AB 51: Employment discrimination: enforcement.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-10-10
Existing law imposes various restrictions on employers with respect to contracts and applications for employment. A violation of those restrictions is a misdemeanor.
Existing law creates the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, which is under the direction of the Labor Commissioner, and generally commits to the commissioner the authority and responsibility for the enforcement of employment laws.
This bill would prohibit a person from, as a condition of employment, continued employment, the receipt of any employment-related benefit, or as a condition of entering into a contractual agreement, prohibiting an applicant for employment, employee, or independent contractor from disclosing to any person an instance of sexual harassment that the employee or independent contractor suffers, witnesses, or discovers in the workplace or in the performance of the contract, or otherwise opposing any lawful practice, or from exercising any right or obligation or participating in any investigation or proceeding with respect to unlawful harassment or discrimination. The bill would also prohibit an employer from requiring any applicant for employment or any employee to waive any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of any provision of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) or other specific statutes governing employment, as a condition of employment, continued employment, the receipt of any employment-related benefit, or as a condition of entering into a contractual agreement. The bill would also prohibit an employer from threatening, retaliating or discriminating against, or terminating any applicant for employment or any employee because of the refusal to consent to the waiver of any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of specific statutes governing employment. The bill would establish a specific exemption from those prohibitions. Because a violation of these prohibitions would be a crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
FEHA makes specified employment and housing practices unlawful and provides procedures for enforcement by the Department of Fair Employment and Housing. FEHA authorizes a person alleging a violation of specified provisions of the act relating to employment discrimination to submit a verified complaint to the Department of Fair Employment and Housing, and requires the department to take actions to investigate and conciliate that complaint. FEHA authorizes the department to bring a civil action on behalf of the person who submitted the complaint upon the failure to eliminate an unlawful practice under these provisions. FEHA requires the department to issue a right-to-sue notice to a person who submitted the complaint if certain conditions occur, and FEHA requires a person who has been issued a right-to-sue notice to bring an action within one year from when the department issued that notice.
This bill would additionally make violations of the prohibitions described above, relating to sexual harassment and waivers, unlawful employment practices under FEHA.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
(a)The Legislature finds and declares that it is the policy of this state to ensure that all persons have the full benefit of the rights, forums, and procedures established in the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (Part 2.8 (commencing with Section 12900) of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) and the Labor Code.
(b)It is the purpose of this act to ensure that individuals are not retaliated against for refusing to consent to the waiver of those rights and procedures and to ensure that any contract relating to those rights and procedures be entered into as a matter of voluntary consent, not coercion.
SEC. 2.Section 12953 is added to the Government Code, to read:12953.It is an unlawful employment practice for an employer to violate Section 432.4 or 432.6 of the Labor Code.
SEC. 3.Section 432.4 is added to the Labor Code, to read:432.4.(a)A person shall not, as a condition of employment, continued employment, the receipt of any employment-related benefit, or as a condition of entering into a contractual agreement, prohibit any applicant for employment, employee, or independent contractor from disclosing to any person an instance of sexual harassment that the employee or independent contractor suffers, witnesses, or discovers in the workplace or in the performance of the contract, or otherwise opposing any unlawful practice, or from exercising any right or obligation or participating in any investigation or proceeding with respect to unlawful harassment or discrimination.
(b)This section applies to contracts for employment entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2020.
SEC. 4.Section 432.6 is added to the Labor Code, to read:432.6.(a)A person shall not, as a condition of employment, continued employment, the receipt of any employment-related benefit, or as a condition of entering into a contractual agreement, require any applicant for employment or any employee to waive any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of any provision of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (Part 2.8 (commencing with Section 12900) of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) or this code, including the right to file and pursue a civil action or a complaint with, or otherwise notify, any state agency, other public prosecutor, law enforcement agency, or any court or other governmental entity of any alleged violation.
(b)An employer shall not threaten, retaliate or discriminate against, or terminate any applicant for employment or any employee because of the refusal to consent to the waiver of any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act or this code, including the right to file and pursue a civil action or a complaint with, or otherwise notify, any state agency, other public prosecutor, law enforcement agency, or any court or other governmental entity of any alleged violation.
(c)For purposes of this section, an agreement that requires an employee to opt out of a waiver or take any affirmative action in order to preserve their rights is deemed a condition of employment.
(d)In addition to injunctive relief and any other remedies available, a court may award a prevailing plaintiff enforcing his or her rights under this section reasonable attorneys fees.
(e)This section does not apply to a person registered with a self-regulatory organization as defined by the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (15 U.S.C. Sec. 78c) or regulations adopted under that act pertaining to any requirement of a self-regulatory organization that a person arbitrate disputes that arise between the person and his or her employer or any other person as specified by the rules of the self-regulatory organization.
(f)Nothing in this section shall be construed to provide a basis on which to challenge the validity, enforceability, or conscionability of any contract or provision therein, once lawfully executed. Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to restrict or expand other legal grounds upon which the validity, enforceability, or conscionability of a contract or provision therein may be challenged, even once executed.
(g)This section applies to contracts for employment entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2020.
(h)The provisions of this section are severable. If any provision of this section or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Oct 10, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 711, Statutes of 2019. |
| Oct 10, 2019 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 24, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | In Assembly. Ordered to Engrossing and Enrolling. |
| Sep 5, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (August 30). |
| Aug 12, 2019 | In committee: Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 1.) (July 9). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 19, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (June 19). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 29, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on L., P.E. & R. and JUD. |
| May 23, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 22, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 20, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 16, 2019 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 13. Noes 5.) (May 16). |
| Apr 10, 2019 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Mar 27, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 26, 2019 | Read second time and amended. |
| Mar 25, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 3.) (March 19). |
| Mar 7, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 5. Noes 1.) (March 6). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jan 17, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on L. & E. and JUD. |
| Dec 4, 2018 | From printer. May be heard in committee January 3. |
| Dec 3, 2018 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 5, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB51 Gonzalez By Jackson | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 12, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 9, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 19, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Labor, Public Employment and Retirement |
Passed |
|
| May 22, 2019 | AB 51 Gonzalez Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 19, 2019 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Mar 6, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 51 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 51
Amended: 3/26/19 in Assembly
SENATE LABOR, PUB. EMP. & RET. COMMITTEE: 4-1, 6/19/19
AYES: Hill, Jackson, Mitchell, Pan
NOES: Morrell
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-1, 7/9/19
AYES: Jackson, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Borgeas
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 8/30/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Durazo, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 47-20, 5/22/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Employment discrimination: enforcement
SOURCE: California Labor Federation
Consumer Attorneys of California
DIGEST:
This bill prohibits requiring applicants for employment or employees to waive their right to a judicial forum as a condition of employment or continued employment.
Existing law:
- Prohibits setting aside or contravening a broad category of labor rights, which includes the minimum wage, timely payment of wages, wage stubs, and overtime pay, through a written or oral contract. (Labor Code §§ 219, 1197.1)
- Prohibits an employer from:
- Requiring, as a condition of employment, that an employee refrain from disclosing information about the employer’s working conditions.
- Requiring an employee to sign a waiver or other document that purports to deny the employee the right to disclose information about the employer’s working conditions.
- Discharging, formally disciplining, or otherwise discriminating against an employee who discloses information about the employer’s working conditions.
(Labor Code § 232.5)
- Provides that it is an unlawful employment practice to discriminate, refuse to hire, or employ any person on the basis of race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status. (Government Code §12940)
- Authorizes a court, if it finds as a matter of law that the contract or any clause of the contract was unconscionable at the time it was made, to refuse to enforce the contract, or it may enforce the remainder of the contract without the unconscionable clause, or it may so limit the application of any unconscionable clause as to avoid any unconscionable result. (Civil Code §1670.5)
- Establishes the California Arbitration Act, which provides that agreements to arbitrate shall be valid, irrevocable, and enforceable, except on such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract. (Code of Civil Procedure §§1280-1294.4)
- Provides, pursuant to the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA), that agreements to arbitrate shall be valid, irrevocable, and enforceable, except on such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract. (9 U.S.C. Sec. 2.)
This bill:
- Finds and declares that it is the policy of the state to ensure that all persons have the full benefit of the rights, forums, and procedures established in the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) and the Labor Code.
- Declares that the purpose of this bill is to ensure that individuals are not retaliated against for refusing to consent to waive their rights and the procedures under FEHA and the Labor Code as well as to ensure that any contract relating to those rights and procedures be executed as a matter of voluntary consent.
- Prohibits an employer from requiring any applicant for employment or prospective employment, or any employee to waive any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of any provision of FEHA or the Labor Code, as a condition of employment, continued employment, or the receipt of any employment-related benefit.
- Provides that an employer shall not threaten, retaliate, or discriminate against, or terminate any applicant for employment or prospective employment or any employee because of the refusal to consent to the waiver of any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of FEHA or the Labor Code.
- Provides that an employee may seek injunctive relief to enforce the provisions of this bill. This bill would provide that its terms do not apply to specified self-regulatory organizations, as defined by the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
- Provides that nothing in this bill is intended to invalidate a written arbitration agreement that is otherwise enforceable under the FAA, and also that this bill does not apply to postdispute settlement agreements or negotiated severance agreements.
- Provides that this bill only applies to contracts for employment entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2020.
Comments
- Need for this bill? The author states the following:
“Forced arbitration is among the most harmful practices that have enabled widespread abuse to go undetected for decades. Workers are forced to sign away their rights in order to get hired. When they seek to report violations, they are denied the ability to go to court or a state agency for help. Instead they are trapped in the employer’s handpicked arbitration system.
…
“Arbitration is a highly effective dispute resolution method when both parties chose it freely. It is far less successful when the more powerful party forces the other to accept the terms. Unfortunately, forced arbitration has increased dramatically in recent years. In 2012, the number of workers bound by forced arbitration agreements was 16 percent. That figure rose to 43 percent in 2014. A new study by Economic Policy Institute found that more than 55 percent of all workers in the private sector today are bound by forced arbitration agreements. That figure goes up to 65 percent when looking at employees of large companies.
“The real impact of forced arbitration is not alternative dispute resolution, but claim suppression. A February 2018 report by Cynthia Estlund at New York University School of law, titled “The Black Hole of Mandatory Arbitration,” concludes that the vast majority of employment disputes subject to mandatory arbitration agreements “simply evaporate before they are ever filed.
…
“The Supreme Court has never ruled that the FAA applies in the absence of a valid agreement. AB 51 regulates employer behavior prior to an agreement being reached. Further, understanding the Courts’ hostile precedence toward policies that outright ban or invalidate arbitration agreements, AB 51 does neither. Both pre-dispute and post dispute agreements remain allowable and the bill takes no steps to invalidate any arbitration agreement that would otherwise be enforceable under the FAA. The steps help ensure this bill falls outside the purview of the FAA.”
- Arbitration and the Challenge of Extrajudicial Justice
Arbitration is a dispute resolution process where, instead of using the court system, disputing parties select an impartial arbiter to hear the facts of the case and develop a binding solution for the dispute. Unlike the court system, arbitration can be flexible, allowing both sides to decide rules of evidence and pursue a more informal process. This can both lower dispute resolution costs and speed up the resolution timeline.
Arbitration is most commonly used in commercial disputes. In these cases, two independent businesses attempt to resolve a dispute as equals. Presumably, both businesses are well-positioned to arbitrate the dispute, and both businesses may frequently utilize arbitration to resolve contractual disputes. In these cases, arbitration may greatly assist in quickly resolving a contractual issue that might be complex, involve sensitive competitive issues, or the like.
Concerns about arbitration generally pop up around a growing arena in the use of arbitration: labor law disputes. In these cases, workers are required to sign arbitration agreements as a condition of employment, and then required to arbitrate disputes around labor law. According to the Economic Policy Institute (EPI), only 2% of workers were covered by an arbitration agreement. After some arbitration-friendly U.S. Supreme Court decisions in the early 2000s, this number grew dramatically. Today, according to EPI, 67.4% of all California employers mandate arbitration of employment disputes.
For the employer, many of the benefits of arbitration remain. For the worker, however, similar benefits are difficult to see. Unlike a business in a commercial dispute, the worker is unlikely to have experience with an arbitration process. The worker would lack an attorney to assist with his or her case. The worker would likely not have a social network to draw from to suggest a different arbiter. If discovery was limited, the worker may not be able to fully pursue his or her case.
And then there’s the potential conflict of interest: if an arbiter secured a significant proportion of his or her income from arbitrating disputes from an employer or group of employers, the arbiter might not be truly impartial. Moreover, as the worker is not going to be utilizing the services of an arbiter or securing arbitration agreements in his or her normal course of business, this would be a one-sided conflict of interest. Taken together, the issues discussed above raise the specter of mandatory labor law arbitration serving employer-funded extrajudicial system that undermines California’s labor law protections and places the aggrieved worker at a fundamental and inherent disadvantage.
- AB 51 and Constitutional Preemption
However, the Legislature is limited in the restrictions that it can place on arbitration. This is because the FAA has been construed by the Supreme Court to limit the applicability of state law (Southland Corp. v. Keating, (1984) 465 U.S. 1; AT&T Mobility v. Concepcion, (2011) 563 U.S. 333; Epic Systems Corp. v. Lewis, (2018) 584 U.S. ____ ).
However, AB 51 seeks to sidestep the preemption issue by not prohibiting, discouraging, or restricting the use of arbitration agreements by employers or workers, but rather requiring applying prior case law that stressed the need for consent in arbitration agreements. For the sake of clarity, this analysis will excerpt a discussion on the issue of federal preemption and state action from the Senate Judiciary Committee’s analysis on AB 3080 of 2018, which was very similar to this bill:
This structure arguably succeeds in steering clear of preemption under the Federal Arbitration Act. Under this theory, the bill does not prohibit, restrict, or discourage anyone from entering into a mandatory arbitration agreement, if they wish to consent to do so freely and voluntarily. It does not interfere with enforcement of arbitration agreements. In fact, once a mandatory arbitration agreement has been signed, this bill has nothing more to say about the situation. All the bill does is say that an employee cannot be forced to sign an arbitration agreement, and if the employee elects not to, the employee cannot be retaliated against. Finally, the bill does not just apply to arbitration agreements: its edicts would apply equally to waiver of any dispute resolution forum or procedure. In short, nothing in the bill discriminates against arbitration and nothing in the bill interferes with the enforcement of an agreement to arbitrate once executed.
…
[T]he opponents of this bill are correct that there is a lengthy and extensive history favoring enforcement of arbitration agreements, striking down state laws that discriminate against arbitration agreements, and voiding state laws that interfere with the enforcement of arbitration agreements once executed. With that in mind, there is no doubt that, if enacted, this bill would be challenged in court and there is a chance, under the current composition of the U.S. Supreme Court, that it would be found preempted. At the same time, there is a reasoned case to be made that the author and sponsor of this bill have carefully crafted a statute that responds to preemption doctrine by taking the U.S. Supreme Court’s admonition seriously: that consent is the touchstone of arbitration agreements. (Stolt-Nielsen S. A. v. Animal Feeds Int’l Corp. (2010) 559 U.S. 662, 681.) In this way, this bill would ensure employees may choose to waive their rights in order to get or keep a job, but they are never forced to.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, the Department of Industrial Relations indicates that it would incur a first-year cost of $427,000, and $404,000 annually thereafter, to implement the provisions of this bill (Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund).
California Labor Federation (co-source)
Consumer Attorneys of California (co-source)
ACLU California
AFSCME, AFL-CIO
American Association of University Women
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees
California NOW
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Faculty Association
California IATSE Council
California Nurses Association
California Professional Firefighters
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
California School Employees Association
California Teachers Association
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
California Voices for Progress
Courage Campaign
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Engineers and Scientists of California, Local 20
Entertainment Union Coalition
Equal Rights Advocates
Fund Her
Inlandboatmen’s Union of the Pacific
Los Angeles Alliance for a New Economy
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Lutheran Office of Public Policy
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
National Employment Law Project
Professional and Technical Engineers, Local 21
Screen Actors Guild - American Federation of Television and Radio Artists
San Diego County Court Employees Association
SEIU California
SMUD Employees
State Building & Construction Trades Council
Stronger California Advocates Network
United Auto Workers
United Auto Workers, Local 2865
United Auto Workers, Local 5810
United Food and Commercial Workers, Western States Council
United Public Employees
United Steelworkers District 12
UNITE-HERE
University Professional and Technical Employees, CWA Local 9119
Utility Workers of America
Voices for Progress
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Writers Guild of America West
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/29/19)
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
California Ambulance Association
California Apartment Association
California Association for Health Services at Home
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Beer and Beverage Distributors
California Building Industry Association
California Cable and Telecommunications Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Dispute Resolution Council
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Hospital Association
California Hotel and Lodging Association
California League of Food Producers
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California New Car Dealers Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California State Council of Shrm (Society for Human Resource Management)
California Trucking Association
Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse
Civil Justice Association of California
CSAC – Excess Insurance Authority
El Centro Chamber of Commerce
El Dorado County Chamber of Commerce
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Family Winemakers of California
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Fresno Chamber of Commerce
Garden Grove Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
Job Creators for Workplace Fairness
Kern County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
League of California Cities
National Federation of Independent Business
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Palm Desert Area Chamber of Commerce
Pleasanton Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Redondo Beach Chamber of Commerce
Roseville Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce
South Bay Association of Chambers of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
Western Carwash Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The California Labor Federation, writing in support, argues the following:
“Recent revelations of widespread sexual harassment have focused policy makers on the need to ensure that victims have access to justice and that violators are held accountable. They have also demonstrated the harm that comes from keeping these cases confidential and exposing countless other women to the same treatment.
…
“Under forced arbitration, these same rules apply to workers who seek to remedy pay equity violations, outright discrimination, and all types of wage theft. They lose access to the state agency charged with worker protection, where staff can help with language or cultural barriers and can protect them from retaliation. They lose access to court, effectively denying them access to counsel who can assist a low-wage worker in navigating a case against a wealthier and more sophisticated employer. They are on their own in an arbitration process they did not chose and do not understand, often against a large corporation that established the rules and paid for the arbitrator.
“Arbitration can be a highly effective dispute resolution method when both parties chose it freely. It is far less successful when the more powerful party forces the other to accept the terms. Unfortunately, the use of forced arbitration has increased dramatically in recent years. In 2012, the number of workers bound by forced arbitration agreements was 16%. That figure rose to 43% in 2014. A new study from the Economic Policy Institute found that today over 55% of all workers in the private sector are bound by forced arbitration agreements.
…
“The disappearance of workplace claims cannot be an acceptable outcome. California has passed a plethora of worker laws and protections and those protections must be enforced to be meaningful. No employer should be able to escape accountability by forcing workers to waive rights.
“AB 51 (Gonzalez) does not prohibit employers from using arbitration agreements to resolve workplace disputes. Instead, it merely requires that employees chose to sign such agreements without the threat of job loss or other retaliatory actions. AB 51 does not seek to render such agreements unenforceable, it simply provides for injunctive relief when employers are forcing workers to waive rights in order to apply, maintain, or keep a job.
“AB 51 (Gonzalez) follows the dictates of the Supreme Court that arbitration under the FAA is a matter of ‘consent and not coercion’ and protects employees from retaliation for not consenting to waive their rights. It is consistent with the bi-partisan legislation introduced in Congress, and moving in numerous other states, that would ensure victims of sexual assault and harassment are not forced into arbitration agreements.
“While the FAA has been interpreted to preempt many state regulations of arbitration, it does not apply here. This bill does not seek to invalidate any arbitration agreement that would be valid under the FAA. It does not make any category of claim arbitrable. It does not shift the burden of proof onto the party seeking to validate the agreement. Instead, it simply ensures that workplace arbitration agreements are entered into willingly and not through coercion.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: A coalition of employer groups, including the California Chamber of Commerce, writing in opposition, argues the following:
“The Federal Arbitration Act prohibits any state statute that seeks to interfere with, limit, or discriminate against arbitration. See Southland Corp. v. Keating, 465 U.S. 1, 10, 104 S.Ct. 852, 79 L.Ed.2d 1 (1984); AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion, 562 U.S. 333 (2011)…. Accordingly, AB 51 will undoubtedly be challenged as preempted under the FAA, creating more litigation, but not actually providing any benefit to employees as intended.
“AB 51 interferes with and will basically eliminate settlement agreements as it prohibits an employer from requiring an applicant or employee to waive any right, forum, or procedure, or the right to pursue any claim in court under FEHA or the Labor Code as a condition of any ‘contractual agreement.’ A settlement agreement in the most basic terms is a contractual agreement to provide something of value to a party who agrees to dismiss a pending complaint in court and/or waive their rights to pursue any claim the individual may have, including those under the Labor Code or FEHA. Precluding the informal resolution of civil claims would eliminate the opportunity for early and expedited resolution of employee claims, overwhelm California’s judiciary system by forcing all claims to be tried by a jury or judge, and thereby create significant delays that would harm individuals who have suffered a wrong.
…
“By banning arbitration and settlement agreements, the only option left for employees to resolve many labor and employment claims is litigation…. Accordingly, eliminating settlement agreements and arbitration as proposed by AB 51 will flood the already crowded dockets of the civil courts with new lawsuits that will significantly delay resolution of all civil claims.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 47-20, 5/22/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooper, Eggman, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Holden, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Santiago, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cunningham, Dahle, Diep, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Irwin, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Melendez, Obernolte, Quirk-Silva, Salas, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cervantes, Cooley, Daly, Frazier, Eduardo Garcia, Gray, Grayson, Mayes, O'Donnell, Patterson, Ramos, Blanca Rubio, Smith
Prepared by: Gideon L. Baum / L., P.E. & R. / (916) 651-1556
9/1/19 10:13:53
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
AB 51 (Gonzalez) - Employment discrimination: enforcement
Version: March 26, 2019 | Policy Vote: L., P.E. & R. 4 - 1, JUD. 7 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: August 12, 2019 | Consultant: Robert Ingenito |
Bill Summary:
AB 51 would prohibit requiring applicants for employment or employees to waive their right to a judicial forum as a condition of employment or continued employment.
Fiscal Impact:
The Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) indicates that it would incur a first-year cost of $427,000, and $404,000 annually thereafter, to implement the provisions of the bill (Labor Enforcement and Compliance Fund).
Background:
Non-disparagement agreements are typically signed as part of a legal settlement, and take place after a violation has occurred and damages have been paid to a victim. However, recent publicized cases of sexual harassment in the workplace have drawn attention to the practice of requiring employees to sign nondisclosure agreements as a condition of employment.
Arbitration is a dispute resolution process where, instead of using the court system, disputing parties select an impartial arbiter to hear the facts of the case and develop a binding solution. Unlike the court system, arbitration can be flexible, allowing both sides to decide rules of evidence and pursue a more informal process. This can both lower dispute resolution costs and speed up the resolution timeline.
Arbitration is most commonly used with respect to commercial disputes. In these cases, two independent businesses attempt to resolve a dispute as equals. Presumably, both businesses are well-positioned to arbitrate the dispute, and both businesses may frequently utilize arbitration to resolve contractual disputes. In these cases, arbitration may greatly assist in quickly resolving a contractual issue that might be complex and involve sensitive competitive issues.
With respect to labor law disputes, arbitration has become much more widely used in recent years. In these cases, workers are required to sign arbitration agreements as a condition of employment, and then required to arbitrate disputes around labor law. In these instances, employees waive their right to sue or to file a complaint. The Economic Policy Institute notes that about twenty years ago, about two percent of workers were covered by an arbitration agreement. Today, about two-thirds of all California employers mandate arbitration of employment disputes.
Proposed Law:
This bill would, among other things, do the following:
- Prohibit an employer from requiring any applicant for employment or prospective employment, or any employee to waive any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of any provision of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act or the Labor Code, as a condition of employment, continued employment, or the receipt of any employment-related benefit.
- Provide that an employer shall not threaten, retaliate, or discriminate against, or terminate any applicant for employment or prospective employment or any employee because of the refusal to consent to the waiver of any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) or the Labor Code.
- Provide that an employee may seek injunctive relief to enforce the provisions of this bill. This bill would provide that its terms do not apply to specified self-regulatory organizations, as defined by the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
- Provide that the bill only would apply to contracts for employment entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2020.
Related Legislation:
- AB 3080 (Gonzalez, 2018) was very similar to this bill, and was vetoed by the Governor.
- AB 2617 (Weber, Chapter 910, Statutes of 2014) provides that any waiver of any legal right, under the Ralph and Tom Bane Civil Rights Acts that is required as a condition of entering into a contract for goods or services shall be deemed involuntary, unconscionable, against public policy, and unenforceable. This law was later found to be preempted by the Federal Arbitration Act in Saheli v. White Memorial Medical Center (2018) 21 Cal.App.5th 308.)
Staff Comments:
DIR indicates that it does not have historical data to reliably estimate the potential fiscal impact of the bill. However, the department anticipates that it would result in it receiving additional retaliation claims, requiring additional staff resources of $427,000 in the first year, and $404,000 annually thereafter.
Any local government costs resulting from the mandate in this measure are not state-reimbursable because the mandate only involves the definition of a crime or the penalty for conviction of a crime.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 51 (Author:Gonzalez)
Version: March 26, 2019
Hearing Date: July 9, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: TSG
SUBJECT
Employment discrimination: enforcement
DIGEST
This bill prohibits California employers from forcing employees to waive, as a condition of employment, continued employment, or the receipt of any employment-related benefit, their right to have future legal disputes over incidents of harassment, discrimination, civil rights-related retaliation, or Labor Code violations heard in the dispute resolution forum of their choice. The bill also protects California workers from retaliation if they refuse to agree to such a waiver.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Forcing workers, as a condition of hire, to agree to mandatory, binding arbitration of any future legal disputes is a common legal tactic that employers use to limit their legal exposure, reduce their litigation costs, and keep incidents of workplace abuse, including sexual harassment, hidden from the public. Since current federal case law strongly favors enforcement of mandatory arbitration agreements, California cannot outlaw or discriminate against such agreements. Instead, this bill operates to ensure that California workers who enter into an agreement waiving their right to any particular forum for dispute resolution do so freely, and that workers who opt not to sign such agreements are not subjected to retaliation as a result.
The bill is sponsored by the California Labor Federation and Consumer Attorneys of California. Support is from organized labor and workers’ rights advocates. Opposition comes from employers and business trade associations, who contend that mandatory arbitration is a useful mechanism for dispute resolution and that the bill conflicts with federal law. The bill passed out of the Senate Labor, Public Employment and Retirement Committee by a vote of 4-1.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing federal law:
- Provides, pursuant to the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA), that agreements to arbitrate shall be valid, irrevocable, and enforceable, except on such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract. (9 U.S.C. § 2.)
Existing state law:
- Prohibits setting aside or contravening a broad category of labor rights, which includes the minimum wage, timely payment of wages, wage stubs, and overtime pay, through a written or oral contract. (Lab. Code §§ 219, 1197.1.)
- Prohibits an employer from:
- requiring, as a condition of employment, that an employee refrain from disclosing information about the employer’s working conditions;
- requiring an employee to sign a waiver or other document that purports to deny the employee the right to disclose information about the employer’s working conditions; or
- discharging, formally disciplining, or otherwise discriminating against an employee who discloses information about the employer’s working conditions. (Lab. Code § 232.5.)
- Provides that no statutory right provided for general occupations under Sections 200 through 244 of the Labor Code, can in any way be contravened or set aside by a private agreement, whether written, oral, or implied. (Lab. Code § 219.)
- Regulates the formation of contracts and provides that anyone may waive the advantage of a law intended solely for that person’s own benefit but specifies that a law established for a public reason cannot be waived by a private agreement. (Civ. Code § 3513.)
- Authorizes a court, if it finds as a matter of law that the contract or any clause of the contract was unconscionable at the time it was made, to refuse to enforce the contract, or it may enforce the remainder of the contract without the unconscionable clause, or it may so limit the application of any unconscionable clause as to avoid any unconscionable result. (Civ. Code § 1670.5(a).)
- Establishes the California Arbitration Act which provides that agreements to arbitrate shall be valid, irrevocable, and enforceable, except on such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract. (Code Civ. Proc. § 1280 et seq.)
This bill:
- Finds and declares that it is the policy of the state to ensure that all persons have the full benefit of the rights, forums, and procedures established in the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) and the Labor Code.
- Declares that the purpose of the bill is to ensure that individuals are not retaliated against for refusing to consent to waive their rights and the procedures under FEHA and the Labor Code as well as to ensure that any contract relating to those rights and procedures be executed as a matter of voluntary consent.
- Prohibits an employer from requiring any applicant for employment or prospective employment, or any employee to waive any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of any provision of FEHA or the Labor Code, as a condition of employment, continued employment, or the receipt of any employment-related benefit.
- Provides that an employer shall not threaten, retaliate, or discriminate against, or terminate any applicant for employment or prospective employment or any employee because of the refusal to consent to the waiver of any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of FEHA or the Labor Code.
- Provides that an employee may seek injunctive relief to enforce the provisions of this bill.
- Exempts specified self-regulatory organizations, as defined by the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
- Provides that nothing in the bill is intended to invalidate a written arbitration agreement that is otherwise enforceable under the FAA, and also that the bill does not apply to post-dispute settlement agreements or negotiated severance agreements.
- Provides that the bill only applies to contracts for employment entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2020.
COMMENTS
- Examples of the problem the bill is intended to address
Alternative dispute resolution mechanisms, arbitration among them, can provide companies and their workers with relatively inexpensive, informal options for resolving workplace claims. As countless stories from the #MeToo movement illustrate, however, when used in the context of allegations about sexual harassment and similar workplace abuses, these same legal tools can also be used as powerful weapons to hide misdeeds from the public and foster an environment of impunity.
A recent, prominent case illustrates this dynamic well. Gretchen Carlson is a well-known cable television journalist. For many years, she was a Fox News anchor. Upon joining that company, and long before she had any reason to believe she would have any problems working there, Carlson signed an employment contract agreeing to resolve any employment conflicts she might have with the company through one particular form of dispute resolution only: confidential arbitration. In July 2016, after years working at Fox News, Carlson sued the network and its CEO, Roger Ailes, for sexual harassment. Fox reportedly tried to force Carlson to arbitrate the matter behind closed doors in accordance with her contract. For reasons that are unclear, Carlson managed to get around the clause that would have prevented her from filing her case in a more public forum. Once Carlson’s allegations became public, other victims came forward, ultimately leading to Ailes’ ouster from Fox News. Had Carlson not been able to find a way around the forced arbitration clause in her employment contract, however, it is not clear that Ailes’ serial sexual harassment would ever have come to light.
This is just one widely reported story. Aside from the involvement of a wealthy celebrity, however, it is not unique. Forced arbitration agreements are now common in the American workplace and their impact may help to explain why sexual harassment remains a widespread and seemingly intractable problem. Whatever other purposes this contractual tool may serve, the #MeToo movement has made it clear that forced arbitration agreements can and do enable serial perpetrators to evade public detection and escape accountability.
2. Ensuring that employees genuinely consent to mandatory arbitration and all other waivers of their right to seek justice through the available forum of their choosing
This bill addresses negotiations between employers and employees, almost always at the time of hire, over what forums and procedures will be available to them in the event that the employee later alleges a violation of either the employee’s workplace civil rights or the Labor Code. Specifically, the bill prohibits employers from conditioning employment, continued employment, or the receipt of any employment-related benefit on waiving any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of those laws, including the right to file and pursue a civil action or a complaint with, or otherwise notify, any state agency, other public prosecutor, law enforcement agency, or any court or other governmental entity of any alleged violation. In addition, the bill prohibits employers from retaliating against an applicant or employee for refusing to sign such a waiver.
The proponents of this bill hope that these provisions will reduce the number of California workers who are forced into arbitration against their will. To the degree that hope is realized, however, it will not be because the bill discourages or discriminates against arbitration. Rather, the idea is that, given a genuine choice in the matter, many workers will opt not to bind themselves to arbitration in advance.
- Dispute resolution forums ordinarily available to California workers for Labor Code or FEHA violations
The provisions of this bill relating to waiver of rights and forums for resolution of claims would apply to two types of disputes: those arising over allegations of violations of the workplace rights enshrined in the Labor Code, and those arising over allegations of workplace discrimination, harassment, and retaliation as prohibited by FEHA.
Absent a contractual agreement waiving these rights, California workers are entitled to file and pursue most Labor Code violation claims through administrative proceedings operated by the California Labor Commissioner. Alternatively, almost all allegations of Labor Code violations can be brought directly in civil courts.
Similarly, absent a contractual agreement waiving this right, California workers can file and pursue claims of workplace discrimination, harassment, or related retaliation through an administrative investigation and enforcement process run by the California Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH). Unlike Labor Code violations, allegations fair employment law violations must be filed with DFEH before a lawsuit can be brought in civil court. This is sometimes referred to as the requirement to exhaust administrative remedies though, in practice, workers can, and many do, request “right to sue” letters from DFEH almost immediately after filing their complaint. Such a letter allows the worker to proceed to file in civil court.
In civil court, workers generally have the option of bringing their case as a class action lawsuit, if they can show the requisite commonalities between what has happened to them and what has happened to others.
When an employer forces a worker to sign a contract waiving access to these legal forums, all of these potential mechanisms for redress – the courts, class actions, and administrative procedures – may be partially or fully foreclosed to the worker, most often in favor of just one alternative dispute resolution method: arbitration.
- The pros and cons of arbitration
Arbitration is an alternative method of resolving disputes in which two parties present their individual sides of a complaint to an arbitrator or panel of arbitrators. The arbitrator decides the rules, weighs the facts and arguments of both parties, and then decides the winner of the dispute. Arbitration may be voluntary or mandatory.
In voluntary arbitration, both sides in the dispute agree to submit their disagreement to arbitration after the dispute arises and they have had an opportunity to investigate their best options for resolving their claim. In mandatory arbitration, the employer and the employee agree to submit any dispute that may arise to binding arbitration in advance, usually as a condition of hire. The employee is required to waive their right to sue, to participate in a class action lawsuit, or to appeal. The arbitrator’s decision is binding, and the results are not public.
In recent years, there have been frequent discussions as to the merits and benefits of mandatory private arbitration as an alternative forum to the civil justice system. Supporters of mandatory arbitration generally assert that it is a more efficient and less costly manner of resolving legal disputes because the parties are able to limit discovery, set their own rules for presenting evidence, schedule proceedings at their own convenience, and select the third party who will decide their cases. However, critics of private arbitration contend that it is an unregulated industry, which is often costly and unreceptive to workers.
Concerns about arbitration are compounded by the fact that there are very few regulations or legal standards imposed on arbitrators or their decisions. Regardless of the level or type of mistake, or even misconduct, by the arbitrator, the grounds on which a court will allow judicial review of an arbitrator’s decision are extremely narrow. (See Moncharsh v. Heily & Blase (1992) 3 Cal.4th 1 (holding that a court is not permitted to vacate an arbitration award based on errors of law by the arbitrator, except for certain narrow exceptions).)
Since Moncharsh, the controversy regarding the merits and flaws of mandatory private arbitration has raged unabated in the Legislature, with at least one or more measures each session attempting to address concerns about the impact of mandatory arbitration. Meanwhile, more and more employers are requiring workers to sign employment documents, before, during, or upon termination of employment, that contain inconspicuous terms, including mandatory arbitration clauses.[1] Current law invalidates waivers of employment rights under Labor Code statutes that are enacted as a matter of public policy, but there is no express limitation on the ability to waive claims for penalties, remedies, forum, or procedures under the Labor Code.
- Does the bill ban arbitration?
It is a mischaracterization of AB 51 to say that it prohibits arbitration agreements. The bill clearly allows employers and employees to enter into mandatory arbitration agreements; it just sets ground rules to ensure that such an agreement is truly voluntary. If AB 51 leads to a reduction in the prevalence of mandatory arbitration agreements, it will not be because this bill discriminates against or otherwise discourages arbitration; it will be because, given a genuinely free choice, fewer employees are willing to bind themselves, in advance, to arbitration as their exclusive path to a possible remedy in the event that a workplace dispute arises.
- Preemption analysis
Under the Supremacy Clause of the U.S. Constitution, federal laws and regulations preempt state laws and policies where they conflict. (U.S. Const., art. VI, cl. 2.) The FAA governs law in the area of arbitration agreements. (9 U.S.C. 1 et seq.)
In March of 2016, this Committee held informational hearings regarding arbitration. A link to the background paper for that hearing can be found on this Committee’s website. It includes an in-depth discussion of federal preemption as it relates to arbitration and includes discussion of all of the major court decisions in this area up to that time. To that comprehensive list and discussion, it suffices just to add that more recent U.S. Supreme Court decisions continue the trend of strong judicial backing for the plenary enforcement of arbitration agreements.
Just last year, for example, the U.S. Supreme Court ruled in a suite of cases that arbitration agreements which have the effect of preventing class actions must nonetheless be enforced, even though class actions might be considered “concerted action” protected under the National Labor Relations Act. (Epic Systems Corp. v. Lewis (2018) 584 U.S. ___ [138 S.Ct. 1612]; decided together with Ernst & Young LLP et al. v. Morris et al. (No. 16–300); and National Labor Relations Board v. Murphy Oil USA, Inc., et al. (No. 16–307).) The holding in that case is only partially related to what this bill would propose, in that this bill proposes to enact a state law and is not specifically related to class action waivers as such. Still, the Epic Systems trio of decisions is a further indication that the judiciary remains strongly supportive of arbitration.
The opponents of this bill are thus correct that there is a lengthy and extensive history favoring enforcement of arbitration agreements, striking down state laws that discriminate against arbitration agreements, and voiding state laws that interfere with the enforcement of arbitration agreements once executed. With that in mind, there is little doubt that, if enacted, this bill would be challenged in court and there is some chance, under the current composition of the U.S. Supreme Court, that it would be found preempted. At the same time, there is a reasoned case to be made that the author and sponsor of this bill have crafted a statute that does not conflict with the FAA and thereby avoids preemption.
Understanding the author and sponsor’s argument begins with a review of the three key aspects of the law surrounding arbitration and preemption. First, the federal courts have ruled that the FAA was intended to promote arbitration. (Epic Systems Corp., supra (May 21, 2018, No. 16–285) 584 U.S. ___ at p. 5.) Second, state laws or rules that interfere with the enforcement of arbitration agreements are preempted, except on such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract. (9 U.S.C. Sec. 2; AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion (2011) 563 U.S. 333, 339.) Third, state laws that explicitly or covertly discriminate against arbitration agreements as compared to other contracts are also preempted. (Epic Systems Corp., supra (May 21, 2018, No. 16–285) 584 U.S. ___ at p. 7.)
According to its proponents, this bill successfully navigates around these rules. Under their theory, the bill does not prohibit, restrict, or discourage anyone from entering into a mandatory arbitration agreement, if they wish to consent to do so freely and voluntarily. The bill does not interfere with enforcement of arbitration agreements. In fact, the proponents point out, once a mandatory arbitration agreement has been signed, this bill has nothing more to say about the situation. All the bill does is say that an employee cannot be forced to sign an arbitration agreement, and if the employee elects not to, the employee cannot be retaliated against. Finally, according to the proponents, the bill does not discriminate against arbitration because its edicts apply equally to waiver of any dispute resolution forum or procedure. AB 51 takes seriously the courts’ repeated admonition that consent is the touchstone of arbitration agreements. (Stolt-Nielsen S. A. v. Animal Feeds Int’l Corp. (2010) 559 U.S. 662, 681.) In this way, this bill would ensure employees may choose to waive their rights in order to get or keep a job, but they are never forced to.
- Distinctions between this bill and prior legislation deemed or thought to be preempted
- Comparison to AB 2167 (Weber, Ch. 910, Stats. 2014) and AB 465 (Hernandez, 2016)
AB 51 shares many features, but is nonetheless distinct from two prior bills on the same general topic: AB 2617 (Weber, Ch. 910, Stats. 2014) and AB 465 (Hernández, 2016). AB 2617 established that Californians could not be required to waive their rights under the Ralph and Bane Civil Rights Acts, while AB 465 proposed a similar law for rights under the Labor Code. Then-Governor Brown vetoed AB 465 based on his desire to see how a preemption challenge to AB 2617 played out in the courts. As it turned out, AB 2617 was eventually struck down by a California appellate court on preemption grounds. (Saheli v. White Memorial Medical Center (2018) 21 Cal.App.5th 308.)
There are key differences between AB 51 and these two prior bills. Both of the prior bills contained provisions making it so that any waiver of rights “shall be deemed involuntary, unconscionable, against public policy, and unenforceable.” Both bills also put the burden of proving voluntary consent, in any dispute to enforce the provisions of a waiver, onto the party seeking to enforce the waiver.
These provisions were at the heart of the Saheli court’s decision that AB 2617 was preempted by the FAA:
The Ralph Act and Bane Act, as amended by Assembly Bill 2617, unquestionably discriminate against arbitration by placing special restrictions on waivers of judicial forums and procedures in connection with claims brought under those acts. In effect, sections 51.7 and 52.1 deem an agreement to arbitrate such claims unenforceable unless the party seeking to enforce it proves (1) the other party knowingly and voluntarily agreed to arbitration, and (2) the arbitration agreement was not made a condition of a contract for goods or services or of providing or receiving goods or services. (§§ 51.7, subd. (b)(5), 52.1, subd. (l).) For the reasons we discuss, we conclude these restrictions are preempted by the FAA. (Saheli, supra, 21 Cal.App.5th 308 at 323.)
AB 51 contains neither of these provisions. AB 51 does not deem waivers involuntary, unconscionable, against public policy, or unenforceable, and AB 51 makes no alterations to the burden of proof in a dispute over enforceability of a waiver. Thus, AB 51 does not appear to contain any of the terms upon which the Saheli court found AB 2617 preempted.
- Comparison to AB 3080 (Gonzalez, 2018)
AB 51 has much more in common with AB 3080 (Gonzalez, 2018). In fact, in many respects, the two bills are identical. Governor Brown vetoed AB 3080. After reciting the history of the two prior bills just described, Brown went on to question the legal reasoning behind AB 3080, writing:
This bill is based on a theory that the Act only governs the enforcement and not the initial formation of arbitration agreements and therefore California is free to prevent mandatory arbitration agreements from being formed at the outset. The Supreme Court has made it explicit this approach is impermissible. In 2017 Justice Kagan, an appointee of President Obama, writing on behalf of a near-unanimous Supreme Court, clearly rejected the assertion that the Federal Arbitration Act has no application to contract formation issues:
“By its terms, . . . the Act cares not only about the “enforce[ment]” of arbitration agreements, but also about their initial “valid[ity]”-that is, about what it takes to enter into them. Or said otherwise: A rule selectively finding arbitration contracts invalid because improperly formed fares no better under the Act than a rule selectively refusing to enforce those agreements once properly made. Precedent confirms that point.” Kindred Nursing Centers Ltd. Partnership v. Clark, 137 S. Ct. 1421, 1428 (2017).
Since this bill plainly violates federal law, I cannot sign this measure.
In response to Governor Brown’s argument, the proponents of this bill point out that AB 51 would not selectively invalidate arbitration contracts because improperly formed. AB 51 would not invalidate any contract once formed (though workers could still challenge the formation of a mandatory arbitration agreement on other grounds, as they can now). AB 51 simply gives the worker the option of whether or not to form the contract in the first place. Moreover, the proponents urge, nothing in AB 51 selectively calls out arbitration contracts as such; the bill applies to contracts requiring waiver of any forum.
8. Arguments in support of the bill
According to the author:
Forced arbitration agreements have become a common tool of employers who seek to prevent employees from filing a lawsuit or, in instances of discrimination or harassment, filing a complaint with the state’s Labor Commissioner or Department of Fair Employment and Housing. Instead, employees who sign these agreements are forced to go through the arbitration process with any workplace violation complaint. A 2015 report by the California Labor Federation described this process as “a rigged system…in which an employer pays for its own arbitrators who then hear disputes in private…this process rarely results in justice for an exploited worker.” Workers often do not even realize what they are signing when they enter into these contracts as a condition of employment. In forced arbitration, any settlements often require the victim to refrain from discussing the case publicly. In a workplace with a culture of discrimination and harassment, these arbitration agreements are particularly toxic, enabling the abusive behavior to continue unchecked.
As sponsor of the bill, the Consumer Attorneys of California write:
The real impact of forced arbitration is not dispute resolution, but claim suppression. The disappearance of workplace claims cannot be an acceptable outcome.
A February 2018 article in the North Carolina Law Review by Cynthia Estlund at New York University School of Law entitled “The Black Hole of Mandatory Arbitration,” concludes that the vast majority of employment disputes subject to mandatory arbitration agreements “simply evaporate before they are ever filed.”
California has passed a plethora of worker laws and protections and those protections must be enforced to be meaningful. No employer should be able to escape accountability by forcing workers to waive their rights.
As sponsor of the bill, the California Labor Federation writes:
Forced arbitration of sexual harassment claims epitomizes all of the most harmful practices that have enabled widespread abuse to go undetected for decades. Workers are forced to sign away their rights in order to get hired. When they seek to report violations, they are denied the ability to go to court or file a claim with the Labor Commissioner. Instead they are trapped in the employer’s handpicked arbitration system. The system is secret and confidential, protecting abusers from any public scrutiny. State agencies have no knowledge of repeat violations or arbitration decisions and there is no public record.
9. Arguments in opposition to the bill
In opposition to the bill, the California Chamber of Commerce and 55 co-signatories writes:
[AB 51]: (1) essentially prohibits arbitration of labor and employment claims as a condition of employment and is likely preempted by federal law; (2) exposes employers to criminal liability regarding arbitration agreements; and, (3) adds another private right of action onto employers under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA). AB 51 will create more litigation, significant delays in the resolution of disputes, and higher costs for employers and employees. […]
[T]he United States Supreme Court and California Supreme Court have issued numerous opinions over the past decade that have consistently held any state statute that interferes with, discriminates against, or limits the use of arbitration is preempted. […] Accordingly, AB 51 will undoubtedly be challenged as preempted under the FAA, creating more litigation, but not actually providing any benefit to employees as intended. […]
Given the placement of the provisions of AB 51 in Chapter 2, Article 3 of the Labor Code, it is subject to Labor Code Section 433, which states that any violation of Article 3 is a misdemeanor. Accordingly, not only will an employer face civil liability for any violation of the various provisions of AB 51 […] but also an employer can face criminal charges. […]
By banning arbitration, the only option left for employees to resolve many labor and employment claims is litigation. […] Accordingly, eliminating arbitration as proposed by AB 51 will flood the already crowded dockets of the civil courts with new lawsuits that will significantly delay effective resolution of all civil claims.
In further opposition to the bill, the California State Council of the Society for Human Resources Management writes:
[A]lthough AB 51 states it is intended to combat “sexual harassment,” as drafted it actually applies to ALL violations of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), as well as the Labor Code. While much the of the testimony on the bill during the legislative process was focused on high profile sexual harassment incidents, it is important to note that the bill would significantly affect the entire body of workplace disputes, including wage and hour claims, discrimination, etc. In this regard, this bill goes way beyond its stated purpose, and would unnecessarily preclude the more efficient arbitration resolution mechanism even where the bill’s author has not identified any public policy reason to do so. [Emphasis in the original.]
SUPPORT
California Labor Federation (sponsor)
Consumer Attorneys of California (sponsor)
9 to 5
Alliance of Californians for Community Empowerment
American Association of University Women of California
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees
California Asset Building Coalition
California Childcare Resource & Referral Network
California Domestic Worker Coalition
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Faculty Association
California Latinas for Reproductive Justice
California Partnership
California Professional Firefighters
California School Employees Association
California Teachers Association
California Women’s Law Center
California Work & Family Coalition
Career Ladders Project
The Center for Popular Democracy
Child Care Law Center
Drug Policy Alliance
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
End Hunger!
Equal Rights Advocates
Fund Her
Legal Aid at Work
Mujeres Unidas y Activas
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Opportunity Institute
Organization of Sacramento Municipal Utility District Employees
Parent Voices
Raising California Together
San Diego County Court Employees Association
Service Employees International Union, California
Stronger California Advocates Network
Tradeswomen, Inc.
United Food and Commercial Workers, Western States Council
Voices for Progress
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Women’s Foundation of California
Writers Guild of America West
OPPOSITION
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
Building Owners and Managers Association
California Ambulance Association
California Apartment Association
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Beer and Beverage Distributors
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Cable and Telecommunications Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Dispute Resolution Council
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Hospital Association
California Hotel and Lodging Association
California League of Food Producers
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California New Car Dealers Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California State Association of Counties – Excess Insurance Authority
California State Council of the Society for Human Resources Management
California Trucking Association
Charter Communications
Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse
Civil Justice Association of California
Commercial Real Estate Development Association
El Centro Chamber of Commerce
El Dorado County Joint Chambers Commission
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Family Winemakers of California
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Fresno Chamber of Commerce
Garden Grove Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
Job Creators for Workplace Fairness
Kern County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
League of California Cities
National Federation of Independent Business
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Palm Desert Area Chamber of Commerce
Pleasanton Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Redondo Beach Chamber of Commerce
Roseville Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce
South Bay Association of Chambers of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
United Chamber Advocacy Network
Western Carwash Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: AB 749 (Stone, 2019) voids no-rehire provisions in any settlement agreement resolving a workplace dispute in which an official allegation of a legal violation has been filed. AB 749 is pending consideration on the Senate Floor.
Prior Legislation:
SB 1300 (Jackson, Ch. 955, Stats. 2018) made it an unlawful employment practice for an employer, in exchange for a raise or bonus, or as a condition of employment or continued employment, to require an employee to sign a non-disparagement agreement or a release of a claim or right under FEHA, except in the context of a negotiated settlement agreement.
AB 3080 (Gonzalez, 2018) was very similar to this bill. In his message vetoing AB 3080, then-Governor Brown wrote:
In my veto message of a similar bill in 2015, I referred to recent court decisions that invalidated state policies which unduly impeded arbitration. I also wanted to see how future United States Supreme Court decisions developed before endorsing a broad ban on mandatory arbitration agreements.
The direction from the Supreme Court since my earlier veto has been clear - states must follow the Federal Arbitration Act and the Supreme Court’s interpretation of the Act. DIRECTV, Inc. v. Imburgia, 136 S. Ct. 463, 468 (2015).
This bill is based on a theory that the Act only governs the enforcement and not the initial formation of arbitration agreements and therefore California is free to prevent mandatory arbitration agreements from being formed at the outset. The Supreme Court has made it explicit this approach is impermissible. In 2017 Justice Kagan, an appointee of President Obama, writing on behalf of a near-unanimous Supreme Court, clearly rejected the assertion that the Federal Arbitration Act has no application to contract formation issues:
“By its terms, . . . the Act cares not only about the “enforce[ment]” of arbitration agreements, but also about their initial “valid[ity]”-that is, about what it takes to enter into them. Or said otherwise: A rule selectively finding arbitration contracts invalid because improperly formed fares no better under the Act than a rule selectively refusing to enforce those agreements once properly made. Precedent confirms that point.” Kindred Nursing Centers Ltd. Partnership v. Clark, 137 S. Ct. 1421, 1428 (2017).
Since this bill plainly violates federal law, I cannot sign this measure.
AB 3109 (Stone, Ch. 949, Stats. 2018) rendered unenforceable, prospectively, any provision in a contract or settlement agreement that prevents a person from testifying, in response to a subpoena or official request, about alleged criminal conduct or sexual harassment in a judicial, administrative, or legislative proceeding.
AB 465 (Hernández, 2016) would have prohibited any person from requiring another person, with some exemptions, to agree, as a condition of employment, to the waiver of any legal right, penalty, forum, or procedure for any employment law violations. The bill would also have prohibited threats, retaliation, or discrimination for refusing to agree to such a waiver. Finally, it would have required that any waiver of these rights be knowing, voluntary, in writing, and expressly not made as a condition of employment. Governor Brown vetoed AB 465, writing: “Recent decisions by both the California and United States Supreme Courts have found that state policies which unduly impede arbitration are invalid. Indeed, the U.S. Supreme Court is currently considering two more cases arising out of California courts involving preemption of state arbitration policies under the FAA. Before enacting a law as broad as this, and one that will surely result in years of costly litigation and legal uncertainty, I would prefer to see the outcome of those cases.”
AB 2617 (Weber, Ch. 910, Stats. 2014) imposed specified, prospective restrictions on the contractual waivers of rights under the Ralph Civil Rights Act and the Tom Bane Civil Rights Act. A California Court of Appeals struck down AB 2617 on preemption grounds. (Saheli v. White Memorial Medical Center (2018) 21 Cal.App.5th 308.)
SB 1407 (Jackson, 2014) would have provided that waiver or release of claims under FEHA is contrary to public policy and unenforceable, unless the waiver or release of claims is knowing and voluntary and is clearly stated as part of a negotiated settlement agreement of the claims. SB 1407 died on the Assembly Floor Inactive File.
AB 1715 (Committee on Judiciary, 2003) would have provided that any waiver of rights or procedures under FEHA must be knowing, voluntary, and not made as a condition of employment or continued employment. AB 1715 also would have invalidated arbitration agreements between employers and employees that relate to employment practices covered by FEHA that are required as a condition of employment or continued employment. Governor Davis vetoed AB 1715, expressing concern about adversely affecting the ability of California business to resolve disputes in a cost-effective manner.
SB 1538 (Burton, 2002) would have prohibited employee waivers of their FEHA rights. AB 1538 was vetoed by Governor Davis who stated that, in those difficult economic times, he was not prepared to place additional burdens on employers by preventing them from requiring alternative dispute resolution of employment claims.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Labor, Public Employment and Retirement Committee (Ayes 4, Noes 1)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 47, Noes 20)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 13, Noes 5)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 3)
Assembly Labor and Employment Committee (Ayes 5, Noes 1)
**************
Colvin, The Growing Use of Mandatory Arbitration (Apr. 6, 2018) Economic Policy Institute https://www.epi.org/publication/the-growing-use-of-mandatory-arbitration-access-to-the-courts-is-now-barred-for-more-than-60-million-american-workers/ (as of Jun. 25, 2019). ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR, PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Senator Jerry Hill, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 51 Hearing Date: June 19, 2019
Author: | Gonzalez | ||
Version: | March 26, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Gideon L. Baum | ||
SUBJECT: Employment discrimination: enforcement
KEY ISSUE
Should the Legislature prohibit requiring applicants for employment or employees to waive their right to a judicial forum as a condition of employment or continued employment?
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Prohibits setting aside or contravening a broad category of labor rights, which includes the minimum wage, timely payment of wages, wage stubs, and overtime pay, through a written or oral contract. (Labor Code §§ 219, 1197.1.)
- Prohibits an employer from:
- Requiring, as a condition of employment, that an employee refrain from disclosing information about the employer’s working conditions.
- Requiring an employee to sign a waiver or other document that purports to deny the employee the right to disclose information about the employer’s working conditions.
- Discharging, formally disciplining, or otherwise discriminating against an employee who discloses information about the employer’s working conditions.
(Labor Code § 232.5.)
- Provides that it is an unlawful employment practice to discriminate, refuse to hire, or employ any person on the basis of race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status. (Government Code §12940)
- Authorizes a court, if it finds as a matter of law that the contract or any clause of the contract was unconscionable at the time it was made, to refuse to enforce the contract, or it may enforce the remainder of the contract without the unconscionable clause, or it may so limit the application of any unconscionable clause as to avoid any unconscionable result. (Civil Code §1670.5)
- Establishes the California Arbitration Act, which provides that agreements to arbitrate shall be valid, irrevocable, and enforceable, except on such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract. (Code of Civil Procedure §§1280-1294.4)
- Provides, pursuant to the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA), that agreements to arbitrate shall be valid, irrevocable, and enforceable, except on such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract. (9 U.S.C. Sec. 2.)
This bill:
- Finds and declares that it is the policy of the state to ensure that all persons have the full benefit of the rights, forums, and procedures established in FEHA and the Labor Code.
- Declares that the purpose of the bill is to ensure that individuals are not retaliated against for refusing to consent to waive their rights and the procedures under FEHA and the Labor Code as well as to ensure that any contract relating to those rights and procedures be executed as a matter of voluntary consent.
- Prohibits an employer from requiring any applicant for employment or prospective employment, or any employee to waive any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of any provision of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act or the Labor Code, as a condition of employment, continued employment, or the receipt of any employment-related benefit.
- Provides that an employer shall not threaten, retaliate, or discriminate against, or terminate any applicant for employment or prospective employment or any employee because of the refusal to consent to the waiver of any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) or the Labor Code.
- Provides that an employee may seek injunctive relief to enforce the provisions of this bill. This bill would provide that its terms do not apply to specified self-regulatory organizations, as defined by the Securities Exchange Act of 1934.
- Provides that nothing in the bill is intended to invalidate a written arbitration agreement that is otherwise enforceable under the Federal Arbitration Act, and also that this bill does not apply to postdispute settlement agreements or negotiated severance agreements.
- Provides that the bill only applies to contracts for employment entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2020.
COMMENTS
1. Need for this bill?
The author states the following:
“Forced arbitration is among the most harmful practices that have enabled widespread abuse to go undetected for decades. Workers are forced to sign away their rights in order to get hired. When they seek to report violations, they are denied the ability to go to court or a state agency for help. Instead they are trapped in the employer’s handpicked arbitration system.
…
Arbitration is a highly effective dispute resolution method when both parties chose it freely. It is far less successful when the more powerful party forces the other to accept the terms. Unfortunately, forced arbitration has increased dramatically in recent years. In 2012, the number of workers bound by forced arbitration agreements was 16 percent. That figure rose to 43 percent in 2014. A new study by Economic Policy Institute found that more than 55 percent of all workers in the private sector today are bound by forced arbitration agreements. That figure goes up to 65 percent when looking at employees of large companies.
The real impact of forced arbitration is not alternative dispute resolution, but claim suppression. A February 2018 report by Cynthia Estlund at New York University School of law, titled “The Black Hole of Mandatory Arbitration,” concludes that the vast majority of employment disputes subject to mandatory arbitration agreements “simply evaporate before they are ever filed.”
…
The Supreme Court has never ruled that the FAA applies in the absence of a valid agreement. AB 51 regulates employer behavior prior to an agreement being reached. Further, understanding the Courts’ hostile precedence toward policies that outright ban or invalidate arbitration agreements, AB 51 does neither. Both pre-dispute and post dispute agreements remain allowable and the bill takes no steps to invalidate any arbitration agreement that would otherwise be enforceable under the FAA. The steps help ensure this bill falls outside the purview of the FAA.”
2. Arbitration and the Challenge of Extrajudicial Justice:
Arbitration is a dispute resolution process where, instead of using the court system, disputing parties select an impartial arbiter to hear the facts of the case and develop a binding solution for the dispute. Unlike the court system, arbitration can be flexible, allowing both sides to decide rules of evidence and pursue a more informal process. This can both lower dispute resolution costs and speed up the resolution timeline.
Arbitration is most commonly used in commercial disputes. In these cases, two independent businesses attempt to resolve a dispute as equals. Presumably, both businesses are well-positioned to arbitrate the dispute, and both businesses may frequently utilize arbitration to resolve contractual disputes. In these cases, arbitration may greatly assist in quickly resolving a contractual issue that might be complex, involve sensitive competitive issues, or the like.
Concerns about arbitration generally pop up around a growing arena in the use of arbitration: labor law disputes. In these cases, workers are required to sign arbitration agreements as a condition of employment, and then required to arbitrate disputes around labor law. According to the Economic Policy Institute (EPI), only 2% of workers were covered by an arbitration agreement. After some arbitration-friendly U.S. Supreme Court decisions in the early 2000s, this number grew dramatically. Today, according to EPI, 67.4% of all California employers mandate arbitration of employment disputes.
For the employer, many of the benefits of arbitration remain. For the worker, however, similar benefits are difficult to see. Unlike a business in a commercial dispute, the worker is unlikely to have experience with an arbitration process. The worker would lack an attorney to assist with his or her case. The worker would likely not have a social network to draw from to suggest a different arbiter. If discovery was limited, the worker may not be able to fully pursue his or her case.
And then there’s the potential conflict of interest: if an arbiter secured a significant proportion of his or her income from arbitrating disputes from an employer or group of employers, the arbiter might not be truly impartial. Moreover, as the worker is not going to be utilizing the services of an arbiter or securing arbitration agreements in his or her normal course of business, this would be a one-sided conflict of interest. Taken together, the issues discussed above raise the specter of mandatory labor law arbitration serving employer-funded extrajudicial system that undermines California’s labor law protections and places the aggrieved worker at a fundamental and inherent disadvantage.
3. AB 51 and Constitutional Preemption:
However, the Legislature is limited in the restrictions that it can place on arbitration. This is because the Federal Arbitration Act has been construed by the Supreme Court to limit the applicability of state law (Southland Corp. v. Keating, (1984) 465 U.S. 1; AT&T Mobility v. Concepcion, (2011) 563 U.S. 333; Epic Systems Corp. v. Lewis, (2018) 584 U.S. ____ ).
However, AB 51 seeks to sidestep the preemption issue by not prohibiting, discouraging, or restricting the use of arbitration agreements by employers or workers, but rather requiring applying prior case law that stressed the need for consent in arbitration agreements. For the sake of clarity, this analysis will excerpt a discussion on the issue of federal preemption and state action from the Senate Judiciary Committee’s analysis on AB 3080 of 2018, which was very similar to this bill:
This structure arguably succeeds in steering clear of preemption under the Federal Arbitration Act. Under this theory, the bill does not prohibit, restrict, or discourage anyone from entering into a mandatory arbitration agreement, if they wish to consent to do so freely and voluntarily. It does not interfere with enforcement of arbitration agreements. In fact, once a mandatory arbitration agreement has been signed, this bill has nothing more to say about the situation. All the bill does is say that an employee cannot be forced to sign an arbitration agreement, and if the employee elects not to, the employee cannot be retaliated against. Finally, the bill does not just apply to arbitration agreements: its edicts would apply equally to waiver of any dispute resolution forum or procedure. In short, nothing in the bill discriminates against arbitration and nothing in the bill interferes with the enforcement of an agreement to arbitrate once executed.
…
[T]he opponents of this bill are correct that there is a lengthy and extensive history favoring enforcement of arbitration agreements, striking down state laws that discriminate against arbitration agreements, and voiding state laws that interfere with the enforcement of arbitration agreements once executed. With that in mind, there is no doubt that, if enacted, this bill would be challenged in court and there is a chance, under the current composition of the U.S. Supreme Court, that it would be found preempted. At the same time, there is a reasoned case to be made that the author and sponsor of this bill have carefully crafted a statute that responds to preemption doctrine by taking the U.S. Supreme Court’s admonition seriously: that consent is the touchstone of arbitration agreements. (Stolt-Nielsen S. A. v. Animal Feeds Int’l Corp. (2010) 559 U.S. 662, 681.) In this way, this bill would ensure employees may choose to waive their rights in order to get or keep a job, but they are never forced to.
3. Proponent Arguments:
The California Labor Federation, writing in support, argues the following:
“Recent revelations of widespread sexual harassment have focused policy makers on the need to ensure that victims have access to justice and that violators are held accountable. They have also demonstrated the harm that comes from keeping these cases confidential and exposing countless other women to the same treatment.
…
Under forced arbitration, these same rules apply to workers who seek to remedy pay equity violations, outright discrimination, and all types of wage theft. They lose access to the state agency charged with worker protection, where staff can help with language or cultural barriers and can protect them from retaliation. They lose access to court, effectively denying them access to counsel who can assist a low-wage worker in navigating a case against a wealthier and more sophisticated employer. They are on their own in an arbitration process they did not chose and do not understand, often against a large corporation that established the rules and paid for the arbitrator.
Arbitration can be a highly effective dispute resolution method when both parties chose it freely. It is far less successful when the more powerful party forces the other to accept the terms. Unfortunately, the use of forced arbitration has increased dramatically in recent years. In 2012, the number of workers bound by forced arbitration agreements was 16%. That figure rose to 43% in 2014. A new study from the Economic Policy Institute found that today over 55% of all workers in the private sector are bound by forced arbitration agreements.
…
The disappearance of workplace claims cannot be an acceptable outcome. California has passed a plethora of worker laws and protections and those protections must be enforced to be meaningful. No employer should be able to escape accountability by forcing workers to waive rights.
AB 51 (Gonzalez) does not prohibit employers from using arbitration agreements to resolve workplace disputes. Instead, it merely requires that employees chose to sign such agreements without the threat of job loss or other retaliatory actions. AB 51 does not seek to render such agreements unenforceable, it simply provides for injunctive relief when employers are forcing workers to waive rights in order to apply, maintain, or keep a job.
AB 51 (Gonzalez) follows the dictates of the Supreme Court that arbitration under the FAA is a matter of “consent and not coercion” and protects employees from retaliation for not consenting to waive their rights. It is consistent with the bi-partisan legislation introduced in Congress, and moving in numerous other states, that would ensure victims of sexual assault and harassment are not forced into arbitration agreements.
While the FAA has been interpreted to preempt many state regulations of arbitration, it does not apply here. This bill does not seek to invalidate any arbitration agreement that would be valid under the FAA. It does not make any category of claim arbitrable. It does not shift the burden of proof onto the party seeking to validate the agreement. Instead, it simply ensures that workplace arbitration agreements are entered into willingly and not through coercion.
4. Opponent Arguments:
A coalition of employer groups, including the California Chamber of Commerce, writing in opposition, argues the following:
“The Federal Arbitration Act prohibits any state statute that seeks to interfere with, limit, or discriminate against arbitration. See Southland Corp. v. Keating, 465 U.S. 1, 10, 104 S.Ct. 852, 79 L.Ed.2d 1 (1984); AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion, 562 U.S. 333 (2011)…. Accordingly, AB 51 will undoubtedly be challenged as preempted under the FAA, creating more litigation, but not actually providing any benefit to employees as intended.
AB 51 interferes with and will basically eliminate settlement agreements as it prohibits an employer from requiring an applicant or employee to waive any right, forum, or procedure, or the right to pursue any claim in court under FEHA or the Labor Code as a condition of any “contractual agreement.” A settlement agreement in the most basic terms is a contractual agreement to provide something of value to a party who agrees to dismiss a pending complaint in court and/or waive their rights to pursue any claim the individual may have, including those under the Labor Code or FEHA. Precluding the informal resolution of civil claims would eliminate the opportunity for early and expedited resolution of employee claims, overwhelm California’s judiciary system by forcing all claims to be tried by a jury or judge, and thereby create significant delays that would harm individuals who have suffered a wrong.
…
By banning arbitration and settlement agreements, the only option left for employees to resolve many labor and employment claims is litigation…. Accordingly, eliminating settlement agreements and arbitration as proposed by AB 51 will flood the already crowded dockets of the civil courts with new lawsuits that will significantly delay resolution of all civil claims.”
5. Double Referral:
This bill has been double referred and, if approved by this committee, it will be sent to the Senate Judiciary Committee for a hearing.
6. Prior Legislation:
AB 3080 (Gonzalez) of 2018 was very similar to this bill. AB 3080 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
AB 2617 (Weber), Chapter 910, Statutes of 2014, provides that any waiver of any legal right, under the Ralph and Tom Bane Civil Rights Acts that is required as a condition of entering into a contract for goods or services shall be deemed involuntary, unconscionable, against public policy, and unenforceable. This law was later found to be preempted by the Federal Arbitration Act in Saheli v. White Memorial Medical Center (2018) 21 Cal.App.5th 308.)
SUPPORT
California Labor Federation (Co-Sponsor)
Consumer Attorneys of California (Co-Sponsor)
ACLU California
AFSCME, AFL-CIO
American Association of University Women
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees
CA NOW
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Employment Lawyers Association
California Faculty Association
California IATSE Council
California Nurses Association
California Professional Firefighters
California Rural Legal Assistance Foundation
California School Employees Association
California Teachers Association
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
California Voices for Progress
Courage Campaign
Ella Baker Center For Human Rights
Engineers and Scientists of CA, Local 20
Entertainment Union Coalition
Equal Rights Advocates
Fund Her
Inlandboatmen’s Union of the Pacific
LAANE
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Lutheran Office of Public Policy
National Association Of Social Workers, California Chapter
National Employment Law Project
Professional and Technical Engineers, Local 21
SAG-AFTRA
San Diego County Court Employees Association
SEIU California
SMUD Employees
State Building & Construction Trades Council
Stronger California Advocates Network
United Auto Workers
United Auto Workers, Local 2865
United Auto Workers, Local 5810
United Food And Commercial Workers, Western States Council
United Public Employees
United Steelworkers District 12
UNITE-HERE
University Professional and Technical Employees, CWA Local 9119
Utility Workers of America
Voices for Progress
Western Center on Law and Poverty
Writers Guild of America West
OPPOSITION
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
California Ambulance Association
California Apartment Association
California Association for Health Services at Home
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Attractions and Parks Association
California Beer and Beverage Distributors
California Building Industry Association
California Cable and Telecommunications Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Dispute Resolution Council
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Hospital Association
California Hotel and Lodging Association
California League of Food Producers
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California New Car Dealers Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California State Council of Shrm (Calshrm)
California Trucking Association
Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse
Civil Justice Association of California
CSAC – Excess Insurance Authority
El Centro Chamber of Commerce
El Dorado County Chamber Of Commerce
Elk Grove Chamber Of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Family Winemakers of California
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Fresno Chamber of Commerce
Garden Grove Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
Job Creators for Workplace Fairness
Kern County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
League of California Cities
National Federation of Independent Business
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Palm Desert Area Chamber of Commerce
Pleasanton Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Redondo Beach Chamber of Commerce
Roseville Chamber Of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce
South Bay Association of Chambers of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
Western Carwash Association
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 51
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Amended Ver:March 26, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits an employer from requiring an employee to waive any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of any provision of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) or the Labor Code as a condition of employment, continued employment or the receipt of any employment-related benefit. This bill also prohibits an employer from threatening, retaliating, or discriminating against an employee for refusing to consent to such a waiver.
Major Provisions
- Prohibits an employer from requiring any applicant for employment or prospective employment, or any employee, to waive any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of any provision of FEHA or the Labor Code, as a condition of employment, continued employment, or the receipt of any employment-related benefit.
- Provides that an employer shall not threaten, retaliate, or discriminate against, or terminate any applicant for employment or any employee because of the refusal to consent to the waiver of any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of FEHA or the Labor Code.
- Provides that an employee may seek injunctive relief to enforce the provisions of this bill, and may be awarded reasonable attorney’s fees.
- Provides that this bill does not apply to specified self-regulatory organizations, as defined by the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 or regulations adopted under that act pertaining to any requirement of a self-regulatory organization that a person arbitrate disputes that arise between the person and his or her employer or any other person as specified by the rules of the self-regulatory organization.
- Provides that the bill only applies to contracts for employment entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2020.
- Provides that any violation of the provisions of the bill constitutes an unlawful employment practice pursuant to FEHA.
- Provides that nothing in the bill is intended to invalidate a written arbitration agreement that is otherwise enforceable under the Federal Arbitration Act of 1925.
- States that the bill does not apply to post-dispute settlement agreements or negotiated severance agreements.
COMMENTS:
The use of mandatory arbitration agreements in the employment context has garnered the attention of both lawmakers and the public. State legislatures and Congress have introduced legislation to curb the use of these agreements, recognizing the inherent power imbalance these contractual arrangements bring to the employee-employer relationship. Most recently, on February 28, 2019, Sen. Richard Blumenthal, (D-Conn.) and Rep. Hank Johnson, (D-Ga.) announced the introduction of the Forced Arbitration Injustice Repeal (FAIR) Act that would prevent forced arbitration before a dispute occurs, allowing employees or consumers to choose arbitration at their will.
According to the Author:
As stated by to the author, no provision of this bill prohibits the use of arbitration agreements or discriminates against these agreements, once executed. The bill seeks to ensure that employees voluntarily enter into these agreements.
Arguments in Support:
The California Labor Federation, a sponsor of the bill, highlights the many harms workers face when forced to sign arbitration agreements, particularly as victims of sexual harassment. According to the Federation, "forced arbitration of sexual harassment claims epitomizes all of the most harmful practices that have enabled widespread abuse to go undetected for decades. Workers are forced to sign away their rights in order to get hired. When they seek to report violations, they are denied the ability to go to court or file a claim with the Labor Commissioner. Instead, they are trapped in the employer’s handpicked arbitration system. The system is secret and confidential, protecting abusers from any public scrutiny. State agencies have no knowledge of repeat violations or arbitration decisions and there is no public record."
The Federation further argues that the use of forced arbitration is on the rise. They state, "In 2012, the number of workers bound by forced arbitration agreements was 16%. That figure rose to 43% in 2014. A new study from the Economic Policy Institute found that today over 55% of all workers in the private sector are bound by forced arbitration agreements."
Arguments in Opposition:
A coalition of employer organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, states that the bill "(1) essentially prohibits arbitration of labor and employment claims as a condition of employment and is likely preempted by federal law; (2) interferes with and prohibits settlement agreements for labor and employment claims; (3) exposes employers to criminal liability regarding arbitration agreements; and, (4) adds another private right of action onto employers under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA). AB 51 will create more litigation, significant delays in the resolution of disputes, and higher costs for employers and employees."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, an unknown cost to the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE). If there are 100 additional retaliation claims each year as a result of this bill, ongoing costs would be $430,000 special fund.
VOTES:
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 5-1-1
YES: Kalra, Carrillo, Gonzalez, Bonta, Luz Rivas
NO: Flora
ABS, ABST OR NV: Diep
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-3-0
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Gallagher, Kiley, Obernolte
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-5-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Diep, Fong, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: March 26, 2019
CONSULTANT: Megan Lane / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0000538
Date of Hearing: April 10, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 51
Author:(Gonzalez) – As Amended Ver:March 26, 2019
Policy Committee: | Labor and Employment | Vote: | 5 - 1 |
Judiciary | 9 - 3 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits, for contracts entered into or modified on or after January 1, 2020, an employer from requiring an employee to waive any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of any provision of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) or the Labor Code as a condition of employment, continued employment or the receipt of any employment-relate benefit. This bill also prohibits an employer from retaliating against an employee for refusing to consent to such a waiver.
FISCAL EFFECT:
An unknown cost to the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement (DLSE). If there are 100 additional retaliation claims each year as a result of this bill, ongoing costs would be $430,000 special fund.
COMMENTS:
- Forced arbitration. Forced arbitration occurs when a company requires, as a condition of employment, an employee to submit any dispute that may arise to binding arbitration. In these instances, the employee waives their right to sue or to file a complaint. According to data cited by supporters of AB 51, instances of forced arbitration is on the rise and currently more than 55% of private sector workers are bound by forced arbitration agreements.
- Purpose. According to supporters, AB 51 will protect workers by empowering them to choose arbitration freely and ending a practice that suppresses legitimate claims against employers. Writing in support of the bill, the California Labor Federation notes that recent revelations of widespread workplace sexual harassment speak to the need to ensure victims have access to justice.
- Recent amendments. AB 51 is a follow-up to AB 3080 (Gonzalez), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, which was vetoed by the governor. While both bills have similar goals, recent amendments to AB 51 differentiate it from last year’s effort in some key ways. First, unlike AB 3080, AB 51 does not explicitly apply to prohibitions against employees disclosing instances of workplace sexual harassment as a condition of employment. Second, amendments also clarify the bill’s provisions do not apply to post-dispute settlement agreements or negotiated severance agreements. Finally, AB 51 aims to more clearly clarify that its provisions do not apply to existing, valid arbitration agreements.
- Legislative response to the #MeToo movement. There are a number of bills introduced this year that follow up on efforts last year to improve workplace protections for workers in the wake of the #MeToo movement. In 2018, the governor signed legislation that expanded workplace sexual harassment prevention training requirements (SB 1343 (Mitchell), Chapter 956), restricted the practice of making sexual harassment claims and settlements confidential (SB 820 (Leyva), Chapter 953), and modified standards around the litigation of sexual harassment claims (SB 1300 (Jackson), Chapter 955).
In addition to the above bills signed into law, other bills in 2018 inspired by the #MeToo movement failed to move forward or were vetoed by the governor. Some of those proposals have returned this year, either in their original form or modified. These bills include:
AB 9 (Reyes) extends, from one year to three years, the filing period with the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH) for complaints of unlawful employment practices. AB 9 is a follow-up to AB 1870 (Reyes), of the 2017 Legislative Session, which was vetoed by the governor.
AB 51 (Gonzalez), as noted above, prohibits an employer from requiring an employee, as a condition of employment, to waive rights granted through the California Fair Employment Housing Act (FEHA) or the Labor Code, as specified. AB 51 is a follow-up to last year’s AB 3080, of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, which was vetoed by the governor. Also noted above, AB 51 does not include specific provisions around sexual harassment.
AB 171 (Gonzalez) prohibits an employer from discharging or in any manner discriminating or retaliating against an employee because of the employee’s status as a victim of sexual harassment. These provisions were part of AB 3081 (Gonzalez), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, which was vetoed by the governor.
AB 403 (Kalra) extends, from one year to three years, the filing period for claims with (DLSE). AB 403 is a follow-up to AB 2946 (Kalra), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, which failed passage on the Assembly floor.
AB 628 (Bonta) allows victims of sexual harassment to take time off from work and extends job-protected leave to immediate family members of victims. AB 628 is a follow-up to AB 2366 (Bonta), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, which was held on this committee’s Suspense File.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: March 19, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 51
Author:(Gonzalez) – As Introduced Ver:December 3, 2018
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Employment discrimination: enforcement
KEY ISSUE: SHOULD CONTRACTS THAT REQUIRE PROSPECTIVE EMPLOYEES OR CURRENT EMPLOYEES TO WAIVE ANY STATUTORY RIGHTS UNDER THE LABOR CODE OR FAIR EMPLOYMENT AND HOUSING ACT AS A CONDITION OF EMPLOYMENT, CONTINUED EMPLOYMENT, OR THE RECEIPT OF AN EMPLOYMENT-RELATED BENEFIT BE PROHIBITED?
SYNOPSIS
This bill seeks to protect employees from being forced to waive their rights under the Fair Employment and Housing Act or the California Labor Code as a condition of new or continued employment and associated benefits. This practice can be highly coercive, and the author contends that, currently, bargaining power is fundamentally skewed in favor of the employer. This bill is substantially similar to Assembly Bill 3080 (Gonzalez, 2018) that was vetoed by Governor Brown. Despite the enactment of several bills regarding sexual harassment and workplace rights in 2018, the author contends that more steps are necessary to protect workers, particularly low income workers. As proposed to be amended, this bill removes several provisions that were originally in AB 3080 that are no longer necessary because they are duplicative of other bills that were enacted in 2018, and clarifies that this bill will not preclude any fair and lawful settlement agreement.
This bill is sponsored by the California Labor Federation and the Consumer Attorneys of California, and has the support of a broad coalition of labor organizations and civil liberties groups who argue that the protections offered to employees in this bill are essential to safeguarding workers and ensuring that employees and employers can negotiate employment agreements on a level playing field. In opposition to this bill, a sizable group of employer-sided organizations, led by the California Chamber of Commerce, claim that this bill will cost jobs in California, potentially preclude settlements in employment cases, and is likely preempted by federal law. While the interaction between state and federal law in certain employment situations is subject to ongoing debate and litigation, the supporters contend that this bill focuses on an area of law that has yet to be settled, and that in the absence of clear federal preemption, the State of California should be free to act in order to protect employees from waiving their rights under the law and the ability to adjudicate employment- related claims in any venue provided by existing law. This bill previously passed the Assembly Labor and Employment Committee with a 5 –1 vote.
SUMMARY: Ensures that California workers cannot be forced to waive their rights, including venues for adjudicating disputes, under the California Labor Code or Fair Employment and Housing Act, as a condition of entering into or continuing employment or receiving an employment-related benefit. Specifically, this bill:
- Finds and declares that it is the policy of this state to ensure that all persons have the full benefit of the rights, forums, and procedures established in the California Fair Employment and Housing Act and Labor Code.
- Declares that the purpose of this act is to ensure that individuals are not retaliated against for refusing to consent to the waiver of the rights and procedures described in 1) and to ensure that any contract relating to those rights and procedures be entered into as a matter of voluntary consent, not coercion.
- Prohibits an employer from requiring any applicant for employment or prospective employment, or any employee, to waive any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of any provision of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act or the Labor Code, as a condition of employment, continued employment, or the receipt of any employment-related benefit.
- Provides that an employer shall not threaten, retaliate, or discriminate against, or terminate any applicant for employment or any employee because of the refusal to consent to the waiver of any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act or the Labor Code.
- Provides that for the purpose of the bill, an agreement that requires an employee to opt out of a waiver or take any affirmative action in order to preserve their rights is deemed a condition of employment.
- Provides that an employee may seek injunctive relief to enforce the provisions of this bill, and may be awarded reasonable attorneys fees.
- Provides that this bill does not apply to specified self-regulatory organizations, as defined by the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 or regulations adopted under that act pertaining to any requirement of a self-regulatory organization that a person arbitrate disputes that arise between the person and his or her employer or any other person as specified by the rules of the self-regulatory organization.
- Provides that the bill only applies to contracts for employment entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2020.
- Provides that any violation of the provisions of the bill constitutes an unlawful employment practice pursuant to the California Fair Employment and Housing Act.
- Provides that nothing in the bill is intended to invalidate a written arbitration agreement that is otherwise enforceable under the Federal Arbitration Act of 1925.
- States that the bill does not apply to post-dispute settlement agreements or negotiated severance agreements.
- Provides that the provisions of the bill are severable.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement, within the Department of Industrial Relations, may enforce the provisions of the Labor Code and all labor laws of the state, the enforcement of which is not specifically vested in any other officer, board, or commission. (Labor Code Section 95.)
- Authorizes the Labor Commissioner to investigate employee complaints and provides that the Commissioner may provide for a hearing in any action to recover wages, penalties, and other demands for compensation, including liquidated damages, and shall determine all matters arising under his or her jurisdiction. (Labor Code Section 98.)
- Provides that the Labor Commissioner may prosecute all actions for the collection of wages, penalties, and demands of persons who in the judgment of the Labor Commissioner are financially unable to employ counsel and the Labor Commissioner believes have claims which are valid and enforceable. (Labor Code Section 98.3.)
- Provides that the Labor Commissioner may provide for a hearing to recover civil penalties due pursuant to violations of any provision regulating working hours against any employer or other person acting on behalf of an employer. (Labor Code Section 98.)
- Provides that the Labor Commissioner, after investigation and upon determination that wages or monetary benefits are due and unpaid to any worker in the State of California, may collect such wages or benefits on behalf of the worker without assignment of such wages or benefits to the Commissioner. (Labor Code Section 95.)
- Prohibits an employer from doing any of the following:
- Requiring, as a condition of employment, that an employee refrain from disclosing the amount of his or her wages;
- Requiring an employee to sign a waiver or other document that purports to deny the employee the right to disclose the amount of his or her wages; or
- Discharging, formally disciplining, or otherwise discriminating against an employee who discloses the amount of his or her wages. (Labor Code Section 232.)
- Prohibits an employer from doing any of the following:
- Requiring, as a condition of employment, that an employee refrain from disclosing information about the employer’s working conditions;
- Requiring an employee to sign a waiver or other document that purports to deny the employee the right to disclose information about the employer’s working conditions;
- Discharging, formally disciplining, or otherwise discriminating against an employee who discloses information about the employer’s working conditions. (Labor Code Section 232.5.)
- Prohibits an employer, or any person acting on behalf of the employer from adopting or enforcing any rule, regulation, or policy preventing an employee from disclosing information to a government or law enforcement agency, to a person with authority over the employee, or to another employee who has authority to investigate, discover, or correct the violation or noncompliance, or from providing information to, or testifying before, any public body conducting an investigation, hearing, or inquiry, if the employee has reasonable cause to believe that the information discloses a violation of state or federal statute, or a violation of or noncompliance with a local, state, or federal rule or regulation, regardless of whether disclosing the information is part of the employee’s job duties. (Labor Code Section 1102.5 (a).)
- Prohibits an employer from retaliating against an employee for disclosing information, or because the employer believes that the employee disclosed or may disclose information, to a government or law enforcement agency, to a person with authority over the employee or another employee who has the authority to investigate, discover, or correct the violation or noncompliance, or for providing information to, or testifying before, any public body conducting an investigation, hearing, or inquiry, if the employee has reasonable cause to believe that the information discloses a violation of state or federal statute, or a violation of or noncompliance with a local, state, or federal rule or regulation, regardless of whether disclosing the information is part of the employee’s job duties. (Labor Code Section 1102.5 (b).)
- Provides that no statutory right provided for general occupations under Article 1, Sections 200 through 244 of the Labor Code, can in any way be contravened or set aside by a private agreement, whether written, oral, or implied. (Labor Code Section 219.)
- Provides that any employee may file a complaint with the Division of Labor Standards Enforcement that the wages paid are less than the wages to which the employee is entitled and provides that the Division may commence and prosecute, unless otherwise requested by the employee or affected group of employees, a civil action on behalf of the employee and on behalf of a similarly affected group of employees to recover unpaid wages and liquidated damages. (Labor Code Section 1197.5.)
- Provides that the Department of Fair Housing and Employment, within the Business, Consumer Services, and Housing Agency, may receive, investigate, conciliate, mediate, and prosecute complaints alleging unlawful employment practices under the Fair Employment and Housing Act. (Government Code Section 12930 (f)(1).)
- Provides that the Department of Fair Employment and Housing may adopt procedural rules regarding investigations, prosecutions, and dispute resolutions to carry out the functions and duties of the Department. (Government Code Section 12930 (e).)
- Provides that it is an unlawful employment practice to discriminate on the basis of race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status of any person, to refuse to hire or employ the person or to refuse to select the person for a training program leading to employment, or to bar or to discharge the person from employment or from a training program leading to employment, or to discriminate against the person in compensation or in terms, conditions, or privileges of employment. (Government Code Section 12940 (a).)
- Prohibits an employer, labor organization, employment agency, or person from discharging, expelling, or otherwise discriminating against any person because the person has opposed any practices forbidden under the Fair Employment and Housing Act or because the person has filed a complaint, testified, or assisted in any proceeding subject to that Act. (Government Code Section 12940 (h).)
- Provides that harassment of an employee shall be unlawful if the employer, or its agents or supervisors, knew or should have known of the conduct and failed to take immediate and appropriate corrective action. (Government Code Section 12940 (j)(1).)
- Regulates the formation of contracts and provides that anyone may waive the advantage of a law intended solely for his benefit but specifies that a law established for a public reason cannot be waived by a private agreement. (Civil Code Section 3513.)
- Authorizes a court, if it finds as a matter of law that the contract or any clause of the contract was unconscionable at the time it was made, to refuse to enforce the contract, or it may enforce the remainder of the contract without the unconscionable clause, or it may so limit the application of any unconscionable clause as to avoid any unconscionable result. (Civil Code Section 1670.5 (a).)
- Prohibits any settlement agreement from containing a provision that prevents the disclosure of factual information that may establish a cause of action for an act that may be prosecuted as a felony sex offense, childhood sexual abuse, or sexual assault. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1002.)
- Establishes the California Arbitration Act which provides that agreements to arbitrate shall be valid, irrevocable, and enforceable, except on such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1280 et seq.)
- Provides, pursuant to the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA), that agreements to arbitrate shall be valid, irrevocable, and enforceable, except on such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract. (9 U.S.C. Section 2.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: This bill seeks to protect California workers against the forced waiver of their statutory rights, including the right to adjudicate employment related claims in any venue permitted by law, as a basic condition of employment. The bill does not dictate a preferred venue for adjudicating any employment claims, rather it provides that an employee cannot be forced to waive a venue for adjudication as a condition of employment.
This bill seeks to level the playing field between employees and employers, and to ensure that employment contracts are the result of mutual consent. To address the employee-employer power imbalance that can breed a culture of workplace harassment, and ensure that all employee rights are protected regardless of the situation, this bill seeks to ensure that employees are not required to waive statutory rights as a condition of accepting or maintaining employment. This bill seeks to return contracting between the employee and employer to the common law notion of an “arm’s length transaction” between two co-equal parties by untying the signing of an employment-related contract from a person’s need to earn a living.
The bill prohibits prospective employees or current employees from being required to waive any statutory rights under the Labor Code or Fair Employment and Housing Act as a condition of employment, continued employment, or the receipt of an employment-related benefit. This bill does not prohibit such a waiver in general; it simply requires both parties to agree to such terms on a level playing field in which one party’s livelihood is not contingent on waiving their statutory rights. This bill seeks to restore confidence in victims of sexual harassment, and other workplace violations, hoping to vindicate their statutory rights by ensuring that they cannot be forced to waive their rights under the law simply as a condition of obtaining or maintaining gainful employment.
Recognizing the need to assist employees of all types, existing law provides several avenues to protect worker rights. Seeking to better protect employees, particularly those without the financial means to seek legal counsel when facing employment issues, California provides significant legal protections designed to better level the power imbalance between employees and employers. Recognizing the diversity of the remedies provided to employees in California, existing law provides employees with numerous methods and opportunities to vindicate their rights, both in and out of court. Generally, employees may turn to the California Labor Commission or the Department of Fair Employment and Housing for assistance in workplace-related claims. These agencies seek to assist employees in disputes with employers. Additionally, the aggrieved employee may file a lawsuit to recover civil penalties on behalf of themselves, other employees, or step into the shoes of the State of California for Labor Code violations utilizing California’s Private Attorney General Act. (Labor Code Sections 2698 et seq.) In many of these cases the employee is not pursuing their own claims, but is rather standing in the shoes of the state to enforce labor law violations on behalf of all Californians. If an employee opts not to file a lawsuit, existing law provides additional non-judicial remedies.
Of particular relevance to this bill, the Department of Fair Employment and Housing provides significant assistance to aggrieved employees. The Department will investigate complaints and provide employees assistance in prosecuting claims. Additionally, the Department offers settlement hearings and dispute resolution services for the employee and employer to utilize in place of filing a lawsuit in court. Similarly, the Labor Commission has the power to hold informal conferences to adjudicate wage claims or hold hearings in which witnesses can be called.
In addition to these processes, California law, generally, also recognizes additional contractual rights, legal venues, or waivers that an employee and employer may agree to in an employment contract. This bill does not preclude such waivers, rather it provides that a waiver cannot be directly conditioned on employment.
The Federal Arbitration Act and this bill’s attempt to prohibit an employer from coercing an employee into waiving any right, forum, or procedure for a violation. Over the past two decades, the United States Supreme Court has broadened the scope and applicability of the Federal Arbitration Act, thereby causing the Act to preempt a growing number of state laws. In vetoing AB 3080 (Gonzalez, 2018), then-Governor Jerry Brown contended that, in his view, the bill, “plainly violated federal law.” The opposition to this present bill share the former governor’s view on the provisions prohibiting the waiver of any right, forum, or procedure for adjudicating labor claims and contend they are preempted by federal law. Writing for a coalition of business organizations in opposition to this measure, the California Chamber of Commerce notes that the Supreme Court has struck down a variety of state laws seeking to reign in arbitration provisions. The coalition in opposition to this bill states, “The United States Supreme Court and California Supreme Court have issued numerous opinions over the past decade that have consistently held any state statute that interferes with, discriminates against, or limits the use of arbitration is preempted.”
Throughout the United States Supreme Court’s jurisprudence regarding arbitration, three primary holdings of the court have become clear. First, as reaffirmed as recently as last summer, the purpose of the Federal Arbitration Act was designed to promote arbitration. (Epic Systems Corp. v. Lewis (2018) 584 U.S. ___). Secondly, state laws or other rules that explicitly interfere with the enforcement of an arbitration agreement are preempted, unless grounds exist to void the contract as a whole. (AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion (2011) 563 U.S. 333.) Finally, the Supreme Court has held that the Federal Arbitration Act, in addition to preempting any “state rule discriminating on its face arbitration… displaces any rule that covertly accomplishes the same objective by disfavoring contracts that (oh so coincidentally) have the defining features of arbitration agreements.” (Kindred Nursing Centers Limited Partnership v. Clark (2017) 137 S. Ct. 1421, 1426.)
Proponents of this measure note that while the courts tend to strongly enforce the Federal Arbitration Act, the United States Supreme Court has also held that that arbitration, “is a matter of consent, not coercion.” (Mastrobuono v. Shearson Lehman Hutton, Inc., (1995) 514 US 52, 57.) The proponents contend that by seeking to prohibit the waiver of any venue for dispute resolution as a condition of employment, AB 51 simply removes the coercive nature of requiring a person to waive their rights in order to obtain, or retain, gainful employment, and fits within the narrow window of state action not prohibited by the Supreme Court. The supporters suggest that any incidental reduction in the amount of arbitration that would be likely to occur in employment cases because of the bill would be the result of employees choosing to avail themselves of other remedies in employment matters. The bill’s sponsor the California Labor Federation even notes that, “arbitration can be a highly effective dispute resolution method when both parties chose it freely.” (Emphasis added.) They suggest that this bill simply makes picking arbitration an equal choice among various options for dispute resolution, and removes the threat of coercion from the process in accordance with prior court holdings.
Additionally, there is added uncertainty regarding the ability to waive certain rights under California’s Private Attorney General Act. As noted above the existing law permits an employee to file a claim under the Private Attorney General Act on behalf of the state. In late 2018, an unpublished decision of the Third Appellate District of the California Court of Appeal invalidated an employment contract that waived certain representative claims under the Private Attorney General Act. This is keeping with several prior court decisions finding such waivers were unconscionable when the plaintiff functions as a substitute for an action brought by the government itself. (See Iskanian v. CLS Transportation Los Angeles, LLC (2014) 59 Cal. 4th 348.) Accordingly, particularly related to representative claims under existing law, the arbitration issues raised by this bill remain unresolved. As the debates around the scope of the Federal Arbitration Act continue in the courts, the Legislature is certainly not precluded from weighing in on the issue of how employment disputes are resolved and stating its preference that employees not be coerced, through the threat of losing gainful employment, into waiving any venue for deciding those disputes.
Nonetheless, to further clarify that the bill does not apply to existing, valid arbitration agreements, the author proposes the following amendment to subdivision (f) of the proposed Labor Code Section 432.6:
(f) Nothing in this section shall be construed to provide a basis on which to challenge the validity, enforceability, or conscionability of any contract or provision therein, once lawfully executed. Nothing in this subdivision shall be construed to restrict or expand other legal grounds upon which the validity, enforceability, or conscionability of a contract or provision therein may be challenged, even once executed is intended to invalidate a written arbitration agreement that is otherwise enforceable under the Federal Arbitration Act of 1925 (9 U.S.C Chapter 1-3).
Proposed author’s amendments narrow the scope of the bill to ensure that fair legal settlements of employment disputes can be achieved. In addition to arguing that this measure is preempted by federal law, the opposition contends that this bill would preclude settlement agreements. In particular, the opposition points to provisions of the bill that prohibit the waiver of an employee’s rights as a condition of any “contractual agreement.” They contend that this prohibits settlement agreements to resolve employment disputes because settlements by their nature involve waiving rights to a legal claim in return for whatever financial or other consideration the employer gives the employee as a part of the settlement agreement. The author notes that this was never the intention of this bill, and accordingly proposes the following amendment to modify subdivision (a), and create a new subdivision (g), in the proposed Section 432.6 of the Labor Code to clarify that nothing in the bill precludes settlement agreements or negotiated severances:
(a) A person shall not, as a condition of employment, continued employment, or the receipt of any employment-related benefit, or as a condition of entering into a contractual agreement, require any applicant for employment or any employee to waive any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of any provision of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (Part 2.8 (commencing with Section 12900) of Division 3 of Title 2 of the Government Code) or this code, including the right to file and pursue a civil action or a complaint with, or otherwise notify, any state agency, other public prosecutor, law enforcement agency, or any court or other governmental entity of any alleged violation.
(g) This section does not apply to post-dispute settlement agreements or negotiated severance agreements.
Additional technical and clarifying amendments. In order to facilitate the above discussed amendments, including the new subdivision (g), the existing subdivisions (g) and (h) will be reordered. Finally, recognizing the passage of SB 1300 (Jackson), Chap. 995, Stats. 2018, which prohibited secret harassment settlements, the author proposes to delete the generally duplicative language in this measure adding Section 432.4 to the Labor Code in Section 3 of the bill, and making a cross reference in the proposed Government Code Section 12953 so that that section, as proposed to be amended would read:
12953. It is an unlawful employment practice for an employer to violate Section 432.4 or 432.6 of the Labor Code.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This measure is supported by a coalition of labor and employment law organizations. Regarding the harms that stem from waiving a venue for adjudicating claims, the bill co-sponsor, the California Labor Federation, notes:
Workers lose access to the state agency charged with worker protection, where staff can help with language or cultural barriers and can protect them from retaliation. They lose access to court, effectively denying them access to counsel who can assist a low-wage worker in navigating a case against a wealthier and more sophisticated employer.
Additionally, fellow co-sponsor the Consumer Attorneys of California, suggest that California should not allow employers to simply make void worker protection statutes by way of contract, arguing:
California has passed a plethora of worker laws and protections and those protections must be enforced to be meaningful. No employer should be able to escape accountability by forcing workers to waive their rights.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: As noted this bill is strongly opposed by a coalition of business organizations and the California Chamber of Commerce. In addition to the above discussed issues regarding arbitration and settlement preclusion, they argue this bill denies employees and employers timely access to justice, stating:
By banning arbitration and settlement agreements, the only option left for employees to resolve many labor and employment claims is litigation. Several studies have indicated that this delay and limited access to the civil courts is worse for low-wage workers.
The opposition further argues that this bill’s provisions providing that violations of the bill would be an unlawful employment practice creates new rights of action under the Fair Employment and Housing Act, and that such provisions will do the following:
Presumably will require an employee to exhaust the administrative remedy under the Fair Employment and Housing Act, placing more costs and burden on the Department of Fair Employment and Housing, and expose an employer to another layer of costly litigation including attorney’s fees, lost wages, and punitive damages. The entire point of an arbitration agreement is to avoid the costs of litigation, which AB 51 only exacerbates.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
California Labor Federation (co-sponsor)
Consumer Attorneys of California (co-sponsor)
American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Employment Lawyers Association
California IATSE Council
California Professional Firefighters
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
California Voices for Progress
Coalition for Human Immigrant Rights
Courage Campaign
Engineers and Scientists of California, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO
Entertainment Union Coalition
Inlandboatmen’s Union of the Pacific
Los Angeles County Professional Peace Officers Association
Lutheran Office of Public Policy-California
Organization of SMUD Employees
Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
SAG-AFTRA
State Building and Construction Trades Council of California
San Diego County Court Employees Association
SEIU California
United Public Employees
Utility Workers of America
Writers Guild of American West
Opposition
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
American Staffing Association
California Ambulance Association
California Association of Joint Powers Authorities
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Bankers Association
California Beer and Beverage Distributors
California Building Industry Association
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Hospital Association
California Hotel and Lodging Association
California League of Food Producers
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California New Car Dealers Association
California Professional Association of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California Trucking Association
Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse
Civil Justice Association of California
Delta Dental
El Centro Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Fresno Chamber of Commerce
Garden Grove Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chambers of Commerce
Job Creators for Workplace Fairness
League of California Cities
National Federation of Independent Business
Official Police Garages of Los Angeles
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Palm Desert Area Chamber of Commerce
Pleasanton Chamber of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Redondo Beach Chamber of Commerce
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Ana Chamber of Commerce
Society for Human Resource Management
South Bay Association of Chambers of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: March 6, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 51 (
Author:Gonzalez) – As Introduced Ver:December 3, 2018
SUBJECT: Employment discrimination: enforcement
SUMMARY: Prohibits the following employment practices:
- Requiring a non-disclosure agreement in regards to a person being a victim of, witness to, or participant in an investigation of workplace sexual harassment;
- Requiring a person to waive a right to take employment-related claims to court; and
- Retaliating against a person for refusing to consent to such a waiver.
Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a person from, as a condition of employment, continued employment, the receipt of any employment-related benefit, or as a condition of entering into a contract, prohibiting an applicant for employment, employee, or independent contractor from disclosing an instance of sexual harassment that the employee or independent contractor suffers, witnesses, or discovers in the workplace or in the performance of the contract, or otherwise opposing any lawful practice, or from exercising any right or obligation or participating in any investigation or proceeding with respect to unlawful harassment or discrimination.
- Provides that the above prohibition applies to contracts for employment entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2020.
- Prohibits an employer from requiring any applicant for employment or any employee to waive any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of any provision of the California Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA) or other specific statutes governing employment, as a condition of employment, continued employment, the receipt of any employment-related benefit, or as a condition of entering into a contractual agreement that is entered into, modified, or extended on or after January 1, 2020.
- Prohibits an employer from threatening, retaliating or discriminating against, or terminating any applicant for employment or any employee because of the refusal to consent to the waiver of any right, forum, or procedure for a violation of specific statutes governing employment.
- Provides that violations of the above prohibitions constitute unlawful employment practices under FEHA.
- Provides that, in addition to injunctive relief and any other available remedies, a court may award reasonable attorney’s fees to a prevailing plaintiff enforcing his or her rights in regards to employment-related waivers.
- Exempts certain persons employed by a self-regulatory organization as defined by the Securities Exchange Act of 1934 (15 U.S.C. Sec. 78c) or in its regulations from the prohibition on waivers.
- Provides that the bill’s provisions regarding waivers shall not be construed to provide a basis on which to challenge the validity, enforceability, or conscionability of any contract or provision therein, once lawfully executed, nor to restrict or expand other legal grounds to challenge the validity, enforceability, or conscionability of a contract or provision therein, once executed.
- States that the above provisions are severable.
EXISTING LAW:
- Prohibits setting aside or contravening a number of labor rights, including minimum wage protections, timely payment of wages and the provision of wage stubs, through a written or oral contract.
- Prohibits an employer from requiring, as a condition of employment, that an employee refrain from disclosing information about the employer’s working conditions; requiring an employee to sign a waiver or other document that purports to deny the employee the right to disclose information about the employer’s working conditions; or discharging, formally disciplining, or otherwise discriminating against an employee who discloses information about their working conditions.
- Authorizes the Department of Fair Employment and Housing (DFEH) to receive, investigate, conciliate, mediate, and prosecute complaints alleging unlawful employment practices under the FEHA.
- Provides that it is an unlawful employment practice to discriminate, refuse to hire, or employ any person based on race, religious creed, color, national origin, ancestry, physical disability, mental disability, medical condition, genetic information, marital status, sex, gender, gender identity, gender expression, age, sexual orientation, or military and veteran status.
- Authorizes a court, if it finds as a matter of law that the contract or any clause of the contract was unconscionable at the time it was made, to refuse to enforce the contract, or it may enforce the remainder of the contract without the unconscionable clause, or it may so limit the application of any unconscionable clause as to avoid any unconscionable result.
- Establishes the California Arbitration Act, which provides that agreements to arbitrate shall be valid, irrevocable, and enforceable, except on such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract.
- Provides, pursuant to the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA), that agreements to arbitrate shall be valid, irrevocable, and enforceable, except on such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of any contract. (9 U.S.C. Sec. 2.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: The use of mandatory arbitration agreements in the employment context has garnered the attention of both lawmakers and the public. State legislatures and Congress have introduced legislation to curb the use of these agreements, recognizing the inherent power imbalance these contractual arrangements bring to the employee-employer relationship. Most recently, on February 28, 2019, Sen. Richard Blumenthal, (D-Conn.) and Rep. Hank Johnson, (D-Ga.) announced the introduction of the Forced Arbitration Injustice Repeal (FAIR) Act that would prevent forced arbitration before a dispute occurs, allowing employees or consumers to choose arbitration at their will.
The use of forced arbitration agreements by tech companies and leading law firms has received much media coverage. In the fall of 2018, Google employees began a public campaign against their employer’s use of mandatory arbitration and more recently, thousands of workers walked off the job to protest the company’s treatment of sexual misconduct by high-ranking male executives. In November 2018, the company announced that it would no longer enforce arbitration agreements for all employment-related disputes. Around the same time, students at Harvard Law School organized a boycott to protest the use of mandatory arbitration agreements in employment contracts by Kirkland and Ellis, an international corporate law firm, which were designed to force employees out of court for claims of discrimination, sexual harassment, or other employment practices. In response, the firm announced that they are doing away with mandatory arbitration agreements for their summer associates.
The use of arbitration agreements has been subject to significant litigation. Both federal and state courts have issued opinions regarding the authority of states to regulate arbitration in light of the FAA preference for and promotion of arbitration. The U.S. Supreme Court recently ruled, in the context of a class action case, that state laws that explicitly or covertly discriminate against arbitration agreements as compared to other contracts are preempted by the FAA. (Epic Systems Corp. v. Lewis, (May 21, 2018, No. 16-285) 584 U.S__at 7.) In addition, courts have generally held that state laws that interfere with the enforcement of arbitration agreements are preempted, except on such grounds as exist at law or in equity for the revocation of a contract. (AT&T Mobility LLC v. Concepcion (2011) 563 U.S. 333, 339.)
As stated by to the author, no provision of this bill prohibits the use of arbitration agreements or discriminates against these agreements, once executed. The bill seeks to ensure that employees voluntarily enter into these agreements. According to the author, “AB 51 avoids preemption by applying only to the condition in which an arbitration agreement is made, as opposed to banning arbitration itself. There has not been a preemption case in the absence of an arbitration agreement.”
Arguments in Support
In support, the California Labor Federation, a sponsor of the bill, highlights the many harms workers face when forced to sign arbitration agreements, particularly as victims of sexual harassment. According to the Federation, “forced arbitration of sexual harassment claims epitomizes all of the most harmful practices that have enabled widespread abuse to go undetected for decades. Workers are forced to sign away their rights in order to get hired. When they seek to report violations, they are denied the ability to go to court or file a claim with the Labor Commissioner. Instead, they are trapped in the employer’s handpicked arbitration system. The system is secret and confidential, protecting abusers from any public scrutiny. State agencies have no knowledge of repeat violations or arbitration decisions and there is no public record.”
The Federation further argues that the use of forced arbitration is on the rise. They state, “In 2012, the number of workers bound by forced arbitration agreements was 16%. That figure rose to 43% in 2014. A new study from the Economic Policy Institute found that today over 55% of all workers in the private sector are bound by forced arbitration agreements.”
Also in support, the California Employment Lawyers Association rejects any argument of federal preemption, stating, “What is unique about AB 51 from other state laws and prior legislation that have been challenged under the FAA, is that this bill would not impact the enforceability of any arbitration agreement. This bill only governs when a worker chooses not to enter into one. If a worker refuses to sign an arbitration agreement, there would be no issue of contract formation or enforceability, because there would simply be no agreement. Furthermore, this bill would not frustrate the purpose of the FAA because that purpose follows the basic precept, emphasized numerous times by the Supreme Court, that arbitration ‘is a matter of consent, not coercion.’ Volt Information Sciences, Inc. v. Board of Trustees of Leland Stanford Junior Univ., 489 U.S. 468; Mastrobuono v. Shearson Lehman Hutton, Inc., 514 US 52.”
Arguments in Opposition
In opposition, a coalition of employer organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, states that the bill “(1) essentially prohibits arbitration of labor and employment claims as a condition of employment and is likely preempted by federal law; (2) interferes with and prohibits settlement agreements for labor and employment claims; (3) exposes employers to criminal liability regarding arbitration agreements; and, (4) adds another private right of action onto employers under the Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA). AB 51 will create more litigation, significant delays in the resolution of disputes, and higher costs for employers and employees.”
The coalition cites a recent appellate case in its argument for federal preemption. The decision invalidated AB 2617 (Weber) from 2014 that deemed the waiver of rights to a judicial forum involuntary and unenforceable. The coalition states, “In March 2018, the Second District California Court of Appeal also determined that banning arbitration agreements as a condition of a consumer contract violated the Federal Arbitration Act (FAA) and was preempted. Specifically, in Saheli v. White Memorial Medical Center, 21 Cal.App.5th 308, the court determined that AB 2617 was preempted under the FAA as it placed a special restriction on arbitration agreements that were not imposed on other contracts.”
Related and Prior Legislation
AB 749 (Stone) 2019 would prohibit an agreement to settle an employment dispute from containing a provision that prohibits, prevents, or otherwise restricts a settling party that is an aggrieved person, as defined, from working for the employer against which the aggrieved person has filed a claim or any parent company, subsidiary, division, affiliate, or contractor of the employer. The measure is pending in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
AB 3080 (Gonzalez) 2018 would have banned the practice of employers requiring workers to sign arbitration agreements as a condition of employment. AB 3080 would also have ensured that a person is not prevented, as a condition of employment or a condition of entering into a contractual agreement, from disclosing to any other person instances of sexual harassment that they may suffer, witness, or discover in the workplace. Additionally, this bill would have prohibited employers from threatening, retaliating, discriminating against, or terminating workers because they refuse to consent to such a waiver. AB 3080 was vetoed by Governor Brown.
SB 1300 (Jackson) Chapter 955, Statutes of 2018 provides guidance to the courts on the “severe or pervasive” legal standard for sexual harassment. SB 1300 also prohibits non-disparagement clauses that prevent victims from speaking out about abuse and seeking justice in court for sexual harassment.
AB 3109 (Stone) Chapter 949, Statutes of 2018 renders unenforceable, prospectively, any provision in a contract or settlement agreement that either: (1) prevents a person from testifying, in response to a subpoena or official request, about alleged criminal conduct or sexual harassment in a judicial, administrative, or legislative proceeding; or (2) substantially constrains a person’s ability to engage in a lawful trade, profession, or occupation.
SB 820 (Leyva) Chapter 953, Statutes of 2018 bans secret settlements (non-disclosure agreements) in cases of sexual assault, sexual harassment, and sex discrimination for both private and public employers in California, including the California State Legislature.
AB 465 (Hernández) 2016 would have prohibited any person from requiring another person, with some exemptions, to agree, as a condition of employment, to the waiver of any legal right, penalty, forum, or procedure for any employment law violations. The bill would also have prohibited threats, retaliation, or discrimination for refusing to agree to such a waiver. Finally, it would have required that any waiver of these rights be knowing, voluntary, in writing, and expressly not made as a condition of employment. Governor Brown vetoed AB 465.
AB 2617 (Weber) Chapter 910, Statutes of 2014 imposed specified, prospective restrictions on the contractual waivers of rights under the Ralph Civil Rights Act and the Tom Bane Civil Rights Act. A California Court of Appeals struck down AB 2617 on preemption grounds. (Saheli v. White Memorial Medical Center (2018) 21 Cal.App.5th 308.)
SB 1407 (Jackson) 2014 would have provided that a waiver or release of claims under FEHA is contrary to public policy and unenforceable, unless the waiver or release of claims is knowing and voluntary and is clearly stated as part of a negotiated settlement agreement of the claims. SB 1407 died on the Assembly Floor Inactive File.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Federation Of State, County And Municipal Employees, AFL-CIO
California Conference Board Of The Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference Of Machinists
California Employment Lawyers Association
California IATSE Council
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO (CoSponsor)
California Professional Firefighters
California State Council Of Service Employees
California Teamsters Public Affairs Council
California Voices For Progress
Coalition For Humane Immigrant Rights
Consumer Attorneys Of California (CoSponsor)
Courage Campaign
Engineers And Scientists Of California Local 20
Entertainment Union Coalition
Lutheran Office Of Public Policy - California
Professional & Technical Engineers, Local 21
SAG-AFTRA
Unite Here International Union, AFL-CIO
Utility Workers Union Of America, Local 132
Writers Guild Of America, West, Inc.
Oppose
American Property Casualty Insurance Association
American Staffing Association
California Ambulance Association
California Association Of Joint Powers Authorities
California Association Of Winegrape Growers
California Bankers Association
California Beer And Beverage Distributors
California Building Industry Association
California Chamber Of Commerce
California Employment Law Council
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Hospital Association
California Hotel & Lodging Association
California League Of Food Producers
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California New Car Dealers Association
California Professional Association Of Specialty Contractors
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California Trucking Association
Citizens Against Lawsuit Abuse
Civil Justice Association Of California
El Centro Chamber Of Commerce
Family Business Association Of California
Folsom Chamber Of Commerce
Fresno Chamber Of Commerce
Garden Grove Chamber Of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber Of Commerce
Greater Riverside Chamber Of Commerce
Job Creators For Workplace Fairness
League Of California Cities
Official Police Garage Association Of Los Angeles
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber Of Commerce
Palm Desert Area Chamber Of Commerce
Rancho Cordova Chamber Of Commerce
Redondo Beach Chamber Of Commerce & Visitors Bureau
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
Santa Ana Chamber Of Commerce
South Bay Association Of Chambers Of Commerce
Southwest California Legislative Council
Western Growers Association
Wine Institute
Analysis Prepared by: Megan Lane / L. & E. /
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):