ACR 99: Civil rights: lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, or queer people.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2019-09-26
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 26, 2019 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Res. Chapter 166, Statutes of 2019. |
| Sep 26, 2019 | Enrolled and filed with the Secretary of State at 3 p.m. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 61. Noes 11.). |
| Sep 5, 2019 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. |
| Sep 4, 2019 | Adopted and to Assembly. |
| Aug 28, 2019 | Amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 27, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and be adopted as amended. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (August 27). |
| Jul 3, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 25, 2019 | In Senate. To Com. on RLS. |
| Jun 24, 2019 | Amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 20, 2019 | From committee: Amend, and be adopted as amended. (Ayes 9. Noes 2.) (June 18). |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 5, 2019 | From printer. |
| Jun 4, 2019 | Introduced. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 9, 2019 | ACR 99 Low Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 4, 2019 | Assembly 3rd Reading ACR99 Low et al. By Umberg | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 27, 2019 | Be adopted as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 18, 2019 | Be adopted as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:ACR 99
Author:(Low)
As Amended Ver:August 28, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Makes declarations relating to the harmfulness and ineffectiveness of "conversion therapy" as a means to "change" sexual orientation, and calls upon religious leaders, and indeed all Californians, to treat all people with understanding and acceptance.
Major Provisions
- Finds and declares the following:
- Makes findings and declarations relating to the professional consensus that being lesbian, gay, bisexual, or transgender, or queer (LGBTQ) is not a disease, disorder, illness, deficiency, or shortcoming, but is rather part of natural variations that occur in sexual orientation and gender identity, and recommend responsive services that foster self-acceptance and skills to cope with social stigma and discrimination.
- Finds that practices or therapies that attempt to create a change in a person's sexual orientation or gender identity are often referred to as conversion therapy, and that some family, caregivers, and communities promote conversion therapy when a person is known or thought to be LGBTQ.
- Finds that California law recognizes that performing conversion therapy on young persons is ineffective, unethical, and harmful and that conversion therapy has been rejected as ineffective, unethical, and harmful by leading medical, mental health, and child welfare organizations in the United States.
- Finds that stigma associated with being LGBTQ has caused disproportionately high rates of suicide, attempted suicide, depression, rejection, and isolation amongst LGBTQ and questioning individuals. Therefore, the State of California has a compelling interest in protecting the physical and psychological well-being of minors, including LGBTQ youth, and in protecting its minors against exposure to serious harms caused by family rejection and attempts to change sexual orientation or gender identity.
- In a pluralistic society, people differing along spectrums of political and religious perspectives share a common responsibility of protecting the health and well-being of all children and vulnerable communities.
- Resolves, in the light of the above findings and declarations, that the Legislature:
- Calls upon all Californians to embrace the individual and social benefits of family and community acceptance.
- Calls upon religious leaders to counsel on LGBTQ matters from a place of love, compassion, and knowledge of the psychological and other harms of conversion therapy.
Calls upon all people and institutions in California, when addressing the stigma often associated with persons who identify as LGBTQ, to model equitable treatment of all people.
The Senate Amendments: Change "transgender" to "transgender, or queer" throughout.
COMMENTS:
This measure reflects an ongoing debate about the merits of so-called "conversion therapy," or what California law refers to as "sexual orientation change efforts" (SOCE). Some (mostly religious-based) counselors contend that SOCE is a legitimate psychological and spiritual therapy that allows persons who have sexual attractions for persons of the same sex, and who are unhappy with that orientation, to re-orient themselves towards heterosexuality. Most professional and licensed psychologists, counselors, and social workers, on the other hand, have long held that SOCE is at best ineffective and at worst psychologically harmful. For example, 10 years ago a task force assembled by the American Psychological Association conducted a systematic review of peer-reviewed journal literature on SOCE. This literature suggested that efforts to change sexual orientation "are unlikely to be successful and involve some risk of harm, contrary to the claims of SOCE practitioners and advocates." (American Psychological Association, Report of the American Psychological Association Task Force on Appropriate Therapeutic Responses to Sexual Orientation, 2009.)
Although past legislation has attempted to prohibit or restrict the practice of SOCE, this resolution is much more modest than those past efforts. After making findings and declarations about the professional consensus that SOCE is ineffective, harmful, and inconsistent with our professed commitment to acceptance of LGBTQ persons, this measure's "resolves" simply to call upon religious leaders to counsel on LGBTQ matters with "love, compassion, and knowledge of the psychological and others harms of conversion therapy."
According to the Author:
The leading bodies of mental and physical health have agreed for decades that being lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender is not a disease, and for almost as long have agreed that conversion therapy has no scientific relevance. ACR 99 is an attempt to bridge some of the divide between religious and LGBTQ communities, and to address the insidious LGBTQ stigma that drives people toward conversion therapy.
Arguments in Support:
Equality California (EQ) supports ACR 99 because, it claims, for "far too long, LGBTQ people have suffered psychological abuse by those who are entrusted to care for their emotional, psychological, and spiritual well-being." EQ claims that "conversion" or "reparative" practices are "dangerous", have no sound scientific basis, and can cause lifelong damage. Finally, EQ insists, "LGBTQ identity cannot change and does not need to be changed."
Arguments in Opposition:
According to the Capitol Resource Institute, "the issue at hand is one of choice. It is the goal of ACR 99 to eventually criminalize one's choice to seek counseling and other services should they disagree with sexual desires or urges they are experiencing or struggling with. People looking for change to fit internal desires of their conscience and heart should be free to find services and resources from counselors, schools, and faith-based organizations to help them achieve their desired goals and outcomes."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-2-1
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gabriel, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Gallagher, Kiley
ABS, ABST OR NV: Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: August 28, 2019
CONSULTANT: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001557
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | ACR 99 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: ACR 99
Amended: 8/28/19 in Senate
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 7-2, 8/27/19
AYES: Jackson, Durazo, Lena Gonzalez, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Borgeas, Jones
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: Read and adopted, 6/24/19
SUBJECT: Civil rights: lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, or queer people
DIGEST:
This resolution calls upon the people of California to model equitable treatment of all people, especially those persons who identify as lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, or queer (LGBTQ), and to embrace the benefits of acceptance. It further calls upon religious leaders to counsel on LGBTQ matters from a place of love, compassion, and knowledge of the harms of conversion therapy.
ANALYSIS: This resolution makes the following findings:
- The Legislature has found that being LGBTQ is not a disease, disorder, illness, deficiency, or shortcoming;
- Major professional associations of mental and physical health recognize that being LGBTQ is part of natural variations that occur in sexual orientation and gender identity, and recommend responsive services that foster self-acceptance and skills to cope with social stigma and discrimination;
- Practices or therapies that attempt to create a change in a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity are often referred to as conversion therapy;
- Some family, caregivers, and communities promote conversion therapy when a person is known or thought to be LGBTQ;
- California law recognizes that performing conversion therapy on young persons is ineffective, unethical, and harmful;
- Conversion therapy has been rejected as ineffective, unethical, and harmful by leading medical, mental health, and child welfare organizations in the United States;
- The stigma associated with being LGBTQ often created by certain groups in society, including therapists and religious groups, has caused disproportionately high rates of suicide, attempted suicide, depression, rejection, and isolation amongst LGBTQ and questioning individuals;
- California has a compelling interest in protecting the physical and psychological well-being of minors, including LGBTQ youth, and in protecting its minors against exposure to serious harms caused by family rejection and attempts to change sexual orientation or gender identity; and
- In a pluralistic society, people differing along spectrums of political and religious perspectives share a common responsibility of protecting the health and well-being of all children and vulnerable communities.
This resolution therefore provides that the Legislature:
- Calls upon all Californians to embrace the individual and social benefits of family and community acceptance;
- Calls upon religious leaders to counsel on LGBTQ matters from a place of love, compassion, and knowledge of the psychological and other harms of conversion therapy; and
- Calls on the people of California, especially its counselors, pastors, religious workers, educators, and legislators, and the institutions of California with great moral influence, especially its churches, universities, colleges, and other schools, counseling centers, activist groups, and religious centers, to model equitable treatment of all people of the state as part of addressing the stigma often associated with persons who identify as LGBTQ.
Comments
According to the author:
The leading bodies of mental and physical health, representing over one-half million experienced practitioners, have agreed for decades that being lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender is not a disease or disorder. Their individual conclusions nearly form a consensus recognizing the lack of scientific, unbiased evidence to support that conversion therapy is possible or beneficial. There is also considerable evidence that conversion therapy is inherently harmful to the subjected individual.
This widely discredited practice has been illegal to perform on minors in California since 2012. However, there are no similar protections for LGBTQ adults, and people continue to be coerced into believing that there is something wrong with them and directed to these ineffective pseudo-therapies. Study after study has found that these practices cause more damage than healing, and we are building a coalition of LGBTQ advocates and faith leaders to raise awareness across cultural borders that there is considerable evidence that conversion therapy is not only discredited but in fact quite harmful.
Sexual orientation change efforts
Sexual orientation change efforts (SOCE) attempt to change an individual’s sexual orientation. SOCE is sometimes referred to as reparative therapy or conversion therapy. The American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Counseling Association, the American Psychiatric Association, the American Psychological Association, the National Association of School Psychologists, and the National Association of Social Workers have all taken the position that “the idea that homosexuality is a mental disorder or that the emergence of same-sex attraction and orientation among some adolescents is in any way abnormal or mentally unhealthy has no support among any mainstream health and mental health professional organizations.[1] They have therefore made clear that sexual orientation is not “something that needs to or can be ‘cured.’”
In 2009, the American Psychological Association (APA) conducted a systematic review of the peer-reviewed journal literature on SOCE.[2] The report concluded that “efforts to change sexual orientation are unlikely to be successful and involve some risk of harm, contrary to the claims of SOCE practitioners and advocates.” The report found evidence that the “negative side effects included loss of sexual feeling, depression, suicidality, and anxiety.” Judith M. Glassgold, the chair of the task force behind the resolution, claimed that “[c]ontrary to claims of sexual orientation change advocates and practitioners, there is insufficient evidence to support the use of psychological interventions to change sexual orientation.” On the issue of harm, Glassgold commented that, “psychologists cannot predict the impact of these treatments and need to be very cautious given that some qualitative research suggests the potential for harm.” These concerns are not new. Twenty years ago, the American Psychiatric Association found the potential risks of SOCE “are great and include depression, anxiety, and self-destructive behavior.”
After outlining the harms that can result from SOCE, the APA’s 2009 report outlines exactly how practitioners can support those struggling with their sexual orientation: “the appropriate application of affirmative therapeutic interventions for those who seek SOCE involves therapist acceptance, support, and understanding of clients and the facilitation of clients’ active coping, social support, and identity exploration and development, without imposing a specific sexual orientation identity outcome.”
NOTE: For a more thorough discussion of this resolution, please see the Senate Judiciary Committee analysis.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
#Out4MentalHealth
American Association for Marriage and Family Therapists
Asians and Pacific Islanders for LGBTQ Equality
Bay Area Municipal Elections Committee
Biola University
California Employment Lawyers Association
California LGBTQ Health and Human Services Network
California Medical Association
California Psychological Association
California Voices for Progress
Central Conference of American Rabbis
City of Long Beach
Congregation Shir Hadash, Los Gatos
Consumer Attorneys of California
Courage Campaign
Episcopal Diocese of Los Angeles
Equality California
Faculty Association of California Community Colleges
Former Ex-Gay Leaders Alliance
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Latino Coalition for a Healthy California
Los Angeles LGBT Center
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Progressive Christians Uniting
Rainbow Chamber of Commerce Silicon Valley
Sacramento LGBT Community Center
Saint Andrew’s Episcopal Church and School
San Francisco AIDS Foundation
Santa Clara Methodist Retirement Foundation
St. Mark’s United Methodist Church, Sacramento
Stonewall Democratic Club of Greater Sacramento
The Trevor Project
Westhope Presbyterian Church, Saratoga
Two individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/27/19)
Advocates for Faith and Freedom
Alliance for Therapeutic Choice and Scientific Integrity
American College of Pediatricians
American Family Association
American Indian Full Gospel Assemblies
Americans for Truth about Homosexuality
Anglican Mainstream
Assemblies of God
Between the Porch and the Altar Ministries
Big Bear Foursquare Church
Bridge Bible Fellowship
Bridge Network
California Counseling Coalition
California Family Council
Calvary Baptist Church
Calvary Chapel Chino Hills
Calvary Chapel Newcastle
Calvary Chapel of Sacramento
Calvary Chapel Walnut Creek
Calvary of the Siskiyous
Capitol Resource Institute
Center for Morality
Chi Alpha Christian Fellowship, Purdue University
Christian Counseling Association
Christian Life Center
Church Nazarene
Church of Christ
Church of God Pittsburg
Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
Coalition for Counseling Choice
Coarsegold Reformed Fellowship
Community Baptist Church
Community Christian Fellowship
Concerned Women for America
Cornerstone Church Congregation
Covenant Chapel
Cross Point Church
CrossCity Christian Church
Crossworks Ministries
Crown Point Baptist Church
Desert Reign Church
Eagle Forum of California
East Bay Baptist
East Clairemont Church
Epic Bible College
Equipped to Love
Faith and Public Policy
Faith Christian Assembly
Faith Christian Reformed Church
Faith Community Church
Family Research Council
Family Watch International
Federation of International Catholic Medical Associations
FireStarters 24/7
First Baptist Church of Angels Camp
First Presbyterian Church Redding
Focus on the Family
Freedom Ministries
Fresno New Creation Ministries
Friends in Christ Ministries
Full Gospel San Francisco Church
Gateway Community Church
Good News Presbyterian Church
Good Shepherd Community Church
Help 4 Families Ministry
Hill Financial and Insurance Services
Horizon Christian Fellowship South Bay
Hydesville Church
Iglesia La Esperanza
Informed Parents of California
International Federation for Therapeutic and Counseling Choice
It Takes a Family
LifeWay Baptist Church
Lighthouse a Christian Church
Lutheran Church
MBCSFV
Ministerio Profético Gedeon Profet
Ministerio Shekinah
Mission America
Napa Valley Community Church
National Day of Repentance
National Task Force for Therapy Equality
Neighborhood Church
New Hope Christian Ministries
Newberry Community Church
Nothing Hidden Ministries
Olive Branch Community Church
Pine Grove Baptist Church
RAD Church
Redding Mayor Julie Winter
Redeemed and Delivered Ministries
Reformed Heritage Church
Restored Hope Network
Rivers of Life Church of God in Christ
Rock of Roseville
SeaCoast Church Redondo Beach
Shalom Disability Ministries
Solid Rock Christian Fellowship
Southport Christian Center
Spirit Life Apple Valley Church
Spring Fountain Church of San Francisco
The Foursquare Church
The Gate Church of the High Desert
The National Center for Law and Policy
The Potter's Ministries
The Salt and Light Council
The Wegener Foundation
Traditional Biblical Values for Next Generations
Trinity Alliance Church
Truth Tabernacle Church
Union Presbyterian Church of Los Altos
Upward International School
Valley Christian Academy
Venture Church
Vineyard Community Church Pomona/Claremont
Voice of the Voiceless
Word Faith Fellowship Church Family Life
Word-A-Live Church
1,349 individuals
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Writing in support, Asians and Pacific Islanders for LGBTQ Equality write: “For far too long, LGBTQ people have suffered psychological abuse by those who are entrusted to care for their emotional, psychological, and spiritual well-being. The dangerous practices of sexual orientation change efforts, frequently called ‘conversion therapy’ or ‘reparative therapy,’ have no sound scientific basis and can cause lifelong damage. In fact, all of the nation’s leading professional medical and mental health associations have rejected conversion therapy as unnecessary, ineffective, and dangerous. To date, 18 other states, Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia have similar laws in place, demonstrating a growing national consensus that these practices are dangerous and damaging.
“LGBTQ identity cannot and does not need to be changed.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: A coalition of largely faith-based groups writes in opposition to this resolution: “Religious freedom is an inalienable right recognized within the context of America’s religious heritage; it rests upon the insight that human beings of every kind are endowed with equal worth because each and every one of us bears the glorious image of Nature’s God. Every person in California, therefore, is entitled to the freedom to develop their own sense of identity whether traditionally unto God or not.”
Prepared by: Christian Kurpiewski / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/29/19 14:50:00
**** END ****
Just the Facts Coalition, Just the Facts About Sexual Orientation and Youth: A Primer for Principals, Educators, and School Personnel (2008) http://www.apa.org/pi/lgbt/resources/just-the-facts.pdf [as of Aug. 20, 2019].). ↑
APA, Task Force on Appropriate Therapeutic Responses to Sexual Orientation, Report of the American Psychological Association Task Force on Appropriate Therapeutic Responses to Sexual Orientation (2009) http://www.apa.org/pi/lgbt/resources/therapeutic-response.pdf [as of Aug. 20, 2019]. ↑
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: ACR 99 (Author:Low)
Version: June 24, 2019
Hearing Date: August 27, 2019
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: CK
SUBJECT
Civil rights: lesbian, gay, bisexual, or transgender people
DIGEST[1]
This resolution calls upon the people of California to model equitable treatment of all people, especially those persons who identify as lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, or queer (LGBTQ), and to embrace the benefits of acceptance. It further calls upon religious leaders to counsel on LGBTQ matters from a place of love, compassion, and knowledge of the harms of conversion therapy.
PURPOSES OF THIS MEASURE
This resolution makes the following findings:
- the Legislature has found that being LGBTQ is not a disease, disorder, illness, deficiency, or shortcoming;
- major professional associations of mental and physical health recognize that being LGBTQ is part of natural variations that occur in sexual orientation and gender identity, and recommend responsive services that foster self-acceptance and skills to cope with social stigma and discrimination;
- practices or therapies that attempt to create a change in a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity are often referred to as conversion therapy;
- some family, caregivers, and communities promote conversion therapy when a person is known or thought to be LGBTQ;
- California law recognizes that performing conversion therapy on young persons is ineffective, unethical, and harmful;
- conversion therapy has been rejected as ineffective, unethical, and harmful by leading medical, mental health, and child welfare organizations in the United States;
- the stigma associated with being LGBTQ often created by certain groups in society, including therapists and religious groups, has caused disproportionately high rates of suicide, attempted suicide, depression, rejection, and isolation amongst LGBTQ and questioning individuals;
- California has a compelling interest in protecting the physical and psychological well-being of minors, including LGBTQ youth, and in protecting its minors against exposure to serious harms caused by family rejection and attempts to change sexual orientation or gender identity; and
- in a pluralistic society, people differing along spectrums of political and religious perspectives share a common responsibility of protecting the health and well-being of all children and vulnerable communities.
This resolution therefore provides that the Legislature:
- calls upon all Californians to embrace the individual and social benefits of family and community acceptance;
- calls upon religious leaders to counsel on LGBTQ matters from a place of love, compassion, and knowledge of the psychological and other harms of conversion therapy;
- calls on the people of California, especially its counselors, pastors, religious workers, educators, and legislators, and the institutions of California with great moral influence, especially its churches, universities, colleges, and other schools, counseling centers, activist groups, and religious centers, to model equitable treatment of all people of the state as part of addressing the stigma often associated with persons who identify as LGBTQ.
COMMENTS
- Stated intent of the bill
According to the author:
The leading bodies of mental and physical health, representing over one-half million experienced practitioners, have agreed for decades that being lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender is not a disease or disorder. Their individual conclusions nearly form a consensus recognizing the lack of scientific, unbiased evidence to support that conversion therapy is possible or beneficial. There is also considerable evidence that conversion therapy is inherently harmful to the subjected individual.
This widely discredited practice has been illegal to perform on minors in California since 2012. However, there are no similar protections for LGBTQ adults, and people continue to be coerced into believing that there is something wrong with them and directed to these ineffective pseudo-therapies. Study after study has found that these practices cause more damage than healing, and we are building a coalition of LGBTQ advocates and faith leaders to raise awareness across cultural borders that there is considerable evidence that conversion therapy is not only discredited but in fact quite harmful.
The National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter explains the need for the resolution and its support for it:
The LGBTQ+ community is a community full of strength, resiliency, and love. They have endured much hardship throughout centuries as a result of negative stigma, stereotypes, and homophobic views. Despite so many attacks and injustice bore on their community they remain steadfast in their love and commitment to their communities and country. However, as these dangerous and hurtful perspectives are often perpetrated by those in positions of power, they have a profound impact [on] the community, especially people of color and gender non-binary individuals within the LGBTQ+ community.
California has done much to right the wrongs of past legislatures, but there is still much to do. Not only to address the current areas of discrimination and abuse, but to rebuild trust with the LGBTQ+ community in general. This resolution works to restore faith in the LGBTQ+ community that the state of California supports them and stands behind them as others in this state and nation work against them.
- Sexual orientation change efforts
Sexual orientation change efforts (SOCE) attempt to change an individual’s sexual orientation. SOCE is sometimes referred to as reparative therapy or conversion therapy. The American Academy of Pediatrics, the American Counseling Association, the American Psychiatric Association, the American Psychological Association, the National Association of School Psychologists, and the National Association of Social Workers have all taken the position that “the idea that homosexuality is a mental disorder or that the emergence of same-sex attraction and orientation among some adolescents is in any way abnormal or mentally unhealthy has no support among any mainstream health and mental health professional organizations.[2] They have therefore made clear that sexual orientation is not “something that needs to or can be ‘cured.’”
In 2009, the American Psychological Association (APA) conducted a systematic review of the peer-reviewed journal literature on SOCE.[3] The report concluded that “efforts to change sexual orientation are unlikely to be successful and involve some risk of harm, contrary to the claims of SOCE practitioners and advocates.” The report found evidence that the “negative side effects included loss of sexual feeling, depression, suicidality, and anxiety.” Judith M. Glassgold, the chair of the task force behind the resolution, claimed that “[c]ontrary to claims of sexual orientation change advocates and practitioners, there is insufficient evidence to support the use of psychological interventions to change sexual orientation.” On the issue of harm, Glassgold commented that, “psychologists cannot predict the impact of these treatments and need to be very cautious given that some qualitative research suggests the potential for harm.” These concerns are not new. Twenty years ago, the American Psychiatric Association found the potential risks of SOCE “are great and include depression, anxiety, and self-destructive behavior.”
After outlining the harms that can result from SOCE, the APA’s 2009 report outlines exactly how practitioners can support those struggling with their sexual orientation: “the appropriate application of affirmative therapeutic interventions for those who seek SOCE involves therapist acceptance, support, and understanding of clients and the facilitation of clients’ active coping, social support, and identity exploration and development, without imposing a specific sexual orientation identity outcome.” The report details these practices:
Acceptance and support include unconditional acceptance of and support for the various aspects of the client; respect for the client’s values, beliefs, and needs; and a reduction in internalized sexual stigma. Comprehensive assessment involves an awareness of the complete person, including mental health concerns that could impact distress about sexual orientation. Active coping includes both cognitive and emotional strategies to manage stigma and conflicts, including the development of alternative cognitive frames to resolve cognitive dissonance and the facilitation of affective expression and resolution of losses. Social support, which can mitigate distress caused by isolation, rejection, and lack of role models, includes psychotherapy, self-help groups, or welcoming communities (e.g., ethnic communities, social groups, religious denominations). Identity exploration and development include offering permission and opportunity to explore a wide range of options and reducing the conflicts caused by dichotomous or conflicting conceptions of self and identity without prioritizing a particular outcome.
Many in opposition to this resolution point to the benefits of SOCE. However, the American Psychiatric Association has addressed the bulk of the evidence purportedly in favor of SOCE:
Psychotherapeutic modalities to convert or “repair” homosexuality are based on developmental theories whose scientific validity is questionable. Furthermore, anecdotal reports of “cures” are counterbalanced by anecdotal claims of psychological harm. In the last four decades, “reparative” therapists have not produced any rigorous scientific research to substantiate their claims of cure. (Emphasis added.)
More recently, in October 2015, the Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration within the United States Department of Health and Human Services published a report “to provide mental health professionals and families with accurate information about effective and ineffective therapeutic practices related to children’s and adolescent’s sexual orientation and gender identity.”[4] The report’s conclusions were based on “professional consensus statements arrived at by experts in the field,” among which is the following: “Interventions aimed at a fixed outcome, such as gender conformity or heterosexual orientation, including those aimed at changing gender identity, gender expression, and sexual orientation are coercive, can be harmful, and should not be part of behavioral health treatment.”
Despite lack of support from leading medical and mental health associations and evidence of its harm, SOCE continues to be practiced and advocated for by certain communities.
- California’s response to SOCE
In 2012, SB 1172 (Lieu, Ch. 835, Stats. 2012) was signed into law. It prohibited a mental health provider, as defined, from engaging in SOCE with a patient under 18 years of age. It defines SOCE as any practices by mental health providers that seek to change an individual’s sexual orientation. This includes efforts to change behaviors or gender expressions, or to eliminate or reduce sexual or romantic attractions or feelings toward individuals of the same sex. The phrase does not include psychotherapies that: (A) provide acceptance, support, and understanding of clients or the facilitation of clients’ coping, social support, and identity exploration and development, including sexual orientation-neutral interventions to prevent or address unlawful conduct or unsafe sexual practices; and (B) do not seek to change sexual orientation. (Bus. & Prof. Code Sec. 865.)
The law classifies such activities as unprofessional conduct and subjected providers to discipline for attempting such efforts. Since then, many other states have passed laws, or have legislation pending, that would similarly restrict SOCE involving minors.
Last session, AB 2943 (Low, 2018) was introduced and would have expanded this attempt to protect Californians from the harmful practice of SOCE by making it a violation of the Consumer Legal Remedies Act (CLRA) for any individual to advertise, offer for sale, or sell services constituting SOCE to an individual in a transaction intended to result or that results in the sale or lease of goods or services to any consumer. The bill passed through the Senate but was never brought up for a concurrence vote on the Assembly Floor.
It should be noted that, arguably, SOCE may already be unlawful under existing consumer protection laws. The evidence makes clear that SOCE does not serve any legitimate purpose and can cause serious harm. As stated by the American Psychoanalytic Association: “Psychoanalytic technique does not encompass purposeful attempts to ‘convert,’ ‘repair,’ change or shift an individual’s sexual orientation, gender identity or gender expression. Such directed efforts are against fundamental principles of psychoanalytic treatment and often result in substantial psychological pain by reinforcing damaging internalized attitudes.” There is no verifiable and reliable scientific evidence that SOCE have the ability to change one’s sexual orientation. Therefore, businesses selling services constituting SOCE, and misrepresenting their effects, may be subject to actions pursuant to both the CLRA and the Unfair Competition Law.
This resolution instead takes a much more modest approach and simply resolves the Legislature to call on Californians to embrace the benefits of acceptance with respect to the LGBTQ community and to model equitable treatment of all people in order to address the stigma often associated with persons who identify as LGBTQ. Religious leaders are also specifically called upon to counsel on LGBTQ matters from a place of “love, compassion, and knowledge of the psychological harms of conversion therapy.”
- First Amendment issues with regulating SOCE
As discussed, SB 1172 prohibited specified practitioners from engaging in SOCE with minors. The law was quickly challenged by various groups in lawsuits that contended the law impermissibly violated various constitutional rights. Two dueling, federal district court opinions were appealed to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. In a joint opinion, the court found that “SB 1172, as a regulation of professional conduct, does not violate the free speech rights of SOCE practitioners or minor patients, is neither vague nor overbroad, and does not violate parents’ fundamental rights.” (Pickup v. Brown (9th Cir. 2014) 740 F.3d 1208, 1222.)
The First Amendment provides that “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof; or abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the Government for a redress of grievances.” (U.S. Const., Amend. I.) Crucially, the Pickup court held that SB 1172 did not regulate speech, but professional treatment, and therefore was subject only to a rational basis review. (Pickup at 1230-1231.) Rational basis review simply requires a law to bear “a rational relationship to a legitimate state interest.” (Id.)
Ultimately, the court in Pickup found that the Legislature relied on “the well-documented, prevailing opinion of the medical and psychological community that SOCE has not been shown to be effective and that it creates a potential risk of serious harm to those who experience it.” (Id.) This speaks to the important governmental interests at stake in regulating SOCE. The United States Supreme Court has held that “when ‘speech’ and ‘nonspeech’ elements are combined in the same course of conduct, a sufficiently important governmental interest in regulating the nonspeech element can justify incidental limitations on First Amendment freedoms.” (United States v. O'Brien (1968) 391 U.S. 367, 376.)
As stated, this resolution simply acknowledges the humanity of those identifying as LGBTQ and calls upon Californians to accept them as equal members of our community. The resolution further calls upon religious leaders to counsel with the knowledge of the harms of conversion therapy, which are discussed above. It does not infringe upon or impact the First Amendment rights of any Californian.
- Stakeholder positions
Writing in support, Asians and Pacific Islanders for LGBTQ Equality write:
For far too long, LGBTQ people have suffered psychological abuse by those who are entrusted to care for their emotional, psychological, and spiritual well-being. The dangerous practices of sexual orientation change efforts, frequently called “conversion therapy” or “reparative therapy,” have no sound scientific basis and can cause lifelong damage. In fact, all of the nation’s leading professional medical and mental health associations have rejected conversion therapy as unnecessary, ineffective, and dangerous. To date, 18 other states, Puerto Rico and the District of Columbia have similar laws in place, demonstrating a growing national consensus that these practices are dangerous and damaging.
LGBTQ identity cannot and does not need to be changed.
A coalition of largely faith-based groups writes in opposition to the resolution:
Religious freedom is an inalienable right recognized within the context of America’s religious heritage; it rests upon the insight that human beings of every kind are endowed with equal worth because each and every one of us bears the glorious image of Nature’s God. Every person in California, therefore, is entitled to the freedom to develop their own sense of identity whether traditionally unto God or not.
Equipped to Love writes in opposition that “ACR-99 poses a grim and inaccurate picture of religion and its role in the lives of LGBTQ identifying people.”
SUPPORT
American Association for Marriage and Family Therapy
Asians and Pacific Islanders for LGBTQ Equality
California Psychological Association
Central Conference of American Rabbis
City of Long Beach
Courage Campaign
Episcopal Diocese of Los Angeles
Equality California
Faculty Association of California Community Colleges
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Los Angeles LGBT Center
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
Progressive Christians Uniting
Rainbow Chamber of Commerce Silicon Valley
Saint Andrew’s Episcopal Church and School
San Francisco AIDS Foundation
Santa Clara Methodist Retirement Foundation
Stonewall Democratic Club of Greater Sacramento
The Trevor Project
Westhope Presbyterian Church
1 individual
OPPOSITION
Advocates for Faith and Freedom
Alliance for Therapeutic Choice and Scientific Integrity
American College of Pediatricians
American Family Association
American Indian Full Gospel Assemblies
Americans for Truth about Homosexuality
Anglican Mainstream
Assemblies of God
Between the Porch and the Altar Ministries
Big Bear Foursquare Church
Bishop Dave Parkes, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints
Bridge Bible Fellowship
Bridge Network
California Counseling Coalition
California Family Council
Calvary Baptist Church
Calvary Chapel Chino Hills
Calvary Chapel Newcastle
Calvary Chapel of Sacramento
Calvary Chapel Walnut Creek
Calvary of the Siskiyous
Capitol Resource Institute
Center for Morality
Chi Alpha Christian Fellowship, Purdue University
Christian Counseling Association
Christian Life Center
Church Nazarene
Church of Christ
Church of God Pittsburg
Coalition for Counseling Choice
Coarsegold Reformed Fellowship
Community Baptist Church
Community Christian Fellowship
Concerned Women for America
Cornerstone Church Congregation
Covenant Chapel
Cross Point Church
CrossCity Christian Church
Crossworks Ministries
Crown Point Baptist Church
Desert Reign Church
Eagle Forum of California
East Bay Baptist
East Clairemont Church
Epic Bible College
Equipped to Love
Faith and Public Policy
Faith Christian Assembly
Faith Christian Reformed Church
Faith Community Church
Family Research Council
Family Watch International
Federation of International Catholic Medical Associations
FireStarters 24/7
First Baptist Church of Angels Camp
First Presbyterian Church Redding
Focus on the Family
Freedom Ministries
Fresno New Creation Ministries
Friends in Christ Ministries
Full Gospel San Francisco Church
Gateway Community Church
Good News Presbyterian Church
Good Shepherd Community Church
Help 4 Families Ministry
Hill Financial and Insurance Services
Horizon Christian Fellowship South Bay
Hydesville Church
Iglesia La Esperanza
Informed Parents of CA
International Federation for Therapeutic and Counseling Choice
It Takes a Family
LifeWay Baptist Church
Lighthouse a Christian Church
Lutheran Church
Mayor Julie Winter, City of Redding
MBCSFV
Ministerio Profético Gedeon Profet
Ministerio Shekinah
Mission America
Napa Valley Community Church
National Day of Repentance
National Task Force for Therapy Equality
Neighborhood Church
New Hope Christian Ministries
Newberry Community Church
Nothing Hidden Ministries
Olive Branch Community Church
Pine Grove Baptist Church
RAD Church
Redeemed and Delivered Ministries
Reformed Heritage Church
Restored Hope Network
Rivers of Life Church of God in Christ
Rock of Roseville
SeaCoast Church Redondo Beach
Shalom Disability Ministries
Solid Rock Christian Fellowship
Southport Christian Center
Spirit Life Apple Valley Church
Spirit Life AV
Spring Fountain Church of San Francisco
The Foursquare Church
The Gate Church of the High Desert
The National Center for Law and Policy
The Potter's Ministries
The Salt and Light Council
The Wegener Foundation
Traditional Biblical Values for Next Generations
Trinity Alliance Church
Truth Tabernacle Church
Union Presbyterian Church of Los Altos
Upward International School
Valley Christian Academy
Venture Church
Vineyard Community Church Pomona/Claremont
Voice of the Voiceless
Word Faith Fellowship Church Family Life
Word-A-Live Church
1349 individuals
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: SR 44 (Wiener, 2019) acknowledged the historical impact of the Stonewall Riots of 1969 and urged all Californians to join in celebrating the culture, accomplishments, and contributions of LGBTQ people, and encourages the people of California to work to help advance the cause of equality for LGBTQ people and their families.
Prior Legislation:
ACR 172 (Low, 2018) apologized for past laws that discriminated against LGBT people and constitutional provisions that resulted in the persecution and oppression of LGBT individuals and their communities.
AB 2943 (Low, 2018) See Comment 3.
SB 1172 (Lieu, Ch. 835, Stats. 2012) See Comment 3.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 2)
**************
This analysis reflects the resolution as agreed to be amended by the author. The term “queer” will be included with lesbian, gay, bisexual, or transgender to more fully and explicitly represent the diversity of the LGBTQ community. ↑
Just the Facts Coalition, Just the Facts About Sexual Orientation and Youth: A Primer for Principals, Educators, and School Personnel (2008) http://www.apa.org/pi/lgbt/resources/just-the-facts.pdf [as of Aug. 20, 2019].). ↑
APA, Task Force on Appropriate Therapeutic Responses to Sexual Orientation, Report of the American Psychological Association Task Force on Appropriate Therapeutic Responses to Sexual Orientation (2009) http://www.apa.org/pi/lgbt/resources/therapeutic-response.pdf [as of Aug. 20, 2019]. ↑
Substance Abuse and Mental Health Services Administration, Ending Conversion Therapy: Supporting and Affirming LGBTQ Youth (Oct. 2015) https://store.samhsa.gov/shin/content//SMA15-4928/SMA15-4928.pdf [as of June 10, 2019]. ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:ACR 99
Author:(Low)
As Amended Ver:June 24, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Makes declarations relating to the harmfulness and ineffectiveness of "conversion therapy" as a means to "change" sexual orientation, and calls upon religious leaders, and indeed all Californians, to treat all people with understanding and acceptance.
Major Provisions
- Finds and declares the following:
- Makes findings and declarations relating to the professional consensus that being lesbian, gay, bisexual, or transgender (LGBTQ) is not a disease, disorder, illness, deficiency, or shortcoming, but is rather part of natural variations that occur in sexual orientation and gender identity, and recommend responsive services that foster self-acceptance and skills to cope with social stigma and discrimination.
- Finds that practices or therapies that attempt to create a change in a person's sexual orientation or gender identity are often referred to as conversion therapy, and that some family, caregivers, and communities promote conversion therapy when a person is known or thought to be LGBTQ.
- Finds that California law recognizes that performing conversion therapy on young persons is ineffective, unethical, and harmful and that conversion therapy has been rejected as ineffective, unethical, and harmful by leading medical, mental health, and child welfare organizations in the United States.
- Finds that stigma associated with being LGBTQ has caused disproportionately high rates of suicide, attempted suicide, depression, rejection, and isolation amongst LGBTQ and questioning individuals. Therefore, the State of California has a compelling interest in protecting the physical and psychological well-being of minors, including LGBTQ youth, and in protecting its minors against exposure to serious harms caused by family rejection and attempts to change sexual orientation or gender identity.
- In a pluralistic society, people differing along spectrums of political and religious perspectives share a common responsibility of protecting the health and well-being of all children and vulnerable communities.
- Resolves, in the light of the above findings and declarations, that the Legislature:
- Calls upon all Californians to embrace the individual and social benefits of family and community acceptance.
- Calls upon religious leaders to counsel on LGBTQ matters from a place of love, compassion, and knowledge of the psychological and other harms of conversion therapy.
- Calls upon all people and institutions in California, when addressing the stigma often associated with persons who identify as LGBTQ, to model equitable treatment of all people.
COMMENTS:
This measure reflects an ongoing debate, both within the Legislature and beyond, about the merits of so-called "conversion therapy," or what California law refers to as "sexual orientation change efforts" (SOCE). Some (mostly religious-based) counselors contend that SOCE is a legitimate psychological and spiritual therapy that allows persons who have sexual attractions for persons of the same sex, and who are unhappy with that orientation, to re-orient themselves towards heterosexuality – which most, but not all, SOCE proponents see as the "natural" or "normal" sexual orientation. Most professional and licensed psychologists, counselors, and social workers, on the other hand, have long held that SOCE is at best ineffective and at worst psychologically harmful. For example, ten years ago a task force assembled by the American Psychological Association (APA) conducted a systematic review of peer-reviewed journal literature on SOCE. This literature suggested that efforts to change sexual orientation "are unlikely to be successful and involve some risk of harm, contrary to the claims of SOCE practitioners and advocates." (American Psychological Association, Report of the American Psychological Association Task Force on Appropriate Therapeutic Responses to Sexual Orientation, 2009. [Hereafter APA Report.] http://www.apa.org/pi/lgbc/publications/therapeutic-resp.html.)
Although past legislation has attempted to prohibit or greatly restrict the practice of SOCE, ACR 99 is much more modest than those past efforts. After making findings and declarations about the professional consensus that SOCE is ineffective, harmful, and inconsistent with our professed commitment to acceptance of LGBTQ persons, this measure's "resolves" simply to call upon religious leaders to counsel on LGBTQ matters with "love, compassion, and knowledge of the psychological and others harms of conversion therapy." ACR 99 calls upon everyone else to embrace the benefits of acceptance and to "model equitable treatment of all people in the state."
According to the Author:
The leading bodies of mental and physical health have agreed for decades that being lesbian, gay, bisexual or transgender is not a disease, and for almost as long have agreed that conversion therapy has no scientific relevance. ACR 99 is an attempt to bridge some of the divide between religious and LGBTQ communities, and to address the insidious LGBTQ stigma that drives people toward conversion therapy.
Arguments in Support:
Equality California (EQ) supports ACR 99 because, it claims, for "far too long, LGBTQ people have suffered psychological abuse by those who are entrusted to care for their emotional, psychological, and spiritual well-being." EQ claims that "conversion" or "reparative" practices are "dangerous", have no sound scientific basis, and can cause lifelong damage. Finally, EQ insists, "LGBTQ identity cannot change and does not need to be changed."
Arguments in Opposition:
According to the Capitol Resource Institute, "the issue at hand is one of choice. It is the goal of ACR 99 to eventually criminalize one's choice to seek counseling and other services should they disagree with sexual desires or urges they are experiencing or struggling with. People looking for change to fit internal desires of their conscience and heart should be free to find services and resources from counselors, schools, and faith-based organizations to help them achieve their desired goals and outcomes."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
None
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 9-2-1
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gabriel, Holden, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Gallagher, Kiley
ABS, ABST OR NV: Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: June 24, 2019
CONSULTANT: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001135
Date of Hearing: June 18, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:ACR 99
Author:(Low) – As Introduced Ver:June 4, 2019
As Proposed to be Amended
SUBJECT: Civil rights: lesbian, gay, bisexual, or transgender people
KEY ISSUES:
- should the legislature call upon religious leaders to approach LGBTQ issues with love, compassion, and knowledge of the harms caused by efforts to change sexual orientation?
- should the legislature call upon all people and institutions in California to embrace the benefits of family and community acceptance and model equitable treatment of all people?
SYNOPSIS
This author-sponsored resolution calls upon religious leaders to counsel LGBTQ persons from a place of “love, compassion, and knowledge of the psychological and other harms of conversion therapy,” and calls upon all Californians to embrace acceptance and equitable treatment of all people. Although the resolution highlights the dangers of “conversion therapy,” also known as “sexual orientation change efforts,” it does not demand the prohibition of the practice, as past legislative efforts have sought to do. Existing law (enacted by SB 1172, Chap. 835, Stats. 2012) prohibits a “mental health provider” from conducting any sexual orientation change efforts (SOCE) with a patient under 18 years of age. Existing law does not prevent unlicensed counselors (including clergy) from offering SOCE to minors, and it does not prevent any person (licensed or unlicensed) from offering SOCE to an adult. Existing law may have minimal impact, because it only applies to licensed mental health professionals, who have largely abandoned the practice, but it does not apply to those most likely to engage in the practice: unlicensed, mostly religious, counselors. Last year’s AB 2943 (Low) attempted to extend the prohibitions in SB 1172 by making it an unlawful business practice to advertise, offer to engage in, or engage in SOCE. AB 2943 assumed, in effect, that those who advertise or offer such services make false claims about the possibility of changing a person’s sexual orientation. After AB 2943 returned for concurrence in Senate amendments, the author placed the measure on the inactive file. Not only is this resolution nonbinding, but what it calls for is quite modest relative to past legislative efforts. While the resolution is rooted in the assumption that “conversion therapy” is ineffective, unethical, and harmful, its resolves are actually quite modest and uncontroversial. It calls upon all Californians “to embrace the individual and social benefits of family and community acceptance.” It calls upon religious leaders “to counsel on LGBTQ matters from a place of love, compassion, and knowledge of the psychological and other harms of conversion therapy.” It calls upon the people and institutions of California “to model equitable treatment of all people of the state.” The author will take non-substantive clarifying amendments in this Committee.
SUMMARY: Makes declarations relating to the harmfulness and ineffectiveness of “conversion therapy” as a means to “change” sexual orientation, and calls upon religious leaders, and indeed all Californians, to treat all people with understanding and acceptance. Specifically, this measure:
- Finds and declares the following:
- The California State Legislature has found that being lesbian, gay, bisexual, or transgender (LGBTQ) is not a disease, disorder, illness, deficiency, or shortcoming.
- Major professional associations of mental and physical health recognize that being LGBTQ is part of natural variations that occur in sexual orientation and gender identity, and recommend responsive services that foster self-acceptance and skills to cope with social stigma and discrimination.
- Practices or therapies that attempt to create a change in a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity are often referred to as conversion therapy.
- Some family, caregivers, and communities promote conversion therapy when a person is known or thought to be LGBTQ.
- California law recognizes that performing conversion therapy on young persons is ineffective, unethical, and harmful.
- Conversion therapy has been rejected as ineffective, unethical, and harmful by leading medical, mental health, and child welfare organizations in the United States.
- The stigma associated with being LGBTQ often created by groups in society, including therapists and religious groups, has caused disproportionately high rates of suicide, attempted suicide, depression, rejection, and isolation amongst LGBTQ and questioning individuals.
- The State of California has a compelling interest in protecting the physical and psychological well-being of minors, including LGBTQ youth, and in protecting its minors against exposure to serious harms caused by family rejection and attempts to change sexual orientation or gender identity.
- In a pluralistic society, people differing along spectrums of political and religious perspectives share a common responsibility of protecting the health and well-being of all children and vulnerable communities.
- Resolves, in the light of the above findings and declarations, that the Legislature:
- Calls upon all Californians to embrace the individual and social benefits of family and community acceptance.
- Calls upon religious leaders to counsel on LGBTQ matters from a place of love, compassion, and knowledge of the psychological and other harms of conversion therapy.
- Calls upon all people and institutions in California, when addressing the stigma often associated with persons who identify as LGBTQ, to model equitable treatment of all people.
EXISTING LAW:
- Provides that under no circumstances shall a mental health provider, as defined, engage in sexual orientation change efforts with a patient under 18 years of age. Provides that sexual orientation change efforts attempted on a patient under 18 years constitutes unprofessional conduct and shall subject a mental health provider to discipline by the relevant licensing agency. (Business & Professions Code Sections 865.1 and 865.2.)
- Defines “sexual orientation change efforts,” for purposes of the above, to mean any practices that seek to change an individual’s sexual orientation, including efforts to change behaviors or gender expressions, or to eliminate or reduce sexual attractions toward persons of the same sex. Specifies that “sexual orientation change efforts” do not include psychotherapies that (A) provide acceptance, support, and understanding of clients or the facilitation of coping, social support, and identity exploration and development, and (B) do not seek to change sexual orientation. (Business and Professions Code Section 865(b).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this resolution is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: This measure reflects an ongoing debate, both within the Legislature and beyond, about the merits of so-called “conversion therapy,” or what California law refers to as “sexual orientation change efforts” (SOCE). Some (mostly religious-based) counselors contend that SOCE is a legitimate psychological and spiritual therapy that allows persons who have sexual attractions for persons of the same sex, and who are unhappy with that orientation, to re-orient themselves towards heterosexuality – which most, but not all, SOCE proponents see as the “natural” or “normal” sexual orientation. Most professional and licensed psychologists, counselors, and social workers, on the other hand, have long held that SOCE is at best ineffective and at worst psychologically harmful. For example, ten years ago a task force assembled by the American Psychological Association (APA) conducted a systematic review of peer-reviewed journal literature on SOCE. This literature suggested that efforts to change sexual orientation “are unlikely to be successful and involve some risk of harm, contrary to the claims of SOCE practitioners and advocates.” (American Psychological Association, Report of the American Psychological Association Task Force on Appropriate Therapeutic Responses to Sexual Orientation, 2009. [Hereafter APA Report.] http://www.apa.org/pi/lgbc/publications/therapeutic-resp.html.)
The 2009 APA Report did not emerge in a vacuum, but rather reflected decades of growing acceptance of homosexuality and bisexuality in the medical and psychiatric professions, as acceptance grew in society more generally. In the 1970s, due to a changing social climate and a growing body of scientific evidence, the APA and other professional organizations accepted that “homosexuality per se is not a mental disorder and rejected the stigma of mental illness that the medical and mental health professions had previously placed on sexual minorities.” As early as 1973, the APA removed “homosexuality” from the list of psychological “disorders” in its influential Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM). In addition to the APA actions, other professional associations followed suit, as licensed mental health providers increasingly took the perspective throughout this period that “homosexuality per se is a normal variant of human sexuality and that lesbian, gay, and bisexual people deserve to be affirmed and supported in their sexual orientation relationships, and social opportunities.” From the professionals’ perspective, not surprisingly, SOCE did not affirm and support LGBTQ people, but instead suggested that there was something wrong with them and that they needed “treatment.” The professional psychiatric and medical community continues to harbor grave doubts about the ethics and effectiveness of SOCE. For example, in 2015 the American College of Physicians explained its opposition to SOCE as follows:
Available research does not support the use of reparative therapy as an effective method in the treatment of LGBT persons. Evidence shows that the practice may actually cause emotional or physical harm to LGBT individuals, particularly adolescents or young persons. Research [has] found that LGBT youth who were rejected by their families because of their identity were more likely than their LGBT peers who were not rejected or only mildly rejected by their families to attempt suicide, report high levels of depression, use illegal drugs, or be at risk for HIV and sexually transmitted illnesses. The American Psychological Association literature review found that reparative therapy is associated with the loss of sexual feeling, depression, anxiety, and suicidality. (American College of Physicians, Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, and Transgender Health Disparities: Executive Summary of a Policy Position Paper from the American College of Physicians, Ann Intern Med. (2015) [Citations omitted.]
However, in fairness to claims made by SOCE advocates, the 2009 APA Report was not as conclusive as it may appear at first blush. For example, while the literature review suggested a professional consensus on the ineffectiveness and potential harmfulness of SOCE, the report nonetheless raised questions about the scientific rigor and methods used in the studies that informed that consensus. Indeed, the 2009 report concluded, “there are no studies of adequate scientific rigor to conclude whether or not recent SOCE do or do not work to change a person’s sexual orientation.” The report cited older, more scientifically rigorous studies, however, that concluded, more modestly, that it was “unlikely” that SOCE could successfully change a person’s sexual orientation. (APA Report, p. 2 and Appendix A, p 119.) Nonetheless, the APA’s resolution made it clear that its position did not require scientific certitude; as a matter of values and professional ethics, the APA resolved that the appropriate response of counselors should be to affirm and accept LGBTQ persons; to the great majority of professionals at least, SOCE appears to be the antithesis of affirmation and acceptance.
Past Legislation on SOCE: The California Legislature led national efforts to curb the use of SOCE or “conversion therapy” in 2012, with SB 1172 (Lieu, Chap. 835, Stats. 2012). SB 1172 prohibited “mental health providers” (generally defined as licensed psychologists, therapists, and social workers) from engaging in sexual orientation change efforts with a patient under 18 years of age. SB 1172 made engaging in such practices “unprofessional conduct” that would subject the licensed practitioner to discipline by the licensing agency. Thus, SB 1172 is limited in two important ways. First, by restricting its application to licensed mental health professionals, it has no impact on unlicensed (mostly religious) counselors. Professional associations, after all, already strongly discourage providers from engaging in SOCE; instead, the professional norm favors approaches that accept and affirm the client’s sexual orientation. The counselors who still engage in SOCE are mostly unlicensed. In short, SB 1172 exempted the very persons most likely to offer SOCE. Second, SB 1172 was limited in that it only prohibited using SOCE with clients under 18 years of age. In other words, unlicensed counselors can provide SOCE to anyone, regardless of age; licensed counselors can still offer SOCE to adults.
Despite its limitations, SB 1172 almost immediately faced legal challenges. However, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals upheld SB 1172 against a variety of constitutional challenges made by practitioners of SOCE, organizations that advocate for SOCE, and by the parents of children who were undergoing SOCE. In Pickup v. Brown (2014) 740 F.3d. 1208, the Ninth Circuit held that, “as a regulation of professional conduct, [SB 1172] does not violate the free speech rights of SOCE practitioners or minor patients, is neither vague nor overbroad, and does not violate parents' fundamental rights.”
AB 2943 (Low, 2018) attempted to address the weaknesses in existing law by making it an unlawful business practice to advertise or offer any services or “therapy” that purported to change a person’s sexual orientation. In light of the professional consensus on the ineffectiveness of SOCE, the bill presupposed that advertising or offering to perform SOCE was essentially a “false” or “deceptive” form of advertising prohibited by the Consumer Legal Remedies Act. Although AB 2943 passed off the floors of both houses, the author nonetheless placed the measure on the inactive file when it returned to the Assembly for concurrence in Senate amendments.
Another measure from last session, AB 1779 (Nazarian, 2018), would have prohibited a mental health provider from engaging in SOCE with a person under a conservatorship or guardianship, regardless of that person’s age, unless the person meaningfully consented. That measure died in the Assembly Committee on Business and Professions.
ACR 99 is much more modest than past efforts to extend the prohibition on SOCE. In addition to the fact that it is a nonbinding resolution, ACR 99 does not call for a prohibition on SOCE or “conversion therapy.” After making findings and declarations about the professional consensus that SOCE is ineffective, harmful, and inconsistent with our professed commitment to acceptance of LGBTQ persons, this measure’s “resolves” simply to call upon religious leaders to counsel on LGBTQ matters with “love, compassion, and knowledge of the psychological and others harms of conversion therapy.” ACR 99 calls upon everyone else to embrace the benefits of acceptance and to “model equitable treatment of all people in the state.”
Author Amendments: The author will take the following technical and clarifying amendments in this Committee:
- On page 2, lines 39-40, delete “with conviction”
- Change “LGBT” to “LGBTQ” throughout, at a minimum at page 2, lines 2, 5, 14, 21, 25, 28, and 40, and page 3, line 4.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Equality California (EQ) supports ACR 99 because, it claims, for “far too long, LGBTQ people have suffered psychological abuse by those who are entrusted to care for their emotional, psychological, and spiritual well-being.” EQ claims that “conversion” or “reparative” practices are “dangerous”, have no sound scientific basis, and can cause lifelong damage. For this reason, EQ contends, “all of the nation’s leading professional, medical, and mental health associations have rejected conversion therapy as unnecessary, ineffective, and dangerous.” Finally, EQ insists, “LGBTQ identity cannot change and does not need to be changed.”
The Santa Clara Methodist Retirement Foundation supports this bill for substantially the same reasons as those noted above, but it also adds that, to date, “eighteen states, Puerto Rico, and the District of Columbia have [laws similar to SB 1172], demonstrating a growing national consensus that these practices are dangerous and damaging.”
Finally, an individual writing as a “Christian pastor” supports ACR 99. It is not entirely clear from the letter whether or not the pastor endorses of opposes SOCE. In any event, the pastor supports ACR 99 because he supports its call for compassion and believes that the resolution will result in “productive dialogue” between persons who might “start from differing points of view regarding human sexuality.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Equality California
Santa Clara Methodist Retirement Foundation
Several individuals
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Thomas Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):