in the coming years."
Arguments in Opposition:
None on file.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, $17.7 million annually until January 1, 2024, to maintain current operations of the DBC.
VOTES:
ASM BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS: 19-0-1
YES: Low, Brough, Bloom, Chen, Cunningham, Dahle, Eggman, Fong, Gipson, Gloria, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Obernolte, Quirk-Silva, Ting
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chiu
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 18-0-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bigelow, Bloom, Bonta, Brough, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Fong, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Obernolte, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
UPDATED:
VERSION: February 22, 2019
CONSULTANT: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301 FN: 0000586
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1519
Author:(Committee on Business and Professions) – As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
Policy Committee: | Business and Professions | Vote: | 19 - 0 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill extends the sunset date for the Dental Board of California (DBC) until January 1, 2024.
FISCAL EFFECT:
$17.7 million annually (State Dentistry Fund), until January 1, 2024, to maintain current operations of the DBC.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill extends the sunset of DBC. Boards and bureaus are generally reviewed and their sunsets extended on a four-year timeline.
- DBC. The DBC licenses and regulates dentists, registered dental assistant, and registered dental assistants in extended functions. Following a comprehensive fee audit conducted in 2015 and legislation passed that year that increased caps on DBC’s fees, the DBC raised its fees via regulation in 2017. Revenues and expenditures are now well-aligned, but the DBC indicates new workload may lead to increased costs and a structural imbalance by 2022-23.
- Related Legislation. AB 1520, AB 1521 and AB 1522, as well as SB 606, SB 607, SB 608, SB 609 and SB 610, all authored by the respective Committee on Business and Professions, contain sunset review provisions for other boards and bureaus.
Analysis Prepared by: Lisa Murawski / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 23, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON BUSINESS AND PROFESSIONS
Evan Low, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1519
Author:(Committee on Business and Professions) – As Introduced Ver:February 22, 2019
SUBJECT: Healing arts: Dental Board of California.
SUMMARY: Extends the sunset date for the Dental Board of California until January 1, 2024.
EXISTING LAW:
- Authorizes the Dental Board of California (DBC) under the Department of Consumer Affairs (DCA) to regulate the practice of dentistry. (Business and Professions Code (BPC) §§ 1600 et seq.)
- Subjects the DBC and its Executive Officer to repeal on January 1, 2020, unless a later enacted statute, that is enacted before January 1, 2020, deletes or extends that date. (BPC § 1601.1)
THIS BILL:
- Extends operation of the DBC until January 1, 2024.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown; this bill is keyed fiscal by the Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Purpose. This bill is authored by the Assembly Business and Professions Committee. This bill is one of five “sunset review bills” authored by the Assembly Business and Professions Committee. There are also five sunset review bills authored by the Chair of the Senate Business, Professions and Economic Development Committee. This bill extends the sunset date for the Commission, as recommended during the Joint Sunset Review Hearings held in February and March. The other Assembly sunset bills are: AB 1519 (Committee on Business and Professions), relating to the Dental Board of California, AB 1520 (Committee on Business and Professions), relating to the Court Reporters Board of California, AB 1521 (Committee on Business and Professions), relating to the California Board of Accountancy, and AB 1521 (Committee on Business and Professions), relating to the Board of Professional Engineers, Land Surveyors, and Geologists. The Senate sunset bills review are: SB 606 (Glazer) relating to the Cemetery and Funeral Bureau, SB 607 (Glazer) relating to the California Board of Barbering and Cosmetology, SB 608 (Glazer) relating to the Board of Architects and Landscape Architects, SB 609 (Glazer) relating to Bureau of Security and Investigative Services, and SB 610 (Glazer) relating to the California Contractors State License Board.
Background.
Overview of the DBC. The (DBC is responsible for licensing and regulating dental professionals in California. The DBC was originally created as the Board of Dental Examiners in 1885 during the twenty-sixth session of the California Legislature. Enacted “to insure the better education of practitioners of dental surgery, and to regulate the practice of dentistry in the State of California,” the original Dental Practice Act required all persons engaged in the practice of dentistry to register with a board of appointed professionals, with a registration fee of one dollar. The Act further allowed for dentists to voluntarily appear before the board of examiners to demonstrate their “knowledge and skill in dental surgery” in exchange for state certification of their qualifications.
Today, the DBC licenses an estimated 89,000 dental professionals, of which approximately 43,500 are fully licensed dentists; 44,500 are registered dental assistants (RDAs); and 1,700 are registered dental assistants in extended functions (RDAEFs). The DBC is also responsible for setting the duties and functions of an estimated 50,000 unlicensed dental assistants. Dental hygienists are licensed and regulated by a separate and distinct regulatory body, the Dental Hygiene Board of California.
Statute defines dentistry as “the diagnosis or treatment, by surgery or other method, of diseases and lesions and the correction of malpositions of the human teeth, alveolar process, gums, jaws, or associated structures; and such diagnosis or treatment may include all necessary related procedures as well as the use of drugs, anesthetic agents, and physical evaluation.” Dentists are health care practitioners authorized to write and issue prescriptions for controlled substances. Oral and maxillofacial surgeons are a surgically trained specialty of dentistry that have completed additional residency requirements.
The Dental Assisting Council within the DBC makes recommendations regarding the DBC’s regulation of dental assistants. Three categories of dental assistants are regulated by the DBC, distinguished by what duties they may perform based on their training. This includes unlicensed dental assistants, authorized to perform “basic supportive dental procedures”; registered dental assistants, authorized to perform more complex duties; and registered dental assistants in extended functions, authorized to perform additional restorative procedures following diagnosis and intervention by a dentist.
The DBC’s regulation of dental professionals includes licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary responsibilities. The DBC reviews and approves applications for initial or renewed licensure, determining whether an applicant has sufficient education and training to possess a license, certification, or permit. The DBC also engages in disciplinary activities through its own enforcement division, investigating potential violations of the Dental Practice Act and taking action against professional misconduct. The DBC additionally monitors licensees who have been placed on probation and manages a diversion program for licensees whose practice may be impaired due to abuse of drugs or alcohol.
Staff. As established in the Dental Practice Act, board staff for the DBC is led by an Executive Officer, who is exempt from civil service and appointed by the board with approval from the Director of Consumer Affairs. Karen Fischer has been Executive Officer for the past six years. Statute also establishes an additional management level staff position, “whose sole responsibilities shall be the management of matters related to dental assisting, including, but not limited to, education, examination, licensure, and enforcement.”
The DBC has a total of 74.3 authorized positions, of which 70.5 are currently filled. The DBC’s organizational chart is divided into divisions on Administration, Licensing & Examination, and Enforcement. Statute states that the DBC “shall have full power to employ all necessary investigators, clerical and other assistants and appoint its own attorney.” The DBC has its own dedicated investigators, led by an Enforcement Chief. However, as of March 5, 2019, no individual has been appointed to the dedicated attorney position expressly authorized for the DBC in statute.
Fiscal and Fund Analysis. Like other regulatory boards and bureaus under the Department of Consumer Affairs, the DBC receives no General Fund support and is operated solely through revenue derived from fees. Currently, fee moneys collected by the DBC are deposited into one of two Special Funds: the Dentistry Fund, which supports operating expenses & equipment (OE&E) and personnel services for the DBC’s regulation of dentists; and the Dental Assisting Fund, which supports OE&E and personnel services for RDAs and RDAEFs. These funds are not comingled and represent a distinguishing bifurcation of the DBC’s licensing and regulation of dentists and dental assistants, respectively.
The DBC has set its own objective of maintaining a three-month reserve in both of its funds. Both funds are currently solvent with a strong level of reserve funding. All loans previously made to the General Fund have been fully repaid with interest. The DBC notes, however, that due to the impending fiscal impact of recently enacted legislation, a structural imbalance is anticipated beginning Fiscal Year 2022-23. The DBC is currently working with the Department of Consumer Affairs Budget Office to develop a plan for addressing this potential shortfall.
The current health of the DBC funds is attributable to the board’s current fee structure. A fee increase for all licenses and permits was achieved in October 2017. For example, license renewal fees increased from $525 to $650; oral and maxillofacial surgery permit fees increased from $365 to $650; and initial application fees for RDA licensure increased from $20 to $120. Prior to that fee increase, the DBC had last adjusted its fee schedule with increases to the DDS renewal fee in 2014 and 2015, and most of the DBC’s fees had not been increased in 15 years. The 2017 fee adjustment followed a fee audit conducted to address potential expenditure increases related to the Consumer Protection Enforcement Initiative and the roll-out of the new BreEZe licensing technology.
Licensing. Statute directs that “protection of the public shall be the highest priority for the Dental Board in exercising its licensing and regulatory functions.” The Dental Practice Act, both directly within statute and through regulations promulgated by the DBC, establishes the requirements for licensure within the dental profession. The DBC’s Licensing Program is responsible for ensuring that licenses and permits are issued only to applicants who meet the minimum requirements and who have not done anything that would warrant denial.
Performance targets for the DBC’s licensure of dentistry are contained in regulations. These regulations set forth a variety of timeline expectations for the DBC to process an application for a license or permit. For example, issuance of a dental license is expected to be completed by the DBC within 90 days of receipt of a completed application; renewal applications are expected to be completed within 30 to 90 days.
Currently, the DBC is meeting these expectations. In 2018, initial application processing for a dental license by each pathway for licensure was completed on average of 27 days. Once an applicant has met all the requirements for a dental license based on the pathway applied for, a separate application for the issuance of a license number is required. Approval of the application and issuance of the license number is completed within 10 days. The processing of renewals was completed on average within 6 days.
Similar regulations lay out timeline expectations for the DBC’s Dental Assisting Program. Regulations state that the DBC should take no longer than 90 days to notify an applicant that their application is complete or deficient, with a final licensing decision within 180 days. License renewals are expected to be completed within 30 days with issuance within a maximum of 90 days.
The current average time from receipt of a completed RDA, RDAEF, Orthodontic Assistant (OA), or Dental Sedation Assistant (DSA) application to approval is 42 days. Upon approval of the application a license is issued to the applicant. An incomplete application is processed in an average of 145 days; these delays are a result of the applicant not providing the necessary information to complete the application process. The processing of renewals is completed on average within 14 days. The DBC is therefore also meeting the performance expectations for licensing of RDAs, RDAEFs, OAs, and DSAs.
On average over the past four years, the DBC has issued approximately 1,119 dental licenses; 1,896 RDA licenses; and 72 RDAEF licenses each year. There are currently 34,172 actively licensed dentists, 29,664 actively licensed RDAs, and 1,447 licensed RDAEFs. The volume of incoming applications has remained steady for nearly every licensing category over the past four years, with the exception of a 33% growth in Orthodontic Assistant permit applications. There are no licensing backlogs.
The DBC fingerprints all applicants as part of the application process, and the National Practitioners Data Bank is reviewed for disciplinary actions taken against applicants by regulators in other states. Beginning July 1, 2020, the process through which boards under the Department of Consumer Affairs may deny an application for licensure due to prior misconduct will have substantively changed. Causes for denial will be limited to criminal convictions reported on an applicant’s rap sheet, along with prior regulatory discipline. Nonviolent, nonsexual offenses will be washed out after seven years. In the past four years the DBC has denied one applicant for a dental license, one applicant for an oral conscious sedation permit, and 22 applicants for a registered dental assistant license.
The DBC currently inquires with applicants and licensees about whether the individual is serving in, or has previously served in, the military. The DBC has received approximately 319 responses to date. All renewal application fees charged by the DBC are waived for licensees who identify themselves as having active military status. In the prior fiscal year, the DBC has waived fees or requirements for 77 licensees. The DBC accepts military clinical practice hours toward satisfying clinical practice requirements, and the DBC will also accept military education, training and experience if the applicant lists this under the general work experience or education requirements for RDA, OA, and/or DSA licensing programs. Further, approximately 35 licenses were expedited in FY 2017/18 for licensed military spouses.
Education. Applicants for licensure are required to submit proof that they have met certain education requirements. For example, applicants for licensure as dentists must demonstrate that they have “completed at dental school or schools the full number of academic years of undergraduate courses required for graduation.” The DBC accepts the findings of the American Dental Association Commission on Dental Accreditation (CODA) when they approve or reapprove a dental school located within the United States. These schools are accredited and re-evaluated by CODA every seven years.
The DBC is responsible for the approval of all foreign dental schools eligible for fulfilling licensure requirements for dental professionals in California. Two international dental schools have been approved by the DBC: the University De La Salle School of Dentistry, located in Leon, Guanajuato, Mexico, and the State of Medicine and Pharmacy “Nicolae Testemintanu” of the Republic of Moldova. Approved foreign dental schools must also undergo reevaluation every seven years, and the DBC may at any time withdraw its approval of an institution that no longer meets the requirements of the Act.
The DBC is also responsible for approving all Dental Assistant Educational Programs and Courses, including Registered Dental Assistant Educational Programs, RDAEF Educational Programs, Coronal Polishing Courses, Orthodontic Assistant Permit Courses, and other courses whose requirements are outlined in board regulations. The approval of several Dental Assisting programs is an administrative responsibility shared with the Bureau for Private Postsecondary Education, which generally regulates private for-profit colleges.
The DBC has approved 97 Registered Dental Assisting Programs, 11 Registered Dental Assistant in Extended Functions Programs, 147 Orthodontic Assistant Permit Courses, 26 Dental Sedation Assistant Permit Courses, and numerous courses for Infection Control, Coronal Polish, Pit and Fissure Sealants, Radiation Safety, Interim Therapeutic Restorations, and Ultrasonic Scaling. These programs and courses are also reevaluated every seven years and may be disapproved if any program or course does not meet the requirements of the Dental Practice Act.
Continuing Education. Dental professionals licensed by the DBC are required to take continuing education as a condition of license renewal. Pursuant to regulations, the DBC has adopted standards for the continuing education of its licensees. At the time of license renewal, the licensee must certify completion of mandatory coursework and the minimum number of units required for each license and/or permit held.
Dentist licensees are required to complete a minimum of 50 units of continuing education, including mandatory coursework, during the two-year period immediately preceding the expiration of their license. RDA, RDAEF, OA, and DSA licensees are required to complete a minimum of 25 units of continuing education, including mandatory coursework, during the two-year period immediately preceding the expiration of their license. Unlicensed dental assistants in California must complete a DBC-approved eight-hour Infection Control course, a DBC-approved two-hour Dental Practice Act course, and a course in Basic Life Support through the American Red Cross or the American Heart Association.
As part of the renewal process, licensees certify under penalty of perjury that they have completed mandatory coursework and the have taken minimum number of units required for the active license or permit. The DBC also conducts random CE audits of one-twelfth of one percent of the total active licensing population for each license type (approximately 30 DDS and 30 RDA licensees per month). Audited licensees are required to supply certificates of completion as proof of meeting the continuing education requirements. As of April 30, 2018, approximately 1,050 DDS licenses were audited for continuing education, of which 195 licensees, or 18.5%, failed the audit. During that same time, approximately 405 RDA licensees were audited for continuing education. 183 of these licensees, or 45%, failed the audit.
There have been no changes made to these requirements over the last four years. However, the DBC is currently anticipating the promulgation of additional regulations to establish Basic Life Support equivalency standards to update this section in the near future. The DBC is also considering requiring additional mandatory continuing education relating to the risks of addiction associated with the use of Schedule II drugs in response to the opioid crisis.
The DBC is tasked with approving providers of continuing education for dental professionals. However, excluding mandatory courses, the DBC does not individually approve specific courses offered by that approved registered provider. Course outlines, brochures, and summaries are required as part of the application process. For mandated courses, the minimum requirements for course content must be adhered to, or the provider risks their registered status. Within the past four fiscal years, the DBC received approximately 523 registered education provider applications. Of these applications submitted, 413 providers were approved. Currently, the DBC does not audit CE providers.
Examination. In addition to the payment of fees and the completion of prelicensure education requirements, dentist applicants are required to make a final demonstration of their readiness to practice dentistry through one of several pathways.
- WREB Examination. Applicants may apply for licensure after passing the Western Regional Examining Board (WREB) examination. This examination tests clinical competence through the use of patients to evaluate candidates for licensure. The examination consists of Operative, Endodontics, and Comprehensive Treatment Planning sections, as well as an optional Periodontal section. The applicant must also pass Parts I and II of the National Board Written Examinations.
- Licensure by Credential. This pathway to licensure is available to dentists who are currently licensed to practice dentistry in another state. To be eligible for Licensure by Credential, the out-of-state dentist must prove that they have either been in active clinical practice or have been a full-time faculty member in an accredited dental education program and in active clinical practice for a total of at least 5,000 hours in five of the seven consecutive years preceding the date application.
- Licensure by Residency. As of February 2008, applicants may apply for licensure on the basis of having completed of a minimum of 12 months of a general practice residency or advanced education in general dentistry program approved by CODA. The applicant must also pass Parts I and II of the National Board Written Examinations, and must have graduated from a CODA-approved dental school.
- Licensure by Portfolio Examination. The Licensure by Portfolio Examination process has been available to dental applicants since November 2014. Under portfolio licensure requirements, instead of taking a single examination, students build a portfolio of completed clinical experiences and clinical competency examinations in six subject areas over the normal course of their clinical training during dental school. The portfolio option gives students in California an alternative to being tested on a live patient over the course of one weekend. The applicant’s portfolio is assessed for demonstration of experiences and competencies, following a letter of good standing signed by the dean of the applicant’s dental school. The applicant must also pass Parts I and II of the National Board Written Examinations.
Under statute, RDA applicants must pass three examinations: a computerized written general knowledge examination; a computerized law and ethics written examination; and a hands-on practical examination performed on a typodont, (a model of the oral cavity). However, the RDA practical examination was suspended in April 2017 following a review by the Office of Professional Examination Services (OPES) of the Department of Consumer Affairs. This suspension was subsequently extended until January 1, 2020 through Assembly Bill 1707 (Low, Chapter 174, Statutes of 2017).
The OPES review had determined that inconsistencies in different test site conditions, deficiencies in scoring criteria, poor calibration of examiners, and the lack of a clear definition of minimum acceptable competence indicated that the RDA practical examination did not meet critical psychometric standards. The OPES believed the presence of other examination requirements prompted a low risk in the practical examination’s suspension. To date, the DBC has not identified any resulting harm from the suspension.
Enforcement. The DBC investigates complaints against licensees through its Enforcement Division. Each year, the DBC receives an average of 3,568 complaints, which has remained consistent over the past four years. Once a complaint is investigated, the DBC decides whether to refer the case to the Attorney General to file an administrative accusation and seek disciplinary action. Filed cases are litigated and adjudicated by an Administrative Law Judge, with ultimate disciplinary action subject to a final vote by the board.
A series of Performance Measures have been put into place to evaluate the effectiveness of the DBC’s enforcement program. In many categories, the DBC is meeting expectations. For example, the target average time for a complaint to be received, assigned to an analyst, and fully investigated is 270 days. For the last three years, the average intake and investigation cycle time was 265 days.
For the entire enforcement process for cases resulting in formal discipline, the target average time is 540 days. Over the past four years, the average has been 886 days. This average falls short of the DBC’s performance measures, but represents an improvement over the 998-day average reported in the DBC’s prior sunset review.
The DBC prioritizes potential disciplinary cases based on guidelines outlined in the Department of Consumer Affair’s 2009 memorandum titled Complaint Prioritization for Health Care Agencies. These guidelines are integrated early in the process during complaint intake and followed throughout the investigation. The standard is for cases to be prioritized during complaint intake with prime consideration assigned to those cases where there has been or is likely to be imminent consumer harm.
Allegations involving patient death, sexual misconduct, pharmaceutical or substance abuse, or physical mental incapacity, as well as unlicensed activity, will receive an “urgent” priority, depending on the details of the allegation. These cases are immediately referred to a sworn investigator. Cases prioritized as “urgent” may reveal the need for immediate action—for example, obtaining an interim suspension order, a temporary restraining order, or compelling a licensee to undergo a mental or physical examination to determine their ability to practice.
Complaints and investigations evaluated as having a “high” priority level include allegations relating to actions that do not pose an immediate threat to the public’s health, safety, or welfare. For example, cases alleging negligence or incompetence, physical or mental abuse (without injury), prescription-related allegations, unlicensed activity, aiding and abetting unlicensed activity, or multiple prior complaints. Depending on the facts behind the allegation, high priority cases may be assigned to a sworn Investigator, or to non-sworn staff. These cases are then also prioritized by investigators based on caseload.
Complaints deemed to be “routine” may include allegations relating to general quality of care, billing fraud, patient abandonment, documentation/records, conviction notifications, out-of-state discipline, and malpractice settlements and judgments. These “routine” investigations may be assigned to investigators or enforcement staff. After assignment, these too are prioritized within each investigator’s caseload.
Many investigated cases do not go to administrative hearing, but are instead settled with the Respondent. Over the past four years, 136 pre-accusation cases were settled. This included 29 probationary licenses, 35 surrenders, 8 diversion referrals and 64 citations. The number of post-accusation cases settled was 201 and included 60 public reprimands, 97 probation orders, and 44 surrenders. 72 cases went to hearing. Overall, 26% of cases resulted in administrative hearing and 52% resulted in settlements.
In addition to full disciplinary action against licensees, the DBC has cite and fine authority. Citations may be used when patient harm is not found, but the quality of care provided to the consumer is substandard. When issuing citations, the DBC’s goal is not to be punitive. Rather, the DBC seeks to protect consumers by getting the subject dentist’s attention, re-educating them, and emphasizing the importance of following dental practices that fall within the community’s standard of care. A variety of factors are considered when deciding whether to issue a citation. The issuance of citations has increased each year—there was a total of 47 citations in FY 2015/16; 56 citations in FY 2016/17; and 64 citations in FY 17/18. Citations are commonly issued to licensees for violations such as failure to produce patient records, failure to follow Infection Control guidelines, and unprofessional conduct.
In addition to using citations to address less egregious violations that would not result in meaningful discipline, the DBC views citation as a means of establishing a public record of an event that might otherwise have been closed without action, and thereby remain nondisclosable. Moreover, citations can address skills and training concerns promptly. In the event that a licensee fails to pay their fine, a hold is placed on the license and it cannot be renewed without payment of the renewal fee and the fine amount. Statute also authorizes the DBC to take disciplinary action for failure to pay a fine within 30 days.
Diversion. Statute directs the DBC to “seek ways and means to identify and rehabilitate licentiates whose competency may be impaired due to abuse of dangerous drugs or alcohol, so that licentiates so afflicted may be treated and returned to the practice of dentistry in a manner that will not endanger the public health and safety.” The DBC has fulfilled this mandate through its Diversion Program. As previously discussed, the DBC has created two Diversion Evaluation Committees—one in Southern and one in Northern California—to manage the Diversion Program. Quarterly meetings are traditionally scheduled in Los Angeles and Sacramento, with four meetings per year for each committee.
The Diversion Program is a voluntary, confidential program that offers an alternative to traditional disciplinary actions for dental licensees whose practice may be impaired due to chemical dependency. The goal of the Diversion Program is to protect the public by early identification of impaired dentists and dental assistants and by providing licensees access to appropriate intervention programs and treatment services. Public safety is protected by suspension of practice, when needed, and by careful monitoring of the participants. Any California licensed dental professional residing in the state and experiencing an alcohol or drug abuse problem is eligible for admission into the program.
A licensee seeking help for substance abuse issues may self-refer themselves by proactively contacting the Diversion Program. Licensees may also be referred by enforcement staff as a result of an investigation, or as a probationary condition following a disciplinary order. Diversion Evaluation Committee members review the history and profiles of applying licensees for consideration into the program and determining eligibility, or if they do not meet the criteria.
Upon acceptance into the program, Diversion Evaluation Committee members are responsible for developing an individual treatment plan that provides both structured support during a participant’s recovery and strict monitoring to ensure California dental consumers are not at risk from impaired licensees. Careful consideration is given in designing a plan that not only includes the appropriate means of rehabilitation, but also considers the participant’s ability to pay for such treatment. In more egregious cases, participants may be suspended from work with outpatient treatment and other structured support, or suspension with more costly in-patient treatment.
Upon entering the program, participants are each assigned a Diversion Evaluation Committee member as their case consultant. The case consultant is responsible for closely following the recovery progress of each of their assigned participant. The consultant leads the interview when their assigned participant appears before the full committee. Each participant must attend scheduled Diversion Evaluation Committee meetings when face-to-face interviews allow the case consultant to monitor their appearance and conduct. During the meetings, Diversion Evaluation Committee members will also consider participant requests for contract changes. Some examples include requests to: reduce or exchange health support group/AA/NA meetings, schedule vacation trips, increase work hours, or change work site monitors.
Depending on the progress observed, Diversion Evaluation Committee members can increase or decrease biological fluid testing times, (including order back-to-back or additional weekend tests), temporarily suspend a participant from practice, or mandate inpatient treatment. In addition to the monthly fees, participants are required to pay the cost of all biological fluid tests ordered (approximately $62.50 per test), and the costs to attend any inpatient or outpatient treatment modalities ordered by the Diversion Evaluation Committee.
Decisions to terminate a participant from the Diversion Program are also made by the Diversion Evaluation Committee. The committee shall determine, based upon the recommendation of both the Diversion Program Manager and the assigned case consultant, whether to terminate participation in the program. Termination can be for failing to comply with the treatment program, failing to derive benefit from the treatment plan, or testing positive on more than one occasion and being deemed a public risk.
Successful completion of the program is granted by the Diversion Evaluation Committee if the participant has demonstrated all of the following:
- The ability to refrain from the use of alcohol and drugs;
- A sound understanding of addiction;
- A commitment to recovery;
- An acceptable relapse prevention plan; and
- A transition period of at least one year, during which time they demonstrate that they are in recovery.
Public Information Policies. The DBC maintains an email list of all interested parties and sends out emails to these individuals each time something new is posted on the website. All board meeting materials are posted online at least one week prior to each meeting, along with draft minutes from the prior meeting. Meeting materials and approved final meeting minutes remain online indefinitely.
The DBC has been webcasting all of the public board and committee meetings since 2012, and plans to continue webcasting all of its public board and committee meetings. Webcasts are archived online for three years. The DBC establishes the following year’s meeting dates at the August Board meeting and posts them on the website immediately.
Online Practice Issues. The DBC actively investigates and prosecutes individuals who dispense or furnish any dangerous drug or device on the internet for delivery to any person in this state without a prescription, as prohibited by law. If an individual is not licensed in California, the additional charge practicing dentistry without a license is also sought. The DBC regularly investigates inappropriate or illegal drug prescribing, although most is unrelated to internet sales. More frequently, the DBC receives complaints regarding online advertising violations. This often includes licensees who are claiming superiority in their treatments and products. Such complaints are typically dealt with by the use of cease and desist letters, as well as citations.
In advertising cases involving the use of neurotoxins or injectable fillers, the DBC investigates whether the products are offered for treatment of a bona fide dental condition or are offered for strictly cosmetic purposes. These cases may facilitate an undercover operation to confirm the illegitimate use which may result in a citation, administrative action against the licensee or criminal charges filed for unlicensed practice of dentistry or medicine.
The DBC has also received complaints of unlicensed denturists advertising to create dentures for customers without a prescription from a licensed dentist. These types of complaints may result in an undercover visit to confirm whether dentistry is taking place, which could result in furtherance of a search warrant, arrest and conviction, or merely an investigator confirming that the location is a legitimate dental lab.
The DBC is currently looking closely at tele-dentistry statutes to determine if dental professional corporations are interpreting the law too broadly, or whether the DBC should seek statutory language to narrow the application of tele-dentistry in order to ensure public protection. Additionally, the DBC is in the process of gathering background information on the newly recognized specialty of dental radiology to determine whether utilizing dental radiologists, outside the state, would be unlicensed activity.
BreEZe. The BreEZe computer system was approved in 2009 and was intended to replace the DCA’s outdated legacy systems. The transition to this new computer system was scheduled incrementally in three phases referred to as “Releases.” Ten boards and bureaus were initially transitioned in Release I, and eight boards were placed in Release II. Release III has been suspended following cancellation of the vendor’s contract as the Department of Consumer Affairs works with each entity to identify a more effective technology solution for their business needs.
The DBC has been on BreEZe since January 19, 2016 as a Release II entity. The DBC participated extensively in the development and implementation of the BreEZe computer system. Board staff has also participated in ongoing testing, updates, and training programs and exercises to identify programmatic issues. The DBC will continue to test, evaluate, and communicate any issues or problems that arise to the Department of Consumer Affairs Office of Information Systems on an ongoing and as needed basis.
To fund the DBC’s transition to the BreEZe system, the Dentistry Fund has contributed approximately $1,758,598 and the Dental Assisting Fund has contributed approximately $1,251,522 from FY 2009-10 through FY 2016-17. This includes vendor costs, Department of Consumer Affairs staff, and other related costs. As the BreEZe program transitions from the project phase into the maintenance phase, the Department of Consumer Affairs anticipates the State Dentistry Fund will contribute approximately $1,404,000 from FY 2017-18 through FY 2019-20. The Dental Assisting Fund will contribute approximately $1,062,000 through the same period.
Workforce Development and Job Creation. The DBC is currently participating in two legislatively mandated programs to gather work force data in order to address issues relating to access to care. The DBC developed a work force survey, which each licensee (dentist and registered dental assistant) is required to complete upon initial licensure and at the time of license renewal. The survey does not include questions related to earnings and benefits, job satisfaction, temporary departure from practice, or future plans of working licensees.
The DBC participates in the Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development (OSHPD)’s health care workforce Clearinghouse Database design phase of its data collection project. The results of this data collection can be found in the OSHPD Facts Sheets for Dentists, RDAs, and RDHs that are available at: http://www.oshpd.ca.gov/hwdd/hwc.
Current Related Legislation. AB 1520 (Committee on Business and Professions), which is pending in this Committee, is the sunset review bill for the Court Reporters Board of California and would extend the board and it’s authority to appoint an executive officer until January 1, 2024.
AB 1521 (Committee on Business and Professions), which is pending in this Committee, is the sunset review bill for the California Board of Accountancy, would extend the board and its authorization to designate an executive officer to January 1, 2024, and would make various nonsubstantive changes.
AB 1522 (Committee on Business and Professions), which is pending in this Committee, is the sunset review bill for the Board for Professional Engineers, Land Surveyors, and Geologists and would extend the board and it’s authority to appoint an executive officer until January 1, 2024.
SB 606 (Glazer), which is pending in the Senate, is the sunset review bill for the Cemetery and Funeral bureau and would remove the time period requirement for the retaking of the embalmer’s examination, require the Bureau to examine the requirements for the issuance of licenses of embalmers in other states every four years rather than “from time to time,” and establishes the next review of the Bureau by the appropriate policy committees of the Legislature
SB 607 (Glazer), which is pending in the Senate, is the sunset review bill for the Board of Barbering and Cosmetology would require the board’s Health and Safety Advisory Committee (Advisory Committee) to include three board members and adds information on professional cosmetic labeling requirements to the list of health and safety issues the Advisory Committee provides advice and recommendations on barbering and cosmetology.
SB 608 (Glazer), which is pending in the Senate, is the sunset review bill for the California Architects Board and the Landscape Architects Technical Committee and requires each to conduct background checks on applicants, modifies requirements of written contracts, aligns executive officer duties for both the board and the committee, requires the board to establish standards for continuing education, and extends the sunset dates for both entities until January 1, 2024.
SB 609 (Glazer), which is pending in the Senate, is the sunset review bill for the bill for the Bureau of Security and Investigative Services, which would prohibit the bureau from issuing firearms permits to applicants under 21 years of age; consolidate the Private Investigator Fund and the Private Security Services Fund into one fund; place the responsibility of completing annual guard skills training on the security guard registrant and require the registrant, instead of the employer, to attest on their renewal application that they have completed the required annual security guard skills training; require security guards who are unemployed or working for a business that does not require a private patrol operator license to be responsible for completing annual guard skills training in order to maintain a valid registration; eliminate the requirement for the employer’s signature that attests to an applicant completing the power to arrest training and instead requires the security guard applicant to provide specified proof of the training; require the bureau to be reviewed by the appropriate policy of the Legislature by January 1, 2024; and make other technical and clarifying changes to the six practice acts regulated by BSIS.
SB 610 (Glazer), which is pending in the Senate, is the sunset review bill for the Contractors’ State License Board and would extend the sunset date of the board and its authority to appoint a registrar until January 1, 2024; requires the board to conduct a study of the contractor bond; and makes other technical and clarifying changes to the Contractors’ State License Law.
Prior Related Legislation. AB 179 (Bonilla, Chapter 510, Statutes of 2015) was the most recent sunset extension vehicle for the DBC to be enacted.
POLICY ISSUE(S) FOR CONSIDERATION:
The DBC’s most recent sunset background paper highlighted the following issues for consideration during its current review by the Legislature.
ISSUE #1: Merger of Special Funds. Should the State Dentistry Fund and the State Dental Assisting Fund be merged to simplify and streamline accounting and budgeting processes for the DBC?
ISSUE #2: Dental Hygiene Board. What is the current state of the DBC’s relationship with the Dental Hygiene Board of California, which also regulates licensees involved in the dental profession?
ISSUE #3: Board Attorney. Does the DBC have sufficient legal counsel?
ISSUE #4: NC Dental. Are there any outstanding concerns that the Supreme Court’s decision in North Carolina State Board of Dental Examiners v. FTC could have implications for the DBC?
ISSUE #5: RDA Practical Examination. Should the practical examination requirement for registered dental assistants be permanently eliminated?
ISSUE #6: Portfolio Examinations. Is the DBC’s portfolio examination process adequately providing pathways to licensure for dental students as an effective alternative to conventional examinations?
ISSUE #7: Foreign Dental Schools. Should the current process by which the DBC approves foreign dental schools continue?
ISSUE #8: Consumer Products. Does the DBC have sufficient oversight over consumer products advertising self-applied corrective treatments for structural or aesthetic oral health conditions?
ISSUE #9: Enforcement Targets. Does available data relating to enforcement timelines suggest any inefficiencies in discipline cases brought by the DBC in collaboration with the Attorney General?
ISSUE #10: Opioid Crisis. What role do dentists play in the ongoing epidemic of opioid abuse and addiction, and how can the DBC support efforts to curb overprescribing within the dental profession?
ISSUE #11: Probation Disclosure. Should dental professionals placed on probation by the DBC be required to disclose their probation status to patients in a manner similar to other healing arts licensees?
ISSUE #12: Dynamex. Does the new test for determining employment status, as prescribed in the court decision Dynamex Operations West Inc. v. Superior Court, have any potential implications for licensees working in the dental profession as independent contractors?
ISSUE #13: Pediatric Anesthesia. Does the DBC anticipate a smooth implementation of Senate Bill 501 (Glazer), a recently enacted measure regarding pediatric dental anesthesia?
ISSUE #14: Technical Cleanup. Is there a need for technical cleanup?
ISSUE #15: Continued Regulation. Should the licensing of dental professionals be continued and be regulated by the Dental Board of California?
REGISTERED SUPPORT:
California Dental Association
REGISTERED OPPOSITION:
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Robert Sumner / B. & P. / (916) 319-3301
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):