SB 1476: Political Reform Act of 1974: State Bar of California.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Senate
- Latest Version Date: 2024-09-22
Current Status:
Passed
(2024-09-22: Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 489, Statutes of 2024.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Under existing law, unless expressly provided by law, the State Bar of California is not subject to various state laws prescribing the mode of procedure for exercising the powers of state public bodies or state agencies, as specified. Existing law, the Political Reform Act of 1974, defines public official broadly, but it expressly excludes specified persons, including those affiliated with the State Bar of California, from that definition.
Under the act, each agency is required to adopt and promulgate a Conflict of Interest Code that requires designated employees of the agency, as defined, to file statements disclosing specified economic interests. Existing law generally requires such a code to contain specific provisions setting forth any circumstances under which designated employees or categories of designated employees must disqualify themselves from making, participating in the making, or using their official position to influence the making of any decision. However, the act specifically provides that the Conflict of Interest Code for members of the Board of Governors of, and designated employees of, the State Bar of California need not contain such a provision. The act further requires certain enumerated public officials to file their conflict of interest statements, and make specified disclosures, pursuant to specific provisions of the act.
This bill would instead expressly require include board members and designated employees of the State Bar of California within its definition of public official. The bill would eliminate the above-referenced exception for Conflict of Interest Codes with respect to board members and designated employees of the State Bar of California, thereby requiring these codes to contain such disqualification provisions. The bill would also specify that board members and designated employees of the State Bar of California are not enumerated public officials required to comply with specified filing and disclosure requirements; rather, they would only need to file conflict of interest statements and make specified disclosures pursuant to the requirements of their own code.
A violation of the acts provisions is punishable as a misdemeanor. By expanding the scope of an existing crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Political Reform Act of 1974, an initiative measure, provides that the Legislature may amend the act to further the acts purposes upon a 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature and compliance with specified procedural requirements.
This bill would declare that it furthers the purposes of the act.
Under existing law, unless expressly provided by law, the State Bar of California is not subject to various state laws prescribing the mode of procedure for exercising the powers of state public bodies or state agencies, as specified. Existing law, the Political Reform Act of 1974, defines public official broadly, but it expressly excludes specified persons, including those affiliated with the State Bar of California, from that definition.
Under the act, each agency is required to adopt and promulgate a Conflict of Interest Code that requires designated employees of the agency, as defined, to file statements disclosing specified economic interests. Existing law generally requires such a code to contain specific provisions setting forth any circumstances under which designated employees or categories of designated employees must disqualify themselves from making, participating in the making, or using their official position to influence the making of any decision. However, the act specifically provides that the Conflict of Interest Code for members of the Board of Governors of, and designated employees of, the State Bar of California need not contain such a provision. The act further requires certain enumerated public officials to file their conflict of interest statements, and make specified disclosures, pursuant to specific provisions of the act.
This bill would instead expressly require include board members and designated employees of the State Bar of California within its definition of public official. The bill would eliminate the above-referenced exception for Conflict of Interest Codes with respect to board members and designated employees of the State Bar of California, thereby requiring these codes to contain such disqualification provisions. The bill would also specify that board members and designated employees of the State Bar of California are not enumerated public officials required to comply with specified filing and disclosure requirements; rather, they would only need to file conflict of interest statements and make specified disclosures pursuant to the requirements of their own code.
A violation of the acts provisions is punishable as a misdemeanor. By expanding the scope of an existing crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Political Reform Act of 1974, an initiative measure, provides that the Legislature may amend the act to further the acts purposes upon a 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature and compliance with specified procedural requirements.
This bill would declare that it furthers the purposes of the act.
Under existing law, unless expressly provided by law, the State Bar of California is not subject to various state laws prescribing the mode of procedure for exercising the powers of state public bodies or state agencies, as specified. Existing law, the Political Reform Act of 1974, defines public official broadly, but it expressly excludes specified persons, including those affiliated with the State Bar of California, from that definition.
Under the act, each agency is required to adopt and promulgate a Conflict of Interest Code that requires designated employees of the agency, as defined, to file statements disclosing specified economic interests. Existing law generally requires such a code to contain specific provisions setting forth any circumstances under which designated employees or categories of designated employees must disqualify themselves from making, participating in the making, or using their official position to influence the making of any decision. However, the act specifically provides that the Conflict of Interest Code for members of the Board of Governors of, and designated employees of, the State Bar of California need not contain such a provision. The act further requires certain enumerated public officials to file their conflict of interest statements, and make specified disclosures, pursuant to specific provisions of the act.
This bill would instead expressly require include board members and designated employees of the State Bar of California to maintain conflict of interest codes in compliance with the Political Reform Act of 1974, and it would subject members of the board of trustees of, and designated employees of, the State Bar of California to enforcement of violations of the Political Reform Act of 1974 related to conflicts of interest. within its definition of public official. The bill would eliminate the above-referenced exception for Conflict of Interest Codes with respect to board members and designated employees of the State Bar of California, thereby requiring these codes to contain such disqualification provisions. The bill would also specify that board members and designated employees of the State Bar of California are not enumerated public officials required to comply with specified filing and disclosure requirements; rather, they would only need to file conflict of interest statements and make specified disclosures pursuant to the requirements of their own code.
A violation of the acts provisions is punishable as a misdemeanor. By expanding the scope of an existing crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Political Reform Act of 1974, an initiative measure, provides that the Legislature may amend the act to further the acts purposes upon a 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature and compliance with specified procedural requirements.
This bill would declare that it furthers the purposes of the act.
Under existing law, unless expressly provided by law, the State Bar of California is not subject to various state laws prescribing the mode of procedure for exercising the powers of state public bodies or state agencies, as specified.
This bill would expressly require the State Bar of California to maintain conflict of interest codes in compliance with the Political Reform Act of 1974, and it would subject members of the board of trustees of, and designated employees of, the State Bar of California to enforcement of violations of the Political Reform Act of 1974 related to conflicts of interest.
A violation of the acts provisions is punishable as a misdemeanor. By expanding the scope of an existing crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Political Reform Act of 1974, an initiative measure, provides that the Legislature may amend the act to further the acts purposes upon a 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature and compliance with specified procedural requirements.
This bill would declare that it furthers the purposes of the act.
Under existing law, unless expressly provided by law, the State Bar of California is not subject to various state laws prescribing the mode of procedure for exercising the powers of state public bodies or state agencies, as specified.
This bill would expressly require the State Bar of California to maintain conflict of interest codes in compliance with the Political Reform Act of 1974, and it would subject members of the board of trustees of, and designated employees of, the State Bar of California to enforcement of violations of the Political Reform Act of 1974 related to conflicts of interest.
A violation of the acts provisions is punishable as a misdemeanor. By expanding the scope of an existing crime, the bill would impose a state-mandated local program.
The California Constitution requires the state to reimburse local agencies and school districts for certain costs mandated by the state. Statutory provisions establish procedures for making that reimbursement.
This bill would provide that no reimbursement is required by this act for a specified reason.
The Political Reform Act of 1974, an initiative measure, provides that the Legislature may amend the act to further the acts purposes upon a 2/3 vote of each house of the Legislature and compliance with specified procedural requirements.
This bill would declare that it furthers the purposes of the act.
Code reviewing body means all of the following:
(a)The commission, with respect to the conflict of interest code of a state agency other than an agency in the judicial branch of government, or any local government agency with jurisdiction in more than one county.
(b)The board of supervisors, with respect to the conflict of interest code of any county agency other than the board of supervisors, or any agency of the judicial branch of government, and of any local government agency, other than a city agency, with jurisdiction wholly within the county.
(c)The city council, with respect to the conflict of interest code of any city agency other than the city council.
(d)The Attorney General, with respect to the conflict of interest code of the commission.
(e)The Chief Justice of California or the Chief Justices designee, with respect to the conflict of interest code of the members of the Judicial Council, Commission on Judicial Performance, and Board of Trustees of the State Bar of California.
(f)The Board of Trustees of the State Bar of California with respect to the conflict of interest code of the State Bar of California.
(g)The Chief Justice of California, the administrative presiding judges of the courts of appeal, and the presiding judges of superior courts, or their designees, with respect to the conflict of interest code of any agency of the judicial branch of government subject to the immediate administrative supervision of that court.
(h)The Judicial Council of California, with respect to the conflict of interest code of any state agency within the judicial branch of government not included under subdivisions (e), (f), and (g).
SEC. 2.Section 82048 of the Government Code is amended to read:82048.(a)(1)Public official means every member, officer, employee, or consultant of a state or local government agency.
(2)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of Section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code, public official includes a designated employee of, and a Member of the Board of Trustees of, the State Bar of California.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), public official does not include the following:
(1)A judge or court commissioner in the judicial branch of government.
(2)A member of the Judicial Council.
(3)A member of the Commission on Judicial Performance, provided that the member is subject to the provisions of Article 2.5 (commencing with Section 6035) of Chapter 4 of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code as provided in Section 6038 of that article.
(4)A federal officer or employee serving in an official federal capacity on a state or local government agency.
SEC. 3.Section 87211 is added to the Government Code, to read:87211.This article does not apply to either of the following of the State Bar of California, who shall file statements under conflict of interest codes developed consistent with Section 87302:
(a)A member of the Board of Trustees.
(b)A designated employee.
SEC. 4.Section 87311.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:87311.5.(a)Notwithstanding the provisions of Section 87311, the review of the Conflict of Interest Code of an agency in the judicial branch of government shall not be subject to the provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act. The review and preparation of Conflict of Interest Codes by these agencies shall be carried out under procedures that guarantee to officers, employees, members, and consultants of the agency and to residents of the jurisdiction adequate notice and a fair opportunity to present their views.
(b)Conflict of Interest Codes of the Judicial Council and the Commission on Judicial Performance shall not be subject to the provisions of subdivision (c) of Section 87302.
SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 6.The Legislature finds and declares that this bill furthers the purposes of the Political Reform Act of 1974 within the meaning of subdivision (a) of Section 81012 of the Government Code.
Code reviewing body means all of the following:
(a)The commission, with respect to the conflict of interest code of a state agency other than an agency in the judicial branch of government, or any local government agency with jurisdiction in more than one county.
(b)The board of supervisors, with respect to the conflict of interest code of any county agency other than the board of supervisors, or any agency of the judicial branch of government, and of any local government agency, other than a city agency, with jurisdiction wholly within the county.
(c)The city council, with respect to the conflict of interest code of any city agency other than the city council.
(d)The Attorney General, with respect to the conflict of interest code of the commission.
(e)The Chief Justice of California or the Chief Justices designee, with respect to the conflict of interest code of the members of the Judicial Council, Commission on Judicial Performance, and Board of Trustees of the State Bar of California.
(f)The Board of Trustees of the State Bar of California with respect to the conflict of interest code of the State Bar of California.
(g)The Chief Justice of California, the administrative presiding judges of the courts of appeal, and the presiding judges of superior courts, or their designees, with respect to the conflict of interest code of any agency of the judicial branch of government subject to the immediate administrative supervision of that court.
(h)The Judicial Council of California, with respect to the conflict of interest code of any state agency within the judicial branch of government not included under subdivisions (e), (f), and (g).
SEC. 2.Section 82048 of the Government Code is amended to read:82048.(a)(1)Public official means every member, officer, employee, or consultant of a state or local government agency.
(2)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of Section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code, public official includes a designated employee of, and a Member of the Board of Trustees of, the State Bar of California.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), public official does not include the following:
(1)A judge or court commissioner in the judicial branch of government.
(2)A member of the Judicial Council.
(3)A member of the Commission on Judicial Performance, provided that the member is subject to the provisions of Article 2.5 (commencing with Section 6035) of Chapter 4 of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code as provided in Section 6038 of that article.
(4)A federal officer or employee serving in an official federal capacity on a state or local government agency.
SEC. 3.Section 87211 is added to the Government Code, to read:87211.This article does not apply to either of the following of the State Bar of California, who shall file statements under conflict of interest codes developed consistent with Section 87302:
(a)A member of the Board of Trustees.
(b)A designated employee.
SEC. 4.Section 87311.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:87311.5.(a)Notwithstanding the provisions of Section 87311, the review of the Conflict of Interest Code of an agency in the judicial branch of government shall not be subject to the provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act. The review and preparation of Conflict of Interest Codes by these agencies shall be carried out under procedures that guarantee to officers, employees, members, and consultants of the agency and to residents of the jurisdiction adequate notice and a fair opportunity to present their views.
(b)Conflict of Interest Codes of the Judicial Council and the Commission on Judicial Performance shall not be subject to the provisions of subdivision (c) of Section 87302.
SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 6.The Legislature finds and declares that this bill furthers the purposes of the Political Reform Act of 1974 within the meaning of subdivision (a) of Section 81012 of the Government Code.
Code reviewing body means all of the following:
(a)The commission, with respect to the conflict of interest code of a state agency other than an agency in the judicial branch of government, or any local government agency with jurisdiction in more than one county.
(b)The board of supervisors, with respect to the conflict of interest code of any county agency other than the board of supervisors, or any agency of the judicial branch of government, and of any local government agency, other than a city agency, with jurisdiction wholly within the county.
(c)The city council, with respect to the conflict of interest code of any city agency other than the city council.
(d)The Attorney General, with respect to the conflict of interest code of the commission.
(e)The Chief Justice of California or the Chief Justices designee, with respect to the conflict of interest code of the members of the Judicial Council, Commission on Judicial Performance, and Board of Governors Trustees of the State Bar of California.
(f)The Board of Governors Trustees of the State Bar of California with respect to the conflict of interest code of the State Bar of California.
(g)The Chief Justice of California, the administrative presiding judges of the courts of appeal, and the presiding judges of superior courts, or their designees, with respect to the conflict of interest code of any agency of the judicial branch of government subject to the immediate administrative supervision of that court.
(h)The Judicial Council of California, with respect to the conflict of interest code of any state agency within the judicial branch of government not included under subdivisions (e), (f), and (g).
SEC. 2.Section 82048 of the Government Code is amended to read:82048.(a)(1)Public official means every member, officer, employee, or consultant of a state or local government agency.
(2)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of Section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code, public official includes a designated employee of, and a Member of the Board of Trustees of, the State Bar of California.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), public official does not include the following:
(1)A judge or court commissioner in the judicial branch of government.
(2)A member of the Board of Governors and designated employees of the State Bar of California.(3)(2)A member of the Judicial Council.
(4)(3)A member of the Commission on Judicial Performance, provided that the member is subject to the provisions of Article 2.5 (commencing with Section 6035) of Chapter 4 of Division 3 of the Business and Professions Code as provided in Section 6038 of that article.
(5)(4)A federal officer or employee serving in an official federal capacity on a state or local government agency.
SEC. 3.Section 87211 is added to the Government Code, to read:87211.This article does not apply to either of the following of the State Bar of California, who shall file statements under conflict of interest codes developed consistent with Section 87302:
(a)A member of the Board of Trustees.
(b)A designated employee.
SEC. 4.Section 87311.5 of the Government Code is amended to read:87311.5.(a)Notwithstanding the provisions of Section 87311, the review of the Conflict of Interest Code of an agency in the judicial branch of government shall not be subject to the provisions of the Administrative Procedure Act. The review and preparation of Conflict of Interest Codes by these agencies shall be carried out under procedures which that guarantee to officers, employees, members, and consultants of the agency and to residents of the jurisdiction adequate notice and a fair opportunity to present their views.
(b)Conflict of Interest Codes of the Judicial Council, Council and the Commission on Judicial Performance, and the Board of Governors and designated employees of the State Bar of California Performance shall not be subject to the provisions of subdivision (c) of Section 87302.
SECTION 1.Section 83116 of the Government Code is amended to read:83116.(a)When the commission determines there is probable cause for believing this title has been violated, it may hold a hearing to determine if a violation has occurred. Notice shall be given and the hearing conducted in accordance with the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500), Part 1, Division 3, Title 2, Government Code). The commission shall have all the powers granted by that chapter. When the commission determines on the basis of the hearing that a violation has occurred, it shall issue an order that may require the violator to do all or any of the following:(1)Cease and desist violation of this title.(2)File any reports, statements, or other documents or information required by this title.(3)Pay a monetary penalty of up to five thousand dollars ($5,000) per violation to the General Fund of the state. When the commission determines that no violation has occurred, it shall publish a declaration so stating.(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of Section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code, this section authorizes the commission to enforce provisions of this title related to conflicts of interest that are applicable to members of the board of trustees and designated employees of the State Bar of California.SEC. 2.Section 87300 of the Government Code is amended to read:87300.(a)Every agency shall adopt and promulgate a Conflict of Interest Code pursuant to the provisions of this article. A Conflict of Interest Code shall have the force of law and any violation of a Conflict of Interest Code by a designated employee shall be deemed a violation of this chapter.(b)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of Section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code, the State Bar of California shall maintain conflict of interest codes for its board of trustees and designated employees that meet the requirements for conflict of interest codes set forth in this chapter, unless otherwise provided by law. (2)A violation of these codes by a member of the board of trustees or a designated employee of the State Bar shall be deemed a violation of this chapter.SEC. 3.Section 91000 of the Government Code is amended to read:91000.(a)Any person who knowingly or willfully violates any provision of this title is guilty of a misdemeanor.(b)In addition to other penalties provided by law, a fine of up to the greater of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) or three times the amount the person failed to report properly or unlawfully contributed, expended, gave or received may be imposed upon conviction for each violation.(c)Prosecution for violation of this title must be commenced within four years after the date on which the violation occurred.(d)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code, this chapter applies to violations of the conflicts of interest provisions that are applicable to members of the board of trustees and designated employees of the State Bar of California.SEC. 4.SEC. 5.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 5.SEC. 6.The Legislature finds and declares that this bill furthers the purposes of the Political Reform Act of 1974 within the meaning of subdivision (a) of Section 81012 of the Government Code.
(a)When the commission determines there is probable cause for believing this title has been violated, it may hold a hearing to determine if a violation has occurred. Notice shall be given and the hearing conducted in accordance with the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500), Part 1, Division 3, Title 2, Government Code). The commission shall have all the powers granted by that chapter. When the commission determines on the basis of the hearing that a violation has occurred, it shall issue an order that may require the violator to do all or any of the following:
(1)Cease and desist violation of this title.
(2)File any reports, statements, or other documents or information required by this title.
(3)Pay a monetary penalty of up to five thousand dollars ($5,000) per violation to the General Fund of the state. When the Commission commission determines that no violation has occurred, it shall publish a declaration so stating.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of Section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code, this section authorizes the commission to enforce provisions of this title related to conflicts of interest that are applicable to members of the board of trustees and designated employees of the State Bar of California.
SEC. 2.Section 87300 of the Government Code is amended to read:87300.(a)Every agency shall adopt and promulgate a Conflict of Interest Code pursuant to the provisions of this article. A Conflict of Interest Code shall have the force of law and any violation of a Conflict of Interest Code by a designated employee shall be deemed a violation of this chapter.
(b)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of Section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code, the State Bar of California shall maintain conflict of interest codes for its board of trustees and designated employees that meet the requirements for conflict of interest codes set forth in this chapter, unless otherwise provided by law.
(2)A violation of these codes by a member of the board of trustees or a designated employee of the State Bar shall be deemed a violation of this chapter.
SEC. 3.Section 91000 of the Government Code is amended to read:91000.(a)Any person who knowingly or willfully violates any provision of this title is guilty of a misdemeanor.
(b)In addition to other penalties provided by law, a fine of up to the greater of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) or three times the amount the person failed to report properly or unlawfully contributed, expended, gave or received may be imposed upon conviction for each violation.
(c)Prosecution for violation of this title must be commenced within four years after the date on which the violation occurred.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code, this chapter applies to violations of the conflicts of interest provisions that are applicable to members of the board of trustees and designated employees of the State Bar of California.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 5.The Legislature finds and declares that this bill furthers the purposes of the Political Reform Act of 1974 within the meaning of subdivision (a) of Section 81012 of the Government Code.
(a)When the commission determines there is probable cause for believing this title has been violated, it may hold a hearing to determine if a violation has occurred. Notice shall be given and the hearing conducted in accordance with the Administrative Procedure Act (Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 11500), Part 1, Division 3, Title 2, Government Code). The commission shall have all the powers granted by that chapter. When the commission determines on the basis of the hearing that a violation has occurred, it shall issue an order that may require the violator to do all or any of the following:
(a)(1)Cease and desist violation of this title.
(b)(2)File any reports, statements, or other documents or information required by this title.
(c)(3)Pay a monetary penalty of up to five thousand dollars ($5,000) per violation to the General Fund of the state. When the Commission determines that no violation has occurred, it shall publish a declaration so stating.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of Section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code, this section authorizes the commission to enforce provisions of this title related to conflicts of interest that are applicable to members of the board of trustees and designated employees of the State Bar of California.
SEC. 2.Section 87300 of the Government Code is amended to read:87300.(a)Every agency shall adopt and promulgate a Conflict of Interest Code pursuant to the provisions of this article. A Conflict of Interest Code shall have the force of law and any violation of a Conflict of Interest Code by a designated employee shall be deemed a violation of this chapter.
(b)(1)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of Section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code, the State Bar of California shall maintain conflict of interest codes for its board of trustees and designated employees that meet the requirements for conflict of interest codes set forth in this chapter, unless otherwise provided by law.
(2)A violation of these codes by a member of the board of trustees or a designated employee of the State Bar shall be deemed a violation of this chapter.
SEC. 3.Section 91000 of the Government Code is amended to read:91000.(a)Any person who knowingly or willfully violates any provision of this title is guilty of a misdemeanor.
(b)In addition to other penalties provided by law, a fine of up to the greater of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) or three times the amount the person failed to report properly or unlawfully contributed, expended, gave or received may be imposed upon conviction for each violation.
(c)Prosecution for violation of this title must be commenced within four years after the date on which the violation occurred.
(d)Notwithstanding subdivision (e) of section 6001 of the Business and Professions Code, this chapter applies to violations of the conflicts of interest provisions that are applicable to members of the board of trustees and designated employees of the State Bar of California.
SEC. 4.No reimbursement is required by this act pursuant to Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution because the only costs that may be incurred by a local agency or school district will be incurred because this act creates a new crime or infraction, eliminates a crime or infraction, or changes the penalty for a crime or infraction, within the meaning of Section 17556 of the Government Code, or changes the definition of a crime within the meaning of Section 6 of Article XIIIB of the California Constitution.
SEC. 5.The Legislature finds and declares that this bill furthers the purposes of the Political Reform Act of 1974 within the meaning of subdivision (a) of Section 81012 of the Government Code.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 22, 2024 | Chaptered by Secretary of State. Chapter 489, Statutes of 2024. |
| Sep 22, 2024 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Aug 22, 2024 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 2 p.m. |
| Aug 15, 2024 | Assembly amendments concurred in. (Ayes 37. Noes 0. Page 5083.) Ordered to engrossing and enrolling. |
| Aug 13, 2024 | Ordered to special consent calendar. |
| Aug 8, 2024 | In Senate. Concurrence in Assembly amendments pending. |
| Aug 8, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 72. Noes 0. Page 6251.) Ordered to the Senate. |
| Jul 3, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to consent calendar. |
| Jul 2, 2024 | From committee: Do pass. Ordered to consent calendar. (Ayes 15. Noes 0.) (July 2). |
| Jun 26, 2024 | June 26 hearing postponed by committee. |
| Jun 18, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 12. Noes 0.) (June 18). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 12, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 8. Noes 0.) (June 12). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 4, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on ELECTIONS. |
| May 20, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on ELECTIONS and JUD. |
| May 9, 2024 | In Assembly. Read first time. Held at Desk. |
| May 9, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. (Ayes 37. Noes 0. Page 3874.) Ordered to the Assembly. |
| May 7, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to consent calendar. |
| May 6, 2024 | From committee: Be ordered to second reading pursuant to Senate Rule 28.8 and ordered to consent calendar. |
| Apr 26, 2024 | Set for hearing May 6. |
| Apr 24, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 11. Noes 0. Page 3727.) (April 23). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 15, 2024 | From committee with author's amendments. Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Apr 9, 2024 | Set for hearing April 23. |
| Apr 2, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. with recommendation: To consent calendar. (Ayes 7. Noes 0. Page 3445.) (April 2). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 15, 2024 | Set for hearing April 2. |
| Feb 29, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on E. & C.A. and JUD. |
| Feb 20, 2024 | From printer. May be acted upon on or after March 18. |
| Feb 16, 2024 | Introduced. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 15, 2024 | Special Consent SB1476 Blakespear et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 8, 2024 | SB 1476 Blakespear Consent Calendar Second Day Regular Session | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2024 | Do pass. To Consent Calendar. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jun 18, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 12, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] with recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Assembly Standing Committee on Elections |
Passed |
|
| May 9, 2024 | Consent Calendar 2nd SB1476 Blakespear et al. | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Apr 23, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] with the recommendation: To Consent Calendar | Senate Standing Committee on Elections and Constitutional Amendments |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Consumer Protection Policy Center | ** Support | |
| State Bar Of California | ** Support |
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1476 |
UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Bill No: SB 1476
Author: Blakespear (D), et al.
Amended: 6/4/24
Vote: 27
SENATE ELECTIONS & C.A. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/2/24
AYES: Blakespear, Nguyen, Allen, Menjivar, Newman, Portantino, Umberg
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 11-0, 4/23/24
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Gonzalez, Laird, Min, Niello, Wahab
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SENATE FLOOR: 37-0, 5/9/24 (Consent)
AYES: Allen, Alvarado-Gil, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dahle, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Jones, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Newman, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Seyarto, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
NO VOTE RECORDED: Grove, Min, Padilla
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 72-0, 8/8/24 (Consent) - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Political Reform Act of 1974: State Bar of California
SOURCE: State Bar of California
DIGEST:
This bill makes members of the Board of Trustees and designated employees of the State Bar of California (State Bar) subject to the conflict of interest provisions of the Political Reform Act (PRA).
Assembly Amendments
refined the bill’s language to clarify that the State Bar is subject to the specific provisions of the PRA.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the State Bar as a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. Provides that every person admitted and licensed to practice law in California is and shall be a member of the State Bar except while holding office as a judge of a court of record.
- Provides that protection of the public, which includes support for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system, shall be the highest priority for the State Bar of California and the board of trustees in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Provides that whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount.
- Provides that the State Bar’s board of trustees and employees of the State Bar shall be subject to the conflicts of interest provisions relating to contracts, pursuant to a specific code sections in the Government Code, and members of the board of trustees of the State Bar shall be deemed state officers and employees of the State Bar shall be deemed state employees thereunder.
- Requires any member of the State Bar’s board of trustees to disqualify themself from making, participating in the making of, or attempting to influence any decisions of the State Bar in which the member has a financial interest that it is reasonably foreseeable may be affected materially by the decision. Requires any member of the State Bar’s board of trustees to disqualify themself when there exists a personal interest that may prevent the member from applying disinterested skill and undivided loyalty to the State Bar in making or participating in the making of decisions.
- Provides that no member of the State Bar shall be prevented from making or participating in the making of any decision to the extent that the member’s participation is legally required for the action or decision to be made, as specified.
- Requires a member of the State Bar who disqualifies themself because of a conflict of interest to: (1) immediately disclose the interest; (2) withdraw from any participation in the matter; (3) refrain from attempting to influence another member; and (4) refrain from voting. It is sufficient for the purpose of this section that the member indicate only that the member has a disqualifying financial or personal interest.
- Creates the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC), and makes it responsible for the impartial, effective administration and implementation of the Political Reform Act.
- Requires every state and local agency to adopt a conflict of interest code that identifies all officials and employees within the agency who make governmental decisions based on the positions they hold. The individuals in the designated positions must disclose their financial interests, as specified in the agency’s conflict of interest code.
This bill:
- Provides that the term “public official,” for the purposes of the PRA, includes trustees and designated employees of the State Bar. Specifies that these officials must file statements of economic interests in accordance with conflict of interest codes adopted for the trustees and designated employees of the State Bar.
- Requires the conflict of interest code for trustees and for designated employees of the State Bar to include provisions that set forth the circumstances under which covered individuals must disqualify themselves from making governmental decisions, as specified.
- Makes technical changes.
Background
Political Reform Act of 1974. In 1974, California voters passed Proposition 9, an initiative commonly known as the PRA. Proposition 9 created the FPPC and codified significant restrictions and prohibitions on candidates, officeholders, and lobbyists. The Legislature is permitted to amend the PRA, but the amendments must further the purposes of the PRA and requires a two-thirds vote of both houses of the Legislature.
Conflict of Interest Codes. The PRA prohibits a public official from using their official position to influence a governmental decision in which the individual has a financial interest. Every state and local agency must adopt a conflict of interest code that identifies all officials and employees within the agency who make governmental decisions based on the positions they hold. The individuals in the designated positions must disclose their financial interests, as specified in the agency’s conflict of interest code. Existing law also requires public officials and employees in designated positions in a conflict of interest code to report their financial interests on statements of economic interests (Form 700).
According to the FPPC’s website, a conflict of interest code must:
- Provide reasonable assurance that all foreseeable potential conflict of interest situations will be disclosed or prevented;
- Provide to each affected person a clear and specific statement of his or her duties under the conflict of interest code; and
- Adequately differentiate between designated employees with different powers and responsibilities.
Each agency is required to review its conflict of interest code at least every other year - state agencies in odd-numbered years and local agencies in even-numbered years.
State Bar of California. Attorneys who wish to practice law in California generally must be admitted and licensed by the State Bar. The State Bar of California is the largest state bar in the country, with approximately over 195,000 active licensees and 64,000 inactive licensees. The mission of the State Bar is, “to protect the public and includes the primary functions of licensing, regulation and discipline of attorneys; the advancement of the ethical and competent practice of law; and support of efforts for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system.”
Over the past few years, the State Bar has been a topic of concern within the Legislature and legal community. Recently, these concerns have appropriately focused on seemingly irresponsible management of the agency’s funds and a failure to implement an effective disciplinary process, highlighted by the downfall of Thomas Girardi and his law firm. These issues have engendered significant skepticism about the State Bar and have triggered renewed calls for reform.
Thomas Girardi. In 2020, the Los Angeles Times broke the story of Thomas V. Girardi, a renowned plaintiff’s attorney, who allegedly embezzled millions of dollars from his clients.
In response to the scandal, the State Bar initiated an investigation into Girardi. However, the issues relating to the State Bar’s involvement with Girardi came to public attention when the Los Angeles Times published a series of articles detailing how “the powerful lawyer cultivated close relationships with investigators and bar executives and showered them with gifts, including private plane rides, boozy lunches at Morton’s, free legal representation and Vegas shindigs.” In June of 2021, the State Bar made what was described as a “stunning public admission” that an audit of Girardi’s disciplinary file “revealed mistakes made in some investigations over the many decades of Mr. Girardi’s career going back some 40 years and spanning the tenure of many Chief Trial Counsels.”
According to the State Bar, it began investigating its own misconduct related to Girardi on an unspecified date “in 2021.” In an Open Letter from the State Bar in November of 2022, the State Bar described its efforts to get to the bottom of what they did and did not do vis-à-vis Girardi and how it handled repeated complaints from the public about Girardi’s serious misconduct as follows:
The State Bar began the process of righting the wrongs brought to light by the Girardi matters in 2021, when [the State Bar] conducted an audit of all closed disciplinary matters concerning Girardi. That was followed by a comprehensive investigation into prior actions taken by any staff or other State Bar affiliated persons, to determine whether the State Bar’s handling of matters involving Girardi was affected by his connections to, or relationships or influence with these individuals.
Throughout the decades, Girardi’s clients and colleagues submitted reports of misconduct to the State Bar. The State Bar failed to issue any form of discipline against Girardi until 2021. Girardi’s law license was ordered inactive on March 9, 2021, and was disbarred by the California Supreme Court in July of the same year.
Lazar Report. In order to obtain an outside investigation about the matter, the State Bar commissioned a report by attorney Alyse Lazar to examine State Bar files regarding Girardi in early 2021. The Lazar investigation was conducted between March and May 2021. The report found that the State Bar’s investigative files did not include documentation of misconduct by State Bar staff or leadership within the files. Therefore, also not surprisingly, the Lazar investigation also “found no evidence of influence by Girardi in the files themselves.” In the report prepared after the investigation (known as the Lazar Report), Lazar noted “errors in how cases were handled over the four decades of Girardi’s career” and “significant issues regarding the investigation and evaluation of high-dollar, high-volume trust accounts.”
May Report. In response, the State Bar’s Board of Trustees hired the Los Angeles law firm Halpern May Ybarra Gelberg LLP to conduct an in-depth investigation of the State Bar’s handling of the Girardi matters. This report, known as the May Report, uncovered Girardi’s efforts to buy relationships and exercise influence at the State Bar and “the State Bar’s handling of past discipline complaints against Girardi was more likely than not affected by Girardi’s connections to and influence at the State Bar, and that there were multiple State Bar insiders who did not properly disclose their connections to Girardi, including employees who handled Girardi discipline cases.”
Legislative Response. In 2023, the Legislature passed and Governor Newsom signed SB 40 (Umberg, Chapter 697, Statutes of 2023). SB 40 provided a number of reforms relating to the State Bar. In particular, the legislation tightened disclosure and conflict requirements as well as conformed the State Bar with conflict provisions in existing law (i.e. Government Code 1090).
Comment
According to the author, “Following an investigation that found regulators at the State Bar had ties to now disbarred attorney Thomas V. Girardi, the State Bar has taken a number of actions to restore the public’s trust, including making changes to their conflict of interest provisions. During the process of enacting reforms, it became evident that a clarification was needed that specifically requires the enforcement provisions of the PRA to apply to the State Bar. Therefore, SB 1476 requires the State Bar’s conflict of interest codes to be in compliance with the PRA and clarifies the FPPC’s administrative enforcement authority with respect to the State Bar.”
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 40 (Umberg, Chapter 697, Statutes of 2023), among other provisions, provided that members of the State Bar’s Board of Trustees and employees are subject to the conflicts of interest provisions relating to contracts.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee:
- Minor and absorbable costs to the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC).
- Negligible costs to the State Bar, as its conflict of interest codes already comply with specified requirements.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/9/24)
State Bar of California (source)
Consumer Protection Policy Center
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/9/24)
None received
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 72-0, 8/8/24
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Cervantes, Chen, Connolly, Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Flora, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Gallagher, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Hoover, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lackey, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, Mathis, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Pellerin, Quirk-Silva, Ramos, Rendon, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ta, Ting, Villapudua, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bauer-Kahan, Bonta, Wendy Carrillo, Garcia, Petrie-Norris, Valencia, Weber
Prepared by: Scott Matsumoto / E. & C.A. / (916) 651-4106
8/9/24 16:38:10
**** END ****
Date of Hearing: July 2, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1476
Author:(Blakespear) – As Amended Ver:June 4, 2024
Policy Committee: | Elections | Vote: | 8 - 0 |
Judiciary | 12 - 0 | ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: Yes Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill repeals the exclusion of board members and designated employees of the State Bar of California (State Bar) from the definition of a “public official” under the Political Reform Act (PRA) and specifies applicable conflict of interest and disclosure requirements.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Minor and absorbable costs to the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC).
- Negligible costs to the State Bar, as its conflict of interest codes already comply with specified requirements.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
Following an investigation that found regulators at the State Bar had ties to now disbarred attorney Thomas V. Girardi, the State Bar has taken a number of actions to restore the public’s trust, including making changes to their conflict of interest provisions and updating their conflict of interest codes that apply to designated employees as well as members of the Board of Trustees. During the process of enacting reforms, it became evident that a clarification was needed eliminating any question that the enforcement provisions of the PRA to apply to the State Bar with respect to violations of the State Bar’s conflict of interest codes.
This bill is sponsored by the State Bar and supported by the Consumer Protection Policy Center.
- Scope of the PRA. When the PRA was first adopted in 1974, courts and other agencies in the judicial branch of government were expressly excluded from the definitions of “state agency” and “local government agency,” likely due to concerns that including the judiciary could present issues related to the separation of powers. Over time, judicial officers and employees have become subject to some aspects of the PRA, such as the PRA’s financial disclosure requirements. Existing law requires the State Bar to adopt a conflict of interest code for trustees and designated employees in accordance with PRA provisions and requires trustees and designated employees to file a Statement of Economic Interest (Form 700). Ultimately, however, State Bar trustees and designated employees remain subject to conflict of interest rules under the Business and Professions Code and are not statutorily subject to the PRA’s conflict of interest rules enforced by the FPPC. This bill expressly provides that State Bar trustees and designated employees are “public officials” under the PRA, thus clarifying that these officials are subject to the full scope of PRA conflict of interest and enforcement rules.
Analysis Prepared by: Irene Ho / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: June 18, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Ash Kalra, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1476
Author:(Blakespear) – As Amended Ver:June 4, 2024
PROPOSED CONSENT
SENATE VOTE: 37-0
SUBJECT: Political Reform Act of 1974: State Bar of California
KEY ISSUE: should the board of trustees of the state bar of California, as well as specified designated employees of the state bar of California, be subject to the same conflict of interest provisions of the political reform act that apply to public officials and designated public employees?
SYNOPSIS
Enacted in 1974, the Political Reform Act is California’s primary legal framework for promoting the transparent and ethical operation of government. The law, at its essence, requires designated public officials and employees to disclose their financial interests to the Fair Political Practices Commission and to recuse themselves from governmental decisions that may impact those financial interests. Through a quirk of the law, only some aspects of the Political Reform Act apply to the judicial branch of government, including the State Bar of California. Certainly, the inapplicability of the Act to the judicial branch makes sense related to judges, who are held to their own cannons of ethics and recusal rules. However, for non-judicial officers working within the judicial branch, these omissions have created ethical loopholes. These loopholes are especially problematic when applied to the State Bar of California, which essentially is a state regulatory agency housed within the judicial branch. The recent scandal involving the disgraced trial attorney Thomas Girardi and the State Bar exposed how persons can exploit these loopholes when their own ethical compass fails.
Seeking to increase the public’s confidence in the State Bar of California, following the Girardi scandal, this bill reflects the latest in a series of reforms proposed by the State Bar to boost internal oversight of State Bar officials and improve agency ethical guidelines. The bill would deem members of the State Bar’s Board of Trustees “public officials” thereby subjecting them to the full scope of the Political Reform Act’s conflict of interest rules. The bill also clarifies that State Bar officials or employees who violate the Political Reform Act's ethical rules may be subject to the full scope of enforcement measures authorized by the Act.
This common sense and non-controversial measure is sponsored by the State Bar of California as a part of the State Bar’s package of reforms that have been heard and approved by this Committee in the wake of the Girardi scandal. This measure has no known opposition and was previously heard and unanimously approved by the Assembly Committee on Elections, which has primary oversight over the Political Reform Act.
SUMMARY: Requires that the members of the Board of Trustees of the State Bar of California, as well as designated employees of the State Bar of California, be subject to the conflict of interest provisions of the Political Reform Act of 1974. Specifically, this bill:
- Expands the definition of “public official” for the purposes of the Political Reform Act to include the Board of Trustees and designated employees of the State Bar of California.
- Requires, as a result of the designation of a public official provided for in 1), the Board of Trustees and designated employees of the State Bar of California to file statements of economic interest in accordance with the conflict of interest provisions of the Political Reform Act, as specified.
- Requires the conflict of interest code for trustees and for designated employees of the State Bar to include provisions that set forth the circumstances under which covered individuals must disqualify themselves from making governmental decisions, as specified.
- Makes various technical and conforming changes, including updating outdated references in the Political Reform Act to the Board of Governors of the State Bar of California and replacing the term with the Board of Trustees of the State Bar of California.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes the State Bar of California as a public corporation and requires all attorneys practicing law in California to be licensed by the State Bar. (Cal. Const., art. VI, Section 9 and Business and Professions Code Section 6001.)
- Provides that the protection of the public, is the highest priority for the State Bar of California in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. (Business and Professions Code Section 6001.1.)
- Provides that the State Bar of California is to be governed by a Board of Trustees comprised of thirteen members consisting of the following:
- Five attorney members appointed by the California Supreme Court;
- Two legislatively appointed attorney members, one appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly and one appointed by the Senate Rules Committee;
- Four, non-attorney, public members appointed by the Governor; and
- Two legislatively appointed, non-attorney, public members one appointed by the Speaker of the Assembly and one appointed by the Senate Rules Committee. (Business and Professions Code Section 6010 et seq.)
- Establishes the Political Reform Act to be administered impartially and effectively by the Fair Political Practices Commission. (Government Code Section 81000.)
- Requires every state and local agency to adopt a conflict of interest code that identifies all officials and employees within the agency who make governmental decisions based on the positions they hold and requires these officials and employees to disclose financial interests, as specified. (Government Code Section 87300.)
- Provides that the conflict of interest codes of the Judicial Council, the Commission on Judicial Performance, and the Board of Governors and designated employees of the State Bar, are not required to include provisions that otherwise generally are required to be included in a conflict of interest code that set forth the circumstances under which designated employees or categories of designated employees must disqualify themselves from making governmental decisions, as specified. (Government Code Section 87311.5.)
- Provides that the term “public official” for the purposes of the Political Reform Act does not include a member of the Board of Governors and designated employees of the State Bar. (Government Code Section 82048.)
- Prohibits a public official at any level of state or local government from making, participating in making, or in any way attempting to use the public official’s official position to influence a governmental decision in which the official knows or has reason to know that the official has a financial interest. (Government Code Section 87100 et seq.)
- Prohibits a public official of a state agency from, for compensation, acting as an agent or attorney for, or otherwise representing, any other person by making any formal or informal appearance before, or any oral or written communication to, the official’s state agency or any officer or employee thereof, if the appearance or communication is for the purpose of influencing a decision on a contract, grant, loan, license, permit, or other entitlement for use. (Government Code Section 87104.)
- Prohibits a public official from making, participating in making, or using the public official’s official position to influence, any governmental decision directly relating to any person with whom the public official is negotiating, or has any arrangement concerning, prospective employment. (Government Code Section 87407.)
- Requires a Trustee of the State Bar of California to disqualify themselves from making, participating in the making of, or attempting to influence any decision of the State Bar of California in which the trustee has a financial interest, as defined, if it is reasonably foreseeable that the financial interest may be affected materially by the decision. (Business and Professions Code Section 6036.)
- Requires a member of the Board of Trustees of the State Bar of California to disqualify themselves when there exists a personal interest that may prevent the member from applying disinterested skill and undivided loyalty to the State Bar in making or participating in the making of decisions. (Ibid.)
- Applies the provisions of 11) and 12) to designed employees of the State Bar of California with respect to making, participating in the making, or attempting to influence, governmental decisions of their respective state agencies other than decisions of a judicial or quasi-judicial nature. (Business and Professions Code Section 6038.)
- Defines for the purpose of the Political Reform Act and the provisions of 11) through 13) a “financial interest” in a decision “to mean a situation in which it is reasonably foreseeable that a material financial effect, distinguishable from its effect on the public generally, will be conferred upon the official, a member of the official’s immediate family, or on any of the following:
- Any business entity in which the public official has a direct or indirect investment worth two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more;
- Any real property in which the public official has a direct or indirect interest worth two thousand dollars ($2,000) or more;
- Any source of income, except gifts or loans by a commercial lending institution made in the regular course of business on terms available to the public without regard to official status, aggregating five hundred dollars ($500) or more in value provided or promised to, received by, the public official within 12 months prior to the time when the decision is made;
- Any business entity in which the public official is a director, officer, partner, trustee, employee, or holds any position of management; or
- Any donor of, or any intermediary or agent for a donor of, a gift or gifts aggregating five hundred ninety ($590) or more in value provided to, received by, or promised to the public official within 12 months prior to the time when the decision is made.” (Government Code Section 87103.)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed fiscal.
COMMENTS: In 2020, as this Committee is well aware, prominent trial lawyer Thomas Girardi was accused of stealing millions of dollars from his injured clients over many years. A federal court found that he had misappropriated $2 million of settlement funds that had been awarded to victims’ families of the 2018 Lion Air Flight 610 plane crash (incidentally the first crash to expose the ongoing failure of Boeing’s 737 MAX program), and referred the matter to federal prosecutors for further investigation. Additional investigations into Thomas Girardi and his law firm, Girardi Keese, determined that between 1983 and 2021, the State Bar of California had received over 200 complaints alleging malfeasance and conduct violating the Rule of Professional Conduct against Girardi. These investigations also exposed the remarkably close relationship that Girardi maintained with senior staff at the State Bar of California and members of the State Bar’s oversight body, the Board of Trustees. The Girardi scandal exposed a systemic lack of oversight of the State Bar of California’s discipline system and spurred numerous reforms to the agency in recent years.
This measure represents yet another positive step in increasing the integrity and oversight of the State Bar of California and the state’s system for disciplining attorney misconduct. This bill expands the applicability of conflict of interest provisions of the Political Reform Act so the Act applies to the State Bar of California and strengthens the State Bar’s adherence to conflict of interest rules as a result. In support of this bill, the author states:
Following an investigation that found regulators at the State Bar had ties to now disbarred attorney Thomas V. Girardi, the State Bar has taken a number of actions to restore the public’s trust, including making changes to their conflict of interest provisions and updating their conflict of interest codes that apply to designated employees as well as members of the Board of Trustees. During the process of enacting reforms, it became evident that a clarification was needed eliminating any question that the enforcement provisions of the PRA to apply to the State Bar with respect to violations of the State Bar’s conflict of interest codes. Therefore, SB 1476 requires the State Bar’s conflict of interest codes to be in compliance with the PRA and clarifies the FPPC’s administrative enforcement authority with respect to the State Bar.
Following the Watergate scandal, the Political Reform Act was enacted to restore the public’s faith in the ethics and efficacy of government. In 1972, then- Secretary of State Jerry Brown launched an ambitious legislative campaign to reform government ethics. When the efforts stalled in the Legislature, seeking to bolster his own public standing as a reformer in advance of a potential gubernatorial campaign, then-Secretary of State Brown lead the campaign to enact Proposition 9 in 1974. (Newton, Man of Tomorrow-The Relentless Life of Jerry Brown (2020) pp. 104-106.) Aided by the Watergate scandal and the August 1974 resignation of President Richard Nixon, Proposition 9 passed with nearly 70 percent of the vote and enacted the Political Reform Act. (Ibid.) The Political Reform Act established the five-member, non-partisan Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) to oversee the state’s campaign finance and government ethics laws.
In accordance with the Political Reform Act, state and local agencies must adopt a conflict of interest code that identifies all officials and employees within the agency who make governmental decisions based on the positions they hold and requires those officials and employees to disclose their financial interests annually by filing a Form 700 with the FPPC or their agency of employment. In addition to providing transparency regarding the financial interests of governmental decision makers, the Political Reform Act also directs public officials and employees to recuse themselves from participating in decisions in which they have a conflict of interest. The existing law regarding conflicts of interest typically requires recusal when a public official or employee’s decision would have a foreseeable financial impact on that individual or their close family.
Notably, however, because the Political Reform Act originally applied to only state or local agencies, the courts were not originally subject to the Act. Over time, legislative decrees have made the judiciary (the branch of government of which the State Bar of California is an agency therein) subject to some aspects of the Political Reform Act. Notably the Political Reform Act requires financial disclosures from many judicial branch officers and employees but does not apply the existing law’s conflict of interest rules. While on its face this omission makes sense, judicial officers are subject to their own cannons of ethics as well as judicial conflict and recusal rules, the existing law generally overlooked other judicial branch officers and employees as it relates to conflict of interest laws. Accordingly, while officials and employees of the State Bar of California must disclose their financial interests, they are not subject to the same conflict of interest standards that apply to most other government employees.
The Thomas Girardi scandal highlighted the flaws in the State Bar of California’s existing ethics rules. As noted above, in 2020, the Los Angeles Times broke the story of Thomas Girardi, a renowned plaintiff’s attorney, allegedly embezzling millions of dollars from his clients. The history of Girardi’s misconduct, according to the news stories, spanned decades and included defrauding victims of the 2010 San Bruno PG&E pipeline explosion, cancer patients who won a settlement against a hormone replacement therapy manufacturer, and victims of faulty surgical instruments. (Hamilton and Ryan, Tom Girardi, disgraced L.A. lawyer and ‘Real Housewives’ spouse, indicted on fraud charges, Los Angeles Times (February 1. 2023) available at: https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2023-02-01/tom-girardi-indictment-la-lawyer.) Seeking to determine exactly how Girardi managed to escape discipline for decades, the State Bar of California hired the law firm of Halpern May Ybarra Gelberg, LLP to investigate the State Bar’s own actions related to Girardi.
Firm partner Aaron May interviewed 74 witnesses; reviewed over 950,000 documents; issued 23 subpoenas; gathered evidence about activities of Girardi (who by that time was disbarred and bankrupt) and the conduct of Bar staff and officials in relation to Girardi; and wrote a report about the investigation and his findings. The report (known as the “May Report”) uncovered Girardi’s efforts to buy relationships and exercise influence at the State Bar and determined that, “the State Bar’s handling of past discipline complaints against Girardi was more likely than not affected by Girardi’s connections to and influence at the State Bar, and that there were multiple State Bar insiders who did not properly disclose their connections to Girardi, including employees who handled Girardi discipline cases.” (Halpern May Ybarra Gelberg LLP, Independent Investigation for the State Bar of California: Report of Investigation (Feb. 2023) at p. 7.) In brief, the alleged conduct of each of these officials constituted significant corruption and unlawful actions. Highlights included then-Executive Director Joe Dunn’s decision to turn a blind eye to complaints of an improper relationship between Girardi and Thomas Layton; Dunn’s decision to fire four attorneys within the State Bar of California’s Office of the Chief Trial Counsel (the State Bar’s disciplinary arm), including two who had actively advocated for investigations to continue into Girardi; Layton’s acceptance of one million dollars in gifts from Girardi for both himself and his wife; Layton’s improper involvement in Girardi’s matters before the State Bar; Robert Hawley’s decision to intervene on behalf of Girardi and ghost write a decision in one of Girardi’s matters on behalf of a special deputy trial counsel; and Sean SeLegue’s failure to disclose that, prior to becoming a member of the Board of Trustees for the Bar, he had worked on a team at his law firm that was assigned to research whether a Ninth Circuit decision to discipline Girardi was sufficient punishment which resulted in a recommendation for no further discipline of Girardi.
The fact that each of the above-mentioned State Bar officials continued to be involved in matters implicating Thomas Girardi, despite having financial, personal, and/or professional ties with him, highlights the deficiency in the State Bar’s existing conflict of interest statute. Given that Girardi had lavished gifts and other benefits on some of these individuals, one can surmise that it was reasonably foreseeable that punishing Girardi, including the potential revocation of suspension of his law license, would impact their own financial status as his loss of income may have limited his ability to spend freely to benefit friends and associates. Accordingly, had the conflict of interest standards of the Political Reform Act applied to these State Bar officials, they would have been obligated to recuse themselves from any decisions impacting Thomas Girardi or face sanction by the FPPC.
This measure strengthens the State Bar of California’s ethics rules and aligns the State Bar’s ethical guidelines with other state agencies. This measure, sponsored by the State Bar of California itself, represents yet another step forward in restoring the public’s confidence in the embattled agency. This bill would require the State Bar of California to draft and maintain conflict of interest codes for members of the Board of Trustees and designated senior employees that meet the minimum requirements of the Political Reform Act. The bill also clarifies that those who violate the State Bar’s conflict code violate the Political Reform Act itself, thus subjecting any violator to the penalties, including criminal misdemeanor conviction. By better aligning the State Bar’s ethics rules with the Political Reform Act, this bill would ensure that should a member of the Board of Trustees or senior State Bar official have a personal or financial interest in a matter before the State Bar--whether a decision related to attorney discipline or the procurement of a contract for services--that person would be required to recuse themselves from the decision.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: This bill is sponsored by the State Bar of California as a part of the agency’s ongoing reform and modernization efforts, and is supported by the Consumer Protection Policy Center. In support of the bill the State Bar writes:
The State Bar has initiated several reforms over the past several years to tighten up conflicts rules and strengthen the State Bar’s accountability and transparency. SB 1476 continues those efforts at accountability and transparency. SB 1476 makes explicit in the Political Reform Act the requirement for the State Bar to maintain conflict of interest codes for its Board of Trustees and staff that meet the requirements of the Political Reform Act. The bill clarifies that violations of the State Bar’s conflict of interest codes are violations of law enforceable under the Political Reform Act. Importantly, the bill also makes it explicit that the enforcement provisions of the Act apply to the State Bar. These are important changes to bolster the State Bar’s efforts to strengthen our conflict-of-interest rules, policies, and procedures and ensure the conflict-of-interest codes have teeth, by making clear there are consequences for violations. The latest amendments, developed in collaboration with the FPPC, simply streamline the proposed statutory language but do not make substantive changes.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
State Bar of California (sponsor)
Consumer Protection Policy Center
Opposition
None on file
Analysis Prepared by: Nicholas Liedtke / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Date of Hearing: June 12, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON ELECTIONS
Gail Pellerin, Chair
SBPCA Bill Id:SB 1476
Author:(Blakespear) – As Amended Ver:June 4, 2024
SENATE VOTE: 37-0
SUBJECT: Political Reform Act of 1974: State Bar of California.
SUMMARY: Makes members of the Board of Trustees (trustees) and designated employees of the State Bar of California (State Bar) subject to the conflict of interest provisions of the Political Reform Act (PRA). Specifically, this bill:
- Provides that the term “public official,” for the purposes of the PRA, includes trustees and designated employees of the State Bar. Specifies that these officials must file statements of economic interests (SEIs) in accordance with conflict of interest codes adopted for the trustees and designated employees of the State Bar.
- Requires the conflict of interest code for trustees and for designated employees of the State Bar to include provisions that set forth the circumstances under which covered individuals must disqualify themselves from making governmental decisions, as specified.
- Makes technical changes.
EXISTING LAW:
- Creates the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC), and makes it responsible for the impartial, effective administration and implementation of the PRA. (Government Code §§83100, 83111)
- Makes violations of the PRA subject to administrative, civil, and criminal penalties. (Government Code §§83116, 91000-91005.5)
- Requires every state or local agency to adopt a conflict of interest code that identifies the officials and employees within the agency who make governmental decisions based on the positions they hold, as specified. Provides that a conflict of interest code shall have the force of law. Requires the individuals in the designated positions, commonly referred to as “designated employees,” to file SEIs that publicly disclose the employees’ financial interests, as specified. (Government Code §§87300, 87302)
- Makes the Chief Justice of California or the Chief Justice’s designee responsible for reviewing and approving the conflict of interest code of the Board of Governors (since renamed the “Board of Trustees”) of the State Bar. Makes the Board of Governors of the State Bar responsible for reviewing and approving the conflict of interest code of the State Bar. (Government Code §§82011(e) & (f), 87303)
- Provides that the conflict of interest codes of the Judicial Council, the Commission on Judicial Performance, and the Board of Governors and designated employees of the State Bar, are not required to include provisions that otherwise generally are required to be included in a conflict of interest code that set forth the circumstances under which designated employees or categories of designated employees must disqualify themselves from making governmental decisions, as specified. (Government Code §87311.5)
- Provides, for the purposes of the PRA, that the term “public official” does not include a member of the Board of Governors and designated employees of the State Bar. (Government Code §82048)
- Prohibits a public official at any level of state or local government from making, participating in making, or in any way attempting to use the public official’s official position to influence a governmental decision in which the official knows or has reason to know that the official has a financial interest. (Government Code §87100 et seq.)
- Prohibits a public official of a state agency from, for compensation, acting as an agent or attorney for, or otherwise representing, any other person by making any formal or informal appearance before, or any oral or written communication to, the official’s state agency or any officer or employee thereof, if the appearance or communication is for the purpose of influencing a decision on a contract, grant, loan, license, permit, or other entitlement for use. (Government Code §87104)
- Prohibits a public official from making, participating in making, or using the public official’s official position to influence, any governmental decision directly relating to any person with whom the public official is negotiating, or has any arrangement concerning, prospective employment. (Government Code §87407)
- Establishes the State Bar as a public corporation with the responsibility of licensing, regulation, and discipline of attorneys. Requires attorneys who practice law in California to be licensed by the State Bar. (California Constitution, Article VI, §9; Business and Professions Code §6000 et seq.)
- Provides that no state law restricting, or prescribing a mode of procedure for the exercise of powers of state public bodies or state agencies, or classes thereof, shall be applicable to the State Bar, unless the Legislature expressly so declares. Expressly declares that the State Bar is subject to the California Public Records Act, the Bagley-Keene Open Meeting Act, and to specified provisions of state law relating to conflicts of interests in contracting decisions. (Business and Professions Code §§6001(e), 6026.7, 6026.11)
- Requires a trustee of the State Bar to disqualify themself from making, participating in the making of, or attempting to influence any decision of the State Bar in which the trustee has a financial interest, as that term is defined in the PRA, if it is reasonably foreseeable that the financial interest may be affected materially by the decision. Requires a trustee of the State Bar to disqualify themself when there exists a personal interest that may prevent the member from applying disinterested skill and undivided loyalty to the State Bar in making or participating in the making of decisions. Makes these provisions applicable to employees designated in the conflict of interest code of the State Bar with respect to making, participating in the making, or attempting to influence, governmental decisions of the State Bar other than decisions of a judicial or quasi-judicial nature. (Business and Professions Code §§6036, 6038)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. State-mandated local program; contains a crimes and infractions disclaimer. Although this bill deals with a similar issue to the version of the bill approved by the Senate, it has been substantially amended from the Senate-approved version. Accordingly, it is unclear whether prior fiscal analyses are relevant to the current version of the bill.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose of the Bill: According to the author:
Following an investigation that found regulators at the State Bar had ties to now disbarred attorney Thomas V. Girardi, the State Bar has taken a number of actions to restore the public’s trust, including making changes to their conflict of interest provisions and updating their conflict of interest codes that apply to designated employees as well as members of the Board of Trustees. During the process of enacting reforms, it became evident that a clarification was needed eliminating any question that the enforcement provisions of the PRA to apply to the State Bar with respect to violations of the State Bar’s conflict of interest codes. Therefore, SB 1476 requires the State Bar’s conflict of interest codes to be in compliance with the PRA and clarifies the FPPC’s administrative enforcement authority with respect to the State Bar.
- Conflict of Interest Rules in the Political Reform Act: The PRA prohibits a public official from using the person’s official position to influence a governmental decision in which the person has a financial interest. As part of the regulatory scheme designed to protect against conflicts of interest, a state or local agency generally is required to adopt a conflict of interest code that identifies all officials and employees within the agency who make governmental decisions based on the positions they hold. To help identify potential conflicts of interest, the PRA requires individuals in the designated positions to disclose their financial interests as specified in the agency’s conflict of interest code on a form called the SEI, also commonly referred to as the “Form 700.”
Because the PRA’s conflict of interest rules apply generally to state and local agencies, it typically is not necessary for the PRA to identify an agency by name and provide that the agency and its officers and employees are subject to the PRA’s conflict of interest rules. When the PRA was first adopted in 1974, however, courts and other agencies in the judicial branch of government were expressly excluded from the definitions of the terms “state agency” and “local government agency.” As a result, those agencies and their officers and employees were not subject to the PRA’s conflict of interest rules. It appears that the judicial branch of government was excluded from the PRA’s conflict of interest provisions in part due to concerns that including the judiciary could present separation of powers issues.
Over time, amendments to the PRA have made judicial officers and employees subject to some aspects of the PRA’s regulatory scheme to protect against conflicts of interest, while still being sensitive to concerns about the separation of powers. In particular, the PRA has been amended to make judicial officers and employees subject to the PRA’s financial disclosure requirements while still excluding many officials and employees in the judiciary from the conflict of interest rules in the PRA.
For instance, AB 959 (Badham), Chapter 499, Statutes of 1975, required a judge of a court of record to annually file an SEI with the clerk of the judge’s court, but did not make judges subject to the PRA’s conflict of interest rules. SB 1427 (Petris), Chapter 727, Statutes of 1984, made members of the Board of Governors and designated employees of the State Bar subject to the PRA’s financial disclosure requirements, while exempting them from the PRA’s conflict of interest rules. SB 1427 instead made these members and employees subject to separate conflict of interest rules that apply exclusively to State Bar personnel. SB 1427 also made court personnel other than judges and court commissioners subject to the PRA’s conflict of interest and financial disclosure rules.
As a result, while the judicial branch of government is subject to some aspects of the PRA’s conflict of interest and financial disclosure rules, those rules are not broadly applicable in their entirety to the judiciary. With respect to the State Bar, it must adopt a conflict of interest code for trustees and designated employees in accordance with the PRA, and those trustees and employees must file SEIs under the PRA. However, those trustees and employees are not subject to the PRA’s conflict of interest rules but instead are subject to conflict of interest rules found in the Business and Professions Code. While those conflict of interest rules have similarities to the financial conflict of interest rules found in the PRA, they are not enforced by the FPPC, and they also require recusal in other situations that are not covered by the PRA. Relatedly, because those officials are not subject to the PRA’s conflict of interest rules, the State Bar’s conflict of interest code is not required to include provisions that detail the circumstances under which trustees and designated employees are required to disqualify themselves from making governmental decisions.
Notwithstanding that fact, the most recently adopted conflict of interest codes that govern trustees and designated employees of the State Bar include recusal provisions and provide that trustees and designated employees shall be considered “public officials” for the purpose of the PRA notwithstanding the fact that the PRA specifies that those individuals are not “public officials.” Because properly adopted conflict of interest codes have the force of law, it is somewhat unclear whether trustees and designated employees of the State Bar are already subject to enforcement of the PRA’s financial conflict of interest rules by the FPPC.
This bill would provide that trustees and designated employees of the State Bar are public officials for the purposes of the PRA, thereby making it clear that these officials are subject to the PRA’s conflict of interest rules and related restrictions that apply generally to public officials.
- State Bar of California: As detailed above, attorneys who wish to practice law in California generally must be admitted and licensed by the State Bar. The State Bar is the largest state bar in the country, with over 197,000 active licensees and nearly 76,000 inactive licensees as of June 3, 2024. (State Bar of Cal, Attorney Status, available at https://members.calbar.ca.gov/search/demographics.aspx.)
The mission of the State Bar is, “to protect the public and includes the primary functions of licensing, regulation and discipline of attorneys; the advancement of the ethical and competent practice of law; and support of efforts for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system.” The State Bar is the regulatory arm of the California Supreme Court, and is responsible for licensing attorneys and regulating the profession and practice of law in California, enforcing rules of professional conduct for attorneys, disciplining attorneys who violate rules and laws, and administering the California Bar Exam.
The State Bar has been embroiled in scandal over its handling of complaints against once prominent trial attorney Thomas Girardi, who has been accused of stealing millions of dollars from his clients over decades. An independent investigation was conducted examining the State Bar’s handling of complaints against Girardi over the past 20 years, referred to as the May Report. The May Report’s findings detailed a history of weak internal enforcement of conflicts of interests and troubling relationships between employees of the State Bar and Girardi. The May Report noted that the State Bar had adopted a conflict of interest code in accordance with state law, but when investigators requested to review Form 700s for individuals relevant to the inquiry “the State Bar was unable to locate all requested forms.” For the Form 700s that the State Bar had on file, many were “incomplete and sometimes not even signed.” The May Report noted that not requiring Form 700s to be tracked or completed accurately makes it difficult for the State Bar to identify conflicts of interest and hold individuals accountable for not handling conflicts in an appropriate manner. The May Report then went on to detail numerous conflicts of interest between certain State Bar employees that were never reported and several instances when those employees never submitted the required Form 700.
The Senate and Assembly Judiciary Committees held a joint oversight hearing of the State Bar in May 2023, in part to examine the findings of the May Report. In last year’s State Bar fee authorization bill, SB 40 (Umberg), Chapter 697, Statutes of 2023, some changes were made to strengthen conflict of interest rules that apply to the State Bar, including subjecting trustees and employees of the State Bar to specified conflict of interest provisions relating to contracts, and expanding the circumstances under which a trustee is required to disqualify themself from a decision of the State Bar. This bill would build upon those reforms by authorizing the FPPC to enforce the PRA’s conflict of interest rules against trustees and designated employees of the State Bar, including the potential imposition of administrative, civil, and criminal penalties.
- Arguments in Support: The sponsor of this bill, the State Bar of California, writes in support:
The State Bar has initiated several reforms over the past several years to tighten up conflicts rules and strengthen the State Bar’s accountability and transparency… SB 1476 continues those efforts at accountability and transparency. SB 1476 makes explicit in the Political Reform Act the requirement for the State Bar to maintain conflict of interest codes for its Board of Trustees and staff that meet the requirements of the Political Reform Act. The bill clarifies that violations of the State Bar’s conflict of interest codes are violations of law enforceable under the Political Reform Act. Importantly, the bill also makes it explicit that the enforcement provisions of the Act apply to the State Bar. These are important changes to bolster the State Bar’s efforts to strengthen our conflict-of-interest rules, policies, and procedures and ensure the conflict-of-interest codes have teeth, by making clear there are consequences for violations.
- Political Reform Act of 1974: California voters passed an initiative, Proposition 9, in 1974 that created the FPPC and codified significant restrictions and prohibitions on candidates, officeholders, and lobbyists. That initiative is commonly known as the PRA. Amendments to the PRA that are not submitted to the voters, such as those contained in this bill, must further the purposes of the initiative and require a two-thirds vote of both houses of the Legislature.
- Double-Referral: This bill has been double-referred to the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
State Bar of California (Sponsor)
Consumer Protection Policy Center/USD School of Law (prior version)
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Ethan Jones / ELECTIONS / (916) 319-2094
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | SB 1476 |
CONSENT
Bill No: SB 1476
Author: Blakespear (D), et al.
Amended: 4/15/24
Vote: 27
SENATE ELECTIONS & C.A. COMMITTEE: 7-0, 4/2/24
AYES: Blakespear, Nguyen, Allen, Menjivar, Newman, Portantino, Umberg
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 11-0, 4/23/24
AYES: Umberg, Wilk, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Gonzalez, Laird, Min, Niello, Wahab
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: Senate Rule 28.8
SUBJECT: Political Reform Act of 1974: State Bar of California
SOURCE: State Bar of California
DIGEST:
This bill specifies that the State Bar of California (State Bar) maintain conflict of interest codes in compliance with the Political Reform Act of 1974 (PRA) and provides that members of the State Bar’s Board of Trustees and designated employees are subject to the enforcement of violations of the PRA.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the State Bar as a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. Provides that every person admitted and licensed to practice law in California is and shall be a member of the State Bar except while holding office as a judge of a court of record.
- Provides that protection of the public, which includes support for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system, shall be the highest priority for the State Bar of California and the board of trustees in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Provides that whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount.
- Provides that the State Bar’s board of trustees and employees of the State Bar shall be subject to the conflicts of interest provisions relating to contracts, pursuant to specific code sections in the Government Code, and members of the board of trustees of the State Bar shall be deemed state officers and employees of the State Bar shall be deemed state employees thereunder.
- Requires any member of the State Bar’s board of trustees to disqualify themself from making, participating in the making of, or attempting to influence any decisions of the State Bar in which the member has a financial interest that is reasonably foreseeable may be affected materially by the decision. Requires any member of the State Bar’s board of trustees to disqualify themself when there exists a personal interest that may prevent the member from applying disinterested skill and undivided loyalty to the State Bar in making or participating in the making of decisions.
- Provides that no member of the State Bar shall be prevented from making or participating in the making of any decision to the extent that the member’s participation is legally required for the action or decision to be made, as specified.
- Requires a member of the State Bar who disqualifies themself because of a conflict of interest to (a) immediately disclose the interest; (b) withdraw from any participation in the matter; (c) refrain from attempting to influence another member; and (d) refrain from voting. It is sufficient for the purpose of this section that the member indicate only that the member has a disqualifying financial or personal interest.
- Creates the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC), and makes it responsible for the impartial, effective administration and implementation of the PRA.
- Requires every state and local agency to adopt a conflict of interest code that identifies all officials and employees within the agency who make governmental decisions based on the positions they hold. The individuals in the designated positions must disclose their financial interests, as specified in the agency’s conflict of interest code.
This bill specifies that the State Bar maintain conflict of interest codes in compliance with the PRA and provides that members of the State Bar’s Board of Trustees and designated employees are subject to the enforcement of violations of the PRA.
Background
Political Reform Act of 1974. In 1974, California voters passed Proposition 9, an initiative commonly known as the PRA. Proposition 9 created the FPPC and codified significant restrictions and prohibitions on candidates, officeholders, and lobbyists. The Legislature is permitted to amend the PRA, but the amendments must further the purposes of the PRA and requires a two-thirds vote of both houses of the Legislature.
Conflict of Interest Codes. The PRA prohibits a public official from using their official position to influence a governmental decision in which the individual has a financial interest. Every state and local agency must adopt a conflict of interest code that identifies all officials and employees within the agency who make governmental decisions based on the positions they hold. The individuals in the designated positions must disclose their financial interests, as specified in the agency’s conflict of interest code. Existing law also requires public officials and employees in designated positions in a conflict of interest code to report their financial interests on a form called Statement of Economic Interests (Form 700).
According to the FPPC’s website, a conflict of interest code must:
- Provide reasonable assurance that all foreseeable potential conflict of interest situations will be disclosed or prevented;
- Provide to each affected person a clear and specific statement of his or her duties under the conflict of interest code; and
- Adequately differentiate between designated employees with different powers and responsibilities.
Each agency is required to review its conflict of interest code at least every other year - state agencies in odd-numbered years and local agencies in even-numbered years.
State Bar of California. Attorneys who wish to practice law in California generally must be admitted and licensed by the State Bar. The State Bar of California is the largest state bar in the country, with approximately over 195,000 active licensees and 64,000 inactive licensees. The mission of the State Bar is, “to protect the public and includes the primary functions of licensing, regulation and discipline of attorneys; the advancement of the ethical and competent practice of law; and support of efforts for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system.”
Over the past few years, the State Bar has been a topic of concern within the Legislature and legal community. Recently, these concerns have appropriately focused on seemingly irresponsible management of the agency’s funds and a failure to implement an effective disciplinary process, highlighted by the downfall of Thomas Girardi and his law firm. These issues have engendered significant skepticism about the State Bar and have triggered renewed calls for reform.
Thomas Girardi. In 2020, the Los Angeles Times broke the story of Thomas V. Girardi, a renowned plaintiff’s attorney, who allegedly embezzled millions of dollars from his clients.
In response to the scandal, the State Bar initiated an investigation into Girardi. However, the issues relating to the State Bar’s involvement with Girardi came to public attention when the Los Angeles Times published a series of articles detailing how “the powerful lawyer cultivated close relationships with investigators and bar executives and showered them with gifts, including private plane rides, boozy lunches at Morton’s, free legal representation and Vegas shindigs.” In June of 2021, the State Bar made what was described as a “stunning public admission” that an audit of Girardi’s disciplinary file “revealed mistakes made in some investigations over the many decades of Mr. Girardi’s career going back some 40 years and spanning the tenure of many Chief Trial Counsels.”
According to the State Bar, it began investigating its own misconduct related to Girardi on an unspecified date “in 2021.” In an Open Letter from the State Bar in November of 2022, the State Bar described its efforts to get to the bottom of what they did and did not do vis-à-vis Girardi and how it handled repeated complaints from the public about Girardi’s serious misconduct as follows:
The State Bar began the process of righting the wrongs brought to light by the Girardi matters in 2021, when [the State Bar] conducted an audit of all closed disciplinary matters concerning Girardi. That was followed by a comprehensive investigation into prior actions taken by any staff or other State Bar affiliated persons, to determine whether the State Bar’s handling of matters involving Girardi was affected by his connections to, or relationships or influence with these individuals.
Throughout the decades, Girardi’s clients and colleagues submitted reports of misconduct to the State Bar. The State Bar failed to issue any form of discipline against Girardi until 2021. Girardi’s law license was ordered inactive on March 9, 2021, and was disbarred by the California Supreme Court in July of the same year.
Lazar Report. In order to obtain an outside investigation about the matter, the State Bar commissioned a report by attorney Alyse Lazar to examine State Bar files regarding Girardi in early 2021. The Lazar investigation was conducted between March and May 2021. The report found that the State Bar’s investigative files did not include documentation of misconduct by State Bar staff or leadership within the files. Therefore, also not surprisingly, the Lazar investigation also “found no evidence of influence by Girardi in the files themselves.” In the report prepared after the investigation (known as the Lazar Report), Lazar noted “errors in how cases were handled over the four decades of Girardi’s career” and “significant issues regarding the investigation and evaluation of high-dollar, high-volume trust accounts.”
May Report. In response, the State Bar’s Board of Trustees hired the Los Angeles law firm Halpern May Ybarra Gelberg LLP to conduct an in-depth investigation of the State Bar’s handling of the Girardi matters. This report, known as the May Report, uncovered Girardi’s efforts to buy relationships and exercise influence at the State Bar and “the State Bar’s handling of past discipline complaints against Girardi was more likely than not affected by Girardi’s connections to and influence at the State Bar, and that there were multiple State Bar insiders who did not properly disclose their connections to Girardi, including employees who handled Girardi discipline cases.”
Legislative Response. In 2023, the Legislature passed and Governor Newsom signed SB 40 (Umberg, Chapter 697, Statutes of 2023). The bill provided a number of reforms relating to the State Bar. In particular, the legislation tightened disclosure and conflict requirements as well as conformed the State Bar with conflict provisions in existing law (i.e. Government Code 1090).
Comments
Author’s statement. According to the author: Following an investigation that found regulators at the State Bar had ties to now disbarred attorney Thomas V. Girardi, the State Bar has taken a number of actions to restore the public’s trust, including making changes to their conflict of interest provisions. During the process of enacting reforms, it became evident that a clarification was needed that specifically requires the enforcement provisions of the PRA to apply to the State Bar. Therefore, SB 1476 requires the State Bar’s conflict of interest codes to be in compliance with the PRA and clarifies the FPPC’s administrative enforcement authority with respect to the State Bar.
Related/Prior Legislation
SB 40 (Umberg, Chapter 697, Statutes of 2023), among other provisions, provided that members of the State Bar’s Board of Trustees and employees are subject to the conflicts of interest provisions relating to contracts.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: Yes
SUPPORT: (Verified 5/6/24)
State Bar of California (source)
Consumer Protection Policy Center
OPPOSITION: (Verified 5/6/24)
None received
Prepared by: Scott Matsumoto / E. & C.A. / (916) 651-4106
5/8/24 11:36:39
**** END ****
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: SB 1476 (Author:Blakespear)
Version: April 15, 2024
Hearing Date: April 23, 2024
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: AM
SUBJECT
Political Reform Act of 1974: State Bar of California
DIGEST
This bill requires the State Bar of California (State Bar) to have conflict of interest codes in compliance with the Political Reform Act of 1974 (PRA) and would provide that members of the Board of Trustees of the State Bar (Board) and designated employees are subject to the enforcement provisions under the PRA.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The State Bar has been embroiled in scandal over its handling, or lack thereof, of once prominent trial attorney Thomas Girardi, who has been accused of stealing millions of dollars from his clients over decades. An independent investigation was conducted examining the State Bar’s handling of complaints against Girard over the past 20 years, referred to as the May Report, which exposed numerous troubling revelations, including a lack of oversight and enforcement in regards to conflict of interest statement reporting at the State Bar. This bill seeks to remedy this by expressly requiring the State Bar to have conflict of interest codes in compliance with the PRA and subjecting members of the Board and designated employees to the enforcement provisions under the PRA.
This bill is sponsored by the State Bar and supported by the Consumer Protection Policy Center. No timely opposition was received by the Committee. This bill passed the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee on a vote of 7 to 0. The bill requires a two-third majority vote because it amends an initiative statute.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Requires all attorneys who practice law in California to be licensed by the State Bar and establishes the State Bar, within the judicial branch of state government, for the purpose of regulating the legal profession. (Cal. const., art. VI, § 9; Bus. & Prof. Code § 6000 et seq.)
- The Legislature sets the annual fees. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6140, 6141.)
- The State Bar is governed by the Board of Trustees of the State Bar (Board). (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6010 et seq.; § 6016.)
- Establishes that protection of the public, which includes support for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system, is the highest priority for the State Bar in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public is to be paramount. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6001.1.)
- Provides that the State Bar is governed by a Board of Trustees (Board) comprised of 13 members, six of who are public members and seven of who are licensed attorneys. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6010 et. seq.)
- Seven are attorney members, with five appointed by the Supreme Court, one by the Senate Committee on Rules and one by the Speaker of the Assembly. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6013.1 & 6013.5(a).)
- Six members are public members, with four appointed by the Governor subject to confirmation of the Senate, one by the Senate Committee on Rules, and one by the Speaker of the Assembly. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6013.5(c)-(d).)
- Requires the Board to appoint an executive director, general counsel, and chief trial counsel, subject to confirmation of the Senate. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6011, 3012, & 6079.5.)
- Provides that no law of this state restricting, or prescribing a mode of procedure for the exercise of powers of state public bodies or state agencies, or classes thereof, is applicable to the State Bar, unless the Legislature expressly so declares.
- Provides that members of the Board and employees of the State Bar are subject to the conflicts of interest provisions relating to contracts in Sections 1090 to 1097.2, inclusive of the Government Code, and members of the Board are deemed to be state officers and employees of the State Bar are deemed to be state employees thereunder. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6001(e)(3).)
- Establishes the Political Reform Act (PRA), which creates the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) and makes it responsible for the impartial, effective administration and implementation of the PRA. (Gov. Code § 81000.)
- Requires every state and local agency to adopt a conflict of interest code that identifies all officials and employees within the agency who make governmental decisions based on the positions they hold.
- Requires the individuals in the designated positions to disclose their financial interests, as specified in the agency’s conflict of interest code. (Gov. Code § 87300.)
- Authorizes the FPPC, when it determines there is probable cause for believing the PRA has been violated, to hold a hearing, as provided. (Gov. Code § 83116.)
- Provides that any person who knowingly or willfully violates the PRA is guilty of a misdemeanor. (Gov. Code § 91000(a).)
- A fine of up to the greater of $10,000 or three times the amount the person failed to report properly or unlawfully contributed, expended, gave or received may be imposed upon conviction for each violation, in addition to other penalties provided by law. (Id. at (b).)
This bill:
- Requires that State Bar to maintain a conflict of interest code for its Board and designated employees that meet the requirements for conflict of interest codes under the PRA.
- Authorizes the FPPC to enforce the provisions of the PRA that are applicable to members of the Board and designated employees of the State Bar.
- Specifies that the PRA applies to violations of the conflicts of interest provisions that are applicable to members of the Board and designated employees of the State Bar.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
Following an investigation that found regulators at the State Bar had ties to now disbarred attorney Thomas Girardi, the State Bar has taken a number of actions to restore the public’s trust, including making changes to their conflict of interest provisions. During the process of enacting reforms, it became evident that a clarification was needed that specifically requires the enforcement provisions of the PRA to apply to the State Bar. Therefore, SB 1476 requires the State Bar’s conflict of interest codes to be in compliance with the PRA and clarifies the FPPC’s administrative enforcement authority with respect to the State Bar.
- The FPPC and conflicts of interest
In the wake of the Watergate scandal, California voters enacted the PRA and established the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC) through Proposition 9 in 1974 (June 1974, prim. elec.). The FPPC is a five-member independent, non-partisan commission tasked with the responsibility of administering the PRA. Under the PRA, state and local agencies must adopt a conflict of interest code that identifies all officials and employees within the agency who make governmental decisions based on the positions they hold, and requires them to disclose their financial interests annually by filing a Form 700 with the FPPC. According to the FPPC, the Form 700 provides transparency and ensures accountability by providing transparency to the public so they can ensure that officials are making decisions in the best interest of the public and not enhancing their own personal finances, and it serves as a reminder to public officials and designated employees of potential conflicts of interest so they can abstain from making or participating in governmental decisions that are deemed conflicts of interest.[1] The PRA provides that a public official has a disqualifying conflict of interest in a governmental decision if it is foreseeable that the decision will have a financial impact on that individual’s personal finances or other financial interests. (Gov. Code § 87103.)
- The May Report showed a need to strengthen existing conflict of interest laws as they relate to the State Bar
- Background on State Bar
The State Bar is a public corporation and the largest state bar in the country with roughly 196,441 active licensed attorneys. Attorneys who wish to practice law in California generally must be admitted and licensed in this state and must be members of the State Bar. (Cal. Const., art. VI, § 9.) Although originally a creature of statute, the State Bar is now “a constitutional entity within the judicial article of the California Constitution.” (Obrien, supra, 23 Cal.4th at 48; see Cal. Const., art. VI, § 9; Bus. & Prof. Code, Sec. 6001.) The State Bar functions as the administrative arm of the Supreme Court for the purpose of assisting in attorney admissions and discipline, with the court retaining its inherent judicial authority to disbar or suspend attorneys. (In re Attorney Discipline System, supra, 19 Cal.4th at 599-600; see Keller v. State Bar of California (1990) 496 U.S. 1, 11.) At the same time, the Legislature’s exercise, under the police power, of a reasonable degree of regulation and control over the profession and practice of law in California, is well established. (Obrien, supra, 23 Cal.4th at 48.) The Legislature exercises regulatory authority pursuant to the State Bar Act and has authority to set the amount of membership fees necessary to fund the disciplinary system. The Legislature has enacted statutes making protection of the public the highest priority of the State Bar (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6001.1.)
- Girardi scandal and aftermath
As discussed above in the Executive Summary, in 2021 prominent attorney Tom Girardi was accused of stealing millions of dollars from his injured clients over decades. The Lazar Report confirmed that serious and repeated allegations of misconduct against Girardi were reported to the State Bar over decades, but the State Bar did not take any disciplinary action against him until 2021 when he was disbarred by the California Supreme Court after a disciplinary hearing by the State Bar.[2] This only occurred after a federal court found that Girardi had misappropriated $2 million that was awarded to victims’ families in the Lion Air flight 610 plane crash of 2018, and referred the matter to federal prosecutors for further investigation. This incident triggered numerous further accusations against Girardi for stealing client funds and the true scope of his malfeasance finally began to materialize. Eventually, Girardi and his law firm, Girardi Keese, were forced into bankruptcy. Last year Girardi was indicted by federal grand juries in Los Angeles and Chicago on charges that he embezzled more than $18 million from his clients.
After the findings of the Lazar Report, the State Bar initiated an independent investigation into Girardi and his relationship with the State Bar, which culminated in the May Report. The May Report’s findings were alarming and detailed a history of weak internal enforcement of conflict of interests and troubling relationships between employees of the State Bar and Girardi. The May Report noted that the State Bar had adopted a conflict of interest code substantially similar to the FPPC’s but when investigators requested to review Form 700s for individuals relevant to the inquiry “the State Bar was unable to locate all requested forms.” [3] For the Form 700s that the State Bar had on file, many were “incomplete and sometimes not even signed.”[4] The May Report noted that not requiring Form 700s to be tracked or completed accurately makes it difficult for the State Bar to identify conflicts of interest and hold individuals accountable for not handling conflicts in an appropriate manner. The May Report then went on to detail numerous conflicts of interest between certain States Bar employees that were never reported and several instances when those employees never even submitted the required Form 700.
The Senate and Assembly Judiciary Committees held a joint oversight hearing of the State Bar in May 2023 to examine the findings of both the Lazar Report and May Report.[5] At the hearing, members of both Committees expressed incredulity over the lackadaisical approach of the State Bar to ensuring Form 700s were filed and alarm that there seemed to be no clear entity that could punish non-compliant board members or employees under existing law. In last year’s State Bar fee authorization bill, SB 40 (Umberg, Ch. 697, Stats. 2023) some changes were made to strengthen conflict of interest statutes as they relate to the State Bar, including subjecting members of the Board and employees of the State Bar to specified conflict of interest provisions relating to contracts and expanding the scope of when a member is to disqualify themselves from a decision of the State Bar. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 6001(e)(3) & § 6036.) However, the May Report’s findings demonstrate a clear need to ensure that an independent entity was charged with overseeing and enforcing conflict of interest provisions for the State Bar. This bill does this by: (1) expressly requiring the State Bar to maintain a conflict of interest code for its Board members and designated employees that meet the requirements for conflict of interest codes under the PRA; and 2) authorizing the FPPC to enforce the provisions of the PRA made applicable to the State Bar, including civil penalties and criminal penalties.
The State Bar, who is the sponsor of this bill, notes that they have made several changes recently to address concerns raised in the May Report, including:
- Creating a Transparency and Accountability webpage[6] where the public can access Statements of Economic Interest and can view compliance of staff and Board members with Form 700 filing requirements, as well as requirements to disclose conflicts that could impact the handling of discipline matters.
- Imposing an additional conflict check before the closing of disciplinary matters (in addition to a conflict check when assigned a disciplinary matter) to ensure the staff involved in the closing decision identify whether they have any conflicts.
- Amending rules and procedures to require candidates for positions on the Board or as judges on the State Bar Court to disclose actual and potential financial and nonfinancial conflicts so that the committees charged with recommending appointments have complete information.
- Updating its conflict of interest codes for the Board and designated employees consistent with the requirements set forth by the FPPC in the California Code of Regulations. (2 Cal. Code of Regs. § 18700 et. seq.)
- Statements in support
The Consumer Protection Policy Center writes in support stating:
In recent years, the State Bar has taken a number of actions to address their mishandlings of complaints against attorneys and to restore the public’s trust, including changes to their conflict of interest provisions. During that process to strengthen accountability and improve transparency, it became evident that clarifications to the PRA were needed to ensure the State Bar’s conflict of interest code must be compliant with the PRA and that the enforcement provisions of the PRA apply to the State Bar.
SUPPORT
State Bar of California (sponsor)
Consumer Protection Policy Center
OPPOSITION
None received
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: AB 3279 (Committee on Judiciary, 2024) is the annual State Bar fee bill that makes various changes to the State Bar Act. This bill is currently pending in the Assembly Judiciary Committee.
Prior Legislation: SB 40 (Umberg, Ch. 697, Stats. 2023), among other things, provided that members of the Board and employees of the State Bar are subject to the conflicts of interest provisions relating to specified contracts.
PRIOR VOTES
Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 0)
**************
Statements of Economic Interests - Form 700, Fair Pol. Practices Comm. https://www.fppc.ca.gov/Form700.html. ↑
Lazar Report (released Mar. 10, 223), available at https://www.calbar.ca.gov/Portals/0/documents/reports/Lazar-Report-and-Attachment-Redacted.pdf. ↑
May Report (released Feb. 4, 2023), available at https://www.calbar.ca.gov/Portals/0/documents/reports/May-Report-and-Addendum-Redacted.pdf at p. 10. ↑
Ibid. ↑
For a detailed description of the findings of both the Lazar Report and the May Report see The California State Bar - Administrative Arm of the Supreme Court:
Disconcerting Revelations Raise Questions About its Ability to Protect the Public, Oversight Hearing of the Ass. and Sen. Comm. on Judiciary, (May 2023) available at https://sjud.senate.ca.gov/sites/sjud.senate.ca.gov/files/background_paper_final_letterhead.pdf. ↑
https://www.calbar.ca.gov/About-Us/Our-Mission/Protecting-the-Public/Transparency-Accountability. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
Senator Catherine Blakespear, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: SB Hearing Date: 4/2/24
Author: | |||
Version: | 2/16/24 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Scott Matsumoto | ||
Subject: Political Reform Act of 1974: State Bar of California
DIGEST
This bill specifies that the State Bar of California (State Bar) maintain conflict of interest codes in compliance with the PRA and provides that members of the State Bar’s Board of Trustees and designated employees are subject to the enforcement of violations of the PRA.
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Establishes the State Bar as a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. Provides that every person admitted and licensed to practice law in California is and shall be a member of the State Bar except while holding office as a judge of a court of record.
- Provides that protection of the public, which includes support for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system, shall be the highest priority for the State Bar of California and the board of trustees in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Provides that whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount.
- Provides that the State Bar’s board of trustees and employees of the State Bar shall be subject to the conflicts of interest provisions relating to contracts, pursuant to a specific code sections in the Government Code, and members of the board of trustees of the State Bar shall be deemed state officers and employees of the State Bar shall be deemed state employees thereunder.
- Requires any member of the State Bar’s board of trustees to disqualify themself from making, participating in the making of, or attempting to influence any decisions of the State Bar in which the member has a financial interest that it is reasonably foreseeable may be affected materially by the decision. Requires any member of the State Bar’s board of trustees to disqualify themself when there exists a personal interest that may prevent the member from applying disinterested skill and undivided loyalty to the State Bar in making or participating in the making of decisions.
- Provides that no member of the State Bar shall be prevented from making or participating in the making of any decision to the extent that the member’s participation is legally required for the action or decision to be made, as specified.
- Requires a member of the State Bar who disqualifies themself because of a conflict of interest to (1) immediately disclose the interest, (2) withdraw from any participation in the matter, (3) refrain from attempting to influence another member, and (4) refrain from voting. It is sufficient for the purpose of this section that the member indicate only that the member has a disqualifying financial or personal interest.
- Creates the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC), and makes it responsible for the impartial, effective administration and implementation of the Political Reform Act (PRA).
- Requires every state and local agency to adopt a conflict of interest code that identifies all officials and employees within the agency who make governmental decisions based on the positions they hold. The individuals in the designated positions must disclose their financial interests, as specified in the agency’s conflict of interest code.
This bill:
- Specifies that the State Bar maintain conflict of interest codes in compliance with the PRA and provides that members of the State Bar’s Board of Trustees and designated employees are subject to the enforcement of violations of the PRA.
BACKGROUND
Political Reform Act of 1974. In 1974, California voters passed Proposition 9, an initiative commonly known as the PRA. Proposition 9 created the FPPC and codified significant restrictions and prohibitions on candidates, officeholders, and lobbyists. The Legislature is permitted to amend the PRA, but the amendments must further the purposes of the PRA and requires a two-thirds vote of both houses of the Legislature.
Conflict of Interest Codes. The PRA prohibits a public official from using their official position to influence a governmental decision in which the individual has a financial interest. Every state and local agency must adopt a conflict of interest code that identifies all officials and employees within the agency who make governmental decisions based on the positions they hold. The individuals in the designated positions must disclose their financial interests, as specified in the agency’s conflict of interest code. Existing law also requires public officials and employees in designated positions in a conflict of interest code to report their financial interests on a form called Statement of Economic Interests (Form 700).
According to the FPPC’s website, a conflict of interest code must:
- Provide reasonable assurance that all foreseeable potential conflict of interest situations will be disclosed or prevented;
- Provide to each affected person a clear and specific statement of his or her duties under the conflict of interest code; and
- Adequately differentiate between designated employees with different powers and responsibilities.
Each agency is required to review its conflict of interest code at least every other year - state agencies in odd-numbered years and local agencies in even-numbered years.
State Bar of California. Attorneys who wish to practice law in California generally must be admitted and licensed by the State Bar. The State Bar of California is the largest state bar in the country, with approximately over 195,000 active licensees and 64,000 inactive licensees. The mission of the State Bar is, “to protect the public and includes the primary functions of licensing, regulation and discipline of attorneys; the advancement of the ethical and competent practice of law; and support of efforts for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system.”
Over the past few years, the State Bar has been a topic of concern within the Legislature and legal community. Recently, these concerns have appropriately focused on seemingly irresponsible management of the agency’s funds and a failure to implement an effective disciplinary process, highlighted by the downfall of Thomas Girardi and his law firm. These issues have engendered significant skepticism about the State Bar and have triggered renewed calls for reform.
Thomas Girardi. In 2020, the Los Angeles Times broke the story of Thomas V. Girardi, a renowned plaintiff’s attorney, who allegedly embezzled millions of dollars from his clients.
In response to the scandal, the State Bar initiated an investigation into Girardi. However, the issues relating to the State Bar’s involvement with Girardi came to public attention when the Los Angeles Times published a series of articles detailing how “the powerful lawyer cultivated close relationships with investigators and bar executives and showered them with gifts, including private plane rides, boozy lunches at Morton’s, free legal representation and Vegas shindigs.” In June of 2021, the State Bar made what was described as a “stunning public admission” that an audit of Girardi’s disciplinary file “revealed mistakes made in some investigations over the many decades of Mr. Girardi’s career going back some 40 years and spanning the tenure of many Chief Trial Counsels.”
According to the State Bar, it began investigating its own misconduct related to Girardi on an unspecified date “in 2021.” In an Open Letter from the State Bar in November of 2022, the State Bar described its efforts to get to the bottom of what they did and did not do vis-à-vis Girardi and how it handled repeated complaints from the public about Girardi’s serious misconduct as follows:
The State Bar began the process of righting the wrongs brought to light by the Girardi matters in 2021, when [the State Bar] conducted an audit of all closed disciplinary matters concerning Girardi. That was followed by a comprehensive investigation into prior actions taken by any staff or other State Bar affiliated persons, to determine whether the State Bar’s handling of matters involving Girardi was affected by his connections to, or relationships or influence with these individuals.
Throughout the decades, Girardi’s clients and colleagues submitted reports of misconduct to the State Bar. The State Bar failed to issue any form of discipline against Girardi until 2021. Girardi’s law license was ordered inactive on March 9, 2021, and was disbarred by the California Supreme Court in July of the same year.
Lazar Report. In order to obtain an outside investigation about the matter, the State Bar commissioned a report by attorney Alyse Lazar to examine State Bar files regarding Girardi in early 2021. The Lazar investigation was conducted between March and May 2021. The report found that the State Bar’s investigative files did not include documentation of misconduct by State Bar staff or leadership within the files. Therefore, also not surprisingly, the Lazar investigation also “found no evidence of influence by Girardi in the files themselves.” In the report prepared after the investigation (known as the Lazar Report), Lazar noted “errors in how cases were handled over the four decades of Girardi’s career” and “significant issues regarding the investigation and evaluation of high-dollar, high-volume trust accounts.”
May Report. In response, the State Bar’s Board of Trustees hired the Los Angeles law firm Halpern May Ybarra Gelberg LLP to conduct an in-depth investigation of the State Bar’s handling of the Girardi matters. This report, known as the May Report, uncovered Girardi’s efforts to buy relationships and exercise influence at the State Bar and “the State Bar’s handling of past discipline complaints against Girardi was more likely than not affected by Girardi’s connections to and influence at the State Bar, and that there were multiple State Bar insiders who did not properly disclose their connections to Girardi, including employees who handled Girardi discipline cases.”
Legislative Response. In 2023, the Legislature passed and Governor Newsom signed SB 40 (Umberg), Chapter 697, Statutes of 2023. SB 40 provided a number of reforms relating to the State Bar. In particular, the legislation tightened disclosure and conflict requirements as well as conformed the State Bar with conflict provisions in existing law (i.e. Government Code 1090).
COMMENTS
- According to the author: Following an investigation that found regulators at the State Bar had ties to now disbarred attorney Thomas V. Girardi, the State Bar has taken a number of actions to restore the public’s trust, including making changes to their conflict of interest provisions. During the process of enacting reforms, it became evident that a clarification was needed that specifically requires the enforcement provisions of the PRA to apply to the State Bar. Therefore, SB 1476 requires the State Bar’s conflict of interest codes to be in compliance with the PRA and clarifies the FPPC’s administrative enforcement authority with respect to the State Bar.
- Double Referral. If approved by this committee, SB 1476 will be referred to the Committee on Judiciary for further consideration.
- Argument in Support. In a letter sponsoring SB 1476, the State Bar stated, in part, the following:
SB 1476 makes explicit in the Political Reform Act the requirement for the State Bar to maintain conflict of interest codes for its Board of Trustees and staff that meet the requirements of the Political Reform Act. The bill clarifies that violations of the State Bar’s conflict of interest codes are violations of law enforceable under the Political Reform Act. Importantly, the bill also makes it explicit that the enforcement provisions of the Act apply to the State Bar. These are important changes to bolster the State Bar’s efforts to strengthen our conflict of interest rules, policies, and procedures and ensure the conflict of interest codes have teeth, by making clear there are consequences for violations.
RELATED/PRIOR LEGISLATION
SB 40 (Umberg), Chapter 697, Statutes of 2023, among other provisions, provided that members of the State Bar’s Board of Trustees and employees are subject to the conflicts of interest provisions relating to contracts.
POSITIONS
Sponsor: State Bar of California
Support: Consumer Protection Policy Center
Oppose: None received
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
ELECTIONS AND CONSTITUTIONAL AMENDMENTS
Senator Catherine Blakespear, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular
Bill No: 1476 Hearing Date: 4/2/24
Author: | Blakespear | ||
Version: |
| ||
Urgency: | Fiscal: | ||
Consultant: | |||
Subject:
DIGEST
This bill specifies that the State Bar of California (State Bar) maintain conflict of interest codes in compliance with the PRA and provides that members of the State Bar’s Board of Trustees and designated employees are subject to the enforcement of violations of the PRA.
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Establishes the State Bar as a public corporation governed by a board of trustees. Provides that every person admitted and licensed to practice law in California is and shall be a member of the State Bar except while holding office as a judge of a court of record.
- Provides that protection of the public, which includes support for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system, shall be the highest priority for the State Bar of California and the board of trustees in exercising their licensing, regulatory, and disciplinary functions. Provides that whenever the protection of the public is inconsistent with other interests sought to be promoted, the protection of the public shall be paramount.
- Provides that the State Bar’s board of trustees and employees of the State Bar shall be subject to the conflicts of interest provisions relating to contracts, pursuant to a specific code sections in the Government Code, and members of the board of trustees of the State Bar shall be deemed state officers and employees of the State Bar shall be deemed state employees thereunder.
- Requires any member of the State Bar’s board of trustees to disqualify themself from making, participating in the making of, or attempting to influence any decisions of the State Bar in which the member has a financial interest that it is reasonably foreseeable may be affected materially by the decision. Requires any member of the State Bar’s board of trustees to disqualify themself when there exists a personal interest that may prevent the member from applying disinterested skill and undivided loyalty to the State Bar in making or participating in the making of decisions.
- Provides that no member of the State Bar shall be prevented from making or participating in the making of any decision to the extent that the member’s participation is legally required for the action or decision to be made, as specified.
- Requires a member of the State Bar who disqualifies themself because of a conflict of interest to (1) immediately disclose the interest, (2) withdraw from any participation in the matter, (3) refrain from attempting to influence another member, and (4) refrain from voting. It is sufficient for the purpose of this section that the member indicate only that the member has a disqualifying financial or personal interest.
- Creates the Fair Political Practices Commission (FPPC), and makes it responsible for the impartial, effective administration and implementation of the Political Reform Act (PRA).
- Requires every state and local agency to adopt a conflict of interest code that identifies all officials and employees within the agency who make governmental decisions based on the positions they hold. The individuals in the designated positions must disclose their financial interests, as specified in the agency’s conflict of interest code.
This bill:
- Specifies that the State Bar maintain conflict of interest codes in compliance with the PRA and provides that members of the State Bar’s Board of Trustees and designated employees are subject to the enforcement of violations of the PRA.
BACKGROUND
Political Reform Act of 1974. In 1974, California voters passed Proposition 9, an initiative commonly known as the PRA. Proposition 9 created the FPPC and codified significant restrictions and prohibitions on candidates, officeholders, and lobbyists. The Legislature is permitted to amend the PRA, but the amendments must further the purposes of the PRA and requires a two-thirds vote of both houses of the Legislature.
Conflict of Interest Codes. The PRA prohibits a public official from using their official position to influence a governmental decision in which the individual has a financial interest. Every state and local agency must adopt a conflict of interest code that identifies all officials and employees within the agency who make governmental decisions based on the positions they hold. The individuals in the designated positions must disclose their financial interests, as specified in the agency’s conflict of interest code. Existing law also requires public officials and employees in designated positions in a conflict of interest code to report their financial interests on a form called Statement of Economic Interests (Form 700).
According to the FPPC’s website, a conflict of interest code must:
- Provide reasonable assurance that all foreseeable potential conflict of interest situations will be disclosed or prevented;
- Provide to each affected person a clear and specific statement of his or her duties under the conflict of interest code; and
- Adequately differentiate between designated employees with different powers and responsibilities.
Each agency is required to review its conflict of interest code at least every other year - state agencies in odd-numbered years and local agencies in even-numbered years.
State Bar of California. Attorneys who wish to practice law in California generally must be admitted and licensed by the State Bar. The State Bar of California is the largest state bar in the country, with approximately over 195,000 active licensees and 64,000 inactive licensees. The mission of the State Bar is, “to protect the public and includes the primary functions of licensing, regulation and discipline of attorneys; the advancement of the ethical and competent practice of law; and support of efforts for greater access to, and inclusion in, the legal system.”
Over the past few years, the State Bar has been a topic of concern within the Legislature and legal community. Recently, these concerns have appropriately focused on seemingly irresponsible management of the agency’s funds and a failure to implement an effective disciplinary process, highlighted by the downfall of Thomas Girardi and his law firm. These issues have engendered significant skepticism about the State Bar and have triggered renewed calls for reform.
Thomas Girardi. In 2020, the Los Angeles Times broke the story of Thomas V. Girardi, a renowned plaintiff’s attorney, who allegedly embezzled millions of dollars from his clients.
In response to the scandal, the State Bar initiated an investigation into Girardi. However, the issues relating to the State Bar’s involvement with Girardi came to public attention when the Los Angeles Times published a series of articles detailing how “the powerful lawyer cultivated close relationships with investigators and bar executives and showered them with gifts, including private plane rides, boozy lunches at Morton’s, free legal representation and Vegas shindigs.” In June of 2021, the State Bar made what was described as a “stunning public admission” that an audit of Girardi’s disciplinary file “revealed mistakes made in some investigations over the many decades of Mr. Girardi’s career going back some 40 years and spanning the tenure of many Chief Trial Counsels.”
According to the State Bar, it began investigating its own misconduct related to Girardi on an unspecified date “in 2021.” In an Open Letter from the State Bar in November of 2022, the State Bar described its efforts to get to the bottom of what they did and did not do vis-à-vis Girardi and how it handled repeated complaints from the public about Girardi’s serious misconduct as follows:
The State Bar began the process of righting the wrongs brought to light by the Girardi matters in 2021, when we conducted an audit of all closed disciplinary matters concerning Girardi. That was followed by a comprehensive investigation into prior actions taken by any staff or other State Bar affiliated persons, to determine whether the State Bar’s handling of matters involving Girardi was affected by his connections to, or relationships or influence with these individuals.
Throughout the decades, Girardi’s clients and colleagues submitted reports of misconduct to the State Bar. The State Bar failed to issue any form of discipline against Girardi until 2021. Girardi’s law license was ordered inactive on March 9, 2021, and was disbarred by the California Supreme Court in July of the same year.
Lazar Report. In order to obtain an outside investigation about the matter, the State Bar commissioned a report by attorney Alyse Lazar to examine State Bar files regarding Girardi in early 2021. The Lazar investigation was conducted between March and May 2021. The report found that the State Bar’s investigative files did not include documentation of misconduct by State Bar staff or leadership within the files. Therefore, also not surprisingly, the Lazar investigation also “found no evidence of influence by Girardi in the files themselves.” In the report prepared after the investigation (known as the Lazar Report), Lazar noted “errors in how cases were handled over the four decades of Girardi’s career” and “significant issues regarding the investigation and evaluation of high-dollar, high-volume trust accounts.”
May Report. In response, the State Bar’s Board of Trustees hired the Los Angeles law firm Halpern May Ybarra Gelberg LLP to conduct an in-depth investigation of the State Bar’s handling of the Girardi matters. This report, known as the May Report, uncovered Girardi’s efforts to buy relationships and exercise influence at the State Bar and “the State Bar’s handling of past discipline complaints against Girardi was more likely than not affected by Girardi’s connections to and influence at the State Bar, and that there were multiple State Bar insiders who did not properly disclose their connections to Girardi, including employees who handled Girardi discipline cases.”
Legislative Response. In 2023, the Legislature passed and Governor Newsom signed SB 40 (Umberg), Chapter 697, Statutes of 2023. SB 40 provided a number of reforms relating to the State Bar. In particular, the legislation tightened disclosure and conflict requirements as well as conformed the State Bar with conflict provisions in existing law (i.e. Government Code 1090).
COMMENTS
- According to the author: Following an investigation that found regulators at the State Bar had ties to now disbarred attorney Thomas V. Girardi, the State Bar has taken a number of actions to restore the public’s trust, including making changes to their conflict of interest provisions. During the process of enacting reforms, it became evident that a clarification was needed that specifically requires the enforcement provisions of the PRA to apply to the State Bar. Therefore, SB 1476 requires the State Bar’s conflict of interest codes to be in compliance with the PRA and clarifies the FPPC’s administrative enforcement authority with respect to the State Bar.
- Double Referral. If approved by this committee, SB 1476 will be referred to the Committee on Judiciary for further consideration.
- Argument in Support. In a letter sponsoring SB 1476, the State Bar stated, in part, the following:
SB 1476 makes explicit in the Political Reform Act the requirement for the State Bar to maintain conflict of interest codes for its Board of Trustees and staff that meet the requirements of the Political Reform Act. The bill clarifies that violations of the State Bar’s conflict of interest codes are violations of law enforceable under the Political Reform Act. Importantly, the bill also makes it explicit that the enforcement provisions of the Act apply to the State Bar. These are important changes to bolster the State Bar’s efforts to strengthen our conflict of interest rules, policies, and procedures and ensure the conflict of interest codes have teeth, by making clear there are consequences for violations.
RELATED/PRIOR LEGISLATION
SB 40 (Umberg), Chapter 697, Statutes of 2023, among other provisions, provided that members of the State Bar’s Board of Trustees and employees are subject to the conflicts of interest provisions relating to contracts.
POSITIONS
Sponsor: State Bar of California
Support: Consumer Protection Policy Center
Oppose: None received
-- END --
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):