AB 589: Employment: unfair immigration-related practices.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-09-16
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jan 21, 2020 | Consideration of Governor's veto stricken from file. |
| Oct 12, 2019 | Vetoed by Governor. |
| Sep 23, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 3:30 p.m. |
| Sep 11, 2019 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 12 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. |
| Sep 5, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 4, 2019 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 13, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 12, 2019 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8. |
| Jul 3, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (July 2). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 12, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 4. Noes 0.) (June 12). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 16, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on L., P.E. & R. and JUD. |
| May 6, 2019 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 6, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Apr 29, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Apr 25, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 14. Noes 1.) (April 24). |
| Apr 2, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 2.) (April 2). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Mar 20, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (March 20). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 25, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on L. & E. and JUD. |
| Feb 15, 2019 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 17. |
| Feb 14, 2019 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 11, 2019 | AB 589 Gonzalez Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 10, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB589 Gonzalez By Rubio | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 12, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Labor, Public Employment and Retirement |
Passed |
|
| May 6, 2019 | AB 589 Gonzalez Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Mar 20, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Labor and Employment |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
GOVERNOR'S VETO
GV Bill Id:AB 589
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Enrolled Ver:September 16, 2019
2/3 vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits an employer from and imposes penalties for withholding an employee's immigration-related documents and establishes a Worker's Bill of Rights regarding freedom of movement and payment of wages.
The Senate Amendments:
- Change the effective date from July 1, 2020 to July 1, 2021 in regards to an employer's obligation to provide the "Worker's Bill of Rights" to specified employees.
- Add that an employer who fails to provide the "Worker's Bill of Rights" shall have 30 days to correct the failure before any enforcement action may be taken.
Governor’s Veto Message:
This bill makes it unlawful for an employer to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess any passport, immigration document or government identification in the course of committing human trafficking or a coercive labor practice. Employers who violate this provision are subject to criminal and civil penalties.
The bill also requires all employers to provide a "Worker's Bill of Rights" to every employee.
Human trafficking is a problem of international proportions, and California must continue to act forcefully to protect workers against these heinous crimes. The provision in this bill that levies a hefty civil penalty on employers who engage in document abuse in order to commit trafficking is a step in the right direction.
Nonetheless, I take issue with the bill's requirement that every employer in the state provide each employee with an enumerated list of rights. Workers should be informed of their rights, including protections against document abuse and trafficking. But the proposed notice requirement is not the answer. It is overly burdensome for law-abiding employers and may not actually help workers who are the targets of trafficking.
COMMENTS:
Human trafficking is a form of modern slavery and includes both labor and sex trafficking. Victims are coerced, exploited, and often held against their will. According to the National Human Trafficking Resource Center, in 2018, California had 760 reported cases of human trafficking—the highest number of cases of any state. While the majority of the cases involved sex trafficking, 72 cases involved labor trafficking and were most prevalent in industries such as domestic services and agriculture.
According to the Author:
The bill "helps protect workers against the immoral practice of 'document servitude' by: 1) providing a framework to hold employers accountable who engage in 'document servitude' and creating a misdemeanor crime for this tactic; 2) bringing the practice of 'document servitude' in line with other unlawful employment practices; and 3) establishing a 'Worker's Bill of Rights.'"
Arguments in Support:
According to the Office of the San Diego County District Attorney, sponsor of the bill, this bill "is necessary to protect immigrant workers who are taken advantage of by unscrupulous employers because of their federal immigration status. Many are recruited or manipulated to enter California with work visas, but later become subject to labor abuses because of their unfamiliarity with the rights that all California workers should enjoy. A 2012 San Diego State University study estimates there are 37,000 victims of labor trafficking in our region alone. It showed that the most vulnerable immigrant workers in San Diego County were in the fields of construction, restaurants, janitorial, and agriculture.
In addition, a 2014 Urban Institute study, 'Understanding the Organization, Operation, and Victimization Process of Labor Trafficking in the United States,' reported that most of the victims entered into the United States lawfully under federal immigration law. Contrary to the stereotype that these enslaved persons had entered unlawfully, in fact, 71% of the victims entered the U.S. on a temporary VISA (H-2A, H-2B) that legally allowed them to work, but by the time they escaped, 69% were unauthorized. These studies showed that the culpable employers used a variety of physical and psychological means to control and enslave victims, including holding on to their work visas and identification documents, controlling where they lived, holding on to their wages, and leveraging the concept of debt bondage, a practice still prevalent in much of the world."
Arguments in Opposition:
A coalition of employer organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, argue in opposition that the bill is duplicative of existing prohibitions against document servitude. They state, "existing California and federal law already prohibit this conduct. CA Penal Code Section 236.1 already considers exactly the situation which AB 589 appears aimed at – an employer taking or concealing a victim's immigration documents in order to compel work – and provides for more stringent punishments than AB 589 - including 5 or more years in prison and a fine up to $500,000. In addition, current federal law (Chapter 77 of Title 18 of the United States Code) also prohibits forcing an individual to labor by withholding their passport or other immigration documents."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8 negligible state costs.
VOTES:
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 7-0-0
YES: Kalra, Flora, Carrillo, Diep, Gonzalez, Jones-Sawyer, Luz Rivas
ASM JUDICIARY: 10-2-0
YES: Mark Stone, Gallagher, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Kiley, Obernolte
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 14-1-3
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Gabriel, Jones-Sawyer, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bigelow, Brough, Fong
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 65-6-9
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Brough, Dahle, Kiley, Mathis, Obernolte, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Bigelow, Chen, Cooper, Fong, Gray, Melendez, Patterson, Salas
SENATE FLOOR: 30-9-1
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Bates, Borgeas, Dahle, Grove, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chang
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 65-9-5
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Cooley, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Gray, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Salas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Frazier, Kiley, Mathis, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chen, Choi, Cooper, Fong, Mayes
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 16, 2019
CONSULTANT: Megan Lane / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0002537
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 589
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Amended Ver:September 4, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits an employer from and imposes penalties for withholding an employee's immigration-related documents and establishes a Worker's Bill of Rights regarding freedom of movement and payment of wages.
The Senate Amendments:
- Change the effective date from July 1, 2020 to July 1, 2021 in regards to an employer's obligation to provide the "Worker's Bill of Rights" to specified employees.
- Add that an employer who fails to provide the "Worker's Bill of Rights" shall have 30 days to correct the failure before any enforcement action may be taken.
COMMENTS:
Human trafficking is a form of modern slavery and includes both labor and sex trafficking. Victims are coerced, exploited, and often held against their will. According to the National Human Trafficking Resource Center, in 2018, California had 760 reported cases of human trafficking—the highest number of cases of any state. While the majority of the cases involved sex trafficking, 72 cases involved labor trafficking and were most prevalent in industries such as domestic services and agriculture.
According to the Author:
The bill "helps protect workers against the immoral practice of 'document servitude' by: 1) providing a framework to hold employers accountable who engage in 'document servitude' and creating a misdemeanor crime for this tactic; 2) bringing the practice of 'document servitude' in line with other unlawful employment practices; and 3) establishing a 'Worker's Bill of Rights.'"
Arguments in Support:
According to the Office of the San Diego County District Attorney, sponsor of the bill, this bill "is necessary to protect immigrant workers who are taken advantage of by unscrupulous employers because of their federal immigration status. Many are recruited or manipulated to enter California with work visas, but later become subject to labor abuses because of their unfamiliarity with the rights that all California workers should enjoy. A 2012 San Diego State University study estimates there are 37,000 victims of labor trafficking in our region alone. It showed that the most vulnerable immigrant workers in San Diego County were in the fields of construction, restaurants, janitorial, and agriculture.
In addition, a 2014 Urban Institute study, 'Understanding the Organization, Operation, and Victimization Process of Labor Trafficking in the United States,' reported that most of the victims entered into the United States lawfully under federal immigration law. Contrary to the stereotype that these enslaved persons had entered unlawfully, in fact, 71% of the victims entered the U.S. on a temporary VISA (H-2A, H-2B) that legally allowed them to work, but by the time they escaped, 69% were unauthorized. These studies showed that the culpable employers used a variety of physical and psychological means to control and enslave victims, including holding on to their work visas and identification documents, controlling where they lived, holding on to their wages, and leveraging the concept of debt bondage, a practice still prevalent in much of the world."
Arguments in Opposition:
A coalition of employer organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, argue in opposition that the bill is duplicative of existing prohibitions against document servitude. They state, "existing California and federal law already prohibit this conduct. CA Penal Code Section 236.1 already considers exactly the situation which AB 589 appears aimed at – an employer taking or concealing a victim's immigration documents in order to compel work – and provides for more stringent punishments than AB 589 - including 5 or more years in prison and a fine up to $500,000. In addition, current federal law (Chapter 77 of Title 18 of the United States Code) also prohibits forcing an individual to labor by withholding their passport or other immigration documents."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8 negligible state costs.
VOTES:
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 7-0-0
YES: Kalra, Flora, Carrillo, Diep, Gonzalez, Jones-Sawyer, Luz Rivas
ASM JUDICIARY: 10-2-0
YES: Mark Stone, Gallagher, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Kiley, Obernolte
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 14-1-3
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Gabriel, Jones‑Sawyer, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bigelow, Brough, Fong
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 65-6-9
YES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NO: Brough, Dahle, Kiley, Mathis, Obernolte, Voepel
ABS, ABST OR NV: Arambula, Bigelow, Chen, Cooper, Fong, Gray, Melendez, Patterson, Salas
SENATE FLOOR: 30-9-1
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Bates, Borgeas, Dahle, Grove, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone
ABS, ABST OR NV: Chang
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 4, 2019
CONSULTANT: Megan Lane / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0002179
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 589 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 589
Amended: 9/4/19 in Senate
SENATE LABOR, PUB. EMP. & RET. COMMITTEE: 4-0, 6/12/19
AYES: Hill, Jackson, Mitchell, Pan
NO VOTE RECORDED: Morrell
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-2, 7/2/19
AYES: Jackson, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Borgeas, Jones
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 65-6, 5/6/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Employment: unfair immigration-related practices
SOURCE: San Diego County District Attorney, Summer Stephan
DIGEST:
This bill makes it unlawful for an employer to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess any passport or other immigration-related document of another person in the course of committing, or with the intent to commit, trafficking, peonage, slavery, involuntary servitude, or a coercive labor practice. This bill provides that violations of this unlawful employment practice would result in a misdemeanor and a $10,000 civil penalty, in addition to any fine that may be levied as a result of any criminal prosecution. This bill also requires employers to post a notice in the workplace with information including the right to maintain custody and control of immigration-related documents. Finally, this bill requires employers to provide employees with a “Worker’s Bill of Rights” document in multiple languages, setting forth labor laws and protections against human trafficking.
Senate Floor Amendments of 9/4/19 provide a one-year delayed implementation for the “Worker’s Bill of Rights” document provisions of the bill and include a 30-day right to cure provision before any enforcement action may be taken against an employer for failing to provide the “Worker’s Bill of Rights.”
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires, under the Immigration and Nationality Act, an employer to verify, through examination of specified documents, whether or not an individual is authorized to work in the United States. Specifies that if the document is presented and reasonably appears on its face to be genuine, then the employer has complied with this requirement and is not required to solicit or demand any other document. (8 U.S.C. §1324a(b))
- Prohibits anyone to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess an actual or purported passport or other immigration document, or any other actual or purported government identification of another person in the course of committing or with intent to commit various crimes involving servitude, trafficking, and coercive labor practices. (18 U.S.C. §1592)
- Specifies that a person who deprives or violates the personal liberty of another with the intent to obtain forced labor or services, and is guilty of human trafficking and shall be punished by imprisonment in the state prison for five, eight, or 12 years and a fine of not more than $500,000. (Penal Code §236.1)
- Prohibits an employer or any other person or entity from engaging in, or directing another person or entity to engage in, an unfair immigration-related practice, as defined, against any person for the purpose of retaliating against that person for exercising his or her rights under state or local labor law. (Labor Code §1019 (a))
- Defines "unfair immigration-related practice," for purposes of state law, to mean any of the following practices when undertaken for retaliatory purposes, and not at the direction or request of the federal government (Labor Code §1019 (b)):
- Requesting more or different documents than are required by federal law or refusing to honor required documents that on their face appear to be genuine.
- Using the federal E-Verify system to check the employment authorization status of a person at a time or in a manner not required or authorized by federal law.
- Threatening to file or filing of a false police report, threatening to file or filing a false report or complaint with any state or federal agency, threatening to contact or contacting immigration authorities.
- Permits an employee or any other person who is subject to an unfair immigration-related practice, where the unfair practice is retaliatory in nature, to bring a civil action for equitable relief and any applicable damages or penalties, and specifies that an employee or other person who prevails shall recover his or her reasonable attorney's fees. (Labor Code §1019(d))
- Prohibits an employer, in the course of satisfying federal immigration law, from requesting more or different documents than are required under federal immigration law; refusing to honor valid documents, as specified; or attempting to reinvestigate or reverify an incumbent employee's authorization to work using an unfair immigration-related practice. Violation of these provisions is subject penalties imposed by the Labor Commissioner, up to $10,000 per violation, and equitable relief. (Labor Code §1019.1)
- Requires employers to display posters in conspicuous locations which describe certain labor laws and worker rights around issues such as paid sick leave and whistleblower protections. (Labor Code §247 and §1102.8(a))
This bill:
- Makes it an unlawful employment practice for an employer to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess any actual or purported passport or other immigration document of another person in the course of committing, or with the intent to commit, trafficking, peonage, slavery, involuntary servitude, a coercive labor practice.
- Specifies that a violation of this unlawful employment practice results in:
- A misdemeanor; and
- A $10,000 civil penalty recoverable by the Labor Commissioner, in addition to any fine that may be levied as a result of any criminal prosecution.
- Requires employers to post, as specified, a prescribed workplace notice with information including an employee’s right to maintain custody and control of immigration documents and that the withholding of these documents by the employer is a crime as well as the contact information for the National Human Trafficking Hotline.
- Specifies that in enacting these provisions, the Legislature does not intend to preclude a prosecution under the labor trafficking provisions or other laws prohibiting the mistreatment of workers generally, or any other civil remedy available at law or equity.
- Requires the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) to, on or before July 1, 2021, develop a document entitled the “Worker’s Bill of Rights,” to inform employees of:
- Their right to hold on to their own immigration and identification documents and that an employer cannot take those documents, except as specified.
- Their right to be paid the mandatory minimum wage or other wage, as specified.
- Their right to live wherever the employee chooses, unless living in employer-provided housing is agreed upon as a lawful condition of employment and living on the premises is customary and necessary to the duties of employment.
- Their right not to be subject to debt bondage in lieu of being paid wages owed.
- Their right to call local or federal authorities, or the National Human Trafficking Hotline if the employer or anyone else is controlling the employee’s movement, documents, or wages, or using threats against the employee or their family.
- Requires DIR to make the “Worker’s Bill of Rights” document available on its Internet Web site for download by employers by July 1, 2021, and make it available in English and translated into the 12 languages most commonly spoken in this state, as specified.
- Requires employers to provide employees hired on or after July 1, 2021, with the “Worker’s Bill of Rights” document before verifying an employee’s employment authorization. For employees hired before July 1, 2021, requires employers to provide each employee with the document when it is made available by DIR.
- Requires employers to provide the “Worker’s Bill of Rights” document in a language understood by the employee, as specified, and requires that the employee sign and date it in acknowledgment that the employee has read and understands his/her rights.
- Requires employers to keep the signed document in its records for a period of no less than three years and give a copy of the signed document to the employee.
- Specifies that before any enforcement action may be taken against an employer for failing to provide the “Worker’s Bill of Rights,” the employer shall be granted 30 days to correct the failure, and, if the employer corrects the failure within that period, an enforcement action shall not be taken.
Background
Human trafficking, the modern day slavery, is the world’s fastest growing criminal enterprise grossing an estimated $32 billion-a-year, according to the California Department of Justice. The illegal act of human trafficking involves compelling or coercing a person to provide labor or services or to engage in commercial sex acts and may involve the use of violence (both physical and psychological), threats, lies, or debt bondage. [NOTE: Please see the Senate Labor, Public Employment and Retirement Committee policy analysis for more background information on human trafficking.]
Comments
Need for this bill? Although illegal, human trafficking is occurring in homes and workplaces throughout California every day. Many of the immigrant workers being enslaved have had their documents confiscated in order to prevent them from leaving, a practice known as “document servitude.” According to the author, in 2016, a San Diego-based couple was arrested for enslaving an Indonesian domestic worker in their home. The couple forced her to work between 16 and 18 hours a day with no pay and no days off. They abused the victim mentally and physically by retaining the worker’s passport and making her believe she would be physically harmed if she did not perform her duties. The author states that this is one of many document servitude cases that has occurred in our state, and in our country, in recent years. The author argues that with many of these human trafficking victims being immigrants, it is vital that California protect these workers by preventing unscrupulous employers from taking advantage of their immigration status.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2732 (Gonzalez, 2018) was nearly identical to this bill but also contained provisions regarding sexual harassment prevention training for janitorial workers. AB 2732 was vetoed by the Governor who stated, “Labor trafficking is a problem in our state and the provision of this bill that prohibits employers from withholding immigration documents from workers is very appropriate. However, there is additional language that requires every single employer to provide to every single employee - millions in the state-- a new and detailed list of rights related to labor trafficking. This goes too far. The vast majority of California employers have nothing to do with labor trafficking, so this mandate as applied to them is burdensome and unwarranted.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
San Diego County District Attorney, Summer Stephan (source)
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees
California District Attorneys Association
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Labor Federation
California Teachers Association
Coalition to Abolish Slavery & Trafficking
Consumer Attorneys of California
CSA San Diego County
End Violence Against Women International
Jewish Public Affairs Committee of California
Lynch Foundation for Children
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Service Employees International Union California
Building Owners and Managers Association
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Farm Bureau Federation
California League of Food Producers
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California State Council of SHRM
Commercial Real Estate Development Association
El Dorado County Joint Chamber Commission
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
International Council of Shopping Centers
National Federation of Independent Business
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Roseville Area Chamber of Commerce
United Chamber Advocacy Network
Western Growers Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to proponents, human trafficking has risen in general in the United States, with California being a primary location. Proponents argue that immigrants are especially targeted and exploited due to the sensitive nature of their immigration status. They argue that employers coerce helpless immigrants into slavery and human trafficking by threatening to destroy and/or withhold their immigration documents and passports and many are vulnerable to involuntary servitude because they do not understand their rights. They point to a 2012 San Diego State University study that found that labor trafficking largely occurs in the construction, restaurant, janitorial, and agriculture fields, which are predominantly comprised of vulnerable immigrant workers. Proponents argue that this bill is critical in ensuring that California can secure safer working environments, and enhance worker protections for all individuals.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents of this bill argue that this bill creates duplicative criminal penalties for conduct that is already criminal, and burdens employers across the state with additional notice, posting, and record keeping requirements. Opponents note that existing California Penal Code Section 236.1 already considers exactly the situation which AB 589 appears aimed at – an employer taking or concealing a victim’s immigration documents in order to compel work – and provides for more stringent punishments than AB 589 - including five or more years in prison and a fine up to $500,000. In addition, they argue, current federal law also prohibits forcing an individual to labor by withholding their passport or other immigration documents.
Regarding the posting notice, distribution of the “Worker’s Bill of Rights” form, and storing of signed records, opponents argue that these steps add to the already numerous requirements for employers related to new employees and simply is not necessary in light of existing legal protections. They note that as Governor Brown’s veto notice of a similar passage in last year’s AB 2732 noted: “the vast majority of California employers have nothing to do with labor trafficking, so this mandate as applied to them is burdensome and unwarranted.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 65-6, 5/6/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Brough, Dahle, Kiley, Mathis, Obernolte, Voepel
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Bigelow, Chen, Cooper, Fong, Gray, Melendez, Patterson, Salas
Prepared by: Alma Perez-Schwab / L., P.E. & R. / (916) 651-1556
9/5/19 15:39:42
**** END ****
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 589 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 589
Amended: 4/25/19 in Assembly
SENATE LABOR, PUB. EMP. & RET. COMMITTEE: 4-0, 6/12/19
AYES: Hill, Jackson, Mitchell, Pan
NO VOTE RECORDED: Morrell
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-2, 7/2/19
AYES: Jackson, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Borgeas, Jones
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 65-6, 5/6/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Employment: unfair immigration-related practices
SOURCE: San Diego County District Attorney, Summer Stephan
DIGEST:
This bill makes it unlawful for an employer to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess any passport or other immigration-related document of another person in the course of committing, or with the intent to commit, trafficking, peonage, slavery, involuntary servitude, or a coercive labor practice. This bill provides that violations of this unlawful employment practice would result in a misdemeanor and a $10,000 civil penalty, in addition to any fine that may be levied as a result of any criminal prosecution. This bill also requires employers to post a notice in the workplace with information including the right to maintain custody and control of immigration-related documents. Finally, this bill requires employers to provide employees with a “Worker’s Bill of Rights,” in multiple languages, setting forth labor laws and protections against human trafficking.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Requires, under the Immigration and Nationality Act, an employer to verify, through examination of specified documents, whether or not an individual is authorized to work in the United States. Specifies that if the document is presented and reasonably appears on its face to be genuine, then the employer has complied with this requirement and is not required to solicit or demand any other document. (8 U.S.C. §1324a(b))
- Prohibits anyone to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess an actual or purported passport or other immigration document, or any other actual or purported government identification of another person in the course of committing or with intent to commit various crimes involving servitude, trafficking, and coercive labor practices. (18 U.S.C. §1592)
- Specifies that a person who deprives or violates the personal liberty of another with the intent to obtain forced labor or services, and is guilty of human trafficking and shall be punished by imprisonment in the state prison for five, eight, or 12 years and a fine of not more than $500,000. (Penal Code §236.1)
- Prohibits an employer or any other person or entity from engaging in, or directing another person or entity to engage in, an unfair immigration-related practice, as defined, against any person for the purpose of retaliating against that person for exercising his or her rights under state or local labor law. (Labor Code §1019 (a))
- Defines "unfair immigration-related practice," for purposes of state law, to mean any of the following practices when undertaken for retaliatory purposes, and not at the direction or request of the federal government (Labor Code §1019 (b)):
- Requesting more or different documents than are required by federal law or refusing to honor required documents that on their face appear to be genuine.
- Using the federal E-Verify system to check the employment authorization status of a person at a time or in a manner not required or authorized by federal law.
- Threatening to file or filing of a false police report, threatening to file or filing a false report or complaint with any state or federal agency, threatening to contact or contacting immigration authorities.
- Permits an employee or any other person who is subject to an unfair immigration-related practice, where the unfair practice is retaliatory in nature, to bring a civil action for equitable relief and any applicable damages or penalties, and specifies that an employee or other person who prevails shall recover his or her reasonable attorney's fees. (Labor Code §1019(d))
- Prohibits an employer, in the course of satisfying federal immigration law, from requesting more or different documents than are required under federal immigration law; refusing to honor valid documents, as specified; or attempting to reinvestigate or reverify an incumbent employee's authorization to work using an unfair immigration-related practice. Violation of these provisions is subject penalties imposed by the Labor Commissioner, up to $10,000 per violation, and equitable relief. (Labor Code §1019.1)
- Requires employers to display posters in conspicuous locations which describe certain labor laws and worker rights around issues such as paid sick leave and whistleblower protections. (Labor Code §247 and §1102.8(a))
This bill:
- Makes it an unlawful employment practice for an employer to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess any actual or purported passport or other immigration document of another person in the course of committing, or with the intent to commit, trafficking, peonage, slavery, involuntary servitude, a coercive labor practice.
- Specifies that a violation of this unlawful employment practice results in:
- A misdemeanor; and
- A $10,000 civil penalty recoverable by the Labor Commissioner, in addition to any fine that may be levied as a result of any criminal prosecution.
- Requires employers to post, as specified, a prescribed workplace notice with information including an employee’s right to maintain custody and control of immigration documents and that the withholding of these documents by the employer is a crime as well as the contact information for the National Human Trafficking Hotline.
- Specifies that in enacting these provisions, the Legislature does not intend to preclude a prosecution under the labor trafficking provisions or other laws prohibiting the mistreatment of workers generally, or any other civil remedy available at law or equity.
- Requires the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) to, on or before July 1, 2020, develop a document entitled the “Worker’s Bill of Rights,” to inform employees of:
- Their right to hold on to their own immigration and identification documents and that an employer cannot take those documents, except as specified.
- Their right to be paid the mandatory minimum wage or other wage, as specified.
- Their right to live wherever the employee chooses, unless living in employer-provided housing is agreed upon as a lawful condition of employment and living on the premises is customary and necessary to the duties of employment.
- Their right not to be subject to debt bondage in lieu of being paid wages owed.
- Their right to call local or federal authorities, or the National Human Trafficking Hotline if the employer or anyone else is controlling the employee’s movement, documents, or wages, or using threats against the employee or their family.
- Requires DIR to make the “Worker’s Bill of Rights” document available on its Internet Web site for download by employers by July 1, 2020, and make it available in English and translated into the 12 languages most commonly spoken in this state, as specified.
- Requires employers to provide employees hired on or after July 1, 2020, with the “Worker’s Bill of Rights” document before verifying an employee’s employment authorization. For employees hired before July 1, 2020, requires employers to provide each employee with the document when it is made available by DIR.
- Requires employers to provide the “Worker’s Bill of Rights” document in a language understood by the employee, as specified, and requires that the employee sign and date it in acknowledgment that the employee has read and understands his/her rights.
- Requires employers to keep the signed document in its records for a period of no less than three years and give a copy of the signed document to the employee.
Background
Human trafficking, the modern day slavery, is the world’s fastest growing criminal enterprise grossing an estimated $32 billion-a-year, according to the California Department of Justice. The illegal act of human trafficking involves compelling or coercing a person to provide labor or services or to engage in commercial sex acts and may involve the use of violence (both physical and psychological), threats, lies, or debt bondage. [NOTE: Please see the Senate Labor, Public Employment and Retirement Committee policy analysis for more background information on human trafficking.]
Comments
Need for this bill? Although illegal, human trafficking is occurring in homes and workplaces throughout California every day. Many of the immigrant workers being enslaved have had their documents confiscated in order to prevent them from leaving, a practice known as “document servitude.” According to the author, in 2016, a San Diego-based couple was arrested for enslaving an Indonesian domestic worker in their home. The couple forced her to work between 16 and 18 hours a day with no pay and no days off. They abused the victim mentally and physically by retaining the worker’s passport and making her believe she would be physically harmed if she did not perform her duties. The author states that this is one of many document servitude cases that has occurred in our state, and in our country, in recent years. The author argues that with many of these human trafficking victims being immigrants, it is vital that California protect these workers by preventing unscrupulous employers from taking advantage of their immigration status.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2732 (Gonzalez, 2018) was nearly identical to this bill but also contained provisions regarding sexual harassment prevention training for janitorial workers. AB 2732 was vetoed by the Governor who stated, “Labor trafficking is a problem in our state and the provision of this bill that prohibits employers from withholding immigration documents from workers is very appropriate. However, there is additional language that requires every single employer to provide to every single employee - millions in the state-- a new and detailed list of rights related to labor trafficking. This goes too far. The vast majority of California employers have nothing to do with labor trafficking, so this mandate as applied to them is burdensome and unwarranted.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
San Diego County District Attorney, Summer Stephan (source)
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees
California District Attorneys Association
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Labor Federation
California Teachers Association
Coalition to Abolish Slavery & Trafficking
Consumer Attorneys of California
CSA San Diego County
End Violence Against Women International
Jewish Public Affairs Committee
Lynch Foundation for Children
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Service Employees International Union California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/12/19)
Building Owners and Managers Association
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Farm Bureau Federation
California League of Food Producers
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California State Council of SHRM
Commercial Real Estate Development Association
El Dorado County Joint Chamber Commission
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
International Council of Shopping Centers
National Federation of Independent Business
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Roseville Area Chamber of Commerce
United Chamber Advocacy Network
Western Growers Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to proponents, human trafficking has risen in general in the United States, with California being a primary location. Proponents argue that immigrants are especially targeted and exploited due to the sensitive nature of their immigration status. They argue that employers coerce helpless immigrants into slavery and human trafficking by threatening to destroy and/or withhold their immigration documents and passports and many are vulnerable to involuntary servitude because they do not understand their rights. They point to a 2012 San Diego State University study that found that labor trafficking largely occurs in the construction, restaurant, janitorial, and agriculture fields, which are predominantly comprised of vulnerable immigrant workers. Proponents argue that this bill is critical in ensuring that California can secure safer working environments, and enhance worker protections for all individuals.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: Opponents of this bill argue that this bill creates duplicative criminal penalties for conduct that is already criminal, and burdens employers across the state with additional notice, posting, and record keeping requirements. Opponents note that existing California Penal Code Section 236.1 already considers exactly the situation which AB 589 appears aimed at – an employer taking or concealing a victim’s immigration documents in order to compel work – and provides for more stringent punishments than AB 589 - including five or more years in prison and a fine up to $500,000. In addition, they argue, current federal law also prohibits forcing an individual to labor by withholding their passport or other immigration documents.
Regarding the posting notice, distribution of the “Worker’s Bill of Rights” form, and storing of signed records, opponents argue that these steps add to the already numerous requirements for employers related to new employees and simply is not necessary in light of existing legal protections. They note that as Governor Brown’s veto notice of a similar passage in last year’s AB 2732 noted: “the vast majority of California employers have nothing to do with labor trafficking, so this mandate as applied to them is burdensome and unwarranted.”
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 65-6, 5/6/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Choi, Chu, Cooley, Cunningham, Daly, Diep, Eggman, Flora, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Cristina Garcia, Eduardo Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Lackey, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, Mayes, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Waldron, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Brough, Dahle, Kiley, Mathis, Obernolte, Voepel
NO VOTE RECORDED: Arambula, Bigelow, Chen, Cooper, Fong, Gray, Melendez, Patterson, Salas
Prepared by: Alma Perez-Schwab / L., P.E. & R. / (916) 651-1556
8/14/19 15:45:45
**** END ****
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 589 (Author:Gonzalez)
Version: April 25, 2019
Hearing Date: July 2, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: TSG
SUBJECT
Employment: unfair immigration-related practices
DIGEST
This bill makes it unlawful and criminally punishable for an employer to confiscate the passport or other immigration-related documents of an employee. It would also require employers to post a notice to this effect in the workplace. Finally, the bill would require employers to provide employees with a bill of rights, in multiple languages, setting forth labor laws and protections against human trafficking.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Despite legislation prohibiting it and law enforcement initiatives to stamp it out, a modern-day version of slavery persists. “Document servitude” refers to one common method by which people gain this kind of control over others. In document servitude scenarios, perpetrators lure victims to come work or live in the United States. Once here, the perpetrators confiscate the victims’ documents: things like passports, identification cards, work permits, and the like. The perpetrators then threaten to turn the victims over to Immigration and Customs Enforcement, the police, or other authorities if the victim does not do exactly what the perpetrators say. Frightened and unsure of the consequences of trying to seek help, some victims remain controlled and exploited for years. This bill seeks to address the problem by adding penalties for the confiscation of documents and by trying to spread awareness about people’s rights through the mandatory distribution of a worker’s bill of rights to all employees at the time of hire.
The bill is sponsored by the San Diego District Attorney’s Office. Support is from organized labor, human trafficking prevention organizations, and immigrant rights advocates. Opposition is from employers and various business associations who argue that requiring distribution of a worker’s bill of rights would be burdensome and would not achieve the intended result. The bill passed out of the Senate Labor, Public Employment and Retirement Committee by a vote of 4-0.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing federal law:
- Requires an employer, under the Immigration and Nationality Act, to verify, through examination of specified documents, whether or not an individual is authorized to work in the United States. So long as the document is presented and reasonably appears on its face to be genuine, then the employer has complied with this requirement and is not required to solicit or demand any other document. (8 U.S.C. § 1324a(b).)
- Prohibits anyone to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess an actual or purported passport or other immigration document, or any other actual or purported government identification of another person in the course of committing or with intent to commit various crimes involving servitude, trafficking, and coercive labor practices. (18 U.S.C. § 1592.)
- Makes it an unfair immigration-related employment practice for any person or entity to do any of the following:
- discriminate against any individual, except as provided, with respect to the hiring, recruitment, or referral of the individual for employment or the discharging of the individual from employment because of the individual’s origin or citizenship; and
- request, with the intent of discriminating against an individual, more or different documents than are required under law or refuse to honor documents tendered which, on their face, reasonably appear to be genuine. (8 U.S.C. § 1324b(a)(1)-(6).)
Existing state law:
- Provides that all protections, rights, and remedies available under state law, except any reinstatement remedy prohibited by federal law, are available to all individuals regardless of immigration status who have applied for employment, or who are or who have been employed, in this state. For purposes of enforcing state labor and employment laws, existing law provides that a person’s immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability, and in proceedings or discovery undertaken to enforce those state laws, no inquiry shall be permitted into a person’s immigration status except where the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law. (Lab. Code § 1171.5; Civ. Code § 3339; Gov. Code § 7285; Health & Saf. Code § 24000.)
- Specifies that a person who deprives or violates the personal liberty of another with the intent to obtain forced labor or services is guilty of human trafficking, and shall be punished by imprisonment in the state prison for five, eight, or 12 years and a fine of not more than $500,000. (Pen. Code § 236.1.)
- Prohibits an employer or any other person or entity from engaging in, or directing another person or entity to engage in, an unfair immigration-related practice, as defined, against any person for the purpose of retaliating against that person for exercising their rights under state or local labor law. (Lab. Code § 1019(a).)
- Defines “unfair immigration-related practice,” for purposes of state law, to mean any of the following practices when undertaken for retaliatory purposes, and not at the direction or request of the federal government:
- requesting more or different documents than are required by federal law or refusing to honor required documents that on their face appear to be genuine;
- using the federal E-Verify system to check the employment authorization status of a person at a time or in a manner not required or authorized by federal law; or
- threatening to file or filing of a false police report, threatening to file or filing a false report or complaint with any state or federal agency, or threatening to contact or contacting immigration authorities. (Lab. Code § 1019(b).)
- Permits an employee or any other person who is subject to an unfair immigration-related practice, where the unfair practice is retaliatory in nature, to bring a civil action for equitable relief and any applicable damages or penalties, and specifies that an employee or other person who prevails shall recover their reasonable attorney’s fees. (Lab. Code § 1019(d).)
- Prohibits an employer, in the course of satisfying federal immigration law, from requesting more or different documents than are required under federal immigration law; refusing to honor valid documents, as specified; or attempting to reinvestigate or re-verify an incumbent employee’s authorization to work using an unfair immigration-related practice. (Lab. Code § 1019.1.)
- Requires employers to display posters in conspicuous locations which describe certain labor laws and workers’ rights around issues such as paid sick leave and whistleblower protections. (Lab. Code §§ 247 and 1102.8(a).)
This bill:
- Makes it unlawful for an employer to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess any actual or purported passport or other immigration document, or any other actual or purported government identification document of another person in the course of committing, or with the intent to commit, trafficking, peonage, slavery, involuntary servitude, or a coercive labor practice. The bill would authorize the Labor Commissioner to issue a citation for a violation and impose civil and criminal penalties, as specified.
- Requires an employer to post in a conspicuous and effective location a notice specifying the rights of an employee to maintain custody and control of the employee’s own immigration documents. Advises employees whose employer has unlawfully held documents to call a federal human trafficking hotline.
- Requires the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) to develop a document entitled “Worker’s Bill of Rights” on or before July 1, 2020. Requires the document to enumerate certain rights, including, among others, the right of an employee to hold on to the employee’s own immigration and identification documents. Requires DIR to translate the document into the 12 most commonly-spoken languages in California, in addition to English, and to make the document available on its website for download by employers.
- Requires an employer to provide any employee hired on or after July 1, 2020, with a copy of the worker’s bill of rights before verifying an employee’s authorization to work in the United States. For employees hired before July 1, 2020, the employer shall provide the document to each employee once DIR makes the document available.
COMMENTS
- Background on modern forms of human slavery and document servitude
According to a California Department of Justice report on the subject, human trafficking, the modern day equivalent of slavery, is the world’s fastest growing criminal enterprise, grossing an estimated $32 billion a year. Of the 8,524 cases of human trafficking reported across the United States in 2017, 1,305 cases of human trafficking were reported in California. A study by the Human Rights Center at UC Berkeley identified 57 forced labor operations in almost a dozen cities throughout California, involving more than 500 individuals from 18 countries.[1]
One key strategy that human traffickers use to manipulate the people they are enslaving is document servitude. Document servitude refers to confiscating someone’s passport or immigration-related documents, demanding that the person work to “earn” the documents back, and threatening to turn the person over to law enforcement or immigration authorities if they do not. Language barriers and physical isolation help make this technique work. Deprived of outside contact and unsure of their rights, victims of trafficking become totally dependent on the person to whom they are enslaved.
Human trafficking, false imprisonment, and involuntary servitude are all already prohibited by California law. Nonetheless, this bill seeks to cut down on document servitude, specifically, by making it a distinct act with its own civil and criminal penalties. Specifically, holding someone in document servitude would be both a criminal misdemeanor and subject to a civil penalty of $10,000.
In addition, to try to help prevent incidents of document servitude from happening in the first place, the bill would require employers to do two things to promote worker awareness. First, the bill would require all employers to conspicuously post a notice regarding employees’ right to maintain control of their immigration documents at all times. Second, the bill would require employers to provide all employees with a copy of a worker’s bill of rights document in English and the 12 other languages most commonly spoken in California, to be developed by the DIR.
2. Examples of the problem the bill is intended to address
As evidence of the problem that this bill is intended to address, the author points to the following incidents, as reported in the media.
A young Egyptian woman was sold into slavery by her parents to a man who then moved her and his family to Irvine in 2000. The young woman was forced to work as a servant for seven family members without pay for up to 20 hours a day. In 2002, after 16 months in California, an anonymous tip to police resulted in her being freed. The man and his wife were arrested and imprisoned on federal slavery charges.[2]
In 2016, federal agents arrested an El Cajon couple for enslaving an Indonesian domestic worker in their home. According to the allegations, the couple forced her to work between 16 and 18 hours a day with no pay and no days off. They abused the victim mentally and physically by retaining the worker’s passport and making her believe she would be physically harmed if she did not perform her duties. [3]
In August 2017, federal agents rescued nearly a dozen immigrant workers from a building in Hayward. According to media reports, the men had been held in the building at night, which was locked from the outside and lacked running water. During the day, a man would take them to construction projects throughout the Bay Area, but paid them less than minimum wage or nothing at all.[4]
3. The requirement to provide a worker’s bill of rights
As mentioned previously, this bill would require employers to provide their employees with a worker’s bill of rights document. To help ensure that employers actually fulfill this requirement, the bill further requires employers to have the employee sign and date the document, indicating receipt of it. The bill then instructs employers to keep this signed version of the worker’s bill of rights in its records for at least three years, while also giving a copy back to the employee.
In theory, at least, this requirement ensures that employees receive information about some of their most basic workplace rights, as well as contact information for how to seek help. In practice, it is hard to imagine that someone malevolent enough to enslave others would also turn out to be a close adherent to the finer points of employment law and human resources management. This is part of what motivates the opponents’ view that the bill imposes bureaucratic burdens without necessarily achieving its stated intent.
4. Language access provisions
The bill requires the DIR to develop a worker’s bill of rights in English and translate it into “the 12 languages most commonly spoken in this state by non-English-speaking people or people with limited English language proficiency.” It is not clear how DIR is to determine which 12 languages these are, but presumably DIR can work that out. Employers must then give the worker’s bill of rights to the employee in the language understood by the employee, or, if that is not English or one of the 12 languages into which DIR has translated the worker’s bill of rights then the employer must have the document interpreted for the employee. This is a very thorough effort to ensure that the information provided in the worker’s bill of rights reaches the populations it is intended to help, who are often isolated linguistically as well as physically. Here again, however, it is a bit hard to imagine that the employer who would go through the effort to comply with these language requirements is the sort of employer who would also confiscate documents in order to enslave someone. From the opponents’ point of view, therefore, this aspect of the bill largely imposes a new human resources processing requirement without necessarily adding any true benefit.
5. The worker’s bill of rights must be received before the employer verifies the employee’s authorization to work
The bill requires that employers provide each employee with a copy of a worker’s bill of rights document development by DIR. To ensure that employees receive this information in a timely fashion, the bill specifies that requirement to provide the copy of the worker’s bill of rights must be fulfilled before conducting the I-9 work authorization verification process. Employers are supposed to conduct the I-9 process within three days after the employee starts work, so this requirement would ensure that workers received the worker’s bill of rights very soon after starting. Also, because employees must hand over certain official documents to the employer for inspection during the I-9 process, it is a key moment at which employers could potentially try to confiscate documents from the employee.
6. Arguments in support of the bill
According to the author:
AB 589 helps protect workers against the immoral practice of “document servitude” […]
While State and Federal law has labor trafficking penalties (Penal Code Section 236.1/U.S. Code Chapter 77 Title 18) for those that would deprive another of their personal liberty to obtain forced labor, this bill would create an additional penalty misdemeanor for withholding documents so that the practice is discouraged. This bill will prohibit the retention of immigration documents with the intent to manipulate or traffic labor. This will provide additional tools for prosecutors to protect victims and potential victims of labor trafficking and go after labor traffickers.
As sponsor of the bill, the San Diego District Attorney’s Office writes:
Document servitude is a serious issue for workers in California. Unscrupulous employers confiscate and withhold immigrants’ passports and legal documents, thereby making it virtually impossible for foreign works to find legitimate employment or even escape their situation. AB 589 provides a strategic framework that will hold accountable those employers who engage in this nefarious activity while providing labor trafficking victims a civil remedy.
In support, the California Labor Federation writes:
In California, existing law makes it illegal to partake in labor trafficking, false imprisonment, and involuntary servitude. However, these laws have not completely stopped these practices from continuing. […] According to the National Human Trafficking Resource Center, more cases of human trafficking were reported in California than in any other state. With many of these human trafficking victims coerced into labor being immigrants, it is vital that California protect these workers by preventing unscrupulous employers from taking advantage of their immigration status.
7. Arguments in opposition to the bill
In opposition to the bill, the California Chamber of Commerce and 19 co-signatories write:
To be clear, the employer community takes very seriously any acts which violate workers’ rights to lawful treatment in the workplace. While we understand the intent of this bill and support efforts to end human trafficking and any form of discrimination in the workplace, AB 589 creates unreasonable burdens for employers, who are already required to inundate new employees with forms at the time of hiring and duplicative criminal liability. […] Though our coalition agrees that this conduct should be criminal, we would like to note that it already is a crime. […] Employers of all sizes, but especially small business owners, struggle to comply with a wide array of documentation and signage requirements, and this bill seeks to impose additional, burdensome requirements upon them, along with additional unintended civil and criminal penalties.
SUPPORT
San Diego County District Attorney’s Office (sponsor)
California District Attorneys Association
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Labor Federation
California Teachers Association
Coalition to Abolish Slavery & Trafficking
Consumer Attorneys of California
CSA San Diego
Jewish Public Affairs Committee of California
Lynch Foundation for Children
National Association of Social Workers – California Chapter
Service Employees International Union – California
OPPOSITION
Building Owners and Managers Association
California Association of Wine Grape Growers
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Farm Bureau Federation
California League of Food Producers
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California State Council of the Society for Human Resource Management
Commercial Real Estate Development Association
El Dorado Joint Chamber Commission
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
International Council of Shopping Centers
National Federation of Independent Business
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Roseville Area Chamber of Commerce
United Chamber Advocacy Network
Western Growers Association
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
AB 828 (Ting, 2019) creates an evidentiary privilege for human trafficking caseworkers in relation to human trafficking victims. AB 828 is currently pending consideration before the Senate Public Safety Committee.
AB 959 (Melendez, 2019) would have provided funding for vertical handling of human trafficking prosecutions. AB 959 was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
AB 1735 (Bauer-Kahan) creates an evidentiary privilege for human trafficking caseworkers in relation to human trafficking victims. AB 1735 is currently pending consideration before the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Prior Legislation:
SR 11 (Leyva, 2019) recognized January as National Slavery and Human Trafficking Prevention month.
AB 2732 (Gonzalez, 2018) was nearly identical to this bill. In his message vetoing AB 2732, Governor Brown wrote:
Labor trafficking is a problem in our state and the provision of this bill that prohibits employers from withholding immigration documents from workers is very appropriate.
However, there is additional language that requires every single employer to provide to every single employee - millions in the state-- a new and detailed list of rights related to labor trafficking. This goes too far. The vast majority of California employers have nothing to do with labor trafficking, so this mandate as applied to them is burdensome and unwarranted.
SB 970 (Atkins, Ch. 842, Stats. 2018) amended the Fair Employment and Housing Act to require hotel and other lodging employers to provide at least 20 minutes of prescribed training and education regarding human trafficking awareness to employees who are likely to interact or come into contact with victims of human trafficking.
SB 1001 (Mitchell, Ch. 782, Stats. 2016) prohibited an employer from requesting more or different employment authorization documents than are required under federal law, refusing to honor documents tendered, refusing to honor documents or work authorization based upon the specific status or the term of status accompanying the authorization, or reinvestigating or re-verifying an incumbent employee’s authorization to work.
AB 622 (Hernández, Ch. 696, Stats. 2015) expanded the definition of an unlawful employment practice to prohibit the use of the E-Verify system at a time or in a manner not required by federal law to check the employment authorization status of an existing employee or an applicant for employment.
AB 263 (Hernández, Ch. 732, Stats. 2013) expanded the scope of employment-based retaliation to include immigration-related practices and provided a civil cause of action for employees who are subject to such practices.
AB 241 (Ammiano, Ch. 374, Stats. 2013) known as the “Domestic Worker Bill of Rights,” established protections and regulated the hours, wages, and working conditions of domestic work employees.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Labor, Public Employment and Retirement Committee (Ayes 4, Noes 0)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 65, Noes 6)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 14, Noes 1)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 10, Noes 2)
Assembly Labor and Employment Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 0)
**************
Tuller, Fletcher, and Stover, Freedom Denied: Forced Labor in California (2005) University of California Human Rights Center https://escholarship.org/uc/item/1q46h64w (as of Jun. 15, 2019) at p. 1. ↑
Walters, The Slave Next Door: 21st century California Still Has Humans in Bondage (May 22, 2017) Sacramento Bee http://www.sacbee.com/news/politics-government/politics-columns-blogs/dan-walters/article152058722.html (as of Jun. 15, 2019). ↑
Zavadski, Feds: San Diego Couple Enslaved Their Maid (Apr. 11, 2016) The Daily Beast https://www.thedailybeast.com/feds-san-diego-couple-enslaved-their-maid (as of Jun. 15, 2019). ↑
Cahillane, Federal Agents Rescue Nearly a Dozen Immigrant Construction Workers in California Who Were Locked Up in Warehouses and Forced to Work for Free (Aug. 30, 2017) The Daily Mail http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-4837550/Prosecutors-Workers-rescued-forced-labor-California.html (as of Jun. 15, 2019). ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR, PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Senator Jerry Hill, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: AB 589 Hearing Date: June 12, 2019
Author: | Gonzalez | ||
Version: | April 25, 2019 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Alma Perez-Schwab | ||
SUBJECT: Employment: unfair immigration-related practices
KEY ISSUES
Should it be unlawful for an employer to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess any passport or other immigration document of another person in the course of committing, or intent to commit, trafficking, peonage, slavery, involuntary servitude, or a coercive labor practice?
Should employers who violate these provisions be subject to a misdemeanor and a civil penalty of up to $10,000?
Should the Legislature require the Department of Industrial Relations to develop a “Worker’s Bill of Rights” document available to employers for distribution to employees and posting?
ANALYSIS
Existing federal law:
- Under the Immigration and Nationality Act, requires an employer to verify, through examination of specified documents, whether or not an individual is authorized to work in the United States. Specifies that if the document is presented and reasonably appears on its face to be genuine, then the employer has complied with this requirement and is not required to solicit or demand any other document. [8 U.S.C. §1324a(b)]
- Prohibits anyone to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess an actual or purported passport or other immigration document, or any other actual or purported government identification of another person in the course of committing or with intent to commit various crimes involving servitude, trafficking, and coercive labor practices.
(18 U.S.C. §1592)
- Makes it an unfair immigration-related employment practice for any person or entity to do any of the following [8 U.S.C. §1324b(a)(1)-(6)]:
- Discriminate against any individual, except as provided, with respect to the hiring, recruitment, or referral of the individual for employment or the discharging of the individual from employment because of the individual’s origin or citizenship.
- Request, with the intent of discriminating against an individual, more or different documents than are required under law or refuse to honor documents tendered which, on their face, reasonably appear to be genuine.
Existing state law:
- Provides that all protections, rights, and remedies available under state law, except any reinstatement remedy prohibited by federal law, are available to all individuals regardless of immigration status who have applied for employment, or who are or who have been employed, in this state. For purposes of enforcing state labor and employment laws, existing law provides that a person’s immigration status is irrelevant to the issue of liability, and in proceedings or discovery undertaken to enforce those state laws, no inquiry shall be permitted into a person’s immigration status except where the person seeking to make this inquiry has shown by clear and convincing evidence that the inquiry is necessary in order to comply with federal immigration law. (Lab. Code §1171.5; Civil Code §3339; Gov. Code §7285; Health & Safety Code §24000)
- Specifies that a person who deprives or violates the personal liberty of another with the intent to obtain forced labor or services, and is guilty of human trafficking and shall be punished by imprisonment in the state prison for 5, 8, or 12 years and a fine of not more than five hundred thousand dollars ($500,000). (Penal Code §236.1)
- Prohibits an employer or any other person or entity from engaging in, or directing another person or entity to engage in, an unfair immigration-related practice, as defined, against any person for the purpose of retaliating against that person for exercising his or her rights under state or local labor law. [Labor Code §1019 (a)]
- Defines "unfair immigration-related practice," for purposes of state law, to mean any of the following practices when undertaken for retaliatory purposes, and not at the direction or request of the federal government [Labor Code §1019 (b)]:
- Requesting more or different documents than are required by federal law or refusing to honor required documents that on their face appear to be genuine.
- Using the federal E-Verify system to check the employment authorization status of a person at a time or in a manner not required or authorized by federal law.
- Threatening to file or filing of a false police report, threatening to file or filing a false report or complaint with any state or federal agency, or threatening to contact or contacting immigration authorities.
- Permits an employee or any other person who is subject to an unfair immigration-related practice, where the unfair practice is retaliatory in nature, to bring a civil action for equitable relief and any applicable damages or penalties, and specifies that an employee or other person who prevails shall recover his or her reasonable attorney's fees. [Labor Code §1019(d)]
- Prohibits an employer, in the course of satisfying federal immigration law, from requesting more or different documents than are required under federal immigration law; refusing to honor valid documents, as specified; or attempting to reinvestigate or reverify an incumbent employee's authorization to work using an unfair immigration-related practice. Violation of these provisions is subject penalties imposed by the Labor Commissioner, up to $10,000 per violation, and equitable relief. (Labor Code §1019.1)
- Requires employers to display posters in conspicuous locations which describe certain labor laws and worker rights around issues such as paid sick leave and whistleblower protections. [Labor Code §247 and §1102.8(a)]
This bill:
- Makes it an unlawful employment practice for an employer to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess any actual or purported passport or other immigration document of another person in the course of committing, or with the intent to commit, trafficking, peonage, slavery, involuntary servitude, a coercive labor practice.
- Specifies that a violation of this unlawful employment practice results in:
- a misdemeanor; and
- a $10,000 civil penalty recoverable by the Labor Commissioner, in addition to any fine that may be levied as a result of any criminal prosecution.
- Requires employers to post, as specified, a prescribed workplace notice with information including an employee’s right to maintain custody and control of immigration documents and that the withholding of these documents by the employer is a crime as well as the contact information for the National Human Trafficking Hotline.
- Specifies that in enacting these provisions, the Legislature does not intend to preclude a prosecution under the labor trafficking provisions or other laws prohibiting the mistreatment of workers generally, or any other civil remedy available at law or equity.
- Requires the Department of Industrial Relations to, on or before July 1, 2020, develop a document entitled the “Worker’s Bill of Rights,” to inform employees of:
- Their right to hold on to their own immigration and identification documents and that an employer cannot take those documents, except as specified.
- Their right to be paid the mandatory minimum wage or other wage, as specified.
- Their right to live wherever the employee chooses, unless living in employer-provided housing is agreed upon as a lawful condition of employment and living on the premises is customary and necessary to the duties of employment.
- Their right not to be subject to debt bondage in lieu of being paid wages owed.
- Their right to call local or federal authorities, or the National Human Trafficking Hotline if the employer or anyone else is controlling the employee’s movement, documents, or wages, or using threats against the employee or their family.
- Requires DIR to make the “Worker’s Bill of Rights” document available on its internet website for download by employers by July 1, 2020 and make it available in English and translated into the 12 languages most commonly spoken in this state, as specified.
- Requires employers to provide employees hired on or after July 1, 2020 with the “Worker’s Bill of Rights” document before verifying an employee’s employment authorization. For employees hired before July 1, 2020, requires employers to provide each employee with the document when it is made available by DIR.
- Requires employers to provide the “Worker’s Bill of Rights” document in a language understood by the employee, as specified, and requires that the employee sign and date it in acknowledgment that the employee has read and understands his/her rights.
- Requires employers to keep the signed document in its records for a period of no less than three years and give a copy of the signed document to the employee.
COMMENTS
1. Background on Human Trafficking:
Human trafficking, the modern day slavery, is the world’s fastest growing criminal enterprise grossing an estimated $32 billion-a-year, according to the California Department of Justice. The illegal act of human trafficking involves compelling or coercing a person to provide labor or services or to engage in commercial sex acts and may involve the use of violence (both physical and psychological), threats, lies, or debt bondage.
Although often perceived as a sex industry, human trafficking is found in many forms of servitude from slave labor in the fields and sweatshops to domestic workers, restaurant workers, janitors, factory workers and even begging rings. Often marked by crowded and unsanitary living conditions, perpetrators exert almost total control over their victims, creating a situation of dependency leaving victims terrified of their captors but also afraid of law enforcement. Many times victims have been lured into forced labor by the promise of a better life in the United States and once here, their immigration documents (if any) are snatched and they are enslaved, forced to work for hours on end with no escape or salvation.
According to the California Department of Justice, the United States is widely regarded as a destination country for human trafficking with federal reports estimating 14,500-17,500 victims being trafficked into the country annually (not including the number of victims trafficked within the United States). According to the National Human Trafficking Hotline (NHTH), which maintains one of the most extensive data sets on the issue, in 2017 they received 26,557 calls resulting in 8,524 human trafficking cases reported. California, with its diverse cultural center is a popular destination and one of the largest sites of human trafficking in the country. Of the 8,524 cases reported countrywide in 2017, 1,305 cases of human trafficking were reported in California. Of those cases, 1,009 were sex trafficking cases, 167 were labor trafficking cases, 63 involved both labor and sex trafficking, and in 66 cases the type of trafficking was not specified.
2. Need for this bill?
As noted above, federal law prohibits employers from withholding or destroying immigration or identification documents in the course of committing, or with the intent to commit, human trafficking or coercive labor practices. Various state laws prohibit unfair immigration-related employment practices and require employers to post various notices about rights and protections afforded to employees in the workplace. Although illegal, human trafficking is occurring in homes and workplaces throughout California every day. Many of the immigrant workers being enslaved have had their documents confiscated in order to prevent them from leaving, a practice known as “document servitude.”
According to the author, in 2016, a San Diego-based couple was arrested for enslaving an Indonesian domestic worker in their home. The couple forced her to work between 16 and 18 hours a day with no pay and no days off. They abused the victim mentally and physically by retaining the worker’s passport and making her believe she would be physically harmed if she did not perform her duties. The author states that this is one of many document servitude cases that has occurred in our state, and in our country, in recent years.
The author argues that with many of these human trafficking victims being immigrants, it is vital that California protect these workers by preventing unscrupulous employers from taking advantage of their immigration status. This bill helps protect workers against the immoral practice of “document servitude” by: 1) providing a framework to hold employers accountable who engage in “document servitude” and creating a misdemeanor crime for this tactic; 2) bringing the practice of “document servitude” in line with other unlawful employment practices; and 3) establishing a “Worker’s Bill of Rights.”
3. Proponent Arguments:
According to proponents, human trafficking has risen in general in the United States, with California being a primary location. Proponents argue that immigrants are especially targeted and exploited due to the sensitive nature of their immigration status. They argue that employers coerce helpless immigrants into slavery and human trafficking by threatening to destroy and/or withhold their immigration documents and passports and many are vulnerable to involuntary servitude because they do not understand their rights. Proponents point to a 2012 San Diego State University study that found that labor trafficking largely occurs in the construction, restaurant, janitorial, and agriculture fields, which are predominantly comprised of vulnerable immigrant workers.
Proponents argue that it is vital that California protect these workers by preventing unethical employers from taking advantage of their immigration status. This bill would bring the practice of document servitude in line with other unlawful employment practices like wage theft, discriminatory hiring, and retaliatory actions against employees who assert their rights under the Labor Code. It would provide a framework to hold employers accountable who engage in document servitude by imposing civil and criminal penalties, and would establish a “Worker’s Bill of Rights” to inform employees of their rights, including the ability to call local or federal authorities if an employer is controlling their movements, documents, or wages. They assert that this bill is critical in ensuring that California can secure safer working environments, and enhance worker protections for all individuals.
4. Opponent Arguments:
Opponents of the measure argue that the bill creates duplicative criminal penalties for conduct that is already criminal, and burdens employers across the state with additional notice, posting, and record keeping requirements. Opponents note that existing California Penal Code Section 236.1 already considers exactly the situation which AB 589 appears aimed at – an employer taking or concealing a victim’s immigration documents in order to compel work – and provides for more stringent punishments than AB 589 - including 5 or more years in prison and a fine up to $500,000. In addition, they argue, current federal law also prohibits forcing an individual to labor by withholding their passport or other immigration documents.
Regarding the posting notice, distribution of the “Worker’s Bill of Rights” form, and storing of signed records, opponents argue that these steps add to the already numerous requirements for employers related to new employees and simply is not necessary in light of existing legal protections. They note that as Governor Brown’s veto notice of a similar passage in last year’s AB 2732 noted: “the vast majority of California employers have nothing to do with labor trafficking, so this mandate as applied to them is burdensome and unwarranted.” According to opponents, employers of all sizes, but especially small business owners, struggle to comply with a wide array of documentation and signage requirements, and this bill seeks to impose additional, burdensome requirements upon them, along with additional unintended civil and criminal penalties.
5. Double Referral:
This bill has been double referred and, if approved by this committee, it will be sent to the Senate Judiciary Committee for a hearing.
6. Prior and Related Legislation:
AB 2732 (Gonzalez) of 2018 was nearly identical to this measure but also contained provisions regarding sexual harassment prevention training for janitorial workers. AB 2732 was vetoed by the Governor who stated, “Labor trafficking is a problem in our state and the provision of this bill that prohibits employers from withholding immigration documents from workers is very appropriate. However, there is additional language that requires every single employer to provide to every single employee - millions in the state-- a new and detailed list of rights related to labor trafficking. This goes too far. The vast majority of California employers have nothing to do with labor trafficking, so this mandate as applied to them is burdensome and unwarranted.”
SB 1001 (Mitchell), Chapter 782, Statutes of 2016, prohibits an employer from requesting more or different employment authorization documents than are required under federal law, refusing to honor documents tendered, refusing to honor documents or work authorization based upon the specific status or the term of status accompanying the authorization, or reinvestigating or reverifying an incumbent employee’s authorization to work.
AB 622(Hernandez), Chapter 732, Statutes of 2015, expanded the definition of an unlawful employment practice to prohibit the use of the E-Verify system at a time or in a manner not required by federal law to check the employment authorization status of an existing employee or an applicant for employment.
AB 263 (Hernandez), Chapter 732, Statutes of 2013, expanded the scope of employment-based retaliation to include immigration-related practices and provided a civil cause of action for employees who are subject to such practices.
SUPPORT
San Diego County District Attorney, Summer Stephan (Sponsor)
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees
California District Attorneys Association
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Labor Federation
California Teachers Association
Coalition to Abolish Slavery & Trafficking
Consumer Attorneys of California
CSA San Diego County
End Violence Against Women International
Jewish Public Affairs Committee
Lynch Foundation for Children
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Service Employees International Union California
OPPOSITION
Building Owners and Managers Association
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Farm Bureau Federation
California League of Food Producers
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California State Council of SHRM
Commercial Real Estate Development Association
El Dorado County Joint Chamber Commission
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
International Council of Shopping Centers
National Federation of Independent Business
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Roseville Area Chamber of Commerce
United Chamber Advocacy Network
Western Growers Association
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 589
Author:(Gonzalez)
As Amended Ver:April 25, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Prohibits an employer from and imposes penalties for withholding an employee's immigration-related documents and establishes a Worker's Bill of Rights regarding freedom of movement and payment of wages.
Major Provisions
- Makes it unlawful for an employer to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess, among other things, any actual or purported passport or other immigration document of another person in the course of committing, or with the intent to commit, trafficking, peonage, slavery, involuntary servitude, or a coercive labor practice.
- Imposes specified civil and criminal penalties for violating the law and provides that they are in addition to any civil fines imposed by another statute.
- Mandates that an employer post a prescribed workplace notice with information including an employee's right to maintain custody and control of immigration documents and that the withholding of these documents by the employer is a crime.
- Requires an employer to provide to each employee a document entitled "Worker's Bill of Rights," in a language understood by the employee, either for those hired on or after July 1, 2020, at the time of verifying employment eligibility, or for those employed prior to July 1, 2020, when the document is made available, and requires that the employee sign and date it in acknowledgment that the employee has read and understands the employee's rights, as specified.
- Requires that the Worker's Bill of Rights be developed by the Department of Industrial Relations, posted on its internet website, and made available in English and in versions translated into the 12 languages most commonly spoken in this state by non-English-speaking people.
- Obligates the employer to keep the signed document in its records for at least three years and provide the employee with a copy.
COMMENTS:
Human trafficking is a form of modern slavery and includes both labor and sex trafficking. Victims are coerced, exploited, and often held against their will. According to the National Human Trafficking Resource Center, in 2018, California had 760 reported cases of human trafficking—the highest number of cases of any state. While the majority of the cases involved sex trafficking, 72 cases involved labor trafficking and were most prevalent in industries such as domestic services and agriculture.
According to the Author:
The bill "helps protect workers against the immoral practice of 'document servitude' by: 1) providing a framework to hold employers accountable who engage in 'document servitude' and creating a misdemeanor crime for this tactic; 2) bringing the practice of 'document servitude' in line with other unlawful employment practices; and 3) establishing a 'Worker's Bill of Rights.'"
Arguments in Support:
According to the Office of the San Diego County District Attorney, sponsor of the bill, this bill "is necessary to protect immigrant workers who are taken advantage of by unscrupulous employers because of their federal immigration status. Many are recruited or manipulated to enter California with work visas, but later become subject to labor abuses because of their unfamiliarity with the rights that all California workers should enjoy. A 2012 San Diego State University study estimates there are 37,000 victims of labor trafficking in our region alone. It showed that the most vulnerable immigrant workers in San Diego County were in the fields of construction, restaurants, janitorial, and agriculture.
In addition, a 2014 Urban Institute study, 'Understanding the Organization, Operation, and Victimization Process of Labor Trafficking in the United States,' reported that most of the victims entered into the United States lawfully under federal immigration law. Contrary to the stereotype that these enslaved persons had entered unlawfully, in fact, 71% of the victims entered the U.S. on a temporary VISA (H-2A, H-2B) that legally allowed them to work, but by the time they escaped, 69% were unauthorized. These studies showed that the culpable employers used a variety of physical and psychological means to control and enslave victims, including holding on to their work visas and identification documents, controlling where they lived, holding on to their wages, and leveraging the concept of debt bondage, a practice still prevalent in much of the world."
Arguments in Opposition:
A coalition of employer organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, argue in opposition that the bill is duplicative of existing prohibitions against document servitude. They state, "existing California and federal law already prohibit this conduct. CA Penal Code Section 236.1 already considers exactly the situation which AB 589 appears aimed at – an employer taking or concealing a victim's immigration documents in order to compel work – and provides for more stringent punishments than AB 589 - including 5 or more years in prison and a fine up to $500,000. In addition, current federal law (Chapter 77 of Title 18 of the U.S. Code) also prohibits forcing an individual to labor by withholding their passport or other immigration documents."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, minor and absorbable costs.
VOTES:
ASM LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT: 7-0-0
YES: Kalra, Flora, Carrillo, Diep, Gonzalez, Jones-Sawyer, Luz Rivas
ASM JUDICIARY: 10-2-0
YES: Mark Stone, Gallagher, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Kiley, Obernolte
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 14-1-3
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Diep, Eggman, Gabriel, Jones‑Sawyer, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bigelow, Brough, Fong
UPDATED:
VERSION: April 25, 2019
CONSULTANT: Megan Lane / L. & E. / (916) 319-2091 FN: 0000242
Date of Hearing: April 24, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 589
Author:(Gonzalez) – As Introduced Ver:February 14, 2019
Policy Committee: | Labor and Employment | Vote: | 7 - 0 |
Judiciary | 10 - 2 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill requires the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR), by July 1, 2020, to develop a “Worker’s Bill of Rights,” which includes specified information related to employee immigration documents and employment rights. This bill also requires employers to provide this document to employees in a specified manner and imposes a penalty up to $10,000 for employers that knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate or possess a passport, immigration document or government identification document in the course of specified activities.
FISCAL EFFECT:
Minor and absorbable costs.
COMMENTS:
- Background and purpose. Existing federal law prohibits employers from withholding or destroying immigration or identification documents in the course of committing, or with the intent to commit, human trafficking or coercive labor practices. A number of state laws prohibit unfair immigration-related employment practices and require employers to post various notices about rights and protections afforded to employees in the place of work.
According to supporters, AB 589 will help protect workers against the practice of “document servitude,” a practice where employers withhold important legal documents in exchange for work.
- Opposition. A variety of business and industry group oppose AB 589. These groups cite duplicative criminal penalties and burdens on employers as reasons for their opposition.
- Previous legislation. AB 2732 (Gonzalez Fletcher), of the 2017-18 Legislative Session, had similar provisions as this bill. AB 2732 was vetoed by the governor, whose veto message stated:
This bill makes it unlawful - punishable by civil and criminal penalties - for an employer to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess any immigration-related documents for human trafficking or any coercive labor practice. The bill also requires employers to provide a written "Worker's Bill of Rights" to every employee in the State of California.
Labor trafficking is a problem in our state and the provision of this bill that prohibits employers from withholding immigration documents from workers is very appropriate.
However, there is additional language that requires every single employer to provide to every single employee - millions in the state-- a new and detailed list of rights related to labor trafficking. This goes too far. The vast majority of California employers have nothing to do with labor trafficking, so this mandate as applied to them is burdensome and unwarranted.
Analysis Prepared by: Luke Reidenbach / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 2, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 589
Author:(Gonzalez) – As Introduced Ver:February 14, 2019
SUBJECT: Employment: unfair immigration-related practices
KEY ISSUES:
- Should it be unlawful for an employer to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess an employee’s passport or other immigration document in the course committing (or intending to commit) human trafficking and related coercive labor practices?
- should an employer be required to post workplace notices and provide all employees with a “Workers bill of rights” that informs employees of specified rights?
SYNOPSIS
The United Nations defines human trafficking as recruiting, transporting, and harboring people for the purposes of forced labor or sexual exploitation. It is slavery updated for the era of globalization and post-colonialism. While many may think of human trafficking as a “third world” problem, it exists here in California. Indeed, according to the National Human Trafficking Resource Center, California has more victims than any other state, ranging from sex trafficking victims in strip-mall massage parlors to labor trafficking victims on farms and in sweatshops. One method that traffickers use to control workers is so-called “document servitude” – that is, confiscating and withholding passports and immigration documents, thereby making it virtually impossible for foreign workers to find legitimate employment or even escape their situation. This bill addresses this problem in two ways. First, tracking the language of federal law, this bill makes it unlawful for an employer to “knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess” any actual or purported passport, or other immigration or identification documents, in the course of committing, or intending to commit, trafficking, slavery, peonage, involuntary servitude, or any coercive labor practice. An employer who violates this provision faces a civil penalty of up to $10,000, in addition to any criminal penalties for the underlying crime of human trafficking. Second, AB 589 will provide actual or potential victims of trafficking with information about their rights, including whom to contact if an employer violates those rights. Employers must disseminate this information by posting notices in the workplace and providing each worker with a “Worker’s Bill of Rights.” The bill would require the Department of Industrial Relations to develop this document no later than July 1, 2020.
The bill is sponsored by the San Diego County District Attorney and is supported by several labor, civil rights, and immigrant rights groups. Several business groups oppose this measure because, first, they believe existing law already provides adequate protection against document servitude and, second, they argue that the expense of providing documents to each worker outweighs any limited benefit that the bill may provide. Groups representing public employers removed their opposition because of case law holding that Labor Code provisions do not apply to public employers unless they are expressly included. The bill previously passed the Assembly Committee on Labor and Employment on a 7-0 vote.
SUMMARY: Makes it unlawful for an employer to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess a passport or immigration documents in the course of committing, or with the intent to commit, trafficking, peonage, slavery, involuntary servitude, or a coercive labor practice. Requires an employer to post information and provide employees with a document enumerating specified worker rights. Specifically, this bill:
- Makes it unlawful for an employer to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess any actual or purported passport or other immigration document, or any other actual or purported government identification document of another person in the course of committing, or with the intent to commit, trafficking, peonage, slavery, involuntary servitude, or a coercive labor practice. The bill would authorize the Labor Commissioner to issue a citation for a violation and impose civil and criminal penalties, as specified.
- Requires an employer to post in a conspicuous and effective location a notice specifying the rights of an employee to maintain custody and control of the employee’s own immigration documents. Advises employees whose employer has unlawfully held documents to call a federal human trafficking hotline.
- Requires the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) to develop a document entitled “Worker’s Bill of Rights” on or before July 1, 2020. Requires the document to enumerate certain rights, including, among others, the right of an employee to hold on to the employee’s own immigration and identification documents. Requires DIR to make the document available on its website for download by employers.
- Requires an employer to provide any employee hired on or after July 1, 2020, with a copy of the “Worker’s Bill of Rights” before verifying an employee’s authorization to work in the United States. For employees hired before July 1, 2020, the employer shall provide the document to each employee once DIR makes the document available.
EXISTING LAW:
- Requires, under federal law, an employer to verify, through examination of specified documents, whether an individual may work in the United States. (8 U.S.C. Section 1324a.)
- Makes in unlawful, under federal law, for any person to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess an actual or purported passport or other immigration document, or any other actual or purported government identification of another person in the course of committing or with intent to commit various crimes involving servitude, trafficking, and coercive labor practices. (18 U.S.C. Section 1592.)
- Makes it an unfair immigration-related employment practice, under federal law, for any person or entity to request, with the intent of discriminating against an individual, more or different documents than are required under law or refuse to honor documents tendered which, on their face, reasonably appear to be genuine. (8 U.S.C. Section 1342a (a)-(b).)
- Defines "unfair immigration-related practice," for purposes of state law, to mean any of the following practices when undertaken for retaliatory purposes, and not at the direction or request of the federal government:
- Requesting more or different documents than are required by federal law or refusing to honor required documents that on their face appear to be genuine.
- Using the federal E-Verify system to check the employment authorization status of a person at a time or in a manner not required or authorized by federal law.
- Threatening to file or filing a false police report, threatening to file or filing a false report or complaint with any state or federal agency, or threatening to contact or contacting immigration authorities. (Labor Code Section 1019 (b).)
- Permits an employee or any other person who is subject to an unfair immigration-related practice, where the unfair practice is retaliatory in nature, to bring a civil action for equitable relief and any applicable damages or penalties, and specifies that an employee or other person who prevails shall recover his or her reasonable attorney's fees. (Labor Code Section 1019 (d)(1).)
- Prohibits an employer, in the course of satisfying federal immigration law, from requesting more or different documents than are required under federal immigration law; refusing to honor valid documents, as specified; or attempting to reinvestigate or reverify an incumbent employee's authorization to work using an unfair immigration-related practice. (Labor Code Section 1019.1.)
- Requires employers to display posters in conspicuous locations that describe certain labor laws and worker rights around issues such as paid sick leave and whistleblower protections. (Labor Code Sections 247 and 1102.8 (a).)
- Makes it a crime to engage in human trafficking or other forms of coerced labor and makes such a crime punishable by a fine of $500,000 and a prison term ranging from five years to life, depending on the age of the victim and the nature of the human trafficking or coerced labor; specifies that coerced labor includes labor procured by “duress,”; and defines “duress” to include, among other things, knowingly destroying, concealing, removing, confiscating, or possessing an actual or purported passport or immigration document of the victim. (Penal Code Section 236.1.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: The United Nations defines human trafficking as recruiting, transporting, and harboring people for the purposes of forced labor or sexual exploitation. It is slavery updated for the era of globalization and post-colonialism. While many think of human trafficking as a “third world” problem, it exists here in California. Indeed, according to the National Human Trafficking Resource Center, California has more victims than any other state, ranging from sex trafficking victims in strip-mall massage parlors to labor trafficking victims on farms and in sweatshops. One method that traffickers use to control workers is so-called “document servitude” – that is, confiscating and withholding passports and immigration documents, making it virtually impossible for foreign workers to find legitimate employment or even escape their situation.
This bill attempts to deal with this problem in three ways. First, tracking the language of federal law, this bill would make it unlawful for an employer to “knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess” any actual or purported passport, or other immigration or identification documents, in the course of committing, or intending to commit, trafficking, slavery, peonage, involuntary servitude, or any coercive labor practice. An employer who violates this provision would be subject to a civil penalty of up to $10,000, in addition to any criminal penalties for the underlying crime of human trafficking.
Second, the bill seeks to provide actual or potential victims of trafficking with information about their rights by requiring employers to post notices about those rights. The notices must be placed in conspicuous locations. They must inform employees of their right to maintain control of their own immigration documents and must make it clear that the withholding of documents by an employer is a crime. The posted notice must contain the following statement: “If your employer or anyone is controlling your movement, documents, or wages, or using direct or implied threats to you or your family, you have the right to call local or federal authorities, or the National Human Trafficking Hotline at 888-373-7888.”
Third, the bill requires an employer to provide every employee hired on or after July 1, 2020, with a copy a “Worker’s Bill of Rights” before verifying the employee’s authorization to work in the United States, as required by federal immigration law. Employers must also provide the bill of rights document to workers hired before July 1, 2020, once DIR develops the document. The document must be in a language that the worker understands; the worker must sign a copy of the document acknowledging that the worker received and understood the document; and the employer must keep one copy of the signed document on file and provide one copy to the worker. The document must list all of the following rights:
- The right of the employee to retain possession of immigration documents, except to the extent that an employer must examine or make copies of documents to comply with federal law.
- The right to a mandatory minimum wage established by law or a wage agreed upon in an employment contract, whichever is higher.
- The right to live wherever the employee chooses and that the employee does not have to live at any place designated by the employer.
- The right not to be subject to debt bondage in lieu of being paid wages.
- The right to call local or federal authorities or the National Human Trafficking Hotline.
Does this bill’s prohibition of document servitude go far enough? This bill replicates existing state and federal law. The first part of the bill, which prohibits an employer from confiscating, destroying, or possessing passports and immigration documents in the course of committing human trafficking, or related criminal offenses, comes nearly word-for-word from federal law. (See 18 U.S.C. Section 1592.) This provision of federal law is part of a more comprehensive statutory framework criminalizing coercive labor practices and providing for both fines and imprisonment for violations of those laws. State law also prohibits human trafficking and related forms of coerced labor. The state law provides for a penalty of up to $500,000 and a prison term from five years up to life, depending on the age of the victim and the nature of the coerced labor. While state law does not prohibit document servitude as such, it does define “duress” (as a form of coercion) to include “knowingly destroying, concealing, removing, confiscating, or possessing an actual or purported passport or immigration document” of a victim. (Penal Code Section 236.1.) This bill would supplement that existing law by creating an additional fine of $10,000, paid to the Labor Commissioner, for the component of the underlying crime that involves destroying or otherwise withholding documents from the employee.
One curious part of this bill, as well as the federal law, is that it only prohibits destroying, concealing, confiscating, or possessing immigration documents in the course of committing, or with the intent to commit, trafficking or some other coercive practice. It is unclear why destroying, confiscating, or possessing an employee’s immigration documents should only be unlawful when done “in the course of human trafficking” when logically it should be illegal under all circumstances. The author has informed the Committee that this provision of the bill tracks federal law. However, the author may wish to consider amending the bill in the future to prohibit employers from confiscating or possessing an employee’s passport or immigration documents for any reason, except to the extent necessary to examine or copy documents in compliance with federal law.
Objections Raised by Opponents (and the Proponents’ Response): Opponents focus their opposition primarily on the requirement that the employer provide a “Worker’s Bill of Rights” to all future and current employees. Opponents claim that this is burdensome and inefficient because the document is required regardless of the employee’s immigration status and regardless of whether the employer’s business is of a type associated with human trafficking. In short, the opponents would apparently support a bill more narrowly focused on industries where human trafficking is prevalent and on immigrant or foreign employees who have immigration documents for the employer to withhold. Proponents, on the other hand, contend that providing a “Workers Bill of Rights,” that will likely fit on a single page, is not a great expense or burden. Indeed, as opponents themselves point out, employers must already provide employees with various documents at the time of hire; therefore, it would not seem terribly burdensome to add another one-page document. To be sure, the bill also requires an employer to provide the document to workers who were hired before July 1, 2020 once the DIR makes the document available for downloading on its internet website. The policy question, therefore, is whether making every effort to help persons escape from modern slavery (even if only a few do so) justifies the small cost and burden of providing a one-page document to all employees.
The Right to Live Where One Chooses: Opponents also object to the provision in the “Worker’s Bill of Rights” declaring that employees have “the right to live wherever the employee chooses and that the employee does not have to live at any place designated by the employer.” Opponents point out that some legitimate jobs may appropriately require an employee to live at certain times in a particular location, such as an on-site apartment manager or security person. If this bill moves forward, the author may wish to consider whether this right could be qualified to account for situations where living in a specified location is a bona fide job requirement.
Veto of AB 2732: This bill is substantially the same as the author’s AB 2732 of last year, which then-Governor Brown vetoed because, he claimed, “the vast majority of California employers have nothing to do with labor trafficking, so this mandate as applied to them is burdensome and unwarranted.” This is a strange argument. Governor Brown was no doubt correct that the vast majority of employers do not engage in human trafficking, but one could say this about any law or regulation. Most employers, after all, do not discriminate because of race, gender, or disability, violate wage and hour laws, or deny eligible employees family leave – but we still require all employers to post and provide notices of these rights in the workplace because of the few who do violate those law. Because we cannot know in advance which employers will violate workers’ rights, we require all employers to provide notices of those rights.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: The Office of the San Diego County District Attorney (SDCDA), the bill’s sponsor, argues that AB 589 “will recognize and prohibit a subtle form of coercive labor practice known as ‘document servitude.’” SDCDA believes that AB 589 will create a “strategic framework that will hold accountable employers who engage in the nefarious practice of withholding an immigrant’s legal documents from them and demanding that they work to earn them back.” SDCDA acknowledges that, “California law seeks to protect the rights of those who are made vulnerable on account of their immigration status.” However, AB 589 also “provides a definitive distinction of ‘document servitude’ and creates the misdemeanor crime of withholding an immigration document from its owner in the course of committing or with the intent to commit trafficking” or other forms of coerced labor. SDCDA believes that this bill will “inform employees of their rights to maintain physical possession of their immigration documentation, and that it is unlawful for an employer to maintain custody of their documentation as a condition of or incident to their employment.”
SDCDA and other supporters of this bill cite a number of studies, reports, and government statistics suggesting that AB 589 is especially necessary at this time because of the scope of the human trafficking problem. For example, a 2012 San Diego State University study estimated that there were 37,000 victims of human trafficking in the San Diego area alone. A 2014 Urban Institute study reported that, contrary to stereotypes, most victims (about 71%) entered the U.S. legally with appropriate immigration documents (e.g. H-2A and H-2B visas), but by the time they escaped, 69% were unauthorized because their status had expired. One powerful strategy that traffickers use to hold persons to labor against their will, it appears, is to hold the documents of workers that would allow them to leave or move on to legitimate employment. Also significant, as the California Labor Federation and the California Immigrant Policy Center note in their letters of support, is that according to the National Human Trafficking Resource Center, “more cases of human trafficking were reported in California than in any other state.”
Several other labor, immigrant rights, and consumer groups support this bill for similar reasons as those articulated above.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Chamber of Commerce, joined by several other business and employer groups, opposes AB 589 “because it creates duplicative criminal penalties for conduct that is already criminal, adds additional documents and notices for all new employees, and creates a nonsensical “right to live wherever the employee chooses” which would create unintended liability for employers.” While employers share the author’s desire to end human trafficking, they see this bill as creating undue burdens in light of existing laws against human trafficking.
Specifically, the opposition makes three central arguments. First, opponents claim that this bill is duplicative because federal law already prohibits human trafficking, in general, and the withholding of documents to serve these ends, in particular, in language that is almost identical to that of this bill. (e.g. 18 U.S.C. Section 1592.) In addition, California Penal Code Section 236.1 already prohibits “taking or concealing a victim’s immigration documents in order to compel work – and provides for more stringent punishments than AB 589.”
Second, opponents object, in particular, to one of the rights enumerated in the proposed “Worker’s Bill of Rights” – namely, that the employee “has the right to live wherever the employee chooses and that the employee does not have to live ay any place designated by the employer.” Opponents contend that his “new right” may contradict existing law, claiming that, “both California Wage Orders and federal regulations recognize that certain employment may require an employee to accept lodging at a particular location.”
Third, opponents claim that the requirement to provide every existing and future employee will “add to the already numerous requirements for employers related to new employees and simply is not necessary in light of existing legal protections.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
San Diego County District Attorney's Office (sponsor)
American Federation Of State, County And Municipal Employees
California Immigrant Policy Center
California Labor Federation
Coalition To Abolish Slavery & Trafficking
Consumer Attorneys Of California
CSA San Diego
End Violence Against Women International
Lynch Foundation For Children
SEIU California
Oppose
California Chamber of Commerce
California Farm Bureau Federation
California League of Food Producers
California Restaurant Association
California Retailers Association
California State Council of SHRM
El Dorado Joint Chamber Commission
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
National Federation of Independent Business
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Roseville Area Chamber of Commerce
United Chamber Advocacy Network
Western Growers Association
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: March 20, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON LABOR AND EMPLOYMENT
Ash Kalra, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 589 (
Author:Gonzalez) – As Introduced Ver:February 14, 2019
SUBJECT: Employment: unfair immigration-related practices
SUMMARY: Prohibits an employer from and imposes penalties for withholding an employee’s immigration-related documents and establishes a Worker’s Bill of Rights regarding freedom of movement and payment of wages. Specifically, this bill:
- Makes it unlawful for an employer to knowingly destroy, conceal, remove, confiscate, or possess, among other things, any actual or purported passport or other immigration document of another person in the course of committing, or with the intent to commit, trafficking, peonage, slavery, involuntary servitude, or a coercive labor practice.
- Imposes specified civil and criminal penalties for violating the law and provides that they are in addition to any civil fines imposed by another statute.
- Mandates that an employer post a prescribed workplace notice with information including an employee’s right to maintain custody and control of immigration documents and that the withholding of these documents by the employer is a crime.
- Requires an employer to provide to each employee a document entitled “Worker’s Bill of Rights,” in a language understood by the employee, either for those hired on or after July 1, 2020, at the time of verifying employment eligibility, or for those employed prior to July 1, 2020, when the document is made available, and requires that the employee sign and date it in acknowledgment that the employee has read and understands the employee’s rights, as specified.
- Requires that the Worker’s Bill of Rights be developed by the Department of Industrial Relations, posted on its internet website, and made available in English and in versions translated into the 12 languages most commonly spoken in this state by non-English-speaking people.
- Obligates the employer to keep the signed document in its records for at least three years and provide the employee with a copy.
EXISTING LAW:
- Makes it unlawful for an employer or any other person or entity to engage in, or direct another person or entity to engage in, unfair immigration-related practices against any person for the purpose of, or with the intent of, retaliating against the person for exercising any right under the Labor Code or under any local workplace ordinance, as specified.
- Defines an unfair immigration-related practice as, among other things, using the federal E-Verify system to check employment authorization status when not legally required to do so, threatening to file a false police report, or threatening to contact immigration authorities.
- Permits an employee subject to an unfair immigration-related practice, or his or her representative, to bring a civil action for equitable relief and any applicable damages or penalties.
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown
COMMENTS: Note: This bill is double-referred to Assembly Judiciary Committee upon passage out of this Committee.
Human trafficking is a form of modern slavery and includes both labor and sex trafficking. Victims are coerced, exploited, and often held against their will. According to the National Human Trafficking Resource Center, in 2018, California had 760 reported cases of human trafficking—the highest number of cases of any state. While the majority of the cases involved sex trafficking, 72 cases involved labor trafficking and were most prevalent in industries such as domestic services and agriculture.
This measure represents a comprehensive approach to combatting coercive labor practices. According to the author, the bill “helps protect workers against the immoral practice of ‘document servitude’ by: 1) providing a framework to hold employers accountable who engage in ‘document servitude’ and creating a misdemeanor crime for this tactic; 2) bringing the practice of ‘document servitude’ in line with other unlawful employment practices; and 3) establishing a ‘Worker’s Bill of Rights.’”
Arguments in Support
According to the Office of the San Diego County District Attorney, sponsor of the bill, AB 589 “is necessary to protect immigrant workers who are taken advantage of by unscrupulous employers because of their federal immigration status. Many are recruited or manipulated to enter California with work visas, but later become subject to labor abuses because of their unfamiliarity with the rights that all California workers should enjoy. A 2012 San Diego State University study estimates there are 37,000 victims of labor trafficking in our region alone. It showed that the most vulnerable immigrant workers in San Diego County were in the fields of construction, restaurants, janitorial, and agriculture.
In addition, a 2014 Urban Institute study, ‘Understanding the Organization, Operation, and Victimization Process of Labor Trafficking in the United States,’ reported that most of the victims entered into the United States lawfully under federal immigration law. Contrary to the stereotype that these enslaved persons had entered unlawfully, in fact, 71% of the victims entered the U.S. on a temporary VISA (H-2A, H-2B) that legally allowed them to work, but by the time they escaped, 69% were unauthorized. These studies showed that the culpable employers used a variety of physical and psychological means to control and enslave victims, including holding on to their work visas and identification documents, controlling where they lived, holding on to their wages, and leveraging the concept of debt bondage, a practice still prevalent in much of the world.”
Also in support, the Service Employees International Union (SEIU California) states, “AB 589 provides a strategic framework that will hold accountable employers who engage in the nefarious activity of withholding an immigrant’s legal documents from them and demanding that they work to earn them back. The provisions also give labor trafficking victims a civil remedy.”
Arguments in Opposition
The California Special Districts Association, the League of California Cities, and the California State Association of Counties, have an opposed unless amended position. They state, “the costs of compliance and the potential costs of liability for improper record keeping far outweigh any potential benefits to the immigrant community by imposing the requirements of AB 589 on public agencies. Moreover, we are not aware of a single allegation of abuse this bill looks to address that has been perpetrated by a public agency.”
A coalition of employer organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, argue in opposition that the bill is duplicative of existing prohibitions against document servitude. They state, “existing California and federal law already prohibit this conduct. CA Penal Code Section 236.1 already considers exactly the situation which AB 589 appears aimed at – an employer taking or concealing a victim’s immigration documents in order to compel work – and provides for more stringent punishments than AB 589 - including 5 or more years in prison and a fine up to $500,000. In addition, current federal law (Chapter 77 of Title 18 of the U.S. Code) also prohibits forcing an individual to labor by withholding their passport or other immigration documents.”
Governor’s Veto Message
AB 2732 (Gonzalez) of 2018 had identical language regarding the provision of the Worker’s Bill of Rights document and was vetoed. The Governor’s veto message stated, in relevant part:
“The bill also requires employers to provide a written ‘Worker's Bill of Rights’ to every employee in the State of California….However, there is additional language that requires every single employer to provide to every single employee - millions in the state-- a new and detailed list of rights related to labor trafficking. This goes too far. The vast majority of California employers have nothing to do with labor trafficking, so this mandate as applied to them is burdensome and unwarranted.”
The author’s office contends that the provisions of the bill are straightforward and simply require that an employer give an employee one document for their signature, retain a copy of it, and post relevant information in a conspicuous place. The author also points out that most employers already have a host of similar requirements regarding the dissemination of information to employees, such as sexual harassment and anti-discrimination policies.
Prior Legislation
AB 2732 (Gonzalez) of 2018 was nearly identical to this measure but also contained provisions regarding sexual harassment prevention training for janitorial workers.
AB 263 (Hernandez), Chapter 732, Statutes of 2013, expanded the scope of employment-based retaliation to include immigration-related practices and provided a civil cause of action for employees who are subject to such practices.
AB 241 (Ammiano), Chapter 374, Statutes of 2013, known as the “Domestic Worker Bill of Rights,” established protections and regulated the hours, wages, and working conditions of domestic work employees.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Federation Of State, County And Municipal Employees
California Immigrant Policy Center
California State Council Of Service Employees
Lynch Foundation for Children
San Diego County District Attorney's Office (Sponsor)
Opposition
California Chamber Of Commerce
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Retailers Association
California State Council Of SHRM
El Dorado Joint Chamber Commission
Elk Grove Chamber Of Commerce
Folsom Chamber Of Commerce
National Federation Of Independent Business
Rancho Cordova Chamber Of Commerce
Roseville Area Chamber Of Commerce
United Chamber Advocacy Network
Western Growers Association
Oppose Unless Amended
California Special Districts Association
California State Association Of Counties
League Of California Cities
Analysis Prepared by: Megan Lane / L. & E. /
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):