AB 1582: Higher Education Employer-Employee Relations Act: collective bargaining: unfair labor practices.
- Session Year: 2025-2026
- House: Assembly
- Latest Version Date: 2026-06-08
Current Status:
In Progress
(2026-06-17: From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (June 17). Re-referred to Com. on JUD.)
Introduced
In Committee
Awaiting First Chamber Vote
Passed First Chamber
In Committee
Awaiting Second Chamber Vote
Passed Second Chamber
Enacted
Existing law, the Higher Education Employer-Employee Relations Act, administered by the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB), provides for negotiations concerning wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment between a higher education employer, as defined, and representatives of recognized employee organizations. Existing law grants higher education employees the right to form, join, and participate in the activities of employee organizations of their own choosing for the purpose of representation on all matters of employer-employee relations and for the purpose of meeting and conferring with their employer.
Existing law authorizes an employer and an exclusive representative who enter into a written memorandum of understanding to agree to procedures for final and binding arbitration of disputes that may arise under the memorandum of understanding or between the parties. Existing law makes it unlawful for the higher education employer to, among other things, refuse or fail to meet and confer with an exclusive representative.
This bill would, with respect to arbitrations over violations of a collective bargaining agreement for the contracting out of bargaining unit work, make it an unfair practice for a higher education employer to, among other things, circumvent or disregard an arbitrators decision by extending or renewing an existing contract, contract or entering into a new contract for the same or similar services, services at the same location, or violating a contract term already interpreted by an arbitrator to prohibit the employers conduct.
This bill would prohibit PERB, among other things, from deferring repeat offenses in the above-described cases to subsequent arbitration proceedings. The bill would require remedies for a violation of these provisions to include the charging partys attorneys fees and costs.
Existing law, the Higher Education Employer-Employee Relations Act, administered by the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB), provides for negotiations concerning wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment between a higher education employer, as defined, and representatives of recognized employee organizations. Existing law grants higher education employees the right to form, join, and participate in the activities of employee organizations of their own choosing for the purpose of representation on all matters of employer-employee relations and for the purpose of meeting and conferring with their employer.
Existing law authorizes an employer and an exclusive representative who enter into a written memorandum of understanding to agree to procedures for final and binding arbitration of disputes that may arise under the memorandum of understanding or between the parties. Existing law makes it unlawful for the higher education employer to, among other things, refuse or fail to meet and confer with an exclusive representative.
This bill would, with respect to arbitrations over violations of a collective bargaining agreement that relate to for the contracting out of bargaining unit work, make it an unfair practice for a higher education employer to, among other things, circumvent or disregard an arbitrators decision by extending or renewing an existing contract, or entering into one or more new contracts a new contract for the same or similar services, or otherwise violating the same a contract term or terms already interpreted by an arbitrator to prohibit the employers conduct.
This bill would prohibit PERB PERB, among other things, from deferring repeat offenses in the above-described cases to subsequent arbitration proceedings. If an arbitrator or PERB finds the employer to be a repeat offender, as described above, the bill would authorize PERB to award civil penalties of $1,000 per day, as specified. The bill would require remedies for a violation of these provisions to include the charging partys attorneys fees and costs.
Existing law, the Higher Education Employer-Employee Relations Act, administered by the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB), provides for negotiations concerning wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment between a higher education employer, as defined, and representatives of recognized employee organizations. Existing law grants higher education employees the right to form, join, and participate in the activities of employee organizations of their own choosing for the purpose of representation on all matters of employer-employee relations and for the purpose of meeting and conferring with their employer.
Existing law authorizes an employer and an exclusive representative who enter into a written memorandum of understanding to agree to procedures for final and binding arbitration of disputes that may arise under the memorandum of understanding or between the parties. Existing law makes it unlawful for the higher education employer to, among other things, refuse or fail to meet and confer with an exclusive representative.
This bill would, with respect to arbitrations over violations of a collective bargaining agreement that relate to the contracting out of bargaining unit work, make it an unfair practice for a higher education employer to, among other things, circumvent or disregard an arbitrators decision by extending or renewing an existing contract, or entering into one or more new contracts for the same or similar services, or otherwise violating the same contract term or terms already interpreted by an arbitrator to prohibit the employers conduct.
This bill would prohibit PERB from deferring repeat offenses in the above-described cases to subsequent arbitration proceedings. If an arbitrator or PERB finds the employer to be a repeat offender, as described above, the bill would authorize PERB to award civil penalties of $1,000 per day, as specified. The bill would require remedies for a violation of these provisions to include the charging partys attorneys fees and costs.
(a)With respect to arbitrations over violations of a collective bargaining agreement that relate to the contracting out of bargaining unit work, it shall be an unfair practice for a higher education employer to do any of the following:
(1)Fail or refuse to schedule an arbitration within a reasonable period of time after the union has appealed the matter to arbitration, unless the exclusive representative has placed the grievance in abeyance or the parties have agreed to do so.
(2)Fail or refuse to implement an arbitration award and remedy in full within 60 days of a decision on the merits.
(3)(A)Circumvent or disregard an arbitrators decision by extending or renewing an existing contract, contract or entering into one or more new contracts for the same or similar services, services at the same location, or otherwise violating the same contract term or terms already interpreted by an arbitrator to prohibit the employers conduct.
(B)In the cases described in subparagraph (A), the board shall not defer repeat offenses to subsequent arbitration proceedings.
(4)(A)Fail or refuse to remedy, in whole or in part, an arbitrators decision that remands the remedy to be determined by the parties.
(B)In the cases described in subparagraph (A), the board shall defer to the merits of the arbitration award but shall not defer disputes regarding the remedy to subsequent arbitration proceedings absent agreement of the parties.
(b)Remedies for a violation of this section shall include the charging partys attorneys fees and costs.
(c)Except as expressly set forth in this section, this section does not limit the boards broad remedial authority.
(a)With respect to arbitrations over violations of a collective bargaining agreement that relate to the contracting out of bargaining unit work, it shall be an unfair practice for a higher education employer to do any of the following:
(1)Fail or refuse to schedule an arbitration within a reasonable period of time after the union has appealed the matter to arbitration, unless the exclusive representative has placed the grievance in abeyance or the parties have agreed to do so.
(2)Fail or refuse to implement an arbitration award and remedy in full within 60 days of a decision on the merits.
(3)(A)Circumvent or disregard an arbitrators decision by extending or renewing an existing contract, or entering into one or more new contracts for the same or similar services, or otherwise violating the same contract term or terms already interpreted by an arbitrator to prohibit the employers conduct.
(B)In the cases described in subparagraph (A), the board shall not defer repeat offenses to subsequent arbitration proceedings.
(4)(A)Fail or refuse to remedy, in whole or in part, an arbitrators decision that remands the remedy to be determined by the parties.
(B)In the cases described in subparagraph (A), the board shall defer to the merits of the arbitration award but shall not defer disputes regarding the remedy to subsequent arbitration proceedings absent agreement of the parties.
(b)Remedies for a violation of this section shall include the charging partys attorneys fees and costs.
(c)(1)If an arbitrator or the board finds the employer to be a repeat offender, as described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a), the board may award civil penalties of one thousand dollars ($1,000) per day starting on the date the unfair practice charge was filed until the violation or violations are remedied in full. (2)Civil penalties collected pursuant to this section shall be deposited into the states general fund. (d)(c)Except as expressly set forth in this section, nothing in this section shall this section does not limit the boards broad remedial authority.
(a)With respect to arbitrations over violations of a collective bargaining agreement that relate to the contracting out of bargaining unit work, it shall be an unfair practice for a higher education employer to do any of the following:
(1)Fail or refuse to schedule an arbitration within a reasonable period of time after the union has appealed the matter to arbitration, unless the exclusive representative has placed the grievance in abeyance or the parties have agreed to do so.
(2)Fail or refuse to implement an arbitration award and remedy in full within 60 days of a decision on the merits.
(3)(A)Circumvent or disregard an arbitrators decision by extending or renewing an existing contract, or entering into one or more new contracts for the same or similar services, or otherwise violating the same contract term or terms already interpreted by an arbitrator to prohibit the employers conduct.
(B)In the cases described in subparagraph (A), the board shall not defer repeat offenses to subsequent arbitration proceedings.
(4)(A)Fail or refuse to remedy, in whole or in part, an arbitrators decision that remands the remedy to be determined by the parties.
(B)In the cases described in subparagraph (A), the board shall defer to the merits of the arbitration award but shall not defer disputes regarding the remedy to subsequent arbitration proceedings absent agreement of the parties.
(b)Remedies for a violation of this section shall include the charging partys attorneys fees and costs.
(c)(1)If an arbitrator or the board finds the employer to be a repeat offender, as described in paragraph (3) of subdivision (a), the board may award civil penalties of one thousand dollars ($1,000) per day starting on the date the unfair practice charge was filed until the violation or violations are remedied in full.
(2)Civil penalties collected pursuant to this section shall be deposited into the states general fund.
(d)Except as expressly set forth in this section, nothing in this section shall limit the boards broad remedial authority.
REVISIONS: HeadingLine 2.|
Date
|
Status
|
|---|---|
| Jun 17, 2026 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on JUD. (Ayes 4. Noes 1.) (June 17). Re-referred to Com. on JUD. |
| Jun 8, 2026 | From committee chair, with author's amendments: Amend, and re-refer to committee. Read second time, amended, and re-referred to Com. on L., P.E. & R. |
| Jun 3, 2026 | Referred to Coms. on L., P.E. & R. and JUD. |
| May 27, 2026 | In Senate. Read first time. To Com. on RLS. for assignment. |
| May 26, 2026 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. |
| May 26, 2026 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 67. Noes 7. Page 5355.) |
| May 26, 2026 | Read third time. Passed. Ordered to the Senate. (Ayes 67. Noes 7.) |
| May 19, 2026 | Read second time. Ordered to third reading. |
| May 18, 2026 | Read second time and amended. Ordered returned to second reading. |
| May 14, 2026 | From committee: Amend, and do pass as amended. (Ayes 13. Noes 2.) (May 14). |
| May 6, 2026 | In committee: Set, first hearing. Referred to APPR. suspense file. |
| Mar 18, 2026 | Coauthors revised. |
| Mar 18, 2026 | From committee: Do pass and re-refer to Com. on APPR. (Ayes 7. Noes 0.) (March 18). Re-referred to Com. on APPR. |
| Feb 2, 2026 | Referred to Com. on P. E. & R. |
| Jan 14, 2026 | From printer. May be heard in committee February 13. |
| Jan 13, 2026 | Read first time. To print. |
|
Date
|
Description
|
Location
|
Votes
|
|
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Jun 30, 2026 | [First] hearing set for [07-01-2026]: Failed passage in Committee. Reconsideration granted | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Passed |
|
| Jun 30, 2026 | Do pass as amended, but first amend, and re-refer to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary |
Failed |
|
| Jun 17, 2026 | Do pass, but first be re-referred to the Committee on [Judiciary] | Senate Standing Committee on Labor, Public Employment and Retirement |
Passed |
|
| May 26, 2026 | AB 1582 Ortega Assembly Third Reading | Assembly Floor |
Passed |
|
| May 14, 2026 | Do pass as amended. | Assembly Standing Committee on Appropriations |
Passed |
|
| Mar 18, 2026 | Do pass and be re-referred to the Committee on [Appropriations] | Assembly Standing Committee on Public Employment and Retirement |
Passed |
This list shows positions taken on this bill by organizations on the date displayed, which is linked to the original source.
Positions by individuals are not included.
|
Organization
|
Position
|
Date
|
|---|---|---|
| AFSCME Local 3299 (Sponsor) | ** Support | |
| American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME) Council 57 | ** Support | |
| American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME) Local 3299 | ** Support | |
| American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME), AFL-CIO | ** Support | |
| Bay Area Council | ** Against | |
| California Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| California Faculty Association | ** Support | |
| California Federation of Labor Unions | ** Support | |
| California Hospital Association | ** Against | |
| California State University, Office Of The Chancellor | ** Against | |
| Central City Association Of Los Angeles | ** Against | |
| CFT – a Union of Educators & Classified Professionals, AFT, AFL-CIO | ** Support | |
| Federated University Police Officers Association | ** Support | |
| Federated University Police Officers' Association | ** Support | |
| Los Angeles Business Council | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles County Business Federation | ** Against | |
| Los Angeles County Business Federation (BIZ-FED) | ** Against | |
| Newport Rib Company | ** Against | |
| Pajaro Valley Federation of Teachers, Aft 1936 | ** Support | |
| Peace Officers Research Association Of California | ** Support | |
| Sacramento Metropolitan Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| San Diego Regional Chamber Of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Santa Barbara South Coast Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Santa Cruz Area Chamber of Commerce | ** Against | |
| Silicon Valley Leadership Group (SVLG) | ** Against | |
| Teamsters California | ** Support | |
| UC Irvine Faculty Association | ** Support | |
| UC Office of the President | ** Against | |
| Union Of American Physicians And Dentists | ** Support | |
| United Domestic Workers/AFSCME Local 3930 | ** Support | |
| University of California | ** Against | |
| UPTE-CWA 9119 | ** Support | |
| Valley Industry and Commerce Association (VICA) | ** Against | |
| West Los Angeles Chamber of Commerce | ** Against |
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2025-2026 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1582 (Author:Ortega)
Version: June 8, 2026
Hearing Date: June 30, 2026
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: ID
SUBJECT
Higher Education Employer-Employee Relations Act: collective bargaining: unfair labor practices
DIGEST
This bill makes various acts by a higher education employer, with respect to arbitrations over violations of a collective bargaining agreement relating to the contracting out of bargaining unit work, unfair practices, as specified.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Under the Higher Education Employee Relations Act of 1978 (HEERA), employees at the University of California (UC) and California State University (CSU) have the right to organize and collectively bargain. (Gov. Code §§ 3560 et seq.) HEERA provides various processes for UC and CSU employees to organize and form a union, and for the good faith bargaining between a recognized union and the university. It is administered by the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB), the quasi-judicial state agency that administers various state public employer-employee relations statutes. HEERA also permits the parties to agree in their collective bargaining agreements (CBAs) to submit to arbitration to resolve disputes regarding the CBA or conflicts between the parties. (Gov. Code § 3589.) However, the author reports that, in numerous instances, the UC has delayed the arbitration process regarding issues relating to the UC contracting out bargaining unit work, or has failed to implement or abide by the arbitrator’s decision. In such instances, the only recourse for the UC workers’ union is to go to court. AB 1582 proposes to make such actions regarding subverting the arbitration process an unfair practice, thereby allowing an aggrieved party to allege such an unfair practice before PERB, as specified.
AB 1582 is sponsored by AFSCME Local 3299 and AFSCME Council 57, and is supported by a number of other AFSCME chapters and unions. It is opposed by the UC, the California State University, the California Chamber of Commerce, and other groups. It previously passed out of the Senate Labor, Public Employment and Retirement Committee by a vote of 4 to 1.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes the University of California (UC) as a public trust under the administration of the Regents of the University of California and grants the Regents all the powers necessary or convenient for the effective administration of this public trust. Establishes that the UC Regents are subject only to such legislative control as may be necessary to insure the security of its funds, to ensure compliance with the terms of the endowments of the university, and such competitive bidding procedures as may be made applicable to the university by statute for the letting of construction contracts, sales of real property, and purchasing of materials, goods, and services. (California Constitution, Article XIV, § 9.)
- Establishes HEERA, which provides a statutory framework to regulate labor relations between the UC, CSU, and the University of California College of the Law, San Francisco (UC Law SF), and their respective employees. (Gov. Code §§ 3560 et seq.)
- Defines “Higher Education Employer” to mean any of the following: the UC Board of Regents, the UC Law SF Board of Directors, the California State University (CSU) Board of Trustees, or a person acting as an agent of one of the aforementioned entities. (Gov. Code §3562 (g).)
- Defines “scope of representation” for HEERA’s application to UC to mean, and be limited to, wages, hours of employment, and other terms and conditions of employment, but not does not include consideration of the merits, necessity, or organization of any service, activity, or program established by law or resolution of the regents or the directors, except for the terms and conditions of employment of employees who may be affected thereby. (Gov. Code § 3562 (q).)
- Establishes the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB) to administer the several collective bargaining statutes covering specified California public employees, including HEERA. PERB functions as a quasi-judicial administrative agency responsible for adjudicating employer-employee relations, resolving disputes, and enforcing the statutory duties and rights of public agency employers and employee organizations (Gov. Code § 3541.)
- Provides that a HEERA employer and an exclusive representative who enter into a written memorandum of understanding (MOU) may agree to procedures for final and binding arbitration of disputes that may arise under the memorandum of understanding or between the parties. (Gov. Code § 3589 (a).)
- Authorizes an aggrieved party to an MOU to seek a court order directing that the arbitration proceed pursuant to the MOU’s procedures if the other party fails, neglects, or refuses to proceed to arbitration. (Gov. Code § 3589 (b).)
- Makes an arbitration award final and binding upon the parties and enforceable by a court pursuant to Title 9 (commencing with Section 1280) of Part 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure. (Gov. Code § 3589 (c).)
- Defines “Arbitration” in HEERA to mean a method of resolving a rights dispute under which the parties to a controversy must accept the award of a third party. (Gov. Code § 3562 (a).)
- Provides that PERB will defer adjudicating an unfair labor practice complaint where the parties have agreed to the arbitration procedure, as specified. (see Regents of the University of California (San Francisco) (1984) PERB Decision No. Ad -139-H.)
- Makes it unlawful for the UC to engage in numerous acts, including denying employee unions rights guaranteed by HEERA, refusing or failing to engage in meeting and conferring with an exclusive representative, and others. (Gov. Code § 3571.)
- Empowers PERB to investigate unfair practices and violations of HEERA’s provisions, and to take any action necessary to resolve any such violations or unfair labor practices charges. Also empowers PERB to bring an action in court to enforce its orders or to obtain temporary relief or a restraining order upon the issuance of an unfair practice charge. (Gov. Code § 3563.)
This bill:
- Makes it an unfair practice, with respect to arbitrations over violations of a collective bargaining agreement that relate to the contracting out of bargaining unit work, for a higher education employer to:
- Fail or refuse to schedule an arbitration within a reasonable period of time after the union has appealed the matter to arbitration, unless the exclusive representative has placed the grievance in abeyance, or the parties have agreed to do so;
- Fail or refuse to implement an arbitration award and remedy in full within 60 days of a decision on the merits;
- Circumvent or disregard an arbitrator’s decision by: extending or renewing an existing contract or entering into one or more new contracts for the same or similar services at the same location, or otherwise violating the same contract term or terms already interpreted by an arbitrator to prohibit the employer’s conduct;
- For such cases, prohibits PERB from deferring repeat offenses to subsequent arbitration proceedings;
- Fail or refuse to remedy, in whole or in part, an arbitrator’s decision that remands the remedy to be determined by the parties. For these cases, requires PERB to defer to the merits of the arbitration award, but prohibits deferring disputes regarding the remedy to subsequent arbitration proceedings absent agreement of the parties.
- Specifies that the remedies for a violation of (1), above, include the charging party’s attorney’s fees and costs.
- Specifies that, except as expressly set forth above, these provisions do not limit PERB’s broad remedial authority.
COMMENTS
- Author’s statement
In support of this measure, the author states:
For decades, the University of California (UC) has contracted out service work.
In recent years, UC agreed to an arbitration process in their collective bargaining agreements with service and patient care technical workers to resolve disagreements over contracting out.
UC is now consistently violating the arbitration process. UC doesn’t follow the arbitrator’s decisions.
Current law does not provide an adequate enforcement remedy to address the harms suffered by workers related to a higher education employer’s refusal to respect the arbitration process and the arbitrator’s decisions regarding the contracting out of work.
AB 1582 restores the integrity of arbitration.
- The UC and AFSCME’s labor dispute over contract work
This bill comes out of the long-running dispute between UCLA and the union that represents 40,000 of its service, patient case, and skilled craft employees, the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME). UCLA and AFSCME were in negotiations for more than two years before finally ratifying a contract earlier this year, though disputes and negotiations between UCLA and AFSCME Local 3299 have been ongoing over the last several years.[1] The union’s previous contract expired in 2024, and the union has struck five times since then, alleging that UCLA has engaged in bad faith bargaining and unfair labor practices. The collective bargaining agreement (CBA) signed by UCLA and AFSCME earlier this year provided a $1,500 one-time payment to permanent employees and increased the union’s minimum wage to $30.10 by April 2029, with annual increases thereafter.[2]
Under the 2020 CBA between UCLA and AFSCME, UCLA is prohibited from contracting out work covered by the bargaining unit, with narrow exceptions. These exceptions include contracting out to address an emergency and for temporary, short-term needs.[3] The prohibition on contracting out work is important, as outsourcing work otherwise covered by unionized employees is a common way in which employers subvert the power of the union and deny the union’s benefits to workers conducting work that would otherwise be covered by the bargaining unit. If UCLA decides to contract out covered services under the exceptions, it must notify the union to review. If the parties disagree relating to the contracting out of services, they must enter into negotiations. Under the CBA, disputes between the parties must be resolved first through arbitration, thereby avoiding expensive and drawn-out proceedings in court.
However, UCLA has not been complying with the limitation on contracting out union worker services and has refused multiple times to comply with the decisions of arbitrators over the outsourcing of covered services.[4] In 2021, UCLA contracted out work within its dining halls, rather than hiring unionized employees, and without giving AFSCME the required notice. When AFSCME challenged the outsourcing of employee work, UCLA stalled the arbitration and ultimately refused to comply with multiple arbitrator decisions that found that its contracting out violated its CBA with the union.
- PERB and the limits of the current system
Under the Higher Education Employee Relations Act of 1978 (HEERA), employees at the UC and CSU have the right to organize and collectively bargain. (Gov. Code §§ 3560 et seq.) HEERA provides various processes for UC and CSU employees to organize and form a union, and for the good faith bargaining between a recognized union and the university. It is administered by the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB), the quasi-judicial state agency that administers various state public employer-employee relations statutes. Under HEERA, it is unlawful for the UC to engage in numerous acts that effectively deny an employee their right to organize and collectively bargain, including denying employee unions the rights guaranteed by HEERA, refusing or failing to engage in meeting and conferring with an exclusive representative, and others acts. (Gov. Code § 3571.) PERB is empowered under HEERA to investigate unfair labor practices and violations of HEERA’s provisions, and to take any action necessary to resolve any such violations or unfair labor practices charges. (Gov. Code § 3563.) PERB is also empowered to bring an action in court to enforce its orders or to obtain temporary relief or a restraining order upon the issuance of an unfair labor practice charge. (Gov. Code § 3563.)
HEERA also permits the parties to agree in their CBAs to submit to arbitration to resolve disputes regarding the CBA or conflicts between the parties. (Gov. Code § 3589.) If a party to such a CBA is aggrieved by the other party’s refusal, failure, or neglect to proceed to arbitration, it can bring a civil action in court to direct the other party to proceed with arbitration. (Ibid.) Any arbitration decision is final and binding upon the parties, and also may be enforced in court. (Ibid.)
- AB 1582 proposes to allow a party to go to PERB for a violation of an arbitrator’s decision
According to the author, the UC has repeatedly failed to engage in arbitration with AFSCME regarding issues of contracting out work covered by unionized employees, and has repeatedly refused to comply with arbitrator awards when they do comply with arbitration. This has resulted in significant delays for the union, and the continued unlawful contracting out of unionized employees’ work. When there has been a dispute regarding UCLA’s failure to comply with the arbitrator’s awards, AFSCME has had to go to court, an expensive and drawn out process.
AB 1582 proposes to allow a party aggrieved by the other party’s failure to engage in arbitration or follow an arbitrator’s decision regarding contracting out of union workers’ services to go directly to PERB for that violation. It makes it an unfair practice to: fail or refuse to schedule an arbitration within a reasonable time; fail or refuse to implement an arbitration award and remedy in full within 60 days; fail or refuse to remedy, in whole or in part, an arbitrator’s decision that remands the remedy to be determined by the parties; and circumvent or disregard an arbitrator’s decision by extending or renewing an existing contract or entering into one or more new contracts for the same or similar services at the same location, or otherwise violating the same contract term or terms already interpreted by an arbitrator to prohibit the employer’s conduct. These provisions are aimed at preventing a party from delaying arbitration or the implementation of an arbitration award, or otherwise getting around the arbitrator’s decision by signing new contracts to contract out similar work. Such actions can undermine the decisions of the arbitrator, and prolong a dispute that was meant to be resolved by the arbitrator.
AB 1582’s provisions would allow the union or the UC to go to PERB, instead of court, to resolve a dispute regarding an arbitrator’s decision or to resolve the other party’s failure to arbitrate. This is notable because PERB has specific expertise in labor law, and can review and decide the unfair labor practice more efficiently than a court. To the degree it needs to enforce its decision on such an unfair labor practice, PERB also can go to court to do so.
In addition, AB 1582’s provisions make clear that certain acts regarding the arbitration process constitute a hinderance or denial an employee’s rights under HEERA to collectively bargain. If an employee’s remedy is arbitration, but arbitration can be excessively delayed or an arbitrator’s decisions ignored, the employee does not have much of a right. Such tactics deny the employee their rights and the union those remedies that the union and the employer agreed to in signing the CBA.
- Amendments
The author has agreed to amendments that will revise the language in the bill to include any time limits and other requirements of any collective bargaining agreement, and to clarify that its provisions do not alter the terms of the parties’ collective bargaining agreement or authorize PERB to alter the arbitrator’s decision. A mock-up of the amendments is attached at the end of this analysis.
- Arguments in support
According to AFSCME Local 3299, which is the sponsor of this bill:
For decades UC has used the practice of contracting out jobs and replacing us with cheap labor. The State Auditor has documented that UC’s private contractors pay less, provide fewer benefits, and mistreat workers with impunity.
When we have challenged contracting out practices and prevailed in arbitration, a process agreed upon in our collective bargaining agreements, UC has responded with disrespect and defiance. They extend the same prohibited contracts, enter into new agreements for identical services, and simply wait for us to go back through the arbitration process again — at our own expense and at the cost of years of delay. This cycle of deliberate noncompliance renders our collective bargaining agreements meaningless and makes a mockery of the arbitration system that both parties agreed to honor.
AB 1582 establishes that it is an unfair labor practice for a higher education employer to circumvent or disregard an arbitrator's decision by renewing or re-entering contracts for the same prohibited services. It prohibits the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB) from deferring repeat violations back to arbitration. It authorizes civil penalties of $1,000 per day for repeat offenders and requires that employers who violate these provisions pay the charging party's attorney's fees and costs. These are not punitive measures – they are minimum accountability standards.
- Arguments in opposition
According to the University of California, which opposes AB 1582:
Codifying a Single Grievance into a Statutory Mandate Is Bad Public Policy. Arbitration is inherently designed to resolve specific, isolated disputes between parties based on unique local circumstances. It should never be used to dictate broad statutory mandates. AB 1582 sets a dangerous precedent by turning narrow and specific arbitration rulings into a blanket prohibitions on service contracts at a UC campus or medical facility.
Under the rigid framework proposed by this bill, if a UC campus or medical center commits a minor technical infraction, such as an administrative failure to provide notice within a specific timeframe, that isolated mistake can be used to block that location from using essential service agreements in perpetuity. This applies even when such agreements would otherwise be allowed under a recently negotiated collective bargaining agreement.
The bill’s "same or similar services" language creates an unworkable standard for UC campuses and medical centers, which often have multiple locations across various regions of California. This is a deliberate attempt to enforce a blanket shutdown of vital day-to-day operations, directly impacting medical center operations (hospital assistants, medical technicians, and frontline clinical staff) and campus infrastructure (dining, food services, building maintenance, custodial care, and security services).
AB 1582 Directly Threatens Patient Safety. Public policy must balance workforce protections with the operational reality of delivering life-saving healthcare. No hospital system can maintain a permanent, standing workforce deep enough to handle unpredictable regional disasters or sudden public health surges on short notice. If a UC medical center faces an unexpected surge in patient demand or a severe flu season, this bill would handcuff UC hospitals and clinics from scaling up temporary care. This restriction will directly result in longer patient wait times and delayed clinical care; a severe, compounding strain on frontline healthcare teams; and restricted access to specialized clinical expertise when patients need it most.
SUPPORT
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME) Local 3299
(co-sponsor)
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME) Council 57
(co-sponsor)
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME), AFL-CIO
California Faculty Association
CFT – a Union of Educators & Classified Professionals, AFT, AFL-CIO
Pajaro Valley Federation of Teachers, AFT 1936
Teamsters California
UC Irvine Faculty Association
Union of American Physicians and Dentists
United Domestic Workers/AFSCME Local 3930
UPTE-CWA 9119
OPPOSITION
Bay Area Council
California Chamber of Commerce
California Hospital Association
California State University, Office of the Chancellor
Central City Association of Los Angeles
Los Angeles Business Council
Los Angeles Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles County Business Federation (BIZ-FED)
Sacramento Metropolitan Chamber of Commerce
San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce
Santa Barbara South Coast Chamber of Commerce
Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce
Silicon Valley Leadership Group (SVLG)
Valley Industry and Commerce Association (VICA)
West Los Angeles Chamber of Commerce
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known.
Prior Legislation:
SB 23 (Durazo, Ch. 480, Stats. 2023) required UC vendors to provide their employees with the total compensation specified by the vendor’s contract, as well as make certain payroll information available to employees, the UC, and exclusive employee representatives. Additionally, it provided a pathway for employees of a vendor contracting with the UC to recover compensation and civil damages, as specified.
SCA 7 (Umberg, 2023) would have established a broad-based constitutional right for any person in California to form or join a union and for that union to represent the person in collective bargaining with the person’s respective employer. It also would have prohibited the passing of any statute or ordinance that interferes with, negates, or diminishes these rights. SCA 7 died in the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee.
SB 27 (Durazo, Ch. 480, Stats. 2023) made it unlawful for any vendor, as defined, to accept payment from the university pursuant to a contract for prescribed services if the vendor is performing services or supplying the university with employees to perform services who are paid less than the higher of the total compensation rate specified in the vendor’s contract with the university or as required by university policy.
ACA 6 (Haney, 2023) would have required individuals who perform work for the UC Regents to have the right to specified basic state labor standards. The measure died in the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee.
SB 1364 (Durazo, 2022) was similar to SB 27 and additionally provided for a vendor in violation to pay a ten percent civil penalty to the General Fund and be disqualified from contracting with the UC for five years. The bill was vetoed by the Governor, who stated “While I support the enforcement of Regents Policy 5402 and the terms of Article 5, as UC is still implementing their audit mechanisms of the policies, this bill is premature.”
ACA 14 (Gonzalez, 2019) would have amended the California Constitution, Article IX, to require the UC Regents ensure that all UC contract workers receive the same equal employment opportunity standards as UC employees that perform similar services. The measure died on the Senate Floor.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Labor, Public Employment and Retirement Committee (Ayes 4, Noes 1)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 67, Noes 7)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 13, Noes 2)
Assembly Public Employment and Retirement Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 0)
**************
Mock-up of proposed amendments to AB 1582 (Ortega)
(Amendments may be subject to technical changes required by Legislative Counsel)
The people of the State of California do enact as follows:
SECTION 1. Section 3571.01 is added to the Government Code, to read:
3571.01.
(a) With respect to arbitrations over violations of a collective bargaining agreement that relate to the contracting out of bargaining unit work, it shall be an unfair practice for a higher education employer to do any of the following:
(1) Fail or refuse to schedule an arbitration within any time limits established in the collective bargaining agreement, or within a reasonable period of time after the union has appealed the matter to arbitration if no time limit is specified, unless the exclusive representative has placed the grievance in abeyance or the parties have agreed to do so. An employer does not violate this paragraph if the exclusive representative has not met its obligation under the parties’ agreement to move forward with arbitration, including, but not limited to, filing a timely appeal, providing information necessary for the parties to select an arbitrator and providing availability. An employer does not violate this paragraph if the selected arbitrator or the exclusive representative are not available within the time limits set in the collective bargaining agreement or if the parties stipulated to alternative timelines.
(2) Fail or refuse to implement an arbitration award and remedy in full within 60: (1) 180 days of a an arbitration decision on the merits that does not include specific timelines; (2) the implementation timelines specified in the arbitrator’s decision; or (3) the parties’ stipulated timelines.
(3) (A) Circumvent or disregard an arbitrator’s decision by extending or renewing an existing contract or entering into one or more new contracts for the same or similar services at the same location, or otherwise violating the same contract term or terms already interpreted by an arbitrator to prohibit the employer’s conduct.
(B) In the cases described in subparagraph (A), the board shall not defer repeat offenses to subsequent arbitration proceedings.
(4) (A) Fail or refuse to remedy, in whole or in part, an arbitrator’s decision that remands the remedy to be determined by the parties.
(B) In the cases described in subparagraph (A), the board shall defer to the merits of the arbitration award but shall not defer disputes regarding the remedy to subsequent arbitration proceedings absent agreement of the parties.
(b) Remedies for a violation of this section shall include the charging party’s attorney’s fees and costs.
(c) Except as expressly set forth in this section, this section does not limit the board’s broad remedial authority, alter the terms of the parties’ collective bargaining agreement related to the contracting out of bargaining unit work, or authorize the board to alter an arbitrator’s decision.
Alex Muchnik, “AFSCME Local 3299 employees vote to ratify contract,” https://dailybruin.com/2026/05/22/afscme-local-3299-employees-vote-to-ratify-contract. ↑
Id. ↑
UC and AFSCME CBA, Article 5, § H. ↑
See. https://afscme3299.org/blog/ucla-violates-contract-refuses-to-insource-workers/; https://www.afscme.org/blog/afscme-members-stand-up-against-outsourcing-at-university-of-california. ↑
Senator Thomas Umberg, Chair
2025-2026 Regular Session
Bill No: AB 1582 (Author:Ortega)
Version: June 8, 2026
Hearing Date: June 30, 2026
Fiscal: Yes
Urgency: No
Consultant: ID
SUBJECT
Higher Education Employer-Employee Relations Act: collective bargaining: unfair labor practices
DIGEST
This bill makes various acts by a higher education employer, with respect to arbitrations over violations of a collective bargaining agreement relating to the contracting out of bargaining unit work, unfair practices, as specified.
EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
Under the Higher Education Employee Relations Act of 1978 (HEERA), employees at the University of California (UC) and California State University (CSU) have the right to organize and collectively bargain. (Gov. Code §§ 3560 et seq.) HEERA provides various processes for UC and CSU employees to organize and form a union, and for the good faith bargaining between a recognized union and the university. It is administered by the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB), the quasi-judicial state agency that administers various state public employer-employee relations statutes. HEERA also permits the parties to agree in their collective bargaining agreements (CBAs) to submit to arbitration to resolve disputes regarding the CBA or conflicts between the parties. (Gov. Code § 3589.) However, the author reports that, in numerous instances, the UC has delayed the arbitration process regarding issues relating to the UC contracting out bargaining unit work, or has failed to implement or abide by the arbitrator’s decision. In such instances, the only recourse for the UC workers’ union is to go to court. AB 1582 proposes to make such actions regarding subverting the arbitration process an unfair practice, thereby allowing an aggrieved party to allege such an unfair practice before PERB, as specified.
AB 1582 is sponsored by AFSCME Local 3299 and AFSCME Council 57, and is supported by a number of other AFSCME chapters and unions. It is opposed by the UC, the California State University, the California Chamber of Commerce, and other groups. It previously passed out of the Senate Labor, Public Employment and Retirement Committee by a vote of 4 to 1.
PROPOSED CHANGES TO THE LAW
Existing law:
- Establishes the University of California (UC) as a public trust under the administration of the Regents of the University of California and grants the Regents all the powers necessary or convenient for the effective administration of this public trust. Establishes that the UC Regents are subject only to such legislative control as may be necessary to insure the security of its funds, to ensure compliance with the terms of the endowments of the university, and such competitive bidding procedures as may be made applicable to the university by statute for the letting of construction contracts, sales of real property, and purchasing of materials, goods, and services. (California Constitution, Article XIV, § 9.)
- Establishes HEERA, which provides a statutory framework to regulate labor relations between the UC, CSU, and the University of California College of the Law, San Francisco (UC Law SF), and their respective employees. (Gov. Code §§ 3560 et seq.)
- Defines “Higher Education Employer” to mean any of the following: the UC Board of Regents, the UC Law SF Board of Directors, the California State University (CSU) Board of Trustees, or a person acting as an agent of one of the aforementioned entities. (Gov. Code §3562 (g).)
- Defines “scope of representation” for HEERA’s application to UC to mean, and be limited to, wages, hours of employment, and other terms and conditions of employment, but not does not include consideration of the merits, necessity, or organization of any service, activity, or program established by law or resolution of the regents or the directors, except for the terms and conditions of employment of employees who may be affected thereby. (Gov. Code § 3562 (q).)
- Establishes the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB) to administer the several collective bargaining statutes covering specified California public employees, including HEERA. PERB functions as a quasi-judicial administrative agency responsible for adjudicating employer-employee relations, resolving disputes, and enforcing the statutory duties and rights of public agency employers and employee organizations (Gov. Code § 3541.)
- Provides that a HEERA employer and an exclusive representative who enter into a written memorandum of understanding (MOU) may agree to procedures for final and binding arbitration of disputes that may arise under the memorandum of understanding or between the parties. (Gov. Code § 3589 (a).)
- Authorizes an aggrieved party to an MOU to seek a court order directing that the arbitration proceed pursuant to the MOU’s procedures if the other party fails, neglects, or refuses to proceed to arbitration. (Gov. Code § 3589 (b).)
- Makes an arbitration award final and binding upon the parties and enforceable by a court pursuant to Title 9 (commencing with Section 1280) of Part 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure. (Gov. Code § 3589 (c).)
- Defines “Arbitration” in HEERA to mean a method of resolving a rights dispute under which the parties to a controversy must accept the award of a third party. (Gov. Code § 3562 (a).)
- Provides that PERB will defer adjudicating an unfair labor practice complaint where the parties have agreed to the arbitration procedure, as specified. (see Regents of the University of California (San Francisco) (1984) PERB Decision No. Ad -139-H.)
- Makes it unlawful for the UC to engage in numerous acts, including denying employee unions rights guaranteed by HEERA, refusing or failing to engage in meeting and conferring with an exclusive representative, and others. (Gov. Code § 3571.)
- Empowers PERB to investigate unfair practices and violations of HEERA’s provisions, and to take any action necessary to resolve any such violations or unfair labor practices charges. Also empowers PERB to bring an action in court to enforce its orders or to obtain temporary relief or a restraining order upon the issuance of an unfair practice charge. (Gov. Code § 3563.)
This bill:
- Makes it an unfair practice, with respect to arbitrations over violations of a collective bargaining agreement that relate to the contracting out of bargaining unit work, for a higher education employer to:
- Fail or refuse to schedule an arbitration within a reasonable period of time after the union has appealed the matter to arbitration, unless the exclusive representative has placed the grievance in abeyance, or the parties have agreed to do so;
- Fail or refuse to implement an arbitration award and remedy in full within 60 days of a decision on the merits;
- Circumvent or disregard an arbitrator’s decision by: extending or renewing an existing contract or entering into one or more new contracts for the same or similar services at the same location, or otherwise violating the same contract term or terms already interpreted by an arbitrator to prohibit the employer’s conduct;
- For such cases, prohibits PERB from deferring repeat offenses to subsequent arbitration proceedings;
- Fail or refuse to remedy, in whole or in part, an arbitrator’s decision that remands the remedy to be determined by the parties. For these cases, requires PERB to defer to the merits of the arbitration award, but prohibits deferring disputes regarding the remedy to subsequent arbitration proceedings absent agreement of the parties.
- Specifies that the remedies for a violation of (1), above, include the charging party’s attorney’s fees and costs.
- Specifies that, except as expressly set forth above, these provisions do not limit PERB’s broad remedial authority.
COMMENTS
- Author’s statement
In support of this measure, the author states:
For decades, the University of California (UC) has contracted out service work.
In recent years, UC agreed to an arbitration process in their collective bargaining agreements with service and patient care technical workers to resolve disagreements over contracting out.
UC is now consistently violating the arbitration process. UC doesn’t follow the arbitrator’s decisions.
Current law does not provide an adequate enforcement remedy to address the harms suffered by workers related to a higher education employer’s refusal to respect the arbitration process and the arbitrator’s decisions regarding the contracting out of work.
AB 1582 restores the integrity of arbitration.
- The UC and AFSCME’s labor dispute over contract work
This bill comes out of the long-running dispute between UCLA and the union that represents 40,000 of its service, patient case, and skilled craft employees, the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME). UCLA and AFSCME were in negotiations for more than two years before finally ratifying a contract earlier this year, though disputes and negotiations between UCLA and AFSCME Local 3299 have been ongoing over the last several years.[1] The union’s previous contract expired in 2024, and the union has struck five times since then, alleging that UCLA has engaged in bad faith bargaining and unfair labor practices. The collective bargaining agreement (CBA) signed by UCLA and AFSCME earlier this year provided a $1,500 one-time payment to permanent employees and increased the union’s minimum wage to $30.10 by April 2029, with annual increases thereafter.[2]
Under the 2020 CBA between UCLA and AFSCME, UCLA is prohibited from contracting out work covered by the bargaining unit, with narrow exceptions. These exceptions include contracting out to address an emergency and for temporary, short-term needs.[3] The prohibition on contracting out work is important, as outsourcing work otherwise covered by unionized employees is a common way in which employers subvert the power of the union and deny the union’s benefits to workers conducting work that would otherwise be covered by the bargaining unit. If UCLA decides to contract out covered services under the exceptions, it must notify the union to review. If the parties disagree relating to the contracting out of services, they must enter into negotiations. Under the CBA, disputes between the parties must be resolved first through arbitration, thereby avoiding expensive and drawn-out proceedings in court.
However, UCLA has not been complying with the limitation on contracting out union worker services and has refused multiple times to comply with the decisions of arbitrators over the outsourcing of covered services.[4] In 2021, UCLA contracted out work within its dining halls, rather than hiring unionized employees, and without giving AFSCME the required notice. When AFSCME challenged the outsourcing of employee work, UCLA stalled the arbitration and ultimately refused to comply with multiple arbitrator decisions that found that its contracting out violated its CBA with the union.
- PERB and the limits of the current system
Under the Higher Education Employee Relations Act of 1978 (HEERA), employees at the UC and CSU have the right to organize and collectively bargain. (Gov. Code §§ 3560 et seq.) HEERA provides various processes for UC and CSU employees to organize and form a union, and for the good faith bargaining between a recognized union and the university. It is administered by the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB), the quasi-judicial state agency that administers various state public employer-employee relations statutes. Under HEERA, it is unlawful for the UC to engage in numerous acts that effectively deny an employee their right to organize and collectively bargain, including denying employee unions the rights guaranteed by HEERA, refusing or failing to engage in meeting and conferring with an exclusive representative, and others acts. (Gov. Code § 3571.) PERB is empowered under HEERA to investigate unfair labor practices and violations of HEERA’s provisions, and to take any action necessary to resolve any such violations or unfair labor practices charges. (Gov. Code § 3563.) PERB is also empowered to bring an action in court to enforce its orders or to obtain temporary relief or a restraining order upon the issuance of an unfair labor practice charge. (Gov. Code § 3563.)
HEERA also permits the parties to agree in their CBAs to submit to arbitration to resolve disputes regarding the CBA or conflicts between the parties. (Gov. Code § 3589.) If a party to such a CBA is aggrieved by the other party’s refusal, failure, or neglect to proceed to arbitration, it can bring a civil action in court to direct the other party to proceed with arbitration. (Ibid.) Any arbitration decision is final and binding upon the parties, and also may be enforced in court. (Ibid.)
- AB 1582 proposes to allow a party to go to PERB for a violation of an arbitrator’s decision
According to the author, the UC has repeatedly failed to engage in arbitration with AFSCME regarding issues of contracting out work covered by unionized employees, and has repeatedly refused to comply with arbitrator awards when they do comply with arbitration. This has resulted in significant delays for the union, and the continued unlawful contracting out of unionized employees’ work. When there has been a dispute regarding UCLA’s failure to comply with the arbitrator’s awards, AFSCME has had to go to court, an expensive and drawn out process.
AB 1582 proposes to allow a party aggrieved by the other party’s failure to engage in arbitration or follow an arbitrator’s decision regarding contracting out of union workers’ services to go directly to PERB for that violation. It makes it an unfair practice to: fail or refuse to schedule an arbitration within a reasonable time; fail or refuse to implement an arbitration award and remedy in full within 60 days; fail or refuse to remedy, in whole or in part, an arbitrator’s decision that remands the remedy to be determined by the parties; and circumvent or disregard an arbitrator’s decision by extending or renewing an existing contract or entering into one or more new contracts for the same or similar services at the same location, or otherwise violating the same contract term or terms already interpreted by an arbitrator to prohibit the employer’s conduct. These provisions are aimed at preventing a party from delaying arbitration or the implementation of an arbitration award, or otherwise getting around the arbitrator’s decision by signing new contracts to contract out similar work. Such actions can undermine the decisions of the arbitrator, and prolong a dispute that was meant to be resolved by the arbitrator.
AB 1582’s provisions would allow the union or the UC to go to PERB, instead of court, to resolve a dispute regarding an arbitrator’s decision or to resolve the other party’s failure to arbitrate. This is notable because PERB has specific expertise in labor law, and can review and decide the unfair labor practice more efficiently than a court. To the degree it needs to enforce its decision on such an unfair labor practice, PERB also can go to court to do so.
In addition, AB 1582’s provisions make clear that certain acts regarding the arbitration process constitute a hinderance or denial an employee’s rights under HEERA to collectively bargain. If an employee’s remedy is arbitration, but arbitration can be excessively delayed or an arbitrator’s decisions ignored, the employee does not have much of a right. Such tactics deny the employee their rights and the union those remedies that the union and the employer agreed to in signing the CBA.
- Amendments
The author has agreed to amendments that will revise the language in the bill to include any time limits and other requirements of any collective bargaining agreement, and to clarify that its provisions do not alter the terms of the parties’ collective bargaining agreement or authorize PERB to alter the arbitrator’s decision. A mock-up of the amendments is attached at the end of this analysis.
- Arguments in support
According to AFSCME Local 3299, which is the sponsor of this bill:
For decades UC has used the practice of contracting out jobs and replacing us with cheap labor. The State Auditor has documented that UC’s private contractors pay less, provide fewer benefits, and mistreat workers with impunity.
When we have challenged contracting out practices and prevailed in arbitration, a process agreed upon in our collective bargaining agreements, UC has responded with disrespect and defiance. They extend the same prohibited contracts, enter into new agreements for identical services, and simply wait for us to go back through the arbitration process again — at our own expense and at the cost of years of delay. This cycle of deliberate noncompliance renders our collective bargaining agreements meaningless and makes a mockery of the arbitration system that both parties agreed to honor.
AB 1582 establishes that it is an unfair labor practice for a higher education employer to circumvent or disregard an arbitrator's decision by renewing or re-entering contracts for the same prohibited services. It prohibits the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB) from deferring repeat violations back to arbitration. It authorizes civil penalties of $1,000 per day for repeat offenders and requires that employers who violate these provisions pay the charging party's attorney's fees and costs. These are not punitive measures – they are minimum accountability standards.
- Arguments in opposition
According to the University of California, which opposes AB 1582:
Codifying a Single Grievance into a Statutory Mandate Is Bad Public Policy. Arbitration is inherently designed to resolve specific, isolated disputes between parties based on unique local circumstances. It should never be used to dictate broad statutory mandates. AB 1582 sets a dangerous precedent by turning narrow and specific arbitration rulings into a blanket prohibitions on service contracts at a UC campus or medical facility.
Under the rigid framework proposed by this bill, if a UC campus or medical center commits a minor technical infraction, such as an administrative failure to provide notice within a specific timeframe, that isolated mistake can be used to block that location from using essential service agreements in perpetuity. This applies even when such agreements would otherwise be allowed under a recently negotiated collective bargaining agreement.
The bill’s "same or similar services" language creates an unworkable standard for UC campuses and medical centers, which often have multiple locations across various regions of California. This is a deliberate attempt to enforce a blanket shutdown of vital day-to-day operations, directly impacting medical center operations (hospital assistants, medical technicians, and frontline clinical staff) and campus infrastructure (dining, food services, building maintenance, custodial care, and security services).
AB 1582 Directly Threatens Patient Safety. Public policy must balance workforce protections with the operational reality of delivering life-saving healthcare. No hospital system can maintain a permanent, standing workforce deep enough to handle unpredictable regional disasters or sudden public health surges on short notice. If a UC medical center faces an unexpected surge in patient demand or a severe flu season, this bill would handcuff UC hospitals and clinics from scaling up temporary care. This restriction will directly result in longer patient wait times and delayed clinical care; a severe, compounding strain on frontline healthcare teams; and restricted access to specialized clinical expertise when patients need it most.
SUPPORT
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME) Local 3299
(co-sponsor)
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME) Council 57
(co-sponsor)
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees (AFSCME), AFL-CIO
California Faculty Association
CFT – a Union of Educators & Classified Professionals, AFT, AFL-CIO
Pajaro Valley Federation of Teachers, AFT 1936
Teamsters California
UC Irvine Faculty Association
Union of American Physicians and Dentists
United Domestic Workers/AFSCME Local 3930
UPTE-CWA 9119
OPPOSITION
Bay Area Council
California Chamber of Commerce
California Hospital Association
California State University, Office of the Chancellor
Central City Association of Los Angeles
Los Angeles Business Council
Los Angeles Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles County Business Federation (BIZ-FED)
Sacramento Metropolitan Chamber of Commerce
San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce
Santa Barbara South Coast Chamber of Commerce
Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce
Silicon Valley Leadership Group (SVLG)
Valley Industry and Commerce Association (VICA)
West Los Angeles Chamber of Commerce
RELATED LEGISLATION
Pending Legislation: None known.
Prior Legislation:
SB 23 (Durazo, Ch. 480, Stats. 2023) required UC vendors to provide their employees with the total compensation specified by the vendor’s contract, as well as make certain payroll information available to employees, the UC, and exclusive employee representatives. Additionally, it provided a pathway for employees of a vendor contracting with the UC to recover compensation and civil damages, as specified.
SCA 7 (Umberg, 2023) would have established a broad-based constitutional right for any person in California to form or join a union and for that union to represent the person in collective bargaining with the person’s respective employer. It also would have prohibited the passing of any statute or ordinance that interferes with, negates, or diminishes these rights. SCA 7 died in the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee.
SB 27 (Durazo, Ch. 480, Stats. 2023) made it unlawful for any vendor, as defined, to accept payment from the university pursuant to a contract for prescribed services if the vendor is performing services or supplying the university with employees to perform services who are paid less than the higher of the total compensation rate specified in the vendor’s contract with the university or as required by university policy.
ACA 6 (Haney, 2023) would have required individuals who perform work for the UC Regents to have the right to specified basic state labor standards. The measure died in the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee.
SB 1364 (Durazo, 2022) was similar to SB 27 and additionally provided for a vendor in violation to pay a ten percent civil penalty to the General Fund and be disqualified from contracting with the UC for five years. The bill was vetoed by the Governor, who stated “While I support the enforcement of Regents Policy 5402 and the terms of Article 5, as UC is still implementing their audit mechanisms of the policies, this bill is premature.”
ACA 14 (Gonzalez, 2019) would have amended the California Constitution, Article IX, to require the UC Regents ensure that all UC contract workers receive the same equal employment opportunity standards as UC employees that perform similar services. The measure died on the Senate Floor.
PRIOR VOTES:
Senate Labor, Public Employment and Retirement Committee (Ayes 4, Noes 1)
Assembly Floor (Ayes 67, Noes 7)
Assembly Appropriations Committee (Ayes 13, Noes 2)
Assembly Public Employment and Retirement Committee (Ayes 7, Noes 0)
**************
Mock-up of proposed amendments to AB 1582 (Ortega)
(Amendments may be subject to technical changes required by Legislative Counsel)
The people of the State of California do enact as follows:
SECTION 1. Section 3571.01 is added to the Government Code, to read:
3571.01.
(a) With respect to arbitrations over violations of a collective bargaining agreement that relate to the contracting out of bargaining unit work, it shall be an unfair practice for a higher education employer to do any of the following:
(1) Fail or refuse to schedule an arbitration within any time limits established in the collective bargaining agreement, or within a reasonable period of time after the union has appealed the matter to arbitration if no time limit is specified, unless the exclusive representative has placed the grievance in abeyance or the parties have agreed to do so. An employer does not violate this paragraph if the exclusive representative has not met its obligation under the parties’ agreement to move forward with arbitration, including, but not limited to, filing a timely appeal, providing information necessary for the parties to select an arbitrator and providing availability. An employer does not violate this paragraph if the selected arbitrator or the exclusive representative are not available within the time limits set in the collective bargaining agreement or if the parties stipulated to alternative timelines.
(2) Fail or refuse to implement an arbitration award and remedy in full within 60: (1) 180 days of a an arbitration decision on the merits that does not include specific timelines; (2) the implementation timelines specified in the arbitrator’s decision; or (3) the parties’ stipulated timelines.
(3) (A) Circumvent or disregard an arbitrator’s decision by extending or renewing an existing contract or entering into one or more new contracts for the same or similar services at the same location, or otherwise violating the same contract term or terms already interpreted by an arbitrator to prohibit the employer’s conduct.
(B) In the cases described in subparagraph (A), the board shall not defer repeat offenses to subsequent arbitration proceedings.
(4) (A) Fail or refuse to remedy, in whole or in part, an arbitrator’s decision that remands the remedy to be determined by the parties.
(B) In the cases described in subparagraph (A), the board shall defer to the merits of the arbitration award but shall not defer disputes regarding the remedy to subsequent arbitration proceedings absent agreement of the parties.
(b) Remedies for a violation of this section shall include the charging party’s attorney’s fees and costs.
(c) Except as expressly set forth in this section, this section does not limit the board’s broad remedial authority, alter the terms of the parties’ collective bargaining agreement related to the contracting out of bargaining unit work, or authorize the board to alter an arbitrator’s decision.
Alex Muchnik, “AFSCME Local 3299 employees vote to ratify contract,” https://dailybruin.com/2026/05/22/afscme-local-3299-employees-vote-to-ratify-contract. ↑
Id. ↑
UC and AFSCME CBA, Article 5, § H. ↑
See. https://afscme3299.org/blog/ucla-violates-contract-refuses-to-insource-workers/; https://www.afscme.org/blog/afscme-members-stand-up-against-outsourcing-at-university-of-california. ↑
SENATE COMMITTEE ON LABOR, PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Senator Lola Smallwood-Cuevas, Chair
2025 - 2026 Regular
Bill No: AB 1582 Hearing Date: June 17, 2026
Author: | Ortega | ||
Version: | May 18, 2026 | ||
Urgency: | No | Fiscal: | Yes |
Consultant: | Glenn Miles | ||
SUBJECT: Higher Education Employer-Employee Relations Act: collective bargaining: unfair labor practices.
KEY ISSUE
This bill makes specified activities by Higher Education Employer-Employee Relations Act (HEERA) covered employers related to arbitration over collective bargaining agreement (CBA) violations subject to unfair labor practice charges at the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB).
ANALYSIS
Existing law:
- Establishes the University of California (UC) as a public trust under the administration of the Regents of the University of California and grants the Regents all the powers necessary or convenient for the effective administration of this public trust. Establishes that the UC Regents are subject only to such legislative control as may be necessary to insure the security of its funds, to ensure compliance with the terms of the endowments of the university, and such competitive bidding procedures as may be made applicable to the university by statute for the letting of construction contracts, sales of real property, and purchasing of materials, goods, and services. (California Constitution, Article XIV, Sec. 9)
- Establishes HEERA which provides a statutory framework to regulate labor relations between the University of California (UC), the California State University (CSU), and the University of California College of the Law, San Francisco (UC Law SF) and their respective employees. (Government Code § 3560 et seq.)
- Defines “Higher Education Employer” to mean any of the following: the UC Board of Regents, the UC Law SF Board of Directors, the California State University (CSU) Board of Trustees, or a person acting as an agent of one of the aforementioned entities. (Government Code §3562 (g))
- Defines “scope of representation” for HEERA’s application to UC to mean, and be limited to, wages, hours of employment, and other terms and conditions of employment but not does not include consideration of the merits, necessity, or organization of any service, activity, or program established by law or resolution of the regents or the directors, except for the terms and conditions of employment of employees who may be affected thereby. (Government Code § 3562 (q))
- Establishes the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB) to administer the several collective bargaining statutes covering specified California public employees. PERB functions as a quasi-judicial administrative agency responsible for adjudicating employer-employee relations, resolving disputes, and enforcing the statutory duties and rights of public agency employers and employee organizations (Government Code §3541).
- Provides that a HEERA employer and an exclusive representative who enter into a written memorandum of understanding (MOU) may agree to procedures for final and binding arbitration of disputes that may arise under the memorandum of understanding or between the parties. (Government Code § 3589 (a))
- Authorizes an aggrieved party to an MOU to seek a court order directing that the arbitration proceed pursuant to the MOU’s procedures if the other party fails, neglects, or refuses to proceed to arbitration. (Government Code § 3589 (b))
- Makes an arbitration award final and binding upon the parties and enforceable by a court pursuant to Title 9 (commencing with Section 1280) of Part 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure. (Government Code § 3589 (c))
- Defines “Arbitration” in HEERA to mean a method of resolving a rights dispute under which the parties to a controversy must accept the award of a third party. (Government Code § 3562 (a))
- Provides that PERB will defer adjudicating an unfair labor practice complaint where the parties have agreed to the arbitration procedure, as specified. (see Regents of the University of California (San Francisco) (1984) PERB Decision No. Ad -139-H (holding that PERB will not defer where the parties have not mutually agreed to arbitration))
- Requires the UC Regents to let all contracts, as specified, involving an expenditure of more than $100,000 annually for goods and materials to be sold to the University of California to the lowest responsible bidder meeting specifications, or else reject all bids. (Public Contract Code § 10507.7)
- Requires UC to make or enter service contracts with the lowest responsible bidder, as specified, or else reject all bids but UC may award a contract to the second lowest responsible bidder if the successful bidder refuses or fails to execute a tendered contract for materials, goods, or services. (Public Contract Code § 10507.7)
- Allows UC contract based on “Best Value” criteria if UC determines that it can expect long-term savings, as specified. (Public Contract Code § 10507.8)
- Authorizes UC to award a contract for the acquisition of goods, services, or information technology that has an estimated value of greater than $100,000 but less than two hundred $250,000, to a certified small business, including a microbusiness, or to a disabled veteran business enterprise, if UC obtains price quotations from two or more certified small businesses, including microbusinesses, or from two or more disabled veteran business enterprises. (Public Contract Code § 10508.5)
- Requires UC vendors to provide their employees with the total compensation specified by the vendor’s contract, as well as make certain payroll information available to employees, the UC, and exclusive employee representatives. Additionally, it provides a pathway for employees of a vendor contracting with the UC to recover compensation and civil damages, as specified. (Public Contract Code § 10510.50 et seq.)
- Provides that vendor employee protection provisions, as specified, do not preclude or alter UC’s ability to contract for services as permitted under existing policies or collective bargaining agreements, nor from hiring in emergency circumstances or to meet other staffing needs. (Public Contract Code § 10510.53 (g)
- Provides a general prohibition on contracting for covered services and only permits contracting out where required by law, Federal requirement, contract or grant requirement, or court decisions or orders, or under the specified limited, exigent circumstances that comply with the state's requirements in Government Code section 19130. (Regents Policy 5402: Policy Generally Prohibiting Contracting for Services)
- Requires UC to provide employee unions advance notice when contracting out covered services, as specified; authorizes employee unions to review proposed contracts for covered services to determine whether the contract complies with Regents Policy 5402; provides a process to resolve disputes over those proposed contracts; and clarifies that where the parties have agreed to an alternative resolution process in a collective bargaining agreement, that process takes precedence. (Regents Policy 5402: Policy Generally Prohibiting Contracting for Services (D) and (E); Agreement Between UC Regents and AFSCME (January 31, 2020, Article 5), (UC Regents LBFO for AFSCME SX and EX bargaining units (April 30, 2025), Article 5) [1]
This bill:
- Makes the following activities by a higher education employer related to arbitration over CBA violations subject to unfair labor practice charges at PERB.
- Failing or refusing to schedule an arbitration within a reasonable period of time, as specified.
- Failing or refusing to implement an arbitration award and remedy in full within 60 days of a decision on the merits.
- Circumventing or disregarding an arbitrator’s decision by extending or renewing an existing contract or entering into one or more new contracts for the same or similar services at the same location or otherwise violating the same contract term or terms already interpreted by an arbitrator to prohibit the employer’s conduct. This provision also prohibits PERB from deferring repeat offenses to subsequent arbitration proceedings.
- Failing or refusing to remedy, in whole or in part, an arbitrator’s decision that remands the remedy to be determined by the parties. This provision also requires PERB to defer to the merits of the arbitration award but not defer disputes regarding the remedy to subsequent arbitration proceedings absent agreement of the parties.
- Provides that remedies for a violation, as specified, shall include the charging party’s attorney’s fees and costs.
- Provides that the bill’s provisions do not limit PERB’s broad remedial authority except as expressly set forth.
COMMENTS
1. Background:
This bill reaches the committee in the context of tumultuous labor relations between UC and AFSCME, including five strikes by the union across the UC since starting contract negotiations in January 2024, the imposition by UC of its last best final offer (LBFO) after 16 months of bargaining, and a near systemwide strike by AFSCME halted at the last minute after UC concessions. [2]
Although the parties finally reached an agreement for UC service and patient care technical employees on May 14, 2026 (ratified on May 21, 2026), it is apparent that AFSCME and UC have not overcome their differences in several areas, including the interpretation and application of their dispute resolution process which is at issue in this bill.[3] (Indeed, the parties are still in bargaining negotiations over contracts for other UC employees. [4])
Under that process, UC must notify AFSCME when it issues a Request for Proposals (RFP) to contract for covered services [5], the union must notify UC if it wants to file a grievance over the outsourced contract, the parties must work to resolve the grievance through mediation, the union can request mandatory arbitration if it contests the mediation result, and the parties can apply to superior court to enforce the arbitration decision if the other party does not comply.[6]
This bill seeks to revise the arbitration procedure by adding recourse to PERB. Under existing PERB decisions, PERB will defer action on an unfair labor practice if the parties have mutually agreed to arbitration. Thus, without this bill, PERB will not hear AFSCME’s complaint that UC is manipulating the arbitration process and evading unfavorable arbitration decisions. Thus, AFSCME must petition the superior court each time it believes that UC is evading an arbitration decision over an outsourced contract. That approach takes a great deal of time and costs a substantial amount of money. In the meantime, workers providing the contracted services whom UC should hire as permanent UC employees lose out on lost compensation, health and pension benefits, seniority, and other university job opportunities. This bill would permit AFSCME to win at arbitration and, if UC evades the decision’s application to a class of similar work, file an unfair labor practice charge at PERB to resolve the disputes quickly and efficiently.
Unsurprisingly, UC holds a different view of the bill and instead sees it as an attempt by AFSCME to alter through legislation, a key provision agreed to in bargaining without giving any concession for it. UC insists that each outsourcing contract proposal is a discrete dispute. The CBA provisions regarding the arbitration procedure specify and limit the scope of the arbitrator’s authority, which can only decide an outcome for each contract. [7] It cannot create a universal university-wide policy. That authority rests with the UC Regents.
2. Need for this bill?
According to the author, despite a 2020 collective bargaining agreement (CBA) that limits UC’s ability to contract out work except for very narrow exceptions, UC continues to outsource work to contractors that should be done by university employees. Pursuant to that CBA, UC is required to notify the union when UC decides to contract for services to allow the union to review the dispute whether work is covered under t
3. Proponent Arguments:
According to AFSCME 3299:
“For decades UC has used the practice of contracting out jobs and replacing us with cheap labor. The State Auditor has documented that UC’s private contractors pay less, provide fewer benefits, and mistreat workers with impunity.”
“When we have challenged contracting out practices and prevailed in arbitration, a process agreed upon in our collective bargaining agreements, UC has responded with disrespect and defiance. They extend the same prohibited contracts, enter into new agreements for identical services, and simply wait for us to go back through the arbitration process again — at our own expense and at the cost of years of delay. This cycle of deliberate noncompliance renders our collective bargaining agreements meaningless and makes a mockery of
the arbitration system that both parties agreed to honor.”
According to the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees:
“AB 1582 strengthens the integrity of California's collective bargaining framework by ensuring that negotiated contract provisions and binding arbitration awards are meaningful and enforceable. When employers violate collective bargaining agreements by improperly contracting out bargaining unit work, employees and unions must have confidence that disputes will be resolved in a timely manner and that arbitration decisions will be respected.”
According to the California Faculty Association:
“It is erroneous that it took four years, three arbitrations, a court proceeding and an enormous cost before dining hall workers were hired directly. If UC had just followed what they had agreed to, all the following arbitrations could have been avoided. Now the workers and AFSCME 3299 have wasted time, resources, and money that will never be regained.
“To address the UC’s repeated violations of their CBAs and arbitration rulings, AB 1582 makes it an unfair labor practice for a higher education employer to fail to schedule arbitrations in a timely manner or to circumvent or disregard an arbitrator’s decision by extending or renewing an existing contract, or entering into one or more new contracts for the same or similar services at the same location, or otherwise violating the same contract term or terms already interpreted by an arbitrator to prohibit the employer’s conduct.”
4. Opponent Arguments:
According to the University of California:
“Codifying a Single Grievance into a Statutory Mandate Is Bad Public Policy. Arbitration is inherently designed to resolve specific, isolated disputes between parties based on unique local circumstances. It should never be used to dictate broad statutory mandates. AB 1582 sets a dangerous precedent by turning narrow and specific arbitration rulings into a blanket prohibition on service contracts at a UC campus or medical facility.”
“Under the rigid framework proposed by this bill, if a UC campus or medical center commits a minor technical infraction, such as an administrative failure to provide notice within a specific timeframe, that isolated mistake can be used to block that location from using essential service agreements in perpetuity. This applies even when such agreements would otherwise be allowed under a recently negotiated collective bargaining agreement.”
According to the Los Angeles Area Chamber of Commerce:
“Higher education institutions operate extensive healthcare facilities, research, and student support programs that often depend on contractors to address workforce shortages or provide specialized expertise, supporting a broader network of businesses and workers across the state. Restrictions on their ability to contract for services could have ripple effects throughout the labor market, reducing opportunities for businesses and workers that provide specialized expertise and critical support functions.”
According to the California Hospital Association:
“Providing patient care in California hospitals is inherently unpredictable, shaped by sudden surges in patient volume, seasonal illness trends, public health emergencies, and the complex, varying needs of individual patients. Punitive measures tied to real-time workforce adjustments can hinder a hospital’s ability to respond effectively to these dynamic conditions. To ensure safe, high-quality care, hospitals must retain flexibility to scale staffing, redeploy clinical teams, and make timely decisions based on patient needs.
The broad impact of AB 1582 applying to the entire UC system with no exception for its hospitals will have the unintended consequence of penalizing UC hospitals when there is a dispute involving contracting out of bargaining unit work without regard for operational and legal mandates imposed on hospitals to maintain staffing levels and continuity of care in all times – even those that are uncertain and unpredictable.”
5. Dual Referral: The Senate Rules Committee referred this bill to the Senate Labor, Public Employees and Retirement Committee and the Senate Judiciary Committee.
6. Prior Legislation:
SB 23 (Durazo), Chapter 480, Statutes of 2023, requires UC vendors to provide their employees with the total compensation specified by the vendor’s contract, as well as make certain payroll information available to employees, the UC, and exclusive employee representatives. Additionally, it provides a pathway for employees of a vendor contracting with the UC to recover compensation and civil damages, as specified.
ACA 6 (Haney, 2023) would have required individuals who perform work for the UC Regents to have the right to specified basic state labor standards. The measure died in the Senate Elections and Constitutional Amendments Committee.
SB 1364 (Durazo, 2022) was similar to SB 27 and additionally provided for a vendor in violation to pay a ten percent civil penalty to the General Fund and be disqualified from contracting with the UC for five years. The bill was vetoed by the Governor, who stated “While I support the enforcement of Regents Policy 5402 and the terms of Article 5, as UC is still implementing their audit mechanisms of the policies, this bill is premature.”
ACA 14 (Gonzalez, 2019) would have amended the California Constitution, Article IX, to require the UC Regents ensure that all UC contract workers receive the same equal employment opportunity standards as UC employees that perform similar services. The measure died on the Senate Floor.
SUPPORT
AFSCME Local 3299 (Sponsor)
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees
California Faculty Association
California Federation of Labor Unions
California Federation of Teachers
Federated University Police Officers' Association
Peace Officers Research Association of California
Teamsters California
OPPOSITION
Bay Area Council
California Association of Public Hospitals and Health Systems
California Chamber of Commerce
California Hospital Association
California State University, Office of the Chancellor
Central City Association of Los Angeles
Los Angeles Business Council
Los Angeles Chamber of Commerce
Los Angeles County Business Federation
Newport Rib Company
Sacramento Metropolitan Chamber of Commerce
San Diego Regional Chamber of Commerce
Santa Barbara South Coast Chamber of Commerce
Santa Clarita Valley Chamber of Commerce
Santa Cruz Area Chamber of Commerce
Silicon Valley Leadership Group
University of California
Valley Industry and Commerce Association
West Los Angeles Chamber of Commerce
-- END --
Hereafter, the parties agreements are denoted as UC and AFSCME CBA. The committee has not seen the recently ratified agreement between the parties - UC and AFSCME CBA (May 14, 2026, Article 5) - but understands that it contains the same provisions cited here. ↑
https://ucnet.universityofcalifornia.edu/resources/employment-policies-contracts/bargaining-units/service/contract/; https://afscme3299.org/blog/we-won/; https://www.universityofcalifornia.edu/press-room/uc-expands-afscme-offer-address-affordability-nearly-33-pay-growth-and-lower-health; ↑
https://dailybruin.com/2026/05/22/afscme-local-3299-employees-vote-to-ratify-contract ↑
https://ucnet.universityofcalifornia.edu/labor-news/labor-news-uc-aft-ix-06-11-26/ ↑
Covered Services refers to work customarily performed by bargaining unit employees, whether in whole or in part, including but not necessarily limited to the following services: cleaning, custodial, janitorial, or housekeeping services; food services; laundry services; grounds keeping; building maintenance (excluding skilled crafts); transportation and parking services; and security services. (Regents Policy 5402 and UC and AFSCME CBA, Article 5, § A.6) ↑
UC and AFSCME CBA, Article 5, § H ↑
Ibid. “The arbitrator shall determine whether Article 5. C. has been/would be violated.
a. If the arbitrator concurs with the University’s determination, an existing contract for services shall remain in place or if the Article 5.C. grievance was filed prior to the formation of a contract, the University may proceed with the contracting process.
b. If the arbitrator determines that the contract is inappropriate the contract shall be terminated. If the grievance was filed prior to the formation of a contract, the University shall not proceed with the contracting process.” ↑
ASSEMBLY THIRD READING
ATR Bill Id:AB 1582
Author:(Ortega)
As Introduced Ver:May 18, 2026
Majority vote
SUMMARY
Amends the Higher Education Employer-Employee Relations Act (HEERA) by adding other prohibited acts of a higher education employer relating to arbitration and violation of a collective bargaining agreement (CBA), among other provisions.
Major Provisions
- Make it an unfair practice charge (UPC) for a higher education employer to engage in the following acts regarding arbitrations over violations of a CBA that relate to the contracting out of bargaining unit work:
- Fail or refuse to schedule an arbitration within a reasonable period of time after the union has appealed the matter to arbitration, unless the exclusive representative has placed the grievance in abeyance, or the parties have agreed to do so.
- Fail or refuse to implement an arbitration award or remedy in full within 60 days of a decision on the merits.
- Circumvent or disregard an arbitrator′s decision by extending or renewing the contract, or entering one or more new contracts for the same or similar services, or otherwise violating the same contract term or terms already interpreted by the arbitrator to prohibit the employer′s conduct. As to these matters, the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB) is prohibited from deferring repeat offenses to subsequent arbitration proceedings.
- Fail or refuse or remedy, in whole or in part, an arbitrator′s decision that remands the remedy to be determined by the parties. As to these matters, the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB) must defer to the merits of the arbitration award, but must not defer disputes regarding the remedy to subsequent arbitration proceedings absent agreement of the parties.
- Establish that remedies for the above-described violations must include the charging party′s attorney′s fees and costs, and expressly provide that nothing in this proposed statute limits the PERB′s broad remedial authority.
COMMENTS
What is an Unfair Practice Under the HEERA?
The HEERA expressly prescribes unlawful acts by a higher education employer as well as acts by a labor union or employee organization. A violation of the express prohibitions thereunder may result in a complaint being filed with the PERB. Violations and resulting complaints filed are commonly referred to as an ″unfair practice charge (UPC)″ or ″unfair labor practice (ULP)″ in which grievance allegations are filed against the other party. As to HEERA-covered employers, it is explicitly unlawful for the employer to engage in certain acts. Similarly, for HEERA-covered unions/employee organizations, it also is unlawful for them to engage in certain acts.
How Does the PERB Enforce the HEERA?
Pursuant to the HEERA, the PERB has exclusive jurisdiction as to the initial determination of a UPC and appropriate remedies. Any HEERA-covered employer or HEERA-covered union/employee organization may file a UPC; however, they must do so within six months after the occurrence of the alleged violation. The PERB does not have authority to enforce agreements and is prohibited from issuing complaints on any charges alleging violation of an agreement, unless the charge also would constitute a UPC. When the PERB finds that a UPC has been committed, it has authority to issue remedies, including cease and desist orders or affirmative remedies, such as employee reinstatement with or without backpay, to effectuate the policies under the HEERA. The rulings issued by the PERB serve to give meaning to the HEERA.
What is Arbitration, Including Under the HEERA?
″Arbitration may be defined as a method for settlement of disputes and differences between two or more parties, whereby such disputes are submitting to the decision of one or more persons specially nominated for the purpose, either instead of having recourse to an action at law, or, by order of the court, after such action has been commenced.″ John P.H. Soper, ″A Treatise on the Law and Practice of Arbitrations and Awards 1.″ (David M. Lawrence ed., 5th ed. 1935.) In the California public sector, arbitration is a dispute-resolution process where the disputing parties choose one or more neutral third parties to make a final and binding decision resolving the dispute. Typically, the parties to the dispute may chose a third party directly by mutual agreement, or indirectly, such as by agreeing to have an arbitration organization select the third party.
As to ″grievance arbitration,″ the HEERA authorizes the higher education employer and exclusive representative of employees to include procedures in a memorandum of understanding (MOU) for final and binding arbitration of disputes under the MOU, and the arbitration award that results from the grievance is final and binding on all parties involved and is enforceable in a court of law. Where a party is aggrieved by another party′s failure to proceed to arbitration pursuant to the terms of the MOU, the aggrieved party may move for a court order enforcing the agreement and directing arbitration. However, the PERB is prohibited from enforcing agreements between parties, and has no jurisdiction over grievances alleging a violation of the agreement, unless the violation, itself, would constitute a UPC.
The PERB and Deferral of Arbitration
Although existing law expressly authorizes the PERB to assume jurisdiction over contractual grievance regarding an unfair practice, traditionally, it has avoided exercising jurisdiction by deferring claims of a contractual breach and an unfair practice to arbitration. Here, the PERB adopted a standard (or doctrine) by the National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) where disputes under a collective bargaining agreement (CBA) should be deferred to arbitration for resolution. (Collyer Insulated Wire (1971) 192 NLRB 837.) (″Collyer.″)
In the PERB decision UC [University of California] (San Francisco) (1984) PERB Decision No. Ad-139-H, the PERB held that under the HEERA, a deferral of a charge to arbitration before either party invoked grievance resolution procedures is appropriate only when the arbitration procedure in question is a product of collective bargaining, and not a unilaterally implemented policy. If a negotiated arbitration procedure exists, the PERB will defer the unfair practice dispute to arbitration where: (i) the dispute falls within the scope of the stable CBA and there is no enmity by the respondent employer toward the employee′s or union′s exercise of protected rights in bringing the unfair practice charge; (ii) the respondent is ready and willing to proceed to arbitration and has waived any contract-based procedural defenses; and (iii) the contract and its meaning are at the center of the dispute. (Dry Creek Elementary School Dist. (1980) PERB Decision No. Ad-81a (Educational Employment Relations Act (EERA) case adopting the deferral standard promulgated by the NLRB in Collyer).)
Although the Collyer standard pursuant to an NLRB decision requires that the respondent be willing to proceed to arbitration as a condition precedent to deferral, in Lake Elsinore, the PERB rejected the argument raised by the union that the employer was unwilling to cooperate with the arbitration process, rendering the contractual grievance resolution procedure futile. (Lake Elsinore School Dist. (1987) PERB No. Decision No. 646.) Where the university refused to submit matters involving mixed claims to the arbitrator, the PERB held the union′s sole remedy was to seek a court order enforcing the arbitration agreement, as it is authorized to do so under Gov. Code Section 3589(b) of the HEERA. Based on this rationale, the PERB deferred the case.
Please refer to the policy committee analysis for a full discussion of this bill.
According to the Author
″For decades, the [UC] has contracted out its service work. In recent years, UC agreed to an arbitration process to resolve disagreements over contracting out. UC is now consistently violating that agreed upon arbitration process. As a result, when the workers win at arbitration, UC doesn′t follow the arbitrator′s decisions. [This bill] restores the integrity of arbitration. It does so by making it an unfair labor practice for UC to fail to schedule arbitrations in a timely manner or to circumvent or disregard an arbitrator′s decision by extending or renewing an existing contract, entering into one or more new contracts for the same or similar services, or otherwise violating the same contract term or terms already interpreted by an arbitrator to prohibit the employer′s conduct. The bill also requires make-whole relief for a violation of these provisions to include the charging party′s attorney′s fees and costs. And, if an arbitrator or PERB finds the employer to be a repeat offender, the bill would authorize PERB to award civil penalties.″
Arguments in Support
Among other things, the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, Local 3299, states that, ″[f]or decades [the] UC has used the practice of contracting out jobs and replacing us with cheap labor. The State Auditor has documented that [the] UC′s private contractors pay less, provide fewer benefits, and mistreat workers with impunity. When we have challenged contracting out practices and prevailed in arbitration, a process agreed upon in our collective bargaining agreements, [the] UC has responded with disrespect and defiance. They extend the same prohibited contracts, enter into new agreements for identical services, and simply wait for us to go back through the arbitration process again — at our own expense and at the cost of years of delay. This cycle of deliberate noncompliance renders our collective bargaining agreements meaningless and makes a mockery of the arbitration system that both parties agreed to honor.″
In part, the Federated University Police Officers Association expresses that, ″…this is a matter of advocating for fair labor practices and institutional accountability in California′s higher education systems. This bill also protects public sector jobs by preventing universities from using ″contracting out″ as a loophole to bypass legally binding union agreements. By introducing a civil penalty for repeated violations and requiring the employer to pay the workers′ attorneys′ fees and cost, would essentially make it financially unfeasible for institutions to break labor laws as a ′cost of doing business.′″
The Peace Officers Research Association expresses, ″[The protections and grievance processes in the HEERA] are intended to ensure that agreements reached between employers and employee organizations are respected and enforced. [This bill] strengthens these protections by clarifying that it is an unfair practice for a higher education employer to circumvent or disregard an arbitrator′s decision regarding the contracting out of bargaining unit work. The bill prohibits employers from renewing or entering into new contracts for the same or similar services after an arbitrator has determined that the contracting violates the collective bargaining agreement. It also establishes appropriate remedies for repeated violations, including civil penalties and the recovery of attorney′s fees and costs. By reinforcing the authority of arbitration decisions and discouraging repeated violations of negotiated agreements, [this bill] helps ensure that collective bargaining agreements are honored and that the dispute resolution process functions as intended.″
Arguments in Opposition
Among other things, the University of California states, ″[This bill] will impede [the] UC′s ability to meet emergency situations in our hospitals, clinics, and campuses. The bill also includes a disproportionate penalty structure that creates unacceptable levels of financial and operational risk for the University. The University values collective bargaining and works in good faith with its labor partners to resolve disputes. These longstanding partnerships have historically proven effective at resolving complex issues internally, utilizing robust grievance and arbitration procedures already established within our agreements. However, [this bill would significantly alter the language of the University′s mutually agreed-upon collective-bargaining agreements by creating and imposing new statutory liabilities and penalties tied to arbitration decisions. In particular, the proposed legislation would have a significant impact on the University and AFSCME′s collective-bargaining agreements and would grant remedies that far exceed the language the parties agreed to at the bargaining table in the last round of contract negotiations.
″The bill also authorizes civil penalties of $1,000 per day for employers deemed ″repeat offenders″ and requires mandatory attorney′s fees and costs. For a large and decentralized institution such as [the] UC, these provisions would create substantial and unpredictable financial exposure. [The] UC already generally prohibits contracting for Covered Services through Regents Policy 5402 and Article 5, which requires that the University contract out sparingly, to address emergencies, and other limited exceptions. By creating a broad standard for contracting for the ′same or similar services,′ [this bill] could effectively make an arbitration decision at one campus a systemwide compliance trigger, exposing other campuses to liability for routine procurement decisions made in good faith. Costly repeat violations would hinge on ambiguous language in [the bill], so that any alleged Article 5 violation could establish a subsequent dispute as a repeat violation.
″The uncertainty created by [this bill] would effectively move the University towards an across-the-board ban on contracting for Covered Services. The narrow exceptions in policy exist for a reason. UC campuses and medical centers must retain operational flexibility to contract for services when necessary to maintain continuity in essential operations, including health system staffing, laboratory support, and emergency response, to serve our students and patients.″
FISCAL COMMENTS
According to the Assembly Committee on Appropriations, this bill would result in the following:
- Ongoing General Fund cost exposure of an unknown amount, possibly in the tens of millions to low hundreds of millions annually, for the UC, cumulatively across five medical centers statewide associated with staffing shortages resulting from an arbitration decision prohibiting temporary contracted workers.
According to the UC Office of the President, if operating room and outpatient room staffing capacity led to a single medical center closing 10 rooms of each type in response to an arbitration decision regarding contracting for short-term nursing and technical support staff, then the bill would result in approximately $42.7 million in net patient revenue loss.
- Ongoing General Fund costs of an unknown but potentially significant amount, likely ranging from the low millions to tens of millions of dollars, for the UC in additional unbudgeted legal expenditures across the UC′s ten campuses and five medical centers.
- Ongoing General Fund costs of $250,000 annually for PERB to arbitrate UPC cases alleging repeated violations instead of deferring them back to the arbitration process.
VOTES
ASM PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT: 7-0-0
YES: McKinnor, Lackey, Alanis, Boerner, Garcia, Nguyen, Michelle Rodriguez
ASM APPROPRIATIONS: 13-2-0
YES: Wicks, Aguiar-Curry, Calderon, Caloza, Fong, Mark González, Krell, Pacheco, Pellerin, Sharp-Collins, Solache, Ta, Tangipa
NO: Hoover, Dixon
UPDATED
VERSION: May 18, 2026
CONSULTANT: Michael Bolden / P. E. & R. / (916) 319-3957 FN: 0002938
Date of Hearing: May 6, 2026
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON APPROPRIATIONS
Buffy Wicks, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1582
Author:(Ortega) – As Introduced Ver:January 13, 2026
Policy Committee: | Public Employment and Retirement | Vote: | 7 - 0 |
|
| ||
|
|
Urgency: No State Mandated Local Program: No Reimbursable: No
SUMMARY:
This bill adds several unfair practice charges (UPCs) to the Higher Education Employer-Employee Relations Act (HEERA), as specified, regarding actions of a higher education employer relating to arbitration and violation of a collective bargaining agreement (CBA). The bill provides for remedies of the described violations, including the charging party’s attorney’s fees and costs, and authorizes the Public Employee Relations Board (PERB), in the case of repeat offenders, to award civil penalties of $1,000 per day from the starting date of the UPC until fully remedied.
FISCAL EFFECT:
- Ongoing General Fund cost exposure of an unknown amount, possibly in the tens of millions to low hundreds of millions annually, for the UC, cumulatively across five medical centers statewide associated with staffing shortages resulting from an arbitration decision prohibiting temporary contracted workers.
According to the UC Office of the President, if operating room and outpatient room staffing capacity led to a single medical center closing 10 rooms of each type in response to an arbitration decision regarding contracting for short-term nursing and technical support staff, then the bill would result in approximately $42.7 million in net patient revenue loss.
- Ongoing General Fund costs of an unknown but potentially significant amount, likely ranging from the low millions to tens of millions of dollars, for the University of California (UC) in additional unbudgeted legal expenditures across the UC’s ten campuses and five medical centers.
- Ongoing General Fund costs of an unknown but potentially significant amount, possibly in the mid hundreds of thousands of dollars in a given year, to the CSU related to potential determinations of repeated noncompliance triggering a $1,000 per day penalty, with appeal time spans often lasting months to one or multiple years.
- Ongoing General Fund costs of $250,000 annually for PERB to arbitrate UPC cases alleging repeated violations instead of deferring them back to the arbitration process.
- Ongoing General Fund revenue of an unknown amount, possibly ranging from the tens of thousands to hundreds of thousands of dollars. If PERB determines an employer to be a repeat offender, it may award civil penalties of $1,000 per day until the violation is remedied in full and such civil penalties are deposited into the state’s general fund.
The Legislative Analyst’s Office recently warned of General Fund structural deficits of around $35 billion per year in the 2027-28 fiscal year and ongoing.
COMMENTS:
- Purpose. According to the author:
In December 2021, UCLA had approximately 200 vacancies in its dining halls and catering services. Instead of hiring UC employees, or giving AFSCME Local 3299 advance notice of its plans, UCLA retroactively extended contracts with vendors which supplied the campus with the equivalent of as many as 75 cooks and other food services workers per month.
- Background. In 2021, UCLA entered contracts with food service worker vendors to fill several vacancies across campus. AFSCME Local 3299 challenged those contracts, alleging UCLA was in violation of existing prohibitions for contracted labor in-lieu of securing bargaining unit employees. Then, in 2023 and again 2025, UCLA issued a request for proposals (RFP) to solicit new contracts for the same work, after multiple arbitration decisions found UCLA in violation of the contracting out prohibitions as alleged by AFSCME initially. These arbitration decisions resulted in three separate instances when UCLA solicited contracts for this work and three times an arbitrator ruled in AFSCME Local 3299’s favor. This bill would make the failure to schedule an arbitration within a reasonable amount of time, failure to take action and remedy the violations addressed by an arbitrator, or the repeated disregard of an arbitrator’s decision an unfair labor practice.
According to the American Federation of State, County, and Municipal Employees (AFSCME), sponsors of the bill:
For decades UC has used the practice of contracting out jobs and replacing us with cheap labor. The State Auditor has documented that UC’s private contractors pay less, provide fewer benefits, and mistreat workers with impunity.
When we have challenged contracting out practices and prevailed in arbitration, a process agreed upon in our collective bargaining agreements, UC has responded with disrespect and defiance. They extend the same prohibited contracts, enter into new agreements for identical services, and simply wait for us to go back through the arbitration process again — at our own expense and at the cost of years of delay. This cycle of deliberate noncompliance renders our collective bargaining agreements meaningless and makes a mockery of the arbitration system that both parties agreed to honor.
AB 1582 establishes that it is an unfair labor practice for a higher education employer to circumvent or disregard an arbitrator's decision by renewing or re-entering contracts for the same prohibited services.
Conversely, the UC Office of the President, writes in opposition of this bill:
The uncertainty created by AB 1582 would effectively move the University towards an across-the-board ban on contracting for Covered Services. The narrow exceptions in policy exist for a reason. UC campuses and medical centers must retain operational flexibility to contract for services when necessary to maintain continuity in essential operations, including health system staffing, laboratory support, and emergency response, to serve our students and patients.
Analysis Prepared by: Aaron Heredia / APPR. / (916) 319-2081
Date of Hearing: March 18, 2026
ASSEMBLY COMMITTEE ON PUBLIC EMPLOYMENT AND RETIREMENT
Tina S. McKinnor, Chair
ABPCA Bill Id:AB 1582 (
Author:Ortega) – As Introduced Ver:January 13, 2026
SUBJECT: Higher Education Employer-Employee Relations Act: collective bargaining: unfair labor practices
SUMMARY: Amends the Higher Education Employer-Employee Relations Act (HEERA) by adding other prohibited acts of a higher education employer relating to arbitration and violation of a collective bargaining agreement (CBA), among other provisions. Specifically, this bill:
- Makes it an unfair practice charge (UPC) for a higher education employer to engage in the following acts regarding arbitrations over violations of a CBA that relate to the contracting out of bargaining unit work:
- Fail or refuse to schedule an arbitration within a reasonable period of time after the union has appealed the matter to arbitration, unless the exclusive representative has placed the grievance in abeyance, or the parties have agreed to do so.[1]
- Fail or refuse to implement an arbitration award or remedy in full within 60 days of a decision on the merits.
- Circumvent or disregard an arbitrator’s decision by extending or renewing the contract or entering one or more new contracts for the same or similar services or otherwise violate the same contract term or terms already interpreted by the arbitrator to prohibit the employer’s conduct. As to these matters, the Public Employment Relations Board (PERB) is prohibited from deferring repeat offenses to subsequent arbitration proceedings.
- Fail or refuse or remedy, in whole or in part, an arbitrator’s decision that remands the remedy to be determined by the parties. As to these matters, the PERB must defer to the merits of the arbitration award, but must not defer disputes regarding the remedy to subsequent arbitration proceedings absent agreement of the parties.
- Establishes that remedies for the above-described violations must include the charging party’s attorney’s fees and costs.
- Grants discretionary authority to the PERB to award civil penalties of one thousand dollars ($1,000) per day starting on the date the UPC was filed until the violation or violations are remedied in full, if an arbitration or the PERB finds the employer to be a repeat offender, as prescribed, and requires civil penalties collected to be deposited into the state’s general fund.
- Expressly provides that nothing in this proposed statute shall limit the PERB’s broad remedial authority.
EXISTING LAW:
- Governs collective bargaining in the private sector under the federal National Labor Relations Act (NLRA), but leaves it to the states to regulate collective bargaining in their respective public sectors. (Sections 151 et seq., Title 29, United States Code.)
While the NLRA and the decisions of its National Labor Relations Board (NLRB) often provide persuasive precedent in interpreting state collective bargaining law, public employees have no collective bargaining rights absent specific statutory authority establishing those rights.
- Provides several statutory frameworks under California law to provide public employees collective bargaining rights, govern public employer-employee relations, and limit labor strife and economic disruption in the public sector through a reasonable method of resolving disputes regarding wages, hours, and other terms and conditions of employment between public employers and recognized public employee organizations or their exclusive representatives. Among these statutes, the HEERA governs employment relations for the California State University (CSU), University of California (UC), and UC Law San Francisco (formerly, UC Hastings College of Law).
- Makes it unlawful for a higher education employer, and a union/employee organization, to engage in certain specified acts (Sections 3571 and 3571.1, Gov. Code, respectively.)
- Establishes the PERB, a quasi-judicial administrative agency charged with administering various statutory frameworks governing employer-employee relations, resolving disputes, and enforcing the statutory duties and rights of public agency employers, employees, and employee organizations, but provides the City and County of Los Angeles a local alternative to PERB oversight. (Sections 3541 et seq., Gov. Code.)
- Expressly grants the PERB certain authority, including, but not limited to:
- Authority to hold hearings; subpoena witnesses; administer oaths; take testimony or deposition of persons, and issue subpoenas duces tecum to require the production and examination of employer or employee organization records, books, or papers relating to any matter within its jurisdiction. (Section 3541.3(h), Gov. Code.)
- Authority to investigate unfair practice charges or alleged violations…, and to take any action and make any determinations in respect of the charges or alleged violations as it deems necessary. However, in actions to recover damages due to an unlawful strike, the PERB does not have authority to award strike-preparation expenses as damages, nor authority to award damages for costs, expenses, or revenue losses during, or because of an unlawful strike. (Section 3541.3(i), Gov. Code.)
- Authority to bring an action in a court of competent jurisdiction to enforce any of its orders, decisions, or rulings or to enforce the refusal to obey a subpoena, and to petition the court for appropriate temporary relief or restraining order upon the issuance of a complaint charging that any person has engaged in, or is engaging, an unfair practice. (Section 3541.3(j), Gov. Code.)
- Authority to take any other action as it deems necessary to discharge its powers and duties to effectuate its purposes. (Section 3541.3(n), Gov. Code.)
- As its exclusive jurisdiction, make the initial determination as to whether the charges of unfair practices are justified, and if so, what remedy is necessary to effectuate its purposes. (Section 3541.5, Gov. Code.)
- Authority to issue a decision and order directing an offending party to cease and desist from the unfair practice, and to take affirmative action […]. (Section 3541.5(c), Gov. Code.)
- Establishes that any person who willfully resists, prevents, impedes, or interferes with a PERB member or any of its agents in the performance of duties, must be guilty of a misdemeanor, and upon conviction, sentenced to pay a fine of no more than one thousand dollars ($1,000). (Section 3514.4, Gov. Code.)
FISCAL EFFECT: Unknown. This bill is flagged as fiscal by Legislative Counsel.
COMMENTS:
Background
Among other things, information provided by the author states that, “[in] December 2021, [UC Los Angeles [UCLA)] had approximately 200 vacancies in its dining halls and catering services. Instead of hiring UC employees, or giving AFSCME Local 3299 advance notice of its plans, UCLA retroactively extended contracts with vendors which supplied the campus with the equivalent of as many as 75 cooks and other food services workers per month. AFSCME Local 3299 promptly challenged those vendor contracts, alleging that UCLA was violating the prohibition on contracting out bargaining unit work. However, due to UC withholding information, it wasn’t until the spring of 2023 that the parties were able to present their case to an arbitrator.
“In June 2023, after the record had closed in the first arbitration, UCLA issued a request for proposals (RFP) to solicit new contracts to perform the very same work. AFSCME 3299 immediately filed a second grievance regarding UCLA’s decision to contract out the same work again. Weeks before the hearing on the second grievance, the arbitrator in the first case returned an award finding UCLA in violation of the prohibition on contracting out and ordered UCLA to cancel the contracts. Despite this arbitration decision, UC persisted in its decision to move forward with new contracts to staff its dining halls and catering services with contracted out workers, and AFSCME Local 3299 was forced to take the second grievance to arbitration in September 2023,” and “[the union] prevailed again in arbitration. And[,] in March 2024, the second arbitrator ordered UCLA to cancel the contracts, again. Rather than follow the arbitration decision, UCLA continued to contract out much of the work and filed a petition in [Los Angeles] Superior Court, seeking to vacate the arbitration decision. AFSCME Local 3299 filed a competing petition to confirm the decision, and [court] confirmed it in September 2024, converting the decision into a court judgment.
“[The] UC was undeterred. Weeks after the court ruling, UCLA issued another RFP to contract out the very same food services work. AFSCME Local 3299 immediately filed another grievance, and the parties held a third arbitration hearing in February 2025. In September 2025, the arbitrator ruled in AFSCME Local 3299’s favor for the third time, and UCLA was ordered to cancel the third wave of food services contracts.
“It is wrong that it took four years, three arbitrations, a court proceeding and an enormous cost before cafeteria workers were hired directly. The union and its members have not been made whole for what they lost during those four years.”
What is an Unfair Practice Under the HEERA?
The HEERA expressly prescribes unlawful acts by a higher education employer as well as acts by a labor union or employee organization. A violation of the express prohibitions thereunder may result in a complaint being filed with the PERB. Violations and resulting complaints filed are commonly referred to as an “unfair practice charge (UPC)” or “unfair labor practice (ULP)” in which grievance allegations are filed against the other party.
As to HEERA-covered employers, it is explicitly unlawful for the employer to: (a) impose or threaten to impose reprisals on employees, discriminate or threaten to discriminate against employees, or otherwise interfere with, restrain, or coerce employees because of their exercise of rights guaranteed by the act; (b) deny to employee organizations rights guaranteed to them by the act; (c) refuse or fail to engage in meeting and conferring with an exclusive representative; (d) dominate or interfere with the formation or administration of any employee organization, or contribute financial or other support to it, or in any way encourage employees to join any organization in preference to another; (e) refuse to participate in good faith in the prescribed impasse procedure; and, (f) consult with any academic, professional, or staff advisory group on any matter within the scope of representation for employees who are represented by an exclusive representative, or for whom an employee organization has filed a request for recognition or certification as an exclusive representative until the request is withdrawn or an election has been held in which “no representative” received a majority of the votes cast, as provided. (Section 3571, ibid.)
As to HEERA-covered unions/employee organizations, it also is unlawful for unions/employee organizations to: (a) cause or attempt to cause the higher education employer to violate the law, as provided, (b) impose or threaten to impose reprisals on employees, to discriminate or threaten to discriminate against employees, or otherwise to interfere with, restrain, or coerce employees because of their exercise of rights guaranteed by the act; (c) refuse or fail to engage in meeting and conferring with the higher education employer; (d) refuse to participate in good faith in the prescribed impasse procedure; (e) fail to represent all employees fairly and impartially who are in the unit for which it is the exclusive representative; (f) require employees covered by a memorandum of understanding to which it is a party the payment of a fee, as a condition precedent to becoming a member of such organization, in an amount which the PERB finds excessive or discriminatory under all the circumstances, among other things, and, (g) cause, or attempt to cause, an employer to pay or deliver, or agree to pay or deliver, any money or other thing of value, in the nature of an exaction, for services which are not performed or not to be performed. (Section 3571.1, ibid.)
How Does the PERB Enforce the HEERA?
Pursuant to the HEERA, the PERB has exclusive jurisdiction as to the initial determination of a UPC and appropriate remedies. (Section 3563.2, Gov. Code.) Any HEERA-covered employer or HEERA-covered union/employee organization may file a UPC; however, they must do so within six months after the occurrence of the alleged violation. (Section 3563.2(a), Gov. Code.)
The PERB does not have authority to enforce agreements and is prohibited from issuing complaints on any charges alleging violation of an agreement, unless the charge also would constitute a UPC. (Section 3563.2, Gov. Code.) When the PERB finds that a UPC has been committed, it has authority to issue remedies, including cease and desist orders or affirmative remedies, such as employee reinstatement with or without backpay, to effectuate the policies under the HEERA. (Section 3563.3, Gov. Code. Also refer to No. 5 under “Existing Law.”)
The rulings issued by the PERB serve to give meaning to the HEERA.
What is Arbitration?
“Arbitration may be defined as a method for settlement of disputes and differences between two or more parties, whereby such disputes are submitting to the decision of one or more persons specially nominated for the purpose, either instead of having recourse to an action at law, or, by order of the court, after such action has been commenced.” John P.H. Soper, “A Treatise on the Law and Practice of Arbitrations and Awards 1.” (David M. Lawrence ed., 5th ed. 1935.) In the California public sector, arbitration is a dispute-resolution process where the disputing parties choose one or more neutral third parties to make a final and binding decision resolving the dispute. Typically, the parties to the dispute may chose a third party directly by mutual agreement, or indirectly, such as by agreeing to have an arbitration organization select the third party.
There are numerous forms or types of arbitration. As examples: “Ad hoc arbitration” (arbitration of only one issue which does not involve an arbitration provider or institution to administer the proceeding); “Compulsory, i.e., mandatory, arbitration” (arbitration required by law or contractual agreement); “Grievance arbitration” (arbitration that involves the violation or interpretation of an existing contract where the arbitrator issues a final decision regarding the meaning of contractual terms, and under labor law where an arbitration of an employee’s grievance usually relates to an alleged violation of their rights under a collective bargaining agreement (CBA), or where the arbitration procedure is set forth in the CBA; “Contract arbitration” (where arbitration is mandated in an agreement between the parties and for all disputes related to the agreement); “Nonbinding arbitration” (a dispute-resolution process that resembles arbitration, except that the award is not binding on the parties);[2] and, “Interest arbitration” (involves settling the terms of a contract being negotiated between parties. In labor law, this involves arbitration of a dispute concerning what provisions will be included in a new CBA), to name a few.
What is Arbitration Under the HEERA?
As to “grievance arbitration,” the HEERA authorizes the higher education employer and exclusive representative of employees to include procedures in a memorandum of understanding (MOU) for final and binding arbitration of disputes under the MOU (Section 3589, Gov. Code.), and the arbitration award that results from the grievance is final and binding on all parties involved and is enforceable in a court of law. (Section 3589(c), Gov. Code.) Where a party is aggrieved by another party’s failure to proceed to arbitration pursuant to the terms of the MOU, the aggrieved party may move for a court order enforcing the agreement and directing arbitration. (Section 3589(b), Gov. Code.) However, the PERB is prohibited from enforcing agreements between parties, and has no jurisdiction over grievances alleging a violation of the agreement, unless the violation, itself, would constitute a UPC. (Section 3563.2(b), Gov. Code.)
The PERB and Deferral of Arbitration
Although existing law expressly authorizes the PERB to assume jurisdiction over contractual grievance regarding an unfair practice, traditionally, it has avoided exercising jurisdiction by deferring claims of a contractual breach and an unfair practice to arbitration. Here, the PERB adopted a standard (or doctrine) by the NLRB where disputes under a collective bargaining agreement (CBA) should be deferred to arbitration for resolution. (Collyer Insulated Wire (1971) 192 NLRB 837.) (“Collyer.”)
In the PERB decision UC (San Francisco), the PERB held that under the HEERA, a deferral of a charge to arbitration before either party invoked grievance resolution procedures is appropriate only when the arbitration procedure in question is a product of collective bargaining, and not a unilaterally implemented policy. (UC (San Francisco) (1984) PERB No. Ad-139-H.)[3] If a negotiated arbitration procedure exists, the PERB will defer the unfair practice dispute to arbitration where: (i) the dispute falls within the scope of the stable CBA and there is no enmity by the respondent employer toward the employee’s or union’s exercise of protected rights in bringing the unfair practice charge; (ii) the respondent is ready and willing to proceed to arbitration and has waived any contract-based procedural defenses; and (iii) the contract and its meaning are at the center of the dispute. (Dry Creek Elementary School Dist. (1980) PERB No. Ad-81a (Educational Employment Relations Act (EERA) case adopting the deferral standard promulgated by the NLRB in Collyer).)[4]
Although the Collyer standard pursuant to an NLRB decision requires that the respondent be willing to proceed to arbitration as a condition precedent to deferral, in Lake Elsinore, the PERB rejected the argument raised by the union that the employer was unwilling to cooperate with the arbitration process, rendering the contractual grievance resolution procedure futile. (Lake Elsinore School Dist. (1987) PERB No. 646.)[5] Where the university refused to submit matters involving mixed claims to the arbitrator, the PERB held the union’s sole remedy was to seek a court order enforcing the arbitration agreement, as it is authorized to do so under Gov. Code Section 3589(b) of the HEERA. Based on this rationale, the PERB deferred the case.
This Bill
Recall from earlier that the HEERA authorizes a higher education employer and exclusive representative of employees to include procedures in a memorandum of understanding (MOU) for final and binding arbitration of disputes under the MOU (Section 3589(c), ibid.), and the arbitration award that results from the grievance is final and binding on all parties involved and is enforceable in a court of law. (Section 3589(c), Gov. Code.) (Emphasis.)
In some respects, this bill could be considered as duplicative or somewhat duplicative of Section 3589(c), ibid., as both a HEERA-covered employer and HEERA-covered labor union/employee organization may seek enforcement of a final and binding arbitration award by a court of law. Further, a court of law may award the prevailing party of an arbitration matter with financial reimbursement of attorney’s fees and costs by the non-prevailing party in addition to imposing fines upon the non-prevailing party (although such fines would not necessarily be directed for remittal to the state general fund by the court, as this bill proposes). However, unlike Section 3589, ibid., which applies to both HEERA-covered employers and HEERA-covered unions/employee organizations, this bill: (i) solely targets HEERA-covered employers to incentivize adherence to an arbitration decision; (ii) narrowly prescribes the specific acts or conduct by such employers to which and when it’s provisions would apply; (iii) prescribes certain requirements and prohibitions by, and discretionary authority to, the PERB relating to repeat employer offenses, the deferral of certain matters, and awarding of civil penalties (including directing such penalties to be remitted to the state general fund); and, (iv) expressly provides that its provisions must not limit the PERB’s remedial authority. As proposed, the overall context of this bill directly relates to matters discussed under “The PERB and Deferral of Arbitration.”
In other respects, although Section 3589, ibid., authorizes the inclusion of final and binding arbitration provisions in a MOU, if a MOU does not include such provisions, what is proposed by this bill may provide a semblance of meaningful parity under those circumstances.
Finally, among other things, this bill proposes that it must be a UPC for a higher education employer to “fail or refuse to schedule an arbitration within a reasonable period of time after the union has appealed the matter to arbitration….” (Emphasis added.) Because the phrase “within a reasonable period of time” may be subjective, it may appear to be insufficiently clear; thus, resulting in ambiguity. For example, one might ponder whether this phrase relates to a determination of the employer or union/employee organization? If one party determines what is “within a reasonable period of time,” what happens if the other party disagrees with that determination? Would, could, or should this phrasing be determined based on explicit provisions included in an agreed upon MOU by the parties thereto? Would the PERB or a court of law make this determination?
Although such reasonable questions might exist, in a legal context and generally, “reasonable time” refers to a period that is considered appropriate and fair given the specific circumstances of a situation. It is neither a fixed number of days, weeks, or months, but rather a flexible standard that courts and parties determine based on the facts and circumstances at hand on case-by-case basis.
Author’s Statement
“For decades, the [UC] has contracted out its service work. In recent years, UC agreed to an arbitration process to resolve disagreements over contracting out. UC is now consistently violating that agreed upon arbitration process. As a result, when the workers win at arbitration, UC doesn’t follow the arbitrator’s decisions. [This bill] restores the integrity of arbitration. It does so by making it an unfair labor practice for UC to fail to schedule arbitrations in a timely manner or to circumvent or disregard an arbitrator’s decision by extending or renewing an existing contract, entering into one or more new contracts for the same or similar services, or otherwise violating the same contract term or terms already interpreted by an arbitrator to prohibit the employer’s conduct. The bill also requires make-whole relief for a violation of these provisions to include the charging party’s attorney’s fees and costs. And, if an arbitrator or PERB finds the employer to be a repeat offender, the bill would authorize PERB to award civil penalties.”
Comments by Supporters
Among other things, the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, Local 3299, states that, “[f]or decades [the] UC has used the practice of contracting out jobs and replacing us with cheap labor. The State Auditor has documented that [the] UC’s private contractors pay less, provide fewer benefits, and mistreat workers with impunity. When we have challenged contracting out practices and prevailed in arbitration, a process agreed upon in our collective bargaining agreements, [the] UC has responded with disrespect and defiance. They extend the same prohibited contracts, enter into new agreements for identical services, and simply wait for us to go back through the arbitration process again — at our own expense and at the cost of years of delay. This cycle of deliberate noncompliance renders our collective bargaining agreements meaningless and makes a mockery of the arbitration system that both parties agreed to honor.”
In part, the Federated University Police Officers Association expresses that, “…this is a matter of advocating for fair labor practices and institutional accountability in California’s higher education systems. This bill also protects public sector jobs by preventing universities from using “contracting out” as a loophole to bypass legally binding union agreements. By introducing a civil penalty for repeated violations and requiring the employer to pay the workers’ attorneys’ fees and cost, would essentially make it financially unfeasible for institutions to break labor laws as a ‘cost of doing business.’”
The Peace Officers Research Association expresses, “[The protections and grievance processes in the HEERA] are intended to ensure that agreements reached between employers and employee organizations are respected and enforced. [This bill] strengthens these protections by clarifying that it is an unfair practice for a higher education employer to circumvent or disregard an arbitrator’s decision regarding the contracting out of bargaining unit work. The bill prohibits employers from renewing or entering into new contracts for the same or similar services after an arbitrator has determined that the contracting violates the collective bargaining agreement. It also establishes appropriate remedies for repeated violations, including civil penalties and the recovery of attorney’s fees and costs. By reinforcing the authority of arbitration decisions and discouraging repeated violations of negotiated agreements, [this bill] helps ensure that collective bargaining agreements are honored and that the dispute resolution process functions as intended.”
Others in support express similar statements as those above.
Comments by Opponents
Among other things, the University of California states, “[This bill] will impede [the] UC’s ability to meet emergency situations in our hospitals, clinics, and campuses. The bill also includes a disproportionate penalty structure that creates unacceptable levels of financial and operational risk for the University. The University values collective bargaining and works in good faith with its labor partners to resolve disputes. These longstanding partnerships have historically proven effective at resolving complex issues internally, utilizing robust grievance and arbitration procedures already established within our agreements. However, [this bill would significantly alter the language of the University's mutually agreed-upon collective-bargaining agreements by creating and imposing new statutory liabilities and penalties tied to arbitration decisions. In particular, the proposed legislation would have a significant impact on the University and AFSCME's collective-bargaining agreements and would grant remedies that far exceed the language the parties agreed to at the bargaining table in the last round of contract negotiations.
“The bill also authorizes civil penalties of $1,000 per day for employers deemed “repeat offenders” and requires mandatory attorney’s fees and costs. For a large and decentralized institution such as [the] UC, these provisions would create substantial and unpredictable financial exposure. [The] UC already generally prohibits contracting for Covered Services through Regents Policy 5402 and Article 5, which requires that the University contract out sparingly, to address emergencies, and other limited exceptions. By creating a broad standard for contracting for the ‘same or similar services,’ [this bill] could effectively make an arbitration decision at one campus a systemwide compliance trigger, exposing other campuses to liability for routine procurement decisions made in good faith. Costly repeat violations would hinge on ambiguous language in [the bill], so that any alleged Article 5 violation could establish a subsequent dispute as a repeat violation.
“The uncertainty created by [this bill] would effectively move the University towards an across-the-board ban on contracting for Covered Services. The narrow exceptions in policy exist for a reason. UC campuses and medical centers must retain operational flexibility to contract for services when necessary to maintain continuity in essential operations, including health system staffing, laboratory support, and emergency response, to serve our students and patients.”
REGISTERED SUPPORT / OPPOSITION:
Support
American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees, Local 3299 (Sponsor)
California Federation of Teachers – a Union of Educators & Classified Professionals, AFT,
AFL-CIO
Federated University Police Officers' Association
Peace Officers Research Association of California
Teamsters California
Opposition
University of California Office of the President
Analysis Prepared by: Michael Bolden / P. E. & R. / (916) 319-3957
In the context of this bill, “abeyance” refers to temporary inactivity or suspension. ↑
The term “nonbinding arbitration” may be a misnomer by some because arbitration is usually intended to result in a final, binding award. ↑
This deferral doctrine has been codified by PERB regulations requiring that unfair practice charges arising under the HEERA that also are subject to final and binding arbitration be held in abeyance by the PERB until arbitration is concluded, then dismissed. (PERB Reg. 32620(b)(6).) “Regulations of the PERB.” Amendments and Additions, current as of October 1, 2025. Visit: https: ://perb.ca.gov/wp-content/uploads/regulations/PERB-regulations-2025.pdf ↑
The Collyer standard or doctrine, named after the NLRB case, is a principle in labor law that allows the NLRB to refer disputes to arbitration if they can be resolved under the terms of a CBA. Essentially, it encourages the resolution of labor disputes through arbitration rather than through direct intervention by the NLRB, promoting adherence to agreed-upon terms between employers and unions. Although originally applied under the EERA, the PERB extended the application of this standard in UC San Francisco, id., and again in California State University (1993) PERB No. 986-H, to mixed contractual and statutory claims under the HEERA. The PERB, however, later overruled Dry Creek, id., holding that because pre-arbitration deferral of mixed claims was mandatory under the EERA, etc., the NLRB’s Collyer standard, insofar as it interposed procedural prerequisites for deferral, was inapplicable to the EERA. ↑
Subsequently, Lake Elsinore, id., was overruled by the PERB in California Union of Safety Employees (Dept. of Food and Agriculture) (2002) PERB No, 1473-S. Unlike the EERA, inter alia, deferral by the PERB under the HEERA is permissive, and the Collyer standard has always applied to HEERA mixed cases. (California State University (1993) PERB No. 986-H.) ↑
Discussed in Hearing
Senate Standing Committee on Judiciary
Senate Standing Committee on Labor, Public Employment and Retirement
Assembly Floor
Assembly Standing Committee on Public Employment and Retirement
Bill Author
Bill Co-Author(s):