AB 218: Damages: childhood sexual assault: statute of limitations.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-13
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 13, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 861, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 13, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 26, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Sep 14, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Sep 14, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 3, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 1.) (July 2). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 10, 2019 | In committee: Set, second hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 4, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on JUD. and APPR. |
| Apr 1, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Apr 1, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Mar 13, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Mar 12, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 8. Noes 2.) (March 12). |
| Mar 7, 2019 | Measure version as revised on March 6 corrected. |
| Mar 6, 2019 | Coauthors Revised. |
| Feb 4, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jan 17, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 16. |
| Jan 16, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 14, 2019 | AB 218 GONZALEZ Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 14, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB218 Gonzalez et al. By Jackson | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 12, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 1, 2019 | AB 218 Gonzalez Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Mar 12, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
(Without Reference to File)
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 218
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Amended Ver:August 30, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Extends the civil statute of limitations for childhood sexual assault by 14 years, revives, for three years, old claims, and increases certain penalties for childhood sexual assault.
Major Provisions
- Redefines childhood sexual abuse as childhood sexual assault and expands the definition slightly.
- Extends the time for commencing a civil action based on injuries resulting from childhood sexual assault to 22 years after the plaintiff reaches majority (i.e., until 40 years of age) or within five years of the date the plaintiff discovers or reasonably should have discovered that the psychological injury or illness occurring after the age of majority was caused by the abuse, whichever occurs later.
- Prohibits suit against third parties after the plaintiff's 40th birthday unless the person or entity knew or had reason to know, or was otherwise on notice, of any misconduct that creates a risk of childhood sexual assault by an employee, volunteer, representative, or agent, or failed to take reasonable steps, or to implement reasonable safeguards, to avoid acts of childhood sexual assault.
- Revives, until three years of January 1, 2020, or the time period under 2), above, whichever is later, any actions for childhood sexual assault that has not been litigated to finality and that would otherwise be barred as of January 1, 2020, because of applicable statute of limitations, claims presentation deadline, or any other time limit.
- Allows a person, in an action for recovery of damages suffered as the result of childhood sexual assault, to recover up to tremble damages if the sexual assault is the result of a cover-up by the defendant of a sexual assault of a minor, unless otherwise prohibited. Defines "cover-up" as a concerted effort to hide evidence relating to childhood sexual assault.
- Eliminates the existing limitation on exemption from the Government Tort Claims Act and instead exempts, from the Government Tort Claims Act, all claims for childhood sexual assault against a local public entity, including those arising out of conduct occurring before January 1, 2009.
The Senate Amendments:
Limit the possible damages for a sexual assault cover up.
COMMENTS:
Childhood sexual abuse continues to ruin children lives and continues to shock the nation because, unfortunately, perpetrators continue to abuse, often with impunity, and sometimes with the help of third parties who either choose not to get involved or actively cover-up the abuse. Whether the abuse occurred through gymnastics, swimming, school, or a religious institution, too many children have been victims of abuse and their lives have been forever impacted by that abuse. Despite the lifetime of damage that this abuse causes its victims, the state's statute of limitations restricts how long actions can be brought to recover for damages caused by childhood sexual abuse. In an effort to allow more victims of childhood sexual assault to be compensated for their injuries and, to help prevent future assaults by raising the costs for this abuse, this bill extends the civil statute of limitations for childhood sexual assault by 14 years, revives old claims for three years, and eliminates existing limitations for claims against public institutions. This bill applies equally to abuse occurring at public and private schools and applies to all local public entities. Lastly, the bill allows a victim of childhood sexual abuse to recover tremble damages against a defendant if the sexual assault is the result of a cover-up by the defendant of a prior sexual assault of a minor.
For more information, see the Assembly Judiciary Committee analysis of the bill.
According to the Author:
AB 218 would expand access to justice for victims of childhood sexual assault by removing the arbitrary time limits upon victims to pursue a case. Several states have already taken this step and have eliminated the civil statute of limitations for these cases. There should not be a reasonable expectation that if simply enough time passes, there will be no accountability for these despicable past acts by individuals and entities. This bill ensures that "time's up" for the perpetrators of childhood sexual assault, not for victims.
AB 218 would also confront the pervasive problem of cover ups in institutions, from schools to sports league, which result in continuing victimization and the sexual assault of additional children. The bill would allow for recovery of up to treble damages from the defendant who covered up sexual assault. This reform is clearly needed both to compensate victims who never should have been victims- and would not have been if past sexual assault had been properly brought to light- and also as an effective deterrent against individuals and entities who have chosen to protect the perpetrators of sexual assault over the victims.
Arguments in Support:
The sponsor, the Victim Policy Institute, writes: "The current law lets too many abusers avoid accountability for their actions. The only good thing to come out of recent scandals was an environment that encouraged well-known women - actors or Olympians - who were victims of childhood sexual assault to come forward. It is time for the law to recognize what we all now know – that it can take decades before some survivors are capable of coming forward. Children being assaulted today may not be ready to come forward until decades in the future."
Arguments in Opposition:
The bill is opposed by California Civil Liberties Advocacy, which argues that the bill will "negatively impact civil defendants because the availability and reliability of evidence diminishes over time," and that "extending the statute of limitations in civil suits is in more in the interests of the plaintiffs' lawyer industry than that of the abuse survivors, in which the negative effects will be felt in the decades to come."
This bill is opposed, unless amended, by public and private school officials, insurance associations, and joint powers associations. All of the opponents raise the same basic concerns: it is very difficult to defend against old claims when records and witnesses may be unavailable, insurance may no longer be available, and the cost of defending these actions could be astronomical and could prevent the impacted entities from being able to support their main work. They request, among other things, that the bill be amended to eliminate the treble damages provision, eliminate the revival period, and limit liability for third parties. They also request amendments to create and fund procedures to prevent future abuse.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Unknown, potentially-significant costs to state entities to the extent litigation is successfully brought outside the current statute of limitations and/or the entities are liable for damages.
- Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate cases filed within the expanded statute of limitations that otherwise would have been time barred. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
- Unknown, potentially-major out-year costs to local entities and school districts to the extent litigation is successfully brought outside the current statute of limitations and/or the entities are liable for damages. If payouts are large enough, this measure could lead to cost pressures to the state to stabilize a local jurisdiction or district.
Additionally, to the extent an extended statute of limitations affects liability insurance premiums, school district could experience unknown, potentially-significant costs related to procuring liability insurance, apart from any specific claims. (Local funds)
*Trial Court Trust Fund
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-2-2
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Reyes
NO: Kiley, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gallagher, Petrie-Norris
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-3-13
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Brough, Obernolte, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Bigelow, Chen, Choi, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Kiley, Mathis, Mayes
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 30, 2019
CONSULTANT: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0000066 FN:
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 218 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 218
Amended: 8/30/19 in Senate
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-1, 7/2/19
AYES: Jackson, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-1, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bates
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-3, 4/1/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Damages: childhood sexual assault: statute of limitations
DIGEST:
This bill extends the time for commencement of actions for childhood sexual assault to 40 years of age or five years from discovery of the injury; provides enhanced damages for a cover up, as defined, of the assault; and provides a three-year window in which expired claims are revived.
Existing law:
- Provides that in an action for recovery of damages suffered as a result of childhood sexual abuse, the time for commencement of the action shall be within eight years of the date the plaintiff attains the age of majority or within three years of the date the plaintiff discovers or reasonably should have discovered that psychological injury or illness occurring after the age of majority was caused by the sexual abuse, whichever period expires later, for any of the following actions:
- an action against any person for committing an act of childhood sexual abuse;
- an action for liability against any person or entity who owed a duty of care to the plaintiff, where a wrongful or negligent act by that person or entity was a legal cause of the childhood sexual abuse which resulted in the injury to the plaintiff; or
- an action for liability against any person or entity where an intentional act by that person or entity was a legal cause of the childhood sexual abuse which resulted in the injury to the plaintiff. (Code Civ. Proc. § 340.1(a).)
- Provides that the actions described above against persons or entities other than the person who committed an act of childhood sexual abuse must be commenced before the plaintiff’s 26th birthday. However, this restriction does not apply if the person or entity knew or had reason to know, or was otherwise on notice, of any unlawful sexual conduct by an employee, volunteer, representative, or agent, and failed to take reasonable steps, and to implement reasonable safeguards, to avoid acts of unlawful sexual conduct in the future by that person, including, but not limited to, preventing or avoiding placement of that person in a function or environment in which contact with children is an inherent part of that function or environment. Existing law states that providing or requiring counseling is not sufficient, in and of itself, to constitute a reasonable step or reasonable safeguard as used therein. (Code Civ. Proc. § 340.1(b).)
- Provides that notwithstanding any other provision of law, any claim for damages described above relating to a nonperpetrator defendant that is permitted to be filed pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) that would otherwise be barred as of January 1, 2003, solely because the applicable statute of limitations has or had expired, is revived, and, in that case, a cause of action may be commenced within one year of January 1, 2003. This revival does not apply to any claim that has been litigated to finality on the merits in any court of competent jurisdiction prior to January 1, 2003. Termination of a prior action on the basis of the statute of limitations does not constitute a claim that has been litigated to finality on the merits. It also does not apply to any written, compromised settlement agreement between the parties, as specified. (Code Civ. Proc. § 340.1(c), (d).)
- Defines “childhood sexual abuse” as used in the above provisions to include any act committed against the plaintiff that occurred when the plaintiff was under the age of 18 years and that would have been proscribed by specified sections of the Penal Code or prior laws of this state of similar effect at the time the act was committed. (Code Civ. Proc. § 340.1(e).)
- Exempts claims made pursuant to Section 340.1 of the Code of Civil Procedure for the recovery of damages suffered as a result of childhood sexual abuse from the Government Tort Claims Act. This provision only applies to claims arising out of conduct occurring on or after January 1, 2009. (Gov. Code § 905.)
- Defines “sexual conduct” for the purposes of certain Penal Code provisions to include any of the following, whether actual or simulated: sexual intercourse, oral copulation, anal intercourse, anal oral copulation, masturbation, bestiality, sexual sadism, sexual masochism, penetration of the vagina or rectum by any object in a lewd or lascivious manner, exhibition of the genitals or pubic or rectal area for the purpose of sexual stimulation of the viewer, any lewd or lascivious sexual act as defined in Section 288, or excretory functions performed in a lewd or lascivious manner, whether or not any of the above conduct is performed alone or between members of the same or opposite sex or between humans and animals. An act is simulated when it gives the appearance of being sexual conduct. (Pen. Code § 311.4.)
This bill:
- Replaces “sexual abuse” with “sexual assault” in Section 340.1 and adds “sexual conduct,” as the term is defined in Penal Code Section 311.4, to the definition of sexual assault.
- Provides that an action for recovery of damages suffered as a result of childhood sexual assault must be commenced within 22 years of the date the plaintiff attains the age of majority or within five years of the date the plaintiff discovered or reasonably should have discovered the causal relationship between the assault and psychological injury or illness occurring after the age of majority.
- Provides that in such actions a person who is sexually assaulted and proves it was as the result of a cover up may recover up to treble damages against a defendant who is found to have covered up the sexual assault of a minor, unless prohibited by another law. “Cover up” is defined as a concerted effort to hide evidence relating to childhood sexual assault.
- Provides that actions described in Section 340.1 involving a nonperpetrator defendant shall not be commenced on or after the plaintiff’s 40th birthday, unless the person or entity knew or had reason to know, or was otherwise on notice, of any misconduct that creates a risk of childhood sexual assault by an employee, volunteer, representative, or agent, or the person or entity failed to take reasonable steps or to implement reasonable safeguards to avoid acts of childhood sexual assault. The bill makes clear that this change shall not be construed to constitute a substantive change in negligence law.
- Removes provisions relating to earlier revival periods that have since elapsed.
- Provides that its changes to the time period provided in subdivision (a) apply to and revive any action commenced on or after the date of enactment of that act, and to any action filed before the date of enactment, and still pending on that date, including any action or causes of action that would have been barred by the laws in effect before the date of enactment.
- Provides that, notwithstanding any other provision of law, any claim for damages described in Section 340.1(a)(1)-(3) that has not been litigated to finality and that would otherwise be barred as of January 1, 2020, because the applicable statute of limitations, claim presentation deadline, or any other time limit had expired, is revived, and these claims may be commenced within three years of January 1, 2020. A plaintiff shall have the later of the three-year time period under this provision or the time period under subdivision (a) of Section 340.1 as amended by this bill.
- Exempts claims made pursuant to Section 340.1 from the Government Tort Claims Act regardless of when the conduct took place. This change is retroactive and applies to new or pending cases.
Background
This bill lengthens the limitations period for claims of childhood sexual assault from eight years past the age of majority, which amounts to 26 years of age, to 22 years past the age of majority, or 40 years of age. In addition, it would extend the period tied to the discovery of the childhood sexual assault from within three years to within five years.
This bill also provides that the claims provided for in Section 340.1 that would otherwise be barred as of January 1, 2020 because an applicable statute of limitations, claim presentation deadline, or any other time limit had expired, and that have not been litigated to finality, are explicitly revived for a three-year period or, if later, within the statute of limitations period established by the bill.
This bill is sponsored by the author and supported by various groups, including the Victim Policy Institute, the California Police Chiefs Association, the Consumer Attorneys of California, and the National Association of Social Workers. It is opposed by various associations that would likely be affected by these revived or extended claims periods, including the California School Boards Association, the California Association of Joint Powers Authorities, and the Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers of California.
Comments
This bill modifies the statute of limitations for childhood sexual abuse claims in various ways and provides another revival period for bringing expired claims. As argued by the author, there has been a dramatic shift in cultural sensitivities around sexual abuse and a more accepting societal climate for victims. Rather than fearing stigma, victims of past abuse are more likely to be willing to come forward now with claims. There are complex psychological effects that result from being victimized in this way. In addition, the systematic incidence of childhood sexual assault in numerous institutions in this country and the cover-ups that accompanied them arguably make both a revival period and an extended statute of limitations warranted. This bill provides another chance for victims, who are currently barred from pursing claims based solely on the passage of time, to seek justice.
Recent revival attempts
In 2013, SB 131 (Beall, 2013) was passed by the Legislature. It would have, among other things, provided a one-year period of revival for otherwise time-barred claims arising from childhood sexual abuse. However, it would only have applied to private entities and not public entities.
In his veto message, Governor Jerry Brown traced the history of Section 340.1 and highlighted the fact that public entities were not subject to the revival of claims as private entities were. The Governor wrote, in part:
This bill does not change a victim’s ability to sue a perpetrator. This bill also does not change the significant inequity that exists between private and public entities. What this bill does do is go back to the only group, i.e. private institutions, that have already been subjected to the unusual “one year revival period” and makes them, and them alone, subject to suit indefinitely. This extraordinary extension of the statute of limitations, which legislators chose not to apply to public institutions, is simply too open-ended and unfair.
In 2018, AB 3120 (Gonzalez, 2018) attempted to create another revival period for childhood sexual assault claims as well as extend the limitations period. The bill was nearly identical to the current bill. Governor Brown again vetoed the bill, asserting the same grounds as above and further arguing that AB 3120 was broader than SB 131, did not fully address the inequity between state defendants and others, and provided a longer revival period for otherwise barred claims.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Unknown, potentially-significant costs to state entities to the extent litigation is successfully brought outside the current statute of limitations and/or the entities are liable for damages.
- Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate cases filed within the expanded statute of limitations that otherwise would have been time barred. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
- Unknown, potentially-major out-year costs to local entities and school districts to the extent litigation is successfully brought outside the current statute of limitations and/or the entities are liable for damages. If payouts are large enough, this measure could lead to cost pressures to the state to stabilize a local jurisdiction or district.
Additionally, to the extent an extended statute of limitations affects liability insurance premiums, school district could experience unknown, potentially-significant costs related to procuring liability insurance, apart from any specific claims. (Local funds)
*Trial Court Trust Fund
American Association of University Women of California
California Association of Marriage and Family Therapists
California Council of Community Behavioral Health Agencies
California Family Resource Association
California Police Chiefs Association
California Protective Parents Association
California State PTA
Center for Judicial Excellence
Child Abuse Prevention Center
CHILD USA
Consumer Attorneys of California
Crime Victims United of California
John Burton Advocates for Youth
Joyful Heart Foundation
Leaving Neverland Support Network
National Association of Social Workers
Stop Educator Sexual Abuse, Misconduct & Exploitation
Victim Policy Institute
One individual
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/30/19)
American Tort Reform Association
Association of California School Administrators
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Association of Private School Organizations
California Association of School Business Officials
California Civil Liberties Advocacy
California School Boards Association
Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers of California
Northern California Regional Liability Excess Fund
Schools Excess Liability Fund
Schools Insurance Authority
Southern California Regional Liability Excess Fund
Statewide Association of Community Colleges
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Victim Policy Institute writes in support of this bill: “The current law lets too many abusers avoid accountability for their actions. The only good thing to come out of recent scandals was an environment that encouraged well-known women - actors or Olympians - who were victims of childhood sexual assault to come forward. It is time for the law to recognize what we all now know – that it can take decades before some survivors are capable of coming forward. Children being assaulted today may not be ready to come forward until decades in the future.
Victims who are ready to come forward today deserve an opportunity to expose their perpetrators and those who covered up the abuse. AB 218 simply provides a forum for victims to come forward. Victims will still be responsible for proving they were sexually assaulted and that someone covered it up. Victims deserve that chance and the safety of our children demands that we provide every opportunity possible for victims to expose these crimes.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: A coalition of groups, including the Schools Excess Liability Fund, the Schools Insurance Authority, the Association of California School Administrators, the California Association of Joint Powers Authorities, and the California Association of School Business Officials, writes in opposition: “As drafted, AB 218 exposes local public schools and others, to claims of abuse going back 40 years ago and longer. It will be impossible for employers to effectively defend against these claims when evidence is likely gone, witnesses have moved or passed away, and there has been a turnover of staff. With these barriers, schools will be unable to adequately respond to these claims. This failure will result in diversion of funding intended to educate students and serve communities to financing increased legal costs, whether or not the claim is valid. This is particularly troubling when considering that AB 218 would permit the recovery of treble damages . . . .”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 64-3, 4/1/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cooper, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Melendez, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Patterson, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Brough, Obernolte, Voepel
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Bigelow, Chen, Choi, Dahle, Flora, Fong, Frazier, Gallagher, Eduardo Garcia, Kiley, Mathis, Mayes
Prepared by: Christian Kurpiewski / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
9/3/19 19:32:40
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 218 (Gonzalez) - Damages: childhood sexual assault: statute of limitations
Version: March 25, 2019 | Policy Vote: JUD. 7 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 30, 2019 | Consultant: Shaun Naidu |
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on August 30, 2019
Bill Summary:
AB 218 would extend the timeframe within which to file civil childhood sexual assault actions, as specified, and expand the actionable conduct; allow enhanced damages for a cover up, as defined; and revive expired claims for a three-year period.
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, potentially-significant costs to state entities to the extent litigation is successfully brought outside the current statute of limitations and/or the entities are liable for damages.
- Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate cases filed within the expanded statute of limitations that otherwise would have been time barred. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
- Unknown, potentially-major out-year costs to local entities and school districts to the extent litigation is successfully brought outside the current statute of limitations and/or the entities are liable for damages. If payouts are large enough, this measure could lead to cost pressures to the state to stabilize a local jurisdiction or district.
Additionally, to the extent an extended statute of limitations affects liability insurance premiums, school district could experience unknown, potentially-significant costs related to procuring liability insurance, apart from any specific claims. (Local funds)
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Author Amendments:
Permit a victim to receive up to treble damages if it is proven that the cover up resulted in the assault unless it is prohibited by another law. Specify that changes to commence certain actions are not to be construed to constitute a substantive change in negligence law.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 218 (Gonzalez) - Damages: childhood sexual assault: statute of limitations
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 218 would extend the timeframe within which to file civil childhood sexual assault actions, as specified, and expand the actionable conduct; allow enhanced damages for a cover up, as defined; and revive expired claims for a three-year period.
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, potentially-significant workload cost pressures to the courts to adjudicate cases filed within the expanded statute of limitations that otherwise would have been time barred. While the superior courts are not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources. For example, the Budget Act of 2019 appropriated $41.8 million from the General Fund to backfill continued reduction in fine and penalty revenue for trial court operations. (General Fund*)
- Unknown, potentially-major out-year costs to local school districts to the extent litigation is successfully brought outside the current statute of limitations and/or the districts are liable for treble damages.
Additionally, to the extent an extended statute of limitations affects liability insurance premiums, school district could experience unknown, potentially-significant costs related to procuring liability insurance, apart from any specific claims. (Local funds)
*Trial Court Trust Fund
Background:
Until 1991, the timeframe within which to commence a civil childhood sexual assault action was one year from the time of the alleged assault. In 1990, the Legislature extended the statute of limitations for these claims to the later of within eight years after the victim-plaintiff becomes an adult (i.e., age 26) or within three years of the date of discovery. Subsequently, the statute of limitations for actions against third parties was extended as well. In 2002, the Legislature extended the timeframe to begin these types of actions beyond a person’s twenty-sixth birthday when a third party knew or had reason to know of complaints against an employee, volunteer, representative or agent and failed to take reasonable steps to prevent similar unlawful conduct. For conduct on or after January 1, 2015, the Legislature extended the statute of limitations for civil childhood sexual assault claims to the later of within 22 years after the victim-plaintiff becomes an adult (i.e., age 40) or within three years of the date of discovery.
Additionally, the Government Tort Claims Act generally governs tort actions against public entities, including claims related to childhood sexual assault. (See Shirk v. Vista Unified School District (2007) 42 Cal.4th 201.) Separate from the statute of limitations, the act requires that an action that is filed against a public entity related to a cause of action for the death of or injury to a person be presented in writing to the public entity before six months after accrual of the cause of action. The effect was that civil childhood sexual assault actions that were initiated within the expanded statute of limitations were barred from moving forward because of this six-month claim presentation requirement. Consequently, in 2008, the Legislature exempted suits seeking damages for childhood sexual assault from the claim presentation requirement. The exemption was prospective, applying only to claims alleging conduct that occurred on or after January 1, 2009. In 2018, the Legislature amended the Government Tort Claims Act to state explicitly that the act does not apply to claims of childhood sexual abuse.
Proposed Law:
This bill would extend the statute of limitations to begin an action for recovery of damages suffered as a result of childhood sexual assault to the later of either (i) within 22 years from the date the plaintiff attains the age of majority (i.e., age 40) or (ii) within five years of the date the plaintiff discovers or reasonably should have discovered that the psychological injury or illness occurring after the age of majority was caused by sexual assault. It would change the term “childhood sexual abuse” to “childhood sexual assault” and would expand the actionable conduct to include actual or simulated sexual intercourse; oral copulation; anal intercourse; anal oral copulation; masturbation; bestiality; sexual sadism; sexual masochism; penetration of the vagina or rectum by any object in a lewd or lascivious manner; exhibition of the genitals or pubic or rectal area for the purpose of sexual stimulation of the viewer; any lewd or lascivious sexual act, as defined; or excretory functions performed in a lewd or lascivious manner, regardless of if the above conduct is performed alone or between members of the same or opposite sex or between humans and animals. Additionally, this measure would provide for the recovery of treble damages against defendants who are found to have “cover[ed] up” the sexual assault of a minor, which would be defined as a concerted effort to hide evidence relating to the assault.
This measure would allow for a three-year revival period, starting January 1, 2020, of any claim for damages for childhood sexual assault that has not been litigated to finality and that otherwise would be barred as of January 1, 2020 because the applicable statute of limitations, claim presentation deadline, or any other time limit had expired.
Lastly, AB 218 would replace the term “childhood sexual abuse” with “childhood sexual assault” in the Government Tort Claims Act and would remove the applicability of the act’s claim presentation requirement to childhood sexual assault claims for conduct occurring before January 1, 2009.
Related Legislation:
AB 1510 (Reyes, 2019) would revive otherwise time-barred claims for damages arising from sexual assault and other inappropriate conduct of a sexual nature, as specified. AB 1510 is pending in this Committee.
SB 108 (Lockyer, Ch. 1578, Stats. 1990) extended the time limit for commencing an action based on injuries resulting from childhood sexual abuse to the later of within eight years after the age of majority or within three years of the date of discovery.
AB 1651 (Ortiz, Ch. 1021, Stats. 1998) applied the extended statute of limitations to actions against third parties.
SB 1779 (Burton, Ch. 149, Stats. 2002) extended the statute of limitations in cases against a third party beyond the victim-plaintiff’s twenty-sixth birthday when the third party knew or had reason to know of complaints against an employee, volunteer, representative, or agent and failed to take reasonable steps to prevent similar unlawful conduct.
SB 640 (Simitian, Ch. 383, Stats. 2008) exempted from the claims presentation requirements in the Government Tort Claims Act claims for the recovery of damages suffered as a result of childhood sexual abuse, as specified.
AB 1628 (Beall, 2012), among other things, would have extended the statute of limitations for civil childhood sexual assault claims to the later of within the victim-plaintiff reaching age thirty-five or within three years of discovery. AB 1628 was held on the Suspense File of the Assembly Committee on Appropriations.
SB 131 (Beall, 2013), among other things, would have provided that the time limits to bring an action for civil childhood sexual abuse be applied retroactively to any claim that had not been adjudicated to finality on the merits as of January 1, 2014 and would have revived, for a period of one year, a cause of action, as specified, that otherwise would have been barred by the statute of limitations as of January 1, 2014, provided that the victim-plaintiff’s twenty-sixth birthday was before January 1, 2003 and the plaintiff discovered the cause of his or her injury on or after January 1, 2004. SB 131 was vetoed by the Governor, who stated, in part:
[SB 131] does not change a victim's ability to sue a perpetrator. This bill also does not change the significant inequity that exists between private and public entities. What this bill does do is go back to the only group, i.e. private institutions, that have already been subjected to the unusual "one year revival period" and makes them, and them alone, subject to suit indefinitely. This extraordinary extension of the statute of limitations, which legislators chose not to apply to public institutions, is simply too open-ended and unfair.
SB 924 (Beall, Ch. 921, Stats. 2014) extended the statute of limitations for civil childhood sexual abuse claims arising from conduct that occurred on or after January 1, 2015 to the later of within 22 years of the date the plaintiff becomes an adult or within three years of the date of discovery.
AB 334 (Cooper, 2017) would have extended the statute of limitation for any civil action for recovery of damages suffered as a result of sexual assault, in situations when an adult was assaulted, as specified. It also would have made a number of changes to existing law regarding sexual assault forensic medical examinations (SAFMEs), including the reimbursement rate for SAFMEs of survivors who do not aid or otherwise participate with law enforcement. AB 334 was never heard in the Senate Committee on Public Safety.
AB 1619 (Berman, Ch. 1619, Stats. 2018) extended the statute of limitations for civil actions seeking damages suffered as a result of sexual assault, in situations when an adult was assaulted.
AB 3120 (Gonzalez Fletcher, 2018) was substantially similar to this bill and was vetoed by the Governor. The Governor stated, in part, that the bill was “broader than SB 131, does not fully address the inequity between state defendants and others, and provides a longer revival period for otherwise barred claims. For these reasons, as well as those previously enumerated in the veto message [for SB 131, he could not] sign this bill.”
SB 1053 (Beall, Ch. 153., Stats. 2018) exempted claims for money or damages against local public entities for claims of childhood sexual abuse from a specific provision of the Government Tort Claims Act.
Staff Comments:
The actual fiscal impact of AB 218 to the courts will depend on many unknown factors, including the numbers of childhood sexual assaults alleged to have occurred, if parties settle before the filing of an action, and the factors unique to each case. While it is unknown how many actions ultimately would be filed that otherwise would be time barred and/or within the expanded definition of childhood sexual assault, it generally costs about $7,644 to operate a courtroom for one day. Additionally, it costs the court almost $2,900, on average, in personnel and resources to adjudicate a limited civil case and about $12,750, on average, in personnel and resources to adjudicate an unlimited civil case. These costs takes into consideration the time from when a petition or complaint is received by the court, processing and calendaring by the clerks, any hearings presided over by a judicial officer, and the finalizing of the outcome by the clerk. Consequently, if AB 218 led to the filing of four or more new large cases, 18 or more smaller cases, or a few complex cases that took longer than six days to adjudicate, the cost pressures to the court would surpass the Suspense File threshold. As indicated above, while the court is not funded on a workload basis, an increase in workload could result in delayed court services and would put pressure on the General Fund to fund additional staff and resources.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 218 (Author:Gonzalez)
Version: March 25, 2019
Hearing Date: July 2, 2019
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Damages: childhood sexual assault: statute of limitations
DIGEST
This bill extends the time for commencement of actions for childhood sexual assault to 40 years of age or five years from discovery of the injury. It provides enhanced damages for a cover up, as defined, of the assault. It also provides a three-year window in which expired claims would be revived.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
This bill lengthens the limitations period for claims of childhood sexual assault from eight years past the age of majority, which amounts to 26 years of age, to 22 years past the age of majority, or 40 years of age. In addition, it would extend the period tied to the discovery of the childhood sexual assault from within three years to within five years.
This bill also provides that the claims provided for in Section 340.1 that would otherwise be barred as of January 1, 2020 because an applicable statute of limitations, claim presentation deadline, or any other time limit had expired, and that have not been litigated to finality, are explicitly revived for a three-year period or, if later, within the statute of limitations period established by the bill.
The bill is sponsored by the author and supported by various groups, including the Victim Policy Institute, the California Police Chiefs Association, the Consumer Attorneys of California, and the National Association of Social Workers. It is opposed by various associations that would likely be affected by these revived or extended claims periods, including the California School Boards Association, the California Association of Joint Powers Authorities, and the Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers of California.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Provides that in an action for recovery of damages suffered as a result of childhood sexual abuse, the time for commencement of the action shall be within eight years of the date the plaintiff attains the age of majority or within three years of the date the plaintiff discovers or reasonably should have discovered that psychological injury or illness occurring after the age of majority was caused by the sexual abuse, whichever period expires later, for any of the following actions:
- an action against any person for committing an act of childhood sexual abuse;
- an action for liability against any person or entity who owed a duty of care to the plaintiff, where a wrongful or negligent act by that person or entity was a legal cause of the childhood sexual abuse which resulted in the injury to the plaintiff; or
- an action for liability against any person or entity where an intentional act by that person or entity was a legal cause of the childhood sexual abuse which resulted in the injury to the plaintiff. (Code Civ. Proc. § 340.1(a).)
- Provides that the actions described above against persons or entities other than the person who committed an act of childhood sexual abuse must be commenced before the plaintiff’s 26th birthday. However, this restriction does not apply if the person or entity knew or had reason to know, or was otherwise on notice, of any unlawful sexual conduct by an employee, volunteer, representative, or agent, and failed to take reasonable steps, and to implement reasonable safeguards, to avoid acts of unlawful sexual conduct in the future by that person, including, but not limited to, preventing or avoiding placement of that person in a function or environment in which contact with children is an inherent part of that function or environment. Existing law states that providing or requiring counseling is not sufficient, in and of itself, to constitute a reasonable step or reasonable safeguard as used therein. (Code Civ. Proc. § 340.1(b).)
- Provides that notwithstanding any other provision of law, any claim for damages described above relating to a nonperpetrator defendant that is permitted to be filed pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (b) that would otherwise be barred as of January 1, 2003, solely because the applicable statute of limitations has or had expired, is revived, and, in that case, a cause of action may be commenced within one year of January 1, 2003. This revival does not apply to any claim that has been litigated to finality on the merits in any court of competent jurisdiction prior to January 1, 2003. Termination of a prior action on the basis of the statute of limitations does not constitute a claim that has been litigated to finality on the merits. It also does not apply to any written, compromised settlement agreement between the parties, as specified. (Code Civ. Proc. § 340.1(c), (d).)
- Defines “childhood sexual abuse” as used in the above provisions to include any act committed against the plaintiff that occurred when the plaintiff was under the age of 18 years and that would have been proscribed by specified sections of the Penal Code or prior laws of this state of similar effect at the time the act was committed. (Code Civ. Proc. § 340.1(e).)
- Exempts claims made pursuant to Section 340.1 of the Code of Civil Procedure for the recovery of damages suffered as a result of childhood sexual abuse from the Government Tort Claims Act. This provision only applies to claims arising out of conduct occurring on or after January 1, 2009. (Gov. Code § 905.)
- Defines “sexual conduct” for the purposes of certain Penal Code provisions to include any of the following, whether actual or simulated: sexual intercourse, oral copulation, anal intercourse, anal oral copulation, masturbation, bestiality, sexual sadism, sexual masochism, penetration of the vagina or rectum by any object in a lewd or lascivious manner, exhibition of the genitals or pubic or rectal area for the purpose of sexual stimulation of the viewer, any lewd or lascivious sexual act as defined in Section 288, or excretory functions performed in a lewd or lascivious manner, whether or not any of the above conduct is performed alone or between members of the same or opposite sex or between humans and animals. An act is simulated when it gives the appearance of being sexual conduct. (Pen. Code § 311.4.)
This bill:
- Replaces “sexual abuse” with “sexual assault” in Section 340.1 and adds “sexual conduct,” as the term is defined in Penal Code Section 311.4, to the definition of sexual assault.
- Provides that an action for recovery of damages suffered as a result of childhood sexual assault must be commenced within 22 years of the date the plaintiff attains the age of majority or within five years of the date the plaintiff discovered or reasonably should have discovered the causal relationship between the assault and psychological injury or illness occurring after the age of majority.
- Provides that in such actions a person who is sexually assaulted as the result of a cover up may recover treble damages against a defendant who is found to have covered up the sexual assault of a minor. “Cover up” is defined as a concerted effort to hide evidence relating to childhood sexual assault.
- Provides that actions described in Section 340.1 involving a nonperpetrator defendant shall not be commenced on or after the plaintiff’s 40th birthday, unless the person or entity knew or had reason to know, or was otherwise on notice, of any misconduct that creates a risk of childhood sexual assault by an employee, volunteer, representative, or agent, or the person or entity failed to take reasonable steps or to implement reasonable safeguards to avoid acts of childhood sexual assault.
- Removes provisions relating to earlier revival periods that have since elapsed.
- Provides that its changes to the time period provided in subdivision (a) apply to and revive any action commenced on or after the date of enactment of that act, and to any action filed before the date of enactment, and still pending on that date, including any action or causes of action that would have been barred by the laws in effect before the date of enactment.
- Provides that, notwithstanding any other provision of law, any claim for damages described in Section 340.1(a)(1)-(3) that has not been litigated to finality and that would otherwise be barred as of January 1, 2020, because the applicable statute of limitations, claim presentation deadline, or any other time limit had expired, is revived, and these claims may be commenced within three years of January 1, 2020. A plaintiff shall have the later of the three-year time period under this provision or the time period under subdivision (a) of Section 340.1 as amended by this bill.
- Exempts claims made pursuant to Section 340.1 from the Government Tort Claims Act regardless of when the conduct took place. This change is retroactive and applies to new or pending cases.
COMMENTS
1. Background on laws governing childhood sexual assault
In 2002, the Legislature enacted SB 1779 (Burton, Chapter 149, Statutes of 2002), to provide that an action for recovery of damages suffered as a result of childhood sexual abuse may be commenced on or after the plaintiff’s 26th birthday if the third party defendant person or entity knew, had reason to know, or was otherwise on notice, of any unlawful sexual conduct by an employee, volunteer, representative, or agent, and failed to take reasonable steps and implement reasonable safeguards to avoid future acts of unlawful sexual conduct. (Code Civ. Proc. § 340.1(b)(2).) SB 1779 also enacted Section 340.1(c) to allow a claim under Section 340.1(b)(2) to be brought within a one-year window, January 1, 2003, to December 31, 2003, even if that claim would otherwise be time barred as of January 1, 2003, because of an applicable statute of limitations.
The Government Tort Claims Act (the Act) generally governs damage claims brought against public entities. (Gov. Code § 815 et seq.) In addition to any time limitations placed by other statutes on such claims, the Act requires that a claim that is brought against a public entity relating to a cause of action for death or for injury to a person be presented in writing to the public entity not later than six months after accrual of the cause or causes of action. (Gov. Code § 911.2.)
In Shirk v. Vista Unified School District (2007) 42 Cal.4th 201, the California Supreme Court held that, notwithstanding Section 340.1, a timely claim to a public entity pursuant to the Act is a prerequisite to maintaining an action for childhood sexual abuse against a public entity school district. The Court based its holding primarily on its finding that nothing in the express language of SB 1779 or the bill’s legislative history indicated an intent by the Legislature to exempt Section 340.1 claims from the Act and its six-month claim presentation requirement. Essentially, many claims for childhood sexual abuse against a public entity could not benefit from the change to Section 340.1 because the six-month presentation requirement for such claims was not addressed by SB 1779.
To address this loophole for childhood sexual abuse claims against public entities, SB 640 (Simitian, Ch. 383, Stats. of 2008) was enacted into law. It added an explicit exception to the claims presentation requirements to Section 905 of the Act for “[c]laims made pursuant to Section 340.1 of the Code of Civil Procedure for the recovery of damages suffered as a result of childhood sexual abuse.” (Gov. Code § 905(m).) Section 905(m) applied to claims arising out of conduct occurring on or after January 1, 2009.
This bill modifies the statute of limitations for these claims in various ways and provides another revival period for bringing expired claims.
2. Extending the statute of limitations period
A statute of limitations is a requirement to commence legal proceedings (either civil or criminal) within a specific period of time. Statutes of limitations are tailored to the cause of action at issue – for example, cases involving injury must be brought within two years from the date of injury, cases relating to written contracts must be brought four years from the date the contract was broken, and, as commonly referenced in the media, there is no statute of limitations for murder. Although it may appear unfair to bar actions after the statute of limitations has elapsed, that limitations period serves important policy goals that help to preserve both the integrity of our legal system and the due process rights of individuals.
For example, one significant reason that a limitations period is necessary in many cases is that evidence may disappear over time – paperwork gets lost, witnesses forget details or pass away, and physical locations that may be critical to a case change over time. Limitations periods also promote finality by encouraging an individual who has been wronged to bring an action sooner rather than later – timely actions arguably ensure that the greatest amount of evidence is available to all parties.
In general, California law requires all civil actions be commenced within applicable statutes of limitations. (Code Civ. Proc. § 312.) Under existing law, the general statute of limitations in California to bring an action for assault, battery, or injury to, or for the death of, an individual caused by the wrongful act or neglect of another, is two years. (Code Civ. Proc. § 335.1)
Currently, certain actions for childhood sexual abuse must be commenced within eight years of the date the plaintiff attains the age of majority or within three years of the date the plaintiff discovers or reasonably should have discovered that psychological injury or illness occurring after the age of majority was caused by the sexual abuse, whichever period expires later. This lengthy limitations period applies to actions against:
- the person alleged to have committed the childhood sexual abuse;
- any person or entity who owed a duty of care to the plaintiff, where a wrongful or negligent act by that person or entity was a legal cause of the childhood sexual abuse which resulted in the injury to the plaintiff; and
- any person or entity where an intentional act by that person or entity was a legal cause of the childhood sexual abuse which resulted in the injury to the plaintiff.
(Code Civ. Proc. § 340.1.)
This bill lengthens the limitations period from eight years past the age of majority, which amounts to 26 years of age, to 22 years past the age of majority, or 40 years of age. In addition, it extends the period tied to the discovery of the childhood sexual assault from within three years to within five years. The extension from three to five years based on discovery seems a minor and reasonable change to the law to provide more flexibility to victims. It is in line with other states’ laws.
As a frame of reference, Massachusetts requires such actions to be brought within 35 years of the alleged acts or within seven years of discovery of the causal relationship between the abuse and the injury. This period is tolled until the child reaches the age of majority. This amounts to a statute of limitations that lasts over a decade longer than that proposed by this bill. In addition, Connecticut provides victims 30 years from the age of majority to bring a claim. Florida allows actions within seven years of the age of majority or within four years from discovery of the causal relationship. Idaho allows claims to be brought within five years of the age of majority or discovery.
There is clearly a wide range of approaches among the states. A number of states have no specific limitations period applying to child sexual abuse. Maine does not even apply limits to when actions based upon sexual acts toward minors may be brought.
In 2019, two additional states have passed similar laws. New York’s new law allows victims until age 55 to bring suit for such abuse. New Jersey passed a bill that extended the statute of limitations to seven years after discovery or when the victim is 55 years of age, whichever is later. In signing the legislation, the New Jersey Governor stated: “Survivors of sexual abuse deserve opportunities to seek redress against their abusers. This legislation allows survivors who have faced tremendous trauma the ability to pursue justice through the court system.”
3. Reviving expired claims
This bill provides that the claims provided for in Section 340.1 that would otherwise be barred as of January 1, 2020, because an applicable statute of limitations, claim presentation deadline, or any other time limit had expired, is explicitly revived by the bill. The bill creates a three-year window in which such claims can be brought, or, if later, within the statute of limitations period newly established by the bill.
The California Supreme Court has squarely addressed the modification of statutes of limitations and the revival of stale claims:
The Legislature has authority to establish—and to enlarge—limitations periods. . . . [H]owever, legislative enlargement of a limitations period does not revive lapsed claims in the absence of express language of revival. This rule of construction grows out of an understanding of the difference between prospective and retroactive application of statutes. . . . As long as the former limitations period has not expired, an enlarged limitations period ordinarily applies and is said to apply prospectively to govern cases that are pending when, or instituted after, the enactment took effect. This is true even though the underlying conduct that is the subject of the litigation occurred prior to the new enactment. . . . However, when it comes to applying amendments that enlarge the limitations period to claims as to which the limitations period has expired before the amendment became law—that is, claims that have lapsed—the analysis is different. Once a claim has lapsed (under the formerly applicable statute of limitations), revival of the claim is seen as a retroactive application of the law under an enlarged statute of limitations. Lapsed claims will not be considered revived without express language of revival.
(Quarry v. Doe I (Quarry) (2012) 53 Cal.4th 945, 955-957, internal citations omitted.)
The court continues, specifically addressing the policy reasons against revival:
“The reason for this rule is a judicial perception of unfairness in reviving a cause after the prospective defendant has assumed its expiration and has conducted his affairs accordingly.” As one court commented, “a statute of limitations grants prospective defendants relief from the burdens of indefinite exposure to stale claims. By reviving lapsed claims, the Legislature may appear to renege on this promise. As Judge [Learned] Hand wrote, there may be something ‘unfair and dishonest’ in after-the-fact withdrawal of this legislative assurance of safety.” Individuals, as well as businesses and other enterprises ordinarily rely upon the running of the limitations period: “The keeping of records, the maintenance of reserves, and the commitment of funds may all be affected by such reliance . . . . To defeat such reliance . . . deprives [enterprises] of the ability to plan intelligently with respect to stale and apparently abandoned claims.”
(Quarry, at 958, internal citations omitted.)
The California Supreme Court thus makes the case against reviving claims that have expired, highlighting the principle that such revival, while within the Legislature’s power, should not be provided lightly. (See also Chase Sec. Corp. v. Donaldson (1945) 325 U.S. 304, 314 [finding statutes of limitations are “good only by legislative grace and to be subject to a relatively large degree of legislative control”]; Liebig v. Superior Court (1989) 209 Cal. App. 3d 828, 831-834; Lent v. Doe (1995) 40 Cal.App.4th 1177, 1181 [finding the Legislature has the power to revive causes of action].) The courts have made clear that important state interests must be at stake to justify such a disruption of the law.
“Childhood sexual abuse has been correlated with higher levels of depression, guilt, shame, self-blame, eating disorders, somatic concerns, anxiety, dissociative patterns, repression, denial, sexual problems, and relationship problems.”[1] Given the horrific damage and life-long trauma that can be caused by childhood sexual assault, these claims are arguably worthy of such revival, despite the general disregard for doing so. In fact, one of the only examples found where claims have been revived is in this context. SB 1779 (Burton, Ch. 149, Stats. 2002) provided a one-year revival period for otherwise expired claims for childhood sexual abuse.
As argued by the author, there has been a dramatic shift in cultural sensitivities around sexual abuse and a more accepting societal climate for victims. Rather than fearing stigma, victims of past abuse are more likely to be willing to come forward now with claims. There are complex psychological effects that result from being victimized in this way. In addition, the systematic incidence of childhood sexual assault in numerous institutions in this country and the cover-ups that accompanied them arguably make both a revival period and an extended statute of limitations warranted. This bill provides another chance for victims, who are currently barred from pursing claims based solely on the passage of time, to seek justice.
California would not be alone. Georgia passed a law that created a two-year window starting July 1, 2015, in which victims could file actions for claims of childhood sexual abuse that were otherwise time barred as of the enactment of the statute. Guam created a similar two-year window. Hawaii has created similar windows several times. Laws in both New York and New Jersey, discussed above and passed earlier this year, create revival periods of one and two years, respectively.
4. Recent revival attempts
In 2013, SB 131 (Beall, 2013) was passed by the Legislature. It would have, among other things, provided a one-year period of revival for otherwise time-barred claims arising from childhood sexual abuse. However, it would only have applied to private entities and not public entities.
In his veto message, Governor Jerry Brown traced the history of Section 340.1 and highlighted the fact that public entities were not subject to the revival of claims as private entities were. The Governor wrote:
[D]ue to a drafting error, the California Supreme Court held in 2007 that SB 1779 did not actually apply to public or governmental agencies. So, unlike private institutions, public schools and government entities were shielded from the one-year revival of lapsed claims. As a result, the similarly situated victims of these entities were not accorded the remedies of SB 1779.
In 2008, the Legislature addressed this unfair distinction between victims of public as opposed to private institutions. Note, however, that the bill enacted, SB 640, did not restore equity between these two sets of victims. Instead of subjecting public/governmental entities to all of the provisions of the 2002 law, the Legislature only allowed victims of public institutions to sue under the new rules prospectively-from 2009 forward-and provided no “one year revival” period.
In passing this 2008 law, I can’t believe the legislature decided that victims of abuse by a public entity are somehow less deserving than those who suffered abuse by a private entity. . . .
This brings us to the bill now before me, SB 131. This bill does not change a victim’s ability to sue a perpetrator. This bill also does not change the significant inequity that exists between private and public entities. What this bill does do is go back to the only group, i.e. private institutions, that have already been subjected to the unusual “one year revival period” and makes them, and them alone, subject to suit indefinitely. This extraordinary extension of the statute of limitations, which legislators chose not to apply to public institutions, is simply too open-ended and unfair.
In 2018, AB 3120 (Gonzalez, 2018) attempted to create another revival period for childhood sexual assault claims as well as extend the limitations period. The bill was nearly identical to the current bill. Governor Brown again vetoed the bill, asserting the same grounds as above and further arguing that AB 3120 was broader than SB 131, did not fully address the inequity between state defendants and others, and provided a longer revival period for otherwise barred claims.
5. Standard of proof
Section 340.1 provides that actions against persons or entities owing a duty of care to a victim where a wrongful or negligent act by that person or entity was a legal cause of the childhood sexual abuse, or against persons or entities where an intentional act by them was a legal cause of the childhood sexual abuse, cannot be commenced after the victim’s 26th birthday. However, in subdivision (b)(2), this limitation is removed where two elements are found:
- the person or entity knew or had reason to know, or was otherwise on notice, of any unlawful sexual conduct by an employee, volunteer, representative, or agent; and
- failed to take reasonable steps, and to implement reasonable safeguards, to avoid acts of unlawful sexual conduct in the future by that person, including, but not limited to, preventing or avoiding placement of that person in a function or environment in which contact with children is an inherent part of that function or environment.
The exact contours of subdivision (b)(2) were outlined by the California Supreme Court in Doe v. City of Los Angeles (2007) 42 Cal. 4th 531. The Court analyzed the legislative history of the enacting statute, SB 1779, to determine the purpose of subdivision (b)(2):
We conclude that subdivision (b)(2) is a remedial statute that the Legislature intended to be construed broadly to effectuate the intent that illuminates section 340.1 as a whole; to expand the ability of victims of childhood sexual abuse to hold to account individuals and entities responsible for their injuries. This principle of broad construction is not consistent with language in the opinion of the Court of Appeal below that imposed heightened pleading requirements on plaintiffs seeking to bring their actions within this expansion of the statute of limitations in childhood sexual abuse cases.
(Id. at 536-537.) Despite this conclusion, the court found that the statute requires more specific allegations than were made by the party to the case:
Fairly construed, then, subdivision (b)(2) requires the victim to establish that the nonperpetrator defendant had actual knowledge, constructive knowledge (as measured by the reason to know standard), or was otherwise on notice that the perpetrator had engaged in past unlawful sexual conduct with a minor and, possessed of this knowledge or notice, failed to take reasonable preventative steps or implement reasonable safeguards to avoid acts of future unlawful sexual conduct by the perpetrator.
(Id. at 549, emphasis added.)
This bill modifies the provisions of subdivision (b)(2) [now subdivision (c) in the bill]. First, it provides that the nonperpetrator defendant only needs to know, have reason to know, or otherwise be on notice, of any misconduct creating a risk of childhood sexual assault, whereas current law requires the relevant misconduct to be specifically “unlawful sexual conduct.” This drastically expands the actionable conduct pursuant to the statute. In addition, the bill modifies the second factor to requiring proof that the defendant failed to take reasonable steps or to implement reasonable safeguards to avoid acts of childhood sexual assault.
Most importantly, this bill replaces an “and” with an “or” and only requires one of the two factors to be proven to move forward with a claim after the relevant limitations period. These changes lessen the burden on a victim to bring such a case after having passed the cutoff age.
6. Expanded definition, penalties, and reach
This bill also replaces “childhood sexual abuse” throughout the statute with “childhood sexual assault.” The only difference in the relevant definition is the addition of “any sexual conduct” as defined in Penal Code Section 311.4(d)(1). That definition includes certain sexual acts or displays whether actual or simulated. (Pen. Code § 311.4.) This change increases the conduct to which the extended limitations period and the enhanced damages apply.
This bill also provides that, in any action described therein, a victim who is sexually assaulted as the result of a cover up may recover treble damages against a defendant who has engaged in that cover up of the sexual assault. The bill defines “cover up” to mean a concerted effort to hide evidence relating to childhood sexual assault. Therefore, the cover up of a victim’s assault does not trigger these enhanced damages. Rather, the victim’s assault must result from a prior cover up of childhood sexual assault.
Existing Section 905 of the Government Code exempts from the Government Tort Claims Act all claims made pursuant to Section 340.1 that arise out of conduct occurring on or after January 1, 2009. This bill deletes the time component from the provision and makes the change retroactive. Therefore, claims arising from relevant misconduct on the part of public entities and their employees occurring before 2009 that would have been barred by the Government Tort Claims Act, are now subject to the statute of limitations laid out in Section 340.1 and are revived pursuant to the relevant provision creating the three-year window. As discussed above, most of these claims were not eligible for the revival established by SB 1779.
7. Support and opposition
The Victim Policy Institute writes in support of this bill:
The current law lets too many abusers avoid accountability for their actions. The only good thing to come out of recent scandals was an environment that encouraged well-known women - actors or Olympians - who were victims of childhood sexual assault to come forward. It is time for the law to recognize what we all now know – that it can take decades before some survivors are capable of coming forward. Children being assaulted today may not be ready to come forward until decades in the future.
Victims who are ready to come forward today deserve an opportunity to expose their perpetrators and those who covered up the abuse. AB 218 simply provides a forum for victims to come forward. Victims will still be responsible for proving they were sexually assaulted and that someone covered it up. Victims deserve that chance and the safety of our children demands that we provide every opportunity possible for victims to expose these crimes.
The Consumer Attorneys of California explains its support for the bill:
The Catholic Church has knowingly covered up years of childhood sex abuse and, tragically, it was not the only institution to do so, allowing serial predators to victimize more and more children. Victims of childhood sexual abuse may not recognize or report the abuse for years. According to the U.S. Department of Justice, nine out of ten child sexual abuse victims are abused by someone close to them and may be hesitant to report them. Many initially feel it is their fault or they will not be believed. For others it may take years, or even decades, to come to terms with what happened and to tell others about it.
A coalition of groups, including the Schools Excess Liability Fund, the Schools Insurance Authority, the Association of California School Administrators, the California Association of Joint Powers Authorities, and the California Association of School Business Officials, writes in opposition:
As drafted, AB 218 exposes local public schools and others, to claims of abuse going back 40 years ago and longer. It will be impossible for employers to effectively defend against these claims when evidence is likely gone, witnesses have moved or passed away, and there has been a turnover of staff. With these barriers, schools will be unable to adequately respond to these claims. This failure will result in diversion of funding intended to educate students and serve communities to financing increased legal costs, whether or not the claim is valid. This is particularly troubling when considering that AB 218 would permit the recovery of treble damages . . . .
This coalition specifically urges the removal of the treble damages provisions:
Coupled with the other provisions of the bill, this component may result in added billions of dollars in costs to schools to settle claims that are decades old and occurred under school boards and administrators that are long gone, with little evidence or ability to defend against them. With little to no evidence available, school districts will be forced to settle a lawsuit resulting in the diversion of critical education funds and services for today’s students.
SUPPORT
American Association of University Women of California
California Association of Marriage and Family Therapists
California Council of Community Behavioral Health Agencies
California Family Resource Association
California Police Chiefs Association
California Protective Parents Association
California State PTA
Center for Judicial Excellence
Child Abuse Prevention Center
CHILD USA
Consumer Attorneys of California
Crime Victims United of California
John Burton Advocates for Youth
Joyful Heart Foundation
Leaving Neverland Support Network
National Association of Social Workers
Stop Educator Sexual Abuse, Misconduct & Exploitation
Victim Policy Institute
One individual
OPPOSITION
American Tort Reform Association
Association of California School Administrators
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Association of Private School Organizations
California Association of School Business Officials
California Civil Liberties Advocacy
California School Boards Association
Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers of California
Northern California Regional Liability Excess Fund
Schools Excess Liability Fund
Schools Insurance Authority
Southern California Regional Liability Excess Fund
Statewide Association of Community Colleges
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: AB 1510 (Reyes, 2019) revives otherwise time-barred claims for damages arising from sexual assault and other inappropriate conduct of a sexual nature, as specified. This bill is currently in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
Prior Legislation:
SB 1053 (Beall, Ch. 153, Stats. 2018) provided that the procedures authorized to be prescribed by Section 935 of the Government Code relating to claims for money or damages against local public entities do not apply to claims of childhood sexual abuse made as described in Section 905(m) of the Government Code.
AB 3120 (Gonzalez, 2018) See Comment 4.
SB 131 (Beall, 2013) See Comment 4.
SB 640 (Simitian, Ch. 383, Stats. 2008) See Comment 1.
SB 1779 (Burton, Ch. 149, Stats. 2002) See Comments 1, 3-6.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 64, Noes 3)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 8, Noes 2)
**************
Melissa Hall and Joshua Hall, The long-term effects of childhood sexual abuse: Counseling implications (2011) https://www.counseling.org/docs/disaster-and-trauma_sexual-abuse/long-term-effects-of-childhood-sexual-abuse.pdf? [as of June 6, 2019]. ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 218
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Amended Ver:March 25, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Extends the civil statute of limitations for childhood sexual assault by 14 years, revives, for three years, old claims, and increases certain penalties for childhood sexual assault
Major Provisions
- Redefines childhood sexual abuse as childhood sexual assault and expands the definition slightly.
- Extends the time for commencing a civil action based on injuries resulting from childhood sexual assault to twenty-two years after the plaintiff reaches majority (i.e., until 40 years of age) or within five years of the date the plaintiff discovers or reasonably should have discovered that the psychological injury or illness occurring after the age of majority was caused by the abuse, whichever occurs later.
- Prohibits suit against third parties after the plaintiff's 40th birthday unless the person or entity knew or had reason to know, or was otherwise on notice, of any misconduct that creates a risk of childhood sexual assault by an employee, volunteer, representative, or agent, or failed to take reasonable steps, or to implement reasonable safeguards, to avoid acts of childhood sexual assault.
- Revives, until three years of January 1, 2020, or the time period under 2), above, whichever is later, any actions for childhood sexual assault that has not been litigated to finality and that would otherwise be barred as of January 1, 2020, because of applicable statute of limitations, claims presentation deadline, or any other time limit.
- Allows a person, in an action for recovery of damages suffered as the result of childhood sexual assault, to recover tremble damages against a defendant if the sexual assault is the result of a cover-up by the defendant of a sexual assault of a minor. Defines "cover-up" as a concerted effort to hide evidence relating to childhood sexual assault.
- Eliminates the existing limitation on exemption from the Government Tort Claims Act and instead exempts, from the Government Tort Claims Act, all claims for childhood sexual assault against a local public entity, including those arising out of conduct occurring before January 1, 2009.
COMMENTS:
Childhood sexual abuse continues to ruin children lives and continues to shock the nation because, unfortunately, perpetrators continue to abuse, often with impunity, and sometimes with the help of third parties who either choose not to get involved or actively cover-up the abuse. Whether the abuse occurred through gymnastics, swimming, school, or a religious institution, too many children have been victims of abuse and their lives have been forever impacted by that abuse. Despite the lifetime of damage that this abuse causes its victims, the state's statute of limitations restricts how long actions can be brought to recover for damages caused by childhood sexual abuse. In an effort to allow more victims of childhood sexual assault to be compensated for their injuries and, to help prevent future assaults by raising the costs for this abuse, this bill extends the civil statute of limitations for childhood sexual assault by 14 years, revives old claims for three years, and eliminates existing limitations for claims against public institutions. This bill applies equally to abuse occurring at public and private schools and applies to all local public entities. Lastly, the bill allows a victim of childhood sexual abuse to recover tremble damages against a defendant if the sexual assault is the result of a cover-up by the defendant of a prior sexual assault of a minor.
For more information, see the Assembly Judiciary Committee analysis of the bill.
According to the Author:
AB 218 would expand access to justice for victims of childhood sexual assault by removing the arbitrary time limits upon victims to pursue a case. Several states have already taken this step and have eliminated the civil statute of limitations for these cases. There should not be a reasonable expectation that if simply enough time passes, there will be no accountability for these despicable past acts by individuals and entities. This bill ensures that "time's up" for the perpetrators of childhood sexual assault, not for victims.
AB 218 would also confront the pervasive problem of cover ups in institutions, from schools to sports league, which result in continuing victimization and the sexual assault of additional children. The bill would allow for recovery of up to treble damages from the defendant who covered up sexual assault. This reform is clearly needed both to compensate victims who never should have been victims- and would not have been if past sexual assault had been properly brought to light- and also as an effective deterrent against individuals and entities who have chosen to protect the perpetrators of sexual assault over the victims.
Arguments in Support:
The sponsor, the Victim Policy Institute, writes: "The current law lets too many abusers avoid accountability for their actions. The only good thing to come out of recent scandals was an environment that encouraged well-known women - actors or Olympians - who were victims of childhood sexual assault to come forward. It is time for the law to recognize what we all now know – that it can take decades before some survivors are capable of coming forward. Children being assaulted today may not be ready to come forward until decades in the future."
Arguments in Opposition:
This bill is opposed, unless amended, by public and private school officials, insurance associations, and joint powers associations. All of the opponents raise the same basic concerns: it is very difficult to defend against old claims when records and witnesses may be unavailable, insurance may no longer be available, and the cost of defending these actions could be astronomical and could prevent the impacted entities from being able to support their main work. They request, among other things, that the bill be amended to eliminate the treble damages provision, eliminate the revival period, and limit liability for third parties. They also request amendments to create and fund procedures to prevent future abuse.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-2-2
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Reyes
NO: Kiley, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gallagher, Petrie-Norris
UPDATED:
VERSION: March 25, 2019
CONSULTANT: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0000066
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 218
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Introduced Ver:January 16, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Extends the civil statute of limitations for childhood sexual assault by 14 years, revives, for three years, old claims, and increases certain penalties for childhood sexual assault.
Major Provisions
- Redefines childhood sexual abuse as childhood sexual assault and expands the definition slightly.
- Extends the time for commencing a civil action based on injuries resulting from childhood sexual assault to twenty-two years after the plaintiff reaches majority (i.e., until 40 years of age) or within five years of the date the plaintiff discovers or reasonably should have discovered that the psychological injury or illness occurring after the age of majority was caused by the abuse, whichever occurs later.
- Prohibits suit against third parties after the plaintiff's 40th birthday unless the person or entity knew or had reason to know, or was otherwise on notice, of any misconduct that creates a risk of childhood sexual assault by an employee, volunteer, representative, or agent, or failed to take reasonable steps, or to implement reasonable safeguards, to avoid acts of childhood sexual assault.
- Revives, until three years of January 1, 2020, or the time period under 2), above, whichever is later, any actions for childhood sexual assault that has not been litigated to finality and that would otherwise be barred as of January 1, 2020, because of applicable statute of limitations, claims presentation deadline, or any other time limit.
- Allows a person, in an action for recovery of damages suffered as the result of childhood sexual assault, to recover tremble damages against a defendant if the sexual assault is the result of a cover-up by the defendant of a sexual assault of a minor. Defines "cover-up" as a concerted effort to hide evidence relating to childhood sexual assault.
- Eliminates the existing limitation on exemption from the Government Tort Claims Act and instead exempts, from the Government Tort Claims Act, all claims for childhood sexual assault against a local public entity, including those arising out of conduct occurring before January 1, 2009.
COMMENTS:
Childhood sexual abuse continues to ruin children lives and continues to shock the nation because, unfortunately, perpetrators continue to abuse, often with impunity, and sometimes with the help of third parties who either choose not to get involved or actively cover-up the abuse. Whether the abuse occurred through gymnastics, swimming, school, or a religious institution, too many children have been victims of abuse and their lives have been forever impacted by that abuse. Despite the lifetime of damage that this abuse causes its victims, the state's statute of limitations restricts how long actions can be brought to recover for damages caused by childhood sexual abuse. In an effort to allow more victims of childhood sexual assault to be compensated for their injuries and, to help prevent future assaults by raising the costs for this abuse, this bill extends the civil statute of limitations for childhood sexual assault by 14 years, revives old claims for three years, and eliminates existing limitations for claims against public institutions. This bill applies equally to abuse occurring at public and private schools and applies to all local public entities. Lastly, the bill allows a victim of childhood sexual abuse to recover tremble damages against a defendant if the sexual assault is the result of a cover-up by the defendant of a prior sexual assault of a minor.
For more information, see the Assembly Judiciary Committee analysis of the bill.
According to the Author:
AB 218 would expand access to justice for victims of childhood sexual assault by removing the arbitrary time limits upon victims to pursue a case. Several states have already taken this step and have eliminated the civil statute of limitations for these cases. There should not be a reasonable expectation that if simply enough time passes, there will be no accountability for these despicable past acts by individuals and entities. This bill ensures that "time's up" for the perpetrators of childhood sexual assault, not for victims.
AB 218 would also confront the pervasive problem of cover ups in institutions, from schools to sports league, which result in continuing victimization and the sexual assault of additional children. The bill would allow for recovery of up to treble damages from the defendant who covered up sexual assault. This reform is clearly needed both to compensate victims who never should have been victims- and would not have been if past sexual assault had been properly brought to light- and also as an effective deterrent against individuals and entities who have chosen to protect the perpetrators of sexual assault over the victims.
Arguments in Support:
The sponsor, the Victim Policy Institute, writes: "The current law lets too many abusers avoid accountability for their actions. The only good thing to come out of recent scandals was an environment that encouraged well-known women - actors or Olympians - who were victims of childhood sexual assault to come forward. It is time for the law to recognize what we all now know – that it can take decades before some survivors are capable of coming forward. Children being assaulted today may not be ready to come forward until decades in the future."
Arguments in Opposition:
This bill is opposed, unless amended, by public and private school officials, insurance associations, and joint powers associations. All of the opponents raise the same basic concerns: it is very difficult to defend against old claims when records and witnesses may be unavailable, insurance may no longer be available, and the cost of defending these actions could be astronomical and could prevent the impacted entities from being able to support their main work. They request, among other things, that the bill be amended to eliminate the treble damages provision, eliminate the revival period, and limit liability for third parties. They also request amendments to create and fund procedures to prevent future abuse.
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-2-2
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Reyes
NO: Kiley, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gallagher, Petrie-Norris
UPDATED:
VERSION: January 16, 2019
CONSULTANT: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0000049
Date of Hearing: March 12, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 218
Author:(Gonzalez) – As Introduced Ver:January 16, 2019
SUBJECT: childhood sexual ASSAULT: EXTENSION OF statute of limitations and INCREASE in Damages
KEY ISSUES:
- IN ORDER TO ENSURE THAT VICTIMS OF CHILDHOOD SEXUAL ASSAULT ARE NOT PREVENTED FROM RECOVERING FOR THEIR INJURIES, SHOULD THE STATUTE OF LIMITATIONS FOR CHILDHOOD SEXUAL ASSAULT CIVIL ACTIONS BE EXTENDED BY 14 YEARS AND SHOULD THAT EXTENSION APPLY RETROACTIVELY, FOR JUST THREE YEARS, TO ANY CASE FOR WHICH THERE WAS NOT A FINAL ADJUDICATION PRIOR TO THE ENACTMENT OF THIS BILL?
- SHOULD A VICTIM OF CHILDHOOD SEXUAL ASSAULT BE PERMITTED TO COLLECT TREBLE DAMAGES AGAINST A DEFENDANT WHOSE ACTIONS IN COVERING UP A PRIOR SEXUAL ASSAULT AGAINST A MINOR RESULTED IN THE ASSAULT OF THE VICTIM?
- SHOULD CASES OF CHILDHOOD SEXUAL ASSAULT BASED ON CONDUCT OCCURRING BEFORE 2009 BE EXEMPTED FROM THE GOVERNMENT TORT CLAIMS ACT?
SYNOPSIS
Childhood sexual abuse continues to ruin children’s lives and continues to shock the nation because, unfortunately, perpetrators continue to abuse, often with impunity, and sometimes with the help of third parties who either choose not to get involved or actively cover-up the abuse. Whether the abuse occurred through gymnastics, swimming, school, or a religious institution, too many children have been victims of abuse and their lives have been forever impacted by that abuse. Despite the lifetime of damage that this abuse causes its victims, the state’s statute of limitations restricts how long actions can be brought to recover for damages caused by childhood sexual abuse.
Many states have special, extended statutes of limitations for childhood sexual abuse because of the uniqueness of childhood sexual abuse and the difficulty that younger victims may have fully understanding the abuse, coming to terms with what has occurred, and then coming forward in a timely fashion. Seven states — Alaska, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Illinois, Maine, and Minnesota — have gone as far as to eliminate the civil statute of limitations with respect to some or all claims based on childhood sexual abuse. Many other states allow for lengthy discovery periods in adulthood. California law, as amended in 1990, requires that such actions be brought within 8 years of the age of majority (generally up to 26 years old) or within 3 years of the date the plaintiff discovers or reasonably should have discovered that the psychological injury or illness occurring after the age of majority was caused by the sexual abuse, whichever period expires later. (SB 108 (Lockyer), Chap. 1578, Stats. 1990.)
This bill, sponsored by the Victim Policy Institute, makes significant changes to address childhood sexual abuse. First and foremost, this bill extends the statute of limitations for bringing an action for recovery of damages suffered as the result of childhood sexual assault by 14 years – from 26 years of age to 40 years of age – and revives, for just three years, any action for childhood sexual assault that may have expired due to the existing statute of limitations, except for cases that have a final adjudication prior to the enactment of this bill. It expands the existing exemption from the Government Tort Claims Act, which today only applies to conduct occurring after January 1, 2009, to include all claims of childhood sexual assault against a local public entity, regardless of when the abuse occurred. Thus local public entities, including schools, could be liable for damages for childhood sexual assaults that occurred before 2009. Lastly, this bill allows a victim of childhood sexual abuse to recover tremble damages against a defendant if the victim’s sexual assault is the result of a cover-up by the defendant of a prior sexual assault of a minor. This measure is almost identical to the author’s AB 3120 from last year, which easily passed the Legislature, but was vetoed by the former governor.
This measure is supported by, among others, children's advocates, the police chiefs, the PTA, and crime victims’ organizations, who write that the psychological injuries from sexually assault emerge later in life and that victims routinely need decades to reach the psychological place where they can come forward. If the statute of limitations is too short, then there can be no justice and more children will be abused. The bill is opposed (unless amended) by the public and private school officials, insurance associations, and joint powers associations. All of the opponents raise the same basic concerns: it is very difficult to defend against old claims when records and witnesses may be unavailable, insurance may no longer be available, and the cost of defending these actions could be astronomical and could prevent the impacted entities from being able to support their main work. They ask for various amendments to the bill, particularly eliminating the revival of old claims and the allowance of treble damages. The bill is opposed outright by the California Civil Liberties Advocacy.
SUMMARY: Extends the civil statute of limitations for childhood sexual assault by 14 years, revives, for three years, old claims, and increases certain penalties for childhood sexual assault. Specifically, this bill:
- Redefines childhood sexual abuse as childhood sexual assault and expands the definition slightly.
- Extends the time for commencing a civil action based on injuries resulting from childhood sexual assault to twenty-two years after the plaintiff reaches majority (i.e., until 40 years of age) or within five years of the date the plaintiff discovers or reasonably should have discovered that the psychological injury or illness occurring after the age of majority was caused by the abuse, whichever occurs later.
- Prohibits suit against third parties after the plaintiff's 40th birthday unless the person or entity knew or had reason to know, or was otherwise on notice, of any misconduct that creates a risk of childhood sexual assault by an employee, volunteer, representative, or agent, or failed to take reasonable steps, or to implement reasonable safeguards, to avoid acts of childhood sexual assault.
- Revives, until three years of January 1, 2020 or the time period under 2), above, whichever is later, any actions for childhood sexual assault that has not been litigated to finality and that would otherwise be barred as of January 1, 2020 because of applicable statute of limitations, claims presentation deadline, or any other time limit.
- Allows a person, in an action for recovery of damages suffered as the result of childhood sexual assault, to recover tremble damages against a defendant if the sexual assault is the result of a cover-up by the defendant of a sexual assault of a minor. Defines "cover-up" as a concerted effort to hide evidence relating to childhood sexual assault.
- Eliminates the existing limitation on exemption from the Government Tort Claims Act and instead exempts, from the Government Tort Claims Act, all claims for childhood sexual assault against a local public entity, including those arising out of conduct occurring before January 1, 2009.
EXISTING LAW:
- Generally provides that the time for commencing a civil action for damages is within two years of the injury or death caused by the wrongful act or neglect of another. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 340. All further references are to this code unless otherwise noted.)
- Provides that the time for commencing a civil action based on injuries resulting from childhood sexual abuse, as defined, is eight years after the plaintiff reaches majority (i.e., until 26 years of age) or within three years of the date the plaintiff discovers or reasonably should have discovered that the psychological injury or illness occurring after the age of majority was caused by the abuse, whichever occurs later. (Section 340.1 (a).)
- Allows suit against the perpetrator or specified third parties, but prohibits suit against third parties after the plaintiff's 26th birthday, unless the person or entity knew or had reason to know, or was otherwise on notice, of any unlawful sexual conduct by an employee, volunteer, representative, or agent, and failed to take reasonable steps, and to implement reasonable safeguards, to avoid acts of unlawful sexual conduct in the future by that person, as specified. (Section 340.1 (b).)
- Exempts, from the Government Tort Claims Act, claims for childhood sexual abuse against a local public entity, arising out of conduct occurring on or after January 1, 2009. (Government Code Sections 905, 935.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: Childhood sexual abuse continues to ruin children lives and continues to shock the nation because, unfortunately, perpetrators continue to abuse, often with impunity, and sometimes with the help of third parties who either choose not to get involved or actively cover-up the abuse. Whether the abuse occurred through gymnastics, swimming, school, or a religious institution, too many children have been victims of abuse and their lives have been forever impacted by that abuse. Despite the lifetime of damage that this abuse causes its victims, the state’s statute of limitations restricts how long actions can be brought to recover for damages caused by childhood sexual abuse. In an effort to allow more victims of childhood sexual assault to be compensated for their injuries and, to help prevent future assaults by raising the costs for this abuse, this bill extends the civil statute of limitations for childhood sexual assault by 14 years, revives old claims for three years, and eliminates existing limitations for claims against public institutions. This bill applies equally to abuse occurring at public and private schools and applies to all local public entities. Lastly, the bill allows a victim of childhood sexual abuse to recover tremble damages against a defendant if the sexual assault is the result of a cover-up by the defendant of a prior sexual assault of a minor.
In support of the bill, the author writes:
California law already recognizes childhood sexual abuse as a unique circumstance with regards to the civil statute of limitations, but has not gone far enough to ensure that victims will have access to justice. It is clear due to psychological trauma, shame, fear, and various other reasons, it can take a long time for victims of childhood sexual assault to come forward publically, to recognize or remember the assault, or want to pursue legal recourse.
AB 218 would expand access to justice for victims of childhood sexual assault by removing the arbitrary time limits upon victims to pursue a case. Several states have already taken this step and have eliminated the civil statute of limitations for these cases. There should not be a reasonable expectation that if simply enough time passes, there will be no accountability for these despicable past acts by individuals and entities. This bill ensures that “time’s up” for the perpetrators of childhood sexual assault, not for victims.
AB 218 would also confront the pervasive problem of cover ups in institutions, from schools to sports league, which result in continuing victimization and the sexual assault of additional children. The bill would allow for recovery of up to treble damages from the defendant who covered up sexual assault. This reform is clearly needed both to compensate victims who never should have been victims- and would not have been if past sexual assault had been properly brought to light- and also as an effective deterrent against individuals and entities who have chosen to protect the perpetrators of sexual assault over the victims.
It often takes victims of childhood sexual abuse years to come forward and face their abusers. All too often, victims of childhood sexual abuse fail to report their abuse timely or sometimes even fail to report it at all. While the victims almost always know their abusers, they often fail to come forward timely because of threats of harm, being ashamed, blaming themselves, fear of not being believed, failing to fully appreciate the wrongfulness of the conduct, or suppressing very painful memories. Writes the sponsor, the Victim Policy Institute:
It often takes decades before victims recognize what was done to them as abuse, realize how they have been harmed by the abuse, or simply find the strength to come forward. When victims are able to disclose the abuse, they often find that the civil statute of limitations has already expired.
The current law lets too many abusers avoid accountability for their actions. The only good thing to come out of recent scandals was an environment that encouraged well-known women - actors or Olympians - who were victims of childhood sexual assault to come forward. It is time for the law to recognize what we all now know – that it can take decades before some survivors are capable of coming forward. Children being assaulted today may not be ready to come forward until decades in the future.
The Joyful Heart Foundation adds:
One in five girls and one in twenty boys is a victim of childhood sexual assault. Sexual assault and abuse is a crime with a lifelong, profound impact on survivors. Victims may experience a wide range of psychological and physical symptoms well into adulthood, including post-traumatic stress disorder, depression, eating disorders, and drug and alcohol problems. The residual effects of the trauma impact the survivor’s education and employment, adding to the economic loss the individual suffers as a result of the crime.
Our laws must be responsive to the reality that surrounds this crime: it is difficult for survivors of childhood sexual assault and abuse to come forward, and it may be decades before a survivor connects the struggles they have with their assault. Shame, guilt, fear of scrutiny, and intimidation all factor into the delay, and when the offender is a family member, it is particularly challenging for survivors to disclose their trauma. With the passage of time, emotional stability, maturity, and effective therapy, survivors may one day feel ready to fully face their perpetrator.
Survivors of childhood sexual assault and abuse must be given a path to hold their offenders accountable and recover damages in civil court. They should not be forced to incur the costs of the assault while the offender escapes liability. Civil suits allow survivors to reclaim monetary losses they have incurred such as paying for health problems, counseling, and drug or alcohol treatment related to the abuse. Civil cases can also be initiated and directed by the survivor, reestablishing a sense of control that was lost during the abuse.
As a result, it may take years for victims to bring civil (or seek criminal) actions, if they bring them at all, against both direct perpetrators of child sexual abuse and those who allowed the abuse to occur and to continue.
Childhood sexual abuse claims often have extended statutes of limitation. As a result of the unique nature of childhood sexual abuse and the difficulty that many younger victims have to fully understand the abuse, come to terms with what has occurred, and then come forward in a timely fashion, many states have special, extended statutes of limitations for childhood sexual abuse. Eight jurisdictions — Alaska, Connecticut, Delaware, Florida, Illinois, Maine, Minnesota, and Guam — have gone as far as to eliminate the civil statute of limitations with respect to some or all claims based on childhood sexual abuse. Other states, including Oregon, which permits claims to be filed until the victim is 40 years old or within five years of discovery, allow for very lengthy discovery periods in adulthood.
California law, as amended in 1990, requires that such actions be brought within 8 years of the age of majority (generally up to 26 years old) or within 3 years of the date the plaintiff discovers or reasonably should have discovered that the psychological injury or illness occurring after the age of majority was caused by the sexual abuse, whichever period expires later. (SB 108 (Lockyer), Chap. 1578, Stats. 1990.) The latter provision — within 3 years of making the relevant connection — is called a “delayed discovery” rule.
This statute of limitations has been amended repeatedly as it applies to third parties. Prior to 1998, actions against third parties who were the legal cause of the abuse had to be commenced within a year of the plaintiff’s 18th birthday. In 1998, the law was amended to allow the same time limits against third parties as against the abuser, provided that the suits were commenced before the plaintiff’s 26th birthday. (AB 1651 (Ortiz), Chap. 1032, Stats. 1998.) In 2002, the law was amended again to allow, among other things, delayed-discovery suits against such third parties after the plaintiff’s 26th birthday under limited conditions. (SB 1779 (Burton), Chap. 149, Stats. 2002.)
This bill extends the statute of limitations for civil actions for childhood sexual assault against both direct perpetrators and third parties who may have helped facilitate the abuse by 14 years, extending the age for victims to bring suit from 26 to 40 years of age. The bill also applies this provision retroactively, for three years of January 1, 2020, to any case not litigated to finality before the bill's enactment.
The Legislature has the power to create, extend, and change statutes of limitation as it deems appropriate. The policy behind statutes of limitations provides that they "are designed to promote justice by preventing surprises through the revival of claims that have been allowed to slumber until evidence has been lost, memories have faded, and witnesses have disappeared. The theory is that even if one has a just claim it is unjust not to put the adversary on notice to defend within the period of limitation and the right to be free of stale claims in time comes to prevail over the right to prosecute them." (3 Witkin, California Procedure Section 433, 4th Ed.)
Nonetheless, courts have acknowledged that "the need for repose is not so overarching that the Legislature cannot by express legislative provision allow certain actions to be brought at any time, and it has occasionally done so." (Duty v. Abex Corp (1989) 214 Cal.App.3rd 742, 749, citations omitted.) The United States Supreme Court has long held that:
Statutes of limitation find their justification in necessity and convenience rather than in logic. They represent expedients, rather than principles. . . . They are by definition arbitrary, and their operation does not discriminate against the just and the unjust claim, or the avoidable or unavoidable delay . . . . Their shelter has never been regarded as what now is called a "fundamental right" . . . . [T]he history of pleas of limitation shows them to be good only by legislative grace and to be subject to a relatively large degree of legislative control. (Chase Securities Corp. v. Donaldson (1945) 325 U.S. 304, 314.)
With regard to reviving cases previously barred by a statute of limitations, in Liebig v. Superior Court (1989) 209 Cal.App.3d 828 and Lent v. Doe (1995) 40 Cal.App.4th 1177, the courts cited Chase Securities and affirmed the Legislature's power to revive civil causes of action, even if the actions were otherwise barred by the running of the statute of limitations. In both cases, the court upheld against constitutional attack the retroactive application of prior legislation amending Section 340.1 (the statute at issue in this bill) to revive childhood abuse actions that had lapsed or technically expired under prior law.
Similarly, in Hellinger v. Farmers Group, Inc. (2001) 91 Cal.App.4th 1049, the court upheld the Legislature's revival of certain insurance claims arising out of the Northridge Earthquake that were not brought previously and that otherwise were time-barred, and allowed these claimants a one-year window to file the revived action. (SB 1899 (Burton), Chap. 1090, Stats. 2000, enacting Section 340.9.)
Another precedent for reviving civil claims or extending the statute of limitations in childhood sexual abuse cases is SB 1678 (Dunn), Chap. 741, Stats. 2004. That bill revived, for a one-year period commencing on January 1, 2005, a civil cause of action for child sexual abuse against the perpetrator if a criminal case filed against the perpetrator for that abuse was dismissed or overturned pursuant to a United States Supreme Court decision which held that the underlying statute was an unconstitutional ex post facto law in authorizing a criminal prosecution (as opposed to a civil action) after the original statute of limitations for the offense had run.
Perhaps most importantly for this bill, the Supreme Court in Quarry v. Doe I (2009) 53 Cal.4th 945, held that the provision allowing a plaintiff over 26 years of age to file suit against specified third parties in specified circumstances did not apply to claims that had lapsed under prior law, but did not say that the Legislature could not revive the claims by express terms; the majority simply held that the Legislature had not done so.
Thus, the appropriate inquiry is whether the Legislature believes that there are sufficient public policy reasons to support extending the statute of limitations and reviving otherwise barred claims under this bill, and whether such an extension and revival would maintain the protections afforded by the statute of limitations, that is, balancing the interests of the victims with the defendants' right to defend against the claim.
In support of the need for eliminating the statute of limitations, the author states:
Current law has also failed to provide an effective deterrent on entities with a duty of care to children from sweeping sexual assault under the rug and engaging in cover-ups. These cover-ups have protected perpetrators of sexual assault over the well-being of the children in their care, and allowed perpetrators to victimize more children.
For instance, A Southern California News Group investigation found that hundreds of underage USA swimmers have been subject to sexual abuse at the hands of their coaches and others in positions of power. “Top USA Swimming executives, board members, top officials and coaches acknowledge […] that they were aware of sexually predatory coaches for years, in some cases even decades, but did not take action against them”.
In another recent example at a high school in the San Diego area, a teacher was investigated for improper behavior towards students multiple times and even removed from the classroom once by the district. However, an investigation by Voice of San Diego found a lack of records for additional complaints that were made to the administration over a 10-year period, stating “some student complaints may have never left the principal’s office”. The former students coming forward are now are in their 20s and 30s.
Additionally, at a San Diego-area middle school between 2008 and 2015, students tried to raise concerns about a teacher to employees of the school, but were met with unhelpful advice and no consequences for the teacher for years, until one of the former middle school students reported a rape. (Citations omitted.)
Statutes of limitations reflect the reality that, over time, documents are lost or destroyed, witnesses’ memories fade, and evidence erodes. However, the current laws regarding the statute of limitations for childhood sexual abuse claims reflect another reality, namely that victims often have difficulty coming forward soon after the abuse for a variety of reasons, including threats, shame, self-blame, lack of trust, and fear. It is often difficult for the child victims to understand the harm done and know how to take action. Current law for younger victims accommodates these difficulties with its delayed-discovery rule. However, current law for older victims (born in 1976 or earlier) does not. This bill would change the law to provide more protection for victims who come forward later in life.
The former governor had extended criminal statutes of limitations for childhood sexual abuse, but not civil ones, and had vetoed similar legislation. In 2013 and 2014, the Legislature passed legislation extending the statute of limitations for criminal and civil actions for childhood sexual abuse. Governor Brown signed the bill extending the criminal statute of limitations from 26 years of age to 40 years of age (SB 926 (Beall), Chap. 921, Stats. 2014), but vetoed the two civil extensions, one for the exact same time period as the criminal expansion (SB 131 (Beall), 2013; SB 924 (Beall), 2014). Governor Brown, in his veto of SB 924, stated:
Statutes of limitations exist as a matter of fundamental fairness. As I wrote last year, there comes a time when an individual or organization should be secure in the reasonable expectation that past acts are indeed in the past and not subject to further lawsuits. With the passage of time, evidence may be lost or disposed of, memories fade and witnesses move away or die.
There needs to be a compelling reason to lengthen the statute of limitations for civil claims against third parties. I do not see evidence of that here.
It is not clear why the former governor was willing to extend the statute of limitations from 26 years of age to 40 for criminal prosecutions, where a defendant's fundamental liberty is at stake (SB 926, 2014), but was unwilling to approve the exact same extension for civil actions when money, but not liberty, is at stake. The same arguments about faded memories and lost evidence apply in both cases and, in both cases, the plaintiff/prosecution retains the burden of proof.
The former governor vetoed an almost identical version of this bill last year – AB 3120 – reiterating his veto message from SB 131 and adding: “The bill now before me, AB 3120, is broader than SB 131, does not fully address the inequity between state defendants and others, and provides a longer revival period for otherwise barred claims. For these reasons, as well as those previously enumerated in the veto message [for SB 131], I cannot sign this bill.”
This bill revives most, but not all, old claims. This bill revives for three years – until January 1, 2023 – any action for damages for childhood sexual assault that has not been litigated to finality. However, some cases have been litigated to finality (the cases ended) but never reached the merits because they were terminated due to the shorter statute of limitations. Terminating a case based on the statute of limitations does not allow for true resolution of the claims presented. As this bill moves forward, the author may wish to consider whether cases that were litigated to finality, but never reached the merits due to the statute of limitations should be revived during the three-year revival period. This would be consistent with prior revival periods under SB 1779 (Burton and Escutia), Chap. 149, Stats. 2002, and SB 1678 (Dunn), Chap. 741, Stats. 2004, which allowed cases terminated based on the statute of limitations to be revived.
Should the author decide, as the bill moves forward, to amend the bill, the following amendment would add in claims that were terminated based on the statute of limitations:
Code of Civil Procedure 304.1(q)(1) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, any claim for damages described in paragraphs (1) through (3), inclusive, of subdivision (a) that has not been litigated to finality on the merits and that would otherwise be barred as of January 1, 2020, because the applicable statute of limitations, claim presentation deadline, or any other time limit had expired, is revived, and these claims may be commenced within three years of January 1, 2020. A plaintiff shall have the later of the three year time period under this subdivision or the time period under subdivision (a) as amended by the act that added this subdivision.
(2) Termination of a prior action on the basis of the statute of limitations does not constitute a claim that has been litigated to finality on the merits.
This measure applies retroactively to local public agencies. The Government Tort Claims Act (GTCA) generally governs damage claims brought against public entities. The GTCA requires that a claim relating to a cause of action for death or for injury to a person be presented in writing to the public entity not later than six months after the date upon which the cause of action would be deemed to have accrued within the meaning of the applicable statutes of limitation. In Shirk v. Vista Unified School District (2007) 42 Cal.4th 201, the California Supreme Court held that, notwithstanding the childhood sexual abuse statute of limitations timeframes in Section 340.1 and its delayed discovery rule, an abuse victim must follow the six-month presentation rule in the GTCA and cannot, without having done so, take advantage of the delayed-discovery rule otherwise applicable to abuse victims.
However, the Legislature in 2008 waived, going forward, the local government six-month notice of claim limitation requirement that applies to all other tort claims for victims of child sexual abuse. (SB 640 (Simitian), Chap. 383, Stats. 2008.) Thus, beginning in 2009, victims, have the same time period to file a claim against local public entities as against private institutions. This bill now extends that GTCA exemption to conduct occurring before 2009. As a result, this bill treats local public and private entities the same. It does not change the law with respect to state public entities.
The bill also exposes those who cover up the sexual abuse of children to additional punishment. In addition to extending the statute of limitations for childhood sexual assault, reviving old claims, and removing the protections of the GTCA from local public entities, this bill allows a victim of childhood sexual assault to recover tremble damages against a defendant if the victim's assault was the result of a cover-up by the defendant of a prior sexual assault of a minor. For example, if the defendant moved a perpetrator to another location without notifying authorities or gave the defendant a positive job recommendation without disclosing the sexual assault accusations, and the victim was assaulted as a result, the victim could recover treble damages. The victim would, of course, first have to prove the case.
Opponents believe that the bill would be financially devastating to, among others, schools, religious institutions, and insurers, and is unfair, especially as applied to third parties. This bill is opposed, unless amended, by public and private school officials, insurance associations, and joint powers associations. All of the opponents raise the same basic concerns: it is very difficult to defend against old claims when records and witnesses may be unavailable, insurance may no longer be available, and the cost of defending these actions could be astronomical and could prevent the impacted entities from being able to support their main work.
In particular, the Association of California School Administrators, California Association of Joint Powers Authorities, California Association of School Business Officials, California School Boards Association, Schools Excess Liability Fund, and Schools Insurance Authorities write:
As drafted, AB 218 exposes local public schools and others, to claims of abuse going back 40 years ago and longer. It will be impossible for employers to effectively defend against these claims when evidence is likely gone, witnesses have moved or passed away, and there has been a turnover of staff. With these barriers, schools will be unable to adequately respond to these claims. This failure will result in diversion of funding intended to educate students and serve communities to financing increased legal costs, whether or not the claim is valid. This is particularly troubling when considering that AB 218 would permit the recovery of treble damages, creating a windfall of public funds for trial attorneys as they take 40 percent of any award provided.
AB 218 will create new liability that will be funded in large part by public dollars that would otherwise go directly to funding education, as many public entities including school districts, cities, counties and other special districts use the joint powers authority mechanism to manage their liability and other risk related obligations in a non-profit, public entity risk pool. These public entity risk pools are not insurance companies with large capital reserves. Instead, they are funded by the revenues of their local government members. This arrangement enables local government entities to band together to create sufficient economies of scale to effectively “self-insure” for these obligations. The benefits to local governments include better local control over their risk exposures, and efficiencies that enable a greater portion of local government dollars to be devoted to important local programs.
If AB 218 is not amended, there will be an immediate fiscal impact on our organizations due to the need to assess and fund risk for older, potentially large exposures. Public entities are already finding that liability coverage is drastically more expensive and difficult to obtain. In fact, our members are facing significantly increased rates, hard caps, exclusions, settlement inflation, lower limits of coverage, and stricter underwriting processes. The liability and related cost pressures could leave our public school students, education partners, local governments, and the risk pools they are members of, without coverage and exposed to the direct cost of these claims.
They request that the bill be amended to eliminate the treble damages provision, eliminate the revival period, and limit liability for third parties. They also request amendments to create and fund procedures to prevent future abuse.
Northern California Regional Liability Excess Fund, Southern California Regional Liability Excess Fund, and Statewide Association of Community Colleges also oppose the bill unless amended as requested above and, in addition, by also retaining the existing limitation on exemption from the Government Tort Claims Act for pre-January 1, 2009 cases.
Similarly, the Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers of California also oppose the bill unless amended to eliminate the treble damages provision, eliminate the revival period, and limit liability for third parties, writing:
From the standpoint of an insurer, the changes proposed by AB 218 make it virtually impossible to insure this risk. Reopening of the statute of limitations a second time for cases 40 years old or older signals to the industry there is really no statute of limitations in California. . . .
Together the changes to current law proposed by AB 218 all but ensures insurance companies will no longer be able to provide this type of coverage to public and private institutions in California ranging from daycare facilities; schools, both public and private; children’s hospitals; and various non-profit organizations serving the youth.
The Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers of California raise particular objection to the application of treble damages retroactively, when it is too late to “deter bad conduct” and will “merely [] line the pockets of the trial bar.”
Obviously, the flip side of the burden of the cost of these claims on schools, churches, and athletic programs that protected sexual abusers of children is the lifetime damage done to those children. Additionally, it should be noted that the elimination of the statute of limitations and the revival of actions against perpetrators or third parties only assures that claims can be heard on their merits. Any other applicable defense would not be affected, and plaintiffs would still have to prove all the elements of their case.
The California Association of Private Schools (CAPS), comprised primarily of religious school, opposes the bill unless it is amended to make state agencies subject to its provisions: “Absent accompanying amendment of the Tort Claims Act (California Government Code Sections 810-996.6) in such a manner as to make state entities subject to AB 218’s provisions, this measure would permit a victim to advance a claim against Stanford University, or the University of Southern California, but would prohibit such action were the defendant in question U.C. Berkeley, or UCLA.” CAPS is correct that the bill does not extend the timeframe for actions against state entities, but it does so against all local entities, including schools – the opponent’s public equivalent. It is unclear if such a change would in any way impact these opponents or actually change their position on the bill.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter (NASW), writes that current law “imposes restrictive limits on the survivors of sexual assault and does not provide an effective deterrent or sufficient remedy against those who covered up sexual assaults, allowing for more children to be victimized.” NASW supports the bill expansion of access to justice for “victims of childhood sexual assault by removing the current time limits placed on victims, while increasing the amount of damages a victim may recover from those who sought to cover up the abuse. We urge you to help victims of childhood sexual assault hold their abusers accountable for their despicable past acts.”
Consumer Attorneys of California adds:
According to the U.S. Department of Justice, nine out of ten child sexual abuse victims are abused by someone close to them, and may be hesitant to report them. Many initially feel it is their fault or they will not be believed. For others it may take years, or even decades, to come to terms with what happened and to tell others about it.
According to a 1983 UCLA Medical Center report, the five most common reactions of children to sexual assault can be classified as the “child sexual abuse accommodation syndrome.” The five categories of reaction are: secrecy; helplessness; entrapment and accommodation; delayed, unconvincing disclosure; and, retraction. And older children are often “groomed,” and led to believe they are in love with their abuser. There is shame, denial, emotional problems . . . .
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: California Civil Liberties Advocacy (CCLA) opposes the bill outright because “lifting the statutes of limitations in any matter will negatively impact civil defendants because the availability and reliability of evidence diminishes over time.” In particular, CCLA is concerned that there could be false allegations of sexual assault that will be difficult to defend against. Finally, CCLA notes that “extending the statute of limitations in civil suits is [] more in the interests of the plaintiffs’ lawyer industry than that of the abuse survivors, in which the negative effects will be felt in the decades to come.”
Prior Related Legislation: AB 3120 (Gonzalez, 2018) is nearly identical to this bill. It passed the Legislature, but was vetoed by the Governor.
SB 1053 (Beall, Chap. 153, Stats. 2018) specifically exempted childhood sexual abuse claims from procedural hurdles enacted by local public entities under the Government Tort Claims Act.
SB 926 (Beall, Chap. 921, Stats. 2014) extended the statute of limitations for felony child sex crimes until the victim is 40 years old.
SB 924 (Beall, 2014) would have extended the statute of limitations for civil childhood sexual abuse until age 40 and would have exempted those claims brought against a local public entity from the Government Tort Claims Act. That bill was vetoed by the Governor.
SB 131 (Beall, 2013) would have made prior extensions of the statute of limitations for childhood sexual abuse retroactive and would have revived certain claims for a year. That bill was vetoed by the Governor.
AB 1628 (Beall, 2012) would have extended the statute of limitations in civil cases involving child sex abuse to 35 years of age, prohibited confidential settlements, and imposed new duties on private entities. This bill died in the Senate Appropriations Committee.
SB 640 (Simitian, Chap. 383, Stats. 2008) provided that child sex abuse claims arising out of conduct on or after January 1, 2009 are not subject to the Government Tort Claims Act, which requires that a claim against a public entity be presented within 6 months of its accrual.
SB 1779 (Burton and Escutia, Chap. 149, Stats. 2002) provided that claims against a third party do not lapse when the plaintiff turned 26, but only if specified requirements are met. It also revived certain expired claims for one year.
SB 674 (Ortiz, Chap. 120, Stats. 1999) made the then-current statutes of limitations for childhood sexual abuse cases against third parties retroactive.
AB 1651 (Ortiz, Chap. 1021, Stats. 1998) extended the statute of limitations in actions against third parties. However, any action against a third party had to be commenced before the plaintiff’s 26th birthday.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Victim Policy Institute (sponsor)
California Police Chiefs Association
California Protective Parents Association
California State PTA
Consumer Attorneys of California
Crime Victims United of California
Joyful Heart Foundation
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Stop Educator Sexual Abuse, Misconduct & Exploitation (S.E.S.A.M.E.)
Opposition (unless amended)
Association of California School Administrators
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Association of Private School Organizations
California Association of School Business Officials
California School Boards Association
Independent Insurance Agents and Brokers of California
Northern California Regional Liability Excess Fund
Schools Excess Liability Fund
Schools Insurance Authorities
Southern California Regional Liability Excess Fund
Statewide Association of Community Colleges
Opposition
California Civil Liberties Advocacy
Analysis Prepared by: Leora Gershenzon / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):