SB 1: California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019.
- Session Year: 2019-2020
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2019-09-17
(1)The federal Clean Air Act regulates the discharge of air pollutants into the atmosphere. The federal Clean Water Act regulates the discharge of pollutants into water. The federal Safe Drinking Water Act establishes drinking water standards for drinking water systems. The federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 generally prohibits activities affecting threatened and endangered species listed pursuant to that act unless authorized by a permit from the United States Fish and Wildlife Service or the National Marine Fisheries Service, as appropriate.
Existing state law regulates the discharge of air pollutants into the atmosphere. The Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act regulates the discharge of pollutants into the waters of the state. The California Safe Drinking Water Act establishes standards for drinking water and regulates drinking water systems. The California Endangered Species Act requires the Fish and Game Commission to establish a list of endangered species and a list of threatened species, and generally prohibits the taking of those species.
This bill would require specified agencies to take prescribed actions regarding certain federal requirements and standards pertaining to air, water, and protected species, as specified. By imposing new duties on local agencies, this bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
(2)Existing law provides for the enforcement of laws regulating the discharge of pollutants into the atmosphere and waters of the state. Existing law provides for the enforcement of drinking water standards. Existing law provides for the enforcement of the California Endangered Species Act.
This bill would authorize a person acting in the public interest to bring an action to enforce certain federal standards and requirements incorporated into certain of the above-mentioned state laws if specified conditions are satisfied.
(3)Existing federal law generally establishes standards for workers rights and worker safety.
Existing state law generally establishes standards for workers rights and worker safety.
This bill would require specified agencies to take prescribed actions regarding certain requirements and standards pertaining to workers rights and worker safety. The bill would authorize a person acting in the public interest to enforce standards and requirements related to workers rights and worker safety, as provided.
(5)This bill would make its provisions inoperative as of January 20, 2025, and would repeal them as of January 1, 2026.
(6) The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that with regard to certain mandates no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
With regard to any other mandates, this bill would provide that, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that the bill contains costs so mandated by the state, reimbursement for those costs shall be made pursuant to the statutory provisions noted above.
This title shall be known, and may be cited, as the California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019.
2.Environment, Natural Resources, and Public Health1.Findings and Declarations120010.The Legislature finds and declares all of the following:
(a)For over four decades, California and its residents have relied on federal laws, including the federal Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 7401 et seq.), the Federal Water Pollution Control Act (Clean Water Act) (33 U.S.C. Sec. 1251 et seq.), the federal Safe Drinking Water Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 300f et seq.), and the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. Sec. 1531 et seq.), along with their implementing regulations and remedies, to protect our states public health, environment, and natural resources.
(b)These federal laws establish standards that serve as the baseline level of public health and environmental protection, while expressly authorizing states like California to adopt more protective measures.
(c)Beginning in 2017, a new presidential administration and United States Congress have signaled a series of direct challenges to these federal laws and the protections they provide, as well as to the underlying science that makes these protections necessary, and to the rights of the states to protect their own environment, natural resources, and public health as they see fit.
(d)It is therefore necessary for the Legislature to enact legislation that will ensure continued protections for the environment, natural resources, and public health in the state even if the federal laws specified in subdivision (a) are undermined, amended, or repealed.
120011.The purposes of this division are to do all of the following:
(a)Retain protections afforded under the federal laws specified in subdivision (a) of Section 120010 and regulations implementing those federal laws in existence as of January 19, 2017, regardless of actions taken at the federal level.
(b)Protect public health and welfare from any actual or potential adverse effect that reasonably may be anticipated to occur from pollution, including the effects of climate change.
(c)Preserve, protect, and enhance the environment and natural resources in California, including, but not limited to, the states national parks, national wilderness areas, national monuments, national seashores, and other areas with special national or regional natural, recreational, scenic, or historic value.
(d)Ensure that economic growth will occur in a manner consistent with the protection of public health and the environment and preservation of existing natural resources.
(e)Ensure that any decision made by a public agency that may adversely impact public health, the environment, or natural resources is made only after careful evaluation of all the consequences of that decision and after adequate procedural opportunities for informed public participation in the decisionmaking process.
2.General Provisions120030.(a)A state agency may adopt standards or requirements pursuant to this title, including, but not limited to, by emergency regulations in accordance with Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2.
(b)The adoption of emergency regulations in furtherance of this title shall be deemed an emergency and necessary for the immediate preservation of the public peace, health, and safety, or general welfare.
(c)Notwithstanding Chapter 3.5 (commencing with Section 11340) of Part 1 of Division 3 of Title 2, emergency regulations adopted by a state agency under this title shall not be subject to review by the Office of Administrative Law and shall remain in effect until revised or repealed by the state agency, or January 20, 2021, whichever comes first.
3.Operative Provisions1.Air120040.For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Air district means an air quality management or air pollution control district.
(b)Baseline federal standards means federal standards in effect as of January 19, 2017.
(c)Federal standards means federal laws or federal regulations implementing the federal Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 7401 et seq.) including federal requirements for a state implementation plan, federal requirements for the transportation conformity program, and federal requirements for the prevention of significant deterioration.
(d)State analogue statute means the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (Division 25.5 (commencing with Section 38500) of the Health and Safety Code) or Division 26 (commencing with Section 39000) of the Health and Safety Code.
(e)State board means the State Air Resources Board.
120041.Except as otherwise authorized by state law, all of the following apply:
(a)The state board shall regularly assess proposed and final changes to the federal standards.
(b)(1)At least quarterly, the state board shall publish a list of changes made to the federal standards and provide an assessment on whether a change made to the federal standards is more or less stringent than the baseline federal standards.
(2)If the state board determines that a change to the federal standards is less stringent than the baseline federal standards, the state board shall consider whether it should adopt the baseline federal standards as a measure in order to maintain the states protections to be at least as stringent as the baseline federal standards.
(3)The state board shall publish its list, assessment, and consideration for adoption at least 30 days prior to a vote on adoption on its internet Web site for public comment.
(c)If the state board decides to adopt a measure pursuant to subdivision (b), the state board shall adopt the measure by either of the following procedures:
(1)As an emergency regulation in accordance with Section 120030.
(2)By promulgation or amendment of a state policy, plan, or regulation.
(d)Notwithstanding any other law, the state board, when adopting a measure under paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) may adopt those measures in accordance with Section 100 of Title 1 of the California Code of Regulations and the measures shall be deemed to be a change without regulatory effect pursuant to paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of that section and not subject to additional notice, procedural, or other considerations contained in state analogue statutes identified in this article. Nothing in this chapter shall affect the imposition of sanctions under the federal Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 7401 et seq.).
(e)In the event that the citizen suit provision set forth in Section 7604 of Title 42 of the United States Code is amended to restrict, condition, abridge, or repeal the citizen suit provision, the state board may consider the amendment as a change to the federal standards and may adopt the baseline federal standards pursuant to subdivision (c).
(f)This article does not prohibit the state board or air districts from establishing rules and regulations for California that are more stringent than the baseline federal standards.
120042.(a)An action may be brought by a person in the public interest exclusively to enforce baseline federal standards adopted as a measure pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 120041 if all of the following requirements are met:
(1)At least 60 days prior to initiating the action, a complainant provides a written notice to the Attorney General and the counsel for the state board, a district attorney, county counsel, counsel of the air district, and prosecutor in whose jurisdiction the violation is alleged to have occurred, and the defendant identifying the specific provisions of the measure alleged to be violated.
(2)The Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney, county counsel, counsel of the state board, counsel of an air district, or a prosecutor has not commenced an action or has not been diligently prosecuting the action.
(b)Upon filing the action, the complainant shall notify the Attorney General that the action has been filed.
(c)The court may award attorneys fees pursuant to Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and expert fees and court costs pursuant to Section 1032 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as appropriate, for an action brought pursuant to this section.
(d)This section does not limit other remedies and protections available under state or federal law.
2.Water120050.For purposes of this article, the following definitions apply:
(a)Baseline federal standards means federal standards in effect as of January 19, 2017, including water quality standards, effluent limitations, and drinking water standards.
(b)Board means the State Water Resources Control Board.
(c)Federal standards means federal laws or federal regulations implementing the federal Safe Drinking Water Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 300f et seq.) and the Federal Water Pollution Control Act (33 U.S.C. Sec. 1251 et seq.) in effect as of January 19, 2017, including water quality standards, effluent limitations, and drinking water standards.
(d)Regional board means a regional water quality control board.
(e)State analogue statute mean the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act (Division 7 (commencing with Section 13000) of the Water Code) or the California Safe Drinking Water Act (Chapter 4 (commencing with Section 116270) of Part 12 of Division 103 of the Health and Safety Code).
120051.Except as otherwise authorized by state law, all of the following apply:
(a)The board shall regularly assess proposed and final changes to the federal standards.
(b)(1)At least quarterly, the board shall publish a list of changes made to the federal standards and provide an assessment on whether a change made to the federal standards is more or less stringent than the baseline federal standards.
(2)If the board determines that a change to the federal standards is less stringent than the baseline federal standards, the board shall consider whether it should adopt the baseline federal standards as a measure in order to maintain the states protections to be at least as stringent as the baseline federal standards.
(3)The state board shall publish its list, assessment, and consideration for adoption at least 30 days prior to a vote on adoption on its Internet Web site for public comment.
(c)If the board decides to adopt a measure pursuant to subdivision (b), the board shall adopt the measure by either of the following procedures:
(1)As an emergency regulation in accordance with Section 120030.
(2)By promulgation or amendment of a state policy for water quality control, a water quality control plan, or regulation.
(d)Notwithstanding any other law, the board, when adopting a measure under paragraph (2) of subdivision (c) may adopt those measures in accordance with Section 100 of Title 1 of the California Code of Regulations and the measures shall be deemed to be a change without regulatory effect pursuant to paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of that section and not subject to additional notice, procedural, or other considerations contained in state analogue statutes identified in this article. Nothing in this chapter shall affect the imposition of sanctions under the federal Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C. Sec. 7401 et seq.).
(g)(1)In the event that the citizen suit provision set forth in Section 1365 of Title 33 of the United States Code is amended to restrict, condition, abridge, or repeal the citizen suit provision, the board may consider the amendment as a change to the federal standards and may adopt the baseline federal standards pursuant to subdivision (c).
(2)In the event that the citizen suit provision set forth in Section 300j-8 of Title 42 of the United States Code is amended to restrict, condition, abridge, or repeal the citizen suit provision, the board may consider the amendment as a change to the federal standards and may adopt the baseline federal standards pursuant to subdivision (c).
(h)This article does not prohibit the board or the regional boards from establishing rules and regulations for California that are more stringent than the baseline federal standards.
120052.(a)An action may be brought by a person in the public interest exclusively to enforce baseline federal standards adopted as a measure pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 120051 if all of the following requirements are met:
(1)At least 60 days prior to initiating the action, a complainant provides a written notice to the Attorney General and the counsel for the board, a district attorney, county counsel, counsel of the regional board, and prosecutor in whose jurisdiction the violation is alleged to have occurred, and the defendant identifying the specific provisions of the measure alleged to be violated.
(2)The Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney, county counsel, counsel of the board, counsel of a regional board, or a prosecutor has not commenced an action or has not been diligently prosecuting the action.
(b)Upon filing the action, the complainant shall notify the Attorney General that the action has been filed.
(c)The court may award attorneys fees pursuant to Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and expert fees and court costs pursuant to Section 1032 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as appropriate, for an action brought pursuant to this section.
(d)This section does not limit other remedies and protections available under state or federal law.
3.Endangered and Threatened Species120060.For purposes of this article, baseline federal standards means the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. Sec. 1531 et seq.) in effect as of January 19, 2017, its implementing regulations, and any incidental take permits, incidental take statements, or biological opinions in effect as of January 19, 2017.
120061.Except as otherwise authorized by state law, the following apply:
(a)To ensure no backsliding as a result of any change to the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 (16 U.S.C. Sec. 1531 et seq.) or its implementing regulations, in the event of the federal delisting of a species that is eligible for protection under the California Endangered Species Act and which is listed as endangered or threatened pursuant to the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 as of January 1, 2017, or a change in the legally protected status of such a species, including through a change in listing from endangered to threatened, the adoption of a rule pursuant to Section 4(d) of the federal Endangered Species Act, or any amendment to the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 or its implementing regulations, or any exemption from the application of the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 to a federally listed species as of January 1, 2017, the Fish and Game Commission shall determine whether to list, in accordance with subdivision (b), that species under the California Endangered Species Act pursuant to this section.
(b)The Fish and Game Commission shall list the affected species identified in subdivision (a), pursuant to subdivision (c) and without following the regular listing process set forth in Article 2 (commencing with Section 2070) of Chapter 1.5 of Division 3 of the Fish and Game Code, no later than the conclusion of its second regularly scheduled meeting or within three months, whichever is shorter, after the occurrence of the event described in subdivision (a) unless either the Fish and Game Commission determines that listing of the species is not warranted because it does not meet the criteria in Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 2050) of Division 3 of the Fish and Game Code or its implementing regulations or the Department of Fish and Wildlife recommends that the species undergo the regular listing process. If the Department of Fish and Wildlife makes a recommendation that the species undergo the regular listing process, the Fish and Game Commission shall either accept the recommendation, in which event the Fish and Game Commission shall be deemed to have accepted a petition for listing the species pursuant to paragraph (2) of subdivision (e) of Section 2074.2 of the Fish and Game Code, or reject the recommendation and immediately list the species pursuant to this subdivision.
(c)Notwithstanding any other law or regulation, because a decision by the Fish and Game Commission to list a species without following the regular listing process becomes effective immediately, the Fish and Game Commission shall add that species to the list of endangered or threatened species pursuant to Section 100 of Title 1 of the California Code of Regulations, and the addition of that species to the list shall be deemed to be a change without regulatory effect pursuant to paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of that section.
(d)(1)Upon the listing of any species under this section, the Fish and Game Commission or the Department of Fish and Wildlife may authorize the taking of such species as otherwise provided for in the Fish and Game Code. In lieu of authorizing take under the provisions of Chapter 1.5 (commencing with Section 2050) of Division 3 of the Fish and Game Code, the Fish and Game Commission or the Department of Fish and Wildlife may adopt the terms and conditions of any rule promulgated under Section 4(d) of the federal Endangered Species Act, federal incidental take statement, incidental take permit, or biological opinion in effect at the time of the event described in subdivision (a).
(2)The Department of Fish and Wildlife shall ensure that protections remain in place pursuant to regulation, incidental take permit, or consistency determination that are at least as stringent as required by the baseline federal standards, as determined by the Department of Fish and Wildlife.
(3)This subdivision does not prohibit the Department of Fish and Wildlife from establishing conditions that are more stringent than the baseline federal standards.
(e)Any species listed pursuant to this section shall be subject to the provisions in the California Endangered Species Act in the same manner as any other listed species, including those provisions related to a change in listing status or delisting.
(f)For those species that the Fish and Game Commission lists pursuant to subdivision (b), or for which baseline federal standards are retained pursuant to subdivision (d), the California Environmental Quality Act (Division 13 (commencing with Section 21000) of the Public Resources Code) shall not apply.
(g)The provisions of the California Endangered Species Act are measures relating to the control, appropriation, use, or distribution of water within the meaning of Section 8 of the federal Reclamation Act of 1902 (43 U.S.C. Section 383) and shall apply to the United States Bureau of Reclamations operation of the federal Central Valley Project.
3.Labor Standards1.Definitions120100.For purposes of this division, the following definitions apply:
(a)Baseline federal standards means federal standards in effect as of January 1, 2017.
(b)Board means the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board.
(c)Department means the Department of Industrial Relations.
(d)Federal standards means the federal Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938, as amended (29 U.S.C. Sec. 201 et seq.), the federal Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970, as amended (29 U.S.C. Sec. 651 et seq.), the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969, as amended (30 U.S.C. Sec. 801 et seq.), or regulations established pursuant to those federal statutes.
2.Operative Provisions120110.Except as otherwise authorized by state law, all of the following apply:
(a)The board and the department shall regularly assess proposed and final changes to the federal standards.
(b)(1)At least quarterly, the board and the department shall publish a list of changes made to the federal standards and provide an assessment on whether a change made to the federal standards is more or less stringent than the baseline federal standards.
(2)If the board or the department, as appropriate, determines that a change to the federal standards is less stringent than the baseline federal standards, the board shall consider whether it should adopt the baseline federal standards as a measure in order to maintain the states protections to be at least as stringent as the baseline federal standards.
(3)The board and the department shall publish its list, assessment, and consideration for adoption at least 30 days prior to a vote on adoption on its Internet Web site for public comment.
(c)If the board or the department, as appropriate, decides to adopt a measure pursuant to subdivision (b), the board or the department shall adopt the measure by an emergency regulation in accordance with Section 120030.
(d)Notwithstanding any other law, the board or department, when adopting a measure under subdivision (c) may adopt those measures in accordance with Section 100 of Title 1 of the California Code of Regulations and the measures shall be deemed to be a change without regulatory effect pursuant to paragraph (6) of subdivision (a) of that section and not subject to additional notice, procedural, or other considerations contained in state analogue statutes.
(e)This division does not prohibit the board or the department from establishing rules and regulations for California that are more stringent than the baseline federal standards.
120111.(a)An action may be brought by a person in the public interest exclusively to enforce a measure adopted pursuant to subdivision (c) of Section 120110 if all of the following requirements are met:
(1)At least 60 days prior to initiating the action, a complainant provides a written notice to the Attorney General and the counsels for the board or department, as appropriate, a district attorney, a city attorney, county counsel, and a prosecutor in whose jurisdiction the violation is alleged to have occurred, and the defendant identifying the specific provisions of the measure alleged to be violated.
(2)The Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney, county counsel, the counsel for the board or department, as appropriate, or a prosecutor has not commenced an action or has not been diligently prosecuting the action.
(b)Upon filing the action, the complainant shall notify the Attorney General that the action has been filed.
(c)The court may award attorneys fees pursuant to Section 1021.5 of the Code of Civil Procedure, and expert fees and court costs pursuant to Section 1032 of the Code of Civil Procedure, as appropriate, for an action brought pursuant to this section.
(d)This section does not limit other remedies and protections available under state or federal law.
4.Miscellaneous120200.The provisions of this title are severable. If any provision of this title or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
120202.(a) This title shall become inoperative on January 20, 2025, and, as of January 1, 2026, is repealed.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), any action brought pursuant to this title on or before January 20, 2025, may proceed to a final judgment.
SEC. 2.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because a local agency or school district has the authority to levy service charges, fees, or assessments sufficient to pay for the program or level of service mandated by certain mandates in this act, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code.
However, if the Commission on State Mandates determines that this act contains other costs mandated by the state, reimbursement to local agencies and school districts for those costs shall be made pursuant to Part 7 (commencing with Section 17500) of Division 4 of Title 2 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jan 13, 2020 | Stricken from file. |
| Sep 27, 2019 | In Senate. Consideration of Governor's veto pending. |
| Sep 27, 2019 | Vetoed by the Governor. |
| Sep 17, 2019 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2 p.m. |
| Sep 14, 2019 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 26. Noes 14.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Sep 14, 2019 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| Sep 13, 2019 | Assembly Rule 96 and 63 suspended. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Sep 10, 2019 | Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. pursuant to Assembly Rule 97. |
| Sep 9, 2019 | Joint Rule 61(a) suspended. |
| Sep 4, 2019 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Sep 3, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Aug 30, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 13. Noes 5.) (August 30). |
| Aug 21, 2019 | August 21 set for first hearing. Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| Jul 9, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 8. Noes 2.) (July 9). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 8, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 8. Noes 3.) (July 8). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jul 1, 2019 | Assembly Rule 56 suspended. |
| Jul 1, 2019 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Jun 25, 2019 | July 1 set for second hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 24, 2019 | June 24 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 19, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on NAT. RES. (Ayes 6. Noes 1.) (June 18). Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Jun 6, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on E.S. & T.M., NAT. RES., and JUD. |
| May 29, 2019 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 29, 2019 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 28. Noes 10.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 21, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 20, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (May 16). |
| May 14, 2019 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2019 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR. suspense file. |
| May 3, 2019 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 24, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 6. Noes 2.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 18, 2019 | Set for hearing April 23. |
| Apr 11, 2019 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 10, 2019 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 7. Noes 2.) (April 9). |
| Mar 22, 2019 | Set for hearing April 9. |
| Mar 20, 2019 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on N.R. & W. (Ayes 5. Noes 2.) (March 20). Re-referred to Com. on N.R. & W. |
| Feb 12, 2019 | Set for hearing March 20. |
| Jan 16, 2019 | Referred to Coms. on EQ., N.R. & W., and JUD. |
| Dec 4, 2018 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after January 3. |
| Dec 3, 2018 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 14, 2019 | Unfinished Business SB1 Atkins | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 13, 2019 | SB 1 Atkins Senate Third Reading By FRIEDMAN | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 30, 2019 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 9, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jul 8, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
|
| Jun 18, 2019 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Natural Resources] | Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials |
Passed |
|
| May 29, 2019 | Senate 3rd Reading SB1 Atkins et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2019 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2019 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 9, 2019 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Natural Resources and Water |
Passed |
|
| Mar 20, 2019 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Natural Resources and Water] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1 |
VETO
Bill No: SB 1
Author: Atkins (D), Portantino (D), and Stern (D), et al.
Amended: 9/10/19
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 3/20/19
AYES: Allen, Hill, Skinner, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Stone
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 7-2, 4/9/19
AYES: Stern, Allen, Caballero, Hertzberg, Hueso, Jackson, Monning
NOES: Jones, Borgeas
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 6-2, 4/23/19
AYES: Jackson, Allen, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Borgeas, Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Caballero
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 4-2, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SENATE FLOOR: 28-10, 5/29/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NOES: Bates, Borgeas, Chang, Grove, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
SENATE FLOOR: 26-14, 9/14/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Dodd, Durazo, Glazer, Lena Gonzalez, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NOES: Bates, Borgeas, Caballero, Chang, Dahle, Galgiani, Grove, Hurtado, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 48-22, 9/13/19 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019
DIGEST:
This bill enacts the California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019 with the purpose of ensuring that protections afforded to Californians under federal environmental and labor laws and regulations as of January 2017, remain in place in the event that the federal government weakens or repeals any of those federal laws or regulations.
ANALYSIS: Existing federal law authorizes states, for each of the following statutes, to act as delegates for implementing and enforcing the federal acts, as long as the state’s laws are at least as stringent as or more stringent than the federal act or to enact their own similar state statute:
- Regulates, under the federal Clean Air Act (FCAA), air emissions from stationary and mobile sources to protect public health and public welfare and to regulate emissions of hazardous air pollutants.
- Regulates, under the Clean Water Act (CWA), discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States and regulates quality standards for surface waters.
- Regulates, under the Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA), the nation’s public drinking water supply, and requires the US EPA to establish mandatory nationwide drinking water standards. SDWA additionally requires water systems to monitor public water supplies to ensure drinking water standards are met and report to consumers if the standards are not met.
- Provides, under the Endangered Species Act (ESA), for the conservation of species that are endangered or threatened throughout all or a significant portion of their range, and the conservation of the ecosystems on which they depend.
Existing state law:
- Prohibits, under the Protect California Air Act of 2003, air quality management districts and air pollution control districts from amending or revising their new source review rules or regulations to be less stringent than those rules or regulations that existed on December 30, 2002, except under certain circumstances.
- Establishes, under the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (AB 32), a comprehensive program to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from all sources throughout the state to combat climate change.
- Regulates, under the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, the discharge of pollutants into the waters of the state.
- Establishes, under the California Safe Drinking Water Act, standards for drinking water and regulates drinking water systems.
- Requires, under the California Endangered Species Act, the Fish and Game Commission to establish a list of endangered species and a list of threatened species and generally prohibits the taking of those species.
This bill:
- Requires the State Air Resources Board to adopt, via regulation, any federal air standard that is weakened after January 2017.
- Authorizes the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board and the Department of Industrial Relations to adopt, via regulation, any worker protections that were in place in federal law or regulation as of January 2017, and were subsequently weakened or repealed.
- Requires the State Water Resources Control Board, by June 30, 2020, to adopt a primary drinking water standard at least as stringent as the national primary drinking water standard as that standard was in affect as of January 2017.
- Authorizes the Fish and Game Commission to adopt, via regulation, protections for species, if the Commission determines that a federal action after January 2017 provides less protection for that species.
- Authorizes, instead of requires, the Fish and Game Commission or the Department of Fish and Wildlife to apply protections provided by any federal biological opinion, incidental take permit, or incidental take statement when authorizing the take of any species listed as endangered or threatened under California law.
- Provides a private right of action to enforce certain air and water standards within California if the private right of action within federal law or regulation is weakened or repealed.
- Provides that any state regulation adopted to ensure protections of federal law or regulation as of January 2017, sunsets on January 20, 2025.
Background
Federal rollbacks. President Trump has made eliminating federal regulations a priority. His administration has often targeted environmental rules it sees as burdensome to the fossil fuel industry and other big businesses.
A New York Times analysis, based on research from Harvard Law School, Columbia Law School, and other sources, counts more than 80 environmental rules and regulations either officially reversed or in the process of being rolled back.
Comments
Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “SB 1 makes federal baseline standards for environmental and worker protection enforceable as a matter of state law, when the current administration in Washington D.C. rolls them back. It has been roughly three years and two months since the new administration took office in Washington D.C. During that time, according to the New York Times and numerous authorities: [More than] 34 different key clean air, clean water, and endangered species standards have been weakened or eliminated. In addition, and for the third year in a row, the federal administration has proposed a budget blueprint that would reduce the budget of the [United States Environmental Protection Agency] to a point where the agency would no longer be able to meaningfully enforce clean air and water laws. SB 1 simply provides that, whatever actions the new federal regime may take, California will continue to enforce the same environmental and public health protections that have been in effect for years, as a matter of state law.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, enactment of this bill could result in significant costs of approximately $5 million for the California Air Resources Board; approximately $6 million for the Department of Fish and Wildlife; minor and absorbable costs for the State Water Resources Control Board; and, unknown, but potentially significant litigation costs for the Department of Justice.
350 Bay Area
350 Sacramento
350 South Bay Los Angeles
American Sportfishing Association
Audubon California
AZUL
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Association of Local Conservation Corps
California Association of Professional Scientists
California Catholic Conference
California Coastal Protection Network
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California Interfaith Power & Light
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
California League of Conservation Voters
California Professional Firefighters
California ReLEAF
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Parks Foundation
California State Pipe Trades Council
Californians Against Waste
CALSTART
Central Valley Air Quality Coalition
City of Del Mar
Clean Water Action
Coachella Valley Waterkeeper
Coalition for Clean Air
Community Action to Fight Asthma
Defenders of Wildlife
East Bay Municipal Utility District
Environment California
Environmental Defense Center
Environmental Defense Fund
Environmental Water Caucus
Environmental Working Group
Fossil Free California
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Heal the Bay
Health Officers Association of California
Humboldt Baykeeper
Latino Outdoors
League of Women Voters of California
Los Angeles Mayor, Eric Garcetti
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District
Mono Lake Committee
Monterey Bay Aquarium
Monterey Coastkeeper
Natural Resources Defense Council
Nextgen California
Orange County Coastkeeper
PawPAC
Planning and Conservation League
Plug In America
Protect American River Canyons
Restore The Delta
Russian Riverkeeper
San Diego 350
San Diego Coastkeeper
Santa Barbara Channelkeeper
Save Our Shores
Save the Bay
Seventh Generation Advisors
Sierra Club California
South Coast Air Quality Management District
State Building & Construction Trades Council of California
Surfrider Foundation
The 5 Gyres Institute
The Nature Conservancy
The Otter Project
The Trust for Public Land
UDW/AFSCME Local 3930
Voices for Progress
Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation
Wildcoast
Yuba River Waterkeeper
Zero Waste USA
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/12/19)
African American Farmers of California
Agricultural Council of California
Agricultural Energy Consumers Association
Almond Alliance of California
American Coatings Association
American Pistachio Growers
Antelope Valley East Kern Water Agency
Association of California Cities - Orange County
Association of California Water Agencies
Auto Care Association
Bizfed Central Valley
Brea Area Chamber of Commerce
Building Owners and Managers Association
Byron-Bethany Irrigation District
California Agricultural Aircraft Association
California Association of Realtors
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Forestry Association
California Fresh Fruit Association
California Grain and Feed Association
California Independent Petroleum Association
California League of Food Producers
California Licensed Foresters Association
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Metals Coalition
California Paint Council
California Poultry Federation
California Restaurant Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
CAWA – Representing the Automotive Parts Industry
Central Coast Water Authority
Chemical Industry Council of California
City of Compton - Water Department
Coachella Valley Water District
Construction Employers Association
County of Fresno
County of Kern
County of Kings
County of Madera
County of Merced
County of San Joaquin
County of Stanislaus
County of Tulare
Cucamonga Valley Water District
Desert Water Agency
Dudley Ridge Water District
El Dorado County Chamber of Commerce
El Dorado Irrigation District
El Monte/South El Monte Chamber of Commerce
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Far West Equipment Dealers Association
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Foothill Municipal Water District
Forest Landowners of California
Friant Water Authority
Glendora Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater West Covina Business Association
Household and Commercial Products Association
Inland Empire Utilities Agency
International Council of Shopping Centers
Kern County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
Kern County Water Agency
La Verne Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Mojave Water Agency
Murrieta Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
NAIOP of California
National Federation of Independent Business
Nisei Farmers League
North of the River Chamber of Commerce
North Orange County Chamber of Commerce
Northern California Water Association
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Palmdale Water District
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Regional Chamber of Commerce San Gabriel Valley
Regional Water Authority
Roseville Chamber of Commerce
Rowland Water District
San Bernardino Valley Municipal Water District
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
San Gabriel Valley Municipal Water District
San Joaquin River Exchange Contractors Water Authority
San Luis Delta-Mendota Water Authority
Santa Clara Valley Water District
Santa Clarita Valley Water Agency
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Southern California Water Coalition
Southwest California Legislative Council
State Water Contractors, Inc.
The Metropolitan Water District of Southern California
Three Valleys Municipal Water District
Torrance Chamber of Commerce
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
United Ag
United Water Conservation District
Valley Ag Water Coalition
Valley Industry and Commerce Association
Walnut Valley Water District
West Coast Lumber & Building Material Association
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Western Independent Refiners Association
Western Municipal Water District
Western Plant Health Association
Western States Petroleum Association
Western Wood Preservers Institute
Westlands Water District
GOVERNOR'S VETO MESSAGE:
I am returning Senate Bill 1 without my signature.
This bill would enact the California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019 with the intent of ensuring that protections afforded under federal environmental and labor laws and regulations as of January 2017, could remain in place in the event of federal regulatory changes.
California is a leader in the fight for resource, environmental, and worker protections. Since 2017, the federal government has repeatedly tried to override and invalidate those protections, and each time, the state has aggressively countered - taking immediate legal action and deploying every tool at the state's disposal to safeguard our natural resources, environmental protections and workers. No other state has fought harder to defeat Trump's environmental policies, and that will continue to be the case.
While I disagree about the efficacy and necessity of Senate Bill 1, I look forward to working with the Legislature in our shared fight against the weakening of California's environmental and worker protections.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 48-22, 9/13/19
AYES: Aguiar-Curry, Bauer-Kahan, Berman, Bloom, Boerner Horvath, Bonta, Burke, Calderon, Carrillo, Cervantes, Chau, Chiu, Chu, Eggman, Frazier, Friedman, Gabriel, Cristina Garcia, Gipson, Gloria, Gonzalez, Grayson, Holden, Irwin, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Kamlager-Dove, Levine, Limón, Low, Maienschein, McCarty, Medina, Mullin, Muratsuchi, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Quirk-Silva, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Santiago, Smith, Mark Stone, Ting, Weber, Wicks, Wood, Rendon
NOES: Arambula, Bigelow, Brough, Chen, Choi, Cooley, Cunningham, Diep, Flora, Fong, Gallagher, Gray, Kiley, Lackey, Mathis, Mayes, Melendez, Obernolte, Patterson, Salas, Voepel, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Cooper, Daly, Eduardo Garcia, Nazarian, O'Donnell, Ramos, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio
Prepared by: Eric Walters / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
10/21/19 11:33:36
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1
Author:(Atkins, et al.)
As Amended Ver:September 10, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Enacts the California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019 (Act) with the purpose of ensuring that protections afforded to Californians under federal environmental and labor laws and regulations as of January 2017, remain in place in the event that President Trump weakens or repeals any of those federal laws or regulations.
Major Provisions
- Requires the State Air Resources Control Board to adopt, via regulation, any federal air standard that is weakened after January 2017.
- Authorizes the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board and the Department of Industrial Relations to adopt, via regulation, any worker protections that were in place in federal law or regulation as of January 2017, and were subsequently weakened or repealed.
- Requires the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board), by June 30, 2020, to adopt a primary drinking water standard at least as stringent as the national primary drinking water standard as that standard was in affect as of January 2017.
- Authorizes the Fish and Game Commission (Commission) to adopt, via regulation, protections for species, if the Commission determines that a federal action after January 2017 provides less protection for that species.
- Authorizes, instead of requires, the Fish and Game Commission (Commission) or the Department of Fish and Wildlife (DFW) to apply protections provided by any federal biological opinion, incidental take permit, or incidental take statement when authorizing the take of any species listed as endangered or threatened under California law.
- Provides a private right of action to enforce certain air and water standards within California if the private right of action within federal law or regulation is weakened or repealed.
- Provides that any state regulation adopted to ensure protections of federal law or regulation as of January 2017, sunsets on January 20, 2025.
COMMENTS:
Response to President Trump's anti-environmental policies: This bill was introduced to respond to the Trump Administration's attack on laws and regulations that protect public health and the environment. It is clear that the new federal administration is interested in easing compliance with laws and regulations for multi-billion dollar corporations; however, it is unclear, exactly, which environmental laws or regulations could become a target for weakening or repealing or what the economic, public health, and environmental impacts the actions might have on California. This bill simply sets a floor for the federal environmental laws currently in place in order to ensure that the economic, environmental, and public health benefits of these laws are maintained in California. The public health and environmental protections provided by the federal Clean Air Act, federal Clean Water Act, and all of the environmental laws and regulations in place provide very important and very real benefits to everyone in this country.
California is the fifth largest economy in the world and has some of the most, if not the most, protective public health and environmental laws in the country. Protecting human health and the environment and promoting economic growth are not mutually exclusive. This bill is intended to ensure that the strong environmental protections, coupled with the strong economic performance that California has achieved, is not un-done by the Trump Administration.
Recent amendments to the bill: After substantial amendments were taken in the Assembly Appropriations Committee, the author further amended the bill on September 10 to address a limited number of issues:
- DFW discretion: the amendments taken in the Assembly Appropriations Committee provided discretion for DFW to make decisions regarding the listing of endangered species in light of any federal de-listing of a species. The author's amendments on September 10 provided DFW with discretion on how to protect listed species that consider the federal protection in place on January 19, 2017;
- Waters of the state: the amendments taken in the Assembly Appropriations Committee added proposed changes to Water Code section 13050 to clarify the definitions of "waste" and "waters of the state." These amendments, in effect, would have confirmed existing wetlands regulations of the State Water Board, which has interpreted current law consistently with the language added in the Appropriations Committee for more than 30 years. The author's amendments removed the section of the bill dealing with Water Code section 13050; and,
- No effect on legal interpretation: in light of the removal of Water Code section 13050 from the bill on September 10, the amendments taken on that day added Section 10: "The amendments made to this measure to strike out sections shall not, in any manner, be construed by a court or other body as legislative intent to affect the interpretation of existing law." The recent changes, made in the Appropriations Committee, proposed to Water Code section 13050 raised concerns (some not even related to the actual language), so the author amendments on September 10 removed this issue and added the legal interpretation provision in order to preclude courts from interpreting that removal as legislative intent to withdraw the State Water Board's authority on wetlands policy. Existing law and the existing interpretations remain, allowing the State Water Board to continue implementing existing statutes, regulations, and guidance.
According to the Author:
"SB 1 makes federal baseline standards for environmental and worker protection enforceable as a matter of state law, when the current administration in Washington D.C. rolls them back. It has been roughly three years and two months since the new administration took office in Washington D.C. During that time, according to the New York Times and numerous authorities: [More than] 34 different key clean air, clean water, and endangered species standards have been weakened or eliminated. SB 1 simply provides that, whatever actions the new federal regime may take, California will continue to enforce the same environmental and public health protections that have been in effect for years, as a matter of state law."
Arguments in Support:
A number of environmental organizations, including the Natural Resources Defense Council, state: "California has long been a leader in ensuring a healthy environment and workplace for its citizens. For many years, the state has enforced its laws protecting the air that Californians breathe, the water that Californians drink, and the wildlife and natural resources that our citizens prize, in tandem with federal agency partners. But the Trump administration now threatens that long-standing partnership with ongoing and persistent efforts to weaken or eliminate critical public health and environmental protections. SB 1 protects our citizens and our environment by ensuring that protections in existence prior to January 19, 2017, under the federal Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, Safe Drinking Water Act, Endangered Species Act, and workplace safety laws are not weakened, and gives California state agencies streamlined authority to enforce these protections under state law. For these reasons, we strongly support SB 1."
Arguments in Opposition:
"The California Chamber of Commerce and the 94 organizations listed remain respectfully OPPOSED to Senate Bill 1, which the Chamber has labeled as a JOB KILLER. We continue to stress that our opposition is not with the intent to protect California’s environmental and labor standards from any federal rollbacks. We focus our critique only on those provisions in SB 1 that unnecessarily threaten water supply reliability for millions of Californians and threaten to exacerbate California’s housing crisis and disrupt agricultural operations throughout California. If amendments are taken to fully address these issues, all known opposition would be removed."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, enactment of this bill could result in significant costs of approximately $5 million for the California Air Resources Board; approximately $6 million for the Department of Fish and Wildlife; minor and absorbable costs for the State Water Resources Control Board; and, unknown, but potentially significant litigation costs for the Department of Justice.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 28-10-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NO: Bates, Borgeas, Chang, Grove, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
ASM ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS: 6-1-1
YES: Quirk, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Muratsuchi
NO: Mathis
ABS, ABST OR NV: Melendez
ASM NATURAL RESOURCES: 8-3-0
YES: Friedman, Chau, Eggman, Cristina Garcia, Limón, McCarty, Muratsuchi, Mark Stone
NO: Flora, Mathis, Fong
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-2-2
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Kiley, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gallagher, Holden
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-5-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Diep, Fong, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 10, 2019
CONSULTANT: Josh Tooker / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0002480
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 1
Author: Atkins (D), Portantino (D) and Stern (D), et al.
Amended: 9/10/19
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 3/20/19
AYES: Allen, Hill, Skinner, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Stone
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 7-2, 4/9/19
AYES: Stern, Allen, Caballero, Hertzberg, Hueso, Jackson, Monning
NOES: Jones, Borgeas
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 6-2, 4/23/19
AYES: Jackson, Allen, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Borgeas, Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Caballero
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 4-2, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SENATE FLOOR: 28-10, 5/29/19
AYES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NOES: Bates, Borgeas, Chang, Grove, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 43-21, 9/13/19
(ROLL CALL NOT AVAILABLE)
SUBJECT: California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019
DIGEST:
This bill enacts the California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019 (Act) with the purpose of ensuring that protections afforded to Californians under federal environmental and labor laws and regulations as of January 2017, remain in place in the event that the federal government weakens or repeals any of those federal laws or regulations.
Assembly Amendments
reorganize the bill, give the Department of Fish and Wildlife discretion regarding their response to removal of an endangered species from the federal list, alter then restored the definitions of “waste” and “waters of the state”, and add a legal interpretation provision regarding the above definitions as to not affect existing interpretation.
ANALYSIS:
Existing federal law:
- Authorizes states, for each of the following statutes, to act as delegates for implementing and enforcing the federal acts, as long as the state’s laws are at least as stringent as or more stringent than the federal act or to enact their own similar state statute:
- Regulates, under the federal Clean Air Act (FCAA), air emissions from stationary and mobile sources to protect public health and public welfare and to regulate emissions of hazardous air pollutants.
- Regulates, under the Clean Water Act (CWA), discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States and regulates quality standards for surface waters.
- Regulates, under the Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA), the nation’s public drinking water supply, and requires the US EPA to establish mandatory nationwide drinking water standards. SDWA additionally requires water systems to monitor public water supplies to ensure drinking water standards are met and report to consumers if the standards are not met.
- Provides, under the Endangered Species Act (ESA), for the conservation of species that are endangered or threatened throughout all or a significant portion of their range, and the conservation of the ecosystems on which they depend.
Existing state law:
- Prohibits, under the Protect California Air Act of 2003, air quality management districts and air pollution control districts from amending or revising their new source review rules or regulations to be less stringent than those rules or regulations that existed on December 30, 2002, except under certain circumstances.
- Establishes, under the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (AB 32), a comprehensive program to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from all sources throughout the state to combat climate change.
- Regulates, under the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, the discharge of pollutants into the waters of the state.
- Establishes, under the California Safe Drinking Water Act, standards for drinking water and regulates drinking water systems.
- Requires, under the California Endangered Species Act, the Fish and Game Commission to establish a list of endangered species and a list of threatened species and generally prohibits the taking of those species.
This bill:
- Requires the State Air Resources Control Board to adopt, via regulation, any federal air standard that is weakened after January 2017.
- Authorizes the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board and the Department of Industrial Relations to adopt, via regulation, any worker protections that were in place in federal law or regulation as of January 2017, and were subsequently weakened or repealed.
- Requires the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board), by June 30, 2020, to adopt a primary drinking water standard at least as stringent as the national primary drinking water standard as that standard was in affect as of January 2017.
- Authorizes the Fish and Game Commission (Commission) to adopt, via regulation, protections for species, if the Commission determines that a federal action after January 2017 provides less protection for that species.
- Authorizes, instead of requires, the Fish and Game Commission (Commission) or the Department of Fish and Wildlife (DFW) to apply protections provided by any federal biological opinion, incidental take permit, or incidental take statement when authorizing the take of any species listed as endangered or threatened under California law.
- Provides a private right of action to enforce certain air and water standards within California if the private right of action within federal law or regulation is weakened or repealed.
- Provides that any state regulation adopted to ensure protections of federal law or regulation as of January 2017, sunsets on January 20, 2025.
Background
Federal rollbacks. President Trump has made eliminating federal regulations a priority. His administration has often targeted environmental rules it sees as burdensome to the fossil fuel industry and other big businesses.
A New York Times analysis, based on research from Harvard Law School, Columbia Law School and other sources, counts more than 80 environmental rules and regulations either officially reversed or in the process of being rolled back.
Comments
Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “SB 1 makes federal baseline standards for environmental and worker protection enforceable as a matter of state law, when the current administration in Washington D.C. rolls them back. It has been roughly three years and two months since the new administration took office in Washington D.C. During that time, according to the New York Times and numerous authorities: [More than] 34 different key clean air, clean water, and endangered species standards have been weakened or eliminated. In addition, and for the third year in a row, the federal administration has proposed a budget blueprint that would reduce the budget of the [United States Environmental Protection Agency] to a point where the agency would no longer be able to meaningfully enforce clean air and water laws. SB 1 simply provides that, whatever actions the new federal regime may take, California will continue to enforce the same environmental and public health protections that have been in effect for years, as a matter of state law.”
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, enactment of this bill could result in significant costs of approximately $5 million for the California Air Resources Board; approximately $6 million for the Department of Fish and Wildlife; minor and absorbable costs for the State Water Resources Control Board; and, unknown, but potentially significant litigation costs for the Department of Justice.
350 Bay Area Action
350 Sacramento
350 South Bay Los Angeles
American Sportfishing Association
Audubon California
AZUL
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Association of Local Conservation Corps
California Association of Professional Scientists
California Catholic Conference
California Coastal Protection Network
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California Interfaith Power & Light
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
California League of Conservation Voters
California Professional Firefighters
California ReLEAF
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Parks Foundation
California State Pipe Trades Council
Californians Against Waste
Central Valley Air Quality Coalition
Clean Water Action
Coachella Valley Waterkeeper
Coalition for Clean Air
Community Action to Fight Asthma
Defenders of Wildlife
East Bay Municipal Utility District
Environment California
Environmental Defense Center
Environmental Defense Fund
Environmental Water Caucus
Environmental Working Group
Eric Garcetti, Mayor of Los Angeles
Fossil Free California
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Heal the Bay
Health Officers Association of California
Humboldt Baykeeper
Latino Outdoors
League of Women Voters of California
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District
Mono Lake Committee
Monterey Bay Aquarium
Monterey Coastkeeper
Natural Resources Defense Council
Nextgen California
Orange County Coastkeeper
Planning and Conservation League
Protect American River Canyons
Restore The Delta
Russian Riverkeeper
San Diego 350
San Diego Coastkeeper
Santa Barbara Channelkeeper
Save Our Shores
Save The Bay
Seventh Generation Advisors
Sierra Club California
South Coast Air Quality Management District
State Building & Construction Trades Council of California
Surfrider Foundation
The 5 Gyres Institute
The Nature Conservancy
The Otter Project
The Trust for Public Land
UDW/AFSCME Local 3930
Voices for Progress
Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation
Wildcoast
Yuba River Waterkeeper
Zero Waste USA
OPPOSITION: (Verified 9/12/19)
African American Farmers of California
Almond Alliance of California
American Coatings Association
American Pistachio Growers
Antelope Valley East Kern Water Agency
Association of California Cities- Orange County
Association of California Water Agencies
Auto Care Association
Bizfed Central Valley
Brea Area Chamber of Commerce
Building Owners and Managers Association
Byron-Bethany Irrigation District
California Agricultural Aircraft Association
California Association of Relators
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Forestry Association
California Fresh Fruit Association
California Grain and Feed Association
California League of Food Producers
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Metals Coalition
California Paint Council
California Poultry Federation
California Restaurant Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
CAWA – Representing the Automotive Parts Industry
Central Coast Water Authority
Chemical Industry Council of California
City of Compton- Water Department
Coachella Valley Water District
Construction Employers Association
County of Kern
County of Kings
County of Madera
County of Merced
County of San Joaquin
County of Stanislaus
County of Tulare
Cucamonga Valley Water District
Desert Water Agency
Dudley Ridge Water District
El Dorado County Chamber of Commerce
El Dorado Irrigation District
El Monte/South El Monte Chamber of Commerce
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Far West Equipment Dealers Association
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Foothill Municipal Water District
Forest Landowners of California
Fresno; County of
Friant Water Authority
Glendora Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater West Covina Business Association
Household and Commercial Products Association
Inland Empire Utilities Agency
International Council of Shopping Centers
Kern County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
Kern County Water Agency
La Verne Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Mojave Water Agency
Murrieta Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
NAIOP of California
National Federation of Independent Business
Nisei Farmers League
North of the River Chamber of Commerce
North Orange County Chamber of Commerce
Northern California Water Association
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Palmdale Water District
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Regional Chamber of Commerce San Gabriel Valley
Regional Water Authority
Roseville Chamber of Commerce
Rowland Water District
San Bernardino Valley Municipal Water District
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
San Gabriel Valley Municipal Water District
San Joaquin River Exchange Contractors Water Authority
San Luis Delta-Mendota Water Authority
Santa Clara Valley Water District
Santa Clarita Valley Water Agency
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Southern California Water Coalition
Southwest California Legislative Council
State Water Contractors, Inc.
The Metropolitan Water District of Southern California
Three Valleys Municipal Water District
Torrance Chamber of Commerce
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
United Ag
United Water Conservation District
Valley Ag Water Coalition
Valley Industry and Commerce Association
Walnut Valley Water District
West Coast Lumber & Building Material Association
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Western Independent Refiners Association
Western Municipal Water District
Western Plant Health Association
Western States Petroleum Association
Western Wood Preservers Institute
Prepared by: Eric Walters / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
9/13/19 22:01:48
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1
Author:(Atkins, et al.)
As Amended Ver:September 3, 2019
Majority vote
SUMMARY:
Enacts the California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019 (Act) with the purpose of ensuring that protections afforded to Californians under federal environmental and labor laws and regulations as of January 2017, remain in place in the event that President Trump weakens or repeals any of those federal laws or regulations.
Major Provisions:
- Requires the State Air Resources Control Board to adopt, via regulation, any federal air standard that is weakened after January 2017.
- Authorizes the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board and the Department of Industrial Relations to adopt, via regulation, any worker protections that were in place in federal law or regulation as of January 2017, and were subsequently weakened or repealed.
- Requires the State Water Resources Control Board, by June 30, 2020, to adopt a primary drinking water standard at least as stringent as the national primary drinking water standard as that standard was in affect as of January 2017.
- Authorizes the Fish and Game Commission (Commission) to adopt, via regulation, protections for species, if the Commission determines that a federal action after January 2017 provides less protection for that species. Provides some flexibility, on whether or not to take regulatory action at the state level, to the Commission and the Department of Fish and Wildlife with federal biological opinions and take permits, if those opinions or permits are weakened after January 2017.
- Provides a private right of action to enforce certain air and water standards within California if the private right of action within federal law or regulation is weakened or repealed.
- Provides that any state regulation adopted to ensure protections of federal law or regulation as of January 2017, sunsets on January 20, 2025.
COMMENTS:
Response to President Trump's anti-environmental policies: This bill was introduced to respond to the Trump Administration's attack on laws and regulations that protect public health and the environment. It is clear that the new federal administration is interested in easing compliance with laws and regulations for multi-billion dollar corporations; however, it is unclear, exactly, which environmental laws or regulations could become a target for weakening or repealing or what the economic, public health, and environmental impacts the actions might have on California. This bill simply sets a floor for the federal environmental laws currently in place in order to ensure that the economic, environmental, and public health benefits of these laws are maintained in California. The public health and environmental protections provided by the federal Clean Air Act, federal Clean Water Act, and all of the environmental laws and regulations in place provide very important and very real benefits to everyone in this country. Loosening these federal requirements, such as allowing businesses to release toxic wastes into rivers, lakes, and streams, near schools and homes, or allow entities to emit toxic chemicals into the air, could set us back decades in terms of the environmental protections that have been achieved.
California is the fifth largest economy in the world and has some of the most, if not the most, protective public health and environmental laws in the country. Protecting human health and the environment and promoting economic growth are not mutually exclusive. There is a balance, and early indications from the Trump Administration are that the President does not see the balance and only sees the side of the equation that does not include protecting human health and the environment or the economic benefits from those protections. This bill is intended to ensure that the strong environmental protections, coupled with the strong economic performance that California has achieved, is not un-done by the Trump Administration.
According to the Author:
"SB 1 makes federal baseline standards for environmental and worker protection enforceable as a matter of state law, when the current administration in Washington D.C. rolls them back. It has been roughly three years and two months since the new administration took office in Washington D.C. During that time, according to the New York Times and numerous authorities: [More than] 34 different key clean air, clean water, and endangered species standards have been weakened or eliminated. In addition, and for the third year in a row, the federal administration has proposed a budget blueprint that would reduce the budget of the [United States Environmental Protection Agency] to a point where the agency would no longer be able to meaningfully enforce clean air and water laws. SB 1 simply provides that, whatever actions the new federal regime may take, California will continue to enforce the same environmental and public health protections that have been in effect for years, as a matter of state law."
Arguments in Support:
A number of environmental organizations, including the Natural Resources Defense Council, state: "California has long been a leader in ensuring a healthy environment and workplace for its citizens. For many years, the state has enforced its laws protecting the air that Californians breathe, the water that Californians drink, and the wildlife and natural resources that our citizens prize, in tandem with federal agency partners. But the Trump administration now threatens that long-standing partnership with ongoing and persistent efforts to weaken or eliminate critical public health and environmental protections. SB 1 protects our citizens and our environment by ensuring that protections in existence prior to January 19, 2017, under the federal Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, Safe Drinking Water Act, Endangered Species Act, and workplace safety laws are not weakened, and gives California state agencies streamlined authority to enforce these protections under state law. SB 1 adopts common-sense measures to allow California to continue on a path to economic and environmental sustainability – and reject the false choice that economic progress must come at the expense of public health, the vitality of our natural surroundings, and a healthy environment for all. For these reasons, we strongly support SB 1."
Arguments in Opposition:
A number of business organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce, argue; "The California Chamber of Commerce and listed organizations must respectfully oppose SB 1 (Atkins) which the California Chamber of Commerce has labeled as a job killer. Our opposition to the bill is not with the author's intent to protect California's air, water, biodiversity and workers from any federal changes that undermine the state's existing standards. Our concern with the bill stems from the significant negative consequences of the bill, including regulatory uncertainty, lack of due process, and unnecessary litigation that would result if the bill were passed and as currently amended [April 11, 2019]. SB 1 joins numerous unrelated labor laws and regulations with environmental laws and regulations under the same excessively general guise of "public welfare" merely because they relate to a "state prerogative." For these reasons, we must oppose SB 1 (Atkins)."
FISCAL COMMENTS:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, enactment of this bill could result in significant costs of approximately $5 million for the California Air Resources Board; approximately $6 million for the Department of Fish and Wildlife; minor and absorbable costs for the State Water Resources Control Board; and, unknown, but potentially significant litigation costs for the Department of Justice.
VOTES:
SENATE FLOOR: 28-10-0
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Atkins, Beall, Bradford, Caballero, Dodd, Durazo, Galgiani, Glazer, Hertzberg, Hill, Hueso, Hurtado, Jackson, Leyva, McGuire, Mitchell, Monning, Pan, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski, Wiener
NO: Bates, Borgeas, Chang, Grove, Jones, Moorlach, Morrell, Nielsen, Stone, Wilk
ASM ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS: 6-1-1
YES: Quirk, Arambula, Bauer-Kahan, Cristina Garcia, Holden, Muratsuchi
NO: Mathis
ABS, ABST OR NV: Melendez
ASM NATURAL RESOURCES: 8-3-0
YES: Friedman, Chau, Eggman, Cristina Garcia, Limón, McCarty, Muratsuchi, Mark Stone
NO: Flora, Mathis, Fong
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-2-2
YES: Mark Stone, Chau, Chiu, Gonzalez, Kalra, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Reyes
NO: Kiley, Obernolte
ABS, ABST OR NV: Gallagher, Holden
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-5-0
YES: Gonzalez, Bloom, Bonta, Calderon, Carrillo, Chau, Eggman, Gabriel, Eduardo Garcia, Maienschein, Petrie-Norris, Quirk, Robert Rivas
NO: Bigelow, Brough, Diep, Fong, Obernolte
UPDATED:
VERSION: September 3, 2019
CONSULTANT: Josh Tooker / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0001832
Date of Hearing: August 21, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Lorena Gonzalez, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1
Author:(Atkins) – As Amended Ver:July 1, 2019
Policy Committee: | Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials | Vote: | 6 - 1 |
Natural Resources | 8 - 3 | ||
Judiciary | 8 - 2 |
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: Yes
SUMMARY:
This bill enacts the California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act (Act) of 2019 to establish minimum federal environmental, public health, worker safety and labor standards as state baselines in the event Congress or the Trump administration weaken or repeal federal law or regulations.
Additionally, this bill provides it is unlawful for a person in this state to transport, sell, receive, acquire or purchase any fish, wildlife or plant (except for cannabis or hemp allowed under state law) taken, possessed, transported or sold in violation of any law, treaty, policy, regulation, or finding of the United States law in effect on January 19, 2017. Sunsets this provision on January 20, 2025.
As it relates to the Act, specifically, this bill:
- Requires the California Air Resources Board (ARB), the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB), the Occupational Health and Safety Board (OSHSB) and the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) to regularly assess, and at least quarterly publish on their individual websites and the California Regulatory Notice Register, a list of changes made to the federal standards that may impact California and provide an assessment on whether a change made to the federal standards is less protective of public health and safety, the environment, natural resources or worker health and safety than the baseline federal standards.
- Defines "baseline federal standards" as the federal standards in effect as of January 1, 2017, or January 19, 2017, that were not otherwise permanently enjoined by a federal court as of that date, or the Endangered Species Act (ESA) in effect as of January 19, 2017. Defines state analogue statutes for federal standards, as specified.
- Requires ARB, SWRCB, OSHSB and DIR, if they determine a change to federal standards is less protective, to consider adopting baseline federal standards, as specified.
- Requires the Fish and Game Commission (FGC) to determine whether to list a species, subspecies or distinct population segment under CESA in the event either of the following occurs:
- The federal delisting of the species, subspecies or distinct population segment that is eligible for protection under CESA and that is listed as endangered or threatened pursuant to the ESA as of January 19, 2017.
- A change in the legally protected status of the species, subspecies or distinct population segment through a change to the ESA or federal baseline standard.
- Applies the provisions of the California Endangered Species Act (CESA) relating to the control, appropriation, use or distribution of water, as specified, to the operation of the federal Central Valley Project.
- Provides that the emergency regulations adopted by a state agency under this title shall not be subject to review by the Office of Administrative Law and shall remain in effect until revised or repealed by the state agency, or January 20, 2025, whichever comes first, as long as the emergency regulations adopt the baseline federal standard without substantial modification.
- Establishes an action may be brought by a person in the public interest to enforce the standards or requirements adopted by the relevant state agency, as provided, or to impose civil penalties for a violation of those standards or requirements pursuant to those acts, as provided. Allows a court to award attorneys’ fees, as specified.
- Makes findings and declarations.
- Includes a severability clause.
- Provides the bill shall become inoperative on January 20, 2025 and repeals the bill on January 1, 2026.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- ARB estimates increased ongoing annual costs of approximately $30 million to adopt state versions of the federal air quality rules, assuming 6 regulations per year, and quarterly review existing federal standards to determine if there are rollbacks until 2025 (General Fund and Air Pollution Control Fund). Staff thinks five million dollars per regulation seems to be an overly high estimate to adopt status quo federal regulations.
- Increased annual costs of approximately $6 million to DFW for 16 staff to list new species, process incidental take permits and make consistency determinations until 2025 (General Fund and Fish and Game Preservation Fund).
- Increased unknown, significant SWRCB costs to adopt state standards, including actions that require CEQA compliance as well as increased litigation costs. Additionally, SWRCB estimates costs to prepare a quarterly list of federal changes is estimated to require $175,000 and one position annually through 2025 (Waste Discharge Permit Fund, Safe Drinking Water Fund and General Fund).
- Increased unknown, but potentially significant DOJ litigation costs associated with defending a state agency against a challenge to a regulation, representing a state agency in citizen lawsuits for non-compliance with the bill’s mandates or DOJ taking action against an entity in violation of the bill.
DOJ and bill proponents have identified five potential pending federal rollbacks. DOJ estimates litigating each rollback would require approximately $350,000 per year for four years. Any DOJ costs for defending a client agency would be fully reimbursable through direct billings (various funds).
- Increased unknown, but potentially significant DIR costs, estimated to be at least $1.5 million the first year and $1 million ongoing until 2025 (General Fund).
DIR is basing this estimate on a single standard, i.e. electronic reporting, currently known to likely trigger the adoption of the baseline federal standards. However, each and every standard that triggers the bill’s provisions has the potential to add new costs.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
SB 1 ensures clean air, clean water, endangered species, and worker safety standards that have been in place for as long as 50 years are not rolled back as a result of the anti-environment actions of the President and Congress. In the past two years, the new administration and congress have adopted action after action to weaken, roll back, and outright repeal longstanding and well-accepted standards to protect workers, public health and the environment. SB 1 simply ensures those standards stay in place to protect everyday Californians, even if the federal government rolls them back.
- Recent Federal ESA Changes. Despite warnings from scientists that humans have driven up to one million species around the world to the brink of extinction, earlier this month, the Trump administration released proposed rules that will weaken the federal Endangered Species Act by making it easier to delist endangered species and more difficult to protect habitat where endangered species live.
The draft rules will allow regulators to ignore climate impacts on species and, instead of relying only on scientific data, economic impacts may also be considered. The new rules will go into effect 30 days after they are published in the Federal Register.
This is the type of federal action this bill seeks to prevent from impacting the state.
- Negotiations Continue. General agreements have been reached on most parts of this bill, with the exception of the application of CESA to the federal water project (CVP) and the provision relating to biological opinions and the impact on the Bay-Delta voluntary water agreements.
Opponents generally argue the federal Reclamation Act preempts CESA from applying to the CVP and this provision will result in litigation. Proponents generally contend there is a legal argument to be made on why CESA applies to the CVP and are prepared to make it, if necessary.
Voluntary water agreements are an alternative to the regulatory approach in SWRCB’s Bay Delta Water Quality Control Plan Update, which establishes flow regulations. The agreements provide water, money and non-flow measures, including habitat restoration managed through a science-based approach, to improve the health of northern California rivers and the Bay-Delta estuary. The agreements rely on federal biological opinions which are currently being updated.
Proponents want to lock the previous biological opinions into place, either to prevent new, less stringent opinions from being used, or to thwart the voluntary agreement process. Without voluntary agreements, SWRCB’s flow regulations would stand. Opponents argue that through adaptive management and other restoration efforts, environmental conditions have improved, and new data recognizing the improvements should be used as a baseline for the agreements.
The Newsom administration and opponents have provided the author and sponsors with sets of amendments to address the two remaining issues. To date, although there has been some progress, no agreement has been reached.
- Prior Legislation. SB 49 (de León), of the 2017–18 Legislative Session, was substantially similar to this bill. SB 49 passed this committee but was not taken up on the Assembly Floor prior to the end of session.
Analysis Prepared by: Jennifer Galehouse / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 9, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Mark Stone, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1
Author:(Atkins) – As Amended Ver:July 1, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 28-10
SUBJECT: California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019
KEY ISSUES:
- To ensure that clean air, clean water, endangered species, and worker safety standards that have been in place for as long as 50 years are not rolled back as a result of the CURRENT FEDERAL ADMINISTRATION, should minimum state baselines for environmental, public health, and labor standards BE ADOPTED?
- TO Preserve, protect, and enhance the environment and natural resources in California, SHOULD THE PUBLIC BE ABLE TO ENFORCE BASELINE ENVIRONMENTAL STANDARDS through a ciTizen suit provision—similar to ones found under current federal environmental law—so that there is no backsliding of california laws and environmental protections?
SYNOPSIS
For decades the State of California has been a national leader in environmental stewardship and protecting the dignity and safety of workers. Despite California’s efforts, the current federal administration is making it clear that it disagrees with California’s values and is making every effort to undermine existing federal policies to protect the environment and workplace health, wage, and safety rules. However, thanks to the foresight of prior federal administrations, the state is not without recourse. By enacting many regulatory schemes that recognize cooperative federalism, California is able to step up to protect the environment and workers when the federal government tries to step back and undermine these policies. To that end, this bill sets a minimum baseline for environmental, public health, and labor standards based on existing federal standards and requires specified state agencies to review any federal actions to determine if the action adopts a rule that is less protective than the existing baseline. If such action would bring the standard below the established baseline, this bill empowers the state to step-up and restore critical environmental and worker protections. Additionally, this bill seeks to maintain several citizen lawsuit provisions that currently are in federal law should the current administration seek to undermine these provisions.
This bill is supported by a large and diverse coalition of environmental and labor organizations who argue that California must continue to set an example for the nation and protect critical environmental and workplace safety laws. They note that the current administration in Washington poses a threat to California’s values and support this bill as a means of protecting California’s values and way-of-life. This measure is opposed by a broad coalition of business interests, local governments, and water agencies. While these organizations note their agreement with the premise of this measure, they express their opposition to several provisions of the bill, especially provisions related to the California Endangered Species Act and its application to certain water conveyance projects. This bill is similar to SB 49 (de Leon, 2017) that passed this Committee before ultimately being held on the Assembly Floor.
SUMMARY: Establishes a minimum baseline for environmental, public health, and labor standards based on existing federal standards and requires specified state agencies to review any federal action in those areas to determine if the action adopts a rule that is less protective than the existing baseline; and provides that if federal action results in the law being less protective than the existing standard, the state agency may adopt the baseline as a regulation under California law. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines “federal baseline standards” as the federal standards in effect as of January 19, 2017, that were not otherwise permanently enjoined by a federal court as of that date.
- Defines “federal standards” as federal laws or federal regulations implementing the federal Clean Air Act, the federal Safe Drinking Water Act and Federal Water Pollution Control Act, the federal Endangered Species Act, the federal Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938, Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970, and Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969, as applicable.
- Defines “state analogue statute” as the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006, Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, the California Safe Drinking Water Act, and the Labor Code, including the California Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1973.
- Requires the California Air Resources Board to regularly assess, and at least quarterly publish on its website and to the California Regulatory Notice Register, a list of changes made to the federal standards that may impact California and provide an assessment on whether a change made to the federal standards is less protective of public health and safety, the environment, natural resources, or worker health and safety than the baseline federal standards.
- Provides that if the California Air Resources Board determines that a change to the federal standards is less protective of public health and safety, the environment, natural resources, or worker health and safety than the baseline federal standards, the Board shall consider whether it should adopt the baseline standard as a regulation in order to ensure that the state’s protections are at least as stringent as the baseline federal standards.
- Provides the list, assessment, and consideration of the California Air Resources Board must be posted on its internet website and open to public comment for at least 30 days prior to any vote to adopt a measure.
- Provides that if the California State Air Resources Board adopts a measure it may do so by either adopting emergency regulations, or by promulgating or amending a state policy, plan, or regulation. Provides that any promulgation of or amendment to a state policy, plan, or regulation is deemed to be a change without regulatory effect.
- Provides that if a citizen suit authorized pursuant to the Clean Air Act is amended to substantially restrict, condition, abridge, or repeal the ability to file such a suit, including limiting the awarding of attorney’s fees, a suit may be brought pursuant to 9) to enforce the baseline federal standards, state standards enacted pursuant to the federal Clean Air Act.
- Provides that an action may be brought by a person in the public interest exclusively to enforce baseline federal standards adopted as a measure pursuant to 7) if citizen suit enforcement of the newly adopted standard is no longer available under federal law. Provides that an action may be brought by that person so long as notice is properly provided to the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney, county counsel, counsel of the California Air Resources Board, counsel of an air district, or a prosecutor, as specified.
- Requires the State Water Resources Control Board to regularly assess, and at least quarterly publish on its website and to the California Regulatory Notice Register, a list of changes made to the federal standards that may impact California and provide an assessment on whether a change made to the federal standards is less protective of public health and safety, the environment, natural resources, or worker health and safety than the baseline federal standards.
- Provides that if the State Water Resources Control Board determines that a change to the federal standards is less protective of public health and safety, the environment, natural resources, or worker health and safety than the baseline federal standards, the Board shall consider whether it should adopt the baseline standard as a regulation in order to ensure that the state’s protections are at least as stringent as the baseline federal standards.
- Provides the list, assessment, and consideration of the State Water Resources Control Board must be posted on its internet website and open to public comment for at least 30 days prior to any vote to adopt a measure.
- Provides that if the State Water Resources Control Board adopts a measure it may do so by either adopting emergency regulations, or by promulgating or amending a state policy, plan, or regulation. Provides that any promulgation of or amendment to a state policy, plan, or regulation is deemed to be a change without regulatory effect.
- Provides that if a citizen suit authorized pursuant to the Clean Water Act or Safe Drinking Water Act is amended to substantially restrict, condition, abridge, or repeal the ability to file such a suit, including limiting the awarding of attorney’s fees, a suit may be brought pursuant to 15) to enforce the baseline federal standards, state standards enacted in accordance with existing state law, or otherwise available under federal law.
- Provides that an action may be brought by a person in the public interest exclusively to enforce baseline federal standards adopted as a measure pursuant to 13) if citizen suit enforcement of the newly adopted standard is no longer available under federal law. Provides that an action may be brought by that person so long as notice is properly provided to the Attorney General, a district attorney, a city attorney, county counsel, counsel of the State Water Resources Control Board, counsel of a regional board, or a prosecutor, as specified.
- Provides that in order to prevent backsliding as a result of any change to the baseline federal standards, the Fish and Game Commission shall determine whether to list, in accordance with 17), a species, subspecies, or distinct population segment under the California Endangered Species Act in the event either of the following occurs:
- The federal delisting of the species, subspecies, or distinct population segment that is eligible for protection under the California Endangered Species Act and that is listed as endangered or threatened pursuant to the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973; or
- A change in the legally protected status of the species, subspecies, or distinct population segment, including through a change in listing from endangered to threatened, the adoption of a rule pursuant to specified provisions the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973, or any amendment to the federal baseline standard.
- Requires the Fish and Game Commission to list the affected species, subspecies, or distinct population segment identified in 16), no later than the conclusion of its second regularly scheduled meeting or within three months, whichever is shorter, after the occurrence of the event described in 16) unless either the Fish and Game Commission determines that listing the species, subspecies, or distinct population segment is not warranted because it does not meet the criteria provided by existing law for listing a species or the Department of Fish and Wildlife recommends that the species, subspecies, or distinct population segment undergo the regular listing process.
- Provides that a decision by the Fish and Game Commission to list a species, subspecies, or distinct population segment without following the regular listing process becomes effective immediately, the Fish and Game Commission shall add that species, subspecies, or distinct population segment to the list of endangered or threatened species, and the addition of that species, subspecies, or distinct population segment to the list shall be deemed to be a change without regulatory effect.
- Provides that provisions of the California Endangered Species Act are measures “relating to the control, appropriation, use, or distribution of water” within the meaning of the federal Reclamation Act of 1902 and shall apply to the United States Bureau of Reclamation’s operation of the federal Central Valley Project.
- Requires the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board and the Department of Industrial Relations to regularly assess, and at least quarterly publish on its website and to the California Regulatory Notice Register, a list of changes made to the federal standards that may impact California and provide an assessment on whether a change made to the federal standards is less protective of worker health and safety than the baseline federal standards.
- Provides that if the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board or the Department of Industrial Relations determines that a change to the federal standards is less protective of public health and safety, the environment, natural resources, or worker health and safety than the baseline federal standards, the Board or Department shall consider whether it should adopt the baseline standard as a regulation in order to ensure that the state’s protections are at least as stringent as the baseline federal standards.
- Provides the list, assessment, and consideration of the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board and the Department of Industrial Relations must be posted on the internet website and open to public comment for at least 30 days prior to any vote to adopt a measure.
- Provides that if the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board and the Department of Industrial Relations adopts a measure it may do so by either adopting emergency regulations, or promulgating or amending a state policy, plan, or regulation. Provides that any promulgation of amendment to a state policy, plan, or regulation is deemed to be a change without regulatory effect.
- Makes findings and declarations.
- Provides that the emergency regulations adopted by a state agency under this title shall not be subject to review by the Office of Administrative Law and shall remain in effect until revised or repealed by the state agency, or January 20, 2025, whichever comes first, as long as the emergency regulations adopt the baseline federal standard without substantial modification.
- Provides that the provisions proposed in this bill become inoperative on January 20, 2025, and, as of January 1, 2026, are repealed.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the federal Clean Air Act to regulate air emissions from stationary and mobile sources through the establishment of National Ambient Air Quality Standards to protect public health and public welfare and to regulate emissions of hazardous air pollutants. (42 U.S.C. Section 7401 et seq.)
- Establishes the federal Clean Water Act to regulate discharge of pollutants into the waters of the United States and regulate quality standards for surface waters. (33 U.S.C. Section 1344 et seq.)
- Establishes the federal Safe Drinking Water Act to set standards for drinking water quality and to oversee the states, localities, and water suppliers who implement those standards, as provided. (42 U.S.C. Section 300f et seq.)
- Establishes the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 to protect and recover imperiled species and the ecosystems upon which they depend, as provided. (16 U.S.C. Section 1531 et seq.)
- Requires, pursuant to the federal Fair Labor Standards Act, the payment of minimum wage and overtime to workers and prohibits the use of child labor. (29 U.S.C. Section 201 et seq.)
- Establishes, pursuant to the federal Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970, standards and provides for the safety of workers on job sites. (30 U.S.C. Section 651 et seq.)
- Provides, pursuant to the federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969, minimum health and safety standards for workers at coal mines and a corresponding inspection regime. (30 U.S.C. Section 801 et seq.)
- Provides, pursuant to the federal Clean Air Act, individual citizens the ability to enforce the laws by bringing suits in court as specified. (42 U.S.C. Section 7604.)
- Provides, pursuant to the federal Clean Water Act, individual citizens the ability to enforce the laws by bringing suits in court as specified. (33 U.S.C. Section 1365.)
- Provides, pursuant to the federal Endangered Species Act, individual citizens the ability to enforce the laws by bringing suits in court as specified. (16 U.S.C. Section 1540.)
- Provides, pursuant to the federal Safe Drinking Water Act, individual citizens the ability to enforce the laws by bringing suits in court as specified. (42 U.S.C. Section 300j-8.)
- Provides, as a part of the federal Reclamation Act of 1902, that nothing in the federal act is to be construed as affecting or interfering with the laws of any state or territory relating to the control, appropriation, use, or distribution of water used in irrigation. (43 U.S.C. Section 372.)
- Establishes, pursuant to the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006, a comprehensive regulatory program to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from all sources throughout California. (Health and Safety Code Section 42500 et seq.)
- Establishes the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act and regulates the discharge of pollutants into the waters of the state. (Water Code Section 13000 et seq.)
- Establishes the California Safe Drinking Water Act and sets standards for drinking water and regulates drinking water systems. (Health and Safety Code Section 116270 et seq.)
- Establishes the California Endangered Species Act and requires the Fish and Game Commission to establish a list of endangered species and a list of threatened species and generally prohibits the taking of those species. (Fish and Game Code Section 2050 et seq.)
- Allows a court to award attorneys’ fees to a successful party in any action which has resulted in the enforcement of an important right affecting the public interest under the following circumstances:
- A significant benefit, whether pecuniary or nonpecuniary, has been conferred on the general public or a large class of persons;
- The necessity and financial burden of private enforcement, or of enforcement by one public entity against another public entity, are such as to make the award appropriate; and
- Such fees should not in the interest of justice be paid out of the recovery, if any. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1021.5.)
- Provides that in an action involving a public entity, attorneys’ fees applies to allowances against, but not in favor of, public entities, and no claim shall be required to be filed therefor, unless one or more successful parties and one or more opposing parties are public entities, in which case no claim shall be required to be filed as provided. (Ibid.)
- Provides that costs or any portion of claimed costs shall be determined by the court in its discretion in a case other than a limited civil case, as provided, where the prevailing party recovers a judgment that could have been rendered in a limited civil case. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1033 (a).)
- Provides items of allowable costs that may be awarded to a prevailing party, which may include fees of expert witnesses ordered by the court. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1033.5.)
- Provides that a state agency may add to, revise, or delete text published in the California Code of Regulations without complying with the rulemaking process specified in the Administrative Procedure Act only if the changes do not materially alter any requirement, right, responsibility, condition, prescription, or other regulatory element of any California Code of Regulation provision. Such additions, revisions, or deletions are considered a change without regulatory effect. (1 C.C.R. Section 100.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: The current federal administration has made little secret of its intention to undermine or rollback as many existing federal regulations related to protection of the environmental, public health, and worker rights as possible. The federal government’s actions are diametrically opposed to California’s ongoing efforts to combat global warming, protect endangered species, and recognize and support the dignity of work. Accordingly, in the face of potentially calamitous rollbacks of federal law, this bill would, generally, require specified state agencies to review any federal action to change existing law in these areas and, if such an action presents a rollback in the protections afforded under those laws, decide if enacting the existing federal standard as a regulation in California is appropriate. In support of this measure to protect the progress made in California, the author states:
California’s geographic, population, and economic size make its impact global in nature. The state’s vast size has also brought an enormous impact on the environment. California has long struggled with some of the most polluted air in the country, discharge of pollution into our water and soil has led to contamination that has degraded the environment and public health.
Over 40 years ago, the federal clean air, clean water, safe drinking water, endangered species, and worker protection acts were all adopted on a bipartisan basis in the 1970’s.
Over the past 3 years, the President and Congress have weakened, eviscerated, and rolled back hundreds of these environmental and worker protections.
SB 1 simply ensures those federal standards stay in place to protect everyday Californians -- even if the federal government rolls them back.
Existing law provides for overlapping state and federal protections. This bill implicates several federal laws, and associated regulations, that are at risk of rollback by the federal administration. Many of these laws were designed to provide for overlapping state and federal governance in order to best protect public health, workers, and the environment under the notion of cooperative federalism. At a minimum, the federal laws implicated by this measure recognized that many states were likely to have, or adopt, overlapping regulatory schemes.
The scheme of overlapping state and federal regulation provides both dangers and benefits to California during the term of the current administration. In many cases, California has simply relied on federal standards to protect workers and the environment. When the federal standards are sufficient, there is little risk for the state to defer to its federal partners to protect the general welfare. However, when an administration seeks to undermine federal law, the state’s reliance on the federal government becomes more perilous. However, thanks to the overlapping regulatory structure provided by many of the federal statutes implicated by this bill, the state is able to step in and protect workers and the environment in the wake of federal retreat.
A brief primer on the relevant federal laws. As noted above, this bill involves state actions that would occur in the event changes at the federal level weaken seven existing federal laws, and the regulations, opinions, and decisions designed to implement those laws. Accordingly below is a brief summary of the history and intent of those federal statutes:
The Clean Air Act. The federal Clean Air Act governs air pollution emitted from both mobile and stationary sources. The Act was originally adopted in 1975 and established the National Ambient Air Quality Standards. These standards, along with state implementation plans, were designed to bring pollution levels down within specified timelines. When the majority of states failed to meet the original deadlines, the Act was amended in 1977 and again in 1990 to establish new compliance dates. In California the California Air Resources Board has primary authority for enforcing mobile source pollutants, while local air quality management districts regulate stationary source pollution.
The Clean Water Act. The federal Water Pollution Control Act of 1948 was the first national law to regulate water pollution. The modern iteration of federal anti-pollution law was enacted in 1972 when Congress amended the Water Pollution Control Act into the Clean Water Act. The federal Clean Water Act establishes the basic structure for regulating discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States and regulating quality standards for surface waters. Under the federal Clean Water Act, the United States Environmental Protection Agency has implemented pollution control programs, including setting wastewater standards for industrial facilities, as well as setting water quality standards for all contaminants in surface waters. The federal Clean Water Act made it unlawful to discharge any pollutant from a point source into navigable waters without a permit. Industrial, municipal, and other facilities must obtain a permit under the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System in order to discharge into surface water. In California, the State Water Resources Control Board has delegated authority to enforce the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System.
The Safe Drinking Water Act. The federal Safe Drinking Water Act was adopted by Congress in 1974 to protect public health against toxins in the water supply. The United States Environmental Protection Agency oversees the Act at the federal level and national health-based standards for drinking water to protect against both naturally-occurring and anthropogenic contaminants that may be found in drinking water. The national standards address a range of contaminants from agricultural run-off including pesticides and animal waste, to underground injection control protocols governing the oil and gas industry, to naturally occurring heavy metals and other toxic substances. The federal Safe Drinking Water Act provides a framework for coordination between the federal government, states, and local water agencies. In California the state has been granted primacy by the United States Environmental Protection Agency and several state agencies have delegated authority to implement and enforce various aspects of the law.
The Endangered Species Act. The Federal Endangered Species Act broadly seeks to protect species in the United States and governs import of endangered species in accordance with international treaties. The Act is administered by the United States Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Marine Fisheries Service. Of relevance to this bill the Act provides that species of plants and animals may be listed as either endangered or threatened. "Endangered" means a species is in danger of extinction throughout all or a significant portion of its range. "Threatened" means a species is likely to become endangered within the foreseeable future. All species of plants and animals, except pest insects, are eligible for listing as endangered or threatened. In addition to the regulations that implement the law, the Endangered Species Act permits federal agencies to publish biological opinions that utilize scientific evidence to opine as to how government actions, and projects, may impact endangered species. These opinions then serve as scientific basis for agency actions including the issuance of species take permits.
The Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938. Originally proposed at the height of the Great Depression and enacted in 1938, the Act provides for the eight hour workday, forty-hour workweek, minimum wage, and the provision of time-and-a-half overtime pay for workers. Additionally, the Act dramatically limited the use of child labor. The Act has been amended numerous times since the 1930’s to reflect increases in the minimum wage and attempts to ameliorate the gender wage gap.
The Occupational Safety and Health Act. Originally enacted in 1970, the federal Occupational Health and Safety Act establishes minimum safety and health standards for a variety of occupations and associated exposures to harmful toxins. The Act also established the federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration. The Act sets standards for a range of topics including asbestos, fall protection, cotton dust, trenching, machine guarding, benzene, lead and bloodborne pathogens. The Act requires employers to provide employees with a workplace that is free of serious hazards and requires employers to strive to eliminate hazards rather than simply mitigate their impact.
Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969. The Act provided for the creation of the Mine Safety and Health Administration. That administration’s powers, and many provisions of the Act, generally mirror the Occupational Safety and Health Act as adopted to the mining industry.
This bill. Seeking to prevent a backsliding of the federal regulatory structure as it existed prior to the current federal administration taking office, this bill establishes a minimum baseline for environmental, public health, and labor standards. The baseline is set as the federal standard that existed prior to the current federal administration assuming office. The bill provides that the California Air Resources Board, the State Water Resources Control Board, the Fish and Game Commission, the Department of Industrial Relations, and the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board must review applicable standards every quarter to determine if federal action has resulted in a federal standard falling below the baseline. In the event that a federal action results in a federal regulation falling below the baseline, the bill enables the above mentioned agencies to enact the federal baseline as a regulation on an expedited basis. Additionally, because many of the above mentioned statutes contain so-called “citizen suit” provisions, whereby the public may step in and file a lawsuit to enforce the law, this bill provides that for certain federal statutes, should a federal citizen suit provision be substantially restricted, conditioned, abridged, or repealed, such a suit may be brought under California law.
In the context of the Endangered Species Act, the bill freezes certain permit conditions and biological opinions as they were in the prior administration. Further, the bill applies various provisions of the California Endangered Species Act to the Central Valley Project water conveyance system operated by the federal Bureau of Reclamation. Finally, this bill provides that the statutes and regulations adopted pursuant to this bill are to remain in effect until January 20, 2025, which happens to be the absolute late date in which the federal administration could be in office under current provisions of the United States Constitution.
State authority to adopt former federal regulations. As noted, the federal laws implicated by this bill, by design, envisioned a role for the state to play in furthering the policy goals of the federal government. Nonetheless, should the state attempt to take an action that conflicts with federal authority, Article VI of the Constitution and a lengthy body of case law provide that the state law would be preempted. The Supreme Court noted, “Under the Supremacy Clause, from which our pre-emption doctrine is derived, any state law, however clearly within a State’s acknowledged power, which interferes with or is contrary to federal law, must yield.” (Gade v. National Solid Waste Management Association (1992) 505 U.S. 88, 108.)
This bill provides a framework for state agencies to adopt former federal standards in the event that the current administration weakens the federal law and thereby leaves a void in the regulatory framework. Because many of these frameworks envisioned a role for the state, statutory authority for such actions is already present in the federal law. For example, the Safe Drinking Water Act states, “[n]othing in this title shall diminish any authority of a State or political subdivision to adopt or enforce any law or regulation respecting drinking water regulations or public water systems, but no such law or regulation shall relieve any person of any requirement otherwise applicable under this title.” (42 U.S.C. Section 300g-3(e).) Most of the other statutes involved in the bill contain similar provisions. (See, e.g. 33 U.S.C. Section 1370, Clean Water Act; 29 U.S.C. Section 218(a), Fair Labor Standards Act; 30 U.S.C. Section 955, Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act; 29 U.S.C. Section 653(b)(4); Occupational Health and Safety Act.) Given that the regulatory process provided by this bill would only occur in the event that the federal government weakened its standards, the state would be free to step up and occupy the regulatory space previously held by the federal government.
The only statute that may present preemption issues is the Clean Air Act. The powers that the Act gives to states to adopt additional standards varies according to the source of the pollutant. As to fixed-point sources of air pollution, states retain the authority to set their own standards, so long as those standards are not less stringent than the federal law. (42 U.S.C. Section 7416.) By contrast, states are generally preempted from setting their own standards as to moving sources of air pollution. (42 U.S.C. Section 7543 (a).) California’s Clean Cars program, and associated exemptions from the Clean Air Act permitting the state to set its own emission standards, are currently the subject of intense debate between the state and federal government. Additionally, states are unable to regulate non-road vehicles, particularly airplanes. Furthermore, unlike the other statutes involved in this bill, California’s clean air rules are overseen at both the state and local level. The California Air Resources Board has authority to regulate mobile pollution sources (i.e. vehicles), while the regional air quality districts regulate stationary pollution sources. This bill would vest all authority to establish federal baseline rules in the state with the California Air Resources Board. Despite the existing delineation of authority, given the need for uniformity in adoption of the former federal rules, the California Air Resources Board appears to be the appropriate authority to carry out the regulatory duties specified in this bill.
Citizen lawsuits and delegated authority. All of the environmentally focused federal laws implicated by this bill contain provisions authorizing a so-called “citizen suit,” whereby a citizen can step into the place of a government regulator to enforce the law. (Safe Drinking Act (42 U.S. Code § 300j–8); Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C. Sec 1365); Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C. § 7604); and Endangered Species Act (16 U.S.C. § 1540 (g).) After significant negotiations between the stakeholders supporting and opposing this measure, a compromise was recently reached regarding the citizen suit provisions. This compromise is reflected in the current in-print version of this measure. As originally drafted this bill would have permitted the state agencies charged with implementing this bill to authorize state-level citizen suits should the federal suit provisions be undermined, utilizing the agencies’ authority under either state or federal law. These provisions may have provided citizen suit authority to enforce state environmental laws where none previously existed. Accordingly, the compromise proposal authorizes a state-based citizen suit to seek enforcement of federal laws should the citizen suit provisions in those laws be undermined, but does not create a new tool for enforcing existing state laws.
The compromise also appears to solve issues related to the state’s delegated authority and the citizen suit provisions. As noted above, some state agencies operate under agreements with the federal government to carry out federal law. For example, the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System is enforced by the State Water Resources Control Board under delegated authority from the federal government. Had the Board been required to adopt the citizen suit via its delegated authority, the door would have been opened for the current administration to seek to revoke such a delegation. This bill now automatically triggers the new state-level cause of action without agency action. Thus, as a result of the compromise, the risk of losing delegated authority would seem to be diminished.
The citizen suit provisions reflect most existing state laws authorizing non-governmental enforcement of environmental laws. In viewing the origins of the citizen suit provisions in federal environmental laws, legal scholars have noted, “Congress knew that despite the cooperative federalist regulatory scheme, government would never be fully able to enforce the law. Congress knew that effective enforcement of environmental law would require government to have, as two scholars have described it, the ‘friendship of the people.’” (Reisinger, Dougherty, & Moser, Environmental Enforcement and the Limits of Cooperative Federalism: Will Courts Allow Citizen Suits to Pick Up the Slack? 20 Duke Envtl. L. & Policy 9-10 (2010).) Although California has not adopted similar provisions in the environmental laws implicated by this bill, the state has provided private rights of action for other environmental laws. For example, the Safe Drinking and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986, better known as Proposition 65, authorizes citizens to stand-in for the government and file lawsuits. That Act recognizes that government authorities should be afforded an opportunity to enforce the law prior to a citizen commencing suit. Accordingly, that Act requires plaintiffs to notify certain government law enforcement officials prior to commencing a citizen lawsuit.
Recognizing the government’s role in enforcing environmental laws, this bill appears to be modeled on many of the notice requirements provided in the Safe Drinking and Toxic Enforcement Act of 1986. This bill requires that a 60-day notice be provided to the Attorney General and the counsel for applicable state agency, a district attorney, county counsel, counsel of the local agency, and prosecutor, prior to the commencement of a lawsuit. This bill provides that independent citizens are only authorized to pursue their claims if the government does not act. This provision appears wholly appropriate in light of the existing legal framework.
The Administrative Procedure Act and the public’s right to participate in governmental decisions. California’s Administrative Procedure Act is designed to enhance transparency and the public’s ability to participate in government. Accordingly, most regulations enacted by a state agency are subject to a formal rulemaking process. The process requires a proposed regulation to be published to the California Regulatory Notice Register and be subject to a 45-day public comment period. Before a regulation can be formally adopted, the agency must respond to the comments received from the public. (https://oal.ca.gov/rulemaking_process/.) Recognizing that a 45-day timeline may be too lengthy in the event of an emergency, the Administrative Procedure Act also provides for emergency rulemaking that may be utilized by an agency to avoid serious harm to the public peace, health, safety, or general welfare, or if a statute deems a situation to be an emergency. (Government Code Section 11342.545.) Emergency regulations, however, are only permitted to remain in effect on a temporary basis until the emergency has subsided, or permanent regulations are adopted. The emergency rulemaking process provides the public with five days to comment on the proposed regulation; however, the agency is not required to respond to those comments. (Title 1, C.C.R. Section 55.)
At the core of this bill is an extensive legislative directive for state agencies to conduct, or at a minimum consider, rulemaking. However, unlike regular rulemaking in which an agency can commence the process at any time, this bill necessitates state action only after the federal government acts. Accordingly, this bill provides a modified process for agency rulemaking. First, this bill requires an agency to publish to the California Regulatory Notice Register a list of all changes to relevant federal standards that may impact California, and the agency’s assessment of whether that change lessened the prior standard. That assessment must be online for at least 30 days prior to any additional agency action, and the agency must receive comment from the public regarding the assessment. If an agency chooses to initiate a rulemaking, the agency may then proceed in utilizing the emergency regulation process, or by promulgating or amending a state policy, plan, or regulation. Under existing law, promulgating or amending a state policy, plan, or regulation without proceeding through the formal rulemaking process would be considered an unlawful underground regulation. This bill, however, deems such actions to be a change without regulatory effect, thereby permitting the agency to bypass the rulemaking process entirely.
By permitting a state agency to bypass the formal rulemaking process, this bill would significantly limit the public’s ability to engage with state agencies on the adoptions of regulations pursuant to this bill. The proponents of this bill note that the bill provides for 30 days of comment on the agency’s list and associated assessment of the federal action, however, there is no formal requirement that agencies solicit comment on the regulations themselves. It should be noted, as well, that there is little on-point case law to provide guidance as to whether the Legislature can preemptively deem the adoption of a prior federal standard in the California Code of Regulations to be a change without regulatory effect without impermissibly delegating legislative authority to a state agency. Under California law, the Legislature may not confer upon an administrative agency unrestricted authority to make fundamental policy decisions. (People v. Wright (1982) 30 Cal.3d 705, 712.) However, “after declaring the legislative goals and establishing a yardstick guiding the administrator, it may authorize the administrator to adopt rules and regulations to promote the purposes of the legislation and to carry it into effect.” (Ibid.)
By providing that the state agency may only utilize the streamlined regulatory process when adopting the baseline federal standards without substantial modification, this bill appears to provide a sufficient “yardstick” to the administrative agency. However, given that the regulations passed by the state agencies are critical to carrying out the intent of the bill, the author may wish to clarify these provisions to better mirror existing state laws. As this bill progresses, the author and proponents of this bill may accomplish this clarity through one of two ways. First, an amendment could be taken to substitute the language deeming certain actions to be changes without regulatory effect with a full Administrative Procedure Act exemption. Such an exemption is well within the authority of the Legislature. Secondly, to ensure the public may participate in the process, the author and proponents may also chose to simply utilize the emergency regulation process and amend out the second method for promulgating regulations. As noted above, the Legislature is well within its authority to deem any situation to be an emergency, thereby permitting an agency to proceed with emergency rulemaking without the need to make any finding of that nature. In fact, this bill already makes such a finding and provides the timelines for which the regulations would remain in effect, thereby preserving the emergency regulations in law beyond the timeline traditionally provided to emergency regulations.
The Endangered Species Act and California’s water conveyance systems. After the stakeholders supporting and opposing this measure reached agreement regarding the citizen suit provisions of the bill, the most contentious issue remaining involves the interplay between the state and federal endangered species acts and the state and federal water projects. Both endangered species and water conveyance are well outside the boundaries of this Committee’s traditional jurisdiction, therefore, this Committee is not proposing any amendments to address the issues raised by the stakeholders. Nonetheless, the topic presents significant issues regarding federalism and the state’s ability to impose conditions on a federal project, and thus will be analyzed in more detail below.
Unlike the provisions of this bill related to air, water, and labor law standards, the provisions of this bill related to the Endangered Species Act go beyond simply the statute and implementing regulations. For the purposes of the Endangered Species Act, this bill sets the baseline standard to also include any incidental take permits, incidental take statements, or biological opinions in effect as of January 19, 2017. The bill additionally calls upon the California Fish and Game Commission to consider listing species as endangered under the California Endangered Species Act should they be delisted from the federal act. As noted above, a biological opinion is issued any time a project may impact an endangered species. The opinion then serves as the scientific foundation for take permits issued to projects and other operational parameters necessary to protect species and their habitat. One such project subject to biological opinions is the Central Valley Project, the federally operated water conveyance project in California that provides critical water resources to, among others, California’s agricultural industry in the Central Valley. After years of litigation regarding the impact of the Central Valley Project, and the state-run California State Water Project, on fish and other species that rely on habitat in the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta, the state and federal government and water users are embarking on a series of voluntary agreements to restore habitat and protect the Delta. These voluntary agreements are based on the scientific evidence provided in the biological opinions and are designed to evolve as scientific understanding of the Delta and California’s river ecosystems evolve.
This bill proposes to freeze these biological opinions. Opponents to this bill, including agricultural interests and some of California’s largest urban water districts, argue that freezing biological opinions as they stood in January 2017, undermines evolving science and makes protecting the Delta difficult. They note that new biological opinions are being drafted related to California’s water projects to reflect new science. The proponents of this measure, however, note that the current federal administration has a long track record of ignoring science in favor of politically motivated decision making, especially as it relates to environmental protections. (Lisa Friedman, E.P.A. Announces a New Rule. One Likely Effect: Less Science in Policymaking. NY Times (Apr. 24, 2018).) Accordingly, in keeping with this bill’s goals of preventing the current federal administration from undermining environmental policy, preserving existing biological opinions appears warranted, in light of the fact that there is no guarantee the current United States Fish and Wildlife Service will be permitted to utilize proper science when updating the biological opinions.
Beyond seeking to preserve existing biological opinions, permits, and empowering the Fish and Game Commission to protected species under California law that were previously protected by federal law, this bill also deems provisions of the California Endangered Species Act to be measures “relating to the control, appropriation, use, or distribution of water” within the meaning of the Reclamation Act of 1902, and applies the California Endangered Species Act to the United States Bureau of Reclamation’s operation of the federal Central Valley Project. The opponents of this measure fear that this an unlawful state encroachment into federal affairs and that such encroachment will derail the cooperative efforts to maintain voluntary agreements to protect the Delta as the parties may have to litigate the impacts of this bill. The proponents contend that the state is well within its authority under federal law to dictate conditions on federal water projects.
The state’s ability to dictate conditions to the federal Central Valley Project turns on an interpretation of Section 8 of the Reclamation Act of 1902 which provides, in part, that, “nothing in th[e] Act shall be construed as affecting…or to in any way interfere with the laws of any State or Territory relating to the control, appropriation, use or distribution of water used in irrigation, or any vested right acquired thereunder…the Secretary of the Interior in carrying out the provisions of this Act, shall proceed in conformity with such laws.” (43 U.S.C 372.) The Reclamation Act was enacted at a time when the federal government was highly deferential to evolving state water laws and envisioned cooperative federalism to be critical to western irrigation projects. Representative of the sentiment of the time, then-President Theodore Roosevelt, while discussing western water law, stated, “the distribution of the water, the division of the streams among irrigators, should be left to the settlers themselves in conformity with state laws and without interference in those law.” (H.R Doc. No. 1, 57th Congress, 1st Session, XXVII (1901).)
The federal government and the State of California have litigated the provisions of Section 8 several times, particularly debating the meaning of the term “control” in the statute. In upholding the State Water Resources Board’s ability to condition permits on the construction of the reservoirs necessary to supply the Central Valley Project, the Supreme Court noted that the Bureau of Reclamation’s guidance to the Project has stated, “reclamation law recognizes state water law and rights thereunder,” and that, “Congress [has] consistently reaffirmed that the Secretary should follow state law in all respects not directly inconsistent with [federal] directives.” (California v. United States 438 U.S. 645, 676, 678.) Building on that seminal case, the courts have also upheld state fish and wildlife regulations in relation to federal water projects holding that “absent displacement by another federal statute, Section 8 requires the Bureau of Reclamation to comply,” with state laws. (Natural Resources Defense Council v. Patterson (2004) 333 F.Supp 2d 906, 914.) However, when a separate federal statutes provides for what is considered a, “broad and paramount federal regulatory role,” Section 8 of the Reclamation Act does not necessarily preserve state control in relation to protecting fish and other endangered species. (California v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission et al. (1990) 495 U.S. 490, 499.)
As it related to the Central Valley Project, both the federal Endangered Species Act and the 1992 Central Valley Project Improvement Act (43 Pub. Law. 102-575 Section 3401 et seq.) play a role in the determination of whether or not the state may impose its own endangered species law onto the project. Of note to this bill Section 3406 of the Central Valley Project Improvement Act states:
The Secretary, immediately upon the enactment of this title, shall operate the Central Valley Project to meet all obligations under state and federal law, including but not limited to the federal Endangered Species Act, 16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq., and all decisions of the California State Water Resources Control Board establishing conditions on the applicable licenses and permits for the project. (43 Pub. Law. 102-575 Section 3406.)
It should be noted that this statutory language cites the federal Endangered Species Act and the State Water Resources Control Board’s authority regarding water rights. However, the statute does not cite the California Endangered Species Act. Accordingly, it is unclear whether or not federal Endangered Species Act specifically governs the project and fully occupies the regulatory space. Courts generally permit states to carve out stricter endangered species regulations than the federal government (see, e.g. Palladio, Inc. v. Diamond (1970) 321 F.Supp. 630, and Cresenzi Bird Importers, Inc. v. State of New York (S.D.N.Y.1987) 658 F.Supp. 1441), however, it is less clear if the state can dictate those regulations to the federal government itself. If a court were to deem the federal Endangered Species Act to be sufficiently “broad and paramount” in protecting species as it relates to the Central Valley Project, following the Supreme Court’s holding in California v. Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, those provisions of this bill would be preempted. However, the proponents of this bill point to a 2008 memorandum from the United States Bureau of Reclamation recognizing the need to protect the longfin smelt, a species listed under the California Endangered Species Act. They contend that this memo, in addition to prior court decisions applying state fish and wildlife laws to the federal project, demonstrates that this bill is a permissible exercise of state authority under Section 8 of the Reclamation Act of 1902.
Needless to say, the existing case law is varied on the subject, and thanks to voluntary cooperation regarding Delta restoration, no case has directly opined on the applicability of the California Endangered Species Act to the federal Central Valley Project. As this bill has progressed through the Legislature, the stakeholders supporting and opposing this bill have already reached agreement on several highly technical, and controversial, aspects of this bill. Given the ambiguity of the existing law, the importance of the ecological health of the Sacramento-San Joaquin River Delta, and the significant implications of the bill on the future of the voluntary agreements for California’s water conveyance system, it would likely behoove all stakeholders to the bill to continue to negotiate these provisions as this bill advances beyond this Committee.
The current federal administration is not the first to contest California’s progressive policies. The present administration is not the first to attack California’s progressive policies, and while many people may express that the current administration is the best in history at exaggerating its accomplishments, the administration has shown a remarkable inability to properly use the tools of the regulatory state. A recent study by the Sabin Center for Climate Change Law at Columbia University notes that the current administration has yet to win a major court challenge to any of its attempts to undo Obama-era environmental regulations. (Dena Adler, U.S. Climate Change Litigation in the Age of Trump: Year Two, Columbia Law School- Sabin Center for Climate Change Law (June 2019) available at: http://columbiaclimatelaw.com/.) In fact, the administration’s inability to adhere to basic principles of administrative law and procedure resulted in a recent rebuke from the Supreme Court and the denial of the administration’s attempt to place a question regarding immigration status on the 2020 Census. (Department of Commerce v. New York, (U.S. Jun. 27, 2019).) No. 18-966.)
Despite the administration’s numerous failures in court, it continues to threaten California’s existing policies and future priorities. Accordingly, this bill is certainly justified. However, the bill provides an existing sunset date that appears directly aimed at the present administration. As noted, this is not the first time a Presidential administration has tried to undermine environmental and worker protections. After the Bush Administration rolled back a provision of the Clean Air Act called “new source review,” which was a set of rules that required industrial facilities like refineries and power plants to install modern pollution control equipment, the Legislature enacted SB 288 (Sher, Chap. 476, Stats. of 2003) which prohibited air quality management districts from amending or revising its new source review rules or regulations to be less stringent than those rules or regulations that existed on December 30, 2002. In fact, many provisions of this bill can trace their origins to that legislation. However, despite that bill, the Legislature is again confronting an attack on California policy. In order to ensure that the Legislature is not forced to enact future legislation should another, perhaps more effective, administration again take aim at California’s policies, the author may wish to eliminate the sunset date provided in this bill. Nonetheless, California and its forward thinking policies face a critical threat from the federal government. This bill is a worthy measure to ensure that California’s environmental and labor goals are not undermined.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is supported by an expansive coalition of environmental and labor organizations. The support coalition states:
While California has long been a leader in protecting our natural resources, many of our environmental protections are built on a foundation of federal standards. Similarly, when it comes to enforcement of worker safety, we rely on a patchwork of state and federal rules to protect workers from catastrophic injuries. SB 1 is designed to strengthen that foundation by incorporating into state law existing federal protections for clean air, clean water, endangered species, worker safety, and safe drinking water when federal standards dip below certain baseline protections.
SB 1 adopts common-sense measures to allow California to continue on a path to economic and environmental sustainability – and reject the false choice that economic progress must come at the expense of public health, the vitality of our natural surroundings, and a healthy environment for all. For these reasons, we strongly support SB 1.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: This measure is opposed by a large coalition of business, agricultural and water interests as well as some local governments. The coalition states:
SB 1 threatens to undermine current state efforts to utilize science-based decision making to manage and provide reliable water supplies for California and protect, restore, and enhance the ecosystems of the Bay-Delta and its tributaries. As drafted, the bill handcuffs the California Department of Fish and Wildlife from being able to apply new science, new adaptive management practices and or consider new on the ground conditions when issuing Biological Opinions (BiOps), Incidental Take Permits or Incidental Take Statements pursuant to the Endangered Species Act by effectively freezing all permits to the January 19, 2017 date certain. In many cases, these permits rely on decades old science and now outdated on the ground conditions.
SB 1’s rigid approach to water management is counterproductive to the historic suite of integrated actions under the voluntary plan envisioned by the Brown and Newsom administrations. Voluntary agreements are essential to advancing a comprehensive approach of flow and non-flow measures to provide reliable water supplies for all of California. SB 1 prevents their full implementation by preventing the Department of Fish and Wildlife from allowing any changes to the BiOps or incidental take permits that may be included in the voluntary agreements.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
350 Bay Area Action
350 Sacramento
350 South Bay Los Angeles
American Sportfishing Association
Audubon California
AZUL
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Association of Local Conservation Corps
California Association of Professional Scientists
California Catholic Conference
California Coastal Protection Network
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California Interfaith Power & Light
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
California League of Conservation Voters
California Professional Firefighters
California ReLEAF
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Parks Foundation
California State Pipe Trades Council
Californians Against Waste
Central Valley Air Quality Coalition
Clean Water Action
Coachella Valley Waterkeeper
Coalition for Clean Air
Community Action to Fight Asthma
Defenders of Wildlife
East Bay Municipal Utility District
Environment California
Environmental Defense Center
Environmental Defense Fund
Environmental Water Caucus
Environmental Working Group
Eric Garcetti, Mayor of Los Angeles
Fossil Free California
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Heal the Bay
Health Officers Association of California
Humboldt Baykeeper
Latino Outdoors
League of Women Voters of California
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District
Mono Lake Committee
Monterey Bay Aquarium
Monterey Coastkeeper
Natural Resources Defense Council
Nextgen California
Orange County Coastkeeper
Planning and Conservation League
Protect American River Canyons
Restore The Delta
Russian Riverkeeper
San Diego 350
San Diego Coastkeeper
Santa Barbara Channelkeeper
Save Our Shores
Save The Bay
Seventh Generation Advisors
Sierra Club California
South Coast Air Quality Management District
State Building & Construction Trades Council of California
Surfrider Foundation
The 5 Gyres Institute
The Nature Conservancy
The Otter Project
The Trust for Public Land
UDW/AFSCME Local 3930
Voices for Progress
Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation
Wildcoast
Yuba River Waterkeeper
Zero Waste USA
Opposition
African American Farmers of California
Almond Alliance of California
American Coatings Association
American Pistachio Growers
Antelope Valley East Kern Water Agency
Association of California Water Agencies
Auto Care Association
Bizfed Central Valley
Brea Area Chamber of Commerce
Byron-Bethany Irrigation District
Building Owners and Managers Association
California Agricultural Aircraft Association
California Association of Relators
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Assocaiton
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Forestry Association
California Fresh Fruit Association
California Grain and Feed Association
California League of Food Producers
California Manufacturers and Technology Association
California Metals Coalition
California Paint Council
California Poultry Federation
California Restaurant Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
CAWA – Representing the Automotive Parts Industry
Central Coast Water Authority
Chemical Industry Council of California
Coachella Valley Water District
Construction Employers Association
Desert Water Agency
Dudley Ridge Water District
El Dorado County Chamber of Commerce
El Dorado Irrigation District
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Far West Equipment Dealers Association
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Forest Landowners of California
Fresno; County of
Friant Water Authority
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber of Commerce
Household and Commercial Products Association
International Council of Shopping Centers
Kern; County of
Kern County Water Agency
Kern County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
Kings; County of
Madera; County of
Merced; County of
Mojave Water Agency
Murrieta Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
NAIOP of California
National Federation of Independent Business
Nisei Farmers League
Northern California Water Association
North of the River Chamber of Commerce
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Palmdale Water District
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Regional Water Authority
Roseville Chamber of Commerce
Rowland Water District
San Bernardino Valley Municipal Water District
San Gabriel Valley Municipal Water District
San Joaquin; County of
San Joaquin River Exchange Contractors Water Authority
San Luis Delta-Mendota Water Authority
Santa Clarita Valley Water Agency
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Stanislaus; County of
State Water Contractors, Inc.
Southwest California Legislative Council
The Metropolitan Water District of Southern California
Torrance Chamber of Commerce
Tulare; County of
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
United Ag
United Water Conservation District
Valley Ag Water Coalition
Valley Industry and Commerce Association
Walnut Valley Water District
West Coast Lumber & Building Material Assocaiton
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Western Independent Refiners Association
Western Plant Health Association
Western States Petroleum Association
Western Wood Preservers Institute
Westlands Water District
Oppose Unless Amended
Association of California Cities- Orange County
City of Compton- Water Department
Cucamonga Valley Water District
El Monte/South El Monte Chamber of Commerce
Foothill Municipal Water District
Glendora Chamber of Commerce
Greater West Covina Business Association
Inland Empire Utilities Agency
La Verne Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Orange County Business Council
North Orange County Chamber of Commerce
Santa Clara Valley Water District
The Metropolitan Water District of Southern California
Regional Chamber of Commerce San Gabriel Valley
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
San Joaquin River Exchange Contractors Water Authority
Southern California Water Coalition
Three Valleys Municipal Water District
Western Municipal Water District
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: July 8, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Laura Friedman, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1
Author:(Atkins) – As Amended Ver:July 1, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 28-10
SUBJECT: California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019
SUMMARY: Enacts the California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act (Act) of 2019, which establishes specified minimum federal environmental, public health, and labor standards as state baselines in the event the Congress or President repeals or weakens corresponding federal standards, and prohibits the corresponding California standards from falling below those baselines. In the event that new federal standards fall below the baseline, this bill allows private citizens to enforce state standards, as specified.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the federal Clean Water Act (CWA) to regulate discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States and to regulate quality standards for surface waters.
- Establishes the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit program to regulate the discharge of pollutants in storm water, including municipal storm water systems.
- Establishes the federal Safe Drinking Water Act to set standards for drinking water quality and to oversee the states, localities, and water suppliers who implement those standards.
- Establishes the federal Endangered Species Act (ESA) to protect and recover imperiled species and the ecosystems upon which they depend.
- Establishes the federal Clean Air Act to regulate air emissions from stationary and mobile sources. Requires the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) to establish National Ambient Air Quality Standards to protect public health and public welfare and to regulate emissions of hazardous air pollutants.
- Establishes the California Safe Drinking Water Act and requires the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) and regional water quality control boards to maintain a drinking water program.
- Establishes the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, which prohibits the discharge of pollutants to surface waters unless the discharger obtains a permit from SWRCB or a regional water quality control board.
THIS BILL:
- States that it is unlawful for a person in this state to transport, sell, receive, acquire, or purchase any fish, wildlife, or plant taken, possessed, transported, or sold in violation of any law, treaty, policy, regulation, or finding of the United States in effect on January 19, 2017. Specifies that nothing in this provision prohibits a person from transporting, selling, receiving, acquiring, or purchasing any cannabis or hemp as allowed under state law. Sunsets this provision on January 20, 2025.
- Establishes the Act to ensure the continued protection of the environment, natural resources, and public health and safety in the state even if federal law is undermined, amended, or repealed.
- Authorizes a state agency to adopt standards or requirements to implement the Act, including by adopting emergency regulations.
- Defines "baseline federal standards" as the federal standards in effect as of January 1, 2017 or January 19, 2017, that were not otherwise permanently enjoined by a federal court as of that date; or the ESA in effect as of January 19, 2017.
- Defines "federal standards" as the federal Clean Air Act; the federal Safe Drinking Water Act; the federal Water Pollution Control Act; the federal Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938; the federal Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970; or the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969.
- Defines "state analogue statute" as the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006; the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act; the California Safe Drinking Water Act; or the Labor Code, including the California Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1973.
- Requires the State Air Resources Board (ARB) to regularly assess proposed and final changes to the federal standards; to at least quarterly publish on its website a list of changes made to the federal standards that may impact California and to provide an assessment on whether those changes are less protective of public health and safety.
- Requires the ARB, if it determines that the change to the federal standards is less protective of public health and safety, to consider whether it should adopt the baseline federal standards as a measure in order to maintain the state's protection as at least as stringent as the baseline federal standards.
- Requires the ARB, if it decides to adopt a measure as a result of a change to federal standards, to adopt the measure by either an emergency regulation or promulgation or amendment of a state policy plan or regulation.
- Requires SWRCB to regularly assess proposed and final changes to the federal standards; to at least quarterly publish on its website a list of changes made to the federal standards; and, to provide an assessment on whether those changes are less protective of public health and safety.
- Requires SWRCB, if it determines that the change to the federal standards is less protective of public health and safety, to consider whether it should adopt the baseline federal standards as a measure in order to maintain the state's protection to be at least as stringent as the baseline federal standards.
- Requires SWRCB, if it decides to adopt a measure as a result of a change to federal standards, to adopt the measure by either an emergency regulation or promulgation or by amendment of a state policy plan or regulation.
- Provides that the Act does not affect the process by which voluntary agreements are entered into to assist in the implementation of new water quality standards lawfully adopted by SWRCB.
- In the event that federal citizen suit provisions are substantially restricted, conditioned, abridged, or repealed, including limiting the recovery of fees and costs, authorizes that an action may be brought to enforce the baseline federal standards, state standards enacted pursuant to the Clean Air Act, Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, or related standards, as specified.
- Requires the Fish and Game Commission (FGC) to determine whether to list a species, subspecies, or distinct population segment under the California Endangered Species Act (CESA) in the event either of the following occurs:
- The federal delisting of the species, subspecies, or distinct population segment that is eligible for protection under CESA and that is listed as endangered or threatened pursuant to the ESA as of January 19, 2019; or,
- A change in the legally protected status of the species, subspecies, or distinct population segment through a change to the ESA or federal baseline standard.
- Specifies that the provisions of the CESA are measures relating to the control, appropriation, use, or distribution of water under the federal Reclamation Act of 1902 and shall apply to the United States Bureau of Reclamation’s operation of the federal Central Valley Project.
- Requires the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board (OSHSB) and the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) to regularly assess proposed and final changes to the federal standards; to at least quarterly publish on its website a list of changes made to the federal standards; and, to provide an assessment on whether those changes are more or less protective of public health and safety.
- Requires the OSHSB or DIR, if either determines that the change to the federal standards is less protective of public health and safety, to consider whether it should adopt the baseline federal standards as a measure in order to maintain the state's protection to be at least as stringent as the baseline federal standards.
- Requires the OSHSB or DIR, if either decides to adopt a measure as a result of a change to federal standards, to adopt the measure by either an emergency regulation or promulgation or amendment of a state policy plan or regulation.
- States that the provisions of the Act are severable and if any provision of the Act or its application is held invalid that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
- Provides that the Act shall become inoperative on January 20, 2025, and as of January 1, 2026 the Act is repealed.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Unknown, likely significant ongoing various special fund costs for the ARB to track federal changes and adopt new regulations pursuant to this bill.
- Unknown, likely significant ongoing special fund costs for the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) to list new species and process incidental take permits and make consistency determinations.
- Unknown, likely significant ongoing special fund costs for SWRCB to update regulations.
- Unknown, potentially significant costs for the Department of Justice associated with defending any and all private citizen lawsuits against state agencies.
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement:
SB 1 ensures clean air, clean water, endangered species, and worker safety standards that have been in place for as long as 50 years are not rolled back as a result of the anti-environment actions of the President and Congress. In the past two years, the new administration and congress have adopted action after action to weaken, roll back, and outright repeal longstanding and well-accepted standards to protect workers, public health and the environment. SB 1 simply ensures those standards stay in place to protect everyday Californians, even if the federal government rolls them back.
- California's impact. California is the most populous state in the union with a population of nearly 40 million people. It is the third largest state by area at 163,696 square miles. It is the 6th largest economy in the world. California’s geography, population, and economy make California’s impact global in nature.
California's population and economic activities have impacted its environment. California began to enact environmental policies before the federal government in many cases, recognizing the importance of these policies to its citizens and economy. California has been a model for other states as well as the federal government. For instance, California had developed clean air standards prior to the federal Clean Air Act. California’s environmental leadership also drives technology and scientific innovation that has strengthened the state’s economy.
- Federal Clean Water Act. The Federal Water Pollution Control Act of 1948 was the first major federal law to address water pollution. The law was amended in 1972, and became commonly known as the CWA. The federal CWA establishes the basic structure for regulating discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States and regulating quality standards for surface waters. Under the CWA, the US EPA has implemented pollution control programs, including setting wastewater standards for industrial facilities, as well as setting water quality standards for all contaminants in surface waters. The CWA made it unlawful to discharge any pollutant from a point source into navigable waters without a permit. Industrial, municipal, and other facilities must obtain a permit under the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System in order to discharge into surface water.
- Federal Safe Drinking Water Act. The federal SDWA was enacted in 1974 to protect public health by regulating drinking water. The US EPA enforces the federal SDWA at the national level. The federal SDWA authorizes the US EPA to set national health-based standards for drinking water to protect against both naturally-occurring and anthropogenic contaminants that may be found in drinking water. There are a number of threats to drinking water: improperly disposed of chemicals; animal wastes; pesticides; human wastes; wastes injected underground; and, naturally-occurring substances. Likewise, drinking water that is not properly treated or disinfected, or which travels through an improperly maintained distribution system, may also pose a health risk.
The SDWA applies to every public water system in the United States. There are currently more than 170,000 public water systems providing water to almost all Americans at some time in their lives. The responsibility for making sure these public water systems provide safe drinking water is divided among US EPA, states, tribes, water systems, and the public. The SDWA provides a framework in which these parties work together to protect this valuable resource.
Most states, including California, have been granted "primacy" by the US EPA, giving them the authority to implement and enforce the federal SDWA at the state level. California has enacted its own safe drinking water act to implement the federal law and establish state standards.
- Federal Clean Air Act (CAA). The federal Clean Air Act (CAA) is the federal law that regulates air emissions from stationary and mobile sources. Among other things, this law authorizes US EPA to establish National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) to protect public health and public welfare and to regulate emissions of hazardous air pollutants. One of the goals of the CAA was to set and achieve NAAQS in every state by 1975 in order to address the public health and welfare risks posed by certain widespread air pollutants. The setting of these pollutant standards was coupled with directing the states to develop state implementation plans, applicable to appropriate industrial sources in the state, in order to achieve these standards. The CAA was amended in 1977 and 1990 to set new goals for achieving attainment of NAAQS since many areas of the country had failed to meet the deadlines.
- Federal Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970. On December 29, 1970, the OSH Act became law, which established the federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA). OSHA’s safety and health standards, including those for asbestos, fall protection, cotton dust, trenching, machine guarding, benzene, lead and bloodborne pathogens, have prevented countless work-related injuries, illnesses and deaths. Significant hazards and unsafe conditions still exist in US workplaces; each year more than 3.3 million working men and women suffer a serious job-related injury or illness. Millions more are exposed to toxic chemicals in the workplace that may cause illnesses years from now. Under federal OSHA, employers are required to provide their workers with a workplace that does not have serious hazards and must follow all OSHA safety and health standards. OSHA requires employers to eliminate or reduce hazards by making feasible changes in working conditions rather than relying on personal protective equipment such as masks, gloves, or earplugs. Switching to safer chemicals, enclosing processes to trap harmful fumes, or using ventilation systems to clean the air are examples of effective ways to eliminate or reduce risks.
- Federal and State Endangered Species Acts. The purpose of the federal ESA is to protect and recover imperiled species and the ecosystems upon which they depend. It is administered by the US Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Marine Fisheries Service. Under the federal ESA, species may be listed as either endangered or threatened. "Endangered" means a species is in danger of extinction throughout all or a significant portion of its range. "Threatened" means a species is likely to become endangered within the foreseeable future. All species of plants and animals, except pest insects, are eligible for listing as endangered or threatened.
The CESA states that all native species of fishes, amphibians, reptiles, birds, mammals, invertebrates, and plants, and their habitats, threatened with extinction and those experiencing a significant decline, which, if not halted, would lead to a threatened or endangered designation, will be protected or preserved. CDFW works with all interested persons, agencies and organizations to protect and preserve such sensitive resources and their habitats. CESA prohibits the take of any species of wildlife designated by the Fish and Game Commission as endangered, threatened, or candidate species. CDFW may authorize the take of any such species if certain conditions are met.
Existing law provides, under the state and federal endangered species acts, for the listing and protection of species determined through biological scientific analysis to be endangered or threatened with extinction. This bill introduces a new, accelerated process that is outside of the regular listing process for including species under CESA. FGC is required to take action under this process if there are actions at the federal level to delist or change the legally protected status of a species, subspecies, or distinct population segment.
The take of listed species is generally prohibited unless authorized by a permit issued by the appropriate regulatory agency. The ESA allows the federal government to allow incidental take through incidental take permits or incidental take statements. CESA provides a mechanism for CDFW to issue incidental take permits under state law, or to concur in a federal incidental take permit or statement through what is termed a consistency determination.
Biological opinions, following consultation with the US Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Marine Fisheries Service, determine if a federal project is likely to jeopardize a listed species or destroy or adversely modify a listed species' critical habitat. Biological opinions often include an incidental take statement that authorizes a predetermined amount of take of the listed species. Concerns have been raised that the state will not concur with new, or revisions to existing, incidental take permits, incidental take statements, or biological opinions issued after January 19, 2017 that are not deemed to be as protective as the baseline federal standards, which may impact the ongoing operation of projects, such as the coordinated operations of the Central Valley Project and the State Water Project, for which the state has previously concurred with the federal government’s biological opinion.
The California Natural Resources Agency has been negotiating voluntary water agreements between federal and state entities, water agencies, and water rights holders to balance environmental and human water needs. The voluntary water agreements, if approved by SWRCB, would take the place of flow requirements established by SWRCB for the Bay-Delta Water Quality Control Plan. While the bill does not affect the process by which voluntary water agreements are entered into for the implementation of new water quality standards, it has the potential to affect the content of the agreements themselves, which raises concerns that it may create issues with implementing the voluntary water agreements.
- Federal rollbacks. The current federal administration has made it clear that it presumes that environmental law and regulation jeopardize economic growth in the United States and has committed to numerous actions to rollback federal environmental protections. A partial list of the president’s actions includes:
- Referring to the concept of man-made climate change as a “hoax created by and for the Chinese to make American manufacturing non-competitive.”
- Purged, a week after taking office, the US EPA of any mention of climate change.
- Withdrew the final determination on strict vehicle fuel-efficiency standards, and eventually his administration decided to end negotiations with California over plans to roll back fuel economy rules designed to reduce GHG emissions.
- Proposed to eliminate 31% of the budget for US EPA.
- Signed an executive order to undo the Waters of the United States Rule that extended federal protections to smaller rivers and streams.
- Signed an executive order to set an annual cap on the cost impact of new regulations, beginning in the current fiscal year 2017 with a cap of $0, meaning that agencies should repeal existing rules to offset the cost of adding any new ones. Further, it directs agencies to suggest repealing at least two existing rules for every new one proposed.
- Signed H.J. Res. 38 (Johnson, R–OH), nullifying the Department of Interior’s Stream Protection Rule. The Stream Protection Rule targets coal-mining industry practices to protect waterways by requiring companies to avoid mining practices that permanently pollute streams, destroy drinking water sources, increase flood risk, and threaten forests by requiring companies to restore streams and return mined areas to the uses they were capable of supporting prior to mining activities, and to replant the areas with native trees and vegetation, unless that would conflict with the implemented land use.
- Ordered a federal hiring freeze, affecting all state agencies, including the hiring of new doctors by the Department of Veterans Affairs.
- Sought the names of civil servants who worked on issues related to climate change, women’s rights, and reproductive health.
- Announced his intention to abandon the Paris climate accords, making the USA the only country in the world not to support the framework deal to combat GHG emissions.
- Opened oil drilling in the Artic when the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management issued a conditional permit to Houston-based Hilcorp to begin drilling from an artificial island in the Beaufort Sea.
- Disbanded a scientific review panel that advises the US EPA about safe levels of pollution in the air.
- Initiated a plan to reverse Obama-Administration rules designed to curtail coal power plant emissions of carbon dioxide and methane that contribute to climate change.
- Ended NASA’s Carbon Monitoring System, a $10-million-per-year effort to fund pilot programs intended to improve the monitoring of global carbon emissions.
- Eliminated a Clinton-era rule that forced large sources of air pollution to remain subject to stricter regulations if they exceeded specified levels.
- Signed an executive order revoking federal flood-risk standards that incorporated rising sea levels predicted by climate science.
- Referring to the concept of man-made climate change as a “hoax created by and for the Chinese to make American manufacturing non-competitive.”
This bill is intended to respond to the Trump Administration's attack on laws and regulations that protect public health and the environment. SB 1 sets the current federal environmental laws as a floor to ensure that the economic, environmental, and public health benefits of these laws are maintained in California. The public health and environmental protections provided by the federal environmental and occupational health and safety laws and regulations provide very important and real benefits.
California is the fifth largest economy in the world and has some of the most, if not the most, protective public health and environmental laws in the country. California has proven that protecting human health and the environment and promoting economic growth are not mutually exclusive. SB 1 is intended to ensure that the strong environmental protections, coupled with the strong economic performance that California has achieved is not reversed by the Trump Administration.
- Previous legislation:
SB 49 (de León, 2017) was substantially similar to this bill. SB 49 was not taken up on the Assembly Floor.
SB 288 (Sher), Chapter 476, Statutes of 2003, established the Protect California Air Act of 2003, prohibiting air quality management districts in California from amending or revising the Federal Clean Air Act (FCAA) related rules or regulations to be less stringent than those federal rules or regulations that existed on December 30, 2002, except under certain circumstances. This bill was a response to federal action on December 31, 2002, to reduce standards associated with the FCAA.
- Triple referral. SB 1 has been referred to the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee, the Assembly Natural Resources Committee, and the Assembly Judiciary Committee. This bill passed out of the Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee on June 18th with a vote of 6-1. If it passes this committee, it will be referred to the Judiciary Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
350 Bay Area
350 Sacramento
350 South Bay Los Angeles
American Sportfishing Association
Audubon California
Azul
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Association of Local Conservation Corps
California Association of Professional Scientists
California Catholic Conference
California Coastal Protection Network
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California Interfaith Power & Light
California Labor Federation, AFI-CIO
California League of Conservation Voters
California Professional Firefighters
California ReLEAF
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Parks Foundation
California State Pipe Trades Council
Californians Against Waste
CALSTART
Central Valley Air Quality Coalition
City of Del Mar
City of Los Angeles, Mayor Eric Garcetti
Clean Water Action
Coachella Valley Waterkeeper
Coalition for Clean Air
Community Action to Fight Asthma
Defenders of Wildlife
East Bay Municipal Utility District
Environment California
Environmental Defense Center
Environmental Defense Fund
Environmental Water Caucus
Environmental Working Group
Fossil Free California
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Heal the Bay
Health Officers Association of California
Humboldt Baykeeper
Latino Outdoors
League of Women Voters of California
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District
Mono Lake Committee
Monterey Bay Aquarium
Monterey Coastkeeper
Natural Resources Defense Council
Nextgen California
Orange County Coastkeeper
Planning and Conservation League
Protect American River Canyons
Restore the Delta
Russian Riverkeeper
San Diego 350
San Diego Coastkeeper
Santa Barbara Channelkeeper
Save Our Shores
Save The Bay
Seventh Generation Advisors
Sierra Club California
South Coast Air Quality Management District
State Building and Construction Trades Council
Surfrider Foundation
The 5 Gyres Institute
The Nature Conservancy
The Otter Project
The Trust for Public Land
UDW/AFSCME Local 3930
Voices for Progress
Western States Council of Sheet Metal Workers
WILDCOAST
Yuba River Waterkeeper
Zero Waste USA
36 Individuals
Opposition
African American Farmers of California
Agricultural Council of California
Agricultural Energy Consumers Association
Almond Alliance of California
American Coatings Association
American Pistachio Growers
Antelope Valley East Kern Water Agency
Association of California Cities-Orange County
Association of California Water Agencies
Auto Care Association
BizFed Central Valley
Brea Chamber of Commerce
Building Owners and Managers Association
Byron-Bethany Irrigation District
California Agricultural Aircraft Association
California Association of Realtors
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association, Inc.
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Forestry Association
California Fresh Fruit Association
California Grain and Feed Association
California Independent Petroleum Association
California League of Food Producers
California Licensed Foresters Association
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Metals Coalition
California Paint Council
California Poultry Federation
California Restaurant Association
California Water Alliance
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
CAWA
Central Coast Water Authority
Chemical Industry Council of California
City of Compton, Water Department
Coachella Valley Water District
Construction Employers' Association
County of Fresno
County of Kern
County of Kings
County of Madera
County of Merced
County of San Joaquin
County of Stanislaus
County of Tulare
Crestline-Lake Arrowhead Water Agency
Cucamonga Valley Water District
Desert Water Agency
Dudley Ridge Water District
El Dorado County Joint Chambers Commission
El Dorado Irrigation District
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
El Monte/South El Monte Chamber of Commerce
Family Business Association of California
Far West Equipment Dealers Association
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Foothill Municipal Water District
Forest Landowners of California
Friant Water Authority
Glendora Chamber of Commerce
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber of Commerce
Household and Commercial Products Association
Inland Empire Utilities Agency
International Council of Shopping Centers
Kern County Board of Supervisors
Kern County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
Kern County Water Agency
Kings River Conservation District
Kings River Water Association
La Verne Chamber of Commerce
Laguna Water District
Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce
Mercy Springs Water District
Metropolitan Water District of Southern California
Modesto Irrigation District
Mojave Water Agency
Murrieta/Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
NAIOP of California
National Federation of Independent Business
Nisei Farmers League
North of the River Chamber of Commerce
North Orange County Chamber of Commerce
Northern California Water Association
Oakdale Irrigation District
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Pacheco Water District
Palmdale Water District
Panoche Water District
Patterson Irrigation District
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Regional Chamber of Commerce San Gabriel Valley
Regional Water Authority
Roseville Area Chamber of Commerce
Rowland Water District
San Benito County Water District
San Bernardino Valley Municipal Water District
San Gabriel Valley Economic Partnership
San Gabriel Valley Municipal Water District
San Joaquin River Exchange Contractors Water Authority
San Luis Canal Company/Henry Miller Reclamation District #2131
San Luis Delta-Mendota Water Authority
Santa Clara Valley Water District
Santa Clarita Valley Water Agency
Santa Maria Valley Chamber of Commerce
Southern California Water Coalition
Southwest California Legislative Council
State Water Contractors, Inc.
The Greater West Covina Business Association
Three Valleys Municipal Water District
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
Turlock Irrigation District
United Ag
United Water Conservation District
Valley Ag Water Coalition
Valley Industry & Commerce Association
Walnut Valley Water District
West Coast Lumber & Building Material Association
West Stanislaus Irrigation District
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Western Independent Refiners Association
Western Municipal Water District
Western Plant Health Association
Western States Petroleum Association
Western Wood Preservers Institute
Westlands Water District
Analysis Prepared by: Elizabeth MacMillan / NAT. RES. /
Date of Hearing: June 18, 2019
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS
Bill Quirk, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1
Author:(Atkins) – As Amended Ver:May 21, 2019
SENATE VOTE: 28-10
SUBJECT: California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019
SUMMARY: Enacts the California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019 (Act) with the purpose of ensuring that protections afforded to Californians under federal environmental and labor laws and regulations as of January 2017, remain in place in the event that President Trump weakens or repeals any of these federal laws or regulations. Specifically, this bill:
1) States that it is unlawful for a person in this state to transport, sell, receive, acquire, or purchase any fish, wildlife, or plant taken, possessed, transported, or sold in violation of any law, treaty, or regulation of the United States in effect on January 19, 2019; in violation of any law or regulation of any other state in effect on January 1, 2020; or, in violation of any foreign law in effect on January 1, 2020.
2) Enacts the Act to ensure the continued protection of the environment, natural resources, and public health and safety in the state even if federal law is undermined, amended, or repealed.
3) Provides that the purposes of the Act are to retain protections afforded under federal laws and regulations as of January 19, 2017; to protect public health, safety, and welfare from any actual or potential adverse effects that could occur from hazards and pollution; preserve, protect, and enhance the environment and natural resources in California; to prevent work-related and environmental illness and injury; and, to ensure that economic growth will occur in a manner consistent with the protection of public health and safety and the environment.
4) Authorizes a state agency to adopt standards or requirements to implement the Act, including by adopting emergency regulations.
5) Defines "baseline federal standards" as the federal standards in effect as of January 1, 2017 or January 19, 2017, that were not otherwise permanently enjoined by a federal court as of that date; or the federal Endangered Species Act of 1973 in effect as of January 19, 2017.
6) Defines "federal standards" as the federal Clean Air Act; the federal Safe Drinking Water Act; the federal Water Pollution Control Act; the federal Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938; the federal Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970; or the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969.
7) Defines "state analogue statute" as the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006; the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act; the California Safe Drinking Water Act; or the Labor Code, including the California Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1973.
8) Requires the State Air Resources Board (Air Board) to regularly assess proposed and final changes to the federal standards; to at least quarterly publish on its internet website a list of changes made to the federal standards and to provide an assessment on whether those changes are more or less protective of public health and safety.
9) Requires the Air Board, if it determines that the change to the federal standards is less protective of public health and safety, to consider whether it should adopt the baseline federal standards as a measure in order to maintain the state's protection as at least as stringent as the baseline federal standards.
10) Requires the Air Board, if it decides to adopt a measure as a result of a change to federal standards, to adopt the measure by either an emergency regulation or promulgation or amendment of a state policy plan or regulation.
11) Authorizes a person to bring an action in the public interest exclusively to enforce baseline federal standards, except for enforcement of the federal Endangered Species Act, as a measure by the appropriate state agency if the person provides a written notice to the Attorney General at least 60 days before initiating the action.
12) Requires the State Water Resources Control Board (Water Board) to regularly assess proposed and final changes to the federal standards; to at least quarterly publish on its internet website a list of changes made to the federal standards; and, to provide an assessment on whether those changes are more or less protective of public health and safety.
13) Requires the Water Board, if it determines that the change to the federal standards is less protective of public health and safety, to consider whether it should adopt the baseline federal standards as a measure in order to maintain the state's protection to be at least as stringent as the baseline federal standards.
14) Requires the Water Board, if it decides to adopt a measure as a result of a change to federal standards, to adopt the measure by either an emergency regulation or promulgation or by amendment of a state policy plan or regulation.
15) Provides that the Act does not affect the process by which voluntary agreements are entered into to assist in the implementation of new water quality standards lawfully adopted by the State Water Board.
16) Requires the Fish and Game Commission (Commission) to determine whether to list a species, subspecies, or distinct population segment under the California Endangered Species Act (CESA) in the event either of the following occurs:
a) The federal delisting of the species, subspecies, or distinct population segment that is eligible for protection under CESA and that is listed as endangered or threatened pursuant to the federal Endangered Species Act (FESA) as of January 19, 2019; or,
b) A change in the legally protected status of the species, subspecies, or distinct population segment through a change to the FESA or federal baseline standard.
17) Requires the Occupational Safety and Health Standards Board (Board) and the Department of Industrial Relations (DIR) to regularly assess proposed and final changes to the federal standards; to at least quarterly publish on its internet website a list of changes made to the federal standards; and, to provide an assessment on whether those changes are more or less protective of public health and safety.
18) Requires the Board or DIR, if either determines that the change to the federal standards is less protective of public health and safety, to consider whether it should adopt the baseline federal standards as a measure in order to maintain the state's protection to be at least as stringent as the baseline federal standards.
19) Requires the Board or DIR, if either decides to adopt a measure as a result of a change to federal standards, to adopt the measure by either an emergency regulation or promulgation or amendment of a state policy plan or regulation.
20) States that the provisions of the Act are severable and if any provision of the Act or its application is held invalid that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
21) Provides that the Act shall become inoperative on January 20, 2025, and as of January 1, 2026 the Act is repealed.
EXISTING LAW:
1) Establishes the federal Clean Water Act (CWA) to regulate discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States and to regulate quality standards for surface waters. (33 United States Code (U.S.C.) §1251 et seq.)
2) Establishes the federal Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA) to set standards for drinking water quality and to oversee the states, localities, and water suppliers who implement those standards. (42 U.S.C. § 300 (f) et. seq.)
3) Establishes the federal Endangered Species Act (ESA) to protect and recover imperiled species and the ecosystems upon which they depend. (16 U.S.C. § 1531 et. seq.)
4) Establishes the federal Clean Air Act to regulate air emissions from stationary and mobile sources. Requires United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) to establish National Ambient Air Quality Standards to protect public health and public welfare and to regulate emissions of hazardous air pollutants. (42 U.S.C. § 7401 et seq.)
5) Establishes the California Safe Drinking Water Act (California SDWA) and requires the State Water Board to maintain a drinking water program. (Health & Safety Code (HSC) § 116270, et seq.)
6) Establishes the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, which prohibits the discharge of pollutants to surface waters unless the discharger obtains a permit from the State Water Board. (Water Code (WC) § 1300 et seq.)
7) Establishes the Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938 to provide for the establishment of fair labor standards in employments in and affecting interstate commerce. (29 U.S.C. § 201, et seq.)
8) Establishes the federal Occupational Safety and Health Act (OSH Act) of 1970 to assure safe and healthful working conditions for working men and women; to provide for research, information, education, and training in the field of occupational safety and health; and for other purposes. (29 U.S.C. § 651 et seq.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill: According to the author, "SB 1 makes federal baseline standards for environmental and worker protection enforceable as a matter of state law, where the current administration in Washington DC rolls them back. It has been roughly three years and two months since the new administration took office in Washington DC. During that time, according to the New York Times and numerous other authorities: Over 34 different key clean air, clean water, and endangered species standards have been weakened or eliminated. In addition, and for the third year in a row, the federal administration has proposed a budget blueprint that would reduce the budget of the US EPA to a point where the agency would no longer be able to meaningfully enforce clean air and water laws. SB 1 simply provides that, whatever actions the new federal regime may take, California will continue to enforce the same environmental and public health protections that have been in effect for years, as a matter of state law."
Federal Clean Water Act (CWA): The Federal Water Pollution Control Act of 1948 was the first major U.S. law to address water pollution. The law was amended in 1972, and became commonly known as the Clean Water Act (CWA). The federal CWA establishes the basic structure for regulating discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States and regulating quality standards for surface waters. Under the CWA, the US EPA has implemented pollution control programs, including setting wastewater standards for industrial facilities, as well as setting water quality standards for all contaminants in surface waters. The CWA made it unlawful to discharge any pollutant from a point source into navigable waters without a permit. Industrial, municipal, and other facilities must obtain a permit under the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System in order to discharge into surface water.
Federal Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA): The federal SDWA was enacted in 1974 to protect public health by regulating drinking water. The US EPA enforces the federal SDWA at the national level. The federal SDWA authorizes the US EPA to set national health-based standards for drinking water to protect against both naturally-occurring and anthropogenic contaminants that may be found in drinking water. There are a number of threats to drinking water: improperly disposed of chemicals; animal wastes; pesticides; human wastes; wastes injected underground; and, naturally-occurring substances. Likewise, drinking water that is not properly treated or disinfected, or which travels through an improperly maintained distribution system, may also pose a health risk.
The SDWA applies to every public water system in the United States. There are currently more than 170,000 public water systems providing water to almost all Americans at some time in their lives. The responsibility for making sure these public water systems provide safe drinking water is divided among US EPA, states, tribes, water systems, and the public. The SDWA provides a framework in which these parties work together to protect this valuable resource.
Most states, including California, have been granted "primacy" by the US EPA, giving them the authority to implement and enforce the federal SDWA at the state level. California has enacted its own safe drinking water act to implement the federal law and establish state standards.
Federal Endangered Species Act (ESA): The purpose of the federal ESA is to protect and recover imperiled species and the ecosystems upon which they depend. It is administered by the US Fish and Wildlife Service and the National Marine Fisheries Service. Under the federal ESA, species may be listed as either endangered or threatened. "Endangered" means a species is in danger of extinction throughout all or a significant portion of its range. "Threatened" means a species is likely to become endangered within the foreseeable future. All species of plants and animals, except pest insects, are eligible for listing as endangered or threatened.
Federal Clean Air Act (CAA): The federal Clean Air Act (CAA) is the federal law that regulates air emissions from stationary and mobile sources. Among other things, this law authorizes US EPA to establish National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) to protect public health and public welfare and to regulate emissions of hazardous air pollutants. One of the goals of the CAA was to set and achieve NAAQS in every state by 1975 in order to address the public health and welfare risks posed by certain widespread air pollutants. The setting of these pollutant standards was coupled with directing the states to develop state implementation plans, applicable to appropriate industrial sources in the state, in order to achieve these standards. The CAA was amended in 1977 and 1990 to set new goals (dates) for achieving attainment of NAAQS since many areas of the country had failed to meet the deadlines.
Federal Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970 (OSH Act): On December 29, 1970, President Nixon signed the OSH Act into law, which established federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA). OSHA’s safety and health standards, including those for asbestos, fall protection, cotton dust, trenching, machine guarding, benzene, lead and bloodborne pathogens, have prevented countless work-related injuries, illnesses and deaths. Significant hazards and unsafe conditions still exist in U.S. workplaces; each year more than 3.3 million working men and women suffer a serious job-related injury or illness. Millions more are exposed to toxic chemicals in the workplace that may cause illnesses years from now. Under federal OSHA, employers are required to provide their workers with a workplace that does not have serious hazards and must follow all OSHA safety and health standards. OSHA requires employers to eliminate or reduce hazards by making feasible changes in working conditions rather than relying on personal protective equipment such as masks, gloves, or earplugs. Switching to safer chemicals, enclosing processes to trap harmful fumes, or using ventilation systems to clean the air are examples of effective ways to eliminate or reduce risks.
Global Warming Solutions Act: The California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (AB 32 Núñez/Pavley, Chapter 488, Statutes of 2006), marked a watershed moment in California’s history. It required a sharp reduction of greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions, and set the stage for California's transition to a sustainable, low-carbon future. AB 32 was the first program in the country to take a comprehensive, long-term approach to addressing climate change, and does so in a way that aims to improve the environment and natural resources while maintaining a robust economy. AB 32 requires California to reduce its GHG emissions to 1990 levels by 2020, which is a reduction of approximately 15 percent below emissions expected under a business as usual scenario.
Pursuant to AB 32, the Air Board must adopt regulations to achieve the maximum technologically feasible and cost-effective GHG emission reductions. The full implementation of AB 32 will help mitigate risks associated with climate change, while improving energy efficiency, expanding the use of renewable energy resources, cleaner transportation, and reducing waste.
California Endangered Species Act (CESA): The CESA states that all native species of fishes, amphibians, reptiles, birds, mammals, invertebrates, and plants, and their habitats, threatened with extinction and those experiencing a significant decline which, if not halted, would lead to a threatened or endangered designation, will be protected or preserved. The California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) works with all interested persons, agencies and organizations to protect and preserve such sensitive resources and their habitats. CESA prohibits the take of any species of wildlife designated by the California Fish and Game Commission as endangered, threatened, or candidate species. CDFW may authorize the take of any such species if certain conditions are met.
Concerns that the Trump Administration could weaken federal environmental protections: On February 24, 2017, President Trump issued an Executive Order on Enforcing the Regulatory Reform Agency, which creates a regulatory reform task force and requires the task force to evaluate existing regulations and make recommendations for their repeal. The task force is required to identify regulations that eliminate jobs or inhibit job creation; are outdated, unnecessary, or ineffective; impose costs that exceed benefits; and create a serious inconsistency or otherwise interfere with regulatory reform initiatives and policies. Missing from this Executive Order is an evaluation of the benefits of a regulation on protecting human health and the environment, including the potential reduction in health care costs, or of increased productivity by having certain environmental regulations in place. Some additional examples of President Trump's actions as President, that could harm California's economy, public health, or environment:
- Called the concept of man-made climate change a "hoax created by and for the Chinese to make American manufacturing non-competitive."
- Purged, a week after taking office, the US EPA of any mention of climate change.
- Withdrew the final determination on strict vehicle fuel-efficiency standards, and eventually ended negotiations with California over plans to roll back fuel economy rules designed to reduce greenhouse gases (GHG) emissions.
- Signed an executive order to undo the Waters of the United States Rule that extended federal protections to smaller rivers and streams.
- Signed House Joint Resolution 38 (Johnson, R–OH), nullifying the Department of Interior’s Stream Protection Rule. The Stream Protection Rule targets coal-mining industry practices to protect waterways by requiring companies to avoid mining practices that permanently pollute streams, destroy drinking water sources, increase flood risk, and threaten forests.
- Announced his intention to abandon the Paris climate accords, making the USA the only country in the world not to support the framework deal to combat GHG emissions.
- Opened oil drilling in the Artic when the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management issued a conditional permit to Houston-based Hilcorp to begin drilling from an artificial island in the Beaufort Sea.
- Disbanded a scientific review panel that advises the US EPA about safe levels of pollution in the air.
- Initiated a plan to reverse Obama-Administration rules designed to curtail coal power plant emissions of carbon dioxide and methane that contribute to climate change.
- Ended the National Aeronautics and Space Administration’s Carbon Monitoring System, a $10-million-per-year effort to fund pilot programs intended to improve the monitoring of global carbon emissions.
- Eliminated a Clinton-era rule that forced large sources of air pollution to remain subject to stricter regulations if they ever exceeded specified levels.
- Signed an executive order revoking federal flood-risk standards that incorporated rising sea levels predicted by climate science.
- Called the concept of man-made climate change a "hoax created by and for the Chinese to make American manufacturing non-competitive."
Response to President Trump's anti-environmental policies: SB 1 was introduced to respond to the Trump Administration's attack on laws and regulations that protect public health and the environment. It is clear that the new federal administration is interested in easing compliance with laws and regulations for multi-billion dollar corporations; however, it is unclear exactly what environmental laws or regulations could become a target for weakening or repealing and what the economic, public health, and environmental impacts the actions might have on California. SB 1 simply sets a floor for the federal environmental laws currently in place in order to ensure that the economic, environmental, and public health benefits of these laws are maintained in California. The public health and environmental protections provided by the federal Clean Air Act, federal Clean Water Act, and all of the environmental laws and regulations in place, provide very important and very real benefits to everyone in this country. Loosening these federal requirements, such as allowing businesses to release toxic wastes into rivers, lakes, and streams, near schools and homes, or allow entities to emit toxic chemicals into the air, could set us back decades in terms of the environmental protections that have been achieved.
California is the fifth largest economy in the world and has some of the most, if not the most, protective public health and environmental laws in the country. Protecting human health and the environment and promoting economic growth are not mutually exclusive. There is a balance, and early indications from the Trump Administration are that the President does not see the balance and only sees the side of the equation that does not include protecting human health and the environment or the economic benefits from those protections. SB 1 is intended to ensure that the strong environmental protections, coupled with the strong economic performance that California has achieved is not un-done by the Trump Administration. SB 1 is substantially similar to SB 49 (De León), from 2017, which passed this committee on a 4 to 2 vote.
Arguments in support: A number of environmental organizations, including the Natural Resources Defense Council, "California has long been a leader in ensuring a healthy environment and workplace for its citizens. For many years, the state has enforced its laws protecting the air that Californians breathe, the water that Californians drink, and the wildlife and natural resources that our citizens prize, in tandem with federal agency partners. But the Trump administration now threatens that long-standing partnership with ongoing and persistent efforts to weaken or eliminate critical public health and environmental protections. SB 1 protects our citizens and our environment by ensuring that protections in existence prior to January 19, 2017 under the federal Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, Safe Drinking Water Act, Endangered Species Act, and workplace safety laws are not weakened, and gives California state agencies streamlined authority to enforce these protections under state law. SB 1 adopts common-sense measures to allow California to continue on a path to economic and environmental sustainability – and reject the false choice that economic progress must come at the expense of public health, the vitality of our natural surroundings, and a healthy environment for all. For these reasons, we strongly support SB 1."
Arguments in opposition: On behalf of a number of business organizations, including the California Chamber of Commerce argue, "The California Chamber of Commerce and listed organizations must respectfully oppose SB 1 (Atkins) which the California Chamber of Commerce has labeled as a job killer. Our opposition to the bill is not with the author's intent to protect California's air, water, biodiversity and workers from any federal changes that undermine the state's existing standards. Our concern with the bill stems from the significant negative consequences of the bill, including regulatory uncertainty, lack of due process, and unnecessary litigation that would result if the bill were passed and as currently amended [April 11, 2019]. SB 1 joins numerous unrelated labor laws and regulations with environmental laws and regulations under the same excessively general guise of "public welfare" merely because they relate to a "state prerogative." For these reasons, we must oppose SB 1 (Atkins)."
Triple referral: SB 1 has been referred to the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee, the Assembly Natural Resources Committee, and the Assembly Judiciary Committee. Should SB 1 pass out of this committee, it will be re-referred to the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
Related legislation:
1) SB 49 (De León, 2017). Would have enacted the California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act (Act) of 2017, to prohibit a state or local agency from amending or revising its rules to be less stringent than the federal baseline standards pertaining to environmental protection. This bill was not heard on the Assembly Floor.
2) SB 288 (Sher, Chapter 476, Statutes of 2003). Established the Protect California Air Act of 2003, prohibiting air quality management districts in California from amending or revising the Federal Clean Air Act (FCAA) related rules or regulations to be less stringent than those federal rules or regulations that existed on December 30, 2002, except under certain circumstances. This bill was a response to federal action on December 31, 2002, to reduce standards associated with the FCAA.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
350 Bay Area Action
350 Sacramento
350 South Bay Los Angeles
American Sportfishing Association
Audubon California
AZUL
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Association of Local Conservation Corps
California Association of Professional Scientists
California Coastal Protection Network
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California Interfaith Power & Light
California Labor Federation, AFL-CIO
California League of Conservation Voters
California Professional Firefighters
California ReLEAF
California State Association of Electrical Workers
California State Parks Foundation
California State Pipe Trades Council
Californians Against Waste
Central Valley Air Quality Coalition
Clean Water Action
Coachella Valley Waterkeeper
Coalition for Clean Air
Community Action to Fight Asthma
Defenders of Wildlife
East Bay Municipal Utility District
Environment California
Environmental Defense Center
Environmental Defense Fund
Environmental Water Caucus
Environmental Working Group
Eric Garcetti, Mayor of Los Angeles
Fossil Free California
Friends Committee on Legislation of California
Heal the Bay
Humboldt Baykeeper
Latino Outdoors
League of Women Voters of California
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Midpeninsula Regional Open Space District
Mono Lake Committee
Monterey Bay Aquarium
Monterey Coastkeeper
Natural Resources Defense Council
Nextgen California
Orange County Coastkeeper
Planning and Conservation League
Protect American River Canyons
Restore The Delta
Russian Riverkeeper
San Diego 350
San Diego Coastkeeper
Santa Barbara Channelkeeper
Save Our Shores
Save The Bay
Seventh Generation Advisors
Sierra Club California
South Coast Air Quality Management District
State Building & Construction Trades Council of California
Surfrider Foundation
The 5 Gyres Institute
The Nature Conservancy
The Otter Project
The Trust for Public Land
UDW/AFSCME Local 3930
Voices for Progress
Western States Council Sheet Metal, Air, Rail and Transportation
Wildcoast
Yuba River Waterkeeper
Zero Waste USA
Opposition
Almond Alliance of California
Antelope Valley East Kern Water Agency
Association of California Water Agencies
Bizfed Central Valley
Byron-Bethany Irrigation District
California Chamber of Commerce
California Poultry Federation
Central Coast Water Authority
Coachella Valley Water District
Desert Water Agency
Dudley Ridge Water District
El Dorado County Chamber of Commerce
El Dorado Irrigation District
Elk Grove Chamber of Commerce
Folsom Chamber of Commerce
Fresno; County of
Friant Water Authority
Kern County Water Agency
Kings; County of
Madera; County of
Merced; County of
Mojave Water Agency
Northern California Water Association
Palmdale Water District
Rancho Cordova Chamber of Commerce
Regional Water Authority
Roseville Chamber of Commerce
Rowland Water District
San Bernardino Valley Municipal Water District
San Gabriel Valley Municipal Water District
San Joaquin; County of
San Joaquin River Exchange Contractors Water Authority
San Luis Delta-Mendota Water Authority
Santa Clarita Valley Water Agency
Stanislaus; County of
State Water Contractors, Inc.
The Metropolitan Water District of Southern California
Tulare; County of
United Water Conservation District
Valley Ag Water Coalition
Valley Industry and Commerce Association
Walnut Valley Water District
Western Growers Association
Westlands Water District
Analysis Prepared by: Josh Tooker / E.S. & T.M. /
Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1
Author: Atkins (D), Portantino (D) and Stern (D), et al.
Amended: 5/21/19
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 5-2, 3/20/19
AYES: Allen, Hill, Skinner, Stern, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Stone
SENATE NATURAL RES. & WATER COMMITTEE: 7-2, 4/9/19
AYES: Stern, Allen, Caballero, Hertzberg, Hueso, Jackson, Monning
NOES: Jones, Borgeas
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 6-2, 4/23/19
AYES: Jackson, Allen, Monning, Stern, Umberg, Wieckowski
NOES: Borgeas, Jones
NO VOTE RECORDED: Caballero
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 4-2, 5/16/19
AYES: Portantino, Bradford, Hill, Wieckowski
NOES: Bates, Jones
SUBJECT: California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019
DIGEST:
This bill establishes specified minimum federal environmental, public health, and labor standards as state baselines in the event the Congress or President repeals or weakens corresponding federal standards, and prohibits the corresponding California standards from falling below those baselines. In the event that new federal standards fall below the baseline, this bill allows private citizens to enforce state standards under specific circumstances.
ANALYSIS: Existing federal law authorizes states, for each of the following statutes, to act as delegates for implementing and enforcing the federal acts, as long as the state’s laws are at least as stringent as or more stringent than the federal act or to enact their own similar state statute (California’s laws often preceded the federal acts and provided a model for the federal government to follow):
- Regulates, under the federal Clean Air Act, air emissions from stationary and mobile sources. Among other things, this law authorizes the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) to establish National Ambient Air Quality Standards to protect public health and public welfare and to regulate emissions of hazardous air pollutants.
- Regulates, under the Clean Water Act (CWA), discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States and regulates quality standards for surface waters. CWA makes it unlawful to discharge any pollutant from a point source into navigable waters, unless a permit was obtained, and specifies that the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit program controls such discharges.
- Regulates, under the Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA), the nation’s public drinking water supply, and requires the US EPA to establish mandatory nationwide drinking water standards. SDWA additionally requires water systems to monitor public water supplies to ensure drinking water standards are met and report to consumers if the standards are not met.
- Provides, under the Endangered Species Act, for the conservation of species that are endangered or threatened throughout all or a significant portion of their range, and the conservation of the ecosystems on which they depend.
Existing state law:
- Prohibits, under the Protect California Air Act of 2003, air quality management districts and air pollution control districts from amending or revising their new source review rules or regulations to be less stringent than those rules or regulations that existed on December 30, 2002, except under certain circumstances.
- Establishes, under the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (AB 32), a comprehensive program to reduce greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions from all sources throughout the state to combat climate change.
- Regulates, under the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, the discharge of pollutants into the waters of the state.
- Establishes, under the California Safe Drinking Water Act, standards for drinking water and regulates drinking water systems.
- Requires, under the California Endangered Species Act, the Fish and Game Commission to establish a list of endangered species and a list of threatened species and generally prohibits the taking of those species.
This bill:
- Requires listed agencies to regularly assess proposed and final changes to federal standards for the above statutes and, when changes are determined to be less protective of public health, the environment, or worker health or safety than the baseline federal standards of January 19, 2017, directs those agencies to consider adopting the baseline federal standards in order to ensure the state’s protections are at least as stringent as the baseline federal standards, as specified.
- Requires listed agencies to take specified actions to maintain and enforce certain requirements and standards pertaining to air, water, protected species, and occupational safety.
- Authorizes a person acting in the public interest to bring an action to enforce certain standards and requirements implementing some, but not all, of the above-mentioned state laws if certain conditions are satisfied, as specified.
- Prohibits specified state agencies that implement the laws above from amending or revising its rules and regulations in a manner that is less stringent in its protection of workers’ rights or worker safety than standards established by federal law in existence as of January 1, 2016.
- Requires state agencies to report to the Legislature on compliance with the above requirements, as specified.
- Makes its provisions inoperative as of January 20, 2025, and would repeal them as of January 1, 2026.
Comments
- Purpose of bill. According to the author, “SB 1 ensures clean air, clean water, endangered species, and worker safety standards that have been in place for as long as 50 years are not rolled back as a result of the anti-environment actions of the President and Congress. In the past two years, the new administration and congress have adopted action after action to weaken, roll back, and outright repeal longstanding and well-accepted standards to protect workers, public health and the environment. SB 1 simply ensures those standards stay in place to protect everyday Californians, even if the federal government rolls them back.”
- A brief and incomplete summary of President Trump’s environmental record. President Trump has clearly stated his view that environmental laws and regulations jeopardize economic growth in the United States. President Trump has taken numerous actions to, and has committed to many other actions that would, rollback environmental protections in the United States. Although far from being an exhaustive list, President Trump has:
- Called the concept of man-made climate change a “hoax created by and for the Chinese to make American manufacturing non-competitive.”
- Purged, a week after taking office, the US EPA of any mention of climate change.
- Withdrew the final determination on strict vehicle fuel-efficiency standards, and eventually his administration decided to end negotiations with California over plans to roll back fuel economy rules designed to reduce GHG emissions.
- Proposed to eliminate 31% of the budget for US EPA.
- Signed an executive order to undo the Waters of the United States Rule that extended federal protections to smaller rivers and streams.
- Signed an executive order to set an annual cap on the cost impact of new regulations, beginning in the current fiscal year 2017 with a cap of $0, meaning that agencies should repeal existing rules to offset the cost of adding any new ones. Further, it directs agencies to suggest repealing at least two existing rules for every new one proposed.
- Signed H.J. Res. 38 (Johnson, R–OH), nullifying the Department of Interior’s Stream Protection Rule. The Stream Protection Rule targets coal-mining industry practices to protect waterways by requiring companies to avoid mining practices that permanently pollute streams, destroy drinking water sources, increase flood risk, and threaten forests by requiring companies to restore streams and return mined areas to the uses they were capable of supporting prior to mining activities, and to replant the areas with native trees and vegetation, unless that would conflict with the implemented land use.
- Ordered a federal hiring freeze, affecting all state agencies, including the hiring of new doctors by the Department of Veterans Affairs.
- Sought the names of civil servants who worked on issues related to climate change, women’s rights, and reproductive health.
- Announced his intention to abandon the Paris climate accords, making the USA the only country in the world not to support the framework deal to combat GHG emissions.
- Opened oil drilling in the Artic when the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management issued a conditional permit to Houston-based Hilcorp to begin drilling from an artificial island in the Beaufort Sea.
- Disbanded a scientific review panel that advises the US EPA about safe levels of pollution in the air.
- Rolled back Obama-era climate change policy, reducing requirements on oil and gas companies to monitor and mitigate releases of methane from wells and other operations.
- Initiated a plan to reverse Obama-Administration rules designed to curtail coal power plant emissions of carbon dioxide and methane that contribute to climate change.
- Ended NASA’s Carbon Monitoring System, a $10-million-per-year effort to fund pilot programs intended to improve the monitoring of global carbon emissions.
- Eliminated a Clinton-era rule that forced large sources of air pollution to remain subject to stricter regulations if they ever exceeded specified levels.
- Signed an executive order revoking federal flood-risk standards that incorporated rising sea levels predicted by climate science.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Unknown, likely significant ongoing various special fund costs for the California Air Resources Board to track federal changes and adopt new regulations pursuant to this bill.
- Unknown, likely significant ongoing special fund costs for the California Department of Fish and Wildlife to list new species and process incidental take permits and make consistency determinations.
- Unknown, likely significant ongoing special fund costs for the State Water Resources Control Board to update regulations.
- Unknown, potentially significant costs for the Department of Justice associated with defending any and all private citizen lawsuits against state agencies.
350 Bay Area Action
Audubon California
Azul
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Association of Professional Scientists
California Coastal Protection Network
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California Interfaith Power & Light
California Labor Federation
California League of Conservation Voters
California Product Stewardship Council
California Professional Firefighters
California ReLEAF
California State Parks Foundation
California Teamsters
Californians Against Waste
CALSTART
Central Valley Air Quality Coalition
Clean Water Action
Coachella Valley Waterkeeper
Coalition for Clean Air
Defenders of Wildlife
East Bay Municipal Utility District
Engineers and Scientists of California, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO
Environment California
Environmental Defense Center
Environmental Defense Fund
Environmental Water Caucus
Environmental Working Group
Fossil Free California
Friends Committee on Legislation in California
Heal the Bay
Humboldt Baykeeper
Inland Empire Waterkeeper
League of Women Voters of California
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Los Cerritos Wetlands Land Trust
Mono Lake Committee
Monterey Coastkeeper
Mountain Lion Foundation
National Stewardship Action Council
Natural Resources Defense Council
Nextgen California
Orange County Coastkeeper
PawPAC
Pesticide Action Network
Planning and Conservation League
Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
Protect American River Canyons
Restore the Delta
Russian Riverkeeper
San Diego Coastkeeper
Santa Barbara Channelkeeper
Save Our Shores
Save the Bay
Seventh Generation Advisors
Sierra Club California
South Coast Air Quality Management District
Southern California Watershed Alliance
State Building & Construction Trades Council
Surfrider Foundation
The 5 Gyres Institute
The Nature Conservancy
The Otter Project
The Trust for Public Land
Utility Workers of America
Voices for Progress
WILDCOAST
Yuba River Waterkeeper
Zero Waste USA
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/17/19)
African American Farmers of California
Agricultural Council of California
Agricultural Energy Consumers Association
Almond Alliance
American Coatings Association
American Pistachio Growers
Association of California Water Agencies
Auto Care Association
Brea Chamber of Commerce
Building Owners and Managers Association
Byron Bethany Irrigation District
California Agricultural Aircraft Association
California Association of Realtors
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Automotive Wholesalers’ Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Council for Environmental and Economic Balance
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Forestry Association
California Fresh Fruit Association
California Grain and Feed Association
California Independent Petroleum Association
California League of Food Producers
California Licensed Foresters Association
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Metals Coalition
California Paint Council
California Restaurant Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
Chemical Industry Council of California
Construction Employers’ Association
Family Business Association of California
Far West Equipment Dealers Association
Forest Landowners of California
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber
Household & Commercial Products Association
International Council of Shopping Centers
Kern County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
Murrieta/Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
NAIOP Commercial Real Estate Development Association
National Federation of Independent Business
Nisei Farmers League
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
Santa Maria Chamber of Commerce
Southern California Water Coalition
Southwest California Legislative Council
The San Luis & Delta-Mendota Water Authority
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
United Chamber Advocacy Network
United Water Conservation District
West Coast Lumber & Building Material Association
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Western Independent Refiners Association
Western Plant Health Association
Western States Petroleum Association
Western Wood Preservers Institute
Prepared by: David Ernest García / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
5/21/19 17:45:22
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 1 (Atkins) - California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019
Version: April 11, 2019 | Policy Vote: E.Q. 5 - 2, N.R. & W. 7 - 2, JUD. 6 - 2 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 16, 2019 | Consultant: Paul Jacobs |
Bill Summary:
This bill establishes mechanisms to preserve specified environmental, public health, and labor standards and remedies in California as they existed on January 19, 2017.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on May 16, 2019
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, likely significant ongoing various special fund costs for the California Air Resources Board (ARB) to track federal changes and adopt new regulations pursuant to this bill.
- Unknown, likely significant ongoing special fund costs for the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) to list new species and process incidental take permits and make consistency determinations.
- Unknown, likely significant ongoing special fund costs for the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) to update regulations.
- Unknown, potentially significant costs for the Department of Justice associated with defending any and all private citizen lawsuits against state agencies.
Author Amendments:
Author amendments do the following:
- Clarifies that if a state agency adopts anything other than a standard substantially the same as the federal baseline standard, the agency must go through the full administrative procedure act process.
- Strikes out the phrase “less stringent than” where it appears in the bill and replaces it with the phrase “less protective of public health, the environment, or worker health or safety.”
- Limits the bill to federal roll backs of trophy hunting of African animals.
- Adds use of “best available science” in CESA provision.
- Narrows the labor provisions to apply only to worker health and safety federal baselines that are rolled back, not to other federal labor laws.
- Clarifies that the bill does not affect voluntary settlement agreements negotiated by the State Water Resources Control Board.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anthony Portantino, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular Session
SB 1 (Atkins) - California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019
Version: April 11, 2019 | Policy Vote: E.Q. 5 - 2, N.R. & W. 7 - 2, JUD. 6 - 2 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: Yes |
Hearing Date: May 13, 2019 | Consultant: Paul Jacobs |
Bill Summary:
This bill establishes mechanisms to preserve specified environmental, public health, and labor standards and remedies in California as they existed on January 19, 2017.
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, likely significant ongoing various special fund costs for the California Air Resources Board (ARB) to track federal changes and adopt new regulations pursuant to this bill.
- Unknown, likely significant ongoing special fund costs for the California Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) to list new species and process incidental take permits and make consistency determinations.
- Unknown, likely significant ongoing special fund costs for the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) to update regulations.
- Unknown, potentially significant costs for the Department of Justice associated with defending any and all private citizen lawsuits against state agencies.
Background:
Existing federal law:
- Regulates air emissions from stationary and mobile sources through the establishment of National Ambient Air Quality Standards to protect public health and public welfare and to regulate emissions of hazardous air pollutants. (Federal Clean Air Act)
- Regulates discharge of pollutants into the waters of the United States and regulates quality standards for surface waters. Makes it unlawful to discharge any pollutant from a point source into navigable waters unless a permit was obtained. Provides that the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System permit program controls discharges. (Clean Water Act)
- Regulates the nation’s public drinking water supply and requires the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to establish mandatory nationwide drinking water standards. Requires water systems to monitor public water supplies to ensure drinking water standards are met and report to consumers if the standards are not met. (Safe Drinking Water Act)
- Provides for the conservation of species that are endangered or threatened throughout all or a significant portion of their range and the conservation of the ecosystems on which they depend. (Endangered Species Act)
- Requires the payment of minimum wage and overtime to workers and prohibits the use of child labor. (Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938)
- Provides for the safety of workers on job sites. (Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970)
- Provides health and safety standards at coal mines and a corresponding inspection regime. (Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969)
- Authorizes states, under each of the statutes above, to act either as delegates for implementing and enforcing the federal acts or to enact their own similar state statute, as long as the state’s laws are at least as stringent as or more stringent than the federal act.
- Allows individual citizens, as part of the statutes listed in (1) through (4), above, to enforce the laws by bringing suit in court, so long as they comply with specified pre-litigation requirements, including prior notice to the state attorney general’s office. Provides that prevailing citizens may be awarded attorney fees.
President Trump has clearly stated his view that environmental laws and regulations jeopardize economic growth in the United States. President Trump has taken numerous actions to, and has committed to many other actions that would, roll back environmental protections in the United States. As a general rule, California is free to adopt its own standards in areas listed above, so long as they do not fall below the standards set by the federal government. However, in cases where the California standard is pegged to, or influenced by, the federal standard, when federal protections slip, so do those in California.
Proposed Law:
In response to potential rollbacks at the federal level, this bill would establish baseline environmental, public health, and labor standards in accordance with the federal standards that were in place on January 19, 2017, President Obama’s last day in office. It would then task the relevant California state agencies with monitoring changes in federal standards and adjusting California’s standards as necessary to ensure that standards here remain at least as stringent as the January 19, 2017 baselines. Specifically, this bill:
- Defines “federal baseline standards” as those in force on January 19, 2017.
- Requires specified California state agencies to regularly assess proposed and final changes to federal standards under the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act, the Endangered Species Act, the Fair Labor Standards Act, the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act, the Occupational Health and Safety Act, and the Safe Drinking Water Act.
- Requires specified agencies to follow specified procedures in response to changes in federal standards that will result in a less stringent standard when compared to the federal baseline standards, including adopting the federal baseline standard as the California standard.
- Authorizes a person acting in the public interest to bring an action to enforce certain standards and requirements implementing the above-mentioned state laws if specified procedural preconditions are met.
- Makes the above provisions inoperative as of January 20, 2025, and repeals them as of January 1, 2026.
- Prohibits anyone to transport, sell, receive, acquire, or purchase any fish, wildlife, or plant taken, possessed, transported, or sold in violation of any law, treaty, or regulation of the United States in effect on January 19, 2017.
- Prohibits anyone to transport, sell, receive, acquire, or purchase any fish, wildlife, or plant taken, possessed, transported, or sold in violation of any law or regulation of any other state in effect on January 1, 2020, or in violation of any foreign law in effect on January 1, 2020.
Related Legislation:
SB 49 (De León, 2017) was substantially similar to this bill. Unlike this bill, however, SB 49 required state agencies to adopt the federal baseline standard when a change in federal standards resulted in a less stringent standard and SB 49 allowed for enforcement actions against state agencies through petition for writ in the superior court of jurisdiction. This bill was held in the Assembly Rules Committee.
SB 288 (Sher), Chapter 476, Statutes of 2003, enacted the Protect California Air Act in response to federal action on December 31, 2002, to reduce standards associated with the federal Clean Air Act. The bill prohibited air quality management districts in California from amending or revising Clean Air Act-related rules or regulations to be less stringent than those federal rules or regulations that existed on December 30, 2002, except under specified circumstances.
Staff Comments:
SB 1 would incur significant but unknown costs for several state agencies affected by the bill. Estimating the fiscal impact from this bill is fraught with uncertainty as it is unclear what potential federal rollbacks could occur in the future. Additionally, should regulations be needed to address a rollback, state agencies would incur varying levels of cost impacts depending on the nature and scope of the rollback. Despite the streamlining of regulation adoption provided in the bill, state agencies would still need to adopt regulations through a public process that in some cases, could be extensive and potentially also be required to comply with the California Environmental Quality Act. Finally, the citizen suit provisions could also lead to significant but unknown additional litigation costs.
-- END --
Senator Hannah-Beth Jackson, Chair
2019-2020 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 1 (Author:Atkins)
Version: April 11, 2019
Hearing Date: April 23, 2019
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: TSG
SUBJECT
California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019
DIGEST
This bill establishes mechanisms to preserve specified environmental, public health, and labor standards and remedies in California as they existed on January 19, 2017.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Since January 20, 2017, the federal government under President Trump has dramatically rolled back federal environmental and workplace safety protections. California’s commitment to maintaining strong environmental and workplace safety protections has been undermined as a result. To address this problem, this bill would establish baseline environmental, public health, and labor standards in accordance with the federal standards that were in place on January 19, 2017, President Obama’s last day in office. It would then task the relevant California state agencies with monitoring changes in federal standards and adjusting California’s standards as necessary to ensure that standards here remain at least as stringent as the January 19, 2017 baselines. Finally, the bill would trigger the availability of state level citizen lawsuits to enforce the relevant standards if the federal standards are weakened or in the event that the existing federal citizen suit provisions are restricted or repealed.
The bill is author-sponsored. It has support from labor and environmental advocates. Opposition is from business groups, industry associations, and some water districts, who contend that the bill introduces uncertainty over applicable standards and exposes them to unwarranted litigation. The bill passed out of the Senate Environmental Quality Committee by a vote of 5-2 and out of the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee by a vote of 7-2.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing federal law:
- Regulates air emissions from stationary and mobile sources through the establishment of National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) to protect public health and public welfare and to regulate emissions of hazardous air pollutants. (Federal Clean Air Act, Pub.L. No. 88-206 (Dec. 17, 1963) 77 Stat. 392, 42 U.S.C. § 7401 et seq.);
- Regulates discharge of pollutants into the waters of the United States and regulates quality standards for surface waters. Makes it unlawful to discharge any pollutant from a point source into navigable waters unless a permit was obtained. Provides that the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit program controls discharges. (Clean Water Act, Pub.L. No. 92-500 (Oct. 18, 1972) 86 Stat. 816.)
- Regulates the nation’s public drinking water supply and requires the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency to establish mandatory nationwide drinking water standards. Requires water systems to monitor public water supplies to ensure drinking water standards are met and report to consumers if the standards are not met. (Safe Drinking Water Act, Pub.L. No. 93-523 (Dec. 16, 1974) 88 Stat. 1660, 42 U.S.C. § 300f.)
- Provides for the conservation of species that are endangered or threatened throughout all or a significant portion of their range and the conservation of the ecosystems on which they depend. (Endangered Species Act, Pub.L. No. 93-203 (Dec. 27, 1973) 87 Stat. 884, 16 U.S.C. 1531 et seq.)
- Requires the payment of minimum wage and overtime to workers and prohibits the use of child labor. (Fair Labor Standards Act of 1938, as amended, 29 U.S.C. § 201 et seq.)
- Provides for the safety of workers on job sites. (Occupational Safety and Health Act of 1970, Pub.L. No. 91-596, as amended, 29 U.S.C. § 651 et seq.)
- Provides health and safety standards at coal mines and a corresponding inspection regime. (Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act of 1969, Pub.L. No. 91-173 (Dec. 30, 1969), as amended, 30 U.S.C. Sec. 801 et seq.)
- Authorizes states, under each of the statutes above, to act either as delegates for implementing and enforcing the federal acts or to enact their own similar state statute, as long as the state’s laws are at least as stringent as or more stringent than the federal act. (Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. § 7416 (fixed point sources of air pollution), 42 U.S.C. § 7543(b) (mobile sources of air pollution, as applied to California); Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C. § 1370; Endangered Species Act, 16 U.S.C. § 1535(f); Fair Labor Standards Act, 29 U.S.C. 218(a); Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act, 30 U.S.C. § 955; Occupational Health and Safety Act, 29 U.S.C. 653(b)(4); Safe Drinking Water Act, 42 U.S.C. § 300g-3(e).)
- Allows individual citizens, as part of the statutes listed in (1) through (4), above, to enforce the laws by bringing suit in court, so long as they comply with specified pre-litigation requirements, including prior notice to the state attorney general’s office. Provides that prevailing citizens may be awarded attorney fees. (Clean Air Act, 42 U.S.C. § 7604; Clean Water Act, 33 U.S.C. § 1365; Endangered Species Act, 16 USC § 1540(g); Safe Drinking Water Act, 42 U.S.C. § 300j-8.)
Existing state law:
- Prohibits air quality management districts and air pollution control districts from amending or revising their new source review rules or regulations to be less stringent than those federal rules or regulations that existed on December 30, 2002, except under certain circumstances. (Protect California Air Act of 2003, Health & Saf. Code § 42500 et seq.)
- Establishes a comprehensive program to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from all sources throughout the state to combat climate change. (California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006, Health & Saf. Code § 38500 et seq.)
- Regulates the discharge of pollutants into the waters of the state. (Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, Wat. Code §§ 13000-16104.)
- Establishes standards for drinking water and regulates drinking water systems. (California Safe Drinking Water Act, Health and Saf. Code §§ 116270 et seq.)
- Requires the Fish and Game Commission to establish a list of endangered species and a list of threatened species and generally prohibits the taking of those species. (California Endangered Species Act, Fish and G. Code §§ 2050-2069.)
This bill:
- Defines “federal baseline standards” as those in force on January 19, 2017.
- Requires specified California state agencies to regularly assess proposed and final changes to federal standards under the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act, the Endangered Species Act, the Fair Labor Standards Act, the Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act, the Occupational Health and Safety Act, and the Safe Drinking Water Act.
- Requires specified agencies to follow specified procedures in response to changes in federal standards that will result in a less stringent standard when compared to the federal baseline standards, including adopting the federal baseline standard as the California standard.
- Authorizes a person acting in the public interest to bring an action to enforce certain standards and requirements implementing the above-mentioned state laws if specified procedural preconditions are met.
- Makes the above provisions inoperative as of January 20, 2025, and repeals them as of January 1, 2026.
- Prohibits anyone to transport, sell, receive, acquire, or purchase any fish, wildlife, or plant taken, possessed, transported, or sold in violation of any law, treaty, or regulation of the United States in effect on January 19, 2017.
- Prohibits anyone to transport, sell, receive, acquire, or purchase any fish, wildlife, or plant taken, possessed, transported, or sold in violation of any law or regulation of any other state in effect on January 1, 2020, or in violation of any foreign law in effect on January 1, 2020.
COMMENTS
- The problem the bill is intended to address
An overlapping hybrid of federal and state laws govern California’s environmental and workplace safety protections. Due to this overlap, what happens to our natural splendor and our workforce is neither fully determined by, nor completely immune from, what takes place at the federal level. As a general rule, California is free to adopt its own standards in these areas, so long as they do not fall below the standards set by the federal government. In cases where the California standard is pegged to, or influenced by, the federal standard, however, when federal protections slip, so do those in California.
Since January 2017, the federal government under President Trump has dramatically rolled back numerous key aspects of national environmental and workplace safety protections.[1] California’s commitment to environmental stewardship and respect for the dignity of work has been undermined in the process.
Rather than attempting to track and respond legislatively to each federal action reducing environmental and worker protections, this bill would direct the relevant California state agencies to regularly monitor federal activity to assess whether each federal change could undermine standards in California and, if so, to adopt the corresponding federal standard that was in place on January 19, 2017, President Obama’s last day in office. In this way, the bill is intended to act as a form of “Trump Insurance” allowing Californians to rest assured that our state’s environmental and labor protections are inoculated against federal attacks.
2. Preemption analysis
Whenever federal and state laws conflict, the federal law governs. (U.S. Const., art. VI.) “Under the Supremacy Clause, from which our pre-emption doctrine is derived, any state law, however clearly within a State’s acknowledged power, which interferes with or is contrary to federal law, must yield.” (Gade v. National Solid Waste Management Association (1992) 505 U.S. 88, 108.)
This bill would create a mechanism through which California would monitor changes in federal standards and, based on its assessment of their effect, potentially respond by adopting higher standards. Nonetheless, the bill does not raise preemption concerns because each of the federal environmental and labor laws in question contain clauses expressly authorizing state governments to adopt their own standards, so long as those state standards do not fall below the federal standard.
For instance, the Endangered Species Act states that:
This Act shall not otherwise be construed to void any State law or regulation which is intended to conserve migratory, resident, or introduced fish or wildlife, or to permit or prohibit sale of such fish or wildlife. Any State law or regulation respecting the taking of species or threatened species may be more restrictive than the exemptions or permits provided for in this Act or in any regulation which implements this Act but not less restrictive than the prohibitions so defined. (16 U.S.C. § 1535(f).)
Similarly, the Safe Drinking Water Act provides that: “[n]othing in this title shall diminish any authority of a State or political subdivision to adopt or enforce any law or regulation respecting drinking water regulations or public water systems, but no such law or regulation shall relieve any person of any requirement otherwise applicable under this title.” (42 U.S.C. § 300g-3(e).)
The other federal statutes contain similar language. (See 33 U.S.C. § 1370, Clean Water Act; 29 U.S.C. 218(a), Fair Labor Standards Act; 30 U.S.C. § 955, Federal Coal Mine Health and Safety Act; 29 U.S.C. 653(b)(4), Occupational Health and Safety Act.)
Preemption issues under the Clean Air Act are more complex because the authority that the federal statute gives to states to adopt additional standards varies according to the source of the pollutant. As to fixed-point sources of air pollution, states retain the authority to set their own standards, so long as those standards are not less stringent than the federal law. (42 U.S.C. § 7416.) By contrast, states are generally preempted from setting their own standards as to moving sources of air pollution. (42 U.S.C. § 7543(a).) There is a key exception, however: the rule does not apply to states that already had road vehicle air pollution standards in place. (42 U.S.C. § 7543(b).) California, as such a state, is free to set its own standards as to moving sources of air pollution. However, there are no exceptions to federal preemption for certain other types of non-road vehicles (aircraft, for example). (42 U.S.C. §§ 7543(e)(1) and 7573.)
Given these provisions of federal law, it seems clear that SB 1’s core concept – that California’s environmental standards could never become less stringent than those in place at the end of the Obama Administration – would not be preempted. Only in the lone case of the Clean Air Act’s standards regarding non-road vehicles, the California Air Resources Board might not be able to adopt the Obama era standards, even if the federal standards became less stringent, because the federal statute appears to reserve exclusive authority over those standards for the federal government.
3. Administrative Procedures Act considerations
For each of the areas that SB 1 covers – public health, environmental, and labor standards – the bill empowers the relevant state agency to quickly adopt regulations through a modified version of the emergency rule-making process under the Administrative Procedures Act (APA). Under those rule-making procedures, a state agency would ordinarily have to provide five days’ notice to interested parties and then allow for a five-day public comment period. (Gov. Code § 11346.1(a).) In addition, proposed emergency regulations would ordinarily be subject to review by the Office of Administrative Law (OAL) and would only be valid for 180 days. In contrast, SB 1 provides that emergency regulations could be adopted as regulatory changes without effect, meaning, in practice, that such regulations could be adopted without further notice or hearing and would not have to undergo OAL review. SB 1 also provides that regulations adopted pursuant to its term would remain in force until January 20, 2025, President Trump’s last day in office if he is re-elected in 2020.
The opponents of the bill assert that this raises procedural due process concerns. Presumably the opponents mean that, because SB 1 bypasses the regular APA rule-making process, stakeholders and the public might not have much opportunity to review the proposed regulations and provide feedback on them.
It should be noted, however, that SB 1 provides for its own notice and comment process, independent of the APA. Specifically, SB 1 requires each relevant agency to publish its quarterly list of identified federal changes, its assessment of whether each change results in a less stringent standard than the standard in place at the end of the Obama Administration, and its determination of whether or not the agency should adopt the Obama era standard in place of the diminished federal standard. These things must be posted on the agency’s website for public comment 30 days before any vote on the matter. Since, under the Bagley-Keene Act, any such vote must happen publicly, at a noticed meeting with time on the agenda for public comment, this process offers ample opportunity for input and feedback. (Gov. Code § 11125.7(a).)
The purpose behind SB 1’s additional process is to allow public comment not only on regulatory changes that the agency proposes to adopt, but also on the agency’s listing and assessment of recent changes in the federal standards. If, for example, the agency did not include a federal change on its quarterly list, the public could comment on that fact and perhaps spur the agency to reconsider. Similarly, if the agency did include a federal change on its list, but in the agency’s assessment the change did not result in a less stringent standard, stakeholders and the public could submit comments questioning that assessment, too. The APA alone would not allow for such input, because federal changes that did not go on the agency list or that did not cause a reduction in the federal standards would not result in any regulatory action and, as a result, would not trigger the APA process.
In summary, while SB 1 bypasses some aspects of the standard APA process, it provides significant other opportunities for notice, public comment, and transparency that are, in some respects, broader than the APA and arguably better suited for carrying out the legislation’s intent.
4. The stringency standard
Opponents of SB 1 raise the point that changes in the federal standards are not always a bad thing. As the California Council of Environmental and Economic Balance (CCEEB) writes, “the federal government routinely reviews and revises federal standards to improve not only the protections they provide but the efficiency in which those standards deliver critical protections.” Similarly, the California Chamber of Commerce and its co-signatories raise the examples of shifts in how the federal government regulates E-coli and negotiations over accidental salmon intakes at Delta water pumps as examples of how they believe SB 1 would create rigidity. As CCEEB puts it, “the premise of SB 1 that any changes to federal standards are always less stringent” is concerning.
The rigidity presupposed by these opposition arguments does not appear to be supported by the text of the bill. SB 1 does not say that all federal legal or regulatory changes are less stringent. It simply directs the relevant state agencies to monitor each federal change to determine if the change results in a less stringent standard. Thus, in the examples raised by the Chamber, for instance, the relevant state agencies would not necessarily reject a change in how bacteria is regulated or a negotiated agreement about how many fish may be sucked into the Delta’s water intakes, but they would review such things and make a determination about whether or not they resulted in less stringent protections in California.
Moreover, SB 1 does not say that the relevant state agencies must always adopt the federal baseline standards upon a determination that a federal change has resulted in less stringent protections for California. Instead, SB 1 says that if the relevant state agency determines the federal change results in a less stringent standard, then the state agency shall consider whether it should adopt the federal standards. Thus, SB 1 may not be as rigid or reflexive as its opponents paint it to be. The CCEEB, for example, concludes its opposition by writing that:
[u]ltimately, California regulatory agencies should continue to have the power and discretion to determine which changes to federal standards to implement and which are inconsistent with that agency’s core mission and values. If a change to a federal standard is inconsistent with an agency’s core mission and values, that agency already has the ability to establish a more stringent standard, and should be trusted, based on its expertise, to make that decision.
This comes close to describing exactly what SB 1 does. SB 1 instructs the relevant state agencies to monitor federal activity. It trusts them to use their expertise to determine when federal changes undermine the health, safety, environmental, and labor standards that represent California’s values and priorities. And it directs them to use their regulatory authority to respond to any such change by ensuring that, at a minimum, California’s standards fall no lower than the federal standards in place at the end of the Obama Administration.
5. Delegation of powers issues
The proponents and opponents of this bill appear to agree that California state agencies already have the power and authority to set regulatory standards in the areas covered by SB 1. Indeed, one part of the opponents’ argument against the bill is that SB 1 is not needed precisely because the relevant agencies already have sufficient authority to respond to changes at the federal level. At the same time, the opponents describe SB 1 as “an unprecedented power transfer from the Legislature to the Executive Branch.”
Under California law, the Legislature may not confer upon an administrative agency unrestricted authority to make fundamental policy decisions. (People v. Wright (1982) 30 Cal.3d 705, 712.) However, “after declaring the legislative goals and establishing a yardstick guiding the administrator, it may authorize the administrator to adopt rules and regulations to promote the purposes of the legislation and to carry it into effect.” (Ibid.) SB 1 makes clear that the goal is to maintain environmental, public health, and labor standards in California, establishes the baseline federal standards as the yardstick, and authorizes the relevant state agencies to adopt standards accordingly.
Nonetheless, while what SB 1 requires of state agencies appears to fit well within traditional regulatory functions, the language used in the current version of SB 1 sometimes make it sound as if greater authority is being bestowed upon the agencies than intended. In particular, the version of SB 1 in print uses the word “measures” to describe the actions that an agency would take in response to its determination that a change at the federal level would render protections less stringent than those in place at the end of the Obama Administration. The term “measures” invokes law-making, as in the phrase “ballot measures.” Setting regulatory standards, by contrast, is a quintessential state agency function and one commonly delegated to those agencies by the Legislature. Replacing the word “measures” with “standards” throughout SB 1 would help to avoid any possible misunderstanding about the extent of what SB 1 is asking the agencies to do.
SB 1 raises two other potential delegation of powers issues. The first has to with the trigger of the state citizen suit provisions. That issue is discussed in the next Comment. The second has to do with the provisions of SB 1 regarding trade in certain animals. They are modeled off of similar provisions in federal law. (See 16 U.S.C. 3372.) As the bill is currently written, those provisions prohibit anyone from transporting, selling, receiving, acquiring, or purchasing any fish, wildlife, or plant taken, possessed, transported, or sold in violation of any law or regulation of any other state in effect on January 19, 2020, or in violation of any foreign law in effect on January 1, 2020. Incorporating laws from other jurisdictions into California law is not a problem so long as those laws are pinned to a particular date in the past. Because this provision of SB 1 would incorporate laws from other jurisdictions pinned to a future date however, it creates the possibility that other jurisdictions might enact new laws that would then become binding on California.
For instance, if the Governor signed SB 1 on October 1, 2019, and India passed a law on November 1, 2019, permanently banning the transport or sale of cows, SB 1’s current language would prohibit the transport or sale of cows in California as of January 1, 2020. This exact scenario is unlikely to occur, but it illustrates the point that, as written, SB 1 places California law-making authority in the hands of other jurisdictions. Although it would be for a short period of time and for a rather narrow category of law, this nonetheless appears to be the type of delegation of legislative authority that the Legislature may not engage in. Accordingly, going forward, the author may wish to amend the bill to ensure that whatever laws it will incorporate from other jurisdictions have already been determined. This can be achieved by pinning the incorporated laws to a date prior to legislative passage of the bill.
6. Citizen suits under SB 1
Each of the federal environmental laws addressed by SB 1 contains a citizen suit provision: Safe Drinking Act (42 U.S. Code § 300j–8); Clean Water Act (33 U.S.C. Sec 1365); Clean Air Act (42 U.S.C. § 7604); and Endangered Species Act (16 USC § 1540(g).) SB 1 contains language that creates the possibility of similar citizen suits under state law as well, as part of the bill’s overarching intent to preserve environmental and labor standards and remedies as they existed immediately prior to President Trump’s inauguration.
SB 1 is drafted so that the state law citizen suit provision springs to life in response to two types of federal actions. First, if the federal government changes a federal environmental or labor standard and the relevant California agency deems that change to result in a standard that is less stringent than the federal baseline standard, then the California agency may adopt the federal baseline standard into state law. If it does so, SB 1’s state citizen suit provision is triggered. Accordingly, from that point forward, a private citizen could bring a state lawsuit in the public interest to enforce that new California standard, assuming the other preconditions are met.
The other way that SB 1’s citizen suit provision could be triggered is a bit more complex and might not, as drafted, always result in preserving all of the Obama era remedies for labor and environmental law violations. SB 1 states that if the federal government repeals or restricts the option of bringing a federal citizen suit to enforce the relevant labor and environmental laws, then the California agencies should treat this as a change to the federal standards and respond accordingly.
There are two possible scenarios that could result. In one scenario, there is an existing federal standard, but no equivalent state standard (or the state standard simply incorporates the federal standard by reference). In such a case, the California agency reviewing the situation could conclude that the repeal or restriction of the federal citizen suit results in a less stringent state standard. Accordingly, the state agency could adopt the federal standard directly into California law. If it did so, SB 1’s citizen suit provision would be triggered, enabling private citizens to continue to enforce the same standard using the state citizen suit provision, just they could previously have done under the federal citizen suit provision.
In the other scenario, California law contains a standard that is at least as stringent as the federal baseline when the federal government repeals or restricts the federal citizen suit provision. In that scenario, the state agency would still respond under SB 1 by treating the repeal or restriction of the federal citizen suit provision as a change in the federal standard. Upon comparing the state standard against the federal baseline standard, however, the state agency would conclude that the state standard is at least as stringent as the federal baseline standard and, accordingly, take no further action. Because SB 1’s state citizen suit provision is only triggered by a state agency’s adoption of federal baseline standards, in this scenario, no state citizen suit remedy would spring to life, even though the federal citizen suit provision had been repealed or restricted. As a result, Obama era remedies would be lost, contrary to the intent behind the bill.
There are ongoing discussions about the ultimate content of this bill. Those talks may render moot the problem outlined above. In the event that the bill moves forward in its current form, however, it may be that a relatively simple fix is available. In its current form, SB 1 is cleverly drafted so that the state citizen suit provision is triggered by a change in regulatory standards. That neatly sidesteps the delegation of powers problem that might arise if SB 1 authorized a state agency to create a citizen suit remedy by itself. (See Dyna-Med, Inc. v. Fair Employment & Housing Com. (1987) 43 Cal. 3d 1379, 1389. “An administrative agency cannot by its own regulations create a remedy which the Legislature has withheld.”) However, it may not be necessary to have the regulatory process trigger the state citizen suit provision in the scenario in which the federal government repeals or restricts the federal citizen suit. Instead of treating federal repeal or restriction of the citizen suit as a change in federal standards, the bill could just make the state citizen suit provision spring to life directly upon federal restriction or repeal of the federal citizen suit provision. This could be accomplished through an amendment to each citizen suit trigger provision in the bill so that it read something like the following:
(x) In the event that the citizen suit provision set forth in [citation to federal citizen suit provision] is amended to restrict, condition, abridge, or repeal the citizen suit provision, an action may be brought pursuant to [the relevant state citizen suit provision in the bill] to enforce the federal baseline standard or the state standard pursuant to [citation to the relevant federal delegation provision], whichever is more stringent.
7. Availability of petition for writ to challenge agency determinations
In overall purpose and in many details, this bill is nearly identical to SB 49 (De León, 2017). Unlike this bill, however, early versions of SB 49 contained explicit provisions allowing people to challenge the relevant state agencies’ decisions through petition to the courts for a writ. Thus, if someone disagreed with an agency’s decision not to adopt the federal baseline standard in response to a federal change, that person could have sought review of the decision in court.
SB 1 contains no such explicit provision about challenging the agencies’ decisions in court. Moreover, because SB 1 is clear that the relevant agencies have discretion to decide whether or not to adopt the federal baseline standards in each instance, bringing a petition for writ in court would probably be more difficult. Courts will generally only issue a writ to an administrative agency when the agency has a “clear, present, and ministerial duty.” (Carrancho v. California Air Resources Board (2003) 111 Cal.App.4th 1255, 1265.) A duty is ministerial if “a public officer is required to perform in a prescribed manner in obedience to the mandate of legal authority and without regard to his own judgment or opinion concerning such act’s propriety or impropriety, when a given state of facts exists.” (Kavanaugh v. West Sonoma County Union High School District (2003) 29 Cal.4th 911, 916.) Accordingly, a writ of mandate is not applicable if the duty involves discretionary power or the exercise of judgment. (County of San Diego v. State of California (2008) 164 Cal.App.4th 580, 596.)
With this in mind, it appears that SB 1 is less likely to lead to frequent litigation against state agencies than SB 49 would have been.
8. Lessons to be drawn from SB 288 of 2003
While the principal opponents of SB 1 characterize it as an “unprecedented” transfer of power from the Legislature to the executive branch, it is in fact modeled off of an existing statute that was designed to do exactly what SB 1 proposes to do: prevent California environmental standards from decreasing as a result of actions taken at the federal level. Specifically, SB 288 (Sher, Ch. 476, Stats. 2003) was California’s response to federal action on December 31, 2002, to reduce standards associated with the federal Clean Air Act. SB 288 established the Protect California Air Act of 2003, prohibiting air quality management districts in California from amending or revising Clean Air Act-related rules or regulations to be less stringent than those federal rules or regulations that existed on December 30, 2002, except under certain circumstances.
SB 1 is modeled on SB 288. Through implementing regulations, SB 288 sets forth an administrative process through which either citizens or the Air Resources Board itself could challenge any proposed changes to local air quality standards on the grounds that the change would result in a less stringent standard. Information on that process can be found here: https://www.arb.ca.gov/nsr/sb288/sb288.htm.
9. Arguments in support of the bill
According to the author:
SB 1 ensures clean air, clean water, endangered species, and worker safety standards that have been in place for as long as 50 years are not rolled back as a result of the anti-environment actions of the President and Congress. In the past two years, the new Administration and Congress have adopted action after action to weaken, roll back, and outright repeal longstanding and well-accepted standards to protect workers, public health and the environment. SB 1 simply ensures those standards stay in place to protect everyday Californians, even if the federal government rolls them back.
In support, a coalition of 49 environmental and labor organizations writes:
While California has long been a leader in protecting our natural resources, many of our environmental protections are built on a foundation of federal standards. Similarly, when it comes to enforcement of worker safety, we rely on a patchwork of state and federal rules to protect workers from catastrophic injuries. […] SB 1 adopts common-sense measures to allow California to continue on a path to economic and environmental sustainability – and reject the false choice that economic progress must come at the expense of public health, the vitality of our natural surroundings, and a healthy environment for all.
10. Arguments in opposition to the bill
In opposition to the bill, the California Chamber of Commerce and 61 co-signatory business, industry, and trade associations write:
While we understand your goal is to protect the state’s environmental legal regime from any federal changes, SB 1 is an unprecedented power transfer from the Legislature to the Executive Branch. It is too broadly written, contains ambiguous and undefined standards that will create significant costs, uncertainty and unintended consequences for the regulated community, raises substantial constitutional concerns regarding a lack of due process and violations to the single-subject rule, circumvents the Administrative Procedures Act (APA) by improperly empowering state agencies with limited Legislative oversight, threatens to undermine wetland regulation efforts currently being pursued by the State Water Resources Control Board, as well as operation of the Central Valley Water Project, and will inevitably result in unnecessary litigation against state agencies and regulated entities.
If the intent of SB 1 is to preserve the status quo in California by preempting our state agencies from mirroring any changes to federal environmental or labor laws or regulations, the bill demands far more precise and targeted language that addresses only circumstances where these is a direct interrelationship between California and federal environmental law. California agencies already retain existing authority to promulgate laws and regulations that exceed federal standards – and with limited exceptions, the majority of California’s environmental and labor laws and regulations already go well beyond federal requirements and stand alone as some of the most protective laws in the nation. Changes at the federal level in these circumstances have no practical effect on California’s human health or the environment since state law is already more protective. (Emphasis in the original.)
SUPPORT
350 Bay Area Action
The 5 Gyres Institute
Audubon California
Azul
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Association of Professional Scientists
California Coastal Protection Network
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Environmental Justice Alliance
California Interfaith Power & Light
California Labor Federation
California League of Conservation Voters
California Product Stewardship Council
California Professional Firefighters
California ReLEAF
California State Parks Foundation
California Teamsters
Californians Against Waste
CALSTART
Central Valley Air Quality Coalition
Clean Water Action
Coachella Valley Waterkeeper
Coalition for Clean Air
Defenders of Wildlife
East Bay Municipal Utility District
Engineers and Scientists of California, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO
Environment California
Environmental Defense Center
Environmental Defense Fund
Environmental Water Caucus
Environmental Working Group
Fossil Free California
Friends Committee on Legislation in California
Heal the Bay
Humboldt Baykeeper
Inland Empire Waterkeeper
League of Women Voters of California
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Los Cerritos Wetlands Land Trust
Mono Lake Committee
Monterey Coastkeeper
Mountain Lion Foundation
National Stewardship Action Council
Natural Resources Defense Council
The Nature Conservancy
Nextgen California
Orange County Coastkeeper
The Otter Project
PawPAC
Pesticide Action Network
Planning and Conservation League
Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
Protect American River Canyons
Restore the Delta
Russian Riverkeeper
San Diego Coastkeeper
Santa Barbara Channelkeeper
Save Our Shores
Save the Bay
Seventh Generation Advisors
Sierra Club California
South Coast Air Quality Management District
Southern California Watershed Alliance
State Building & Construction Trades Council
Surfrider Foundation
The Trust for Public Land
Utility Workers of America
Voices for Progress
WILDCOAST
Yuba River Waterkeeper
Zero Waste USA
OPPOSITION
African American Farmers of California
Agricultural Council of California
Agricultural Energy Consumers Association
Almond Alliance
American Coatings Association
American Pistachio Growers
Association of California Water Agencies
Auto Care Association
Brea Chamber of Commerce
Building Owners and Managers Association
Byron Bethany Irrigation District
California Agricultural Aircraft Association
California Association of Realtors
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Automotive Wholesalers’ Association
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Council for Environmental and Economic Balance
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Forestry Association
California Fresh Fruit Association
California Grain and Feed Association
California Independent Petroleum Association
California League of Food Producers
California Licensed Foresters Association
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Metals Coalition
California Paint Council
California Restaurant Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
Chemical Industry Council of California
Construction Employers’ Association
Family Business Association of California
Far West Equipment Dealers Association
Forest Landowners of California
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber
Household & Commercial Products Association
International Council of Shopping Centers
Kern County Hispanic Chamber of Commerce
Murrieta/Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
NAIOP Commercial Real Estate Development Association
National Federation of Independent Business
Nisei Farmers League
Orange County Business Council
Oxnard Chamber of Commerce
The San Luis & Delta-Mendota Water Authority
Santa Maria Chamber of Commerce
Southern California Water Coalition
Southwest California Legislative Council
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
United Chamber Advocacy Network
United Water Conservation District
West Coast Lumber & Building Material Association
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Western Independent Refiners Association
Western Plant Health Association
Western States Petroleum Association
Western Wood Preservers Institute
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known
Prior Legislation:
SB 49 (De León, 2017) was substantially similar to this bill. Unlike this bill, however, SB 49 required state agencies to adopt the federal baseline standard when a change in federal standards resulted in a less stringent standard and SB 49 allowed for enforcement actions against state agencies through petition for writ in the superior court of jurisdiction. This bill died in the Assembly Rules Committee.
SB 288 (Sher, Chapter 476, Statutes of 2003) enacted the Protect California Air Act in response to federal action on December 31, 2002, to reduce standards associated with the federal Clean Air Act. The bill prohibited air quality management districts in California from amending or revising Clean Air Act-related rules or regulations to be less stringent than those federal rules or regulations that existed on December 30, 2002, except under specified circumstances.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Environmental Quality Committee (Ayes 5, Noes 2)
Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 2)
**************
See, Sen. Environmental Quality Com., Analysis of SB 1 (2019-2020 Reg. Sess.) as introduced, at p. 5, for a “brief and incomplete summary of President Trump’s environmental record”. See also, Greshko et al, A Running List of How President Trump is Changing Environmental Policy (Mar. 15, 2019) National Geographic https://news.nationalgeographic.com/2017/03/how-trump-is-changing-science-environment/ (as of Mar. 31, 2019); Lipton, Eder, and Branch, This is Our Reality Now (Dec. 27, 2018) New York Times https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2018/12/26/us/politics/donald-trump-environmental-regulation.html (as of Mar. 31, 2019). ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES AND WATER
Senator Henry Stern, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 1 Hearing Date: April 9, 2019
Author: | Atkins | ||
Version: | December 3, 2018 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | William Craven | ||
Subject: California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019
BACKGROUND AND EXISTING LAW
Among the most important federal environmental laws are the Clean Air Act, the Clean Water Act, the Safe Drinking Water Act, and the Endangered Species Act. While there are other federal environmental laws, including the National Environmental Policy Act, these four statutes are considered primary and bedrock environmental statutes.
California has similar statutes that, in some cases, preceded these federal laws. In other situations, California has regulations that apply to provisions covered by federal laws. One important example is the underground injection well regulations that implement provisions of the Safe Drinking Water Act. California has been delegated authority for this program and is the primary regulator. This has been a topic of significant interest in the Legislature as part of the oversight functions of the Division of Oil, Gas, and Geothermal Resources within the Department of Conservation.
Note: This bill has been referred to this committee, the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, and the Senate Judiciary Committee. This committee’s jurisdiction extends only to the endangered species and underground injection well aspects of the bill.
Existing law includes the California Endangered Species Act (CESA) which is an analog to the federal endangered species act. CESA provides a mechanism for the Department of Fish and Wildlife (CDFW) to issue “incidental take permits” under state law, or to concur in a federal incidental take permit through what is termed a “consistency determination” that avoids the need of a project applicant to apply twice for the same take authority under both acts.
The Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA) was originally passed by the US Congress in 1974 in order to protect public health by regulating the public drinking water supply nationwide. One of the motivations underlying the passage of the SDWA was to set national standards for wells that have the potential to impact underground aquifers suitable to provide drinking water. The Underground Injection Control (UIC) Program was subsequently promulgated (see Title 40, Code of Federal Regulations, parts 144 – 148) by the US Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA). Of particular note to this Committee are the Class II UIC wells which are oil and gas injection and disposal wells.
Class II UIC wells are an integral part of oil and gas development here in California. According to the Division of Oil, Gas and Geothermal Resources (DOGGR), approximately 60% of all oil produced in California is due to the use of enhanced oil recovery processes facilitated by UIC wells. A substantial portion of oil and gas field-produced waste water is also disposed of in Class II wells. There are on the order of 55,000 new, active or idle Class II UIC wells in California.
In 1981, the then-Division of Oil and Gas sought primacy to implement the UIC Class II well program in the state from the US EPA under section 1425 of the SDWA which allowed states with oil and gas regulatory programs that “effectively protect” drinking water sources to continue using their existing programs. Approval was granted in 1982. DOGGR and the State Water Resources Control Board have a Memorandum of Understanding signed in 1988 delineating their respective responsibilities and coordination related to oil and gas production and water.
In the last three years, DOGGR, the Water Boards and the US EPA have been working closely together to address the thousands of improperly permitted Class II UIC wells identified in the state. These improperly permitted wells inject into aquifers that were not properly exempted from the SDWA through the appropriate state and federal process. It is important to note that the state’s standards for water quality for these aquifers also depend upon federal regulatory language underpinned by the SDWA (see State Water Resources Control Board Resolution 88-63 and 40 CFR 146.4). The SDWA and its accompanying regulations are therefore fundamental to and constitute minimum standards for the state’s oil and gas program.
As described by the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, other provisions of existing law (many of which are not within this Committee’s jurisdiction but included for completeness) include:
Existing federal law:
- Authorizes states, for each of the following statutes, to act as delegates for implementing and enforcing the federal acts, as long as the state’s laws are at least as stringent as or more stringent than the federal act or to enact their own similar state statute (California’s laws often preceded the federal acts and provided a model for the federal government to follow):
- Regulates, under the federal Clean Air Act (FCAA), air emissions from stationary and mobile sources. Among other things, this law authorizes the US EPA to establish National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) to protect public health and public welfare and to regulate emissions of hazardous air pollutants.
- Regulates, under the Clean Water Act (CWA), discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States and regulates quality standards for surface waters. CWA makes it unlawful to discharge any pollutant from a point source into navigable waters, unless a permit was obtained, and specifies that the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit program controls such discharges.
- Regulates, under the SDWA, the nation’s public drinking water supply, and requires the US EPA to establish mandatory nationwide drinking water standards. SDWA additionally requires water systems to monitor public water supplies to ensure drinking water standards are met and report to consumers if the standards are not met.
- Provides, under the Endangered Species Act (ESA), for the conservation of species that are endangered or threatened throughout all or a significant portion of their range, and the conservation of the ecosystems on which they depend.
- Regulates, under the federal Clean Air Act (FCAA), air emissions from stationary and mobile sources. Among other things, this law authorizes the US EPA to establish National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) to protect public health and public welfare and to regulate emissions of hazardous air pollutants.
Existing state law:
- Prohibits, under the Protect California Air Act of 2003, air quality management districts and air pollution control districts from amending or revising their new source review rules or regulations to be less stringent than those rules or regulations that existed on December 30, 2002, except under certain circumstances.
- Establishes, under the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (AB 32), a comprehensive program to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from all sources throughout the state to combat climate change.
- Regulates, under the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, the discharge of pollutants into the waters of the state.
- Establishes, under the California Safe Drinking Water Act, standards for drinking water and regulates drinking water systems.
- Requires, under the California Endangered Species Act, the Fish and Game Commission to establish a list of endangered species and a list of threatened species and generally prohibits the taking of those species.
PROPOSED LAW
This bill establishes specified minimum federal environmental, public health, and labor standards as state baselines in the event the Congress or President repeals or weakens corresponding federal standards, and prohibits the corresponding California standards from falling below those baselines. In the event that new federal standards fall below the baseline, this bill allows private citizens to enforce state standards under specific circumstances. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires listed agencies to regularly assess proposed and final changes to federal standards for the above statutes and, when changes are determined to be less stringent than the baseline federal standards of January 19, 2017, directs those agencies to consider adopting the baseline federal standards in order to ensure the state’s protections are at least as stringent as the baseline federal standards.
- Requires listed agencies to take specified actions to maintain and enforce certain requirements and standards pertaining to air, water, protected species, and occupational safety.
- Authorizes a person acting in the public interest to bring an action to enforce certain standards and requirements implementing some, but not all, of the above-mentioned state laws if certain conditions are satisfied, as specified. This provision excludes Article 3 dealing with endangered and threatened species.
- Prohibits specified state agencies that implement the laws above from amending or revising its rules and regulations in a manner that is less stringent in its protection of workers’ rights or worker safety than standards established by federal law in existence as of January 1, 2016.
- Requires state agencies to report to the Legislature on compliance with the above requirements, as specified.
- Makes its provisions inoperative as of January 20, 2025, and would repeal them as of January 1, 2026.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT
According to the author, “SB 1 ensures clean air, clean water, endangered species, and worker safety standards that have been in place for as long as 50 years are not rolled back as a result of the anti-environment actions of the President and Congress. In the past two years, the new administration and congress have adopted action after action to weaken, roll back, and outright repeal longstanding and well-accepted standards to protect workers, public health and the environment. SB 1 simply ensures those standards stay in place to protect everyday Californians, even if the federal government rolls them back.”
Other supporters of the bill, including a large environmental coalition, point to the threat to California’s environmental leadership from the current federal administration and the need to ensure that there are no rollbacks of the laws that protect air and water quality or other conservation standards in the state. Additionally, supporters point to the fact that the environmental laws in California must be adequate to deal with climate change and wildfires.
According to this coalition, the federal administration plans to scale back protections for animals and plants most at risk of extinction; dismantle protections for local drinking water supplies, salmon, delta smelt, rivers and estuaries; allow pollution from other states to cross state lines at higher levels without considering potential health impacts like asthma and increased heart attacks; and loosen critical requirements to find and fix leaks of methane, a potent greenhouse gas.
A longer list of federal rollbacks is contained in the Senate Environmental Quality Committee analysis.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION
Opposition groups, including a large business coalition, consider the bill broad, vague, and written with ambiguous and undefined standards. It considers the bill unnecessary, a violation of the state Administrative Procedures Act, and, in fact, as one reads their letter, there is nothing in the bill that these groups appreciate about the bill except for acknowledging the author’s intent to protect the state’s environmental legal regime. The opposition believes that state agencies can already adopt regulations that are more restrictive than federal law (when allowed by federal law). The opposition also argues that the bill allows state agencies to completely bypass the notice and comment procedures of state law in adopting regulations, and it is concerned about the private right of action.
COMMENTS
In discussions with the author, staff recommends two amendments.
The federal endangered species act currently defines "species" to include any subspecies of fish or wildlife or plants, and any distinct population segment of any species. 16 U.S.C. § 1532(16). The amendment to add "subspecies, and distinct population segments" to what can be listed under the California Endangered Species Act in response to any federal backsliding clarifies that this directive covers all taxa and is consistent with the definition of what can be listed under the federal ESA. Given the intent of this provision is to protect biological diversity, the inclusion of "subspecies and distinct population segments" is based on sound legal and scientific bases. (Amendment 1).
The second amendment establishes a baseline and thereby strengthens state-law protections for wildlife that are necessary because of potential rollbacks by the Trump administration. The Trump administration has formalized several rollbacks on protections of trophy hunted endangered species and even formed a new “International Wildlife Conservation Commission” to advise the US Fish and Wildlife Service director that is composed primarily of trophy hunters.
Additionally, the Trump administration lifted a ban on importing sport-hunted trophies of elephants from certain African countries, just over three months after President Trump appeared poised not to do so following a first attempt that resulted in considerable public uproar. In a memo dated March 1, the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service said that in place of the Obama-era ban, the agency will consider importation permits "on a case-by-case basis."
The U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service has also issued an unknown number of permits for lion trophies since authorizing imports from Zimbabwe and Zambia were first allowed in November 2017. At least three dozen were confirmed as of July 2018. A lawsuit is pending against the federal government seeking more specificity about the number of permits issued and the circumstances under which those animals were killed.
While California’s Penal Code 653o – which was strengthened with regard to rhino and elephant parts via AB 96 in 2015 (Atkins) – prohibits trade in lion and elephant parts in California, there is sufficient reason for concern that new federal law will preempt state protections and that additional species in peril around the world that are deemed desirable by American trophy hunters with significant influence over the Trump administration will become jeopardized. (Amendment 2).
Comments as the bill moves forward:
Several of the opposition made the following points in a recent discussion. While the opposition has other arguments, those within this committee’s jurisdiction are:
- The terms “backsliding” and “more stringent than” may need definition.
- Some of the opposition believe that the provision on page 11, line 27 relating to the interplay of the state endangered species act and various federal water projects is pre-empted by federal law. However, it is worth noting that a variation of this language was also in SB 49 (Stern, 2017).
- They would like consideration for the possibility that federally listed species that are de-listed because they have sufficiently recovered in the wild should not automatically be listed under state law by operation of SB 1.
SUGGESTED AMENDMENTS
AMENDMENT 1
Add new Government Code Section 120061 as follows:
To ensure no backsliding as a result of any change to the federal Endangered Species Act, all native species, subspecies, and distinct population segments not already listed pursuant to Article 2 (commencing with Section 2070) of Chapter 1.5 of Division 3 of the Fish and Game Code that are listed as endangered or threatened pursuant to the federal Endangered Species Act as of January 1, 2017, are deemed to be an endangered or threatened species, as appropriate, for purposes of Article 2 (commencing with Section 2070) of Chapter 1.5 of Division 3 of the Fish and Game Code. The Fish and Game Commission may review and modify the listing of species pursuant to this section.
AMENDMENT 2
Section 2351 is added to the Fish and Game Code to read:
2351. It is unlawful for any person to do either of the following:
(a) To transport, sell, receive, acquire, or purchase any fish or wildlife or plant taken, possessed, transported, or sold in violation of any law, treaty, or regulation of the United States in effect on January 19, 2017; or
(b) To transport, sell, receive, acquire, or purchase any fish or wildlife taken, possessed, transported, or sold in violation of any law or regulation of any other State or in violation of any foreign law.
SUPPORT
350 Bay Area
Audubon California
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Association of Local Conservation Corps
California Coastal Protection Network
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Interfaith Power & Light
California Labor Federation
California League of Conservation Voters
California Product Stewardship Council
California ReLEAF
California State Parks Foundation
Californians Against Waste
CALSTART
Central Valley Air Quality Coalition
Clean Water Action
Coachella Valley Waterkeeper
Coalition for Clean Air
Defenders of Wildlife
Environment California
Environmental Defense Center
Environmental Defense Fund
Environmental Water Caucus
Environmental Working Group
Fossil Free California
Friends Committee on Legislation in California
Golden Gate Salmon Association
Heal the Bay
Humboldt Baykeeper
Independent California
Inland Empire Waterkeeper
Institute for Fisheries Resources
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Los Cerritos Wetlands Land Trust
Mono Lake Committee
Monterey Coastkeeper
Mountain Lion Foundation
National Stewardship Action Council
Natural Resources Defense Council
Nextgen California
Orange County Coastkeeper
Pacific Coast Federation of Fishermen’s Associations
Pesticide Action Network
Planning and Conservation League
Protect American River Canyons
Restore the Delta
Russian Riverkeeper
San Diego Coastkeeper
Santa Barbara Channelkeeper
Save Our Shores
Save The Bay
Seventh Generation Advisors
Sierra Club California
Southern California Watershed Alliance
State Building & Construction Trades Council
Surfrider Foundation
The 5 Gyres Institute
The Nature Conservancy\
The Otter Project
The Trust for Public Land
Voices for Progress
WILDCOAST
Yuba River Waterkeeper
Zero Waste USA
OPPOSITION
African American Farmers of California
Agricultural Council of California
Agricultural Energy Consumers Association
Almond Alliance
American Coatings Association
American Pistachio Growers
Auto Care Association
Brea Chamber of Commerce
Building Owners and Managers Association
California Agricultural Aircraft Association
California Association of Realtors
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Forestry Association
California Fresh Fruit Association
California Grain and Feed Association
California Independent Petroleum Association
California League of Food Producers
California Licensed Foresters Association
California Manufacturers & Technology Association
California Metals Coalition
California Paint Council
California Restaurant Association
Camarillo Chamber of Commerce
CAWA – Representing the Automotive Parts Industry
Chemical Industry Council of California
Construction Employers’ Association
Family Business Association of California
Far West Equipment Dealers Association
Forest Landowners of California
Greater Coachella Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater Conejo Valley Chamber of Commerce
Greater San Fernando Valley Chamber
Household & Commercial Products Association
International Council of Shopping Centers
Murrieta/Wildomar Chamber of Commerce
NAIOP
National Federation of Independent Business
Nisei Farmers League
Orange County Business Council
Santa Maria Chamber of Commerce
Southern California Water Coalition
Southwest California Legislative Council
Torrance Area Chamber of Commerce
Tulare Chamber of Commerce
West Coast Lumber & Building Material Association
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Western Independent Refiners Association
Western Plant Health Association
Western States Petroleum Association
Western Wood Preservers Institute
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 1
Author: | Atkins, et al. | ||
Version: | 12/3/2018 | Hearing Date: | 3/20/2019 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | David Ernest García | ||
SUBJECT: California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019
DIGEST: This bill establishes specified minimum federal environmental, public health, and labor standards as state baselines in the event the Congress or President repeals or weakens corresponding federal standards, and prohibits the corresponding California standards from falling below those baselines. In the event that new federal standards fall below the baseline, this bill allows private citizens to enforce state standards, as specified.
ANALYSIS:
Existing federal law:
- Authorizes states, for each of the following statutes, to act as delegates for implementing and enforcing the federal acts, as long as the state’s laws are at least as stringent as or more stringent than the federal act or to enact their own similar state statute (California’s laws often preceded the federal acts and provided a model for the federal government to follow):
- Regulates, under the Federal Clean Air Act (FCAA), air emissions from stationary and mobile sources. Among other things, this law authorizes the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) to establish National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) to protect public health and public welfare and to regulate emissions of hazardous air pollutants.
- Regulates, under the Clean Water Act (CWA), discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States and regulates quality standards for surface waters. CWA makes it unlawful to discharge any pollutant from a point source into navigable waters, unless a permit was obtained, and specifies that the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit program controls such discharges.
- Regulates, under the Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA), the nation’s public drinking water supply, and requires the US EPA to establish mandatory nationwide drinking water standards. SDWA additionally requires water systems to monitor public water supplies to ensure drinking water standards are met and report to consumers if the standards are not met.
- Provides, under the Endangered Species Act (ESA), for the conservation of species that are endangered or threatened throughout all or a significant portion of their range, and the conservation of the ecosystems on which they depend.
- Regulates, under the Federal Clean Air Act (FCAA), air emissions from stationary and mobile sources. Among other things, this law authorizes the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) to establish National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) to protect public health and public welfare and to regulate emissions of hazardous air pollutants.
Existing state law:
- Prohibits, under the Protect California Air Act of 2003, air quality management districts and air pollution control districts from amending or revising their new source review rules or regulations to be less stringent than those rules or regulations that existed on December 30, 2002, except under certain circumstances.
- Establishes, under the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (AB 32), a comprehensive program to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from all sources throughout the state to combat climate change.
- Regulates, under the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, the discharge of pollutants into the waters of the state.
- Establishes, under the California Safe Drinking Water Act, standards for drinking water and regulates drinking water systems.
- Requires, under the California Endangered Species Act, the Fish and Game Commission to establish a list of endangered species and a list of threatened species and generally prohibits the taking of those species.
This bill:
- Requires specified agencies to regularly assess proposed and final changes to federal standards for the above statutes and, when changes are determined to be less stringent than the baseline federal standards of January 19, 2017, directs those agencies to consider adopting the baseline federal standards in order to ensure the state’s protections are at least as stringent as the baseline federal standards.
- Requires specified agencies to take specified actions to maintain and enforce certain requirements and standards pertaining to air, water, protected species, and occupational safety.
- Authorizes a person acting in the public interest to bring an action to enforce certain standards and requirements implementing the above-mentioned state laws if specified conditions are satisfied, as specified.
- Prohibits specified state agencies that implement the laws above from amending or revising its rules and regulations in a manner that is less stringent in its protection of workers’ rights or worker safety than standards established by federal law in existence as of January 1, 2016.
- Requires state agencies to report to the Legislature on compliance with the above requirements, as specified.
- Makes its provisions inoperative as of January 20, 2025, and would repeal them as of January 1, 2026.
Background
- California is an environmental leader. California is the most populous state in the union with a population of nearly 40 million people. It is the third largest state by area at 163,696 square miles and is the fifth largest economy on the planet. California’s geographic, population, and economic size make California’s impact global in nature.
The state’s vast size has also brought an enormous impact on the environment. California has long struggled with some of the most polluted air in the country, and the discharge of pollution into the state’s water and soil has led to contamination that has degraded the environment and public health.
The responsibility to correct damage, and preserve and protect the environment, is a key tenant of California policy. Degradation of the state’s environment would make it impossible for California to continue to thrive.
In many cases, California began to clean the air, water, and soil before the federal government, recognizing the importance of these types of controls for both public health and economic strength. California’s laws and policy have served as a national model for other states, as well as the federal government. For instance, California had developed clean air standards prior to the FCAA, which is why California has its waiver provisions within the act.
California’s environmental leadership drives technology and scientific innovation as a key part of the state’s economy. For example, solar and other clean energy technologies have developed because of California’s strong policies on renewable energy and environmental sustainability. Consistency in the state’s ability to enforce strict environmental protections is paramount for these, and other, industries to continue to innovate and prosper. - Previous actions to preserve state rights for environmental protection. SB 288 (Sher, Chapter 476, Statutes of 2003) was enacted to preserve the state’s ability to protect state air quality standards from a US EPA that was weakening, or proposing to weaken, federal air quality standards.
The FCAA requires each major new and modified source of air pollution to undergo “new source review” to ensure that facilities install the best available control equipment, obtain offsets for any new emissions, and comply with any other requirement to ensure that the new and modified sources do not adversely affect air quality. On December 31, 2002, the Administrator of US EPA promulgated regulations implementing the new source review program that changed that program.
SB 288 established the Protect California Air Act of 2003, which prohibits air quality management districts from amending or revising their new source review rules or regulations to be less stringent than those rules or regulations that existed on December 30, 2002, except under certain circumstances.
Much like SB 1, the purpose of SB 288 was to maintain the requirement to attain and maintain ambient air quality standards by the earliest practicable date, to protect public health and welfare from the adverse effects of air pollution, and to ensure that economic growth will occur in a manner consistent with the preservation of existing clean air resources.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “SB 1 ensures clean air, clean water, endangered species, and worker safety standards that have been in place for as long as 50 years are not rolled back as a result of the anti-environment actions of the President and Congress. In the past two years, the new administration and congress have adopted action after action to weaken, roll back, and outright repeal longstanding and well-accepted standards to protect workers, public health and the environment. SB 1 simply ensures those standards stay in place to protect everyday Californians, even if the federal government rolls them back.”
- A brief and incomplete summary of President Trump’s environmental record. President Trump has clearly stated his view that environmental laws and regulations jeopardize economic growth in the United States. President Trump has taken numerous actions to, and has committed to many other actions that would, rollback environmental protections in the United States. Although far from being an exhaustive list, President Trump has:
- Called the concept of man-made climate change a “hoax created by and for the Chinese to make American manufacturing non-competitive.”
- Purged, a week after taking office, the US EPA of any mention of climate change.
- Withdrew the final determination on strict vehicle fuel-efficiency standards, and eventually his administration decided to end negotiations with California over plans to roll back fuel economy rules designed to reduce GHG emissions.
- Proposed to eliminate 31% of the budget for US EPA.
- Signed an executive order to undo the Waters of the United States Rule that extended federal protections to smaller rivers and streams.
- Signed an executive order to set an annual cap on the cost impact of new regulations, beginning in the current fiscal year 2017 with a cap of $0, meaning that agencies should repeal existing rules to offset the cost of adding any new ones. Further, it directs agencies to suggest repealing at least two existing rules for every new one proposed.
- Signed H.J. Res. 38 (Johnson, R–OH), nullifying the Department of Interior’s Stream Protection Rule. The Stream Protection Rule targets coal-mining industry practices to protect waterways by requiring companies to avoid mining practices that permanently pollute streams, destroy drinking water sources, increase flood risk, and threaten forests by requiring companies to restore streams and return mined areas to the uses they were capable of supporting prior to mining activities, and to replant the areas with native trees and vegetation, unless that would conflict with the implemented land use.
- Ordered a federal hiring freeze, affecting all state agencies, including the hiring of new doctors by the Department of Veterans Affairs.
- Sought the names of civil servants who worked on issues related to climate change, women’s rights, and reproductive health.
- Announced his intention to abandon the Paris climate accords, making the USA the only country in the world not to support the framework deal to combat GHG emissions.
- Opened oil drilling in the Artic when the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management issued a conditional permit to Houston-based Hilcorp to begin drilling from an artificial island in the Beaufort Sea.
- Disbanded a scientific review panel that advises the US EPA about safe levels of pollution in the air.
- Rolled back Obama-era climate change policy, reducing requirements on oil and gas companies to monitor and mitigate releases of methane from wells and other operations.
- Initiated a plan to reverse Obama-Administration rules designed to curtail coal power plant emissions of carbon dioxide and methane that contribute to climate change.
- Ended NASA’s Carbon Monitoring System, a $10-million-per-year effort to fund pilot programs intended to improve the monitoring of global carbon emissions.
- Eliminated a Clinton-era rule that forced large sources of air pollution to remain subject to stricter regulations if they ever exceeded specified levels.
- Signed an executive order revoking federal flood-risk standards that incorporated rising sea levels predicted by climate science.
- Called the concept of man-made climate change a “hoax created by and for the Chinese to make American manufacturing non-competitive.”
Given these, and other, threats to environmental quality from the current federal government, the Committee may wish to consider supporting this measure.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 49 (De León, 2017) contained nearly identical provisions to SB 1. SB 49 died in the Assembly Rules Committee.
TRIPLE REFERRAL:
If this measure is approved by the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, the do pass motion must include the action to re-refer the bill to the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee. If this measure is approved by the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee, the do pass motion must include the action to re-refer the bill to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
350 Bay Area
Audubon California
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Association of Professional Scientists (CAPS)
California Coastal Protection Network
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Interfaith Power & Light
California Labor Federation
California League of Conservation Voters
California Product Stewardship Council
California ReLEAF
California State Parks Foundation
California Teamsters
Californians Against Waste
CALSTART
Central Valley Air Quality Coalition
Clean Water Action
Coachella Valley Waterkeeper
Coalition for Clean Air
Defenders of Wildlife
Engineers and Scientists of CA, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO
Environment California
Environmental Defense Center
Environmental Defense Fund
Environmental Water Caucus
Environmental Working Group
Fossil Free California
Friends Committee on Legislation in California
Heal the Bay
Humboldt Baykeeper
Inland Empire Waterkeeper
League of Women Voters of California
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Los Cerritos Wetlands Land Trust
Mono Lake Committee
Monterey Coastkeeper
Mountain Lion Foundation
National Stewardship Action Council
Natural Resources Defense Council
Nextgen California
Orange County Coastkeeper
PawPAC
Pesticide Action Network
Planning and Conservation League
Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
Protect American River Canyons
Restore the Delta
Russian Riverkeeper
San Diego Coastkeeper
Santa Barbara Channelkeeper
Save Our Shores
Save The Bay
Seventh Generation Advisors
Sierra Club California
South Coast Air Quality Management District
Southern California Watershed Alliance
State Building & Construction Trades Council
Surfrider Foundation
The 5 Gyres Institute
The Nature Conservancy
The Otter Project
The Trust for Public Land
Utility Workers of America
Voices for Progress
WILDCOAST
Yuba River Waterkeeper
Zero Waste USA
OPPOSITION:
California Agricultural Aircraft Association
California Association of Realtors
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Chamber of Commerce
California Citrus Mutual
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association, Inc.
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Forestry Association
California Independent Petroleum Association
California League of Food Producers
California Metals Coalition
CAWA- Representing the Automotive Parts Industry
Household & Commercial Products Association
NAIOP
National Federation of Independent Business
Nisei Farmers League
West Coast Lumber & Building Material Association
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Western Independent Refiners Association
Western Plant Health Association
Western Wood Preservers’ Institute
Western States Petroleum Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to a coalition of supporters:
“California has long been a leader in ensuring a healthy environment and workplace for its citizens. For many years, the state has enforced its laws protecting the air that Californians breathe, the water that Californians drink, and the wildlife and natural resources that our citizens prize, in tandem with federal agency partners. But the Trump administration now threatens that long-standing partnership with ongoing and persistent efforts to weaken or eliminate critical public health and environmental protections. SB 1 protects our citizens and our environment by ensuring that protections in existence prior to January 19, 2017 under the federal Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, Safe Drinking Water Act, Endangered Species Act, and workplace safety laws are not weakened, and gives California state agencies streamlined authority to enforce these protections under state law.
“Californians are already suffering from the devastating impacts of climate change and continue to struggle with poor air and water quality. Recent wildfires have broken records and claimed dozens of lives, destroyed tens of thousands of structures, harmed wildlife, scorched large swathes of the state, and spewed millions of metric tons of greenhouse gases and toxic pollutants into the air. Despite these unprecedented disasters, the Trump administration continues to push an anti-environment agenda that benefits polluters at the expense of our nation’s most important assets – our people and natural resources.
“Among other rollbacks, the federal administration plans to scale back protections for animals and plants most at risk of extinction; dismantle protections for local drinking water supplies, salmon, delta smelt, rivers and estuaries; allow pollution from other states to cross state lines at higher levels without considering potential health impacts like asthma and increased heart attacks; and loosen critical requirements to find and fix leaks of methane, a potent greenhouse gas. We are alarmed by these attacks on the country’s most fundamental and necessary environmental protections.
“While California has long been a leader in protecting our natural resources, many of our environmental protections are built on a foundation of federal standards. Similarly, when it comes to enforcement of worker safety, we rely on a patchwork of state and federal rules to protect workers from catastrophic injuries. SB 1 is designed to strengthen that foundation by incorporating into state law existing federal protections for clean air, clean water, endangered species, worker safety, and safe drinking water when federal standards dip below certain baseline protections.
“SB 1 adopts common-sense measures to allow California to continue on a path to economic and environmental sustainability – and reject the false choice that economic progress must come at the expense of public health, the vitality of our natural surroundings, and a healthy environment for all. For these reasons, we strongly support SB 1.”
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2019 - 2020 Regular
Bill No: SB 1
Author: | Atkins, et al. | ||
Version: | 12/3/2018 | Hearing Date: | 3/20/2019 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | David Ernest García | ||
SUBJECT: California Environmental, Public Health, and Workers Defense Act of 2019
DIGEST: This bill establishes specified minimum federal environmental, public health, and labor standards as state baselines in the event the Congress or President repeals or weakens corresponding federal standards, and prohibits the corresponding California standards from falling below those baselines. In the event that new federal standards fall below the baseline, this bill allows private citizens to enforce state standards, as specified.
ANALYSIS:
Existing federal law:
- Authorizes states, for each of the following statutes, to act as delegates for implementing and enforcing the federal acts, as long as the state’s laws are at least as stringent as or more stringent than the federal act or to enact their own similar state statute (California’s laws often preceded the federal acts and provided a model for the federal government to follow):
- Regulates, under the Federal Clean Air Act (FCAA), air emissions from stationary and mobile sources. Among other things, this law authorizes the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) to establish National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) to protect public health and public welfare and to regulate emissions of hazardous air pollutants.
- Regulates, under the Clean Water Act (CWA), discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States and regulates quality standards for surface waters. CWA makes it unlawful to discharge any pollutant from a point source into navigable waters, unless a permit was obtained, and specifies that the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit program controls such discharges.
- Regulates, under the Safe Drinking Water Act (SDWA), the nation’s public drinking water supply, and requires the US EPA to establish mandatory nationwide drinking water standards. SDWA additionally requires water systems to monitor public water supplies to ensure drinking water standards are met and report to consumers if the standards are not met.
- Provides, under the Endangered Species Act (ESA), for the conservation of species that are endangered or threatened throughout all or a significant portion of their range, and the conservation of the ecosystems on which they depend.
- Regulates, under the Federal Clean Air Act (FCAA), air emissions from stationary and mobile sources. Among other things, this law authorizes the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) to establish National Ambient Air Quality Standards (NAAQS) to protect public health and public welfare and to regulate emissions of hazardous air pollutants.
Existing state law:
- Prohibits, under the Protect California Air Act of 2003, air quality management districts and air pollution control districts from amending or revising their new source review rules or regulations to be less stringent than those rules or regulations that existed on December 30, 2002, except under certain circumstances.
- Establishes, under the California Global Warming Solutions Act of 2006 (AB 32), a comprehensive program to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from all sources throughout the state to combat climate change.
- Regulates, under the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, the discharge of pollutants into the waters of the state.
- Establishes, under the California Safe Drinking Water Act, standards for drinking water and regulates drinking water systems.
- Requires, under the California Endangered Species Act, the Fish and Game Commission to establish a list of endangered species and a list of threatened species and generally prohibits the taking of those species.
This bill:
- Requires specified agencies to regularly assess proposed and final changes to federal standards for the above statutes and, when changes are determined to be less stringent than the baseline federal standards of January 19, 2017, directs those agencies to consider adopting the baseline federal standards in order to ensure the state’s protections are at least as stringent as the baseline federal standards.
- Requires specified agencies to take specified actions to maintain and enforce certain requirements and standards pertaining to air, water, protected species, and occupational safety.
- Authorizes a person acting in the public interest to bring an action to enforce certain standards and requirements implementing the above-mentioned state laws if specified conditions are satisfied, as specified.
- Prohibits specified state agencies that implement the laws above from amending or revising its rules and regulations in a manner that is less stringent in its protection of workers’ rights or worker safety than standards established by federal law in existence as of January 1, 2016.
- Requires state agencies to report to the Legislature on compliance with the above requirements, as specified.
- Makes its provisions inoperative as of January 20, 2025, and would repeal them as of January 1, 2026.
Background
- California is an environmental leader. California is the most populous state in the union with a population of nearly 40 million people. It is the third largest state by area at 163,696 square miles and is the fifth largest economy on the planet. California’s geographic, population, and economic size make California’s impact global in nature.
The state’s vast size has also brought an enormous impact on the environment. California has long struggled with some of the most polluted air in the country, and the discharge of pollution into the state’s water and soil has led to contamination that has degraded the environment and public health.
The responsibility to correct damage, and preserve and protect the environment, is a key tenant of California policy. Degradation of the state’s environment would make it impossible for California to continue to thrive.
In many cases, California began to clean the air, water, and soil before the federal government, recognizing the importance of these types of controls for both public health and economic strength. California’s laws and policy have served as a national model for other states, as well as the federal government. For instance, California had developed clean air standards prior to the FCAA, which is why California has its waiver provisions within the act.
California’s environmental leadership drives technology and scientific innovation as a key part of the state’s economy. For example, solar and other clean energy technologies have developed because of California’s strong policies on renewable energy and environmental sustainability. Consistency in the state’s ability to enforce strict environmental protections is paramount for these, and other, industries to continue to innovate and prosper. - Previous actions to preserve state rights for environmental protection. SB 288 (Sher, Chapter 476, Statutes of 2003) was enacted to preserve the state’s ability to protect state air quality standards from a US EPA that was weakening, or proposing to weaken, federal air quality standards.
The FCAA requires each major new and modified source of air pollution to undergo “new source review” to ensure that facilities install the best available control equipment, obtain offsets for any new emissions, and comply with any other requirement to ensure that the new and modified sources do not adversely affect air quality. On December 31, 2002, the Administrator of US EPA promulgated regulations implementing the new source review program that changed that program.
SB 288 established the Protect California Air Act of 2003, which prohibits air quality management districts from amending or revising their new source review rules or regulations to be less stringent than those rules or regulations that existed on December 30, 2002, except under certain circumstances.
Much like SB 1, the purpose of SB 288 was to maintain the requirement to attain and maintain ambient air quality standards by the earliest practicable date, to protect public health and welfare from the adverse effects of air pollution, and to ensure that economic growth will occur in a manner consistent with the preservation of existing clean air resources.
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “SB 1 ensures clean air, clean water, endangered species, and worker safety standards that have been in place for as long as 50 years are not rolled back as a result of the anti-environment actions of the President and Congress. In the past two years, the new administration and congress have adopted action after action to weaken, roll back, and outright repeal longstanding and well-accepted standards to protect workers, public health and the environment. SB 1 simply ensures those standards stay in place to protect everyday Californians, even if the federal government rolls them back.”
- A brief and incomplete summary of President Trump’s environmental record. President Trump has clearly stated his view that environmental laws and regulations jeopardize economic growth in the United States. President Trump has taken numerous actions to, and has committed to many other actions that would, rollback environmental protections in the United States. Although far from being an exhaustive list, President Trump has:
- Called the concept of man-made climate change a “hoax created by and for the Chinese to make American manufacturing non-competitive.”
- Purged, a week after taking office, the US EPA of any mention of climate change.
- Withdrew the final determination on strict vehicle fuel-efficiency standards, and eventually his administration decided to end negotiations with California over plans to roll back fuel economy rules designed to reduce GHG emissions.
- Proposed to eliminate 31% of the budget for US EPA.
- Signed an executive order to undo the Waters of the United States Rule that extended federal protections to smaller rivers and streams.
- Signed an executive order to set an annual cap on the cost impact of new regulations, beginning in the current fiscal year 2017 with a cap of $0, meaning that agencies should repeal existing rules to offset the cost of adding any new ones. Further, it directs agencies to suggest repealing at least two existing rules for every new one proposed.
- Signed H.J. Res. 38 (Johnson, R–OH), nullifying the Department of Interior’s Stream Protection Rule. The Stream Protection Rule targets coal-mining industry practices to protect waterways by requiring companies to avoid mining practices that permanently pollute streams, destroy drinking water sources, increase flood risk, and threaten forests by requiring companies to restore streams and return mined areas to the uses they were capable of supporting prior to mining activities, and to replant the areas with native trees and vegetation, unless that would conflict with the implemented land use.
- Ordered a federal hiring freeze, affecting all state agencies, including the hiring of new doctors by the Department of Veterans Affairs.
- Sought the names of civil servants who worked on issues related to climate change, women’s rights, and reproductive health.
- Announced his intention to abandon the Paris climate accords, making the USA the only country in the world not to support the framework deal to combat GHG emissions.
- Opened oil drilling in the Artic when the Bureau of Ocean Energy Management issued a conditional permit to Houston-based Hilcorp to begin drilling from an artificial island in the Beaufort Sea.
- Disbanded a scientific review panel that advises the US EPA about safe levels of pollution in the air.
- Rolled back Obama-era climate change policy, reducing requirements on oil and gas companies to monitor and mitigate releases of methane from wells and other operations.
- Initiated a plan to reverse Obama-Administration rules designed to curtail coal power plant emissions of carbon dioxide and methane that contribute to climate change.
- Ended NASA’s Carbon Monitoring System, a $10-million-per-year effort to fund pilot programs intended to improve the monitoring of global carbon emissions.
- Eliminated a Clinton-era rule that forced large sources of air pollution to remain subject to stricter regulations if they ever exceeded specified levels.
- Signed an executive order revoking federal flood-risk standards that incorporated rising sea levels predicted by climate science.
- Called the concept of man-made climate change a “hoax created by and for the Chinese to make American manufacturing non-competitive.”
Given these, and other, threats to environmental quality from the current federal government, the Committee may wish to consider supporting this measure.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 49 (De León, 2017) contained nearly identical provisions to SB 1. SB 49 died in the Assembly Rules Committee.
TRIPLE REFERRAL:
If this measure is approved by the Senate Environmental Quality Committee, the do pass motion must include the action to re-refer the bill to the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee. If this measure is approved by the Senate Natural Resources and Water Committee, the do pass motion must include the action to re-refer the bill to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
350 Bay Area
Audubon California
Breast Cancer Prevention Partners
California Association of Professional Scientists (CAPS)
California Coastal Protection Network
California Coastkeeper Alliance
California Conference Board of the Amalgamated Transit Union
California Conference of Machinists
California Interfaith Power & Light
California Labor Federation
California League of Conservation Voters
California Product Stewardship Council
California ReLEAF
California State Parks Foundation
California Teamsters
Californians Against Waste
CALSTART
Central Valley Air Quality Coalition
Clean Water Action
Coachella Valley Waterkeeper
Coalition for Clean Air
Defenders of Wildlife
Engineers and Scientists of CA, IFPTE Local 20, AFL-CIO
Environment California
Environmental Defense Center
Environmental Defense Fund
Environmental Water Caucus
Environmental Working Group
Fossil Free California
Friends Committee on Legislation in California
Heal the Bay
Humboldt Baykeeper
Inland Empire Waterkeeper
League of Women Voters of California
Los Angeles Waterkeeper
Los Cerritos Wetlands Land Trust
Mono Lake Committee
Monterey Coastkeeper
Mountain Lion Foundation
National Stewardship Action Council
Natural Resources Defense Council
Nextgen California
Orange County Coastkeeper
PawPAC
Pesticide Action Network
Planning and Conservation League
Professional and Technical Engineers, IFPTE Local 21, AFL-CIO
Protect American River Canyons
Restore the Delta
Russian Riverkeeper
San Diego Coastkeeper
Santa Barbara Channelkeeper
Save Our Shores
Save The Bay
Seventh Generation Advisors
Sierra Club California
South Coast Air Quality Management District
Southern California Watershed Alliance
State Building & Construction Trades Council
Surfrider Foundation
The 5 Gyres Institute
The Nature Conservancy
The Otter Project
The Trust for Public Land
Utility Workers of America
Voices for Progress
WILDCOAST
Yuba River Waterkeeper
Zero Waste USA
OPPOSITION:
California Agricultural Aircraft Association
California Association of Realtors
California Association of Winegrape Growers
California Building Industry Association
California Business Properties Association
California Citrus Mutual
California Construction and Industrial Materials Association
California Cotton Ginners and Growers Association, Inc.
California Farm Bureau Federation
California Forestry Association
California Independent Petroleum Association
California League of Food Producers
California Metals Coalition
CAWA- Representing the Automotive Parts Industry
Household & Commercial Products Association
NAIOP
National Federation of Independent Business
Nisei Farmers League
West Coast Lumber & Building Material Association
Western Agricultural Processors Association
Western Growers Association
Western Independent Refiners Association
Western Plant Health Association
Western Wood Preservers’ Institute
Western States Petroleum Association
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According to a coalition of supporters:
“California has long been a leader in ensuring a healthy environment and workplace for its citizens. For many years, the state has enforced its laws protecting the air that Californians breathe, the water that Californians drink, and the wildlife and natural resources that our citizens prize, in tandem with federal agency partners. But the Trump administration now threatens that long-standing partnership with ongoing and persistent efforts to weaken or eliminate critical public health and environmental protections. SB 1 protects our citizens and our environment by ensuring that protections in existence prior to January 19, 2017 under the federal Clean Air Act, Clean Water Act, Safe Drinking Water Act, Endangered Species Act, and workplace safety laws are not weakened, and gives California state agencies streamlined authority to enforce these protections under state law.
“Californians are already suffering from the devastating impacts of climate change and continue to struggle with poor air and water quality. Recent wildfires have broken records and claimed dozens of lives, destroyed tens of thousands of structures, harmed wildlife, scorched large swathes of the state, and spewed millions of metric tons of greenhouse gases and toxic pollutants into the air. Despite these unprecedented disasters, the Trump administration continues to push an anti-environment agenda that benefits polluters at the expense of our nation’s most important assets – our people and natural resources.
“Among other rollbacks, the federal administration plans to scale back protections for animals and plants most at risk of extinction; dismantle protections for local drinking water supplies, salmon, delta smelt, rivers and estuaries; allow pollution from other states to cross state lines at higher levels without considering potential health impacts like asthma and increased heart attacks; and loosen critical requirements to find and fix leaks of methane, a potent greenhouse gas. We are alarmed by these attacks on the country’s most fundamental and necessary environmental protections.
“While California has long been a leader in protecting our natural resources, many of our environmental protections are built on a foundation of federal standards. Similarly, when it comes to enforcement of worker safety, we rely on a patchwork of state and federal rules to protect workers from catastrophic injuries. SB 1 is designed to strengthen that foundation by incorporating into state law existing federal protections for clean air, clean water, endangered species, worker safety, and safe drinking water when federal standards dip below certain baseline protections.
“SB 1 adopts common-sense measures to allow California to continue on a path to economic and environmental sustainability – and reject the false choice that economic progress must come at the expense of public health, the vitality of our natural surroundings, and a healthy environment for all. For these reasons, we strongly support SB 1.”
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):