AB 2319: California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2024-09-26
Current Status:
Passed
(2024-09-26: Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 621, Statutes of 2024.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law requires the State Department of Public Health to maintain a program of maternal and child health, which may include, among other things, facilitating services directed toward reducing infant mortality and improving the health of mothers and children. Existing law requires the Office of Health Equity within the department to serve as a resource for ensuring that programs collect and keep data and information regarding ethnic and racial health statistics, and strategies and programs that address multicultural health issues, including, but not limited to, infant and maternal mortality. Existing law makes legislative findings relating to implicit bias and racial disparities in maternal mortality rates. Existing law requires a hospital that provides perinatal care, and an alternative birth center or a primary clinic that provides services as an alternative birth center, to implement an evidence-based implicit bias program, as specified, for all health care providers involved in perinatal care of patients within those facilities. Existing law requires the health care provider to complete initial basic training through the program and a refresher course every 2 years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility. Existing law requires the facility to provide a certificate of training completion upon request, to accept certificates of completion from other facilities, and to offer training to physicians not directly employed by the facility. Existing law requires the department to track and publish data on pregnancy-related death and severe maternal morbidity, as specified.
This bill would make a legislative finding that the Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience. The bill would extend the evidence-based implicit bias training requirements to specified health care providers at hospitals that provide perinatal care, alternative birth centers, or primary care clinics, as specified. The bill would require an implicit bias program to include recognition of intersecting identities and the potential associated biases. The bill would require initial basic training for the implicit bias program to be completed by June 1, 2025, for current health care providers, and within 6 months of their start date for new health care providers, unless exempted. The bill would require specified facilities to, by February 1 of each year, commencing in 2026, provide the Attorney General with proof of compliance with these provisions, as specified. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to pursue civil penalties for violations of these provisions, as specified. The bill would require that Attorney General be awarded all attorneys fees and costs in any civil action in which a court imposes any of those civil penalties. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to post on its internet website a list of facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance or were assessed penalties under these provisions, as specified. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to post any other compliance data they deem necessary and would authorize the Attorney General to biennially publish a report outlining compliance data related to these provisions. The bill would make the provisions of the act severable.
Existing law requires the State Department of Public Health to maintain a program of maternal and child health, which may include, among other things, facilitating services directed toward reducing infant mortality and improving the health of mothers and children. Existing law requires the Office of Health Equity within the department to serve as a resource for ensuring that programs collect and keep data and information regarding ethnic and racial health statistics, and strategies and programs that address multicultural health issues, including, but not limited to, infant and maternal mortality. Existing law makes legislative findings relating to implicit bias and racial disparities in maternal mortality rates. Existing law requires a hospital that provides perinatal care, and an alternative birth center or a primary clinic that provides services as an alternative birth center, to implement an evidence-based implicit bias program, as specified, for all health care providers involved in perinatal care of patients within those facilities. Existing law requires the health care provider to complete initial basic training through the program and a refresher course every 2 years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility. Existing law requires the facility to provide a certificate of training completion upon request, to accept certificates of completion from other facilities, and to offer training to physicians not directly employed by the facility. Existing law requires the department to track and publish data on pregnancy-related death and severe maternal morbidity, as specified.
This bill would make a legislative finding that the Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience. The bill would extend the evidence-based implicit bias training requirements to specified health care providers at hospitals that provide perinatal care, alternative birth centers, or primary care clinics, as specified. The bill would require an implicit bias program to include recognition of intersecting identities and the potential associated biases. The bill would require initial basic training for the implicit bias program to be completed by June 1, 2025, for current health care providers, and within 6 months of their start date for new health care providers, unless exempted. The bill would require specified facilities to, by February 1 of each year, commencing in 2026, provide the Attorney General with proof of compliance with these provisions, as specified. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to pursue civil penalties for violations of these provisions, as specified. The bill would require that Attorney General be awarded all attorneys fees and costs in any civil action in which a court imposes any of those civil penalties. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to post on its internet website a list of facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance or were assessed penalties under these provisions, as specified. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to post any other compliance data they deem necessary and would authorize the Attorney General to biennially publish a report outlining compliance data related to these provisions. The bill would make the provisions of the act severable.
Existing law requires the State Department of Public Health to maintain a program of maternal and child health, which may include, among other things, facilitating services directed toward reducing infant mortality and improving the health of mothers and children. Existing law requires the Office of Health Equity within the department to serve as a resource for ensuring that programs collect and keep data and information regarding ethnic and racial health statistics, and strategies and programs that address multicultural health issues, including, but not limited to, infant and maternal mortality. Existing law makes legislative findings relating to implicit bias and racial disparities in maternal mortality rates. Existing law requires a hospital that provides perinatal care, and an alternative birth center or a primary clinic that provides services as an alternative birth center, to implement an evidence-based implicit bias program, as specified, for all health care providers involved in perinatal care of patients within those facilities. Existing law requires the health care provider to complete initial basic training through the program and a refresher course every 2 years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility. Existing law requires the facility to provide a certificate of training completion upon request, to accept certificates of completion from other facilities, and to offer training to physicians not directly employed by the facility. Existing law requires the department to track and publish data on pregnancy-related death and severe maternal morbidity, as specified.
This bill would make a legislative finding that the Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience. The bill would extend the evidence-based implicit bias training requirements to specified health care providers at hospitals that provide perinatal care, alternative birth centers, or primary care clinics, as specified. The bill would require an implicit bias program to include recognition of intersecting identities and the potential associated biases. The bill would require initial basic training for the implicit bias program to be completed by June 1, 2025, for current health care providers, and within 6 months of their start date for new health care providers, unless exempted. The bill would require specified facilities to, by February 1 of each year, commencing in 2026, provide the Attorney General with proof of compliance with these provisions, as specified. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to pursue civil penalties for violations of these provisions, as specified. The bill would require that Attorney General be awarded all attorneys fees and costs in any civil action in which a court imposes any of those civil penalties. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to post on its internet website a list of facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance or were assessed penalties under these provisions, as specified. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to post any other compliance data they deem necessary and would authorize the Attorney General to biennially publish a report outlining compliance data related to these provisions. The bill would make the provisions of the act severable.
Existing law requires the State Department of Public Health to maintain a program of maternal and child health, which may include, among other things, facilitating services directed toward reducing infant mortality and improving the health of mothers and children. Existing law requires the Office of Health Equity within the department to serve as a resource for ensuring that programs collect and keep data and information regarding ethnic and racial health statistics, and strategies and programs that address multicultural health issues, including, but not limited to, infant and maternal mortality. Existing law makes legislative findings relating to implicit bias and racial disparities in maternal mortality rates. Existing law requires a hospital that provides perinatal care, and an alternative birth center or a primary clinic that provides services as an alternative birth center, to implement an evidence-based implicit bias program, as specified, for all health care providers involved in perinatal care of patients within those facilities. Existing law requires the health care provider to complete initial basic training through the program and a refresher course every 2 years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility. Existing law requires the facility to provide a certificate of training completion upon request, to accept certificates of completion from other facilities, and to offer training to physicians not directly employed by the facility. Existing law requires the department to track and publish data on pregnancy-related death and severe maternal morbidity, as specified.
This bill would make a legislative finding that the Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience. The bill would extend the evidence-based implicit bias training requirements to specified health care providers at hospitals that provide perinatal care, alternative birth centers, or primary care clinics, as specified. The bill would require an implicit bias program to include recognition of intersecting identities and the potential associated biases. The bill would require initial basic training for the implicit bias program to be completed by June 1, 2025, for current health care providers, and within 6 months of their start date for new health care providers, unless exempted. The bill would require specified facilities to, by February 1 of each year, commencing in 2026, provide the Attorney General with proof of compliance with these provisions, as specified. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to pursue civil penalties for violations of these provisions, as specified. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to post on its internet website a list of facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance or were assessed penalties under these provisions, as specified. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to post any other compliance data they deem necessary and would authorize the Attorney General to biennially publish a report outlining compliance data related to these provisions. The bill would make the provisions of the act severable.
Existing law requires the State Department of Public Health to maintain a program of maternal and child health, which may include, among other things, facilitating services directed toward reducing infant mortality and improving the health of mothers and children. Existing law requires the Office of Health Equity within the department to serve as a resource for ensuring that programs collect and keep data and information regarding ethnic and racial health statistics, and strategies and programs that address multicultural health issues, including, but not limited to, infant and maternal mortality. Existing law makes legislative findings relating to implicit bias and racial disparities in maternal mortality rates. Existing law requires a hospital that provides perinatal care, and an alternative birth center or a primary clinic that provides services as an alternative birth center, to implement an evidence-based implicit bias program, as specified, for all health care providers involved in perinatal care of patients within those facilities. Existing law requires the health care provider to complete initial basic training through the program and a refresher course every 2 years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility. Existing law requires the facility to provide a certificate of training completion upon request, to accept certificates of completion from other facilities, and to offer training to physicians not directly employed by the facility. Existing law requires the department to track and publish data on pregnancy-related death and severe maternal morbidity, as specified.
This bill would make a legislative finding that the Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience. The bill would extend the evidence-based implicit bias training requirements to also include hospitals that provide perinatal care, as defined. specified health care providers at hospitals that provide perinatal care, alternative birth centers, or primary care clinics, as specified. The bill would require an implicit bias program to include recognition of intersecting identities and the potential associated biases. The bill would require initial basic training for the implicit bias program to be completed by June 1, 2025, for current health care providers, and within 6 months of their start date for new health care providers, unless exempted. The bill would require specified facilities to, by February 1 of each year, commencing in 2026, provide the Attorney General with proof of compliance with these provisions, as specified. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to pursue civil penalties for violations of these provisions, as specified. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to post on its internet website a list of facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance or were assessed penalties under these provisions, as specified. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to post any other compliance data they deem necessary and would authorize the Attorney General to biennially publish a report outlining compliance data related to these provisions. The bill would make the provisions of the act severable.
Existing law requires the State Department of Public Health to maintain a program of maternal and child health, which may include, among other things, facilitating services directed toward reducing infant mortality and improving the health of mothers and children. Existing law requires the Office of Health Equity within the department to serve as a resource for ensuring that programs collect and keep data and information regarding ethnic and racial health statistics, and strategies and programs that address multicultural health issues, including, but not limited to, infant and maternal mortality. Existing law makes legislative findings relating to implicit bias and racial disparities in maternal mortality rates. Existing law requires a hospital that provides perinatal care, and an alternative birth center or a primary clinic that provides services as an alternative birth center, to implement an evidence-based implicit bias program, as specified, for all health care providers involved in perinatal care of patients within those facilities. Existing law requires the health care provider to complete initial basic training through the program and a refresher course every 2 years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility. Existing law requires the facility to provide a certificate of training completion upon request, to accept certificates of completion from other facilities, and to offer training to physicians not directly employed by the facility. Existing law requires the department to track and publish data on pregnancy-related death and severe maternal morbidity, as specified.
This bill would make a legislative finding that the Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience. The bill would extend the evidence-based implicit bias training requirements to also include hospitals that provide perinatal care, as defined. The bill would require an implicit bias program to include recognition of intersecting identities and the potential associated biases. The bill would require initial basic training for the implicit bias program to be completed by June 1, 2025, for current health care providers, and within 6 months of their start date for new health care providers, unless exempted. The bill would require specified facilities to document each employees implicit bias training in accordance with regulations adopted by the department for documenting staff development programs. The bill would require the department to assess each hospitals compliance with this requirement during periodic inspections. The bill would authorize the department to issue an administrative penalty if it determines that a facility has violated these provisions, and would require the department to annually post on its internet website a list of facilities that have been issued administrative penalties. The bill would vest the State Department of Public Health with full administrative power, authority, and jurisdiction to implement and enforce the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. The bill would require the department to solicit participation and adopt regulations to further the purposes of the act, as specified. to, by February 1 of each year, commencing in 2026, provide the Attorney General with proof of compliance with these provisions, as specified. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to pursue civil penalties for violations of these provisions, as specified. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to post on its internet website a list of facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance or were assessed penalties under these provisions, as specified. The bill would authorize the Attorney General to post any other compliance data they deem necessary and would authorize the Attorney General to biennially publish a report outlining compliance data related to these provisions. The bill would make the provisions of the act severable.
Existing law requires the State Department of Public Health to maintain a program of maternal and child health, which may include, among other things, facilitating services directed toward reducing infant mortality and improving the health of mothers and children. Existing law requires the Office of Health Equity within the department to serve as a resource for ensuring that programs collect and keep data and information regarding ethnic and racial health statistics, and strategies and programs that address multicultural health issues, including, but not limited to, infant and maternal mortality. Existing law makes legislative findings relating to implicit bias and racial disparities in maternal mortality rates. Existing law requires a hospital that provides perinatal care, and an alternative birth center or a primary clinic that provides services as an alternative birth center, to implement an evidence-based implicit bias program, as specified, for all health care providers involved in perinatal care of patients within those facilities. Existing law requires the health care provider to complete initial basic training through the program and a refresher course every 2 years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility. Existing law requires the facility to provide a certificate of training completion upon request, to accept certificates of completion from other facilities, and to offer training to physicians not directly employed by the facility. Existing law requires the department to track and publish data on pregnancy-related death and severe maternal morbidity, as specified.
This bill would make a legislative finding that the Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience. The bill would extend the evidence-based implicit bias training requirements to also include hospitals that provide perinatal or prenatal care, as defined. The bill would require an implicit bias program to include recognition of intersecting identities and the potential associated biases. The bill would require initial basic training for the implicit bias program to be completed by June 1, 2025, for current health care providers, and within 6 months of their start date for new health care providers, unless exempted. The bill would require, by February 1 of each year, that a facility provide the department with proof of compliance, with specified requirements. The bill would require specified facilities to document each employees implicit bias training in accordance with regulations adopted by the department for documenting staff development programs. The bill would require the department to assess each hospitals compliance with this requirement during periodic inspections. The bill would authorize the department to issue an administrative penalty if it determines that a facility has violated these provisions, and would require the department to annually post on its internet website a list of facilities that did not submit timely proof of compliance and have been issued administrative penalties. The bill would specify that, for these purposes, each health care provider that does not complete the required training constitutes a separate violation. The bill would vest the State Department of Public Health with full administrative power, authority, and jurisdiction to implement and enforce the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. The bill would require the department to solicit participation and adopt regulations to further the purposes of the act, as specified. The bill would make the provisions of the act severable.
Existing law requires the State Department of Public Health to maintain a program of maternal and child health, which may include, among other things, facilitating services directed toward reducing infant mortality and improving the health of mothers and children. Existing law requires the Office of Health Equity within the department to serve as a resource for ensuring that programs collect and keep data and information regarding ethnic and racial health statistics, and strategies and programs that address multicultural health issues, including, but not limited to, infant and maternal mortality. Existing law makes legislative findings relating to implicit bias and racial disparities in maternal mortality rates. Existing law requires a hospital that provides perinatal care, and an alternative birth center or a primary clinic that provides services as an alternative birth center, to implement an evidence-based implicit bias program, as specified, for all health care providers involved in perinatal care of patients within those facilities. Existing law requires the health care provider to complete initial basic training through the program and a refresher course every 2 years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility. Existing law requires the facility to provide a certificate of training completion upon request, to accept certificates of completion from other facilities, and to offer training to physicians not directly employed by the facility. Existing law requires the department to track and publish data on pregnancy-related death and severe maternal morbidity, as specified.
This bill would make a legislative finding that the Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience. The bill would extend the evidence-based implicit bias training requirements to also include hospitals that provide perinatal or prenatal care, as defined. The bill would require an implicit bias program to include recognition of intersecting identities and the potential associated biases. The bill would require initial basic training for the implicit bias program to be completed by June 1, 2025, for current health care providers, and within 6 months of their start date for new health care providers, unless exempted. The bill would require, by February 1 of each year, that a facility provide the department with proof of compliance, with specified requirements. The bill would authorize the department to issue an administrative penalty if it determines that a facility has violated these provisions, and would require the department to annually post on its internet website a list of facilities that did not submit timely proof of compliance and have been issued administrative penalties. The bill would specify that, for these purposes, each health care provider that does not complete the required training constitutes a separate violation. The bill would vest the State Department of Public Health with full administrative power, authority, and jurisdiction to implement and enforce the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. The bill would require the department to solicit participation and adopt regulations to further the purposes of the act, as specified.
The Legislature hereby finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Every person should be entitled to dignity and respect during and after pregnancy and childbirth. Patients should receive the best care possible regardless of their race, gender, age, class, sexual orientation, gender identity, disability, language proficiency, nationality, immigration status, gender expression, or religion.
(b)The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. About 700 women die each year from childbirth, and another 50,000 suffer from severe complications. In California, since 2006, the rate of maternal death has decreased 55 percent, in contrast to the steady increase in the United States as a whole.
(c)However, for women of color, particularly Black women, the maternal mortality rate remains three to four times higher than White women. Black women make up 5 percent of the pregnancy cohort in California, but 21 percent of the pregnancy-related deaths.
(d)Forty-one percent of all pregnancy-related deaths had a good to strong chance of preventability. California has a responsibility to decrease the number of preventable pregnancy-related deaths.
(e)Pregnancy-related deaths among Black women are also more likely to be miscoded. Thirty-five percent of pregnancy-related deaths among Black women in California were miscoded, misidentifying pregnancy-related deaths as other deaths.
(f)Access to prenatal care, socioeconomic status, and general physical health do not fully explain the disparity seen in Black womens maternal mortality and morbidity rates. There is a growing body of evidence that Black women are often treated unfairly and unequally in the health care system.
(g)Implicit bias is a key cause that drives health disparities in communities of color. At present, health care providers in California are not required to undergo any implicit bias testing or training. Nor does there exist any system to track the number of incidents where implicit prejudice and implicit stereotypes have led to negative birth and maternal health outcomes.
(h)It is the intent of the Legislature to reduce the effects of implicit bias in pregnancy, childbirth, and postnatal care so that all people are treated with dignity and respect by their health care providers.
(i)The Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience.
(j)All persons who may interact with perinatal patients to gatekeep, facilitate, or coordinate access to timely, responsive, respectful, and appropriate medical care may impact Black birthing persons maternal mortality and morbidity outcomes, including, but not limited to, hospital or facility employees who facilitate, control, or directly or indirectly coordinate access to timely and appropriate medical treatment as well as those who provide medical and ancillary treatment.
SEC. 2.Section 123630.2 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:123630.2.For the purposes of this article, the following terms have the following meanings:
(a)Pregnancy-related death is the death of a person while pregnant or within 365 days of the end of a pregnancy, irrespective of the duration or site of the pregnancy, from any cause related to, or aggravated by, the pregnancy or its management, but not from accidental or incidental causes.
(b)Implicit bias is a bias in judgment or behavior that results from subtle cognitive processes, including implicit prejudice and implicit stereotypes that often operate at a level below conscious awareness and without intentional control.
(c)Implicit prejudice is prejudicial negative feelings or beliefs about a group that a person holds without being aware of them.
(d)Implicit stereotypes are the unconscious attributions of particular qualities to a member of a certain social group. Implicit stereotypes are influenced by experience and are based on learned associations between various qualities and social categories, including race or gender.
(e)Perinatal care is the provision of care during pregnancy, labor, delivery, and postpartum and neonatal periods. Perinatal care includes, but is not limited to, prenatal care.
SEC. 3.Section 123630.3 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:123630.3.(a)A hospital as defined in subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 1250 that provides perinatal care, and an alternative birth center or primary care clinic subject to Section 1204.3, shall implement an evidence-based implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities, including:
(1)All persons licensed under Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code (commencing with Section 500) who are regularly assigned to provide perinatal care, including, but not limited to, those in primary care clinics, alternative birthing centers, outpatient clinics, or emergency departments.
(2)All persons who are regularly assigned to positions where they interact with perinatal patients, including, but not limited to, physician assistants, medical assistants, licensed vocational nurses, doctors, or those who facilitate, control, or coordinate access to timely and appropriate medical treatment, as well as any others who provide medical and ancillary treatment.
(b)An implicit bias program implemented pursuant to subdivision (a) shall include all of the following:
(1)Identification of previous or current unconscious biases and misinformation.
(2)Identification of personal, interpersonal, institutional, structural, and cultural barriers to inclusion.
(3)Corrective measures to decrease implicit bias at the interpersonal and institutional levels, including ongoing policies and practices for that purpose.
(4)Information on the effects, including, but not limited to, ongoing personal effects, of historical and contemporary exclusion and oppression of minority communities.
(5)Information about cultural identity across racial or ethnic groups.
(6)Information about communicating more effectively across identities, including racial, ethnic, religious, and gender identities.
(7)Discussion on power dynamics and organizational decisionmaking.
(8)Discussion on health inequities within the perinatal care field, including information on how implicit bias impacts maternal and infant health outcomes.
(9)Perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, cultural, and provider-community relations issues in the community.
(10)Information on reproductive justice.
(11)Recognition of intersecting identities, including, but not limited to, nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience, and the multiple layers of potential biases that could come into play, resulting in harm to patients and their infants.
(c)(1)A health care provider described in subdivision (a) shall complete initial basic training through the implicit bias program based on the components described in subdivision (b). This initial basic training must be completed by June 1, 2025, for all current health care providers. The initial basic training must be provided to new health care providers at all facilities within six months of their start at the new facility unless subdivision (d) applies.
(2)Upon completion of the initial basic training, a health care provider shall complete a refresher course under the implicit bias program every two years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends and best practices in decreasing interpersonal and institutional implicit bias.
(3)The training shall be provided during paid work time.
(d)A facility described in subdivision (a) shall provide a certificate of training completion to another facility or a training attendee upon request. A facility may accept a certificate of completion from another facility described in subdivision (a) to satisfy the training requirement described in subdivision (c) for a health care provider who works in more than one facility.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, if a physician involved in the perinatal care of patients is not directly employed by a facility, the facility shall offer the training to the physician.
(f)By February 1 of each year, commencing in 2026, a facility described in subdivision (a) shall provide the Attorney General with proof of compliance. Proof of compliance shall include all of the following:
(1)A list of all of the health care providers described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) who completed the training requirements outlined in subdivision (c).
(2)The dates that each health care provider completed their training.
(3)The written materials used in the training.
(4)A description of the training, including substance, format, and duration.
(5)A list that outlines the categories by job title of the health care providers described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) who did not participate in the training, if any. Each category shall include both of the following:
(A)A delineation of the respective health care provider or providers by employee status.
(B)The number and percentage of the health care providers who failed to complete the training out of the total relevant health care providers within the respective category.
(g)A facility described in subdivision (a) that violates the requirement to implement an implicit bias program pursuant to subdivision (a) of this section, or fails to submit proof of compliance to the Attorney General pursuant to subdivision (f) of this section shall be liable for a civil penalty of five thousand dollars ($5,000) for the first violation and fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) for the second and each subsequent violation. In the event a facilitys proof of compliance submitted to the Attorney General reveals systemic failure of providers to complete the training requirements outlined in subdivision (c), the facility shall be liable for a civil penalty of five thousand dollars ($5,000) for the first violation, and fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) for the second and each subsequent violation. Civil penalties specified in this subdivision shall be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General in any court of competent jurisdiction. The Attorney General shall be awarded all attorneys fees and costs in any civil action in which a court imposes any of the penalties described in this section. The penalties provided by this subdivision are not exclusive and do not limit other remedies available in law for such violations.
(h)(1)For purposes of subdivision (g), systemic failure means the lesser of the following:
(A)Ten percent or more of providers failing to complete the training, provided that if only one or two providers did not receive the training, the facility was provided a reasonable opportunity to cure before a penalty is pursued.
(B)Twenty-five providers failing to complete the required training.
(2)For purposes of the definition of systemic failure, failure by a physician who is not directly employed by the facility shall not be counted toward the percentage of providers failing to complete the required training where the facility demonstrates that the required training was offered to the physician, pursuant to subdivision (e).
(i)The Attorney General may post on their website a list of all facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance pursuant to subdivision (f) or that were assessed penalties pursuant to subdivision (g). The Attorney General may include all of the following information when listing the facilities that were assessed penalties:
(1)The date the penalty was issued.
(2)The amount of the penalty.
(3)The reason the penalty was issued.
(4)The percentage of untrained providers.
(5)The date of facility noncompliance.
(j)The Attorney General may post on their internet website any other compliance data related to this article they deem appropriate.
(k)This section shall not be construed to limit the Attorney General from disclosing, on their internet website or otherwise, any information that they are otherwise not restricted from disclosing by any other provision of law.
SEC. 4.Section 123630.6 is added to the Health and Safety Code, immediately following Section 123630.5, to read:123630.6.The Attorney General may publish a report outlining compliance data related to this article on a biennial basis. The report may be posted on the Attorney Generals internet website.
SEC. 5.Section 123630.7 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:123630.7.If any provision of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, or the application of any such provision to any person or circumstances, shall be held invalid, the remainder of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, to the extent it can be given effect, or the application of such provision to persons or circumstances other than those as to which it is held invalid, shall not be affected thereby, and to this end the provisions of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act are severable.
The Legislature hereby finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Every person should be entitled to dignity and respect during and after pregnancy and childbirth. Patients should receive the best care possible regardless of their race, gender, age, class, sexual orientation, gender identity, disability, language proficiency, nationality, immigration status, gender expression, or religion.
(b)The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. About 700 women die each year from childbirth, and another 50,000 suffer from severe complications. In California, since 2006, the rate of maternal death has decreased 55 percent, in contrast to the steady increase in the United States as a whole.
(c)However, for women of color, particularly Black women, the maternal mortality rate remains three to four times higher than White women. Black women make up 5 percent of the pregnancy cohort in California, but 21 percent of the pregnancy-related deaths.
(d)Forty-one percent of all pregnancy-related deaths had a good to strong chance of preventability. California has a responsibility to decrease the number of preventable pregnancy-related deaths.
(e)Pregnancy-related deaths among Black women are also more likely to be miscoded. Thirty-five percent of pregnancy-related deaths among Black women in California were miscoded, misidentifying pregnancy-related deaths as other deaths.
(f)Access to prenatal care, socioeconomic status, and general physical health do not fully explain the disparity seen in Black womens maternal mortality and morbidity rates. There is a growing body of evidence that Black women are often treated unfairly and unequally in the health care system.
(g)Implicit bias is a key cause that drives health disparities in communities of color. At present, health care providers in California are not required to undergo any implicit bias testing or training. Nor does there exist any system to track the number of incidents where implicit prejudice and implicit stereotypes have led to negative birth and maternal health outcomes.
(h)It is the intent of the Legislature to reduce the effects of implicit bias in pregnancy, childbirth, and postnatal care so that all people are treated with dignity and respect by their health care providers.
(i)The Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience.
(j)All persons who may interact with perinatal patients to gatekeep, facilitate, or coordinate access to timely, responsive, respectful, and appropriate medical care may impact Black birthing persons maternal mortality and morbidity outcomes, including, but not limited to, hospital or facility employees who facilitate, control, or directly or indirectly coordinate access to timely and appropriate medical treatment as well as those who provide medical and ancillary treatment.
SEC. 2.Section 123630.2 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:123630.2.For the purposes of this article, the following terms have the following meanings:
(a)Pregnancy-related death is the death of a person while pregnant or within 365 days of the end of a pregnancy, irrespective of the duration or site of the pregnancy, from any cause related to, or aggravated by, the pregnancy or its management, but not from accidental or incidental causes.
(b)Implicit bias is a bias in judgment or behavior that results from subtle cognitive processes, including implicit prejudice and implicit stereotypes that often operate at a level below conscious awareness and without intentional control.
(c)Implicit prejudice is prejudicial negative feelings or beliefs about a group that a person holds without being aware of them.
(d)Implicit stereotypes are the unconscious attributions of particular qualities to a member of a certain social group. Implicit stereotypes are influenced by experience and are based on learned associations between various qualities and social categories, including race or gender.
(e)Perinatal care is the provision of care during pregnancy, labor, delivery, and postpartum and neonatal periods. Perinatal care includes, but is not limited to, prenatal care.
SEC. 3.Section 123630.3 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:123630.3.(a)A hospital as defined in subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 1250 that provides perinatal care, and an alternative birth center or primary care clinic subject to Section 1204.3, shall implement an evidence-based implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities, including:
(1)All persons licensed under Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code (commencing with Section 500) who are regularly assigned to provide perinatal care, including, but not limited to, those in primary care clinics, alternative birthing centers, outpatient clinics, or emergency departments.
(2)All persons who are regularly assigned to positions where they interact with perinatal patients, including, but not limited to, physician assistants, medical assistants, licensed vocational nurses, doctors, or those who facilitate, control, or coordinate access to timely and appropriate medical treatment, as well as any others who provide medical and ancillary treatment.
(b)An implicit bias program implemented pursuant to subdivision (a) shall include all of the following:
(1)Identification of previous or current unconscious biases and misinformation.
(2)Identification of personal, interpersonal, institutional, structural, and cultural barriers to inclusion.
(3)Corrective measures to decrease implicit bias at the interpersonal and institutional levels, including ongoing policies and practices for that purpose.
(4)Information on the effects, including, but not limited to, ongoing personal effects, of historical and contemporary exclusion and oppression of minority communities.
(5)Information about cultural identity across racial or ethnic groups.
(6)Information about communicating more effectively across identities, including racial, ethnic, religious, and gender identities.
(7)Discussion on power dynamics and organizational decisionmaking.
(8)Discussion on health inequities within the perinatal care field, including information on how implicit bias impacts maternal and infant health outcomes.
(9)Perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, cultural, and provider-community relations issues in the community.
(10)Information on reproductive justice.
(11)Recognition of intersecting identities, including, but not limited to, nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience, and the multiple layers of potential biases that could come into play, resulting in harm to patients and their infants.
(c)(1)A health care provider described in subdivision (a) shall complete initial basic training through the implicit bias program based on the components described in subdivision (b). This initial basic training must be completed by June 1, 2025, for all current health care providers. The initial basic training must be provided to new health care providers at all facilities within six months of their start at the new facility unless subdivision (d) applies.
(2)Upon completion of the initial basic training, a health care provider shall complete a refresher course under the implicit bias program every two years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends and best practices in decreasing interpersonal and institutional implicit bias.
(3)The training shall be provided during paid work time.
(d)A facility described in subdivision (a) shall provide a certificate of training completion to another facility or a training attendee upon request. A facility may accept a certificate of completion from another facility described in subdivision (a) to satisfy the training requirement described in subdivision (c) for a health care provider who works in more than one facility.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, if a physician involved in the perinatal care of patients is not directly employed by a facility, the facility shall offer the training to the physician.
(f)By February 1 of each year, commencing in 2026, a facility described in subdivision (a) shall provide the Attorney General with proof of compliance. Proof of compliance shall include all of the following:
(1)A list of all of the health care providers described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) who completed the training requirements outlined in subdivision (c).
(2)The dates that each health care provider completed their training.
(3)The written materials used in the training.
(4)A description of the training, including substance, format, and duration.
(5)A list that outlines the categories by job title of the health care providers described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) who did not participate in the training, if any. Each category shall include both of the following:
(A)A delineation of the respective health care provider or providers by employee status.
(B)The number and percentage of the health care providers who failed to complete the training out of the total relevant health care providers within the respective category.
(g)A facility described in subdivision (a) that violates the requirement to implement an implicit bias program pursuant to subdivision (a) of this section, or fails to submit proof of compliance to the Attorney General pursuant to subdivision (f) of this section shall be liable for a civil penalty of five thousand dollars ($5,000) for the first violation and fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) for the second and each subsequent violation. In the event a facilitys proof of compliance submitted to the Attorney General reveals systemic failure of providers to complete the training requirements outlined in subdivision (c), the facility shall be liable for a civil penalty of five thousand dollars ($5,000) for the first violation, and fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) for the second and each subsequent violation. Civil penalties specified in this subdivision shall be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General in any court of competent jurisdiction. The Attorney General shall be awarded all attorneys fees and costs in any civil action in which a court imposes any of the penalties described in this section. The penalties provided by this subdivision are not exclusive and do not limit other remedies available in law for such violations.
(h)(1)For purposes of subdivision (g), systemic failure means the lesser of the following:
(A)Ten percent or more of providers failing to complete the training, provided that if only one or two providers did not receive the training, the facility was provided a reasonable opportunity to cure before a penalty is pursued.
(B)Twenty-five providers failing to complete the required training.
(2)For purposes of the definition of systemic failure, failure by a physician who is not directly employed by the facility shall not be counted toward the percentage of providers failing to complete the required training where the facility demonstrates that the required training was offered to the physician, pursuant to subdivision (e).
(i)The Attorney General may post on their website a list of all facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance pursuant to subdivision (f) or that were assessed penalties pursuant to subdivision (g). The Attorney General may include all of the following information when listing the facilities that were assessed penalties:
(1)The date the penalty was issued.
(2)The amount of the penalty.
(3)The reason the penalty was issued.
(4)The percentage of untrained providers.
(5)The date of facility noncompliance.
(j)The Attorney General may post on their internet website any other compliance data related to this article they deem appropriate.
(k)This section shall not be construed to limit the Attorney General from disclosing, on their internet website or otherwise, any information that they are otherwise not restricted from disclosing by any other provision of law.
SEC. 4.Section 123630.6 is added to the Health and Safety Code, immediately following Section 123630.5, to read:123630.6.The Attorney General may publish a report outlining compliance data related to this article on a biennial basis. The report may be posted on the Attorney Generals internet website.
SEC. 5.Section 123630.7 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:123630.7.If any provision of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, or the application of any such provision to any person or circumstances, shall be held invalid, the remainder of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, to the extent it can be given effect, or the application of such provision to persons or circumstances other than those as to which it is held invalid, shall not be affected thereby, and to this end the provisions of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act are severable.
The Legislature hereby finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Every person should be entitled to dignity and respect during and after pregnancy and childbirth. Patients should receive the best care possible regardless of their race, gender, age, class, sexual orientation, gender identity, disability, language proficiency, nationality, immigration status, gender expression, or religion.
(b)The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. About 700 women die each year from childbirth, and another 50,000 suffer from severe complications. In California, since 2006, the rate of maternal death has decreased 55 percent, in contrast to the steady increase in the United States as a whole.
(c)However, for women of color, particularly Black women, the maternal mortality rate remains three to four times higher than White women. Black women make up 5 percent of the pregnancy cohort in California, but 21 percent of the pregnancy-related deaths.
(d)Forty-one percent of all pregnancy-related deaths had a good to strong chance of preventability. California has a responsibility to decrease the number of preventable pregnancy-related deaths.
(e)Pregnancy-related deaths among Black women are also more likely to be miscoded. Thirty-five percent of pregnancy-related deaths among Black women in California were miscoded, misidentifying pregnancy-related deaths as other deaths.
(f)Access to prenatal care, socioeconomic status, and general physical health do not fully explain the disparity seen in Black womens maternal mortality and morbidity rates. There is a growing body of evidence that Black women are often treated unfairly and unequally in the health care system.
(g)Implicit bias is a key cause that drives health disparities in communities of color. At present, health care providers in California are not required to undergo any implicit bias testing or training. Nor does there exist any system to track the number of incidents where implicit prejudice and implicit stereotypes have led to negative birth and maternal health outcomes.
(h)It is the intent of the Legislature to reduce the effects of implicit bias in pregnancy, childbirth, and postnatal care so that all people are treated with dignity and respect by their health care providers.
(i)The Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience.
(j)All persons who may interact with perinatal patients to gatekeep, facilitate, or coordinate access to timely, responsive, respectful, and appropriate medical care may impact Black birthing persons maternal mortality and morbidity outcomes, including, but not limited to, hospital or facility employees who facilitate, control, or directly or indirectly coordinate access to timely and appropriate medical treatment as well as those who provide medical and ancillary treatment.
SEC. 2.Section 123630.2 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:123630.2.For the purposes of this article, the following terms have the following meanings:
(a)Pregnancy-related death is the death of a person while pregnant or within 365 days of the end of a pregnancy, irrespective of the duration or site of the pregnancy, from any cause related to, or aggravated by, the pregnancy or its management, but not from accidental or incidental causes.
(b)Implicit bias is a bias in judgment or behavior that results from subtle cognitive processes, including implicit prejudice and implicit stereotypes that often operate at a level below conscious awareness and without intentional control.
(c)Implicit prejudice is prejudicial negative feelings or beliefs about a group that a person holds without being aware of them.
(d)Implicit stereotypes are the unconscious attributions of particular qualities to a member of a certain social group. Implicit stereotypes are influenced by experience and are based on learned associations between various qualities and social categories, including race or gender.
(e)Perinatal care is the provision of care during pregnancy, labor, delivery, and postpartum and neonatal periods. Perinatal care includes, but is not limited to, prenatal care.
SEC. 3.Section 123630.3 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:123630.3.(a)A hospital as defined in subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 1250 that provides perinatal care, and an alternative birth center or primary care clinic subject to Section 1204.3, shall implement an evidence-based implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities, including:
(1)All persons licensed under Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code (commencing with Section 500) who are regularly assigned to provide perinatal care, including, but not limited to, those in primary care clinics, alternative birthing centers, outpatient clinics, or emergency departments.
(2)All persons who are regularly assigned to positions where they interact with perinatal patients, including, but not limited to, physician assistants, medical assistants, licensed vocational nurses, doctors, or those who facilitate, control, or coordinate access to timely and appropriate medical treatment, as well as any others who provide medical and ancillary treatment.
(b)An implicit bias program implemented pursuant to subdivision (a) shall include all of the following:
(1)Identification of previous or current unconscious biases and misinformation.
(2)Identification of personal, interpersonal, institutional, structural, and cultural barriers to inclusion.
(3)Corrective measures to decrease implicit bias at the interpersonal and institutional levels, including ongoing policies and practices for that purpose.
(4)Information on the effects, including, but not limited to, ongoing personal effects, of historical and contemporary exclusion and oppression of minority communities.
(5)Information about cultural identity across racial or ethnic groups.
(6)Information about communicating more effectively across identities, including racial, ethnic, religious, and gender identities.
(7)Discussion on power dynamics and organizational decisionmaking.
(8)Discussion on health inequities within the perinatal care field, including information on how implicit bias impacts maternal and infant health outcomes.
(9)Perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, cultural, and provider-community relations issues in the community.
(10)Information on reproductive justice.
(11)Recognition of intersecting identities, including, but not limited to, nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience, and the multiple layers of potential biases that could come into play, resulting in harm to patients and their infants.
(c)(1)A health care provider described in subdivision (a) shall complete initial basic training through the implicit bias program based on the components described in subdivision (b). This initial basic training must be completed by June 1, 2025, for all current health care providers. The initial basic training must be provided to new health care providers at all facilities within six months of their start at the new facility unless subdivision (d) applies.
(2)Upon completion of the initial basic training, a health care provider shall complete a refresher course under the implicit bias program every two years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends and best practices in decreasing interpersonal and institutional implicit bias.
(3)The training shall be provided during paid work time.
(d)A facility described in subdivision (a) shall provide a certificate of training completion to another facility or a training attendee upon request. A facility may accept a certificate of completion from another facility described in subdivision (a) to satisfy the training requirement described in subdivision (c) for a health care provider who works in more than one facility.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, if a physician involved in the perinatal care of patients is not directly employed by a facility, the facility shall offer the training to the physician.
(f)By February 1 of each year, commencing in 2026, a facility described in subdivision (a) shall provide the Attorney General with proof of compliance. Proof of compliance shall include all of the following:
(1)A list of all of the health care providers described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) who completed the training requirements outlined in subdivision (c).
(2)The dates that each health care provider completed their training.
(3)The written materials used in the training.
(4)A description of the training, including substance, format, and duration.
(5)A list that outlines the categories by job title of the health care providers described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) who did not participate in the training, if any. Each category shall include both of the following:
(A)A delineation of the respective health care provider or providers by employee status.
(B)The number and percentage of the health care providers who failed to complete the training out of the total relevant health care providers within the respective category.
(g)A facility described in subdivision (a) that violates the requirement to implement an implicit bias program pursuant to subdivision (a) of this section, or fails to submit proof of compliance to the Attorney General pursuant to subdivision (f) of this section shall be liable for a civil penalty of five thousand dollars ($5,000) for the first violation and fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) for the second and each subsequent violation. In the event a facilitys proof of compliance submitted to the Attorney General reveals systemic failure of providers to complete the training requirements outlined in subdivision (c), the facility shall be liable for a civil penalty of five thousand dollars ($5,000) for the first violation, and fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) for the second and each subsequent violation. Civil penalties specified in this subdivision shall be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General in any court of competent jurisdiction. The Attorney General shall be awarded all attorneys fees and costs in any civil action in which a court imposes any of the penalties described in this section. The penalties provided by this subdivision are not exclusive and do not limit other remedies available in law for such violations.
(h)(1)For purposes of subdivision (g), systemic failure means the lesser of the following:
(A)Ten percent or more of providers failing to complete the training, provided that if only one or two providers did not receive the training, the facility was provided a reasonable opportunity to cure before a penalty is pursued.
(B)Twenty-five providers failing to complete the required training.
(2)For purposes of the definition of systemic failure, failure by a physician who is not directly employed by the facility shall not be counted toward the percentage of providers failing to complete the required training where the facility demonstrates that the required training was offered to the physician, pursuant to subdivision (e).
(i)The Attorney General may post on their website a list of all facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance pursuant to subdivision (f) or that were assessed penalties pursuant to subdivision (g). The Attorney General may include all of the following information when listing the facilities that were assessed penalties:
(1)The date the penalty was issued.
(2)The amount of the penalty.
(3)The reason the penalty was issued.
(4)The percentage of untrained providers.
(5)The date of facility noncompliance.
(j)The Attorney General may post on their internet website any other compliance data related to this article they deem appropriate.
(k)This section shall not be construed to limit the Attorney General from disclosing, on their internet website or otherwise, any information that they are otherwise not restricted from disclosing by any other provision of law.
SEC. 4.Section 123630.6 is added to the Health and Safety Code, immediately following Section 123630.5, to read:123630.6.The Attorney General may publish a report outlining compliance data related to this article on a biennial basis. The report may be posted on the Attorney Generals internet website.
SEC. 5.Section 123630.7 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:123630.7.If any provision of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, or the application of any such provision to any person or circumstances, shall be held invalid, the remainder of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, to the extent it can be given effect, or the application of such provision to persons or circumstances other than those as to which it is held invalid, shall not be affected thereby, and to this end the provisions of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act are severable.
The Legislature hereby finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Every person should be entitled to dignity and respect during and after pregnancy and childbirth. Patients should receive the best care possible regardless of their race, gender, age, class, sexual orientation, gender identity, disability, language proficiency, nationality, immigration status, gender expression, or religion.
(b)The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. About 700 women die each year from childbirth, and another 50,000 suffer from severe complications. In California, since 2006, the rate of maternal death has decreased 55 percent, in contrast to the steady increase in the United States as a whole.
(c)However, for women of color, particularly Black women, the maternal mortality rate remains three to four times higher than White women. Black women make up 5 percent of the pregnancy cohort in California, but 21 percent of the pregnancy-related deaths.
(d)Forty-one percent of all pregnancy-related deaths had a good to strong chance of preventability. California has a responsibility to decrease the number of preventable pregnancy-related deaths.
(e)Pregnancy-related deaths among Black women are also more likely to be miscoded. Thirty-five percent of pregnancy-related deaths among Black women in California were miscoded, misidentifying pregnancy-related deaths as other deaths.
(f)Access to prenatal care, socioeconomic status, and general physical health do not fully explain the disparity seen in Black womens maternal mortality and morbidity rates. There is a growing body of evidence that Black women are often treated unfairly and unequally in the health care system.
(g)Implicit bias is a key cause that drives health disparities in communities of color. At present, health care providers in California are not required to undergo any implicit bias testing or training. Nor does there exist any system to track the number of incidents where implicit prejudice and implicit stereotypes have led to negative birth and maternal health outcomes.
(h)It is the intent of the Legislature to reduce the effects of implicit bias in pregnancy, childbirth, and postnatal care so that all people are treated with dignity and respect by their health care providers.
(i)The Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience.
(j)All persons who may interact with perinatal patients to gatekeep, facilitate, or coordinate access to timely, responsive, respectful, and appropriate medical care may impact Black birthing persons maternal mortality and morbidity outcomes, including, but not limited to, hospital or facility employees who facilitate, control, or directly or indirectly coordinate access to timely and appropriate medical treatment as well as those who provide medical and ancillary treatment.
SEC. 2.Section 123630.2 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:123630.2.For the purposes of this article, the following terms have the following meanings:
(a)Pregnancy-related death is the death of a person while pregnant or within 365 days of the end of a pregnancy, irrespective of the duration or site of the pregnancy, from any cause related to, or aggravated by, the pregnancy or its management, but not from accidental or incidental causes.
(b)Implicit bias is a bias in judgment or behavior that results from subtle cognitive processes, including implicit prejudice and implicit stereotypes that often operate at a level below conscious awareness and without intentional control.
(c)Implicit prejudice is prejudicial negative feelings or beliefs about a group that a person holds without being aware of them.
(d)Implicit stereotypes are the unconscious attributions of particular qualities to a member of a certain social group. Implicit stereotypes are influenced by experience and are based on learned associations between various qualities and social categories, including race or gender.
(e)Perinatal care is the provision of care during pregnancy, labor, delivery, and postpartum and neonatal periods. Perinatal care includes, but is not limited to, prenatal care.
SEC. 3.Section 123630.3 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:123630.3.(a)A hospital as defined in subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 1250 that provides perinatal care, and an alternative birth center or primary care clinic subject to Section 1204.3, shall implement an evidence-based implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities, including:
(1)All persons licensed under Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code (commencing with Section 500) who are regularly assigned to provide perinatal care, including, but not limited to, those in primary care clinics, alternative birthing centers, outpatient clinics, or emergency departments.
(2)All persons who are regularly assigned to positions where they interact with perinatal patients, including, but not limited to, physician assistants, medical assistants, licensed vocational nurses, doctors, or those who facilitate, control, or coordinate access to timely and appropriate medical treatment, as well as any others who provide medical and ancillary treatment.
(b)An implicit bias program implemented pursuant to subdivision (a) shall include all of the following:
(1)Identification of previous or current unconscious biases and misinformation.
(2)Identification of personal, interpersonal, institutional, structural, and cultural barriers to inclusion.
(3)Corrective measures to decrease implicit bias at the interpersonal and institutional levels, including ongoing policies and practices for that purpose.
(4)Information on the effects, including, but not limited to, ongoing personal effects, of historical and contemporary exclusion and oppression of minority communities.
(5)Information about cultural identity across racial or ethnic groups.
(6)Information about communicating more effectively across identities, including racial, ethnic, religious, and gender identities.
(7)Discussion on power dynamics and organizational decisionmaking.
(8)Discussion on health inequities within the perinatal care field, including information on how implicit bias impacts maternal and infant health outcomes.
(9)Perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, cultural, and provider-community relations issues in the community.
(10)Information on reproductive justice.
(11)Recognition of intersecting identities, including, but not limited to, nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience, and the multiple layers of potential biases that could come into play, resulting in harm to patients and their infants.
(c)(1)A health care provider described in subdivision (a) shall complete initial basic training through the implicit bias program based on the components described in subdivision (b). This initial basic training must be completed by June 1, 2025, for all current health care providers. The initial basic training must be provided to new health care providers at all facilities within six months of their start at the new facility unless subdivision (d) applies.
(2)Upon completion of the initial basic training, a health care provider shall complete a refresher course under the implicit bias program every two years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends and best practices in decreasing interpersonal and institutional implicit bias.
(3)The training shall be provided during paid work time.
(d)A facility described in subdivision (a) shall provide a certificate of training completion to another facility or a training attendee upon request. A facility may accept a certificate of completion from another facility described in subdivision (a) to satisfy the training requirement described in subdivision (c) for a health care provider who works in more than one facility.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, if a physician involved in the perinatal care of patients is not directly employed by a facility, the facility shall offer the training to the physician.
(f)By February 1 of each year, commencing in 2026, a facility described in subdivision (a) shall provide the Attorney General with proof of compliance. Proof of compliance shall include all of the following:
(1)A list of all of the health care providers described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) who completed the training requirements outlined in subdivision (c).
(2)The dates that each health care provider completed their training.
(3)The written materials used in the training.
(4)A description of the training, including format substance, format, and duration.
(5)A list that outlines the categories by job title of the health care providers described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) who did not participate in the training, if any. Each category shall include both of the following:
(A)A delineation of the respective health care provider or providers by employee status.
(B)The number and percentage of the health care providers who failed to complete the training out of the total relevant health care providers within the respective category.
(g)A facility described in subdivision (a) that violates the provisions of this section requirement to implement an implicit bias program pursuant to subdivision (a) of this section, or fails to submit proof of compliance to the Attorney General pursuant to subdivision (f) of this section shall be liable for a civil penalty of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) five thousand dollars ($5,000) for the first violation and twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) for the second and each subsequent violation, which violation. In the event a facilitys proof of compliance submitted to the Attorney General reveals systemic failure of providers to complete the training requirements outlined in subdivision (c), the facility shall be liable for a civil penalty of five thousand dollars ($5,000) for the first violation, and fifteen thousand dollars ($15,000) for the second and each subsequent violation. Civil penalties specified in this subdivision shall be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General in any court of competent jurisdiction. For purposes of this subdivision, each health care provider that does not timely complete the required training before the relevant deadline described in subdivision (c) shall constitute a separate violation for purposes of determining the first, second, or subsequent violations. The penalties provided by this subdivision are not exclusive and do not limit other remedies available in law for such violations.
(h)(1)For purposes of subdivision (g), systemic failure means the lesser of the following:
(A)Ten percent or more of providers failing to complete the training, provided that if only one or two providers did not receive the training, the facility was provided a reasonable opportunity to cure before a penalty is pursued.
(B)Twenty-five providers failing to complete the required training.
(2)For purposes of the definition of systemic failure, failure by a physician who is not directly employed by the facility shall not be counted toward the percentage of providers failing to complete the required training where the facility demonstrates that the required training was offered to the physician, pursuant to subdivision (e).
(h)(i)The Attorney General may post on their website a list of all facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance pursuant to subdivision (f) or that were assessed penalties pursuant to subdivision (g). The Attorney General may include all of the following information when listing the facilities that were assessed penalties:
(1)The date the penalty was issued.
(2)The amount of the penalty.
(3)The reason the penalty was issued.
(4)The percentage of untrained providers.
(5)The date of facility noncompliance.
(i)(j)The Attorney General may post on their internet website any other compliance data related to this article they deem appropriate.
(j)(k)This section shall not be construed to limit the Attorney General from disclosing, on their internet website or otherwise, any information that they are otherwise not restricted from disclosing by any other provision of law.
SEC. 4.Section 123630.6 is added to the Health and Safety Code, immediately following Section 123630.5, to read:123630.6.The Attorney General may publish a report outlining compliance data related to this article on a biennial basis. The report may be posted on the Attorney Generals internet website.
SEC. 5.Section 123630.7 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:123630.7.If any provision of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, or the application of any such provision to any person or circumstances, shall be held invalid, the remainder of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, to the extent it can be given effect, or the application of such provision to persons or circumstances other than those as to which it is held invalid, shall not be affected thereby, and to this end the provisions of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act are severable.
The Legislature hereby finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Every person should be entitled to dignity and respect during and after pregnancy and childbirth. Patients should receive the best care possible regardless of their race, gender, age, class, sexual orientation, gender identity, disability, language proficiency, nationality, immigration status, gender expression, or religion.
(b)The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. About 700 women die each year from childbirth, and another 50,000 suffer from severe complications. In California, since 2006, the rate of maternal death has decreased 55 percent, in contrast to the steady increase in the United States as a whole.
(c)However, for women of color, particularly Black women, the maternal mortality rate remains three to four times higher than White women. Black women make up 5 percent of the pregnancy cohort in California, but 21 percent of the pregnancy-related deaths.
(d)Forty-one percent of all pregnancy-related deaths had a good to strong chance of preventability. California has a responsibility to decrease the number of preventable pregnancy-related deaths.
(e)Pregnancy-related deaths among Black women are also more likely to be miscoded. Thirty-five percent of pregnancy-related deaths among Black women in California were miscoded, misidentifying pregnancy-related deaths as other deaths.
(f)Access to prenatal care, socioeconomic status, and general physical health do not fully explain the disparity seen in Black womens maternal mortality and morbidity rates. There is a growing body of evidence that Black women are often treated unfairly and unequally in the health care system.
(g)Implicit bias is a key cause that drives health disparities in communities of color. At present, health care providers in California are not required to undergo any implicit bias testing or training. Nor does there exist any system to track the number of incidents where implicit prejudice and implicit stereotypes have led to negative birth and maternal health outcomes.
(h)It is the intent of the Legislature to reduce the effects of implicit bias in pregnancy, childbirth, and postnatal care so that all people are treated with dignity and respect by their health care providers.
(i)The Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience.
(j)All persons who may interact with perinatal patients to gatekeep, facilitate, or coordinate access to timely, responsive, respectful, and appropriate medical care may impact Black birthing persons maternal mortality and morbidity outcomes, including, but not limited to, hospital or facility employees who facilitate, control, or directly or indirectly coordinate access to timely and appropriate medical treatment as well as those who provide medical and ancillary treatment.
SEC. 2.Section 123630.2 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:123630.2.For the purposes of this article, the following terms have the following meanings:
(a)Pregnancy-related death is the death of a person while pregnant or within 365 days of the end of a pregnancy, irrespective of the duration or site of the pregnancy, from any cause related to, or aggravated by, the pregnancy or its management, but not from accidental or incidental causes.
(b)Implicit bias is a bias in judgment or behavior that results from subtle cognitive processes, including implicit prejudice and implicit stereotypes that often operate at a level below conscious awareness and without intentional control.
(c)Implicit prejudice is prejudicial negative feelings or beliefs about a group that a person holds without being aware of them.
(d)Implicit stereotypes are the unconscious attributions of particular qualities to a member of a certain social group. Implicit stereotypes are influenced by experience and are based on learned associations between various qualities and social categories, including race or gender.
(e)Perinatal care is the provision of care during pregnancy, labor, delivery, and postpartum and neonatal periods. Perinatal care includes, but is not limited to, prenatal care.
SEC. 3.Section 123630.3 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:123630.3.(a)A hospital as defined in subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 1250 that provides perinatal care, and an alternative birth center or primary care clinic subject to Section 1204.3, shall implement an evidence-based implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities, including:
(1)All persons licensed under Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code (commencing with Section 500) who are regularly assigned to provide perinatal care, including, but not limited to, those in primary care clinics, alternative birthing centers, outpatient clinics, or emergency departments.
(2)All persons who are regularly assigned to positions where they interact with perinatal patients, including, but not limited to, physician assistants, medical assistants, licensed vocational nurses, or doctors. doctors, or those who facilitate, control, or coordinate access to timely and appropriate medical treatment, as well as any others who provide medical and ancillary treatment.
(b)An implicit bias program implemented pursuant to subdivision (a) shall include all of the following:
(1)Identification of previous or current unconscious biases and misinformation.
(2)Identification of personal, interpersonal, institutional, structural, and cultural barriers to inclusion.
(3)Corrective measures to decrease implicit bias at the interpersonal and institutional levels, including ongoing policies and practices for that purpose.
(4)Information on the effects, including, but not limited to, ongoing personal effects, of historical and contemporary exclusion and oppression of minority communities.
(5)Information about cultural identity across racial or ethnic groups.
(6)Information about communicating more effectively across identities, including racial, ethnic, religious, and gender identities.
(7)Discussion on power dynamics and organizational decisionmaking.
(8)Discussion on health inequities within the perinatal care field, including information on how implicit bias impacts maternal and infant health outcomes.
(9)Perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, cultural, and provider-community relations issues in the community.
(10)Information on reproductive justice.
(11)Recognition of intersecting identities, including, but not limited to, nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience, and the multiple layers of potential biases that could come into play, resulting in harm to patients and their infants.
(c)(1)A health care provider described in subdivision (a) shall complete initial basic training through the implicit bias program based on the components described in subdivision (b). This initial basic training must be completed by June 1, 2025, for all current health care providers. The initial basic training must be provided to new health care providers at all facilities within six months of their start at the new facility unless subdivision (d) applies.
(2)Upon completion of the initial basic training, a health care provider shall complete a refresher course under the implicit bias program every two years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends and best practices in decreasing interpersonal and institutional implicit bias.
(d)A facility described in subdivision (a) shall provide a certificate of training completion to another facility or a training attendee upon request. A facility may accept a certificate of completion from another facility described in subdivision (a) to satisfy the training requirement described in subdivision (c) for a health care provider who works in more than one facility.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, if a physician involved in the perinatal care of patients is not directly employed by a facility, the facility shall offer the training to the physician.
(f)By February 1 of each year, commencing in 2026, a facility described in subdivision (a) shall provide the Attorney General with proof of compliance. Proof of compliance shall include all of the following:
(1)A list of all of the health care providers described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) who completed the training requirements outlined in subdivision (c).
(2)The dates that each health care provider completed their training.
(3)The written materials used in the training.
(4)A description of the training, including format and duration.
(5)A list of the health care providers described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) who did not participate in the training, if any.
(g)A facility described in subdivision (a) that violates the provisions of this section shall be liable for a civil penalty of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for the first violation and twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for the second and each subsequent violation, which shall be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General in any court of competent jurisdiction. For purposes of this subdivision, each health care provider that does not timely complete the required training before the relevant deadline described in subdivision (c) shall constitute a separate violation for purposes of determining the first, second, or subsequent violations. The penalties provided by this subdivision are not exclusive and do not limit other remedies available in law for such violations.
(h)The Attorney General may post on their website a list of all facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance pursuant to subdivision (f) or that were assessed penalties pursuant to subdivision (g). The Attorney General may include all of the following information when listing the facilities that were assessed penalties:
(1)The date the penalty was issued.
(2)The amount of the penalty.
(3)The reason the penalty was issued.
(4)The percentage of untrained providers.
(5)The date of facility noncompliance.
(i)The Attorney General may post on their internet website any other compliance data related to this article they deem appropriate.
(j)This section shall not be construed to limit the Attorney General from disclosing, on their internet website or otherwise, any information that they are otherwise not restricted from disclosing by any other provision of law.
SEC. 4.Section 123630.6 is added to the Health and Safety Code, immediately following Section 123630.5, to read:123630.6.The Attorney General may publish a report outlining compliance data related to this article on a biennial basis. The report may be posted on the Attorney Generals internet website.
SEC. 5.Section 123630.7 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:123630.7.If any provision of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, or the application of any such provision to any person or circumstances, shall be held invalid, the remainder of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, to the extent it can be given effect, or the application of such provision to persons or circumstances other than those as to which it is held invalid, shall not be affected thereby, and to this end the provisions of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act are severable.
The Legislature hereby finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Every person should be entitled to dignity and respect during and after pregnancy and childbirth. Patients should receive the best care possible regardless of their race, gender, age, class, sexual orientation, gender identity, disability, language proficiency, nationality, immigration status, gender expression, or religion.
(b)The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. About 700 women die each year from childbirth, and another 50,000 suffer from severe complications. In California, since 2006, the rate of maternal death has decreased 55 percent, in contrast to the steady increase in the United States as a whole.
(c)However, for women of color, particularly Black women, the maternal mortality rate remains three to four times higher than White women. Black women make up 5 percent of the pregnancy cohort in California, but 21 percent of the pregnancy-related deaths.
(d)Forty-one percent of all pregnancy-related deaths had a good to strong chance of preventability. California has a responsibility to decrease the number of preventable pregnancy-related deaths.
(e)Pregnancy-related deaths among Black women are also more likely to be miscoded. Thirty-five percent of pregnancy-related deaths among Black women in California were miscoded, misidentifying pregnancy-related deaths as other deaths.
(f)Access to prenatal care, socioeconomic status, and general physical health do not fully explain the disparity seen in Black womens maternal mortality and morbidity rates. There is a growing body of evidence that Black women are often treated unfairly and unequally in the health care system.
(g)Implicit bias is a key cause that drives health disparities in communities of color. At present, health care providers in California are not required to undergo any implicit bias testing or training. Nor does there exist any system to track the number of incidents where implicit prejudice and implicit stereotypes have led to negative birth and maternal health outcomes.
(h)It is the intent of the Legislature to reduce the effects of implicit bias in pregnancy, childbirth, and postnatal care so that all people are treated with dignity and respect by their health care providers.
(i)The Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience.
SEC. 2.Section 123630.2 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:123630.2.For the purposes of this article, the following terms have the following meanings:
(a)Pregnancy-related death is the death of a person while pregnant or within 365 days of the end of a pregnancy, irrespective of the duration or site of the pregnancy, from any cause related to, or aggravated by, the pregnancy or its management, but not from accidental or incidental causes.
(b)Implicit bias is a bias in judgment or behavior that results from subtle cognitive processes, including implicit prejudice and implicit stereotypes that often operate at a level below conscious awareness and without intentional control.
(c)Implicit prejudice is prejudicial negative feelings or beliefs about a group that a person holds without being aware of them.
(d)Implicit stereotypes are the unconscious attributions of particular qualities to a member of a certain social group. Implicit stereotypes are influenced by experience and are based on learned associations between various qualities and social categories, including race or gender.
(e)Perinatal care is the provision of care during pregnancy, labor, delivery, and postpartum and neonatal periods. Perinatal care includes, but is not limited to, prenatal care.
(f)Department means the State Department of Public Health.SEC. 3.Section 123630.3 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:123630.3.(a)A hospital as defined in subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 1250 that provides perinatal care, and an alternative birth center or primary care clinic subject to Section 1204.3, shall implement an evidence-based implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities, including:
(1)All persons licensed under Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code (commencing with Section 500) who are regularly assigned to provide perinatal care, including, but not limited to, those in primary care clinics, alternative birthing centers, outpatient clinics, or emergency departments.
(2)All persons who are regularly assigned to positions where they interact with perinatal patients, including, but not limited to, physician assistants, medical assistants, licensed vocational nurses, or doctors.
(b)An implicit bias program implemented pursuant to subdivision (a) shall include all of the following:
(1)Identification of previous or current unconscious biases and misinformation.
(2)Identification of personal, interpersonal, institutional, structural, and cultural barriers to inclusion.
(3)Corrective measures to decrease implicit bias at the interpersonal and institutional levels, including ongoing policies and practices for that purpose.
(4)Information on the effects, including, but not limited to, ongoing personal effects, of historical and contemporary exclusion and oppression of minority communities.
(5)Information about cultural identity across racial or ethnic groups.
(6)Information about communicating more effectively across identities, including racial, ethnic, religious, and gender identities.
(7)Discussion on power dynamics and organizational decisionmaking.
(8)Discussion on health inequities within the perinatal care field, including information on how implicit bias impacts maternal and infant health outcomes.
(9)Perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, cultural, and provider-community relations issues in the community.
(10)Information on reproductive justice.
(11)Recognition of intersecting identities, including, but not limited to, nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience, and the multiple layers of potential biases that could come into play, resulting in harm to patients and their infants.
(c)(1)A health care provider described in subdivision (a) shall complete initial basic training through the implicit bias program based on the components described in subdivision (b). This initial basic training must be completed by June 1, 2025, for all current health care providers. The initial basic training must be provided to new health care providers at all facilities within six months of their start at the new facility unless subdivision (d) applies.
(2)Upon completion of the initial basic training, a health care provider shall complete a refresher course under the implicit bias program every two years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends and best practices in decreasing interpersonal and institutional implicit bias.
(d)A facility described in subdivision (a) shall provide a certificate of training completion to another facility or a training attendee upon request. A facility may accept a certificate of completion from another facility described in subdivision (a) to satisfy the training requirement described in subdivision (c) for a health care provider who works in more than one facility.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, if a physician involved in the perinatal care of patients is not directly employed by a facility, the facility shall offer the training to the physician.
(f)A facility described in subdivision (a) shall document each employees implicit bias training in accordance with regulations adopted by the department for documenting staff development programs. The department shall assess each hospitals compliance with this section during periodic inspections conducted pursuant to Section 1279.(g)If the department determines that a facility described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) has violated these provisions, the department may assess an administrative penalty consistent with regulations promulgated pursuant to Section 1280.3. The departments ability to issue a penalty is not the exclusive means of enforcing the act. Civil remedies available to the Attorney General under any other statute remain available to enforce the provisions of this act.(h)The department must annually post on its internet website by April of each year a list of all facilities that have been issued administrative penalties as set forth in subdivision (g). In listing facilities that have been issued administrative penalties, the department must include all of the following:(1)The date the penalty was issued.(2)The amount of the penalty.(3)The reason the penalty was issued.(4)The percentage of untrained providers.(5)The date of facility noncompliance.(i)If the facility disputes a determination rendered by the department pursuant to subdivision (g), the facility may, within 10 working days, request a hearing pursuant to Section 131071. Penalties shall be paid when all appeals have been exhausted and the departments position has been upheld.(f)By February 1 of each year, commencing in 2026, a facility described in subdivision (a) shall provide the Attorney General with proof of compliance. Proof of compliance shall include all of the following:
(1)A list of all of the health care providers described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) who completed the training requirements outlined in subdivision (c).
(2)The dates that each health care provider completed their training.
(3)The written materials used in the training.
(4)A description of the training, including format and duration.
(5)A list of the health care providers described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) who did not participate in the training, if any.
(g)A facility described in subdivision (a) that violates the provisions of this section shall be liable for a civil penalty of ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for the first violation and twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for the second and each subsequent violation, which shall be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General in any court of competent jurisdiction. For purposes of this subdivision, each health care provider that does not timely complete the required training before the relevant deadline described in subdivision (c) shall constitute a separate violation for purposes of determining the first, second, or subsequent violations. The penalties provided by this subdivision are not exclusive and do not limit other remedies available in law for such violations.
(h)The Attorney General may post on their website a list of all facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance pursuant to subdivision (f) or that were assessed penalties pursuant to subdivision (g). The Attorney General may include all of the following information when listing the facilities that were assessed penalties:
(1)The date the penalty was issued.
(2)The amount of the penalty.
(3)The reason the penalty was issued.
(4)The percentage of untrained providers.
(5)The date of facility noncompliance.
(i)The Attorney General may post on their internet website any other compliance data related to this article they deem appropriate.
(j)This section shall not be construed to limit the Attorney General from disclosing, on their internet website or otherwise, any information that they are otherwise not restricted from disclosing by any other provision of law.
SEC. 4.Section 123630.6 is added to the Health and Safety Code, immediately following Section 123630.5, to read:123630.6.(a)The State Department of Public Health is vested with full administrative power, authority, and jurisdiction to implement and enforce the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act.(b)On or before ____, the department shall solicit broad public participation and adopt regulations to further the purposes of the act, including, but not limited to, the following areas:(1)The department shall issue guidance on training methodologies sufficient to address the findings specified in Section 123630.1.(2)The department shall issue guidance on each of the categories of training specified in subdivision (b) of Section 123630.1.(3)(A)The department may issue and revise or adopt existing trainings that it certifies as a model sufficient to comply with the requirements specified in Section 123630.3, current research, and best practices. The department shall make any certified training available on its internet website.(B)The department shall review and ensure that the training continues to comply with the requirements of Section 123630.3. The department shall recertify training on an annual basis or the department shall withdraw its certification.(4)The department may adopt additional regulations, as necessary, to further the purposes of the act.(c)The department shall conduct a review of a facility subject to the requirements of subdivision (a) of Section 123630.3 under any of the following circumstances:(1)Upon the death of a birthing parent or child during or one month after birth, unless the department had completed a review of the facility within one year prior to the death.(2)Upon the departments receipt of at least three complaints of racial bias or quality of care against perinatal care providers in a facility subject to the training requirements of subdivision (a) of Section 123630.3 by a patient or patients identifying as any race but White, not Hispanic or Latino.(3)At any other time that the department deems appropriate.(d)A facility review shall include a review of the facilitys compliance with the training requirement of subdivision (a) of Section 123630.1, and review the substance of the facilitys training program to assess compliance with the requirements of subdivision (b) of Section 123630.1, and any relevant regulation.(e)The department shall publish a report outlining compliance data on a biannual basis. The report shall be posted on the departments internet website.SEC. 4.Section 123630.6 is added to the Health and Safety Code, immediately following Section 123630.5, to read:123630.6.The Attorney General may publish a report outlining compliance data related to this article on a biennial basis. The report may be posted on the Attorney Generals internet website.
SEC. 5.Section 123630.7 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:123630.7.If any provision of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, or the application of any such provision to any person or circumstances, shall be held invalid, the remainder of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, to the extent it can be given effect, or the application of such provision to persons or circumstances other than those as to which it is held invalid, shall not be affected thereby, and to this end the provisions of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act are severable.
The Legislature hereby finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Every person should be entitled to dignity and respect during and after pregnancy and childbirth. Patients should receive the best care possible regardless of their race, gender, age, class, sexual orientation, gender identity, disability, language proficiency, nationality, immigration status, gender expression, or religion.
(b)The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. About 700 women die each year from childbirth, and another 50,000 suffer from severe complications. In California, since 2006, the rate of maternal death has decreased 55 percent, in contrast to the steady increase in the United States as a whole.
(c)However, for women of color, particularly Black women, the maternal mortality rate remains three to four times higher than White women. Black women make up 5 percent of the pregnancy cohort in California, but 21 percent of the pregnancy-related deaths.
(d)Forty-one percent of all pregnancy-related deaths had a good to strong chance of preventability. California has a responsibility to decrease the number of preventable pregnancy-related deaths.
(e)Pregnancy-related deaths among Black women are also more likely to be miscoded. Thirty-five percent of pregnancy-related deaths among Black women in California were miscoded, misidentifying pregnancy-related deaths as other deaths.
(f)Access to prenatal care, socioeconomic status, and general physical health do not fully explain the disparity seen in Black womens maternal mortality and morbidity rates. There is a growing body of evidence that Black women are often treated unfairly and unequally in the health care system.
(g)Implicit bias is a key cause that drives health disparities in communities of color. At present, health care providers in California are not required to undergo any implicit bias testing or training. Nor does there exist any system to track the number of incidents where implicit prejudice and implicit stereotypes have led to negative birth and maternal health outcomes.
(h)It is the intent of the Legislature to reduce the effects of implicit bias in pregnancy, childbirth, and postnatal care so that all people are treated with dignity and respect by their health care providers.
(i)The Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience.
SEC. 2.Section 123630.2 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:123630.2.For the purposes of this article, the following terms have the following meanings:
(a)Pregnancy-related death is the death of a person while pregnant or within 365 days of the end of a pregnancy, irrespective of the duration or site of the pregnancy, from any cause related to, or aggravated by, the pregnancy or its management, but not from accidental or incidental causes.
(b)Implicit bias is a bias in judgment or behavior that results from subtle cognitive processes, including implicit prejudice and implicit stereotypes that often operate at a level below conscious awareness and without intentional control.
(c)Implicit prejudice is prejudicial negative feelings or beliefs about a group that a person holds without being aware of them.
(d)Implicit stereotypes are the unconscious attributions of particular qualities to a member of a certain social group. Implicit stereotypes are influenced by experience and are based on learned associations between various qualities and social categories, including race or gender.
(e)Perinatal care is the provision of care during pregnancy, labor, delivery, and postpartum and neonatal periods. Perinatal care includes, but is not limited to, prenatal care.
(f)Department means the State Department of Public Health.
SEC. 3.Section 123630.3 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:123630.3.(a)(1)A hospital as defined in subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 1250 that provides perinatal or prenatal care, and an alternative birth center or primary care clinic subject to Section 1204.3, shall implement an evidence-based implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities. facilities, including:
(2)Health care providers involved in the perinatal care or prenatal care of patients includes: (i)(1)All persons licensed under Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code (commencing with Section 500) who may are regularly assigned to provide perinatal or prenatal care, including, but not limited to, those in primary care clinics, alternative birthing centers, outpatient clinics, or emergency departments.
(ii)(2)All persons who may are regularly assigned to positions where they interact with perinatal patients, including, but not limited to, receptionists, housekeeping, orderlies, physician assistants, medical assistants, licensed vocational nurses, or doctors.
(b)An implicit bias program implemented pursuant to subdivision (a) shall include all of the following:
(1)Identification of previous or current unconscious biases and misinformation.
(2)Identification of personal, interpersonal, institutional, structural, and cultural barriers to inclusion.
(3)Corrective measures to decrease implicit bias at the interpersonal and institutional levels, including ongoing policies and practices for that purpose.
(4)Information on the effects, including, but not limited to, ongoing personal effects, of historical and contemporary exclusion and oppression of minority communities.
(5)Information about cultural identity across racial or ethnic groups.
(6)Information about communicating more effectively across identities, including racial, ethnic, religious, and gender identities.
(7)Discussion on power dynamics and organizational decisionmaking.
(8)Discussion on health inequities within the perinatal care field, including information on how implicit bias impacts maternal and infant health outcomes.
(9)Perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, cultural, and provider-community relations issues in the community.
(10)Information on reproductive justice.
(11)Recognition of intersecting identities, including, but not limited to, nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience, and the multiple layers of potential biases that could come into play, resulting in harm to patients and their infants.
(c)(1)A health care provider described in subdivision (a) shall complete initial basic training through the implicit bias program based on the components described in subdivision (b). This initial basic training must be completed by June 1, 2025, for all current health care providers. The initial basic training must be provided to new health care providers at all facilities within six months of their start at the new facility unless subdivision (d) applies.
(2)Upon completion of the initial basic training, a health care provider shall complete a refresher course under the implicit bias program every two years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends and best practices in decreasing interpersonal and institutional implicit bias.
(d)A facility described in subdivision (a) shall provide a certificate of training completion to another facility or a training attendee upon request. A facility may accept a certificate of completion from another facility described in subdivision (a) to satisfy the training requirement described in subdivision (c) from for a health care provider who works in more than one facility.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, if a physician involved in the perinatal care of patients is not directly employed by a facility, the facility shall offer the training to the physician.
(f)By February 1 of each year, a facility described in subdivision (a) shall provide the department with proof of compliance. Proof of compliance shall include all of the following:(1)A list of health care providers described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) that completed the training requirements outlined in subdivision (c).(2)The dates that the training was completed for each health care provider.(3)Written materials used in training.(4)A description of the training, including format and duration.(5)A list of health care providers described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) who did not participate in the training, if any.(f)A facility described in subdivision (a) shall document each employees implicit bias training in accordance with regulations adopted by the department for documenting staff development programs. The department shall assess each hospitals compliance with this section during periodic inspections conducted pursuant to Section 1279.
(g)If the department determines that a facility described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) has violated these provisions, the department may assess an administrative penalty of up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for the first violation and twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for the second and each subsequent violation. For purposes of this subdivision, each health care provider that does not timely complete the required training shall constitute a separate violation for purposes of determining whether the violation was a first, second, or subsequent violation. consistent with regulations promulgated pursuant to Section 1280.3. The departments ability to issue a penalty is not the exclusive means of enforcing the act. Remedies Civil remedies available to the Attorney General under any other statute remain available to enforce the provisions of this act.
(h)The department must annually post on its internet website by April of each year a list of all facilities that do not timely submit proof of compliance and have been issued administrative penalties as set forth in subdivision (g). In listing facilities that have been issued administrative penalties, the department must include all of the following:
(1)The date the penalty was issued.
(2)The amount of the penalty.
(3)The reason the penalty was issued.
(4)The percentage of untrained providers.
(5)The date of facility noncompliance.
(i)If the facility disputes a determination rendered by the department pursuant to subdivision (g), the facility may, within 10 working days, request a hearing pursuant to Section 131071. Penalties shall be paid when all appeals have been exhausted and the departments position has been upheld.
(j)Notwithstanding any other restriction, the department shall respond to any request made pursuant to the California Public Records Act (Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Division 10 of Title 1 of the Government Code) for the following data, disaggregated by facility, race, and year:(i)The number of individuals who died during labor.(ii)The percentage of total individuals who gave birth that died during labor.(iii)The number of individuals who had complications during birth.(iv)The percentage of individuals who gave birth that had complications during birth.(v)The number of miscarriages in the third trimester and stillbirths during labor.(vi)The percentage of individuals who entered labor and had a miscarriage in the third trimester or stillbirth during labor.SEC. 4.Section 123630.6 is added to the Health and Safety Code, immediately following Section 123630.5, to read:123630.6.(a)The State Department of Public Health is vested with full administrative power, authority, and jurisdiction to implement and enforce the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act.
(b)On or before ____, the department shall solicit broad public participation and adopt regulations to further the purposes of the act, including, but not limited to, the following areas:
(1)The department shall issue guidance on training methodologies sufficient to address the findings specified in Section 123630.1.
(2)The department shall issue guidance on each of the categories of training specified in subdivision (b) of Section 123630.1.
(3)(A)The department may issue and revise or adopt existing trainings that it certifies as a model sufficient to comply with the requirements specified in Section 123630.3, current research, and best practices. The department shall make any certified training available on its internet website.
(B)The department shall review and ensure that the training continues to comply with the requirements of Section 123630.3. The department shall recertify training on an annual basis or the department shall withdraw its certification.
(4)The department may adopt additional regulations, as necessary, to further the purposes of the act.
(c)The department shall conduct a review of a facility subject to the requirements of subdivision (a) of Section 123630.3 under any of the following circumstances:
(1)Upon the death of a birthing parent or child during or one month after birth, unless the department had completed a review of the facility within one year prior to the death.
(2)Upon the departments receipt of at least three complaints of racial bias or quality of care against perinatal or prenatal care providers in a facility subject to the training requirements of subdivision (a) of Section 123630.3 by a patient or patients identifying as any race but White, not Hispanic or Latino.
(3)At any other time that the department deems appropriate.
(d)A facility review shall include a review of the facilitys compliance with the training requirement of subdivision (a) of Section 123630.1, and review the substance of the facilitys training program to assess compliance with the requirements of subdivision (b) of Section 123630.1, and any relevant regulation.
(e)The department shall publish a report outlining compliance data on a biannual basis. The report shall be posted on the departments internet website.
SEC. 5.Section 123630.7 is added to the Health and Safety Code, to read:123630.7.If any provision of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, or the application of any such provision to any person or circumstances, shall be held invalid, the remainder of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, to the extent it can be given effect, or the application of such provision to persons or circumstances other than those as to which it is held invalid, shall not be affected thereby, and to this end the provisions of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act are severable.
The Legislature hereby finds and declares all of the following:
(a)Every person should be entitled to dignity and respect during and after pregnancy and childbirth. Patients should receive the best care possible regardless of their race, gender, age, class, sexual orientation, gender identity, disability, language proficiency, nationality, immigration status, gender expression, or religion.
(b)The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. About 700 women die each year from childbirth, and another 50,000 suffer from severe complications. In California, since 2006, the rate of maternal death has decreased 55 percent, in contrast to the steady increase in the United States as a whole.
(c)However, for women of color, particularly Black women, the maternal mortality rate remains three to four times higher than White women. Black women make up 5 percent of the pregnancy cohort in California, but 21 percent of the pregnancy-related deaths.
(d)Forty-one percent of all pregnancy-related deaths had a good to strong chance of preventability. California has a responsibility to decrease the number of preventable pregnancy-related deaths.
(e)Pregnancy-related deaths among Black women are also more likely to be miscoded. Thirty-five percent of pregnancy-related deaths among Black women in California were miscoded, misidentifying pregnancy-related deaths as other deaths.
(f)Access to prenatal care, socioeconomic status, and general physical health do not fully explain the disparity seen in Black womens maternal mortality and morbidity rates. There is a growing body of evidence that Black women are often treated unfairly and unequally in the health care system.
(g)Implicit bias is a key cause that drives health disparities in communities of color. At present, health care providers in California are not required to undergo any implicit bias testing or training. Nor does there exist any system to track the number of incidents where implicit prejudice and implicit stereotypes have led to negative birth and maternal health outcomes.
(h)It is the intent of the Legislature to reduce the effects of implicit bias in pregnancy, childbirth, and postnatal care so that all people are treated with dignity and respect by their health care providers.
(i)The Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience.
SEC. 2.Section 123630.2 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:123630.2.For the purposes of this article, the following terms have the following meanings:
(a)Pregnancy-related death is the death of a person while pregnant or within 365 days of the end of a pregnancy, irrespective of the duration or site of the pregnancy, from any cause related to, or aggravated by, the pregnancy or its management, but not from accidental or incidental causes.
(b)Implicit bias is a bias in judgment or behavior that results from subtle cognitive processes, including implicit prejudice and implicit stereotypes that often operate at a level below conscious awareness and without intentional control.
(c)Implicit prejudice is prejudicial negative feelings or beliefs about a group that a person holds without being aware of them.
(d)Implicit stereotypes are the unconscious attributions of particular qualities to a member of a certain social group. Implicit stereotypes are influenced by experience and are based on learned associations between various qualities and social categories, including race or gender.
(e)Perinatal care is the provision of care during pregnancy, labor, delivery, and postpartum and neonatal periods.
(f)Department means the State Department of Public Health.
SEC. 3.Section 123630.3 of the Health and Safety Code is amended to read:123630.3.(a)(1)A hospital as defined in subdivision (a) or (f) of Section 1250 that provides perinatal or prenatal care, and an alternative birth center or primary care clinic subject to Section 1204.3, shall implement an evidence-based implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities.
(2)Health care providers involved in the perinatal care or prenatal care of patients includes:
(i)All persons licensed under Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code (commencing with Section 500) who may provide perinatal or prenatal care, including, but not limited to, those in primary care clinics, alternative birthing centers, outpatient clinics, or emergency departments.
(ii)All persons who may interact with perinatal patients, including, but not limited to, receptionists, housekeeping, orderlies, physician assistants, medical assistants, licensed vocational nurses, or doctors.
(b)An implicit bias program implemented pursuant to subdivision (a) shall include all of the following:
(1)Identification of previous or current unconscious biases and misinformation.
(2)Identification of personal, interpersonal, institutional, structural, and cultural barriers to inclusion.
(3)Corrective measures to decrease implicit bias at the interpersonal and institutional levels, including ongoing policies and practices for that purpose.
(4)Information on the effects, including, but not limited to, ongoing personal effects, of historical and contemporary exclusion and oppression of minority communities.
(5)Information about cultural identity across racial or ethnic groups.
(6)Information about communicating more effectively across identities, including racial, ethnic, religious, and gender identities.
(7)Discussion on power dynamics and organizational decisionmaking.
(8)Discussion on health inequities within the perinatal care field, including information on how implicit bias impacts maternal and infant health outcomes.
(9)Perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, cultural, and provider-community relations issues in the community.
(10)Information on reproductive justice.
(11)Recognition of intersecting identities, including, but not limited to, nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience, and the multiple layers of potential biases that could come into play, resulting in harm to patients and their infants.
(c)(1)A health care provider described in subdivision (a) shall complete initial basic training through the implicit bias program based on the components described in subdivision (b). This initial basic training must be completed by June 1, 2025, for all current health care providers. The initial basic training must be provided to new health care providers at all facilities within six months of their start at the new facility unless subdivision (d) applies.
(2)Upon completion of the initial basic training, a health care provider shall complete a refresher course under the implicit bias program every two years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends and best practices in decreasing interpersonal and institutional implicit bias.
(d)A facility described in subdivision (a) shall provide a certificate of training completion to another facility or a training attendee upon request. A facility may accept a certificate of completion from another facility described in subdivision (a) to satisfy the training requirement described in subdivision (c) from a health care provider who works in more than one facility.
(e)Notwithstanding subdivisions (a) to (d), inclusive, if a physician involved in the perinatal care of patients is not directly employed by a facility, the facility shall offer the training to the physician.
(f)By February 1 of each year, a facility described in subdivision (a) shall provide the department with proof of compliance. Proof of compliance shall include all of the following:
(1)A list of health care providers described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) that completed the training requirements outlined in subdivision (c).
(2)The dates that the training was completed for each health care provider.
(3)Written materials used in training.
(4)A description of the training, including format and duration.
(5)A list of health care providers described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) who did not participate in the training, if any.
(g)If the department determines that a facility described in paragraph (1) of subdivision (a) has violated these provisions, the department may assess an administrative penalty of up to ten thousand dollars ($10,000) for the first violation and twenty-five thousand dollars ($25,000) for the second and each subsequent violation. For purposes of this subdivision, each health care provider that does not timely complete the required training shall constitute a separate violation for purposes of determining whether the violation was a first, second, or subsequent violation. The departments ability to issue a penalty is not the exclusive means of enforcing the act. Remedies available to the Attorney General under any other statute remain available to enforce the provisions of this act.
(h)The department must annually post on its internet website by April of each year a list of all facilities that do not timely submit proof of compliance and have been issued administrative penalties as set forth in subdivision (g). In listing facilities that have been issued administrative penalties, the department must include all of the following:
(1)The date the penalty was issued.
(2)The amount of the penalty.
(3)The reason the penalty was issued.
(4)The percentage of untrained providers.
(5)The date of facility noncompliance.
(i)If the facility disputes a determination rendered by the department pursuant to subdivision (g), the facility may, within 10 working days, request a hearing pursuant to Section 131071. Penalties shall be paid when all appeals have been exhausted and the departments position has been upheld.
(j)Notwithstanding any other restriction, the department shall respond to any request made pursuant to the California Public Records Act (Chapter 1 (commencing with Section 7920.000) of Division 10 of Title 1 of the Government Code) for the following data, disaggregated by facility, race, and year:
(i)The number of individuals who died during labor.
(ii)The percentage of total individuals who gave birth that died during labor.
(iii)The number of individuals who had complications during birth.
(iv)The percentage of individuals who gave birth that had complications during birth.
(v)The number of miscarriages in the third trimester and stillbirths during labor.
(vi)The percentage of individuals who entered labor and had a miscarriage in the third trimester or stillbirth during labor.
SEC. 4.Section 123630.6 is added to the Health and Safety Code, immediately following Section 123630.5, to read:123630.6.(a)The State Department of Public Health is vested with full administrative power, authority, and jurisdiction to implement and enforce the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act.
(b)On or before ____, the department shall solicit broad public participation and adopt regulations to further the purposes of the act, including, but not limited to, the following areas:
(1)The department shall issue guidance on training methodologies sufficient to address the findings specified in Section 123630.1.
(2)The department shall issue guidance on each of the categories of training specified in subdivision (b) of Section 123630.1.
(3)(A)The department may issue and revise or adopt existing trainings that it certifies as a model sufficient to comply with the requirements specified in Section 123630.3, current research, and best practices. The department shall make any certified training available on its internet website.
(B)The department shall review and ensure that the training continues to comply with the requirements of Section 123630.3. The department shall recertify training on an annual basis or the department shall withdraw its certification.
(4)The department may adopt additional regulations, as necessary, to further the purposes of the act.
(c)The department shall conduct a review of a facility subject to the requirements of subdivision (a) of Section 123630.3 under any of the following circumstances:
(1)Upon the death of a birthing parent or child during or one month after birth, unless the department had completed a review of the facility within one year prior to the death.
(2)Upon the departments receipt of at least three complaints of racial bias or quality of care against perinatal or prenatal care providers in a facility subject to the training requirements of subdivision (a) of Section 123630.3 by a patient or patients identifying as any race but White, not Hispanic or Latino.
(3)At any other time that the department deems appropriate.
(d)A facility review shall include a review of the facilitys compliance with the training requirement of subdivision (a) of Section 123630.1, and review the substance of the facilitys training program to assess compliance with the requirements of subdivision (b) of Section 123630.1, and any relevant regulation.
(e)The department shall publish a report outlining compliance data on a biannual basis. The report shall be posted on the departments internet website.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Sep 26, 2024 | Chaptered by Secretary of State - Chapter 621, Statutes of 2024. |
| Sep 26, 2024 | Approved by the Governor. |
| Sep 11, 2024 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4 p.m. |
| Aug 29, 2024 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 62. Noes 9.). |
| Aug 29, 2024 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. |
| Aug 28, 2024 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after August 30 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Aug 28, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 32. Noes 6.). |
| Aug 19, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 15, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| Aug 15, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 4. Noes 2.) (August 15). |
| Aug 5, 2024 | In committee: Referred to APPR suspense file. |
| Jul 3, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 10. Noes 1.) (July 2). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Jun 27, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 26, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 9. Noes 2.) (June 26). |
| Jun 17, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Hearing canceled at the request of author. |
| Jun 5, 2024 | Referred to Coms. on HEALTH and JUD. |
| May 24, 2024 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 24, 2024 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 56. Noes 5. Page 5665.) |
| May 20, 2024 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to third reading. (Page 5328.) |
| May 20, 2024 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 20, 2024 | Assembly Rule 69(b)(1) suspended. (Page 5328.) |
| May 16, 2024 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 16, 2024 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 11. Noes 4.) (May 16). |
| May 16, 2024 | Assembly Rule 63 suspended. |
| May 1, 2024 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Apr 3, 2024 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 12. Noes 2.) (April 2). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Apr 1, 2024 | Re-referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Mar 21, 2024 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on HEALTH. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 26, 2024 | Referred to Com. on HEALTH. |
| Feb 13, 2024 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 14. |
| Feb 12, 2024 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aug 29, 2024 | AB 2319 Wilson Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 28, 2024 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB2319 Wilson et al. By Smallwood-Cuevas | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Aug 15, 2024 | Do pass as amended | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Aug 5, 2024 | Placed on suspense file | Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Jul 2, 2024 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 26, 2024 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
|
| May 24, 2024 | AB 2319 Wilson Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 16, 2024 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Apr 2, 2024 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Health |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| Access Reproductive Justice | ** Support | |
| American Atheists | ** Support | |
| American Civil Liberties Union California Action | ** Support | |
| Asian Americans Advancing Justice Southern California | ** Support | |
| Attorney General Rob Bonta | ** Support | |
| Black Woman Organized for Political Action, Political Action Committee | ** Support | |
| Black Women For Wellness Action Project | ** Support | |
| Black Women Organized for Political Action | ** Support | |
| Board of Supervisors San Francisco | * Support | Apr 2, 2024 |
| California Black Health Network | ** Support | |
| California Black Women's Collective Empowerment Institute | ** Support | |
| California Coalition of the National Council of Negro Women | * Support | Jun 26, 2024 |
| California Commission on the Status of Women and Girls | ** Support | |
| California Department of Justice | * Support | Apr 2, 2024 |
| California Family Council | ** Against | |
| California Family Resource Association | ** Support | |
| California Federation Of Teachers | ** Support | |
| California Legislative Women Caucus | ** Support | |
| California Nurse-Midwives Association | ** Support | |
| California Pan-Ethnic Health Network | ** Support | |
| California State Association of Psychiatrists | ** Support | |
| California State Council of Service Employees International Union | ** Support | |
| California Women's Law Center | ** Support | |
| Catalyst California | ** Support | |
| Child Abuse Prevention Center | ** Support | |
| Children Now | ** Support | |
| Children of the Sun Doula Project | * Support | Jun 26, 2024 |
| City and County of San Francisco, Board of Supervisors | ** Support | |
| Community Health Councils | ** Support | |
| County Of Alameda | * Support | Jul 2, 2024 |
| County Of San Diego | ** Support | |
| County of Santa Clara | ** Support | |
| Courage California | ** Support | |
| Disability Rights California | ** Support | |
| Diversity Uplifts | ** Support | |
| Diversity Uplifts, Inc. | ** Support | |
| Equality California | ** Support | |
| Essential Access Health | ** Support | |
| Essential Access Health and AIDS Project, Los Angeles | ** Support | Jun 26, 2024 |
| First 5 Alameda County | ** Support | |
| First 5 California | ** Support | |
| First 5 Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| First Live California | * Support | Jun 26, 2024 |
| First Live LA | * Support | Jun 26, 2024 |
| Health Access California | ** Support | |
| Health Net | ** Support | |
| Hispanas Organized for Political Equality | ** Support | |
| Latino Coalition for a Healthy California | ** Support | |
| March of Dimes | * Support | Jun 26, 2024 |
| National Council Of Jewish Women Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| National Council of Negro Women | ** Support | |
| National Council of Negro Women, Inc., Northern California Region | ** Support | |
| National Health Law Program | ** Support | |
| Office of Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis | ** Support | |
| Perinatal Health Equity Initiative | ** Support | |
| Planned Parenthood Affiliates Of California | ** Support | |
| Protect Kids California | * Against | Apr 2, 2024 |
| Reproductive Freedom for All California | ** Support | |
| Rising Communities | ** Support | |
| Santa Clara County Board of Supervisors | * Support | Jun 26, 2024 |
| SCU California | * Support | Jun 26, 2024 |
| The Child Abuse Prevention Center And Its Affiliates Safe Kids California Prevent Child Abuse California And The California Family Resource Association | ** Support | |
| The Children's Partnership | ** Support | |
| Western Center on Law & Poverty, INC. | ** Support | |
| Women Lawyers of Sacramento | ** Support | |
| Women'S Foundation California | ** Support | |
| Women's Health Specialists | ** Support |
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 2319
Author:(Wilson and Weber)
As Amended Ver:August 15, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Expands the types of health care providers and health facility employees who must participate in implicit bias training pursuant to the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act (the Act.) Requires initial basic training on implicit bias to be completed by June 1, 2025 for current health care providers and health facility employees, and within six months of their start date for new health care providers and health facility employees. Requires facilities subject to the provisions of the Act, commencing in 2026, to provide the Attorney General (AG) with proof of compliance by February 1 of each year.
Senate Amendments
- Require training to be provided during paid work time;
- Require compliance information provided to the AG to include the number and percentage of health care providers who fail to complete the training;
- Provides for civil penalties for failure to submit proof of compliance to the AG, including for the "systemic failure" of providers to complete training, as defined; and,
- Require that Attorney General be awarded all attorney's fees and costs in any civil action in which a court imposes any of those civil penalties.
COMMENTS
Implicit bias. According to the University of San Francisco's Office of Outreach and Diversity, bias is a prejudice in favor of or against one thing, person, or group compared with another usually in a way that is considered to be unfair. Biases may be held by an individual, group, or institution and can have negative or positive consequences. There are types of biases: conscious bias (also known as explicit bias) and unconscious bias (also known as implicit bias). Biases, conscious or unconscious, are not limited to ethnicity and race. Though racial bias and discrimination are well documented, biases may exist toward any social group. Age, gender, gender identity, physical abilities, religion, sexual orientation, weight, and many other characteristics are subject to bias. Unconscious, or implicit, biases are social stereotypes about certain groups of people that individuals form outside their own conscious awareness. Unconscious bias is far more prevalent than conscious prejudice and often incompatible with one's conscious values. It is well-documented that implicit bias among health care professionals is prevalent and impacts patient care.
A July 2022 article, "Tackling Implicit Bias in Health Care," published in the New England Journal of Medicine, notes that our individual biases operate within larger social, cultural, and economic structures whose biased policies and practices perpetuate systemic racism, sexism, and other forms of discrimination. The article notes that in medicine, bias-driven discriminatory practices and policies not only negatively affect patient care and the medical training environment, but also limit the diversity of the health care workforce, lead to inequitable distribution of research funding, and can hinder career advancement. The article discusses a review of studies involving physicians, nurses, and other medical professionals which found that health care providers' implicit racial bias is associated with diagnostic uncertainty and, for Black patients, negative ratings of their clinical interactions, less patient-centeredness, poor provider communication, under-treatment of pain, and views of Black patients as less medically adherent than white patients.
Maternal and infant health outcomes in California. In California, the rate of maternal death since 2006 has decreased by 55% even though the rate in the United States as a whole has steadily increased. However, according to data in the Department of Public Health's (DPH) 2018 California Pregnancy-Associated Mortality Review, for women of color, and in particular Black women, the rate remains three to four times higher than that for white women in California. The racial disparity is even starker when looking at particular conditions. Black women account for 5% of those pregnant in California but account for 21% of the total pregnancy-related deaths. Further, the disparity in maternal health between Black and non-Hispanic white birthing mothers exists independent of the socio-economic status of the birthing mother. A recent study that looked at the records of millions of births in California illustrates that across all parental income levels, Black mothers, as well as their infants, have much worse health outcomes than their non-Hispanic white counterparts do.
AG report on the Act. To ascertain compliance with the Act's training requirements, the Department of Justice (DOJ) sent a letter on August 23, 2021, to facilities subject to the requirements of the Act. Through this letter, DOJ requested that each facility provide:
- Dates of any implicit bias training providers have completed;
- Dates of implicit bias trainings planned for the future;
- Lists of attendees at each training;
- Copies of all written training materials used;
- A list of the perinatal healthcare workers at each facility who have yet to participate in any training; and,
- A description of each facility's efforts to reduce implicit bias among its perinatal healthcare providers.
DOJ further requested that facilities provide responsive documents and information by September 20, 2021. One hundred and fifty facilities requested, and were granted, an extension and did not produce any responsive documents or information until early January 2022. DOJ continued to receive information from a small minority of letter recipients through April 2022. DOJ's investigation found that 42 hospitals had not fully trained a single employee prior to being contacted by DOJ on August 23, 2021. Responding hospitals on average completed trainings for 81.36% of their relevant providers, though this figure includes both facilities that completed trainings for all of the appropriate providers and facilities that failed to complete any trainings. Average completion rates were 79.41% at private hospitals, 81.08% at non-profit hospitals, 86.26% at government hospitals, and 84.81% at University of California hospitals. All staff had completed their training at 41 hospitals, and no staff had completed their training at two hospitals. Nearly a third of facilities to which DOJ reached out, began training only after DOJ contacted them, suggesting that DOJ's outreach caused compliance in many cases.
According to the Author
The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. In California Black women continue to die at three to four times the rate of white women. A 2023 study by DPH, "Centering Black Mothers in California: Insights into Racism, Health, and Well-being for Black Women and Infants," found that women of color, in particular Black women, die of pregnancy-related complications at much higher rates than white women in California. Evidence suggests one key cause of this disparity is the implicit bias of healthcare providers. A provider's level of bias, whether conscious or unconscious, can influence their interactions with patients and their diagnoses and treatment of the patient's pain, and can undermine patients' trust and engagement in care. The author notes that, to address this, the legislature passed the Act in 2019, which requires hospitals, alternative birth centers and primary care clinics to conduct evidence-based implicit bias training for all health professionals who provide care during a patient's pregnancy, childbirth, and immediate postpartum period.
Arguments in Support
AG Rob Bonta is the sponsor of this bill and states that investigations into the cause of all pregnancy-related deaths by DPH determined that more than half are preventable. This bill is a substantial part of the systemic change needed to reduce the disparate impact on Black mothers and pregnant persons of color and to prevent these deaths from happening.
Arguments in Opposition
The California Family Council is opposed to this bill and states that the recognition of motherhood as biologically based upholds the dignity of women. Motherhood is an intrinsic and unique aspect of female biology, and acknowledging this fact celebrates and respects the role of women in society. Denying the biological basis of motherhood not only diminishes the special contributions of women but also erodes the foundational understanding of family and community.
The Department of Finance is opposed to this bill because it results in additional costs not included in the 2024 Budget Act.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, unknown, ongoing costs for DPH for state administration (General Fund and Licensing and Certification Fund). Ongoing General Fund costs, likely low hundreds of thousands, for DOJ for workload related to collecting information from regulated entities, assisting with the biannual report and website updates. Costs may potentially be offset to the extent the AG is awarded attorney's fees and costs
VOTES:
ASM HEALTH: 12-2-2
YES: Bonta, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Wendy Carrillo, Haney, Jones-Sawyer, Maienschein, Rodriguez, Santiago, Schiavo, Weber
NO: Joe Patterson, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Flora, McCarty
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-4-0
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Villapudua
NO: Sanchez, Dixon, Jim Patterson, Ta
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 56-5-19
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Ramos, Reyes, Rodriguez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wilson, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NO: Dixon, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Hoover, Joe Patterson
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bauer-Kahan, Cervantes, Chen, Megan Dahle, Davies, Essayli, Flora, Holden, Lackey, Mathis, Quirk-Silva, Rendon, Luz Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Ta, Villapudua, Wicks, Wood
SENATE FLOOR: 32-6-2
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener, Wilk
NO: Dahle, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Seyarto
ABS, ABST OR NV: Alvarado-Gil, Ochoa Bogh
UPDATED
VERSION: August 15, 2024
CONSULTANT: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0004180
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 2319
Author:(Wilson and Weber)
As Amended Ver:August 15, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Expands the types of health care providers and health facility employees who must participate in implicit bias training pursuant to the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act (the Act.) Requires initial basic training on implicit bias to be completed by June 1, 2025 for current health care providers and health facility employees, and within six months of their start date for new health care providers and health facility employees. Requires facilities subject to the provisions of the Act, commencing in 2026, to provide the Attorney General (AG) with proof of compliance by February 1 of each year.
Senate Amendments
- Require training to be provided during paid work time;
- Require compliance information provided to the AG to include the number and percentage of health care providers who fail to complete the training;
- Provides for civil penalties for failure to submit proof of compliance to the AG, including for the "systemic failure" of providers to complete training, as defined; and,
- Require that Attorney General be awarded all attorney's fees and costs in any civil action in which a court imposes any of those civil penalties.
COMMENTS
Implicit bias. According to the University of San Francisco's Office of Outreach and Diversity, bias is a prejudice in favor of or against one thing, person, or group compared with another usually in a way that is considered to be unfair. Biases may be held by an individual, group, or institution and can have negative or positive consequences. There are types of biases: conscious bias (also known as explicit bias) and unconscious bias (also known as implicit bias). Biases, conscious or unconscious, are not limited to ethnicity and race. Though racial bias and discrimination are well documented, biases may exist toward any social group. Age, gender, gender identity, physical abilities, religion, sexual orientation, weight, and many other characteristics are subject to bias. Unconscious, or implicit, biases are social stereotypes about certain groups of people that individuals form outside their own conscious awareness. Unconscious bias is far more prevalent than conscious prejudice and often incompatible with one's conscious values. It is well-documented that implicit bias among health care professionals is prevalent and impacts patient care.
A July 2022 article, "Tackling Implicit Bias in Health Care," published in the New England Journal of Medicine, notes that our individual biases operate within larger social, cultural, and economic structures whose biased policies and practices perpetuate systemic racism, sexism, and other forms of discrimination. The article notes that in medicine, bias-driven discriminatory practices and policies not only negatively affect patient care and the medical training environment, but also limit the diversity of the health care workforce, lead to inequitable distribution of research funding, and can hinder career advancement. The article discusses a review of studies involving physicians, nurses, and other medical professionals which found that health care providers' implicit racial bias is associated with diagnostic uncertainty and, for Black patients, negative ratings of their clinical interactions, less patient-centeredness, poor provider communication, under-treatment of pain, and views of Black patients as less medically adherent than white patients.
Maternal and infant health outcomes in California. In California, the rate of maternal death since 2006 has decreased by 55% even though the rate in the United States as a whole has steadily increased. However, according to data in the Department of Public Health's (DPH) 2018 California Pregnancy-Associated Mortality Review, for women of color, and in particular Black women, the rate remains three to four times higher than that for white women in California. The racial disparity is even starker when looking at particular conditions. Black women account for 5% of those pregnant in California but account for 21% of the total pregnancy-related deaths. Further, the disparity in maternal health between Black and non-Hispanic white birthing mothers exists independent of the socio-economic status of the birthing mother. A recent study that looked at the records of millions of births in California illustrates that across all parental income levels, Black mothers, as well as their infants, have much worse health outcomes than their non-Hispanic white counterparts do.
AG report on the Act. To ascertain compliance with the Act's training requirements, the Department of Justice (DOJ) sent a letter on August 23, 2021, to facilities subject to the requirements of the Act. Through this letter, DOJ requested that each facility provide:
- Dates of any implicit bias training providers have completed;
- Dates of implicit bias trainings planned for the future;
- Lists of attendees at each training;
- Copies of all written training materials used;
- A list of the perinatal healthcare workers at each facility who have yet to participate in any training; and,
- A description of each facility's efforts to reduce implicit bias among its perinatal healthcare providers.
DOJ further requested that facilities provide responsive documents and information by September 20, 2021. One hundred and fifty facilities requested, and were granted, an extension and did not produce any responsive documents or information until early January 2022. DOJ continued to receive information from a small minority of letter recipients through April 2022. DOJ's investigation found that 42 hospitals had not fully trained a single employee prior to being contacted by DOJ on August 23, 2021. Responding hospitals on average completed trainings for 81.36% of their relevant providers, though this figure includes both facilities that completed trainings for all of the appropriate providers and facilities that failed to complete any trainings. Average completion rates were 79.41% at private hospitals, 81.08% at non-profit hospitals, 86.26% at government hospitals, and 84.81% at University of California hospitals. All staff had completed their training at 41 hospitals, and no staff had completed their training at two hospitals. Nearly a third of facilities to which DOJ reached out, began training only after DOJ contacted them, suggesting that DOJ's outreach caused compliance in many cases.
According to the Author
The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. In California Black women continue to die at three to four times the rate of white women. A 2023 study by DPH, "Centering Black Mothers in California: Insights into Racism, Health, and Well-being for Black Women and Infants," found that women of color, in particular Black women, die of pregnancy-related complications at much higher rates than white women in California. Evidence suggests one key cause of this disparity is the implicit bias of healthcare providers. A provider's level of bias, whether conscious or unconscious, can influence their interactions with patients and their diagnoses and treatment of the patient's pain, and can undermine patients' trust and engagement in care. The author notes that, to address this, the legislature passed the Act in 2019, which requires hospitals, alternative birth centers and primary care clinics to conduct evidence-based implicit bias training for all health professionals who provide care during a patient's pregnancy, childbirth, and immediate postpartum period.
Arguments in Support
AG Rob Bonta is the sponsor of this bill and states that investigations into the cause of all pregnancy-related deaths by DPH determined that more than half are preventable. This bill is a substantial part of the systemic change needed to reduce the disparate impact on Black mothers and pregnant persons of color and to prevent these deaths from happening.
Arguments in Opposition
The California Family Council is opposed to this bill and states that the recognition of motherhood as biologically based upholds the dignity of women. Motherhood is an intrinsic and unique aspect of female biology, and acknowledging this fact celebrates and respects the role of women in society. Denying the biological basis of motherhood not only diminishes the special contributions of women but also erodes the foundational understanding of family and community.
The Department of Finance is opposed to this bill because it results in additional costs not included in the 2024 Budget Act.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee, unknown, ongoing costs for DPH for state administration (General Fund and Licensing and Certification Fund). Ongoing General Fund costs, likely low hundreds of thousands, for DOJ for workload related to collecting information from regulated entities, assisting with the biannual report and website updates. Costs may potentially be offset to the extent the AG is awarded attorney's fees and costs
VOTES:
ASM HEALTH: 12-2-2
YES: Bonta, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Wendy Carrillo, Haney, Jones-Sawyer, Maienschein, Rodriguez, Santiago, Schiavo, Weber
NO: Joe Patterson, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Flora, McCarty
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-4-0
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Villapudua
NO: Sanchez, Dixon, Jim Patterson, Ta
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 56-5-19
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Ramos, Reyes, Rodriguez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wilson, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NO: Dixon, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Hoover, Joe Patterson
ABS, ABST OR NV: Bauer-Kahan, Cervantes, Chen, Megan Dahle, Davies, Essayli, Flora, Holden, Lackey, Mathis, Quirk-Silva, Rendon, Luz Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Ta, Villapudua, Wicks, Wood
UPDATED
VERSION: August 15, 2024
CONSULTANT: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0004180
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 2319 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 2319
Author: Wilson (D) and Weber (D), et al.
Amended: 8/15/24 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE HEALTH COMMITTEE: 9-2, 6/26/24
AYES: Roth, Glazer, Gonzalez, Hurtado, Limón, Menjivar, Rubio, Smallwood-Cuevas, Wiener
NOES: Nguyen, Grove
SENATE APPROPRIATIONS COMMITTEE: 4-2, 8/15/24
AYES: Caballero, Ashby, Becker, Wahab
NOES: Jones, Seyarto
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bradford
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 56-5, 5/24/24 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act
SOURCE: Attorney General Rob Bonta
Black Women for Wellness Action Project
California Black Women’s Collective Empowerment Institute
California Nurse-Midwives Association
Reproductive Freedom for All California
Western Center on Law & Poverty, Inc.
DIGEST:
This bill revises the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, which requires hospitals and alternative birth centers to implement an implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients, including by specifying what providers are subject to training requirements, and adding deadlines for compliance with the training requirements. This bill establishes an enforcement mechanism through the Attorney General by requiring health facilities to submit proof of compliance for their providers, and subjecting health facilities to civil penalties of $5,000 for a first violation, and $15,000 for subsequent violations.
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- Establishes the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) and sets forth its powers and duties, including, but not limited to, licensing and regulating health facilities, including hospitals as well as clinics providing alternative birth center services. [Health and Safety Code (HSC) §1204, et seq., and §1250]
- Defines an “alternative birth center” as a clinic that is not part of a hospital and that provides comprehensive perinatal services and delivery care to pregnant women who remain less than 24 hours at the facility. Requires alternative birth centers to meet certain requirements of licensure. [HSC §1204.3]
- Enacts the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, which requires a general acute care hospital, and a special hospital that provides perinatal care and an alternative birth center or primary care clinic that provides alternative birth center services, to implement an implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities. [HSC §123630.3]
- Requires the implicit bias program to include all of the following:
- Identification of previous or current unconscious biases and misinformation;
- Identification of personal, interpersonal, institutional, structural, and cultural barriers to inclusion;
- Corrective measures to decrease implicit bias at the interpersonal and institutional levels, including ongoing policies and practices for that purpose;
- Information on the effects, including, but not limited to, ongoing personal effects, of historical and contemporary exclusion and oppression of minority communities;
- Information about cultural identity across racial or ethnic groups;
- Information about communicating more effectively across identities, including racial, ethnic, religious, and gender identities;
- Discussion on power dynamics and organizational decision making;
- Discussion on health inequities within the perinatal care field, including information on how implicit bias impacts maternal and infant health outcomes;
- Perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, cultural, and provider-community relations issues in the community; and,
- Information on reproductive justice. [HSC 123630.3(b)]
- Requires a healthcare provider involved in the perinatal care of patients within a hospital or alternative birth center to complete initial basic training through the implicit bias program, and upon completion of the initial basic training, to complete a refresher course every two years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends and best practices in decreasing interpersonal and institutional implicit bias. [HSC 123630.3(c)]
This bill:
- Adds more specificity to the types of health care providers who are required to receive implicit bias training from hospitals and alternative birth centers, currently described as “all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities,” to specify that it applies to both of the following:
- All persons licensed under the healing arts, as specified, who are regularly assigned to provide perinatal care, including but not limited to, those in primary care clinics, alternative birthing centers, outpatient clinics, or emergency departments; and,
- All persons who are regularly assigned to positions where they interact with perinatal patients, including, but not limited to, physician assistants, medical assistants, licensed vocational nurses, doctors, or those who facilitate, control, or coordinate access to timely and appropriate medical treatment, as well as any others who provide medical and ancillary treatment.
- Adds to the list of subjects that are required to be included in an implicit bias training program for perinatal care providers the recognition of intersecting identities, including, but not limited to, nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience, and the multiple layers of potential biases that could come into play, result in harm to patients and their infants.
- Adds a deadline of June 1, 2025, by which all current providers are required to complete the initial basic training through the implicit bias program, and requires the initial basic training to be provided to new health care providers at all facilities within six months of their start at the new facility, unless the provider has a certificate of completion from another facility. Requires the training to be provided during paid work time.
- Requires, by February 1 of each year commencing in 2026, a facility required to have a perinatal implicit bias program to provide the Attorney General with proof of compliance. Requires proof of compliance to include all of the following:
- A list of all of the health care providers, as described in this bill, who have completed the initial basic training requirement;
- The dates that each health care provider completed their training;
- The written materials used in the training;
- A description of the training, including substance, format and duration; and,
- A list that outlines the categories by job title of the health care providers who did not participate in the training, if any. Requires each category to include both a delineation of the respective health care provider or provides by employee status, and the number and percentage of the health care providers who failed to complete the training out of the total relevant health care providers within the respective category.
- Requires a facility that violates the requirement to implement an implicit bias program or fails to submit proof of compliance to be liable for a civil penalty of $5,000 for the first violation and $15,000 for the second and each subsequent violation. In the event a facility’s proof of compliance reveals systemic failure of providers to complete the training requirements, requires the facility to be liable for a civil penalty of up to $5,000 for the first violation and $15,000 for subsequent violations.
- Defines “systemic failure,” for purposes of 5) above, as the lesser of the following:
- 10% or more of providers failing to complete the training, provided that if only one or two providers did not receive the training, the facility was provided a reasonable opportunity to cure before a penalty is pursued; or,
- 25 providers failing to complete the required training.
- Prohibits failure by a physician who is not directly employed by the facility from counting toward the percentage of providers failing to complete the required training where the facility demonstrates that the required training was offered to the physician.
- Requires the Attorney General to be awarded all attorney’s fees and costs in any civil action in which a court imposes any of the penalties in this bill.
- Permits the Attorney General to post on their website a list of all facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance, or that were assessed penalties. Permits the Attorney General to include all of the following information when listing the facilities that were assessed penalties: the date the penalty was issued, the amount, the reason the penalty was issued, the percentage of untrained providers, and the date of facility noncompliance. Prohibits this provision from being construed to limit the Attorney General from disclosing any information that they are otherwise not restricted from disclosing by any other provision of law.
- Permits the Attorney General to publish a report outlining compliance data related to the perinatal implicit bias program requirements on a biennial basis.
- Includes a severability clause, in the event any provision of the implicit bias program is held invalid, the remainder shall not be affected to the extent it can be given effect.
Comments
- Author’s statement. According to the author, the U.S. has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. In California, people of color, particularly Black women, continue to die at three to four times the rate of White women. A recent study by CDPH found that women of color, in particular Black women, die of pregnancy-related complications at much higher rates than White Women in California. Evidence suggests one key cause of this disparity is the implicit bias of healthcare providers. A provider’s level of bias, whether conscious or unconscious, can influence their interactions with patients and their diagnoses and treatment of the patient’s pain, and can undermine patients’ trust and engagement in care. This risk is particularly acute where provider-patient concordance may be affected by racial, ethnic, cultural, and gender differences. To address this, the legislature passed the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act (Act) in 2019, which requires hospitals, alternative birth centers and primary care clinics to conduct evidence-based implicit bias training for all health professionals who provide care during a patient’s pregnancy, childbirth, and immediate postpartum period. The California Attorney General recently issued a report following an investigation into facility compliance with that Act. The report and its findings highlight the need for additional action to continue the work started by the Act. Specifically, additional steps are necessary to ensure hospitals and facilities comply and are equipped to meet those requirements.
- DOJ Report on Healthcare Facilities and the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. In October 2023, DOJ published a report showing the results of their investigation into the extent of compliance with the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, which took effect January 1, 2020. According to this report, DOJ used informal letter requests and an electronic survey to collect compliance data from 242 California facilities for the period between January 1, 2020, the effective date of the statute, and July 8, 2022. Of the 258 facilities to which DOJ issued a letter or a survey, 242 (93.79%) responded with data. On average, 81.44% of the relevant staff in those facilities had completed the required training by July 8, 2022. According to DOJ, while this number may appear high, a substantial number of facilities had not completed or even begun training staff until after receiving DOJ’s August 23, 2021 letter, despite the January 1, 2020 effective date of the training requirement. Regarding training approaches, the DOJ report found that the vast majority of hospitals (166 out of those reporting) used an asynchronous training such as a one- to two-hour training provided via video, developed by Diversity Science called “Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth,” which was developed with the goal of satisfying the requirement of the law.
According to DOJ, based on its findings, policymakers should consider options to link training requirements to outcome monitoring by an appropriate state agency. DOJ stated that this could including:- Setting hospital improvement metrics or goals and linking them to training, which could be reported to regulators along with training completion metrics;
- Creating a registry that reports metrics or issues grades for similarly situated hospitals, for cases of similar complexity;
- Setting consequences, such as corrective action plan implementation, for falling below certain metrics;
- Instigating implicit bias training requirements with hospital accreditation and provider licensing examination and renewal requirements.
- Center Black Mothers in California report. In collaboration with the UCSF Center for Health Equity, Black Women for Wellness, and a statewide group of Black women leaders and academics, CDPH published a report in 2023 to inform efforts to promote racial equity and bolster opportunities to be healthy among Black women, other Black birthing people, and their families. This report, Center Black Mothers in California, found that factors at the societal, neighborhood, family, and individual levels have worked in concert over many generations to affect many Black birthing people’s abilities to achieve optimal health across their life course and to have healthy pregnancies, births, and babies. While rates of pregnancy-related mortality have declined, they remain much higher than those of other groups, at 47.3 pregnancy-related deaths for Black mothers per 100,000 live births, compared to 15.1 per 100,000 for Asian/Pacific Islander, 12.6 for Hispanic, and 11.1 for White. Further, while the mortality rate among Black infants has declined over the past decade, in 2018 Black infants were still twice as likely as other infants to die before their first birthdays. The report stated that several pathways connect structural racism to the results presented in this report, including unhealthy and/or under-resourced neighborhood conditions, chronic stress, and lack of respectful care. Because structural racism operates at multiple levels to influence the health of Black families, strategies to ameliorate poor health conditions among Black families cannot be handled within the health care and public health systems alone. However, implementing methods to monitor for and address racism and implicit bias among health care personnel and public health professionals was among the strategies the report suggested be considered.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: Yes Local: No
According to the Senate Appropriations Committee:
- Unknown, ongoing costs for the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) for state administration (General Fund and Licensing and Certification Fund).
- Ongoing General Fund costs, likely low hundreds of thousands, for the Department of Justice for workload related to collecting information from regulated entities, assisting with the biannual report and website updates. Costs may potentially be offset to the extent the Attorney General is awarded attorney’s fees and costs.
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/7/24)
Attorney General Rob Bonta (co-source)
Black Women for Wellness Action Project (co-source)
California Black Women’s Collective Empowerment Institute (co-source)
California Nurse-Midwives Association (co-source)
Reproductive Freedom for All California (co-source)
Western Center on Law & Poverty, Inc. (co-source)
Access Reproductive Justice
American Civil Liberties Union California Action
Asian Americans Advancing Justice-southern California
Black Women Organized for Political Action
California Black Health Network
California Commission on the Status of Women and Girls
California Family Resource Association
California Federation of Teachers
California Legislative Women’s Caucus
California Pan-Ethnic Health Network
California State Association of Psychiatrists
California State Council of Service Employees International Union
California Women's Law Center
Catalyst California
Child Abuse Prevention Center
City and County of San Francisco, Board of Supervisors
Children Now
Community Health Councils
County of San Diego
County of Santa Clara
Courage California
Disability Rights California
Diversity Uplifts, Inc.
Equality California
Essential Access Health
First 5 Alameda County
First 5 California
First 5 Los Angeles
Health Access California
Health Net
Hispanas Organized for Political Equality
Latino Coalition for a Healthy California
National Council of Jewish Women Los Angeles
National Council of Negro Women
National Health Law Program
Office of Lieutenant Governor Eleni Kounalakis
Perinatal Health Equity Initiative
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
The Children's Partnership
Women Lawyers of Sacramento
Women's Foundation California
Women's Health Specialists
Two individuals
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/7/24)
None received
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to Black Women for Wellness Action Project, this bill aims to reduce the alarming and disproportionate maternal morbidity and mortality rate of Black women and other birthing people of color by ensuring the successful implementation of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. With mounting research that establishes the role of implicit bias in maternal health outcomes, a rigorous training grounded in reproductive justice values that stands to improve the quality of care that our mamas receive when seeking care during the perinatal period is a simple step and minimal ask compared to the harms inflicted due to not addressing one’s bias. The California Black Health Network states that Black Women in California make up 5% of those pregnant but account for 21% of the total pregnancy-related deaths, and this disparity exists across all income levels. A provider’s level of bias, whether conscious or unconscious, can influence their interactions with patients, their diagnoses, and their treatment of the patient’s pain, and can undermine patients’ trust and engagement in care. Attorney General Rob Bonta states, in support that this bill (1) provides clarity on which facilities are mandated to administer anti-bias trainings and which employees need to be trained, (2) establishes firm deadlines by which trainings must be completed to better guide compliance, authorizes the DOJ to enforce the law and assess civil penalties for noncompliance, and (4) authorize the DOJ to post compliance data online so the public is made aware of which facilities have provided anti-bias trainings and which have not. The Attorney General states this bill is a substantial part of the systemic change needed to reduce the disparate impact on Black mothers and pregnant persons of color and to prevent these deaths from happening.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 56-5, 5/24/24
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Alanis, Alvarez, Arambula, Bains, Bennett, Berman, Boerner, Bonta, Bryan, Calderon, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gabriel, Garcia, Gipson, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Irwin, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Kalra, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Ortega, Pacheco, Papan, Jim Patterson, Pellerin, Petrie-Norris, Ramos, Reyes, Rodriguez, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Waldron, Wallis, Ward, Weber, Wilson, Zbur, Robert Rivas
NOES: Dixon, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Hoover, Joe Patterson
NO VOTE RECORDED: Bauer-Kahan, Cervantes, Chen, Megan Dahle, Davies, Essayli, Flora, Holden, Lackey, Mathis, Quirk-Silva, Rendon, Luz Rivas, Blanca Rubio, Sanchez, Ta, Villapudua, Wicks, Wood
Prepared by: Vincent D. Marchand / HEALTH / (916) 651-4111
8/19/24 10:55:43
**** END ****
SENATE COMMITTEE ON
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 2319 (Wilson) - California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act
Version: | Policy Vote: |
Urgency: | Mandate: |
Hearing Date: | Consultant: |
Bill Summary:
AB 2319 would make revisions to the existing California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act.
*********** ANALYSIS ADDENDUM – SUSPENSE FILE ***********
The following information is revised to reflect amendments
adopted by the committee on August 15, 2024
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, ongoing costs for the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) for state administration (General Fund and Licensing and Certification Fund).
- Ongoing General Fund costs, likely low hundreds of thousands, for the Department of Justice for workload related to collecting information from regulated entities, assisting with the biannual report and website updates. Costs may potentially be offset to the extent the Attorney General is awarded attorney’s fees and costs.
Author Amendments:
Require that the Attorney General be awarded all attorney’s fees and costs in any civil action in which a court imposes penalties, as specified.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Senator Anna Caballero, Chair
2023 - 2024 Regular Session
AB 2319 (Wilson) - California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act
Version: June 27, 2024 | Policy Vote: HEALTH 9 - 2, JUD. 10 - 1 |
Urgency: No | Mandate: No |
Hearing Date: August 5, 2024 | Consultant: Agnes Lee |
Bill Summary:
AB 2319 would make revisions to the existing California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act.
Fiscal Impact:
- Unknown, ongoing costs for the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) for state administration (General Fund and Licensing and Certification Fund).
- The Department of Justice estimates General Fund costs of $171,000 in 2025-26 and $161,000 in 2026-27 and ongoing thereafter for state administration.
Background:
The California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act requires a general acute care hospital, and a special hospital that provides perinatal care and an alternative birth center or primary care clinic that provides alternative birth center services, to implement an implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities. Current law requires the implicit bias program to include all of the following:
- Identification of previous or current unconscious biases and misinformation.
- Identification of personal, interpersonal, institutional, structural, and cultural barriers to inclusion.
- Corrective measures to decrease implicit bias at the interpersonal and institutional levels, including ongoing policies and practices for that purpose.
- Information on the effects, including, but not limited to, ongoing personal effects, of historical and contemporary exclusion and oppression of minority communities.
- Information about cultural identity across racial or ethnic groups.
- Information about communicating more effectively across identities, including racial, ethnic, religious, and gender identities.
- Discussion on power dynamics and organizational decisionmaking.
- Discussion on health inequities within the perinatal care field, including information on how implicit bias impacts maternal and infant health outcomes.
- Perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, cultural, and provider-community relations issues in the community.
- Information on reproductive justice.
In October 2023, the DOJ published a report showing the results of their investigation into the extent of compliance with the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, which took effect January 1, 2020. The report’s conclusions included, “The Act requiring implicit bias training for covered facilities includes no explicit enforcement mechanism and does not assign oversight of its requirements to any particular agency, undermining its efficacy. Those who do fulfill the requirement are under no obligation or incentive to evolve their training over the years with updated evidence-based and gender-inclusive standards aligned with current research on implicit bias and health outcomes. Those who do not fulfill the requirement are unlikely to face repercussions because a lack of public access to compliance data makes it challenging for consumers to know whether or not their covered provider has fulfilled its obligation.”
Proposed Law:
Specific provisions of the bill would:
- Specify further the individuals required to receive implicit bias training.
- Add to the list of program components, the recognition of intersecting identities, including, but not limited to, nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience, and the multiple layers of potential biases that could come into play, resulting in harm to patients and their infants.
- Provide that the required initial basic training must be completed by June 1, 2025, for all current health care providers; and that the required initial basic training must be provided to new health care providers at all facilities within six months of their start at the new facility, except as provided.
- Require, by February 1 of each year, commencing in 2026, the facility to provide the Attorney General with proof of compliance, as specified.
- Require that a facility that violates the requirement to implement an implicit bias program, or fails to submit proof of compliance to the Attorney General is liable for a civil penalty of $5,000 for the first violation and $15,000 for the second and each subsequent violation; require that in the event a facility’s proof of compliance submitted to the Attorney General reveals systemic failure of providers to complete the training requirements, as described, the facility is liable for a civil penalty of $5,000 for the first violation, and $15,000 for the second and each subsequent violation; and require that civil penalties be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General in any court of competent jurisdiction.
- Authorize the Attorney General to post on their website a list of all facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance or that were assessed penalties; and authorize the Attorney General to publish a report outlining compliance data on a biennial basis.
-- END --
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 2319 (Author:Wilson and Weber)
Version: June 27, 2024
Hearing Date: July 2, 2024
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: AM
SUBJECT
California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act
DIGEST
This bill revises the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act (Act) by specifying what providers are subject to implicit bias training in hospitals that provide perinatal care and alternative birth centers or primary care clinics involved in perinatal care, and that the training should include recognition of intersecting identities and the multiple layers of potential biases that could come into play, resulting in harm to patients and their infants. The bill requires the initial basic training to be completed by June 1, 2025, for all current health care providers, and within six months of the start at a new facility by a provider, except as specified. The bill requires proof of compliance be submitted to the Attorney General, and makes a violation of the Act punishable by a civil penalty.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Studies, including a recent California Department of Public Health (CDPH) one, [1] have found that women of color, especially Black women, die of pregnancy-related complications at much higher rates than white women. Black women make up 5 percent of those pregnant in California but account for 21 percent of the total of pregnancy-related deaths.[2] The Act was enacted in 2019 to address these stark racial disparities, by requiring health facilities to train providers of perinatal care on implicit bias and the negative and dangerous impacts it can have on patients. In 2021, the California Department of Justice (DOJ) sought to investigate compliance with the Act and found that fewer than 17 percent of responding providers had begun training employees and not a single employee had been trained fully.[3] This bill seeks to address this issue by, among other, things requiring proof of compliance with the Act be provided to the Attorney General and providing civil liability for failure to complete the required training.
This bill was previously analyzed by the Senate Health Committee—where it passed by a vote of 9 to 2—regarding issues relating to the public health implications of the bill’s provisions. This analysis, however, is limited to the issues within the Committee’s jurisdiction—namely, the enforcement and public posting of compliance data. This bill is sponsored by the Attorney General, Rob Bonta, Black Women for Wellness Action Project, the California Black Women’s Collective Empowerment Institute, the California Nurse-Midwives Association, Reproductive Freedom for All California, and Western Center on Law & Poverty. The bill is opposed by the California Family Council.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Enacts the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, which requires a general acute care hospital, and a special hospital that provides perinatal care and an alternative birth center or primary care clinic that provides alternative birth center services, to implement an implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities. (Health & Saf. Code § 123630.3.)
- Defines “perinatal care” as the provision of care during pregnancy, labor, delivery, and postpartum and neonatal periods.
- Requires the implicit bias program to include specified topics, including, among others:
- identification of previous or current unconscious biases and misinformation;
- identification of personal, interpersonal, institutional, structural, and cultural barriers to inclusion; corrective measures to decrease implicit bias at the interpersonal and institutional levels;
- information on the effects of historical and contemporary exclusion and oppression of minority communities;
- information about cultural identity across racial or ethnic groups;
- information about communicating more effectively across identities, including racial, ethnic, religious, and gender identities;
- discussion on power dynamics and organizational decision making;
- discussion on health inequities within the perinatal care field;
- perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, cultural, and provider-community relations issues in the community; and
- information on reproductive justice. (Id. at (b).)
- Requires a healthcare provider involved in the perinatal care of patients within a hospital or alternative birth center to complete initial basic training through the implicit bias program, and upon completion of the initial basic training, to complete a refresher course every two years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends and best practices in decreasing interpersonal and institutional implicit bias. (Id. at (c).)
- Provides for the licensure and regulation of various healing arts professions under Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code, including, among others, doctors, nurses, nurse-midwives, and midwives. (Bus. & Prof. Code § 500 et. seq.)
This bill:
- Specifies that health care providers who are required to complete the implicit bias training described above includes:
- all persons licensed under Division 2 of the Business and Professions Code (commencing with Section 500) who are regularly assigned to provide perinatal care, including, but not limited to, those in primary care clinics, alternative birthing centers, outpatient clinics, or emergency departments; and
- all persons who are regularly assigned to positions where they interact with perinatal patients, including, but not limited to, physician assistants, medical assistants, licensed vocational nurses, doctors, or those who facilitate, control, or coordinate access to timely and appropriate medical treatment, as well as any others who provide medical and ancillary treatment.
- Defines “perinatal care” to include, but not limited to, prenatal care.
- Expands the topics required under the implicit bias training to also include recognition of intersecting identities, including, but not limited to, nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience, and the multiple layers of potential biases that could come into play, resulting in harm to patients and their infants.
- Provides that initial basic training must be completed by June 1, 2025 for all current health care providers, and within six months of the start date for all new health care providers, except as provided.
- Requires the training to be provided during paid work time.
- Requires a facility to provide the Attorney General proof of compliance by February 1 of each year, commencing in 2026, as specified.
- A facility that violates these provisions is liable for a civil penalty of $5,000 for the first violation and $15,000 for ae second and each subsequent violation.
- The civil penalty is to be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought in the name of the people of the State of California by the Attorney General in any court of competent jurisdiction.
- Specifies that in the event a facility’s proof of compliance reveals systemic failure, as defined, of providers to complete the training requirements, the facility is liable for a civil penalty of $5,000 for a first violation, and $15,000 for the second and each subsequent violation.
- The penalties provided are not exclusive and do not limit other remedies available in law for other violations.
- Authorizes the Attorney General to post on their website a list of all facilities that did not submit timely proof of compliance or that were assessed penalties. Authorizes the Attorney General to include the following information:
- the date the penalty was issued;
- the amount of the penalty;
- the reason the penalty was issued;
- the percentage of untrained providers;
- the date of facility noncompliance; and
- any other compliance data related to the Act that the Attorney General deems appropriate.
- Authorizes the Attorney General to publish a report outlining compliance data related to the Act on a biennial basis. The report may be posted on the Attorney General’s website.
- Adds additional findings and declarations to the Act that state:
- the Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience; and
- all persons who may interact with perinatal patients to gatekeep, facilitate, or coordinate access to timely, responsive, respectful, and appropriate medical care may impact Black birthing persons’ maternal mortality and morbidity outcomes, including, but not limited to, hospital or facility employees who facilitate, control, or directly or indirectly coordinate access to timely and appropriate medical treatment as well as those who provide medical and ancillary treatment.
- Includes a severability clause.
COMMENTS
- Stated need for the bill
The author writes:
The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. In California, people of color, particularly Black women, continue to die at three to four times the rate of White women. A recent study by the California Department of Public Health found that women of color, in particular Black women, die of pregnancy-related complications at much higher rates than White Women in California. Evidence suggests one key cause of this disparity is the implicit bias of healthcare providers. A provider’s level of bias, whether conscious or unconscious, can influence their interactions with patients and their diagnoses and treatment of the patient’s pain, and can undermine patients’ trust and engagement in care.
The Attorney General, Rob Bonta, one of the sponsors of the bill, writes:
The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world — a burden disproportionately borne by communities of color, especially Black women. In California in particular, Black women make up 5% of those pregnant but account for 21% of the total pregnancy-related deaths. This disparity exists across all income levels. Evidence suggests one key cause of this disparity is the implicit bias of healthcare providers. A provider’s level of bias, whether conscious or unconscious, can influence their interactions with patients and their diagnoses and treatment of the patient’s pain, and can undermine patients’ trust and engagement in care.
AB 2319 strengthens the Act to further address the continued racial disparity in maternal morbidity rates by changing the way that healthcare providers recognize and overcome their own implicit bias when treating pregnancy. Specifically, the key provisions of AB 2319 would: (1) provide clarity on which facilities are mandated to administer anti-bias trainings and which employees need to be trained, (2) establish firm deadlines by which trainings must be completed to better guide compliance, (3) authorize the DOJ to enforce the Act and assess civil penalties for noncompliance, and (4) authorize the DOJ to post compliance data online so the public is made aware of which facilities have provided anti-bias trainings and which have not.
AB 2319 is a substantial part of the systemic change needed to reduce the disparate impact on Black mothers and pregnant persons of color and to prevent these deaths from happening.
- Disparities in maternal morbidity and mortality
The Senate Health Committee analysis of this bill analyzed the public health aspects of the bill and noted, among other data, the following:
- According to the California Birth Equity Collaborative (CBEC), an initiative at Stanford University’s California Maternal Quality of Care Collaborative (CMQCC), maternal mortality rates nearly doubled in California between 1999 and 2006.
- Data shows that even in the absence of risk factors such as age over 35 years, lack of health insurance, inadequate or no prenatal care, and less than a high school education, the U.S. system of health care is not protecting Black mothers.
- According to CBEC, increasing evidence points to racism within and across multiple levels, and not race, as a key cause of these birth disparities. Data also shows variations in the quality of care and outcomes across hospitals in California, highlighting opportunities for advancing equity in quality improvement.
- AB 1810 (Committee on Budget, Ch. 34, Stats. 2018) established the California Perinatal Equity Initiative (PEI) at the CDPH, and appropriated $8 million from the General Fund, to expand the scope of interventions provided under the Black Infant Health Program (BIH).
- The goal of BIH is to improve African-American infant and maternal health, as well as decrease Black-White health inequities and social inequities for women and infants, by providing services to African-American women who are 18 years of age or older and up to 30 weeks pregnant at the time of enrollment.
- CDPH published a report in 2023 titled Centering Black Mothers in California, which found that factors at the societal, neighborhood, family, and individual levels have worked in concert over many generations to affect many Black birthing people’s abilities to achieve optimal health across their life and to have healthy pregnancies, births, and babies.
- While rates of pregnancy-related mortality have declined, they remain much higher than those of other groups, at 47.3 pregnancy-related deaths for Black mothers per 100,000 live births, compared to 15.1 per 100,000 for Asian/Pacific Islander, 12.6 for Hispanic, and 11.1 for White.
- In 2018, Black infants were still twice as likely as other infants to die before their first birthdays, even though the mortality rate among Black infants has declined over the past decade.[4]
- DOJ Report on Healthcare Facilities and the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act
In October of 2023, the DOJ published the Report on Healthcare Facilities and the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act presenting the results of their inquiry into the extent of compliance with the Act, which became operative on January 1, 2020. The DOJ used informal letter requests and an electronic survey to collect compliance data for the period between January 1, 2020, the effective date of the statute, and July 8, 2022.[5] The DOJ issues a letter or survey to 258 facilities, 242 (93.79 percent) responded with data that showed 81.44 percent of the relevant staff in the responding facilities had completed the required training by July 8, 2022.[6] However, the DOJ notes that a substantial number of facilities had not completed or even begun training staff until after receiving the initial letter from the DOJ on August of 2021, despite the January 1, 2020 effective date of the training requirement.[7] It should be highlighted that this time period was during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic when hospitals were overwhelmed with addressing the influx of patients and new protocols to address the pandemic.
In the DOJ report, they noted that, “compliance could be furthered by ensuring more transparency and public access to compliance data.”[8] The report also noted that the statute does not “acknowledge and clarify that non-binary people and transgender men also give birth and are subject to additional compounding barriers of transphobia, homophobia, and biphobia. While Black maternal mortality is centered in the statute, ideally training should cover all forms of bias experienced by pregnant patients from at risk-groups.”[9] The report states that there was confusion expressed by those in the medical community about the scope of the Act and what providers were required to complete the training as well.[10]
- This bill seeks to address the findings of the DOJ report
This bill seeks to address the findings of the DOJ report in several ways:
- specifies that health care providers who are required to complete the implicit bias training;
- expands the definition of perinatal care to include prenatal care;
- provides a date by which the initial training must be completed, and when training for new providers must be completed;
- requires proof of compliance be submitted to the Attorney General annually;
- expands the training to include the recognition of intersecting identities, including, but not limited to, nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience, and the multiple layers of potential biases that could come into play, resulting in harm to patients and their infants;
- provides a civil penalty for not complying with the implicit bias training requirements of the Act; and
- authorizes the Attorney general to post compliance data on their website.
Under the bill, a facility that violates the training provisions is liable for a civil penalty of $5,000 for the first violation and $15,000 for a second and each subsequent violation.
The civil penalty is to be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought by the Attorney General in any court of competent jurisdiction. Specifies that in the event a facility’s proof of compliance reveals systemic failure, as defined, of providers to complete the training requirements, the facility is liable for a civil penalty of $5,000 for a first violation, and $15,000 for the second and each subsequent violation. Systemic failure means the lesser of the following: (a) 10 percent or more of providers failing to complete the training, provided that if only one or two providers did not receive the training, the facility is provided a reasonable opportunity to cure before the penalty is assessed, or (b) 25 percent of providers failing to complete the training. These penalties are not exclusive and do not limit other remedies available in law for other violations.
The bill also authorizes the Attorney General to post on their website a list of all facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance or that were assessed penalties, including the following information:
- the date the penalty was issued;
- the amount of the penalty;
- the reason the penalty was issued;
- the percentage of untrained providers;
- the date of facility noncompliance; and
- any other compliance data related to the Act that the Attorney General deems appropriate.
Additionally, the Attorney General is authorized to publish a report outlining compliance data related to the Act on a biennial basis, which may be posted on the Attorney General’s website.
- Statements in support
The Western Center on Law and Poverty, one of the sponsors of the bill, writes:
The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world - a burden disproportionately borne by communities of color, especially Black women. According to the California Department of Public Health (CDPH), Black women in California make up 5% of those pregnant but account for 21% of the total pregnancy related deaths. This disparity exists across all income levels. Evidence suggests one key cause of this disparity is the implicit bias of healthcare providers. A provider’s level of bias, whether conscious or unconscious, can influence their interactions with patients and their diagnoses and treatment of the patient’s pain, and can undermine patients’ trust and engagement in care.
AB 2319 strengthens the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act (the Act) to further address the continued racial disparity in maternal morbidity rates by changing the way that healthcare providers recognize and overcome their own implicit bias when treating pregnancy. […] AB 2319 is an important part of the systemic change needed to reduce the disparate impact on Black mothers and pregnant persons of color and to prevent these deaths from happening.
- Statements in opposition
The California Family Council writes in opposition, stating:
AB 2319, [is] a piece of legislation that fundamentally misconstrues the nature of implicit bias and imposes harmful consequences on medical professionals for adhering to biological truths.
Firstly, it is not implicit bias to recognize that only females give birth. This is a biological fact that has been consistently observed and confirmed by science. The notion that acknowledging such a fundamental truth constitutes bias is both erroneous and misleading. Medical professionals must rely on accurate biological information to provide the best care possible, and penalizing them for recognizing basic biological differences undermines the integrity of medical practice.
Secondly, AB 2319 unfairly shames medical staff for believing that male and female bodies are biologically distinct. It is essential for healthcare providers to understand and acknowledge these distinctions to ensure appropriate medical care. By labeling this understanding as biased, the bill risks creating an environment where medical professionals may feel pressured to deny biological realities, leading to potential harm to patients. This bill could deter medical professionals from entering or remaining in the field, exacerbating existing shortages and impacting the quality of care available to patients.
Lastly, the recognition of motherhood as biologically based upholds the dignity of women. Motherhood is an intrinsic and unique aspect of female biology, and acknowledging this fact celebrates and respects the role of women in society. Denying the biological basis of motherhood not only diminishes the special contributions of women but also erodes the foundational understanding of family and community. Affirming the biological reality of motherhood is essential to supporting women's rights and ensuring their unique experiences are valued and respected.
SUPPORT
Attorney General, Rob Bonta (sponsor)
Black Women for Wellness Action Project (sponsor)
California Black Women’s Collective Empowerment Institute (sponsor)
California Nurse-Midwives Association (sponsor)
Reproductive Freedom for All California (sponsor)
Western Center on Law and Poverty (sponsor)
ACCESS REPRODUCTIVE JUSTICE
ACLU California Action
American Atheists
Asian Americans Advancing Justice
Board of Supervisors for the City and County of San Francisco
Black Woman Organized for Political Action, Political Action Committee
California Black Health Network
California Black Women's Collective Empowerment Institute
California Commission on the Status of Women and Girls
California State Association of Psychiatrists
California State Council of Service Employees International Union
California Women’s Law Center
Catalyst California
California Family Resource Association
California Federation of Teachers
Children Now
Children’s Partnership
Courage California
Disability Rights California
Diversity Uplifts
Equality California
Essential Access Health
Health Access California
Health Net
Hispanas Organized for Political Equality (HOPE)
National Council of Jewish Women Los Angeles
National Council of Negro Women, Inc., Northern California Region
National Health Law Program
Perinatal Health Equity Initiative
Rising Communities
The Child Abuse Prevention Center
Women’s Foundation of California
Women’s Health Specialists
OPPOSITION
California Family Council
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known.
Prior Legislation:
SB 464 (Mitchell, Ch. 533, Stats. 2019) enacted the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, which requires hospitals and alternative birth centers to implement an implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities.
AB 241 (Kamlager-Dove, Ch. 417, Stats. 2019) requires continuing education courses for physicians, nurses, and physician assistant to containing curriculum on understanding implicit bias.
PRIOR VOTES
Senate Health Committee (Ayes 9, Noes 2)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 56, Noes 5)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 11, Noes 4)
Assembly Health Committee (Ayes 12, Noes 2)
**************
Centering Black Mothers in California, Cal. Dept. of Pub. Health, (2023), available at https://www.cdph.ca.gov/Programs/CFH/DMCAH/CDPH%20Document%20Library/Centering-Black-Mothers/Centering-Black-Mothers-Report-2023.pdf. ↑
Attorney General Bonta Announces Results of Investigation into Anti-Bias Training for Pregnancy Care Providers, Press Release, Cal. Dept. of Justice, (Oct. 27, 2023), available at https://oag.ca.gov/news/press-releases/attorney-general-bonta-announces-results-investigation-anti-bias-training. ↑
Ibid. ↑
Sen. Health Comm. analysis on AB 2319 (2023-24 reg. sess.) as amended May 20, 2024. ↑
Report on Healthcare Facilities and the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, Cal. Dept. of Justice, (Oct. 2023), available at https://oag.ca.gov/system/files/attachments/press-docs/Report%20on%20Healthcare%20Facilities%20and%20the%20California%20Dignity%20in%20Pregnancy%20and%20Childbirth%20Act%20%282%29.pdf. ↑
Id. at 3. ↑
Ibid. ↑
Id. at 13. ↑
Id. at 15. ↑
Id. at 16. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Richard Roth, Chair
BILL NO: AB 2319
AUTHOR: | Wilson | ||
VERSION: | May 20, 2024 | ||
HEARING DATE: | June 26, 2024 | ||
CONSULTANT: | Vincent D. Marchand | ||
SUBJECT: California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act
SUMMARY:
Revises the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, which requires hospitals and alternative birth centers to implement an implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients, including by specifying what providers are subject to training requirements, and adding deadlines for compliance with the training requirements. Establishes an enforcement mechanism through the Attorney General by requiring health facilities to submit proof of compliance for their providers, and subjecting health facilities to civil penalties of $10,000 for a first violation, and $25,000 for subsequent violations..
Existing law:
- Establishes the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) and sets forth its powers and duties, including, but not limited to, licensing and regulating health facilities, including hospitals as well as clinics providing alternative birth center services. [HSC §1204, et seq., and §1250]
- Defines an “alternative birth center” as a clinic that is not part of a hospital and that provides comprehensive perinatal services and delivery care to pregnant women who remain less than 24 hours at the facility. Requires alternative birth centers to meet certain requirements of licensure. [HSC §1204.3]
- Enacts the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, which requires a general acute care hospital, and a special hospital that provides perinatal care and an alternative birth center or primary care clinic that provides alternative birth center services, to implement an implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities. [HSC §123630.3]
- Requires the implicit bias program to include all of the following:
- Identification of previous or current unconscious biases and misinformation;
- Identification of personal, interpersonal, institutional, structural, and cultural barriers to inclusion;
- Corrective measures to decrease implicit bias at the interpersonal and institutional levels, including ongoing policies and practices for that purpose;
- Information on the effects, including, but not limited to, ongoing personal effects, of historical and contemporary exclusion and oppression of minority communities;
- Information about cultural identity across racial or ethnic groups;
- Information about communicating more effectively across identities, including racial, ethnic, religious, and gender identities;
- Discussion on power dynamics and organizational decision making;
- Discussion on health inequities within the perinatal care field, including information on how implicit bias impacts maternal and infant health outcomes;
- Perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, cultural, and provider-community relations issues in the community; and,
- Information on reproductive justice. [HSC 123630.3(b)]
- Requires a healthcare provider involved in the perinatal care of patients within a hospital or alternative birth center to complete initial basic training through the implicit bias program, and upon completion of the initial basic training, to complete a refresher course every two years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends and best practices in decreasing interpersonal and institutional implicit bias. [HSC 123630.3(c)]
This bill:
- Adds more specificity to the types of health care providers who are required to receive implicit bias training from hospitals and alternative birth centers, currently described as “all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities,” to specify that it applies to both of the following:
- All persons licensed under the healing arts, as specified, who are regularly assigned to provide perinatal care, including but not limited to, those in primary care clinics, alternative birthing centers, outpatient clinics, or emergency departments; and,
- All persons who are regularly assigned to positions where they interact with perinatal patients, including, but not limited to, physician assistants, medical assistants, licensed vocational nurses, doctors, or those who facilitate, control, or coordinate access to timely and appropriate medical treatment, as well as any others who provide medical and ancillary treatment.
- Adds to the list of subjects that are required to be included in an implicit bias training program for perinatal care providers the recognition of intersecting identities, including, but not limited to, nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience, and the multiple layers of potential biases that could come into play, result in harm to patients and their infants.
- Adds a deadline of June 1, 2025, by which all current providers are required to complete the initial basic training through the implicit bias program, and requires the initial basic training to be provided to new health care providers at all facilities within six months of their start at the new facility, unless the provider has a certificate of completion from another facility.
- Requires, by February 1 of each year commencing in 2026, a facility required to have a perinatal implicit bias program to provide the Attorney General with proof of compliance. Requires proof of compliance to include all of the following:
- A list of all of the health care providers, as described in this bill, who have completed the initial basic training requirement;
- The dates that each health care provider completed their training;
- The written materials used in the training;
- A description of the training, including format and duration; and,
- A list of the health care providers who did not participate in the training, if any.
- Requires a facility that violates the provisions of the perinatal implicit bias program to be liable for a civil penalty of $10,000 for the first violation and $25,000 for the second and each subsequent violation, which is required to be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought by the Attorney General in any court of competent jurisdiction. Specifies that for purposes of this civil penalty, each health care provider that does not timely complete the required training before the relevant deadline constitutes a separate violation for purposes of determining the first, second, or subsequent violations. Specifies that the penalties provided in this bill are not exclusive and do not limit other remedies available in law for such violations.
- Permits the Attorney General to post on their website a list of all facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance, or that were assessed penalties. Permits the Attorney General to include all of the following information when listing the facilities that were assessed penalties: the date the penalty was issued, the amount, the reason the penalty was issued, the percentage of untrained providers, and the date of facility noncompliance. Prohibits this provision from being construed to limit the Attorney General from disclosing any information that they are otherwise not restricted from disclosing by any other provision of law.
- Permits the Attorney General to publish a report outlining compliance data related to the perinatal implicit bias program requirements on a biennial basis.
- Includes a severability clause, in the event any provision of the implicit bias program is held invalid, the remainder shall not be affected to the extent it can be given effect.
FISCAL EFFECT:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, the Department of Justice (DOJ) estimates costs of about $150,000 per year to collect proof of compliance and post on its website a list of facilities that are not in compliance with the provisions of this bill (General Fund).
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor: | 56 - 5 |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: | 11 - 4 |
Assembly Health Committee: | 12 - 2 |
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, the U.S. has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. In California, people of color, particularly Black women, continue to die at three to four times the rate of White women. A recent study by CDPH found that women of color, in particular Black women, die of pregnancy-related complications at much higher rates than White Women in California. Evidence suggests one key cause of this disparity is the implicit bias of healthcare providers. A provider’s level of bias, whether conscious or unconscious, can influence their interactions with patients and their diagnoses and treatment of the patient’s pain, and can undermine patients’ trust and engagement in care. This risk is particularly acute where provider-patient concordance may be affected by racial, ethnic, cultural, and gender differences. To address this, the legislature passed the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act (Act) in 2019, which requires hospitals, alternative birth centers and primary care clinics to conduct evidence-based implicit bias training for all health professionals who provide care during a patient’s pregnancy, childbirth, and immediate postpartum period. The California Attorney General recently issued a report following an investigation into facility compliance with that Act. The report and its findings highlight the need for additional action to continue the work started by the Act. Specifically, additional steps are necessary to ensure hospitals and facilities comply and are equipped to meet those requirements.
- DOJ Report on Healthcare Facilities and the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. In October 2023, DOJ published a report showing the results of their investigation into the extent of compliance with the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, which took effect January 1, 2020. According to this report, DOJ used informal letter requests and an electronic survey to collect compliance data from 242 California facilities for the period between January 1, 2020, the effective date of the statute, and July 8, 2022. Of the 258 facilities to which DOJ issued a letter or a survey, 242 (93.79%) responded with data. On average, 81.44% of the relevant staff in those facilities had completed the required training by July 8, 2022. According to DOJ, while this number may appear high, a substantial number of facilities had not completed or even begun training staff until after receiving DOJ’s August 23, 2021 letter, despite the January 1, 2020 effective date of the training requirement. Regarding training approaches, the DOJ report found that the vast majority of hospitals (166 out of those reporting) used an asynchronous training such as a one- to two-hour training provided via video, developed by Diversity Science called “Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth,” which was developed with the goal of satisfying the requirement of the law.
According to DOJ, based on its findings, policymakers should consider options to link training requirements to outcome monitoring by an appropriate state agency. DOJ stated that this could including:- Setting hospital improvement metrics or goals and linking them to training, which could be reported to regulators along with training completion metrics;
- Creating a registry that reports metrics or issues grades for similarly situated hospitals, for cases of similar complexity;
- Setting consequences, such as corrective action plan implementation, for falling below certain metrics;
- Instigating implicit bias training requirements with hospital accreditation and provider licensing examination and renewal requirements.
- Center Black Mothers in California report. In collaboration with the UCSF Center for Health Equity, Black Women for Wellness, and a statewide group of Black women leaders and academics, CDPH published a report in 2023 to inform efforts to promote racial equity and bolster opportunities to be healthy among Black women, other Black birthing people, and their families. This report, Center Black Mothers in California, found that factors at the societal, neighborhood, family, and individual levels have worked in concert over many generations to affect many Black birthing people’s abilities to achieve optimal health across their life course and to have healthy pregnancies, births, and babies. While rates of pregnancy-related mortality have declined, they remain much higher than those of other groups, at 47.3 pregnancy-related deaths for Black mothers per 100,000 live births, compared to 15.1 per 100,000 for Asian/Pacific Islander, 12.6 for Hispanic, and 11.1 for White. Further, while the mortality rate among Black infants has declined over the past decade, in 2018 Black infants were still twice as likely as other infants to die before their first birthdays. The report stated that several pathways connect structural racism to the results presented in this report, including unhealthy and/or under-resourced neighborhood conditions, chronic stress, and lack of respectful care. Because structural racism operates at multiple levels to influence the health of Black families, strategies to ameliorate poor health conditions among Black families cannot be handled within the health care and public health systems alone. However, implementing methods to monitor for and address racism and implicit bias among health care personnel and public health professionals was among the strategies the report suggested be considered.
- Disparities in maternal morbidity and mortality. According to the California Birth Equity Collaborative (CBEC), an initiative at Stanford University’s California Maternal Quality of Care Collaborative (CMQCC), maternal mortality rates nearly doubled in California between 1999 and 2006. Since CMQCC was founded in 2006, California’s maternal mortality rate has declined by 55% while the national maternal mortality rate has continued to rise. The expectation was that widespread adoption of CMQCC’s clinical safety bundles would reduce the gap in the number of maternal deaths among Black women. However, the difference in outcomes for Black mothers has persisted. Further analysis revealed that clinical safety bundles and social support interventions done in isolation, without an integrated approach, did not produce the desired outcomes. Data shows that even in the absence of risk factors such as age over 35 years, lack of health insurance, inadequate or no prenatal care, and less than a high school education, the U.S. system of health care is not protecting Black mothers. According to CBEC, increasing evidence points to racism within and across multiple levels, and not race, as a key cause of these birth disparities. Data also shows variations in the quality of care and outcomes across hospitals in California highlighting opportunities for advancing equity in quality improvement. A 2017 study published in Seminars in Perinatology, Improving hospital quality to reduce disparities in severe maternal morbidity and mortality, found that growing research suggests that hospital quality may be a critical lever for improving outcomes and narrowing disparities. This study stated that with Black women three to four times more likely to die from pregnancy-related causes than white women, this represents the largest disparity among all the conventional population perinatal health measures. Among other things, the study suggested that team training is an important step to providing coordinated care, and that implementation of a disparities dashboard, which stratifies quality metrics by race and ethnicity, is a useful tool, which allows hospitals to become aware of disparities.
- Black Infant Health (BIH) Program. BIH is one of the programs within CDPH’s Division of Maternal, Child, and Adolescent Health. The goal of BIH is to improve African-American infant and maternal health, as well as decrease Black-White health inequities and social inequities for women and infants. BIH serves African-American women who are 18 years of age or older and up to 30 weeks pregnant at the time of enrollment. According to CDPH’s BIH website, “within a culturally affirming environment and honoring the unique history of African-American women, BIH aims to help women have healthy babies. Participants learn proven strategies to reduce stress and develop life skills. This is accomplished through a group-based approach with complementary case management.” BIH services are provided by family health advocates, group facilitators, public health nurses, and social workers. BIH participants report stronger positive connections to their heritage and the African-American community, increased empowerment to make behavior changes that lead to living a healthier life, and better understanding of effective stress-reduction strategies.
- California Perinatal Equity Initiative. AB 1810 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 34, Statutes of 2018) established the California Perinatal Equity Initiative (PEI) at CDPH, and appropriated $8 million from the General Fund, to expand the scope of interventions provided under BIH. The PEI is intended to foster Community Centers of Excellence in perinatal health and promote the use of interventions designed to fill gaps in current programming offered through BIH. Under the PEI, CDPH is required to allocate funds to up to 15 county health departments, to work collaboratively with state and local BIH programs, for the purposes of improving back infant birth outcomes and reducing infant mortality. County health departments are required to use the funds to develop local Community Centers of Excellence at hospitals, federal qualified health centers, clinics, or community-based organizations that have demonstrated capacity to work with public health and health care systems as well as within the Black community. Recipients of local grants are required to implement or expand two of five types of programs: evidence-based group prenatal care that has shown promise in reducing the incidence of adverse birth outcomes; pregnancy intentionality and preconception programs; fatherhood or partnership initiatives; evidence-based home visiting programs inclusive of case management to increase advocacy and empowerment for Black women and to ensure linkages to prenatal care; or, a different strategy that is justified based on local needs and resources, if a county determines that the strategy is evidence-based in relation to reducing adverse birth outcomes.
- Prior legislation. SB 464 (Mitchell, Chapter 533, Statutes of 2019) enacted the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, which requires hospitals and alternative birth centers to implement an implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities, including requiring these healthcare providers to complete initial basic training through the implicit bias program and a refresher course every two years thereafter. SB 464 requires CDPH to track and publish data on maternal death and severe morbidity; and adds, to the list of written information a hospital is required to provide to each patient upon admission, information on how to file a discrimination complaint with CDPH or the Medical Board of California if the patient feels they were discriminated against.
AB 241 (Kamlager-Dove, Chapter 417, Statutes of 2019) requires continuing education courses for physicians, nurses, and physician assistant to containing curriculum on understanding implicit bias. - Double referral. This bill is double referred. Should it pass out of this Committee, it will be referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
- Support. This bill is co-sponsored by Attorney General Rob Bonta, Black Women for Wellness Action Project, the California Black Women’s Collective Empowerment Institute, California Nurse-Midwives Association, Reproductive Freedom for All California, and Western Center on Law & Poverty. According to Black Women for Wellness Action Project, this bill aims to reduce the alarming and disproportionate maternal morbidity and mortality rate of Black women and other birthing people of color by ensuring the successful implementation of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. With mounting research that establishes the role of implicit bias in maternal health outcomes, a rigorous training grounded in reproductive justice values that stands to improve the quality of care that our mamas receive when seeking care during the perinatal period is a simple step and minimal ask compared to the harms inflicted due to not addressing one’s bias. The California Black Health Network states that Black Women in California make up 5% of those pregnant but account for 21% of the total pregnancy-related deaths, and this disparity exists across all income levels. A provider’s level of bias, whether conscious or unconscious, can influence their interactions with patients, their diagnoses, and their treatment of the patient’s pain, and can undermine patients’ trust and engagement in care. Attorney General Rob Bonta states, in support that this bill (1) provides clarity on which facilities are mandated to administer anti-bias trainings and which employees need to be trained, (2) establishes firm deadlines by which trainings must be completed to better guide compliance, authorizes the DOJ to enforce the law and assess civil penalties for noncompliance, and (4) authorize the DOJ to post compliance data online so the public is made aware of which facilities have provided anti-bias trainings and which have not. The Attorney General states this bill is a substantial part of the systemic change needed to reduce the disparate impact on Black mothers and pregnant persons of color and to prevent these deaths from happening.
- Policy comments.
- Who should enforce the Act? The California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act is part of a body of law governing maternal, child, and adolescent health, which is administered by CDPH. CDPH also licenses and regulates the hospitals and alternative birth centers that are subject to the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. However, the Act is not included within the provisions of law governing the licensing and regulation of health facilities, and so the administrative penalties granted to CDPH to enforce licensing laws do not apply to the requirements of the Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. While earlier versions of this bill included enforcement provisions under CDPH, it was amended in Assembly Appropriations Committee to have the Act enforced by DOJ. While DOJ has authority to review sales, transfers, and purchases of nonprofit health facilities, having a department outside of CDPH enforce a requirement without involvement from CDPH is unusual. The Committee may wish to consider whether DOJ is the appropriate enforcement entity for violations by health facilities licensed by CDPH.
- Is the fine structure appropriate? Under the fine structure for hospitals that violate licensing laws, CDPH is permitted to assess administrative penalties of up to $25,000 per violation for those violations that do not constitute immediate jeopardy to a patient (immediate jeopardy violations are up to $75,000 for a first offense, and as much as $125,000 for multiple offenses). Violations deemed to be minor by CDPH are not subject to a fine. Under this bill, DOJ is required to assess a $10,000 fine for a first violation, and $25,000 for each subsequent violation. Additionally, it defines a single violation as one provider failing to obtain the required training by the deadline. Therefore, if a health facility had one doctor and one medical assistant subject to this bill fail to obtain the training by the required deadline, the hospital would be fined $35,000, with an additional $25,000 for any other provider at the hospital subject to the training requirements. Under the Corporate Practice of Medicine doctrine, hospitals, with various exceptions, are prohibited from directly employing physicians, and therefore have limited ability to compel a physician to obtain the required training. In addition to potentially large fines under this bill, hospitals could be subject to these fines for failure by a physician who was outside of the hospital’s control.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: Attorney General Rob Bonta (co-sponsor)
Black Women for Wellness Action Project (co-sponsor)
California Black Women’s Collective Empowerment Institute (co-sponsor)
California Nurse-Midwives Association (co-sponsor)
Reproductive Freedom for All California (co-sponsor)
Western Center on Law & Poverty, Inc. (co-sponsor)
Access Reproductive Justice
American Civil Liberties Union California Action
Asian Americans Advancing Justice-southern California
Black Women Organized for Political Action
California Black Health Network
California Commission on the Status of Women and Girls
California Family Resource Association
California Federation of Teachers
California Pan-Ethnic Health Network
California State Association of Psychiatrists
California Women's Law Center
Catalyst California
Child Abuse Prevention Center
City and County of San Francisco, Board of Supervisors
Children Now
Community Health Councils
Courage California
Disability Rights California
Diversity Uplifts, Inc.
Equality California
Essential Access Health
First 5 Alameda County
First 5 California
First 5 Los Angeles
Health Access California
Health Net
Hispanas Organized for Political Equality
National Council of Jewish Women Los Angeles
National Council of Negro Women
National Health Law Program
Perinatal Health Equity Initiative
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
The Children's Partnership
Women's Foundation California
Women's Health Specialists
One individual
Oppose: None received.
-- END --
SENATE COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Senator Richard Roth, Chair
BILL NO: AB 2319
AUTHOR: | Wilson and Weber | ||
VERSION: | May 20, 2024 | ||
HEARING DATE: | June 19, 2024 | ||
CONSULTANT: | Vincent D. Marchand | ||
SUBJECT: California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act
SUMMARY:
Revises the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, which requires hospitals and alternative birth centers to implement an implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients, including by specifying what providers are subject to training requirements, and adding deadlines for compliance with the training requirements. Establishes an enforcement mechanism through the Attorney General by requiring health facilities to submit proof of compliance for their providers, and subjecting health facilities to civil penalties of $10,000 for a first violation, and $25,000 for subsequent violations.
Existing law:
- Establishes the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) and sets forth its powers and duties, including, but not limited to, licensing and regulating health facilities, including hospitals as well as clinics providing alternative birth center services. [HSC §1204, et seq., and §1250]
- Defines an “alternative birth center” as a clinic that is not part of a hospital and that provides comprehensive perinatal services and delivery care to pregnant women who remain less than 24 hours at the facility. Requires alternative birth centers to meet certain requirements of licensure. [HSC §1204.3]
- Enacts the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, which requires a general acute care hospital, and a special hospital that provides perinatal care and an alternative birth center or primary care clinic that provides alternative birth center services, to implement an implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities. [HSC §123630.3]
- Requires the implicit bias program to include all of the following:
- Identification of previous or current unconscious biases and misinformation;
- Identification of personal, interpersonal, institutional, structural, and cultural barriers to inclusion;
- Corrective measures to decrease implicit bias at the interpersonal and institutional levels, including ongoing policies and practices for that purpose;
- Information on the effects, including, but not limited to, ongoing personal effects, of historical and contemporary exclusion and oppression of minority communities;
- Information about cultural identity across racial or ethnic groups;
- Information about communicating more effectively across identities, including racial, ethnic, religious, and gender identities;
- Discussion on power dynamics and organizational decision making;
- Discussion on health inequities within the perinatal care field, including information on how implicit bias impacts maternal and infant health outcomes;
- Perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, cultural, and provider-community relations issues in the community; and,
- Information on reproductive justice. [HSC 123630.3(b)]
- Requires a healthcare provider involved in the perinatal care of patients within a hospital or alternative birth center to complete initial basic training through the implicit bias program, and upon completion of the initial basic training, to complete a refresher course every two years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends and best practices in decreasing interpersonal and institutional implicit bias. [HSC 123630.3(c)]
This bill:
- Adds more specificity to the types of health care providers who are required to receive implicit bias training from hospitals and alternative birth centers, currently described as “all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities,” to specify that it applies to both of the following:
- All persons licensed under the healing arts, as specified, who are regularly assigned to provide perinatal care, including but not limited to, those in primary care clinics, alternative birthing centers, outpatient clinics, or emergency departments; and,
- All persons who are regularly assigned to positions where they interact with perinatal patients, including, but not limited to, physician assistants, medical assistants, licensed vocational nurses, doctors, or those who facilitate, control, or coordinate access to timely and appropriate medical treatment, as well as any others who provide medical and ancillary treatment.
- Adds to the list of subjects that are required to be included in an implicit bias training program for perinatal care providers the recognition of intersecting identities, including, but not limited to, nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience, and the multiple layers of potential biases that could come into play, result in harm to patients and their infants.
- Adds a deadline of June 1, 2025, by which all current providers are required to complete the initial basic training through the implicit bias program, and requires the initial basic training to be provided to new health care providers at all facilities within six months of their start at the new facility, unless the provider has a certificate of completion from another facility.
- Requires, by February 1 of each year commencing in 2026, a facility required to have a perinatal implicit bias program to provide the Attorney General with proof of compliance. Requires proof of compliance to include all of the following:
- A list of all of the health care providers, as described in this bill, who have completed the initial basic training requirement;
- The dates that each health care provider completed their training;
- The written materials used in the training;
- A description of the training, including format and duration; and,
- A list of the health care providers who did not participate in the training, if any.
- Requires a facility that violates the provisions of the perinatal implicit bias program to be liable for a civil penalty of $10,000 for the first violation and $25,000 for the second and each subsequent violation, which is required to be assessed and recovered in a civil action brought by the Attorney General in any court of competent jurisdiction. Specifies that for purposes of this civil penalty, each health care provider that does not timely complete the required training before the relevant deadline constitutes a separate violation for purposes of determining the first, second, or subsequent violations. Specifies that the penalties provided in this bill are not exclusive and do not limit other remedies available in law for such violations.
- Permits the Attorney General to post on their website a list of all facilities that did not timely submit proof of compliance, or that were assessed penalties. Permits the Attorney General to include all of the following information when listing the facilities that were assessed penalties: the date the penalty was issued, the amount, the reason the penalty was issued, the percentage of untrained providers, and the date of facility noncompliance. Prohibits this provision from being construed to limit the Attorney General from disclosing any information that they are otherwise not restricted from disclosing by any other provision of law.
- Permits the Attorney General to publish a report outlining compliance data related to the perinatal implicit bias program requirements on a biennial basis.
- Includes a severability clause, in the event any provision of the implicit bias program is held invalid, the remainder shall not be affected to the extent it can be given effect.
FISCAL EFFECT:
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, the Department of Justice (DOJ) estimates costs of about $150,000 per year to collect proof of compliance and post on its website a list of facilities that are not in compliance with the provisions of this bill (General Fund).
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor: | 56 - 5 |
Assembly Appropriations Committee: | 11 - 4 |
Assembly Health Committee: | 12 - 2 |
COMMENTS:
- Author’s statement. According to the author, the U.S. has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. In California, people of color, particularly Black women, continue to die at three to four times the rate of White women. A recent study by CDPH found that women of color, in particular Black women, die of pregnancy-related complications at much higher rates than White Women in California. Evidence suggests one key cause of this disparity is the implicit bias of healthcare providers. A provider’s level of bias, whether conscious or unconscious, can influence their interactions with patients and their diagnoses and treatment of the patient’s pain, and can undermine patients’ trust and engagement in care. This risk is particularly acute where provider-patient concordance may be affected by racial, ethnic, cultural, and gender differences. To address this, the legislature passed the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act (Act) in 2019, which requires hospitals, alternative birth centers and primary care clinics to conduct evidence-based implicit bias training for all health professionals who provide care during a patient’s pregnancy, childbirth, and immediate postpartum period. The California Attorney General recently issued a report following an investigation into facility compliance with that Act. The report and its findings highlight the need for additional action to continue the work started by the Act. Specifically, additional steps are necessary to ensure hospitals and facilities comply and are equipped to meet those requirements.
- DOJ Report on Healthcare Facilities and the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. In October 2023, DOJ published a report showing the results of their investigation into the extent of compliance with the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, which took effect January 1, 2020. According to this report, DOJ used informal letter requests and an electronic survey to collect compliance data from 242 California facilities for the period between January 1, 2020, the effective date of the statute, and July 8, 2022. Of the 258 facilities to which DOJ issued a letter or a survey, 242 (93.79%) responded with data. On average, 81.44% of the relevant staff in those facilities had completed the required training by July 8, 2022. According to DOJ, while this number may appear high, a substantial number of facilities had not completed or even begun training staff until after receiving DOJ’s August 23, 2021 letter, despite the January 1, 2020 effective date of the training requirement. Regarding training approaches, the DOJ report found that the vast majority of hospitals (166 out of those reporting) used an asynchronous training such as a one- to two-hour training provided via video, developed by Diversity Science called “Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth,” which was developed with the goal of satisfying the requirement of the law.
According to DOJ, based on its findings, policymakers should consider options to link training requirements to outcome monitoring by an appropriate state agency. DOJ stated that this could including:- Setting hospital improvement metrics or goals and linking them to training, which could be reported to regulators along with training completion metrics;
- Creating a registry that reports metrics or issues grades for similarly situated hospitals, for cases of similar complexity;
- Setting consequences, such as corrective action plan implementation, for falling below certain metrics;
- Instigating implicit bias training requirements with hospital accreditation and provider licensing examination and renewal requirements.
- Center Black Mothers in California report. In collaboration with the UCSF Center for Health Equity, Black Women for Wellness, and a statewide group of Black women leaders and academics, CDPH published a report in 2023 to inform efforts to promote racial equity and bolster opportunities to be healthy among Black women, other Black birthing people, and their families. This report, Center Black Mothers in California, found that factors at the societal, neighborhood, family, and individual levels have worked in concert over many generations to affect many Black birthing people’s abilities to achieve optimal health across their life course and to have healthy pregnancies, births, and babies. While rates of pregnancy-related mortality have declined, they remain much higher than those of other groups, at 47.3 pregnancy-related deaths for Black mothers per 100,000 live births, compared to 15.1 per 100,000 for Asian/Pacific Islander, 12.6 for Hispanic, and 11.1 for White. Further, while the mortality rate among Black infants has declined over the past decade, in 2018 Black infants were still twice as likely as other infants to die before their first birthdays. The report stated that several pathways connect structural racism to the results presented in this report, including unhealthy and/or under-resourced neighborhood conditions, chronic stress, and lack of respectful care. Because structural racism operates at multiple levels to influence the health of Black families, strategies to ameliorate poor health conditions among Black families cannot be handled within the health care and public health systems alone. However, implementing methods to monitor for and address racism and implicit bias among health care personnel and public health professionals was among the strategies the report suggested be considered.
- Disparities in maternal morbidity and mortality. According to the California Birth Equity Collaborative (CBEC), an initiative at Stanford University’s California Maternal Quality of Care Collaborative (CMQCC), maternal mortality rates nearly doubled in California between 1999 and 2006. Since CMQCC was founded in 2006, California’s maternal mortality rate has declined by 55% while the national maternal mortality rate has continued to rise. The expectation was that widespread adoption of CMQCC’s clinical safety bundles would reduce the gap in the number of maternal deaths among Black women. However, the difference in outcomes for Black mothers has persisted. Further analysis revealed that clinical safety bundles and social support interventions done in isolation, without an integrated approach, did not produce the desired outcomes. Data shows that even in the absence of risk factors such as age over 35 years, lack of health insurance, inadequate or no prenatal care, and less than a high school education, the U.S. system of health care is not protecting Black mothers. According to CBEC, increasing evidence points to racism within and across multiple levels, and not race, as a key cause of these birth disparities. Data also shows variations in the quality of care and outcomes across hospitals in California highlighting opportunities for advancing equity in quality improvement. A 2017 study published in Seminars in Perinatology, Improving hospital quality to reduce disparities in severe maternal morbidity and mortality, found that growing research suggests that hospital quality may be a critical lever for improving outcomes and narrowing disparities. This study stated that with Black women three to four times more likely to die from pregnancy-related causes than white women, this represents the largest disparity among all the conventional population perinatal health measures. Among other things, the study suggested that team training is an important step to providing coordinated care, and that implementation of a disparities dashboard, which stratifies quality metrics by race and ethnicity, is a useful tool, which allows hospitals to become aware of disparities.
- Black Infant Health (BIH) Program. BIH is one of the programs within CDPH’s Division of Maternal, Child, and Adolescent Health. The goal of BIH is to improve African-American infant and maternal health, as well as decrease Black-White health inequities and social inequities for women and infants. BIH serves African-American women who are 18 years of age or older and up to 30 weeks pregnant at the time of enrollment. According to CDPH’s BIH website, “within a culturally affirming environment and honoring the unique history of African-American women, BIH aims to help women have healthy babies. Participants learn proven strategies to reduce stress and develop life skills. This is accomplished through a group-based approach with complementary case management.” BIH services are provided by family health advocates, group facilitators, public health nurses, and social workers. BIH participants report stronger positive connections to their heritage and the African-American community, increased empowerment to make behavior changes that lead to living a healthier life, and better understanding of effective stress-reduction strategies.
- California Perinatal Equity Initiative. AB 1810 (Committee on Budget, Chapter 34, Statutes of 2018) established the California Perinatal Equity Initiative (PEI) at CDPH, and appropriated $8 million from the General Fund, to expand the scope of interventions provided under BIH. The PEI is intended to foster Community Centers of Excellence in perinatal health and promote the use of interventions designed to fill gaps in current programming offered through BIH. Under the PEI, CDPH is required to allocate funds to up to 15 county health departments, to work collaboratively with state and local BIH programs, for the purposes of improving back infant birth outcomes and reducing infant mortality. County health departments are required to use the funds to develop local Community Centers of Excellence at hospitals, federal qualified health centers, clinics, or community-based organizations that have demonstrated capacity to work with public health and health care systems as well as within the Black community. Recipients of local grants are required to implement or expand two of five types of programs: evidence-based group prenatal care that has shown promise in reducing the incidence of adverse birth outcomes; pregnancy intentionality and preconception programs; fatherhood or partnership initiatives; evidence-based home visiting programs inclusive of case management to increase advocacy and empowerment for Black women and to ensure linkages to prenatal care; or, a different strategy that is justified based on local needs and resources, if a county determines that the strategy is evidence-based in relation to reducing adverse birth outcomes.
- Prior legislation. SB 464 (Mitchell, Chapter 533, Statutes of 2019) enacted the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act, which requires hospitals and alternative birth centers to implement an implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities, including requiring these healthcare providers to complete initial basic training through the implicit bias program and a refresher course every two years thereafter. SB 464 requires CDPH to track and publish data on maternal death and severe morbidity; and adds, to the list of written information a hospital is required to provide to each patient upon admission, information on how to file a discrimination complaint with CDPH or the Medical Board of California if the patient feels they were discriminated against.
AB 241 (Kamlager-Dove, Chapter 417, Statutes of 2019) requires continuing education courses for physicians, nurses, and physician assistant to containing curriculum on understanding implicit bias. - Double referral. This bill is double referred. Should it pass out of this Committee, it will be referred to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
- Support. This bill is co-sponsored by Attorney General Rob Bonta, Black Women for Wellness Action Project, the California Black Women’s Collective Empowerment Institute, California Nurse-Midwives Association, Reproductive Freedom for All California, and Western Center on Law & Poverty. According to Black Women for Wellness Action Project, this bill aims to reduce the alarming and disproportionate maternal morbidity and mortality rate of Black women and other birthing people of color by ensuring the successful implementation of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. With mounting research that establishes the role of implicit bias in maternal health outcomes, a rigorous training grounded in reproductive justice values that stands to improve the quality of care that our mamas receive when seeking care during the perinatal period is a simple step and minimal ask compared to the harms inflicted due to not addressing one’s bias. The California Black Health Network states that Black Women in California make up 5% of those pregnant but account for 21% of the total pregnancy-related deaths, and this disparity exists across all income levels. A provider’s level of bias, whether conscious or unconscious, can influence their interactions with patients, their diagnoses, and their treatment of the patient’s pain, and can undermine patients’ trust and engagement in care. Attorney General Rob Bonta states, in support that this bill (1) provides clarity on which facilities are mandated to administer anti-bias trainings and which employees need to be trained, (2) establishes firm deadlines by which trainings must be completed to better guide compliance, authorizes the DOJ to enforce the law and assess civil penalties for noncompliance, and (4) authorize the DOJ to post compliance data online so the public is made aware of which facilities have provided anti-bias trainings and which have not. The Attorney General states this bill is a substantial part of the systemic change needed to reduce the disparate impact on Black mothers and pregnant persons of color and to prevent these deaths from happening.
- Policy comments.
- Who should enforce the Act? The California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act is part of a body of law governing maternal, child, and adolescent health, which is administered by CDPH. CDPH also licenses and regulates the hospitals and alternative birth centers that are subject to the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. However, the Act is not included within the provisions of law governing the licensing and regulation of health facilities, and so the administrative penalties granted to CDPH to enforce licensing laws do not apply to the requirements of the Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. While earlier versions of this bill included enforcement provisions under CDPH, it was amended in Assembly Appropriations Committee to have the Act enforced by DOJ. While DOJ has authority to review sales, transfers, and purchases of nonprofit health facilities, having a department outside of CDPH enforce a requirement without involvement from CDPH is unusual. The Committee may wish to consider whether DOJ is the appropriate enforcement entity for violations by health facilities licensed by CDPH.
- Is the fine structure appropriate? Under the fine structure for hospitals that violate licensing laws, CDPH is permitted to assess administrative penalties of up to $25,000 per violation for those violations that do not constitute immediate jeopardy to a patient (immediate jeopardy violations are up to $75,000 for a first offense, and as much as $125,000 for multiple offenses). Violations deemed to be minor by CDPH are not subject to a fine. Under this bill, DOJ is required to assess a $10,000 fine for a first violation, and $25,000 for each subsequent violation. Additionally, it defines a single violation as one provider failing to obtain the required training by the deadline. Therefore, if a health facility had one doctor and one medical assistant subject to this bill fail to obtain the training by the required deadline, the hospital would be fined $35,000, with an additional $25,000 for any other provider at the hospital subject to the training requirements. Under the Corporate Practice of Medicine doctrine, hospitals, with various exceptions, are prohibited from directly employing physicians, and therefore have limited ability to compel a physician to obtain the required training. In addition to potentially large fines under this bill, hospitals could be subject to these fines for failure by a physician who was outside of the hospital’s control.
SUPPORT AND OPPOSITION:
Support: Attorney General Rob Bonta (co-sponsor)
Black Women for Wellness Action Project (co-sponsor)
California Black Women’s Collective Empowerment Institute (co-sponsor)
California Nurse-Midwives Association (co-sponsor)
Reproductive Freedom for All California (co-sponsor)
Western Center on Law & Poverty, Inc. (co-sponsor)
Access Reproductive Justice
Asian Americans Advancing Justice-southern California
Black Women Organized for Political Action
California Black Health Network
California Commission on the Status of Women and Girls
California Family Resource Association
California Federation of Teachers
California Pan-Ethnic Health Network
California State Association of Psychiatrists
California Women's Law Center
Child Abuse Prevention Center
City and County of San Francisco, Board of Supervisors
Children Now
Community Health Councils
Courage California
Disability Rights California
Diversity Uplifts, Inc.
Equality California
Essential Access Health
First 5 Alameda County
First 5 California
First 5 Los Angeles
Health Access California
Health Net
Hispanas Organized for Political Equality
National Council of Jewish Women Los Angeles
National Council of Negro Women
National Health Law Program
Perinatal Health Equity Initiative
Planned Parenthood Affiliates of California
The Children's Partnership
Women's Foundation California
Women's Health Specialists
One individual
Oppose: None received
-- END --
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2319
Author:(Wilson and Weber)
As Amended Ver:May 20, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Expands the types of health care providers and health facility employees who must participate in implicit bias training pursuant to the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act (the Act.) Requires initial basic training on implicit bias to be completed by June 1, 2025 for current health care providers and health facility employees, and within six months of their start date for new health care providers and health facility employees. Requires facilities subject to the provisions of the Act, commencing in 2026, to provide the Attorney General (AG) with proof of compliance by February 1 of each year.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS
Implicit bias. According to the University of San Francisco's Office of Outreach and Diversity, bias is a prejudice in favor of or against one thing, person, or group compared with another usually in a way that is considered to be unfair. Biases may be held by an individual, group, or institution and can have negative or positive consequences. There are types of biases: conscious bias (also known as explicit bias) and unconscious bias (also known as implicit bias). Biases, conscious or unconscious, are not limited to ethnicity and race. Though racial bias and discrimination are well documented, biases may exist toward any social group. Age, gender, gender identity, physical abilities, religion, sexual orientation, weight, and many other characteristics are subject to bias. Unconscious, or implicit, biases are social stereotypes about certain groups of people that individuals form outside their own conscious awareness. Unconscious bias is far more prevalent than conscious prejudice and often incompatible with one's conscious values. It is well-documented that implicit bias among health care professionals is prevalent and impacts patient care.
A July 2022 article, "Tackling Implicit Bias in Health Care," published in the New England Journal of Medicine, notes that our individual biases operate within larger social, cultural, and economic structures whose biased policies and practices perpetuate systemic racism, sexism, and other forms of discrimination. The article notes that in medicine, bias-driven discriminatory practices and policies not only negatively affect patient care and the medical training environment, but also limit the diversity of the health care workforce, lead to inequitable distribution of research funding, and can hinder career advancement. The article discusses a review of studies involving physicians, nurses, and other medical professionals which found that health care providers' implicit racial bias is associated with diagnostic uncertainty and, for Black patients, negative ratings of their clinical interactions, less patient-centeredness, poor provider communication, under-treatment of pain, and views of Black patients as less medically adherent than white patients.
Maternal and infant health outcomes in California. In California, the rate of maternal death since 2006 has decreased by 55% even though the rate in the United States as a whole has steadily increased. However, according to data in DPH's 2018 California Pregnancy-Associated Mortality Review, for women of color, and in particular Black women, the rate remains three to four times higher than that for white women in California. The racial disparity is even starker when looking at particular conditions. Black women account for 5% of those pregnant in California but account for 21% of the total pregnancy-related deaths. Further, the disparity in maternal health between Black and non-Hispanic white birthing mothers exists independent of the socio-economic status of the birthing mother. A recent study that looked at the records of millions of births in California illustrates that across all parental income levels, Black mothers, as well as their infants, have much worse health outcomes than their non-Hispanic white counterparts do.
AG report on the Act. To ascertain compliance with the Act's training requirements, the Department of Justice (DOJ) sent a letter on August 23, 2021, to facilities subject to the requirements of the Act. Through this letter, DOJ requested that each facility provide:
- Dates of any implicit bias training providers have completed;
- Dates of implicit bias trainings planned for the future;
- Lists of attendees at each training;
- Copies of all written training materials used;
- A list of the perinatal healthcare workers at each facility who have yet to participate in any training; and,
- A description of each facility's efforts to reduce implicit bias among its perinatal healthcare providers.
DOJ further requested that facilities provide responsive documents and information by September 20, 2021. One hundred and fifty facilities requested, and were granted, an extension and did not produce any responsive documents or information until early January 2022. DOJ continued to receive information from a small minority of letter recipients through April 2022. DOJ's investigation found that 42 hospitals had not fully trained a single employee prior to being contacted by DOJ on August 23, 2021. Responding hospitals on average completed trainings for 81.36% of their relevant providers, though this figure includes both facilities that completed trainings for all of the appropriate providers and facilities that failed to complete any trainings. Average completion rates were 79.41% at private hospitals, 81.08% at non-profit hospitals, 86.26% at government hospitals, and 84.81% at University of California hospitals. All staff had completed their training at 41 hospitals, and no staff had completed their training at two hospitals. Nearly a third of facilities to which DOJ reached out, began training only after DOJ contacted them, suggesting that DOJ's outreach caused compliance in many cases.
According to the Author
The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. In California Black women continue to die at three to four times the rate of white women. A 2023 study by DPH, "Centering Black Mothers in California: Insights into Racism, Health, and Well-being for Black Women and Infants," found that women of color, in particular Black women, die of pregnancy-related complications at much higher rates than white women in California. Evidence suggests one key cause of this disparity is the implicit bias of healthcare providers. A provider's level of bias, whether conscious or unconscious, can influence their interactions with patients and their diagnoses and treatment of the patient's pain, and can undermine patients' trust and engagement in care. The author notes that, to address this, the legislature passed the Act in 2019, which requires hospitals, alternative birth centers and primary care clinics to conduct evidence-based implicit bias training for all health professionals who provide care during a patient's pregnancy, childbirth, and immediate postpartum period. The California AG recently issued a report following an investigation into facility compliance with the Act. The report and its findings highlight the need for additional action to continue the work started by the Act.
Arguments in Support
AG Rob Bonta is the sponsor of this bill and states that this bill aims to reduce the alarming and disproportionate maternal mortality rate of Black women and other pregnant persons of color by ensuring successful implementation of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. Under the Act, health facilities are required to train perinatal care providers in recognizing and overcoming their own implicit or unconscious racial biases and prejudices that could negatively impact the quality of care — and even endanger the lives of — pregnant patients of color. The Act went in to effect on January 1, 2020, and in August 2021, the DOJ initiated an investigation to determine compliance with the law. At that time, fewer than 17% of responding providers had begun training their employees and not a single employee had been fully trained. By the time DOJ's investigation and outreach efforts concluded 10 months later, the training completion rate had improved to more than 81%.
Arguments in Opposition
There is no known opposition to this bill.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, DOJ estimates costs of about $150,000 per year to collect proof of compliance and post on its website a list of facilities that are not in compliance with the provisions of this bill (General Fund).
VOTES
ASM HEALTH: 12-2-2
YES: Bonta, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Wendy Carrillo, Haney, Jones-Sawyer, Maienschein, Rodriguez, Santiago, Schiavo, Weber
NO: Joe Patterson, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Flora, McCarty
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-4-0
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Villapudua
NO: Sanchez, Dixon, Jim Patterson, Ta
UPDATED
VERSION: May 20, 2024
CONSULTANT: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0003456
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 2319
Author:(Wilson and Weber)
As Amended Ver:May 16, 2024
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Expands the types of health care providers who must participate in implicit bias training pursuant to the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act (the Act.) Requires initial basic training on implicit bias to be completed by June 1, 2025 for current health care providers, and within six months of their start date for new health care providers. Requires facilities subject to the provisions of the Act, commencing in 2026, to provide the Attorney General (AG) with proof of compliance by February 1 of each year.
Major Provisions
COMMENTS
Implicit bias. According to the University of San Francisco's Office of Outreach and Diversity, bias is a prejudice in favor of or against one thing, person, or group compared with another usually in a way that is considered to be unfair. Biases may be held by an individual, group, or institution and can have negative or positive consequences. There are types of biases: conscious bias (also known as explicit bias) and unconscious bias (also known as implicit bias). Biases, conscious or unconscious, are not limited to ethnicity and race. Though racial bias and discrimination are well documented, biases may exist toward any social group. Age, gender, gender identity, physical abilities, religion, sexual orientation, weight, and many other characteristics are subject to bias. Unconscious, or implicit, biases are social stereotypes about certain groups of people that individuals form outside their own conscious awareness. Unconscious bias is far more prevalent than conscious prejudice and often incompatible with one's conscious values. It is well-documented that implicit bias among health care professionals is prevalent and impacts patient care.
A July 2022 article, "Tackling Implicit Bias in Health Care," published in the New England Journal of Medicine, notes that our individual biases operate within larger social, cultural, and economic structures whose biased policies and practices perpetuate systemic racism, sexism, and other forms of discrimination. The article notes that in medicine, bias-driven discriminatory practices and policies not only negatively affect patient care and the medical training environment, but also limit the diversity of the health care workforce, lead to inequitable distribution of research funding, and can hinder career advancement. The article discusses a review of studies involving physicians, nurses, and other medical professionals which found that health care providers' implicit racial bias is associated with diagnostic uncertainty and, for Black patients, negative ratings of their clinical interactions, less patient-centeredness, poor provider communication, under-treatment of pain, and views of Black patients as less medically adherent than white patients.
Maternal and infant health outcomes in California. In California, the rate of maternal death since 2006 has decreased by 55% even though the rate in the United States as a whole has steadily increased. However, according to data in Department of Public Health (DPH's) 2018 California Pregnancy-Associated Mortality Review, for women of color, and in particular Black women, the rate remains three to four times higher than that for white women in California. The racial disparity is even starker when looking at particular conditions. Black women account for 5% of those pregnant in California but account for 21% of the total pregnancy-related deaths. Further, the disparity in maternal health between Black and non-Hispanic white birthing mothers exists independent of the socio-economic status of the birthing mother. A recent study that looked at the records of millions of births in California illustrates that across all parental income levels, Black mothers, as well as their infants, have much worse health outcomes than their non-Hispanic white counterparts do.
AG report on the Act. To ascertain compliance with the Act's training requirements, the Department of Justice (DOJ) sent a letter on August 23, 2021, to facilities subject to the requirements of the Act. Through this letter, DOJ requested that each facility provide:
- Dates of any implicit bias training providers have completed;
- Dates of implicit bias trainings planned for the future;
- Lists of attendees at each training;
- Copies of all written training materials used;
- A list of the perinatal healthcare workers at each facility who have yet to participate in any training; and,
- A description of each facility's efforts to reduce implicit bias among its perinatal healthcare providers.
DOJ further requested that facilities provide responsive documents and information by September 20, 2021. One hundred and fifty facilities requested, and were granted, an extension and did not produce any responsive documents or information until early January 2022. DOJ continued to receive information from a small minority of letter recipients through April 2022. DOJ's investigation found that 42 hospitals had not fully trained a single employee prior to being contacted by DOJ on August 23, 2021. Responding hospitals on average completed trainings for 81.36% of their relevant providers, though this figure includes both facilities that completed trainings for all of the appropriate providers and facilities that failed to complete any trainings. Average completion rates were 79.41% at private hospitals, 81.08% at non-profit hospitals, 86.26% at government hospitals, and 84.81% at University of California hospitals. All staff had completed their training at 41 hospitals, and no staff had completed their training at two hospitals. Nearly a third of facilities to which DOJ reached out, began training only after DOJ contacted them, suggesting that DOJ's outreach caused compliance in many cases.
According to the Author
The United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. In California Black women continue to die at three to four times the rate of white women. A 2023 study by DPH, "Centering Black Mothers in California: Insights into Racism, Health, and Well-being for Black Women and Infants," found that women of color, in particular Black women, die of pregnancy-related complications at much higher rates than white women in California. Evidence suggests one key cause of this disparity is the implicit bias of healthcare providers. A provider's level of bias, whether conscious or unconscious, can influence their interactions with patients and their diagnoses and treatment of the patient's pain, and can undermine patients' trust and engagement in care. The author notes that, to address this, the legislature passed the Act in 2019, which requires hospitals, alternative birth centers and primary care clinics to conduct evidence-based implicit bias training for all health professionals who provide care during a patient's pregnancy, childbirth, and immediate postpartum period. The California AG recently issued a report following an investigation into facility compliance with the Act. The report and its findings highlight the need for additional action to continue the work started by the Act.
Arguments in Support
AG Rob Bonta is the sponsor of this bill and states that this bill aims to reduce the alarming and disproportionate maternal mortality rate of Black women and other pregnant persons of color by ensuring successful implementation of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. Under the Act, health facilities are required to train perinatal care providers in recognizing and overcoming their own implicit or unconscious racial biases and prejudices that could negatively impact the quality of care — and even endanger the lives of — pregnant patients of color. The Act went in to effect on January 1, 2020, and in August 2021, the DOJ initiated an investigation to determine compliance with the law. At that time, fewer than 17% of responding providers had begun training their employees and not a single employee had been fully trained. By the time DOJ's investigation and outreach efforts concluded 10 months later, the training completion rate had improved to more than 81%.
Arguments in Opposition
There is no known opposition to this bill.
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Appropriations Committee, DOJ estimates costs of about $150,000 per year to collect proof of compliance and post on its website a list of facilities that are not in compliance with the provisions of this bill (General Fund).
VOTES
ASM HEALTH: 12-2-2
YES: Bonta, Waldron, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Wendy Carrillo, Haney, Jones-Sawyer, Maienschein, Rodriguez, Santiago, Schiavo, Weber
NO: Joe Patterson, Sanchez
ABS, ABST OR NV: Flora, McCarty
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 11-4-0
YES: Wicks, Arambula, Bryan, Calderon, Wendy Carrillo, Mike Fong, Grayson, Haney, Hart, Pellerin, Villapudua
NO: Sanchez, Dixon, Jim Patterson, Ta
UPDATED
VERSION: May 16, 2024
CONSULTANT: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097 FN: 0003337
Date of Hearing: May 1, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2319
Author:(Wilson) – As Amended Ver:March 21, 2024
Policy Committee: | Health | Vote: | 12 - 2 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill expands the types of health care providers required to take implicit bias training pursuant to the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act (Act) and requires health facilities subject to the provisions of the Act to comply with training requirements by June 1, 2025, and to annually provide the California Department of Public Health (CDPH) proof of compliance. The bill authorizes CDPH to implement and enforce the Act and requires CDPH to adopt regulations, issue guidelines, and publish a report on facility compliance every two years, among other activities.
FISCAL EFFECT:
CDPH anticipates costs of approximately $5.4 million in fiscal year (FY) 2025-26, $6.1 million in FY 2026-27, $5.9 million in FY 27-28, and $5.1 million in FY 28-29 and ongoing to implement the provisions of this bill (General Fund and Licensing and Certification Fund). CDPH activities will include establishing a new program to certify model trainings and review facilities’ training programs and documentation of employees’ training upon deaths or complaints and during periodic relicensure inspections, assess administrative penalties, update CDPH’s electronic licensing database, and promulgate regulations for staff development program documentation.
According to the Legislative Analyst’s Office, the General Fund faces a structural deficit in the tens of billions of dollars over the next several fiscal years.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. This bill is sponsored by Attorney General (AG) Rob Bonta. According to the author:
A recent study by the California Department of Public Health found that women of color, in particular Black women, die of pregnancy-related complications at much higher rates than White Women in California. Evidence suggests one key cause of this disparity is the implicit bias of healthcare providers. A provider’s level of bias, whether conscious or unconscious, can influence their interactions with patients and their diagnoses and treatment of the patient’s pain, and can undermine patients’ trust and engagement in care. To address this, the Legislature passed the [Act] in 2019, which requires certain health care providers to participate in implicit bias training for all health professionals who provide care during a patient’s pregnancy, childbirth, and immediate postpartum period. The California Attorney General recently issued a report following an investigation into facility compliance with that Act. The report and its findings highlight the need for additional action to…ensure hospitals and facilities comply and are equipped to meet those requirements …This is a small, necessary step towards making California a safer place for black and brown mothers.
- Background.
The Act. The Act (SB 464 (Mitchell), Chapter 533, Statutes of 2019,) requires an alternative birth center, a hospital that provides perinatal care, or a primary care clinic to implement an implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients. These healthcare providers are required to complete initial training through the implicit bias program and a refresher course every two years thereafter. The Act also requires CDPH to track and publish data on maternal death and severe morbidity, and requires the list of written information a hospital provides to each patient upon admission to include information on how to file a discrimination complaint if the patient feels they experienced discrimination.
AG Compliance Assessment. To ascertain compliance with the Act, the Department of Justice (DOJ) sent a letter on August 23, 2021, to facilities subject to the requirements of the Act, requesting each facility provide specific information about its implicit bias training efforts. One hundred and fifty facilities requested, and were granted, an extension and did not produce any responsive documents or information until early January 2022. Forty-two hospitals had not fully trained a single employee prior to being contacted by DOJ. Responding hospitals on average completed trainings for 81% of their relevant providers. All staff at 41 hospitals had completed their training, and no staff at two hospitals had completed their training. Nearly a third of facilities to which DOJ reached out began training only after DOJ contacted them. - Related Legislation. AB 3161 (Bonta) requires CDPH to collect self-reported patient demographics when receiving complaints regarding hospitals and long-term care facilities, and to review, analyze, and publish trends in patient safety events in a manner consistent with patient privacy. AB 3161 also requires hospital patient safety plans to address racism and discrimination in health care and CDPH to publish hospital patient safety plans. AB 3161 also establishes a multi-agency partnership to share data on racial bias in health care specific to patient adverse events. AB 3161 is pending in Assembly Health Committee.
Analysis Prepared by: Allegra Kim / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: April 2, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Mia Bonta, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2319
Author:((Wilson and Weber) – As Amended Ver:March 21, 2024
SUBJECT: California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act.
SUMMARY: Requires all persons who are regularly assigned to positions where they interact with perinatal patients to receive implicit bias training. Requires initial basic training on implicit bias to be completed by June 1, 2025, and requires facilities subject to the provisions of the Act to document each employees implicit bias training. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires hospitals that provide perinatal care, alternative birth centers, and primary care clinics to implement evidence-based implicit bias programs for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities.
- Defines health care providers for the purposes of this bill to include:
- Licensed health care providers, including, but not limited to, physicians and surgeons, physicians’ assistants, registered nurses, respiratory therapists, and licensed vocational nurses, who are regularly assigned to provide perinatal care, including, but not limited to, those in primary care clinics, alternative birthing centers, outpatient clinics, or emergency departments; and,
- All persons who are regularly assigned to positions where they interact with perinatal patients, including, but not limited to, physician assistants, medical assistants, licensed vocational nurses, or doctors.
- Licensed health care providers, including, but not limited to, physicians and surgeons, physicians’ assistants, registered nurses, respiratory therapists, and licensed vocational nurses, who are regularly assigned to provide perinatal care, including, but not limited to, those in primary care clinics, alternative birthing centers, outpatient clinics, or emergency departments; and,
- Requires health care providers described in 2) above to complete initial basic training through the implicit bias training by June 1, 2025, for all current health care providers, and for the initial basic training to be provided to new health care providers at all facilities within six months of their start at the new facility.
- Requires a facility described in 1) above to document each employee’s implicit bias training in accordance with regulations adopted by the Department of Public Health (DPH) for documenting staff development programs. Requires DPH to assess each hospital’s compliance with this provision during periodic inspections conducted pursuant to 2) in existing law, below.
- Authorizes DPH, if DPH determines that a facility has violated these provisions, to assess an administrative penalty consistent with 11) in existing law, below.
- Specifies that DPH’s ability to issue a penalty is not the exclusive means of enforcing the Act, and that civil remedies available to the Attorney General (AG) under any other statute remain available to enforce the provisions of this Act. Grants DPH full administrative power, authority, and jurisdiction to implement and enforce the Act.
- Requires DPH to annually post on its internet website by April of each year a list of all facilities that have been issued administrative penalties for violations of the Act. Requires, when listing facilities that have been issued administrative penalties, DPH to include all of the following:
- The date the penalty was issued;
- The amount of the penalty;
- The reason the penalty was issued;
- The percentage of untrained providers; and,
- The date of facility noncompliance.
- Authorizes, if a facility disputes a determination rendered by DPH pursuant to 5) above, the facility to request a hearing within 10 working days. Requires penalties to be paid when all appeals have been exhausted and DPH’s position has been upheld.
- Requires DPH, on or before ____, to solicit broad public participation and adopt regulations to further the purposes of the Act, including, but not limited to, the following areas:
- Guidance on training methodologies sufficient to address the findings and declarations in the Act;
- Guidance on each of the categories of training specified in the Act; and,
- Authorizing DPH to issue and revise or adopt existing trainings that it certifies as a model sufficient to comply with the requirements of the Act, current research, and best practices. Requires DPH to make any certified training available on its internet website.
- Requires DPH to review and ensure that the training continues to comply with the requirements of the Act, and to recertify training on an annual basis or to withdraw its certification.
- Authorizes DPH to adopt additional regulations, as necessary, to further the purposes of the Act.
- Requires DPH to conduct a review of a facility subject to the requirements of the Act:
- Upon the death of a birthing parent or child during or one month after birth, unless DPH had completed a review of the facility within one year prior to the death;
- Upon DPH’s receipt of at least three complaints of racial bias or quality of care against perinatal or prenatal care providers in a facility subject to the training requirements of the Act by a patient or patients identifying as any race but white, not Hispanic or Latino; or,
- At any other time that DPH deems appropriate.
- Requires a facility review to include a review of the facility’s compliance with the training requirements of the Act, and review the substance of the facility’s training program to assess compliance with the requirements of the Act, and any relevant regulation.
- Requires DPH to publish a report outlining compliance data on a biannual basis. Requires the report to be posted on DPH’s internet website.
- Defines “perinatal care” as the provision of care during pregnancy, labor, delivery, and postpartum and neonatal periods. Specifies that perinatal care includes, but is not limited to prenatal care.
- Makes the provisions of the Act severable.
- Finds and declares that it is the intent of the Legislature to reduce the effects of implicit bias in pregnancy, childbirth, and postnatal care so that all people are treated with dignity and respect by their health care providers, and that the Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes DPH, which among other functions, licenses and regulates health facilities, including general acute care hospitals and special hospitals (hospitals) and clinics, as specified. [Health and Safety Code (HSC) §1250 (a) and (f) and §1226]
- Requires DPH to periodically inspect hospitals no less that once every three years, and as often as necessary to ensure the quality of care being provided. [HSC §1279]
- Requires a hospital to report an adverse event (AE) to DPH no later than five days after the AE has been detected, or, if that event is an ongoing urgent or emergent threat to the welfare, health, or safety of patients, personnel, or visitors, not later than 24 hours after the AE has been detected. [HSC §1279.1]
- Requires in any case in which DPH receives a report from a facility, or a written or oral complaint involving a hospital, that indicates an ongoing threat of imminent danger of death or serious bodily harm, DPH to make an onsite inspection or investigation within 48 hours or two business days, whichever is greater, of the receipt of the report or complaint and to complete that investigation within 45 days. [HSC §1279.2]
- Requires a hospital, to develop, implement, and comply with a patient safety plan for the purpose of improving the health and safety of patients and reducing preventable patient safety events. Requires the patient safety plan to be developed by the hospital, in consultation with the hospital’s various health care professionals. [HSC §1279.6]
- Establishes the Act, which requires hospitals that provide perinatal care, and alternative birth centers or primary care clinics to implement an evidence-based implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities. [HSC §123630.3]
- Requires an implicit bias program to include all of the following:
- Identification of previous or current unconscious biases and misinformation;
- Identification of personal, interpersonal, institutional, structural, and cultural barriers to inclusion;
- Corrective measures to decrease implicit bias at the interpersonal and institutional levels, including ongoing policies and practices for that purpose;
- Information on the effects, including, but not limited to, ongoing personal effects, of historical and contemporary exclusion and oppression of minority communities;
- Information about cultural identity across racial or ethnic groups;
- Information about communicating more effectively across identities, including racial, ethnic, religious, and gender identities;
- Discussion on power dynamics and organizational decision-making;
- Discussion on health inequities within the perinatal care field, including information on how implicit bias impacts maternal and infant health outcomes;
- Perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, cultural, and provider-community relations issues in the community; and,
- Information on reproductive justice. [Ibid.]
- Requires health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within the facilities described in 2) above, to complete initial basic training through an implicit bias program, and upon completion of the initial basic training, a health care provider to complete a refresher course under the implicit bias program every two years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends and best practices in decreasing interpersonal and institutional implicit bias. [Ibid.]
- Requires facilities, described in 2) above, to provide a certificate of training completion to another facility or a training attendee upon request. Authorizes a facility to accept a certificate of completion from another facility to satisfy the training requirements from a health care provider who works in more than one facility. [Ibid.]
- Requires, if a physician involved in the perinatal care of patients is not directly employed by a facility, the facility to offer the training to the physician. [Ibid.]
- Authorizes DPH to assess an administrative penalty for a deficiency constituting an immediate jeopardy violation, as defined, up to a maximum of $75,000 for the first administrative penalty, up to $100,000 for the second administrative penalty, and up to $125,000 for the third and every subsequent administrative penalty. Permits DPH to assess an administrative penalty of up to $25,000 per violation for those not deemed to constitute immediate jeopardy. Prohibits DPH from assessing an administrative penalty for minor violations. [HSC §1280.3 (a) (b) and (c)]
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, the United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. In California Black women continue to die at three to four times the rate of white women. A 2023 study by DPH, “Centering Black Mothers in California: Insights into Racism, Health, and Well-being for Black Women and Infants,” found that women of color, in particular Black women, die of pregnancy-related complications at much higher rates than white women in California. Evidence suggests one key cause of this disparity is the implicit bias of healthcare providers. A provider’s level of bias, whether conscious or unconscious, can influence their interactions with patients and their diagnoses and treatment of the patient’s pain, and can undermine patients’ trust and engagement in care. The author notes that, to address this, the legislature passed the Act in 2019, which requires hospitals, alternative birth centers and primary care clinics to conduct evidence-based implicit bias training for all health professionals who provide care during a patient’s pregnancy, childbirth, and immediate postpartum period. The California AG recently issued a report following an investigation into facility compliance with the Act. The report and its findings highlight the need for additional action to continue the work started by the Act. Specifically, additional steps are necessary to ensure hospitals and facilities comply and are equipped to meet those requirements. It is time for these institutions to come into compliance with the law. The author concludes that this is a small, necessary step towards making California a safer place for Black and Brown mothers.
- BACKGROUND.
- Implicit bias. According to the University of San Francisco’s Office of Outreach and Diversity, bias is a prejudice in favor of or against one thing, person, or group compared with another usually in a way that is considered to be unfair. Biases may be held by an individual, group, or institution and can have negative or positive consequences. There are types of biases: conscious bias (also known as explicit bias) and unconscious bias (also known as implicit bias). Biases, conscious or unconscious, are not limited to ethnicity and race. Though racial bias and discrimination are well documented, biases may exist toward any social group. Age, gender, gender identity, physical abilities, religion, sexual orientation, weight, and many other characteristics are subject to bias. Unconscious, or implicit, biases are social stereotypes about certain groups of people that individuals form outside their own conscious awareness. Unconscious bias is far more prevalent than conscious prejudice and often incompatible with one’s conscious values. It is well-documented that implicit bias among health care professionals is prevalent and impacts patient care.
A July 2022 article, “Tackling Implicit Bias in Health Care,” published in the New England Journal of Medicine, notes that our individual biases operate within larger social, cultural, and economic structures whose biased policies and practices perpetuate systemic racism, sexism, and other forms of discrimination. The article notes that in medicine, bias-driven discriminatory practices and policies not only negatively affect patient care and the medical training environment, but also limit the diversity of the health care workforce, lead to inequitable distribution of research funding, and can hinder career advancement. The article discusses a review of studies involving physicians, nurses, and other medical professionals which found that health care providers’ implicit racial bias is associated with diagnostic uncertainty and, for Black patients, negative ratings of their clinical interactions, less patient-centeredness, poor provider communication, under-treatment of pain, and views of Black patients as less medically adherent than white patients.
While studies examining the effectiveness of anti-implicit bias training among medical providers in the field continue to develop, there are a number of completed studies finding that such training, if grounded in a comprehensive, evidence-based approach, can succeed in significantly reducing implicit stereotyping and prejudice in participants. Such evidence supports the conclusion that comprehensive, multifaceted implicit bias training can help individuals become more attuned to their own biases and lead to improved patient outcomes.
- Maternal and infant health outcomes in California. According to the 2023 California Health Care Foundation report, “Maternity Care in California,” there were 420,000 births in California in 2021, accounting for about one in 10 of all births nationwide. The number of births in the state declined 26% between 2007 and 2021. In 2021, about one in four hospital births in California were low-risk, first-birth cesareans (c-sections). In 2021, half of California hospitals’ c-section rates were higher than the Healthy People 2030 target of 23.6%. Significant racial/ethnic disparities existed across a variety of maternal quality measures in California, from prenatal visits to preterm births to maternal and infant mortality rates. For many of these measures, Black women / birthing people and infants had lower scores than their peers in other racial/ethnic groups.
In California, the rate of maternal death since 2006 has decreased by 55% even though the rate in the United States as a whole has steadily increased. However, according to data in DPH’s 2018 California Pregnancy-Associated Mortality Review, for women of color, and in particular Black women, the rate remains three to four times higher than that for white women in California. The racial disparity is even starker when looking at particular conditions. Black women account for 5% of those pregnant in California but account for 21% of the total pregnancy-related deaths. Further, the disparity in maternal health between Black and non-Hispanic white birthing mothers exists independent of the socio-economic status of the birthing mother. A recent study that looked at the records of millions of births in California illustrates that across all parental income levels, Black mothers, as well as their infants, have much worse health outcomes than their non-Hispanic white counterparts do. - AG report on the Act. To ascertain compliance with the Act’s training requirements, the Department of Justice (DOJ) sent a letter on August 23, 2021, to facilities subject to the requirements of the Act. Through this letter, DOJ requested that each facility provide:
- Dates of any implicit bias training providers have completed;
- Dates of implicit bias trainings planned for the future;
- Lists of attendees at each training;
- Copies of all written training materials used;
- A list of the perinatal healthcare workers at each facility who have yet to participate in any training; and,
- A description of each facility’s efforts to reduce implicit bias among its perinatal healthcare providers.
- Maternal and infant health outcomes in California. According to the 2023 California Health Care Foundation report, “Maternity Care in California,” there were 420,000 births in California in 2021, accounting for about one in 10 of all births nationwide. The number of births in the state declined 26% between 2007 and 2021. In 2021, about one in four hospital births in California were low-risk, first-birth cesareans (c-sections). In 2021, half of California hospitals’ c-section rates were higher than the Healthy People 2030 target of 23.6%. Significant racial/ethnic disparities existed across a variety of maternal quality measures in California, from prenatal visits to preterm births to maternal and infant mortality rates. For many of these measures, Black women / birthing people and infants had lower scores than their peers in other racial/ethnic groups.
DOJ further requested that facilities provide responsive documents and information by September 20, 2021. One hundred and fifty facilities requested, and were granted, an extension and did not produce any responsive documents or information until early January 2022. DOJ continued to receive information from a small minority of letter recipients through April 2022.
DOJ’s investigation found that 42 hospitals had not fully trained a single employee prior to being contacted by DOJ on August 23, 2021. Responding hospitals on average completed trainings for 81.36% of their relevant providers, though this figure includes both facilities that completed trainings for all of the appropriate providers and facilities that failed to complete any trainings. Average completion rates were 79.41% at private hospitals, 81.08% at non-profit hospitals, 86.26% at government hospitals, and 84.81% at University of California hospitals. All staff had completed their training at 41 hospitals, and no staff had completed their training at two hospitals.
Nearly a third of facilities to which DOJ reached out, began training only after DOJ contacted them, suggesting that DOJ’s outreach caused compliance in many cases.
- Current AE reporting requirements. On September 12, 2021 DPH notified hospitals, via All Facility Letter (AFL), that AE reporting regulations had been updated. The AFL notes that, consistent with existing law, hospitals are required to report AEs no later than five days after the AE is detected. If the event is an ongoing urgent or emergent threat to the welfare, health, or safety of patients, personnel, or visitors, the hospital must report no later than 24 hours after detection. The detection of or allegation of sexual assault is considered an ongoing or emergent threat and must be reported within 24 hours. In addition, the regulations specify the hospital is subject to an onsite investigation when DPH determines that an AE or complaint is an ongoing threat of imminent danger of death or serious bodily harm. The regulations require hospitals to report AEs via DPH's secure electronic web-based portal. DPH provides alternative means, by email or telephone, for submission if the web-based portal is unavailable. This requirement preserves patient confidentiality and standardizes reporting requirements. Hospitals are also required to develop policies and procedures for the internal reporting of preventable patient safety events, conducting a root cause analysis, and assessing the hospital's culture of safety every 24 months.
- Current AE reporting requirements. On September 12, 2021 DPH notified hospitals, via All Facility Letter (AFL), that AE reporting regulations had been updated. The AFL notes that, consistent with existing law, hospitals are required to report AEs no later than five days after the AE is detected. If the event is an ongoing urgent or emergent threat to the welfare, health, or safety of patients, personnel, or visitors, the hospital must report no later than 24 hours after detection. The detection of or allegation of sexual assault is considered an ongoing or emergent threat and must be reported within 24 hours. In addition, the regulations specify the hospital is subject to an onsite investigation when DPH determines that an AE or complaint is an ongoing threat of imminent danger of death or serious bodily harm. The regulations require hospitals to report AEs via DPH's secure electronic web-based portal. DPH provides alternative means, by email or telephone, for submission if the web-based portal is unavailable. This requirement preserves patient confidentiality and standardizes reporting requirements. Hospitals are also required to develop policies and procedures for the internal reporting of preventable patient safety events, conducting a root cause analysis, and assessing the hospital's culture of safety every 24 months.
- SUPPORT. AG Rob Bonta is the sponsor of this bill and states that this bill aims to reduce the alarming and disproportionate maternal mortality rate of Black women and other pregnant persons of color by ensuring successful implementation of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. Under the Act, health facilities are required to train perinatal care providers in recognizing and overcoming their own implicit or unconscious racial biases and prejudices that could negatively impact the quality of care — and even endanger the lives of — pregnant patients of color. The Act went in to effect on January 1, 2020, and in August 2021, the DOJ initiated an investigation to determine compliance with the law. At that time, fewer than 17% of responding providers had begun training their employees and not a single employee had been fully trained. By the time DOJ’s investigation and outreach efforts concluded 10 months later, the training completion rate had improved to more than 81%. The AG notes that while some facilities have gone above and beyond the requirements of the Act, there is still work to be done to further address the continued racial disparity in maternal morbidity rates by changing the way that healthcare providers recognize and overcome their own implicit bias when treating pregnancy. The AG concludes that investigations into the cause of all pregnancy-related deaths by DPH determined that more than half are preventable, and that this bill is a substantial part of the systemic change needed to reduce the disparate impact on Black mothers and pregnant persons of color and to prevent these deaths from happening.
- RELATED LEGISLATION. AB 3161 (Bonta) requires DPH to collect self-reported patient demographics when receiving complaints regarding hospitals and long-term care facilities. Requires DPH to review, analyze, and publish trends among patient safety events in a manner consistent with patient privacy. Requires hospital patient safety plans to include specified methods to address racism and discrimination in health care, including procedures for staff to anonymously report instances of racial bias. Requires DPH to publicly publish hospital patient safety plans. Establishes a partnership between DPH, the California Department of Civil Rights, and Department of Justice to share data on racial bias in health care specific to patient adverse events. AB 3161 is pending in the Assembly Health Committee.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION. SB 464 (Mitchell), Chapter 533, Statutes of 2019, requires hospitals and alternative birth centers to implement an implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities, including requiring these healthcare providers to complete initial basic training through the implicit bias program and a refresher course every two years thereafter. Requires DPH to track and publish data on maternal death and severe morbidity, and, adds to the list of written information a hospital is required to provide to each patient upon admission, information on how to file a discrimination complaint with DPH or the Medical Board of California if the patient feels they were discriminated against.
- SUGGESTED AMENDMENT. Moving forward, the author will need to specify the date by which DPH must solicit public participation, and adopt regulations to further the purposes of the Act.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Attorney General Rob Bonta (sponsor)
Access Reproductive Justice
Asian Americans Advancing Justice-southern California
Black Women for Wellness Action Project
Board of Supervisors for The City and County of San Francisco
California Black Health Network
California Commission on The Status of Women and Girls
California Family Resource Association
California Federation of Teachers AFL-CIO
California State Association of Psychiatrists (CSAP)
California Women's Law Center
Child Abuse Prevention Center and Its Affiliates Safe Kids California, Prevent Child Abuse California and The California Family Resource Association; the
Children Now
Community Health Councils
Courage California
Equality California
Essential Access Health
Health Access California
Hispanas Organized for Political Equality (HOPE)
National Council of Jewish Women Los Angeles
National Health Law Program
Perinatal Health Equity Initiative
Reproductive Freedom for All
The Children's Partnership
Western Center on Law & Poverty, INC.
Women's Foundation California
Women's Health Specialists
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Date of Hearing: April 2, 2024
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON HEALTH
Mia Bonta, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 2319
Author:((Wilson and Weber) – As Amended Ver:March 21, 2024
SUBJECT: California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act.
SUMMARY: Expands the types of health care providers who must participate in implicit bias training pursuant to the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act (the Act.) Requires initial basic training on implicit bias to be completed by June 1, 2025, and requires facilities subject to the provisions of the Act to provide the Department of Public Health (DPH) with proof of compliance by February 1 of each year. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires hospitals that provide perinatal care, alternative birth centers, and primary care clinics to implement evidence-based implicit bias programs for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities.
- Defines health care providers for the purposes of this bill to include:
- Licensed health care providers, including, but not limited to, physicians and surgeons, physicians’ assistants, registered nurses, respiratory therapists, and licensed vocational nurses, who are regularly assigned to provide perinatal care, including, but not limited to, those in primary care clinics, alternative birthing centers, outpatient clinics, or emergency departments; and,
- All persons who are regularly assigned to positions where they interact with perinatal patients, including, but not limited to, physician assistants, medical assistants, licensed vocational nurses, or doctors.
- Licensed health care providers, including, but not limited to, physicians and surgeons, physicians’ assistants, registered nurses, respiratory therapists, and licensed vocational nurses, who are regularly assigned to provide perinatal care, including, but not limited to, those in primary care clinics, alternative birthing centers, outpatient clinics, or emergency departments; and,
- Requires health care providers described in 2) above to complete initial basic training through the implicit bias training by June 1, 2025, for all current health care providers, and for the initial basic training to be provided to new health care providers at all facilities within six months of their start at the new facility.
- Requires a facility described in 1) above to document each employee’s implicit bias training in accordance with regulations adopted by DPH for documenting staff development programs. Requires DPH to assess each hospital’s compliance with this provision during periodic inspections conducted pursuant to 2) in existing law, below.
- Authorizes DPH, if DPH determines that a facility has violated these provisions, to assess an administrative penalty consistent with 11) in existing law, below.
- Specifies that DPH’s ability to issue a penalty is not the exclusive means of enforcing the Act, and that civil remedies available to the Attorney General (AG) under any other statute remain available to enforce the provisions of this Act. Grants DPH full administrative power, authority, and jurisdiction to implement and enforce the Act.
- Requires DPH to annually post on its internet website by April of each year a list of all facilities that have been issued administrative penalties for violations of the Act. Requires, when listing facilities that have been issued administrative penalties, DPH to include all of the following:
- The date the penalty was issued;
- The amount of the penalty;
- The reason the penalty was issued;
- The percentage of untrained providers; and,
- The date of facility noncompliance.
- Authorizes, if a facility disputes a determination rendered by DPH pursuant to 5) above, the facility to request a hearing within 10 working days. Requires penalties to be paid when all appeals have been exhausted and DPH’s position has been upheld.
- Requires DPH, on or before ____, to solicit broad public participation and adopt regulations to further the purposes of the Act, including, but not limited to, the following areas:
- Guidance on training methodologies sufficient to address the findings and declarations in the Act;
- Guidance on each of the categories of training specified in the Act; and,
- Authorizing DPH to issue and revise or adopt existing trainings that it certifies as a model sufficient to comply with the requirements of the Act, current research, and best practices. Requires DPH to make any certified training available on its internet website.
- Requires DPH to review and ensure that the training continues to comply with the requirements of the Act, and to recertify training on an annual basis or to withdraw its certification.
- Authorizes DPH to adopt additional regulations, as necessary, to further the purposes of the Act.
- Requires DPH to conduct a review of a facility subject to the requirements of the Act:
- Upon the death of a birthing parent or child during or one month after birth, unless DPH had completed a review of the facility within one year prior to the death;
- Upon DPH’s receipt of at least three complaints of racial bias or quality of care against perinatal or prenatal care providers in a facility subject to the training requirements of the Act by a patient or patients identifying as any race but white, not Hispanic or Latino; or,
- At any other time that DPH deems appropriate.
- Requires a facility review to include a review of the facility’s compliance with the training requirements of the Act, and review the substance of the facility’s training program to assess compliance with the requirements of the Act, and any relevant regulation.
- Requires DPH to publish a report outlining compliance data on a biannual basis. Requires the report to be posted on DPH’s internet website.
- Defines “perinatal care” as the provision of care during pregnancy, labor, delivery, and postpartum and neonatal periods. Specifies that perinatal care includes, but is not limited to prenatal care.
- Makes the provisions of the Act severable.
- Finds and declares that it is the intent of the Legislature to reduce the effects of implicit bias in pregnancy, childbirth, and postnatal care so that all people are treated with dignity and respect by their health care providers, and that the Legislature recognizes all birthing people, including nonbinary persons and persons of transgender experience.
EXISTING LAW:
- Establishes DPH, which among other functions, licenses and regulates health facilities, including general acute care hospitals and special hospitals (hospitals) and clinics, as specified. [Health and Safety Code (HSC) §1250 (a) and (f) and §1226]
- Requires DPH to periodically inspect hospitals no less that once every three years, and as often as necessary to ensure the quality of care being provided. [HSC §1279]
- Requires a hospital to report an adverse event (AE) to DPH no later than five days after the AE has been detected, or, if that event is an ongoing urgent or emergent threat to the welfare, health, or safety of patients, personnel, or visitors, not later than 24 hours after the AE has been detected. [HSC §1279.1]
- Requires in any case in which DPH receives a report from a facility, or a written or oral complaint involving a hospital, that indicates an ongoing threat of imminent danger of death or serious bodily harm, DPH to make an onsite inspection or investigation within 48 hours or two business days, whichever is greater, of the receipt of the report or complaint and to complete that investigation within 45 days. [HSC §1279.2]
- Requires a hospital, to develop, implement, and comply with a patient safety plan for the purpose of improving the health and safety of patients and reducing preventable patient safety events. Requires the patient safety plan to be developed by the hospital, in consultation with the hospital’s various health care professionals. [HSC §1279.6]
- Establishes the Act, which requires hospitals that provide perinatal care, and alternative birth centers or primary care clinics to implement an evidence-based implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities. [HSC §123630.3]
- Requires an implicit bias program to include all of the following:
- Identification of previous or current unconscious biases and misinformation;
- Identification of personal, interpersonal, institutional, structural, and cultural barriers to inclusion;
- Corrective measures to decrease implicit bias at the interpersonal and institutional levels, including ongoing policies and practices for that purpose;
- Information on the effects, including, but not limited to, ongoing personal effects, of historical and contemporary exclusion and oppression of minority communities;
- Information about cultural identity across racial or ethnic groups;
- Information about communicating more effectively across identities, including racial, ethnic, religious, and gender identities;
- Discussion on power dynamics and organizational decision-making;
- Discussion on health inequities within the perinatal care field, including information on how implicit bias impacts maternal and infant health outcomes;
- Perspectives of diverse, local constituency groups and experts on particular racial, identity, cultural, and provider-community relations issues in the community; and,
- Information on reproductive justice. [Ibid.]
- Requires health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within the facilities described in 2) above, to complete initial basic training through an implicit bias program, and upon completion of the initial basic training, a health care provider to complete a refresher course under the implicit bias program every two years thereafter, or on a more frequent basis if deemed necessary by the facility, in order to keep current with changing racial, identity, and cultural trends and best practices in decreasing interpersonal and institutional implicit bias. [Ibid.]
- Requires facilities, described in 2) above, to provide a certificate of training completion to another facility or a training attendee upon request. Authorizes a facility to accept a certificate of completion from another facility to satisfy the training requirements from a health care provider who works in more than one facility. [Ibid.]
- Requires, if a physician involved in the perinatal care of patients is not directly employed by a facility, the facility to offer the training to the physician. [Ibid.]
- Authorizes DPH to assess an administrative penalty for a deficiency constituting an immediate jeopardy violation, as defined, up to a maximum of $75,000 for the first administrative penalty, up to $100,000 for the second administrative penalty, and up to $125,000 for the third and every subsequent administrative penalty. Permits DPH to assess an administrative penalty of up to $25,000 per violation for those not deemed to constitute immediate jeopardy. Prohibits DPH from assessing an administrative penalty for minor violations. [HSC §1280.3 (a) (b) and (c)]
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill has not yet been analyzed by a fiscal committee.
COMMENTS:
- PURPOSE OF THIS BILL. According to the author, the United States has the highest maternal mortality rate in the developed world. In California Black women continue to die at three to four times the rate of white women. A 2023 study by DPH, “Centering Black Mothers in California: Insights into Racism, Health, and Well-being for Black Women and Infants,” found that women of color, in particular Black women, die of pregnancy-related complications at much higher rates than white women in California. Evidence suggests one key cause of this disparity is the implicit bias of healthcare providers. A provider’s level of bias, whether conscious or unconscious, can influence their interactions with patients and their diagnoses and treatment of the patient’s pain, and can undermine patients’ trust and engagement in care. The author notes that, to address this, the legislature passed the Act in 2019, which requires hospitals, alternative birth centers and primary care clinics to conduct evidence-based implicit bias training for all health professionals who provide care during a patient’s pregnancy, childbirth, and immediate postpartum period. The California AG recently issued a report following an investigation into facility compliance with the Act. The report and its findings highlight the need for additional action to continue the work started by the Act. Specifically, additional steps are necessary to ensure hospitals and facilities comply and are equipped to meet those requirements. It is time for these institutions to come into compliance with the law. The author concludes that this is a small, necessary step towards making California a safer place for Black and Brown mothers.
- BACKGROUND.
- Implicit bias. According to the University of San Francisco’s Office of Outreach and Diversity, bias is a prejudice in favor of or against one thing, person, or group compared with another usually in a way that is considered to be unfair. Biases may be held by an individual, group, or institution and can have negative or positive consequences. There are types of biases: conscious bias (also known as explicit bias) and unconscious bias (also known as implicit bias). Biases, conscious or unconscious, are not limited to ethnicity and race. Though racial bias and discrimination are well documented, biases may exist toward any social group. Age, gender, gender identity, physical abilities, religion, sexual orientation, weight, and many other characteristics are subject to bias. Unconscious, or implicit, biases are social stereotypes about certain groups of people that individuals form outside their own conscious awareness. Unconscious bias is far more prevalent than conscious prejudice and often incompatible with one’s conscious values. It is well-documented that implicit bias among health care professionals is prevalent and impacts patient care.
A July 2022 article, “Tackling Implicit Bias in Health Care,” published in the New England Journal of Medicine, notes that our individual biases operate within larger social, cultural, and economic structures whose biased policies and practices perpetuate systemic racism, sexism, and other forms of discrimination. The article notes that in medicine, bias-driven discriminatory practices and policies not only negatively affect patient care and the medical training environment, but also limit the diversity of the health care workforce, lead to inequitable distribution of research funding, and can hinder career advancement. The article discusses a review of studies involving physicians, nurses, and other medical professionals which found that health care providers’ implicit racial bias is associated with diagnostic uncertainty and, for Black patients, negative ratings of their clinical interactions, less patient-centeredness, poor provider communication, under-treatment of pain, and views of Black patients as less medically adherent than white patients.
While studies examining the effectiveness of anti-implicit bias training among medical providers in the field continue to develop, there are a number of completed studies finding that such training, if grounded in a comprehensive, evidence-based approach, can succeed in significantly reducing implicit stereotyping and prejudice in participants. Such evidence supports the conclusion that comprehensive, multifaceted implicit bias training can help individuals become more attuned to their own biases and lead to improved patient outcomes.
- Maternal and infant health outcomes in California. According to the 2023 California Health Care Foundation report, “Maternity Care in California,” there were 420,000 births in California in 2021, accounting for about one in 10 of all births nationwide. The number of births in the state declined 26% between 2007 and 2021. In 2021, about one in four hospital births in California were low-risk, first-birth cesareans (c-sections). In 2021, half of California hospitals’ c-section rates were higher than the Healthy People 2030 target of 23.6%. Significant racial/ethnic disparities existed across a variety of maternal quality measures in California, from prenatal visits to preterm births to maternal and infant mortality rates. For many of these measures, Black women / birthing people and infants had lower scores than their peers in other racial/ethnic groups.
In California, the rate of maternal death since 2006 has decreased by 55% even though the rate in the United States as a whole has steadily increased. However, according to data in DPH’s 2018 California Pregnancy-Associated Mortality Review, for women of color, and in particular Black women, the rate remains three to four times higher than that for white women in California. The racial disparity is even starker when looking at particular conditions. Black women account for 5% of those pregnant in California but account for 21% of the total pregnancy-related deaths. Further, the disparity in maternal health between Black and non-Hispanic white birthing mothers exists independent of the socio-economic status of the birthing mother. A recent study that looked at the records of millions of births in California illustrates that across all parental income levels, Black mothers, as well as their infants, have much worse health outcomes than their non-Hispanic white counterparts do. - AG report on the Act. To ascertain compliance with the Act’s training requirements, the Department of Justice (DOJ) sent a letter on August 23, 2021, to facilities subject to the requirements of the Act. Through this letter, DOJ requested that each facility provide:
- Dates of any implicit bias training providers have completed;
- Dates of implicit bias trainings planned for the future;
- Lists of attendees at each training;
- Copies of all written training materials used;
- A list of the perinatal healthcare workers at each facility who have yet to participate in any training; and,
- A description of each facility’s efforts to reduce implicit bias among its perinatal healthcare providers.
- Maternal and infant health outcomes in California. According to the 2023 California Health Care Foundation report, “Maternity Care in California,” there were 420,000 births in California in 2021, accounting for about one in 10 of all births nationwide. The number of births in the state declined 26% between 2007 and 2021. In 2021, about one in four hospital births in California were low-risk, first-birth cesareans (c-sections). In 2021, half of California hospitals’ c-section rates were higher than the Healthy People 2030 target of 23.6%. Significant racial/ethnic disparities existed across a variety of maternal quality measures in California, from prenatal visits to preterm births to maternal and infant mortality rates. For many of these measures, Black women / birthing people and infants had lower scores than their peers in other racial/ethnic groups.
DOJ further requested that facilities provide responsive documents and information by September 20, 2021. One hundred and fifty facilities requested, and were granted, an extension and did not produce any responsive documents or information until early January 2022. DOJ continued to receive information from a small minority of letter recipients through April 2022.
DOJ’s investigation found that 42 hospitals had not fully trained a single employee prior to being contacted by DOJ on August 23, 2021. Responding hospitals on average completed trainings for 81.36% of their relevant providers, though this figure includes both facilities that completed trainings for all of the appropriate providers and facilities that failed to complete any trainings. Average completion rates were 79.41% at private hospitals, 81.08% at non-profit hospitals, 86.26% at government hospitals, and 84.81% at University of California hospitals. All staff had completed their training at 41 hospitals, and no staff had completed their training at two hospitals.
Nearly a third of facilities to which DOJ reached out, began training only after DOJ contacted them, suggesting that DOJ’s outreach caused compliance in many cases.
- Current AE reporting requirements. On September 12, 2021 DPH notified hospitals, via All Facility Letter (AFL), that AE reporting regulations had been updated. The AFL notes that, consistent with existing law, hospitals are required to report AEs no later than five days after the AE is detected. If the event is an ongoing urgent or emergent threat to the welfare, health, or safety of patients, personnel, or visitors, the hospital must report no later than 24 hours after detection. The detection of or allegation of sexual assault is considered an ongoing or emergent threat and must be reported within 24 hours. In addition, the regulations specify the hospital is subject to an onsite investigation when DPH determines that an AE or complaint is an ongoing threat of imminent danger of death or serious bodily harm. The regulations require hospitals to report AEs via DPH's secure electronic web-based portal. DPH provides alternative means, by email or telephone, for submission if the web-based portal is unavailable. This requirement preserves patient confidentiality and standardizes reporting requirements. Hospitals are also required to develop policies and procedures for the internal reporting of preventable patient safety events, conducting a root cause analysis, and assessing the hospital's culture of safety every 24 months.
- Current AE reporting requirements. On September 12, 2021 DPH notified hospitals, via All Facility Letter (AFL), that AE reporting regulations had been updated. The AFL notes that, consistent with existing law, hospitals are required to report AEs no later than five days after the AE is detected. If the event is an ongoing urgent or emergent threat to the welfare, health, or safety of patients, personnel, or visitors, the hospital must report no later than 24 hours after detection. The detection of or allegation of sexual assault is considered an ongoing or emergent threat and must be reported within 24 hours. In addition, the regulations specify the hospital is subject to an onsite investigation when DPH determines that an AE or complaint is an ongoing threat of imminent danger of death or serious bodily harm. The regulations require hospitals to report AEs via DPH's secure electronic web-based portal. DPH provides alternative means, by email or telephone, for submission if the web-based portal is unavailable. This requirement preserves patient confidentiality and standardizes reporting requirements. Hospitals are also required to develop policies and procedures for the internal reporting of preventable patient safety events, conducting a root cause analysis, and assessing the hospital's culture of safety every 24 months.
- SUPPORT. AG Rob Bonta is the sponsor of this bill and states that this bill aims to reduce the alarming and disproportionate maternal mortality rate of Black women and other pregnant persons of color by ensuring successful implementation of the California Dignity in Pregnancy and Childbirth Act. Under the Act, health facilities are required to train perinatal care providers in recognizing and overcoming their own implicit or unconscious racial biases and prejudices that could negatively impact the quality of care — and even endanger the lives of — pregnant patients of color. The Act went in to effect on January 1, 2020, and in August 2021, the DOJ initiated an investigation to determine compliance with the law. At that time, fewer than 17% of responding providers had begun training their employees and not a single employee had been fully trained. By the time DOJ’s investigation and outreach efforts concluded 10 months later, the training completion rate had improved to more than 81%. The AG notes that while some facilities have gone above and beyond the requirements of the Act, there is still work to be done to further address the continued racial disparity in maternal morbidity rates by changing the way that healthcare providers recognize and overcome their own implicit bias when treating pregnancy. The AG concludes that investigations into the cause of all pregnancy-related deaths by DPH determined that more than half are preventable, and that this bill is a substantial part of the systemic change needed to reduce the disparate impact on Black mothers and pregnant persons of color and to prevent these deaths from happening.
- RELATED LEGISLATION. AB 3161 (Bonta) requires DPH to collect self-reported patient demographics when receiving complaints regarding hospitals and long-term care facilities. Requires DPH to review, analyze, and publish trends among patient safety events in a manner consistent with patient privacy. Requires hospital patient safety plans to include specified methods to address racism and discrimination in health care, including procedures for staff to anonymously report instances of racial bias. Requires DPH to publicly publish hospital patient safety plans. Establishes a partnership between DPH, the California Department of Civil Rights, and Department of Justice to share data on racial bias in health care specific to patient adverse events. AB 3161 is pending in the Assembly Health Committee.
- PREVIOUS LEGISLATION. SB 464 (Mitchell), Chapter 533, Statutes of 2019, requires hospitals and alternative birth centers to implement an implicit bias program for all health care providers involved in the perinatal care of patients within those facilities, including requiring these healthcare providers to complete initial basic training through the implicit bias program and a refresher course every two years thereafter. Requires DPH to track and publish data on maternal death and severe morbidity, and, adds to the list of written information a hospital is required to provide to each patient upon admission, information on how to file a discrimination complaint with DPH or the Medical Board of California if the patient feels they were discriminated against.
- SUGGESTED AMENDMENT. Moving forward, the author will need to specify the date by which DPH must solicit public participation, and adopt regulations to further the purposes of the Act.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
Attorney General Rob Bonta (sponsor)
Access Reproductive Justice
Asian Americans Advancing Justice-southern California
Black Women for Wellness Action Project
Board of Supervisors for The City and County of San Francisco
California Black Health Network
California Commission on The Status of Women and Girls
California Family Resource Association
California Federation of Teachers AFL-CIO
California State Association of Psychiatrists (CSAP)
California Women's Law Center
Child Abuse Prevention Center and Its Affiliates Safe Kids California, Prevent Child Abuse California and The California Family Resource Association; the
Children Now
Community Health Councils
Courage California
Equality California
Essential Access Health
Health Access California
Hispanas Organized for Political Equality (HOPE)
National Council of Jewish Women Los Angeles
National Health Law Program
Perinatal Health Equity Initiative
Reproductive Freedom for All
The Children's Partnership
Western Center on Law & Poverty, INC.
Women's Foundation California
Women's Health Specialists
Opposition
None on file.
Analysis Prepared by: Lara Flynn / HEALTH / (916) 319-2097
Discussed in Hearing
Assembly Floor
Senate Floor
Senate Standing Committee on Appropriations
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Health
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Health
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):