SB 1208: Waste discharge permits: landfills.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-07-03
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-09-01: Read third time. Refused passage. (Ayes 28. Noes 8. Page 7157.))
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Under existing law, the State Water Resources Control Board and the 9 California regional water quality control boards regulate water quality and prescribe waste discharge requirements in accordance with the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act and the federal national pollutant discharge elimination system permit program established by the federal Clean Water Act.
The California Integrated Waste Management Act of 1989 prohibits a regional water board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill, or a lateral expansion of an existing landfill, that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land has been primarily used at any time for the mining or excavation of gravel or sand, as specified. The act defines landfill used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste as a disposal site regulated by a regional water board as a Class III landfill, as provided.
This bill would additionally prohibit a regional water board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land is located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River, except as provided. The bill would also expand the definition of landfill used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste to also include a disposal site regulated by a regional water board as a Class II landfill, as provided. The bill would state that its provisions are severable.
Under existing law, the State Water Resources Control Board and the 9 California regional water quality control boards regulate water quality and prescribe waste discharge requirements in accordance with the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act and the federal national pollutant discharge elimination system permit program established by the federal Clean Water Act.
The California Integrated Waste Management Act of 1989 prohibits a regional water board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill, or a lateral expansion of an existing landfill, that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land has been primarily used at any time for the mining or excavation of gravel or sand, as specified. The act defines landfill used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste as a disposal site regulated by a regional water board as a Class III landfill, as provided.
This bill would additionally prohibit a regional water board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land is located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River. River, except as provided. The bill would also expand the definition of landfill used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste to also include a disposal site regulated by a regional water board as a Class II landfill, as provided.
Under existing law, the State Water Resources Control Board and the 9 California regional water quality control boards regulate water quality and prescribe waste discharge requirements in accordance with the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act and the federal national pollutant discharge elimination system permit program established by the federal Clean Water Act.
The California Integrated Waste Management Act of 1989 prohibits a regional water board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill, or a lateral expansion of an existing landfill, that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land has been primarily used at any time for the mining or excavation of gravel or sand, as specified. The act defines landfill used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste as a disposal site regulated by a regional water board as a Class III landfill, as provided.
This bill would additionally prohibit a regional water board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land is located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River. The bill would also expand the definition of landfill used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste to also include a disposal site regulated by a regional water board as a Class II landfill, as provided.
The Legislature finds and declares that the use of areas within the Tijuana River watershed for landfill disposal and related activities create the potential for pollution and other hazardous conditions that can adversely affect human health and the environment.
SEC. 2.Section 40060 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:40060.(a)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, a regional water board shall not issue a waste discharge permit for a new landfill, or a lateral expansion of an existing landfill, which is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land has been primarily used at any time for the mining or excavation of gravel or sand.
(2)(A)Notwithstanding any other law, and not subject to a variance, a regional water board shall not issue a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the new landfill is to be located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River. This prohibition does not apply if both of the following conditions are satisfied:
(i)The Secretary for Environmental Protection makes written findings, based on clear and convincing evidence, and posts on the agencys internet website, that the construction, operation, and closure or postclosure of a new nonhazardous solid waste landfill within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River will not harm or otherwise adversely affect the Tijuana River or areas tributary to the Tijuana River.
(ii)A regional water board makes a finding that the waste discharge requirements for the landfill protect water quality, meet water quality objectives, and protect beneficial uses.
(B)Subparagraph (A) shall does not apply to a public agency restoration and beneficial reuse project for abandoned sand and gravel mining quarries located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River.
(b)A regional water board, in a public meeting, may grant a variance from paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) if the applicant demonstrates and the regional water board determines that the discharges to a new facility or expansion of an existing facility during its operation and postclosure period will not pollute or threaten to pollute the waters of the state. In deciding whether to grant a variance, the regional water board shall consider, among other factors, site characteristics, including permeability and transmissivity of the underlying soils and depth to groundwater. For the purpose of this section, groundwater means the uppermost aquifer usable for beneficial purposes.
(c)Nothing in this section precludes any This section does not preclude a local jurisdiction from exercising any power that it has pursuant to any other law.
(d)The following definitions govern the construction of this section:
(1)Landfill used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste means a disposal site regulated by a regional water board as a Class II or III landfill pursuant to Subchapter 2 (commencing with Section 20200) of Chapter 3 of Subdivision 1 of Division 2 of Title 27 of the California Code of Regulations.
(2)Lateral expansion means a new or expanded waste management unit that is not authorized on January 1, 1989, under existing waste discharge requirements issued pursuant to Division 7 (commencing with Section 13000) of the Water Code and an existing solid waste facility permit issued pursuant to this division. For purposes of subdivision (f), lateral expansion does not include a new or expanded waste management unit for which waste discharge requirements were issued by a regional water board before January 1, 1989, but were subject to review after that date pursuant to Section 13320 of the Water Code.
(e)The regional water board may hold a single hearing for purposes of granting a variance pursuant to subdivision (b) and establishing waste discharge requirements.
(f)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), a regional water board shall not grant a variance from paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) if the variance is for a new landfill, or a lateral expansion of an existing landfill, located within the boundaries of the Main San Gabriel Groundwater Basin. For purposes of this subdivision, the boundaries of the Main San Gabriel Groundwater Basin are the boundaries described in Exhibit A of the judgment in Upper San Gabriel Valley Municipal Water District v. City of Alhambra, et al., Case Number 924128 of the Superior Court for the County of Los Angeles.
(g)The provisions of this section are severable. If any provision of this section or its application is held invalid, that invalidity shall not affect other provisions or applications that can be given effect without the invalid provision or application.
The Legislature finds and declares that the use of areas within the Tijuana River watershed for landfill disposal and related activities create the potential for pollution and other hazardous conditions that can adversely affect human health and the environment.
SEC. 2.Section 40060 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:40060.(a)(1)Notwithstanding any other law, a regional water board shall not issue a waste discharge permit for a new landfill, or a lateral expansion of an existing landfill, which is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land has been primarily used at any time for the mining or excavation of gravel or sand.
(2)(A)Notwithstanding any other law, and not subject to a variance, a regional water board shall not issue a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the new landfill is to be located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River.
(B)Subparagraph (A) shall not apply to a public agency restoration and beneficial reuse project for abandoned sand and gravel mining quarries located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River.
(b)A regional water board, in a public meeting, may grant a variance from paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) if the applicant demonstrates and the regional water board determines that the discharges to a new facility or expansion of an existing facility during its operation and postclosure period will not pollute or threaten to pollute the waters of the state. In deciding whether to grant a variance, the regional water board shall consider, among other factors, site characteristics, including permeability and transmissivity of the underlying soils and depth to groundwater. For the purpose of this section, groundwater means the uppermost aquifer usable for beneficial purposes.
(c)Nothing in this section precludes any local jurisdiction from exercising any power that it has pursuant to any other law.
(d)The following definitions govern the construction of this section:
(1)Landfill used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste means a disposal site regulated by a regional water board as a Class II or III landfill pursuant to Subchapter 2 (commencing with Section 20200) of Chapter 3 of Subdivision 1 of Division 2 of Title 27 of the California Code of Regulations.
(2)Lateral expansion means a new or expanded waste management unit that is not authorized on January 1, 1989, under existing waste discharge requirements issued pursuant to Division 7 (commencing with Section 13000) of the Water Code and an existing solid waste facility permit issued pursuant to this division. For purposes of subdivision (f), lateral expansion does not include a new or expanded waste management unit for which waste discharge requirements were issued by a regional water board before January 1, 1989, but were subject to review after that date pursuant to Section 13320 of the Water Code.
(e)The regional water board may hold a single hearing for purposes of granting a variance pursuant to subdivision (b) and establishing waste discharge requirements.
(f)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), a regional water board shall not grant a variance from paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) if the variance is for a new landfill, or a lateral expansion of an existing landfill, located within the boundaries of the Main San Gabriel Groundwater Basin. For purposes of this subdivision, the boundaries of the Main San Gabriel Groundwater Basin are the boundaries described in Exhibit A of the judgment in Upper San Gabriel Valley Municipal Water District v. City of Alhambra, et al., Case Number 924128 of the Superior Court for the County of Los Angeles.
The Legislature finds and declares that the use of areas within the Tijuana River watershed for landfill disposal and related activities create the potential for pollution and other hazardous conditions that can adversely affect human health and the environment.
SEC. 2.Section 40060 of the Public Resources Code is amended to read:40060.(a)(1)Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a regional water board shall not issue a waste discharge permit for a new landfill, or a lateral expansion of an existing landfill, which is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land has been primarily used at any time for the mining or excavation of gravel or sand.
(2)Notwithstanding any other law, and not subject to a variance, a regional water board shall not issue a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the new landfill is to be located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River.
(b)A regional water board, in a public meeting, may grant a variance from paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) if the applicant demonstrates and the regional water quality control board determines that the discharges to a new facility or expansion of an existing facility during its operation and postclosure period will not pollute or threaten to pollute the waters of the state. In deciding whether to grant a variance, the regional water board shall consider, among other factors, site characteristics, including permeability and transmissivity of the underlying soils and depth to groundwater. For the purpose of this section, groundwater means the uppermost aquifer usable for beneficial purposes.
(c)Nothing in this section precludes any local jurisdiction from exercising any power which that it has pursuant to any other provision of law.
(d)The following definitions govern the construction of this section:
(1)Landfill used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste means a disposal site regulated by a regional water board as a Class II or III landfill pursuant to Sections 2533 and 2541 of Subchapter 2 (commencing with Section 20200) of Chapter 3 of Subdivision 1 of Division 2 of Title 23 27 of the California Code of Regulations.
(2)Lateral expansion means a new or expanded waste management unit which that is not authorized on January 1, 1989, under existing waste discharge requirements issued pursuant to Division 7 (commencing with Section 13000) of the Water Code and an existing solid waste facility permit issued pursuant to this title. division. For purposes of subdivision (f), lateral expansion does not include a new or expanded waste management unit for which waste discharge requirements were issued by a regional water board before January 1, 1989, but were subject to review after that date pursuant to Section 13320 of the Water Code.
(e)The regional water board may hold a single hearing for purposes of granting a variance pursuant to subdivision (b) and establishing waste discharge requirements.
(f)Notwithstanding subdivision (b), a regional water board shall not grant a variance from paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) if the variance is for a new landfill, or a lateral expansion of an existing landfill, located within the boundaries of the Main San Gabriel Groundwater Basin. For purposes of this subdivision, the boundaries of the Main San Gabriel Groundwater Basin are the boundaries described in Exhibit A of the judgment in Upper San Gabriel Valley Municipal Water District v. City of Alhambra, et al., Case Number 924128 of the Superior Court for the County of Los Angeles.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 1, 2024 | Read third time. Refused passage. (Ayes 28. Noes 8. Page 7157.) |
| Aug 19, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 15, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 11. Noes 0.) (August 15). |
| Aug 7, 2024 | August 7 set for first hearing. Placed on suspense file. |
| Jul 3, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jul 2, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 9. Noes 1.) (July 1). |
| Jun 26, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on NAT. RES. (Ayes 5. Noes 0.) (June 25). Re-referred to Com. on NAT. RES. |
| Jun 3, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on E.S. & T.M. and NAT. RES. |
| May 21, 2024 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 20, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 28. Noes 6. Page 4029.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 5. Noes 2. Page 3975.) (May 16). |
| May 16, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 14, 2024 | Set for hearing May 16. |
| May 13, 2024 | May 13 hearing: Placed on APPR suspense file. |
| May 3, 2024 | Set for hearing May 13. |
| Apr 29, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 25, 2024 | From committee: Do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 4. Noes 0. Page 3754.) (April 24). |
| Apr 11, 2024 | Set for hearing April 24. |
| Apr 9, 2024 | April 17 set for first hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Mar 12, 2024 | Set for hearing April 17. |
| Feb 29, 2024 | Referred to Com. on E.Q. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 17. |
| Feb 15, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 1, 2024 | SB 1208 Padilla Senate Third Reading By Boerner | Assembly Floor |
Failed |
|
| Aug 15, 2024 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 1, 2024 | Do pass as amended and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources |
Passed |
|
| Jun 25, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Natural Resources] | Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials |
Passed |
|
| May 20, 2024 | Senate 3rd Reading SB1208 Padilla | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| May 13, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 24, 2024 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Alliance San Diego | ** Support | |
| Alonso Gonzalez, Deputy Mayor, Chula Vista | ** Support | |
| Azul | ** Support | |
| Azul and Latino Outdoors | * Support | Jul 1, 2024 |
| California Building Industry Association | * Against | Jul 1, 2024 |
| California Coast Keeper Alliance | * Support | Jun 25, 2024 |
| California Coastal Protection Network | * Support | Jul 1, 2024 |
| California Environmental Voters | * Support | Jul 1, 2024 |
| California Latino Environmental Advocacy Network | ** Support | |
| Californians Against Waste | * Support | Jul 1, 2024 |
| Center for Biological Diversity | * Support | Jul 1, 2024 |
| Chula Vista Deputy Mayor Alonso Gonzalez | ** Support | |
| City of Chula Vista Office of Deputy Mayor Alonso Gonzalez 2024 | ** Support | |
| City of National City | ** Support | |
| Clean Earth 4 Kids | ** Support | |
| Climate Action Campaign | ** Support | |
| Council Member Jose Rodriguez, City of National City | ** Support | |
| Councilmember Marni von Wilpert, City of San Diego | ** Against | |
| Councilmember Moreno, City of San Diego | ** Against | |
| Councilmember Sean Elo-Rivera, City of San Diego, District 9 | ** Support | |
| East Otay Mesa Landfill Project | * Against | Jul 1, 2024 |
| Endangered Habitats League | ** Support | |
| Environmental Center of San Diego | ** Support | |
| Food and Water Watch | ** Support | |
| Jennifer Campbell, Councilmember, San Diego | ** Support | |
| Jose Rodriguez, Council Member, Nevada City | ** Support | |
| Marni Von Wilpert, Councilmember, San Diego | ** Support | |
| Monica Montgomery Steppe, Supervisor, San Diego County | ** Support | |
| Morning Sun Clare | ** Support | |
| National City Councilmember Jose Rodriguez | ** Support | |
| National Enterprises | * Against | Jun 25, 2024 |
| National Enterprises | * Against | Jun 25, 2024 |
| National Enterprises | * Support | Apr 24, 2024 |
| National Enterprises, Inc. | ** Against | |
| Natural Resources Defense Council | ** Support | |
| Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC) | * Support | Jul 1, 2024 |
| Nora Vargas, Chair, San Diego County Board of Supervisors | ** Support | |
| North County Equity & Justice | * Support | Jun 25, 2024 |
| Office of Supervisor Nora Vargas, San Diego County Board of Supervisors | ** Support | |
| Otay Mesa Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Paloma Aguirre, Mayor, City of Imperial Beach | ** Support | |
| Protect Otay Foothills | * Support | Jun 25, 2024 |
| Protect Otay Foothills | * Support | Apr 24, 2024 |
| Protect Otay Foothills | * Support | Jul 1, 2024 |
| Protect Otay Foothills | ** Support | |
| Ron Morrison, Mayor, National City | ** Support | |
| San Diego Audubon Society | ** Support | |
| San Diego Coast Keeper | * Support | Jun 25, 2024 |
| San Diego Coastkeeper | ** Support | |
| San Diego Councilmember Jennifer Campbell | ** Support | |
| San Diego Councilmember Marni Von Wilpert | ** Support | |
| San Diego Count Democrats for Environmental Action | ** Support | |
| San Diego Pediatricians for Clean Air | ** Support | |
| San Diego350 | ** Support | |
| SanDiego350 | ** Support | |
| Sean Elo Rivera, Council President, City of San Diego | ** Support | |
| Sierra Club California | * Support | Jul 1, 2024 |
| Surf Rider Foundation | * Support | Jun 25, 2024 |
| Unite Here Local 30 | ** Support | |
| United Domestic Workers | * Support | Jul 1, 2024 |
| Wildcoast | ** Support |
SENATE THIRD READING
STR Bill Id:SB 1208
Author:(Padilla)
As Amended Ver:July 3, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Prohibits a Regional Water Quality Control Board (Regional Water Board) from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste, if the new landfill is to be located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve, or within an area that is a tributary of the Tijuana River.
Major Provisions
- Provides that the prohibition of a waste discharge permit for a new solid waste landfill applies if both of the following conditions are satisfied:
a) The Secretary for the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) makes written findings, based on clear and convincing evidence, and posts on CalEPA's internet website, that the construction, operation, and closure or postclosure of a new nonhazardous solid waste landfill within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River will not harm or otherwise adversely affect the Tijuana River or areas tributary to the Tijuana River; and,
b) A Regional Water Board makes a finding that the waste discharge requirements for the landfill protect water quality, meet water quality objectives, and protect beneficial uses.
COMMENTS
Cross-border pollution: Several waterbodies straddle the international border between the U.S. and Mexico. Among those, the Tijuana River and the New River are recognized polluted rivers that affect both sides of the border and have required state resources to help mitigate the harm to environmental and public health.
Tijuana River watershed: The Tijuana River watershed is a large binational watershed of approximately 1,750 square miles that lies across the California-Mexico border. A large portion of the watershed (approximately 75%) is within Mexico and encompasses the densely urbanized city of Tijuana, Baja California, Mexico. The watershed drains into the Tijuana River Estuary in the U.S. and ultimately to the Pacific Ocean in the City of Imperial Beach.
Tijuana River Estuary: The Tijuana Estuary is the largest coastal wetland in Southern California and it is located on the international border between the U.S. and Mexico. The estuary is primarily a shallow water habitat, though it is often termed an "intermittent estuary," as it undergoes extreme changes in streamflow at different times of the year. The Tijuana River Estuary is one of the few salt marshes remaining in Southern California. The site is an essential breeding, feeding, and nesting ground and key stopover point on the Pacific Flyway for over 370 species of migratory and native birds, including six endangered species.
Tijuana River pollution: In the past 30 years, the city of Tijuana, Baja California, Mexico, has experienced tremendous population and industrial growth, along with rapid urbanization. According to census data presented by the National Institute of Statistics and Geography, an agency of the Mexican Government, the City of Tijuana had a population of 1,922,523 in 2020, representing a 23.3% growth in population compared to 2010 census data. The population in the City of Tijuana has nearly tripled compared to census data from 1990. This rapid growth has put a strain on aging Mexican sewage infrastructure causing serious pollution problems on both sides of the border. A concerning number of homes in the City of Tijuana do not have connections to any wastewater or solid waste collection system. These infrastructure problems result in massive flows of untreated sewage that affect the Tijuana River Estuary and adjacent beach coastal waters.
The pollution in the Tijuana River has impacted beaches and businesses and is a major public health threat in San Diego County. The San Diego Department of Environmental Health and Quality's Beach and Bay Water Quality Program currently lists five shorelines closed to the public in South San Diego County due to bacteria levels exceeding health standards. These closures date back to December 2021. Local news stations, such as NBC 7 San Diego, have visited numerous businesses in the city of Imperial Beach that stated concerns over revenue loss and the future of their small businesses, since beach closures have caused a decrease in tourism in the area. While beach closures deter the public from entering contaminated waters and prevent illnesses from direct contact, a recent study by the Scripps Institution of Oceanography suggests that bacteria from the raw, untreated sewage can be airborne and affect people living in close proximity to coastal waters. Data analyses have demonstrated that up to 76% of the bacteria people breathe in the City of Imperial Beach comes from the aerosolization of raw sewage from the Tijuana River, suggesting that pollution in the Tijuana River may have farther-reaching health consequences than previously thought. Further studies are needed to understand the impacts on human health and how climate change may contribute to this crisis.
The East Otay Mesa Recycling Collection Center and Landfill: On June 8, 2010, a county-wide initiative, Proposition A, amended San Diego County's general plan to allow for the construction and operation of a new landfill and recycling center. The question before the voters of San Diego County was: "Shall this Initiative be adopted for the purpose of siting a new recycling center and class III solid waste landfill in East Otay Mesa area of unincorporated San Diego County?"
In 2011, the developer of this proposed landfill began the regulatory process by initiating the environmental review process (under state law) for a class III solid waste landfill occupying approximately 340 acres. The proposed project site would be located approximately one and one-half miles from the City of San Diego, two and one-half miles from the City of Chula Vista, and one-quarter mile from the U.S./Mexico border.
According to the website of the County of San Diego Department of Health and Quality, there were two environmental documents submitted (an Initial Study and a Notice of Preparation) on September 12, 2011. There are no additional environmental documents posted since 2011. However, since that time, the project proponent has indicated they are in the process of applying for a solid waste facility permit and are preparing the environmental documents to be submitted under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA). During conversations about this bill, the proponents of the landfill are confident that there will not be any negative impacts on the Tijuana River associated with the landfill.
While voters approved a zoning change to allow for the recycling center and class III landfill, the project still needs to obtain the approval of various local, state, and federal agencies and those regulatory approvals cannot be guaranteed in advance. This includes the requirements under CEQA which include evaluating potential impacts on Native American cultural sites.
CalEnviroScreen: In order to address the cumulative effects of both pollution burden and certain population characteristics, and to identify which communities might be in need of particular policy, investment, or programmatic interventions, the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) developed and now maintains and updates the CalEnviroScreen tool. The tool applies a framework for assessing cumulative impacts such as exposures and public health or environmental effects from all sources of pollution in a geographic area. Cumulative impacts also take into account groups of people that are especially sensitive to the effects of pollution and socioeconomic factors. According to CalEnviroScreen 4.0, Otay Mesa, the site of the proposed landfill, has a score in the 90-100% (which is the most burdened percentile). Therefore, citing a solid waste landfill in this area could increase the pollution burden this community already is faced with.
This bill: SB 1208 would prohibit the San Diego Regional Water Board from issuing a waste discharge permit for the proposed landfill in Otay Mesa unless the Secretary for CalEPA makes a specified finding that the landfill will not harm the Tijuana River, and a Regional Water Board makes a finding that the waste discharge permit requirements protect water quality, meet water quality objectives, and protect beneficial uses.
According to the Author
"Border communities already face some of California's most pressing environmental hazards in the form of dangerously polluted air and water that has created a public health crisis. The Tijuana River is already one of the most polluted watersheds in the nation. Allowing developers to build an unnecessary landfill in that watershed would further impact local communities that are already enduring ecological disasters. SB 1208 will protect vulnerable Californians by prohibiting a landfill that would further pollute the waters of the Tijuana River and threaten local residents."
Arguments in Support
According to a coalition in support of the bill, "The project could impair water and air quality throughout the Tijuana River Watershed, including the Tijuana River Valley and Estuary, contributing to harmful health impacts to downstream communities in a region already burdened by the cross border pollution crisis, one of the worst ongoing public health and environmental justice crises in the country.
There is no need for a new landfill in San Diego County, as the county has more than adequate assured disposal capacity for the next 30 years as documented in San Diego County's 2022 detailed analysis of the region's landfill capacity. We applaud Senator Padilla's recognition that "we all live downstream", and, pointedly, that an unnecessary landfill developed in the watershed of the already impaired Tijuana River could adversely affect water and air quality in the lower watershed and exacerbate the ongoing pollution issues from which our border cities and communities have suffered for decades."
Arguments in Opposition
According to National Enterprises, Inc., "SB 1208 adds significant, unbudgeted state costs for redundant enforcement and review of federal, state, and local environmental protection functions. In addition, the measure introduces an unprecedented and costly project review by the CalEPA Secretary that will undoubtedly be replicated in future legislation to halt housing and other development projects.
It is important to note that the permitting and environmental documents being prepared are for both the recycling center and landfill components in a single application.
SB 1208 undermines San Diego voters' approval and property rights. In 2010, County of San Diego voters approved Proposition A, by 84.49% to allow for the construction and operation of a recycling collection center and class III solid waste landfill on the East Otay Mesa project site. SB 1208 flagrantly defies the voters and provides them with no viable alternative."
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, enactment of, and compliance with, this bill could cost CalEPA approximately $225,000 annually and the State Water Board approximately $900,000 annually.
VOTES
SENATE FLOOR: 28-6-6
YES: Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Cortese, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Newman, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener
NO: Dahle, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Seyarto
ABS, ABST OR NV: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Caballero, Min, Ochoa Bogh, Wilk
ASM ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS: 5-0-2
YES: Garcia, Connolly, McKinnor, Papan, Reyes
ABS, ABST OR NV: Hoover, Ta
ASM NATURAL RESOURCES: 9-1-2
YES: Bryan, Bauer-Kahan, Connolly, Friedman, Kalra, Muratsuchi, Pellerin, Wicks, Wood
NO: Flora
ABS, ABST OR NV: Hoover, Lackey
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-0-4
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Villapudua
ABS, ABST OR NV: Sanchez, Dixon, Jim Patterson, Ta
UPDATED
VERSION: July 3, 2024
CONSULTANT: Josh Tooker / E.S. & T.M. / (916) 319-3965 FN: 0003922
Date of Hearing: August 7, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1208
Author:(Padilla) – As Amended Ver:July 3, 2024
Policy Committee: | Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials | Vote: | 5 - 0 |
Natural Resources | 9 - 1 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill prohibits a regional water board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill for disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the landfill is to be located within the Tijuana River area in San Diego, unless the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA) secretary and regional water board make specified findings to protect against negative impact.
Specifically, this bill:
- Prohibits a regional water board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the landfill is to be located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve (Reserve) or an area that is a tributary to the Tijuana River.
- Provides this prohibition does not apply if two conditions are met:
- The Secretary of CalEPA makes formal written findings, based on clear and convincing evidence, and posts on the agency’s internet website, that the construction, operation, and closure/post-closure of a new nonhazardous solid waste landfill within the Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River will not harm or otherwise adversely affect the Tijuana River or areas tributary to the Tijuana River.
- A regional water board makes a finding that the waste discharge requirements protect water quality, meet water quality objectives, and protect beneficial uses.
- Specifies this prohibition does not apply to a public agency restoration and beneficial reuse project for abandoned sand and gravel mining quarries located within the Reserve or within an area that is a tributary to the Tijuana River.
- Makes legislative findings that the use of areas within the Tijuana River watershed for landfill disposal and related activities create the potential for pollution and other hazardous conditions that can adversely affect human health and the environment.
FISCAL EFFECT:
CalEPA reports General Fund costs estimated at $225,000 annually, potentially ongoing, for the Secretary to make the written findings under the clear and convincing evidence standard required by this bill, with technical support from agency departments.
The State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) reports costs estimated at $900,000 annual ongoing from the Waste Discharge Permit Fund to address unintended consequences resulting from this bill, with costs primarily associated with enforcement actions, involving minor, moderate, and major violations of water quality statutes and regulations, depending on the number, type, and severity of the violations that occur. SWRCB describes these unintended consequences as deriving from illegal dumping if a proposed landfill does not become operative.
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the General Fund faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Border communities already face some of California’s most pressing environmental hazards in the form of dangerously polluted air and water that has created a public health crisis. The Tijuana River is already one of the most polluted watersheds in the nation. Allowing developers to build an unnecessary landfill in that watershed would further impact local communities that are already enduring ecological disasters. SB 1208 will protect vulnerable Californians by prohibiting a landfill that would further pollute the waters of the Tijuana River and threaten local residents.
- Background. This bill sets a new standard for approval of a landfill proposed for siting in the Tijuana River watershed in San Diego with the goal of protecting against more adverse health and environmental impacts in an area already considered one of the most polluted in the nation. In 2010, about 84% of voters approved a local ballot measure to site a proposed 340-acre class III (nonhazardous) solid waste landfill and recycling center in the unincorporated area of south San Diego County, one and one-half miles from the City of San Diego, two and one-half miles from the City of Chula Vista, and one-quarter mile from the United States/Mexico border. Initial environmental impact documents were filed in 2011 but, as of June 2024, environmental review is still underway. The project is known as the East Otay Mesa Recycling Collection Center and Landfill, but current plans under review appear to not include the recycling center. California has enacted several significant recycling laws in the last decade, which likely increased costs of the proposed project. Moreover, dramatically increased water and air pollution in the project area in recent years has heightened concerns about whether the landfill project presents risk of even more public health hazards. The landfill developer, however, claims that the landfill will have no negative impacts on the Tijuana River watershed.
The developer still faces several regulatory hurdles to build the proposed landfill, including obtaining a waste discharge permit from the regional water control board. This bill imposes new requirements for obtaining that permit. The findings by the CalEPA Secretary and regional water board that this bill requires are intended to verify the developer’s claims that there will be no negative impacts and to protect the residents and community from more health and environmental hazards.
- Prior legislation. AB 2601 (Eduardo Garcia), of the 2021-22 Legislative Session, would have prohibited a regional water board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill, or a lateral expansion of an existing landfill, if the land is located within three miles of the United States’ border with Mexico. AB 2601 was held in this committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Jay Dickenson / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: July 1, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON NATURAL RESOURCES
Isaac G. Bryan, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1208
Author:(Padilla) – As Amended Ver:April 29, 2024
SENATE VOTE: 28-6
SUBJECT: Waste discharge permits: landfills
SUMMARY: Prohibits a Regional Water Quality Control Board (regional water board) from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land is located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve (Reserve) or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River, except as specified.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit program and authorizes the State Water Resources Control Board (SWRCB) and the nine regional water boards to prescribe waste discharge requirements (WDRs) which, among other things, regulate the discharge of pollutants in stormwater, including municipal stormwater systems. (33 United States Code 1342 and Water Code (WC) 13377)
- Prohibits, pursuant to the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, the discharge of pollutants to surface waters unless the discharger obtains a permit from SWRCB or a regional water board. (WC 13000, et seq.)
- Prohibits a regional water board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill, or lateral expansion of an existing landfill, which is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste, if the land has been primarily used at any time for the mining or excavation of gravel or sand, except as specified. (Public Resources Code (PRC) 40060 (a))
THIS BILL:
- Prohibits a regional water board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the new landfill is to be located within the Reserve or within an area that is a tributary to the Tijuana River.
- Specifies that this prohibition does not apply to a public agency restoration and beneficial reuse project for abandoned sand and gravel mining quarries located within the Reserve or within an area that is a tributary to the Tijuana River.
- Expands the definition of “landfill used for the disposal for nonhazardous solid waste” to include Class II landfills.
- States that the Legislature finds and declares that the use of areas within the Tijuana River watershed for landfill disposal and related activities create the potential for pollution and other hazardous conditions that can adversely affect human health and the environment.
FISCAL EFFECT: According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, SWRCB estimates ongoing costs of approximately $900,000 annually (Waste Discharge Permit Fund) to address unintended consequences that SWRCB anticipates resulting from this bill’s provisions. The costs would be primarily associated with enforcement actions, involving minor, moderate, and major violations of water quality statutes and regulations, and would depend on the number, type, and severity of the violations that occur.
COMMENTS:
- Tijuana River and Estuary. The Tijuana River flows north from Tijuana into the Tijuana River and Estuary (TJRE) in the United States, emptying into the Pacific Ocean at Imperial Beach. The TJRE is severely contaminated by untreated sewage, industrial waste, and urban run-off due to inadequate infrastructure and urbanization. The watershed is classified as an impaired water body according to the federal Clean Water Act. This contamination is a persistent environmental and public health threat with substantial economic, legal, social, and health implications for the nearby communities, such as San Ysidro and Imperial Beach.
- The East Otay Mesa Recycling Collection Center and Landfill. In 2011, there was a proposal submitted for a class III (nonhazardous) solid waste landfill occupying approximately 340 acres. The proposed project would have been located in the unincorporated area of south San Diego County, approximately two miles east of the Siempre Viva Road exit from Interstate 905, one-quarter mile from Loop Road/Paseo De La Fuente and east of planned State Route 11. The site is approximately one and one-half miles from the City of San Diego, two and one-half miles from the City of Chula Vista, and one-quarter mile from the United States/Mexico border.
On June 8, 2010, a San Diego County initiative, Proposition A, which asked voters “shall this initiative be adopted for the purpose of siting a new recycling center and class III solid waste landfill in East Otay Mesa area of unincorporated San Diego County?” The measure was approved by 84.49% to revise the county's general plan to allow for the construction and operation of a recycling center and a landfill on the site. According to the County of San Diego Department of Health and Quality, there were two environmental documents submitted (an Initial Study and a Notice of Preparation) on September 12, 2011. The San Diego Solid Waste Local Enforcement Agency notes that as of June 14, 2024, the applicant is actively working on the environmental review process; however, the current plans don’t appear to include a recycling facility. - Pollution burden. In order to address the cumulative effects of pollution burden and socioeconomic factors and identify which communities might be in need of policy, investment, or programmatic interventions, the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) maintains the CalEnviroScreen tool on behalf of the California Environmental Protection Agency. The tool applies a framework, developed by OEHHA in 2010, for assessing cumulative environmental and socioeconomic impacts. According to OEHHA cumulative impacts refer to exposures and public health or environmental effects from all sources of pollution in a geographic area. Cumulative impacts also take into account groups of people that are especially sensitive to the effects of pollution and socioeconomic factors. The CalEnviroScreen tool's framework is based in large part on input from a statewide working group on environmental justice that pointed out the unmet need to assess cumulative burdens and vulnerabilities affecting California communities. Otay Mesa and the neighboring communities of San Ysidro and Nestor have among the most burdened CalEnviroScreen scores in the state. Citing a new solid waste landfill in this area would increase the pollution burden on these communities.
- Capacity. According to the County of San Diego’s Five-Year Review, which was completed as part of the solid waste Countywide Integrated Waste Management Plan in 2022, the county has sufficient landfill capacity to accommodate disposal through 2053. The projected capacity is based on the assumption that the Sycamore Landfill will apply for projected expansions to their daily permitted capacity and that the county will achieve landfill disposal reductions targets through increased conservation and recycling, expanding composting and construction and demolition recycling, and implementing mandatory recycling ordinances. The expansion of Sycamore Landfill is expected to occur before two of the county’s four landfills are estimated to close in 2030. Sycamore Landfill has completed California Environmental Quality Act requirements for the expansions; however, the Local Enforcement Agency has not received an application to revise the facility’s Solid Waste Facility Permit.
- This bill. This bill would prohibit the regional water board from issuing a waste discharge permit for the proposed East Otay Mesa landfill or any other new or expanded solid waste disposal facility that might be proposed in the Reserve or in a Tijuana River tributary in the future.
- Prior legislation. AB 2601 (Eduardo Garcia, 2022) would have prohibited a regional water board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill, or a lateral expansion of an existing landfill, if the land is located within three miles of the United States’ border with Mexico. Additionally, this bill would have prohibited a regional water board from granting a variance for a new landfill or lateral expansion of an existing landfill located within three miles of the United States’ border with Mexico. This bill was held in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
- Author’s statement:
Border communities already face some of California’s most pressing environmental hazards in the form of dangerously polluted air and water that has created a public health crisis. The Tijuana River is already one of the most polluted watersheds in the nation. Allowing developers to build an unnecessary landfill in that watershed would further impact local communities that are already enduring ecological disasters. SB 1208 will protect vulnerable Californians by prohibiting a landfill that would further pollute the waters of the Tijuana River and threaten local residents.
- Double referral. This bill was previously heard by the Assembly Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee, which has jurisdiction over water quality permitting. This bill passed that committee on June 25th with a vote of 5-0.
Due to the timing of the committees’ hearings, amendments agreed to in the Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials Committee will be adopted in this committee, should the bill pass. Those amendments:- Require the Secretary of the California Environmental Protection Agency to make formal written findings, based on clear and convincing evidence, that the construction, operation, and closure/post-closure of a new nonhazardous solid waste landfill within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River will not harm or otherwise adversely affect the Tijuana River or areas tributary to the Tijuana River.
- Require a regional water board to make a finding that the waste discharge requirements protect water quality, meet water quality objectives, and protect beneficial uses.
- Add a severability clause.
- Require the Secretary of the California Environmental Protection Agency to make formal written findings, based on clear and convincing evidence, that the construction, operation, and closure/post-closure of a new nonhazardous solid waste landfill within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River will not harm or otherwise adversely affect the Tijuana River or areas tributary to the Tijuana River.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Activist San Diego
Alliance San Diego
Alonso Gonzalez, Deputy Mayor, Chula Vista
California Environmental Voters
California Latino Environmental Advocacy Network
Clean Earth 4 Kids
Food and Water Watch
Jennifer Campbell, Councilmember, San Diego
Jose Rodriguez, Council Member, Nevada City
Marni Von Wilpert, Councilmember, San Diego
Monica Montgomery Steppe, Supervisor, San Diego County
Natural Resources Defense Council
Nora Vargas, Chair, San Diego County Board of Supervisors
Paloma Aguirre, Mayor, City of Imperial Beach
Ron Morrison, Mayor, National City
San Diego Pediatricians for Clean Air
Sean Elo Rivera, Council President, City of San Diego
Sierra Club California
UDW/AFSCME Local 3930
Unite Here Local 30
1,000 individuals
Opposition
National Enterprises, Inc.
Analysis Prepared by: Elizabeth MacMillan / NAT. RES. /
Date of Hearing: June 25, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL SAFETY AND TOXIC MATERIALS
Eduardo Garcia, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1208
Author:(Padilla) – As Amended Ver:April 29, 2024
SENATE VOTE: 28-6
SUBJECT: Waste discharge permits: landfills
SUMMARY: Prohibits a Regional Water Quality Control Board (Regional Water Board) from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste, if the new landfill is to be located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve, or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the federal Clean Water Act (CWA) to regulate discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States (U.S.) and to regulate quality standards for surface waters. (33 United States Code (USC) § 1251, et seq.)
- Establishes the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit program, requiring the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board) and the nine Regional Water Boards to prescribe waste discharge requirements which, among other things, regulate the discharge of pollutants in stormwater, including municipal stormwater systems. (33 USC § 1342)
3) Prohibits a Regional Water Board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill, or a lateral expansion of an existing landfill, that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land has been primarily used at any time for the mining or excavation of gravel or sand. (Public Resources Code § 40060 (a))
4) Establishes the State Water Board and Regional Water Boards to preserve, enhance, and restore the quality of California’s water resources and drinking water for the protection of the environment, public health, and all beneficial uses, and to ensure proper water resource allocation and efficient use, for the benefit of present and future generations. (WC § 13100, et. seq.)
5) Requires each Regional Water Board to formulate and adopt water quality control plans for all areas within the region, with specified plan elements, including:
- A requirement for water quality control plans to include water quality objectives, to ensure the reasonable protection of beneficial uses and the prevention of nuisance; and,
- An authorization for water quality control plans to specify certain conditions or areas where the discharge of waste, or certain types of waste, will not be permitted. (WC § 13240, et seq.)
6) Prohibits, pursuant to the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, the discharge of waste or pollutants to surface and ground waters unless the discharger obtains a permit from the State Water Board or a Regional Water Board. (WC § 13260, et seq.)
7) Requires a Regional Water Board to prescribe requirements for any proposed discharge, existing discharge, or material change in an existing discharge, except discharges into a community sewer system, with relation to the conditions existing in the disposal area upon or receiving waters into which the discharge is made or proposed. Specifies that requirements shall implement any relevant water quality control plans that have been adopted, and take into consideration the beneficial uses to be protected, water quality objectives, other waste discharges, and the need to prevent nuisance. (WC § 13263.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown.
COMMENTS:
Need for the bill: According to the author, "Border communities already face some of California’s most pressing environmental hazards in the form of dangerously polluted air and water that has created a public health crisis. The Tijuana River is already one of the most polluted watersheds in the nation. Allowing developers to build an unnecessary landfill in that watershed would further impact local communities that are already enduring ecological disasters. SB 1208 will protect vulnerable Californians by prohibiting a landfill that would further pollute the waters of the Tijuana River and threaten local residents."
Federal Clean Water Act (CWA): The Federal Water Pollution Control Act of 1948 was the first major U.S. law to address water pollution. The law was amended in 1972 and became commonly known as the Clean Water Act (CWA). The federal CWA establishes the basic structure for regulating discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States (U.S.) and regulating quality standards for surface waters. Under the CWA, the United States Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA) has implemented pollution control programs, including setting wastewater standards for industrial facilities, as well as setting water quality standards for all contaminants in surface waters. The CWA made it unlawful to discharge any pollutant from a point source into navigable waters without a permit. Industrial, municipal, and other facilities must obtain a permit under the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System in order to discharge into surface water.
National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES): As authorized by the CWA, the NPDES Permit Program controls water pollution by regulating point sources that discharge pollutants into waters of the U.S. Point sources are discrete conveyances such as pipes or man-made ditches. Examples of pollutants include, but are not limited to, rock, sand, dirt, and agricultural, industrial, and municipal waste discharged into waters of the U.S. The NPDES Program is a federal program that has been delegated to the State of California for implementation through the State Water Board and the Regional Water Boards.
The State Water Board oversees implementation of the NPDES Permit Program throughout the state and, as such, coordinates with and supports Regional Water Board efforts, and reviews Regional Water Board actions. While the State Water Board has issued some NPDES permits, the Regional Water Boards issue the vast majority of NPDES permits in the state and ensure compliance with their permits through compliance inspections, monitoring report reviews, and enforcement actions. In California, NPDES permits are also referred to as waste discharge requirements (WDRs) that regulate discharges to waters of the U.S.
State Water Board: Created by the State Legislature in 1967, the five-member Board allocates water rights, adjudicates water right disputes, develops statewide water protection plans, establishes water quality standards, and guides the nine Regional Water Boards located in the major watersheds of the state.
Regional Water Boards: There are nine Regional Water Boards statewide. Regional boundaries are based on watersheds and water quality requirements are based on the unique differences in climate, topography, geology, and hydrology for each watershed. Each Regional Water Board makes critical water quality decisions for its region, including setting standards, issuing waste discharge requirements, determining compliance with those requirements, and taking appropriate enforcement actions.
Cross-border pollution: Several waterbodies straddle the international border between the U.S. and Mexico. Among those, the Tijuana River and the New River are recognized polluted rivers that affect both sides of the border and have required state resources to help mitigate the harm to environmental and public health.
Tijuana River watershed: According to the San Diego Regional Water Quality Control Board (San Diego Water Board), the Tijuana River watershed is a large binational watershed of approximately 1,750 square miles that lies across the California-Mexico border. A large portion of the watershed (approximately 75%) is within Mexico and encompasses the densely urbanized city of Tijuana, Baja California, Mexico. The watershed drains into the Tijuana River Estuary in the U.S. and ultimately to the Pacific Ocean in the City of Imperial Beach.
Tijuana River Estuary: According to the California Department of Parks and Recreation, the Tijuana Estuary is the largest coastal wetland in Southern California and it is located on the international border between the U.S. and Mexico. The estuary is primarily a shallow water habitat, though it is often termed an "intermittent estuary," as it undergoes extreme changes in streamflow at different times of the year. The Tijuana River Estuary is one of the few salt marshes remaining in Southern California. The site is an essential breeding, feeding, and nesting ground and key stopover point on the Pacific Flyway for over 370 species of migratory and native birds, including six endangered species.
Tijuana River pollution: In the past 30 years, the city of Tijuana, Baja California, Mexico has experienced tremendous population and industrial growth, along with rapid urbanization. According to census data presented by the National Institute of Statistics and Geography, an agency of the Mexican Government, the City of Tijuana had a population of 1,922,523 in 2020, representing a 23.3% growth in population compared to 2010 census data. The population in the City of Tijuana has nearly tripled compared to census data from 1990. This rapid growth has put a strain on aging Mexican sewage infrastructure causing serious pollution problems on both sides of the border. A concerning number of homes in the City of Tijuana do not have connections to any wastewater or solid waste collection system. These infrastructure problems result in massive flows of untreated sewage that affect the Tijuana River Estuary and adjacent beach coastal waters.
The pollution in the Tijuana River has impacted beaches and businesses and is a major public health threat in San Diego County. The San Diego Department of Environmental Health and Quality’s Beach and Bay Water Quality Program currently lists five shorelines closed to the public in South San Diego County due to bacteria levels exceeding health standards. These closures date back to December 2021. Local news stations, such as NBC 7 San Diego, have visited numerous businesses in the city of Imperial Beach that stated concerns over their revenue and the future of their small businesses, since beach closures have decreased tourism in the area. While beach closures deter the public from entering contaminated waters and prevent illnesses from direct contact, a recent study by the Scripps Institution of Oceanography suggests that bacteria from the raw, untreated sewage can be airborne and affect people living in close proximity to coastal waters. Data analyses have demonstrated that up to 76% of the bacteria people breathe in the City of Imperial Beach comes from the aerosolization of raw sewage from the Tijuana River, suggesting that pollution in the Tijuana River may have farther-reaching health consequences than previously thought. On February 14, 2024, San Diego State University's School of Public Health released a report on the escalating public health crisis due to the Tijuana River pollution. This report was commissioned by the Prebys Foundation at the request of U.S. Representative Scott Peters. Further studies are needed to understand the impacts on human health and how climate change may contribute to this crisis.
The military is also affected by untreated wastewater that enters San Diego County coastal waters. The US Naval Special Warfare Command trains in the City of Coronado and has had to move ocean training events to different locations in Southern California to protect their personnel and avoid illnesses from polluted waters. Federal Homeland Security agents assigned to the region are also exposed to hazards when patrolling in Tijuana River Valley, putting their health at risk. The impact on military and national safety operations further emphasizes the need for a comprehensive plan with proper funding to address the pollution at the border.
On June 28, 2023, members representing San Diego County in the California Legislature wrote a letter addressing Governor Newsom, to urge him to declare a state of emergency. In their letter, they state that an astonishing 100 billion gallons of untreated toxic wastewater had crossed the border since December 2018. Furthermore, 35 billion gallons had crossed the border in the first six months of 2023, demonstrating that the environmental disaster has worsened over the years.
The East Otay Mesa Recycling Collection Center and Landfill: On June 8, 2010, a county-wide initiative, Proposition A, amended San Diego County's general plan to allow for the construction and operation of a new landfill. The question before the voters of San Diego County was: "Shall this Initiative be adopted for the purpose of siting a new recycling center and class III solid waste landfill in East Otay Mesa area of unincorporated San Diego County?"
In 2011, the developer of this proposed landfill began the regulatory process by initiating the environmental review process (under state law) for a class III solid waste landfill occupying approximately 340 acres. The proposed project would be located in the unincorporated area of south San Diego County, approximately two miles east of the Siempre Viva Road exit from Interstate 905, one-quarter mile from Loop Road/Paseo De La Fuente and east of planned State Route 11. The proposed project site would be located approximately one and one-half miles from the City of San Diego, two and one-half miles from the City of Chula Vista, and one-quarter mile from the U.S./Mexico border.
According to the website of the County of San Diego Department of Health and Quality, there were two environmental documents submitted (an Initial Study and a Notice of Preparation) on September 12, 2011. There are no additional environmental documents posted since 2011. However, since that time, the project proponent has indicated they are in the process of applying for a solid waste facility permit and are preparing the environmental documents to be submitted under the California Environmental Quality Act. It is important to note that the permitting and environmental documents are being prepared only for the landfill and not for the recycling center (the voters' approval was for two projects: a recycling center and landfill). During conversations about this bill, the proponents of the landfill are confident that there will not be any negative impacts on the Tijuana River associated with the landfill. The Committee and author may wish to consider some type of requirement that ensures there will not be any negative impacts on the Tijuana River from this landfill.
If this bill passes, then this proposed landfill in Otay Mesa would not be able to receive a waste discharge permit from the San Diego Water Board, and therefore would not be able to operate.
Additionally, while the voters approved of a zoning change to allow for the recycling center and class III landfill, the project still needs to obtain the approval of various local, state and federal agencies and those regulatory approvals cannot be guaranteed in advance. This includes the requirements under the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) which include evaluating potential impacts on Native American cultural sites.
Solid waste facilities/recycling: The voters in San Diego County approved projects for a recycling center and a landfill. Since this vote, state law has changed considerably as it relates to recycling and landfills. As a result of the passage of SB 1383 (Lara, Chapter 395, Statutes of 2016), all new or expanding landfills must implement organic waste recovery activities as described in regulations adopted by the Department of Resources, Recycling and Recovery (CalRecycle). Additionally, SB 54 (Allen, Chapter 75, Statutes of 2022) enacted the Plastic Pollution Prevention and Packaging Producer Responsibility Act, which requires producers (manufacturers) of packaging and single-use plastic food ware products to ensure that the products are recyclable or compostable. These two laws dramatically change the nature of recycling and the role of landfills in California.
This bill is double-referred to the Assembly Natural Resources Committee, where issues of recycling and landfills (including landfill capacity) will be discussed in greater detail.
CalEnviroScreen: In order to address the cumulative effects of both pollution burden and certain population characteristics, and to identify which communities might be in need of particular policy, investment, or programmatic interventions, the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) developed and now maintains and updates the CalEnviroScreen tool on behalf of the California Environmental Protection Agency (CalEPA). The tool applies a framework, developed by OEHHA in 2010, for assessing cumulative impacts. According to OEHHA cumulative impacts refer to exposures and public health or environmental effects from all sources of pollution in a geographic area. Cumulative impacts also take into account groups of people that are especially sensitive to the effects of pollution and socioeconomic factors. The CalEnviroScreen tool's framework is based in large part on input from a statewide working group on environmental justice that pointed out the unmet need to assess cumulative burdens and vulnerabilities affecting California communities. The tool uses thirteen pollution burden indicator and eight population characteristics in order to calculate a score. According to CalEnviroScreen 4.0, Otay Mesa, the site of the proposed landfill, has a score in the 90-100% (which is the most burdened percentile). Therefore, citing a solid waste landfill in this area could increase the pollution burden this community already is faced with.
This bill: SB 1208 would prohibit the San Diego Water Board from issuing a waste discharge permit for the proposed landfill in Otay Mesa. The author's concern is the overwhelming pollution burden facing the community, the region, and the Tijuana River Watershed. If this bill is enacted, it would likely mean that the landfill could not operate (if constructed). Some stakeholders have raised legal concerns around this.
Legal considerations: During discussions on this bill, some stakeholders have opined that the state cannot change the rules and effectively prohibit this particular landfill from operating. It has been noted that the vote of the people in San Diego approved a zoning change – but that vote cannot alone guarantee approval of the various local, state, and federal permits that are required for this landfill. In other words, even with the locally approved voting change, the project may not achieve the necessary permits, with or without a bill. However, this is an important conversation, and one best had in the Assembly Judiciary Committee. This bill has not been referred to that committee; however, if the bill continues to move through the process, perhaps their expertise could be sought to help shed some light on any potential legal issues there might be if this bill were to be enacted.
Options for consideration: As currently drafted, the bill, if enacted, would likely mean the landfill could not open. However, given that the voters in San Diego County voted on a recycling center and landfill, there could be other options to consider. These options could recognize that while there was a vote, it was over a decade ago and the state of recycling in California has drastically changed. Additionally, the voters approved two projects and currently only the landfill is moving forward. Some options, taken alone or combined, for consideration include:
- Should approval of waste discharge requirements for landfill, be contingent on the approval and operation of the recycling center that was also approved by the voters?
- Given that the state of recycling has changed, should there be a review of a need for this facility by CalRecycle and potentially, should CalRecycle also certify that the landfill will meet the requirements of SB 1383 and SB 54?
- Could the prohibition on the waste discharge requirements for the landfill be removed, if, after enactment of this bill, the voters of San Diego County were to approve a new measure (given that a lot has changed since the vote 14 years ago)?
- The Secretary of CalEPA could be required to make formal written findings, based on clear and convincing evidence, that the construction, operation, and closure/post-closure of a new nonhazardous solid waste landfill within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River will not harm or otherwise adversely affect the Tijuana River or areas tributary to the Tijuana River.
- A regional water board makes a finding that the waste discharge requirements protect water quality, meet water quality objectives, and protect beneficial uses.
Arguments in support: According to a coalition in support of the bill, "The project could impair water and air quality throughout the Tijuana River Watershed, including the Tijuana River Valley and Estuary, contributing to harmful health impacts to downstream communities in a region already burdened by the cross border pollution crisis, one of the worst ongoing public health and environmental justice crises in the country.
There is no need for a new landfill in San Diego County, as the county has more than adequate assured disposal capacity for the next 30 years as documented in San Diego County’s 2022 detailed analysis of the region’s landfill capacity. We applaud Senator Padilla’s recognition that "we all live downstream", and, pointedly, that an unnecessary landfill developed in the watershed of the already impaired Tijuana River could adversely affect water and air quality in the lower watershed and exacerbate the ongoing pollution issues from which our border cities and communities have suffered for decades.
The protection of the Tijuana River tributary system from the significant and irreparable impacts of a proposed new landfill is critical and imperative. That fragile system is affected by transboundary flows, disturbances to hydrologic conditions, and impacts from land uses.
The Tijuana River Valley experiences transboundary flows which contain treated and untreated wastewater, groundwater, stormwater, surface water run-off and trash. Cross-border canyon tributaries along the U.S.-Mexico border operate as entry points for transboundary flows into the Tijuana River, carrying pollutants in sediment from the canyons and upstream in the river.
The construction of a landfill disturbs an area’s natural hydrology. The removal of existing vegetation and alteration of the natural slopes and soils changes the hydrologic conditions which affects stormwater, run-off and erosion patterns. Stormwater, run-off and erosion flow through the watershed, carrying pollutants downstream. Given the topography and terrain of the location, the proposed project would require extensive grading and excavation – earth-moving and land alteration activities which would disturb the hydrology of the area."
Arguments in opposition: According to National Enterprises, Inc., "SB 1208 is a solution in search of a problem. While we deeply respect the author's steadfast leadership on the restoration of the Tijuana River, SB 1208 is based on the false premise that the proposed East Otay Mesa recycling and landfill project will pollute the river. There is no basis for this claim other than overly simplified refrains that the landfill could drain even more pollution into the Pacific Ocean and elementary illustrations of discharge flowing south from the proposed site.
SB 1208 undermines San Diego voters' approval and property rights. In 2010, County of San Diego voters approved Proposition A, by 84.49% to allow for the construction and operation of a recycling collection center and class III solid waste landfill on the East Otay Mesa project site. SB 1208 flagrantly defies the voters and provides them with no viable alternative."
Double-referral: Should this bill pass this Committee it will be re-referred to the Assembly Natural Resources Committee.
Related legislation:
1) AJR 12 (Alvarez). Urges the U.S Congress to support President Joseph R. Biden’s $310 million supplemental funding request for the U.S. Section of the International Boundary and Water Commission (USIBWC), due to the ongoing impacts to public health, the environment, and the local economy caused by cross-border pollution in the Tijuana River Valley; urges President Joseph R. Biden to declare a national emergency due to those ongoing impacts; and urges the U.S. Congress to secure funding for the New River Project to address the impacts on public health, the environment, and the local economy of Imperial County. This measure is pending action on the Senate Floor.
2) AB 1597 (Alvarez). Authorizes, upon appropriation by the Legislature, funds to be made available to the North American Development Bank (NADBank) for loans, grants, and direct expenditures that address water quality problems of the California-Mexico cross-border rivers, including the New and Tijuana Rivers; authorizes appropriation of funds to recipients that are authorized to work in Mexico, if recipients are, or consent to be, subject to the jurisdiction of the California courts for enforcement purposes, and if the project will provide water quality benefits to California. This bill is pending action in the Senate Environmental Quality Committee.
- AB 2601 (Garcia, 2022). Would have prohibited a Regional Water Board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill, or a lateral expansion of an existing landfill, that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land is located within three miles of the U.S. border with Mexico. Additionally, would have prohibited a Regional Water Board from granting a variance for a new landfill or lateral expansion of an existing landfill located within three miles of the U.S. border with Mexico. This bill was held on the suspense file in the Assembly Appropriations Committee and subsequently died on file.
- SB 833 (Vargas, 2011). Would have prohibited the operation of a solid waste landfill in San Diego County that is located within 1,000 feet of the San Luis Rey River and within 1,000 feet of a Native American sacred site. This bill was vetoed by the Governor.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Activist San Diego
Alliance San Diego
Azul
California Coastal Protection Network
California Environmental Voters (formerly CLCV)
California Latino Environmental Advocacy Network
Californians Against Waste
Center for Biological Diversity
Chair Nora Vargas, San Diego County Board of Supervisors
Chula Vista Deputy Mayor Alonso Gonzalez
Clean Earth 4 Kids
Cleanearth4kids.org
Climate Action Campaign
Council Member Jose Rodriguez, City of National City
Council President Sean Elo Rivera, City of San Diego
Endangered Habitats League
Environmental Center of San Diego
Food & Water Watch
Mayor Paloma Aguirre - City of Imperial Beach
National City Mayor Ron Morrison
Natural Resources Defense Council (NRDC)
Over 1000 Individuals
Protect Otay Foothills
San Diego Audubon Society
San Diego Coastkeeper
San Diego Councilmember Jennifer Campbell
San Diego Councilmember Marni Von Wilpert
San Diego County Democrats for Environmental Action
San Diego Pediatricians for Clean Air
San Diego350
Sierra Club California
Supervisor Monica Montgomery Steppe
Surfrider Foundation San Diego Chapter
UDW/AFSCME Local 3930
Unite Here Local 30
Wildcoast
Youth Will
Opposition
California Building Industry Association
National Enterprises, Inc.
Analysis Prepared by: Josh Tooker / E.S. & T.M. /
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1208 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: SB 1208
Author: Padilla (D)
Amended: 4/29/24
Vote: 21
SENATE ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY COMMITTEE: 4-0, 4/24/24
AYES: Gonzalez, Hurtado, Menjivar, Skinner
NO VOTE RECORDED: Allen, Dahle, Nguyen
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 5-2, 5/16/24
AYES: Caballero, Ashby, Becker, Bradford, Wahab
NOES: Jones, Seyarto
SUBJECT: Waste discharge permits: landfills
SOURCE: Author
DIGEST:
This bill rohibits a Regional Water Quality Control Board (Regional Water Board) from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land is located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River, except as provided.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit program and authorizes the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board) and the nine Regional Water Boards to prescribe waste discharge requirements (WDRs) which, among other things, regulate the discharge of pollutants in stormwater, including municipal stormwater systems. (33 USC § 1342; Water Code (WC) § 13377)
3) Prohibits, pursuant to the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, the discharge of pollutants to surface waters unless the discharger obtains a permit from the State Water Board or a Regional Water Board. (WC § 13000, et seq.)
4) Requires a Regional Water Board to prescribe requirements for any proposed discharge, existing discharge, or material change in an existing discharge, except discharges into a community sewer system, with relation to the conditions existing in the disposal area upon or receiving waters into which the discharge is made or proposed. Specifies that requirements must implement any relevant water quality control plans that have been adopted, and take into consideration, the beneficial uses to be protected, water quality objectives, other waste discharges, the need to prevent nuisance and other factors. (WC § 13263)
This bill:
- Prohibits a Regional Water Board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land is located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River. Provides that this provision does not apply to a public agency restoration and beneficial reuse project for abandoned sand and gravel mining quarries located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River.
- Expands the definition of “landfill used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste” to also include a disposal site regulated by a Regional Water Board as a Class II landfill, as provided.
Background
- Federal Clean Water Act (CWA). The Federal Water Pollution Control Act of 1948 was the first major U.S. law to address water pollution. The law was amended in 1972 and became commonly known as the Clean Water Act (CWA). The federal CWA establishes the basic structure for regulating discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States and regulating quality standards for surface waters. Under the CWA, the United States Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) has implemented pollution control programs, including setting wastewater standards for industrial facilities, as well as setting water quality standards for contaminants in surface waters. The CWA made it unlawful to discharge any pollutant from a point source into navigable waters without a permit. Industrial, municipal, and other facilities must obtain a permit under the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System in order to discharge into surface water.
- National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES). As authorized by the CWA, the NPDES Permit Program controls water pollution by regulating point sources that discharge pollutants into waters of the United States. Point sources are discrete conveyances such as pipes or man-made ditches. Examples of pollutants include, but are not limited to, rock, sand, dirt, and agricultural, industrial, and municipal waste discharged into waters of the United States. The NPDES Program is a federal program which has been delegated to the State of California for implementation through the State Water Board and the Regional Water Boards.
- Tijuana River and Estuary Contamination. The Tijuana River flows north from Tijuana into the Tijuana River and Estuary (TJRE) in the U.S., emptying into the Pacific Ocean at Imperial Beach. The TJRE is severely contaminated by untreated sewage, industrial waste, and urban run-off due to inadequate infrastructure and urbanization and the watershed is classified as an impaired water body according to the U.S. Clean Water Act. This contamination is a persistent environmental and public health threat with major economic, legal, social, and health implications for the nearby communities such as San Ysidro and Imperial Beach, according to a February 13, 2024, white paper from the San Diego State University, School of Public Health, titled Tijuana River Contamination from Urban Runoff and Sewage: A Public Health Crisis at the Border.
- Environmental impacts of landfills. In support of this measure, the author provided the committee with a July 2022 article from Environmental Science and Pollution Research, titled An overview of the environmental pollution and health effects associated with waste landfilling and open dumping. The article reports that landfilling is associated with various environmental pollution problems, namely, underground water pollution due to the leaching of organic, inorganic, and various other substances of concern contained in the waste, air pollution due to suspension of particles, odor pollution from the deposition of municipal solid waste, and even marine pollution from any potential run-offs. Further, the research shows health impacts may occur through the pollution of the underground water and the emissions of gases, leading to carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic effects of the exposed population living in their vicinity.
- The East Otay Mesa Recycling Collection Center and Landfill. More than a decade ago, San Diego County voters approved a county-wide initiative to allow for the construction and operation of a landfill and recycling center in East Otay Mesa. In 2011, a proposal submitted for a class III solid waste landfill occupying approximately 340 acres of the 450-acre site. The remaining 110 acres would remain undeveloped with an additional 1000-foot buffer. The proposed project is located in the unincorporated area of south San Diego County, approximately one and one-half miles from the City of San Diego, two and one-half miles from the City of Chula Vista, and one-quarter mile from the United States/Mexico border. If this bill passes, this proposed landfill in East Otay Mesa would not be able to receive a waste discharge permit from the Regional Water Board.
- San Diego’s land-fill capacity. San Diego has 12 facilities that process waste: eight recycling and transfer stations and four landfills: Otay Mesa Landfill, Miramar Landfill, Sycamore Landfill, and Borrego Landfill. Two of the largest landfills (Miramar and Otay) are set to close by 2030.
On September 20, 2022, CalRecycle approved the Five-Year Review Report for the Countywide Integrated Waste Management Plan for the County of San Diego. The report indicates that the county has enough capacity with existing landfills to last through 2053. However, this scenario assumes the Sycamore Landfill will apply for three expansions to their daily permitted capacity. Sycamore Landfill has complete California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) for these landfill expansions; however, there has been no application to the Local Enforcement Agency to revise the Solid Waste Facility Permit. The disposal projection scenario also assumes the county will meet aggressive recycling and organic waste targets, thereby diverting a greater rate of organic materials from the landfills. - CalEnviroScreen. In order to address the cumulative effects of both pollution burden and these additional factors, and to identify which communities might be in need of particular policy, investment, or programmatic interventions, the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) developed and now maintains and updates the CalEnviroScreen tool on behalf of CalEPA. The tool applies a framework, developed by OEHHA in 2010, for assessing cumulative impacts. According to OEHHA cumulative impacts refer to exposures and public health or environmental effects from all sources of pollution in a geographic area. Cumulative impacts also take into account groups of people that are especially sensitive to the effects of pollution and socioeconomic factors. According to CalEnviroScreen 4.0, Otay Mesa, the site of the proposed landfill, has a score in the 90-100% (which is the most polluted percentile).
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “Border communities already face some of California’s most pressing environmental justice challenges. The Tijuana River is already one of the most polluted watersheds in the nation. Allowing developers to build an unnecessary landfill in that watershed would further impact local communities that are already enduring ecological disasters. SB 1208 will protect vulnerable Californians by prohibiting a landfill that would further pollute the waters of the Tijuana River and threaten local residents.”
- Is the landfill needed? As discussed above, Tijuana River contamination is a persistent environmental and public health threat for the nearby communities. The author contends that citing a solid waste landfill at East Otay Mesa would increase the pollution burden of already overburdened border communities.
The author further maintains that the East Otay Mesa landfill is “not necessary as the County of San Diego has found the current landfill capacity will last through 2053.” Proponents of the proposal argue that with efforts to meet aggressive state goals and continued improvements in recycling, “there is a significant potential for increased waste diversion, which would extend landfill capacity over an even longer term.” While this may be true, as noted previously, the projections of San Diego’s landfill capacity are predicated on the anticipated expansions of Sycamore Landfill.
It is worth noting that the proposed East Otay Mesa landfill includes a recycling center (RCC) and organic waste processing and composting facility. The RCC would contain a materials recovery facility which would be used to separate recyclable materials to be hauled off-site. - Negates Regional Water Board authority and expertise. This bill prohibits the San Diego Regional Water Board from issuing a waste discharge permit for the proposed landfill in East Otay Mesa, thereby stopping the project from moving forward. This approach, however, negates the existing decision-making authority and expertise of the Regional Water Board, whose job it is to ensure landfills comply with existing laws and procedures that protect water quality from the impacts of landfill operations. Board approval of a waste discharge permit for a new Class III landfill, such as East Otay Mesa, is an extensive, project specific process. State regulations specify general construction criteria, criteria for containment structures, liners, leachate collection and removal systems, subsurface barriers, precipitation and drainage controls, as well as requirements for water quality monitoring.
Once a permit applicant submits a Report of Waste Discharge (ROWD), a yearlong Board staff review of the application begins, followed by staff preparation of the draft WDRs. The completion of the draft WDRs triggers a public review and comment process. Then, the draft WDRs is publicly noticed for consideration by the Regional Water Board. The Board can vote to approve the WDRs, deny, or grant limited approval if any outstanding concerns cannot be mitigated. If approved, the Regional Water Board has authority to enforce all aspects of the WDRs, including groundwater monitoring requirements. Importantly, current law states that all discharges of waste into waters of the state are privileges, not rights. - Overburdening existing landfills? Stopping the East Otay Mesa landfill from moving forward could also result in increased demands on San Diego’s existing waste disposal infrastructure and landfills. Opponents of this measure argue that SB 1208 would “effectively extend the life and heights of existing landfills that are known to be harming residents,” noting that Sycamore landfill, the landfill that is anticipated to be expanded, is located less than a half mile away from a residential area, increasing the likelihood for potential exposures to methane emissions. Further, opponents argue that the bill would inappropriately “undermine the will of San Diego County voters” and impede “ongoing and rigorous environmental review of a proposed recycling and landfill facility – effectively undermining the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).”
- Question for consideration. While it is clear that TJRE is severely contaminated by untreated sewage and that this has created a public health crisis at the border, it is less clear what potential impacts a new landfill at East Otay Mesa will have on the Tijuana River watershed and neighboring communities. These impacts are currently being evaluated through the CEQA process. Further, without this bill, the potential water quality impacts of the project would be vetted through the Regional Water Board.
A question for consideration is whether the potential health and environmental impacts to overburdened border communities warrant a blanket prohibition on new landfills in the TJRE, thereby stopping a voter-approved local project, or if it is more appropriate to let CEQA process currently underway and the anticipated Regional Water Board regulatory process play out. The latter option would enable the Board to assess the specific impacts of the proposed landfill and require appropriate mitigation measures to protect water quality.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, “The Water Boards estimate ongoing costs of approximately $900,000 annually (Waste Discharge Permit Fund) to address unintended consequences that the State Water Board anticipates resulting from this bill’s provisions. The costs would be primarily associated with enforcement actions, involving minor, moderate, and major violations of water quality statutes and regulations, and would depend on the number, type, and severity of the violations that occur.”
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/16/24)
Azul
California Coastal Protection Network
California Coastkeeper Alliance
Californians Against Waste
Center for Biological Diversity
Center for Biological Diversity, INC.
Chula Vista Deputy Mayor Alonso Gonzalez
City of Chula Vista Office of Deputy Mayor Alonso Gonzalez 2024
City of National City
Cleanearth4kids.org
Climate Action Campaign
Council Member Jose Rodriguez, City of National City
Councilmember Sean Elo-rivera, City of San Diego, District 9
Endangered Habitats League
Environmental Center of San Diego
Mayor Paloma Aguirre - City of Imperial Beach
Morning Sun Clare
National City Councilmember Jose Rodriguez
Natural Resources Defense Council
Office of Supervisor Nora Vargas, San Diego County Board of Supervisors
Protect Otay Foothills
San Diego Audubon Society
San Diego Coastkeeper
San Diego Councilmember Jennifer Campbell
San Diego Councilmember Marni Von Wilpert
San Diego County Democrats for Environmental Action
San Diego Pediatricians for Clean Air
San Diego350
Sandiego350
Sierra Club California
Surfrider Foundation San Diego Chapter
Surfrider Foundation San Diego County
Wildcoast
203 individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 05/16/2024)
California Building Industry Association
Councilmember Moreno, City of San Diego
National Enterprises, INC.
Otay Mesa Chamber of Commerce
1 individual
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to the San Diego Coastkeeper, Surfrider Foundation of San Diego County, and Protect Otay Foothills, “This legislation addresses our grave concerns about a new private landfill proposed to be developed in that tributary system in the upper Tijuana River Watershed in the Otay Mountain Foothills.
“The project could impair water and air quality throughout the Tijuana River Watershed, including the Tijuana River Valley and Estuary, causing negative health impacts to downstream communities in a region already burdened by one of the worst ongoing public health and environmental justice crises in the country.
“Fundamentally, there is no need for a new landfill in San Diego County, as the County has more than adequate assured disposal capacity as documented in the County’s detailed analysis of the region’s landfill capacity. We applaud Senator Padilla’s recognition that “we all live downstream”, and pointedly that an unnecessary landfill developed in the watershed of the already impaired Tijuana River, could adversely affect water and air quality in the lower watershed and exacerbate the ongoing pollution issues from which our border cities and communities have suffered for decades.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to National Enterprises, Inc., “While we share in your concern and appreciate your steadfast leadership on the restoration of the Tijuana River, SB 1208 would also effectively extend the life and heights of existing toxic landfills that are known to be harming residents in your district, require your residents pay even more for waste and recycling, and undermine the will of San Diego County voters. Furthermore, SB 1208 inappropriate impedes on ongoing and rigorous environmental review of a proposed recycling and landfill facility – effectively undermining the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).
“SB 1208 undermines San Diego County Voters Approval of Environmentally Superior Alternative located outside of the Tijuana River NERR [National Estuarine Research Reserve]. In 2010, County of San Diego voters approved, with 84.49%, Proposition A to allow for the construction and operation of a recycling collection center and class III solid waste landfill on the East Otay Mesa project site…
“In contrast to existing facilities, the project is currently going through stringent environmental review by the San Diego Solid Waste Local Enforcement Agency (LEA) and a Draft Environmental Impact Report (EIR) is being prepared. This is the appropriate process for studying any potential impacts to the Tijuana River watershed and identifying any necessary mitigations.”
Prepared by: Gabrielle Meindl / E.Q. / (916) 651-4108
5/17/24 17:19:24
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
SB 1208 (Padilla) - Waste discharge permits: landfills
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
This bill would prohibit a Regional Water Quality Control Board (Regional Water Board) from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land is located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River, except as provided.
Fiscal Impact:
- The Water Boards estimate ongoing costs of approximately $900,000 annually (Waste Discharge Permit Fund) to address unintended consequences that the State Water Board anticipates resulting from this bill’s provisions. The costs would be primarily associated with enforcement actions, involving minor, moderate, and major violations of water quality statutes and regulations, and would depend on the number, type, and severity of the violations that occur.
Background:
Federal Clean Water Act (CWA). The Federal Water Pollution Control Act of 1948 was the first major U.S. law to address water pollution. The law was amended in 1972 and became commonly known as the Clean Water Act (CWA). The federal CWA establishes the basic structure for regulating discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States and regulating quality standards for surface waters. Under the CWA, the United States Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) has implemented pollution control programs, including setting wastewater standards for industrial facilities, as well as setting water quality standards for contaminants in surface waters. The CWA made it unlawful to discharge any pollutant from a point source into navigable waters without a permit. Industrial, municipal, and other facilities must obtain a permit under the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System in order to discharge into surface water.
National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES). As authorized by the CWA, the NPDES Permit Program controls water pollution by regulating point sources that discharge pollutants into waters of the United States. Point sources are discrete conveyances such as pipes or man-made ditches. Examples of pollutants include, but are not limited to, rock, sand, dirt, and agricultural, industrial, and municipal waste discharged into waters of the United States. The NPDES Program is a federal program which has been delegated to the State of California for implementation through the State Water Board and the Regional Water Boards.
Tijuana River and Estuary Contamination. The Tijuana River flows north from Tijuana into the Tijuana River and Estuary (TJRE) in the U.S., emptying into the Pacific Ocean at Imperial Beach. The TJRE is severely contaminated by untreated sewage, industrial waste, and urban run-off due to inadequate infrastructure and urbanization and the watershed is classified as an impaired water body according to the U.S. Clean Water Act. This contamination is a persistent environmental and public health threat with major economic, legal, social, and health implications for the nearby communities such as San Ysidro and Imperial Beach, according to a February 13, 2024, white paper from the San Diego State University, School of Public Health, titled Tijuana River Contamination from Urban Runoff and Sewage: A Public Health Crisis at the Border.
Environmental impacts of landfills. In support of this measure, the author provided the committee with a July 2022 article from Environmental Science and Pollution Research, titled An overview of the environmental pollution and health effects associated with waste landfilling and open dumping. The article reports that landfilling is associated with various environmental pollution problems, namely, underground water pollution due to the leaching of organic, inorganic, and various other substances of concern contained in the waste, air pollution due to suspension of particles, odor pollution from the deposition of municipal solid waste, and even marine pollution from any potential run-offs. Further, the research shows health impacts may occur through the pollution of the underground water and the emissions of gases, leading to carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic effects of the exposed population living in their vicinity.
It should be noted that this article was based on a “desk review,” which is a scientific method that involves scanning the available body of literature. The study did not specifically look at the environmental impacts of landfills in California. California’s Regional Water Boards are required to ensure landfills comply with existing laws and procedures that protect water quality from the impacts of landfill operations.
The East Otay Mesa Recycling Collection Center and Landfill. More than a decade ago, San Diego County voters approved a county-wide initiative to allow for the construction and operation of a landfill and recycling center in East Otay Mesa. In 2011, a proposal submitted for a class III solid waste landfill occupying approximately 340 acres of the 450-acre site. The remaining 110 acres would remain undeveloped with an additional 1000-foot buffer. The proposed project is located in the unincorporated area of south San Diego County, approximately one and one-half miles from the City of San Diego, two and one-half miles from the City of Chula Vista, and one-quarter mile from the United States/Mexico border. If this bill passes, this proposed landfill in East Otay Mesa would not be able to receive a waste discharge permit from the Regional Water Board.
San Diego’s land-fill capacity. San Diego has 12 facilities that process waste: eight recycling and transfer stations and four landfills: Otay Mesa Landfill, Miramar Landfill, Sycamore Landfill, and Borrego Landfill. Two of the largest landfills (Miramar and Otay) are set to close by 2030.
On September 20, 2022, CalRecycle approved the Five-Year Review Report for the Countywide Integrated Waste Management Plan for the County of San Diego. The report indicates that the county has enough capacity with existing landfills to last through 2053. However, this scenario assumes the Sycamore Landfill will apply for three expansions to their daily permitted capacity. Sycamore Landfill has complete California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) for these landfill expansions; however, there has been no application to the Local Enforcement Agency to revise the Solid Waste Facility Permit. The disposal projection scenario also assumes the county will meet aggressive recycling and organic waste targets, thereby diverting a greater rate of organic materials from the landfills.
As noted above, the report references that Miramar and Otay are estimated to close by 2030. This closure date may happen earlier, opponents argue, since, to date, diversion targets have not been met. “If that does happen, Sycamore may not be fully prepared or even authorized to accept higher inflows,” according to opponents.
CalEnviroScreen. In order to address the cumulative effects of both pollution burden and these additional factors, and to identify which communities might be in need of particular policy, investment, or programmatic interventions, the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) developed and now maintains and updates the CalEnviroScreen tool on behalf of CalEPA. The tool applies a framework, developed by OEHHA in 2010, for assessing cumulative impacts. According to OEHHA cumulative impacts refer to exposures and public health or environmental effects from all sources of pollution in a geographic area. Cumulative impacts also take into account groups of people that are especially sensitive to the effects of pollution and socioeconomic factors. The CalEnviroScreen tool's framework is based in large part on input from a statewide working group on environmental justice that pointed out the unmet need to assess cumulative burdens and vulnerabilities affecting California communities. According to CalEnviroScreen 4.0, Otay Mesa, the site of the proposed landfill, has a score in the 90-100% (which is the most polluted percentile).
Proposed Law:
This bill would prohibit a Regional Water Board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land is located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River, except as provided. This bill would:
- Prohibit a Regional Water Board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land is located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River.
- Expand the definition of “landfill used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste” to also include a disposal site regulated by a Regional Water Board as a Class II landfill, as provided.
- Provide that it does not apply to a public agency restoration and beneficial reuse project for abandoned sand and gravel mining quarries located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River.
Related Legislation:
AB 2601 (Garcia, 2022) would have prohibited a Regional Water Board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill, or a lateral expansion of an existing landfill, that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land is located within three miles of the United States border with Mexico. This bill was held on suspense in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 1383 (Garcia, Chapter 395, Statutes of 2016) establishes methane emissions reduction targets in a statewide effort to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants including to reduce the disposal of organic waste 75 percent below 2014 levels by 2025 and to recover 20 percent of edible food for human consumption that is currently landfilled by 2025.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON ENVIRONMENTAL QUALITY
Senator Allen, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB 1208
Author: | Padilla | ||
Version: | 2/15/2024 | Hearing Date: | 4/24/2024 |
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Gabrielle Meindl | ||
SUBJECT: Waste discharge permits: landfills
DIGEST: Prohibits a Regional Water Quality Control Board (Regional Water Board) from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land is located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the federal Clean Water Act (CWA) to regulate discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States and to regulate quality standards for surface waters. (33 United States Code (USC) §1251 et seq.)
- Establishes the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) permit program and authorizes the State Water Resources Control Board (State Water Board) and the nine Regional Water Boards to prescribe waste discharge requirements (WDRs) which, among other things, regulate the discharge of pollutants in stormwater, including municipal stormwater systems. (33 USC § 1342; Water Code (WC) § 13377)
3) Prohibits a Regional Water Board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill, or a lateral expansion of an existing landfill, that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land has been primarily used at any time for the mining or excavation of gravel or sand. (Public Resources Code § 40060 (a))
4) Prohibits, pursuant to the Porter-Cologne Water Quality Control Act, the discharge of pollutants to surface waters unless the discharger obtains a permit from the State Water Board or a Regional Water Board. (WC § 13000, et seq.)
5) Requires California’s Regional Water Boards to adopt water quality standards within their region of jurisdiction. (WC § 13240)
6) Requires a Regional Water Board to prescribe requirements for any proposed discharge, existing discharge, or material change in an existing discharge, except discharges into a community sewer system, with relation to the conditions existing in the disposal area upon or receiving waters into which the discharge is made or proposed. Specifies that requirements must implement any relevant water quality control plans that have been adopted, and take into consideration, the beneficial uses to be protected, water quality objectives, other waste discharges, the need to prevent nuisance and other factors. (WC § 13263)
This bill:
- Prohibits a Regional Water Board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land is located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River.
- Expands the definition of “landfill used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste” to also include a disposal site regulated by a Regional Water Board as a Class II landfill, as provided.
Background
- Federal Clean Water Act (CWA). The Federal Water Pollution Control Act of 1948 was the first major U.S. law to address water pollution. The law was amended in 1972 and became commonly known as the Clean Water Act (CWA). The federal CWA establishes the basic structure for regulating discharges of pollutants into the waters of the United States and regulating quality standards for surface waters. Under the CWA, the United States Environmental Protection Agency (U.S. EPA) has implemented pollution control programs, including setting wastewater standards for industrial facilities, as well as setting water quality standards for contaminants in surface waters. The CWA made it unlawful to discharge any pollutant from a point source into navigable waters without a permit. Industrial, municipal, and other facilities must obtain a permit under the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System in order to discharge into surface water.
- National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES). As authorized by the CWA, the NPDES Permit Program controls water pollution by regulating point sources that discharge pollutants into waters of the United States. Point sources are discrete conveyances such as pipes or man-made ditches. Examples of pollutants include, but are not limited to, rock, sand, dirt, and agricultural, industrial, and municipal waste discharged into waters of the United States. The NPDES Program is a federal program which has been delegated to the State of California for implementation through the State Water Board and the Regional Water Boards.
- State Water Board. Created by the State Legislature in 1967, the five-member Board allocates water rights, adjudicates water right disputes, develops statewide water protection plans, establishes water quality standards, and guides the nine Regional Water Boards located in the major watersheds of the state
- Regional Water Boards. There are nine regional water quality control boards statewide. Regional boundaries are primarily based on watersheds and some water quality requirements may be based on the unique differences in climate, topography, geology, and hydrology for each watershed. Each Regional Water Board makes critical water quality decisions for its region, including setting standards, issuing WDRs, determining compliance with those requirements, and taking appropriate enforcement actions.
By taking away the Regional Water Board’s authority to issue waste discharge permits, this bill would establish a blanket prohibition on new landfills in the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River. - Tijuana River and Estuary Contamination. The Tijuana River flows north from Tijuana into the Tijuana River and Estuary (TJRE) in the U.S., emptying into the Pacific Ocean at Imperial Beach. The TJRE is severely contaminated by untreated sewage, industrial waste, and urban run-off due to inadequate infrastructure and urbanization and the watershed is classified as an impaired water body according to the U.S. Clean Water Act. This contamination is a persistent environmental and public health threat with major economic, legal, social, and health implications for the nearby communities such as San Ysidro and Imperial Beach, according to a February 13, 2024, white paper from the San Diego State University, School of Public Health, titled Tijuana River Contamination from Urban Runoff and Sewage: A Public Health Crisis at the Border. Below is an excerpt from the white paper:
“Threats to public health include known concerns posed by any exposure to untreated sewage in the U.S., but of special concern and specific to this watershed are the unusual threats to health from pollutants arising in Mexico, including human and livestock diseases eradicated in California, pathogens carrying antibiotic-resistant genes, and industrial and municipal chemicals not permitted to be discharged into the environment in California, among others…Contaminated water is flowing into the ocean year-round, and, especially after rain events, has forced beach closures in the region for years; however, this problem does not just adversely affect beachgoers and surfers exposed to contaminated seawater. Exposures impact the health of people who live and work nearby like children, seniors, lifeguards, military personnel, border patrol officers and other at-risk populations. Current regulation and monitoring measures are inadequate in relation to known contaminants yet potential health risks to surrounding communities from harmful viruses, bacteria and parasites as well as toxic chemicals in water and air, presenting a pressing public health crisis.”
- Environmental impacts of landfills. In support of this measure, the author provided the committee with a July 2022 article from Environmental Science and Pollution Research, titled An overview of the environmental pollution and health effects associated with waste landfilling and open dumping. The article reports that landfilling is associated with various environmental pollution problems, namely, underground water pollution due to the leaching of organic, inorganic, and various other substances of concern contained in the waste, air pollution due to suspension of particles, odor pollution from the deposition of municipal solid waste, and even marine pollution from any potential run-offs. Further, the research shows health impacts may occur through the pollution of the underground water and the emissions of gases, leading to carcinogenic and non-carcinogenic effects of the exposed population living in their vicinity.
It should be noted that this article was based on a “desk review,” which is a scientific method that involves scanning the available body of literature. The study did not specifically look at the environmental impacts of landfills in California. California’s Regional Water Boards are required to ensure landfills comply with existing laws and procedures that protect water quality from the impacts of landfill operations. - The East Otay Mesa Recycling Collection Center and Landfill. More than a decade ago, San Diego County voters approved a county-wide initiative to allow for the construction and operation of a landfill and recycling center in East Otay Mesa. In 2011, a proposal submitted for a class III solid waste landfill occupying approximately 340 acres of the 450-acre site. The remaining 110 acres would remain undeveloped with an additional 1000-foot buffer. The proposed project is located in the unincorporated area of south San Diego County, approximately one and one-half miles from the City of San Diego, two and one-half miles from the City of Chula Vista, and one-quarter mile from the United States/Mexico border. If this bill passes, this proposed landfill in East Otay Mesa would not be able to receive a waste discharge permit from the Regional Water Board.
- San Diego’s land-fill capacity. San Diego has 12 facilities that process waste: eight recycling and transfer stations and four landfills: Otay Mesa Landfill, Miramar Landfill, Sycamore Landfill, and Borrego Landfill. Two of the largest landfills (Miramar and Otay) are set to close by 2030.
On September 20, 2022, CalRecycle approved the Five-Year Review Report for the Countywide Integrated Waste Management Plan for the County of San Diego. The report indicates that the county has enough capacity with existing landfills to last through 2053. However, this scenario assumes the Sycamore Landfill will apply for three expansions to their daily permitted capacity. Sycamore Landfill has complete California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA) for these landfill expansions; however, there has been no application to the Local Enforcement Agency to revise the Solid Waste Facility Permit. The disposal projection scenario also assumes the county will meet aggressive recycling and organic waste targets, thereby diverting a greater rate of organic materials from the landfills.
As noted above, the report references that Miramar and Otay are estimated to close by 2030. This closure date may happen earlier, opponents argue, since, to date, diversion targets have not been met. “If that does happen, Sycamore may not be fully prepared or even authorized to accept higher inflows,” according to opponents. - CalEnviroScreen. In order to address the cumulative effects of both pollution burden and these additional factors, and to identify which communities might be in need of particular policy, investment, or programmatic interventions, the Office of Environmental Health Hazard Assessment (OEHHA) developed and now maintains and updates the CalEnviroScreen tool on behalf of CalEPA. The tool applies a framework, developed by OEHHA in 2010, for assessing cumulative impacts. According to OEHHA cumulative impacts refer to exposures and public health or environmental effects from all sources of pollution in a geographic area. Cumulative impacts also take into account groups of people that are especially sensitive to the effects of pollution and socioeconomic factors. The CalEnviroScreen tool's framework is based in large part on input from a statewide working group on environmental justice that pointed out the unmet need to assess cumulative burdens and vulnerabilities affecting California communities. According to CalEnviroScreen 4.0, Otay Mesa, the site of the proposed landfill, has a score in the 90-100% (which is the most polluted percentile).
Comments
- Purpose of Bill. According to the author, “Border communities already face some of California’s most pressing environmental justice challenges. The Tijuana River is already one of the most polluted watersheds in the nation. Allowing developers to build an unnecessary landfill in that watershed would further impact local communities that are already enduring ecological disasters. SB 1208 will protect vulnerable Californians by prohibiting a landfill that would further pollute the waters of the Tijuana River and threaten local residents.”
- Is the landfill needed? As discussed above, Tijuana River contamination is a persistent environmental and public health threat for the nearby communities. The author contends that citing a solid waste landfill at East Otay Mesa would increase the pollution burden of already overburdened border communities.
The author further maintains that the East Otay Mesa landfill is “not necessary as the County of San Diego has found the current landfill capacity will last through 2053.” Proponents of the proposal argue that with efforts to meet aggressive state goals and continued improvements in recycling, “there is a significant potential for increased waste diversion, which would extend landfill capacity over an even longer term.” While this may be true, as noted previously, the projections of San Diego’s landfill capacity are predicated on the anticipated expansions of Sycamore Landfill.
It is worth noting that the proposed East Otay Mesa landfill includes a recycling center (RCC) and organic waste processing and composting facility. The RCC would contain a materials recovery facility which would be used to separate recyclable materials to be hauled off-site. - Negates Regional Water Board authority and expertise. SB 1208 would prohibit the San Diego Regional Water Board from issuing a waste discharge permit for the proposed landfill in East Otay Mesa, thereby stopping the project from moving forward. This approach, however, negates the existing decision-making authority and expertise of the Regional Water Board, whose job it is to ensure landfills comply with existing laws and procedures that protect water quality from the impacts of landfill operations. Board approval of a waste discharge permit for a new Class III landfill, such as East Otay Mesa, is an extensive, project specific process. State regulations specify general construction criteria, criteria for containment structures, liners, leachate collection and removal systems, subsurface barriers, precipitation and drainage controls, as well as requirements for water quality monitoring.
Once a permit applicant submits a Report of Waste Discharge (ROWD), a yearlong Board staff review of the application begins, followed by staff preparation of the draft WDRs. The completion of the draft WDRs triggers a public review and comment process. Then, the draft WDRs is publicly noticed for consideration by the Regional Water Board. The Board can vote to approve the WDRs, deny, or grant limited approval if any outstanding concerns cannot be mitigated. If approved, the Regional Water Board has authority to enforce all aspects of the WDRs, including groundwater monitoring requirements. Importantly, current law states that all discharges of waste into waters of the state are privileges, not rights.
The San Diego Regional Water Board has not received a ROWD for the proposed East Otay Landfill. According to the Board, “at a minimum, Regional Board approval would be contingent on prohibitions of surface discharges to any drainages offsite in both the Waste Discharge Requirements (WDRs) themselves as well as the Industrial and Construction Storm Water Permit Enrollments. Groundwater controls would be extensive and monitored onsite and offsite, if approved.” - Overburdening existing landfills? Stopping the East Otay Mesa landfill from moving forward could also result in increased demands on San Diego’s existing waste disposal infrastructure and landfills. Opponents of this measure argue that SB 1208 would “effectively extend the life and heights of existing landfills that are known to be harming residents,” noting that Sycamore landfill, the landfill that is anticipated to be expanded, is located less than a half mile away from a residential area, increasing the likelihood for potential exposures to methane emissions. Further, opponents argue that the bill would inappropriately “undermine the will of San Diego County voters” and impede “ongoing and rigorous environmental review of a proposed recycling and landfill facility – effectively undermining the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).”
- Question before the committee. While it is clear that TJRE is severely contaminated by untreated sewage and that this has created a public health crisis at the border, it is less clear what potential impacts a new landfill at East Otay Mesa will have on the Tijuana River watershed and neighboring communities. These impacts are currently being evaluated through the CEQA process. Further, without this bill, the potential water quality impacts of the project would be vetted through the Regional Water Board.
The question before the committee is whether the potential health and environmental impacts to overburdened border communities warrant a blanket prohibition on new landfills in the TJRE, thereby stopping a voter-approved local project, or if it is more appropriate to let CEQA process currently underway and the anticipated Regional Water Board regulatory process play out. The latter option would enable the Board to assess the specific impacts of the proposed landfill and require appropriate mitigation measures to protect water quality.
Should the committee wish to advance this proposal, the committee and author may wish to consider amending the bill to provide an exception to the prohibition if a regional water board makes a finding that the WDRs protect water quality, meet water quality objectives, and protect beneficial uses. - Could this bill shelve the Nelson Sloan Quarry reclamation project? According to the information provided by the author, the aim of this bill is to prohibit the construction the proposed East Otay Mesa landfill and recycling center. The bill seeks to accomplish this by prohibiting the a Regional Water Board from issuing “a waste discharge permit for a new landfill that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the new landfill is to be located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River.” However, while the proposed East Otay Mesa site is within an area that is tributary to the Tijuana River (via Mexico and Rio Alamar), it is not within the Tijuana River National Esturarine Research Reserve. A concern has been raised by the San Diego Regional Water Board that another significant project, described as core to the Tijuana River Valley recovery, which is located in the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve, could be stalled by this proposal (i.e., prohibiting the Regional Water Board from considering a waste discharge permit for the project).
The Nelson Sloan Quarry Restoration and Beneficial Reuse of Sediment Project (Project) represents a multi-jurisdictional agreement developed over the past decade. One of the first projects identified in the Tijuana River Valley Recovery Strategy, the Project is an effort to restore an abandoned sand and gravel quarry within the Tijuana River National Esturarine Research Reserve with sediments dredged from the Goat Canyon Sediment Basin and the pending Tijuana Estuary Tidal Restoration Project, a key climate adaptation strategy for the Estuary. The sediment management and restoration activities proposed is anticipated to improve water quality within the watershed as well as improve recreational access and quality of life for downstream communities. In addition, the long-term goals of the project include the enhancement of upland habitat on site and riparian and estuarine habitats in the valley, and reduced flooding hazards throughout the valley.
The California Department of Parks and Recreation (CDPR) received $1.2 million in state grants to develop the project through the final design and environmental review. CDPR certified the CEQA environmental impact report in June 2023 and submitted it to the Regional Water Board. Staff are reviewing it at this time. CDPR will also be submitting the ROWD to the Board for review soon.
According to the San Diego Regional Water Board, “The Nelson Sloan Quarry Restoration and Beneficial Reuse of Sediment Project is an important environmental restoration effort identified within the TJ River Recovery Strategy in 2012 and is critical to CA State Parks protection and restoration of the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve. This Project will also help address transboundary flows of sewage, trash, and sediment, into the Tijuana River Valley and out to the Pacific Ocean.”
If the committee chooses to advance this proposal, to ensure the Regional Water Board is not precluded from considering the Nelson Sloan Quarry Project, the committee and author may wish to consider clarifying that the bill’s prohibition shall not apply to a public agency restoration and beneficial reuse project for abandoned sand and gravel mining quarries located within the Tijuana River National Estuarine Research Reserve or areas tributary to the Tijuana River. - Committee amendments. Staff recommends the committee adopt the bolded amendments contained in comments 5 and 6 above.
Related/Prior Legislation
AB 2601 (Garcia, 2022) would have prohibited a Regional Water Board from issuing a waste discharge permit for a new landfill, or a lateral expansion of an existing landfill, that is used for the disposal of nonhazardous solid waste if the land is located within three miles of the United States border with Mexico. This bill was held on suspense in the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
SB 1383 (Garcia, Chapter 395, Statutes of 2016) establishes methane emissions reduction targets in a statewide effort to reduce emissions of short-lived climate pollutants including to reduce the disposal of organic waste 75 percent below 2014 levels by 2025 and to recover 20 percent of edible food for human consumption that is currently landfilled by 2025.
SOURCE:
Author
SUPPORT:
California Coastal Protection Network
California Coastkeeper Alliance
Californians Against Waste
Center for Biological Diversity Inc.
Cleanearth4kids.org
Climate Action Campaign
Endangered Habitats League
Environmental Center of San Diego
Protect Otay Foothills
San Diego Audubon Society
San Diego Coastkeeper
San Diego Count Democrats for Environmental Action
SanDiego350
Surfrider Foundation San Diego Chapter
Surfrider Foundation San Diego County
Wildcoast
129 Individuals
OPPOSITION:
California Building Industry Association
Councilmember Marni von Wilpert, City of San Diego
Councilmember Moreno, City of San Diego
National Enterprises, INC.
1 Individual
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT:
According the San Diego Coastkeeper, Surfrider Foundation of San Diego County, and Protect Otay Foothills, “This legislation addresses our grave concerns about a new private landfill proposed to be developed in that tributary system in the upper Tijuana River Watershed in the Otay Mountain Foothills.
“The project could impair water and air quality throughout the Tijuana River Watershed, including the Tijuana River Valley and Estuary, causing negative health impacts to downstream communities in a region already burdened by one of the worst ongoing public health and environmental justice crises in the country.
“Fundamentally, there is no need for a new landfill in San Diego County, as the County has more than adequate assured disposal capacity as documented in the County’s detailed analysis of the region’s landfill capacity. We applaud Senator Padilla’s recognition that “we all live downstream”, and pointedly that an unnecessary landfill developed in the watershed of the already impaired Tijuana River, could adversely affect water and air quality in the lower watershed and exacerbate the ongoing pollution issues from which our border cities and communities have suffered for decades.”
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION:
According to National Enterprises, Inc., “While we share in your concern and appreciate your steadfast leadership on the restoration of the Tijuana River, SB 1208 would also effectively extend the life and heights of existing toxic landfills that are known to be harming residents in your district, require your residents pay even more for waste and recycling, and undermine the will of San Diego County voters. Furthermore, SB 1208 inappropriate impedes on ongoing and rigorous environmental review of a proposed recycling and landfill facility – effectively undermining the California Environmental Quality Act (CEQA).
“SB 1208 undermines San Diego County Voters Approval of Environmentally Superior Alternative located outside of the Tijuana River NERR [National Estuarine Research Reserve]. In 2010, County of San Diego voters approved, with 84.49%, Proposition A to allow for the construction and operation of a recycling collection center and class III solid waste landfill on the East Otay Mesa project site…
“In contrast to existing facilities, the project is currently going through stringent environmental review by the San Diego Solid Waste Local Enforcement Agency (LEA) and a Draft Environmental Impact Report (EIR) is being prepared. This is the appropriate process for studying any potential impacts to the Tijuana River watershed and identifying any necessary mitigations.”
-- END –
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Natural Resources
Assembly Standing Committee on Environmental Safety and Toxic Materials
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Senate Standing Committee on Environmental Quality
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):