AB 170: Worker status: employees and independent contractors.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-02
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 2, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 415, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 2, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 17, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 11 a.m. |
| Sep 14, 2019 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 12, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (September 12). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Joint Rules 61 and 62 suspended. (Ayes 28. Noes 9.) |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read third time. Refused passage. (Ayes 19. Noes 13.). |
| Aug 27, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 26, 2019 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Aug 21, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. pursuant to Joint Rule 10.5. |
| Aug 21, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 20, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jul 5, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 3, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (July 2). |
| Jun 13, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 12, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (June 12). |
| May 1, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on L., P.E. & R. and JUD. |
| Apr 23, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 22, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Apr 2, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 1, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Mar 28, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 8. Noes 3.) (March 26). |
| Mar 25, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 21, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 12, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 7, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (March 6). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jan 24, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on L. & E. and JUD. |
| Jan 9, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 8. |
| Jan 8, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 14, 2019 | AB 170 Gonzalez Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 13, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB170 Gonzalez et al. By Mitchell | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 13, 2019 | With recommendation: That Senate amendments be concurred in. | Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment |
Passed |
|
| Sep 12, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Labor, Public Employment and Retirement |
Passed |
|
| Sep 3, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB170 Gonzalez By Durazo Reconsider | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 3, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB170 Gonzalez By Durazo | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 12, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Labor, Public Employment and Retirement |
Passed |
|
| Apr 22, 2019 | AB 170 Gonzalez Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Mar 26, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Mar 6, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
(Without Reference to File)
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA2 Bill Id:AB 170
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Amended Ver:September 10, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Exempts newspaper distributors and carriers, as defined, from the three-part Dynamex test for determining employee status until January 1, 2021.
The Senate Amendments:
- Delete the prior version of the bill.
- Exempt a newspaper distributor working under contract, as defined, and a newspaper carrier working under contract, as defined, from the three-part Dynamex test as codified in AB 5 (Gonzalez) of the current legislative session, currently before the Legislature, until January 1, 2021.
- Provide that the bill's provisions shall become operative only if AB 5 is enacted and becomes effective.
COMMENTS:
AB 5 of the 2019-20 Regular Session both codifies and clarifies the application of the California Supreme Court's ruling in Dynamex Operations West, Inc. v. Superior Court of Los Angeles (2018). The Dynamex ruling presumes a worker is an employee unless a hiring entity satisfies a three-factor test. AB 5 provides that certain occupations and business to business relationships that meet specified criteria are exempt from the three-part test and are, instead, governed by the definition of an employee as set forth in the decision of the California Supreme Court in S. G. Borello & Sons, Inc. v. Department of Industrial Relations (Borello) (1989). This measure delays the application of the Dynamex test to the newspaper delivery industry until January 1, 2021.
Background on the Newspaper Carrier Industry
The newspaper carrier or delivery industry is arguably one of the first gig sectors in the U.S. Dating back to the 19th century, the industry has utilized "news boys" and so-called "little merchants" to deliver the news, and has done so primarily by calling them independent contractors. While the industry has since evolved to utilize adults who largely use their own vehicle to deliver the papers, their classification as independent contractors remains an ongoing issue.
Many argue that the long-standing practice of classifying carriers as independent contractors has put carriers in a position of economic precarity. Misclassification of newspaper carriers has led to "serious injustice, with thousands of carriers being denied millions of dollars in tax contributions, benefits, and workers' compensation in the instances where carriers have been injured on the job."[1] Without irony, the industry has tried to have it both ways, by controlling the pay and terms and conditions of the carriers' employment, while evading other traditional employer duties such as the provision of minimum wage, overtime, and meal and rest breaks.
Newspaper Carrier Misclassification Cases
Courts have addressed the issue of misclassification of newspaper carriers since the 1920's.[2] In 1922, in Press Publishing Co. v. Industrial Accident Commission, the California Supreme Court concluded that a paperboy was an employee of the publishing company for purposes of workers' compensation.[3] The court reasoned that "the most significant fact in this regard and one which points towards the relation of employee rather than to the status of an independent contractor is the fact that [the plaintiff] was hired on the same terms as the other carriers and the [defendant newspaper] had the right to exercise the same direction and control over [the plaintiff] as it did over the other carrier boys ..."[4] In 1944, the California Supreme Court concluded that newspaper carriers are employees for purposes of the Unemployment Insurance Act.[5] As recently as 2017, a California appellate court—applying the Borello test for causes of action under the Labor Code—affirmed a trial court decision that newspaper carriers were employees.[6]
According to the Author:
None
Arguments in Support:
The California News Publishers Association writes in support, "If AB 170 is approved by the legislature and signed into law, the news industry will have breathing space to find a way to, within its means, create systems that further the values expressed by proponents of AB 5. Making carriers employees right now without time for careful research and consideration, would have grave consequences for newspapers and imperil newspapers that are already under financial stress.
Without AB 170, coverage of important events and developments in communities throughout California would be threatened and the people that live in these communities would become less informed."
Arguments in Opposition:
Mr. Jim Treglio, Esq., in opposition states, "I currently represent Vicky Aronson, a former newspaper carrier for Gannett Co. Inc., in a case entitled, Vicky Aronson, et al., v. Gannett Co. Inc., U.S. District Court for the Central District of California case no. SACV- 19-00996-AG-JEM. Ms. Aronson seeks to represent a class of 527 individuals, all of whom were affected by Gannett's abusive labor practices.
Mr. Treglio goes on to state, "newspaper carriers are, as a result of their misclassification, paid less than minimum wage. Newspaper carriers, some of whom work 365 days per year, often from midnight to 7 a.m., are paid only on a per-delivery basis, and, as a result, receive no pay for several hours of work per day. They are also subject to penalties and deductions from their pay when their employer determines that they did not properly deliver newspapers, reducing their pay. Further, newspaper carriers who are misclassified as independent contractors are required to cover their own expenses and actually indemnify their employers – that is, buy insurance to protect their employer from litigation associated with the delivery of newspapers. The end result of these policies is that newspaper carriers are dramatically underpaid. In my case, the
Defendant has calculated the amount of underpayment, including mileage costs, to be in excess of $20 million – and that's just to get 527 individuals to be paid up to the minimum wage for the hours they worked."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
Unknown
VOTES:
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 5-1-1
YES: Kalra, Carrillo, Gonzalez, Bonta, Luz Rivas
NO: Flora
ABS, ABST OR NV: Diep
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-3-1
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Reyes
NO: Gallagher, Fong, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Petrie-Norris
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 49-17-14
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Gray, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Frazier, Eduardo Garcia, Grayson, Kamlager-Dove, Mayes, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris
SENATE FLOOR: 19-13-8
YES: Allen, Atkins, Beall, Caballero, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hueso, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Skinner, Stern, Wieckowski, Wiener
NO: Bates, Borgeas, Chang, Dahle, Galgiani, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Archuleta, Bradford, Dodd, Glazer, Hill, Roth, Rubio, Umberg
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 4-2-1
YES: Flora, Carrillo, Jones-Sawyer, Luz Rivas
NO: Kalra, Gonzalez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Diep
SENATE FLOOR: 40-0-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Bates, Beall, Borgeas, Bradford, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Grove, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Jones, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Stone, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 10, 2019
CONSULTANT: Megan Lane / Justin Delacruz/ L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0002483
Jean Tom, "Note: Is a Newscarrier an Employee or an Independent Contractor? Deterring Abuse of the 'Independent Contractor' Label via State Tort Claims," Yale Law and Policy Review, Volume 19, page 493, 2001. ↑
See Press Publishing Co. v. Industrial Accident Com. (1922) 190 Cal. 114; Call Publishing Co. v. Industrial Accident Com. (1928) 89 Cal. App. 194. ↑
Press Publishing Co., supra 190 Cal. 114. ↑
Id. at pp. 120-121. ↑
Cal. Employment Com. v. Los Angeles Down Town Shopping News Corp. (1944) 24 Cal. 2d 421. ↑
Espejo v. The Copley Press, Inc. (2017) 207 Cal.App.5th 329, 342-352. ↑
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 170 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 170
Amended: 9/10/19 in Senate
PRIOR VOTES NOT RELEVANT
SENATE LABOR, PUB. EMP. & RET. COMMITTEE: 5-0, 9/12/19 (Pursuant to Senate Rule 29.10)
AYES: Hill, Morrell, Jackson, Mitchell, Pan
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Worker status: employees and independent contractors
DIGEST:
This bill places, until January 1, 2021, newspaper carriers and newspaper distributors under the Borello employment test, rather than the Dynamex employment test, provided that AB 5 (Gonzalez) becomes law.
Existing law:
- Establishes a comprehensive set of protections for employees, including a time-sure minimum wage, meal and rest periods, workers’ compensation coverage in the event of an industrial injury, sick leave, disability insurance in the event of a non-industrial disability, paid family leave, and unemployment insurance (UI). (Labor Code §§201, 226.7, 246, 512, 1182.12, & 3600 and UI Code §§1251 & 2601)
- Creates the Industrial Welfare Commission (IWC), which promulgates industry-specific wage orders that set the wages, hours, and working conditions of employees. The IWC wage orders have the force of regulation and are enforced by the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement. (Labor Code §§70, 1173, 1177, 1195 & 1197)
- Requires, for the purposes of IWC wage orders, that the specific work conditions of a worker must conform with the following three circumstances to be considered an independent contractor:
- The worker is free from the control and direction of the hirer in connection with the performance of the work, both under the contract for the performance of such work and in fact;
- The worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business; and
- The worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as the work performed for the hiring entity.
(Dynamex Operations West v. Superior Court (2018) 4 Cal. 5th 903)
This bill:
- Provides that, for newspaper distributor working under a contract with newspaper publisher, and for a newspaper carries working for a newspaper distributor, the applicable test for determining if an individual is an employee or an independent contractor is the predecessor test to Dynamex developed by the California Supreme Court in S. G. Borello & Sons, Inc. v. Department of Industrial Relations (1989) 48 Cal.3d 341.
- Provides that the provisions described above become inoperative on January 1, 2021, unless extended by the Legislature.
- Provides that the provisions described above do not become law unless AB 5 (Gonzalez) becomes law as well.
Comments
- Newspapers, Dynamex, and AB 5
Newspaper distributors and newspapers carriers have a uniquely complex regulatory and legal history when it comes to independent contractor law. The core of this complexity comes from an Employment Development Department (EDD) regulation: 22 CCR §4304-6. Created in 1987 under the Deukmajian administration, this regulation is designed to specifically address the question of when a newspaper carrier or newspaper distributor is an employee for the purposes of Unemployment Insurance Code.
Despite the fact that the regulation has not been updated since 1987, 22 CCR §4304-6 conspicuously reads as an anachronism. For example, under §4304-6 (c)(9), which deals with workers’ compensation, the regulation provides that a newspaper carrier being covered by workers’ compensation coverage “shall not create an inference of employment or independence.” However, by definition, workers’ compensation coverage applies to employees – an independent contractor is not eligible to access workers’ compensation benefits. Moreover, in Yellow Cab Cooperative v. WCAB (1991) 226 Cal. App. 3d 1288, which came four years after the creation of the 22 CCR §4304-6, held that an employer-employee relationship was present if:
- The principal retains pervasive control over the operation as a whole;
- The worker's duties are an integral part of the operation; and
- The nature of the work makes detailed control unnecessary.
It is difficult to imagine a newspaper distribution operation where all three would not apply.
In other contexts, the regulations seems to place workers in a precarious economic position. For example, the regulation provides that a written contract between a newspaper distributor and newspaper carrier “shall be evidence of intent”. Yet, the next line provides: “However, if the terms of the agreement are not complied with in practice, the agreement shall not determine the intent or the relationship of the parties.” Similarly, the regulations hold that an hourly rate of pay or a rate of pay that is increased due to the requirement of posting a bond is evidence of employment. This construct perversely encourages newspaper distributors to require bonds and not provide additional compensation, as well as make payment to newspaper carriers contingent and less predictable.
Notably, this regulation was not put into place during a time of financial turmoil for the newspaper industry. For example, a 1998 study of 15 publically traded newspapers found that 14 of the newspapers earned average profit margins in excess of 9% from 1984-1994. In a January 6, 1991 New York Times article reported average profit margins for papers owned by publically traded communications companies at 20.2% in 1985, 17% in 1989, and 15% in the first half of 1990. During that same period, the aggregate profit margin of S&P 500 companies was between 5-7%.
In all contexts, however, 22 CCR §4304-6 shows its age: coming 2 years before the Borello test and related decisions, the regulation does not reflect the 1989 decision and its focus on factors of control in determining an employer-employee relationship. Despite this, in recent litigation, some newspaper publishers have used the EDD regulation to defend against wage and hour litigation – something that the regulation cannot be extended to without ignoring both case law and the permissible scope of EDD regulations.
- Borello, Dynamex, and AB 170
AB 170 addresses these problems by definitely placing newspaper distributors and newspaper carriers under the Borello decision for both the purposes of unemployment insurance and wage and hour requirements, effectively nullifying 22 CCR §4304-6, which was already dubious law. By placing newspaper distributors and carriers under the Borello test until January 1, 2021, AB 170 gives the newspaper industry a year to remedy their contracts with newspaper carriers and newspaper distributors in order to come into compliance with the 2018 California Supreme Court decision in Dynamex and the recently-passed Assembly Bill 5 (Gonzalez), which codifies the Dynamex decision.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 5 (Gonzalez, 2019) will, among other things, codifies the 2018 Dynamex decision, requiring that employers prove that their workers can meet a three-part (ABC) test in order to be lawfully classified as independent contractors.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
California News Publishers Association
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/11/19)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The California News Publishers Association argues the following:
“If AB 170 is approved by the legislature and signed into law, the news industry will have breathing space to find a way to, within its means, create systems that further the values expressed by proponents of AB 5. Making carriers employees right now without time for careful research and consideration, would have grave consequences for newspapers and imperil newspapers that are already under financial stress….
“As newspaper circulation would be reduced, advertising revenue would be reduced. Reduction of both circulation and ad revenue would force newspapers to employ fewer journalists. This would result in fewer stories being told, less investigation of corruption, and ultimately, an inability for citizens to gain the information necessary for self-governance. All of this at a time when access to authoritative, reliable information is more important than ever.
“A community with a strong newspaper is a strong community. Recent research says both readers and non-readers substantially benefit from their newspaper: cleaner government, better economy, more folks willing to run for office, better environment, lower government debt, less corruption. Newspapers create a community forum for the betterment of all.”
Prepared by: Gideon L. Baum / L., P.E. & R. / (916) 651-1556
9/12/19 12:48:36
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR, PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Senator Jerry Hill, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 170 Hearing Date: September 12, 2019
Author: | Gonzalez | ||
Version: | September 10, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Gideon L. Baum | ||
SUBJECT: Worker status: employees and independent contractors
KEY ISSUE
Should the Legislature, until January 1, 2021, place newspaper carriers and newspaper distributors under the Borello employment test, rather than the Dynamex employment test?
Should the Legislature require that the above-described provisions only become law if Assembly Bill 5 (Gonzalez) becomes law?
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Establishes a comprehensive set of protections for employees, including a time-sure minimum wage, meal and rest periods, workers’ compensation coverage in the event of an industrial injury, sick leave, disability insurance (DI) in the event of a non-industrial disability, paid family leave, and unemployment insurance (UI).
(Labor Code §§201, 226.7, 246, 512, 1182.12, & 3600 and UI Code §§1251 & 2601) - Creates the Industrial Welfare Commission (IWC), which promulgates industry-specific wage orders that set the wages, hours, and working conditions of employees. The IWC wage orders have the force of regulation and are enforced by the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE).
(Labor Code §§70, 1173, 1177, 1195 & 1197) - Requires, for the purposes of IWC wage orders, that the specific work conditions of a worker must conform with the following three circumstances to be considered an independent contractor:
(A) The worker is free from the control and direction of the hirer in connection with the performance of the work, both under the contract for the performance of such work and in fact;
(B) The worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business; and
(C) The worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as the work performed for the hiring entity.
(Dynamex Operations West v. Superior Court (2018) 4 Cal. 5th 903)
This bill:
- Provides that, for newspaper distributor working under a contract with newspaper publisher, and for a newspaper carries working for a newspaper distributor, the applicable test for determining if an individual is an employee or an independent contractor is the predecessor test to Dynamex developed by the California Supreme Court in S. G. Borello & Sons, Inc. v. Department of Industrial Relations (1989) 48 Cal.3d 341.
- Provides that the provisions described above become inoperative on January 1, 2021, unless extended by the Legislature.
- Provides that the provisions described above do not become law unless Assembly Bill 5 (Gonzalez) becomes law as well.
COMMENTS
1. Newspapers, Dynamex, and Assembly Bill 5:
Newspaper distributors and newspapers carriers have a uniquely complex regulatory and legal history when it comes to independent contractor law. The core of this complexity comes from an Employment Development Department (EDD) regulation: 22 CCR §4304-6. Created in 1987 under the Deukmajian administration, this regulation is designed to specifically address the question of when a newspaper carrier or newspaper distributor is an employee for the purposes of Unemployment Insurance Code.
Despite the fact that the regulation has not been updated since 1987, 22 CCR §4304-6 conspicuously reads as an anachronism. For example, under §4304-6 (c)(9), which deals with workers’ compensation, the regulation provides that a newspaper carrier being covered by workers’ compensation coverage “shall not create an inference of employment or independence.” However, by definition, workers’ compensation coverage applies to employees – an independent contractor is not eligible to access workers’ compensation benefits. Moreover, in Yellow Cab Cooperative v. WCAB (1991) 226 Cal. App. 3d 1288, which came 4 years after the creation of the 22 CCR §4304-6, held that an employer-employee relationship was present if:
- The principal retains pervasive control over the operation as a whole;
- The worker's duties are an integral part of the operation; and
- The nature of the work makes detailed control unnecessary.
It is difficult to imagine a newspaper distribution operation where all three would not apply.
In other contexts, the regulations seems to place workers in a precarious economic position. For example, the regulation provides that a written contract between a newspaper distributor and newspaper carrier “shall be evidence of intent”. Yet, the next line provides: “However, if the terms of the agreement are not complied with in practice, the agreement shall not determine the intent or the relationship of the parties.” Similarly, the regulations hold that an hourly rate of pay or a rate of pay that is increased due to the requirement of posting a bond is evidence of employment. This construct perversely encourages newspaper distributors to require bonds and not provide additional compensation, as well as make payment to newspaper carriers contingent and less predictable.
Notably, this regulation was not put into place during a time of financial turmoil for the newspaper industry. For example, a 1998 study of 15 publically traded newspapers found that 14 of the newspapers earned average profit margins in excess of 9% from 1984-1994. In a January 6, 1991 New York Times article reported average profit margins for papers owned by publically traded communications companies at 20.2% in 1985, 17% in 1989, and 15% in the first half of 1990. During that same period, the aggregate profit margin of S&P 500 companies was between 5-7%.
In all contexts, however, 22 CCR §4304-6 shows its age: coming 2 years before the Borello test and related decisions, the regulation does not reflect the 1989 decision and its focus on factors of control in determining an employer-employee relationship. Despite this, in recent litigation, some newspaper publishers have used the EDD regulation to defend against wage and hour litigation – something that the regulation cannot be extended to without ignoring both case law and the permissible scope of EDD regulations.
2. Borello, Dynamex, and AB 170:
AB 170 addresses these problems by definitely placing newspaper distributors and newspaper carriers under the Borello decision for both the purposes of unemployment insurance and wage and hour requirements, effectively nullifying 22 CCR §4304-6, which was already dubious law. By placing newspaper distributors and carriers under the Borello test until January 1, 2021, AB 170 gives the newspaper industry a year to remedy their contracts with newspaper carriers and newspaper distributors in order to come into compliance with the 2018 California Supreme Court decision in Dynamex and the recently-passed Assembly Bill 5 (Gonzalez), which codifies the Dynamex decision.
3. Proponent Arguments
The California News Publishers Association argues the following:
“If AB 170 is approved by the legislature and signed into law, the news industry will have breathing space to find a way to, within its means, create systems that further the values expressed by proponents of AB 5. Making carriers employees right now without time for careful research and consideration, would have grave consequences for newspapers and imperil newspapers that are already under financial stress….
As newspaper circulation would be reduced, advertising revenue would be reduced. Reduction of both circulation and ad revenue would force newspapers to employ fewer journalists. This would result in fewer stories being told, less investigation of corruption, and ultimately, an inability for citizens to gain the information necessary for self-governance. All of this at a time when access to authoritative, reliable information is more important than ever.
A community with a strong newspaper is a strong community. Recent research says both readers and non-readers substantially benefit from their newspaper: cleaner government, better economy, more folks willing to run for office, better environment, lower government debt, less corruption. Newspapers create a community forum for the betterment of all.”
4. Opponent Arguments:
None on file.
5. Current Legislation:
AB 5 (Gonzalez) of 2019 will, among other things, codifies the 2018 Dynamex decision, requiring that employers prove that their workers can meet a 3 part (ABC) test in order to be lawfully classified as independent contractors.
SUPPORT
California News Publishers Association
OPPOSITION
None on file.
-- END --
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 170 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 170
Amended: 8/20/19 in Senate
SENATE LABOR, PUB. EMP. & RET. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 6/12/19
AYES: Hill, Jackson, Mitchell, Pan
NOES: Morrell
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-2, 7/2/19
AYES: Jackson, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Borgeas, Jones
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SENATE FLOOR: 19-13, 9/3/19 (FAIL)
AYES: Allen, Atkins, Beall, Caballero, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hueso, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Skinner, Stern, Wieckowski, Wiener
NOES: Bates, Borgeas, Chang, Dahle, Galgiani, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Archuleta, Bradford, Dodd, Glazer, Hill, Roth, Rubio, Umberg
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 49-17, 4/22/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Employment: harassment: liability
DIGEST:
This bill specifies that an employer is responsible for the acts of contracted supervisors, as defined, with respect to harassment of an employee, an applicant, an unpaid intern or volunteer, or a person providing services pursuant to a contract in the workplace. Per existing law, for the acts of nonemployees, other than contracted supervisors (this bill), an employer may be responsible if the employer, or its agents or supervisors, know or should have known of the conduct and fails to take immediate and appropriate corrective action.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/20/19 revise and recast the previous version of this bill which would have added Section 12940.2 to the Government Code to specify that client employers share with a labor contractors all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for harassment for all workers supplied by that labor contractor. Instead, this bill now amends existing law to achieve the same goal in a narrowed approach that specifies that an employer is responsible for the acts of contracted supervisors with respect to harassment.
Existing law:
- Makes it an unlawful employment practice, under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), for an employer, or other specified entity, to harass an employee or other specified persons because of the employee’s or other person’s race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status. “Harassment” because of sex includes sexual harassment, and harassment based on pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions. [Government Code §12940 (j)]
- Specifies that harassment of an employee, an applicant, an unpaid intern or volunteer, or a person providing services pursuant to a contract by an employee, other than an agent or supervisor, shall be unlawful if the entity, or its agents or supervisors, knows or should have known of this conduct and fails to take immediate and appropriate corrective action. [Government Code §12940 (j)]
- Specifies further that an employer may also be responsible for the acts of nonemployees, with respect to harassment, if the employer, or its agents or supervisors, know or should have known of the conduct and fails to take immediate and appropriate corrective action. [Government Code §12940 (j)]
- Prohibits, explicitly, an employer, labor organization, employment agency, apprenticeship training program, or any training program leading to employment, from failing to take all reasonable steps necessary to prevent discrimination and harassment from occurring. [Government Code §12940(k)]
- Defines an “employer” – for purposes harassment provisions under FEHA – as any person regularly employing persons or regularly receiving the services of persons providing services pursuant to a contract, or any person acting as an agent of an employer, directly or indirectly, the state, or any political or civil subdivision of the state, and cities. [Government Code §12940 (j)(4)]
- Defines “a person providing services pursuant to a contract” – for purposes of the harassment provisions of FEHA only – as a person providing services to the employer and meeting all of the following criteria:
- The person has the right to control the performance of the contract for services and has discretion as to the manner of performance.
- The person is customarily engaged in an independently established business.
- The person has control over the time and place the work is performed, supplies the tools and instruments used in the work, and performs work that requires a particular skill not ordinarily used in the course of employer’s work. [Government Code Section 12940 (j)(5)]
- Requires a client employer, as defined, to share with a labor contractor, as defined, all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for all workers supplied by that labor contractor for the payment of wages and the failure to secure valid workers’ compensation coverage. [Labor Code §2810.3 (b)]
This bill:
- Specifies that an employer is responsible for the acts of a contracted supervisor with respect to harassment of an employee, an applicant, an unpaid intern or volunteer, or a person providing services pursuant to a contract in the workplace.
- Defines “a contracted supervisor” as a person providing services pursuant to a contract who supervises one or more employees, applicants, unpaid interns or volunteers, or persons providing services pursuant to a contract.
Background
Sexual Harassment in the Workplace and Recent Policy Changes. Since 2017, the country has been rocked by disturbing accounts of workplace sexual harassment that have shed light on a problem hidden in plain sight. Propelled by the #MeToo and #WeSaidEnough movements, brave individuals have come forward exposing the prevalence of this problem across various industries and the harm it inflicts on victims, both personally and professionally. In response, in 2018 the Legislature passed various policy changes including expansion of sexual harassment training requirements for all employees; enhanced FEHA provisions to require more employer accountability; and prohibiting employers from requiring employees to sign a release of claims under FEHA in exchange for a raise or as a condition of employment. Please see policy committee analysis for more background information.
Comments
Need for this bill? According to the author, “Although California has extensive workplace protections in statute; sexual harassment has remained a persistent problem across industries, especially for women in low-wage jobs. An estimated 60 percent of workers nationwide who have experienced sexual harassment in their workplace have not reported it. Among the reasons cited for why workers do not raise complaints, the most common are fears of disbelief of their testimony, of inaction on their claim, of blame for the harassment, and of social and professional retaliation. By reporting or even sharing an issue with a colleague, workers risk their ability to provide for their children and families.”
The author argues that, “Workers may go to work each day at the same location, wearing the same uniform as other staff, and reporting to managers onsite—while not being employees of the company. Workers are, in many cases, not aware of their subcontracting agency, or of their direct supervisor. In spite of this clear de facto workplace and managers, these contracting companies are not held responsible when sexual harassment and assault happen on their watch to subcontracted workers. Currently, it is not clear under existing law (FEHA) if an employee would be responsible for harassment committed by a contract employee against a direct employee.”
This bill specifies that an employer is responsible for the acts of contracted supervisors (strict liability) with respect to harassment of an employee, an applicant, an unpaid intern or volunteer, or a person providing services pursuant to a contract in the workplace; for all other employees of the labor contractor (nonemployees of the hiring employer), the hiring employer would be liable only if the employer knew or should have known about their conduct, which is consistent with existing liability provisions for conduct of nonemployees [Government Code Section 12940 (j)].
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 171 (Gonzalez, 2019) (1) extends existing law prohibiting an employer from discharging or in any manner discriminating or retaliating against an employee because of the employee’s status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking to victims of victims of sexual harassment, as defined; (2) establishes a 90-day rebuttable presumption of unlawful retaliation based on an employee’s status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, sexual harassment, or stalking; and (3) defines “employer” for purposes of these provisions to include the state, political subdivision of the state, and municipalities.
AB 3081 (Gonzales, 2018), among other things, would have required employers to share civil legal responsibility and civil liability for all workers who are provided by a contractor in cases harassment, as defined. The bill was vetoed by Governor Brown who stated, “This bill creates a new, ill-defined standard of joint liability between labor contractors and client employers, prohibits both entities from retaliating against an employee who has filed a harassment claim, and establishes a 30-day notice requirement before certain workers can file a civil action against a client employer. Most of the provisions in this bill are contained in current law and are therefore unnecessary. To the extent there are new provisions, they are confusing.”
AB 1701 (Thurmond, Chapter 804, Statutes of 2017) held general contractors and subcontractors jointly liable for unpaid wages, including fringe benefits, and authorized civil actions to enforce the joint liability.
AB 1897 (R. Hernández, Chapter 728, Statutes of 2014) required a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for all workers supplied by that labor contractor for the payment of wages and the failure to obtain valid workers’ compensation coverage.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
UNITE HERE Local 11 (source)
American Association of University Women
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Federation of Teachers
California Labor Federation
California Professional Firefighters
California Teamsters
Consumer Attorneys of California
Engineers and Scientists of CA, IFPTE Local 20
Inlandboatmen’s Union of the Pacific
Orange County Employees Association
Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21
Screen Actors Guild‐American Federation of Television and Radio Artists
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers of America
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/20/19)
American Pistachio Growers
Associated General Contractors
Brea Chamber of Commerce
California Ambulance Association
California Apartment Association
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Bankers Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business & Industrial Alliance
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Hotel and Lodging Association
California Landscape Contractors Association
California League of Food Producers
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse
Civil Justice Association of California
Construction Employers’ Association
El Centro Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Fresno Chamber of Commerce
Garden Grove Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
National Federation of Independent Business
North Orange County Chamber
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Palm Desert Area Chamber of Commerce
Redondo Beach Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
South Bay Association of Chambers of Commerce
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The sponsor of this bill, UNITE HERE Local 11, shares the case of Sandra Pezquada, a former dishwasher at the Terranea Resort who was employed through a temporary staffing agency. They write, “Shortly after she began working, Sandra’s male supervisor allegedly began to sexually harass her. She later filed a lawsuit against the staffing agency and the resort, alleging, among other claims, that the supervisor pursued her sexually over a period of months and tried to kiss her in a storage room. She alleged that when she rebuffed his sexual advances, the supervisor retaliated against her, changing her schedule and cutting her hours so that she was working too little to support herself. After Sandra came forward to report sexual harassment, she was fired. Even though Sandra worked each day at the Terranea, washing the resort’s dishes alongside the resort’s directly employed employees and managers, the Terranea denied responsibility in part because the supervisor who allegedly harassed her was employed by the staffing agency.”
In support, the California Employment Lawyers Association (CELA) writes, “our attorneys often represent victims of sexual harassment and have found that subcontracting work arrangements are becoming an increasingly common tactic employers use to try to evade liability. Given the important mandate under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) to ‘provide effective remedies that will both prevent and deter unlawful employment practices and redress the adverse effects of those practices on aggrieved persons,’ it is critical that client employers are not able to use subcontracting work arrangements to shield themselves from the commands and duties of the FEHA.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Chamber of Commerce and a coalition of employers is opposed to the measure arguing that it would create another pathway for costly litigation against employers for issues that are already protected under FEHA. They write “While the recent amendments purport to limit employer liability to actions of “contracted supervisors,” the bill would still subject employers to automatic joint liability for harassment, even in cases where the employer had no knowledge of the acts or ability to control the actions of the contracted supervisor. Moreover, by eliminating the definitions of “client employer,” “labor contractor,” and the various exemptions therein, the recent amendments actually broaden the bill by potentially making it applicable to a wider category of employers and situations.”
Opponents further state, “Making matters worse, AB 170 imposes joint liability even if the employees of the employer are not involved in the harassment.
… Finally, compliance with FEHA’s training and notice requirements is not a complete defense for harassment liability. Even if an employer ensured that the contractor was training all of its supervisors, had all of the appropriate anti-harassment policies in place, and provided the proper notices regarding harassment prevention, the employer would still be liable for the harassing conduct of the labor contractor’s supervisors.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 49-17, 4/22/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Gray, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Frazier, Eduardo Garcia, Grayson, Kamlager-Dove, Mayes, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris
Prepared by: Alma Perez-Schwab / L., P.E. & R. / (916) 651-1556
9/3/19 17:17:15
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 170 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 170
Amended: 6/13/19 in Senate
SENATE LABOR, PUB. EMP. & RET. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 6/12/19
AYES: Hill, Jackson, Mitchell, Pan
NOES: Morrell
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-2, 7/2/19
AYES: Jackson, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Borgeas, Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 49-17, 4/22/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Employment: sexual harassment: liability
DIGEST:
This bill requires a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for harassment, as defined, for all workers supplied by that labor contractor.
Existing law:
- Makes it an unlawful employment practice, under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), for an employer, or other specified entity, to harass an employee or other specified persons because of the employee’s or other person’s race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status. “Harassment” because of sex includes sexual harassment, and harassment based on pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions. [Government Code §12940 (j)]
- Specifies that an employer shall be liable for harassment if the employer, or its agents or supervisors, knows or should have known of this conduct and fails to take immediate and appropriate corrective action. Specifies further that an employer may also be responsible for the acts of nonemployees, with consideration to the extent of the employer’s control and any other legal responsibility over their conduct. [Government Code §12940 (j)]
- Prohibits, explicitly, an employer, labor organization, employment agency, apprenticeship training program, or any training program leading to employment, from failing to take all reasonable steps necessary to prevent discrimination and harassment from occurring. [Government Code §12940(k)]
- Requires employers to post a poster on discrimination in employment at the workplace and provide specified notices about sexual harassment to all employees. (Government Code §12950)
- Requires employers with five or more employees to provide at least two hours of training and education regarding sexual harassment to all supervisory employees and at least one hour of training to all nonsupervisory employees within six months of their assumption of a position, and once every two years. (Government Code §12950.1)
- Requires a client employer, as defined, to share with a labor contractor, as defined, all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for all workers supplied by that labor contractor for the payment of wages and the failure to secure valid workers’ compensation coverage. [Labor Code §2810.3 (b)]
- Defines an “employer” – for purposes of the harassment provisions of FEHA only – as any person regularly employing persons or regularly receiving the services of persons providing services pursuant to a contract, or any person acting as an agent of an employer, directly or indirectly, the state, or any political or civil subdivision of the state, and cities. [Government Code §12940 (j)(4)]
- Defines “a person providing services pursuant to a contract” – for purposes of the harassment provisions of FEHA only – as a person providing services to the employer and meeting all of the following criteria:
- The person has the right to control the performance of the contract for services and has discretion as to the manner of performance.
- The person is customarily engaged in an independently established business.
- The person has control over the time and place the work is performed, supplies the tools and instruments used in the work, and performs work that requires a particular skill not ordinarily used in the course of employer’s work. [Government Code Section 12940 (j)(5)]
This bill:
- Requires a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for harassment, as defined, for all workers supplied by that labor contractor.
- Specifies that the provisions of this bill are in addition to, and shall be supplemental of, any other theories of liability or requirement established by statute or common law.
- Defines "client employer" as a private business entity, regardless of its form, that obtains workers to perform labor within the usual course of business from a labor contractor. However, a "client employer" does not include the following: a business entity with fewer than 25 workers, including those hired directly and those obtained by a labor contractor; or a business entity with five or fewer workers supplied by a labor contractor.
- Defines "labor contractor" as an individual or entity that supplies, either with or without a contract, a client employer with workers to perform labor within the client employer's usual course of business and specifies that a "labor contractor" does not include community nonprofit organizations, labor organizations, apprenticeship programs, motion picture payroll services, as defined, or a third party who is a party to an employee leasing arrangement, as defined.
- Provides definitions for “motion picture payroll services” and “employee leasing arrangement” as currently defined in Labor Code Section 2810.3.
Background
Sexual Harassment in the Workplace and Recent Policy Changes. Since 2017, the country has been rocked by disturbing accounts of workplace sexual harassment that have shed light on a problem hidden in plain sight. Propelled by the #MeToo and #WeSaidEnough movements, brave individuals have come forward exposing the prevalence of this problem across various industries and the harm it inflicts on victims, both personally and professionally. In response, in 2018 the Legislature passed various policy changes including expansion of sexual harassment training requirements for all employees; enhanced FEHA provisions to require more employer accountability; and prohibiting employers from requiring employees to sign a release of claims under FEHA in exchange for a raise or as a condition of employment. Please see policy committee analysis for more background information.
Comments
Need for this bill? According to the author, “Although California has extensive workplace protections in statute, sexual harassment has remained a persistent problem across industries, especially for women in low-wage jobs. An estimated 60 percent of workers nationwide who have experienced sexual harassment in their workplace have not reported it. Among the reasons cited for why workers do not raise complaints, the most common are fears of disbelief of their testimony, of inaction on their claim, of blame for the harassment, and of social and professional retaliation. By reporting or even sharing an issue with a colleague, workers risk their ability to provide for their children and families.”
The author argues that, “Workers may go to work each day at the same location, wearing the same uniform as other staff, and reporting to managers onsite—while not being employees of the company. Workers are, in many cases, not aware of their subcontracting agency, or of their direct supervisor. In spite of this clear de facto workplace and managers, these contracting companies are not held responsible when sexual harassment and assault happen on their watch to subcontracted workers. Currently, it is not clear under existing law (FEHA) if an employee would be responsible for harassment committed by a contract employee against a direct employee.”
This bill ensures that contracted workers could seek recourse from both their direct employer and the contracting client employer if they have experienced harassment on any protected basis in the workplace. By requiring employers to share civil legal responsibility and civil liability, workers will be more equipped to have their reports taken seriously, and to hold their workplaces accountable.
Shared Civil Legal Responsibility and Shared Civil Liability for Harassment. Please see policy committee analysis for more background information.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 171 (Gonzalez, 2019) (1) extends existing law prohibiting an employer from discharging or in any manner discriminating or retaliating against an employee because of the employee’s status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, or stalking to victims of victims of sexual harassment, as defined; (2) establishes a 90-day rebuttable presumption of unlawful retaliation based on an employee’s status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, sexual harassment, or stalking; and (3) defines “employer” for purposes of these provisions to include the state, political subdivision of the state, and municipalities.
AB 3081 (Gonzales, 2018), among other things, would have required employers to share civil legal responsibility and civil liability for all workers who are provided by a contractor in cases harassment, as defined. The bill was vetoed by Governor Brown who stated, “This bill creates a new, ill-defined standard of joint liability between labor contractors and client employers, prohibits both entities from retaliating against an employee who has filed a harassment claim, and establishes a 30-day notice requirement before certain workers can file a civil action against a client employer. Most of the provisions in this bill are contained in current law and are therefore unnecessary. To the extent there are new provisions, they are confusing.”
AB 1701 (Thurmond, Chapter 804, Statutes of 2017) held general contractors and subcontractors jointly liable for unpaid wages, including fringe benefits, and authorized civil actions to enforce the joint liability.
AB 1897 (R. Hernández, Chapter 728, Statutes of 2014) required a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for all workers supplied by that labor contractor for the payment of wages and the failure to obtain valid workers’ compensation coverage.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
UNITE HERE Local 11 (source)
American Association of University Women
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Federation of Teachers
California Labor Federation
California Professional Firefighters
California Teamsters
Consumer Attorneys of California
Engineers and Scientists of CA, IFPTE Local 20
Inlandboatmen’s Union of the Pacific
Orange County Employees Association
Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21
Screen Actors Guild‐American Federation of Television and Radio Artists
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers of America
American Pistachio Growers
American Staffing Association
Associated General Contractors
Brea Chamber of Commerce
California Ambulance Association
California Apartment Association
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Bankers Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business & Industrial Alliance
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Hotel and Lodging Association
California Landscape Contractors Association
California League of Food Producers
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse
Civil Justice Association of California
Construction Employers’ Association
El Centro Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Fresno Chamber of Commerce
Garden Grove Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
National Federation of Independent Business
North Orange County Chamber
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Palm Desert Area Chamber of Commerce
Redondo Beach Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
South Bay Association of Chambers of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The sponsors of this bill, UNITE HERE Local 11, share the case of Sandra Pezquada, a former dishwasher at the Terranea Resort who was employed through a temporary staffing agency. They write, “Shortly after she began working, Sandra’s male supervisor allegedly began to sexually harass her. She later filed a lawsuit against the staffing agency and the resort, alleging, among other claims, that the supervisor pursued her sexually over a period of months and tried to kiss her in a storage room. She alleged that when she rebuffed his sexual advances, the supervisor retaliated against her, changing her schedule and cutting her hours so that she was working too little to support herself. After Sandra came forward to report sexual harassment, she was fired. Even though Sandra worked each day at the Terranea, washing the resort’s dishes alongside the resort’s directly employed employees and managers, the Terranea denied responsibility in part because the supervisor who allegedly harassed her was employed by the staffing agency.”
In support of this bill, the California Employment Lawyers Association (CELA) writes, “our attorneys often represent victims of sexual harassment and have found that subcontracting work arrangements are becoming an increasingly common tactic employers use to try to evade liability. Given the important mandate under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) to ‘provide effective remedies that will both prevent and deter unlawful employment practices and redress the adverse effects of those practices on aggrieved persons,’ it is critical that client employers are not able to use subcontracting work arrangements to shield themselves from the commands and duties of the FEHA.” CELA argues that courts “have already found joint employer liability for harassment under the FEHA, recognizing that to hold otherwise would allow workers to be sent into hostile and discriminatory workplaces without remedy.” CELA cites the case Mathieu v. Norrell Corp. (2004), which noted that, “the purposes of FEHA are promoted if both the staffing agency and the client are treated as the employer, and the employees of the client entity are treated as coworkers of employees of the staffing agency within the meaning of FEHA.” CELA concludes, “AB 170 will help ensure that client employers are not able to opt out of the statutory duties under the Fair Employment and Housing Act by imposing joint liability for harassment for all workers supplied by a labor contractor.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: A coalition of employers, including the California Chamber of Commerce writes in opposition arguing that the bill creates another pathway to costly litigation against employers for issues that are already protected under FEHA. They write, “If a non-supervisory employee harasses a “person providing services pursuant to a contract,” the client employer is liable if they knew or should have known about the harassing conduct and failed to take immediate and appropriate corrective action. A client employer will also be liable for harassment by a third-party non-employee if the client employer knew or should have known of the unlawful conduct and failed to take immediate action. In reviewing cases involving the acts of third-party nonemployees with regards to harassment, the extent of the client employer's control and any other legal responsibility which the employer may have with respect to the conduct of those nonemployees shall be considered.”
Additionally, they write “if an individual does not meet the definition of a “person providing services pursuant to a contract,” the client employer will still be held liable for any unlawful harassment if the client employer exerted such control over the working conditions of the contractor’s employees that essentially the third party acted as the real employer. See Bradley v. California Dept. of Corrections and Rehabilitation, 158 Cal.App.4th 1612 (2008) (state agency exerted sufficient control over the individual to be considered an employer for purposes of FEHA).” They argue that this bill completely ignores this common law and statutory analysis and imposing liability despite the lack of any knowledge or control exerted by the client employer and even if the employees of the client employer are not involved in the harassment.
In comparing these provisions to existing joint liability provisions for the payment of wages and workers’ compensation coverage, opponents argue that “while a client employer cannot fully protect themselves from liability, these items are at least objectively verifiable….There is no basis for a business that contracts for services being deemed statutorily liable for harassment of another’s employees when there is absolutely no way in which that contractor can engage or force the labor contract company to comply with provisions of FEHA or the Labor Code.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 49-17, 4/22/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Gray, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Frazier, Eduardo Garcia, Grayson, Kamlager-Dove, Mayes, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris
Prepared by: Alma Perez-Schwab / L., P.E. & R. / (916) 651-1556
7/5/19 15:02:18
**** END ****
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 170 (Author:Gonzalez)
Version: June 13, 2019
Hearing Date: July 2, 2019
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: TSG
SUBJECT
Employment: sexual harassment: liability
DIGEST
This bill creates joint liability for a client employer with a labor contractor for workplace harassment, as follows: if the labor contractor is liable for the workplace harassment, then the client employer is automatically liable for that workplace harassment as well.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
In the traditional employer-employee relationship, a business hires the employee, tells the employee what to do, and, once the work is done, pays the wages. Sometimes, however, instead of hiring, directing, and paying a workforce themselves, businesses will hire a “labor contractor” to fill this role. Arrangements like these raise tricky questions about who should be held responsible in the event of workplace violations, such as harassment. On the one hand, where the labor contractor controls conditions at the worksite and the client employer does not, it seems unfair to hold the client employer responsible for what takes place. On the other hand, absolving the client employer in this fashion creates an incentive for the client employer to turn a blind eye to workplace abuse. In light of this dilemma, existing California law deems two aspects of employment law so fundamental that both client employers and labor contractors are liable for ensuring them, regardless of who maintains control: failure to pay wages and failure to provide of workers’ compensation insurance coverage. This bill would add harassment based on membership in a protected group to the things for which a client employer and a labor contractor are jointly liable, regardless of workplace control. Such liability would be limited, however, to client employers that have 25 or more total employees and that use more than five employees provided through a labor contractor.
The bill is sponsored by UNITE HERE, Local 11. Support is from organized labor and workers’ rights advocates. Opposition is from business and trade associations who assert that existing law provides sufficient worker protection and who worry about increased liability. The bill passed out of the Senate Labor, Public Employment, and Retirement Committee by a vote of 4-1.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing state law:
- Makes it an unlawful employment practice for an employer, labor organization, employment agency, apprenticeship training program or any training program leading to employment, or any other person to harass an employee, an applicant, an unpaid intern or volunteer, or an independent contractor on the basis of race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status. (Gov. Code § 12940(j)(1).)
- Holds client employers jointly liable, together with labor contractors, for the payment of wages and maintaining workers’ compensation coverage for all workers supplied by the labor contractor. (Lab. Code § 2810.3.)
This bill:
- Defines a “client employer” as a private business entity, regardless of its form, that obtains workers to perform labor within the usual course of business from a labor contractor. A client employer does not include the following: a business entity with fewer than 25 workers, including those hired directly and those obtained by a labor contractor, or a business entity with five or fewer workers supplied by a labor contractor.
- Defines a “labor contractor” as an individual or entity that supplies, either with or without a contract, a client employer with workers to perform labor within the client employer’s usual course of business. A labor contractor does not include community nonprofit organizations, labor organizations, apprenticeship programs, motion picture payroll services, as defined, or a third party who is a party to an employee leasing arrangement, as defined.
- Provides that a client employer shall share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for harassment of any worker supplied by that labor contractor on the basis of race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status
- Specifies that its provisions are in addition to, and shall be supplemental of, any other theories of liability or requirements established by statute or common law.
COMMENTS
- Background
In the traditional employer-employee relationship, a business hires the employee, tells the employee what to do, and, once the work is done, pays the wages. Sometimes, however, instead of hiring, directing, and paying a workforce themselves, businesses will hire a labor contractor to fill this role. The classic example of this is a farm labor contractor: rather than hire individual employees to pick a crop, growers frequently hire a labor contractor to recruit, manage, and pay farmworkers to get the job done on the grower’s behalf. “Temp” agencies are another variation on this theme, though in a typical temp agency scenario, the agency recruits the worker and pays the worker, but it is the business that tells the “temp” what to do. Further variations on these more traditional models are now cropping up in the form of online platforms that crowdsource labor – businesses like Task Rabbit, for example.
Arrangements like these are known as joint employer situations and they raise tricky questions about who should be held responsible in the event of workplace violations, such as harassment. Under existing California law, the key determinant of who is liable in a joint employer situation is who exerted control over the working conditions. (See Martinez v. Combs (2010) 49 Cal.4th 35 (2010).) Thus, a business that pays a labor contractor or other third party responsible for bringing workers to the job will generally be jointly liable with the labor contractor for what happens in the workplace, including harassment, but only if the business has the requisite degree of control over the conditions of employment.
Proponents of this standard believe it appropriately assigns legal responsibility to the party or parties that actually control the situation. Critics of the standard point out that it incentivizes client employers to avoid exercising any control over the workplace, in order to avoid liability, which leaves workers to fend for themselves against the labor contractor.
In the context of sexual harassment, for instance, UNITEHERE! Local 11 provides the following example:
[t]ake the case of [S.P.], a former dishwasher at… a fancy hotel along the California coast. Like many dishwashers at [the resort], [S.P.] was employed through a temporary staffing agency. Shortly after she began working, [S.P.]’s male supervisor allegedly began to sexually harass her. She later filed a lawsuit against the [hotel] and the staffing agency, alleging, among other claims, that the supervisor pursued her sexually over a period of months and tried to kiss her in a storage room. She alleged that when she rebuffed his sexual advances, the supervisor retaliated against her, changing her schedule and cutting her hours so that she was working too little to support herself. After [S.P.] came forward to report the sexual harassment, she was fired.
Even though [S.P.] worked each day at the [hotel], washing the resort’s dishes alongside the resort’s directly employed employees and managers, the [hotel] denied responsibility in part because the supervisor who allegedly harassed her was employed by the staffing agency. In legal papers, for example, the [hotel] asserted that [S.P.]’s discrimination claim should be dismissed in part because she could not “show that there was ever an employer and employee relationship” between herself and the [hotel] defendants.
Recognizing the fundamental importance of getting paid and having insurance coverage for workplace injuries, California law currently makes an exception to the general rule regarding control over the workplace for payment of wages and workers’ compensation. With respect to those two things, client employers are jointly liable for any violations to the same degree as the labor contractor, regardless of the degree of control that either exerts over the workplace. (Lab. Code § 2810.3(b).)
This bill would add workplace harassment, as defined by FEHA, to the list of things for which client employers are jointly liable with the labor contractors they utilize, regardless of the degree of control that the client employer has over the workplace.
2. Comparison to AB 3081 (Gonzalez, 2018)
AB 3081 (Gonzalez, 2018), like this bill, proposed to impose joint liability on client employers and labor contractors for workplace harassment. Then-Governor Brown vetoed AB 3081. Describing his view of that bill, he wrote:
This bill creates a new, ill-defined standard of joint liability between labor contractors and client employers, prohibits both entities from retaliating against an employee who has filed a harassment claim, and establishes a 30-day notice requirement before certain workers can file a civil action against a client employer.
Most of the provisions of this bill are contained in current law and are therefore unnecessary. To the extent there are new provisions, they are confusing.
While the basic concept of joint liability for client employers is the same, this bill differs from AB 3081 in a number of details. First, this bill does not apply to small businesses or bigger companies that use only a minimal amount of contracted labor. Second, unlike AB 3081, this bill does not contain a 30-day notice requirement and it does not have an anti-retaliation provision. Such retaliation would appear to be covered already by the Fair Employment and Housing Act’s (FEHA’s) broad anti-retaliation provision. (Gov. Code § 12940(h), making it an unlawful employment practice “[f]or any employer, labor organization, employment agency, or person to discharge, expel, or otherwise discriminate against any person because the person has opposed any practices forbidden under this part or because the person has filed a complaint, testified, or assisted in any proceeding under this part.”) Lastly, AB 3081 included provisions regarding the rights of employees to take time off to deal with the effects of sexual harassment, and it created a rebuttable presumption of retaliation in relation to any adverse action taken against an employee in the immediate wake of making a report about sexual harassment. None of those provisions are in this bill; versions of some of them can now be found in AB 171 (Gonzalez, 2019).
- What knowledge is required to establish joint liability under the bill?
The bill states that client employers shall share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for workplace harassment for workers supplied by the labor contractor. Given its origins in a Labor Code section which makes client employers legally responsible for ensuring that a labor contractor pays wages and maintains workers compensation, the intent behind the bill’s language seems clear: it extends joint liability onto the client employer for workplace harassment anytime the labor contractor is liable for workplace harassment.
It is important to clarify what this does and does not mean. It does not mean that the client employer is strictly liable for absolutely any workplace harassment that takes among its employees or the workers supplied by the labor contractor. Thus, if one worker supplied by the labor contractor harasses another worker supplied by the labor contractor, but neither the labor contractor nor the client employer knew or should have known about it, then neither the labor contractor nor the client employer is liable. On the other hand, under this bill the client employer is jointly liable for workplace harassment that the labor contractor knew or should have known about, even if the client employer itself did not have actual or constructive knowledge about the harassment. Thus, if the labor contractor directly harassed a worker supplied by the labor contractor, then the client employer would be jointly liable with the labor contractor for that harassment, even if the client employer did not know about it when it occurred. Similarly, if one worker supplied by the labor contractor harassed another worker supplied by the labor contractor, and the labor contractor knew or should have known about the harassment but did not take action to stop it, then the client employer would be jointly liable with the labor contractor for that harassment, even if the client employer itself did not know what was going on at the time.
The idea behind imposing this kind of joint liability is to ensure that the client employer has some skin in the game and is therefore invested in doing everything possible to ensure that workplace harassment does not take place. It contrasts with the present legal incentive structure which rewards client employers who avoid awareness about, and exercise as little control as possible over, what is happening to that part of their workforce that is supplied to them through a labor contractor.
The opponents of the bill assert that harassment is qualitatively different from payment of wages and maintenance of workers’ compensation coverage, which are things that the Labor Code already makes client employers liable to ensure. Wages and workers’ compensation coverage are verifiable things that the client employer can audit, the opponents point out; whether or not harassment has taken place is not. On the other hand, client employers are not helpless in the face of the prospect of harassment among workers supplied to them by a labor contractor. They can vet the labor contractors they use, inquiring about what anti-harassment training and protocols the labor contractor has in place. Client employers can take extra steps to check in on workers who have been supplied by the labor contractors, monitoring for signs of harassment and intervening when appropriate to nip it in the bud. Finally, of course, client employers could hire people directly to fulfill their workforce needs, rather than operating through a labor contractor at all.
4. Client employers that are exempt from the bill
The bill makes a number of exceptions to its general rule that client employers are on the hook for workplace harassment of employees obtained through a labor contractor.
First, the bill makes some exclusions based on size. It would not apply to business entities with 25 or fewer total employees, including those who were hired by the labor contractor. It also would not apply to larger business entities with five or fewer workers supplied by a labor contractor.
The decision to exclude smaller employers as well as larger employers who use little contracted labor appears to reflect a recognition that imposition of legal responsibility should bear some relation to the ability of the entity to undertake that responsibility. A large business will typically have greater resources with which to properly vet labor contractors and to help monitor worksites to ensure that harassment does not take place there. For smaller companies, by contrast, the relative burden would be much more significant. Similarly, it makes more sense to require large companies using many contract workers to bear legal responsibility for those workers than it does to impose that same risk of liability on a large company that only utilizes a handful of employees brought in through a labor contractor. In the former case, contracted employees are central to the business model, so the company can be expected to devote more attention and resources to making sure they are not harassed. In the latter circumstance, contracted labor is relatively rare. Under that scenario, asking the company to devote significant attention and resources to what is only a small aspect of their overall operation represents a far greater relative burden. In short, the bill tailors its automatic extension of joint liability for harassment to those situations in which it is likely to have the most impact and represent the smallest burden relative to the overall operation of the business.
In addition to the exclusions based on size discussed above, the bill also contains a series of carve-outs for particular types of employers. The bill would not apply to: community non-profit organizations, labor organizations, or apprenticeship programs. It would also not apply to motion picture payroll companies, as defined in detail by the bill. Finally, the bill would not apply to any third party under an employee leasing arrangement, which is defined to mean a circumstance in which the client employer is already contractually obligated to assume liability for harassment. These carve-outs match closely with the existing carve-outs from joint liability for wages and workers’ compensation coverage in the Labor Code section on which this bill is modeled. It may be worth inquiring whether these carve-outs make the same sense in the context of FEHA that they do in the Labor Code.
4. Arguments in support of the bill
According to the author:
The Me Too movement has gone a long way to further the dialogue on how to better protect workers from sexual harassment in the workplace. However, the experiences of workers in hospitality and service industries are far too often left out of the conversation. The trend we have seen, especially in the janitorial and hotel housekeeping services, has been toward outsourcing work to staffing agencies. These workers may go to work each day at the same location, wearing the uniform of the office or hotel they are cleaning, and reporting to managers onsite. Workers are, in many cases, not aware of their subcontracting agency, or of their direct supervisor. AB 170 would ensure that contracted workers can seek recourse from both their direct employer and their contracting client employer if they have experienced sexual harassment, assault, discrimination and retaliation. By requiring employers to share civil legal responsibility and civil liability, workers will be more empowered to have their reports taken seriously, and to hold accountable their workplaces.
As sponsor of the bill, UNITE HERE, Local 11 writes:
AB 170 will put an end to arguments that companies […] use to deny responsibility when subcontracted employees are allegedly sexually harassed at work. Under California law, companies must already share in civil liability when their labor contractors fail to pay workers or to provide workers’ compensation insurance. AB 170 will extend the same sound principle to sexual harassment.
In support, the California Labor Federation writes:
From actors to farmworkers, and just about every workplace in between, sexual harassment remains ever-present on the job for far too many women. Just like all labor abuses, it is more pervasive for low-wage workers, who have less bargaining power at the workplace. The more unequal the power dynamic, the harder it becomes for workers to challenge abuse.
Today, women workers are increasingly hired as part-time workers with no schedule or guarantee of hours, as temporary workers with no clear employer, and as independent contractors without basic labor rights. All of these arrangements make women workers much more vulnerable to employer abuse and coercion. A boss can easily cut their hours or move them to the night shift if they reject his advances or report abuses. If we want to empower women, we need to extend greater protections to workers in the growing contingent economy.
This bill will extend client employer liability to sexual assault, harassment, and discrimination, offering greater protection for temporary and contract workers. Under this bill, companies can no longer turn a blind eye to worker abuses by contractors.
5. Arguments in opposition to the bill
In opposition to the bill, a coalition of business and trade associations led by the California Chamber of Commerce writes:
AB 170 would require a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and liability for harassment of workers supplied by that labor contractor. This statutory mandate ignores and disrupts current law that already provides liability for harassment claims for third parties. […] The expansion of statutory joint liability under AB 170 is also inappropriate in light of the inability of the business to objectively verify and ensure that a contractor’s workers do not engage in harassing conduct. Currently, Labor Code Section 2810.3 requires a client employer to automatically share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for the payment of wages and the failure to obtain valid workers’ compensation coverage regardless of the amount of control exerted by the client employer.
However, while a client employer cannot fully protect themselves from liability, these items are at least objectively verifiable. […]
In further opposition to the bill, the American Staffing Association writes:
Although well-intentioned, AB 170 would unfairly hamstring employers when making lawful human resources decisions and impose strict liability, with respect to the unlawful actions of third parties, upon companies that may have no knowledge of or play any part in sexual harassment or discrimination. […] Such strict liability would stand conventional notions of fairness and equity on their head and would have a devastating impact on the staffing industry and almost all commerce within the state.
SUPPORT
UNITE HERE, Local 11 (Sponsor)
American Association of University Women of California
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME), AFL-CIO
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Federation of Teachers, AFT, AFL-CIO
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
California Professional Firefighters
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
Consumer Attorneys of California
Engineers and Scientists of California, Local 20, IFPTE AFL-CIO & CLC
Inlandboatmen’s Union of the Pacific
Professional & Technical Engineers, Local 21, IFPT, AFL-CIO
Screen Actors Guild - American Federation of Television and Radio Artists
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers of America
OPPOSITION
American Pistachio Growers
American Staffing Association
Associated General Contractors of California
Brea Chamber of Commerce
California Ambulance Association
California Apartment Association
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Bankers Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business & Industry Alliance
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau
California Hotel and Lodging Association
California Landscape Contractors Association
California League of Food Producers
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California Staffing Professionals
Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse
Civil Justice Association of California
Construction Employers’ Association
El Centro Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Fresno Chamber of Commerce
Garden Grove Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chamber of Commerce
National Federation of Independent Business
North Orange County Chamber
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Palm Desert Area Chamber of Commerce
Redondo Beach Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Schools Excess Liability Fund
South Bay Association of Chambers of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
Valley Industry and Commerce Association
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
AB 171 (Gonzalez, 2019) creates a rebuttal presumption of retaliation when an employer takes adverse action against an employee in the immediate wake of that employee’s complaint about sexual harassment. AB 171 is currently pending consideration before the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Prior Legislation:
AB 3081 (Gonzalez, 2018) would have, among other things, required a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for harassment for all workers supplied by that labor contractor. In his message vetoing AB 3081, then-Governor Brown wrote: “Most of the provisions of this bill are contained in current law and are therefore unnecessary. To the extent there are new provisions, they are confusing.”
AB 1701 (Thurmond, Ch. 804, Stats. 2017) holds general contractors and subcontractors jointly liable for unpaid wages, including fringe benefits.
AB 1897 (R. Hernández, Ch. 728, Stats. 2014) requires a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for all workers supplied by that labor contractor for the payment of wages and the failure to obtain valid workers’ compensation coverage.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Labor, Public Employment, and Retirement Committee (Ayes 4, Noes 1)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 49, Noes 17)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 8, Noes 3)
Assembly Labor and Employment Committee (Ayes 5, Noes 1)
**************
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR, PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Senator Jerry Hill, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 170 Hearing Date: June 12, 2019
Author: | Gonzalez | ||
Version: | April 1, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | No |
Consultant: | Alma Perez-Schwab | ||
SUBJECT: Employment: sexual harassment: liability
KEY ISSUE
Should a client employer share with a labor contractor all legal responsibility and all civil liability for harassment of the workers supplied by that labor contractor?
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), makes it an unlawful employment practice for an employer, or other specified entity, to harass an employee or other specified persons because of the employee’s or other person’s race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status. “Harassment” because of sex includes sexual harassment, and harassment based on pregnancy, childbirth, or related medical conditions. [Government Code §12940 (j)]
- Specifies that an employer shall be liable for harassment if the employer, or its agents or supervisors, knows or should have known of this conduct and fails to take immediate and appropriate corrective action. Specifies further that an employer may also be responsible for the acts of nonemployees, with consideration to the extent of the employer’s control and any other legal responsibility over their conduct. [Government Code §12940 (j)]
- Explicitly prohibits an employer, labor organization, employment agency, apprenticeship training program, or any training program leading to employment, from failing to take all reasonable steps necessary to prevent discrimination and harassment from occurring. [Government Code §12940(k)]
- Requires employers to post a poster on discrimination in employment at the workplace and provide specified notices about sexual harassment to all employees. (Government Code §12950)
- Requires employers with five or more employees to provide at least two hours of training and education regarding sexual harassment to all supervisory employees and at least one hour of training to all nonsupervisory employees within six months of their assumption of a position, and once every two years. (Government Code §12950.1)
- Requires a client employer, as defined, to share with a labor contractor, as defined, all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for all workers supplied by that labor contractor for the payment of wages and the failure to secure valid workers’
compensation coverage. [Labor Code §2810.3 (b)]
- Defines an “employer” – for purposes of the harassment provisions of FEHA only – as any person regularly employing persons or regularly receiving the services of persons providing services pursuant to a contract, or any person acting as an agent of an employer, directly or indirectly, the state, or any political or civil subdivision of the state, and cities. [Government Code §12940 (j)(4)]
- Defines “a person providing services pursuant to a contract”—for purposes of the harassment provisions of FEHA only – as a person providing services to the employer and meeting all of the following criteria:
- The person has the right to control the performance of the contract for services and has discretion as to the manner of performance.
- The person is customarily engaged in an independently established business.
- The person has control over the time and place the work is performed, supplies the tools and instruments used in the work, and performs work that requires a particular skill not ordinarily used in the course of employer’s work.
[Government Code Section 12940 (j)(5)]
This bill:
- Requires a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for harassment, as defined, for all workers supplied by that labor contractor.
- Specifies that the provisions of this bill are in addition to, and shall be supplemental of, any other theories of liability or requirement established by statute or common law.
- Defines "client employer" as a private business entity, regardless of its form, that obtains workers to perform labor within the usual course of business from a labor contractor. However, a "client employer" does not include the following: a business entity with fewer than 25 workers, including those hired directly and those obtained by a labor contractor; or a business entity with five or fewer workers supplied by a labor contractor.
- Defines "labor contractor" as an individual or entity that supplies, either with or without a contract, a client employer with workers to perform labor within the client employer's usual course of business and specifies that a "labor contractor" does not include community nonprofit organizations, labor organizations, apprenticeship programs, motion picture payroll services, as defined, or a third party who is a party to an employee leasing arrangement, as defined.
COMMENTS
1. Sexual Harassment in the Workplace and Recent Policy Changes:
Since 2017, the country has been rocked by disturbing accounts of workplace sexual harassment that have shed light on a problem hidden in plain sight. Propelled by the #MeToo and #WeSaidEnough movements, brave individuals have come forward exposing the prevalence of this problem across various industries and the harm it inflicts on victims, both personally and professionally. In response, in 2018 the Legislature passed various policy changes including expansion of sexual harassment training requirements for all employees; enhanced FEHA provisions to require more employer accountability; and prohibiting employers from requiring employees to sign a release of claims under FEHA in exchange for a raise or as a condition of employment.
Among the bills introduced last year, AB 3081 (Gonzalez), vetoed by the Governor, would have: 1) prohibit an employer from discharging or in any manner discriminating or retaliating against an employee because of the employee’s status as a victim of sexual harassment; 2) created a rebuttable presumption of unlawful retaliation; 3) imposed joint civil and legal liability between a client employer and a labor contractor for harassment, as defined, for all workers supplied by that labor contractor; and 4) prohibit the client employer and the labor contractor from taking any adverse action against any worker for providing notification of violations or for filing a claim or civil action. This bill, AB 170, addresses in very similar provisions the joint civil legal responsibility and liability portion of AB 3081 from last year.
2. Need for this bill?
According to the author, “Although California has extensive workplace protections in statute, sexual harassment has remained a persistent problem across industries, especially for women in low-wage jobs. An estimated 60 percent of workers nationwide who have experienced sexual harassment in their workplace have not reported it. Among the reasons cited for why workers do not raise complaints, the most common are fears of disbelief of their testimony, of inaction on their claim, of blame for the harassment, and of social and professional retaliation. By reporting or even sharing an issue with a colleague, workers risk their ability to provide for their children and families.”
The author argues that, “Workers may go to work each day at the same location, wearing the same uniform as other staff, and reporting to managers onsite—while not being employees of the company. Workers are, in many cases, not aware of their subcontracting agency, or of their direct supervisor. In spite of this clear de facto workplace and managers, these contracting companies are not held responsible when sexual harassment and assault happen on their watch to subcontracted workers. Currently, it is not clear under existing law (FEHA) if an employee would be responsible for harassment committed by a contract employee against a direct employee.”
This bill would ensure that contracted workers could seek recourse from both their direct employer and the contracting client employer if they have experienced harassment on any protected basis in the workplace. By requiring employers to share civil legal responsibility and civil liability, workers will be more equipped to have their reports taken seriously, and to hold their workplaces accountable.
3. Shared Civil Legal Responsibility and Shared Civil Liability for Harassment:
As noted above, existing FEHA provisions prohibit a number of unlawful employment practices to protect the rights of employees. FEHA prohibits harassment because of an employee’s race, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, sexual orientation, veteran status, or other protected characteristic and includes sexual harassment under the definition of “harassment.” Concerning the goal of this bill, to make a client employer share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for harassment, it is unclear whether FEHA already captures these situations.
According to the Assembly Judiciary Committee analysis on this bill, “To understand the reach of the bill before the Committee, and how it changes existing law, it is necessary to understand the extent of an employer’s existing obligations under FEHA. Although the bill’s opponents claim that current law “already provides appropriate liability for harassment claims in relation to third parties,” this is only partially true. In fact, FEHA imposes different obligations depending upon, among other things, who commits the harassment and who is the victim of the harassment. Harassment by the employer (including by an agent or supervisory employee) against an employee, applicant, intern, volunteer, or “person providing services under contract” is an unlawful employment practice and directly subjects the employer to liability. However, harassment committed by a non-supervisory employee – whether committed against another employee or a contracted worker – is an unlawful employment practice on the part of the employer, but only if the employer or other covered entity knew or should have known about the harassing conduct and failed to take immediate and appropriate corrective action. An employer may also be responsible for the acts of a nonemployee who harasses employees, applicants, interns, volunteers, or persons providing service under contract, if the employer knew or should have known about the conduct. FEHA specifies that in reviewing cases involving the acts of nonemployees, the reviewing entity (DFEH or a court) shall consider the “extent of the employer’s control” over the conduct of the nonemployee. (Government Code Section 12940 (j)(1).)”
The author wants to ensure that the party best positioned to learn of the conduct, and who in fact does first learn of the conduct, will have the legal responsibility to take appropriate corrective action to prevent harassment. AB 170 would make both the client employer and the labor contractor legally responsible for protecting workers against harassment.
The issue of shared liability and responsibility has already been addressed by the Legislature with regards to the payment of wages and failure to secure worker’ compensation coverage under Labor Code Section 2810.3 (AB 1897, Hernandez, 2014). This bill takes the same approach of requiring shared liability and legal responsibility but under FEHA provisions in the Government Code. With these changes, this bill will encourage both client employers and labor contractors to share the responsibility of ensuring a harassment free work environment while also ensuring that appropriate corrective action is taken when necessary.
4. Suggested Amendments:
Beginning on page 2, the bill provides the following definition:
“Labor contractor” means an individual or entity that supplies, either with or without a contract, a client employer with workers to perform labor within the client employer’s usual course of business. “Labor contractor” does not include community nonprofit organizations, labor organizations, apprenticeship programs, motion picture payroll services, as defined, or a third party who is a party to an employee leasing arrangement, as defined.”
The definition for “labor contractor” is modeled very similarly after the existing definition under Labor Code Section 2810.3. However, the definition in this bill refers to the terms “motion picture payroll services” and “employee leasing arrangement” as defined but fails to provide a definition or reference where it is defined. The author may wish to amend the bill to include definitions for these terms as follows (taken directly from existing Labor Code Section 2810.3 and Unemployment Insurance Code Section 679):
AMENDMENT:
On page 3, add the following at line 5:
(3) “Motion picture payroll services company” means any employing unit that directly or through its affiliated entities meets all of the following criteria:
(a) Contractually provides the services of motion picture production workers to a motion picture production company or to an allied motion picture services company.
(b) Is a signatory to a collective bargaining agreement for one or more of its clients.
(c) Controls the payment of wages to the motion picture production workers and pays those wages from its own account or accounts.
(d) Is contractually obligated to pay wages to the motion picture production workers without regard to payment or reimbursement by the motion picture production company or allied motion picture services company.
(e) At least 80 percent of the wages paid by the motion picture payroll services company each calendar year are paid to workers associated between contracts with motion picture production companies and motion picture payroll services companies.
(4) “Employee leasing arrangement” has the same meaning as that term is defined by Rule 4 of Section V of the California Workers’ Compensation Experience Rating Plan-1995 (Section 2353.1 of Title 10 of the California Code of Regulations), as it read on January 1, 2019, except those arrangements described in subrule d of Rule 4 of Section V, if the employee leasing arrangement contractually obligates the client employer to assume all civil legal responsibility and civil liability under this act.
5. Proponent Arguments:
The sponsors of the measure, Unite Here Local 11, share the case of Sandra Pezquada, a former dishwasher at the Terranea Resort who was employed through a temporary staffing agency. They write, “Shortly after she began working, Sandra’s male supervisor allegedly began to sexually harass her. She later filed a lawsuit against the staffing agency and the resort, alleging, among other claims, that the supervisor pursued her sexually over a period of months and tried to kiss her in a storage room. She alleged that when she rebuffed his sexual advances, the supervisor retaliated against her, changing her schedule and cutting her hours so that she was working too little to support herself. After Sandra came forward to report sexual harassment, she was fired. Even though Sandra worked each day at the Terranea, washing the resort’s dishes alongside the resort’s directly employed employees and managers, the Terranea denied responsibility in part because the supervisor who allegedly harassed her was employed by the staffing agency.”
In support of the bill, the California Employment Lawyers Association writes, “our attorneys often represent victims of sexual harassment and have found that subcontracting work arrangements are becoming an increasingly common tactic employers use to try to evade liability. Given the important mandate under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) to ‘provide effective remedies that will both prevent and deter unlawful employment
practices and redress the adverse effects of those practices on aggrieved persons,’ it is critical that client employers are not able to use subcontracting work arrangements to shield themselves from the commands and duties of the FEHA.” CELA argues that courts “have already found joint employer liability for harassment under the FEHA, recognizing that to hold otherwise would allow workers to be sent into hostile and discriminatory workplaces without remedy.” CELA cites the case Mathieu v. Norrell Corp. (2004), which noted that, “the purposes of FEHA are promoted if both the staffing agency and the client are treated as the employer, and the employees of the client entity are treated as coworkers of employees of the staffing agency within the meaning of FEHA.” CELA concludes, “AB 170 will help ensure that client employers are not able to opt out of the statutory duties under the Fair Employment and Housing Act by imposing joint liability for harassment for all workers supplied by a labor contractor.”
6. Opponent Arguments:
A coalition of employers, including the California Chamber of Commerce writes in opposition arguing that the bill creates another pathway to costly litigation against employers for issues that are already protected under FEHA. They write, “If a non-supervisory employee harasses a “person providing services pursuant to a contract,” the client employer is liable if they knew or should have known about the harassing conduct and failed to take immediate and appropriate corrective action. A client employer will also be liable for harassment by a third-party non-employee if the client employer knew or should have known of the unlawful conduct and failed to take immediate action. In reviewing cases involving the acts of third-party nonemployees with regards to harassment, the extent of the client employer's control and any other legal responsibility which the employer may have with respect to the conduct of those nonemployees shall be considered.”
Additionally, they write “if an individual does not meet the definition of a “person providing services pursuant to a contract,” the client employer will still be held liable for any unlawful harassment if the client employer exerted such control over the working conditions of the contractor’s employees that essentially the third party acted as the real employer. See Bradley v. California Dept. of Corrections and Rehabilitation, 158 Cal.App.4th 1612 (2008) (state agency exerted sufficient control over the individual to be considered an employer for purposes of FEHA).” They argue that this bill completely ignores this common law and statutory analysis and imposing liability despite the lack of any knowledge or control exerted by the client employer and even if the employees of the client employer are not involved in the harassment.
In comparing these provisions to existing joint liability provisions for the payment of wages and workers’ compensation coverage, opponents argue that “while a client employer cannot fully protect themselves from liability, these items are at least objectively verifiable. A client employer can conduct audits of wage and hour practices and confirm whether or not the labor contractor has valid worker’s compensation coverage for its employees. In contrast, there is no way to force or ensure that a labor contractor and all of its employees are complying with FEHA. There is no basis for a business that contracts for services being deemed statutorily liable for harassment of another’s employees when there is absolutely no way in which that contractor can engage or force the labor contract company to comply with provisions of FEHA or the Labor Code.” Further, they assert that expanding this automatic liability to all harassment is inappropriate because “controlling the acts of individual employees is hard enough, let alone the acts of another employer’s employees that the client employer does not control.” Overall, they argue that current law already provides adequate pathway for civil liability for a business that is actually controlling the employees of another and there is no basis for that analysis to be completely disregarded under this bill.
7. Double Referral:
This bill has been double referred and, if approved by this committee, it will be sent to the Senate Judiciary Committee for a hearing.
8. Prior/Related Legislation:
AB 3081 (Gonzales) of 2018, among other things, would have required employers to share civil legal responsibility and civil liability for all workers who are provided by a contractor in cases harassment, as defined. This bill was vetoed by Governor Brown who stated, “This bill creates a new, ill-defined standard of joint liability between labor contractors and client employers, prohibits both entities from retaliating against an employee who has filed a harassment claim, and establishes a 30-day notice requirement before certain workers can file a civil action against a client employer. Most of the provisions in this bill are contained in current law and are therefore unnecessary. To the extent there are new provisions, they are confusing.”
SB 1300 (Jackson), Chapter 955, Statutes of 2018 addresses the severe or pervasive standard for litigating sexual harassment claims and prohibits employers from requiring employees to sign a release of claims under FEHA in exchange for a raise or as a condition of employment.
SB 1343 (Mitchell), Chapter 956, Statutes of 2018 requires employers of 5 or more employees to provide at least 2 hours of sexual harassment training to all employees by January 1, 2020, and once every 2 years after that. The bill also requires the development of specified training tools and posting requirements.
AB 1870 (Reyes) of 2018, would have extended the deadline for filing a complaint with the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH) about a violation of the employment protections in FEHA from one year after the date of the violation to three years after the date of the violation. This bill was vetoed by Governor Brown.
AB 1701 (Thurmond) Chapter 804, Statutes of 2017 holds general contractors and subcontractors jointly liable for unpaid wages, including fringe benefits, and authorizes civil actions to enforce the joint liability.
AB 1978 (Gonzalez), Chapter 373, Statutes of 2016 created a registration process for janitorial employers and requires sexual harassment and violence prevention training for janitorial workers.
AB 1897 (R. Hernández) Chapter 728, Statutes of 2014 requires a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for all workers supplied by that labor contractor for the payment of wages and the failure to obtain valid workers’ compensation coverage.
SUPPORT
UNITE HERE Local 11 (Sponsor)
American Association of University Women
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Federation of Teachers
California Labor Federation
California Professional Firefighters
California Teamsters
Consumer Attorneys of California
Engineers and Scientists of CA, IFPTE Local 20
Inlandboatmen’s Union of the Pacific
Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21
SAG-AFTRA
UNITE-HERE, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers of America
OPPOSITION
American Pistachio Growers
American Staffing Association
Associated General Contractors
Brea Chamber of Commerce
California Ambulance Association
California Apartment Association
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Bankers Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business & Industrial Alliance
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Hotel and Lodging Association
California Landscape Contractors Association
California League of Food Producers
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse
Civil Justice Association of California
Construction Employers’ Association
El Centro Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Fresno Chamber of Commerce
Garden Grove Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
National Federation of Independent Business
North Orange County Chamber
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Palm Desert Area Chamber of Commerce
Redondo Beach Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
South Bay Association of Chambers of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 170
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Amended Ver:April 1, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Provides that a client employer and a labor contractor shall share civil legal responsibility and civil liability for harassment of workers supplied by the labor contractor.
Major Provisions
- Provides that a client employer shall share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for harassment, as defined, for all workers supplied by the labor contractor.
- Specifies that the provisions of this bill are in addition to, and shall be supplemental of, any other theories of liability or requirement established by statute or common law.
- Defines "client employer" to mean a private business entity, regardless of its form, that obtains workers to perform labor within the usual course of business from a labor contractor. However, a "client employer" does not include the following: a business entity with fewer than 25 workers, including those hired directly and those obtained by a labor contractor; or a business entity with five or fewer workers supplied by a labor contractor.
- Defines "labor contractor" to mean an individual or entity that supplies, either with or without a contract, a client employer with workers to perform labor within the client employer's usual course of business and specifies that a "labor contractor" does not include community nonprofit organizations, labor organizations, apprenticeship programs, motion picture payroll services, as defined, or a third party who is a party to an employee leasing arrangement, as defined.
COMMENTS:
A 2017 report by the Center for American Progress reviewed Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) data from 2005-2015 on sexual harassment charges and found that "more than one-quarter of sexual harassment charges were filed in industries with large numbers of service-sector workers, including many low-wage jobs that are often occupied by women." The report also found that nearly three-quarters of sexual harassment charges included an allegation of retaliation either upon being filed or later on in an investigation.
According to the Author:
According to the author, this bill is necessary to address and provide recourse for these workers, often contracted or even subcontracted, if they are sexually harassed. The author points out that many hotel workers "go to work each day at the same location, wearing the uniform of the office or hotel they are cleaning, and reporting to managers onsite. Workers are, in many cases, not aware of their subcontracting agency, or of their direct supervisor. In spite of this clear de facto workplace and managers, these contracting companies and hotels are not held responsible when sexual harassment and assault happen on their watch to subcontracted workers."
Arguments in Support:
UNITE HERE, Local 11, the sponsor of this bill, argues that this measure will put an end to arguments that companies use to deny responsibility when subcontracted employees are allegedly sexually harassed at work. Under California law, companies must already share in civil liability when their labor contractors fail to pay workers or to provide workers' compensation insurance. This bill will extend the same sound principle to sexual harassment.
In support of the bill, the California Employment Lawyers Association writes, "our attorneys often represent victims of sexual harassment and have found that subcontracting work arrangements are becoming an increasingly common tactic employers use to try to evade liability. Given the important mandate under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) to 'provide effective remedies that will both prevent and deter unlawful employment practices and redress the adverse effects of those practices on aggrieved persons,' it is critical that client employers are not able to use subcontracting work arrangements to shield themselves from the commands and duties of the FEHA. (See Government Code Section 12920.5)"
Arguments in Opposition:
A group of employer organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, states in opposition, "AB 170 would require a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and liability for harassment of workers supplied by that labor contractor. This statutory mandate ignores and disrupts current law that already provides liability for harassment claims for third parties. Per FEHA, a client employer may be held strictly liable for harassment of a "person providing services pursuant to a contract" if a supervisory employee is the harasser. Government Code Section 12940(j)(1). If a non-supervisory employee harasses a 'person providing services pursuant to a contract,' the client employer is liable if they knew or should have known about the harassing conduct and failed to take immediate and appropriate corrective action."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None
VOTES:
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 5-1-1
YES: Kalra, Carrillo, Gonzalez, Bonta, Luz Rivas
NO: Flora
ABS, ABST OR NV: Diep
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-3-1
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Reyes
NO: Gallagher, Fong, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Petrie-Norris
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 1, 2019
CONSULTANT: Megan Lane / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0000082
Date of Hearing: March 26, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 170
Author:(Gonzalez) – As Amended Ver:March 21, 2019
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Employment: harassment: liability
KEY ISSUE: Should a client employer share with a labor contractor all legal responsIbility and civil liability for harassment of the workers provided by the labor contractor?
SYNOPSIS
California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) prohibits a number of “unlawful employment practices” in order to protect certain fundamental rights of employees. Most relevant to this bill, FEHA makes it an unlawful employment practice for an employer, labor organization, employment agency, or related entity to harass an employee because of the employee’s race, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, sexual orientation, veteran status, or other protected characteristic. This bill would require a “client employer” to share with a labor contractor all “legal responsibility and civil liability” relating to the harassment of workers provided to the client employer by the labor contractor. According to the author, shared legal responsibility for harassment is necessary because employers are increasingly relying on “contract workers” (that is, employees provided by a staffing agency) in place of more conventional workers who are employed directly by the employer. One consequence of this practice is that some “client employers” may attempt to shift responsibility for complying with labor and civil rights laws to the “labor contractor,” notwithstanding the fact that many “contract workers” are de facto employees who often work side-by-side with regular employees. The Legislature has already recognized this problem and attempted to address it by requiring client employers to share certain legal duties and liabilities with the labor contractors that provide workers. Most notably, in 2014, AB 1897 (Hernández) created Labor Code Section 2810.3, which requires client employers to share legal responsibility and civil liability with labor contractors on matters dealing with wages and workers’ compensation coverage. This bill, drawing upon the language of Labor Section 2810.3, adds a provision to FEHA that will similarly require client employers to share responsibility and liability with labor contractors in order to better protect workers from harassment, and to encourage both client employers and labor contractors to take the immediate and appropriate corrective action that is required by law.
AB 170 is sponsored by Unite Here Local 11 and supported by several labor organizations, as well as the Consumer Attorneys of California and the California Employment Lawyers Association. For reasons discussed in the analysis, a coalition of business and employer groups, spearheaded by the California Chamber of Commerce, oppose AB 170. The author will take technical amendments in this Committee, which are reflected in the analysis.
SUMMARY: Provides that a client employer and a labor contractor shall share legal responsibility and civil liability for harassment of workers supplied by the labor contractor. Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that a client employer shall share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for harassment, as defined, for all workers supplied by the labor contractor.
- Specifies that the provisions of this bill are in addition to, and shall be supplemental of, any other theories of liability or requirement established by statute or common law.
- Defines “client employer” to mean a private business entity, regardless of its form, that obtains workers to perform labor within the usual course of business from a labor contractor. However, a “client employer” does not include the following: a business entity with fewer than 25 workers, including those hired directly and those obtained by a labor contractor; or a business entity with five or fewer workers supplied by a labor contractor.
- Defines “labor contractor” to mean an individual or entity that supplies, either with or without a contract, a client employer with workers to perform labor within the client employer’s usual course of business; and specifies that a “labor contractor” does not include community nonprofit organizations, labor organizations or apprenticeship programs, motion picture payroll services, as defined, or a third party who is a party to an employee leasing arrangement, as defined.
EXISTING LAW:
- Makes it an unlawful employment practice for an employer, or other specified entity, to harass an employee or other specified persons because of the employee’s or other person’s race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status. Specifies that an employer shall be liable for harassment if the employer, or its agents or supervisors, knows or should have known of this conduct and fails to take immediate and appropriate corrective action. Specifies further that an employer may also be responsible for the acts of nonemployees, as specified. (Government Code Section 12940 (j).)
- Requires an employer to provide specified notices about sexual harassment to all employees and requires an employer with fifty or more employees to provide sexual harassment prevention training, as specified. (Government Code Sections 12950 and 12950.1.)
- Provides that a client employer shall share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for all workers supplied by the labor contractor for the payment of wages and failure to secure valid workers’ compensation coverage. (Labor Code Section 2810.3 (b).)
- Defines an “employer” – for purposes of the harassment provisions of FEHA only – as any person regularly employing persons or regularly receiving the services of persons providing services pursuant to a contract, or any person acting as an agent of an employer, directly or indirectly, the state, or any political or civil subdivision of the state, and cities.
- Defines “a person providing services pursuant to a contract”—for purposes of the harassment provisions of FEHA only – as a person providing services to the employer and meeting all of the following criteria:
- The person has the right to control the performance of the contract for services and has discretion as to the manner of performance.
- The person is customarily engaged in an independently established business.
- The person has control over the time and place the work is performed, supplies the tools and instruments used in the work, and performs work that requires a particular skill not ordinarily used in the course of employer’s work. (Government Code Section 12940 (j)(5) (A)-(C).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: According to the author, AB 170 will “ensure that contracted workers can seek recourse from both their direct employer and their contracting client employer if they have experienced sexual harassment, assault, discrimination and retaliation.” The author believes that by “requiring employers to share civil legal responsibility and civil liability, workers will be more empowered to have their reports taken seriously.” Shared responsibility and liability is especially important, the author contends, where contracted workers “go to work each day at the same location, wearing the same uniform as other staff, and reporting to managers on site – while not being employees of the company.” Because such workers are technically employees of the labor contractor but de facto employees of the client employer, the legal responsibility for protecting contracted workers is not always clear. This lack of clarity creates an opportunity for irresponsible client employers and labor contractors to attempt to shift liability to the other party. AB 170 seeks to avoid this possibility by making both the client employer and the labor contractor legally responsible for protecting workers from harassment. AB 170 does this by modeling the language of an existing statute that requires employers to share with a labor contractor “all civil legal responsibility and civil liability” on matters of wages and workers compensation coverage.
Existing Employer Responsibility under FEHA: California’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) prohibits a number of “unlawful employment practices” in order to protect certain fundamental rights of employees. Most relevant to this bill, FEHA makes it an unlawful employment practice for an employer, labor organization, employment agency, or related entity [hereafter “employer or other covered entity”] to harass an employee because of the employee’s race, religion, sex, gender, gender identity, sexual orientation, veteran status, or other protected characteristic. Although the Legislative Council digest title refers to sexual harassment, both the bill and the existing provisions of FEHA prohibit harassment based on any of the enumerated classifications, not just sex.
To understand the reach of the bill before the Committee, and how it changes existing law, it is necessary to understand the extent of an employer’s existing obligations under FEHA. Although the bill’s opponents claim that current law “already provides appropriate liability for harassment claims in relation to third parties,” this is only partially true. In fact, FEHA imposes different obligations depending upon, among other things, who commits the harassment and who is the victim of the harassment. Harassment by the employer (including by an agent or supervisory employee) against an employee, applicant, intern, volunteer, or “person providing services under contract” is an unlawful employment practice and directly subjects the employer to liability. However, harassment committed by a non-supervisory employee – whether committed against another employee or a contracted worker – is an unlawful employment practice on the part of the employer, but only if the employer or other covered entity knew or should have known about the harassing conduct and failed to take immediate and appropriate corrective action. An employer may also be responsible for the acts of a nonemployee who harasses employees, applicants, interns, volunteers, or persons providing service under contract, if the employer knew or should have known about the conduct. FEHA specifies that in reviewing cases involving the acts of nonemployees, the reviewing entity (DFEH or a court) shall consider the “extent of the employer’s control” over the conduct of the nonemployee. (Government Code Section 12940 (j)(1).)
In short, FEHA attempts to ensure that all workers – whether direct employees, contract workers that are de facto employees, or true independent contractors – are reasonably free from harassment. FEHA also attempts to ensure that most persons authorized to enter the workplace, and under the control of the employer, do not harass others. Nevertheless, existing law also leaves significant gaps that this bill attempts to fill. For example, existing law makes an employer responsible for harassment committed by a non-supervisory employee against a contracted worker or independent contractor, if the employer knew or should have known about the conduct. Similarly, the employer is responsible for harassment committed by a contracted worker against a direct employee, at least to the extent that the employer knew or should have known about the conduct. However, it is not certain, under existing statutory law, whether an employer would be responsible for an act of harassment committed by a contracted worker against another contracted worker, even if both are under the de facto control of the employer.
To a certain extent, case law has filled in some of the gaps in the FEHA statutory provisions on responsibility for harassment by treating contracted workers as “special employees” for purposes of the statute, depending largely on the extent to which the employer exercises “control” over the work of the contracted worker. For example, in Bradley v. California Dept. of Corrections and Rehabilitation (2008) 158 Cal. App. 4th 1612, Sallie Mae Bradley, a social worker who provided counseling services in a California prison, sued CDCR for failing to respond to her complaints about sexual harassment by a prison doctor. By most standard definitions, Bradley was an “independent contractor.” That is, the prison contracted with a medical personnel registry, and the registry paid Bradley’s salary. However, in holding that Bradley could sue CDCR as her “employer” under FEHA, a California appellate court noted that the registry’s role was limited to sending qualified professionals to the prisons; once in the prison, however, the professionals received assignments and supervision from prison officials. The court concluded, therefore, for purposes of the FEHA provisions making harassment an unlawful employment practice, CDCR was an “employer” and Bradley was a “special employee.” In short, the court does not look to words of a service contract (which clearly designated Bradley an independent contractor), but to the substance of the relationship, which made Bradley a de facto employee and CDCR her employer.
Even had the Bradley court concluded that Bradley had too much independence to be a “special employee,” the court could have found, in the alternative, that Bradley still enjoyed protection under FEHA as a “person providing services pursuant to a contract.” This is precisely what another California appellate court did in Hirst v. City of Oceanside (2015) 236 Cal. App. 4th 774. In that case, the court found that a phlebotomist who provided services for a city police department performed her work with enough freedom and independence that she did not fall under the “special employee” category articulated by Bradley. However, the court noted that she did fit the definition of a “person providing services under contract,” and thus was protected under FEHA.
Liability and the Question of “Control:” Citing much of the same case law discussed above, the opponents of this bill argue that this bill is unnecessary because, they claim, existing law already provides “appropriate liability” in relation to contracted workers or other “third party non-employees.” The truth of this claim depends upon how one defines “appropriate.” According to the opponents, existing case law provides appropriate liability because it holds an employer liable for harassment committed by a contracted worker or other nonemployee only if the employer exercises enough “control” over the person committing the harassment to know about the conduct and, once known, has the power to take appropriate corrective action.
Opponents correctly note that existing case law already relies on the concept of “control” and the “special employee” to hold employers accountable for harassment against a contract employee that is committed by a direct employee. However, it is less clear that an employer would be responsible for harassment committed by a contract employee against another contract employee, nor is it entirely clear who is responsible for harassment committed by a contract employee against a direct employee. The FEHA statute only makes the employer responsible for harassment committed by the employer, a supervisor or agent, a direct employee, or a nonemployee over whom the employer exercises control. However, the statute does not clearly make the employer responsible for harassment committed by a contracted worker against either a direct employee or another contracted worker. The case law suggests that protection afforded to someone harassed by a nonemployee or contracted worker will depend upon the extent of the employer’s control over the involved parties. For example, did the employer exercise enough control over the victim to make the victim a “special employee” with standing to sue? Alternatively, did the employer exercise enough control over the harasser to impose a duty upon the employer to take corrective actions? According to the opponents, this is how it should be: employers should only be responsible for the conduct of persons that they control.
The problem with the opposition argument, however, is that in many situations, it is not always clear (at least before adjudication) whether the client employer or the labor contractor is in the best position to gain knowledge of the harassment and take immediate and appropriate corrective action to stop it. Moreover, as the bill’s sponsor notes in its letter of support, employees do not always know to whom they should turn when harassed. When they do report, the client employer may deny responsibility because the client employer is not the direct employer of the harasser. The sponsor points specifically to the case of Sandra Pezqueda, a dishwasher at a coastal resort who endured sexual harassment from a male supervisor. The resort had obtained the services of both Sandra and the harassing supervisor from a temporary staffing agency. When Sandra complained to the resort managers, they denied any responsibility because the resort was not the direct employer of either party. Although Sandra eventually received a settlement from the staffing agency (not the resort), it is not certain whether a court using the reasoning in the Bradley decision would have allowed Sandra to sue the resort, given that the harassing supervisor was employed by the staffing agency. (In Bradley, the harassing supervisor was employed by the prison, not by the staffing agency.) Under this bill, both the resort and the staffing agency would be responsible for taking corrective action upon learning of the conduct, and both would be liable if they failed to take any action. In short, under this bill, the burden would not be on the victim to perform a Bradley analysis in order to know where to direct the report.
Bill requires sharing both “responsibility” and “liability:” Significantly, AB 170 requires the client employer to share with the labor contractor “all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for harassment.” This phrase comes from Labor Code Section 2810.3, which requires a client employer and a labor contractor to share legal duties and liabilities relating to the payment of wages and providing workers’ compensation coverage. Because the letters of opposition focus mostly on the shared “liability” component when they claim that the bill will “create another pathway for costly litigation,” it is important to stress that the bill requires the employer and labor contractor to share both legal responsibility and liability.
AB 170 does not merely create joint and several liability so that the aggrieved employee can sue either entity; more important, the bill imposes shared responsibility under FEHA. The primary purpose of FEHA, after all, is not to allow an employee who has been harassed to sue the employer; rather, its primary purpose is to require employers, when they learn of the harassment, to take “immediate and appropriate corrective action” to stop the harassment and prevent further harm. As noted in the author’s background material, this bill is primarily concerned with arrangements in which staffing agencies provide the employer with workers that perform the same functions as workers who often are employed directly by, and the under the supervision of, the employer. In some of those cases, the role of the labor contractor or staffing agency in day-to-day supervision may be limited; in others, the labor contractor or staffing agency may also provide supervisors, thereby leaving a more limited supervisory role of the client employer. Under such circumstances, it seems plausible that either the client employer or the labor contractor will have opportunities to gain knowledge of the harassment. This bill will ensure that the party best positioned to learn of the conduct, and who in fact does first learn of the conduct, will have the legal responsibility to take appropriate corrective action.
What the “appropriate” corrective action will be may vary as between the client employer and the labor contractor. If the ability of the employer to take corrective action were limited, then appropriate corrective action on the employer’s part would include, at a minimum, notifying the labor contractor. In short, this bill will not create an additional pathway to litigation, as opponents fear; to the contrary, by imposing a duty on both the employer and contractor to take appropriate corrective action to prevent harassment, it may actually reduce litigation.
Relevance of Existing Precedent for Shared Responsibility and Liability: Existing law (Labor Code Section 2810.3) creates a precedent for imposing shared legal responsibility and civil liability on client employers and labor contractors, specifically to ensure that workers receive fair wages and workers’ compensation coverage. Many of the factors that gave rise to the prior statute would seem to justify the shared responsibility and liability created by this bill. The legislative history of Labor Code Section 2810.3 suggests that it was concerned not so much with workers who fit the more traditional definition of an “independent contractor” – that is, an individual and independent professional providing a service unrelated that was ancillary to the employer’s main business. Rather, Labor Code Section 2810.3 was concerned with farm workers, janitors, hotel workers, and others who performed a core function of the employer’s business and often worked alongside an employer’s “regular” employees, or performed the same tasks as regular employees of the business. Under these circumstances, it is not always clear who bore responsibility for protecting basic worker rights. (See Assembly Committee on Labor and Employment, Analysis of AB 1897, April 23, 2014.) According to the background material provided by the author’s office and information provided in the support letters, it appears that a similar ambiguity exists as to who is responsible for responding to sexual harassment complaints, and who is responsible for taking appropriate corrective action upon learning of the harassment. Thus, from the perspective of the author and sponsor, Labor Code Section 2810.3 provides an apt precedent for this bill.
Opponents, on the other hand, stress the difference between creating shared responsibility for wages and workers compensation coverage, on the one hand, and shared responsibility for addressing workplace sexual harassment, on the other. Opponents contend that employers can ask independent contracts for concrete evidence that it pays legal wages and provides workers’ compensation coverage. However, employers cannot ask the labor contractor for evidence that sexual harassment is not occurring. While this is a valid distinction, its significance holds less weight in situations where the client employer and labor contractor are both in a position to learn of the harassment.
Opponents also claim that this bill will hold them liable regardless of whether the employer has knowledge of the harassment. This, however, does not appear to be the case. Under FEHA, the employer commits an unlawful employment practice if the employer, or one of its agents or supervisory employees, commits the harassment. For example, an employer would be liable if the harassment was committed by one its supervisors, even if the employer had no knowledge of the harassment. However, when someone other than the employer or supervisor commits the harassment (e.g. a direct non-supervisory employee), the employer is liable for an unlawful employment practice only if the employer knew or should have known of the harassment and failed to take appropriate corrective action. AB 170 will not change that. What AB 170 will do is impose upon both the client employer and independent contractor the legal duty to take appropriate corrective action to address and prevent harassment, whether the victim or harasser is a contract worker or a direct employee. This seems reasonable and consistent in light of existing precedents, both in statutory law and in case law.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Unite Here Local 11, the bill’s sponsor, notes that sexual harassment is not an “abstract issue” to its membership and provides a detailed and concrete example of the kind of problem that this bill seeks to address. According to the sponsor, Sandra Pezqueda worked as a dishwasher at Terranea Resort, along the California coast, side-by-side with employees who were direct employees of Terranea. When Sandra informed management at Terranea that her supervisor had sexually harassed her, the company denied any responsibility and sought to dismiss her complaint because both Sandra and the supervisor were employees of a staffing agency, and therefore not employees of Terranea. Unite Here argues that, “AB 170 will put an end to arguments that companies like Terranea use to deny responsibility when subcontracted employees are allegedly sexually harassed at work. Under California law, companies must already share in civil liability when their labor contractors fail to pay workers or to provide workers’ compensation insurance. AB 170 will extend the same sound principle to sexual harassment.”
The California Employment Lawyers Association (CELA) aptly places this bill within the context of the overall purpose of FEHA. CELA writes that its attorneys “often represent victims of sexual harassment and have found that subcontracting work arrangements are becoming an increasingly common tactic employers use to try to evade liability. Given the important mandate under [FEHA] to ‘provide effective remedies that will both prevent and deter unlawful employment practices and address the adverse effects of those practices on aggrieved persons,’ it is critical that client employers are not able to use subcontracting work arrangements to shield themselves from the commands and duties of the Act.” CELA argues that courts “have already found joint employer liability for harassment under the FEHA, recognizing that to hold otherwise would allow workers to be sent into hostile and discriminatory workplaces without remedy.” CELA cites, in particular, Mathieu v. Norrell Corp. (2004), which noted that, “the purposes of FEHA are promoted if both the staffing agency and the client are treated as the employer, and the employees of the client entity are treated as coworkers of employees of the staffing agency within the meaning of FEHA.” CELA concludes, “AB 170 will help ensure that client employers are not able to opt out of the statutory duties under [FEHA]” by shifting responsibility to contractors.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: A large coalition of business and employer groups, spearheaded by the California Chamber of Commerce, vigorously oppose AB 170. Opposition arguments make two central claims.
First, opponents contend that the bill is unnecessary because existing law already provides appropriate liability for harassment claims by linking liability to knowledge of the harassment and effective control over the worker’s conduct. Specifically, opponents claim that AB 170 creates a “statutory mandate [that] ignores and disrupts current law that already provides liability for harassment claims of third parties. Per FEHA, a client employer may be held strictly liable for harassment of a ‘person providing services pursuant to a contract if a supervisory employee is the harasser. . . If a non-supervisory employee harasses a ‘person providing services pursuant to a contract, the client employer is liable if they knew or should have known about the harassing conduct and failed to take immediate and appropriate corrective action.’” [Emphasis in the original.] Opponents also point out that “a client employer will also be liable for a harassment by a third-party contractor if the client knew or should have known of the unlawful conduct and failed to take immediate action.” [Emphasis in the original.] Finally, in support of the claim that existing law is adequate, the opponents cite the Bradley v. California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, discussed above. The Bradley decision shows that even if the victim does not meet the definition of a “person providing services pursuant to a contract,” a court may still find the client employer liable “if the client employer exerted such control over the working conditions of the contractor’s employees that essentially the third party acted as the real employer.” In sum, opponents claim that, “AB 170 completely ignores this common law and statutory analysis and imposes liability despite the lack of any knowledge or control exerted by the employer.”
Second, opponents distinguish the shared responsibility created by existing law over wage and workers’ compensation issues from shared responsibility for sexual harassment, claiming that the latter is not “objectively verifiable.” For example, opponents argue that while Labor Code Section 2810.3 holds client employers jointly liable with the labor contractor for payment of wages and failure to provide workers compensation coverage, “these terms are least objectively verifiable.” For example, a client employer “can conduct audits of wage and hour practices and confirm whether or not the labor contractor has valid worker’s compensation coverage for its employees. In contrast, there is no way to force or ensure that a labor contractor and all of its employees are complying with FEHA.” Opponents also contend that Labor Code Section 2810.3 is different because, under that statute, the client employer is jointly liable for violations committed by the labor contractor, not by the labor contractor’s employees.
Proposed Author Amendments: The most recent amendments to the bill struck out lines 7-20 on page 2 of the bill in print. The author’s intent was to strike lines 7-17. Therefore, the author will take a technical amendment in this Committee to restore lines 18-20. In addition, the bill in print defines “client employer” by reference to Labor Code Section 2810.3. However, the Labor Code section defines “client employer” to exclude public employers, while the harassment provisions of FEHA apply to both public and private employers. In order to maintain consistency with FEHA, the author will delete the reference to the Labor Code definition and instead insert a definition of “employer” specific to this bill. The amendments, therefore, will be as follows:
- On page 2 after line 17 insert:
(b)The provisions of this section are in addition to, and shall be supplemental of, any other theories of liability or requirement established by statute or common law.
- On page 2, delete lines 22-24 and insert:
(b) For purposes of this section:
(1) “Client employer” means a private business entity, regardless of its form, that obtains workers to perform labor within the usual course of business from a labor contractor. However, a “client employer” does not include the following: a business entity with fewer than 25 workers, including those hired directly and those obtained by a labor contractor; or a business entity with five or fewer workers supplied by a labor contractor.
(2) “Labor contractor” means an individual or entity that supplies, either with or without a contract, a client employer with workers to perform labor within the client employer’s usual course of business. Specifies that a “labor contractor” does not include community nonprofit organizations, labor organizations or apprenticeship programs, motion picture payroll services, as defined, or a third party who is a party to an employee leasing arrangement, as defined.
Prior Legislation: AB 3081 (Gonzalez, 2018), would have, first, required a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for harassment for all workers supplied by that labor contractor. Second, it would have prohibited an employer from discharging or taking any other adverse action against an employee because of the employee’s status as a victim of sexual harassment. Third, it would have created a rebuttable presumption of unlawful retaliation based on the employee’s status as a victim of domestic violence, sexual assault, stalking, or sexual harassment if an employer takes specific actions within 30 days following the date that the victim provides notice to the employer or the employer has actual knowledge of the status. AB 3081 was vetoed.
AB 1701 (Thurmond) Chap. 804, Stats. 2017, holds general contractors and subcontractors jointly liable for unpaid wages, including fringe benefits.
AB 1897 (R. Hernández) Chap. 728, Stats. 2014, requires a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for all workers supplied by that labor contractor for the payment of wages and the failure to obtain valid workers’ compensation coverage.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Labor Federation
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
Consumer Attorneys of California
Engineers and Scientists of California Local 20
Professional & Technical Engineers, Local 21
SAG-AFTRA
Unite Here International Union
Unite Here, Local 11
Utility Workers Union of America, Local 132
Oppose
American Pistachio Growers
American Staffing Association
Associated General Contractors of California
Brea Chamber of Commerce
California Ambulance Association
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Building Industry Association
California Business Industrial Alliance
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Cotton Ginners & Growers Association
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Hotel & Lodging Association
California League of Food Processors
California League of Food Producers
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California Retailers Association
California Special Districts Association
California State Association of Counties
Citizens against Lawsuit Abuse
Civil Justice Association of California
El Centro Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Fresno Chamber of Commerce
Garden Grove Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chamber of Commerce
League of California Cities
National Federation of Independent Business
North Orange County Chamber of Commerce
Official Police Garage Association of Los Angeles
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Palm Desert Area Chamber of Commerce
Palm Desert Chamber
Redondo Beach Chamber of Commerce & Visitor’s Bureau
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
South Bay Association of Chambers Of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
Valley Industry and Commerce Association
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: March 6, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 170 (
Author:Gonzalez) – As Introduced Ver:January 8, 2019
SUBJECT: Employment: sexual harassment: liability
SUMMARY: Requires a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for harassment for all workers supplied by the labor contractor. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for harassment on any protected basis under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) for all workers supplied by the labor contractor.
- Provides that a client employer shall not shift to the labor contractor any legal duties or liabilities pertaining to workplace health and safety with respect to workers supplied by the labor contractor.
- Provides that a worker or his or her representative shall notify the client employer of violations of this section at least 30 days prior to filing a civil action against the client employer.
- Prohibits the client employer and the labor contractor from taking any adverse action against any worker for providing notification of violations or for filing a claim or civil action.
- States that the provisions of this section are in addition to, and shall be supplemental of, any other theories of liability or requirement established by statute or common law.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the Fair Employment and Housing Act that, among other things, makes it a unlawful employment practice for an employee, labor organization, employment agency, apprenticeship training program, or any training program leading to employment, to engage in harassment of an employee or other specified person.
- Provides that harassment of an employee or other specified person by an employee, other than an agent or supervisor, is unlawful if the entity, or its agents or supervisors, knows or should have known of this conduct and fails to take immediate and appropriate corrective action.
- Provides that an employer may be responsible for the acts of nonemployees, with respect to sexual harassment of employees and other specified persons, if the employer, or its agents or supervisors, knows or should have known of the conduct and fails to take immediate and appropriate corrective action.
- Requires a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for workers supplied by the labor contractor for the payment of wages and the failure to obtain workers’ compensation coverage.
- Defines a client employer as a business entity, regardless of its form, that obtains or is provided workers to perform labor within its usual course of business from a labor contractor, with specified exceptions.
- Defines a labor contractor as an individual or entity that supplies, either with or without a contract, a client employer with workers to perform labor within the client employer’s usual course of business, with specified exceptions.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: A 2017 report by the Center for American Progress reviewed Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) data from 2005-2015 on sexual harassment charges and found that “more than one-quarter of sexual harassment charges were filed in industries with large numbers of service-sector workers, including many low-wage jobs that are often occupied by women.” The report also found that nearly three-quarters of sexual harassment charges included an allegation of retaliation either upon being filed or later on in an investigation.
According to the author, this bill is necessary to address and provide recourse for these workers, often contracted or even subcontracted, if they are sexually harassed. The author points out that many hotel workers “go to work each day at the same location, wearing the uniform of the office or hotel they are cleaning, and reporting to managers onsite. Workers are, in many cases, not aware of their subcontracting agency, or of their direct supervisor. In spite of this clear de facto workplace and managers, these contracting companies and hotels are not held responsible when sexual harassment and assault happen on their watch to subcontracted workers.”
Arguments in Support
In support of the bill, the California Employment Lawyers Association writes, “our attorneys often represent victims of sexual harassment and have found that subcontracting work arrangements are becoming an increasingly common tactic employers use to try to evade liability. Given the important mandate under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) to ‘provide effective remedies that will both prevent and deter unlawful employment
practices and redress the adverse effects of those practices on aggrieved persons,’ it is critical that client employers are not able to use subcontracting work arrangements to shield themselves from the commands and duties of the FEHA. (See Government Code § 12920.5)”
Arguments in Opposition
A group of employer organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, states in opposition, “AB 170 would require a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and liability for harassment of workers supplied by that labor contractor. This statutory mandate ignores and disrupts current law that already provides liability for harassment claims for third parties. Per FEHA, a client employer may be held strictly liable for harassment of a “person providing services pursuant to a contract” if a supervisory employee is the harasser. Gov. Code § 12940(j)(1). If a non-supervisory employee harasses a ‘person providing services pursuant to a contract,’ the client employer is liable if they knew or should have known about the harassing conduct and failed to take immediate and appropriate corrective action.”
Prior Legislation
AB 1701 (Thurmond) Chapter 804, Statutes of 2017 holds general contractors and subcontractors jointly liable for unpaid wages, including fringe benefits.
AB 1897 (R. Hernández) Chapter 728, Statutes of 2014 requires a client employer to share with a labor contractor all civil legal responsibility and civil liability for all workers supplied by that labor contractor for the payment of wages and the failure to obtain valid workers’ compensation coverage.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Federation Of State, County And Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
California Employment Lawyers Association
Consumer Attorneys Of California
Oppose
American Pistachio Growers
American Staffing Association
Associated General Contractors Of California
Brea Chamber Of Commerce
California Ambulance Association
California Association Of Joint Powers Authorities
California Chamber Of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Cotton Ginners & Growers Association
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California League Of Food Processors
California Professional Association Of Specialty Contractors (Calpasc)
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California State Association Of Counties
Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse
El Centro Chamber Of Commerce
Family Business Association Of California
Folsom Chamber Of Commerce
Fresno Chamber Of Commerce
Garden Grove Chamber Of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber Of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chamber Of Commerce
League Of California Cities
North Orange County Chamber Of Commerce
Official Police Garage Association Of Los Angeles
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber Of Commerce
Palm Desert Chamber
Redondo Beach Chamber Of Commerce & Vistors Bureau
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Ana Chamber Of Commerce
Santa Maria Valley Chamber Of Commerce
South Bay Association Of Chambers Of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
Analysis Prepared by: Megan Lane / L. & E. /
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):