AB 1830: State claims.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-07-12
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jul 12, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 117, Statutes of 2019. |
| Jul 12, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Jul 8, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Jul 1, 2019 | In Assembly. Ordered to Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Jul 1, 2019 | Read third time. Urgency clause adopted. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Jun 25, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (June 24). |
| May 29, 2019 | Referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 23, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 22, 2019 | Read third time. Urgency clause adopted. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 16, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to Consent Calendar. |
| May 15, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. To Consent Calendar. (Ayes 16. Noes 0.) (May 15). |
| May 13, 2019 | Joint Rule 62(a), file notice suspended. (Page 1609.) |
| May 7, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| May 6, 2019 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on APPR. Read second time and amended. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | Referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 9, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee May 9. |
| Apr 8, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jul 1, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB1830 Gonzalez By Portantino Urgency Clause | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 24, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2019 | AB 1830 Gonzalez Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 15, 2019 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 1830 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 1830
Amended: 5/6/19 in Assembly
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 7-0, 6/24/19
AYES: Portantino, Bates, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Jones, Wieckowski
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 5/22/19 (Consent) - See last page for vote
DIGEST:
This bill, an urgency measure, appropriates $3,446,800 to the Executive Officer of the California Victims Compensation Board (Board) for the payment of five specified erroneous conviction claims.
ANALYSIS: Existing law authorizes a person convicted and imprisoned for a felony to submit a claim to the Board for pecuniary injury sustained as a result of erroneous conviction and imprisonment.
This bill appropriates General Fund revenues to the Board for the payment of the following erroneous conviction claims:
- Marco Contreras, finding of factual innocence, $843,080. On October 3, 1996, Contreras was arrested and subsequently charged by the Los Angeles District Attorney (LADA) with the attempted murder and attempted robbery of Manuel Garcia. Enhancements for personally using a firearm and inflicting great bodily injury were also alleged. A jury convicted Contreras of all charges on April 30, 1997, and the trial court sentenced him to an indeterminate term of 32-years-to-life imprisonment. The California Court of Appeal affirmed both convictions on May 15, 1998, and the California Supreme Court denied review on July 29, 1998. Contreras was later also convicted in 2001 on a charge of assault with a deadly weapon while incarcerated.
On March 23, 2017, after Contreras had served over 20 years imprisonment, the LADA filed a habeas petition on his behalf in the Los Angeles Superior Court following an investigation that unequivocally confirmed that another individual was the shooter. The petition sought to vacate both of Contreras’ 1997 convictions and further stipulated that Contreras was factually innocent of Garcia’s attempted murder and robbery. In an uncontested hearing conducted that same day, the superior court granted the joint petition and dismissed Contreras’ convictions for attempted murder and attempted robbery.
On August 4, 2017, Contreras’s counsel submitted a claim to Board on behalf of Contreras seeking compensation as an erroneously convicted person under Penal Code section 4900. The application requested $1,047,340 for having served a total of 7,481 days imprisonment. On August 13, 2018, the Board accepted that Contreras is actually innocent of offenses of attempted murder and attempted robbery, for which he was incarcerated a total of 7,482 days. However, the Board found Contreras remains guilty of the 2001 assault conviction, for which he simultaneously served 1,460 days imprisonment. Consequently, the Board found that found Contreras’ demonstrated injury is limited to 6,022 days of his total incarceration, and, pursuant to Penal Code sections 4903 and 4904, recommended that the Legislature appropriate $843,080 as payment to Contreras for being wrongfully imprisoned for 6,022 days, “even though Contreras’ own actions contributed to his incarceration for 20 years.” - Emmanuel Castillo-Lopez, finding of factual innocence, $59,780. On January 23, 2018, Emmanuel Castillo-Lopez (Castillo-Lopez) submitted a claim as an erroneously convicted person to the Board pursuant to Penal Code section 4900. The claim was based upon a 2012 conviction and wrongful incarceration for carrying a concealed dirk or dagger, which the Court of Appeal reversed based on insufficient evidence. The California Supreme Court affirmed the Court of Appeals judgment after finding that the Swiss Army knife possessed by Castillo-Lopez did not have a fixed or locking blade, and therefore does not constitute the prohibited dirk or dagger. The application requested compensation in the amount of $229,880 for the 1,642 days of incarceration. In a response letter filed March 23, 2018, the Attorney General conceded that Castillo-Lopez was entitled to $59,780 for only 427 days of his 1,642 days of imprisonment. The Attorney General objected to compensation for the remaining 1,215 days, during which Castillo-Lopez was simultaneously serving a four-year prison sentence for two valid convictions.
On November 5, 2018, the Board granted, in part, Castillo-Lopez’s claim for compensation under section 4900 based upon his 2012 conviction for carrying a concealed dirk or dagger. The Board accepted that Castillo-Lopez is actually innocent of this offense and was imprisoned for a total of 1,642 days for the 2012 and 2014 convictions, but found that he remains guilty of his 2014 convictions, for which he served 1,215 days imprisonment. Consequently, The Board determined that Castillo-Lopez’s demonstrated injury is limited to 427 days of his total incarceration. Pursuant to Penal Code sections 4903 and 4904, the Board recommended the Legislature appropriate $59,780 as payment to Castillo-Lopez for being wrongfully imprisoned for 427 days. - Deshawn Reed, finding of factual innocence, $369,460. On December 13, 2018, an application for compensation as an erroneously convicted person was filed on behalf of Deshawn Reed with the Board. The application includes findings of actual innocence for both first and second degree murder convictions in May of 2014. In January of 2017, the Court of Appeal granted Reed’s habeas petition and vacated the conviction in its entirety, based on ineffective assistance of counsel. On May 19, 2017, the Alameda County District Attorney dismissed the case due to insufficient evidence and in the interest of justice. Mr. Reed was transported back to state prison and released from custody on May 25, 2017.
On October 12, 2018, Mr. Reed filed a motion for a finding of factual innocence pursuant to Penal Code section 1485.55, subdivision (b). On November 6, 2018, the trial court granted Reed’s motion.
On December 13, 2018, counsel for Mr. Reed submitted an application to the Board for compensation as an erroneously convicted person pursuant to Penal Code section 4900. The Board determined that Mr. Reed was erroneously incarcerated for a total of 2,639 days, which includes time spent in Atascadero State Hospital, pursuant to Penal Code section 1368.16. On January 18, 2019, the Board granted Reed’s application for compensation and recommended the Legislature appropriate $369,460 as payment to Reed for his 2,639 days of erroneous incarceration. - Horace Roberts, finding of factual innocence, $1,044,820. On July 16, 1999, following a third jury trial, Horace Roberts was convicted of second-degree murder and subsequently sentenced to an indeterminate term of 15 years to life. Thereafter, his conviction was affirmed on direct appeal.
Roberts maintained his innocence and moved for DNA testing of crime scene evidence, which was granted on June 23, 2016. According to a California Department of Justice lab report, Roberts was definitively excluded as the source of identifiable male DNA detected on the victim. Based upon these DNA results, the Riverside County District Attorney readily agreed to vacate Mr. Roberts’ conviction and stipulated to his factual innocence. On October 2, 2018 the Riverside County Superior Court “reversed in whole” the conviction and ordered his immediate release from prison.
On January 15, 2019, Mr. Roberts submitted an application for compensation as an erroneously convicted person to the Board pursuant to Penal Code section 4900. The application is based upon Mr. Roberts’ 20 years of imprisonment for a 1999 conviction for second-degree murder, for which he was found to be factually innocent. On January 17, 2019, the Board recommended the Legislature appropriate $1,044,820 as payment to Mr. Roberts for being wrongfully imprisoned for 7,463 days. - Timothy Atkins, finding of factual innocence, $1,129,660. Atkins was arrested on January 7, 1985. He was subsequently charged in the Los Angeles County Superior Court with one count of murder, two counts of robbery, plus an enhancement for personally using a firearm. On July 28, 1987, a jury convicted Atkins of all charges and he was sentenced on February 5, 1988, to an indeterminate term of 32 years to life imprisonment.
Nineteen years later, on March 6, 2006, Atkins filed a petition for writ of habeas corpus in Los Angeles County Superior Court. The petition alleged that Mr. Atkins’ convictions were based upon materially false evidence. On February 8, 2007, the Honorable Michael A. Tynan, who had also presided over Mr. Atkins’ jury trial, granted the writ after finding that eye witness and trial testimony identifying Atkins as the shooter was false. The LADA declined to retry Mr. Atkins.
Mr. Atkins was released from prison on February 9, 2007, after having served a total of 8,069 days, consisting of 932 days pre-conviction from January 7, 1985, to July 28, 1987, plus 7,137 days post-conviction from July 28, 1987, to February 9, 2007.
On August 9, 2007, Mr. Atkins submitted his application for compensation to the Board. The application requested compensation in the amount of $713,100 for serving 7,131 days post-conviction (based on the $100 per day compensation rates in effect at the time of his application). This initial application was denied by the Board. Following several Board and court proceedings, one of which made a finding of factual innocence, the appellate court required the Board to recommend to the Legislature that an appropriation be made and Mr. Atkins’ claim be paid, and the superior court’s modified order was issued on February 7, 2019. On April 8, 2019, the Board granted the application for compensation under Penal Code section 4900 as mandated by Penal Code section 1485.55 and recommended the Legislature appropriate $1,129,660 as payment to Mr. Atkins for all 8,069 days of his erroneous incarceration (at the current rate of $140 per day).
Background
The State Board of Control was established in 1945. It was revised and renamed the Victim Compensation and Government Claims Board by AB 2491 (Jackson, Chapter 1016, Statutes of 2000), and recently renamed the California Victim Compensation Board by SB 836 (Budget and Fiscal Review Committee, Chapter 31, Statutes of 2016). SB 836 transferred the authority to approve general government claims for which no legal available appropriation exists to the Department of General Services, and the Board currently administers the Victim Compensation Program, the Revenue Recovery Program, Claims of Erroneously Convicted Felons, the Good Samaritan Act, and the Missing Children Reward Program.
Existing law authorizes a person convicted and imprisoned for a felony to submit a claim to the Board for pecuniary injury sustained as a result of erroneous conviction and imprisonment. Pursuant to SB 618 (Leno, Chapter 800, Statutes of 2013), a person who has secured a declaration of factual innocence from the court after having his or her conviction set aside is eligible for payment in a claim against the state. Upon application by the petitioner, the Board shall, without a hearing, recommend to the Legislature an appropriation to cover the claim. Likewise, if the court finds the petitioner has proven his or her innocence by a preponderance of the evidence, or the court grants a writ of habeas corpus concerning a person who is unlawfully imprisoned, or when the court vacates a judgment for a person on the basis of new evidence concerning a person who is no longer unlawfully imprisoned, and the court finds the evidence points unerringly to innocence, the Board shall, upon application by the claimant, without a hearing, recommend to the Legislature an appropriation to cover the petitioner's claim.
Otherwise, a claimant is required to introduce evidence in support of his or her claim at a hearing before the Board, and the Attorney General may introduce evidence in opposition. The claimant must prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that: (a) the crime was not committed at all, or, if committed, was not committed by the claimant; and (b) the claimant sustained pecuniary injury though the erroneous conviction and imprisonment.
If a claimant meets the burden of proof, the Board shall recommend to the Legislature an appropriation of $140 per day of incarceration served, including any time spent in custody that is considered part of the term of incarceration, such as time served in a county jail.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: Yes Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- One-time General Fund appropriation in the amount of $843,080 in 2019-20 to pay the claim of Marco Contreras, approved by the Board on August 13, 2018.
- One-time General Fund appropriation in the amount of $59,780 in 2019-20 to pay the claim of Emmanuel Castillo-Lopez, approved by the Board on November 5, 2018.
- One-time General Fund appropriation in the amount of $369,460 in 2019-20 to pay the claim of Deshawn Reed, approved by the Board on January 18, 2019.
- One-time General Fund appropriation in the amount of $1,044,820 in2019-20 to pay the claim of Horace Roberts, approved by the Board on January 17, 2019.
- One-time General Fund appropriation in the amount of $1,129,660 in 2019-20 to pay the claim of Timothy Atkins, approved by the Board on April 8, 2019.
None received
OPPOSITION: (Verified 6/26/19)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 77-0, 5/22/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bigelow, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Brough, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chen, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooper, Cunningham, Dahle, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Kiley, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mathis, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Obernolte, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Voepel, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooley, Eduardo Garcia, Mullin
Prepared by: Mark McKenzie / APPR. / (916) 651-4101
6/26/19 15:53:54
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 1830 (Gonzalez) - State claims
Version: May 6, 2019 | Policy Vote: N/A |
Urgency: Yes | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: June 24, 2019 | Consultant: Mark McKenzie |
Pursuant to the Committee’s rules, the Suspense File rule does not apply to this bill as claims are considered valid obligations of the state. Additionally, claims may have time sensitivity.
Bill Summary:
AB 1830, an urgency measure, would appropriate $3,446,800 to the Executive Officer of the California Victims Compensation Board (Board) for the payment of five specified erroneous conviction claims.
Fiscal Impact:
- General Fund appropriation in the amount of $843,080 to pay the claim of Marco Contreras, approved by the Board on August 13, 2018.
- General Fund appropriation in the amount of $59,780 to pay the claim of Emmanuel Castillo-Lopez, approved by the Board on November 5, 2018.
- General Fund appropriation in the amount of $369,460 to pay the claim of Deshawn Reed, approved by the Board on January 18, 2019.
- General Fund appropriation in the amount of $1,044,820 to pay the claim of Horace Roberts, approved by the Board on January 17, 2019.
- General Fund appropriation in the amount of $1,129,660 to pay the claim of Timothy Atkins, approved by the Board on April 8, 2019.
Background:
The State Board of Control was established in 1945. It was revised and renamed the Victim Compensation and Government Claims Board by Chapter 1016/2000 (AB 2491, Jackson), and recently renamed the California Victim Compensation Board by Chapter 31/2016 (SB 836, Budget and Fiscal Review Committee). SB 836 transferred the authority to approve general government claims for which no legal available appropriation exists to the Department of General Services, and the Board currently administers the Victim Compensation Program, the Revenue Recovery Program, Claims of Erroneously Convicted Felons, the Good Samaritan Act, and the Missing Children Reward Program.
Existing law authorizes a person convicted and imprisoned for a felony to submit a claim to the Board for pecuniary injury sustained as a result of erroneous conviction and imprisonment. Pursuant to SB 618 (Leno), Chapter 800/2013, a person who has secured a declaration of factual innocence from the court after having his or her conviction set aside is eligible for payment in a claim against the state. Upon application by the petitioner, the Board shall, without a hearing, recommend to the Legislature an appropriation to cover the claim. Likewise, if the court finds the petitioner has proven his or her innocence by a preponderance of the evidence, or the court grants a writ of habeas corpus concerning a person who is unlawfully imprisoned, or when the court vacates a judgment for a person on the basis of new evidence concerning a person who is no longer unlawfully imprisoned, and the court finds the evidence points unerringly to innocence, the Board shall, upon application by the claimant, without a hearing, recommend to the Legislature an appropriation to cover the petitioner's claim.
Otherwise, a claimant is required to introduce evidence in support of his or her claim at a hearing before the Board, and the Attorney General may introduce evidence in opposition. The claimant must prove, by a preponderance of the evidence, that: (a) the crime was not committed at all, or, if committed, was not committed by the claimant; and (b) the claimant sustained pecuniary injury though the erroneous conviction and imprisonment.
If a claimant meets the burden of proof, the Board shall recommend to the Legislature an appropriation of $140 per day of incarceration served, including any time spent in custody that is considered part of the term of incarceration, such as time served in a county jail.
Proposed Law:
AB 1830, an urgency measure, would appropriate $3,446,800 to Board for the payment of five specified erroneous conviction claims.
Staff Comments:
- This bill appropriates funds for the following erroneous conviction claims:
- Marco Contreras, finding of factual innocence, $843,080. On October 3, 1996, Contreras was arrested and subsequently charged by the Los Angeles District Attorney (LADA) with the attempted murder and attempted robbery of Manuel Garcia. Enhancements for personally using a firearm and inflicting great bodily injury were also alleged. A jury convicted Contreras of all charges on April 30, 1997, and the trial court sentenced him to an indeterminate term of 32-years-to-life imprisonment. The California Court of Appeal affirmed both convictions on May 15, 1998, and the California Supreme Court denied review on July 29, 1998. Contreras was later also convicted in 2001 on a charge of assault with a deadly weapon while incarcerated.
On March 23, 2017, after Contreras had served over 20 years imprisonment, the LADA filed a habeas petition on his behalf in the Los Angeles Superior Court following an investigation that unequivocally confirmed that another individual was the shooter. The petition sought to vacate both of Contreras’ 1997 convictions and further stipulated that Contreras was factually innocent of Garcia’s attempted murder and robbery. In an uncontested hearing conducted that same day, the superior court granted the joint petition and dismissed Contreras’ convictions for attempted murder and attempted robbery.
On August 4, 2017, Contreras’s counsel submitted a claim to Board on behalf of Contreras seeking compensation as an erroneously convicted person under Penal Code section 4900. The application requested $1,047,340 for having served a total of 7,481 days imprisonment. On August 13, 2018, the Board accepted that Contreras is actually innocent of offenses of attempted murder and attempted robbery, for which he was incarcerated a total of 7,482 days. However, the Board found Contreras remains guilty of the 2001 assault conviction, for which he simultaneously served 1,460 days imprisonment. Consequently, the Board found that found Contreras’ demonstrated injury is limited to 6,022 days of his total incarceration, and, pursuant to Penal Code sections 4903 and 4904, recommended that the Legislature appropriate $843,080 as payment to Contreras for being wrongfully imprisoned for 6,022 days, “even though Contreras’ own actions contributed to his incarceration for 20 years.” - Emmanuel Castillo-Lopez, finding of factual innocence, $59,780. On January 23, 2018, Emmanuel Castillo-Lopez (Castillo-Lopez) submitted a claim as an erroneously convicted person to the Board pursuant to Penal Code section 4900. The claim was based upon a 2012 conviction and wrongful incarceration for carrying a concealed dirk or dagger, which the Court of Appeal reversed based on insufficient evidence. The California Supreme Court affirmed the Court of Appeals judgment after finding that the Swiss Army knife possessed by Castillo-Lopez did not have a fixed or locking blade, and therefore does not constitute the prohibited dirk or dagger. The application requested compensation in the amount of $229,880 for the 1,642 days of incarceration. In a response letter filed March 23, 2018, the Attorney General conceded that Castillo-Lopez was entitled to $59,780 for only 427 days of his 1,642 days of imprisonment. The Attorney General objected to compensation for the remaining 1,215 days, during which Castillo-Lopez was simultaneously serving a four-year prison sentence for two valid convictions.
On November 5, 2018, the Board granted, in part, Castillo-Lopez’s claim for compensation under section 4900 based upon his 2012 conviction for carrying a concealed dirk or dagger. The Board accepted that Castillo-Lopez is actually innocent of this offense and was imprisoned for a total of 1,642 days for the 2012 and 2014 convictions, but found that he remains guilty of his 2014 convictions, for which he served 1,215 days imprisonment. Consequently, The Board determined that Castillo-Lopez’s demonstrated injury is limited to 427 days of his total incarceration. Pursuant to Penal Code sections 4903 and 4904, the Board recommended the Legislature appropriate $59,780 as payment to Castillo-Lopez for being wrongfully imprisoned for 427 days. - Deshawn Reed, finding of factual innocence, $369,460. On December 13, 2018, an application for compensation as an erroneously convicted person was filed on behalf of Deshawn Reed with the Board. The application includes findings of actual innocence for both first and second degree murder convictions in May of 2014. In January of 2017, the Court of Appeal granted Reed’s habeas petition and vacated the conviction in its entirety, based on ineffective assistance of counsel. On May 19, 2017, the Alameda County District Attorney dismissed the case due to insufficient evidence and in the interest of justice. Reed was transported back to state prison and released from custody on May 25, 2017.
On October 12, 2018, Reed filed a motion for a finding of factual innocence pursuant to Penal Code section 1485.55, subdivision (b). On November 6, 2018, the trial court granted Reed’s motion.
On December 13, 2018, counsel for Reed submitted an application to the Board for compensation as an erroneously convicted person pursuant to Penal Code section 4900. The Board determined that Reed was erroneously incarcerated for a total of 2,639 days, which includes time spent in Atascadero State Hospital, pursuant to Penal Code section 1368.16. On January 18, 2019, the Board granted Reed’s application for compensation and recommended the Legislature appropriate $369,460 as payment to Reed for his 2,639 days of erroneous incarceration. - Horrace Roberts, finding of factual innocence, $1,044,820. On July 16, 1999, following a third jury trial, Horace Roberts was convicted of second-degree murder and subsequently sentenced to an indeterminate term of 15 years to life. Thereafter, his conviction was affirmed on direct appeal.
Roberts maintained his innocence and moved for DNA testing of crime scene evidence, which was granted on June 23, 2016. According to a California Department of Justice lab report, Roberts was definitively excluded as the source of identifiable male DNA detected on the victim. Based upon these DNA results, the Riverside County District Attorney readily agreed to vacate Mr. Roberts’ conviction and stipulated to his factual innocence. On October 2, 2018 the Riverside County Superior Court “reversed in whole” the conviction and ordered his immediate release from prison.
On January 15, 2019, Mr. Horace Roberts submitted an application for compensation as an erroneously convicted person to the Board pursuant to Penal Code section 4900. The application is based upon Roberts’ 20 years of imprisonment for a 1999 conviction for second-degree murder, for which Roberts was found to be factually innocent. On January 17, 2019, the Board recommended the Legislature appropriate $1,044,820 as payment to Roberts for being wrongfully imprisoned for 7,463 days. - Timothy Atkins, finding of factual innocence, $1,129,660. Atkins was arrested on January 7, 1985. He was subsequently charged in the Los Angeles County Superior Court with one count of murder, two counts of robbery, plus an enhancement for personally using a firearm. On July 28, 1987, a jury convicted Atkins of all charges and he was sentenced on February 5, 1988, to an indeterminate term of 32 years to life imprisonment.
Nineteen years later, on March 6, 2006, Atkins filed a petition for writ of habeas corpus in Los Angeles County Superior Court. The petition alleged that Atkins’ convictions were based upon materially false evidence. On February 8, 2007, the Honorable Michael A. Tynan, who had also presided over Atkins’ jury trial, granted Atkin’s writ after finding that eye witness and trial testimony identifying Atkins as the shooter was false. The LADA declined to retry Atkins.
Atkins was released from prison on February 9, 2007, after having served a total of 8,069 days, consisting of 932 days pre-conviction from January 7, 1985, to July 28, 1987, plus 7,137 days post-conviction from July 28, 1987, to February 9, 2007.
On August 9, 2007, Atkins submitted his application for compensation to the Board. The application requested compensation in the amount of $713,100 for serving 7,131 days post-conviction (based on the $100 per day compensation rates in effect at the time of his application). This initial application was denied by the Board. Following several Board and court proceedings, one of which made a finding of factual innocence, the appellate court required the Board to recommend to the Legislature that an appropriation be made and Atkins’ claim be paid, and the superior court’s modified order was issued on February 7, 2019. On April 8, 2019, the Board granted Atkins’ application for compensation under Penal Code section 4900 as mandated by Penal Code section 1485.55 and recommended the Legislature appropriate $1,129,660 as payment to Atkins for all 8,069 days of his erroneous incarceration (at the current rate of $140 per day).
-- END --
Date of Hearing: May 15, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1830
Author:(Gonzalez) – As Amended Ver:May 6, 2019
Policy Committee: |
| Vote: |
|
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: Yes State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill, one of two annual state claims bills introduced pursuant to the California Victim Compensation Board (board) determinations and required to be authored by the Appropriations Committee Chairs, appropriates $3,446,800 to pay the cost of three erroneous conviction cases.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Appropriates $3,446,800 (GF) for payment of board approved claims for three erroneous convictions cases.
COMMENTS:
- Background. Current law authorizes a person convicted and imprisoned for a felony to submit a claim to the board for pecuniary injury sustained as a result of erroneous conviction and imprisonment. Pursuant to SB 618 (Leno) Statutes of 2013, if a person has secured a declaration of factual innocence from the court after having his or her conviction set aside, the finding is grounds for payment of a claim against the state and upon application by the petitioner, the board shall, without a hearing, recommend to the Legislature an appropriation to cover the claim. Likewise, if the court finds the petitioner has proven his or her innocence by a preponderance of the evidence, or the court grants a writ of habeas corpus concerning a person who is unlawfully imprisoned, or when the court vacates a judgment for a person on the basis of new evidence concerning a person who is no longer unlawfully imprisoned, and the court finds the evidence points unerringly to innocence, the board shall, upon application by the claimant, without a hearing, recommend to the Legislature an appropriation to cover the petitioner's claim.
Otherwise, a claimant is required to introduce evidence in support of his or her claim at a hearing before the board, and the Attorney General may introduce evidence in opposition. The claimant must prove, by a preponderance of the evidence: (a) the crime was not committed at all, or, if committed, was not committed by the claimant; (b) the claimant did not contribute to the arrest or conviction for the crime; and (c) the claimant sustained pecuniary injury though the erroneous conviction and imprisonment.
If a claimant meets the burden of proof, the board shall recommend to the Legislature an appropriation of $140 per day of incarceration served in a state prison subsequent to the claimant’s conviction.
- Purpose. This bill appropriates funds for the following erroneous conviction claims:
- Timothy Atkins, finding of factual innocence, $1,129,660. Atkins was arrested on January 7, 1985. He was subsequently charged in the Los Angeles County Superior Court with one count of murder, two counts of robbery, plus an enhancement for personally using a firearm. On July 28, 1987, a jury convicted Atkins of all charges and sentenced on February 5, 1988, to an indeterminate term of 32 years to life imprisonment.
Nineteen years later, on March 6, 2006, Atkins filed a petition for writ of habeas corpus in Los Angeles County Superior Court. The petition alleged that Atkins’ convictions were based upon materially false evidence. On February 8, 2007, the Honorable Michael A. Tynan, who had also presided over Atkins’ jury trial, granted Atkin’s writ. The Los Angeles District Attorney (LADA) declined to retry Atkins.
Atkins was released from prison on February 9, 2007, after having served a total of 8,069 days, consisting of 932 days pre-conviction from January 7, 1985, to July 28, 1987, plus 7,137 days post-conviction from July 28, 1987, to February 9, 2007.
On August 9, 2007, Atkins submitted his application for compensation to CalVCB. The application requested compensation in the amount of $713,100 for serving 7,131 days post-conviction. On April 8, 2019, VCB granted Atkins’ application for compensation under Penal Code section 4900 as mandated by Penal Code section 1485.55 and recommended the Legislature appropriate $1,129,660 as payment to Atkins for all 8,069 days of his erroneous incarceration.
- Marco Contreras, finding of factual innocence, $843,080. On October 3, 1996, Contreras was arrested and subsequently charged by the LADA with the attempted murder and attempted robbery. Enhancements for personally using a firearm and inflicting great bodily injury were also alleged. A jury convicted Contreras of all charges on April 30, 1997, and the trial court sentenced him to an indeterminate term of 32-years-to-life imprisonment.2 The California Court of Appeal affirmed both convictions on May 15, 1998, and the California Supreme Court denied review on July 29, 1998.
On March 23, 2017, after Contreras had served over 20 years imprisonment, LADA filed a habeas petition in the Los Angeles Superior Court on behalf of Contreras. The petition sought to vacate both of Contreras’ 1997 convictions and further stipulated that Contreras was factually innocent of Garcia’s attempted murder and robbery. In an uncontested hearing conducted that same day, the superior court granted the joint petition and dismissed Contreras’ convictions for attempted murder and attempted robbery
On August 4, 2017, Contreras’s counsel submitted a claim to CalVCB on behalf of Contreras seeking compensation as an erroneously convicted person under Penal Code section 4900. The application requested $1,047,340 for having served a total of 7,481 days imprisonment.
On August 13, 2018, CalVCB accepted that Contreras is actually innocent of offenses of attempted murder and attempted robbery, for which he was incarcerated a total of 7,482 days. However, CalVCB found Contreras remains guilty of his 2001 assault conviction, for which he simultaneously served 1,460 days imprisonment. Consequently, CalVCB found Contreras’ demonstrated injury is limited to 6,022 days of his total incarceration, and, pursuant to Penal Code sections 4903 and 4904, CalVCB recommended that the Legislature appropriate $843,080 as payment to Contreras for being wrongfully imprisoned for 6,022 days, “even though Contreras’ own actions contributed to his incarceration for 20 years.”
- Emmanuel Castillo-Lopez, finding of factual innocence, $59,780. On January 23, 2018, Emmanuel Castillo-Lopez (Castillo-Lopez) submitted a claim as an erroneously convicted person to the CalVCB pursuant to Penal Code section 4900. The claim was based upon a 2012 conviction and wrongful incarceration for carrying a concealed dirk or dagger, which the Court of Appeal reversed based on insufficient evidence. The application requested compensation in the amount of $229,880 for the 1,642 days of incarceration. In a response letter filed March 23, 2018, the Attorney General conceded that Castillo-Lopez was entitled to $59,780 for only 427 days of his 1,642 days of imprisonment. The Attorney General objected to compensation for the remaining 1,215 days, during which Castillo-Lopez was simultaneously serving a four-year prison sentence for two valid convictions.
On November 5, 2018, CalVCB granted, in part, Castillo-Lopez’s claim for compensation under section 4900 based upon his 2012 conviction for carrying a concealed dirk or dagger. CalVCB accepted that Castillo-Lopez is actually innocent of this offense and was imprisoned for a total of 1,642 days for the 2012 and 2014 convictions. However, CalVCB found Castillo-Lopez remains guilty of his 2014 convictions, for which he served 1,215 days imprisonment. Consequently, CalVCB found Castillo-Lopez’s demonstrated injury is limited to 427 days of his total incarceration. Pursuant to Penal Code sections 4903 and 4904, CalVCB recommended the Legislature appropriate $59,780 as payment to Castillo-Lopez for being wrongfully imprisoned for 427 days.
- Deshawn Reed, finding of factual innocence, $369,460. On December 13, 2018, an application for compensation as an erroneously convicted person was filed on behalf of Deshawn Reed with CalVCB. The application includes findings of actual innocence for both first and second degree murder convictions in May of 2014. In January of 2017, the Court of Appeal granted Reed’s habeas petition and vacated the conviction in its entirety, based on ineffective assistance of counsel. On May 19, 2017, the Alameda County District Attorney dismissed the case due to insufficient evidence and in the interest of justice. Reed was transported back to state prison and released from custody on May 25, 2017.
On October 12, 2018, Reed filed a motion for a finding of factual innocence pursuant to Penal Code section 1485.55, subdivision (b). On November 6, 2018, the trial court granted Reed’s motion.
On December 13, 2018, counsel for Reed submitted an application to CalVCB for compensation as an erroneously convicted person pursuant to Penal Code section 4900. CalVCB determined that Reed was erroneously incarcerated for a total of 2,639 days, which includes time spent in Atascadero State Hospital, pursuant to Penal Code section 1368.16 On January 18, 2019, VCB granted Reed’s application for compensation and recommended the Legislature appropriate $369,460 as payment to Reed for his 2,639 days of erroneous incarceration.
- Horrace Roberts, finding of factual innocence, $1,044,820. On January 15, 2019, Horace Roberts submitted an application for compensation as an erroneously convicted person to CalVCB pursuant to Penal Code section 4900. The application is based upon Roberts’ 20 years of imprisonment for a 1999 conviction for second-degree murder, for which Roberts was found to be factually innocent. On January 17, 2019, CalVCB recommended the Legislature appropriate $1,044,820 as payment to Roberts for being wrongfully imprisoned for 7,463 days.
Analysis Prepared by: Jay Dickenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):