AB 957: Family law: gender identity.
- Session Year: 2023-2024
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2023-09-08
Current Status:
Failed
(2024-01-29: Consideration of Governor's veto stricken from file.)
Introduced
In Committee
First Chamber
In Committee
Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law governs the determination of child custody and visitation in contested proceedings and requires the court, for purposes of deciding custody, to determine the best interests of the child based on certain factors, including, among other things, the health, safety, and welfare of the child.
This bill, for purposes of this provision, would include a parents affirmation of the childs gender identity or gender expression as part of the health, safety, and welfare of the child.
This bill would incorporate additional changes to Section 3011 of the Family Code proposed by SB 599 to be operative only if this bill and SB 599 are enacted and this bill is enacted last.
Existing law governs the determination of child custody and visitation in contested proceedings and requires the court, for purposes of deciding custody, to determine the best interests of the child based on certain factors, including, among other things, the health, safety, and welfare of the child.
This bill, for purposes of this provision, would include a parents affirmation of the childs gender identity or gender expression as part of the health, safety, and welfare of the child.
This bill would incorporate additional changes to Section 3011 of the Family Code proposed by SB 599 to be operative only if this bill and SB 599 are enacted and this bill is enacted last.
Existing law governs the determination of child custody and visitation in contested proceedings and requires the court, for purposes of deciding custody, to determine the best interests of the child based on certain factors, including, among other things, the health, safety, and welfare of the child.
This bill, for purposes of this provision, would include a parents affirmation of the childs gender identity or gender expression as part of the health, safety, and welfare of the child.
Existing law governs the determination of child custody and visitation in contested proceedings and requires the court, for purposes of deciding custody, to determine the best interests of the child based on certain factors, including, among other things, the nature and amount of contact with both parents and the health, safety, and welfare of the child.
This bill would require a court, when determining the best interests of a child, to also consider a parents affirmation of the childs gender identity.This bill, for purposes of this provision, would include a parents affirmation of the childs gender identity as part of the health, safety, and welfare of the child.
Existing law authorizes a person to petition for a court order conforming the persons name to the persons gender identity. Existing law requires the court, upon the filing of a petition commencing a proceeding for a change of name to conform the petitioners name to the petitioners gender identity, to make an order reciting the filing of the petition and directing all persons interested in the matter to make their objections known, as specified. Existing law requires the petition and order to be served on the parent who did not sign the petition if a petition to change the name of a minor to conform to their gender identity does not include the signature of both living parents, as specified.
This bill would require the court to strongly consider that affirming the minors gender identity is in the best interest of the child if a nonconsenting parent objects to a name and gender marker change to affirm conform to the minors gender identity.
Existing law governs the determination of child custody and visitation in contested proceedings and requires the court, for purposes of deciding custody, to determine the best interests of the child based on certain factors, including, among other things, the nature and amount of contact with both parents and the health, safety, and welfare of the child.
This bill would require a court, when determining the best interests of a child, to also consider a parents affirmation of the childs gender identity.
Existing law requires all applications for change of names to be made to the superior court of the persons county of residence, except for minors with a court-appointed guardian. Existing law requires the court in which a petition for a change of name has been filed to issue an order to show cause inviting interested persons to file written objections to the proposed change of name, as specified. Existing law requires a petitioner, if a petition for a name change has been filed for a minor by a parent, to cause notice of the time and place of the hearing, or a copy of the order, to be served on the other parent not less than 30 days before the hearing if the other parent does not consent to the name change.
This bill would require the court to strongly consider that affirming the minors gender identity is in the best interest of the child if a nonconsenting parent objects to a name and gender marker change to affirm the minors gender identity.
Existing law governs the determination of child custody and visitation in contested proceedings and requires the court, for purposes of deciding custody, to determine the best interests of the child based on certain factors, including, among other things, the nature and amount of contact with both parents and the health, safety, and welfare of the child.
This bill would require a court, when determining the best interests of a child, to also consider a parents affirmation of the childs gender identity.
(a)In making a determination of the best interests of the child in a proceeding described in Section 3021, the court shall, among any other factors it finds relevant and consistent with Section 3020, consider all of the following:
(1)(A)The health, safety, and welfare of the child.
(B)As used in this paragraph, the health, safety, and welfare of the child includes, among other comprehensive factors, a parents affirmation of the childs gender identity or gender expression. Affirmation includes a range of actions and will be unique for each child, but in every case must promote the childs overall health and well-being.
(2)(A)A history of abuse by one parent or another person seeking custody against any of the following:
(i)A child to whom the parent or person seeking custody is related by blood or affinity or with whom the parent or person seeking custody has had a caretaking relationship, no matter how temporary.
(ii)The other parent.
(iii)A parent, current spouse, or cohabitant of the parent or person seeking custody, or a person with whom the parent or person seeking custody has a dating or engagement relationship.
(B)(i)As a prerequisite to considering allegations of abuse, the court may require independent corroboration, including, but not limited to, written reports by law enforcement agencies, child protective services or other social welfare agencies, courts, medical facilities, or other public agencies or private nonprofit organizations providing services to victims of sexual assault or domestic violence.
(ii)As used in this paragraph, abuse against a child means child abuse or neglect as defined in Section 11165.6 of the Penal Code.
(iii)Abuse against another person, as described in clause (ii) or (iii) of subparagraph (A), means abuse as defined in Section 6203.
(3)The nature and amount of contact with both parents, except as provided in Section 3046.
(4)(A)The habitual or continual illegal use of controlled substances or the habitual or continual abuse of alcohol or prescribed controlled substances by either parent. Before considering these allegations, the court may first require independent corroboration, including, but not limited to, written reports from law enforcement agencies, courts, probation departments, social welfare agencies, medical facilities, rehabilitation facilities, or other public agencies or nonprofit organizations providing drug and alcohol abuse services.
(B)As used in this paragraph, controlled substances has the same meaning as defined in the California Uniform Controlled Substances Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 11000) of the Health and Safety Code).
(5)(A)When allegations about a parent pursuant to paragraph (2) or (4) have been brought to the attention of the court in the current proceeding and the court makes an order for sole or joint custody or unsupervised visitation to that parent, the court shall state its reasons in writing or on the record. In these circumstances, the court shall ensure that an order regarding custody or visitation is specific as to time, day, place, and manner of transfer of the child as set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 6323.
(B)This paragraph does not apply if the parties stipulate in writing or on the record regarding custody or visitation.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the court shall not consider the sex, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation of a parent, legal guardian, or relative in determining the best interests of the child.
SEC. 1.5.Section 3011 of the Family Code is amended to read:3011.(a)In making a determination of the best interests of the child in a proceeding described in Section 3021, the court shall, among any other factors it finds relevant and consistent with Section 3020, consider all of the following:
(1)(A)The health, safety, and welfare of the child.
(B)As used in this paragraph, the health, safety, and welfare of the child includes, among other comprehensive factors, a parents affirmation of the childs gender identity or gender expression. Affirmation includes a range of actions and will be unique for each child, but in every case must promote the childs overall health and well-being.
(2)(A)A history of abuse by one parent or another person seeking custody against any of the following:
(i)A child to whom the parent or person seeking custody is related by blood or affinity or with whom the parent or person seeking custody has had a caretaking relationship, no matter how temporary.
(ii)The other parent.
(iii)A parent, current spouse, or cohabitant of the parent or person seeking custody, or a person with whom the parent or person seeking custody has a dating or engagement relationship.
(B)(i)As a prerequisite to considering allegations of abuse, the court may require independent corroboration, including, but not limited to, written reports by law enforcement agencies, child protective services or other social welfare agencies, courts, medical facilities, or other public agencies or private nonprofit organizations providing services to victims of sexual assault or domestic violence.
(ii)As used in this paragraph, abuse against a child means child abuse or neglect as defined in Section 11165.6 of the Penal Code.
(iii)Abuse against another person, as described in clause (ii) or (iii) of subparagraph (A), means abuse as defined in Section 6203.
(3)The nature and amount of contact with both parents, including as provided in Sections 3046 and 3100.
(4)(A)The habitual or continual illegal use of controlled substances or the habitual or continual abuse of alcohol or prescribed controlled substances by either parent. Before considering these allegations, the court may first require independent corroboration, including, but not limited to, written reports from law enforcement agencies, courts, probation departments, social welfare agencies, medical facilities, rehabilitation facilities, or other public agencies or nonprofit organizations providing drug and alcohol abuse services.
(B)As used in this paragraph, controlled substances has the same meaning as defined in the California Uniform Controlled Substances Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 11000) of the Health and Safety Code).
(5)(A)When allegations about a parent pursuant to paragraph (2) or (4) have been brought to the attention of the court in the current proceeding and the court makes an order for sole or joint custody or unsupervised visitation to that parent, the court shall state its reasons in writing or on the record that the order is in the best interest of the child and protects the safety of the parties and the child. In these circumstances, the court shall ensure that an order regarding custody or visitation is specific as to time, day, place, and manner of transfer of the child as set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 6323.
(B)Nothing in this paragraph eliminates the requirement that the contents of the stipulation be in the best interest of the child and be specific as to time, day, place, and manner of transfer of the child if the parties do stipulate in writing or on the record regarding custody or visitation.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the court shall not consider the sex, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation of a parent, legal guardian, or relative in determining the best interests of the child.
SEC. 2.Section 1.5 of this bill incorporates amendments to Section 3011 of the Family Code proposed by both this bill and Senate Bill 599. That section shall only become operative if (1) both bills are enacted and become effective on or before January 1, 2024, (2) each bill amends Section 3011 of the Family Code, and (3) this bill is enacted after Senate Bill 599, in which case Section 1 of this bill shall not become operative.
(a)In making a determination of the best interests of the child in a proceeding described in Section 3021, the court shall, among any other factors it finds relevant and consistent with Section 3020, consider all of the following:
(1)(A)The health, safety, and welfare of the child.
(B)As used in this paragraph, the health, safety, and welfare of the child includes, among other comprehensive factors, a parents affirmation of the childs gender identity or gender expression. Affirmation includes a range of actions and will be unique for each child, but in every case must promote the childs overall health and well-being.
(2)(A)A history of abuse by one parent or another person seeking custody against any of the following:
(i)A child to whom the parent or person seeking custody is related by blood or affinity or with whom the parent or person seeking custody has had a caretaking relationship, no matter how temporary.
(ii)The other parent.
(iii)A parent, current spouse, or cohabitant of the parent or person seeking custody, or a person with whom the parent or person seeking custody has a dating or engagement relationship.
(B)(i)As a prerequisite to considering allegations of abuse, the court may require independent corroboration, including, but not limited to, written reports by law enforcement agencies, child protective services or other social welfare agencies, courts, medical facilities, or other public agencies or private nonprofit organizations providing services to victims of sexual assault or domestic violence.
(ii)As used in this paragraph, abuse against a child means child abuse or neglect as defined in Section 11165.6 of the Penal Code.
(iii)Abuse against another person, as described in clause (ii) or (iii) of subparagraph (A), means abuse as defined in Section 6203.
(3)The nature and amount of contact with both parents, except as provided in Section 3046.
(4)(A)The habitual or continual illegal use of controlled substances or the habitual or continual abuse of alcohol or prescribed controlled substances by either parent. Before considering these allegations, the court may first require independent corroboration, including, but not limited to, written reports from law enforcement agencies, courts, probation departments, social welfare agencies, medical facilities, rehabilitation facilities, or other public agencies or nonprofit organizations providing drug and alcohol abuse services.
(B)As used in this paragraph, controlled substances has the same meaning as defined in the California Uniform Controlled Substances Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 11000) of the Health and Safety Code).
(5)(A)When allegations about a parent pursuant to paragraph (2) or (4) have been brought to the attention of the court in the current proceeding and the court makes an order for sole or joint custody or unsupervised visitation to that parent, the court shall state its reasons in writing or on the record. In these circumstances, the court shall ensure that an order regarding custody or visitation is specific as to time, day, place, and manner of transfer of the child as set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 6323.
(B)This paragraph does not apply if the parties stipulate in writing or on the record regarding custody or visitation.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the court shall not consider the sex, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation of a parent, legal guardian, or relative in determining the best interests of the child.
SEC. 1.5.Section 3011 of the Family Code is amended to read:3011.(a)In making a determination of the best interests of the child in a proceeding described in Section 3021, the court shall, among any other factors it finds relevant and consistent with Section 3020, consider all of the following:
(1)(A)The health, safety, and welfare of the child.
(B)As used in this paragraph, the health, safety, and welfare of the child includes, among other comprehensive factors, a parents affirmation of the childs gender identity or gender expression. Affirmation includes a range of actions and will be unique for each child, but in every case must promote the childs overall health and well-being.
(2)(A)A history of abuse by one parent or any other another person seeking custody against any of the following:
(i)A child to whom the parent or person seeking custody is related by blood or affinity or with whom the parent or person seeking custody has had a caretaking relationship, no matter how temporary.
(ii)The other parent.
(iii)A parent, current spouse, or cohabitant, cohabitant of the parent or person seeking custody, or a person with whom the parent or person seeking custody has a dating or engagement relationship.
(B)(i)As a prerequisite to considering allegations of abuse, the court may require independent corroboration, including, but not limited to, written reports by law enforcement agencies, child protective services or other social welfare agencies, courts, medical facilities, or other public agencies or private nonprofit organizations providing services to victims of sexual assault or domestic violence. As used in this paragraph, abuse against a child means child abuse and neglect as defined in Section 11165.6 of the Penal Code and abuse against any other person described in clause (ii) or (iii) of subparagraph (A) means abuse as defined in Section 6203.
(ii)As used in this paragraph, abuse against a child means child abuse or neglect as defined in Section 11165.6 of the Penal Code.
(iii)Abuse against another person, as described in clause (ii) or (iii) of subparagraph (A), means abuse as defined in Section 6203.
(3)The nature and amount of contact with both parents, except as provided in Section 3046. including as provided in Sections 3046 and 3100.
(4)(A)The habitual or continual illegal use of controlled substances, substances or the habitual or continual abuse of alcohol, or the habitual or continual abuse of alcohol or prescribed controlled substances by either parent. Before considering these allegations, the court may first require independent corroboration, including, but not limited to, written reports from law enforcement agencies, courts, probation departments, social welfare agencies, medical facilities, rehabilitation facilities, or other public agencies or nonprofit organizations providing drug and alcohol abuse services. As used in this paragraph, controlled substances has the same meaning as defined in the California Uniform Controlled Substances Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 11000) of the Health and Safety Code).
(B)As used in this paragraph, controlled substances has the same meaning as defined in the California Uniform Controlled Substances Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 11000) of the Health and Safety Code).
(5)(A)When allegations about a parent pursuant to paragraph (2) or (4) have been brought to the attention of the court in the current proceeding, proceeding and the court makes an order for sole or joint custody or unsupervised visitation to that parent, the court shall state its reasons in writing or on the record. record that the order is in the best interest of the child and protects the safety of the parties and the child. In these circumstances, the court shall ensure that any an order regarding custody or visitation is specific as to time, day, place, and manner of transfer of the child as set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 6323.
(B)This paragraph does not apply if the parties stipulate in writing or on the record regarding custody or visitation.(B)Nothing in this paragraph eliminates the requirement that the contents of the stipulation be in the best interest of the child and be specific as to time, day, place, and manner of transfer of the child if the parties do stipulate in writing or on the record regarding custody or visitation.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the court shall not consider the sex, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation of a parent, legal guardian, or relative in determining the best interests of the child.
SEC. 2.Section 1.5 of this bill incorporates amendments to Section 3011 of the Family Code proposed by both this bill and Senate Bill 599. That section shall only become operative if (1) both bills are enacted and become effective on or before January 1, 2024, (2) each bill amends Section 3011 of the Family Code, and (3) this bill is enacted after Senate Bill 599, in which case Section 1 of this bill shall not become operative.
(a)In making a determination of the best interests of the child in a proceeding described in Section 3021, the court shall, among any other factors it finds relevant and consistent with Section 3020, consider all of the following:
(1)(A)The health, safety, and welfare of the child.
(B)As used in this paragraph, the health, safety, and welfare of the child includes a parents affirmation of the childs gender identity.(B)As used in this paragraph, the health, safety, and welfare of the child includes, among other comprehensive factors, a parents affirmation of the childs gender identity or gender expression. Affirmation includes a range of actions and will be unique for each child, but in every case must promote the childs overall health and well-being.
(2)(A)A history of abuse by one parent or another person seeking custody against any of the following:
(i)A child to whom the parent or person seeking custody is related by blood or affinity or with whom the parent or person seeking custody has had a caretaking relationship, no matter how temporary.
(ii)The other parent.
(iii)A parent, current spouse, or cohabitant of the parent or person seeking custody, or a person with whom the parent or person seeking custody has a dating or engagement relationship.
(B)(i)As a prerequisite to considering allegations of abuse, the court may require independent corroboration, including, but not limited to, written reports by law enforcement agencies, child protective services or other social welfare agencies, courts, medical facilities, or other public agencies or private nonprofit organizations providing services to victims of sexual assault or domestic violence.
(ii)As used in this paragraph, abuse against a child means child abuse or neglect as defined in Section 11165.6 of the Penal Code.
(iii)Abuse against another person, as described in clause (ii) or (iii) of subparagraph (A), means abuse as defined in Section 6203.
(3)The nature and amount of contact with both parents, except as provided in Section 3046.
(4)(A)The habitual or continual illegal use of controlled substances or the habitual or continual abuse of alcohol or prescribed controlled substances by either parent. Before considering these allegations, the court may first require independent corroboration, including, but not limited to, written reports from law enforcement agencies, courts, probation departments, social welfare agencies, medical facilities, rehabilitation facilities, or other public agencies or nonprofit organizations providing drug and alcohol abuse services.
(B)As used in this paragraph, controlled substances has the same meaning as defined in the California Uniform Controlled Substances Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 11000) of the Health and Safety Code).
(5)(A)When allegations about a parent pursuant to paragraph (2) or (4) have been brought to the attention of the court in the current proceeding and the court makes an order for sole or joint custody or unsupervised visitation to that parent, the court shall state its reasons in writing or on the record. In these circumstances, the court shall ensure that an order regarding custody or visitation is specific as to time, day, place, and manner of transfer of the child as set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 6323.
(B)This paragraph does not apply if the parties stipulate in writing or on the record regarding custody or visitation.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the court shall not consider the sex, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation of a parent, legal guardian, or relative in determining the best interests of the child.
(a)In making a determination of the best interests of the child in a proceeding described in Section 3021, the court shall, among any other factors it finds relevant and consistent with Section 3020, consider all of the following:
(1)(A)The health, safety, and welfare of the child.
(B)As used in this paragraph, the health, safety, and welfare of the child includes a parents affirmation of the childs gender identity.
(2)(A)A history of abuse by one parent or another person seeking custody against any of the following:
(i)A child to whom the parent or person seeking custody is related by blood or affinity or with whom the parent or person seeking custody has had a caretaking relationship, no matter how temporary.
(ii)The other parent.
(iii)A parent, current spouse, or cohabitant of the parent or person seeking custody, or a person with whom the parent or person seeking custody has a dating or engagement relationship.
(B)(i)As a prerequisite to considering allegations of abuse, the court may require independent corroboration, including, but not limited to, written reports by law enforcement agencies, child protective services or other social welfare agencies, courts, medical facilities, or other public agencies or private nonprofit organizations providing services to victims of sexual assault or domestic violence.
(ii)As used in this paragraph, abuse against a child means child abuse or neglect as defined in Section 11165.6 of the Penal Code.
(iii)Abuse against another person, as described in clause (ii) or (iii) of subparagraph (A), means abuse as defined in Section 6203.
(3)The nature and amount of contact with both parents, except as provided in Section 3046.
(4)(A)The habitual or continual illegal use of controlled substances or the habitual or continual abuse of alcohol or prescribed controlled substances by either parent. Before considering these allegations, the court may first require independent corroboration, including, but not limited to, written reports from law enforcement agencies, courts, probation departments, social welfare agencies, medical facilities, rehabilitation facilities, or other public agencies or nonprofit organizations providing drug and alcohol abuse services.
(B)As used in this paragraph, controlled substances has the same meaning as defined in the California Uniform Controlled Substances Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 11000) of the Health and Safety Code).
(5)(A)When allegations about a parent pursuant to paragraph (2) or (4) have been brought to the attention of the court in the current proceeding and the court makes an order for sole or joint custody or unsupervised visitation to that parent, the court shall state its reasons in writing or on the record. In these circumstances, the court shall ensure that an order regarding custody or visitation is specific as to time, day, place, and manner of transfer of the child as set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 6323.
(B)This paragraph does not apply if the parties stipulate in writing or on the record regarding custody or visitation.
(6)A parents affirmation of the childs gender identity because it is in the best interest of the child to affirm their gender identity.(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the court shall not consider the sex, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation of a parent, legal guardian, or relative in determining the best interests of the child.
(a)(1)If a proceeding for a change of name to conform the petitioners name to the petitioners gender identity is commenced by the filing of a petition, the court shall thereupon make an order reciting the filing of the petition, the name of the person by whom it is filed, and the name proposed. The order shall direct all persons interested in the matter to make known any an objection to the change of name by filing a written objection, which includes any the reasons for the objection, within six weeks of the making of the order, order and shall state that if no objection showing good cause to oppose the name change is timely filed, the court shall, without hearing, enter the order that the change of name is granted.
(2)(A)If a petition is filed to change the name of a minor to conform to their gender identity that and the petition does not include the signatures of both living parents, the petition and the order to show cause made in accordance with paragraph (1) shall be served on the parent who did not sign the petition, pursuant to Section 413.10, 414.10, 415.10, or 415.40, within 30 days from the date on which the order is made by the court. If service cannot reasonably be accomplished pursuant to Section 415.10 or 415.40, the court may order that service be accomplished in a manner that the court determines is reasonably calculated to give actual notice to the parent who did not sign the petition.
(B)If a nonconsenting parent objects to a name change to conform to the minors gender identity, the court shall strongly consider that affirming the minors gender identity is in the best interest of the child pursuant to Section 3011 of the Family Code.
(b)The proceeding for a change of name to conform the petitioners name to the petitioners gender identity is exempt from any a requirement for publication.
(c)A hearing date shall not be set in the proceeding unless an objection is timely filed and shows good cause for opposing the name change. Objections based solely on concerns that the proposed change is not the petitioners actual gender identity or gender assigned at birth shall not constitute good cause. At the hearing, the court may examine under oath any of the petitioners, remonstrants, or other persons touching the petition or application, application and may make an order changing the name or dismissing the petition or application as the court may deem right and proper.
SEC. 2.Section 3011 of the Family Code is amended to read:3011.(a)In making a determination of the best interests of the child in a proceeding described in Section 3021, the court shall, among any other factors it finds relevant and consistent with Section 3020, consider all of the following:
(1)The health, safety, and welfare of the child.
(2)(A)A history of abuse by one parent or another person seeking custody against any of the following:
(i)A child to whom the parent or person seeking custody is related by blood or affinity or with whom the parent or person seeking custody has had a caretaking relationship, no matter how temporary.
(ii)The other parent.
(iii)A parent, current spouse, or cohabitant of the parent or person seeking custody, or a person with whom the parent or person seeking custody has a dating or engagement relationship.
(B)(i)As a prerequisite to considering allegations of abuse, the court may require independent corroboration, including, but not limited to, written reports by law enforcement agencies, child protective services or other social welfare agencies, courts, medical facilities, or other public agencies or private nonprofit organizations providing services to victims of sexual assault or domestic violence.
(ii)As used in this paragraph, abuse against a child means child abuse or neglect as defined in Section 11165.6 of the Penal Code.
(iii)Abuse against another person, as described in clause (ii) or (iii) of subparagraph (A), means abuse as defined in Section 6203.
(3)The nature and amount of contact with both parents, except as provided in Section 3046.
(4)(A)The habitual or continual illegal use of controlled substances or the habitual or continual abuse of alcohol or prescribed controlled substances by either parent. Before considering these allegations, the court may first require independent corroboration, including, but not limited to, written reports from law enforcement agencies, courts, probation departments, social welfare agencies, medical facilities, rehabilitation facilities, or other public agencies or nonprofit organizations providing drug and alcohol abuse services.
(B)As used in this paragraph, controlled substances has the same meaning as defined in the California Uniform Controlled Substances Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 11000) of the Health and Safety Code).
(5)(A)When allegations about a parent pursuant to paragraph (2) or (4) have been brought to the attention of the court in the current proceeding and the court makes an order for sole or joint custody or unsupervised visitation to that parent, the court shall state its reasons in writing or on the record. In these circumstances, the court shall ensure that an order regarding custody or visitation is specific as to time, day, place, and manner of transfer of the child as set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 6323.
(B)This paragraph does not apply if the parties stipulate in writing or on the record regarding custody or visitation.
(6)A parents affirmation of the childs gender identity because it is in the best interest of the child to affirm their gender identity.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the court shall not consider the sex, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation of a parent, legal guardian, or relative in determining the best interests of the child.
(a)(1)If a proceeding for a change of name is commenced by the filing of a petition, except as provided in subdivisions (b), (c), (d), and (f), (f) or Section 1277.5, the court shall thereupon make an order reciting the filing of the petition, the name of the person by whom it is filed, and the name proposed. The order shall direct all persons interested in the matter to appear before the court at a time and place specified, which shall be not less than 6 weeks nor more than 12 weeks from the time of making the order, unless the court orders a different time, to show cause why the application for change of name should not be granted. The order shall direct all persons interested in the matter to make known any an objection that they may have to the granting of the petition for change of name by filing a written objection, which includes the reasons for the objection, with the court at least two court days before the matter is scheduled to be heard and by appearing in court at the hearing to show cause why the petition for change of name should not be granted. The order shall state that, if no written objection is timely filed, the court may grant the petition without a hearing.
(2)(A)A copy of the order to show cause shall be published pursuant to Section 6064 of the Government Code in a newspaper of general circulation to be designated in the order published in the county. If a newspaper of general circulation is not published in the county, a copy of the order to show cause shall be posted by the clerk of the court in three of the most public places in the county in which the court is located, located for a like period. Proof shall be made to the satisfaction of the court of this publication or posting at the time of the hearing of the application.
(B)(i)On or after January 1, 2023, if the person whose name is proposed to be changed does not live in the county where the petition is filed, pursuant to subdivision (g) of Section 1276, the copy of the order to show cause shall be published published, pursuant to Section 6064 of the Government Code Code, in a newspaper of general circulation published in the county of the persons residence. If a newspaper of general circulation is not published in the county of the persons residence, a copy of the order to show cause shall be posted by the clerk of the court in the county of the persons residence or a similarly situated local official in three of the most public places in the county of the persons residence, residence for a like period. If the place where the person seeking the name change lives does not have counties, publication shall be made according to the requirements of this paragraph in the local subdivision or territory of the persons residence. Proof shall be made to the satisfaction of the court of this publication or posting at the time of the hearing of the application.
(ii)If the person is unable to publish or post a copy of the order to show cause pursuant to clause (i), the court may allow an alternate method of publication or posting or may waive this requirement after sufficient evidence of diligent efforts to publish or post a copy of the order has been submitted to the satisfaction of the court.
(3)Four weekly publications shall be sufficient publication of the order to show cause. If the order is published in a daily newspaper, publication once a week for four successive weeks shall be sufficient.
(4)(A)If a petition has been filed for a minor by a parent and the other parent, if living, does not join in consenting thereto, the petitioner shall cause, not less than 30 days before the hearing, to be served notice of the time and place of the hearing or a copy of the order to show cause on the other parent pursuant to Section 413.10, 414.10, 415.10, or 415.40. If notice of the hearing cannot reasonably be accomplished pursuant to Section 415.10 or 415.40, the court may order that notice be given in a manner that the court determines is reasonably calculated to give actual notice to the nonconsenting parent. In that case, if the court determines that notice by publication is reasonably calculated to give actual notice to the nonconsenting parent, the court may determine that publication of the order to show cause pursuant to this subdivision is sufficient notice to the nonconsenting parent.
(B)If a nonconsenting parent objects to a name and gender marker change to affirm the minors gender identity, the court shall strongly consider that affirming the minors gender identity is in the best interest of the child pursuant to Section 3011 of the Family Code.
(b)(1)If the petition for a change of name alleges a reason or circumstance described in paragraph (2), (2) and the petitioner has established (A) that the petitioner is they are an active participant in the address confidentiality program created pursuant to Chapter 3.1 (commencing with Section 6205) of Division 7 of Title 1 of the Government Code, Code and (B) that the name the petitioner is seeking to acquire is on file with the Secretary of State, the action for a change of name is exempt from the requirement for publication of the order to show cause under subdivision (a), and the petition and the order of the court shall, in lieu of reciting the proposed name, indicate that the proposed name is confidential and is on file with the Secretary of State pursuant to the provisions of the address confidentiality program.
(2)The procedure described in paragraph (1) applies to petitions alleging any of the following reasons or circumstances:
(A)To avoid domestic violence, violence as defined in Section 6211 of the Family Code.
(B)To avoid stalking, stalking as defined in Section 646.9 of the Penal Code.
(C)To avoid sexual assault, assault as defined in Section 1036.2 of the Evidence Code.
(D)To avoid human trafficking, trafficking as defined in Section 236.1 of the Penal Code.
(3)For any a petition under this subdivision, the current legal name of the petitioner shall be kept confidential by the court and shall not be published or posted in the courts calendars, indexes, or register of actions, as required by Article 7 (commencing with Section 69840) of Chapter 5 of Title 8 of the Government Code, or by any means or in any a public forum, including a hardcopy or hardcopy, an electronic copy, or any other type of public media or display.
(4)Notwithstanding paragraph (3), the court may, at the request of the petitioner, issue an order reciting the name of the petitioner at the time of the filing of the petition and the new legal name of the petitioner as a result of the courts granting of the petition.
(5)A petitioner may request that the court file the petition and any other papers associated with the proceeding under seal. The court may consider the request at the same time as the petition for name change, change and may grant the request in any a case in which the court finds that all of the following factors apply:
(A)There exists an overriding interest that overcomes the right of public access to the record.
(B)The overriding interest supports sealing the record.
(C)A substantial probability exists that the overriding interest will be prejudiced if the record is not sealed.
(D)The proposed order to seal the records is narrowly tailored.
(E)No less restrictive means exist to achieve the overriding interest.
(c)If the petition is filed for a minor or nonminor dependent who is under the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, the action for a change of name is exempt from the requirement for publication of the order to show cause under subdivision (a).
(d)A proceeding for a change of name for a witness participating in the state Witness Relocation and Assistance Program Program, established by Title 7.5 (commencing with Section 14020) of Part 4 of the Penal Code Code, who has been approved for the change of name by the program program, is exempt from the requirement for publication of the order to show cause under subdivision (a).
(e)If an application for change of name is brought as part of an action under the Uniform Parentage Act (Part 3 (commencing with Section 7600) of Division 12 of the Family Code), whether as part of a petition or cross-complaint or as a separate order to show cause in a pending action thereunder, service of the application shall be made upon all other parties to the action in a like manner as prescribed for the service of a summons, summons as set forth in Article 3 (commencing with Section 415.10) of Chapter 4 of Title 5 of Part 2. Upon the setting of a hearing on the issue, notice of the hearing shall be given to all parties in the action in a like manner and within the time limits prescribed generally for the type of hearing (whether hearing, whether trial or order to show cause) cause, at which the issue of the change of name is to be decided.
(f)If a guardian files a petition to change the name of the guardians minor ward pursuant to Section 1276:
(1)The guardian shall provide notice of the hearing to any living parent of the minor by personal service at least 30 days before the hearing.
(2)If either or both parents are deceased or cannot be located, the guardian shall cause, not less than 30 days before the hearing, to be served a notice of the time and place of the hearing or a copy of the order to show cause on the childs grandparents, if living, pursuant to Section 413.10, 414.10, 415.10, or 415.40.
SEC. 2.Section 3011 of the Family Code is amended to read:3011.(a)In making a determination of the best interests of the child in a proceeding described in Section 3021, the court shall, among any other factors it finds relevant and consistent with Section 3020, consider all of the following:
(1)The health, safety, and welfare of the child.
(2)(A)A history of abuse by one parent or any other another person seeking custody against any of the following:
(i)A child to whom the parent or person seeking custody is related by blood or affinity or with whom the parent or person seeking custody has had a caretaking relationship, no matter how temporary.
(ii)The other parent.
(iii)A parent, current spouse, or cohabitant, cohabitant of the parent or person seeking custody, or a person with whom the parent or person seeking custody has a dating or engagement relationship.
(B)(i)As a prerequisite to considering allegations of abuse, the court may require independent corroboration, including, but not limited to, written reports by law enforcement agencies, child protective services or other social welfare agencies, courts, medical facilities, or other public agencies or private nonprofit organizations providing services to victims of sexual assault or domestic violence. As
(ii)As used in this paragraph, abuse against a child means child abuse and or neglect as defined in Section 11165.6 of the Penal Code and abuse Code.
(iii)Abuse against any other person another person, as described in clause (ii) or (iii) of subparagraph (A) (A), means abuse as defined in Section 6203.
(3)The nature and amount of contact with both parents, except as provided in Section 3046.
(4)(A)The habitual or continual illegal use of controlled substances, substances or the habitual or continual abuse of alcohol, or the habitual or continual abuse of alcohol or prescribed controlled substances by either parent. Before considering these allegations, the court may first require independent corroboration, including, but not limited to, written reports from law enforcement agencies, courts, probation departments, social welfare agencies, medical facilities, rehabilitation facilities, or other public agencies or nonprofit organizations providing drug and alcohol abuse services. As
(B)As used in this paragraph, controlled substances has the same meaning as defined in the California Uniform Controlled Substances Act (Division 10 (commencing with Section 11000) of the Health and Safety Code).
(5)(A)When allegations about a parent pursuant to paragraph (2) or (4) have been brought to the attention of the court in the current proceeding, proceeding and the court makes an order for sole or joint custody or unsupervised visitation to that parent, the court shall state its reasons in writing or on the record. In these circumstances, the court shall ensure that any an order regarding custody or visitation is specific as to time, day, place, and manner of transfer of the child as set forth in subdivision (c) of Section 6323.
(B)This paragraph does not apply if the parties stipulate in writing or on the record regarding custody or visitation.
(6)A parents affirmation of the childs gender identity.
(b)Notwithstanding subdivision (a), the court shall not consider the sex, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation of a parent, legal guardian, or relative in determining the best interests of the child.
|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jan 29, 2024 | Consideration of Governor's veto stricken from file. |
| Jan 3, 2024 | Consideration of Governor's veto pending. |
| Sep 22, 2023 | Vetoed by Governor. |
| Sep 14, 2023 | Enrolled and presented to the Governor at 4:30 p.m. |
| Sep 8, 2023 | Senate amendments concurred in. To Engrossing and Enrolling. (Ayes 61. Noes 16. Page 3123.). |
| Sep 7, 2023 | Assembly Rule 77 suspended. (Page 3011.) |
| Sep 6, 2023 | In Assembly. Concurrence in Senate amendments pending. May be considered on or after September 8 pursuant to Assembly Rule 77. |
| Sep 6, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Assembly. (Ayes 30. Noes 9. Page 2402.). |
| Aug 21, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Aug 17, 2023 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jul 5, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jul 3, 2023 | Read third time and amended. Ordered to second reading. |
| Jun 15, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Jun 14, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 8. Noes 2.) (June 13). |
| Jun 5, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| May 3, 2023 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 30, 2023 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| Mar 30, 2023 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 51. Noes 13. Page 998.) |
| Mar 22, 2023 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| Mar 21, 2023 | From committee: Do pass. (Ayes 8. Noes 3.) (March 21). |
| Mar 14, 2023 | Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Mar 13, 2023 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to Com. on JUD. Read second time and amended. |
| Feb 23, 2023 | Referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Feb 15, 2023 | From printer. May be heard in committee March 17. |
| Feb 14, 2023 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sep 8, 2023 | AB 957 Wilson Concurrence in Senate Amendments | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Sep 6, 2023 | Assembly 3rd Reading AB957 Wilson et al. By Umberg | Senate Floor |
Passed |
|
| Jun 13, 2023 | Do pass | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Mar 30, 2023 | AB 957 Wilson Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| Mar 21, 2023 | Do pass. | Assembly Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| 2-1-1 los angeles county | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Aclu California Action | ** Support | |
| affirming transgender children is right for Some families, but not all | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| AMAAD Institute | ** Support | |
| Anti-Defamation League | ** Support | |
| Arming Minorities Against Addiction & Disease Institute | ** Support | |
| Bridge Network | ** Against | |
| California Alliance Of Child And Family Services | * Support | Jun 13, 2023 |
| California Capital Connection for Independent Baptist Churches | * Against | Mar 21, 2023 |
| California Capitol Connection | ** Against | |
| California Catholic Conference | ** Against | |
| California Catholic Families 4 Freedom CA | ** Against | |
| California Coalition For Youth | ** Support | |
| California Faculty Association | ** Support | |
| California Family Council | ** Against | |
| California Latinas for Reproductive Justice | ** Support | |
| California LGBT Health and Human Services Network | ** Support | |
| California LGBTQ Health and Human Services Network | ** Support | |
| California Parents Rights Act Now | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| California Parents Union | ** Against | |
| California Policy Center | ** Against | |
| California Resident | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| California Rise Up | ** Against | |
| California State PTA | ** Support | |
| California TGI Policy Alliance | ** Support | |
| California Transgender, Gender-nonconforming and Intersex Policy Alliance | ** Support | |
| California Youth Empowerment Network | ** Support | |
| California’s Legislative Voice | ** Against | |
| Carlsbad C2O | ** Against | |
| Central Coast Health Coalition | ** Against | |
| CHANGED Movement | ** Against | |
| Chico Environmental Health Advocacy | * Against | Mar 21, 2023 |
| Children's Legal Services of San Diego | ** Support | |
| Children’s Legal Services | ** Support | |
| Citizens for Choice | ** Support | |
| City Of Huntington Beach | ** Against | |
| City Of Riverside | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| City Of Sacramento | ** Support | |
| City Of Temecula | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Coachman Moore & Associates | ** Support | |
| Coachman Moore and Associates | ** Support | |
| Coalition of Mothers and Grandmothers of Orange County | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Concerned Women for America Legislative Action Committee | ** Against | |
| County Of Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| Desert AIDS Project | ** Support | |
| Disability Rights Califonia | * Support | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Eagle Forum California | ** Against | |
| El Dorado Hills Republican women | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Ella Baker Center For Human Rights | ** Support | |
| EmpowerTHEM Collective | ** Support | |
| Equal Rights Advocates | * Support | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Equality California | ** Support | |
| face to face | ** Support | |
| Faith Baptist Church | * Against | Mar 21, 2023 |
| Fieldstead And Company | ** Against | |
| Frederick Douglass Foundation of California | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Freedom Angels | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Gender Justice Los Angeles | ** Support | |
| Grandmother | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Grandmother | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Harm Reduction Institute | ** Support | |
| Highland, California | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Informed parents of Contra Costa | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| International Federation for Therapeutic and Counselling Choice | ** Against | |
| La Mirindans for education | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Lighthouse Baptist Church Marino Valley | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Los Angeles LGBT Center | ** Support | |
| MOM Army | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Moms for liberty | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Moms for Liberty Placer County | ** Against | |
| Monterey County | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Mora Employment Law | * Support | Jun 13, 2023 |
| NARAL Pro-Choice California | ** Support | |
| National Association of Social Workers California Chapter | ** Support | |
| National Center for Lesbian Rights | ** Support | |
| National Center for Youth Law | * Support | Jun 13, 2023 |
| National Harm Reduction Coalition | ** Support | |
| National Health Law Program | ** Support | |
| None | * Against | Mar 21, 2023 |
| Orange County | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Our Duty | ** Against | |
| Pacific Justice Institute | ** Against | |
| Perk Advocacy | ** Against | |
| Placer County Board of Supervisors | ** Against | |
| Planned Parent Affiliates of California | * Support | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Radiant Health Centers | ** Support | |
| Real Impact | ** Against | |
| Rebuild California | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| registered nurse | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Sacramento LGBT Community Center | ** Support | |
| Sacramento Stonewall Democratic Club | * Support | Jun 13, 2023 |
| San Diego | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| San Gabriel Valley LGBTQ Center | ** Support | |
| San Joaquin County Republican Assembly | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| San Mateo County | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Santa Clara County | * Against | Mar 21, 2023 |
| Silicon Valley Association of Republican Women | ** Against | |
| Soldiers of St. Michael of Elk Grove | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Solid Rock Baptist Tabernacle | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Solis Policy Institute | * Support | Mar 21, 2023 |
| Somos Familia Valle | ** Support | |
| Source LGBT+ Center | ** Support | |
| Special Education Teacher | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Stand Up Sacramento County | ** Against | |
| Standing for Women | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| TEACH | ** Support | |
| TGI Policy Alliance | * Support | Jun 13, 2023 |
| the san diego lgbt community center | ** Support | |
| The Western Center on Law and Poverty | * Support | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Traditional Values for the Next Generation | ** Against | |
| Traditional Values Next Generation - TV Next | * Against | Jun 13, 2023 |
| Trans Youth Liberation | ** Support | |
| Transfamily Support Services | ** Support | |
| Transgender Advisory Council, Office of Lt. Governor Eleni Kounalakis | ** Support | |
| Valorus | ** Support | |
| Womens Foundation of California | ** Support | |
| Womens Health Specialists of California | ** Support |
GOVERNOR'S VETO
GV Bill Id:AB 957
Author:(Wilson)
As Enrolled Ver:September 11, 2023
2/3 vote
SUMMARY
Requires a court to consider a minor's gender identity or gender expression when determining the best interest of the child, as specified.
Major Provisions
Requires a court, when determining the best interests of a child in a child custody or visitation proceeding, to consider, among other factors, a parent's affirmation of the child's gender identity or gender expression.
Senate Amendments
- Delete the naming provisions of this bill.
- Clarify the provision of existing law that enumerates the factors that a court must consider in determining the best interest of a child when making orders regarding the physical or legal custody or visitation of children to include a parent's affirmation of the child's gender identity or gender expression.
- Incorporate changes made to Family Code Section 3011 by SB 599 (Caballero) of the current legislative session and add chaptering provisions.
Governor’s Veto Message
This legislation would require a court, when determining the best interests of a child in a child custody or visitation proceeding, to consider, among other comprehensive factors, a parent's affirmation of the child's gender identity or gender expression.
I appreciate the passion and values that led the author to introduce this bill. I share a deep commitment to advancing the rights of transgender Californians, an effort that has guided my decisions through many decades in public office.
That said, I urge caution when the Executive and Legislative branches of state government attempt to dictate - in prescriptive terms that single out one characteristic - legal standards for the Judicial branch to apply. Other-minded elected officials, in California and other states, could very well use this strategy to diminish the civil rights of vulnerable communities.
Moreover, a court, under existing law, is required to consider a child's health, safety, and welfare when determining the best interests of a child in these proceedings, including the parent's affirmation of the child's gender identity.
COMMENTS
This bill would require the court, when making an order regarding the physical or legal custody or visitation of children, to consider a parent's affirmation of their child's gender identity or gender expression. The bill specifies that "affirmation" includes a range of actions and will be unique for each child, but in every case must promote the child's overall health and well-being. This does not necessarily require the court to side with the parent that affirms a child's gender identity. Existing law requires the court to consider several factors which prioritize the health, safety, and welfare of the child. For example, the court is required to consider, among other factors it deems relevant, whether either parent has a history of abusing drugs or alcohol or of committing acts of physical abuse. The court may also consider the nature of the amount of contact that the child has had with both parents. This bill would merely add a parent's affirmation of the child's gender identity or gender expression as an additional factor that a court would weigh in favor of the best interest of the child.
Notwithstanding the concerns of some opponents, this bill does not mark a major change in family law policy. The courts will continue to give paramount importance to the best of interest of the child based on multiple factors; an affirmation of gender identity or gender expression will be added as one of those factors.
According to the Author
According to the author, when two parents do not agree on affirming the gender identity of their TGI (transgender, gender diverse, or intersex) child, existing statutes do not provide guidance to the court on how to determine the TGI child's best interest. The author and many of the supporters point to studies showing that TGI youth are at much higher risk for depression, mental health crises, and suicidal thoughts than their cisgender peers. The author argues that having "at least one adult in a child's life who affirms their gender identity decreases their chances of attempting suicide significantly." Moreover, many TGI minors face health and safety risks in their homes if they have non-affirming caretakers. The author believes this bill will clarify that "affirming a child's gender identity is in the best interest of the child for purposes of decisions on matters of child custody and gender-affirming petitions to change names and gender markers."
Arguments in Support
Equality California (EC), one of the co-sponsors of this bill, writes that while "states across the country are passing discriminatory policies attacking LGBTQ+ people, especially transgender and non-binary youth, AB 957 will ensure that California TGI youth have access to a legal system that affirms and protects their health, safety, and livelihood." EC notes that while TGI youth face higher rates of mental illness and suicidal thoughts, research shows that they do much better with supportive parents who affirm rather than disapprove of their gender identity. EC also observes that while the Family Code lists several factors that a court should consider when determining the best interests of the child, it "fails to take into account this very vulnerable population of [TGI] children who are at increased risk of harm." This bill, EC concludes, "will center the health and well-being of TGI youth by clarifying that affirming their gender identity is in their best interest."
The California chapter of the National Association of Social Workers (NASW-CA) believes this bill "is important for transgender youth, as it prioritizes the best interest of the child for legal name change and custody decision purposes." NASW-CA notes that California has already taken strides to protect transgender youth, and that this bill will offer further protection to transgender youth "if they come to California from such states as Alabama, which criminalizes gender-affirming care." Finally, NASW-CA notes that its Code of Ethics includes "advocating for social justice for those who are marginalized and vulnerable. This bill would do just that, ensuring that transgender youth dignity and worth is upheld and the court system ensures their gender identity is affirmed. With the nation increasingly creating anti-trans youth bills, this is a necessary counter-measure."
Arguments in Opposition
The California Capitol Connection opposes this bill because it will undermine the current law that "allows parents to object to their child's request for a change of gender and/or name on government documents." They fear this bill will instead "force family courts to ignore the parents' objections and rule in favor of the minor's request. Parents are responsible for the well-being of their children. Parents should have the final say in every major decision a minor makes." Finally, the California Capital Connection points to a higher law: "The Bible and nature also teach us that there are only two genders. Genesis 1:27 says, "So God created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him; male and female created he them."
The California Parents' Union (CPU) opposes this bill because it would violate judicial independence. CPU argues that no judge "can be dictated to - by the legislature - as to how to rule on a case. [Judges] are required to rule based on the law and the facts before them objectively and without bias. I would submit this is especially important when a ruling is based on a very dangerous issue that could result in a permanent life altering decision. The undisputed fact is that participating in changing "genders" of a minor child is extremely controversial and medically dangerous. Judges cannot be told to favor one side or the other ethically."
FISCAL COMMENTS
None
VOTES
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-3-0
YES: Maienschein, Connolly, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, Robert Rivas
NO: Essayli, Dixon, Sanchez
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 51-13-16
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner Horvath, Bryan, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gipson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Pacheco, Papan, Petrie-Norris, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Wallis, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NO: Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Hoover, Lackey, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Ta, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Alanis, Alvarez, Bonta, Calderon, Chen, Flora, Gabriel, Garcia, Grayson, Irwin, Kalra, Mathis, Ortega, Pellerin, Quirk-Silva, Ward
SENATE FLOOR: 30-9-1
YES: Allen, Archuleta, Ashby, Atkins, Becker, Blakespear, Bradford, Caballero, Cortese, Dodd, Durazo, Eggman, Glazer, Gonzalez, Laird, Limón, McGuire, Menjivar, Min, Newman, Padilla, Portantino, Roth, Rubio, Skinner, Smallwood-Cuevas, Stern, Umberg, Wahab, Wiener
NO: Alvarado-Gil, Dahle, Grove, Jones, Nguyen, Niello, Ochoa Bogh, Seyarto, Wilk
ABS, ABST OR NV: Hurtado
UPDATED
VERSION: September 11, 2023
CONSULTANT: Tom Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001298
CONCURRENCE IN SENATE AMENDMENTS
CSA1 Bill Id:AB 957
Author:(Wilson)
As Amended Ver:August 17, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires a court to consider a minor's gender identity or gender expression when determining the best interest of the child, as specified.
Major Provisions
Requires a court, when determining the best interests of a child in a child custody or visitation proceeding, to consider, among other factors, a parent's affirmation of the child's gender identity or gender expression.
Senate Amendments
- Delete the naming provisions of the bill.
- Clarify the provision of existing law that enumerates the factors that a court must consider in determining the best interest of a child when making orders regarding the physical or legal custody or visitation of children to include a parent's affirmation of the child's gender identity or gender expression.
- Incorporate changes made to Section 3011 of the Family Code by SB 599 and add chaptering provisions.
COMMENTS
This bill would require the court, when making an order regarding the physical or legal custody or visitation of children, to consider a parent's affirmation of their child's gender identity or gender expression. The bill specifies that "affirmation" includes a range of actions and will be unique for each child, but in every case must promote the child's overall health and well-being. This does not necessarily require the court to side with the parent that affirms a child's gender identity. Existing law requires the court to consider several factors which prioritize the health, safety, and welfare of the child. For example, the court is required to consider, among other factors it deems relevant, whether either parent has a history of abusing drugs or alcohol or of committing acts of physical abuse. The court may also consider the nature of the amount of contact that the child has had with both parents. This bill would merely add a parent's affirmation of the child's gender identity or gender expression as an additional factor that a court would weigh in favor of the best interest of the child.
Notwithstanding the concerns of some opponents, the bill does not mark a major change in family law policy. The courts will continue to give paramount importance to the best of interest of the child based on multiple factors; an affirmation of gender identity or gender expression will be added as one of those factors.
According to the Author
According to the author, when two parents do not agree on affirming the gender identity of their TGI (transgender, gender diverse, or intersex) child, existing statutes do not provide guidance to the court on how to determine the TGI child's best interest. The author and many of the supporters point to studies showing that TGI youth are at much higher risk for depression, mental health crises, and suicidal thoughts than their cisgender peers. The author argues that having "at least one adult in a child's life who affirms their gender identity decreases their chances of attempting suicide significantly." Moreover, many TGI minors face health and safety risks in their homes if they have non-affirming caretakers. The author believes this bill will clarify that "affirming a child's gender identity is in the best interest of the child for purposes of decisions on matters of child custody and gender-affirming petitions to change names and gender markers."
Arguments in Support
Equality California (EC), one of the co-sponsors of this bill, writes that while "states across the country are passing discriminatory policies attacking LGBTQ+ people, especially transgender and non-binary youth, AB 957 will ensure that California TGI youth have access to a legal system that affirms and protects their health, safety, and livelihood." EC notes that while TGI youth face higher rates of mental illness and suicidal thoughts, research shows that they do much better with supportive parents who affirm rather than disapprove of their gender identity. EC also observes that while the Family Code lists several factors that a court should consider when determining the best interests of the child, it "fails to take into account this very vulnerable population of [TGI] children who are at increased risk of harm." This bill, EC concludes, "will center the health and well-being of TGI youth by clarifying that affirming their gender identity is in their best interest."
The California chapter of the National Association of Social Workers (NASW-CA) believes this bill "is important for transgender youth, as it prioritizes the best interest of the child for legal name change and custody decision purposes." NASW-CA notes that California has already taken strides to protect transgender youth, and that this bill will offer further protection to transgender youth "if they come to California from such states as Alabama, which criminalizes gender-affirming care." Finally, NASW-CA notes that its Code of Ethics includes "advocating for social justice for those who are marginalized and vulnerable. This bill would do just that, ensuring that transgender youth dignity and worth is upheld and the court system ensures their gender identity is affirmed. With the nation increasingly creating anti-trans youth bills, this is a necessary counter-measure."
Arguments in Opposition
The California Capitol Connection opposes this bill because it will undermine the current law that "allows parents to object to their child's request for a change of gender and/or name on government documents." They fear this bill will instead "force family courts to ignore the parents' objections and rule in favor of the minor's request. Parents are responsible for the well-being of their children. Parents should have the final say in every major decision a minor makes." Finally, the California Capital Connection points to a higher law: "The Bible and nature also teach us that there are only two genders. Genesis 1:27 says, "So God created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him; male and female created he them."
The California Parents' Union (CPU) opposes this bill because it would violate judicial independence. CPU argues that no judge "can be dictated to - by the legislature - as to how to rule on a case. [Judges] are required to rule based on the law and the facts before them objectively and without bias. I would submit this is especially important when a ruling is based on a very dangerous issue that could result in a permanent life altering decision. The undisputed fact is that participating in changing "genders" of a minor child is extremely controversial and medically dangerous. Judges cannot be told to favor one side or the other ethically."
FISCAL COMMENTS
None
VOTES:
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-3-0
YES: Maienschein, Connolly, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, Robert Rivas
NO: Essayli, Dixon, Sanchez
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 51-13-16
YES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner Horvath, Bryan, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gipson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Pacheco, Papan, Petrie-Norris, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Wallis, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NO: Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Hoover, Lackey, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Ta, Waldron
ABS, ABST OR NV: Alanis, Alvarez, Bonta, Calderon, Chen, Flora, Gabriel, Garcia, Grayson, Irwin, Kalra, Mathis, Ortega, Pellerin, Quirk-Silva, Ward
UPDATED
VERSION: August 17, 2023
CONSULTANT: Tom Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0001298
SENATE RULES COMMITTEE Office of Senate Floor Analyses (916) 651-1520 Fax: (916) 327-4478 | AB 957 |
THIRD READING
Bill No: AB 957
Author: Wilson (D), et al.
Amended: 8/17/23 in Senate
Vote: 21
SENATE JUDICIARY COMMITTEE: 8-2, 6/13/23
AYES: Umberg, Allen, Ashby, Caballero, Durazo, Laird, Min, Wiener
NOES: Wilk, Niello
NO VOTE RECORDED: Stern
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 51-13, 3/30/23 - See last page for vote
SUBJECT: Family law: gender identity
SOURCE: California State PTA
California TGI Policy Alliance
EmpowerTHEM Collective
Equality California
Gender Justice Los Angeles
Los Angeles LGBT Center
TransFamily Support Services
TransYouth Liberation
Women’s Foundation of California
DIGEST:
This bill clarifies that a family court, when determining the best interest of the child in a proceeding to determine custody or visitation for a child, shall consider, as one comprehensive factor in the consideration of the health, safety, and welfare of the child, a parent’s affirmation of the child’s gender identity or gender expression; and provides that “affirmation” includes a range of actions and will be unique for each child, but in every case must promote the child’s overall health and well-being.
Senate Floor Amendments of 8/17/23 make nonsubstantive changes to avoid a chaptering conflict with SB 599 (Caballero, 2023).
ANALYSIS:
Existing law:
- States that it is the public policy of this state to ensure that:
- The health, safety, and welfare of children is the court’s primary concern in determining the best interests of children when making any orders regarding the physical or legal custody or visitation of children;
- Children have the right to be safe and free from abuse, because the perpetration of child abuse or domestic violence in a household where a child resides is detrimental to the health, safety, and welfare of the child; and
- Children have frequent and continuing contact with both parents after the parents have separated or dissolved their marriage, or ended their relationship, and parents are encouraged to share the rights and responsibilities of child rearing in order to effect this policy, except when the contact would not be in the best interests of the child, as provided. (Fam. Code, § 3020(a), (b).).
- Requires a court, when determining the best interest of the child in a proceeding to determine child custody and visitation rights, to consider all of the following and any other factors it find relevant:
- The health, safety, and welfare of the child.
- A history of abuse by one parent or any other person seeking custody against a child to whom the parent is related or with whom the parent has a caretaking relationship, as specified; the other parent; a parent, current spouse, of the parent, or a person with whom the parent has a dating or engagement relationship.
- The nature and amount of contact with both parents.
- The habitual or continual illegal use of controlled substances and the habitual or continual abuse of alcohol or prescribed controlled substances, as specified. (Fam. Code, §§ 3011, 3021.)
- Establishes an order of preference for custody of a child, starting with jointly to both parents or to either parent, which is subject to the best interest of the child as set forth in 1) and 2). (Fam. Code, § 3040.)
This bill:
- Clarifies that, as part of the court’s obligation to determine the best interests of a child in a custody proceeding, the “health, safety, and welfare of the child” includes, among other comprehensive factors, a parent’s affirmation of the child’s gender identity or gender expression; affirmation includes a range of actions and will be unique for each child, but in every case must promote the child’s overall health and well-being.
- Makes nonsubstantive technical and conforming changes.
Comments
“Under California’s statutory scheme governing child custody and visitation determinations, the overarching concern is the best interest of the child.”[1] That scheme “allows the court and the family the widest discretion to choose a parenting plan that is in the best interest of the child.”[2] When determining the best interest of a child, a court may consider any relevant factors, and must consider the following: the health, safety, and welfare of the child; any history of abuse or neglect by the party seeking custody; the nature and amount of contact with the parents; and substance abuse by a parent.[3] The analysis is always informed by the fact that the right to participate in the raising of one’s child is a protected constitutional right that cannot be cast aside without good cause.[4]
While the correlation between gender acceptance and the mental health and safety of transgender youth is clear,[5] the Family Code does not currently explicitly require a court to consider gender affirmation when determining the best interest of a child for purposes of custody or visitation. This bill simply clarifies that family courts, when making determinations about a child’s best interest in a custody or visitation proceeding, must consider, as one factor comprising the health, safety, and welfare of the child, a parent’s affirmation of the child’s gender identity or gender expression. The bill further clarifies that “affirmation” is different for each child and does not require any particular types of responses, provided that the parent’s response promotes the overall health and well-being. This bill does not compel the court to come to a particular outcome based on this factor or override the court’s discretion to reach a determination about the child’s best interest in light of all of the facts;[6] it merely makes explicit the fact that affirmance of a child’s gender identity or gender expression is an important component of a child’s overall health, safety, and welfare which should be considered by the family court.
FISCAL EFFECT: Appropriation: No Fiscal Com.: No Local: No
SUPPORT: (Verified 8/29/23)
California State PTA (co-source)
California TGI Policy Alliance (co-source)
EmpowerTHEM Collective (co-source)
Equality California (co-source)
Gender Justice Los Angeles (co-source)
Los Angeles LGBT Center (co-source)
TransFamily Support Services (co-source)
TransYouth Liberation (co-source)
Women’s Foundation of California (co-source)
ACLU California Action
Anti-Defamation League
Arming Minorities Against Addiction & Disease Institute
California Coalition for Youth
California Faculty Association
California Latinas for Reproductive Justice
California LGBTQ Health and Human Services Network
California Youth Empowerment Network
Children’s Legal Services of San Diego
Citizens for Choice
City of Sacramento
Coachman Moore & Associates
County of Los Angeles
Desert AIDS Project
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Face to Face
Harm Reduction Institute
NARAL Pro-Choice California
National Association of Social Workers – California Chapter
National Center for Lesbian Rights
National Harm Reduction Coalition
National Health Law Program
Radiant Health Centers
Sacramento LGBT Community Center
San Gabriel Valley LGBTQ+ Center
Somos Familia Valle
Source LGBT+ Center
TEACH
The San Diego LGBT Community Center
Transgender Advisory Council, Office of Lt. Governor Eleni Kounalakis
ValorUS
Women’s Health Specialists of California
OPPOSITION: (Verified 8/29/23)
Bridge Network
California Capitol Connection
California Catholic Conference
California Catholic Families 4 Freedom CA
California Family Council
California Parents Union
California Policy Center
California Rise Up
California’s Legislative Voice
Carlsbad C2O
Central Coast Health Coalition
CHANGED Movement
City of Huntington Beach
Concerned Women for America Legislative Action Committee
Eagle Forum California
Fieldstead and Company
International Federation for Therapeutic and Counselling Choice
Moms for Liberty Placer County
Our Duty
Pacific Justice Institute
PERK Advocacy
Placer County Board of Supervisors
Real Impact
Silicon Valley Association of Republican Women
Stand Up Sacramento County
Traditional Values for the Next Generation
Approximately 280 individuals
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: According to TransFamily Support Services and TransYouth Liberation, two of the bill’s sponsors:
The Family Code is intended to center the child’s best interest in decisions about visitation and custody. California Family Code section 3011 lists several factors to consider when determining the child’s best interest. Still, it fails to consider this vulnerable population of children at increased risk of harm. [This bill] will provide gender-affirming parents with the support needed to continue to love and affirm their diverse [transgender, gender-diverse, and intersex] children.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: According to PERK Advocacy:
A parent’s ability to love, care for, and provide a safe environment for the child should be the focus of concern. Custody and visitation rights for parents should not be based on a minor’s gender identity or the parent’s support of how their minor child identifies. Furthermore, a parent’s affirmation of the child’s gender identity does not determine if the parent is a safe or appropriate option compared to their counterpart. The health, safety, and welfare of the child requires consideration of a variety of issues, some having more weight than others as not all families are in the same situations. It is irresponsible not to side with parents who have valid concerns and err on the side of caution for the child’s health and wellbeing.
ASSEMBLY FLOOR: 51-13, 3/30/23
AYES: Addis, Aguiar-Curry, Arambula, Bains, Bauer-Kahan, Bennett, Berman, Boerner Horvath, Bryan, Juan Carrillo, Wendy Carrillo, Cervantes, Connolly, Mike Fong, Friedman, Gipson, Haney, Hart, Holden, Jackson, Jones-Sawyer, Lee, Low, Lowenthal, Maienschein, McCarty, McKinnor, Muratsuchi, Stephanie Nguyen, Pacheco, Papan, Petrie-Norris, Ramos, Reyes, Luz Rivas, Robert Rivas, Rodriguez, Blanca Rubio, Santiago, Schiavo, Soria, Ting, Valencia, Villapudua, Wallis, Weber, Wicks, Wilson, Wood, Zbur, Rendon
NOES: Megan Dahle, Davies, Dixon, Essayli, Vince Fong, Gallagher, Hoover, Lackey, Jim Patterson, Joe Patterson, Sanchez, Ta, Waldron
NO VOTE RECORDED: Alanis, Alvarez, Bonta, Calderon, Chen, Flora, Gabriel, Garcia, Grayson, Irwin, Kalra, Mathis, Ortega, Pellerin, Quirk-Silva, Ward
Prepared by: Allison Whitt Meredith / JUD. / (916) 651-4113
8/29/23 13:12:00
**** END ****
Montenegro v. Diaz (2001) 26 Cal.4th 249, 255; see §§ 3011, 3020, 3040 & 3041. ↑
Fam. Code, § 3040. ↑
Id., §§ 3011, 3020. ↑
E.g., Troxel v. Granville (2000) 530 U.S. 57, 65-66. ↑
E.g., Price & Green, Association of Identity Acceptance with Fewer Suicide Attempts Among Transgender and Nonbinary Youth, Transgender Health, Vol. 1, No. 1 (Feb. 2023), p. 56; Jin, et al., Maternal Support Is Protective Against Suicidal Ideation Among a Diverse Cohort of Young Transgender Women, LGBT Health, 7(7): 349-357 (Oct. 2020); University of Texas at Austin, UT News, Using Chosen Names Reduces Odds of Depression and Suicide in Transgender Youths (Mar. 30, 2018), https://news.utexas.edu/2018/03/30/name-use-matters-for-transgender-youths-mental-health/. All links in this analysis are current as of July 5, 2023. ↑
For example, certain opponents of the bill argue that this bill will compel judges to overlook evidence that a child is being harmed in the form of overly accelerated surgical gender-affirming care. This is incorrect: the judge retains the discretion to look at all of the factors contributing to the child’s health, safety, and welfare, including whether gender-affirming treatments are being provided consistent with the recommendations of medical professionals (which correlates with positive mental health outcomes for transgender youth). (See, e.g., Tordoff, et al., Mental Health Outcomes in Transgender and Nonbinary Youths Receiving Gender-Affirming Care, JAMA Network, Pediatrics (Feb. 25, 2022), available at https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2789423). ↑
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2023-2024 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 957 (Author:Wilson)
Version: June 5, 2023
Hearing Date: June 13, 2023
Fiscal: No
Urgency: No
Consultant: AWM
SUBJECT
Family law: gender identity
DIGEST
This bill clarifies that a family court, when determining the best interest of the child in a proceeding to determine custody or visitation for a child, shall consider, as part of the consideration of the health, safety, and welfare of the child, a parent’s affirmation of the child’s gender identity.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Under California law, the overarching principle in a court’s determination in a parental custody or visitation case is the best interest of the child. What constitutes the best interest of the child is an intensely fact-specific determination that requires the court to look at the child’s health, safety, and welfare, the child’s relationship with each parent, and other factors that may contribute to the overall wellbeing of the child. The Legislature has, over the past few decades, added more specific factors for courts to consider (such as in cases where there have been allegations of domestic violence) and expressly prohibited courts from considering other factors (such as the immigration status of a parent) to ensure that the child’s best interest remains paramount.
One factor that is strongly correlated with the health, safety, and wellbeing of a child is the affirmation of their gender identity. As explained further in Part 2 of this analysis, the numbers are staggering: nearly one in five transgender or nonbinary youth in California have attempted suicide, and over half of them have seriously considered suicide. Parental affirmation of a child’s gender identity, however, reduces the odds that a transgender or nonbinary youth will attempt suicide by over 50 percent. In recognition of the clear connection between gender affirmance and a child’s mental health, this bill clarifies that, as part of a court’s holistic consideration of the child’s health, safety, and welfare, the court must consider whether each parent affirms the child’s gender identity. The consideration of a parent’s affirmance, or lack thereof, will not be determinative in the court’s custody or visitation order; the bill simply makes clear that gender-affirmance should be considered as part of the comprehensive determination of the child’s best interest.
This bill is sponsored by the California State PTA, the California TGI Policy Alliance, the EmpowerTHEM Collective, Equality California, Gender Justice Los Angeles, the Los Angeles LGBT Center, TransFamily Support Services, TransYouth Liberation, and the Women’s Foundation of California, and is supported by the California Faculty Association, the California Youth Empowerment Network. This bill is opposed by Bridge Network, the California Parents Union, California’s Legislative Voice, Carlsbad C2O, the Silicon Valley Association of American Women, Stand Up Sacramento County, and 14 individuals.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- States that it is the public policy of this state to ensure that:
- The health, safety, and welfare of children is the court’s primary concern in determining the best interests of children when making any orders regarding the physical or legal custody or visitation of children;
- Children have the right to be safe and free from abuse, because the perpetration of child abuse or domestic violence in a household where a child resides is detrimental to the health, safety, and welfare of the child; and
- Children have frequent and continuing contact with both parents after the parents have separated or dissolved their marriage, or ended their relationship, and parents are encouraged to share the rights and responsibilities of child rearing in order to effect this policy, except when the contact would not be in the best interests of the child, as provided. (Fam. Code, § 3020(a), (b).).
- Requires a court, when determining the best interest of the child in a proceeding to determine child custody and visitation rights, to consider all of the following and any other factors it find relevant:
- The health, safety, and welfare of the child.
- A history of abuse by one parent or any other person seeking custody against a child to whom the parent is related or with whom the parent has a caretaking relationship, as specified; the other parent; a parent, current spouse, of the parent, or a person with whom the parent has a dating or engagement relationship.
- The nature and amount of contact with both parents.
- The habitual or continual illegal use of controlled substances and the habitual or continual abuse of alcohol or prescribed controlled substances, as specified. (Fam. Code, §§ 3011, 3021.)
- Establishes an order of preference for custody of a child, starting with jointly to both parents or to either parent, which is subject to the best interest of the child as set forth in 1) and 2). (Fam. Code, § 3040.)
This bill:
- Clarifies that the court’s obligation to consider a child’s health, safety and welfare, as part of the determination of the best interest of the child for purposes of custody or visitation, includes the consideration of whether a parent affirms the child’s gender identity.
- Makes nonsubstantive technical and conforming changes.
COMMENTS
- Author’s comment
According to the author:
AB 957 would clarify that affirming a child’s gender identity is in the best interest of the child for purposes of child custody and visitation decisions, increasing the likelihood that a gender affirming parent is given legal custody and authority to make important decisions about the child’s medical care and education.
2. The correlation between affirming a child’s gender identity and the child’s safety and welfare
According to data published at the end of 2022, 54 percent of California transgender and nonbinary youth seriously considered suicide, and 19 percent of California transgender and nonbinary youth attempted suicide in the past year.[1] These rates of considering suicide and attempting suicide are dramatically higher for transgender youth than for cisgender youth.[2]
One proven factor that reduces the likelihood that a transgender or nonbinary youth will attempt suicide is the acceptance of the youth’s gender identity by the adults and peers in their life.[3] Parents, in particular, make a difference: having at least one parent accept a transgender youth’s gender identity has shown to be the number one factor that reduces suicide risk, even more than acceptance by peers.[4] Even small measures of acceptance can make a difference; for example, one study showed that allowing transgender youths who were allowed to use their chosen names at school, home, work, and with friends “experienced 71 percent fewer symptoms of severe depression, a 34 percent decrease in reported thoughts of suicide and a 65 percent decrease in suicide attempts.”[5]
3. This bill clarifies that a child’s health, safety, and welfare, within a custody or visitation proceeding, includes a parent’s affirmation of the child’s gender identity
“Under California’s statutory scheme governing child custody and visitation determinations, the overarching concern is the best interest of the child.”[6] That scheme “allows the court and the family the widest discretion to choose a parenting plan that is in the best interest of the child.”[7] When determining the best interest of a child, a court may consider any relevant factors, and must consider the following: the health, safety, and welfare of the child; any history of abuse or neglect by the party seeking custody; the nature and amount of contact with the parents; and substance abuse by a parent.[8] The analysis is always informed by the fact that the right to participate in the raising of one’s child is a protected constitutional right that cannot be cast aside without good cause.[9]
While the correlation between gender acceptance and the mental health and safety of transgender youth is clear, the Family Code does not currently explicitly require a court to consider gender affirmation when determining the best interest of a child for purposes of custody or visitation. This bill simply clarifies that family courts, when making determinations about a child’s best interest in a custody or visitation proceeding, must consider a parent’s acceptance of a child’s gender identity as a component of the child’s overall health, safety, and welfare. The bill does not compel the court to come to a particular outcome based on this factor or override the court’s discretion to reach a determination about the child’s best interest in light of all of the facts;[10] it merely makes explicit the fact that affirmance of a child’s gender identity is an integral component of a child’s overall health, safety, and welfare which should be considered by the family court. As explained by TransFamily Support Services and TransYouth Liberation, two of the bill’s sponsors:
The Family Code is intended to center the child’s best interest in decisions about visitation and custody. California Family Code section 3011 lists several factors to consider when determining the child’s best interest. Still, it fails to consider this vulnerable population of children at increased risk of harm. [This bill] will provide gender-affirming parents with the support needed to continue to love and affirm their diverse [transgender, gender-diverse, and intersex] children.
The bill’s opponents appear to generally take issue with the concept that youths can identify as transgender and, on that basis, argue that gender affirmation should not be considered as a factor in determining the best interest of a child. Supporters of the bill disagree; for example, according to the California Youth Empowerment Network:
Our transgender youth go a long way towards self-discovery. It can be extremely difficult to be one’s authentic self under scrutiny of classmates, friends, and family members. A step someone would take towards reaffirming one’s gender identity is by changing their name. However, sometimes the parent or guardian will actively oppose all attempts of gender-reaffirming care, causing undue harm to our transgender youth such as, but not limited to, anxiety, depression, and thoughts of suicide. Assembly Bill 957 would require the courts to consider reaffirming a youth’s gender identity as it is in the youth’s best interest when one parent does not consent to a child’s name and gender marker change. This, in turn, will help to protect and improve the mental health of these transgender youth.
SUPPORT
California Transgender, Gender Non-Confirming and Intersex Policy Alliance (co-sponsor)
California State PTA
EmpowerTHEM Collective (co-sponsor)
Equality California (co-sponsor)
Gender Justice LA (co-sponsor)
Los Angeles LGBT Center (co-sponsor)
TransFamily Support Services (co-sponsor)
TransYouth Liberation (co-sponsor)
Women’s Foundation of California (co-sponsor)
ACLU California Action
Arming Minorities Against Addiction & Disease Institute
California Faculty Association
California LGBTQ Health and Human Services Network
California Youth Empowerment Network
Children’s Legal Services
Citizens for Choice
Coachman Moore & Associates
Desert AIDS Project
Ella Baker Center for Human Rights
Face to Face
Harm Reduction Institute
National Association of Social Workers – California Chapter
National Harm Reduction Coalition
National Health Law Program
Radiant Health Centers
Sacramento LGBT Community Center
San Gabriel Valley LGBTQ+ Center
Somos Familia Valle
Source LGBT+ Center
TEACH
The San Diego LGBT Community Center
ValorUS
OPPOSITION
Bridge Network
California Capitol Connection
California Catholic Conference
California Family Council
California Parents Union
California’s Legislative Voice
Carlsbad C2O
Eagle Forum California
International Federation for Therapeutic and Counselling Choice
Moms for Liberty Placer County
Our Duty
Pacific Justice Institute
Silicon Valley Association of Republican Women
Stand Up Sacramento County
Traditional Values for the Next Generation
15 individuals
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation:
SB 407 (Wiener, 2023) requires the Department of Social Services (DSS) to include, in its standards for assessing potential resource families, a requirement that the potential resource family demonstrate the capacity and willingness to care for a child regardless of the child’s sexual orientation or gender identity. SB 407 is pending before the Assembly Human Services Committee.
AB 1522 (Cervantes, 2023) requires DSS to convene a workgroup to create a report with recommendations to prevent housing instability among LGBTQ youth in foster care. AB 1522 is pending before the Assembly Appropriations Committee.
Prior Legislation:
AB 421 (Ward, Ch. 40, Stats. 2022) updated procedures for changing gender and sex identifiers on official documents and resolved internal inconsistencies introduced as a result of chaptering amendments taken to AB 218 (see below).
AB 218 (Ward, Ch. 577, Stats. 2021) established a process for a petitioner seeking a change of gender to also request that their marriage license and certificate and their children’s birth certificates be reissued with updated information about the petitioner.
AB 2119 (Gloria, Ch. 385, Stats. 2018) clarified the right of foster youth to gender affirming health care and gender affirming mental health care and required the Department of Social Services (DSS), in consultation with stakeholders, to develop and issue written guidance regarding foster youth access to gender affirming health care and gender affirming mental health care by January 1,2020.
PRIOR VOTES:
Assembly Floor (Ayes 51, Noes 13)
Assembly Judiciary Committee (Ayes 8, Noes 3)
**************
The Trevor Project, 2022 U.S. National Survey on LGBTQ Youth Mental Health by State: California (Dec. 15, 2022), p. 2. ↑
E.g., Price & Green, Association of Identity Acceptance with Fewer Suicide Attempts Among Transgender and Nonbinary Youth, Transgender Health, Vol. 1, No. 1 (Feb. 2023), p. 56. ↑
E.g., id. at p. 59; Jin, et al., Maternal Support Is Protective Against Suicidal Ideation Among a Diverse Cohort of Young Transgender Women, LGBT Health, 7(7): 349-357 (Oct. 2020). ↑
Price & Green, supra, at p. 59. ↑
University of Texas at Austin, UT News, Using Chosen Names Reduces Odds of Depression and Suicide in Transgender Youths (Mar. 30, 2018), https://news.utexas.edu/2018/03/30/name-use-matters-for-transgender-youths-mental-health/. All links in this analysis are current as of June 8, 2023. ↑
Montenegro v. Diaz (2001) 26 Cal.4th 249, 255; see §§ 3011, 3020, 3040 & 3041. ↑
Fam. Code, § 3040. ↑
Id., §§ 3011, 3020. ↑
E.g., Troxel v. Granville (2000) 530 U.S. 57, 65-66. ↑
For example, certain opponents of the bill argue that this bill will compel judges to overlook evidence that a child is being harmed in the form of overly accelerated surgical gender-affirming care. This is incorrect: the judge retains the discretion to look at all of the factors contributing to the child’s health, safety, and welfare, including whether gender-affirming treatments are being provided consistent with the recommendations of medical professionals (which correlates with positive mental health outcomes for transgender youth). (See, e.g., Tordoff, et al., Mental Health Outcomes in Transgender and Nonbinary Youths Receiving Gender-Affirming Care, JAMA Network, Pediatrics (Feb. 25, 2022), available at https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2789423). ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 957
Author:(Wilson)
As Amended Ver:March 13, 2023
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Requires a court to consider a minor's gender identity when issuing name change and child custody orders, as specified.
Major Provisions
- Requires the court to strongly consider that affirming the minor's gender identity is in the best interest of the child if a nonconsenting parent objects to a change of name or gender marker that conforms to the minor's gender identity.
- Requires a court, when determining the best interests of a child in a child custody proceeding, to consider, among other factors, a parent's affirmation of the child's gender identity.
COMMENTS
This bill makes two changes to existing law:
First, under existing law, a person seeking a legal name change files a petition with the court. Prior to any hearing on the name change, the petition must notify "other persons interested" in the matter to appear and "show cause" if, for some reason, they object to the name change. Minors may also petition the court for a name change, but generally they may not change their name without a parent's consent. When one parent files a petition on behalf of a minor child, the court requires the petitioner to serve notice on the other parent prior to the hearing. If the other parent objects to the change, existing law does not specify what the court should consider, though as in all matters pertaining to minors, the judge must consider the "best interests of the child." This bill provides that if one parent objects to a name or gender marker change to affirm the minor's gender identity, the court shall "strongly consider" that affirming the minor's gender identity is in the best interest of the child. The bill does not require the court to side with the consenting parent; it may place a thumb on the scale in favor of the consenting parent, but that is true of any number of factors that courts consider in determining the best interests of a child.
Second, in a child custody proceeding, this bill would require the court, when determining the best interest of the child, to consider a parent's affirmation of their child's gender identity. This does not necessarily require the court to side with the parent that affirms a child's gender identity. Existing law requires the court to consider several factors which prioritize the health, safety, and welfare of the child. For example, the court is required to consider, among other factors it deems relevant, whether either parent has a history of abusing drugs or alcohol or of committing acts of physical abuse. The court may also consider the nature of the amount of contact that the child has had with both parents. This bill would merely add a parent's affirmation of the child's gender identity as an additional factor that a court would weigh in favor of the best interest of the child.
This bill does not uniquely or negatively impact parental rights. This bill touches upon a controversial and complex topic, and it is not the first or the last bill that the Committee will hear on this topic in this legislative session. Many of the letters in opposition to this bill contend that this bill is an unprecedented erosion of parental rights. Opponents argue that this bill interferes with the rights of parents, especially those whose views on this controversial subject are at odds with the views of the author and, it should be added, are also at odds with the views of most medical and mental health professionals who support this bill.
However, this bill does not mark a dramatic shift in family law, nor does it uniquely or unprecedentedly impact parental rights. Of course, whenever the courts must make decisions about the "best interests of the child," they often override the will of one or both parents. Parental rights are not absolute. For example, parental rights do not shield parents from the consequences of child abuse or neglect. In addition, any determination of the best interest of a child in a contested custody proceeding will often favor one parent over the other. This bill, therefore, does not uniquely interfere with parental rights; for when parents disagree in a legal matter, the court necessarily must decide. If losing in a legal proceeding equated to the loss of parental rights, then by definition one parent would always lose parental rights, no matter what the court decided. In a perfect world, parents would cooperatively reach a consensus on such matters without legal intervention; but in the real world, they do not. The court must make a decision about the child's best interests, whether it wants to or not. And under this bill, the courts will continue to give paramount importance to the best of interest of the child based on multiple factors.
According to the Author
According to the author, when two parents do not agree on affirming the gender identity of their TGI (transgender, gender diverse, or intersex) child, existing statutes do not provide guidance to the court on how to determine the TGI child's best interest. The author and many of the supporters point to studies showing that TGI youth are at much higher risk for depression, mental health crises, and suicidal thoughts than their cisgender peers. The author argues that having "at least one adult in a child's life who affirms their gender identity decreases their chances of attempting suicide significantly." Moreover, many TGI minors face health and safety risks in their homes if they have non-affirming caretakers. The author believes this bill will clarify that "affirming a child's gender identity is in the best interest of the child for purposes of decisions on matters of child custody and gender-affirming petitions to change names and gender markers."
Arguments in Support
Equality California (EC), one of the co-sponsors of this bill, writes that while "states across the country are passing discriminatory policies attacking LGBTQ+ people, especially transgender and non-binary youth, AB 957 will ensure that California TGI youth have access to a legal system that affirms and protects their health, safety, and livelihood." EC notes that while TGI youth face higher rates of mental illness and suicidal thoughts, research shows that they do much better with supportive parents who affirm rather than disapprove of their gender identity. EC also observes that while the Family Code lists several factors that a court should consider when determining the best interests of the child, it "fails to take into account this very vulnerable population of [TGI] children who are at increased risk of harm." This bill, EC concludes, "will center the health and well-being of TGI youth by clarifying that affirming their gender identity is in their best interest."
The California chapter of the National Association of Social Workers (NASW-CA) believes this bill "is important for transgender youth, as it prioritizes the best interest of the child for legal name change and custody decision purposes." NASW-CA notes that California has already taken strides to protect transgender youth, and that this bill will offer further protection to transgender youth "if they come to California from such states as Alabama, which criminalizes gender-affirming care." Finally, NASW-CA notes that its Code of Ethics includes "advocating for social justice for those who are marginalized and vulnerable. This bill would do just that, ensuring that transgender youth dignity and worth is upheld and the court system ensures their gender identity is affirmed. With the nation increasingly creating anti-trans youth bills, this is a necessary counter-measure."
Arguments in Opposition
The California Capitol Connection opposes this bill because it will undermine the current law that "allows parents to object to their child's request for a change of gender and/or name on government documents." They fear this bill will instead "force family courts to ignore the parents' objections and rule in favor of the minor's request. Parents are responsible for the well-being of their children. Parents should have the final say in every major decision a minor makes." Finally, the California Capital Connection points to a higher law: "The Bible and nature also teach us that there are only two genders. Genesis 1:27 says, "So God created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him; male and female created he them."
The California Parents' Union (CPU) opposes this bill because it would violate judicial independence. CPU argues that no judge "can be dictated to - by the legislature - as to how to rule on a case. [Judges] are required to rule based on the law and the facts before them objectively and without bias. I would submit this is especially important when a ruling is based on a very dangerous issue that could result in a permanent life altering decision. The undisputed fact is that participating in changing "genders" of a minor child is extremely controversial and medically dangerous. Judges cannot be told to favor one side or the other ethically."
FISCAL COMMENTS
None.
VOTES
ASM JUDICIARY: 8-3-0
YES: Maienschein, Connolly, Haney, Kalra, Pacheco, Papan, Reyes, Robert Rivas
NO: Essayli, Dixon, Sanchez
UPDATED
VERSION: March 13, 2023
CONSULTANT: Tom Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334 FN: 0000157
Date of Hearing: March 21, 2023
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON JUDICIARY
Brian Maienschein, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 957
Author:(Wilson) – As Amended Ver:March 13, 2023
SUBJECT: Family law: gender identity
KEY ISSUES:
- should the court strongly consider that affirming a minor’s gender identity is in the best interest of the child, if a nonconsenting parent objects to a Gender Affirming name change?
- Should a court, when determining the best interest of a child in child custody proceeding, consider a parent’s affirmation of the child’s gender identity?
SYNOPSIS
This bill addresses legal issues that arise when parents cannot agree on whether to affirm the gender identity of their child, including via a request for the child’s name, or gender marker change. First, under existing law, a person seeking a legal name change files a petition with the court. When one parent files a petition on behalf of a minor child, the court requires the petitioner to serve notice on the other parent prior to the hearing. If the other parent objects to the change, existing law does not specify what the court should consider, though as in all matters pertaining to minors, the judge must consider the “best interests of the child.” This bill provides that if one parent objects to a name or gender marker change that affirms the minor’s gender identity, then the court shall “strongly consider” that affirming the minor’s gender identity is in the best interest of the child. Contrary to the claims of some opponents, the bill does not require the court to side with the consenting parent; it may place a thumb on the scale in favor of the consenting parent, but that is true of any number of factors that the court considers in determining the best interests of the child.
Second, in a child custody proceeding this bill would require the court, when determining the best interest of the child, to consider a parent’s affirmation of the child’s gender identity. Again, this does not require the court to side with the parent that affirms a child’s gender identity. Existing law requires the judge to consider several factors which prioritize the health, safety, and welfare of the child. This bill would add a parent’s affirmation of the child’s gender identity as an additional factor weighing in favor of the child’s health, safety, and welfare.
This bill touches upon a controversial and complex topic. However, the bill does not mark a dramatic shift in family law. Courts will continue to give paramount importance to the best interest of the child. The bill does not uniquely interfere with parental rights, for when parents disagree in a legal matter, the court necessarily sides with one parent over the other. In a perfect world, parents would agree on such matters; but in the real world, they do not. The court must therefore make a decision when parents disagree. The bill is supported by several youth advocacy groups and others and is opposed by religious and parental rights groups.
SUMMARY: Requires a court to consider a minor’s gender identity when issuing name change and child custody orders, as specified. Specifically, this bill:
- Requires the court to strongly consider that affirming the minor’s gender identity is in the best interest of the child if a nonconsenting parent objects to a change of name or gender marker that conforms to the minor’s gender identity.
- Requires a court, when determining the best interests of a child in a child custody proceeding, to consider, among other factors, a parent’s affirmation of the child’s gender identity.
EXISTING LAW:
- Sets forth the procedure by which a person may petition the court for a name change. Specifies that the court shall issue an order reciting the filing of the petition and directing all persons interested in the matter to appear before the court at a specified time and place to express any objections and to “show cause” why the petition for a name change should not be granted. Provides further that the order to show cause must be published in a newspaper of general circulation, as specified. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1277.5.)
- Provides that if a change of name petition is filed for a minor by a parent and the other parent, if living, does not join in consenting thereto, the petitioner must serve notice on the other parent not less than 30 days before the hearing to consider the petition. (Code of Civil Procedure Section 1277.5 (a)(4).)
- Requires the court, when making a determination of the best interest of the child in a child custody proceeding, to consider, among other factors it deems relevant, all of the following:
- The health, safety, and welfare of the child.
- A history of abuse by either parent, or by that parent’s current spouse or cohabitants, as specified.
- The nature and amount of contact with both parents, as specified.
- The habitual substance abuse by either parent. (Family Code Section 3011 (a).)
- Specifies that the court shall not consider the sex, gender identity, gender expression, or sexual orientation of a parent, legal guardian, or relative in determining the best interests of a child. (Family Code Section 3011 (b).)
FISCAL EFFECT: As currently in print this bill is keyed non-fiscal.
COMMENTS: According to the author, when two parents do not agree on affirming the gender identity of their TGI (transgender, gender diverse, or intersex) child, existing statutes do not provide guidance to the court on how to determine the TGI child’s best interest. The author and many of the supporters point to studies showing that TGI youth are at much higher risk for depression, mental health crises, and suicidal thoughts than their cisgender peers. The author argues that having “at least one adult in a child’s life who affirms their gender identity decreases their chances of attempting suicide significantly.” Moreover, many TGI minors face health and safety risks in their homes if they have non-affirming caretakers. The author believes that AB 957 will clarify that “affirming a child’s gender identity is in the best interest of the child for purposes of decisions on matters of child custody and gender-affirming petitions to change names and gender markers.”
This bill makes two changes to existing law:
First, under existing law, a person seeking a legal name change files a petition with the court. Prior to any hearing on the name change, the petition must notify “other persons interested” in the matter to appear and “show cause” if, for some reason, they object to the name change. Minors may also petition the court for a name change, but generally they may not change their name without a parent’s consent. When one parent files a petition on behalf of a minor child, the court requires the petitioner to serve notice on the other parent prior to the hearing. If the other parent objects to the change, existing law does not specify what the court should consider, though as in all matters pertaining to minors, the judge must consider the “best interests of the child.” This bill provides that if one parent objects to a name or gender marker change to affirm the minor’s gender identity, the court shall “strongly consider” that affirming the minor’s gender identity is in the best interest of the child. The bill does not require the court to side with the consenting parent; it may place a thumb on the scale in favor of the consenting parent, but that is true of any number of factors that courts consider in determining the best interests of a child.
Second, in a child custody proceeding, this bill would require the court, when determining the best interest of the child, to consider a parent’s affirmation of their child’s gender identity. This does not necessarily require the court to side with the parent that affirms a child’s gender identity. Existing law requires the court to consider several factors which prioritize the health, safety, and welfare of the child. For example, the court is required to consider, among other factors it deems relevant, whether either parent has a history of abusing drugs or alcohol or of committing acts of physical abuse. The court may also consider the nature of the amount of contact that the child has had with both parents. This bill would merely add a parent’s affirmation of the child’s gender identity as an additional factor that a court would weigh in favor of the best interest of the child.
The bill does not uniquely or negatively impact parental rights. This bill touches upon a controversial and complex topic, and it is not the first or the last bill that the Committee will hear on this topic in this legislative session. Many of the letters in opposition to this bill contend that the bill is an unprecedented erosion of parental rights. Opponents argue that the bill interferes with the rights of parents, especially those whose views on this controversial subject are at odds with the views of the author and, it should be added, are also at odds with the views of most medical and mental health professionals who support this bill.
However, the bill under consideration does not mark a dramatic shift in family law, nor does it uniquely or unprecedentedly impact parental rights. Of course, whenever the courts must make decisions about the “best interests of the child,” they often override the will of one or both parents. Parental rights are not absolute. For example, parental rights do not shield parents from the consequences of child abuse or neglect. In addition, any determination of the best interest of a child in a contested custody proceeding will often favor one parent over the other. The bill, therefore, does not uniquely interfere with parental rights; for when parents disagree in a legal matter, the court necessarily must decide. If losing in a legal proceeding equated to the loss of parental rights, then by definition one parent would always lose parental rights, no matter what the court decided. In a perfect world, parents would cooperatively reach a consensus on such matters without legal intervention; but in the real world, they do not. The court must make a decision about the child’s best interests, whether it wants to or not. And under this bill, the courts will continue to give paramount importance to the best of interest of the child based on multiple factors.
A minor amendment that the author may wish to consider, strongly or otherwise, if the bill moves out of this Committee. As noted above, this bill requires the court to “strongly” consider that affirming a minor’s gender identity is in the child’s best interest. However, while several statutes require courts to “consider” various factors in several different areas of the law, it is unclear to the Committee, as a matter of law, what it means to “strongly” consider something; nor is the Committee entirely sure how a judge would interpret this subjective adjective. In child custody cases, for example, the court is directed to “consider” several factors related to the health, safety and welfare of the child, including, for example, whether either parent has a history of physical abuse or substance abuse, factors that could jeopardize a child’s well-being. If the court must only “consider” those factors, but “strongly consider” whether a parent affirms the child’s gender identity, does this mean that the court must give more weight to gender affirmation than the other enumerated factors? All other things being equal, for example, does this mean that the court should favor a gender-affirming but physically abusive parent over a non-confirming but not physically abusive parent? It seems unlikely that this is the author’s or co-sponsors’ intent. Therefore, if the bill moves out of this Committee, the author may wish to strike the word “strongly,” or define it in a manner that explains why this factor deserves more weight than the other extremely important factors that courts must otherwise consider.
ARGUMENTS IN SUPPORT: Equality California (EC), one of the co-sponsors of this bill, writes that while “states across the country are passing discriminatory policies attacking LGBTQ+ people, especially transgender and non-binary youth, SB 957 will ensure that California TGI youth have access to a legal system that affirms and protects their health, safety, and livelihood.” EC notes that while TGI youth face higher rates of mental illness and suicidal thoughts, research shows that they do much better with supportive parents who affirm rather than disapprove of their gender identity. EC also observes that while the Family Code lists several factors that a court should consider when determining the best interests of the child, it “fails to take into account this very vulnerable population of [TGI] children who are at increased risk of harm.” AB 957, EC concludes, “will center the health and well-being of TGI youth by clarifying that affirming their gender identity is in their best interest.”
The California chapter of the National Association of Social Workers (NASW-CA) believes that AB 957 “is important for transgender youth, as it prioritizes the best interest of the child for legal name change and custody decision purposes.” NASW-CA notes that California has already taken strides to protect transgender youth, and that this bill will offer further protection to transgender youth “if they come to California from such states as Alabama, which criminalizes gender-affirming care.” Finally, NASW-CA notes that its Code of Ethics includes “advocating for social justice for those who are marginalized and vulnerable. This bill would do just that, ensuring that transgender youth dignity and worth is upheld and the court system ensures their gender identity is affirmed. With the nation increasingly creating anti-trans youth bills, this is a necessary counter-measure.”
Several other groups advocating for the rights of youth and LGBTQ people support this bill for substantially the same reasons as those articulated above.
ARGUMENTS IN OPPOSITION: The California Capitol Connection opposes AB 957 because it will undermine the current law that “allows parents to object to their child’s request for a change of gender and/or name on government documents.” They fear that AB 957 will instead “force family courts to ignore the parents’ objections and rule in favor of the minor’s request. Parents are responsible for the well-being of their children. Parents should have the final say in every major decision a minor makes.” Finally, the California Capital Connection points to a higher law: “The Bible and nature also teach us that there are only two genders. Genesis 1:27 says, ‘So God created man in his own image, in the image of God created he him; male and female created he them.”
The California Parents’ Union (CPU) opposes this bill because it would violate judicial independence. CPU argues that no judge “can be dictated to - by the legislature - as to how to rule on a case. [Judges] are required to rule based on the law and the facts before them objectively and without bias. I would submit this is especially important when a ruling is based on a very dangerous issue that could result in a permanent life altering decision. The undisputed fact is that participating in changing “genders” of a minor child is extremely controversial and medically dangerous. Judges cannot be told to favor one side or the other ethically.”
Several other groups oppose this bill for similar reasons, contending that the bill interferes with parental rights and improperly compels the court to favor one side in a contentious cultural debate.
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
ACLU California Action
AMAAD Institute (arming Minorities against Addiction & Disease)
California LGBT Health and Human Services Network
California Transgender, Gender-nonconforming and Intersex Policy Alliance (CTPA)
Children's Legal Services of San Diego
Citizens for Choice
Coachman Moore and Associates
Desert Aids Project
Equality California
Face to Face
Gender Justice LA
Harm Reduction Institute
Los Angeles LGBT Center
National Association of Social Workers, California Chapter
National Harm Reduction Coalition
National Health Law Program
Radiant Health Centers
Sacramento LGBT Community Center
San Gabriel Valley LGBTQ Center
Somos Familia Valle
The San Diego LGBTQ Community Center
The Source LGBT+ Center
Trans Family Services
Trans Youth Liberation
Valorcalifornia / Valorus
Women's Foundation of California, Dr. Beatriz Maria Solis Policy Institute (SPI)
Opposition
California Capitol Connection
California Family Council
California Parents Union
Moms for Liberty Placer County
Our Duty
Pacific Justice Institute
Stand Up Sacramento County
One individual parent
Analysis Prepared by: Tom Clark / JUD. / (916) 319-2334
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):